Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Liquidity Flashback - An NCUA Perspective with Todd Miller
Transcript
- 0:03Katie: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, Visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:31Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive
- 0:34episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:37I hope you enjoy.
- 0:45Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:48It is April 4th and about, let's see, about 45 minutes ago, NCUA
- 0:55ended their liquidity webinar.
- 0:58And I listened to it and Todd Miller of my team listened to it.
- 1:02If you've listened to this show before Todd, he talks a lot about a lot
- 1:06of different topics, but including liquidity as a former capital
- 1:09market specialist and supervisor of capital market specialists at NCOA.
- 1:14So Todd and I are going to basically give our take on what NCOA said
- 1:18relative to liquidity and maybe dive into some related issues to that.
- 1:23So Todd, how are you doing today?
- 1:26Miller: I'm doing fine, Mark.
- 1:27Spring has finally come to Montana and winter is going to come back tomorrow,
- 1:31but for now, we've got some days in the 70s, which are quite nice for us.
- 1:36That's nice.
- 1:38Treichel: That's good.
- 1:3870 degree days.
- 1:39That, that is, that doesn't seem like spring.
- 1:41That seems like summer in Montana.
- 1:45All right, so Todd, give it for, if anybody, there might be some new
- 1:48listeners listening for the first time.
- 1:50Why don't you give those folks a little synopsis of what
- 1:54you did at your time at NCUA.
- 1:56Miller: Okay, I spent from 1987 through 2021 at NCUA.
- 2:02Started as an examiner in Montana, spent the early 90s as a problem case officer.
- 2:07From 2000 to 2010, I was a regional capital market specialist.
- 2:13I'm involved in a lot of training and policies that go on around
- 2:18capital markets issues at NCUA.
- 2:21Um, 2009, I had a lost year.
- 2:23I spent it at Westcorp while the agency had Westcorp in conservatorship,
- 2:28um, cleaning up at Westcorp and helping wind things down there.
- 2:33And then from 2010 to the end of my career in 2011, I was the director
- 2:37of special actions supervising problem case officers and supervising
- 2:42regional capital market specialists.
- 2:44I enjoyed all of my 34 years with NCUA.
- 2:49I was short a couple months.
- 2:51But it was an enjoyable time.
- 2:52I really enjoyed working with Freddie Indians and all the people at NCUA.
- 2:57Treichel: Very good.
- 2:58Yeah.
- 2:58And you've been in a lot involved in a lot of podcasts.
- 3:02You've been involved in a lot of clients that we've been helping and it's nice.
- 3:06To be able to talk here about our take on what NCOA's take is, and, and they
- 3:11had a, an, an hour long webinar, it was about 50 percent questions, 50
- 3:16percent presentation, which is a good mix, and I'll just throw it to you,
- 3:20uh, based on what you heard on NCOA's liquidity webinar, what's your takeaway
- 3:25from what they had to say today?
- 3:27Miller: I'm going to throw out maybe three resources first, right at the
- 3:31beginning, because most of what NCUA talked about in the webinar really
- 3:36comes from these three source documents.
- 3:39And really, that's the 2010 Interagency Policy Statement on
- 3:43Funding and Liquidity Risk Management.
- 3:45If people listen to the webinar, that was brought up, especially in the question
- 3:49and answer session, on multiple times.
- 3:52Back in 2013, NCUA issued CU 10 guidance on how to comply
- 3:57with NCUA Regulation 741 12.
- 4:01They mentioned that today.
- 4:02That was when NCUA came up with the regulation requiring different
- 4:06crowding needs to have policies, contingency funding plans.
- 4:09larger credit unions access to the Federal Reserve discount window or the CLF.
- 4:14And then last year in 2023 they issued, um, NCWA issued an interagency or
- 4:21an addendum to that 2010 interagency statement on funding and liquidity
- 4:26risk, just on the importance of contingency funding plans.
- 4:30Everything in today's webinar is really just a subset of what was
- 4:35in one of those three documents, primarily that interagency statement.
- 4:40Policy statement on funding and liquidity risk management that was put out in
- 4:452010, right after the last financial crisis shortly after that, the OCC
- 4:51updated their liquidity handbook in 2012.
- 4:55Those are all really good source documents overall today's seminar or
- 5:01webinar the way I'd characterize it.
- 5:04This is a refresher course on those policy statements.
- 5:07I think they were probably, it may have been more helpful to smaller credit unions
- 5:11than larger credit unions in my mind.
