Latest / Newcomer Pod / Staying Global (with Bejul Somaia)
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to the Newcomer podcast. I'm Eric Newcomer.
- 0:04I had an awesome conversation with Bajol Somaya at Lightspeed
- 0:09Venture Partners talked about two huge topics in the world of
- 0:12venture capital India. Bajol spent many years investing
- 0:17for Lightspeed in India and for the ups and downs of the venture
- 0:21market. And then in the latter half hour
- 0:24of our conversation, we looked at how venture capital is
- 0:28becoming more like the private equity business, What happens to
- 0:32venture capital in a world of rising interest rates And how
- 0:35does he think about the future of a venture capital firm that
- 0:39has more than $7 billion in funds raised to invest?
- 0:44It's great conversation deep in the world of venture capital.
- 0:48Give it a list, Bejil. Welcome to the podcast.
- 0:51Thanks so much for coming on. Thanks, Eric.
- 0:53It's great to be on. There's a lot here.
- 0:56You've sort of taken the journey with Lightspeed and growing up
- 1:00with what's become a huge firm. I thought part of the episode,
- 1:04we just get to sort of look at what's going on outside the US,
- 1:08especially since you spent a bunch of time in India, spent
- 1:10some time thinking about Europe, and then get to the US but sort
- 1:13of trying to make sense of the global venture landscape.
- 1:19How did you get to Lightspeed India or get us to that moment
- 1:22in time sort of working with Lightspeed India?
- 1:26Yeah. And just before I do, you know,
- 1:27something felt jarring to me, which is that, you know, this
- 1:30idea of a huge firm and the reason it felt jarring to me is
- 1:33because we don't think of ourselves that way and I don't
- 1:37think we ever want to show up in the market in that way.
- 1:40I think there's such an art to our business and there's such a
- 1:43sort of relationship aspect to the business and a sense of just
- 1:48a very high degree of personalization and often being
- 1:50large can conflict with that. And that's actually, you know,
- 1:53I'm sure we'll talk about later what's the total fund size?
- 1:56So I lost set of funds that we raised early last year, Eric,
- 1:59were just under 7 billion. Yeah, across early and growth
- 2:03vehicles that we've raised over time and the growth vehicles are
- 2:06global vehicles, you know, but it's just sort of more one of
- 2:09the things we think about a lot, right, is how we continue to
- 2:13operate in a very nimble, agile way.
- 2:16Right. And that's while having what is
- 2:18objectively a huge amount of money, yes.
- 2:21That's fair. That's fair.
- 2:22But anyway, we'll come to that. I know.
- 2:23I know. I get it, you know.
- 2:25So like my journey has been really, you know, as a
- 2:27entrepreneur and operator, you know, and an investor or across
- 2:30sort of different parts of my career in the US and in India.
- 2:35I was in the US until I moved to India to start up Lightspeed
- 2:39business in 2008. And out of Business School, you
- 2:42know, was a participant in the.com craziness.
- 2:45As an early member of a startup during that time, and I think I
- 2:48still sort of have that, you know, etched into my memo was
- 2:51the startup. It's a company called edu.com
- 2:54that was creating a sort of a protected channel for brands to
- 2:57sell to students at differential pricing and so integrated with
- 3:00colleges to create a protected channel where brands could.
- 3:03And that was in the Bay Area. That was actually on the East
- 3:06Coast okbutduring.com. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:09And I was an early member of the team there.
- 3:12And that company was acquired, you know, really in an asset
- 3:15sale in early 2001 by a then public company called Student
- 3:19Advantage. And that's where I met the
- 3:21General Catalyst team because they were one of the, you know,
- 3:24early investors in that business.
- 3:26And after I served out my six months of the transition, Joel,
- 3:30over a General Catalyst, who I think understands entrepreneurs
- 3:33very well, called me and said, hey, you must be pretty fed up
- 3:36of doing that. Why don't you come over and join
- 3:38us. And this is just when General
- 3:39Catalyst was getting going. You know, as an institutional
- 3:42fund and yeah, I loved it because it was my first exposure
- 3:45to venture, but in a very entrepreneurial environment.
- 3:48And that continues again to shape a lot of, you know, how I
- 3:52practiced the Business Today and how we think about the business.
- 3:56And then in 2003, I just was so envious of all of these
- 4:00incredibly passionate founders building things and I stepped
- 4:04out and I started a company focused on local search and
- 4:07context specific search. This was before it was.
- 4:10You know, it was as widely known as it is today.
- 4:14And the idea being that, gosh, there's all of this information
- 4:17out there, but yet I just bought a home and I was rifling through
- 4:21the Yellow Pages and calling service providers who had bought
- 4:25the biggest ads. This is crazy, You know, that
- 4:28this cannot possibly be how I'm going to make a decision.
- 4:32And so that kind of led me to think about how do we bring
- 4:35technology to really understand the information that's out there
- 4:38in a context specific way. And started that company with
- 4:41actually the former CTO of edu.com who I got to know, and
- 4:45then subsequently someone that's become a dear friend of mine,
- 4:48Brad Gerstner at Altimeter. And Brad and I had cross pots
- 4:52originally. He was an ambassador or a
- 4:53cofounder. No.
- 4:54So he joined as a cofounder and yeah, And we first met, Yeah,
- 4:58when he was running. National Leisure Group which was
- 5:01a general catalyst funded business and so you know we got
- 5:04going and eventually we didn't raise any outside capital but
- 5:07ended up selling the business to a public company called March X
- 5:10at the time. And and that was kind of really
- 5:13when I thought about my life and career in a slightly different
- 5:16way And and I was really drawn to what was happening in India.
- 5:19You know, the country was going through a very significant
- 5:21period of economic growth, lot of innovation happening and I
- 5:25moved out there and actually for the first few years I was
- 5:28running a. You know what would typically be
- 5:30described as a more traditional growth equity business, you know
- 5:33a manufacturing business that you know here would be a GDP
- 5:37growth business, but there was growing at about 3035% a year,
- 5:41but was very myopic, very inward facing.
- 5:44And I thought there was so much more that we could do with that
- 5:46business and it was a wonderful way to learn that country and
- 5:49that market and actually learn a lot about how applying a US lens
- 5:54or a developed market lens is not only.
