Latest / Politics with Paul / The Politics of Physical and Mental Fitness | Politics with Paul #102
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:09Today, we're going to talk about the politics of mental and physical fitness and how healthy
- 0:17our elected officials should be.
- 0:19The sudden death of senator Lindsey Graham and the uncertainty surrounding the state of
- 0:25senator Mitch McConnell's health has injected new life, no pun intended, into the debate over
- 0:33one, whether our elected officials need to be able to pass mental and physical fitness tests
- 0:39to stay in office, and two, whether we need maximum age limits on our officials.
- 0:45We have minimum age limits, but many officials don't have maximum age limits.
- 0:51And many government bodies in The US, namely congress, are significantly older than the
- 0:57average population of the citizens they represent.
- 1:00And for some political observers, if you can't get older and unhealthy elected officials out
- 1:06of office at the ballot box, then there need to be laws to force them out.
- 1:10But not surprisingly, these debates are often still subject to partisan and ideological
- 1:16battles, not in the sense that Republicans support one side of the debate and Democrats
- 1:21support the other.
- 1:22No.
- 1:22It's more because concerns about physical and mental fitness tend to be selectively applied.
- 1:30At least elected officials and political pundits do so.
- 1:34Republicans tend to care about this fitness a lot more when it's a democrat's health in
- 1:39question, and the same goes for democrats when it's about a republican's health.
- 1:44The very first episode of this podcast covered maximum age limits on congress and the
- 1:50proposals for that.
- 1:51And so I wanna revisit some of the points there, but to expand upon that a lot more,
- 1:57especially into the political jostling about agent fitness that doesn't get talked about
- 2:03enough, but also more about these fitness tests that are being proposed as well.
- 2:09So today is all about mental and physical fitness for elected officials.
- 2:15Whether we might see more stringent requirements for it, the trickiness in
- 2:19implementing such requirements, how old is too old, how unhealthy is too unhealthy, where do
- 2:26we draw the line for, quote, unquote, too unfit for office, and more.
- 2:31So here we go.
- 2:33First of all, really want to not not hammer the point too much, but it does bear talking about
- 2:42this selectiveness of applying fitness standards because biased media does cover
- 2:48topics of physical and mental fitness.
- 2:51But typically, it's in the context of politicians on the other side of the aisle.
- 2:55We get really wrapped up in the health of people we don't like.
- 3:01You saw Republicans talk about it a lot when it came to Joe Biden, and now you see Democrats
- 3:07talk about a lot with Donald Trump.
- 3:09But democrats were a lot more reluctant to talk about Joe Biden's health, and republicans have
- 3:14been more reluctant to talk about health when it comes to Donald Trump.
- 3:18And so you see a lot of shielding or at least less attention paid to like minded politicians
- 3:27from these, whether it's these media outlets or from other political figures when it comes to
- 3:32somebody who's within the party.
- 3:34Republicans are not gonna talk as much about Republicans' health, or they'll say that their
- 3:40health is actually really good.
- 3:41And the same thing goes with Democrats about Democrats.
- 3:44And it's not that biased media won't cover the health of their favorite officials, but it
- 3:50tends to be with a lot less scrutiny or they want to talk about how we need to be more
- 3:54understanding of their medical issues, whereas that same level of grace is not given to people
- 4:01who are on the other side of the aisle conveniently enough.
- 4:05But it's not just these political pundits and these media outlets and these politicians.
- 4:11Oftentimes, you hear doctors for an elected official, especially when it comes to
- 4:15president.
- 4:16They come out and say, Oh, the president is in great health.
- 4:19This is the healthiest that they've ever been, this may be the most healthy person to have
- 4:25ever occupied this particular office, or some sort of either obviously or subtly over the top
- 4:36description of what these officials are going through.
- 4:40Donald Trump's doctors or doctors talked about how much he's in great health.
- 4:45Joe Biden's doctors or doctor would have talked about how much in shape that he was in.
- 4:54But of course, they're going to say these things because this is their personal doctor,
- 4:57and they might have a personal rapport with this president or congressperson that's not
- 5:03necessarily about their political views.
- 5:07They might just have built a personal rapport with them being around them for so long, and
- 5:10also they don't wanna get fired by this person that is their personal that they're the
- 5:15personal doctor for.
- 5:17And there's no legal obligation in most of these cases to actually reveal this info of
- 5:23these medical results.
- 5:25And when these medical results are released, lot of times, it's very selective parts of it.
- 5:32The parts that tend to reflect positively on that person.
- 5:38But you will sometimes see political officials and pundits and influencers and so on call for
- 5:45the retirement or fitness testing for people in their own party.
- 5:50But usually, that's because of factional and ideological disputes.
- 5:54A lot of times, these people are those who are much more to the right or much more to the
- 6:01left, and the elected official is somebody who's, quote, unquote, not conservative enough
- 6:06or, quote, unquote, not liberal or progressive enough.
- 6:09So a lot of times, it's there is still that even if it's not based on party, there's still
- 6:15ideology at play.
- 6:16I I don't wanna make it sound like it's all a partisan thing.
- 6:20It's not, but there is a lot of it that is going on.
