Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Applied Improvisation for Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:04Hi, everyone. I am Neda Sighafi, vice chair of
- 0:08the HBA's litigation section. I am delighted
- 0:12to introduce our speakers today, Paul Markajani
- 0:16and Jennifer Cho. Paul is a Los Angeles -based
- 0:21performance coach, a former entertainment lawyer
- 0:24and founder CEO of Vox Vera, a veteran of Warner
- 0:30Brothers, NBC Universal, Miramax. and Amazon
- 0:34Studios. He spent over 15 years leading business
- 0:37and label teams and advising top producers and
- 0:40studio heads. He is a trained stage performer
- 0:44and certified Patsy Rodenberg coach. And Paul
- 0:48now teaches communication and public speaking
- 0:50at leading law schools, including Stanford, Berkeley,
- 0:54and the University of Chicago. Jennifer is a
- 0:57partner at Piper Wolf, Carr, Kane, Conway, and
- 1:01Wise LLP in Los Angeles, where she focuses on
- 1:04the firm's IVF clinic and fertility misconduct
- 1:07practice. She is a former assistant United States
- 1:11attorney for over 17 years. She prosecuted complex
- 1:15violent and organized crime cases and argued
- 1:17numerous appeals before the Ninth Circuit. Jennifer
- 1:21also teaches trial advocacy at USC Gold School
- 1:24of Law and leads professional improv workshops
- 1:26that combine creativity and communication skills
- 1:29for legal and corporate professionals. Paul and
- 1:32Jennifer, thanks so much for being here with
- 1:34us today. And now let's get started. Thank you
- 1:37so much, Neda. And we are so excited to be here.
- 1:39Thanks for joining us for Applied Improvisation
- 1:41for Lawyers. This is a presentation that Jen
- 1:44and I are so excited to present today. It's something
- 1:47that we work together on because we think that
- 1:50improvisation skills are essential for lawyers.
- 1:53It's useful for litigators. It's useful for transactional
- 1:56lawyers. And it's also just great life skills.
- 1:59So our goal for today, we'll say a little bit
- 2:01more about how we came to improv and what improvisation
- 2:04means for us. But our goal today is to give you
- 2:09a sense of how improvisation is useful for you
- 2:13in your practice, in your life. and hopefully
- 2:16give you some practical exercises that you can
- 2:19try at your own firm and give you a little taste,
- 2:23a little taste of what it feels like to improvise
- 2:26and how we can use that in our practice of law.
- 2:28So to get started, I'm going to say a little
- 2:31bit more about how I came to improvisation and
- 2:33why we do this, and then I'll hand it off to
- 2:36Jen. For me, I come to the practice of law as
- 2:40a performer first. So I studied music in high
- 2:44school, in college. I was a voice major and did
- 2:47opera for a while. And then I went straight to
- 2:49law school, did the litigation track, moot court,
- 2:53mock trial championship team, wanted to be a
- 2:56courtroom lawyer. The performance aspect was
- 2:58really interesting to me. And then I did that.
- 3:00I was a litigator for five years up in San Francisco.
- 3:02And around my fourth or fifth year as a litigator,
- 3:06after some long days in conference rooms reviewing
- 3:08documents, I pulled aside a friend from my prior
- 3:12firm and said, Hey, why don't we sign up for
- 3:14this improv class? I'd heard some things about
- 3:16improv. It seemed fun. It fit in our schedules.
- 3:19So we both did it and we were hooked immediately.
- 3:23And what we loved about it was it was this three
- 3:28hour session every week where we could be completely
- 3:31free. We could make mistakes and not worry about
- 3:35the consequences, which is rare in law. We could
- 3:38also exercise our creative muscles, right? Stretch
- 3:42that rubber band in the opposite direction, as
- 3:44I like to say, right? Remind ourselves that we
- 3:47have this ability to create rather than just
- 3:50distill as lawyers, which we tend to be really
- 3:53good at. So did that. moved to Los Angeles and
- 3:56went in -house at NBC Universal. And then in
- 3:59Los Angeles, which is where I live now for the
- 4:01last 15, 16 years, I have done lots and lots
- 4:05of improv. So Upright Citizens Brigade, which
- 4:07is Amy Poehler's group. The Groundlings, which
- 4:12a lot of the SNL folks like Kristen Wiig and
- 4:14Phil Hartman back in the day came through. And
- 4:17that's very character -based and commitment -based.
- 4:21And then where Jen and I met is Impro Theater.
- 4:24in Los Feliz, which comes from a different improv
- 4:27tradition based on the work of Keith Johnstone,
- 4:29a Canadian improviser. And it's very much about
- 4:33getting us back to a state of play and building
- 4:36stories where you're present with each other,
- 4:40you're... You're not trying to pre plan and you
- 4:44really get out of your head Well with this kind
- 4:45of improv and then also it does theater sports
- 4:47which are short games that we're gonna take you
- 4:49through a little bit today So that's how I come
- 4:51to this. I've also been performing as sung at
- 4:55LA Opera a couple seasons I've done a lot of
- 4:56musical theater and I studied with a Shakespeare
- 4:59coach in the UK So I left the practice of law
- 5:02the practice of transactional business affairs
- 5:04to do this full -time to do performance skills
- 5:08for lawyers, for leaders, and improvisation is
- 5:11a key part of that. So in my Stanford class,
- 5:13in my Berkeley class, we do a lot of work on
- 5:17getting lawyers comfortable being vulnerable
- 5:20in front of each other, making mistakes, getting
- 5:23out of their head. So that's how I use it in
- 5:25my work now as a performance skills and public
- 5:27speaking coach for lawyers. Jen, I'll hand it
- 5:30over to you. Sure. Thank you all for joining
- 5:33us. I understand there were some technical difficulties,
- 5:37and as improvisers, Paul and I are pretty well
- 5:42-versed in just rolling with the punches, and
- 5:44I think that's something that lawyers need to
- 5:46be able to do as well. Just real quick about
- 5:51me. was a big theater kid, a big theater geek,
- 5:57all through my childhood. I did a lot of theater
- 6:01and started doing improv in college at Stanford
- 6:05and knew that I was interested in the law, knew
- 6:09I wanted to be a lawyer. But once I started doing
- 6:12improv, I also never stopped doing that. And
- 6:14I continued to do it. I took a break between
- 6:18college and law school to teach seventh and eleventh
- 6:21grade English at a school. in the South Bay where
- 6:24I started the improv group there and it continues
- 6:28to this day because a heroic math teacher took
- 6:30my class and has taken over the group and then
- 6:33continue to do it through law school and I really
- 6:35have not stopped performing, studying, teaching
- 6:38improv for almost 30 years now. And after law
- 6:44school, I knew I wanted to be a litigator. I
- 6:47clerked on the Ninth Circuit. And I was at a
- 6:51firm in DC for a little bit. And then for 17
- 6:54years, I was a federal prosecutor as an assistant
- 6:57US attorney here in Los Angeles at the US attorney's
- 7:01office. And I tried a lot of cases, argued a
- 7:06lot of appeals. And also for the last nine years,
- 7:09I've been teaching This would be my ninth year
- 7:12of teaching trial advocacy at USC Gould School
- 7:15of Law. And just recently, I had a big pivot
- 7:19myself in which I left the US Attorney's Office
- 7:22to join Piper Wolf, Carr, Kane, Conway, and Weiss
- 7:28as a plaintiff side litigation, civil litigation
- 7:30firm, and I joined their fertility and IVF misconduct
- 7:35practice. The thread throughout all of this is
- 7:41that I have always been doing improv, regardless
- 7:45of what I've been doing in the law, because I
- 7:49see that the skills that you get from improv
- 7:51as something that will really enrich and and
- 7:58heighten your legal practice. Again, I'm a litigator.