- 5:15They didn't really say anything new to us.
- 5:18There's some specifics we can talk about as we go here.
- 5:21My initial take, this was all primarily a review of Those guidance documents
- 5:26that NCUA has issued previously,
- 5:30Treichel: and I'll put in the show notes.
- 5:31I'll have links to those all 3 of those.
- 5:34So that if someone wants to get access to more details.
- 5:37And I'll also probably do a blog on my website that'll have links to that.
- 5:42So if someone's listening and wants to find a quick way to find all
- 5:44three of those, we'll provide that.
- 5:46Yeah, so let's get into the details.
- 5:48What's the first detail that you think's worth highlighting?
- 5:53Miller: They talked a lot about cash flow statements in here and
- 5:56cash flow forecasts and triggers for contingency funding plans.
- 6:01They talked about using historical numbers.
- 6:03They talked about using stress numbers.
- 6:05I think that the interesting pieces of all of this is if you go back
- 6:11to the last recession in 2010 2009, we'll look at 2009, Credien's deposit
- 6:19space back then were about 1, 55 percent were money markets and CDs.
- 6:25And then another, that was money market CDs and wholesale funding.
- 6:30Today we're at 52%.
- 6:32There was some big changes in 2022 when rates started rising.
- 6:37I think credit unions were maybe slow to react or the market changed
- 6:41so fast, they couldn't react.
- 6:43So there was these stresses placed on liquidity.
- 6:46We go from a low end rate environment, low cost shares are
- 6:51migrating to higher cost shares.
- 6:53Credit unions are using borrowings to manage that marginal cost of funds.
- 6:59And I think they did that in a very appropriate way.
- 7:03So while the agency seems to be very stressed about liquidity
- 7:08pressures, I think they were right to be stressed about them in 2022.
- 7:12But if you look at what's going on in 2023, I think credit unions have
- 7:16adjusted to this rate environment.
- 7:19The migration from lower cost to higher cost shares is going
- 7:22to continue for another year, at least, maybe a little bit longer.
- 7:27And I think that's really just historical numbers tell us that's where it's going
- 7:30to go in terms of member behavior.
- 7:33I think a lot of their sense of urgency here with this webinar was maybe
- 7:38needed in January or September of January of 2023 or September of 2022.
- 7:44I think right now the industry has done a really good job
- 7:48of managing this environment.
- 7:50And a lot of the liquidity stuff is behind us.
- 7:52NCUA is still nervous, but the numbers would indicate most of the
- 7:57credit unions have adjusted really well, uh, in the, you know, you
- 8:03Treichel: talk, you talk about that 55 and we're getting close to that.
- 8:07I think in some of our other conversations and maybe some client
- 8:09conversations, you've called that the reversion to the mean and.
- 8:13I have.
- 8:14Yeah.
- 8:14And the other times, when I think reversions to the mean, I think about
- 8:18the basketball player that just made 10 straight shots, which means that
- 8:22over time he's going to miss 10 more.
- 8:23Right.
- 8:24So you get back if he's a 50 percent shooter, but, but
- 8:27that was in the old days.
- 8:28Now I think when I think about reversion to the mean, I think about that mix of
- 8:32deposits that that credit unions have and they, I might've missed something, but
- 8:38they did highlight, I'm going to probably get the phrase Roz, but they talked about.
- 8:44For deposits and the best sources of liquidity and they
- 8:48talked about member shares plus like borrowings being utilized.
- 8:52But did I if I write that?
- 8:55I don't think I heard a reference to like non member deposits at all.
- 8:58Miller: They left non member deposits out.
- 9:00I don't remember them using that word at all.
- 9:03Even though non member deposits are up a little bit and you had me work with 38
- 9:10different clients over the last two years.
- 9:12There's a good number of them that have been dinged on their usage of non
- 9:16member deposits and a lot of them have used non member deposits so they didn't
- 9:20have to raise their certificate rates.
- 9:22Another thing that wasn't mentioned today, and this is a huge part of
- 9:26the whole liquidity risk management, is I never mentioned pricing today.
- 9:31They said, you got to have an appropriate share structure and
- 9:33an appropriate loan structure.
- 9:35And that's all created by pricing and catering to your members individual needs.
- 9:40Some members are going to chase rates.
- 9:42Some members, they want to keep a pool of liquid assets there.
- 9:46My wife calls it, she wants her 1.
- 9:4799 in the bank.
