Latest / The Team House / Russian Space Nukes & How the US is Losing the Missile Race to China | Alex Hollings | EYES ON Ep. 6
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple or
- 0:10Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get recognized,
- 0:16and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really appreciate
- 0:19your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is to
- 0:24become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five dollars
- 0:29a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all of
- 0:32our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is the
- 0:42biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if you'd
- 0:48like to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us out
- 0:51at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone, Andy Boben here,
- 0:57Welcome to another episode of mines On. I'm a little bit out of breath.
- 1:00Just literally walked into my hotel room here and checked in set up.
- 1:04Super excited though we have today Alex Hollings, mister Airpower, a rational air
- 1:14Power zealot, as we're about to find out. So without further ado,
- 1:18I'm going to turn over to D to introduce himself. Thanks. Andy's is
- 1:22D. I'm the producer. I want to thank Alex for being here,
- 1:23and I want everyone to go and check out Sandbox News and Airpower. The
- 1:27links will be in the description. And I'm gonna turn it over to Jason
- 1:30because Jason and Alex have a connection from back in the day. They've been
- 1:36in the Wars together, the media Awards together. A good morning everybody,
- 1:42Jason Lyons, former Marine, former CIA officer. So last week we gave
- 1:47you the Beauty with our good friend and guest Jack Murphy and the team House,
- 1:53and this week we're giving you the Beast. Alex is a great friend.
- 1:57We met when we were both writing for software at the time, and
- 2:02Alex now he became a great friend, but he also became a fellow aviation
- 2:07geek where he took it to level ten with it and now he's the resident
- 2:13expert on all things aviation, especially military aviation. Welcome aboard, man.
- 2:19We're glad to have you tell us a little bit about yourself. Hey,
- 2:23honestly, thanks a lot for having me here. You know, Jason said,
- 2:25he and I go back aways where really my journey into media and journalism
- 2:31started. I had been writing without bylines for a year or so before I
- 2:36started working with Jason at ZAFRAP, but Jack Murphy and Jason really were there
- 2:40when I got my first break into this industry, and I've sort of been
- 2:45very fortunate since then, where not only was I working with guys that had
- 2:49a great deal of expertise who were able to sort of steer me in the
- 2:52right direction, but then I kind of found my niche with air power and
- 2:57with defense technology, and so over the past few years, I've been running
- 3:00Sandbox News, which you can find Sandbox with two Axes news dot com,
- 3:05and I run Airpower with Alex Allins on YouTube, and you can also find
- 3:08me on TikTok at Alex Hellings fifty two awesome. So one thing, just
- 3:14putting in a plug very quickly for for Alex. The the YouTube videos,
- 3:20Okay, they are you know, for those who like kind of aviation porn
- 3:23there they are their core, they're everything that that excites you. But at
- 3:29the same time, with Alex's smooth talkover they you know, he's taxing a
- 3:32lot of comments that we talk about on this show that are in fact front
- 3:36and center for anyone who cares about national security, things like armed overwatch,
- 3:39manned unman teaming with aviation, unmanned systems, you know, six generation,
- 3:46the six generation fighter what you know, what what does it bring to the
- 3:51fight? I guess. So, yeah, we really all we're all a
- 3:53gone. We're on the cusp of you know, I would contend that back
- 3:58in the sixties, the lates sixties, through the seventies and the eighties and
- 4:01into the early nineties was this incredible period of time and aviation technology where a
- 4:08lot of the most dominant platforms still today were being fielded, you know,
- 4:12back during those few decades. And we're sort of on the cusp of the
- 4:15next revolutionary cycle in that which is such an exciting time and aviation technology where
- 4:21the next you know, F sixteen, the next F twenty two, these
- 4:26are the things that are emerging today, which is a super exciting time to
- 4:30be an airplane nerd like me. Yeah, really quick question for you,
- 4:35and I'm just going to show my display migrance right up front as a ground
- 4:41guy. But we're talking about multi role fighters, right, and we've got
- 4:45the you know, we've got the F thirty five, one component made,
- 4:48you know, at least one component made in every state of the Union,
- 4:51right, just to just to keep a bit of political positioning on their part.
- 4:58Yeah, that's right, to keep cappy. But here now we're talking
- 5:02about the F a x X, right, which is not the replacement for
- 5:10the F thirty five. But can you talk a little bit about what so
- 5:13what what does the brain and why the Navy and the Air Force embarking on
- 5:16different models. Didn't we didn't didn't you know? F thirty five features that
- 5:21the that a that a multirole fighter should be a joint one. So the
- 5:28truth is that the Pentagon has been trying to feel, to find a way
- 5:31to feel the same tactical aircraft for Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps applications
- 5:36for a very long time. You know, the F sixteen had the Vaught
- 5:40sixteen hundred program, which was aimed at sticking you know, the F sixteen
- 5:44on aircraft carriers. The F fifteen had the F fifteen n C Eagle program,
- 5:48very similar concept. The idea is that the fewer airframes you can feel,
- 5:53the easier it is to manage, the lower the cost is for logistics
- 5:57and so forth. And the Joint Strike Fight program really was sort of the
- 6:00culmination of that effort where the Pentagon thought that if we could field one general
- 6:06airframe that could serve all of these different purposes, it'll be the most cost
- 6:11effective way to field a large force, you know. And the F thirty
- 6:15five was envisioned as a replacement for a number of aircraft, but it was
- 6:18supposed to stand in directly for the F sixteen as sort of you know,
- 6:23the massive production. You know, the F sixteen's the backbone of the Air
- 6:27Force today with some two thousand active airframes, you know, forty six hundred
- 6:30airframes out there in the world, right But you know, the F thirty
- 6:34five was meant to do things no other fighter had done before, in a
- 6:41larger volume than any other fighter had before. And the acquisition process was a
- 6:46downright boondoggle as a result, you know, the not just when it comes
- 6:51to cost overruns, but when it comes to technical setbacks and delays, in
- 6:56large part because we just kept adding more things that we wanted this aircraft to
- 7:00do, and the Air Force and Navy are trying to learn the lesson from
- 7:03the F thirty five acquisition problems. When it comes to now the next Generation
- 7:09Air Dominance and Development for the Air Force and the FAXX and development for the
- 7:14Navy, Interestingly, they're both actually evolving out of one formerly classified xplane program.
- 7:21Now, if people aren't familiar with explanes, they're usually experimental aircraft meant
- 7:26to help mature technologies towards service. So if it's got an X prefix,
- 7:30it's not meant to go into service. More often than not, it's meant
- 7:32to help us get something ready for service. Now, we don't know exactly
- 7:38what they primarily focused on, other than manned on manned teaming, but that
- 7:43one xplane program back from twenty fifteen or so proves something so effectively to the
- 7:48Pentagon that the Air Force and the Navy both kicked off next generation Air dominance
- 7:54programs sort of out of that. And now the Air Force's next generation Air
- 7:59Dominance fighter, which is said to be a sixth generation aircraft, but we
- 8:01can talk about why that may be a misnomer. And then FAXX is another
- 8:07separate program emerging from that same effort that will produce a totally different airframe,
- 8:13but the expectation is that they'll share modular systems alike. So the outside acronym
- 8:20though right, I mean it's exactly the same acronym for the programs. The
- 8:22air domination is absolutely the acronym again, Next Generation Air Dominance or MNGAD is
- 8:31they're using in Gago. But to make different aircraft, as confusing as that
- 8:37sounds, but the reason why they'll have the same DNA is that we'll be
- 8:43looking at different airframes, different fuselages. But a lot of the interior systems
- 8:46will be modular in other words, meant to be replaced easily and somewhat interchangeable.
- 8:52So uh, the avionics suite effectively might be very much the same,
- 8:58whereas the exterior shape of the aircraft maybe it's ultimate performance characteristics will be different.
- 9:05But they'll be able to leverage the same sorts of weapons systems and importantly
- 9:09have an open architecture that allows them to be updated more quickly than today's jets.