- 5:58The wrong answer, but can actually, you know, be
- 6:01problematic. And that was really valuable and
- 6:04ultimately sort of brought that to bear And in what we ended up
- 6:07building at Lightspeed, how long were you investing in India and
- 6:11how much was deployed? So look, I you know today Eric,
- 6:17we have now we think of the region as India, Southeast Asia
- 6:20because there's actually a lot of talent movement between those
- 6:24regions, founder movement. And companies from India, when
- 6:27they're thinking about getting out of India, often Southeast
- 6:30Asia is the next frontier. So I think about that region,
- 6:33you know, we have today 19 investment professionals in the
- 6:37and then an operating team or a platform team that supports our
- 6:40portfolio of about 10, So quite sizable across 4 offices, Delhi,
- 6:46Bangalore, Mumbai and Singapore. And you know, since we started
- 6:51investing in India, we've invested approximately 1 1/2
- 6:54billion dollars in the market. So it's, you know, it's
- 6:57meaningful, but kind of always I think timed to how the market
- 7:01was developing. So actually up until 2015, we
- 7:05continued to invest out of our global funds at a very measured
- 7:08pace. And you know, again, many of our
- 7:10peers had raised dedicated fund vehicles and there were a set of
- 7:13local homegrown funds as well. You know, we knew this was a
- 7:18market we wanted to be in, but we didn't think it warranted A
- 7:21dedicated strategy up until sort of I'd say in 1314.
- 7:25We began to see changes on the ground, founder quality, more
- 7:28risk capital and sort of really now the beginning of significant
- 7:32Internet adoption, right, which is really the trend line that
- 7:35we're investing behind. And so in 2015, we raised our
- 7:38first dedicated early stage fund for the market, but it was still
- 7:42a very. I think a very disciplined size
- 7:45at 135 million. You know, fund two was 175, fund
- 7:50three was 275 and the idea was really to keep the bar high, you
- 7:55know, to focus on the highest impact opportunities, you know
- 7:59and then over time as we've raised our growth funds if we do
- 8:02miss things at early, which obviously we do.
- 8:04Then we do have the ability now to hopefully still be able to
- 8:07partner with those entrepreneurs later in their journey.
- 8:09What were the key companies or like?
- 8:11What successful investments did you see?
- 8:14So early on an early investment in a company called Tudor Vista,
- 8:17which was essentially one of the first companies that was
- 8:20connecting in that case tutors in that market with students
- 8:24globally. So a very early incarceration of
- 8:27Ed tech. That company was acquired in a
- 8:29trade sale by Pearson. What was one of the early exits
- 8:33in the market And then an investment that I led in 2010 in
- 8:36a company called the Indian Energy Exchange, which was
- 8:39building an electronic market for power.
- 8:42You know, and this is an example actually of where, you know,
- 8:45when we talked about it in the partnership and the natural
- 8:47thing to do is to seek analogs, Where else has this been built?
- 8:51And the answer was nowhere. And then it can be very well.
- 8:54If there's no examples of success, we shouldn't do it.
- 8:56It obviously can't be successful.
- 8:58But we should have got into being very first principles
- 9:00about what's happening in the power market in India and why
- 9:04does something like this need to exist.
- 9:06And I won't bore you with the details, but there was a set of
- 9:09reasons why something like this needed to exist and it was a
- 9:12classic example of how we could think about getting venture type
- 9:16exposure to a sector like energy or power, right.
- 9:21That was going through a massive investment cycle.
- 9:24And so we Co led the company's Series A and actually the only
- 9:28round of external capital that they ended up raising in late 20
- 9:31and and that company we took public in 2017 and the local
- 9:35Stock Exchange and then over time fully exited over the
- 9:39subsequent few years. So that was one of our sort of
- 9:42early investments and it helps right when you go to a new
- 9:44market to to know that you can, you know, invest but also take
- 9:49money out and get a company public and see the full life
- 9:52cycle. Is this strategy generally like
- 9:55looking for companies that can be global players or do you
- 9:58invest in startups that could just sort of dominate the Indian
- 10:03tech market and would that be sort of large enough?
- 10:06It's all of the above, right? Typically on the consumer side
- 10:09and on some B to BI wouldn't say B to B software.
- 10:13I don't think the Indian market for software is large enough to
- 10:16support a high impact company. But those are those companies
- 10:21tend to get outside India. For example, we have a company
- 10:24called Innovasor which is focused on the healthcare
- 10:26segment in software that got outside India very early or
- 10:30Darwin Box and HR SAS you know that you know built in India now
- 10:34has gone to Southeast Asia. But in I would say in consumer
- 10:39that tends to be almost exclusively focused on the
- 10:41domestic economy and you know, B to B networks or B to B
- 10:45commerce. You know will typically be
- 10:47focused or B to B fintech. You know on the local economy
- 10:51what we're now seeing more recently as the founder universe
- 10:58has sort of become more confident I think bolder
- 11:00building better products is we're seeing more of them today.
- 11:04Start off with A we want to build for the world kind of you
- 11:08know mindset which is really energizing and one area that
- 11:12we're specifically seeing a lot of that and if invested behind
- 11:15is. Are sort of B to B marketplaces
- 11:17that are connecting supply in India and other markets with
- 11:22demand globally, you know, primarily starting out with the
- 11:26US and the idea being that you have, you know, with the
- 11:29disruption from COVID of supply chains, right.
- 11:32And then the geopolitical issues with China, there's a very
- 11:35strong movement towards China plus one sourcing, right?
- 11:39And a lot of the supply base is actually in the Southeast Asia
- 11:42region and India region, India, Vietnam, Thailand, so on.
- 11:46And so how do you now connect that supply right with buyers
- 11:50anywhere in the world? And so we're beginning to see
- 11:52ideas like that emerge and investing actively behind that.
- 11:56Again, it's one of the reasons that we're so excited about
- 11:59continuing to build a global firm because we see ideas like
- 12:03this. I feel like a lot of the like
- 12:05India's story that trickles back to Silicon Valley has been know
- 12:08the Flipkart Wars and like Amazon diving in and all the
- 12:13investment around that space. What was the impact of that
- 12:16enthusiasm on sort of the Indian like startup ecosystem and how
- 12:21did you guys sort of navigate? That, yeah, you know, I think
- 12:24the first, I mean this is sort of an observation now with
- 12:27hindsight across various different markets is the first
- 12:30generation of companies often tends to be copycats, right, for
- 12:34better or for worse. And that's okay.
- 12:36You know, we saw in India it would be the online travel
- 12:39agents in e-commerce, Flipkart, Amazon ride sharing and.
- 12:44Online booking for shows and movies and so on.
- 12:49There were the deal a day businesses at one point until
- 12:51folks realize that it is a different market that doesn't
- 12:54work there, right? And it's really interesting
- 12:55because I think investors are equally culpable, right?