- 8:01Paul's coming more from a transactional side.
- 8:04But regardless of your legal practice, it will
- 8:07be something that will be made better for you
- 8:11if you apply the skills that you do as an improviser.
- 8:15The other reason that I keep doing improv is
- 8:17that it's, as Paul mentioned, it's fun. It brings
- 8:20joy. It's a safe space where you can let go of
- 8:25the The rules and restrictions of being a lawyer.
- 8:29I mean, you know we go through law school Being
- 8:33taught how to be a lawyer and that almost always
- 8:36means saying no, right? You're learning how to
- 8:38be careful. You're learning how to be cautious.
- 8:40You're learning how to evaluate risk cost -benefit
- 8:43analysis, you know think of and anticipate and
- 8:48make contingencies for negative consequences,
- 8:51it's a lot of worrying about the future and you
- 8:56know, that is good for lawyers. Sometimes it's
- 8:59not that great in your life, right? Sometimes
- 9:02it can make you kind of an unpleasant person
- 9:04to your partner, to your kids, to your family,
- 9:07to your friends. If you're the one that's always
- 9:08saying, no, no, no, no, no. Improv and continuing
- 9:12to do improv for me is a great reminder that
- 9:16I'm not just a lawyer. I am also a human and
- 9:20that and that life is made better when you're
- 9:25able to embrace some of these tenets of improv,
- 9:28particularly saying yes. You know, I could do
- 9:32a whole several hours on how I apply improv as
- 9:36a parent to parenting two small kids. Maybe we'll
- 9:40touch on some of that later. But for sure, you
- 9:43know, what Paul and I hope to accomplish in this
- 9:46hour is to give you a little sense of some of
- 9:51the skills that we have developed as improvisers
- 9:54over the, you know, our careers. And because
- 9:58we're also both attorneys, how it is that we
- 10:01have found those skills to apply in our legal
- 10:05practices. But always, it's going to come back
- 10:08for me to how can it make you a happier and better
- 10:11person. Paul, you want to get started? I love
- 10:17that so much, Jen. Some of these games that we're
- 10:19going to show you today will definitely be useful
- 10:21for kids. Watery is a great one. Hopefully that'll
- 10:25be useful for you. I do want to say just briefly
- 10:28before we launch into the practical skills and
- 10:32the fun games that we're going to show you, that
- 10:34science backs us up now. So we're at a place,
- 10:37you've all heard about improv in the workplace.
- 10:40There's a burgeoning industry out there, often
- 10:43of improvisers and improvisation companies that'll
- 10:45go into corporations and teach this. And there's
- 10:49research on it. So there's the Alda Center at
- 10:51Stony Brook. He's done a lot of work on this
- 10:53recently and other programs that are... Sorry.
- 11:01You have some good yard work going on there.
- 11:03I love it. So there's research now and what it
- 11:08shows from the science, from the cognitive science
- 11:10aspect is really exciting for lawyers. So there's
- 11:13a few areas where improv is shown now to help
- 11:17thinking skills and divergent thinking is a big
- 11:21one. So we do a lot of convergent thinking as
- 11:24lawyers. That's when you're distilling down the
- 11:27case. That's when you are doing a deductive or
- 11:30sorry. Yeah. Deductive reasoning. Right. So you're,
- 11:34you're putting something into a smaller category.
- 11:37Divergent thinking is creative thinking. So that's
- 11:40thinking outside the box. That's finding the
- 11:43creative way to close a deal, which is what I
- 11:46was doing in Hollywood for 15 years. Right. When
- 11:48it seems like you're at an impasse. How do you
- 11:51reset and have an ability to have creative thinking?
- 11:54And improv is shown scientifically to help you
- 11:57with that. And that's useful in litigation too,
- 12:00right? So if you want to follow a new piece of
- 12:06information that comes up in a deposition or
- 12:08in a witness examination, not being locked into
- 12:11your brief, into your outline is gonna be really
- 12:13helpful for that. So divergent thinking, uncertainty
- 12:16tolerance, dealing with risk. wow we are we are
- 12:20the people that are at the center of risk in
- 12:22any company in any um client dispute right so
- 12:27we're we're asked to weigh risk and we need to
- 12:29be comfortable with that ambiguity and improv
- 12:31is shown now to help you with that comfort level
- 12:35and then effective well -being which gets back
- 12:37to joy affective well -being so that's the positive
- 12:40emotional state so improv is really useful from
- 12:43a scientific perspective and what jen and i are
- 12:45doing is we're bringing this what we know to
- 12:48be true in our hearts. Now we know it to be true
- 12:50in our heads. We're bringing it to you as practicing
- 12:52lawyers that can help you apply this in your
- 12:56daily life. No, I know many of you guys. just
- 13:00joined us. We had to restart the Zoom because
- 13:02of technical difficulties. So I just want to
- 13:05repeat something that you may have missed the
- 13:07first time, which is this is a very unusual format
- 13:10for us. Paul and I have been teaching improv
- 13:13to law schools around the country, to lawyers
- 13:15all over. And it's rarely a non -interactive
- 13:20webinar where you just see us talking and we're
- 13:23going to play some games later. But just the
- 13:25two of us, if you have somebody with you, feel
- 13:27free to do some games. there but you know if
- 13:32you want to have a more complete and frankly
- 13:37a lot more fun experience you know I encourage
- 13:40you to reach out to us about doing a workshop
- 13:43at your firm with your team whatever it is because
- 13:48you know improv is inherently collaborative and
- 13:51it is about understanding how you're going to
- 13:54interact with the people around you whether it's
- 13:56your co -counsel, opposing council judge, client,
- 14:02jury, right? And so I just wanna sort of lay
- 14:07the mattress for us here that it is a little
- 14:10odd to just be listening to two talking heads
- 14:12discussing how great doing improv is without
- 14:16the chance to actually do it. My hope is that
- 14:18you guys can listen to what we're saying, see
- 14:21what it is that we're doing and then... get excited
- 14:26for more in a more interactive and in -person
- 14:29way. Even on Zoom is better if we can actually
- 14:33see everybody. We know you're out there. We're
- 14:36told you're out there. And if you have any feedback,
- 14:40questions, comments, please use the chat because
- 14:44we want this to be as useful for you guys as
- 14:47possible. So please be a part of this conversation
- 14:50through the chat. Thank you, Jen. Yes. And as
- 14:56we get into the material here, so we've we've
- 14:58thought about how to divide this up for lawyers.
- 15:01So we came up with three different areas that
- 15:03we think this this concept of applied improvisation
- 15:06can be useful for the practice of law. The first
- 15:08one's readiness. The second one is collaboration.