- 9:13But on there two questions really that standout. One is range combat range,
- 9:18and the other is on board weapons systems. What is the range of
- 9:24those things? Because again it seems like we're building mister mister potato head right
- 9:28to extend the range of our carriers, because we're so in love with carriers,
- 9:33and so we need an airframe that can at least fly has a combat
- 9:39range what a thousand, one thousand miles? So so amnis really kindomized what
- 9:43six hundred, but we want at least one thousand miles? And then and
- 9:48then talked a little bit about the surface, I mean about air to air
- 9:50missiles too. Do you got what it needs to happen if you don't mine
- 9:56just like carry? No, this is this is what I do. So
- 10:00the biggest thing you're right is range is one of the primary focuses here,
- 10:03although it's worth noting that with range, you also really need to talk about
- 10:07an increase in speed, preferably because the longer the distance that you're trying to
- 10:13cover, the tyranny of distance is a problem not just in terms of logistics
- 10:18and resources, but also in time. It takes that much longer to engage
- 10:22a target or to respond to a threat. So we need why is the
- 10:26distance so important, Alex, I mean, and what is the golden what
- 10:31is kind of what are the golden numbers here? So this the big focus
- 10:35here is if we're talking about the potential for a Pacific conflict, is China's
- 10:39anti access area denial strategy we're effectively over the past few decades of conflict,
- 10:45China has been paying very close attention to how the United States conducts combat operations
- 10:50all around the world, and they don't need to develop the means to match
- 10:54American military capabilities to effectively cause huge problems for the global economy in the South
- 11:03China Sea and so forth. Basically, they don't need to have a military
- 11:05that can stand in the ring and swing. They've spent the past two decades
- 11:09developing and fielding systems that can leverage vulnerabilities that they've identified. One of those
- 11:16big ones being ranged. So right now, the longest ranged carrier based fighter
- 11:20we have is the F thirty five C with a combat radius of maybe six
- 11:24hundred and fifty nautical miles, so you know, a bit north of seven
- 11:28hundred miles, which means if an F thirty five takes off from a carrier
- 11:33here, the furthest it can go to engage at target before it has to
- 11:35turn around is maybe seven hundred miles. China has the largest anti ship ballistic
- 11:43cruise and hypersonic missile arsenal on the planet. Now, the kill chain you
- 11:48need to effectively engage a target at long distance is very complex, and there's
- 11:52no guarantee that they have it, but they are definitely working hard to develop
- 11:56it. And their hypersonic df Z, which is carried aloft by an intermediate
- 12:01range ballistic missile called the DF seventeen, is probably the most potent threat,
- 12:07specifically because it's a maneuvering hypersonic, which makes it very difficult to intercept.
- 12:13Now, this weapon was designed specifically to engage American carriers at four digit ranges,
- 12:18So if we want to be able to launch combat sorties against Chinese targets
- 12:24effectively, there's no way to do so without putting a carrier within range of
- 12:28this very difficult to intercept carrier killing missile. So effectively, we now need
- 12:35to either devise a reliable means of intercepting a maneuvering hypersonic, or we need
- 12:39to launch sorties from outside the reach of that weapon. Now, there are
- 12:43ballistic missiles, ballistic anti ship missiles China could launch at further range, but
- 12:48agis the air defense apparatus that the carrier strike group uses prettied aren't effective at
- 12:54anti ballistic operations basically though, because we don't have an answer to hypersonics.
- 13:00We need range, and the Navy's doing a bunch of band aid solutions right
- 13:03now. But FAXX, if it can deliver a great deal of more range,
- 13:07could solve that problem. So Alex, now that we've talked about the
- 13:11the sexy fighters and you know, the attack aircraft, can you talk a
- 13:18little bit about the false force multiplier, which would be the the tankers,
- 13:22the air air refuelers that would get them to you know, extend that range.
- 13:28That's the thing people tend to forget about. Like you know, I
- 13:31know that Lord knows. The people I'm speaking to are well aware that logistics
- 13:35is one of the most, if not the most important aspect of prolonged war
- 13:39fighting operations right and one of America's biggest strategic advantages is its tanker fleet.
- 13:46We have some four hundred you know, air to air refueling aircraft dedicated,
- 13:50as well as the means to use super hornets and other platforms for the job.
- 13:54But again, this range problem creates issues because you can't always have a
- 14:00tanker aircraft in the neighborhood tanker aircraft need their own logistics and they are very
- 14:05vulnerable urgeable. So the Navy is fielding something called the MQ twenty five Stingray,
- 14:11which is an autonomous drone refueler fielded for carrier operations that will basically be
- 14:16able to take off and go out and meet you know, FA eighteen super
- 14:20hornets F thirty five c's to refuel them both on their way out and potentially
- 14:24on their way back, and that alone could extend the range of the F
- 14:28thirty five C maybe up toward one thousand mile range. But again we are
- 14:33still talking about, you know, operating these aircraft on the outside limits of
- 14:39their operational parameters, which is something that you never want to do as a
- 14:43combat planner. You never want to plan to stress a limit to its max
- 14:46in order to just accomplish the objective. And that's really what we're still talking
- 14:52about doing when it comes to using the MQ twenty five with the F thirty
- 14:54five for instance today. Now there are some programs though that could offset that
- 15:01a bit, like the low drag tank and pylon program underway for the F
- 15:03twenty two right now, is fielding stealth underwing fuel tanks that alone could stand
- 15:09the F thirty five C by a ways, but there will be a performance
- 15:13trade off. You know, it won't be as aerobatically maneuverable, it won't
- 15:16be able to carry as much payload in terms of internal ordinance, you know,
- 15:20everything that comes with weight, And isn't it fatas say to Alexa,
- 15:26Until we war gain this really realistically, and I know, you know there's
- 15:31some controversy regarding the Marine Corps wargaming of Force Design twenty thirty. But you
- 15:37know, unless until we do really wargame this, we probably won't get a
- 15:43picture of all vulnerabilities. You know, we're talking about tanking. The whole
- 15:46procedure of tanking is more right, It's more than the vulnerability of the tankers.
- 15:50It's the vulnerability that whole package. You've got all these highly volatile aircraft
- 15:54doing a figure eight in the sky. You can use drones, but this
- 16:00still there's still susceptible being destroyed. So you haven't completely solved the problem.
- 16:04You've just taken the human beings, you know, out of it. So
- 16:08yeah, A wax and tankers are really juicy targets that people tend not to
- 16:12think about when they're talking about these kind of combat operations. But if you
- 16:17can take out an a wax or take out some tankers, you can dramatically
- 16:21reduce the number of sorties, the number of combat sorties that a carrier,
- 16:26stripe group or a ground based element can fly. And the fewer sorties,
- 16:29the fewer aircraft in the air, simpler air defense becomes, you know,
- 16:33and that just makes the job a lot easier for China to take out aircraft,
- 16:37even when they're pretty tough targets to engage. Yeah, so I suppose,
- 16:42you know, when we're talking about refueling and everything, it's a great
- 16:47example of kind of the knock on effects as we look at this, right,
- 16:52you do a great job, Alex and describing this very complex scenario that
- 16:57he sings off because they're not doing me any good. Complex. Well,
- 17:00you know, kind of a complex scenario that we want to to to really
- 17:04overwhelm the enemy is to have a spectrum of of expendability on our platforms right
- 17:12from you know, high end, yeah, high high end the XX where
- 17:18arguably you know, you'd only have perhaps one aircraft which goes against all paradigms,
- 17:23right, But then the spectrum that goes all the way from high end
- 17:29drones sophisticated, not expendable, down to things like the Valkyrie, right,
- 17:34which is sophisticated enough but nevertheless expendable. But the but but what what gets
- 17:45to me, Alex is, you know, I've known a number of pilots
- 17:51and they're not that bright. I don't care what they're saying right through the
- 17:55same school in the Marine Corps. Those guys get lost on land navigation.
- 17:59They do all the you know, stupid fucked up things that we grunts through.
- 18:03But the pressure on a guy handling all these unmanned systems flying at mark
- 18:11whatever it is, you know, at night on nods. Really, you
- 18:18know, I would contend that there are a few positions with more innate responsibility
- 18:23than being a modern fighter pilot, maybe being a submarine commander, especially you
- 18:26know, the captain of a boomer. But you know, it's it's hard
- 18:30to overstate the complexity of flying one hundred million dollars worth of state secrets,
- 18:36you know, the speed of a of a rifle round into a combat environment
- 18:40where you're trying to not just engage targets, know you're flying in with an
- 18:44intention. But there's also telephone pole sized missiles coming at you from directly below
- 18:48you, you know, and they're they're flying at supersonic to even hypersonic speeds.
- 18:52There's a lot of threats to manage. And that's what a lot of
- 18:56this AI effort is focused on. People tend to focus on the AI enabled
- 19:00wingmen, which are going to be a game changer, and that may be
- 19:04the step change that justifies the title sixth generation fighter rather than a fifth gen
- 19:11fighter with drone wingmen. But what Project Venom, for instance, that the
- 19:15Air Force is doing right now is it's got AI pilots, AI agents riding
- 19:19in the cockpit today of six F sixteens that are being tested in Florida,
- 19:25with those pilots flying standard combat exercises and things like that for the AI agent
- 19:30to learn these practices and the decision making process pilots go through when they're exposed
- 19:37to new variables and the idea I'm sorry, go ahead, no no I
- 19:41I. But the pilot still has to make the decision to pickle right.
- 19:45We United States and never going to go to the you know, it's never
- 19:49going to so that is always going to slow how I kill chain down,
- 19:53and it's a function of the fact that we are a democracy blah blah blah.