- 12:58Investors will oh, that's an idea that's working in market X.
- 13:03So I will invest in market Y, except market Y may not support
- 13:08that particular idea. And then if founders sense that
- 13:12investors want to invest there, well, guess what, they'll start
- 13:15a company and they'll go raise money.
- 13:16And so that's invariably the first set of companies.
- 13:19And then we started to see, and I EX was an example, another
- 13:23company that we've invested in and you know very early and has
- 13:26grown a significant scale is a company called Oyo, which is a
- 13:28virtual hospitality network. You start seeing founders build
- 13:32companies with a lot more nuance and understanding of how those
- 13:37models need to be adapted for the local market.
- 13:40And I would actually go so far as to say that in most
- 13:44businesses where there is sort of a real world component or
- 13:47linkage including ecommerce or ride sharing, the Indian
- 13:51startups have competed very strongly with what are the best
- 13:56companies out of the US. So whether it is Flipkart and
- 13:59Amazon or Ola and Uber or Makemytrip and Expedia.
- 14:05The Ornokri, which is the job site and early on Monster,
- 14:09actually what you see is that the Indian companies are winning
- 14:14or are certainly very strong competitors on the food side,
- 14:17Swiggy and Zamato, right. And so I think that's been very
- 14:22energizing for the startup ecosystem where the products
- 14:25tend to be more fully virtual and catering to, let's say the
- 14:3080 to 100 million English speaking population.
- 14:34Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, there it will typically be and
- 14:38is the global products that dominate because there isn't
- 14:41this real world nuance and component.
- 14:44Although once you get beyond that English speaking population
- 14:47again there's probably a need. And you know, we're investors in
- 14:49a company called Share Chat, which is a social network for
- 14:52actually none of the English speaking audience.
- 14:55You know and so I think then what you start seeing is these
- 14:58businesses that are being built actually that are very unique to
- 15:01the market and that's really exciting to us because those
- 15:04businesses will typically also have higher defensibility and
- 15:07stronger capital efficiency. And so today what is the level
- 15:11of enthusiasm for like India with the firm.
- 15:15So you just for context for listener when get into this, you
- 15:18know you come back eventually to the US to sort of focus on the
- 15:22firm and investments here, but yeah, you're still very involved
- 15:25in sort of the strategy. Absolutely.
- 15:28So what is the sort of approach at the moment or what's your
- 15:30sense of the market and how much capital you're putting behind
- 15:34it? I think this is true about
- 15:35technology. Investing in general, which is
- 15:38the long arc, is really a one way street right?
- 15:41This is something that is chatting with one of my
- 15:43colleagues about earlier In 2000, the digital economy in the
- 15:46US represented about 6% share of GDP.
- 15:50You know, today that's at 10.2% and obviously absolute GDP has
- 15:53grown. This is in the US, right.
- 15:54So there's just significant growth and it will be no
- 15:57different in the other markets that we invest behind.
- 16:00And so you know in India when we think about just overall GDP
- 16:04growth, population growth, but adoption of the Internet and
- 16:07digital technologies, it is a one way St. and so kind of over
- 16:12the right horizon. You know, I think that our level
- 16:15of excitement remains very high. Although not rose colored for
- 16:20lots of reasons that we can talk about right and it sort of
- 16:23reflects why we've paced the way that we have.
- 16:26That said you know I think anytime you over index on a
- 16:28point in time and that could have been 2022 or 2021 in
- 16:33technology you know or 2022 in global technology you know or a
- 16:38point in time like you know 2223 in India.
- 16:42You know clearly activity is lower.
- 16:44I would argue that's really healthy.
- 16:46You know, 2021. We know was out of control
- 16:50everywhere, but in shallow markets, Eric, out of control is
- 16:55even more damaging, right, because the asset price
- 16:59inflation is even more significant in shallow markets,
- 17:03right. And sort of the movements are
- 17:05more jarring. And so I think it's healthy,
- 17:08it's necessary, it's painful, But again, if I draw from my
- 17:13experienceinthe.com, boom, you know, in the US and then the
- 17:17subsequent. You know, bust in 2001, I
- 17:19remember looking at these numbers.
- 17:21So the peak of US venture capital in 2000 was about 180
- 17:26billion. In 2002 that number was 20
- 17:30billion. Brutal, brutal, right.
- 17:33And I remember it because it was like, Oh my gosh, I mean this is
- 17:36when I was at GC kind of early and it's like, do we need to
- 17:40exist, You know, it just wasn't clear what was investable and
- 17:45what was going to come next and. You know, and what we know today
- 17:49is during those periods of capital scarcity, you know, true
- 17:53innovation happened and true builders were still drawn to
- 17:56solving problems using technology.
- 17:59But in that moment in time, I remember it was entirely
- 18:02possible to think that nothing was happening, right.
- 18:06And so again, I tend to sort of want to be able to see what's
- 18:09happening today clearly so that I can be and we can be
- 18:13intellectually honest. But I think equally importantly,
- 18:16to be able to pull up and say okay, what is the trend line
- 18:19here? You know, what's happening?
- 18:21Where is that going? And to consistently question
- 18:23whether there's a challenge to that thesis, whether it's
- 18:26technology more broadly or the development of India's digital
- 18:29economy and SE Asia's digital economy, do you have a dedicated
- 18:33amount of capital? On the early stage side, we just
- 18:36raised Lightspeed India for that, we started investing out
- 18:39of early this year, which is a $500 million vehicle.
- 18:42And that reflects our view of how the opportunity has
- 18:45continued to grow, but we still want to be measured, right.
- 18:49And then on on the growth side, there's no allocation.
- 18:52You know, we tend to focus on the best opportunities.
- 18:55And so, yeah, if you think about the dedicated pool, it's that
- 18:58500 million, you're probably more of a scholar of this than I
- 19:01am. But you know US venture has sort
- 19:03of a history of diving into regions and then sort of pulling
- 19:08back with you know like Europe like a benchmark I think used to
- 19:12have a presence in Europe and you know they're all sort you
- 19:14know in and out like China, India have sort of been hot and
- 19:19then not. And I totally hear what you're
- 19:21saying about overtime like technology continues to eat more
- 19:24markets but then you you need like or at least the traditional
- 19:27venture ecosystem depends on follow on rounds and other firms
- 19:31playing and you know obviously you and me but to put it out for
- 19:36the listener like at this moment in time, you know Sequoia has
- 19:38just sort of spun off its China and India fund sort of moving
- 19:43away from a global firm like focusing on those regions.
