Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / PROFESSOR KRIS D'AOUT DISCUSSES MINIMALIST SHOES4
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant doctor Carlos. Welcome back everybody. Well today we're
- 0:32gonna have a fascinating conversation with a fascinating gas professor Chris Doat. That's d
- 0:38apostrophe aout, d apostrophe aout. You can find him at Liverpool dot ac
- 0:44dot UK. Well who is he? You probably asking, boy, He's
- 0:48a biomechanist or mechanist, Okay, mechanist, so anyway you can know what
- 0:52I mean. Biomechanist with a zoology background from Antwerp University in Belgium, with
- 0:57a longstanding interest in human locomotion. If you're thinking we're gonna be talking about
- 1:00walking, you're right, and also minimalist shoes as well. He works in
- 1:04the Evolutionary Morphology and Biomechanics group of the Institute of Life, Course and Medical
- 1:08Sciences of the University of Liverpool. And we're gonna be talking about walking feet,
- 1:15minimalist shoes, shoes in general, and a whole lot more. But
- 1:18you know what to do before we get started, to make sure to share,
- 1:19subscribe and hit that I like button. You know we like it.
- 1:22It's not waste any more time. Welcome to the show, Professor Dode.
- 1:23Welcome, sir. Hello, nice to be you. Thank you for doing
- 1:29this. As I've talked to you before the show, I think it was
- 1:32a week or two ago. Feet keep coming up a lot of feet discussions
- 1:37lately, and toes and things. So I guess my first question to you
- 1:42what got you interested in feet and shoes? Well, I've found a bit
- 1:49of a journey and you just said in intro I have asology background, so
- 1:53I've always been interesting in how animals move, so I've done a lot of
- 1:57research on apes for an exam PG was actually and how fish swim. So
- 2:02it's it's it's it's a bit of a long story how I got there,
- 2:06But how it happened is I'm not just a zologist, but also very interesting
- 2:10one particular species, which is ourselves humans, and we've done something quite spectacular
- 2:16and unique during our history, our evolutionary history. We decided to walk on
- 2:22two feet, so we became upright creatures. And in fact, that decision
- 2:28between inverted commas because it wasn't towardsn't just any decision obviously, but that has
- 2:32influenced us enormously. We can see anatomically adaptations throughout our body, but the
- 2:39fact that we have these large brains, that we have such highly developed cognitive
- 2:44skills, etc. It all boils down to basically becoming upright creatures. So
- 2:51obviously feet are very interesting because once you are upright, you don't use their
- 2:54hands anymore to walk around. The only mechanical link to your environment is through
- 3:00your feet. So you can't be an efficient and effective bipet if you don't
- 3:06have highly functional feet. So that's how I became interested in feed to me
- 3:10feet a sort of what tires are to form all about racing cars. You
- 3:15might have the most powerful engine, you might have the best roodynamics. If
- 3:20you don't stick to the road using your cars, you're not getting anywhere.
- 3:23So that's why I believe our feet are so important. But also clinically,
- 3:30not just biologically. Clinically, a lot of people suffer for food problems,
- 3:36So it's an interesting topic from from different angles, beat fundamental or clinical.
- 3:40You know, it's interesting. I know when we talked about before I had
- 3:43interviewed the podiatrists. I mean, this whole thing started with I'll give them
- 3:46a shout out. Cal Deet Athletica train or River University of Minnesota, and
- 3:51we were talking about as athletes, and he trains a lot of Olympic athletes.
- 3:54And it's one of the things that keeps standing out to me over the
- 3:57years. Thing has been doing it for twelve years. Was the big toe
- 4:00and how important the big toe was to everything, including the big toe in
- 4:06the butt were the two most important areas, he said for athletes where he
- 4:10saw the power that balance explosiveness explosiveness which is power. But he mentioned the
- 4:16big toe and did remind me of something I forgot to mention to you last
- 4:19time. It was interesting because I had worked years ago as a physical therapy
- 4:23aid and I remember an individual who was working as a machine shop and his
- 4:27toe got cut off. It was his big toe and he was having a
- 4:30heck of a time and trying to balance without it. It was really interesting
- 4:34to see it. He just really couldn't walk and people would think, you
- 4:38know, just one toe, but it was the big toe. Yeah,
- 4:41yeah, Well it learned about because some people lose big toes, for instance,
- 4:45if after a trauma or maybe because they had diabetes, et cetera.
