Latest / Sacrilegious Discourse - Bible Study for Atheists / Introduction to The Gospel of Mark: Bible Study by Atheists
Transcript
- 0:00[UNKNOWN]: Have fun!
- 0:00[SPEAKER_00]: Wife!
- 0:01[SPEAKER_00]: Do you know what we're doing today?
- 0:05[SPEAKER_01]: We're starting Mark!
- 0:07[UNKNOWN]: Wife, Wife, Wife!
- 0:08[SPEAKER_00]: Maki Maki!
- 0:10[SPEAKER_00]: You got to go to that position.
- 0:12[SPEAKER_00]: Come on, come on, come on.
- 0:14[SPEAKER_00]: He's got sweet vibration.
- 0:16[SPEAKER_01]: He's got a funky bunch too.
- 0:17[SPEAKER_00]: He does.
- 0:17[SPEAKER_00]: He's got a funky bunch.
- 0:19[SPEAKER_01]: Jesus has a funky bunch.
- 0:20[SPEAKER_00]: No, Jesus has 2G game.
- 0:23[SPEAKER_01]: Whatever, but I think for Mark, since you know you're going with that, I guess we have a funky bunch.
- 0:28[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, but then I come with a new game for each gospel.
- 0:31[SPEAKER_01]: So what does the gospel game?
- 0:32[SPEAKER_01]: What does it take with a 2G game?
- 0:33[SPEAKER_00]: The Apple Dumpling Gang.
- 0:36[SPEAKER_00]: Did you ever see those movies?
- 0:37[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 0:38[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god.
- 0:38[SPEAKER_00]: They were so stupid fun good.
- 0:40[SPEAKER_01]: Were they?
- 0:41[SPEAKER_00]: When I was a kid, the Apple Dumpling Gang's such good Disney family fun movie.
- 0:45[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 0:46[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 0:47[SPEAKER_00]: I think rubber and orphans in the south, oh my gosh, it's so good.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_01]: South sounds like Disney.
- 0:54[SPEAKER_00]: Yep.
- 0:56[SPEAKER_01]: So did you want to touch on anything that we're going to be talking about or any any tidbits before we get into it?
- 1:02[SPEAKER_00]: Mark is not Matthew.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_01]: Mark is not Matthew.
- 1:05[SPEAKER_00]: They both are with Elido and I resent that because I have problems with literation.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_00]: And I get names compute.
- 1:14[SPEAKER_01]: But I do think Matthew was a Mark thief.
- 1:16[SPEAKER_00]: It was.
- 1:17[SPEAKER_00]: Tim and Luke both.
- 1:18[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 1:19[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 1:20[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't got to Luke yet.
- 1:21[SPEAKER_00]: No, I know.
- 1:22[SPEAKER_00]: So weird though because like they go Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, but Matthew stole from Mark and Mark comes after Matthew, but before Luke, but Luke also stole from Mark.
- 1:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, who's on first?
- 1:36[SPEAKER_00]: And then, and then John comes in and John's like, I'm gonna steal from all you motherfuckers.
- 1:41[SPEAKER_01]: What's on second?
- 1:42[SPEAKER_00]: And then I keep hearing about Paul, and I'm like, there's no book of Paul, and then we get Acts, and I'm like, what is Acts?
- 1:51[SPEAKER_00]: And apparently, like, all these guys are stealing for, I don't know why.
- 1:55[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, it's on third floor.
- 1:57[SPEAKER_00]: Ah, remember when we played that for kid?
- 2:00[SPEAKER_00]: And they were like, those slaps.
- 2:04[SPEAKER_00]: That made me really happy because I was like, it does like, it's still fucking hilarious.
- 2:09[SPEAKER_00]: Like, like, it's so old.
- 2:11[SPEAKER_00]: It was old when we were kids.
- 2:13[SPEAKER_01]: It was.
- 2:13[SPEAKER_01]: It was.
- 2:14[SPEAKER_00]: And that was super old.
- 2:15[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 2:16[SPEAKER_00]: And our kid is 21 and they were like, nah, dog, this still slaps.
- 2:21[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that's slapstick for you, right?
- 2:24[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, look at you, it's brought at home.
- 2:26[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 2:26[SPEAKER_00]: You brought, you brought slapstick, it's slapstick.
- 2:29[SPEAKER_00]: You brought it all the way around.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_00]: That is a full motherfucking circle there.
- 2:33[SPEAKER_01]: So Mark.
- 2:34[SPEAKER_00]: Mark.
- 2:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you ready to do some Mark?
- 2:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, let's go do some synoptic gossiping.
- 2:39[SPEAKER_01]: OK, let's do this.
- 2:40[SPEAKER_00]: OK, don't keep.
- 2:48[SPEAKER_00]: All right, mark the mark.
- 2:49[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 2:49[SPEAKER_00]: You ready to get into mark the mark?
- 2:51[SPEAKER_01]: I'm ready, yeah.
- 2:53[SPEAKER_00]: Let me ask you a question.
- 2:54[SPEAKER_00]: Besides everything that we said in the intro, do you know anything else about this motherfucker?
- 2:59[SPEAKER_01]: Um, but then what we said in the intro?
- 3:01[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 3:02[SPEAKER_01]: No.
- 3:03[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 3:04[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, well, he was the first, it's the first, the earliest ridden, what are they called?
- 3:12[SPEAKER_01]: The Gospels, yeah, sorry, I brain took a, it went blank, it went blank, it hit it down.
- 3:20[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, gospel, earliest one.
- 3:22[SPEAKER_00]: I think we also said that in the intro from being honest.
- 3:25[SPEAKER_00]: So do you know anything else about that?
- 3:26[SPEAKER_01]: We said other ones copy them.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 3:28[SPEAKER_01]: That was.
- 3:28[SPEAKER_01]: You know anything else?
- 3:29[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 3:30[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to know before we go.
- 3:32[SPEAKER_01]: I do.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_01]: I do.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_01]: This one is used more frequently than Matthew is.
- 3:37[SPEAKER_01]: Matthew apparently is used more around Christmas time from what I'm to understand.
- 3:42[SPEAKER_01]: And this is just.
- 3:44[SPEAKER_01]: taking from what we have heard on our discord.
- 3:46[SPEAKER_01]: So I didn't know that prior to some people talking about that on our discord.
- 3:51[SPEAKER_00]: which we do a live discord even every Tuesday at 10 p.m. Yeah, you should join us and tell us all the things you know about marking mark.
- 3:58[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 3:59[SPEAKER_00]: That is actually correct.
- 4:01[SPEAKER_00]: And the reason being is that because as the earliest written, because of its provenance, it's considered the most accurate.
- 4:10[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 4:10[SPEAKER_00]: So that's why it's the most heavily quoted from.
- 4:14[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 4:15[SPEAKER_00]: But.