- 15:11And the last one is storytelling. So what we're
- 15:14going to do right now, we'll walk you through
- 15:15each of them and give you a few one or two different
- 15:19games that we can play. And Jen and I will demonstrate
- 15:22them. So at times we might be asking for comments,
- 15:27for suggestions from the audience. I don't know
- 15:30how many people we have live on the webinar now.
- 15:32If we don't get one, that's all right. We'll
- 15:34make it up ourselves. But we're going to ask
- 15:37for a little bit of participation in that way
- 15:39at times. So first of all, with readiness, embracing
- 15:43failure, embracing failure. We talked about how
- 15:48lawyers tend to be perfectionists. I certainly
- 15:50would have called myself a perfectionist for
- 15:52the first 20 years of my career. And this is
- 15:56a safe space now when you're doing an improvisation
- 15:58exercise to make mistakes. In fact, mistakes
- 16:01are required in improv, I would say. So Jen,
- 16:04why don't we try a foundational improvisation
- 16:08exercise just between the two of us where we're
- 16:12telling a story together? Sure. Ren, can you
- 16:15take the slide down? Oh, yes. Thank you. Thanks.
- 16:18So this is called word at a time story. This
- 16:21is what I love about improv. Often the titles
- 16:23are very, very obvious, which we'll get to later.
- 16:26So word at a time story. What we're gonna do
- 16:27is we're gonna tell a story together. We're gonna
- 16:30make it up. We haven't practiced this. We don't
- 16:32know what the story is gonna be about. If you
- 16:34have a suggestion for a story, do put it in the
- 16:39Q &A. So what is the topic of this story? The
- 16:44way that this works is we're gonna take turns
- 16:46So each of us only get one word or in improv
- 16:51terms one offer at a time So part of what we
- 16:55have to do is we have to share control of the
- 16:58story So Jen anything else you want to add before
- 17:02we get started? You want to just dive right into
- 17:03it? I think we'll go ahead and do it. All right.
- 17:08And just so you guys know, Paul and I have been
- 17:12doing improv together for a long time. We met
- 17:15over, I think, nearly 15 years ago. And we're
- 17:19part of the same improv group, actually. But
- 17:22these games that we're talking about, I don't
- 17:24know that we've ever actually played these games,
- 17:26just the two of us. So, you know, we're gonna
- 17:29see what happens. All right? Okay. Cats is our
- 17:32suggestion, Jen. Cats? Cats. cat wait cats or
- 17:36hats cats cats okay all right once upon a time
- 17:43there was a man who loved cats every morning
- 17:52he would go to the store and buy a cat until
- 18:05one day he looked at his cats and realized he
- 18:15had 300 cats. Oh, that's a lot of cats. All right,
- 18:30we saw how this goes thank you for the suggestion
- 18:34of cats So that we didn't know where the story
- 18:38was gonna go we started it once upon a time That's
- 18:40typically how you would start a word at a time
- 18:42story. That's the structure of the game, but
- 18:44we didn't know where it was gonna go so How did
- 18:48we tell that story together? Well, we had to
- 18:53first of all not be afraid to make a mistake.
- 18:55It wasn't gonna be a perfect story we knew that
- 18:59you know, maybe one word would surprise us. Jen,
- 19:01were you ever surprised by anything that I said
- 19:03in that? Uh, store. I think store threw me. Um,
- 19:10uh, you know, but we went ahead and, and, and
- 19:13went with it. Yeah. And I was surprised by three.
- 19:17Like I didn't know, was it, he only had a few
- 19:19cats or do we have to make it a bigger number?
- 19:21So yeah, I had to go with that. So that's part
- 19:25of what you do in this. And then The other thing
- 19:28we had to do is we had to commit to it. And you'll
- 19:31notice we committed to it, not just in terms
- 19:33of the truth of the story, keeping it simple.
- 19:36I was imagining this man who was going to the
- 19:38store and had all these cats at his house as
- 19:40we told it. And maybe, Jen, you had a different
- 19:43image of it. But we were committed to that image.
- 19:46And we didn't let our brain get in the way to
- 19:50second guess what we were saying. I want to add
- 19:53a note about embracing failure. I actually think
- 19:57that that was a fairly successful story. It made
- 20:00sense. And I think that if you had the 300 cats,
- 20:03you too would look at them and say, oh, that's
- 20:05a lot of cats. But what I noticed when I'm playing
- 20:08this game and when I'm teaching this game is
- 20:10I'm not only listening to what people are saying
- 20:12in terms of the words, but I'm also looking at
- 20:14their faces. Because their faces will reveal
- 20:16how they feel about how the story is going. And
- 20:20this is something that I am cognizant of when
- 20:24I'm in trial or when I'm appearing before a judge,
- 20:27when I'm appearing before a jury, basically anybody
- 20:29who is going to be looking at my face, my body,
- 20:32my posture, and evaluating or interpreting that
- 20:38nonverbal expression that I'm giving. And so
- 20:42I don't think that this happened here, but I've
- 20:44certainly seen it where if somebody says a word
- 20:47in the story that I did not like or I wasn't
- 20:51or I'm thinking in my head, that's dumb. I want
- 20:55to not let my face give it away too much, right?
- 20:58But I have certainly seen people in playing these
- 21:01games, they're closed off, they're standing like
- 21:03this, and then when a word comes up and they're
- 21:05going, ah, you know, that is... I mean, it's
- 21:09okay when you're doing improv, but even in a
- 21:12safe improv space to express this kind of negativity
- 21:15over an offer that you are trying to or that
- 21:19has come up in the course of collaboration, I
- 21:22mean, you're making a response to that, right?
- 21:25If my witness gives an answer that is confusing
- 21:29or that is not something that I was expecting,
- 21:32you know, I know cerebrally, I need to fix it,
- 21:36right? I'm going to have to clarify. I'm gonna
- 21:38have to rehabilitate it. But the last thing I
- 21:40wanna do is highlight that this was a quote unquote
- 21:43mistake. I don't wanna... give it away, right?
- 21:47I don't want to undermine my witness's credibility
- 21:49by making a face or acting confused. I want to
- 21:53say, yes, OK, let's clarify that. Or can we fix
- 21:58that? Or how am I going to rehabilitate your
- 22:00answer? Because I don't want the jury to think
- 22:04that I think that he's made a mistake, right?
- 22:06I don't want the jury to think that I'm judging.