- 4:49It's possible, but big toes are definitely very important. And also if you
- 4:54look on an evolutionary scale between like a typical eight foot and arboreal foot,
- 4:59so made for life in the trees, and then how our feet evolved as
- 5:03hominis, as early humans and eventually Homo Homo sapiens. That's one of the
- 5:09big changes happened. It is a shape and the position and the sturdiness of
- 5:14the big toe. If you look at our ancestors and also early hominims,
- 5:19the big toe was more of a grasping though it was maybe not much bigger
- 5:24than the other ones. It was set to the side, so what we
- 5:27say abducted, it looked a bit more like like a human hand. And
- 5:32what we see with the transition to like upright walking as a normal way of
- 5:36life, that the big toe became in line with the other photos to add
- 5:43to a very sturdy platform that allows us to push off very efficiently at the
- 5:46end of stands. And it also became very strong and stable, supported by
- 5:53a muscle as well as bones and ligaments. So the big from an evolutionary
- 5:58perspective, we definitely see huge changes in the big toe, and that has
- 6:01to mean that it's important to have a good big toe, because evolution doesn't
- 6:06just happen at random. It's it's result of selective pressures that help shape how
- 6:13our anatomy changes. But also if you look at it here and now,
- 6:17a lot of pressure go through the pig toe. If you if you take
- 6:20a measurement of how the pressure in the foot unrolls as we step from say,
- 6:26he'll strike, and then we have our typical unrolled pattern to the toes.
- 6:30At the end of stance where we push off very strongly, that's when
- 6:35the center of pressure goes to the big toe. So evidently it plays plays
- 6:41a big role therea So having a strong big toe has to be important.
- 6:46That's crazy. It's really amazing because you don't think about it. You don't
- 6:49think about it much. I mean I never did before, and now it
- 6:54has changed alive. We're almost verty the seguay. It looks like to the
- 6:59minimal shoes before we get over there. Why did just just get your thought
- 7:01on something I thought about to The last conversation we had was not recorded,
- 7:04folks, It was pre interview. But um, I thought about the apes
- 7:09and how they kind of walk on their feet, they walk a lot more
- 7:13on their hands. It seems like they're kind of like quadrupeds. But then
- 7:15I thought about the kangaroo. Somebody mentioned the kangaroo to I mean, I
- 7:19thought, that's a good point, but I don't know they're people are not
- 7:23because they kind of hop talks about the kangaroo. So so when I say
- 7:28that we as humans are very special, that is compared to all the other
- 7:32primates. So if you look at more distant, distantly related groups, obviously
- 7:38all the birds are bipeds when on the ground because their their arms have developed
- 7:42into wings and more soupials there are another example of animals that are bipeds,
- 7:48but that's a totally different kind of bipedoles and than humans. So if kangaroo's
- 7:54really hop and they are full of all tendence, but the tendons function like
- 8:01very strong elastic bounds and the story and release energy when they jump or when
- 8:05they hop, which which is actually fascinating because they are very very efficient.
- 8:09If we walk, we don't. We don't really do that, so we
- 8:13are less efficient in that sense. When we run, we also do use
- 8:16some storage and release of elastic energy, but we're not quite as good as
- 8:22it as a as in your kangaroos. No, it's interesting that I'm looking
- 8:28at thinking about physiology and concentric and excentric and just watching them bounce and how
- 8:33they probably store up energy in the booms. Bring up exactly. This is
- 8:37not a kangaroo even I was wanted to talk about kangaroos. That's fascinating indeed.
- 8:43Um, so let's head over now. You know, people like to
- 8:48always were some people. There's some groups out there and just not a knock
- 8:50against them, but some people will say, hey, you know, we
- 8:52were cavemen or cave women or whatever they call it, hominids and all kinds
- 8:56of different names for these individuals. People like to always revert back some groups.