- 6:25And although substantial proportions of citizens and voters in both major parties have
- 6:32been in support of maximum age limits, you still arguably some low see arguably some level
- 6:38of partisan bias at play here too.
- 6:42For example, back in 2023, Pew Research Center had polled people about whether they supported
- 6:49age limits on congress and age limits on the supreme court.
- 6:53And there was a difference in support for both of those.
- 6:56And you saw there was a significant proportion of both parties that said there should be age
- 7:03limits on supreme court justices, but there was a noticeable difference in party affiliation.
- 7:0982% of Democrats said that about the Supreme Court, and 68% of Republicans said that about
- 7:14the Supreme Court.
- 7:15And if you follow the Supreme Court at all, you know that they are a decidedly conservative
- 7:21court, and even back in 2023, they lean that way too.
- 7:25So that, to some extent, explains that difference between Democrats and Republicans.
- 7:32But, again, I don't wanna just make it seem like everything is just a matter of partisan
- 7:37and ideological battles here.
- 7:40It's not.
- 7:42Because overall, there are significant numbers of Americans, democrats, republicans, and
- 7:48independents that back some sort of way to ensure competency for our elected officials in
- 7:56terms of mental or physical capabilities.
- 8:02But that begs the question, how do we deal with these quote unquote unfit officials or how
- 8:08should we deal with them?
- 8:11Because there's several different ways that could be considered or that have been
- 8:17considered.
- 8:18You have things like maximum age limits or another way to put it is mandatory retirement
- 8:24ages.
- 8:25Some people suggest even though it's not directly based on age, they talk about term
- 8:31limits because longer serving officials tend to be older, so they would be the ones that are
- 8:36more subject to these term limits.
- 8:39Then of course, you have these proposals for mental competency tests, whether they're ones
- 8:46that already exist or ones that would be made specifically for elected officials.
- 8:51And then maybe not as commonly brought up as mental competency tests, but physical
- 8:56competency tests.
- 8:58Because even though the job is more so mentally based than physically based, physical
- 9:04capability is still quite relevant to this job.
- 9:09And we're definitely going to get to that in just a moment.
- 9:11But first, let's talk about this debate over maximum age limits.
- 9:16And with any sort of debate in politics, you always assume those are there are at least two
- 9:21sides to a debate.
- 9:23Sometimes there's three or four,
- 9:25but there's always going to be at least two no matter how much it seems like one side of the
- 9:31argument is favored.
- 9:34A significant majority of people are backing either competency tests or mandatory retirement
- 9:43ages for elected officials.
- 9:46But there are still quite
- 9:47a few people that don't agree with those.
- 9:50So you have to think about those arguments that are being made.
- 9:54Whenever you're fighting for any sort of reform, no matter how good you think it is, no
- 10:00matter how strongly you feel you are justified, how how solid and airtight you think your
- 10:08argument is.
- 10:09You have to understand what the other side is saying.
- 10:12Because even if you do have a quote unquote objectively better argument, they are still
- 10:19trying to persuade people too.
- 10:21If you don't take their argument seriously, they might persuade enough people to go against
- 10:26what you're looking for, whether it's trying to influence lawmakers in congress or in state
- 10:32legislatures, or if you are trying to pass state constitutional amendments or even an
- 10:38amendment to the US constitution, you always or you're trying to win any sort of campaign,
- 10:42you always have to think about what the other side is arguing because if you don't, that
- 10:50might be what gets you beat.
- 10:54So you need to understand what the other side thinks and why they think that so that you can
- 10:59also counteract any of those arguments as well.
- 11:06You need to
- 11:06be prepared for those so that you can more effectively convince people.
- 11:11And so when it comes to these age limit debates, you have to think about what people
- 11:17who support age limits say and people who don't support age limits say.
- 11:21And three of
- 11:22the most common arguments
- 11:25for both of those sides that we'll bring up here.
- 11:29So let's talk about the pro age limit side.
- 11:33So people who think that there needs to be some sort of maximum threshold for being an elected
- 11:40official.
- 11:43The actual parameters of that we'll get to in a second.
- 11:46But first, people who support a maximum age limit or mandatory retirement age.
- 11:52One of the major arguments they make is that if you have younger people, you have more
- 11:57energetic and fresh ideas because old people are stale and they've they're set in their ways
- 12:03and how they think about doing things.
- 12:06Maybe it worked at one point, but it's not working anymore and you need somebody else
- 12:10that's new.
- 12:11And sometimes it's true, but is it true in x y and z cases?
- 12:17Pro age limit people would also argue that older people are more likely to die.
- 12:24Naturally, that's just how things happen.
- 12:27Of course, younger people can also die too, but older people tend to have more health problems.
- 12:31So not only are they more likely to die while they're in office, if they do die in office,
- 12:37they're more likely to be the ones that need special elections to fill their seat.
- 12:41And you know what elections cost?
- 12:43Money, not just for people that are campaigning for these offices, but to actually hold these
- 12:48elections.
- 12:49And so local governments have to foot that bill predominantly because local governments are the
- 12:55ones that primarily handle election administration in The United States.
- 13:01And then pro age limit people also argued that they are better for democracy.