- 19:48Yeah. So I guess where are we in this
- 19:50sort of venture mood in India right now?
- 19:54Or do you see sort of other investors sort of as dedicated
- 19:58at this move? Yeah, I can't comment on Sequoia
- 20:02and I'm not Privy to, you know, sort of the thinking behind
- 20:05their decisions, but I can sort of comment on how we think about
- 20:08this. It's really hard to build a
- 20:10global firm, you know, and it's really hard to attract the right
- 20:15kind of talent to inculcate again that shared vocabulary and
- 20:20sense of of mission and values and culture.
- 20:23And do you see what I see and trust which is so foundational
- 20:27to our business, It's difficult and I think that's one of the
- 20:31main reasons I would suspect that firms that have gone
- 20:35internationally, you know, may subsequently have sort of
- 20:38retrenched and anytime something is, is really difficult, really
- 20:41hard. Naturally the right question to
- 20:43ask yourself is it worth it? You know, and I think that's a
- 20:47very personal question. In many cases, it's personal at
- 20:51the individual level, right. Because for a firm to go to
- 20:54another market does require, you know, someone that has political
- 20:59capital within the firm at that point in time to put their hand
- 21:02up and say, I'm going to invest my time and energy, you know, to
- 21:05do this right. And so that individual will ask
- 21:08them whether it's worth it, will ask themselves whether it's
- 21:10worth it. The firm will ask themselves
- 21:12whether it's worth it. And you know, that argument can
- 21:16be made well if within a 30 minute drive from Sand Hill Rd.
- 21:20as was the case not so long ago. If I can, you know, find a set
- 21:25of companies that are great, why do I need to go beyond that?
- 21:29Right. And I would argue then that that
- 21:30thinking would apply to why go to New York, why go to LA,
- 21:35right. Why go to Europe?
- 21:37Why go to Lat Am? I mean, why go beyond 30 minutes
- 21:40of Sandhill Road? And that's what Venture used to
- 21:42be. Why go to Boston, right?
- 21:45There was this long period where, you know, it was like
- 21:47totally cool to just say like, we love San Francisco, Silicon
- 21:52Valley, like startups and everything else is sort of like
- 21:54a distraction. And that was something you would
- 21:57hear pretty regularly, I think, the pandemic.
- 22:00Blew a lot of that up. You know, all of a sudden people
- 22:02were excited about Europe. It was easier to do deals
- 22:06abroad. I mean, obviously there have
- 22:08been other moments where people were, but I think the pandemic
- 22:11in particular was like there was a brief period where it was like
- 22:14everything's global. Everybody can invest everywhere.
- 22:17Like there's an arbitrage. Like people started, you know,
- 22:20sending partners out to Europe and now like, I mean.
- 22:24Some of the, you know, Hoppin is sort of more challenged UI path
- 22:28didn't sustain like some of the actual companies that were
- 22:31fueling the narrative didn't sort of live up.
- 22:34And then at the same time now we're seeing that so much
- 22:37adventure is in AI and AI is really centralized, you know, in
- 22:44Silicon Valley and San Francisco.
- 22:45I don't, yeah. So what do you make of?
- 22:47Sort of the return to, sort of? Silicon Valley exceptionalism in
- 22:52in sort of the adventure world at the moment.
- 22:53Yeah, I don't think there's a right or a wrong answer right.
- 22:57I think different firms, different people, different
- 23:00personalities, different strategies, different ambitions,
- 23:04different levels of hunger and kind of fire to go build
- 23:08something. Remember again, part of what you
- 23:10need to even consider in a sense, you know going and doing
- 23:14something and building something larger and expanding the
- 23:17cannabis is the same way with a founder, right?
- 23:19They'll be founders who will build a company that they want
- 23:22to own 100% of and they're fine if that company grows 15% of a
- 23:26year and throws off a certain amount of cash.
- 23:28And then there are some founders who want to change the world and
- 23:31we're not judging, you know one is better than the other.
- 23:34We know that for venture Capital One is more of the type that we
- 23:37would back than the other. And so I think it's the same in
- 23:40venture which is it's a function of what the firms and the
- 23:44individuals aspiration is, right.
- 23:47And if you don't have people that are willing to say, geez, I
- 23:50have a burning desire to go do this because I see this
- 23:53opportunity, well then you know that will be as big a part of
- 23:57the discussion as where a I is or where the opportunity is.
- 24:01You know what I would tell you is the way we think about it,
- 24:04Lightspeed is what are we optimizing for, right, because
- 24:07we've got to have that clarity and that then drives our
- 24:10decisions. So it's three things.
- 24:13We want to see access and compete for the very best
- 24:17opportunities wherever they are, because to generate the best
- 24:21returns, we think we need to be in the best companies.
- 24:25And if a significant proportion of those companies are now
- 24:27outside the US or outside Silicon Valley, then we need to
- 24:33be able to see them in order to perform right.
- 24:36Again, part of this is also a choice about scale.
- 24:38Sure. If you raise $200 million, you
- 24:41don't need to, but it's also because of learning.
- 24:44I mean, a lot of what we bring to our companies is because of
- 24:46the journeys that we've been on, you know, and the different
- 24:49models that we've seen and how our conceptual models get
- 24:53challenged because you've seen something somewhere else.
- 24:55I would argue that actually, you know, markets like India where
- 24:58there's UPI and Latdam where there's pigs are a little bit,
- 25:02you know, showing us what the future of fintech could be, you
- 25:05know, with these very low cost or 0 cost payment rails, right.
- 25:09I think, you know, we saw virtual goods models and kind
- 25:13of, you know, monetization models that came out of China,
- 25:16right, that innovated around kind of how social media
- 25:20companies could monetize and generate revenue.
- 25:22So for the learning and the experience, we think that's
- 25:25important. So we want to see access and
- 25:27compete for the very best opportunities wherever they are.
- 25:30The second thing is we want to serve founders and companies in
- 25:34the most impactful way, right, in a way that moves the needle
- 25:37for them. So that's sort of another design
- 25:39principle. And the third is that we want to
- 25:42attract the best talent to Lightspeed and enable them to do
- 25:46their best work. Those are the three things we
- 25:48want to do. Now for any other firm, those
- 25:52things may be different and that's okay, but this is what
- 25:55we're building towards. And then the question becomes,
- 25:59you know, well, do you get distracted, right?
- 26:02And I think in my mind, anytime I'm presented with this idea of
- 26:07a trade off, you can either do X or Y.