- 4:16[SPEAKER_00]: Um, as I said in the intro, it is the second of the four canonical gospels, which means the four gospels that are, you know, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John's.
- 4:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 4:27[SPEAKER_00]: That's canon.
- 4:29[SPEAKER_00]: And it's one of the three synoptic gospels, synoptic being the ones that tell the same story.
- 4:36[SPEAKER_01]: Got it.
- 4:36[SPEAKER_00]: So that would be Matthew, Mark, and Luke.
- 4:39[SPEAKER_01]: It's interesting to me that they, they tried to put,
- 4:42[SPEAKER_01]: for gospels into the Bible.
- 4:45[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, we're going to get into it.
- 4:47[SPEAKER_01]: And two other people copied the same fucking gospel.
- 4:50[SPEAKER_00]: And then the fourth one copied from the second two.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_01]: No, so it's like a telephonic.
- 4:55[SPEAKER_01]: Telephonic.
- 4:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yes.
- 4:58[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark narrates the ministry of Jesus, as we know.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_00]: Sure, okay.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_00]: It's so far as.
- 5:06[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 5:06[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I don't believe it, but like, because it's so... No, it narrates the story.
- 5:12[SPEAKER_00]: It's whether you believe that the story actually happened.
- 5:15[SPEAKER_01]: Right, which based on what I know from Matthew,
- 5:18[SPEAKER_00]: Hmm.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_01]: Very questionable.
- 5:20[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 5:21[SPEAKER_00]: So anyway, but it is a narration of the ministry of this real or fabled character.
- 5:28[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 5:28[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_00]: Name Jesus.
- 5:30[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 5:30[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_00]: And it talks about Jesus' baptism by John the Baptist.
- 5:35[SPEAKER_00]: That's where it starts.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 5:37[SPEAKER_00]: Unlike Matthew.
- 5:38[SPEAKER_00]: Get some back.
- 5:39[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 5:39[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't get a birth story in Mark does not give one.
- 5:43[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 5:43[SPEAKER_01]: Which.
- 5:44[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sorry, I'm speaking in the past tense.
- 5:46[SPEAKER_01]: We have already recorded a couple of episodes of Mark's.
- 5:49[SPEAKER_01]: So.
- 5:49[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 5:50[SPEAKER_01]: And I'll apologize now for past tense usage.
- 5:54[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, Mark does not give any backstory childhood, nothing.
- 5:59[SPEAKER_00]: It jumps right in with his baptism.
- 6:01[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 6:02[SPEAKER_00]: And then it goes through his crucifixion is burial and the discovery of his empty tomb.
- 6:06[SPEAKER_00]: But I have something to say about his ending.
- 6:08[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to go into a spoiler because
- 6:13[SPEAKER_00]: It blew my fucking mind.
- 6:15[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 6:15[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 6:16[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm not going to say it yet, but before the end of the end.
- 6:19[SPEAKER_01]: We don't want to save it for the end when we cover it in the Q and A's.
- 6:21[SPEAKER_00]: No.
- 6:22[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 6:23[SPEAKER_00]: No, because we're going to be like, what?
- 6:26[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that's part of the fun, though.
- 6:28[SPEAKER_00]: And this is fun.
- 6:29[SPEAKER_00]: I'm telling you, this is the fun.
- 6:30[SPEAKER_01]: All right.
- 6:31[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark portrays Jesus as a teacher and exorcist, a healer and a miracle worker, which is where Matthew got all those ideas on.
- 6:39[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 6:40[SPEAKER_00]: Do you know who wrote Marky Mark?
- 6:42[SPEAKER_01]: I would assume not Mark.
- 6:44[SPEAKER_00]: not mark the gospel is traditionally attributed to mark the evangelist who was a companion of the Apostle Peter Peter Peter pumpkin eater.
- 6:55[SPEAKER_00]: That guy the cockadil du Peter.
- 6:57[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 6:57[SPEAKER_00]: That guy.
- 6:59[SPEAKER_00]: The author is not actually named within the text.
- 7:02[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 7:03[SPEAKER_00]: And that was actually common for biographies of that time.
- 7:08[SPEAKER_00]: They often did not name themselves.
- 7:10[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 7:10[SPEAKER_00]: The biographies that they were writing.
- 7:12[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 7:12[SPEAKER_00]: So scholars even debate the actual identity of the author.
- 7:16[SPEAKER_00]: Because they're like, we don't fucking know.
- 7:18[SPEAKER_00]: It's probably not a guy named Mark.
- 7:20[SPEAKER_00]: But you know, that could have been anybody including a guy named Mark.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_00]: So then like, right.
- 7:26[SPEAKER_00]: Um, here's the thing, there's this one guy named papias or papayas, which do you like better papias papayas?
- 7:34[SPEAKER_01]: Whichever one you want.
- 7:35[SPEAKER_00]: You're going to pick any way, so papayatri of heropolis.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 7:41[SPEAKER_00]: He lived from about 60 to 130 AD.
- 7:44[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 7:44[SPEAKER_00]: So very early and
- 7:50[SPEAKER_00]: in that time period.
- 7:53[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 7:53[SPEAKER_00]: He was an epistolic father.
- 7:57[SPEAKER_00]: And he was an author mainly known for gathering oral stories about Jesus and his disciples.
- 8:05[SPEAKER_00]: He gathered these stories during this time period.
- 8:08[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 8:09[SPEAKER_00]: Which is very interesting.
- 8:11[SPEAKER_00]: He gathered these stories from John the Elder and the Daughters of Philip, which is another Philip is one of the,
- 8:19[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 8:19[SPEAKER_00]: The, you know, half a dumpling game, the, uh, funky buns.
- 8:23[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 8:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 8:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 8:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 8:26[SPEAKER_00]: So.
- 8:27[SPEAKER_00]: Dilah, one of the apostles had some daughters and then this papaya tree guy came along and was like, so turning about the stories that your father Dilah told you about Jesus.
- 8:38[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 8:40[SPEAKER_00]: So an early Christian tradition recorded by papias or papaya tree regards the gospel of Mark as being based on the preaching of Saint Peter, Peter Peter Pumpkin-Eater.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_00]: as recorded by John Mark, who is Mark.
- 9:02[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 9:02[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 9:03[SPEAKER_00]: A companion and interpreter of Peter.
- 9:06[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 9:07[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 9:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 9:08[SPEAKER_00]: So.
- 9:10[SPEAKER_00]: We've got this papaya tree guy, and he is gathering stories, and he got the stories from Philip Stauders, and they're based on the preaching of Peter.
- 9:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 9:29[SPEAKER_00]: and who wrote those down was a guy named John Mark, who is very likely the mark of this.
- 9:36[SPEAKER_01]: I just want to throw this out there because Matthew and Luke are both copied from Mark that this sounds like a really flimsy, like baseline.
- 9:48[SPEAKER_00]: Why haven't said Matthew or Luke?