- 13:05Age limits because it would mitigate entrenchment of these officials because older
- 13:11people tend to be longer tenured and so they have more power at their disposal to stay in
- 13:17power.
- 13:18And you see this reflected in the very high incumbency win rates, meaning people who are
- 13:23already sitting in office tend to win reelection to that office at a very high clip.
- 13:31But what about the anti age limit side?
- 13:34We have to talk about both sides here.
- 13:36So for people who are anti age limit, they would say, well, yeah, younger people might be
- 13:44more energetic, but they also tend to be less experienced.
- 13:48They tend to not know things because they haven't had that experience, whereas older
- 13:53people are more experienced with tackling whatever issues have come up.
- 13:58They will also say these anti age limit or these opponents of age limits in or for elected
- 14:07officials will say that people age differently.
- 14:10So one person who's, quote unquote, too old for the office might not be too old in somebody
- 14:17else's case.
- 14:18So you can meet a 70 or 75 year old who's just not with it, but there's another 70 or 75 year
- 14:26old who is sharp as attack and might be more with things than a, say, 35, 40, 45 year old.
- 14:34And so if you're going to make some sort of standard that people need to abide by, then you
- 14:41need to apply to everybody and these people who can still perform these duties would then be
- 14:47affected.
- 14:48And also people who are against age limits would also say that it actually hinders
- 14:51democracy to have these maximum age limits because these are inherently ageist proposals.
- 14:58You're targeting people for being too old.
- 15:00And it would also go against the wishes of people who want to keep these older officials
- 15:04in office.
- 15:05They would say, well, you know, for all the complaints that people have about elected
- 15:09officials being too old, well, they keep winning.
- 15:12And so even if and sometimes even from people who otherwise complain about elected officials
- 15:19being too old.
- 15:21And if that's the case, who are we to tell voters that they can't keep putting these
- 15:26people back in office?
- 15:30And so no matter how much you may agree or disagree with any of those points, all of those
- 15:35arguments can be fair and strong depending on the context.
- 15:40And so you need to be able to counteract any of those things that people say, or you might have
- 15:45to balance to see which one of those arguments is stronger.
- 15:50Do we really get more younger people with more energetic and fresh ideas in one context, but
- 15:57maybe not in another context.
- 15:59And in one context, maybe older people are really more experienced with tackling problems,
- 16:04but in another situation, yeah, they might have the greater experience, but that doesn't mean
- 16:10that they've actually been good at tackling problems.
- 16:15So you see how it becomes much more complicated than people may realize.
- 16:21And another way that that might become more complicated is to think about what would these
- 16:26mandatory retirement ages look like, or these requirements specifically for mandatory
- 16:32retirement ages.
- 16:35There is actually one particular area in government that you do see a lot of mandatory
- 16:42retirement ages in or maximum age limits in, and that is when it comes to state level
- 16:47judges.
- 16:4831 states as of 2022 had a mandatory age limit, though what exactly those parameters were
- 16:56differed.
- 16:57Some of them might have had 70 years old.
- 16:58Some of them might have had 75 or something a little bit more oddly specific like 72 or 73.
- 17:06I believe it's Vermont or Rhode Island that has 90, which seems like it if you are gonna have a
- 17:13mandatory retirement age, it seems like 90 kinda defeats that purpose.
- 17:17But may may yeah.
- 17:18Maybe it doesn't.
- 17:19Maybe that's just a bias I have.
- 17:20That just seems like it's kind of over the top if you really are gonna have a mandatory
- 17:24retirement age, but maybe there's a very specific reason they have it at 90.
- 17:30But in any case, it's one thing to say that we should have a mandatory retirement age to say
- 17:35that, okay.
- 17:36Yeah.
- 17:36People who reach x age, they need to get out of office.
- 17:40Goodbye.
- 17:40You're not running anymore.
- 17:42But it's another to agree on what that age actually looks like.
- 17:47Because what should be that mandatory retirement age?
- 17:50You can have two very staunchly pro age limit advocates that say, Oh yeah, we absolutely need
- 18:00to have a certain maximum threshold for people.
- 18:03But what if somebody really strongly believes it should be 70 years old?
- 18:07And then somebody else says it should be 75?
- 18:09And then you have a third person that comes and says, that's stupid.
- 18:11It should be 80.
- 18:14And then somebody else comes in and says a different age.
- 18:16What should that age be?
- 18:18Even if we were to say that objectively, there should be a maximum age limit.
- 18:25What the best number is for that age isn't necessarily obvious.
- 18:31But not only that, should there be any sort of exceptions to that rule?
- 18:35So if we go back to those state level judges, there are, in some cases, that judge can serve
- 18:41out the rest of that term that they reach that mandatory retirement agent.
- 18:44So if they were supposed to retire when they were 70 when they turned 75 and they hit 75 in
- 18:51the middle of a six year term, well, they would technically be retiring when they're 78.
- 18:58So are those nuances?
- 19:00Is that kind of nuance okay?
- 19:02Or should they only be able to serve to the end of that month that they hit the age, the
- 19:07mandatory retirement age in, and then they have to be replaced?
- 19:11Or can they serve the rest of that term if they hit that age past the halfway point of that
- 19:17term?