- 26:11The first thing at least I want to do is I want to challenge
- 26:15that trade off. I don't want to just accept it,
- 26:17right, because then we go deeper and understanding why there is a
- 26:20trade off. Is there a trade off, you know,
- 26:23we say to companies, well either you grow fast or you have
- 26:27compelling unit economics really.
- 26:30Is that really the choice, You know to build value you have to
- 26:34do both and the best companies will figure out a way to do both
- 26:38and some will not. And so for us, I think it is,
- 26:42you know, it is well, how do we, our enterprise team is we think
- 26:46one of the best in the business. Well, they are deeply focused on
- 26:50enterprise, right. They're not getting distracted
- 26:54by necessarily what the India team is doing, but then
- 26:57organizationally, how do you create points of intersection so
- 27:00that we're exchanging ideas, right, and experiences.
- 27:05So to me that comes to firm design and being very mindful of
- 27:09the risks and obviously we're still building this, but you
- 27:12know we. People, is it right now
- 27:14globally? Yeah, Total headcount will be
- 27:16north of 200 and I think we have about 70 investors you know
- 27:21globally across the US, Israel, Europe, India, Southeast Asia,
- 27:28you know in the China is an affiliate.
- 27:29So in a sense separate business and so that would be the size
- 27:32and we've been at it since I think Israel was a first in the
- 27:36national market in the early 2000s.
- 27:39So this isn't a new thing for us.
- 27:42It's not something we've done quickly.
- 27:44You know, we've not tried to do things overnight.
- 27:47Are you still gung ho about the China affiliate?
- 27:50I mean, the tensions there have. You know become more
- 27:54complicated. Yes, certainly and we have to be
- 27:56you know mindful of that. I think you know it is a in a
- 27:58sense of benefit that is an independent entity and I think
- 28:02sort of their investment strategy primarily centers right
- 28:05now around sustainability, climate and the EV ecosystem.
- 28:09And so there's some learning there.
- 28:11But you know, I would say that it's a good relationship that we
- 28:14have and you know we are very sensitive to kind of everything
- 28:18that's happening globally. And you know it'll be something
- 28:21that we continue to think about what the right answer is.
- 28:24But you know, as of now it is run separately, but you know
- 28:29they're friends of ours, just like you know any other firm
- 28:31would be. And you can collaborate and
- 28:33share notes you know and learnings about things.
- 28:35But you know in essence it is a separate business.
- 28:39Just before I totally move off India and start talking about
- 28:41like firm construction all that. What do you think are the most
- 28:44promising areas in terms of India like startup investments
- 28:48right now or where are you guys deploying sort of the most money
- 28:52or what sort of the promise? So you know one area that I
- 28:55mentioned earlier is a lot of these cross-border businesses
- 28:58beyond software, so cross-border marketplaces, cross-border
- 29:02payments and in payment infrastructure.
- 29:05And so if if five years ago, if we talked about what businesses
- 29:09were getting outside of India, those were primarily SAS
- 29:12companies. You know, today I would say
- 29:14there's a lot more in these other categories and I think
- 29:17that's a very compelling theme. The other is we're beginning to
- 29:20see a fair amount of activity around the EV ecosystem there
- 29:24and we've made an initial set of investments.
- 29:27Like manufacturers or no. Again, we'll think about a
- 29:30little bit like our India Energy exchange, you know, kind of lens
- 29:33which is gosh, there's this very compelling trend line, but you
- 29:37know the bulk of it is not really a venture play, right.
- 29:43But how do we think about getting venture like exposure.
- 29:46And so for example, we've invested in a company called
- 29:49Exponent Energy which is building fast charging batteries
- 29:52and intellectual property and then a fast charging network in
- 29:56a sense that's tied to their batteries.
- 29:59And so think about Intel inside, you know the Exponent battery is
- 30:03now being adopted by OE M's you know so that their customers
- 30:07don't have to think. This is primarily in commercial
- 30:09applications where downtime can be very expensive.
- 30:13And so you know OEMs are adopting their batteries with an
- 30:17Exponent battery inside makes it more marketable.
- 30:19You know those batteries then work at the Exponent franchised
- 30:23fast charging network. So that's an example, it's
- 30:25really an IP business you know within the you know the network
- 30:28being franchised. So that would be an example of
- 30:32the venture play on that sector. We are looking at financial
- 30:36technology in particular in Southeast Asia.
- 30:40We've invested fairly actively in India there as well.
- 30:43But you know there's a lot to be built in Southeast Asia and
- 30:45that's an example of you know, kind of global themes, right.
- 30:49The CFO suite or you know, these financial products for small
- 30:53businesses, right, with different insertion points.
- 30:56It could be a credit insertion point or a banking insertion
- 30:59point. That's an area that we've
- 31:00invested across geographies in the US and Europe and India and
- 31:04in Southeast Asia. And wealth management, digital
- 31:07wealth management is an area that we're looking at too.
- 31:10What do you think is sort of the biggest strength of the Indian
- 31:12market right now, the opportunity and the biggest sort
- 31:15of like blocker or like barrier to making sort of investments at
- 31:19the moment? It's really interesting
- 31:20question. I think the biggest strength is
- 31:25the raw material for our business which is the founders.
- 31:28You know, it's really interesting.
- 31:29When we started investing in India, I would have
- 31:31characterized the typical Indian founder as a somewhat defensive,
- 31:38risk averse control oriented founder archetype, right, which
- 31:44is not great for venture capital.
- 31:45And I would characterize today, you know, the founder archetype
- 31:49is no different than what we would talk about here, which is,
- 31:53you know, wanting to change the world really can lean into not
- 31:57everyone but leans into risk and they've sort of seen this first
- 32:01wave of venture scale companies get built, right.
- 32:03And so there's a repeat flywheel and founders really are and
- 32:07talent is the raw material of our business, right.
- 32:10And so you know, for me that's the most exciting change instead
- 32:14of the, if you will, the superpower of the market.
- 32:17And I will say the work ethic. I mean you've got to realize
- 32:20that many of these folks or almost all of these folks are
- 32:23from Indian middle class families.
- 32:26Now when I say Indian middle class, I do not mean US middle
- 32:29class, right. I mean, you know, families with
- 32:33income levels of of $3000 to $15,000, like they're from those
- 32:38families, insanely driven, you know, and what they've had to
- 32:42accomplish to get to this point. You know, is it self evidence of
- 32:46really what's under the hood and the work ethic, you know, the
- 32:50intensity, the hunger, it's sort of you know, like gives me
- 32:54whatever, you know, shivers up my spine because there is this
- 32:57sense of this is their moment, right.