- 9:50[SPEAKER_00]: I've only mentioned
- 9:51[SPEAKER_00]: Peter, I fell up and marked.
- 9:53[SPEAKER_01]: No, yeah, no, I'm only mentioning Matthew and Luke because they both copied from Mark, right?
- 10:00[SPEAKER_01]: So this is a really flimsy way to gather the information for what went into Mark that's so much of the origin story of Jesus.
- 10:10[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I'm telling this part.
- 10:12[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, no, I see what you're saying.
- 10:14[SPEAKER_00]: And I totally am on board with you.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_00]: So, papayas, papayatri guy, he says that Marky Mark recorded what Peter remembered about Jesus, but not necessarily in chronological order.
- 10:31[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so we've got Peter who, you know, denied Jesus three times before the cockroach, right?
- 10:39[SPEAKER_00]: And then later on in life he's telling Mark some of the story along with Philip or what the fuck ever all his disciple guys, right?
- 10:49[SPEAKER_00]: And so we've got these disciple guys.
- 10:52[SPEAKER_00]: telling Mark these stories.
- 10:53[SPEAKER_00]: And then Papaya comes along and he's like, I would like also to hear these stories.
- 10:58[SPEAKER_00]: So I may also record them in my histories.
- 11:01[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 11:01[SPEAKER_00]: And so then that is what we're using as quote unquote corroborating evidence that some of this kind of kind of happened a little bit.
- 11:13[SPEAKER_00]: maybe.
- 11:14[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 11:16[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not even going to deny that there probably was a Jesus figure, right?
- 11:20[SPEAKER_01]: But by the time this all got written down and disseminated it into a form, it feels like it was it was much like the fish stories, you know, like, yeah, it was this big, you know, like, way to we get to the resurrection, just wait till Mark's version of the resurrection.
- 11:37[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 11:38[SPEAKER_01]: And I
- 11:43[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 11:44[SPEAKER_00]: So a scholarly, a scholarly consensus dates the work of papayas to around 1 10 80.
- 11:52[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 11:54[SPEAKER_00]: So he was right now.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_00]: They should after Jesus' death, but still when it was fresh in the next generation's minds, what had happened.
- 12:05[SPEAKER_01]: Now I thought that.
- 12:07[SPEAKER_01]: Someone had said that, like I thought we had talked about Matthew haven't been written around 70 or 80 AD, see, whatever, which if it was copying from Mark, lens two that that was probably written in that same time frame.
- 12:21[SPEAKER_00]: But Papayas was recording stories separately.
- 12:25[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, Papayas, his work.
- 12:28[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just wondering how this all translates back to Mark is all.
- 12:32[SPEAKER_00]: Papaya's was writing and got some of his stories around the same time from the same people that Mark did.
- 12:40[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 12:41[SPEAKER_00]: that's all.
- 12:42[SPEAKER_00]: They were contemporaries of each other.
- 12:43[SPEAKER_01]: Got it.
- 12:44[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 12:45[SPEAKER_00]: And papayas was a separate corroborating source of information.
- 12:51[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 12:51[SPEAKER_00]: So scholars are looking back going, wow, we've got these four gospely guys or what the fuck ever.
- 12:57[SPEAKER_00]: And then we've got this separate historian dude that talked to some of these guys.
- 13:01[SPEAKER_00]: That's why I'm bringing him up.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 13:04[SPEAKER_00]: So his works papayas, they're considered an important early source on Christian oral tradition because he was again collecting the oral stories and especially on the origins of the canonical gospels.
- 13:21[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, all right, remember they were like writing things down, but they didn't all get into their finalized forms until various different time periods, so papayas is like one of the dudes that was like writing this is what they're talking about over here around this time, okay.
- 13:40[SPEAKER_00]: But as we said, there remains much debate among scholars.
- 13:44[SPEAKER_00]: Some deny that the gospel was written by anyone named Mark.
- 13:49[SPEAKER_00]: They were like, get the fuck out of here with that.
- 13:50[SPEAKER_01]: All right, I can buy that.
- 13:52[SPEAKER_01]: Probably better than I could buy that mark.
- 13:54[SPEAKER_01]: Someone named Mark wrote it.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you will leave even more into that here shortly.
- 13:59[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 13:59[SPEAKER_00]: Others accept the view that John Mark, a person who appears in the book of Acts, which that's the one that comes after Matthew Mark, Luke and John.
- 14:09[SPEAKER_00]: Um, is next comes the book of Acts.
- 14:11[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 14:11[SPEAKER_00]: Um, that's where John Mark appears.
- 14:13[SPEAKER_00]: And so others accept the view that John Mark and some of Paul's letters was the author.
- 14:20[SPEAKER_01]: Got it.
- 14:20[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 14:21[SPEAKER_00]: And then others argue that the gospel was written by a different mark entirely who was never mentioned in the Bible or connected to Peter in any way whatsoever.
- 14:31[SPEAKER_00]: So we've got a no mark.
- 14:33[SPEAKER_00]: We've got a John Mark and we've got a mark mark or no mark.
- 14:37[SPEAKER_01]: I was going to say it doesn't have to be rid of my a mark at all.
- 14:40[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 14:40[SPEAKER_01]: They could have just picked a name that was convenient and use it.
- 14:44[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, no, totally.
- 14:45[SPEAKER_00]: Because connecting the Gospels author to John Mark, it's a historical inference based largely on later tradition, the subtitle
- 15:01[SPEAKER_00]: We call it the book of Mark, but it's the gospel according to Mark.
- 15:04[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 15:04[SPEAKER_00]: That whole according to Mark part was attached later.
- 15:08[SPEAKER_01]: Got it.
- 15:09[SPEAKER_00]: It was not part of the original documents.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_00]: So we don't know who the fuck wrote it, but maybe maybe a guy named Mark or John Mark or sure.
- 15:19[SPEAKER_00]: Marky Mark might as well throw that in the mix because we're not right.
- 15:24[SPEAKER_00]: So tradition says that I should specify Christian tradition.
- 15:30[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 15:31[SPEAKER_00]: Indicates that the gospel is usually dated through the eschatological discourse in Mark chapter 13.
- 15:40[SPEAKER_00]: Which scholars interpret as pointing to the first Jewish room in war, and that took place around 66 to 74 80.
- 15:50[SPEAKER_00]: So Christians are like, it took place right during the Jewish room in war, 66 to 74 80.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_00]: And this is the war that led to the destruction of the second temple in 78.
- 16:05[SPEAKER_01]: which we discussed in Matthew is why we have symmetry and some of the stories that kind of allude to that.
- 16:11[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 16:12[SPEAKER_00]: And so academics, most scholars place Mark during the build-up of the first Jewish Roman war.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_00]: So not during, but in the time leading up to it.
- 16:25[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 16:26[SPEAKER_00]: And the destruction of the Jerusalem and the second temple.