- 19:17So if it's a six year term, but they hit the mandatory retirement age two years in, well,
- 19:22that's not halfway through, so they have to retire.
- 19:24But if they hit that mandatory retirement age four years into that term, then suddenly they
- 19:30would be okay to serve the rest of that term out.
- 19:32Should that be okay, or does it depend on what the office is?
- 19:36Should a president only be able to serve until they're 70?
- 19:41And then the US senate, a US senator should only be able to serve when they're 65, and then
- 19:47a US house member should serve when they're only two sixty years old.
- 19:52Do we make different stipulations depending on the office?
- 19:55And then that's not even counting what if we applied it to state level officials as well
- 19:59beyond state level judges.
- 20:01I'm talking about, like, governors, for example, or state legislators.
- 20:04Or could you continue to serve past that mandatory retirement age, but you lose any sort
- 20:09of benefits that you would get like retirement if you decided that you were gonna keep going.
- 20:15Arkansas state level judges do this where it's I believe it's 70 years old that they can serve
- 20:20you or maybe it's 75, but they don't have to stop at that point.
- 20:25If they don't stop at that point though, they lose their retirement benefits.
- 20:30So is that something that could be considered for members of Congress or the president or
- 20:37governors or state legislators.
- 20:42And even apart from all of that, can you be exempt if you pass some sort of mental or
- 20:47physical fitness test?
- 20:49So if you're 75, but you're at the top of your game mentally and physically, should you be
- 20:54able to still serve?
- 20:55Some people might say, no.
- 20:57Just just across the board, don't let that happen.
- 20:59But then somebody might say, well, hang on.
- 21:01What if this person is really good at their job and they show that they can still do it?
- 21:06But then what defines being good at your job when it comes to politics?
- 21:10Because boy, a lot of people have different ideas of who is good at their job and who is
- 21:15not.
- 21:17But speaking of these fitness tests though, what would these fitness tests look like?
- 21:22So forget about the age limits.
- 21:24How do we assess physical and mental acuity?
- 21:29Well, first of all,
- 21:33is one of those things trickier to assess than the other?
- 21:36Is it more difficult to assess physical fitness or mental fitness?
- 21:41A lot of times when we're talking about these fitness tests, we're typically talking about
- 21:46the mental side because you need to be able to think and there's a lot of thinking that you
- 21:51have to do when it comes to politics.
- 21:53Things get very complicated, but there is some level of physical capability that you need.
- 22:00And not just talking about walking to different rooms for your conference or your committee
- 22:05assignments or going to the full chamber.
- 22:08We're talking about you having to travel back to your districts or having to stay up long
- 22:13nights to get bills drafted and then passed and doing all sorts of wheeling and dealing behind
- 22:20the scenes to get things figured out and then also calling constituents and then not to
- 22:28mention lobbyists being involved.
- 22:30And then you might have to stay awake for long periods of time and for many, many days.
- 22:36So you still need physical capabilities.
- 22:39And so the demand these demands of public office can considerably weaken people
- 22:44physically.
- 22:45You look at presidents, for example, from the beginning of their term to the end of their
- 22:52term, whether they serve four years or eight years, they look like they age a lot more than
- 22:59four or eight years.
- 23:00You talk about George Bush or Barack Obama.
- 23:03They certainly look like they aged a lot more than they actually did, and it's the same case
- 23:08for a lot of other elected officials as well or even appointed government officials.
- 23:16And so you see some politicians retire not because their mental acuity is isn't up to
- 23:22snuff.
- 23:23They might be able to think very clearly and lucidly and quickly, even if you think they're
- 23:29not good at their job or their policy suck, they might mentally be up for the job, but they
- 23:36retire not because of that, but because they are physically exhausted.
- 23:42And so physical fitness might be easier to assess than the mental because there are
- 23:49arguably more quote unquote objective ways to measure physical fitness.
- 23:54Or is that even actually true?
- 23:56I I might just be talking out of my, you know what?
- 23:59I might be completely wrong about that.
- 24:01Maybe they're both equally difficult to assess.
- 24:05I mean, both of them are gonna be difficult to assess in this context, but is physical or
- 24:09mental fitness necessarily harder to assess?
- 24:13Maybe they're not.
- 24:16But in any case, it's easy to say that we should have these fitness tests, and everybody
- 24:22wants their elected officials to be fit for office.
- 24:26Nobody wants them to be unfit.
- 24:28It's just we disagree about whether somebody is fit or not.
- 24:33But we all want them to be able to be up to the task.
- 24:38But how we come to that conclusion of whether they're up to the task is where things get
- 24:45murky.
- 24:46And so we can say we should have mental or physical tests, but it's much harder to agree
- 24:52on what those parameters look like.
- 24:55Because you may look at a politician and think that you know mental or physical fitness when
- 25:01you see it, but it's not entirely objective, not to mention there are partisan or
- 25:06ideological factors at play.
- 25:08You may be a lot more harsh on somebody in
- 25:11their supposed mental or physical fitness because they are somebody that you don't
- 25:18personally agree with.
- 25:19And I think every one of us has been guilty of that at some point.
- 25:23Some people are more guilty than others, but even when we're really trying not to be biased
- 25:28in that regard, we can still have that level of bias.