- 22:09Uh the witness's answer. I want to keep that
- 22:12positive flow going. I want to keep the story
- 22:15going Oh, I love that so much jen and with the
- 22:19lawyers that I work with. I don't know if you're
- 22:20like this I'm certainly like this. We're very
- 22:22hard on ourselves When we make mistakes And I
- 22:26think that can sometimes blow the mistake out
- 22:28of proportion So if we're beating ourselves up
- 22:31over making a quote unquote mistake in the practice
- 22:33of law Oftentimes it doesn't read as a mistake
- 22:36to the others in the room And the more that you
- 22:39beat yourself up over it and the more that you
- 22:41internalize it, like that's undercutting your
- 22:44client's needs in cases. So part of this is just
- 22:47reframing it and zooming out a bit and putting
- 22:50less pressure on what those mistakes are. Because
- 22:52as we all know, the more you practice, most mistakes
- 22:54can be fixed later on. So give yourself some
- 22:59grace there. I love that, Jen. I mean, I just
- 23:03want to say, but especially, right? I mean, the
- 23:06law, even if you're a solo practitioner, you're
- 23:08again, very seldom just totally by yourself,
- 23:11right? And so when you think about how you react
- 23:14to other people's mistakes, particularly your
- 23:17colleagues, right? I mean, think about how you
- 23:20can give them some grace as well. The last piece
- 23:24of readiness that I think is really important
- 23:26and this is something that's a bigger subject
- 23:28that I spent a lot of time coaching executives
- 23:30and lawyers on is presence and For me what we
- 23:35had to do when we were telling that story. We
- 23:37had to be ready We had to be here with each other
- 23:40so that we weren't stopping the story that we
- 23:43weren't retreating from the story and also That
- 23:46we weren't pushing too much and trying to get
- 23:47our next word and drive the story in a certain
- 23:50direction So there was a give and take that had
- 23:53to be there. And so this state of readiness is
- 23:56really, really important when it comes to executive
- 23:59presence, when it comes to courtroom presence,
- 24:02when, when I was negotiating deals, how you show
- 24:06up, right? Are you showing up as a full human
- 24:09being in that moment when things matter the most?
- 24:13So for me and what I teach and a lot of my presence
- 24:17theories that I teach go back to Patsy Rodenberg,
- 24:19who is the Shakespeare scholar that I studied
- 24:21with in the UK. And she came up with this idea
- 24:24that actors when they have stage presence are
- 24:28in this state where they're neither retreating
- 24:30and they're neither pushing too much. So having
- 24:33that sense of give and take, that sense of flow
- 24:35is something that's attention. It's how are you
- 24:39paying attention in a moment? But there's also
- 24:40a physical aspect. There's a physical aspect
- 24:43to presence that's really, really important.
- 24:46So are you standing tall? Is your spine long?
- 24:49Are you connected to the ground? Are you breathing?
- 24:53Which is a huge thing for us. So that's part
- 24:57of why we do improv is that it keeps us in this
- 24:59state of alertness, but reminds us the practice
- 25:03of it. The tough thing about it is can you breathe?
- 25:06Can you stay grounded while being there attention
- 25:09wise? So that's a great thing that improv can
- 25:11help with. I always tell my students in my trial
- 25:14ed class that you in trial want to present yourself
- 25:17as the most credible version of yourself. You
- 25:21know, and so if you are, by nature, kind of shifty
- 25:23and shady looking, you're going to have to work
- 25:25on it, right? You have to open up yourself. You
- 25:29have to present a version of yourself that is
- 25:33still you, right? Juries can totally tell when
- 25:36you're faking it, but you want it to be the most
- 25:39credible version. And if, you know, and that
- 25:41can be achieved. This is sort of more like self
- 25:43-awareness and a little more theater, you know,
- 25:46presentation presence, like Paul is saying, and
- 25:48less about improv, but just know. the character
- 25:52that you are gonna express depending on whether
- 25:56you stand up tall and your arms are by your side
- 26:00and your head is still and you're speaking in
- 26:02complete sentences versus... you know, just even
- 26:06small minor adjustments where you're not holding
- 26:10eye contact, where you're touching your face.
- 26:13I mean, this really can make a big difference
- 26:16in how you present and that kind of self -awareness
- 26:19can can be very handy. You know, you walk into
- 26:22a room and you want to know what is the version
- 26:24of myself I need to present right now. Yes, a
- 26:27shifty lawyer. Most people don't want a shifty
- 26:29lawyer. Some might. I don't know. Yeah, so so
- 26:33so valuable. So this is the next section, collaboration.
- 26:37This is a huge part of improv and a huge benefit
- 26:40to anybody, as Jen said, who works in a team,
- 26:43which we all do. Practicing law, even if you're
- 26:46a tax lawyer, figuring out something really intricate
- 26:49at your desk, that ultimately you have to communicate
- 26:52it, right? And you have to show up in those client
- 26:54meetings and you have to show up in partner meetings
- 26:57or wherever it may be and be heard and listen
- 27:01and connect. So improv is great for that. So
- 27:07we're gonna talk about a few different aspects
- 27:09here. We'll put the slide down in a second. So
- 27:11listening is one thing we'll go through. Saying
- 27:13yes, which as most of us who know anything about
- 27:16improv have heard, yes and is one of the principle
- 27:19foundational principles. Being obvious we've
- 27:22mentioned and then sharing control and making
- 27:23your partner look good. So we can put down the
- 27:26slide now Rin, thank you so much. uh and let's
- 27:29do a couple exercises that get to listening and
- 27:32saying yes so this is a fun one this is called
- 27:36last letter first letter and if anybody wants
- 27:39to put another suggestion in the q a right now
- 27:43feel free to uh one word is is great that's all
- 27:45we need so this one is exactly how it sounds
- 27:49last letter first letter so we're going to have
- 27:51a conversation and jen is going to be listening
- 27:55to me And when I am done with my sentence or
- 28:00paragraph, hopefully we'll keep it to just a
- 28:02second here. She's going to be listening for
- 28:05the last letter spelling wise of the last word
- 28:10that I speak. So that's K if it's speak. And
- 28:15then she will start her next sentence, her response
- 28:19to me as we have this conversation with the letter
- 28:21K. So 26 options. and you don't know which one
- 28:27it's gonna be. So that's last letter, first letter.
- 28:31Okay, do we have a suggestion? Coffee, awesome.
- 28:38Jen, you wanna start? Sure. Hazelnut latte for
- 28:46Paul. Let's give her another hazelnut latte.
- 28:53Every morning. She comes in and she tries to
- 28:57put down a different name so that we don't realize
- 29:01she drinks hailed nut lattes far more than she
- 29:05should. Darn it. I wish I wish I could work somewhere
- 29:09else. This is a stressful job. Boy, tell me about
- 29:14it. I don't even have time to drink my own coffee
- 29:17these days. Sandra, you're so right. Neither
- 29:20do I. If we owned our own coffee shop, but only
- 29:27sold one coffee every five minutes, that would
- 29:31give us time to live our lives. So true. And
- 29:35if we charge the right amount for that one cup
- 29:37of coffee, we could be millionaires too. Oh my
- 29:41God, people love overpriced artisanal coffees.
- 29:47Everyone loves them. I can't get enough myself.
- 29:51For sure So that's how it goes right we don't
- 29:58know what's gonna come up Sometimes there's gonna
- 30:00be a letter that I don't and I wasn't trying
- 30:02to trick you with any letters We kept it pretty
- 30:04simple, but F is a tougher one. Maybe not expected
- 30:07one So how is that for you, Jen? Any observations
- 30:10from that game? Sure. I love Last Letter, First
- 30:13Letter because it is one of those games where
- 30:17the rule requires you to listen from the beginning
- 30:20of the sentence all the way to the end. I will
- 30:23play this in my trial ad class where, you know,
- 30:26I will set up the witness and the attorney who's
- 30:32examining the witness and I will make the attorney
- 30:34have to play Last Letter, First Letter. Um, and
- 30:38I often find that, you know, when you're in trial
- 30:41or, um, or a deposition, right, that you have
- 30:44your scripted questions and you have a sense
- 30:46of what the witness is going to say. And, um,
- 30:50you're not really listening to your witness and
- 30:53you're just thinking about your next question.