- 16:29[SPEAKER_00]: So they placed it a little bit earlier, 65 to 70.
- 16:32[SPEAKER_00]: So we've got 65 to 70 according to scholars, or 66 to 74, according to Christians, that's so like close in time, honestly, is such an insignificant number that
- 16:48[SPEAKER_00]: most scholars and most people who talk about it, they just shorthand it to around 70.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_00]: Because that makes sense.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_00]: 65 to 75 or you could say 70 give or take five years.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_01]: Well, in the truth is, we don't actually know.
- 17:05[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 17:06[SPEAKER_01]: It's going to be in it.
- 17:06[SPEAKER_01]: And it's going to be in a range anyway.
- 17:08[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so it's somewhere around 70 CE and I keep saying AD and I wish I would get that out of my head.
- 17:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's CE current era.
- 17:18[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 17:20[SPEAKER_00]: Usually we just say approximately 70 CE, because it's a useful short hand, and it gives us like a time period to kind of look right at.
- 17:29[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 17:30[SPEAKER_00]: So the Gospel of Mark was written in Greek, which is very interesting for a primarily Gentile, non-Jewish audience, probably in Rome.
- 17:42[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 17:43[SPEAKER_00]: It's interesting that we say non-Jewish and Gentile because it also simultaneously was not for an audience that was like, hey, I'm trying to evangelize to you and get you to come join our club.
- 18:01[SPEAKER_00]: This is a club that already exists that is Jewish adjacent.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_00]: They're gentiles, they're non-Jews, but they're in that Jewish area.
- 18:16[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 18:17[SPEAKER_00]: Does that make sense?
- 18:18[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 18:18[SPEAKER_00]: So it's really confusing.
- 18:20[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 18:22[SPEAKER_00]: It was most likely in Rome, is where it was most likely written.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 18:27[SPEAKER_00]: Even though it was written in Greek, most likely, most likely in Galilee, Antioch.
- 18:37[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 18:37[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sorry.
- 18:39[SPEAKER_00]: We believe most likely that it was in Rome, but other places have been also suggested as just as likely, which could be Galilee, Antioch, which was the third largest city in the Roman Empire, or southern Syria.
- 18:54[SPEAKER_00]: So somewhere thereabouts.
- 18:56[SPEAKER_01]: Got it.
- 18:57[SPEAKER_00]: But, but, but other alternate proposals, so basically, we don't know where the pusher is written.
- 19:03[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 19:04[SPEAKER_00]: Libya is a possible setting, because that was the location of Cyrene, and there's a long-held Arabic tradition of Mark having a residence there.
- 19:15[SPEAKER_00]: So, I don't know, I'm leaning toward Rome because we're talking about
- 19:23[SPEAKER_00]: um, Jesus being a rebel in a Roman empire.
- 19:28[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 19:28[SPEAKER_00]: Not a mean.
- 19:29[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm leaning towards it was written in Rome, but who fucking cares, honestly, at the end of the day.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_00]: Great.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_00]: It was written somewhere over there.
- 19:37[SPEAKER_01]: It was written somewhere.
- 19:38[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 19:39[SPEAKER_00]: Um, but the fact that it was written in Greek is super important regardless of any of those places.
- 19:45[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 19:45[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 19:46[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 19:46[SPEAKER_00]: Um, Jesus and his earliest followers would primarily have spoken aromate.
- 19:51[SPEAKER_01]: Great.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_00]: So that's the first point.
- 19:54[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 19:55[SPEAKER_00]: Hebrew would have been there are other language having an important religious and literary role.
- 20:01[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 20:02[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 20:02[SPEAKER_01]: So it's interesting that it made it switch.
- 20:05[SPEAKER_01]: within a 30-year time span, right, to a Greek language?
- 20:09[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 20:12[SPEAKER_00]: Greek was functioning widely through the Eastern Roman Empire.
- 20:16[SPEAKER_00]: And that also is why people would say somewhere in or around Rome.
- 20:20[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 20:21[SPEAKER_00]: Because that's what they were speaking was Greek.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 20:24[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark occasionally translates and explains aeromagic expressions in the text.
- 20:32[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_00]: So he'll say something in aeromagic or say something about Palestinian Jewish custom or certain Jewish practices and then he'll explain it or he'll translate it.
- 20:45[SPEAKER_00]: So that's how we know like these are clues that Mark expected at least some of his readers not to understand these things naturally.
- 20:55[SPEAKER_00]: Otherwise he wouldn't have to translate or explain for us.
- 20:58[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 20:58[SPEAKER_00]: So it's one reason scholars often think that his audience included a substantial number of Gentile Christians, which is interesting that we're calling them Christians.
- 21:10[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 21:14[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I mean, you know, I don't think we get a solid definition of what a Christian is until much later.
- 21:20[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, if they're following this Christ figure the way they are, it is already a cult.
- 21:27[SPEAKER_01]: And there's a reason why it became quite on quote Christianity.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like, I mean, that so I could see that maybe they refer to themselves in such a way.
- 21:35[SPEAKER_01]: But you know,
- 21:36[SPEAKER_00]: They didn't refer to themselves as Christians yet, but we can start referring to them as such in hindsight, because they sure as fuck have already shown throughout Matthew, that they were not living as Jewish people.
- 21:50[SPEAKER_00]: They were already the followers of Jesus.
- 21:53[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, Jesus' main theme was, and the Jews believed that to this day, not us, because we're not like that of them.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 22:02[SPEAKER_00]: So, and I know I threw a fit about that before, but it just bears repeating that they already viewed themselves as either, yeah, distinguished from, separate from, either like superior Jewish or Jewish adjacent or quasi Jewish, something that was not standard Judaism.
- 22:26[SPEAKER_00]: to me it makes sense to go ahead and refer to them as Christian, even though they didn't refer to themselves as Christian, but they sure as fuck were not Jewish.
- 22:34[SPEAKER_00]: Sorry, but they just fucking weren't.
- 22:36[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 22:37[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark's depiction of Jesus, dude lives in a Jewish society under Roman imperial domination.
- 22:46[SPEAKER_00]: We know that from having already read Matthew.
- 22:48[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 22:50[SPEAKER_00]: Galilei at the time, like some of this is going to sound repetitive, but it's just like a reminder since we're like starting the story over again.
- 22:58[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 22:58[SPEAKER_00]: Galilei was governed by Herod and Antipiss Antipiss, a Roman client ruler, and then Judea itself was under romantic administration with Pontius Pilate representing Roman authority in Jerusalem.
- 23:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 23:15[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, and we know Pontius Pilate.
- 23:17[SPEAKER_01]: I know how that one goes.
- 23:18[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, he's a hand-washing guy.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_00]: He's like, I washed my hands at this bullshittery.
- 23:23[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 23:23[SPEAKER_00]: So the political atmosphere at that time becomes really important when Jesus is executed as King of the Jews, which we already read about.