- 25:33And even with party and ideological considerations aside, someone can appear to be
- 25:39more mentally or physically fit when they actually aren't.
- 25:43And that's not even
- 25:43us being partisan or ideological about it.
- 25:48It's just we just happen to think that they're more fit than they actually are.
- 25:52Maybe they're the way that they're being covered in
- 25:56the story makes them seem like they're more fit or we just don't have the information on hand.
- 26:00And so when we create these proposed ideas for physical or mental fitness tests, what should
- 26:10they look like?
- 26:11Here's some things to consider.
- 26:14What questions or criteria should they pass to stay in office?
- 26:18So if you're assessing physical fitness, is there are we measuring things like blood
- 26:24pressure or their how quickly they move or their ability to stay awake in committee
- 26:31meetings?
- 26:32And then if you're talking about mental fitness, are we saying like, okay.
- 26:36Do they still remember how the rules of lawmaking work?
- 26:40Are are we assessing all any sort of weird things that they say or trying to think of
- 26:50something else that that could be an idea.
- 26:54But sometimes then somebody might think, oh, this person is absolutely out of their mind,
- 26:57and it's really just because they have a policy view that they don't agree with.
- 27:03But then even if you do have some agreement on what questions or criteria they should pass,
- 27:08how many questions or criteria should be passed.
- 27:11You're probably not gonna pass every sort of physical capability assessment or mental
- 27:17capability assessment, but if you pass say 80% of them, is that good enough?
- 27:23What about 70 or 60 or even 50?
- 27:26If you get below 50%, then you're probably getting a little bit into uncertain territory.
- 27:33But if somebody's passing sixty, seventy, 90%, is that good enough?
- 27:40And then even if you agree on how many questions or criteria need to be passed in
- 27:46order to stay in office, who is administering this fitness test?
- 27:51Because they could be somebody who has a political objective.
- 27:54They might be somebody who's assessing if it's a democrat assessing a republican, they might
- 27:58be more harsh in a critique.
- 28:00Same thing if it's a republican assessing a democrat.
- 28:03And then even if you get somebody to administer the fitness test, who is overseeing that
- 28:09administrator or administrators?
- 28:12Then it starts to get into that whole, like, who's overseeing the overseer?
- 28:16And then, you know, at some at some point, you need to come up with a highest echelon of
- 28:21person who's overseeing things, but you also need some level of accountability and
- 28:28transparency.
- 28:29And also, if you miss that cutoff of, Oh, you should have gotten 70% of these criteria in
- 28:37order to stay in office or 80% or whatever it is, can somebody have a second chance to retake
- 28:42the test?
- 28:42Some people are just really bad at taking tests.
- 28:44Should we allow for that?
- 28:46Or can we say that, well, you know what?
- 28:48They just happen to have a very bad day.
- 28:50Maybe we just need to give them a second shot.
- 28:53Okay?
- 28:54Maybe you give them a second try at it.
- 28:56Can they even get a third try?
- 28:59And then after all that is figured out, do these full test results become public?
- 29:07That might sound like, well, yeah, of course, they should be public.
- 29:10And you you hear a
- 29:11lot of times where even outside of this context, people call constantly call for a
- 29:17especially for president, call for them to release their educational or medical records,
- 29:23and oftentimes, they don't actually release those for one reason or another.
- 29:28But they can't just
- 29:32always say we're gonna request this information and it's gonna be given to us.
- 29:37There might be privacy laws involved, especially when it comes to medical records,
- 29:41and we'll talk about that in just a minute.
- 29:44But there are all these other obstacles against mandatory retirement and fitness tests that you
- 29:52have to account for.
- 29:53Because even if we have large agreement amongst supporters on what these maximum age limits are
- 30:00going to look like or what these mental and physical competency tests look like.
- 30:05Or do we even care that much about the physical side and we just want the mental side?
- 30:10I don't know.
- 30:10But we if we agree on all those things of what those should look like, now we'd have actually
- 30:15get those passed.
- 30:16Now we'd have to actually implement them into law.
- 30:19And obviously, that's a lot easier said than done.
- 30:22Otherwise, we'd see these things come to fruition more frequently, and you'd see
- 30:25mandatory retirement ages for a lot more than just state level judges.
- 30:29And you'd see them in all the states or most of the states at least, or the vast majority of
- 30:34states, I should say, because 31 states do have those mandatory retirement ages for state level
- 30:39judges, but that's still another 19 states that don't have it.
- 30:43And so you might think you have an airtight argument for these reforms, and you maybe you
- 30:48do have a really good argument for it.
- 30:50I'm not gonna say you do or you don't, but you still have to incentivize lawmakers to pass
- 30:56those reforms for mandatory age limits and and or physical and mental capability tests,
- 31:06assuming you're trying to get the law passed instead of as an amendment.
- 31:10And so if you're going the lawmaking route, if you're going to specific lawmakers, you have to
- 31:16understand that they're balancing not only their own interests, but those of political
- 31:21allies and constituents as well.
- 31:23So a lot of these officials, especially ones who are older themselves, they're probably
- 31:30gonna be pretty reluctant to pass these age limit and fitness tests requirements unless
- 31:38they were somehow maybe exempt from those requirements.
