Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 143 - Max Hillebrand: The Praxeology of Privacy
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:19hello and welcome to this episode number 143 of the free cities podcast brought to you by of course
- 0:37veritas villages veritas villages are off-grid energy self-sufficient luxury communities in
- 0:44latin america designed for freedom lovers just like yourself bitcoin is accepted at all villages
- 0:51and that includes purchasing property there as well more info at www.ecovillages.life
- 1:01forward slash free cities also in the show notes they've got four big projects on the go
- 1:07at the moment to in panama veritas village coronado and veritas village chirokee chirokee
- 1:14is the new one launched near vulcan and boquette solar powered communities with riverfront home
- 1:22sites beautiful place that nicaragua their place is playa pacifica that's a beachfront village and
- 1:29hot off the presses brand new land acquired in Atenas Costa Rica. Atenas is known for having one
- 1:38of the best climates in the world. Right ecovillages.life forward slash free cities for more info
- 1:47please mention us when you do business with them if you choose to and just to let you know I did
- 1:53an interview with Patrick, their CEO, about three weeks ago, and it's on their channel.
- 1:59Now you can hear all about my trials and tribulations in the wonderful country of the
- 2:05United Kingdom and all the shenanigans going on there. See the show notes for more on that. Right,
- 2:10deep breath. Before I tell you about today's show, I'm going to talk to you about the absolute
- 2:18nightmare of a last few days that I've had tech wise. It will also help explain why there is
- 2:26currently no video with this episode. Basically, I've been in Riga for the last week and a bit
- 2:33recording interviews. And I have to say, I think it's been my favorite trip of all time
- 2:41for content on this pod so look out for those i've got nine phenomenal interviews
- 2:47coming up over the next nine weeks however right at the end of the trip
- 2:53just before i left my most important podcast hard drive in history had an absolutely catastrophic
- 3:04failure quite randomly it appears one of those photons just hitting something and doing something
- 3:11anyway there's nothing obvious that triggered it now whilst there was actually none of my
- 3:17unpublished episodes on there so all the content I recorded in Riga was absolutely safe fortunately
- 3:23I put that on a different drive and I back it all up no that was every single other piece of content
- 3:30that I have created for this podcast and stupidly I suppose it wasn't backed up mainly I think my
- 3:38thought process was I've published it so I don't need to think too much about it but actually
- 3:43what I've realized is there are lots of files that I need on that drive to produce this podcast
- 3:51not least all the video and audio templates and all the assets that go into those templates anyway
- 3:59what this means in reality is that I need to record a lot of stuff again from scratch if I
- 4:08can't retrieve it from the broken drive. That was a couple of days ago and with the help of
- 4:13ChatGPT I've been trying to recover the data. However this is a five terabyte drive filled up
- 4:22to 4.65 terabytes and as you can imagine that's a lot of data crunching. A single process takes
- 4:29about 20 hours and I have to do quite a few of them to try and recover the data. Anyway
- 4:34what it means is i will only be putting out an audio episode right now the video one will be
- 4:42coming in due course please accept my apologies i'll have to wait until either i get the data back
- 4:50which is going to be at least another two to three days or i can recreate all the templates and i will
- 4:55decide to do that if i realize i can't get the data back anyway just to let you know i'm on it
- 5:02I'm trying to fix it, but it takes a hell of a long time to probe a five terabyte corrupted drive.
- 5:09And I'm doing my best.
- 5:10Right. Today's guest.
- 5:12It's a good one.
- 5:13It's a really good one.
- 5:14In fact, he's a returning guest and he's a bit of a legend in the Bitcoin and privacy tech world.
- 5:21Max Hillebrand brings cypherpunk and praxeological principles to his work.
- 5:28And I, for one, am definitely here for it.
- 5:32My new best friend ChatGPT.
- 5:35Yes, I had to get a paid subscription because I'm doing so much coding.
- 5:39I'm getting it to write all the scripts for delving into my drive.
- 5:43It's analysed the episode this week.
- 5:46Max joins me to explore freedom, privacy and property in the modern world.
- 5:51As we enter the broader battleground of ideas, we discuss concepts like mean time to harassment
- 5:58as a measure of personal freedom, the cypherpunk strategy of raising the cost of attack
- 6:04and the appeal of Bitcoin, free cities and digital nomadism as ways to resist creeping
- 6:11socialism and surveillance. Drawing on Lockean ownership theory, Austrian economics and his new
- 6:19book, Max makes the case for combining decentralisation, community and technology
- 6:24to defend liberty in both physical and digital realms correct that's choc gpt's summary my summary
- 6:31mind blown again uh last time i spoke to max it was a four and a half hour epic and i i was come
- 6:38away from conversations with him needing a lie down if you know what i mean um and i really like
- 6:44pushing myself and you'll probably hear my brain grind to a halt a couple of times during this
- 6:49episode as i sort of reach the edge of what's conceivable for me that is anyway many thanks
- 6:56max always a pleasure mate my philosophical journey continues right more thanks before we go
- 7:03into it thanks to antcb christopher albanese bullish my cousin vinnie dovidas matthias to name
- 7:12but a few for actually choosing to send your hard-earned bitcoin to this podcast's strategic
- 7:20bitcoin reserve in the form of your monthly subscription to the show uh the bonus episode
- 7:27should have been coming this week but i didn't anticipate all the problems i was having
- 7:32with the hard drive so sorry about that i'll try and get it in next week the new bonus episode
- 7:37with gg another bitcoin og uh if you find value here and you're not one of those people just
- 7:44mentioned please consider doing this yourself hit the subscribe button on the fountain app
- 7:51and you'll gain early access to long interviews the bonus episodes i just spoke about
- 7:55and obviously the warm fuzzy feeling that you're helping out this phenomenal podcast
- 8:01disseminating ideas of freedom and liberty right many thanks to you all time to have your mind
- 8:09altered come on up to my studio in Riga grab a coffee in a chair adopt a relaxed position why
- 8:19you could even sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with Max Hillebrand
- 8:31looking forward to this yeah what is it my my second appearance i think on the show it is
- 8:44first one was epic yeah blew my mind there was another conference where we're sitting in your
- 8:49very small hotel room you did upgrade it's bigger now we were that that was the that was the free
- 8:54podcast when it was just starting out we were literally in prague in a weird little hotel
- 9:00down the side of the bed weren't we how far we've come i'm glad you remember that because wonderful
- 9:06it's um it's quite exciting actually i really enjoy this job uh it's kind of making money
- 9:13kind of you know it like um it not exactly can you maybe just bring that across a bit like Being a podcast is the most ridiculous job right Because you have the best excuse to talk to people Yeah That all it is
- 9:27It's talking around the fire.