- 30:55You're thinking ahead to your closing. You're
- 30:57thinking, you know, head to your next witness,
- 30:58whatever it is, you're missing out on the most
- 31:02important thing that is happening, which is the
- 31:04witnesses answers to your question. And if you're
- 31:07not listening, you can miss out on all kinds
- 31:11of gold nuggets. Maybe the witness is. you know,
- 31:16skipping ahead to a new topic that you realize
- 31:22makes a lot of sense now to discuss instead of
- 31:25waiting, you know, and you're gonna go with it,
- 31:27right? And we're gonna get into yes and in a
- 31:29second, but you yes and your witness, cause you've
- 31:32been listening to your witness and you go down
- 31:34that road and the jury actually will understand
- 31:37that particular line of questioning more than
- 31:39if you had waited to where you had planned it
- 31:41in your script. The witness might say, something
- 31:45that, you know, is not accurate. And now you
- 31:48need to, you know, either fix it if you're on
- 31:51direct or exploit it if you're on cross, right?
- 31:55If you're on cross and your witness says something
- 31:57that opens the door to a line of questioning
- 31:59that you didn't think you'd be able to get into.
- 32:01But now they've done it and you go down that
- 32:04road and it benefits your case. Right. If you
- 32:07hadn't been listening and you miss it, a lot
- 32:10of missed opportunities there. So, you know,
- 32:13especially for a litigator. But, you know, even
- 32:15if you are doing negotiations, transactions,
- 32:19anything that requires active listening, this
- 32:23is a good game for you to practice active listening.
- 32:27And honestly, if you want to show respect to
- 32:30somebody, if you want to show someone that you
- 32:32really, really, really respect them, love them,
- 32:34whatever it is, listening to them with your full
- 32:37attention is the greatest thing that you can
- 32:38do. That's awesome. Jen, I'm going off script
- 32:42a little bit. Can we demonstrate the witness
- 32:44examination with last letter, first letter briefly?
- 32:47Oh, sure. I'll be your witness. Oh, OK. All right.
- 32:50Sure. All right. Well, you know, I was a federal
- 32:53prosecutor for a long time, so let's make this
- 32:55a criminal case. All right. So, all right. Detective
- 33:01O'Malley, what did you see when you first arrived
- 33:07at the crime scene? Everything was covered in
- 33:12blood. It was horrific. There was a body that
- 33:19was strewn out over the couch. And it was one
- 33:22of the worst things I've seen in my entire career.
- 33:26Really? Strewn all over the couch? That seems
- 33:30to suggest that the body was in multiple pieces.
- 33:34So many pieces. It was horrific. Can you describe
- 33:42for the jury Where each body part was on the
- 33:48couch when you first entered the living room?
- 33:54Most of them were on the cushions Some of the
- 33:59bigger body parts were on the floor Right the
- 34:07body part on the floor that I'm most interested
- 34:09in is the head. Could you describe what the expression
- 34:17on the victim's face appeared to be to you? Understanding.
- 34:31It looked like the witness had just realized
- 34:35something really, or the victim had just realized
- 34:37something really important. That is a very interesting
- 34:47observation. Perhaps the victim could have just
- 34:52discovered the secret that the killer was trying
- 34:58to keep. Perhaps. Of course, that calls for speculation,
- 35:02so wow, drawing the objection there. All right,
- 35:05that's your Halloween, your gory improv game.
- 35:09That's so fun. I love doing that, Jen. I just
- 35:11have to say, I know you guys are watching and
- 35:14hopefully you're enjoying this. I'm enjoying
- 35:17the hell out of this because it is such a delight
- 35:19that when Paul and I started this webinar 20,
- 35:2330 minutes ago, we had no idea that we were going
- 35:26to end up doing a witness examination about body
- 35:30parts with an understanding victim. So how fun
- 35:34to just create something out of nothing on a
- 35:37random Wednesday morning. So the second important
- 35:43tool with collaboration that we have here is
- 35:45YesAnd. Let's talk about that. So most people,
- 35:50if you ask them what is the first rule of improv,
- 35:53somebody out there knows enough about improv
- 35:54that they're probably going to say yes and. When
- 35:57I'm teaching an in -person class, I actually
- 36:00point out that the most important rule of improv
- 36:02is safety first. That is where the improv and
- 36:06the law collide. We always want to make sure
- 36:08that people are being safe, especially physically
- 36:11in a room. But yes and is fundamental. It's fundamental
- 36:15to any kind of progress in collaboration. Paul
- 36:20has already used the word offer. Sometimes you
- 36:23can think of it as a gift, right? So whenever
- 36:25anybody says something to you or offers you an
- 36:28idea, think of it as a gift and something that
- 36:32you are being offered and that you have the choice
- 36:36now to accept. And not just accept, but how are
- 36:39you gonna accept it? Are you gonna accept it
- 36:40with positivity? Are you gonna accept it sort
- 36:43of like how? Are you going to not accept it at
- 36:45all? And this is especially crucial for negotiations,
- 36:51but yes and is how you're going to advance any
- 36:55kind of interpersonal collaboration. So Paul,
- 36:59I want us to do a little conversation in which
- 37:02we're going to plan something and go ahead and
- 37:05put in the Q &A. What is this thing that Paul
- 37:07and I are planning? But here's the thing is that
- 37:11I am only allowed to say one of three lines.
- 37:15I can only say no, I can say no way, or I can
- 37:20say that's dumb, which I hear from my children
- 37:23all the time when I'm making suggestions to them.
- 37:26So let's see how that lands. Did we get a suggestion
- 37:29in the Q &A? I don't think so. Oh, a bank robbery
- 37:34dressed as clowns. You have bank robbery and
- 37:36clowns. Oh, Jen, I have a question for you before
- 37:38we start. So am I also doing those same? Three
- 37:41responses or no, no, you get to say whatever
- 37:44you want. I've got my three responses and I hear
- 37:47clowns. So let's plan a birthday party, a kid's
- 37:49birthday or a terrifying adult party. No, let's
- 37:52do a kid's birthday party. So Elizabeth, I'm
- 37:57really excited about Jenny's party this week.
- 38:02No. She's been looking forward to it all year.
- 38:09No way. Yeah, she she came to me last week and
- 38:15asked that we have clowns for her so no way I
- 38:23Think clowns are a great idea and there's one
- 38:25that lives down the street. She offered to do
- 38:27it for free. No Jenny's gonna be so sad That's
- 38:34dumb You're calling our child dumb because you
- 38:40don't like clowns That's dumb. Oh Okay, okay.
- 38:46Okay. Let's just stop it here. Let's stop it
- 38:48here. Okay, so uh What got planned? Ultimately
- 38:52what changed what was accomplished, right? Literally
- 38:56nothing. Okay. Maybe they're getting a divorce.
- 38:58Yeah, let's play on something else. I know Oh
- 39:01poor poor Jenny. Let's plan something else. Go
- 39:03ahead and drop that wait What was the other suggestion
- 39:06that we had in the chat? It was something and
- 39:08it was a bank robbery Okay, let's plan a bank
- 39:11robbery Only this time I will speak the lines
- 39:14and Paul your only lines You get to say your
- 39:18own lines, too. Oh wait. No, you know what? Let's
- 39:20just go straight to the no Let's go to the no
- 39:22so or let's go to the hmm Let's go to the yes.