- 9:49And then in her term, that means that it has to be like right at that 100, 000.
- 9:53She kind of freaks out if it's less than that.
- 9:55Well, we're not going to put that in an account earning us two basis
- 9:58points, but we don't need a 5 percent certificate rate either.
- 10:01We want that somewhere in the middle, and I think our current bank's paying
- 10:05three and a half, not that it's germane.
- 10:07Pricing and creating an appropriate structure means meeting the
- 10:10needs of your members on both sides of the balance sheet.
- 10:13Ad Dude: Are you worried about an NCUA exam in process or looming on the horizon?
- 10:18Don't face it alone.
- 10:19We're ex NCUA insiders with decades of experience, ready to guide you to success.
- 10:24Our team understands the intricacies of NCUA examinations from the inside out.
- 10:29Hire us and gain peace of mind during your exam process, insider knowledge of NCUA
- 10:34procedures and expectations, strategies to address potential issues before they
- 10:39become problems, continuous access to our extensive subject matter expertise.
- 10:43With our Access Retainer, you'll have on demand support from former NCUA experts.
- 10:49We're here to ensure your credit union passes your exam with flying colors.
- 10:53Contact Credit Union Exam Solutions today to learn more about our services and how
- 10:58we can help your credit union succeed.
- 11:01Miller: And loan demand is up and part of that is inflation
- 11:05and things of that nature.
- 11:06Borrowing requirements are a little bit higher amongst your members.
- 11:10And I think the credit unions overall, the industry, they've done a really
- 11:14good job of meeting those member needs.
- 11:17Maybe they were a little bit slow to price loans upwards, and that has to catch
- 11:23up a little bit before they can start creating these appropriate price products
- 11:27to grow these core deposits again.
- 11:30In this high rate environment, it could be totally expected.
- 11:33that you're going to see this migration from low cost shares into higher cost
- 11:38CDs and higher cost money markets.
- 11:40And like I said, credit is going out and using borrowed funds and using non
- 11:44member deposits to keep that marginal cost down is a perfectly normal
- 11:50reaction for them to the marketplace.
- 11:53Yeah.
- 11:56So I think they've done really well with that.
- 11:59Treichel: Yeah, no, I would agree.
- 12:00Another word I wrote down was decay rates and decay rate assumptions.
- 12:05And it's like they, when I heard it, and, and again, this is an area that
- 12:12I'm far from an expert, but I know that it plays a big role in ALM and I know
- 12:16you've talked about it here and you've talked about it on our client with our
- 12:20clients, but they basically brought it up and then pivoted away from it and
- 12:23didn't give any background relative to it.
- 12:25But maybe any thoughts on.
- 12:28The pay rates, how those are impacting credit unions, liquidity.
- 12:33How we're seeing NCUA maybe respond in some instances to clients.
- 12:38So I'm diverging from what was said in the letter into kind of a maybe what
- 12:42should have they said about decay rates?
- 12:44Miller: I think this is one where they're still overreacting and responding late.
- 12:48The cash flow forecasts are very much tied to the same assumptions that go
- 12:52into an asset liability management model.
- 12:54I think they mentioned that during the webinar or during one of the questions.
- 12:58But if you go back in these stress tests and Even your 300 basis point shock
- 13:03in an ALM model, that whole thing is intended to get members to exercise the
- 13:10options in these financial instruments.
- 13:12Rates have went up 500 basis points.
- 13:14All the options on the loan portfolio have been exercised.
- 13:18It's not going to get any slower.
- 13:20Even though they talk about stressing this, the loan assumptions are
- 13:24not really going to be stressed much more than they are now.
- 13:27They're already Those prepayments are as slow as they're going to go in most cases.
- 13:32So that's maybe why they backed away from it is because you can't stress
- 13:36it much farther than you already have.
- 13:38On the share side of it, and coming up with decay rates, we're
- 13:42finding this with lots of clients.
- 13:44Parties used very conservative assumptions for a lot of years during the flat rates.
- 13:48Of course, when things start changing in 2022, the examiners,
- 13:52you need to update your assumptions.
- 13:54A lot of credit unions did that.
- 13:56Their vendors did it.
- 13:57What they found out is their previous assumptions were overly conservative.
- 14:01They're slowing them down and using more reasonable assumptions.
- 14:04And the examiners don't like that because it makes them look better.