- 9:29It is.
- 9:30It's like the same thing.
- 9:31Like if Neanderthal men realized they could make a living sitting around the fire talking,
- 9:36they'd be much happier.
- 9:37I think they wouldn't always have that sullen look on their face whenever you see them.
- 9:40But, um, no, it is, um, I honestly believe mate, um, that the, the kind of battleground
- 9:49of ideas is it's the new, the new place to be.
- 9:55I mean, really, when you think about it, if you think about all the places that you could
- 9:59operate in the physical world, the digital world, the, this, the realm of ideas in this
- 10:06day and age is, is, is where to be.
- 10:08And you're fighting, putting in your own ideas and hoping that they catch on.
- 10:15Yeah. Mises was already saying this many years ago, right?
- 10:18That this battle for freedom has to be fought with ideas.
- 10:22That's why he was a prolific writer and author and lecturer, right?
- 10:26So we're just standing on those shoulders of giants.
- 10:28I haven't done this yet. We've started, but I'm better just do one of those.
- 10:33the reason why i'm so dis uh disheveled is because i've just had the most infuriating
- 10:41um interaction with the with the with normie world in the form of that's traumatic my
- 10:49it was it's not traumatic it's just like most things it's like end of the end of it soviet era
- 10:56bullshit yeah you know and it basically involves me getting it starts with me getting the most
- 11:03expensive vodafone plan i can because i don't want any bullshit right so just leave me alone
- 11:11take my money it literally says unlimited everywhere unlimited unlimited unlimited unlimited
- 11:16limited of course unlimited doesn't mean unlimited unlimited data means in when i'm in latvia means
- 11:2525 gigabytes which disappeared after two days i'm a bloody i'm a bloke you know like and i run my
- 11:32business on the internet so um and i'm like so it's called fair use it's obviously not fair use
- 11:40i'm not an unfair person i'm very fair i'm a very fair person so my unlimited so me trying to keep
- 11:48bullshit at bay doesn't work bullshit is there i said is anyone on vodafone getting unlimited i've
- 11:55just been on the phone to them first thing is first of all first thing is i get a text saying
- 11:59you've just run out of data i'm like well on unlimited i've run out of data um and in the
- 12:05text it said if you want to increase your limit go to this web address so i pressed it and it's like
- 12:11i've got no data i can't go to the web address
- 12:14it literally directs you to a web address obviously they're expecting you to have wi-fi
- 12:21i don't have wi-fi here funnily enough i don't know why this is the first airbnb i've ever
- 12:26got that didn't have wi-fi so now i'm like pressing the button it's not going to the page
- 12:32oh my god anyway a good future uh tech for this is called tollgate it is a a wi-fi router
- 12:41whom you can pay in Bitcoin to get online.
- 12:44But the thing is, you're offline, right?
- 12:46So how are you going to pay with Bitcoin for the internet
- 12:48when you're not even on the internet yet?
- 12:49Correct.
- 12:50And so the answer is eCash.
- 12:52CashU specifically.
- 12:53You can make CashU payments as a sender while being offline.
- 12:56And the receiver is a router, so he is online.
- 12:59So you just paste some eCash and you get internet.
- 13:02Well, there's a topic of conversation.
- 13:03Because I use CashU.
- 13:04I use the Minibits wallet for small payments, right?
- 13:07so and i know i don't care to know exactly what i'm doing i just know that everyone thinks it's
- 13:14really good and people i trust say use that use cashew but anyway can we come back to that i've
- 13:18got to get to the end of my story because basically i had this wonderful morning planned my wife
- 13:24arrived in riga last night so woke up this morning let's go out for a coffee i've got plenty of time
- 13:30on my hands i i've got a bit of research to do i'm interviewing max sort of one so it'd be great
- 13:36you know and then basically the whole thing starts crumbling beside me i got no internet i can't
- 13:42research you i can't even talk to you i sent you that text saying saying and you the last i heard
- 13:48of you was i'm on my way and basically people don't realize where i'm recording is in a big
- 13:54commie block you can't just arrive see the doorman say send him up you know it's like
- 14:00you have to go in through the kitchens to get to get up here you know and you're on your way and
- 14:05i'm like oh no and i've got no data i can't get your messages blah blah blah and so i've basically
- 14:11done no research at all not that we need to do research but i did want i did want to i want to
- 14:17know what you've been up to because we haven't spoken for quite a long time i'm not sure i sure
- 14:21i've seen you since prague probably over a year ago or something that's been a while but but um
- 14:26But I now am back online.