- 23:33[SPEAKER_00]: Again, Mark's readers are hearing a story about someone proclaiming a kingdom.
- 23:41[SPEAKER_00]: in a world where Rome already has an emperor and client kings are already governing parts of Judea.
- 23:49[SPEAKER_00]: So they hear this king of the Jews stuff and they're like, right that scratch excuse you?
- 23:54[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 23:56[SPEAKER_00]: So Matthew, which we just finished reading and Luke, as I said, both appear to have independently used Mark, which is what we're talking about as one of their major sources.
- 24:07[SPEAKER_00]: So they basically copied it, but they didn't just copy it though.
- 24:11[SPEAKER_00]: This is part of the basis for scholarly consensus.
- 24:15[SPEAKER_00]: So like academics all agree that Mark came first.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 24:19[SPEAKER_00]: Because they clearly took from his stuff.
- 24:22[SPEAKER_01]: Great.
- 24:22[SPEAKER_00]: Most scholars believe that Mark is the earliest gospel and was used by Matthew and Luke, which were in turn used by John.
- 24:29[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 24:31[SPEAKER_00]: I did not know that until preparing this, right?
- 24:34[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, so John's a third party got it.
- 24:38[SPEAKER_00]: Or fourth party depending on where the first guys got their stories from.
- 24:41[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 24:42[SPEAKER_00]: So that means when we are eventually able to compare Mark with Matthew and Luke, the copycatters, we're gonna see that they aren't just telling the same story, they are literally editing Mark's version of it.
- 24:57[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 24:59[SPEAKER_00]: Which we can tell already because if Mark came first,
- 25:05[SPEAKER_00]: At this point, we've already read chapter one, you and I. Yeah.
- 25:08[SPEAKER_00]: Although we haven't published it yet because we wanted to do this intro first.
- 25:12[SPEAKER_00]: We know where the story starts at Mark and we were like, eh, because it doesn't start as a baby Jesus.
- 25:19[SPEAKER_01]: Right, right.
- 25:20[SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't have all of that.
- 25:21[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we jump right into the.
- 25:22[SPEAKER_01]: And so the adult Jesus story.
- 25:24[SPEAKER_00]: Where Matthew get that.
- 25:26[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 25:26[SPEAKER_00]: We don't know.
- 25:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 25:28[SPEAKER_00]: I guess he makes some shit up.
- 25:31[SPEAKER_00]: Most scholars regard Mark as the most reliable gospel, owing to its early provenance, and because of that papaya guy, papias, what's his name?
- 25:43[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 25:43[SPEAKER_01]: If I can interject for just a second.
- 25:47[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if you recall, but early in the gospel of Matthew, there was a lot of prophecy stuffing, like a lot of prophecy stuffing.
- 25:57[SPEAKER_01]: So my guess is that one of the biggest complaints that happened after Mark was Britain was that there wasn't enough of a tie between Jesus and prophecies.
- 26:06[SPEAKER_00]: right to legitimize their religion, their new religion.
- 26:12[SPEAKER_00]: They had to make a seem like a fulfillment of the old religion.
- 26:17[SPEAKER_01]: Now I don't know that 100% to be true.
- 26:19[SPEAKER_01]: It feels like that's what it is.
- 26:20[SPEAKER_00]: I'm pretty sure that you are on the right track with that.
- 26:24[SPEAKER_00]: That sounds pretty much what happens.
- 26:28[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 26:28[SPEAKER_00]: Because some shit gets added to Mark.
- 26:31[SPEAKER_01]: right.
- 26:32[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 26:32[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 26:33[SPEAKER_00]: But let's talk about the world at that time a little bit more.
- 26:36[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 26:36[SPEAKER_00]: So the gospels, all of them are classified as ancient biographies that were likely intended to strengthen the existing faith of a gentle audience in Rome, rather than to evangelize or to act as tracks for missionary conversion.
- 26:55[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 26:55[SPEAKER_00]: which is funny because at the end of Matthew, we get the whole, hey, let's, yes, do missionary conversion.
- 27:03[SPEAKER_01]: Ray, so there might have been some changing thoughts on that too.
- 27:06[SPEAKER_00]: Hold on to that thought.
- 27:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 27:08[SPEAKER_00]: Just hold real tight to that.
- 27:10[SPEAKER_00]: Wait, like just with your fist and your fingernails, just grab that thought real tight.
- 27:16[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 27:17[SPEAKER_00]: We are definitely coming back to that thought.
- 27:21[SPEAKER_00]: Christianity began with Judaism.
- 27:24[SPEAKER_00]: As we know, that's why we read the whole Old Testament, Hebrew Bible with a Christian quote-unquote assembly.
- 27:30[SPEAKER_00]: Like that's where we get the word church from.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 27:33[SPEAKER_00]: It comes from the word assembly.
- 27:36[SPEAKER_00]: Um, so.
- 27:38[SPEAKER_00]: Christianity began with Judaism and then there was a Christian assembly, meaning these groups of churches that arose shortly after Jesus' death, when some of his followers claim to have witnessed him risen from the dead.
- 27:53[SPEAKER_00]: And they're like, that's so magical of him.
- 27:55[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my God, that's great!
- 27:59[SPEAKER_00]: Christian's depended heavily, however, on Jewish literature, why?
- 28:04[SPEAKER_00]: Because they grew up in the Jewish faith.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_00]: And they knew all about y'all.
- 28:08[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, Jesus was a Jew.
- 28:09[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 28:09[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah.
- 28:10[SPEAKER_00]: So that supported their convictions through Jewish scriptures.
- 28:16[SPEAKER_00]: So it's so funny that like you said that because yeah, they needed, they needed Judaism to still be part of the story.
- 28:25[SPEAKER_01]: Obviously.
- 28:26[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 28:26[SPEAKER_01]: I mean,
- 28:28[SPEAKER_01]: That's their whole understanding of this figure of Jesus, right?
- 28:31[SPEAKER_01]: Like he is the next step in Judaism.
- 28:35[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 28:35[SPEAKER_01]: You have to tie it through.
- 28:37[SPEAKER_01]: Somehow you have to make it relevant.
- 28:38[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 28:39[SPEAKER_01]: And they...
- 28:41[SPEAKER_01]: they had to work at doing that.
- 28:42[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 28:43[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, especially for those crafts, because they would have known the Old Testaments so much better than this new religion thing.
- 28:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, exactly.
- 28:51[SPEAKER_00]: So those convictions that the people had, they involved a nucleus of key concepts like the Messiah.
- 29:00[SPEAKER_00]: They don't, they'd read about this and the Hebrew Bible that a Messiah is gonna come someday.
- 29:05[SPEAKER_00]: the son of God and the son of man.
- 29:06[SPEAKER_00]: Those were mentioned a few times in the Hebrew Bible, the suffering servant, the day of the Lord, the kingdom of God, they had heard all of these things.