- 19:57But that is that serious? Is that a serious vulnerability? So there
- 20:03is some ethical debate here because you're right, the DoD's requirements the regulation state
- 20:08that a human operator needs to make the kill decision. Right, the question
- 20:14effectively becomes how distant, how far removed from that decision can that human operator
- 20:19be for us to still consider it to be that decision. And the example
- 20:23that I would offer is, if we launch Tomahawk land attack cruise missile,
- 20:27you know, at a target twelve hundred miles from now, that missile is
- 20:32going to cover twelve hundred miles and much the same way a tactical aircraft might,
- 20:37you know, flying along a fairly horizontal flight path under power, it's
- 20:41going to respond to threats to some extent, especially as they get more advanced,
- 20:45and then execute that target once it gets close enough. And we consider
- 20:48the person making the fire decision maybe an hour before the weapon impacts target,
- 20:53making the kill decision, despite the fact that the weapon did have to react
- 20:57to some stimulus along away, and we're going to have to decide how far
- 21:03removed we consider still in the loop. So for instance, the human pilot
- 21:08flying inn faxx a six generation you know, carrier based aircraft with AI enabled
- 21:14drone wingmen. That pilot will tell the drone execute that target, whether an
- 21:18air to air or an air to ground target, whatever it may be.
- 21:22That drone will then use you know, onboard decision making capability to execute within
- 21:27the parameters of the command. Is that still the human making the kill decision?
- 21:33If that drone has to go and conduct you know, three or four
- 21:37complex operations to position in itself to get a beat on that target and then
- 21:41fire if it fires an hour after the command was made, was that still
- 21:45a human in the loop or at that point are we saying that the AI
- 21:49effectively made the kill decision? You know, So there's there's still a great
- 21:53deal of ethical wiggle room within the regulation as it's written. That's something they
- 22:00have to contend with, you know. And and before we get a stream
- 22:03of of complaints, you know about why is Melbourne trying to slow the kill
- 22:10chain with these ridiculous questions? These questions are a thing especially in you know,
- 22:15the tech industry, and is we try and close the gap between d
- 22:19O D and and real tech industry, not defense contractors. I mean,
- 22:26like you know, innovators, the guys on the cutting edge. Then we
- 22:29need to address problems like that, which I know is very difficult to do
- 22:33this. Yeah, and it's tough to the conversation sometimes because people, uh,
- 22:37you know, to your point can be dismissive of the debate. Yeah,
- 22:42that's right. Yeah, And there's and and it's and it becomes quite
- 22:47complex because there are you know, we already use autonomous we already have autonomous
- 22:52weapons systems that make a decision to kill without a human and elite like you
- 22:56know, seacat all the I mean all that a lot of stuff that we
- 23:00use for ship protection is just one example, right, Yeah, you know,
- 23:03it really is. It's a it's a practical application of the trolley problem.
- 23:07You know, where we if you're not familiar with the trolley problem out
- 23:11there listening, it's it's the idea that you know, you're you're on a
- 23:15trolley that is on a track that could potentially run three people over. You
- 23:19have the ability to pull a lever to switch tracks and only run one person
- 23:22over. But then you go from it being a passive decision to allow three
- 23:26people to die to an active decision to kill that one person, and we're
- 23:33facing that, but instead we're facing the question of leaving it up to the
- 23:37trolley And then how do you manage accountability thereafter? You know, it's tough
- 23:42to as it is right now. You know, the United States and the
- 23:48world at large has made huge strides in minimizing sort of, you know,
- 23:52the secondary casualties of tactical operations, using things like the R nine X,
- 23:56you know, the hell Fire Fullest swords and things like these, ever to
- 24:00mitigate the chances of innocent people being hurt. But when you pass the decision
- 24:04off to an automated system, who do you hold accountable when innocent people get
- 24:08hurt? For instance? It's the sort of thing you need to have an
- 24:11answer to optimally before you're passing off the decision, so that way, when
- 24:17something does happen, as it inevitably will in warfare, you know you have
- 24:22a policy in place, you have a procedure to lean on. So Alex,
- 24:26you use the word intention, and for the purposes of what we're talking
- 24:30about, the intention of air power is at its root cause is to clear
- 24:37the skies for the grunt on the ground. So where do you see or
- 24:42is there a connection between all of these advances in aviation technology and the grunt
- 24:48on the ground. Is the grunt on the ground, is that corporal lance,
- 24:52corporal sergeant going to have the ability to interact with these air assets so
- 24:56that when that pickle switch is hit, they might have the depending on the
- 25:02munition, and you know, in the future, the ability to say,
- 25:04you know, break, break, you know, you know that you're there,
- 25:10it's too close or whatever, wrong target, whatever it is. So
- 25:12is there that link and if not, are we working on that so that,
- 25:15I would argue is probably the most important part of all of this technology
- 25:21that's that's emerging and being matured right now, is this idea of creating a
- 25:26coherent battle network that actually leverages all of the sensors in the thinkers that you've
- 25:33got in the battle space more effectively. Because right now, as to your
- 25:37point, you know, there are people on the ground who know things that
- 25:40the people in the air do not, you know, and we do a
- 25:42great deal of networking and communications and training to try to mitigate that. But
- 25:48at the end of the day, we're still basically relying on a bunch of
- 25:52big brain monkeys with walkie talkies to relay very complicated things and stressful situations with
- 25:59no time. You know, and to our previous point about these pilots,
- 26:02you know, the cognitive load of all the things that they're paying attention to,
- 26:06and then the combat power that you have, Especially when you've got six
- 26:10drones also carrying ordinance, also operating under your command, you've got the means
- 26:15to devastate a whole neighborhood or to you know, take out an entire target
- 26:21facility. So what we need to do is find ways to not just create
- 26:26the network that connects those which there are in place and there are some being
- 26:30worked on, but also it needs to be able to heal itself effectively,
- 26:36so when a system comes down, the network automatically re establishes its own connections.
- 26:42That's a huge part of the manned unmanned teeming concept is that if all
- 26:48of these things are networked and one of these drones gets taken out, the
- 26:52other drones need to be able to shift to accommodate and still accomplish the mission,
- 26:56even though they may not have the same systems anymore that they had when
- 26:59they started. And if you can create a network that not only allows these
- 27:04things to share information readily for a fused battle space awareness, but can also
- 27:10quickly change and go Okay, all the telephone poles got knocked out. Now
- 27:14we've got to use cell phone towers or something, you know, that equivalent.
- 27:17It's got to be able to do it fast enough that it's seamless to
- 27:22the operator in the fight. And right now we definitely don't have that capability.
- 27:26But that is the long term goal of using all of these variety of
- 27:32low to extremely high cost drones for varying jobs. If they can't interact with
- 27:37one another and coordinate, we're spending a fortune on this stuff that we're basically
- 27:42just shotgun blasting, you know, which can be and that's supposed to be
- 27:48the defining difference of this system, and that is why it has the acronym.
- 27:52It is a domination. It's not about a single platform. It's about
- 27:56the teeming, you know. That's which which makes sense. And I am
- 28:00anything but a lot. I this is overdue, but I but at the
- 28:04same time, you know, I'm watching how and I recognize against you know,
- 28:11near peer competitor. We have to do all this stuff. My concern
- 28:15is this that at the other end of the text, spectrum. We have
- 28:18requirements too for armed overwatch and the other part about it, you know,
- 28:23so we still have to focus on that. That's but the other part that
- 28:27really concerns me about this whole package is we've got to change the culture and
- 28:33training on the ground. We are so far behind. We have been paying
- 28:37lip service a long time to this feeling. You know this any sense or
- 28:41any shooter, I can tell you within you know, Jason's and my old
- 28:45service and Marine Corps always a marine, right, we are far behind culturally.
- 28:52You know, I've talked about this before, but the average lance corp
- 28:56doesn't have the training or confidence to pick up a a handset to call for
- 29:03far as is now, I'm just going to say that that is a problem.
- 29:07So we have thirteen guys, several batoon commander, maybe the you know,
- 29:15I mean thirteen guys said you got the squad leader. Maybe one or
- 29:18two other guys are useful, and the rest are just targets. I mean
- 29:22that is they all have to My point is, human beings on the ground
- 29:26have to be integrated into this for it to work. And in order to
- 29:30do that, we need to really look at who we're bringing. You know,
- 29:33can we do this, can we reduce do we really? Now?
- 29:37Now is the time perhaps to look at getting a much higher quality guy taking
- 29:41kind of a soft approach, soft like we you know, and this is
- 29:45going to terrify a lot of people, maybe reduced sense strength as we you
- 29:48know, as we get up to this machining. But we we've got a
- 29:52long way to go just in training and educating our own people'll shut up.
- 29:56But that's it's a three layered problem too, you know, because it's a
- 30:00technological problem in that the systems need to be user friendly enough that you don't
- 30:07need a year of training in order to effectively leverage a system in combat.