- 9:03Yeah, you know, this is the way we used to eat,
- 9:05This is the way we used to live. Which I don't know if they
- 9:07how much they really know about how they live in but how did they used
- 9:11to walk? Now? Because I remember the Bible, if you can count
- 9:16the Bible in the six thousand years, whatever it is that you want to
- 9:18do that, if you believe in that. But you know, the Egyptians
- 9:20and the Israelis. They used to use sandals, I remember, I remember
- 9:24correctly, but I'm talking way before the sandal episode. Do you think they
- 9:31always walk barefoot? Did they use some kind of leaf or bark of trees
- 9:35or something or what do you think? Yeah? So, yeah, so
- 9:39we have done what every other single animal species does, which is walk barefoot.
- 9:45There are no animals at your shoes, and so we also haven't done
- 9:48it for well the first six to seven million years of our evolution as hominians,
- 9:54which means so actually walking upright is a diagnostic feature of of a hormonion,
- 10:00so an early human, if you will. So it's that important.
- 10:05So that's seven seven million years ago, so we're not talking about six thousand
- 10:09years. That's in another realm that we would be a topic of another post.
- 10:16I suppose I'm going to talk about science today, and that's it.
- 10:22So yeah, So the first so when I say seven million years ago,
- 10:26that's six million years something like that. That's when we became bipeds. But
- 10:30we looked very different. We looked much more like say, like a chimpanzee.
- 10:35More like a chimpanzee in terms of body proportions, et. Cetera.
- 10:39We were anatomically modern Homo sapience about one hundred thousand years ago, So one
- 10:45hundred thousand years ago people looked exactly that they were our species. They looked
- 10:50exactly like us in terms of anatomy, et cetera. So if you if
- 10:54you moved with a machine one hundred thousand years flash forward to current life,
- 11:00if you put them in the suit, you wouldn't you wouldn't notice that they
- 11:03are like us essentially, and we only we have the So the oldest shows
- 11:09we found in the in the archaeological record are about eight thousand, three hundred
- 11:13years old. Wore some reasons to believe that the old but of course you
- 11:18don't always find the very first show. That would be quite a coincidence if
- 11:22you find something that's quite likely it has existed for a few years. So
- 11:28probably footwear was invented, because it is it is a human invention, maybe
- 11:33twenty or thirty thousand years ago, but it is basically after we became an
- 11:37atomically modern. So that does say we can we can function very well without
- 11:43shoes. On the other hand, and that's coming back to your your initial
- 11:50thoughts, like shouldn't we shouldn't we do that because that's the biologically normal condition.
- 11:56Um, now that's a trap we shouldn't fall into. It's called naturalistic
- 12:00fallacy. And that would be assuming that everything which is natural is good and
- 12:05everything which is unnatural is bad. But there are so many examples of exceptions
- 12:11to that rule, it's not really a rule. Like all of medicine is
- 12:15basically unnatural. We try to fight things like fire, infections, et cetera.
- 12:20Which is it's natural to die of diarrhea as a child, but we
- 12:22need to fight as footwear is the same thing. Footwear in a way,
- 12:28you could say it's not natural, but that doesn't mean it can't have a
- 12:31role, it can't be useful to us, like so many other things.
- 12:35So even though I'm a biologist and always have this evolutionary background in the back
- 12:39of my mind and very wary of sort of extrapolating that everything which is natural
- 12:46has to be the best, I completely agree with it. Sometimes they'll say
- 12:50things like, you know, I don't want to get too far everything,
- 12:52but they'll say certain substances are good for you because they're natural. And I'm
- 12:58looking at the bachelorism in a shoef with that thought pretty quick. If you
- 13:03want to go that route, well, be dealed by the toxins of a
- 13:07black beadow. He's perfectly natural. But that's right. Um, yeah,
- 13:13well I gotta go there. But yeah, it's interesting. And I just
- 13:16brought that up because I know sometimes people would argue with that, and I
- 13:20like the Hegelian principle a lot too, and I think that can apply it
- 13:22sometimes in this capacity. Right, the thesis and antithesis ecosynthesis, And that's
- 13:28what kind of what we see over time, especially because cars changed a lot
- 13:31of things. And I don't know, it's always fascinating to see when things
- 13:39started. And I'm kind of drifting away for a second, but when did
- 13:41we start? Do you know when we started? You said we started using
- 13:46sandals around eight thousand years back. Do you know why? What was the
- 13:50reason back then? Was because of the roads or what was the deal?