- 29:15[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 29:15[SPEAKER_01]: And again, we can argue all day about how they sounded to us, which was not anything about something that was going to be happening hundreds of years later.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 29:24[SPEAKER_01]: But...
- 29:26[SPEAKER_01]: It's still in the moment when this is written, they're either getting ready to or at war with Rome.
- 29:33[SPEAKER_01]: And so the savior figure is a very sexy thing to add in.
- 29:38[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I mean, especially like, you know, the culmination of all this Jewish shit.
- 29:42[SPEAKER_01]: And now we're going to win with our, with our,
- 29:45[SPEAKER_00]: some of our questions were why we're so many people willing to just jump on board with this Jesus guy and the answer was that many of them believed that this Jesus guy was going to raise up against Rome and then they were disappointed when he didn't like that's where we get the whole John the Baptist story from like John the Baptist
- 30:11[SPEAKER_00]: Um, we were like, why are they pals?
- 30:13[SPEAKER_00]: What's going on there?
- 30:14[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 30:15[SPEAKER_00]: And everybody expected that either John the Baptist or Jesus was going to throw off the yoke of Rome over them.
- 30:23[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 30:23[SPEAKER_00]: And then they were so disappointed when that didn't happen.
- 30:26[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 30:27[SPEAKER_00]: So which is where you get your, you know, Judas maybe is why.
- 30:32[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 30:32[SPEAKER_00]: He betrayed them.
- 30:33[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
- 30:33[SPEAKER_00]: Let's see.
- 30:34[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 30:35[SPEAKER_00]: Um, these ideas were linked by apocalyptic expectations, so Jews and Christians alike.
- 30:42[SPEAKER_00]: And again, I'm using Christians as this descriptor shorthand for the non-Jewish people, the followers of Jesus.
- 30:53[SPEAKER_00]: So Jews and followers of Jesus alike believed that God would punish their enemies, establish his rule, and place them at the center of his plan.
- 31:02[SPEAKER_00]: And they still both believe that to this day.
- 31:04[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 31:05[SPEAKER_00]: To differing degrees and levels of importance.
- 31:10[SPEAKER_00]: Christians read the Jewish scripture as a figure or type of Jesus so that the goal of Christian literature became an experience of the living Christ.
- 31:23[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 31:23[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 31:24[SPEAKER_00]: So they read it as part of their history, but not as important, you know, right, because they don't have that like emotional tidal it.
- 31:34[SPEAKER_00]: So you can come to Jesus so fucking easily, but to come, you know, to Judaism, there's a lot of conversion stuff.
- 31:42[SPEAKER_00]: You got to take classes.
- 31:44[SPEAKER_00]: It's like a year's long.
- 31:45[SPEAKER_00]: You've got to be tested right it's all kinds of stuff.
- 31:49[SPEAKER_00]: You can't just like You don't just get to find Jesus and then you're done.
- 31:53[SPEAKER_01]: You know, Jesus says the hand wavy on you're good to go.
- 31:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah Yeah, it's it's very easy to get in to have and if you're a Christian Yeah, if you can figure out the fucking rule system and which church to attend or dodge Yeah, so this movement the
- 32:09[SPEAKER_00]: Jewish followers of Christ, whenever we're calling them.
- 32:12[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 32:13[SPEAKER_00]: Um, Christianity as it became spread around the Eastern Mediterranean and to Rome and then further west and it assumed the distinct identity that we know today as Christianity.
- 32:25[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 32:26[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 32:27[SPEAKER_00]: Alright.
- 32:27[SPEAKER_00]: Here's the most exciting part.
- 32:29[SPEAKER_00]: But into the material.
- 32:30[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:32[SPEAKER_00]: This ship blew my lid off, okay?
- 32:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 32:35[SPEAKER_00]: So the first half of Mark is overwhelmingly associated with Galilee and the surrounding regions.
- 32:42[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 32:42[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:43[SPEAKER_00]: Then Jesus begins moving toward Jerusalem.
- 32:46[SPEAKER_00]: And we're going to see the words suddenly pop up a lot.
- 32:50[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:50[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:51[SPEAKER_00]: Apparently Jesus does a lot of shit suddenly.
- 32:54[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:55[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:55[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 32:57[SPEAKER_00]: sudden sudden that's pace like the book moves you along.
- 33:01[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 33:01[SPEAKER_00]: It's the shortest book of the gospels.
- 33:04[SPEAKER_00]: There's only 16 chapters.
- 33:05[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 33:07[SPEAKER_00]: And it gets you there, right?
- 33:08[SPEAKER_00]: Especially by, you know, not talking about where he came from or where he got.
- 33:12[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 33:13[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, no.
- 33:14[SPEAKER_00]: Have I said too much?
- 33:15[SPEAKER_00]: And once he reaches Jerusalem, the narrative accelerates immediately or suddenly toward his death.
- 33:22[SPEAKER_01]: Well, yeah, it did that in Matthew too.
- 33:24[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 33:24[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 33:26[SPEAKER_00]: Mark starts with an adult Jesus.
- 33:28[SPEAKER_00]: As I said, it contains none of Jesus' childhood.
- 33:31[SPEAKER_00]: There's no genealogy like I don't know if you were called, but Matthew gave us this genealogy where he loved the number 14.
- 33:37[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 33:38[SPEAKER_00]: And in order to do that, he had to like fudge several numbers like he missed.
- 33:44[SPEAKER_00]: There's no virgin birth story, there's no immaculate conception, there's no like.
- 33:50[SPEAKER_01]: Well, again, that's what I was getting at with the prophecy stuff.
- 33:53[SPEAKER_00]: You know, there's no sermon on the Mount.
- 33:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, we just get straight to him.
- 33:59[SPEAKER_00]: Boom.
- 34:00[SPEAKER_00]: He, hi John the Baptist.
- 34:01[SPEAKER_00]: How you doing?
- 34:02[SPEAKER_00]: Drown me.
- 34:03[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 34:03[SPEAKER_00]: Cool.
- 34:04[SPEAKER_00]: Good friends now.
- 34:05[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 34:07[SPEAKER_00]: Jesus is baptism essentially launches the story in Mark.
- 34:10[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 34:11[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, this is so interesting.
- 34:14[SPEAKER_00]: The earliest and best Greek manuscripts of Mark and at chapter 16 verse eight.
- 34:21[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 34:22[SPEAKER_00]: So I don't know if you have ever looked at Mark.
- 34:25[SPEAKER_01]: I have not.
- 34:26[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so Mark has 20 verses in chapter 16.
- 34:32[SPEAKER_00]: 9 through 20 question mark.
- 34:34[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 34:34[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 34:35[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark 16, which ends with a resurrection announcement was the original ending.
- 34:41[SPEAKER_00]: He gets resurrected.
- 34:43[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 34:44[SPEAKER_00]: So Mark chapter 16.