- 30:11Right, So we need technology that is simple and robust, We need a
- 30:15user base that is confident and trained, and then we need a culture that
- 30:21embraces both of those things. And those are three separate challenges. Those are
- 30:26three separate expenses at that, you know, because with the technology, we're
- 30:30not only facing the challenges that come inherent to fielding new technology, but also
- 30:36bureaucracy associated with fielding new technology. With training, again we're facing cultural issues,
- 30:41but again bureaucracy associated with changing the way that we go about training.
- 30:47And then when it comes to culture. We've got the bureaucracy problems and the
- 30:49technology problems, but we also have our monkey brain problems, where this is
- 30:56the way I've done it and I'm not going to do it a different way,
- 31:00or even those with the best of intentions who are saying, I've been
- 31:03doing this for twenty two years. I am the best in the world at
- 31:07what I do, and I don't understand this new system. How do I
- 31:11manage it on the twilight of my career, you know, and still be
- 31:15effective at what I'm doing while this new generation is coming up. And again
- 31:18you always face that challenge of capacity versus capability, where we could field all
- 31:25these systems today, and again, as you said at the beginning of this
- 31:29episode, be ready for war in ten years and just have to hope there's
- 31:33no conflict in the interim, or we have to piecemail these solutions out so
- 31:37that we maintain, you know, one portion of the force structure that's ready
- 31:41to respond to something that breaks out tomorrow, and a portion of the force
- 31:45structure that is predicated entirely on modernizing for what conflict is short to look like
- 31:52five years from now, you know, because drones aren't going away. That
- 31:56are going to become cheaper, more capable, more robust, and more available
- 32:01as time goes on, so we can find ourselves. You know, I
- 32:06always think back to when I was deployed to Mosambique, Africa, and you
- 32:09know, the cott Marines spent three days getting calms up. They were intermittent
- 32:14throughout, but the guys in Mozambique who were just using their little Nextel chirps,
- 32:19had calms up the whole time. They weren't secure, sure, but
- 32:22they were in active communication with one another using off the shelf technology while we
- 32:28were putting up tents and talking about what we would do once we had calms
- 32:31up on Wednesday. And we face that challenge kinetically as well, because these
- 32:37drones will get cheaper, they'll get easier to use, and the force that's
- 32:42buying them off the shelf and operating them versus the massive structure wide acquisition process
- 32:49and then training pipeline is so much slower to leverage these new technologies force wide
- 32:55than it is to be the plucky underdog who's buying them off the show shelf.
- 33:00And we need to find ways to work around that just sluggish pivot that's
- 33:07inherent to a massive military structure, you know, the on the you know,
- 33:15on the point of and I won't believe the point on aircraft carriers.
- 33:17I suppose it's the grunt in me that it just gets infuriated by the by
- 33:22the nadies, you know, going down with the ship thing of no no
- 33:28A. We'll find a way to be make eventually, will aircraft carrier halfway
- 33:32not obsolete? Right? And so I mean it seems to me as though
- 33:37we're developing this aircraft in order to keep the aircraft carrier relevant because we have
- 33:44burnship four star admirals who who's you know, Holcian days were were spent on
- 33:52a carrier. Although I do I think that there is a great deal of
- 34:00value to what you're saying, You're not wrong. The aircraft carrier, I
- 34:04would contend, in today's world is a strategic deterrent, sure, but it's
- 34:07a diplomatic tool as much as a combat platform. And what I mean by
- 34:13that is that the aircraft carrier is very effective for asymmetric conflicts, and it's
- 34:17very it's a very effective means of making a presence known and making a big
- 34:22spectacle of you know, American support. But in a near peer conflict.
- 34:28The aircraft carrier is a target, and it's important to understand the economics of
- 34:34one hundred million dollar hypersonic missile might be immensely expensive, but when the target
- 34:38costs sixteen billion to replace, that one hundred million dollar missile is a bargain.
- 34:45Yeah, that's yeah, And that was the question I had for you,
- 34:50alex Is. I was still blocking up when it comes to drones that
- 34:55we're being too high tech, you know. I mean, look, think
- 34:58about Agora Carabat, and I know that that was presented in a way that
- 35:02made it sounded too slip. But the bottom line is, you know,
- 35:06with with loitering ammunitions, I believe it was the Horrop and the bioctar.
- 35:10Neither of those are very complicated, right, Yeah, and yes they were
- 35:15going against kind of a third rate military, but they had a first rate
- 35:19i ADS and these things went through it like a knight through hot butter.
- 35:22And the biactar is maybe two million dollars a platform. You see what I'm
- 35:25saying. I mean, this was all being orchestrated. Now or volume does
- 35:31not require a great deal of technical proficiency. You know, you can do
- 35:36a high volume of drones without an advanced battle network meant to help them accommodate
- 35:43the new variables the way we're trying to field. Because you're overwhelming the enemy
- 35:46and you want to throw it onto decoys. Whatever you are doing, even
- 35:50if you're running logistics resupply using drones, you want to throw up decoys and
- 35:54all kinds of shit to Right now, what is you know, what is
- 36:00arguably the first ever naval blockade without a navy, you know, and this
- 36:06is what we're seeing is that you can use these low cost systems to impact
- 36:12very high cost strategic operations. How with learning that teaching it, you know,
- 36:23you could look at what the houthis are doing in the Red Sea right
- 36:25now and extrapolate that to a much larger margin and see what the South China
- 36:31Sea would look like in a conflict because China's massive anti ship stockpile, they
- 36:37would they would be operating in a similar way, but with that with a
- 36:40better kill chain and a much larger arsenal and a wider variety of targets.
- 36:45But yeah, yeah, you know, whereas the United States would be looking
- 36:52at, Okay, how do you operate in an environment that is so contested
- 36:57that there's constant twenty four hours balance. There's supersonic drones that are providing targeting
- 37:04information to hypersonic missiles that are adjusting course in flight. How do you operate
- 37:08in an environment like this where the Marine Corps plans for you know, hot
- 37:14loading on austere airstrips and stuff like that. The faster the kill chain can
- 37:17execute the lesson, You've got to create ambiguity at that point, right,
- 37:22because you don't have enough You just don't have enough stuff to intercept all the
- 37:28killed chain speak thrown at against you. Especially you're will to throw up multiple
- 37:31targets. Yeah, if you want to use you know, for the Navy,
- 37:37for instance, on the you know, on age's equipped chips right now,
- 37:39the cheaper interceptors, the SM two's one point two million dollars apiece,
- 37:45you know, So when you're trying to intercept a swarm of drones lobbing you
- 37:52know, one million dollar interceptors at ten thousand dollars drones becomes a problem very
- 37:58quickly in a large scale content. But aside from the economic attrition, there's
- 38:01just the fact that we can't restock these ships underway. They need to go
- 38:07back to port to be resupplied. They need to be taken out of the
- 38:09combat environment entirely in order to be put back in and combat effective. And
- 38:15this is why we're seeing harriers and super hornets conducting a lot of intercepts lately.
- 38:21It is a lot cheaper. They haven't disclosed, I think, all
- 38:23the systems that they've been using, but it is much cheaper to use a
- 38:28top end AIM nine X sidewinder to take out a target for maybe four hundred
- 38:32and seventy thousand dollars versus an SM you know, like an SM three for
- 38:37instance, can be as much as thirty six million dollars to replace. Still
- 38:42and still a balance, it's still you know, it's still an ineffective,
- 38:45inefficient way of in a method of ad offense. Yeah, it works against
- 38:50the houthis when we know that we can still out spend them. But but
- 38:54there was still a drone, you know, according to I mean the Navies
- 38:59says that looking at still a drune caup within four seconds of hitting, I
- 39:04forget the night. It wasn't a Connie shit, but it for real,
- 39:07it was the real thing happened in this last week, and it's an important
- 39:13and a very unsophisticated drone too. Yeah. I think that this is something
- 39:17that the hypersonic discussion has misled the public on in general, is the fact
- 39:22that air defense is never a certainty. It doesn't matter the complexity or the
- 39:28capability of the threat. When you are trying to shoot something down in the
- 39:32sky, there's never it's never a sure thing, you know, no matter
- 39:36how capable your air defenses are or how inept their assets may be, you
- 39:40can never be one hundred percent certain that you're going to take everything out.
- 39:44But in the higher the volume, the less the chance becomes that you're going
- 39:49to be able to stop them, which is now what the Navy is aiming
- 39:52to do in the Pacific to China. Inversely, Yeah, that's what I
- 39:55was gonna ask Alex, like, what's the move, Like, just keep
- 39:59building fifteen million dollar targets. So that's a great question. So the Pentagon
- 40:04kicked off about six months ago something that they call the Replicator Initiative, And
- 40:08this concept is basically not a new procurement plan. It's not a new program.