- 14:08And it's just a matter of when rates were low and interest rate risk were low
- 14:12and there wasn't stresses, there wasn't this impetus to put time and resources
- 14:17on getting those assumptions precise.
- 14:19And now it is, and they're making it more precise.
- 14:21And in many cases, the examiners don't like the results.
- 14:25Stressing share growth and share migration, that does become
- 14:29very much an individual thing for each credit union loans.
- 14:34That's pretty much homogeneous across the industry loans behave the same.
- 14:38But shares are very different from credit union to credit union, and it has a
- 14:41lot to do with your field of membership and your whole pricing strategy for
- 14:45your whole product suite that is really not homogeneous across the industry.
- 14:51It's different for credit unions to credit unions, so a lot of your
- 14:54stress tests are going to be geared to changing your member behavior.
- 14:58But I think most credit unions probably have a pretty good idea
- 15:01of what has occurred in the last year, how much money has migrated.
- 15:04And there's going to be a little bit more to migrate, so I don't think the stress
- 15:09is, it's almost if NCUA is behaving, we have another 300 basis point upcoming
- 15:15when we don't, and we're going to be probably staying somewhat flat, or if
- 15:20you believe what everyone else says, rates will start coming down, and that
- 15:24will help folks, and it'll give time for Credien's investments to catch back up.
- 15:28Credien's really got caught in a trap.
- 15:30They're long term assets.
- 15:31It's really peaked right at 2021, right before the rates started up.
- 15:38When all that COVID money came in during those flat rates, credit unions
- 15:43went long term with that either on their loans or their investments.
- 15:47And then rates shot up on them.
- 15:50And so it made them a little bit harder to reprice, price assets.
- 15:54But I think we're catching up to them now that.
- 15:57The repricing is starting to catch up when rates went up.
- 16:00Initially, cratings were slow to raise those loan rates.
- 16:03They've started to catch that back up.
- 16:05So I think the future is looking good in terms of that.
- 16:10So, I guess the biggest variability that we see, and a person in the
- 16:16webinar asked a question about liquidity ratios and the basal coverage ratio.
- 16:24Their response was, well, there's lots of ratios out there and we
- 16:27have a data dictionary of them.
- 16:28And one thing I think we're finding with our clients is.
- 16:34On exams, what's important to the examiners varies a great
- 16:38deal from examiner to examiner.
- 16:40We've got examiners from credit unions that are making up liquidity
- 16:44ratios that are not mentioned anywhere in NCUA's guidance.
- 16:48And we have examiners in larger credit unions think people should
- 16:52be using the Basel coverage ratio.
- 16:55The variations of that are extremely difficult to
- 17:00actually calculate that ratio.
- 17:02So that variations in examiner's impetus, that's a challenge for credit unions.
- 17:09And so they better be just prepared to justify what they're using to
- 17:13measure liquidity versus how an examiner suggests maybe they should.
- 17:19So they should be able to defend what they're doing.
- 17:22They brought up the things with cash flow, and they brought up limits a lot.
- 17:25NCUA, they issue all these disclaimers at the start of it, and, hey,
- 17:28this is this person's opinion, not the agency's opinion, even
- 17:31though it's the agency's webinar.
- 17:33I find that interesting.
- 17:34But for credit unions, I think one thing that we see that is consistent out
- 17:39there and is Where they get criticized for examiners legitimately is looking
- 17:46at liquidity in a rear view mirror.
- 17:48I'll use that term rear view mirror.
- 17:51What was our liquidity ratios last month?
- 17:53Or, or here's our last quarter end and now we're doing May.
- 17:58And looking at ratios that were 45 days old.
- 18:01Realistically, credit gains with your cash flow forecast, you need to be
- 18:05looking and computing your policy limits.
- 18:08What do they look like in your cash flow forecast six months from now, nine
- 18:11months from now, and a year from now?
- 18:13If managing from a forward looking space than that.
- 18:18NCUA didn't really use that terminology, forward looking, but
- 18:22that's what liquidity management needs to be, is forward looking,
- 18:26not looking in a rear view mirror.
- 18:28And I noticed the one or two times they did quote ratios, they quoted ratios
- 18:32that were rear view mirror looks.
- 18:35During the webinar, but they inferred with a lot of their emphasis on cash
- 18:39flow forecast is managing liquidity needs to be a forward looking process,
- 18:44not looking in our rear mirror.
- 18:48Treichel: Yeah, I wrote down some, I have liquidity measures.
- 18:50I wrote down some of the exact same things you did there.