- 13:54We can only guess, but back in that time, well there were no
- 13:58roads, as we know, probably earlier than that, so let's talk about
- 14:01maybe twenty thousand years ago. So well, we see that these these sandals,
- 14:07these very early shoes, that they're very flexible, etc. So they
- 14:11don't provide any cushioning or support. But what they would do is provide us
- 14:16against trauma. So maybe it would feel more comfortable to walk over sharps and
- 14:20over rocks. Some of the old shoes they might insulate against against the cold.
- 14:28And I think those two functions are still important functions of footwear and just
- 14:31providing us with some comfort and protection. And that's what not just these very
- 14:37old shoes did, but actually most shoes until very recently did that. If
- 14:41we look at quite recently in our history, if we look at Roman shoes
- 14:46which are well documented, or Egyptian shoes two three thousand years ago, they
- 14:50are very minimal in a sense, so they are quite often made of leather
- 14:56or plant fiber, but very flexible. They might be decorated, but mechanically
- 15:03they didn't do much. They didn't they don't have heels or art support or
- 15:05cushioning or anything like that. All of these features came much later, even
- 15:11even in the last century, like cushioning, for example. Heels are a
- 15:15bit older than that, but they are probably not very functional. They might
- 15:20have had more like a status symbol where if you could afford heels, you
- 15:24could also physically stand up from from the dirt, which was very common in
- 15:30the streets, say in the Middle Ages. So there's a lot of reasons
- 15:33why our shoes became what they are today. Not all of them, and
- 15:39probably not many of them are actually by mechanically useful, and some of them
- 15:45are even by mechanically harmful. So we can almost say we were ordered backwards
- 15:48with the minimal shoes of today, we're kind of going back to the original
- 15:52ones. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you could say that. But the
- 15:58thing is, some populations have never abandoned. So if you if you travel
- 16:02you go to indigenous populations, some populations still where they've never stopped wearing these
- 16:08shoes that are helpful in terms of installation and protection but don't too much else.
- 16:14So if you look at like a moocasin or like the sandals that people
- 16:18in hot areas, if you go to Africa to Asia, people wear their
- 16:25historical shoes still to some extent, and so they've never they've basically skipped what
- 16:30we've done, which is have all these fancy issues with lots of features.
- 16:33They've they've stuck to what they knew worked for centuries. Interesting they didn't let
- 16:38their ego get in the way. I want to look daller, I want
- 16:42to look better. Yeah, but that's it. That's often why people where
- 16:47the shoes they do. It's nothing to do with by mechanics. It's to
- 16:49do with cultural aspects of footwear. And shoes have always had an important role
- 16:55in culture. It used to be a status symbol. And even now sometimes
- 17:00you hero, oh, these people are really good. They can't even afford
- 17:03choose. It's it's considered shoes have this very special position, like if you
- 17:07can afford good shoose or shoes, that's you've achieved something that they are important
- 17:15culturally. It's interesting when I asked social psych students in the past, there's
- 17:21a chapter we talk about love and relationships, and there's one section of it
- 17:26with attraction. We talk about attraction and social psych And I said, what's
- 17:30the first thing you notice? When I asked the girls about boys, meaning
- 17:34if they're head asexual, what's the first thing you notice about boys? Like
- 17:41I always say the thing it's the shoes, And it's like, oh,
- 17:45and that hasn't changed for years. I think. I remember they used to
- 17:49tell me that when I was single twenty years ago. It was the same
- 17:52thing. Girls look at your shoes. It's like, really, look at
- 17:56my shoes. I don't even look at my shoes. Yeah, fascinating stuff.
- 18:03I think they think we look at their shoes, but I don't.
- 18:07I don't look at their ses. There's quite a lot of interesting research being
- 18:11don't actually on high heels. Yeah, yeah, so we know from a
- 18:15biomechanical point of view, there's a lot we don't know about footwear. But
- 18:21one thing we definitely do know is that high heels are unhealthy. That's very
- 18:25well documented. But there's these interesting more like psychological studies on high eagles,
- 18:30and they do influence the way you walk, and that has a sexual signal
- 18:37and signaling function, so that they are they are functional in that sense sexual
- 18:47point of view, but not from a biomechanical point of view. It's interesting,
- 18:52that's very true. I'm gonna switch gears and head over to the minimal
- 18:55issues now. But minimal is shoes. Somebody who's telling me their predectious talking
- 19:00about things in Australia. We're talking about when you when you land the key
- 19:03acid, so the minimal shoes explaining that happens with the toes. What's your
- 19:07take on that? Is that accurate? Yeah? So um, it depends
- 19:14on whether we are running or whether we're walking. Their mechanically quite different,
- 19:18but also simplistically speaking, running involved much higher forces. So if we land
- 19:23during a run, yeah, then the food deforms and it can do so
- 19:27less if you have a constricting shoe with an arrow toebox, so that that's
- 19:33definitely true. Now, minimal shoes. I find it always funny to talk
- 19:41about minimal shoes because I think we should consider them as the normal shoes.