- 39:26Yes, you get to say yes You get to say sounds
- 39:30good and you get to say let's go. All right.
- 39:33These are your only three options Okay, okay.
- 39:36All right Okay, I'm so excited to finally hit
- 39:43the federal credit union on first and main Let's
- 39:48go. I got the car and back. Okay. Yeah. No, you
- 39:51only get to say yes Oh, sounds good. And let's
- 39:56go. Right. No, those are your only three lines.
- 39:58All right. OK. I failed. Yay. Yay. Ordinarily,
- 40:03of course. And I actually got very excited that
- 40:05you had a car. But for the purpose of this exercise,
- 40:08I want the audience to see here what happens
- 40:11when you do say those lines, because the next
- 40:14one we're going to get to. OK? All right. So
- 40:16do we have a suggestion for something else that
- 40:17we're planning? The Federal Credit Union is safe
- 40:19for now. I saw turtles earlier in the chat. Turtles.
- 40:25Okay. All right. Let's plan a let's plan a beach
- 40:28vacation. Okay, great All right. Okay. Hey, honey
- 40:31So when we get to Hawaii, I was thinking maybe
- 40:36we could Get a cabana at the pool sounds good
- 40:41okay, and what if we You know, what if we woke
- 40:48up super early so we could get out to the beach
- 40:51and like stake out the best piece of real estate
- 40:53Let's go. And what if we actually took some scuba
- 41:01lessons? Yes. Because then we could go scuba
- 41:06diving. Yes. And we could see those turtles that
- 41:10everybody has been talking about on Reddit. Yes.
- 41:14So let's go ahead and book all those things.
- 41:19Let's go. Okay, all right. Okay, so that was
- 41:23great. We accomplished a lot. But what I want
- 41:26to point out is that Paul, although he did not
- 41:31stop me from suggesting any of the plans, his
- 41:34character did not exactly contribute to it, right?
- 41:37And so we're talking about the various levels
- 41:39of from no to yes. And so we started at no, we
- 41:45got to yes, and now I want to kind of backtrack
- 41:50a little bit to what's in between and this is
- 41:52something that lawyers do all the time either
- 41:56when we're saying we're either saying no or we
- 41:58are going to say yes but okay and so paul and
- 42:03i are going to plan something else and um this
- 42:06time we both get to say our you know our our
- 42:09lines but our lines must start with yes butt.
- 42:13And I want you guys watching this to clock what
- 42:16kind of progress we're able to make. Do we have
- 42:19another suggestion for something that we could
- 42:21plan? In the Q &A? Yeah. Do you have anything?
- 42:32Yeah, cruise to Antarctica. Okay. A cruise to
- 42:35Antarctica. Cool. Okay. All right. So I was thinking
- 42:44that for our anniversary we could, I don't know,
- 42:49go on a cruise to Antarctica? Yes, but it sounds
- 42:55sort of cold. Maybe we can go to Mexico instead?
- 43:08Yeah, but I don't... We were just there and,
- 43:14you know, I thought it'd be nice to do something
- 43:16we haven't done yet. Oh, what about deep sea
- 43:23fishing? We can charter a boat. Yes. But I do
- 43:29get seasick, too, if we're out too long. Maybe...
- 43:41We could go to Las Vegas. Yes, but last time,
- 43:53I mean, things got a little out of hand and we
- 43:57barely made it out, you know, so I'm not sure
- 44:02that actually were allowed back into the entire
- 44:07strip. Okay, all right, so let's stop there.
- 44:12All right, so again, we were saying yes to each
- 44:16other, but nothing got accomplished, right? At
- 44:19the end of the, at the scene, they still have
- 44:22no anniversary plan because yes, but is a sneaky
- 44:26no. So just be mindful of that when your goal
- 44:31is to accept an offer and to advance and have
- 44:36progress. Yes, but. is a sneaky no that is actually
- 44:40going to stop that. And so the final thing we're
- 44:43going to do is write the fundamental, the yes
- 44:48and, where you are not only accepting the offer,
- 44:50but you're going to build on it. And that is
- 44:52where true collaboration is going to live. So
- 44:55do we have another suggestion for something we're
- 44:57planning? Jewelry shopping. Jewelry shopping?
- 45:01Oh, I like that. So everything we say has to
- 45:05start with yes and. Okay. Great. Okay. Well,
- 45:12I'm so happy to help you select the special ring
- 45:18for your special person. Yes, and I want it to
- 45:21be a big diamond. Yes, and this is our very,
- 45:27very biggest diamond that we have in the entire
- 45:29store. I'll let you guess how many carats it
- 45:32is. Oh, I'll just tell you, it's 30. Yes, and
- 45:38I love all of the different colorings in it.
- 45:40It seems very unusual. Yes, and there is no other
- 45:45ring in the entire world like it. We actually
- 45:49commissioned this from not one, not two, but
- 45:54three celebrity wives of actual celebrities who
- 46:00are now celebrity jewelers. Yes, and my wife
- 46:04Denise is an aspiring celebrity, so I think she'll
- 46:07like it a lot. Yes, and I have heard about your
- 46:12wife Denise, and I think she has the perfect
- 46:15frame to carry off a 30 -carat ring. Although
- 46:19it seems like, you know, she has two hands, you
- 46:23might want to have something to offset this ring
- 46:27and balance it on the other hand. Yes. And if
- 46:32the price is right, I think there's a deal to
- 46:34be made there. Yes. And for somebody who is going
- 46:40to buy 60 carats worth of diamonds, there is
- 46:45definitely a deal to be made. OK. All right.
- 46:49And so this is, of course, the magic of improv,
- 46:52which is something from nothing. Now, obviously,
- 46:56when we are talking about you know, real cases
- 47:00with real facts, you do not have creative license,
- 47:03you do not get to make up your fact. But the
- 47:06principle, the skill is there, which is, you
- 47:09know, even in the direct examination that we
- 47:11did about the body parts strewn over the couch,
- 47:14right, there is yes and at work there. Because
- 47:17if he had said there were body parts strewn over
- 47:20the couch, right, I could have known him. I could
- 47:24have ignored him. I could have moved on to the
- 47:28next question. And now I want to ask you about
- 47:30what's happening in the garage, right? But if
- 47:33you yes and, that is a form of very effective
- 47:38storytelling, right? In which you are continuing
- 47:41down the path that you have set and your audience,
- 47:45your fact -finders, your judge, your jury, and
- 47:48your witness, they feel like they're a part of
- 47:51it. They feel like they're on the same page and
- 47:54they're going to be able to build on it. And
- 47:55this actually - Go ahead, Jen. No, no, go ahead.
- 47:58I was gonna move on to the next thing but I was
- 48:00gonna add on the transactional side and this
- 48:02is really really important for yes and and this
- 48:05is why you should have lawyers teach you improv
- 48:07because yet saying yes does not in this context
- 48:11does not necessarily mean you are agreeing to
- 48:14the words that the other side is saying what
- 48:17we were asking for is a you're a yes ending the
- 48:21situation you're not denying the the reality
- 48:23of the situation so as a negotiator I don't have
- 48:26to agree that your client deserves $500 million.