- 14:28Cut a long story short.
- 14:31I've actually, I'm so vindictive, mate.
- 14:35I have told Vodafone I'm leaving.
- 14:38And they've sent me one of those codes to go to port me to another.
- 14:42I just went there.
- 14:43I just went, right, dude, I'm out.
- 14:44This is absolute bullshit.
- 14:46How do I cancel my contract?
- 14:49And, you know, like sometimes when you get that irate, they say, oh, here's some data.
- 14:53Here's a...
- 14:53You get your fix.
- 14:55basically they're gonna lose i don't know i've been with vodafone like what 20 years
- 14:59what have i been spending 60 a month 50 a month you know that's like five six hundred a year that's
- 15:05a lot of that's a lot that's a lot of money yeah back then that's a lot of money right
- 15:09and going forward i had no plans on changing from vodafone that's another 10 grand
- 15:14so they're basically for the sake of what does 25 gigs of data cost them
- 15:19the marginal cost is really small right you have the upkeep of the whole infrastructure that's
- 15:24ballistically expensive yeah but once it's there sending a couple bits it's fine right and they are
- 15:29prepared because i said can i have some data please you know i'm i've been with you 20 years
- 15:35you've told me it's unlimited but it's not and now you're telling me this is fair use which
- 15:40like i'm one of the fairest people i know i'm like mr scales i want the scales to to really be fair
- 15:46so it's obviously not fair use and you've kind of sold it to me with you know and they just went
- 15:53computer says no and i said right i'm out dude so they've now sent me one of those codes to port me
- 15:58to another network so now i've got to find another network i'm not going to do it today but i think
- 16:02i'm going to do it i'm like no f you like i why are you doing business like that yeah why are you
- 16:09treating your customers like that and the answer is because the guy i was talking to on the phone
- 16:14it's not his problem he he was computer said no the other guy was computer said no and all this
- 16:19stuff is like this is end of an era stuff like i heard the same story that we've been doing the
- 16:26rounds at this conference about this guy who ordered some knives off amazon and they arrived
- 16:32at the door and the guy said um you need to prove how old you are you know and this is some old dude
- 16:37at the door saying here i am like you know do i look under 18 no no i need you i need i need some
- 16:45id and he's like what do you mean he said no i need to take a photo of your id and and he's like
- 16:49he's a kind of privacy person.
- 16:51He's like, no, just give me the stuff.
- 16:54And in the end, they sent it away.
- 16:56And this is like the kind of shit you see
- 16:59in the Soviet era,
- 17:02you know, like these itty bitty little laws
- 17:04that get more and more tedious
- 17:06and more tedious and more tedious
- 17:08until they're literally dictating
- 17:10how long your fingernails can be
- 17:12and all that stuff.
- 17:13Yeah.
- 17:14Rothbard would call it a triangular intervention.
- 17:17And so this means that the state intervenes
- 17:19how two, three people get to do their business.
- 17:22You're not allowed to buy the knife from this merchant
- 17:25and get it delivered.
- 17:26That's a ridiculous notion.
- 17:27That sounds like terrorism to us.
- 17:29We would like to see some ID to protect the children.
- 17:33This is unfortunate.
- 17:35And there's this intervention cascade.
- 17:39Mies has also spoke about this greatly in his book,
- 17:41Socialism.
- 17:42As soon as you start with one set of interventions,
- 17:44let's say price control for socialism
- 17:46or these types of things,
- 17:49then the market fails or like it stops being nice.
- 17:55And so it gets worse.
- 17:56And then the state, of course, is, well, let's try some more intervention.
- 17:59Maybe that will fix it.
- 18:00And that just makes it worse.
- 18:02And the only answer is more intervention and so on.
- 18:04And that leads to nowhere.
- 18:07And in the end, it almost certainly collapses.
- 18:11Yeah.
- 18:11Because everyone is falling foul of the rules.
- 18:15So everyone's committing crimes constantly.
- 18:17A felony a day.
- 18:19Yeah. And I'll be honest, you know, I've always been aware that I break the law, obviously, in little bits and bobs and ways and this and that. But, you know, like take our online safety bill that's just come. That's one step away from VPNs being banned, which is being talked about.
- 18:38Now banning a VPN is going to make me a bonafide criminal because I been using a vpn for a long time purely for simple reasons like yeah i don really like to know what i don think my isp has any interest
- 18:52knowing what i'm doing and i don't want them to sort of sell that data use that data release that
- 18:58data reveal that data yeah nothing wrong with that simple privacy even but even the the kind of
- 19:04I don't trust you guys to look after my bank details or my this or my that.
- 19:09And so when that happens, which they're talking about it now,
- 19:13you know, when they start talking about stuff, it's not that far.
- 19:15It's already done.
- 19:16Yeah, yeah.
- 19:18And, you know, where else have you seen VPNs banned?
- 19:23What?
- 19:23North Korea.
- 19:25Where else is VPNs banned?
- 19:26Probably China in a roundabout way.
- 19:29They're probably not.
- 19:30You probably get penalized, you know.
- 19:33You get penalized everywhere.