- 19:47Yeah, or most people they're not. They're not on normal shoes. Normal
- 19:49shoes would be what you find in most shops. But actually these are very
- 19:53special to me because they have all these features that we've put in for whatever
- 19:57reason. So many simal shoes to me are just or should be just shoes.
- 20:03And yeah, one of the ideas that they have a last that's compatible
- 20:07with the shape of a human foot, which most typical shoes you can buy
- 20:12are not. So there's quite a lot of work done on shape and fits
- 20:17of shoes, and the majority of people use shoes that are actually narrower than
- 20:22their feet. So that's something we wouldn't attep for it, like nobody would
- 20:26wear a jacket that's too narrow and that squeeze your body. We would say,
- 20:30well, that's unconsortably, not accepting that in terms of food, where
- 20:33we are willing to accept that because narrow shoes are perceived, at least in
- 20:40our in the Western society, are typically perceived as more attractive. We have
- 20:44narrow, narrow feet, So animal shoes allow allow the natural movement of your
- 20:49foot, which and that's coming back to what's natural. I think unless we
- 20:55can really prove that unnatural is better, we have to we have to take
- 21:00our default position that natural is better, which will very often be decayed.
- 21:06So I think the burden of proof lies with people who claim that unnatural features
- 21:11of footwear are there to help. I'm absolutely willing to accept that, but
- 21:15I need to see proof. If there is no proof, then my go
- 21:19to footwear would be footwear that does not have any impact on how we walk.
- 21:25That that's sort of my default position because it has worked for seven million
- 21:29years, so it might not be perfect, but it's pretty good. I
- 21:33agree. Does your mechanics change on sand dry sand compared to dirt or carcrete?
- 21:40Does it change? The substrate has a huge influence on the way we
- 21:44walk well, mostly if you have a compliance substrate, it makes walking more
- 21:51costly, So it costs you more energy. That's quite a bit of a
- 21:56because you basically you deform the substrate. If you walk in sand, you
- 22:00spend energy deforming a substrate, and that's energy you can't use in propelling your
- 22:04body forwards exactly. So it's less efficient if you walk on very complex substrates
- 22:12or very sleepily substrates. We tend to move with more bent hips and bent
- 22:18knees because we feel more stable that way, but it's also more costly.
- 22:23So if you just try and stand up, it will cost you almost no
- 22:26energy. If you flex your knees a little bit, you can just imagine
- 22:30you'll start to feel your quads quite soon. That's not even moving. So
- 22:34if you walk with more flexed posture, yeah, it's gonna costume more energy,
- 22:41but it will make you more stable, more able to respond to small
- 22:45deformations of the substrate, et cetera. It's interesting in the way, in
- 22:52a way, a shoe with cushioning it's a bit like a like a variable
- 22:56substrate. I like to think of it like that. It's if you have
- 23:00a flexible soul under your it's almost as if you're walking on something flexible all
- 23:04the time. You folks actually did it stary on minimal shoes. Where did
- 23:10you find in that step? Yeah, we've been studying animal shoes for a
- 23:15few years and we looked at a few aspects, again because they're interesting from
- 23:22a biological point of view, but they are also interesting from a clinical point
- 23:25of view. One aspect is strength, so we looked at if you wear
- 23:32minimal shoes rather than conventional Western shoes, does that change the strength of your
- 23:37feet? And the answer was very clearly yes. So we had randomized to
- 23:42groups. One group just carried on wearing their normal shoes, and the other
- 23:47group he gave them minimal shoes and they had to wear them not all the
- 23:49time, but at least seventy percent of the time, and apart from that,
- 23:56they didn't change their hands, so they carried on their normal lives.