- 40:15It is a philosophy to sort of be implemented across programs, where the
- 40:19idea is to emphasize affordable mass, right, So we want to have those
- 40:24high end, exquisite platforms, the six generation fighters that can be combatant commanders
- 40:30in the sky. But then we want something that costs half as much as
- 40:35that jet that we also don't want to die, but has not quite the
- 40:37same level of capability but a great deal. And then something that costs half
- 40:42as much as that, half as much as that, half as much as
- 40:44that, all the way down to very small, very low cost platforms,
- 40:47and if you can field enough of them in volume. That's why they call
- 40:52it the replicator initiative. The idea is basically to overwhelm by volume the same
- 40:57way we did in World War Two, know where our military was exponentially larger
- 41:04than it is now but far more specialized by platform. We're sort of getting
- 41:07back to that where we're going to have specialized drones that have a few specific
- 41:12jobs, and we want to be able to pump them out in huge numbers.
- 41:15But the other answer is how do you stop the opponent from doing the
- 41:17same to you? And I think people are mistaken to place all of their
- 41:23stock and lasers directed energy weapons in atmosphere. There are real limitations to directed
- 41:30energy weapons, particularly atmospheric scattering and thermal blooming. And what these problems are
- 41:37basically is it's air particles in the air work effectively like a lens. As
- 41:43a laser burns through the atmosphere, thermal blooming lenses it and makes it less
- 41:47accurate. The further way you are atmospheric scattering is just you know, imagine
- 41:52shining a flashlight into a room with a smoke machine. The smoke machine catches
- 41:57a lot of those light particles. So, as a result, maybe is
- 42:00not confident that lasers will ever be effective outside of ten miles, and today
- 42:05the most powerful lasers we've got are maybe a mile. When a hypersonic weapon
- 42:08is doing five miles a second or whatever it might be, that's not enough
- 42:13time. You're not ever going to be able to burn through the nose cone
- 42:15of one of these weapons. Lasers will probably work for low cost drones,
- 42:21but we need to find a way to solve the cost attrition problem of how
- 42:27do you take out a large volume of targets quickly without expending every interceptor you've
- 42:32got on your ship and compromising your combat capabilities. Alex see in the last
- 42:38I think it was the lossips so we had we talked about this, particularly
- 42:43about so the Russians are using just massive use of EW. And you've probably
- 42:49read a Russi's report last month that estimated that the Ukrainians so losing up to
- 42:54ten thousand drones a month to Russian EW efforts. So my point here is,
- 43:00yes, I know W has short falls, and I know the Ukrainians
- 43:02are working around it, you know, with the FPV drones, drones.
- 43:07I mean, you know more about this than I do. There are workarounds,
- 43:09but for a lot for a while at least, you know, maybe
- 43:14I don't know next five ten years. We know that W is going to
- 43:17be an effect of the system against a lot of drones, if not the
- 43:22majority of drones, and those it doesn't work against, we can focus greater
- 43:25efforts, but we're behind the EW race. I mean, that's what you
- 43:30know. G I saw a greater interview with General Hodges, former Yukon't commander
- 43:35the other day where he was very upfront about this, say, the Russians
- 43:38are so much more advanced than we are at EW. And I'm not talking
- 43:44about necessarily the systems, but their doctrine, their training, their application,
- 43:49how it's integrated into their combat operations, and it really comes down to effective
- 43:54priorities. And this is one of the places where the past few decades of
- 43:58basometric conflict have really hurt the United States because we had a great deal,
- 44:04We had a lot of efforts that were maturing and robust, and then atrophied
- 44:07on the vine as we focused on these asymmetric conflicts over the past few decades.
- 44:13And just like you're saying, Russia and China have had the benefit of
- 44:17being able to focus on these as offensive assets based on the idea that they
- 44:23would need to leverage them against US. So basically we called time out and
- 44:28let these other countries we imagined to play catch up, but they weren't trying
- 44:31to catch up. They were trying to poke holes. That's a way more
- 44:36effective strategy, and now we're in this position. Electronic warfare is one of
- 44:40a number of places where it's not just the technology we have fielded that's a
- 44:45concern. It's the academic infrastructure, the pipeline into fielding these systems that has
- 44:52atrophied. China's biggest advantage in hypersonics isn't the df ZF. Chances are good
- 44:59if we went to war with China today, it'd be tough for them to
- 45:01actually hit a carrier with that weapon. China's big hypersonic advantage is their massive
- 45:07academic infrastructure that they've built in the past ten years, all focused on developing
- 45:13these technologies, so that ten years from now they'll be significantly further ahead at
- 45:19least, is the plan, you know. And we helped educate it.
- 45:22We helped educate a lot of that as scientists, absolutely, And part of
- 45:25that plan was to send a bunch of students to our schools too, you
- 45:30know. And we and we shoot ourselves a little bit further. Because America's
- 45:34solution to these problems is money, right, We go, all right,
- 45:37well, we'll pile up a bunch of money over there and lighted on fire,
- 45:39and when it's done burning, we'll have a solution. The problem that
- 45:44we run into is that not everything can be solved that way. We saw
- 45:46this with Arrow, it was to be America's first operational maneuvering hypersonic weapon.
- 45:52We were trying to field it in like eighteen months as an operational weapon because
- 45:57it was a glide vehicle and we thought we had that technology fairly well in
- 46:00hand. Then all The tests failed not because of the missile, but things
- 46:04that we should have had on lock, like its ability to detach from the
- 46:07aircraft, the wiring bus to the aircraft's command system. The failures came in
- 46:13those portions of the test. But because there's only maybe two flight corridors in
- 46:17the United States where you can test a missile with a thousand mile range and
- 46:22a mock five plus top speed, they had to wait six months to try
- 46:25to test it again, and then when they got to their new test date
- 46:29they launched it. The missile worked right, The sensors on the test range
- 46:31were down that day. They don't get another day for six more months.
- 46:36So because we have seventy hypersonic weapons programs competing for resources with each other,
- 46:43we're slowing all of their progress down by this lack of testing. An academic
- 46:47and why not just distill it down to like instead of seventy like four.
- 46:52A lot of it comes down to you're not sure which programs are going to
- 46:58work, so by investing in a bunch of them, you know you've got
- 47:00a really high likely out of success, and that usually works because it's usually
- 47:06not a weapon that needs to travel at MAC ten. You know, and
- 47:09you need to also see how effective its warhead is against different kinds of targets.
- 47:15So the methods that we're accustomed to using aren't working when it comes to
- 47:21these emerging technologies. Because we didn't invest in the infrastructure required to support these
- 47:27emerging technologies. We sort of rested on the laurels of well, we've got
- 47:30the most money, we'll figure it out, and that isn't even necessarily true.
- 47:36You know. Some of the more recent, you know, assessments of
- 47:38Chinese defense spending actually places it north of seven hundred billion dollars a year,
- 47:43and with their difference in purchasing power parity, that's more than we're spending.
- 47:49And when you think of it that way, China has the advantage. I
- 47:53think of Hazardly, who's an F thirty five pilot. A friend of mine
- 47:57who used to be an F sixteen wild weasel pilot talked about wild weasel is
- 48:00the suppression of enemy air defense operation. It's the closest thing to being a
- 48:06wild bust gunfighter that fighter jets get to do. You fly into contested airspace
- 48:10and wait for the enemy air defenses to paint a target on you or your
- 48:15wingman and Once that target's painted on you, you launch an anti radiation missile,
- 48:19a weapon that hones in on the signal they're using to target you.
- 48:22It is a gunfight. You try to hit them before they hit you.
- 48:27And the problem that you have as a wild weasel pilot is that you're not
- 48:30competing against another aircraft that has to worry about weight of systems or fuel load
- 48:37on missiles. You're competing against the ground, which can hold missiles with twice
- 48:40the fuel that you can, which can carry ten times the munitions the ordinance
- 48:46that you can. It's an unfair fight. And that's what we're talking about
- 48:50in China on a much larger scale. We're talking about expeditionary forces squaring off
- 48:55against stationary forces on their own home heurf. It's an asymmetric battle inherently,
- 49:01and then on top of that, they're able to invest heavily into not matching
- 49:07our capability. They don't need the expeditionary power, but the US has.
- 49:12They can lay siege to the south China see and turn off the world's economy.
- 49:16You know, what do they need to invade for alex What about what
- 49:21about the Russians? Now, can they really launch a nuclear weapon. Can
- 49:29they detonate a co weapon all right, and and say destroy destroy one or
- 49:36more of our satellites without and and what would be you know, no pun
- 49:40intended, what would be the fallout? So I think that, uh,
- 49:45this nuclear weapon and orbit thing is not a new concern. This weapon would
- 49:53be a new means to the same end that we've been concerned about for a
- 49:57long time now. A few years back, when Heather Wilson was the Secretary
- 50:00of the Air Force, but she was talking about America's satellite infrastructure, she
- 50:05said, the US built an exquisite glasshouse before the invention of stones. And
- 50:09what she meant was that most of these satellites that we rely on today were
- 50:15launched at a time when there were no orbital threats to be concerned with,
- 50:19and as such they're not parted anything. So now the United States face is
- 50:24the very real threat of China or Russia in particular, compromising america satellite infrastructure
- 50:30that we rely on not just for combat ops but for day to day life.