- 19:34like you know these captcha portals yes they're way more prevalent when you use a vpn right they
- 19:40know that you're using a vpn or tor and then every business every like website is making your life
- 19:46just a little bit more difficult because there's a risk behind it right yeah well yeah but the risk
- 19:51is for them to get to get into trouble exactly it's nothing they're not they're not thinking oh
- 19:57you know this this is very risky some you know they're literally worried that the rule says you
- 20:02can't do that or the rule says you need to identify who's on your website and send it to us and if you
- 20:08don't you're in trouble and that's basically how they enforce it in the beginning i think probably
- 20:13in the later stages they start enforcing it on you do you know what i mean that's when you know
- 20:18it's getting serious but i'm not even sure and this is amazing look a bit of plastic literally
- 20:24just came off my water bottle this is this is like this is a criminal offensive how did these
- 20:29get through the net look they haven't even got that i suppose it is still attached but
- 20:33oh my god you know anyway when they start coming directly for you and i think it's almost like
- 20:41in the old world you could do that you could be an authoritarian and you could steam in with guns
- 20:46point them at people and say do what we say and then in the more in the more contemporary kind of
- 20:51western world it's like people would would think that was bad so they just say right everyone that
- 20:56you do business with everyone you deal with everyone you have to they have to police you
- 21:01and now it's like oh i'm dealing with a friendly face i'm not dealing with the state the you know
- 21:06it's it's i don't know it's it's getting serious don't you think it is getting serious it has been
- 21:12getting serious for for many years and the trend is definitely in the wrong direction right like
- 21:16it got worse over the last 10 years a lot right and and so unfortunately it will continue to get
- 21:21worse the real question is when does this socialist system fall apart and i do hope that it does fall
- 21:28apart like the soviet union more with a whimper than with a bang right but war and and a lot more
- 21:34destruction is definitely on the menu do you know what though um i it's taken me a long time as a
- 21:41as someone i would think of as quite free thinking quite inquisitive quite it's taken me quite a long
- 21:47time to comprehend that this is a sort of socialist system a communist system it's bizarre because
- 21:53and and you know voting and and and democracy and all these things are kind of communistic in their
- 22:03nature yeah i know but that's a i i don't think um 99 of people are anywhere near and not
- 22:11acknowledging that yeah yeah no but i mean read through the communist manifesto by karl marx right
- 22:17and there's a little list of bullet points with what what what should be there in a communist
- 22:21society right and we have like centralization of education right so in in germany for example if
- 22:27you want to homeschool your kids the police show up like literally this happened to many of my
- 22:31friends that kids got dragged by the police into the school building right so it's that's a thing
- 22:37then we have of course that like the the the central bank let me name me a country that does
- 22:43not have a central bank right now and so that those those two aspects already if you have
- 22:48the power of propaganda and the power to print money then all of the other thing kind of is
- 22:54becomes very easy because the people just kind of do what you want them because you taught them
- 22:59literally and you have unlimited budgets because you can print it and trick everyone into using
- 23:04that fiat currency, that together is extremely powerful.
- 23:08So we're deep down the socialist rabbit hole.
- 23:11We're very far away from a free market.
- 23:13But people would never think that.
- 23:18No, people would never think that.
- 23:20I didn't think that for a very, very long time.
- 23:24You look at communist empires and you think, ah, there's communism.
- 23:30That's communism.
- 23:31But I suppose the sort of owning the means of production and no private property stuff and that.
- 23:37Although you will own nothing and be happy.
- 23:39Yeah.
- 23:40And you know, there's a real actionable metric of success of freedom.
- 23:45It was defined by Rayo, an anonymous author from the 70s.
- 23:48And he was saying, what's your mean time to harassment?
- 23:52And in other words, when was the last time you were stolen from?
- 23:55When was the last time someone physically assaulted you?
- 23:58When was the last time you had to ask for permission to use your stuff?
- 24:01right and all of a sudden you realize wait a second i just had to ask for permission from
- 24:06vodafone to get my internet back right that that didn't happen so long ago it was their internet i
- 24:12suppose yeah theoretically but i know what you mean yeah or like you you know you pay taxes on
- 24:16that internet bill right you pay taxes on the bubble gun if you want to drive your car you need
- 24:21to have to drive a license if you want to start a business you need to ask for permission to have
- 24:24that business license the meantime to harassment if we analyze the the intervention of the state
- 24:30is within hours or days, right?
- 24:33Not weeks or months.
- 24:35So we really are in a situation
- 24:37where the amount of theft is so pervasive
- 24:40that we don't even realize anymore.
- 24:43We're like the fish in water
- 24:44and completely unaware of the extent of the tyranny
- 24:51that we're suffering through.
- 24:53But once you step out of it,
- 24:55specifically, for example, Bitcoin is the perfect example.
- 24:57Once you opt out of the theft of the fiat system, now all of a sudden you realize, wow, this is not just a little bit better, that's like so much better.
- 25:07And we all adjust our life completely around this new phenomenon that we've experienced and move on in a much freer way.
- 25:14And then are baffled of how long could we have used this fiat money without even asking it, without questioning it.
- 25:19It's interesting coming to Latvia now and obviously being around.
- 25:24Honey Badge is the real cypherpunk kind of gathering.
- 25:27mainstream anyway, cypherpunks.
- 25:31But for me, it's the one place where I do tend to mix more
- 25:35with those people who really do live the principles.
- 25:39And I've got a lot of respect for people whose mindset is
- 25:42what's legitimate and what's illegitimate.
- 25:46Like, you know, someone telling me what to do.
- 25:50This is some guy wearing a police outfit.
- 25:54And being able to stand in front of that person
- 25:56and consider them illegitimate.