- 23:59After the year, we saw that the group that had been wearing the minimal
- 24:02shoes gained about sixty percent in foot strength. So that's that's a huge amount.
- 24:07If you go to the gym and you gain sixty percent in strength,
- 24:11that's that's a good workout. It costs you a lot of sweat. Just
- 24:17changing the different shoes can also give you those benefits. Now, what's the
- 24:19benefit of having that sixty percent increase in shoe stringth I mean foot strength.
- 24:25Yeah, So the muscles that support our feet, they're really important for a
- 24:32lot of things. They support our arch, the arch of the foot,
- 24:34so they make the food stronger during push off, but also in terms of
- 24:38balance. If we are disrupted in balance, which we are all the time,
- 24:45we don't notice, but we are constantly making small adjudgments to our balance
- 24:48if we stand still or if we walk. And usually these perturbations from the
- 24:52outside world could be like maybe a tile that's a little bit oblique, or
- 24:56some little stone in steps whatever, it can be intrinsically, even on a
- 25:02completely flapsot trade, we vary between the one step and the other. So
- 25:07how we deal with those perturbations and how we stay stable and upright and don't
- 25:11fall. We have a sequence of things we do, and the first attempt
- 25:18to stay upright is all what we call the angle strategy. We make small
- 25:22adjustments using our ankle muscles to bring us back on the right track, and
- 25:27nine times of ten that's enough. If that fails, then we start moving
- 25:32our whole body. If that fails, we start waving our arms. If
- 25:36that also fails, we step into the direction we're going to fall, or
- 25:41we stick out around. But basically, the most important and the first thing
- 25:45we do to remain stable, it's a it's an angle strategy. So the
- 25:48stronger your foot muscles, the more you will be able to stay stable.
- 25:55And that's so we also measured stability directly, not in people who have been
- 26:00trained to have stronger ankle muscle, but just people we got into the lab.
- 26:04We gave them conventional shoes with cushioning. We also asked them to walk
- 26:11barefoot and to be asked them to walk with minimal shoes. And as a
- 26:15work of my post doctormash to Dako, we saw that our different instability.
- 26:22So basically, cushioned shoes make you less stable. Barefoot walking is more stable.
- 26:30But interestingly, and that was not really expected, the minimal shoes are
- 26:34a little bit more stable still than barefoot walking, so they offer an improvement
- 26:38over barefoot. So that's one example how our invention could be helpful to us.
- 26:45You think it was, let me see our phra example. I guess
- 26:51it makes me wonder just curiosity and it's probably just completely conjecture. But as
- 26:56a psychological the differences you saw there between the few the minimals. You know,
- 27:00where when you're walking perfect you might be a little bit more tentative where
- 27:03you step, you're going to feel more things. But the minimal issue you
- 27:07kind of I just bot mine. Yeah, two weeks ago. Well,
- 27:11if you change a condition, if it's difficult to completely exclude psychological obviously,
- 27:18how we try to minimize that is by not telling people exactly what we what
- 27:22we are interested in. We just give them different types of hues and barefoot
- 27:26them. We measure their gates, so we don't we don't really tell them
- 27:30that if they do this or that will be happy as research, so we
- 27:33keep we keep them blind to Obviously there are different conditions. They do realize
- 27:38it's impossible to completely blind our research in many cases, as you can do
- 27:44if you inject a drug, you inject a liquid, and you can make
- 27:48your participants completely blind to whether the liquid contains an active substance or just water.
- 27:53We can't do that. If you give people shoes versus barefoot they obviously
- 27:57know that there's a difference, but luckily we are. We are measuring mechanics,
- 28:03and even if there is a psychological difference, which I don't think is
- 28:08very likely, but even if it would be the case, we still measure
- 28:12an effect. It's still true for whatever reason, that if you walk barefoot,
- 28:18if you walk in minimum shoes, you're more stable. In addition,
- 28:22we have insights from physiology that makes us that give us good arguments why it's
- 28:27probably not psychological, but it's an actual physical, physical effect going on because
- 28:34we have a lot of mechano receptors in the source of our feet. I
- 28:37mean, I think we all know how nice it feels to have a food
- 28:41massage, or even just to walk barefoot over a nice substrate. Our feet
- 28:45are full of sensors and our joints are as well, to give them what
- 28:51we call appropriate reception, a sense of awareness of where our own bodies if
- 28:56we are barefoot or in minimal shoes. We allow these sensors to work.