- 34:47[SPEAKER_00]: So the last chapter of the book versus 9 through 20.
- 34:51[SPEAKER_00]: which is the ending most Christians are familiar with from modern bibles is generally regarded by textual scholars as a later addition and not part of the original text.
- 35:03[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so we get the two girls like walking up to the cave going, holy fuck this cave is empty.
- 35:10[SPEAKER_00]: Where do you go?
- 35:11[SPEAKER_00]: I guess he rules the end.
- 35:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 35:14[SPEAKER_00]: That's it.
- 35:15[SPEAKER_01]: I see.
- 35:16[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, nine through 20 verses apparently cover the and Jesus told them to tell his boys to meet him up the road and Gally like all those there's probably people like what we means how do we know he was resurrect what how do you what who
- 35:34[SPEAKER_01]: Who's going to try to kill girls basically said that he came about now we know girls are dying Thank you.
- 35:39[SPEAKER_00]: What kind of story is that bro when Matthew wrote it and when Luke wrote it They added in some ending stuff and so then Mark got edited to match them interesting right right.
- 35:49[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah
- 35:50[SPEAKER_00]: Um, so that whole ending, the extra bit is absent from the two oldest major Greek manuscripts of the time, and as well as several early Christian writers who appear never to have heard that story.
- 36:04[SPEAKER_01]: Wow.
- 36:05[SPEAKER_00]: And that is why I mentioned papias that the proprietary guy that's so fun.
- 36:12[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 36:12[SPEAKER_01]: I love that.
- 36:14[SPEAKER_00]: I have goosebumps even though I already read that when I was preparing for this episode, but I thought it was so important that we talk about it going into the book, knowing that it's possible.
- 36:26[SPEAKER_01]: You would really think though, if it was like the word of God, that it couldn't be altered.
- 36:31[SPEAKER_01]: Wouldn't you wouldn't need that?
- 36:32[SPEAKER_01]: Head of theulator.
- 36:33[SPEAKER_01]: You want to say that's just my theory.
- 36:35[SPEAKER_00]: Now, um, there's people who would argue, not all that's a lie that's Satan.
- 36:40[SPEAKER_00]: Sure, blah, blah, blah, but they, those are the same people that are like the King James version is the best.
- 36:46[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't want to hear it, you know, right, right.
- 36:49[SPEAKER_00]: But I just, I really felt like it's important that we know that going in so that when we get to chapter 16 verse 8, we can take a minute and say, this is actually where the book ended.
- 37:02[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 37:03[SPEAKER_00]: You know, this is actually where it ended before we carry on with the rest of that chapter.
- 37:07[SPEAKER_00]: That was the actual end.
- 37:09[SPEAKER_01]: That's interesting.
- 37:10[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 37:10[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 37:10[SPEAKER_00]: So I couldn't hold that back.
- 37:12[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 37:12[SPEAKER_00]: You can understand that.
- 37:13[SPEAKER_00]: You ever get right.
- 37:14[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 37:15[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
- 37:16[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, there are actually multiple endings to this.
- 37:20[SPEAKER_01]: whole gospel that choose your own adventure.
- 37:22[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, preserved in the manuscript tradition, including a shorter ending, and then there's the familiar longer ending that we're familiar with, but all of those came way later, huh, you know, including the one that we're going to read.
- 37:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, right way later.
- 37:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, just, you know, take on whatever ending, whatever.
- 37:38[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
- 37:38[SPEAKER_00]: What did, what did Matthew say, I said,
- 37:43[SPEAKER_00]: So there is a huge scholarly disagreement over whether Mark deliberately ended at chapter 16 verse eight, because it's very abrupt.
- 37:54[SPEAKER_00]: The girl just runs screaming from the cave, the end.
- 37:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 37:57[SPEAKER_00]: Or whether maybe the original ending was lost, you know, maybe he wasn't done writing and then his page got fucked up and the hurricane came in a lion and honey looked fix and I don't know.
- 38:09[SPEAKER_00]: or something else happened in transmission through time.
- 38:13[SPEAKER_01]: I believe in a double.
- 38:14[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
- 38:15[SPEAKER_01]: My fucker is always getting this.
- 38:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's the honey lip fixings for me.
- 38:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 38:18[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, yeah.
- 38:20[SPEAKER_00]: I still want a t-shirt that says, you got damn right.
- 38:23[SPEAKER_00]: I'm a honey lip fixings.
- 38:26[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, that just hits for me.
- 38:27[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 38:28[SPEAKER_00]: So the current scholarly preference, even though nobody can agree because nobody fucking knows, generally what we think happened is that 16-8 is the original ending period the end.
- 38:43[SPEAKER_00]: And we don't know why it was such an abrupt ending other than like maybe it didn't feel abrupt at the time.
- 38:49[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe he's just like, no, that's what happened.
- 38:51[SPEAKER_01]: I came back and I said, yeah, we're done.
- 38:53[SPEAKER_00]: The girl saw them decayed.
- 38:55[SPEAKER_00]: One more is there to say.
- 38:56[SPEAKER_01]: The thing happened.
- 38:57[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't know y'all didn't like women and couldn't trust their word.
- 39:01[SPEAKER_00]: Like, dude, what world are you in?
- 39:04[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 39:05[SPEAKER_00]: This is twenty twenty six and they still don't believe us.
- 39:09[SPEAKER_01]: But anyway, yeah, that was that's interesting.
- 39:12[SPEAKER_01]: It's incredible.
- 39:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I always love it when they have stuff that gets added on later.
- 39:19[SPEAKER_01]: And it's obvious to the scholars like, you know, we've we've set this mobile tied word not scholars were not academics, but
- 39:27[SPEAKER_01]: you know, we do read about what they say.
- 39:31[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 39:31[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's always fun for me to like hear how they're like, nah, that didn't get written at that time.
- 39:38[SPEAKER_01]: This is different because of X, Y, Z, and I'm just like, and I think it's because I have been told so many times throughout my life how the Bible is the word of God.
- 39:49[SPEAKER_00]: Just read it.
- 39:50[SPEAKER_00]: Just read it, and then you'll know.
- 39:52[SPEAKER_01]: No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no
- 40:05[SPEAKER_00]: It didn't, according to them, I think I just told you there was a big hug pile of lies.
- 40:10[SPEAKER_01]: But that's bullshit.
- 40:11[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 40:12[SPEAKER_01]: That's bullshit.
- 40:12[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sorry, but I will always trust historians and scientists which, you know, studying history and language is a form of science.
- 40:22[SPEAKER_01]: This is why we can never be Christians because we can't just accept the lie.
- 40:25[SPEAKER_00]: I cannot.
- 40:26[SPEAKER_00]: Well, okay.
- 40:27[SPEAKER_00]: I saw this really cool video where Neil deGrasse Tyson was doing an interview with a couple guys.