- 31:42That's another thing to consider too.
- 31:43Are people grandfathered in where their current officials are exempt from these tests or do
- 31:49they have to or these age limits or do they have to abide by them as well?
- 31:54So you're still balancing their own interests and then their political allies, some of them
- 32:00might be older and they don't want to have these laws on the books that's hinder them in
- 32:06their careers.
- 32:10Or what about their constituents?
- 32:12Maybe their constituents don't like these laws because these elected officials that they
- 32:17really support and they've supported for a long time.
- 32:19Now they're going to be losing that official if they are subject to these age limit or fitness
- 32:25tests.
- 32:25And in the case of the fitness test, they don't pass.
- 32:28Or maybe these one of these constituents wants to run for office themselves and they're older.
- 32:35But fortunately for reformers, this isn't an issue that is divided strictly along party
- 32:39lines.
- 32:40Yes.
- 32:40People selectively apply their standards for physical and mental acuity based on party, but
- 32:47it's not like a, oh, Republicans support this idea and Democrats don't, or Democrats support
- 32:52this idea and Republicans don't.
- 32:54It doesn't really work that way.
- 32:57But beyond the incentivizing
- 33:00or the balancing of lawmakers interest in this regard.
- 33:05Another big issue had to contend with is that you have to make age limits a salient part of
- 33:11the political agenda.
- 33:13Yes, it might be a relevant talking point for media outlets and for regular voters.
- 33:20That doesn't mean that politicians are gonna be considering it anytime soon.
- 33:26A lot of times they won't.
- 33:28What their idea is of what their idea of relevant is might be
- 33:34a lot different than what media thinks is relevant or what the general population thinks
- 33:40is relevant.
- 33:42And you just have so many other
- 33:45issues competing for the spotlight in the lawmaking process at both the federal and state
- 33:49levels that can be very difficult for something like mandatory age limits to make it into that
- 33:59process.
- 33:59And especially when you're talking about the state level, a lot of these state legislatures
- 34:04have sessions where they're actually the where they're making the vast majority of the laws.
- 34:12They are only going for like maybe three, four, five, six months of the year.
- 34:18A lot of them do not even
- 34:19approach a year round cycle like there is for congress.
- 34:25And so that constricts the amount
- 34:29of time that you might see this happen at the state level.
- 34:32And then at the federal level, because there it's it's federal, it's nationwide, They have
- 34:40even more issues to to think about just because they're covering the whole nation and because
- 34:46it's the federal government, they're also dealing with the rest of the world too.
- 34:51So that can make things even harder when it comes to trying to make age limits or fitness
- 34:58tests a core part of the political agenda.
- 35:01And also, while many candidates and officials could say they support these ideas like they do
- 35:08a lot with term limits.
- 35:09You have to make sure they actually follow through on such promises.
- 35:12That's always something I find very interesting whenever I see some sort of reform campaign
- 35:19say, so and so says that they support this.
- 35:23And it's very easy to to score those simple political brownie points and say, oh, yeah.
- 35:28This thing that a lot of people support, I totally support it too.
- 35:31But they don't actually do anything about it.
- 35:34And you see that a lot with term limits.
- 35:36There are a lot of people blow smoke about how much they support term limits, and we need to
- 35:41get people to cycle through Congress and state legislatures more and more, but they don't
- 35:48actually do anything about it.
- 35:51And you can see that sometimes with these mandatory age limits and fitness tests as well.
- 36:00Now, of course, these reform campaigns are going to highlight these officials that are
- 36:05saying, oh, yeah.
- 36:06I'm totally in support of
- 36:07this thing.
- 36:07But it's still something that strikes me as kind
- 36:12of funny because they politicians say lots of things that they don't follow through on.
- 36:16If you go the lawmaking route, you still have to contend with a bunch of other roadblocks
- 36:21that could be thrown in your way as well.
- 36:23And those are things like HIPAA laws that greatly restrict the release of medical records
- 36:28without patient approval.
- 36:30So if we say that you should have to pass a mental or physical fitness test, well, now you
- 36:38got to actually have those results released to for people to verify and hold accountable those
- 36:44people that are taking those tests and the people who are administering those tests.
- 36:48But HIPAA laws can really make it very difficult to get a hold of those medical
- 36:54records.
- 36:54Though one could maybe argue that them being a public official entitles them to a lower bar
- 37:01for privacy, which has all has been a thing in courts that public figures do have a somewhat
- 37:08lower threshold for privacy than regular private citizens do.
- 37:12And so maybe the argument then is that, well, these medical records are a matter of great
- 37:17public interest.
- 37:18I'm not entirely sure about the intricacies of HIPAA laws, but that might be something that
- 37:23you could argue.
- 37:24But in any case, these medical privacy laws do make it difficult to try to implement something
- 37:31like this.
- 37:32Again, you have accusations of ageism because you're targeting older people.
- 37:38And so you might also run afoul of equal employment laws, which are typically more based
- 37:44on race and gender, but they also do apply to age.
- 37:49And somebody might say, well, you're not entitled to being employed as an elected
- 37:54official, which is quite true.
- 37:56But to flat out tell people that they can't run for the office because they are too old, well,
- 38:03now you might start to run-in those into those issues of equal employment.