- 50:35And it would hurt the US more than China or Russia. But make
- 50:39no mistake, compromising the whole satellite infrastructure would be a death blow to all
- 50:45developed nations. But it is worth noting why Mike Blincoln brought it up right
- 50:53with China exactly, you know it was it was almost hate dan't listening to
- 51:00us. Let me tell you what that's going to happen, you know.
- 51:05So this is the thing that we need to worry about when it comes to
- 51:07a nuclear detonation in orbit is twofold. There's two big concerns. The first
- 51:12one is the detonation itself. And we can look back to I want to
- 51:15say, nineteen sixty two Starfish Prime Juhnpson at all right, exactly what happened
- 51:22exactly. So Starfish Prime was one of five tests as a part of Operation
- 51:27fish Bowl. These were high altitude nuclear detonations. Starfish Prime was a W
- 51:31forty nine nuclear warhead carried aloft by a Thor rocket to about two hundred and
- 51:37fifty miles which is fourish miles shy of where the International Space Station ORBITS today,
- 51:43so well into lower Earth orbit. When it detonated, we weren't really
- 51:47sure what it was going to do, but what it did was way worse
- 51:52than we anticipated. There were twenty four satellites in orbit at the time on
- 51:57Earth. It immediately knocked out three of them, including the UK's first,
- 52:00which I'm sure didn't go over great diplomatically relationship, you know. And then
- 52:07the radiation belt that it produced knocked out six more of the only twenty four
- 52:12satellites in orbit. Bigger concerns than that it put a huge cavity in the
- 52:16ionosphere and expelled the Earth's magnetic field for almost thirty seconds, So I mean,
- 52:22if it had lasted longer than that, we'd all have a real bad
- 52:24sunburn, you know. Immediately thereafter, the EMP knocked out some three hundred
- 52:30street lights in Hawaii nine hundred miles away. It interfered with telephone calls,
- 52:36it set off burglar alarms. The concern with the EMP is not what we
- 52:38often hear in science fiction, but it is certainly a concern. So the
- 52:44first thing that would happen is that nuclear detonation would probably way about the functionality
- 52:49of a third of the world's satellite infrastructure, and the radiation belts created by
- 52:54it would recavoc thereafter. But the more dangerous situation immediately thereafter is something we
- 53:00call the Kessler syndrome, and what that effectively is. It was named that
- 53:05for Donald Kessler, who came up with us in the seventies. Is the
- 53:08idea that there are so many satellites in orbit now that if you destroy a
- 53:13small number of them and the debris cloud created by those satellites continues to orbit
- 53:17at seventeen thousand plus miles per hour, that debris impacts other satellites, destroys
- 53:23those satellites, which then turn into an even larger debris cloud, and it
- 53:28creates a cascade that eventually consumes all of the satellites in orbit and makes lower
- 53:34orbit pretty unmanageable for us to get back into thereafter. And that's really what
- 53:37this weapon would do. It would create a Kessler syndrome scenario in one fell
- 53:43swoop. One hopes that Putin supmises of letting them know, But remember the
- 53:52Russians don't necessarily they're not necessarily the first to plug amps when it comes to
- 53:57nuclear safety. Yeah, and that's number one concern. And number two is
- 54:01that I'm not sure anyone's willing to tell Putin that he's not wearing clothes anymore.
- 54:07But you can see how I think I'm not a chicken little but you
- 54:12can see how he thinks, you know, he's yes, the war in
- 54:16Ukraine that has sensed Dance still, but he still has points to make.
- 54:21He wants to he wants to hold on to Dombas and he it probably it
- 54:25probably sounds to him like the most rational thing in the earth, in the
- 54:30world to a nuclear detonation. And you know, when we're talking about the
- 54:37vaccine, you know, with a with a nuclear weapon, which you know
- 54:42we're talking about at the end of the day, diplomatic leverage above all else.
- 54:45What this is, it's a means for Russia. I would contend the
- 54:50RS twenty eight Sarmat, which is there potentially as much as fifty megaton yield
- 54:55ICBM that they've described as capable of wiping out an area the size of Texas
- 55:00or France with one launch. Likewise, they're Poseidon status six, this doomsday
- 55:06torpedo. But these are these are big bang for your buck options where you
- 55:09can feel the small number of systems that garner lots of news headlines and lots
- 55:15of discourse and lots of concern, and it gives you diplomatic leverage when you're
- 55:21conventional military FIRS doesn't happen the you know, these things are all predicated,
- 55:30you know Russia puts io first, and Kinsel being billed as a hypersonic weapon
- 55:37was about advancing foreign weapon sales. They want to be the weapon supplier of
- 55:40choice for everyone on America's naughty list. So look at how advanced our tech
- 55:45is. So got a bad rap. They're more conventional. Oh, they
- 55:50got a bad rap from the Ukraine War. Right when this systems, Russia
- 55:57is playing the game of if we can instill enough fear in the global populace,
- 56:01they will apply political pressure to their own leadership to back off. And
- 56:07systems like being able to threaten you know, James Bond villain systems are the
- 56:13best bang for your buck. They're the most cost efficient way of scaring the
- 56:16general public into wanting to back off. And that is really what I think
- 56:22we're seeing here, you know, especially Kinsle being a great example, but
- 56:28hypersonics in general. Russia has built an entire industry around lying about these capabilities
- 56:37to create this idea that they're a looming presence you need to be worried about.
- 56:42When they are looming presence that people you know in the Baltics certainly need
- 56:46to be worried about. But they want, you know, mom at home
- 56:52in Tulsa, Oklahoma, to be afraid of Russia, and that's what they're
- 56:55hoping systems like this can provide for them. Yeah, kind of a bummer
- 57:02thing there. Does the US have any kind of like counter to this or
- 57:07do we have our own system that does the same thing. So, the
- 57:09first thing that you need to know, especially when it comes to strategic deterrence
- 57:13like putting a nuken orbit, mutually assured destruction is still basically it. I
- 57:20can tell you right now. Without putting a nuke and orbit rush, Russia
- 57:23could create a Kessler Syndrome scenario with anti satellite missiles. They already have an
- 57:29inventory. Likewise, if they launched a full scale nuclear attack on the US,
- 57:32America's ground based mid course defense system would have no hope, not even
- 57:38you know, America's homely in defense system could intercept a North Korean launch and
- 57:44a small number of inbound weapons very high likelihood none of them would make landfall.
- 57:49If Russia or China did a full scale launch, there's nothing you can
- 57:52do but respond. And so right now, to be clear, no,
- 57:58mutually assured destruction is still basically it. If Russia, now I want to
- 58:02be clear that this nuclear weapon Russia does not have in orbit. It looks
- 58:06as though it's just a system they want a field, And it's similar to
- 58:09the question of what wouldn't that violate the nineteen sixty seven Outer Space Treaty.
- 58:15Sure, but they don't care, right. All we can do now is
- 58:20develop the means to respond in a way that creates such a threat that they
- 58:24wouldn't dare use it. And that's basically the only effective weapon. There are
- 58:29lots of hypersonic weapon interception systems in development now, and I am sure it's
- 58:35a nut that will get cracked, but again, air defense is never a
- 58:38certainty. So the real answer, as bad as it sounds, is a
- 58:43good offense is to be such a looming threat that they don't dare launch.
- 58:46It's really the only safe that Alex is this, you know, in fair
- 58:52in mind, this is a very grunt level kind of this discussion of the
- 58:57I mean, for me, of the problem that doesn't it come down to
- 59:01essentially this and to your point that the only thing we can do is throw
- 59:06worse weapons systems back because we cannot really adequately. We can't defend against a
- 59:10hypersonic blight bomb that is maneuvering, you know, and we can defend against
- 59:15them. Yeah, we cruse missiles that are slower and maneuvering, or a
- 59:20ballistic missile that doesn't maneve it, but that comes in, you know,
- 59:23from ballistically, but a glime bomb I mean it goes up right into the
- 59:30stratosphere, I mean in order to launch. And it's that incredible speed plus
- 59:34the ability of it to maneuver that makes it that's the repossible impossible. So
- 59:40you raise a great point about what makes a hypersonic weapon special. It's not
- 59:45really necessarily as speed. In fact, often they're slower than ballistic missiles in
- 59:50terms of time to target because of those maneuvers. But the way air defense
- 59:54systems work is it's just complicated math. You establish it's tragical factory based on
- 1:00:00multiple points of travel, and then you figure out where a point in the
- 1:00:04future trajectory will be that your interceptor can meet it there to stop it from
- 1:00:08coming. So by maneuvering dramatically, what you do is you render those calculations
- 1:00:13moot, and so then it's got to assess where your new trajectory is,
- 1:00:16do the calculations again, and then come up with a new intercept point to
- 1:00:21launch an interceptor and maybe then it maneuvers again. And so what we're doing
- 1:00:24is we're making it far more complicated to conduct the intercept. Not impossible,
- 1:00:30but a way bigger challenge. But the problem isn't how do you stop one?