- 40:34[SPEAKER_00]: I can't remember their name, but they were talking about the anti-vax movement, right?
- 40:38[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 40:39[SPEAKER_00]: And the anti-science movement that has been adopted by the right.
- 40:44[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 40:44[SPEAKER_00]: And the guy, I can't remember his name that he was interviewing with said, here's the thing.
- 40:51[SPEAKER_00]: We scientists, we might get it wrong sometimes, but y'all always get it wrong, and that's the difference.
- 40:59[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 40:59[SPEAKER_00]: And I was like, a man brother.
- 41:01[SPEAKER_00]: Wait, that is it.
- 41:03[SPEAKER_01]: Science has methods to double check.
- 41:06[SPEAKER_00]: right because yeah they are sometimes wrong initially and they are wrong and they steal from each other sometimes and they hold each other back due to pride and arrogance and their own personal agendas and you know think about all the women and people of color who may discover these that were either held back or stolen by white guys like yes science ain't perfect I do it one pet peeve
- 41:33[SPEAKER_01]: they always harp on theories.
- 41:35[SPEAKER_01]: It's just a theory.
- 41:37[SPEAKER_01]: Well, my thought process in that moment is go back to fucking middle school.
- 41:43[SPEAKER_01]: You literally, you learned about this and fucking middle school.
- 41:46[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I learned about the scientific...
- 41:48[SPEAKER_00]: process, you know, where you have a hypothesis and then you, you know, make steps to test your, you make a theory and you have steps to to test it and questions and all of that.
- 42:03[SPEAKER_00]: Like I literally can remember that.
- 42:06[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, the scientific method.
- 42:07[SPEAKER_00]: I can specifically remember learning that in fifth grade life sciences.
- 42:11[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
- 42:12[SPEAKER_01]: And I said middle school because at least by then, you know.
- 42:15[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 42:16[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to say, I know where I learned it was specifically, but I have frames of reference because I didn't always go to the same school, so I can like picture where I was in the world at any given time.
- 42:28[SPEAKER_00]: And I can see the classroom where I've learned this.
- 42:32[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 42:32[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm like, no, that was fucking fifth grade.
- 42:35[SPEAKER_01]: No, the levels of stupidity just can always blow me away, right?
- 42:40[SPEAKER_00]: By seventh grade, y'all should have known that hypothesis and a theory is not what you think it is.
- 42:47[SPEAKER_01]: And really, it's not a huge wonder as to why the Bible has endured, right?
- 42:55[SPEAKER_01]: Because because acceptance of false information is rampant.
- 43:01[SPEAKER_01]: across our society.
- 43:02[SPEAKER_00]: Me and you both will bring each other's stuff and more like, no, dog, that ain't right.
- 43:06[SPEAKER_00]: Right, right.
- 43:07[SPEAKER_00]: And we check each other and we actually know.
- 43:11[SPEAKER_00]: So I can't even think of what it must be like to be so stupid and to be surrounded by people that don't check each other.
- 43:17[SPEAKER_01]: There's a saying in society called go along to get along.
- 43:20[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 43:21[SPEAKER_01]: And that's essentially what is.
- 43:23[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, push it up.
- 43:24[SPEAKER_00]: Push it up.
- 43:25[SPEAKER_00]: It's also the Dunning Kruger affair.
- 43:28[SPEAKER_01]: It's the same thing, essentially.
- 43:29[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 43:29[SPEAKER_00]: But yeah.
- 43:30[SPEAKER_00]: For those who don't know, the more that you don't know,
- 43:36[SPEAKER_00]: This actually smarter that you are because you're open to questioning, but the less that you know the more confident that you are that you're right, because you have so little fact to base it on yeah.
- 43:47[SPEAKER_00]: So generally, if somebody is an arrogant motherfucker, they're probably wrong.
- 43:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 43:52[SPEAKER_00]: Whereas if they're like asking questions and they're self deprecating and they have a really solid sense of humor and they don't mind laughing at themselves and curiosity and empathy like all that goes hand in hand.
- 44:04[SPEAKER_00]: I would say, even if they're wrong, they're still trustworthy because they'll get it right or they're sure fucking trying to get it right, which is why I feel for Dr. Fauci.
- 44:18[SPEAKER_01]: That is pretty terrible.
- 44:19[SPEAKER_01]: It's going on there.
- 44:21[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know all the ins and outs, but I mean, I cannot stand what's happening to that 80 some of your, he's like a 85 year old man.
- 44:29[SPEAKER_00]: He should be retired on a beach right now.
- 44:31[SPEAKER_00]: Just enjoying his life having work hard and done so much to try to eradicate disease and educate the population.
- 44:43[SPEAKER_00]: And instead he's being questioned because he's
- 44:46[SPEAKER_00]: He didn't always have the right science and because we had a president and they wanted a fucking put light and bleach inside our bodies.
- 44:52[SPEAKER_00]: Jesus Christ, I'll never forget the look that he made.
- 44:55[SPEAKER_00]: Do you remember when Trump was fucking on stage?
- 44:59[SPEAKER_00]: Trump said, put, what did we put bleach and then Dr. Fauci was trying so hard to keep a straight face and his hand flew up to his forehead like, oh, Jesus helped me get me off the stage right now.
- 45:11[SPEAKER_00]: Like, what was he supposed to say in that moment?
- 45:15[SPEAKER_00]: Please don't say, please don't urge people to put bleach in their body.
- 45:19[SPEAKER_01]: Great, great.
- 45:20[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, fucking on science, and that is why.
- 45:24[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 45:24[SPEAKER_00]: So there's a higher measles outbreak now than we've seen since measles was first on the fucking scene.
- 45:30[SPEAKER_00]: What the fuck even?
- 45:32[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
- 45:33[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, sorry, go on.
- 45:34[SPEAKER_01]: On that note.
- 45:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 45:37[SPEAKER_01]: That's all we got from Mark today.
- 45:38[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 45:39[SPEAKER_01]: Sorry if we're going off about just, you know, everything.
- 45:43[SPEAKER_00]: I mean,
- 45:45[SPEAKER_00]: the Bible, everything about the Bible that I read is just like, and this is why, and this is why.
- 45:50[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 45:50[SPEAKER_00]: And it just serves, it does not give me peace, it just serves to piss me off.
- 45:52[SPEAKER_00]: The end.
- 45:52[SPEAKER_00]: All right, thank you all for joining us, and join us next time for Mark.
- 45:55[SPEAKER_01]: Chapter one, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Mark, Marky Marky Mark, Marky Marky Mark, Marky Marky Mark, Marky Marky Marky Marky Mark
- 46:09[SPEAKER_00]: Such a good vibration.
- 46:11[SPEAKER_00]: Come on.
- 46:12[SPEAKER_00]: Come on.
- 46:12[SPEAKER_00]: Come on.
- 46:13[SPEAKER_01]: We'll see you then guys