- 38:11Then there's also possible constitutional objections, not necessarily for the US
- 38:16constitution, but there might be state constitutional laws that make it difficult to
- 38:22try to implement an age based requirement or a fitness test requirement is does the fitness
- 38:27test would be.
- 38:30Would be with age in mind.
- 38:33And so.
- 38:35If you run to constitutional objections and it's found that your idea is unconstitutional,
- 38:41you're not gonna be going anywhere with it.
- 38:43And in a similar vein to constitutional questions, if you try to get a national limit
- 38:48on congress passed specifically, now the argument might be, well, that's actually a
- 38:55state political jurisdiction issue.
- 38:57That's actually a tenth amendment issue because the state should be able to dictate how old is
- 39:03too old for their elected officials.
- 39:05North Dakota a few years ago did pass a state constitutional amendment that I believe I
- 39:10believe they made it where members of congress or prospective members of congress cannot be 80
- 39:16years old by the at at by the
- 39:18time that they in the term that they won election for, I think, is what it was.
- 39:24So somebody might come back and say if you try to apply to all of congress, they might say,
- 39:30well, no.
- 39:31No.
- 39:31No.
- 39:31No.
- 39:31This is a state's rights issues.
- 39:33The states have to dictate how old is too old for their elected officials.
- 39:39And then if congress tries to pass a law for maximum age and fitness test on the president
- 39:45or the supreme court, not on themselves, but the other two branches of government.
- 39:50Now you're running into an issue with checks and balances.
- 39:53Now are we saying that, well, congress is trying to dictate certain parameters of who can
- 40:00serve for president or supreme court unlawfully, and they're they're overstepping
- 40:07their bounds.
- 40:07Now that might run into the checks and balances and separation of powers debates
- 40:13and issues.
- 40:15And then if you if the lawmaker route fails, then you'd have
- 40:19to go through a state or national constitutional amendment process.
- 40:22And then those are even more arduous most of the time than the lawmaking process, especially
- 40:28if you try to amend the US constitution.
- 40:31And then you still have to deal with a lot of the same roadblocks like medical privacy laws
- 40:35and ageism concerns and sorts of other issues with, you know, determining what is the what
- 40:45are
- 40:45the appropriate parameters for age limits and fitness tests.
- 40:49And so you're still running into a
- 40:53lot of those problems that you're already running into with lawmakers.
- 40:56Instead of now, you're not trying to incentivize lawmakers.
- 40:59Now you're trying to convince a whole bunch of voters to support that.
- 41:04Or then what if you have a state government try to say that your amendment is illegal because
- 41:11it's doesn't pass some sort of per legal requirement for an amendment.
- 41:18Like a lot of states, what the amendment is trying to do has to be it has to be quote
- 41:24unquote clear and concise or or not necessarily concise, but it has to be clear what that
- 41:28amendment is trying to do.
- 41:30And sometimes the stipulations for what's considered a clear and obvious intent of an
- 41:37amendment is rife with partisan and ideological considerations.
- 41:44But apart from all that, let's say that you are going to get a.
- 41:53An age limit passed.
- 41:54You're getting a fitness test pass and you got a whole bunch of people that agree on what that
- 41:58should look like.
- 41:59Okay, great.
- 42:01Well.
- 42:03There is an old saying that goes that you should be careful what you wish for because you
- 42:08might get what you want and eventually realize it's not quite working out the way that you
- 42:13thought it would or that you would intended.
- 42:16There might be unintended consequences that come up or you later come to find out that the
- 42:20law you wanted is now negatively impacting you specifically.
- 42:25I'm not trying to say that national retirement age or fitness tests or are a bad idea.
- 42:35I'm I'm not here to make public value judgments on these things even if I have my own opinions
- 42:40one way or another.
- 42:41I'm here to just lay out the actual arguments for both sides to try to give people more well
- 42:47rounded, nonpartisan, impartial as possible look at how these things work.
- 42:55But what I am saying is that you must consider the trade offs that come with policies because
- 43:00there are always trade offs, always trade offs.
- 43:03No matter what the policy is, no matter how good you think it is, no matter how airtight
- 43:09and foolproof you think it is, there is always going to be something that can be attacked
- 43:13about it or not necessarily that it's attacked about it, but at some point in time, that
- 43:18policy might now start to negatively impact you.
- 43:23And so you need to understand that there may be some tough pills to swallow from the effects of
- 43:29these reforms, and sometimes these effects were predictable and sometimes they aren't.
- 43:35And so not to persuade or dissuade you from your side of the debate, but there are some
- 43:43things you should carefully think about when it comes to implementing mandatory retirement age
- 43:51limits or fitness tests for physical and mental competence.
- 43:59There is an inevitable loss of institutional knowledge when you force people out because of
- 44:05their age, because older people tend to have been serving longer, which means that they have
- 44:10more experience and knowledge.
- 44:12Now, again, doesn't necessarily mean that they were good at their job, but by default, they're
- 44:18going to have more knowledge about how things work because they were there for longer.
- 44:22Because politics is extraordinarily complicated with its rules about the lawmaking process and
- 44:28the complex relationships between people and on and on.