- 18:53And then a couple other things you said, it's almost as if NCOA is thinking
- 18:57there's going to be another 300 basis point shock, which I would bet against
- 19:01right now, you don't want to bet on where rates are going, but I'm going
- 19:04to bet they're going to, they might not go down as quick as we thought
- 19:06they might inch up and probably NEV.
- 19:10Which has, which, as we've discussed in other podcasts, NEV has weaknesses
- 19:15because it doesn't take into considerations a lot of positives.
- 19:19And it seems like what we're seeing with some of our clients is they're
- 19:24using that and saying, well, you know, if it goes up another 300 basis
- 19:28points, you're going to have these issues and you need to develop a plan.
- 19:31And then adding that to, was it two years ago now NCUA separated the S from the L.
- 19:37You used to have just camel and now it's camels.
- 19:40And I think there was a reference to this topic where they just subtly
- 19:45brought it up in the podcast, but it, and then, so one last rambling part
- 19:50of this question, which, you know, the fed hat for large institutions, the
- 19:55fed has their shock test that they do.
- 19:57And I was looking at that the other day and the shock test they do right
- 20:01now is they're having credit unions.
- 20:04Shocked their balance sheet with rates going down and then at the same time they
- 20:08got to do they got to look at the nev and i get i guess you should have a plan
- 20:11for both directions but even the fed is saying let's test it in this direction all
- 20:16right so that's a long rambling statement more than a question any anything you
- 20:20can you any did that trick Thoughts Todd.
- 20:23Miller: They made one statement and I wrote it down.
- 20:25So this was the whole part of our webinar supposedly on liquidity, but in their
- 20:31discussions on liquidity, they brought up the fact that the NCUA supervisory
- 20:37test is not how credit unions should manage their interest rate risk.
- 20:41And I wrote it down because I don't know how many clients we have, but we have
- 20:45multiple clients that have gotten DOORS to reduce interest rate risk on the basis
- 20:50of that NCUA supervisory test measure.
- 20:53That, those are the words that are in their document of resolution.
- 20:57And publicly they've said this on many webinars and last year when they
- 21:02got rid of the extreme interest rate risk, they said Freddie Eanes don't
- 21:06manage to our NCUA supervisory test.
- 21:09But they keep writing doors to credit unions that says that is going to be our
- 21:15measurement is our NCUA supervisory test.
- 21:18So no matter how many times they say it to the public, their examiners don't.
- 21:24The message isn't filtering down to their field staff, put it that way.
- 21:29Treichel: That's what you'd always hear when I was at NSUA, you'd hear that from
- 21:33when you'd go to GAC and you'd get in a line, meet and greet line and the,
- 21:37the NSUA board would chat with them and saying, yeah, I heard you say this
- 21:40six months ago at the board table, but my examiner saying the exact opposite.
- 21:45And then they'd come back and we'd.
- 21:46We we'd have a little discussion on it, but, and the other thing too.
- 21:50So think about that statement and your earlier statement about
- 21:53the disclaimer at the front.
- 21:55Right?
- 21:55So if a credit union is going to cite what was said at this webinar, the examiner
- 22:01might say at the beginning, we came to you, disclosure is just the opinion of
- 22:04those facts, those people at the table, and that's not really what it should be.
- 22:07They are the government, they are speaking for the government.
- 22:11And and the webinar was kicked off by the chairman of the agency who, if this was
- 22:17face to face, would be sitting right there and people should be able to rely on it.
- 22:22But, like you said, their statement is incongruent with
- 22:25what we're seeing an exam.
- 22:26So I'll just leave it at that.
- 22:28Miller: Yeah, and I'm sure there's more than a few examiners
- 22:31were listening to the webinar.
- 22:32I didn't keep track until they were like just about done with the questions.
- 22:37And then I looked up and there was 1220 participants on and some of them
- 22:42were probably dropping off already at the one time I chose to look.
- 22:47But I do know examiners, especially the subject matter type experts
- 22:51and the RCMSs, they're given time to listen to the webinars.
- 22:55They don't all listen to them, but certainly a fair number of them do.
- 23:01They hear this, but there's lots of ways for it to trickle down and just
- 23:05sometimes it doesn't seem to be the case.
- 23:08They never said during this webinar that borrowing is bad.
- 23:12They never said non member deposits are bad, um, but amongst our clients, um,
- 23:19they certainly get treated as if borrowing and non member deposits are frowned upon.