- 48:30I could have a very different point of view on
- 48:32what the facts are and what's right in this case.
- 48:35But what I can yes and is that your client's
- 48:37really upset about something and that their business
- 48:42realities are a certain way. So there's a way
- 48:45to listen and a way to use yes and that involves
- 48:48more than just the semantic meaning of the words
- 48:51that you're saying. And we as lawyers get cautious
- 48:54about that because of course contracts are formed
- 48:56with yes and, but when you're having a conversation,
- 49:00when you're having a negotiation, when you're
- 49:01deescalating conflict, yes anding the emotional
- 49:04stakes behind something or just the facts on
- 49:07the ground or that it feels true to them can
- 49:10be really, really valuable. I feel like there's
- 49:13a lot of yes anding, as well, that potential
- 49:17for yes anding in the regulatory sphere. If you're
- 49:21trying to come up with policy for regulating
- 49:24something and you have a lot of stakeholders
- 49:26and you have a lot of differing perspectives
- 49:28and differing interests and needs, I mean, you
- 49:32have to take those things into consideration.
- 49:34Now, it doesn't mean that you're going to give
- 49:35everybody what they want. But like Paul said,
- 49:37you want to be you know open to receiving uh
- 49:43and hearing what it is that they have to say
- 49:45so oh my god this is gonna summarize everything
- 49:47we just talked about you have to listen to what
- 49:48they're saying uh you know you have to fully
- 49:51listen you have to understand it and then you
- 49:53have to be ready to receive it and then you have
- 49:55to think about well you know if the goal is to
- 49:57try to come up with the scheme that makes the
- 50:00most sense with the best results for as many
- 50:02people as possible right how can we yes and what
- 50:06it is that they're trying to get at So I want
- 50:08to move on to the last thing that was on the
- 50:10collaboration slide, which is being obvious.
- 50:13And this ties into what I was saying before about,
- 50:16you know, when we are storytelling, when we are
- 50:21we're going down a particular path, that being
- 50:25obvious is one of the most important things that
- 50:27you can do as a lawyer who is trying to communicate
- 50:30your thoughts and persuade, be persuasive about
- 50:35your theory of the case or to get at whatever
- 50:38it is your end goal is. In improv, being obvious
- 50:45is crucial. When we are making things up together,
- 50:51it's not that I can actually read Paul's mind.
- 50:54He can't read mine. But when we're on the same
- 50:56page and we're advancing the story, it can feel
- 50:59like we're able to read each other's minds. But
- 51:01we're not. We're just being obvious. We're just
- 51:04doing the thing that makes the most sense that
- 51:06probably he's already thinking of anyway. And
- 51:08so even in the games that we've demonstrated
- 51:10here, even in the story about the man with the
- 51:13300 cats, I think it is a very obvious choice
- 51:16that he looked at his cat. and said, oh, that's
- 51:18a lot of cats. Suddenly this man is from Minnesota.
- 51:28Let's put it this way. You cannot be persuasive
- 51:31without being obvious. It's much harder to be
- 51:35persuasive when you're being clever. In improv
- 51:38parlance, the word clever is actually antithetical
- 51:42to improv. It means that you are doing something
- 51:46that may seem kind of cool and tricksy, but it
- 51:50is going to be by definition not obvious and
- 51:53so harder for the people who are on stage with
- 51:56you to follow and if the people on stage with
- 51:59you can't necessarily follow where you're going
- 52:01then think of where the audience is you know
- 52:03and I when I'm performing improv you can always
- 52:06tell that when an when an improviser says something
- 52:09clever the response that they get from the audience
- 52:11is like oh clever snap snaps it's a very different
- 52:15response than when the improviser says something
- 52:18obvious because the audience was thinking that
- 52:21too. And it's so satisfying to them that the
- 52:25improviser just said the thing that they were
- 52:27thinking, that they actually have a much more
- 52:30visceral and positive response. All right, now
- 52:33turn that audience into your jury. If you need
- 52:36to persuade your jury to believe the version
- 52:40of the story that you're trying to tell based
- 52:43on the facts that are in evidence, right? If
- 52:46you are telling the story in a very convoluted
- 52:48way, you're trying to be clever, maybe you're
- 52:52using words that the jury doesn't understand,
- 52:57or you're not speaking clearly, you're being
- 52:59too fancy with your syntax, guess what? You're
- 53:04going to lose your jury. And then guess what?
- 53:06You haven't persuaded them. And then guess what?
- 53:09you're going to lose, right? And so when I'm
- 53:12in trial, when I'm teaching trial ad, I am pushing
- 53:16being obvious as much as possible. Because if
- 53:21somebody doesn't understand what you're saying,
- 53:23even in that moment, if you've said something
- 53:26that the listener doesn't understand, Just in
- 53:29that moment that they're trying to figure out
- 53:31what it is you mean, you have lost them. You
- 53:34have lost their engagement because now they've
- 53:36retreated into their own head to make sense of
- 53:38what you've just said. But if you're doing everything
- 53:41in a very obvious way, you're going to be able
- 53:43to keep them on your train of thought. Juries
- 53:48in America, I don't know if juries elsewhere
- 53:50are like this, but the American jury process
- 53:53is inherently terrible for being obvious and
- 53:56very bad for storytelling. I'm skipping ahead
- 53:58a little bit to storytelling because I see we're
- 54:00kind of running out of time a little bit, but.
- 54:02you know, how does information come through in
- 54:05a jury trial, right? Not chronologically, you
- 54:08know, it's disjointed. You put one witness on,
- 54:12you got to pull everything out of that witness,
- 54:14you know, as you can. And then, you know, there's
- 54:19multiple cross -examinations sometimes, right?
- 54:22I mean, the information's coming at the jury
- 54:24in like the least effective way for storytelling
- 54:26as possible. And so, You have two large tasks.
- 54:31You have to be strategic in the way that that
- 54:33information is coming in within the constraints
- 54:36of a jury trial. And then you have to be ready
- 54:39to retell this story to the jury in your closings
- 54:44in a way that ties everything together, in a
- 54:48way that makes sense in an obvious way. And that
- 54:52is how you're going to be. persuasive. So we
- 54:55have here a couple of ways in which we talk about
- 54:58storytelling. I don't know that we're going to
- 55:00have time to get to all of it, but if you ever
- 55:06want to give yourself a very quick and visceral
- 55:11reminder of how great it is to be obvious, a
- 55:15game that I will play in my workshops is I will
- 55:18tell people to just walk around the room and
- 55:21point at objects, but then say, you know, what
- 55:24it's not, right? So I'm pointing at my laptop,
- 55:27but instead of saying computer, I'm going to
- 55:29say palm tree, right? And you just go around
- 55:32and for like one minute, just keep pointing at
- 55:34objects, really stare at them, but then come
- 55:36up with a word that is not what it is. And then
- 55:40take 30 seconds and walk around the same room
- 55:42and pointed objects and say what it is. And your
- 55:45brain will literally feel this huge sense of
- 55:50relief. because you just made it do all this
- 55:53work by being not obvious, having to come up
- 55:57with something that it is not, right? Palm tree
- 56:00instead of computer. And then to be able to go
- 56:03back to just saying what it is, great reminder
- 56:05that, you know, obvious is easier. Don't make
- 56:09your... Don't don't make your audience have to
- 56:12to work for it The last thing I'll say about
- 56:14being obvious is I also compare I teach a lot
- 56:17of legal research and writing as well You know
- 56:19and when I talk about clear persuasive writing
- 56:23the the big takeaway in what I teach is you need
- 56:27to put your argument in literally every sentence
- 56:32that you're writing, and you need to make sure
- 56:34that your argument is obvious and that you are
- 56:37not making your reader have to work for it, right?