- 26:00It's quite a power and it takes quite a lot of power
- 26:04and a lot of knowledge and a lot of understanding
- 26:07that you can just do stuff.
- 26:09You know, this meme that's going around,
- 26:10you can just do stuff.
- 26:11You can just not listen to that thing, you know.
- 26:15And this is the place where, you know,
- 26:17in my yearly calendar, if I get to come here,
- 26:19where I actually get to mix with those kind of people.
- 26:21And it's a real skill.
- 26:23It's something that I forget so easily
- 26:25and lose myself in my head and before I know it,
- 26:27I'm looking for permission or looking for, you know,
- 26:30am I legitimate?
- 26:33You know, we've moved to a new area, right?
- 26:35We need to register here to get a doctor
- 26:38or we need to do this or do that.
- 26:40And then you need to sit back and relax and go,
- 26:43actually, no, I don't.
- 26:44No, I don't.
- 26:45I'm a, it's something going on outside.
- 26:48I'm a human being walking the earth
- 26:51or something along those lines, you know.
- 26:53So I'm, or even worse, I'm a spirit just here.
- 26:58And, you know, it's a funny old matrix that's imprisoned us.
- 27:05Do you know what I mean?
- 27:06Yeah, absolutely.
- 27:07Right.
- 27:07It's propaganda.
- 27:09Propaganda is extremely powerful.
- 27:11It was powerful 100 years ago.
- 27:12It got exponentially better.
- 27:15So to this mind control of making sure people don't ask the right question and that people don't go against the mainstream.
- 27:21it's literally been
- 27:24like carefully designed and implemented
- 27:26starting basically from birth
- 27:28especially from kindergarten or school
- 27:31and that's really really difficult to get rid of
- 27:34and it actually takes like a de-culting
- 27:38we need to de-brainwash people
- 27:41and that's why ideas are so powerful right
- 27:43and you're part of the counter propaganda machine
- 27:46to instill a new form of way of thought
- 27:50in the minds of people
- 27:51I had a conversation in America about six or eight months ago and it was put very well that if you survive school and you a freedom lover you done incredibly well Because school teaches you authoritarianism It literally teaches you the relationship between you and the person in charge
- 28:14This is all based on outcome-based education
- 28:17that was first introduced in Prussia, specifically Bismarck.
- 28:23And he wanted to have obedient soldiers.
- 28:26Prussia was a military regime, let's say.
- 28:30So they needed to have frontline soldiers that walk into death without flinching, without questioning.
- 28:37If you get the order, you move forward.
- 28:39And if you die, that's all right, because the body of the army has survived.
- 28:44That's scary shit.
- 28:46And that's literally, literally what that system is built upon with the intent of creating soldiers.
- 28:51Now, back then it was for military school.
- 28:54Now it's for everyone.
- 28:56Here's the teacher.
- 28:57He's the authority.
- 28:58He stands in front of you.
- 28:59He knows what is correct, right?
- 29:01He will tell it to you and you shall repeat it until you repeat it correctly.
- 29:05And if you don't, then you get punished.
- 29:07First, you got hit on the fingers, right?
- 29:09And now you have to leave the room and go for detention or whatnot.
- 29:13But ultimately, you do as you are told to.
- 29:16And that's just not an encouraging mindset to explore and to be creative and to be who you actually want to be.
- 29:24Do you, I mean, when you think about the way it's implemented now, it seems like there's a lot of useful, and this is a horrible way to describe it, but it's kind of true, useful idiots that implement this stuff.
- 29:39um are you are you someone that believes in a grander plan or is this just a natural incentive
- 29:47of power to sort of secure itself look for more power look for more obedience or the or is it
- 29:54is it something more conscious than that do people sit around thinking i want to control someone else
- 30:00that's what i kind of mean i suppose i think it's a bit of both like there there are thieves out
- 30:06there right no question they they want to get more money more capital from others without actually
- 30:12getting their permission they always have been there they always will be there right the question
- 30:16is how what what are the systems we we utilize and do they incentivize and make this theft
- 30:24profitable because thieves are entrepreneurs too right there's a proxiology to violence
- 30:29meaning that if you have to spend 10 bitcoin on an attack on equipment on time on fuel etc
- 30:37and at the end of the day you earn one bitcoin in by stealing from your victim then you just lost
- 30:43nine bitcoin you're no longer profitable and that that means you have less capital than before
- 30:47right and maybe you have so much less that you cannot afford to do the next run
- 30:51and and so thieves need to be profitable and and then obviously thieves are incentivized to decrease
- 30:58their cost and to increase their revenue. And that will naturally lead to some structure where
- 31:05they make sure that this is more towards their favor. And so they become in charge of, for example,
- 31:12the school system and then dictate that, no, you should actually hand over your money to the thief
- 31:18without questioning, without resisting, because that's the right thing to do. That's what we do
- 31:23in a civilized society, etc.
- 31:25And all of a sudden,
- 31:26you've decreased the amount of resistance,
- 31:29you've decreased the cost of attack,
- 31:31and therefore you become more profitable.
- 31:33And that gets iterated like on a free market, right?
- 31:37There's not just one gang of thieves.
- 31:39There's countless thieves
- 31:40who are more or less interoperating
- 31:43and coordinating with each other.
- 31:45But ultimately, there's a massive demand for this,
- 31:49and so people figure out solutions to it.
- 31:51The real trick then and how we make the stop and that's the cypherpunk insight is to increase the cost of attack and to decrease the cost of defense because then we have an economic solution to theft and to slavery.