- 33:01And then obviously the rapid digitization of this country and
- 33:03the government's commitment to that, you know, rides along with
- 33:07the development of talent. You know what are maybe some of
- 33:10the biggest challenges. I think it is the time it takes
- 33:14to build these companies and the just the challenges in the
- 33:19economics and and these are related.
- 33:21So here's a really interesting thing, which is because GDP per
- 33:25capita is so much lower in a market like India than in the
- 33:28West, to build a billion dollar revenue or scale company in
- 33:34India means that operationally you are building an 8 to $10
- 33:40billion scale company in the US, right?
- 33:44Because the terms of like people you touch, right, whatever in
- 33:47terms of the volume of transactions, the number of
- 33:49people you acquire touch, the number of shipments, the supply
- 33:52chain scale, just think about that, right.
- 33:56So the complexity of that, you know it's really high and what
- 34:02it means is it will take longer and we can't force it beyond a
- 34:06certain point. Capital forcing capital into
- 34:08these companies is not necessarily the answer and I
- 34:11think we've learned that time and again.
- 34:14So that's one. And then because you know
- 34:17typically GDP per capita is lower, that translates into a
- 34:21smaller absolute profit pool, right.
- 34:24And so you know in terms of the unit economics, it can be tough
- 34:28and so profitability actually takes longer for many of these
- 34:32companies especially if you're trying to scale and build
- 34:36leadership. So I think those are important
- 34:38challenges that we have to be mindful of as we're company
- 34:42building. And then as it relates to
- 34:43investing, look liquidity, this is not a market that is as
- 34:48developed as the US or China. And so you know we've been very
- 34:53mindful of this. We've distributed you know, over
- 34:56a billion dollars of liquidity from the market, you know, but
- 34:59it's tough to come by. You have to be very switched on
- 35:02to it. And so I'd say as a venture
- 35:04investor, you know that's another challenge that we think
- 35:07a lot about. As a global firm, how much do
- 35:10you force sort of consistent multiples or you know, you're
- 35:15just sort of saying the challenge like if you looked at
- 35:18sort of users, you might think one thing if you tried to model
- 35:21out, you know. Profitability or whatever, you
- 35:23would come to a different assessment, but how much is
- 35:27there an effort to say, oh, we want not think about like, oh,
- 35:32what this sort of game on the field is in any particular
- 35:34market. We want to think about what a
- 35:35company is worth on some global metric or do you end up having
- 35:39to look at it region by region? So substitute region for sector,
- 35:44Eric. OK, right.
- 35:46Would we apply consistent multiples to AI companies?
- 35:53Mature enterprise software spaces?
- 35:56Ecommerce, Social media? Right.
- 35:59The answer is no. You can make some argument that
- 36:02on a fundamental level, like their ability to eventually
- 36:04produce cash flow, they should root out.
- 36:07But I understand sort of in the early stage that becomes like
- 36:10very difficult and so you have to, yeah, it's sort of I think
- 36:13there always is nuance. Now should we be aware of that?
- 36:17Yes. If we see a significant
- 36:19difference in multiple, should we question why?
- 36:22Yes. Should we understand why?
- 36:24Yes. You know, should we apply our
- 36:26own judgment? Absolutely right.
- 36:29But you know, one of the things you'll notice is that scaled
- 36:33companies that become market leaders and have high quality
- 36:36teams with strong governance in India trade at significant
- 36:41premiums to their peers almost anywhere in the world.
- 36:45Interesting. All right.
- 36:46Now early on, we as a global firm, we just couldn't reconcile
- 36:50that. We're like, no, it seems too
- 36:51expensive, seems too expensive. Well, 15 years in, it hasn't
- 36:56changed, Okay. So then you sort of say why?
- 36:59Well, there's several reasons. One is that those companies are
- 37:05so difficult to replicate because of the friction required
- 37:10to build them and the time that it takes, right, that there's a
- 37:15certain kind of gravity that those businesses have and
- 37:19there's a scarcity of those kinds of businesses, right?
- 37:22And so now when you think about capital allocators in the world
- 37:26that want to have exposure to those kinds of companies,
- 37:29there's a limited set, right? And so this is what I mean by we
- 37:34don't just want to accept it and we'll never just say, well, it's
- 37:36sort of like in 2021 when we were investing, we weren't
- 37:40assuming 2021 multiples on exit. You're still questioning it.
- 37:44You're saying what are normalized multiples.
- 37:46And OK, let's be eyes wide open that we may be overpaying on the
- 37:49way in, but let's not think this is normal, right?
- 37:53Right. Part of what you're saying is
- 37:54the multiples that are rational to pay to win the deal and the
- 37:57multiples that you're sort of giving it to assess sort of the
- 38:01payoff in the long term and you sort of need both.
- 38:04That's right. And as a result there is a lot
- 38:06of companies that we will pass on because ultimately it doesn't
- 38:09make sense you know based on the entry multiple.
- 38:12But my point was more that, yeah, I think each market, each
- 38:15sector you know has its own dynamics, right.
- 38:19Life sciences different, Fintech different, you know enterprise
- 38:23software different and the same for geographies.
- 38:25And it's actually that thinking for us Eric that every time sort
- 38:28of these questions, it's often like we think of geos as these
- 38:31you can think of, oh geez, it's very different things.
- 38:34But literally if you if you start substituting sector for
- 38:38Geo, right, because as venture firms we've had to reinvent
- 38:43ourselves, we've had to go to new sectors, we've had to
- 38:46understand new opportunities and often they look different and
- 38:52we've got to challenge ourselves and adapt our mental models and
- 38:56then either embrace or reject that's OK.
- 38:58But we can't say well it's different.
- 39:00So let's not, you know, at least that's how we think about it.
- 39:04What motivated you to come back to the US and what is sort of
- 39:08your focus at the moment? Lightspeed is a special place
- 39:12and the ability to play a bigger role at the firm is really
- 39:16exciting. I mean, you know, I think we're
- 39:18all very lucky to be doing what we do, you know, but to have the
- 39:22opportunity to kind of continue to help build on the growth of
- 39:24the firm, you know, the platform that is built so far by the
- 39:27founders and the team, that's hugely energizing.
- 39:31And as you're probably hearing, I think there's a lot of kind of
- 39:34learnings and observations from, you know, my journey and our
- 39:37firm's journey outside of the US that are abstracted away from
- 39:43India or a geography. They're really just about
- 39:46learnings. Having invested, you know and to
- 39:49think about how do we now bring some of those learnings to the
- 39:52firm and along with the learnings of everyone else here
- 39:56and to now build the next phase, you know, in a sense of the firm
- 39:59and the firm has grown a lot incredible talent.