- 1:00:36The problem is how do you stop ten? You know? Because you
- 1:00:39may well be able to even with today's age's systems, we might be able
- 1:00:44to take down some mi prosonic glide vehicles the same way you might be able
- 1:00:47to take down, you know, a ballistic missile with a system that wasn't
- 1:00:52designed to take down a ballistic missile, but you might be able to swing
- 1:00:54it. The problem becomes, you're not going to get lucky with three at
- 1:01:00you. You might get lucky with one, you know, And so the
- 1:01:04real question becomes, how do you establish a system that can not only defend
- 1:01:08against these threats, but can do so consistently without expending every interceptor on board,
- 1:01:15without taking yourself out of the fight, or without the economic attrition of
- 1:01:19lobbing something that costs ten times what the weapon does at the weapon to stop
- 1:01:23it from getting there. And right now, the only answer to that on
- 1:01:29in a tactical standpoint is distance is range the But then you were a problem
- 1:01:35of how do you hit back and in a distance. But also, you
- 1:01:38know, with and I hate to use the tone, but I'm going to
- 1:01:42the transparent battle field and long range precision targets, you make yourself arguably less
- 1:01:47of the target. You know, a carrier is a huge fucking target.
- 1:01:52Satellites, in the words of General Hayden, are big, fat, juicy
- 1:01:55targets. So you know there's an active when at the active measures part.
- 1:02:00But we've got to figure out a way how to accomplish the mission using less
- 1:02:05vulnerable platforms. That's kind of the point of fitting at that. Rather than
- 1:02:10just keep trying to build on these same obsolete platforms to try and bring them
- 1:02:15into back into obsolescence, we just need to figure out a new way of
- 1:02:19doing launching attacks, of providing logistics. Replace the capacity you lose when one
- 1:02:27of those exquisite platforms does go down, when one of those ducy satellite targets
- 1:02:31or one of those carriers is compromised. How do you replace the combat capacity
- 1:02:37that it delivered on the short term quickly enough to have an effect. With
- 1:02:44the weapon systems we have with the f thirty five and now with the FAXX,
- 1:02:49why do we need to have a carrier with all these aircraft on the
- 1:02:52deck when we can have one with unmanned systems that can you know, can
- 1:02:57direct havoc among the enemy and it's not going to need a massive platform except
- 1:03:00for the one man system, right, And so that kind of gets back
- 1:03:02to as soon as we put a man into anything, it becomes less capable,
- 1:03:08more vulnerable. In that circumstance is still the political insulation. And what
- 1:03:15I mean this is something we ran into in the Cold War with the U
- 1:03:19two. This is why we actually operated the U two off of aircraft carriers
- 1:03:23in three separate instances, is because you run into situations where the partner nations
- 1:03:30in the region, because of their own geopolitical implications, suddenly won't gain grant
- 1:03:36you access to the airstrip that you need. You may not have the facilities
- 1:03:39that are required anymore, and a carrier strike group is something you can park
- 1:03:43in the region and conduct those operations from without that political debate. But the
- 1:03:49problem becomes, how do you keep these platforms effective when they're so large and
- 1:03:55expensive to replace. It's a challenge, Like you know, we've heard that
- 1:04:01argument all our careers as a defense to the carrier, and and it really
- 1:04:05it was a good argument when we were in coin, right, But it's
- 1:04:10really difficult, really difficult looking ahead to think of a circumstance where a carrier
- 1:04:15would be the right answer to any geopolitical problem aside from show of force,
- 1:04:20right, you know, kind of it's always a car A carrier is flastid,
- 1:04:27hard power, right. I mean, it's just you know, it
- 1:04:30looks like an erection, but it's not. Actually, may you have to
- 1:04:34carry? But I mean I've gotten that, Yeah, But my point is
- 1:04:41there's a whole bunch of capabilities that we do need at that end. You
- 1:04:45know, as a former soft guy, we need aviation, and we need
- 1:04:49a platform that can remain there constantly providing fire support, or as we need
- 1:04:57with our partner nation forces, to have expendable drones, blue collar drones that
- 1:05:02are that are that they can afford, but they can afford to lose.
- 1:05:05But at the same time publish condition. You know, these are all things
- 1:05:10that we really do need. But what is happening now while we're preparing all
- 1:05:15these high end stuff, all these high end things to keep the carriers relevant
- 1:05:20and the high the high end challenge grunt, a blood eye grunt, devil's
- 1:05:27advocate. You no, you're this is the reason why the Marine Corps is
- 1:05:30pursuing the lightning carrier concept to your very point, right, this idea of
- 1:05:34using amphibious assault chips as more widely dispersed carriers in the Pacific fight. Because
- 1:05:42again, you know, I don't want to over or I don't want to
- 1:05:45understate just how tough it is. A carrier is a massive target. There
- 1:05:48is no doubt about it. It is really tough to hit a carrier moving
- 1:05:51at full clip against the backdrop of the Pacific Ocean at a four digit range.
- 1:05:57That is a massive targeting challenge, not one that now you're exactly right
- 1:06:03right now, if you're using sea drones, well see, and this is
- 1:06:09exactly what China is working on now, is developing a very robust kill chain
- 1:06:14that leverages drones on the surface, drones below the surface, drones in the
- 1:06:18air, not just the type of drones that we think of, but aerostats
- 1:06:23uh long duration, high altitude balloons supplemented by satellites, supplemented by geosynchronous satellites.
- 1:06:30So we have multiple layers of systems that are all working together to geolocate
- 1:06:35targets in the South China Sea to be able to put missiles on target very
- 1:06:40quickly. And this is an incredibly dangerous situation when you have a four structure
- 1:06:45like America's, where you know, people like to say China has the superior
- 1:06:50numbers, but America has the superior tonnage, as though that's a flex it's
- 1:06:57sort of, is it. You know, when we say America's navy is
- 1:07:00significantly larger in terms of tonnage but not numbers, what we mean is we
- 1:07:04have a bunch of much larger vessels and way fewer small ones. And what
- 1:07:09that really means is that we've got some very very big targets that if we
- 1:07:14don't defend effectively, we'll have a lot of trouble replacing. But I want,
- 1:07:18but I do want to highlight again though that it is hard to overstate
- 1:07:23the value of having a four acre airfield that you can park where you need
- 1:07:28to if you've got an aircraft with the range that you need in order to
- 1:07:32effectively engage these targets. So a hypothetical engagement with China would have to start.
- 1:07:39I would argue with submarine based you know, Tomahawk and B twenty one
- 1:07:43Raider maybe the stand in attack weapon based engagements. And what they would need
- 1:07:47to do is fly to the Chinese coast first identify using its ISR suite these
- 1:07:55anti ship weapon inmplacements that are closest to the coastline. You've got to engage
- 1:07:59those to clear a path for these carriers to get into the fight. Otherwise
- 1:08:03they won't be in the fight at all. And if we don't wipe out
- 1:08:08these systems effectively, when you look at wargame scenarios for Taiwan, for instance,
- 1:08:13it is effectively a sure thing that the US could win this conflict if
- 1:08:15it stepped into it, but almost assuredly at the cost of at least one
- 1:08:19carrier and often two based on how these war games play out. And that
- 1:08:25is all about this range game. Now, if we can interfere with China's
- 1:08:28kill chain, great, that helps. If we can clear a path and
- 1:08:30these anti ship weapons systems, that helps too, because the closer we can
- 1:08:34get this projectable power to Chinese shores, the more effective it can be.
- 1:08:40But at the end of the day, what we really need is a variety
- 1:08:45of different types of platforms and systems, just like you're saying. So that
- 1:08:48way, the carrier isn't the only threat you're worried about. You want to
- 1:08:53be worried about these other threats posed by the submarines, by the soft units
- 1:08:57that are able to use submersibles to get in the drone support. But you
- 1:09:01want to be worried about all of it. Otherwise they could focus on one
- 1:09:04thing and recavoc on it. Well you want to, yeah, I mean,
- 1:09:08I I agree, Alex. And and if you know, if carriers,
- 1:09:14as I'm afraid they will remain remain the backbone of our of our navy.