- 32:05That's literally what ended slavery in America. It was more profitable to work with free people than it was to enslave them. You simply made more money by not stealing from them because they were more incentivized to actually do the work etc.
- 32:21So the slavery in America did not fall because some politician said, oh, no, no, we don't do that anymore. It fell because entrepreneurs on the market realized that there is more profit opportunity in collaborative, voluntary interaction than there is with slavery.
- 32:37And the exact same thing is happening now with the added bonus that we have builders of technologies, of tools, who have now optimized for this metric specifically.
- 32:47How do we make theft more expensive?
- 32:49How do we make using defensive force cheaper?
- 32:52And that's ultimately cryptography is the prime example of what we've achieved here, of making theft so expensive that it becomes completely uneconomical.
- 33:00And so, and you could, and as I mean, modern day slaves tend to be people that just work under the, under an inflationary system, I suppose.
- 33:11That's kind of, that's, that's the modern definition of a slave, right?
- 33:14Yeah.
- 33:15And it's, it's not only the inflation, right?
- 33:18I mean, Germany, for example, right?
- 33:20Many other European countries are the same.
- 33:22There's a 50% income tax, right?
- 33:24Then you have a 20 or 19% value added tax.
- 33:28whatever value was added here is a bit out of scope, but we're already at 70%, right?
- 33:33Is that what it is in Germany?
- 33:35Yeah. And then when you buy diesel, there's like a 300% tax on that because we're saving the planet,
- 33:40right? If you would buy some tobacco, that's not good for you. So we actually have to punish you
- 33:44with another 250% tax rate, right? So we're getting above 90% easily, easily, just by direct
- 33:52taxation of goods.
- 33:54You think that in Germany
- 33:5690% of your income is
- 33:58being taken from you? Absolutely.
- 34:0090? Before inflation.
- 34:02How can it be 90, mate? How do you live?
- 34:05That's the thing.
- 34:07You actually don't.
- 34:11But I mean, I've heard
- 34:1270, I think, when you add it all up
- 34:15and 90 just seems like...
- 34:17How do you get like
- 34:18one month of the year of your own money?
- 34:21Yeah.
- 34:22I just have to believe you, I suppose.
- 34:24God, that seems crazy.
- 34:26Yeah, no, it really is crazy if you think about it like this.
- 34:30And then we haven't even talked about the regulatory cost of everything, right?
- 34:34If you want to start a bakery, you need like 50 hours, 500 hours of lawyers to get all the licensing that you need to have the permission properly.
- 34:44You need to invest in all types of weird building constructions that might not actually be necessary for you to provide a good service.
- 34:50but they are required in order for you to do it.
- 34:53And so if we add up all of this cost,
- 34:56it's baffling.
- 34:57It's baffling.
- 34:58Like it's more balls and shackles slavery
- 35:01than it used to be
- 35:02just by the percentage of what of your work
- 35:06has to be given away.
- 35:07So, okay, let's,
- 35:08I need to get this straight in my mind
- 35:10because I've never thought about this before.
- 35:12So take your example of the original abolition of slavery
- 35:16and what made the cost of attack more.
- 35:22And then tell me how the modern-day version of slavery gets solved.
- 35:27So ultimately, if you enslave someone, you need to police him.
- 35:34Because if he doesn't do what you want him to do,
- 35:36you need to make him change his opinion and change his actions.
- 35:40So ultimately, for every, I don't know, 10 slaves that work on the field,
- 35:45you need like what two guys with guns to make sure they don't run away to make sure they're
- 35:51not lazy right to make sure that they actually do stuff um and and do it adequately not not just
- 35:56lazily and then half-assing it and so you have costs of of two guys in order to enforce these
- 36:0210 guys for for doing stuff right and and these two like protectors they or or guards let's say
- 36:09they need to get paid as well right and and um funnily the kind of it's often recounted as the
- 36:17worst kind of slaves were the house slaves right the slaves who could live in the house of the lord
- 36:22um and who in exchange did their bidding right they these were the slaves who who kicked down
- 36:28all the other slaves and made sure that they did not revolt they and they were politicians
- 36:33Kind of.
- 36:36So these slaves were the most vicious,
- 36:40according to some accounts,
- 36:41because they could have a leg up on the others.
- 36:45They still weren't free,
- 36:46and they would ensure that the others aren't free either.
- 36:50So that's quite sad.
- 36:51And we see, of course, a lot of that happening
- 36:53with politicians, with military personnel,
- 36:57with police, etc.
- 36:58They have quite a good time of telling others
- 37:02that no, you cannot meet two people in a park bench.
- 37:05We have a virus going on.
- 37:06You're supposed to be at home.
- 37:08And this type of intervention is costly.
- 37:12Plus, you have the unseen,
- 37:15the opportunity of what would have a group of free people achieved.
- 37:21That's way more than what any group of slaves would achieve
- 37:24because they don't have skin in the game.
- 37:25They don't have that fire, that creativity.
- 37:27Here's the problem though, right?
- 37:30The internet made the cost of policing cheap, didn't it?
- 37:36That's the thing.
- 37:37Really cheap.
- 37:38What I'm saying, the cost of attack, the cost of defense,
- 37:41and how technology can aid us freedom fighters,
- 37:44it can also aid the thieves.
- 37:46If we have a massive dragnet surveillance, as we currently do,
- 37:51if nobody has any privacy,
- 37:53then the cost of attack becomes very cheap.