- 40:02And so, yeah, just the opportunity to to do more.
- 40:05How much time are you sort of internally focused versus trying
- 40:08to do deals? Yeah, I mean if sort of
- 40:10internally focused is I'll exclude from that let's say kind
- 40:13of you know serving on investment committees, right,
- 40:17where obviously that's part of the investment business probably
- 40:20say it's, you know it's 25 to 30%.
- 40:23So it's still mostly doing the deals, yeah, you know, serving
- 40:27on deal teams and partnering with other investors.
- 40:30But it's yeah, I'd say it's still predominantly, you know,
- 40:32we are in the investment business and it predominantly is
- 40:35still investing. But you know 25 to 30% really on
- 40:40thinking about our business, our firm, our strategy, our people,
- 40:45our systems, you know and what it takes to operate a firm of
- 40:48this scale. But we've got to be more
- 40:50deliberate about it. It won't just happen.
- 40:53So you know, I think there's been this question percolating
- 40:56now for a couple years, which is like.
- 40:58Is venture capital going to follow some of the lessons of
- 41:01like private equity, You know, it's going to become a more sort
- 41:05of grown up asset class like maybe a venture capital firm
- 41:09will like go public someday. They will get much larger.
- 41:13You know, they're a lot, you know, you could organize
- 41:15differently there. You know, the way the firms sort
- 41:18of survive generational transition could change.
- 41:21Like what do you think is sort of appropriate to take from
- 41:24private equity and what do you think?
- 41:27You know, venture capital is just like so different.
- 41:29It's not the right comparison. One of the things that I'm
- 41:31thinking about, so one is that, look, you know what you just
- 41:34said has happened, right? So just look at the data, which
- 41:38is 2022 venture capital, a UM was roughly 2/3 of total global
- 41:46private market a UMA decade ago. Just think about that, just
- 41:50venture capital, a UM in 2022, right.
- 41:54And by total global private market, a UM, infrastructure
- 41:57growth, all of that stuff, equity and credit, right.
- 42:01So that's happened. I don't think, you know, I like
- 42:04why are we debating it? It's happened now.
- 42:08Will it shrink 80%? We should debate that.
- 42:10We don't think it will, but that happened 2000 to 2002, right.
- 42:15So there's precedent for that. I think technology, and this is
- 42:19the second point I'd make, the technology in terms of its
- 42:24importance and emergence as a sector, if you will, in the
- 42:29mainstream economy has changed relative to 2000.
- 42:35And that was a sort of share of GDPI mentioned.
- 42:38It's not this little cottage industry anymore, right.
- 42:41And so then this brings me to something we talk about here.
- 42:44Is venture capital the right way to think about our business,
- 42:50right. So when our business started,
- 42:53venture capital was synonymous with technology investing,
- 42:57right, because that was the innovation economy.
- 43:00There was very small number of these companies.
- 43:03You know the balance sheets are all intellectual property and
- 43:07people, so they couldn't raise capital from anywhere else.
- 43:10And so this type of capital called venture capital, risk
- 43:13capital emerged to serve that part of the economy, right.
- 43:18But today that part of the economy is changed radically.
- 43:23And so then we think about, well, if we're serving our
- 43:27customers, which are technology companies, should that not be
- 43:33the lens through which we think about our business and what is
- 43:36the business? The same way we would want our
- 43:38founders to be thinking about how their industries are
- 43:40changing, how their customers are changing and how they can
- 43:43keep serving those customers better than anyone else can.
- 43:47How can we keep serving our founders and our customers
- 43:52better than anyone else can? And I think that if you just
- 43:56assume that it's only venture capital, well, that's a fine
- 44:00business, right? But I don't know this is sort
- 44:04of. Just.
- 44:05Yeah. No, this is this is more a
- 44:08technology investor than sort of venture capital or I mean we saw
- 44:13you know general Catalyst your Old Firm is.
- 44:16Trying to figure out as third of their own type of debt for fund.
- 44:20I mean I think there's a lot of talk of you know bigger firms
- 44:24going out and raising and saying we don't need to invest to you
- 44:29know a seed fund level returns. We need to prove that we can
- 44:34consistently outperform, you know the stock market.
- 44:38And if we can do that, it'll make sense for large investors
- 44:42to come to us and we're doing a sort of.
- 44:45Big enough fund size, is that the way you think about it or
- 44:48what do you mean by saying not venture capital, It's about
- 44:51different types of investments in different virtual profiles.
- 44:54So I want to be clear, this is not about, well, let's just
- 44:57scale to scale. It's working back from what are
- 45:00the needs of the companies and founders that we serve and
- 45:03recognizing that the core for Lightspeed still is an early
- 45:07entry point, right. So, so we invest early even 2/3
- 45:12of our capital, of the growth capital that we've raised
- 45:15historically has gone into companies that we were earlier
- 45:19investors in, right. And so that is, it's back to
- 45:22that serves those companies and those founders, right.
- 45:26And then a third is, gosh, you know, unfortunately, we do miss,
- 45:29you know, companies early. But if we can catch them at the
- 45:32Series B or the Series C, there's still, you know, the
- 45:34prices have gotten bigger than they used to be and we still,
- 45:37you know, want to be a part of those journeys.
- 45:39So it really is just coming back to none of this means moving
- 45:43away from early, I would argue. In fact, in our last fun cycle,
- 45:47Eric, we doubled our commitment to seed through B, right.
- 45:52And we've increased our early stage investment team and we're
- 45:56doing more there because we think the opportunity has grown.
- 46:00But it's just to say well over time, what do those founders
- 46:04need and those companies need and that's where even as we
- 46:08think about our platform teams, it's not, you know, we haven't
- 46:11built an army. We're being very surgical about
- 46:14what are we hearing from our customers, what is most needle
- 46:17moving to them. And so it's defining back from
- 46:20that. And when we do that, I would
- 46:22just suggest that if you just apply a venture capital lens,
- 46:25then arguably you will operate the same type of firm that you
- 46:29would have 20 years ago. But in an industry that is
- 46:33unrecognizable from 20 years ago now you can do that.
- 46:37I'm not suggesting you can't. But what we think about is the
- 46:41industry has shifted, our customers have shifted.
- 46:44What is it that they want today and how can we provide that?
- 46:47And then let's not label it like yes, a part of that is venture
- 46:50capital, but why do we provide talent, capability, You know,
- 46:55why do we use data and have a, why do we have a data science
- 46:58group at our firm, You know, why would we build an in house
- 47:01corporate development group? Well, it's it's because we've
- 47:05got to think about what's the right business to build in 2023
- 47:09and looking forward to the next decade.
