Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / The Hidden Tax of Your Job Title
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a quiet erosion happening in career trajectories that has nothing to do with performance reviews and everything to do with semantics. I am talking about the specific way job titles function as currency, and how they can depreciate faster than your actual skill set if you are not careful. Luna: You mean when people chase bigger labels on their business card instead of focusing on the actual scope of work or the revenue impact? Lucas: Exactly. And the most dangerous version of this isn't just vanity. It is what I call the title mismatch, where a candidate leaves a large corporation with a highly recognizable internal designation only to find that the external market does not assign it any real weight. Let me give you a concrete example from last quarter involving a Senior Product Manager at a legacy financial software firm. Luna: I have seen that pattern before. The title sounds impressive internally, but externally it means nothing because everyone knows the company has fifty different levels of Senior Product Manager. Lucas: Right, and in this specific case, he moved to a Series B startup where his new title was Head of Product Strategy. On paper, that looks like a step up. But here is the structural problem: the startup had no formal product department, so he was effectively doing sales enablement, customer support, and basic roadmapping for a team of three engineers. He traded operational clarity for a label that sounded better on LinkedIn but carried less actual authority. Luna: So he got demoted in practice but promoted in name, which usually backfires when the next hiring cycle comes around and recruiters realize the title didn't reflect the responsibility. Lucas: Precisely. The market prices based on the actual work you did, not the adjective you attached to your role. When he went looking for his next move six months later, he was filtered out by algorithms looking for leaders who had managed teams or budgets, neither of which he had done despite the fancy title. He essentially paid a career tax for accepting a label over a learning opportunity. Luna: That is a brutal way to lose ground. Does this happen more in tech, or do you see it in traditional industries too? Lucas: It happens everywhere, but it is acute in technology and marketing where titles evolve faster than corporate HR structures can keep up with. You see it with things like Chief Happiness Officer or Director of Evangelism, which are real roles but often carry zero path to P&L ownership or operational leadership. If you are building a resume, you want a title that signals decision-making power, not just cultural fit. Luna: But surely some title inflation is necessary? If you join a tiny company, you need a big title to attract talent or close deals, right? Lucas: There is a distinction between functional necessity and vanity inflation. If you need the title to sign contracts or manage a team, that is functional. The problem arises when you accept a title that implies scope you do not actually possess, purely because the recruiter said it would look good on your profile. That creates a gap between your perceived value and your actual capability, and the market always corrects that gap eventually. Luna: So the key is ensuring the title matches the budget or headcount you control, rather than just the complexity of the tasks you perform. Lucas: Yes, and that leads us to another subtle trap. People often confuse seniority with specialization. A Principal Engineer might sound more prestigious than a Vice President of Engineering, but in many organizations, the VP holds the firing authority and the budget approval. If you prioritize the specialist title, you may inadvertently wall yourself off from general management roles that pay significantly more in the long run. Luna: It is almost like choosing between being the best player on the bench versus a starter on a weaker team. Which one do you actually want? Lucas: That is a perfect analogy. The bench player gets the shiny jersey, but the starter gets the minutes that build the stats recruiters care about. We are going to take a quick pause here to talk about how you can keep this kind of insight coming to your inbox without interruption. Luna: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: It really helps us dig deeper into these specific cases rather than just skimming the surface of broad trends. Your contribution keeps the research sharp and the conversations honest. Luna: Thanks for listening, we appreciate you keeping the signal strong and the noise low. Lucas: Let us get back to the mechanics of title negotiation. One thing I notice is that candidates often let the recruiter define the title before they even discuss the compensation package. This is a mistake because the title sets the anchor for your entire career trajectory moving forward. Luna: So you should be pushing back early in the process to ensure the title reflects the actual level of responsibility you will have day-to-day? Lucas: Absolutely. You want to ask specifically what the reporting line looks like and what the promotion criteria are for that specific title. If the answer is vague, that is a red flag that the title might be inflated to compensate for a lack of resources or clear direction. You are essentially asking for the rulebook before you agree to play the game. Luna: That makes sense. It shifts the dynamic from them selling you a dream to you evaluating the actual structure of the role. Lucas: Exactly. And there is another layer to this. Internal titles within a single company can also be misleading if those companies use non-standard leveling systems. Some firms have titles that jump from Associate to Director without ever having a Manager level, which can confuse external recruiters who rely on standard industry hierarchies to sort resumes. Luna: So you end up having to translate your own experience for people who don't know the internal context. That adds friction to every application you submit. Lucas: It does, and it forces you to spend time explaining what you did rather than letting the title do the heavy lifting. This is why I advise people to keep a detailed description of their responsibilities separate from their official title. When you apply for jobs, you can clarify that your title was Director, but your actual scope included managing a team of ten and overseeing a two million dollar budget. Luna: Transparency wins every time. It builds trust with the hiring manager who might otherwise be confused by the jump in title. Lucas: Trust is the currency of hiring. If you are upfront about the discrepancy, you demonstrate self-awareness and strategic thinking, both of which are highly valued traits. Conversely, if you hide behind an inflated title and then struggle in the interview because you cannot articulate the missing pieces of the puzzle, you damage your credibility permanently. Luna: It is basically integrity checking your career assets. You want them to be accurate so they hold value when you need to liquidate them for a new opportunity. Lucas: I love that framing. Assets that depreciate because of misrepresentation are toxic assets. You want clean equity in your professional history. Another common issue is the use of consulting or contract titles that imply permanent employment. Someone might list themselves as a Full-Time Consultant, which sounds stable, but recruiters know that often means project-based work with no benefits or long-term security. Luna: So the market penalizes ambiguity. If you are not sure what your title means, assume the worst interpretation. Lucas: Assume the worst, yes. Because the default assumption for many modern titles is gig work or temporary status unless proven otherwise. This is particularly relevant in the current economic environment where companies are hesitant to commit to full-time headcount. If you are navigating this landscape, you need to be very precise about the nature of your engagement and the deliverables you were responsible for. Luna: Precision becomes your shield against a market that is increasingly skeptical of traditional employment structures. Lucas: Exactly. And this brings us back to the core lesson. Your title is a tool, not a trophy. Use it to accurately convey your scope, your authority, and your impact. Do not use it to mask a lack of progress or to inflate your perceived worth beyond your actual capabilities. The market is efficient, and it will eventually price you correctly based on what you have actually delivered. Luna: So the question for anyone considering a new role should be, does this title help me tell the truth about my work, or does it obscure it? Lucas: That is the litmus test. If the title obscures, walk away. If it clarifies, negotiate hard for the substance behind the words. We will leave it there for today, but keep that precision in mind as you review your next offer letter.