- 23:26We're getting findings indoors to reverse the trend in your core deposit
- 23:33migration and use less borrowings and use less non member deposits.
- 23:38And the examiners don't seem to think that there's a cost to that, but there
- 23:42is, because that means you're raising the cost to your whole entire deposit base,
- 23:46which is sometimes much more than the cost to borrow or use non member deposits.
- 23:51And yes, credit unions shouldn't be using those.
- 23:54Funding sources without a plan.
- 23:57Um, but most of them, even our clients that we've talked to a
- 24:00lot of that is part of their plan.
- 24:02And it's an active strategy to not raise their funding costs and then
- 24:06maintain their capital and maintain their earnings and some examiner.
- 24:10They're still just nervous.
- 24:12And like I said, at the beginning.
- 24:14I think in some ways they're reacting to liquidity events in 2022
- 24:19rather than what went on in 2023.
- 24:22The industry seems to have adjusted really well to this rising in
- 24:27rate environment over time.
- 24:30And time heals a lot of wounds is I think something I've heard you say many times.
- 24:35It's not something I've said, but I've gotten that from you.
- 24:38And I think that's where we're at.
- 24:40Where the industry is at is they've adjusted to these high rates.
- 24:44And yes, there's going to be some more adjustments to come yet.
- 24:47And there is going to be some more migration from core deposits to other.
- 24:52Share types, but I think that's all part of a reversion to historical
- 24:58means their members are still adjusting to these high rates as well.
- 25:02We're all adjusting to it a little bit slow, and I'm sure even when rates
- 25:06start going down, whatever date the Fed decides that's going to start to occur.
- 25:12I think you'll still see a lag where they're still going to be
- 25:14credit and they're going to be having to raise deposit rates
- 25:17even when rates start falling.
- 25:19Right.
- 25:20Just right sizes.
- 25:21Themselves to their funding needs and their members needs.
- 25:26Treichel: Just as we were chatting, one of the federal reserve folks, one of
- 25:30the, one of the, one of the districts came out and said, I don't think we're
- 25:33going to drop rates at all this year.
- 25:34So, you know, and oh, by, oh, by the way, the market went down right after he
- 25:38said it, it'll impact rates a little bit.
- 25:41So
- 25:41Miller: from a bank deposit side, I would be fine if rates don't go down,
- 25:46Treichel: right?
- 25:46Yeah.
- 25:47Yeah.
- 25:47I know all those
- 25:48Miller: retirement account balances of growing really fast in the last six months
- 25:52Treichel: and that's that's part of the economic challenge Getting off
- 25:55topic here But the white collar worker and the and those who are well off
- 26:00Economically are doing better than the folks that are having to pay that their
- 26:06grocery bills gone up 10 percent then 20 percent and another 20% And then we get
- 26:11excited that it's only growing at 3%.
- 26:12But yeah, it's of that new inflated rate.
- 26:15And those folks are struggling right now.
- 26:17And it's going to impact credit unions in a lot of ways.
- 26:21Like you, you've said in some other podcasts that, that one of the reasons
- 26:25share growth has disappeared is because they're paying, they're paying for
- 26:29their, their food, they're paying for their gas to get to work instead
- 26:33of putting it into the credit union.
- 26:36Miller: Yeah, I see it just and I belong to a couple of volunteer clubs
- 26:39where you pay dues and we've seen over the last few years where people have.
- 26:43Stepped away or complained about just 150 a year for dues is wait,
- 26:48that's a big bill for me right now.
- 26:50So there is that segment of the population and I think it's bigger
- 26:54than a lot of people suspect.
- 26:56It was last fall or maybe early this spring, the Federal Reserve had
- 27:01their annual little article out of how many people can meet an expense
- 27:05of, I don't know what it was, 400.
- 27:07400,
- 27:07Treichel: yeah.
- 27:08Miller: And it's a huge percentage of people can't.
- 27:12That's why that loan demand is out there in the industry is even though
- 27:17the inflation is down, it's real and it's impacted a lot of people's budgets.
- 27:24Treichel: No doubt.
- 27:25No doubt.
- 27:26I'm looking back to my list of notes.
- 27:281, 2 things.
- 27:29When we were talking about ratios, just cash to assets or cash to
- 27:33shares, there was reference to that.
- 27:34There was reference to loan to assets.
- 27:37Yeah, I've seen, we've become acquainted with some state laws that say you
- 27:41need to have X percent, which seems like a higher percent than any credit
- 27:44union might want to have on the books.