- 37:56Because you know exactly whom to attack, when to attack,
- 37:59and what to attack for.
- 38:01And then you can make a much more educated economic decision
- 38:05of will I get my money's worth from this attack?
- 38:09You're not going to attack the guy who doesn't have any money
- 38:11because you know exactly that he doesn't have any money.
- 38:13Rather, you focus on the guy who just was productive
- 38:16and sold some stuff and now has capital to spare.
- 38:20If you have a perfect surveillance system,
- 38:23then that makes the profitability of the attack way in your favor.
- 38:28So the cost of attack on the internet becomes more costly if you employ cryptography. Is that the kind of theory?
- 38:38Yeah, exactly.
- 38:39That's the one tool to make those things costly.
- 38:43So, yeah.
- 38:44Yeah.
- 38:45And like, I mean, let's take encryption as one example, right?
- 38:50Like encryption depends on private public keys.
- 38:54So you have a private key, that's your secret number, basically, a password that gets you
- 39:00to decrypt stuff.
- 39:02And you have a public key, which I can use to encrypt messages to you.
- 39:08In order to create a private key, all you need to do is flip a coin.
- 39:1156 times, done, you have your private key.
- 39:14Your computer can do it a million times a second.
- 39:17It's basically free, a tiny bit of compute power, electricity,
- 39:22which amortized across the entire use of the computer is nothing.
- 39:26In order to create a public key out of a private key
- 39:29is, again, just a simple math formula.
- 39:31You need to multiply some numbers, and that's it.
- 39:34Again, almost free.
- 39:37But now, if I have your public key,
- 39:39and I would like to have your private key.
- 39:42All of a sudden that requires such an enormous amount of computation
- 39:45that it's not just infeasible.
- 39:48Like if we would have a computer that could do this in the classical setting,
- 39:52it would consume so much electricity that we would create a black hole.
- 39:56It's just unbafflingly how much more difficult it is
- 40:01to get the private key from a public key.
- 40:04And now this is an asymmetry.
- 40:06and that is part of what makes it so powerful.
- 40:10It's literally free and instant
- 40:13for you to create the private and public key
- 40:15and it's virtually impossible for me
- 40:18to get your private key from the public key
- 40:20and that extends to things like encryption.
- 40:23Now I can encrypt messages to you
- 40:25so that for me to encrypt it, it's trivial.
- 40:29I take my message, I multiply it with your public key basically
- 40:31and I have something, a new number that I can send to you
- 40:35and other people will not have any ability to get to the actual true message.
- 40:40It will be, again, infeasibly expensive for them to read that message.
- 40:45But for you, it's, again, just multiplying that ciphertext number with your private key,
- 40:50and all of a sudden you have a clear text message, exactly what I sent you,
- 40:55and it was extremely cheap for you and me to do this,
- 40:59and basically impossible for anyone else to intervene,
- 41:02to make sure that we cannot use this because it's just math right once you know it you know it
- 41:07and then also to undo the math formulas that we made and so these trapdoor functions are are
- 41:14miracle technology like the fact that this works in this universe is is wild is absolutely wild and
- 41:21and it's kind of like a gift of god that we have to use in in our favor and and that's ultimately
- 41:26what cypherpunk is about.
- 41:28Herein lies the problem, though.
- 41:30And this is the, I think this is the number one question for freedom lovers right now.
- 41:37What you've just described in the digital realm is pretty much the solution,
- 41:42currently at least, and for probably quite a long time into the future.
- 41:45This is the solution in the digital world.
- 41:49But we live in the physical world.
- 41:51Yeah.
- 41:52Right?
- 41:52And so do our computers.
- 41:54Right.
- 41:54Okay.
- 41:55Now, the physical realm is the realm where the search for freedom and privacy is way more esoteric, way more difficult, way more.
- 42:07And I think I've always thought of our movement, the Free Cities movement, is searching for freedom in the real world.
- 42:15You've got the cypherpunk world or the Bitcoin world or the Nostra world.
- 42:19This is searching for freedom in the digital realm.
- 42:21And it's quite easy, actually. It is now, at least. But there's no route in the physical world that's easy. And in fact, I don't actually think there's a definitive solution like cryptography in the real world. What do you think?
- 42:35Yeah, that's a really good point. And I just like to highlight that all of these beautiful things that we can do in cyberspace, these constructs of the mind, they absolutely depend on a secure physical space.
- 42:48The perfect example is you want to create a new Bitcoin wallet, you want to send a thousand Bitcoin into it. And so you sit in front of your computer and the computer generates your private key and shows it to you as 12 words. So you write down the 12 words and super secure, only you know it. Now you can receive and send money to it.
- 43:05But unfortunately, over there is a small drone with a telescopic camera like a kilometer away.
- 43:11And it's zooming in and sees exactly what you're doing in front of your computer.
- 43:15It sees exactly what the screen is doing, sees exactly what you're typing in.
- 43:18All of a sudden, cyberspace can no longer protect you because meatspace was compromised.
- 43:23And everything in cyberspace is anchored to meatspace.
- 43:28Not just for your backups of your private keys, but literally for the computing hardware.
- 43:32with any computer basically whoever has physical access to the computer can do whatever he wants
- 43:38there are some great advancements in computer science that does not make that so you can have
- 43:43secure enclaves that even with physical access to the machine you cannot really intervene or read
- 43:47what was happening amazing tech but that's not really implemented wildly yet and and that's that's
- 43:53a serious serious problem and that's why we absolutely do need to fix freedom in in meatspace
- 43:58in the physical reality.