- 47:11But would you look at like rather than?
- 47:12Buying out or I guess it poses so many questions about If it's
- 47:17not just VC, what are the other things that you would seriously
- 47:21sort of consider? Yeah, it does.
- 47:24And I think the key is really to have a true north, right and to
- 47:28you know anything that we do sort of be leveraging our
- 47:31capability and we think we're good at okay.
- 47:34So you know it's interesting you ask about buyouts.
- 47:36Well, I think there's going to be a way of a venture recaps
- 47:41that are going to be coming, right.
- 47:43Those are companies we understand.
- 47:45Those are domains that we understand, right.
- 47:48But there's going to be a slightly different kind of
- 47:51mindset, right, to the work that's going to need to be done
- 47:54there. Should we be thinking about
- 47:56that? I think we should, right?
- 47:59But are we gonna go and next year, are we gonna start doing,
- 48:03you know, buyouts control deals in IT services companies?
- 48:07No. There are people that that do
- 48:09that far better than we ever will.
- 48:11It's not what we're good at. It's not who we are.
- 48:13You are thinking about products around sort of the downturn of
- 48:17unicorns and that what's it, I mean that's like convertible
- 48:20debt type deals or well not necessarily.
- 48:23I mean again I think there are structured finance specialists
- 48:26that we'll do that better than we can.
- 48:29I mean playing straight, you know converts are fine, but you
- 48:33know as you get into more structured products there are
- 48:36folks that it's a different skill set.
- 48:38You know, we'll still come at it from understanding the domain,
- 48:42understanding the trend lines at depth, the technical shifts, the
- 48:47founders, the people, the products.
- 48:50That's still going to be at the heart of any investing that we
- 48:53do as opposed to is this more of a, did you make your money
- 48:57because you've figured out a structure that gives you a
- 49:01kicker in the event of X, right? Like, that's not what we're
- 49:05really good at. And so we'll leave that to the
- 49:08experts to do that. You've sort of alluded, well,
- 49:11first of all you're not gonna, you haven't announced something
- 49:14so you're not telling me specifically what you're exactly
- 49:17you have in mind in terms of the new structure, right?
- 49:19I just wanna make sure I'm not missing.
- 49:21Oh no, I'm riffing with you. But you have, is there a
- 49:24particular like fund or something that you're raising?
- 49:26No, there's nothing. I mean we our most recent set of
- 49:28funds are what they are, which is kind of early through, you
- 49:32know, through late stage. No, I'm riffing with you about
- 49:35really under this sort of, hey, I think we are a firm that looks
- 49:39to embrace where the opportunity is going.
- 49:42And so we think about that and we work back from our customers
- 49:45and the opportunity. But yeah, this, no, there's
- 49:48nothing there's. Not one that I have to like go
- 49:50figure out after this call. No, no, no, no, no.
- 49:52Philosophical like we're open to yes.
- 49:54You've sort of talked about how large the retrenchment was
- 49:58after.com that sort of framed the beginning of the
- 50:01conversation. You know, to put it another way,
- 50:03just interest rates have gone up significantly.
- 50:07You know, we were in a 0 interest rate environment and
- 50:10now? We're not and nobody knows for
- 50:13sure what that means for the venture capital asset class.
- 50:16Like I'm asking you to compare venture capital to private
- 50:19equity. But like nobody, private equity
- 50:21is not loved right now because of the interest rate problem.
- 50:24Yeah. So to put it directly to you, I
- 50:26mean how do you think venture capital changes in this world of
- 50:29like you know higher interest rates and can it sustain if
- 50:34interest rates go up. So, so you know the reason I
- 50:36would I'd separate this from again in 2000 is that part of
- 50:42the challenge with the inventory of the set companies that were
- 50:45built during that boom was a lot of them simply didn't work
- 50:49right. So the retrenchment was that
- 50:51there was just a bunch of stuff that was upside down okay.
- 50:55I think you know today there's certainly some of those, but the
- 51:00vast majority is there a real companies there arguably they
- 51:04can't sustain the rates of growth they were operating at if
- 51:06they have to drive more free cash flow And the change in the
- 51:10interest rate environment will impact what those companies are
- 51:13worth, right, as opposed to you know just they're going to go
- 51:17away, right. And so I think that the set of
- 51:21companies that obviously you know will have to go through
- 51:24those value adjustments, those valuation adjustments that will
- 51:28happen, that has started to happen.
- 51:29More will happen through the rest of this year and likely
- 51:312024 is more of those companies come to market.
- 51:35As it relates to going forward, you know the opportunity to buy
- 51:4310 to 25% of companies that are potentially disruptive to very
- 51:50large markets and over time we'll build companies worth
- 51:53billions of dollars remains as true now as it did five years
- 51:59ago as it did 10 years ago and certainly more true than 20
- 52:03years ago, more true, right. And so then the question is
- 52:07really about you know, entry discipline on the way in and
- 52:12doing the building and all the things that we have to do.
- 52:14You know, arguably you have again a more educated season
- 52:18talent base, technology is a broader part of the economy.
- 52:21So I would say that we remain optimistic, you know about the
- 52:27opportunities for venture capital and it's sort of why I
- 52:30would say it's different than 2000.
- 52:32That is not to say that the adjustment will not be painful
- 52:36for the companies that you know that were funded in a different
- 52:39environment and in a sense tuned their businesses right, far more
- 52:44tilted towards growth and the capital efficiency was not great
- 52:47as a result. And that will need to happen and
- 52:50that will be a painful adjustment.
- 52:53Great. Thank you so much for coming on
- 52:54the show. This was a lot of fun.
- 52:56Thank you, Eric. Yeah, I enjoyed it too.
- 52:57Time Flu. That's our episode.
- 52:59I'm Eric Newcomer. Thanks so much for listening.
- 53:02Thank you to Bejol Somaya Lightspeed for coming on.
- 53:07Shout out to Tommy Herron, our Audio Editor, Riley Catsella, my
- 53:10Chief of staff, anyone, our intern who's been booking a
- 53:13bunch of guests helping with the podcast and young Chomsky for
- 53:18the wonderful theme music. Please like comments, subscribe
- 53:21on YouTube, register, review on Apple Podcasts and of course,
- 53:25subscribe to the sub stack newcomer.co.
- 53:29See you next week. Goodbye.
- 53:31Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 53:32Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 53:33Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 53:35Goodbye. Goodbye.