- 56:40And so don't do that thing where you lay out
- 56:42paragraphs of what the applicable law is and
- 56:45then you get to your facts, right? That's asking
- 56:48your reader to have to keep flipping back and
- 56:50forth. You know, that's not legal analysis. Same
- 56:53thing in oral advocacy, right? Don't tell convoluted
- 56:56stories. Don't make them have to work for it.
- 56:58The analogy that I use is feeding a small child,
- 57:02feeding a toddler. I want my kid to eat. I am
- 57:06literally going to spoon feed the bite into her
- 57:09mouth. I am not going to make her work for it.
- 57:12Because at the end of the day, I want her to
- 57:14eat. And I'm not going to be clever about it.
- 57:16I'm going to be obvious. And I'm going to put
- 57:18it in her mouth. Put your persuasive arguments
- 57:21in the mouths of your fact -finders, in your
- 57:23readers, the judges, whatever it is. You want
- 57:26to be obvious. This is so helpful, Jen. And this
- 57:31is true in transactional work, too. You're telling
- 57:34the story of your client's case. You're putting
- 57:37together a merger deal. What's going to happen?
- 57:39What are the benefits of the merger? What are
- 57:41the positive outcomes of it? So this comes up
- 57:44all the time, no matter what your practice is.
- 57:47And we have about five minutes left. And so if
- 57:50you have questions for us, please start putting
- 57:52them in the Q &A, and we'll try to get to as
- 57:54many as we can. Jen, I think it would be useful
- 57:56to do color advance emotion for this. Group really
- 58:00quickly only because this as you're fleshing
- 58:02out a story It reminds you of maybe all the different
- 58:06things that that aren't as linear as when we
- 58:08think about okay What happened? What were the
- 58:10facts what happened on the night of December
- 58:1224th, right? So if we could play that really
- 58:16quickly, I think that'd be a useful skill to
- 58:17demonstrate Sure. All right We'll make up our
- 58:23own suggestion for this and Jen do you want to
- 58:26tell us to our Joe? What do you tell a story
- 58:28about something? That happened in the last week
- 58:30doesn't have to be anything dramatic But just
- 58:32something interesting that happened in the last
- 58:33week for you and I will insert I have three options
- 58:36color Which means flesh out? What things looked
- 58:40like what's the visual of the scene? Advance
- 58:43go further in the plot and emotion. How did you
- 58:46feel? How did what was your reaction to what
- 58:49was happening? Sure. Sure. Okay, um, so Last
- 58:55week, I traveled up to the Bay Area and I tacked
- 59:01on a day at our San Francisco office. Emotion.
- 59:06And I was I was excited. I was really, you know,
- 59:10I only just recently joined the firm and I hadn't
- 59:13met, you know, my paralegal sits in San Francisco
- 59:16and I had spoken to her on the phone and I had,
- 59:19you know, even had some, you know, zooms with
- 59:21her, but I had never met her in person. So I
- 59:23learned the paralegal. excited to to meet her
- 59:26in person. And, you know, when I did finally
- 59:30meet her, well, she was like, you know, just
- 59:34so bubbly and so welcoming. And she was a little
- 59:39taller than I expected because I'd only ever
- 59:42seen her on Zoom. And she was so welcoming. And
- 59:48and it was, you know, she even showed up earlier
- 59:50than the law firm. So I went into the law firm.
- 59:58I had brought pastries to bring to everybody
- 1:00:02at the firm. The office occupies part of the
- 1:00:09eighth floor and the windows were all open. It
- 1:00:15was a beautiful day and the light was coming
- 1:00:17through all the glass. And I walked in holding
- 1:00:21enough pastries for like 20 people and my wonderful
- 1:00:25paralegal greeted us and she said, well, there's
- 1:00:28only three of us here today. Emotion. Because
- 1:00:31everybody else is either out or at a conference.
- 1:00:34A lot of people are at a conference. felt simultaneously
- 1:00:38like kind of disappointed that I wasn't going
- 1:00:42to get a chance to meet everybody in the office,
- 1:00:45but also kind of relieved that I would be able
- 1:00:48to have more time to spend with my paralegal
- 1:00:52and the other two people. All right, great. We
- 1:00:54can end it there. Great job, Jen. So this is
- 1:00:57something that you can do with other attorneys
- 1:01:00in your office, right, as they're walking through
- 1:01:02an opening statement. What's missing? What's
- 1:01:04missing from the story? Right? So help your colleagues
- 1:01:07with that. And it's a great way just to pause
- 1:01:09and really see the scene that's around you. Yeah.
- 1:01:13Well, I forgot to mention that the last prevailing
- 1:01:15feeling that I had was excitement that I would
- 1:01:17get to eat more of these pastries, which is in
- 1:01:19fact what happened. Well, listen, so it's 1121.
- 1:01:24We are going to stop this webinar in a moment.
- 1:01:28But do we have any questions in the chat or in
- 1:01:30the Q &A? Let's see. I don't think we have any
- 1:01:33right now. So I do not see any questions in the
- 1:01:37Q &A, so I think we are good to end here. Paul
- 1:01:40and Jennifer, thank you so much. This webinar
- 1:01:42was fantastic, very entertaining, and very helpful.
- 1:01:45And thank you to our attendees for joining us
- 1:01:47today. Can we just make another plug for if you
- 1:01:52enjoyed this, if you thought this was interesting,
- 1:01:54and you would like to get a taste of what this
- 1:01:56is like in person or even on Zoom. I really,
- 1:02:00really encourage you guys to reach out to us
- 1:02:03because we run workshops at law firms, at law
- 1:02:08schools. And people come through these workshops,
- 1:02:11and they're like, that was really cool. I'm a
- 1:02:15total improv evangelist. I think a lawyer. need
- 1:02:18it more than anybody else, and I would love for
- 1:02:21the people who are attending this webinar to
- 1:02:25get a little more intrigued and to reach out
- 1:02:26to us. I also want to plug that Paul and I are
- 1:02:31in a group in LA, it's called NowTown, and that
- 1:02:34we do have... We do improv shows. We do improv
- 1:02:38shows in Los Feliz. This December, we're gonna
- 1:02:43be doing an improvised holiday romance. So basically
- 1:02:47coming out and see some stories made up in front
- 1:02:51of your eyes in a very cozy holiday setting.
- 1:02:55So reach out to us for more information. You
- 1:02:57can also find us on, we're on Facebook actually,
- 1:02:59facebook .com slash now town, one word. Paul?
- 1:03:04Thanks, everyone. Yeah, and I'm at Voxvera .com,
- 1:03:06V -O -X -V -E -R -A .com, and you can reach out
- 1:03:09to us for any trainings or questions. Thank you,
- 1:03:11Beverly Hills Bar Association. And thank you
- 1:03:14all for watching. Hope to see you soon. Take
- 1:03:15care.