- 27:46But I've also seen some situations where credit unions are being encouraged
- 27:50to increase their cash balance.
- 27:53Um, there is no perfect measure, but when I throw that out there, Todd,
- 27:57does it trigger anything in your head?
- 27:59Miller: I think NCUA is a little nervous about it.
- 28:02In 2022, across the industry, cash and short term assets were down to 10%, which
- 28:08is I think the lowest I have numbers here in front of me going back to 2000.
- 28:13That's the lowest it was ever in 2022.
- 28:17And virtually the highest it ever was in 2020 at 18.
- 28:20So it dropped just tremendously.
- 28:23And then it ended 2023 at 11%, which is.
- 28:27Still below historical norms where it used to run 1315.
- 28:32Part of that though is I think credit unions have actually just
- 28:34gotten more analytic about how much cash do you actually need.
- 28:38And we've seen that after the last recession from 2010 on, at least in
- 28:44the western region, there was a lot of credit unions were tracking daily deposit
- 28:48volatility and things of that nature.
- 28:51And really when they go through those exercises, there's a lot of the larger
- 28:55credit unions, they really only need three to 6 percent to handle a couple
- 29:01standard deviations, a daily deposit.
- 29:03So in the absence of ways to measure how much liquidity they should have,
- 29:09I think the industry as a whole is just carried a lot of excess.
- 29:13Treichel: That's a great point.
- 29:14Yeah.
- 29:14The, the more credit unions.
- 29:17digest the data that they have, the more into a pushes the need to have
- 29:21a good estimate of what your needs are looking forward, the tighter you
- 29:26can get, the closer you can get to reality, which then allows you to
- 29:30trim a few percentages off the cash.
- 29:32That makes sense.
- 29:33Miller: You can manage your risk a little bit more efficiently and allocate it
- 29:37where it Best generates rewards for you.
- 29:41And so a side effect of getting more analytical and being better at
- 29:46measuring numbers is you can ride closer to what the examiner might
- 29:51think is the edge of risk, right?
- 29:53Because they don't see the analytics.
- 29:55They have their different historical perspective of what
- 29:58they think is appropriate.
- 30:00Usually.
- 30:01Based on exams they've done in their district over the year, and
- 30:05that could be smaller cardigans.
- 30:06It could be larger cardigans.
- 30:07It could be a wide divergence, but there's just a great deal of just even the
- 30:12risk acceptance amongst the exam staff.
- 30:15There's quite a variance as to what's acceptable from one examiner to the next.
- 30:21But, you know, when examiners get more analytical, they run things closer
- 30:24to the edge, a higher loan to share ratio, a lower level of liquidity.
- 30:28Take on a little bit more operational risk here, a little bit more credit risk there.
- 30:33Those types of things make examiners nervous when they see credits changing
- 30:38their risk profile, even if they're doing it because they have better
- 30:43analytical tools to manage it.
- 30:45It still makes examiners nervous.
- 30:49Treichel: So the last word I had written down that I wanted to mention was in
- 30:53reference to underwater investments.
- 30:55They had a little bit of discussion of your sources of liquidity
- 30:58and with where rates are at.
- 31:00You've got a lot of credit unions that have investments that are upside down.
- 31:04And quite frankly, if they book loans that are fixed, they're upside down.
- 31:08And it reminds me of something you've said on here and the clients about liquidity.
- 31:15Liquidity can maybe turn into a liquid.
- 31:17I'm going to get this wrong, but here's what it is in my head.
- 31:20Liquidity can be turned into some sort of liquidity event.
- 31:23If you have problems with your asset quality, right?
- 31:25So if you have, if you lose the ability to hold those underwater assets, or you
- 31:29start having loan losses in a way, Okay.
- 31:32That it's eating up your flexibility and your cash that can exacerbate
- 31:37a liquidity event or a liquidity.
- 31:42Miller: With adequate capital, well capitalized, a decent asset quality are
- 31:47always going to be able to go to the wholesale markets and get liquidity.
- 31:51It's never going to be an issue.
- 31:53I mentioned the whole interagency policy statement that was issued back in 2010.
- 31:58That actually has a whole section on credit unions that are have falling
- 32:02capital and are fall into PCA that they need better contingency funding plans.
- 32:08So it breaks them out whole separately.
- 32:10We do have, I think, at least one client that has some capital challenges that.