- 29:00We give a lot of information to our brain about what's happening with our feet,
- 29:04how they sense the substrate. We are very sensitive to what's happening,
- 29:11and with that input, your brain can produce a good motor program to keep
- 29:15stable. Now, if we wear very cushioned shoes, what makes them comfortable
- 29:21also means which is the cushioning also means that we are sort of filtering out
- 29:26all the information we could have. Whatever happens with the ground, we'll only
- 29:32sends it's very very poorly if we have this big cushioning device under under our
- 29:37feet. So from that point of view, it makes sense that we don't
- 29:41have as much neurological input in our system to help us stay stable. And
- 29:47secondly, purely mechanically, if you have a cushion shoe, it is a
- 29:52bit like sitting on a gin ball. You're constantly babbling it. It makes
- 29:55you naturally less stable. So because of these mechanical and physiological factors, we
- 30:02believe the effect it is a real and it can't exclude some psychological input,
- 30:07but we think it's a it's a real mechanical effect. Fasctanding stuff. Again,
- 30:11we have a few minutes to go and this is probably going to be
- 30:15a complete guest in your parfect You understand mechanic biomechanics, so well do you
- 30:22think, trying to how I'll phrase it, do you think it will reduce
- 30:26knee issues? And low back paint. If people started shifting over the minimalist
- 30:32shoes, I guess I'm also assuming that it caused a lot we started wearing
- 30:37the heeled shoes. But do you think you have an impact there? So
- 30:41do we whether we'll have less issues with minimal shoes? Yeah? Do you
- 30:45think people? So, there is really fascinating research being done, mostly backed
- 30:51by other people who are into for example, knee osteoarthritis that is very important
- 30:57to limit the loading on the kne as well as as hip by mechanics,
- 31:02and some of these studies they give us very counterintuitive results. So you would
- 31:07think intuitively that cushioning is a good thing to have less load on the human
- 31:11body. The thing is, we are not robots. If we walk with
- 31:15cushion shoes, we ajust our gate and we walk in a less cautious way.
- 31:19And the end result might be that despite the cushioning, to force on
- 31:22our body is actually higher. And that's been measured. So there is a
- 31:27there's a research team in Brazil that works on knee of stuartritis. They've found
- 31:33that if you wear very thin shoes, very cheap thin salt minimalist shoes,
- 31:38that the loading on the knee joint is actually lower than with conventional heeled shoes,
- 31:45so that that was very interesting. The second study that used so that
- 31:51worked on total hip replacements, so prostasies artificial hips, and they they implanted
- 31:57hips into the patients with four sensors within the prosthesis. So these sensors measure
- 32:02actually what's going on inside or inside the socket, so it doesn't like it's
- 32:08an actual measurement, it's not an estimate. And they found the same thing
- 32:13that but minimal shoes and bare footwalk in the load on the hip prosthesis is
- 32:16actually lower. So there's definitely a lot going on and counter intuitive, which
- 32:22is one why we need to measure it now. I'm not gonna say that
- 32:27we should all be wearing minimal shoes and every single patient should. There is
- 32:30definitely a place for heels in some patients. For example, heels do off
- 32:36load thea kill the stendards have kiender nineties. They might be at least temporarily
- 32:42a good solution to help you recover people with diabetes, for example, they
- 32:49need they need very good shoes to prevent formation of ulcers and cushioning could be
- 32:55definitely be one part of it or a rocket profile. So I'm definitely not
- 33:00for bas go minimal. Always follow the doctor's advice. And for some patients
- 33:07a shoe is an intervention. It's not supposed to be minimal. It's supposed
- 33:12to have a function. But what I would say is, for most people
- 33:15who are healthy, I want to stay healthy for as long as possible,
- 33:20minimal shoes are a good idea, and in some patients groups they could be.