- 44:34You have to think about whether that loss of institutional knowledge is worth the injection
- 44:39of new blood and fresh ideas from people who are new to the game or at least new to being
- 44:48elected official and this ability for more people to be able to directly influence the
- 44:54lawmaking process.
- 44:58Seasoned people aren't necessarily good at their job and it doesn't mean that new and bold
- 45:03ideas are going to be good either.
- 45:05You have to think about whether that trade off is the right one to make in a certain
- 45:12circumstance, and you can't pick and choose certain circumstances where it's, oh, but this
- 45:15older person that I like, I like them.
- 45:18They shouldn't be subject to these fitness tests.
- 45:20Now it doesn't work like that.
- 45:22You either have to have it across the board or if you don't have it across the board, you have
- 45:25to have a very specific set of exemptions for how people can evade these mandatory retirement
- 45:33ages or these fitness tests.
- 45:36That is a nice segue into this next point.
- 45:41At some point in time, if not now, then in the future, these
- 45:49reforms meant to target the age of members of Congress or the age of the president is going
- 45:58to hit politicians that you like.
- 46:00And when we think about these politicians where we want to assess their fitness or impose age
- 46:06limits on, they tend to be ones that we don't like.
- 46:08So when democrats think about these age limits, they tend to think about guys like the now late
- 46:15senator Lindsey Graham or senator Mitch McConnell.
- 46:20Republicans tend to think about people like Joe Biden and the late Dianne Feinstein who was a
- 46:28US senator from California.
- 46:31But the thing is, it doesn't just apply to democrats.
- 46:35It doesn't just apply to republicans.
- 46:37It applies to both of them, and then it also applies to independents whenever they happen to
- 46:41serve.
- 46:41And in this case, you think about Bernie Sanders.
- 46:44Angus King is also up there in years too, but Bernie Sanders in particular is up there in
- 46:50years.
- 46:51And so if you have these age limits at fitness tests, they start to apply to him too.
- 46:55And somebody who is young now that you may firmly support, they might go on to serve for a
- 47:02long time, and then all of a
- 47:03sudden now they come up on these age limits or these fitness
- 47:08tests.
- 47:09Everybody who is old now was young at one point, and many older politicians started off
- 47:15relatively young.
- 47:16These people who have served thirty, forty years, they were once youthful and energetic
- 47:22and injected bold ideas too.
- 47:24At least according to somebody, they injected bold ideas.
- 47:30But now they're at a point where they're older and now people are saying, well, now they're
- 47:36too old to serve in office.
- 47:38Young people who are serving now, some of them will run into this same issue.
- 47:45But now you say, oh, wait.
- 47:47Woah.
- 47:47Wait a minute.
- 47:47No.
- 47:47But not not this person.
- 47:48I I like this person, though.
- 47:50They're they're they're doing a good job.
- 47:53But you can't just pick and choose who to apply these rules to unless once again you have those
- 47:59exemptions already set in stone.
- 48:02And then lastly, what if you wanted to become an elected official one day or people that you
- 48:11personally know like friends and family?
- 48:14Well, if you wanna eventually serve, now you might eventually contend with these age limit
- 48:20and fitness test laws.
- 48:21And if
- 48:21you are prepared to do that, then, hey,
- 48:25then I commend you for at least acknowledging that.
- 48:27But some people don't think that far ahead necessarily, and then they think, well, wait a
- 48:32minute.
- 48:32This isn't what I signed up for.
- 48:33Actually, it is what you signed up for.
- 48:37You are not exempt from age limit and fitness test laws if they get implemented just because
- 48:43you don't wanna be adherent to them, but that's how it works.
- 48:52So once again, not to persuade you or dissuade you one way or another.
- 48:58It's just you have to think about these things before you really firmly say, you know what?
- 49:04I do support this.
- 49:05And if you are prepared to face anything that might negatively impact you, then I commend you
- 49:11for that being willing to accept those drawbacks and acknowledge that those drawbacks
- 49:17exist.
- 49:19But.
- 49:20Some people don't necessarily think about that ahead of time.
- 49:24And so.
- 49:27Even if age limits, maximum age limits, mandatory retirement ages, and fitness tests
- 49:33are the way to go, and we figure out the right the quote unquote right way to do them, even
- 49:41so, there's going to be some sort of drawbacks.
- 49:43There's going to be something that is negative about them because every policy has flaws.
- 49:50And so you have to make sure that those are things that you're willing to deal with.
- 49:58And that's gonna be end for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 50:02As always, thank
- 50:03you so much for listening and watching.
- 50:07Links in
- 50:07the show notes, my other works, including my writings on medium.com, my five day educational
- 50:14email course about how we can all more effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization
- 50:20in politics, and my book on Amazon about political independence.
- 50:25And my other links, my LinkedIn, my Facebook, my website, and my email.
- 50:32And so that's gonna wrap things up here for today.
- 50:36Please like, comment, share, and subscribe.
- 50:39And any sort of support that you provide to this podcast helps tremendously in my efforts
- 50:47to help promote civic education and political education, try to make these things more
- 50:53accessible to people.
- 50:55So thank you so much for all that you guys do and for listening to this podcast, and we'll
- 51:01see you next time.