- 32:15Has to post physical collateral.
- 32:17They haven't been cut off, but they've been asked to post physical collateral
- 32:21just because of where they're at.
- 32:22That's a warning sign.
- 32:24But in general, a well capitalized credit union, you're sitting here
- 32:27eight, 9 percent and your delinquency and charge offs are under control.
- 32:31You are going to be able to go to the second wholesale markets and get liquidity
- 32:38at a reasonable market cost.
- 32:41Treichel: That's a good thing for that credit union.
- 32:43That's a good thing for the industry.
- 32:44It's good.
- 32:45The good thing for the insurance fund, because that's where most credit
- 32:47unions are at, there may be examiners who push, beat them up a little bit
- 32:52more than you and I would like from the side of the table that we sit
- 32:55on now, but you're right, they're going to be able to get access.
- 32:59Miller: Like I said, overall, I think the industry in 2023 has responded
- 33:03to liquidity events and the current market conditions very well, and their
- 33:10liquidity is pretty well managed.
- 33:12Yes, core deposits are still going out the door.
- 33:15They're finding their way into certificates of deposit.
- 33:18Maybe they're going to another institution who's paying a higher CD rate.
- 33:21Down the road, Cardigans have been able to utilize that wholesale funding,
- 33:25borrowings, and increasingly non member deposits to manage through that because
- 33:30they see this as something that we have to manage through for 18 months or 12
- 33:34months or whatever the case may be.
- 33:37And so their whole utilization of those wholesale funding
- 33:42sources is perfectly reasonable.
- 33:45It helps them maintain profitability as they right size
- 33:49those member share offerings.
- 33:52I see it as a positive thing.
- 33:53Treichel: Yeah, me too.
- 33:54It's a tool in their toolbox.
- 33:55So, anything that else you want to highlight before we wrap up today, Todd?
- 33:59Anything we missed?
- 34:00Miller: No, I'll just reiterate this whole webinar.
- 34:03It was just subsets of what was in that interagency policy
- 34:07statement issued back in 2010.
- 34:09There's really nothing new under the sun in terms of how you go and manage this.
- 34:14Yes, you can get more sophisticated.
- 34:16with how you create these cash flows and you can get more sophisticated
- 34:19about your stress test, but really liquidity management about is really
- 34:24about these cash flow forecasts and managing down the road, not looking
- 34:29behind you, but having a forward looking mirror and how do you best.
- 34:33Serve your members.
- 34:36I thought overall the webinar was maybe better than some that NCUA have done.
- 34:42Um, I don't know that larger cardians would have benefited from listening it.
- 34:46Maybe some of the smaller ones have.
- 34:49Um, I've seen it more as a good refresher course on some of these principles.
- 34:54They didn't give you a lot of specifics, but they tend to, regulators
- 34:57tend to not do that in webinars.
- 35:00Treichel: That's a fact.
- 35:01That's a fact.
- 35:02We've seen that, uh, we've, we lived it when we were there and we see it
- 35:06from a different angle right now.
- 35:07And I would agree it was better than the average as far as information.
- 35:11Miller: I always ask at least one question on these webinars
- 35:14just to see if they'll answer it.
- 35:16I don't know.
- 35:16I may be about 1 for 10 right now over the last few.
- 35:19Treichel: Yeah, I think I'm, I think I'm like 1 for 15.
- 35:21I'm gonna, I'm gonna log in as, I don't know, Johnny Rockets or something
- 35:25next time so they can't tell it's me.
- 35:29Miller: I haven't thought about doing that.
- 35:32Yeah, it might change the results.
- 35:34If we do that,
- 35:34Treichel: they figure if we ask the question, it might be a loaded one.
- 35:37Miller: Yeah, sometimes I asked benign ones that should be easy to answer.
- 35:41And they still don't.
- 35:44They see my name.
- 35:45I'm saying, no, not you, Todd.
- 35:47Treichel: Yeah, that's right.
- 35:48Yeah, that's right.
- 35:49We're going to answer all the credit union questions first.
- 35:52All right, Todd, thank you so much for your time and listening to that, that,
- 35:57that hour and sharing your thoughts with, with our audience here today.
- 36:01I appreciate it.
- 36:03Have a great day, Mark.
- 36:05You too, Todd.
- 36:05And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 36:08I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 36:09Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 36:17Katie: Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 36:21Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 36:25experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 36:30If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 36:33out our services at marktreichel.
- 36:35com.