- 33:24But I'm not going to make a blanket statement like minimal shoes are the
- 33:28best for everything. But that's that's not true. What do you see a
- 33:32difference? And again, I know it's going to be another guess. Maybe
- 33:36do you see a difference of growing up with minimal is shoes, So at
- 33:39the age of four or five we start of wearing shoes, probably younger than
- 33:44that, but we start wearing minimal is shoes all the way through. Do
- 33:45you think that would make a huge difference for that individual. Yeah, I
- 33:50don't have to guess, luckily, because there are a few studies good They're
- 33:53not so much on minimal shoes but on barefoot walking, and so there are
- 34:00studies from Africa, from India. Those are the most huge amount of volunteers,
- 34:05so very good quality data thousands of So for example, one study from
- 34:10Africa studied children who went to school so young age before all the foot bones
- 34:16are bone. So because they only turned to bone a sort of the age
- 34:22of six or seven, so they're their cartoonage before that, so they're highly
- 34:27flexible. They found that children who keep on walking barefoot, they have less
- 34:36the odds of them having a low arch, so flat foot are smaller than
- 34:39kids that war shoes. So basically being barefoot give you the best chance of
- 34:45developing a well developed foot arch. So that that was interesting. So it
- 34:53makes sense that being barefoot gives our feet to the right mechanical environment to develop
- 35:00into strong feeds if you overprotect them. It's like anything if if you have
- 35:06an accident and you break your arm, you put it in a plaster of
- 35:08Paris cast. After six weeks weeks, your your muscles will be atro feed,
- 35:15your bone will become weaker, et cetera. So if we if we
- 35:19give kids very very supportive thirty boots, where is the mechanical input to stimulate
- 35:25their feet to become strong. So there is now good evidence and actually the
- 35:31American Association of Pediatrictions. The guidelines for decades now have been to give kids
- 35:39well, to stimulate them to walk barefoot, or to give them very flexible
- 35:43shoes. So the evidence is quite good there, and I think, to
- 35:49be honest, people like you and me, if we start walking in minimal
- 35:53shoes, there's only so much we can do because our feet won't grow anymore.
- 35:58They are fully ossified. But children's feet are so plastic that they do
- 36:05respond to whether their barefoot or shots about mine or two weeks ago. I
- 36:10love them. That's really been fun. We're walking around with them. I
- 36:14haven't I haven't really paid attention to any changes. I'm not sure if I'm
- 36:17a ball arena or anything right now in balance, but I'm definitely a lot
- 36:21better than I was just walking. It's interesting. I definitely thought it was
- 36:23going to cause me some issues down below, causing kind of tendern issue or
- 36:29something, but now didn't do a dark thing. That feel really good.
- 36:32Listen to your body, if you if you if you switch, it's like
- 36:36anything new, your body has to adjust to it. So if you switch
- 36:39from a very protective, sturdy, supportive shoe to a minimal shoe, especially
- 36:45at a later age talking about me, not about you. You have to
- 36:52take it easy. Your body has to adjust it. It's all shown that
- 36:55if you start running with minimal shoes and you keep the same mileage, you
- 37:00go from a cushion trainer to a minimal shoe within within a few weeks.
- 37:05Basically you are probably looking for trouble. You have to take it easy.
- 37:09You have to keep your body time to adjust a good point. I can
- 37:14keep your all day. They have so many more questions. Part chill.
- 37:17You're running out of time. We'll have to bring it back and we can
- 37:21continue to explore because I was also going to look at athletes and cleats and
- 37:25all kinds of other types of shoes and lots of stuff going on out there.
- 37:29The professor do thank you so much for doing this. Yeah, my
- 37:32pleasure. It's been nice talking to you folks again. If you want to
- 37:36learn more, you can go to Liverpool dot AC dot UK. I think
- 37:39it's life course. I can't see exactly what this is, but you can
- 37:45type go ahead life course and medical Sciences. That's my institute. There you
- 37:49go, so Liverpool dot AC dot UK Life Course Medical Sciences. You can
- 37:52find professor DoD. That's the apostrophe. Ao ut to learn more, check
- 37:59it out, go look at Minimalis shoes if you haven't tried them, I
- 38:02just like professor said here, I would probably try it first and see how
- 38:06they goes for you, slowly and surely, and tell us let us know
- 38:08if you like them as much as I do. Thank you so much everybody
- 38:12for listening, Share, subscribe, hit that I like button. You know
- 38:14we like it. We don't walk barefoot every so often, would yea