- 1:09:21Yeah, I mean my point is, and then we have to present
- 1:09:26when the enemy looks at our order of battle, we have to he has
- 1:09:29to see something that we've we've manufactured for him that presents one hundred carriers,
- 1:09:33you know, and he's going to decide which are the real ones. I
- 1:09:36mean, that's right now. You know, the navy that's out there today
- 1:09:42is, for all intents and purposes, not all that dissimilar from the Navy
- 1:09:45of Desert Storm in terms of system functionality out there, we have some Alex,
- 1:09:51not completely. Sailors can now keep their hands in their pockets. You
- 1:09:56know, progress is progress. You know, it makes this famal formidable and
- 1:10:01adversary. But you know, when you look at Desert Storm, it was
- 1:10:05a symphony of planning and technology, you know, executed very, very effectively.
- 1:10:13But I worry that we now have a bit more of a disparate network
- 1:10:17of systems where you know, Frank Kendall, the Secretary of the Air Force,
- 1:10:21said this fairly recently, where there's been emphasis on developing systems but not
- 1:10:27necessarily on integrating them. You know, we're trying to create these capabilities in
- 1:10:32a vacuum rather than having a really good overarching strategy for how to put these
- 1:10:38capabilities together into an effective battle plan. And I think part of that is
- 1:10:43that Americans buy and large have this misunderstanding that America has a preordained right to
- 1:10:48air supremacy and to you know, dominance in a combat environment. You'll see
- 1:10:54commenters that are furious at the prospect in America the steamroll through China. Know,
- 1:11:00in a conflict, it's but that's the truth of the of the situation
- 1:11:02is that warfare is obviously I don't need to tell you guys, but warfare
- 1:11:06is complicated and messy business. No strategy works the way that you intended to
- 1:11:13when you start, and we can't look at you know, the fact that
- 1:11:17China is still using horses and trains to move troops around, you know,
- 1:11:20inside their own borders. That doesn't mean that China can't pose a massive threat
- 1:11:26to American interests, to global stability, to national security. We have this
- 1:11:31bad habit of going, oh, well, they don't have the F thirty
- 1:11:33five. So that's not how war works, you know, you know,
- 1:11:40we're seeing it, you know, live in action in Ukraine, where you
- 1:11:44know, Ukraine really didn't have any right to do what they did. And
- 1:11:47people often say, oh, well, Ukraine's getting all this support from the
- 1:11:51West and that's why they're still in the fight. They don't realize that if
- 1:11:55Russia had executed effectively in the first five weeks of the campaign the way the
- 1:11:59Coalition did, does Storm help never would have come in time. Ukraine would
- 1:12:02have been over before support arrived. Russia's an efficacy created room for Ukraine to
- 1:12:13mount this resistance. And if Ukraine can do it, if the Hooties can
- 1:12:15do it in the Red Sea, it is crazy not to think that China
- 1:12:19could do it. On a much larger scale. You know, Alex,
- 1:12:23we need to we need to bring you back on again because you know,
- 1:12:28there's so much more to talk about this on on this subject, whether it's
- 1:12:33drones or whether it's whether it's on Overwatch, but also what you've just been
- 1:12:41talking about, the lessons from the air war in Ukraine. Why here,
- 1:12:46you know, I just was talking to Arali soldier downstairs about you know,
- 1:12:50I didn't bring it up, but you know, a large number of civilian
- 1:12:56casualties a reflection of the fact that the Israelis aren't using the Jadam kits.
- 1:13:01Why is that? What are they learning? You know, they've gone to
- 1:13:04die palming techniques, but they're still having problems, right, you know,
- 1:13:10So there's so much to tool abound as far as you know, and I
- 1:13:13think a lot of that can be attributed to again, you know, I
- 1:13:16remember the ambassador to a Pianistan a few years ago saying something to akin to
- 1:13:23it's tough to have conversations with our partners because they based their understanding of our
- 1:13:28capabilities on movies. And I think that people often misunderstand the level of technology
- 1:13:35that we have. With the level of technology that's deployed force wide and how
- 1:13:41effectively it can be leveraged. Russia being a good example. You've got a
- 1:13:45lot of precision munitions that are pilots never trained to leverage. Doesn't make them
- 1:13:48good for much. Likewise, it doesn't matter how many you know, maybe
- 1:13:53Jada M kits you have, if you don't have people trained to put them
- 1:13:56on the systems they need to be on, or people train and how best
- 1:14:00to leverage them, or in the maintenance of those kits, or in you
- 1:14:03know. Something that people tend not to understand is that every system has not
- 1:14:08only flight hour restrictions, but g restrictions. So if you put a weapon
- 1:14:12system on an aircraft, it goes out and flies a combat sorty and doesn't
- 1:14:15leverage that munition. The force the exertion put on that weapon degrades its service
- 1:14:21life, it's operational lifespan, and you need to spend money to keep these
- 1:14:26systems in the air. Basically, there's there are so many different pieces of
- 1:14:30the puzzle that I think people tend to think of warfare as a video game
- 1:14:35where they go, oh, I got an upgraded system. This is what
- 1:14:39all my systems are now, and whereas the truth is is It's always a
- 1:14:43trickle, you know, right of you know, the systems getting out to
- 1:14:45where they need to be and then the people learning how to leverage them,
- 1:14:49you know, right. I can't say that's what's happening but in Israel,
- 1:14:55but that's one possibility. Yeah, I mean, it's a good egg the
- 1:15:00nation. Well, guys, I honestly have a blast. I know,
- 1:15:05I know, I don't stop to get me started. So I think we've
- 1:15:10probably got many more questions for you, Alex, so definitely want to bring
- 1:15:16you back before we closed down, though DNJ said anything anything more or anything,
- 1:15:24Well, while we have well, while we have the the a theorist
- 1:15:30haam, I mean I had, you know, the Russian space lasers.
- 1:15:32That's what I wrote down here, the nukes, you know what I mean?
- 1:15:35Yeah, I want to be clear that the Russian weapon might not be
- 1:15:39an orbital nuke but a nuclear powered weapon, which is what some people argue.
- 1:15:45I would contend strategically that would have even less value, only because it
- 1:15:51would be a capability they already have in their anti satellite weapon systems and their
- 1:15:56orbital inspector satellites. Interfering with the satellites functions pretty easy nudget into a degrading
- 1:16:01orbit and it's done, and as a result, you can actually take out
- 1:16:06a lot of satellites without having to expend kinetic anything. Uh so, yeah,
- 1:16:12it could be a nuclear powered weapon, but that would again again we're
- 1:16:15talking about bond villain weapons that have greater value in terms of perception than it's
- 1:16:21a propaganda win. Right, Yeah, I got nothing. I'd say ax
- 1:16:28on the on that note, key, wasn't there Wasn't there an American who
- 1:16:32shut down a satellite? Was he flying afteen or at sixteen to sixty degree?
- 1:16:39Fine? I want to say it was an ASM one thirty five was
- 1:16:43the name of the ordinance, But yeah, it was an air to airic
- 1:16:46kill on a satellite. But to be so, when the US did that
- 1:16:50back in nineteen eighty two and Russia did their it was yeah, believe it
- 1:16:56or not, or maybe it was eighty five. So Russia did their test
- 1:16:59in twenty one and the US said, Russia, that was pretty irresponsible,
- 1:17:02and Russia said, well, you guys did it in the eighties, not
- 1:17:06recognizing that there are a lot more satellites in orbit in twenty twenty one than
- 1:17:11in the eighties, and that makes that Kessler syndrome threat that much more real.
- 1:17:15But yeah, China has also conducted an anti satellite weapons testimony. I
- 1:17:19want to say maybe India as well. So yeah, orbit. When people
- 1:17:26say that the Space Force is militarizing space, space has been a warfare theater
- 1:17:31since Sputnik. It has always been, you know, a theater of warfare.
- 1:17:36People are just catching up with it now. Russia and China both have
- 1:17:40space based branches up their military that have been active for years prior to the
- 1:17:45Space Force. Well, ixcite, I for one want to thank you very
- 1:17:49much for coming on. Jason, thank you too for hooking him in.
- 1:17:55Absolutely please, Yeah, this is great all right everyone, I just want
- 1:18:05to thank Alex very much coming on, and also T and Jason and and
- 1:18:11all of you. And we'll see you again in another three days, right
- 1:18:15there. Yeah, let's remember, don't forget to like, don't forget to
- 1:18:18subscribe. If you're listening to us on any audio platforms, you can rate
- 1:18:21and review it. You can check out the Patreon uh and of course check
- 1:18:27out Sandbox and Alex's outfit. Airpower, I mean it's you know, if
- 1:18:31you're watching this, you know all about airpower and the huge numbers it does.
- 1:18:38Yeah, and make sure to check me out on TikTok too, you
- 1:18:40know, not using your government phone, but it's it's where it's where I
- 1:18:45try to speak to the children. Yeah. So everything will be in the
- 1:18:47description in the show notes of this show, so you can check out Alex
- 1:18:50there. Okay, cool, all right, everyone, see you in three
- 1:18:55days. Tak