- 44:00That's why I'm such a massive supporter of your work
- 44:03and the Free Cities Movement's work
- 44:04because we need to have a secure, long-lasting,
- 44:09decentralized alternative to the violence of the state
- 44:13in the physical world.
- 44:15And that's really hard because the state has a money printer
- 44:17and they can literally print tanks and missiles and spies.
- 44:21I've never heard it.
- 44:22You print it perfectly, mate.
- 44:24I would have said they print money to make tanks.
- 44:26He's like, no, they print tanks.
- 44:28No, but it's true.
- 44:31It's scary.
- 44:31All right.
- 44:32Okay.
- 44:32So let's talk about that then because creating sort of safety and freedom and privacy in the meat space is a very, very difficult thing.
- 44:44I've only nailed down three techniques.
- 44:47This has been from three years almost of talking about it.
- 44:51You've got three ways to do it.
- 44:52One is legal.
- 44:54so you've got the whole legal system this this bit of meatspace technology that kind of it's
- 45:00that exists well it exists in the digital realm almost now but it's there and and it's like a
- 45:06an abstract power that you can you can use to protect your physical space that's number one
- 45:11number two is you've got community so you've got the ability to get everyone on board with your
- 45:19safe place that they all want to protect it. Right. And the third one is that, um, well,
- 45:28in the case of a free city, um, you're, you're, you're making, everyone is making such, so
- 45:35everyone, yeah, is that the community one? Everyone's making so much money, a bit like Venice,
- 45:40you know, Venice is, is such a, or somewhere like Dubai at the moment, no one's attacking Dubai
- 45:45because everyone that's living there is pretty good. And they're, they're all making money and
- 45:48they're all doing things and so you've got this kind of no one wants to be the person that attacks
- 45:53this thing um everyone is makes a profit out of it right yes if we would attack it we would make a
- 45:59loss yes exactly so you join the profit rather than the loss and you've got so you've got these
- 46:04three things you've got defending it you've got legally defending it and you've got the fact that
- 46:09it doesn't need defending because no one wants to attack it but there's not much else i can think of
- 46:13There's no, you know, guns are all included in that, you know.
- 46:18And we've got an example of that right now happening in Prospera in Honduras.
- 46:23We've got this, and interestingly, and I don't know how much you know about what's going on over there at the moment.
- 46:28I'm not sure about the very, very latest work, but the whole drama with the new opposition is.
- 46:34Well you be pleased to know that people over there are relatively hopeful and think that not only are the socialist well the socialist government are backed down and they already started spinning this new narrative that they managed to stop There were a number of things they stopped Basically they said that Prospera is illegitimate
- 47:02and kind of backed themselves into a corner because at that point now they need to basically
- 47:06go in with guns and shut it down. That's what they do. They didn't. They didn't. And now they
- 47:13started saying, well, we stopped the new occurrence of these places.
- 47:18So they're backtracking to that because they basically realized, obviously, that they couldn't do that.
- 47:25And Prospera was using legal.
- 47:27What they weren't using very well, I mean, legal was their big one, this treaty that they have,
- 47:33which basically allows them to go to an international court,
- 47:38and they ended up basically suing the Honduran government for an astronomical amount of money.
- 47:43So that kind of, that part of the plan worked.
- 47:47It seems to have worked.
- 47:48Where they weren't so strong was in the community,
- 47:54because there was a lot of rumors spread about the whole thing.
- 47:57And there's so much misinformation that they didn't really get on top of.
- 48:01It's a very difficult one to get on top of.
- 48:02And then, of course, there's the fact that, I mean,
- 48:05they've just had a massive new round of investment in there and in amongst all this so that people
- 48:09realize the potential to make money so they're still they're still pumping money in but what's
- 48:14good about that situation is is if you can beat the socialist government and they're a proper
- 48:19socialist government they're not like you know they're not like democratic socialists or whatever
- 48:23then that's a really good precedent that's just been set as far as i can tell and you know that's
- 48:31securing an independent place. And it's a small one as well. It's not like a vast place. There's
- 48:37hardly anyone there. And it would be a wonderful, wonderful precedent to be set.
- 48:42Yeah, absolutely. But as you say, it's a small place. It's only one place. It's not going to be
- 48:48enough. We need to decentralize, so to say, because the likelihood of any one physical
- 48:55location being compromised is there, right? It's not zero for sure. And so we need to have
- 49:01basically an evacuation plan, right? Because when in direct conflict with the state,
- 49:07oftentimes de-escalation and evacuation is the more profitable way to go. Because either you can
- 49:14stand your ground and fight it out against tanks and missiles, right? And again, they print them
- 49:21faster than you could ever spend your own money on it. So a direct conflict with the state,
- 49:26the cards are not in your favor. Plus, you're wasting all of this time trying to destroy the
- 49:31other guy's tanks, when instead you could evacuate, pack up all your stuff, move to a new location
- 49:37that does not attack you, and then continue building. So instead of fighting a destructive
- 49:42fight, we move on and continue creating something more beautiful. That is the frontiers minertitude,
- 49:49In fact, that's why America was founded, that exact thing.
- 49:54I've often thought about this because I used to think I was a stay and fight guy.
- 49:58And I don't think I am now.
- 50:00I've noticed that.
- 50:02And it's even as I've adopted more libertarian ideas that I've become the, there's a point where I go, okay, now I'm better off leaving and creating something new.
- 50:13But this is the problem because a lot of, this is what free cities are pretty much.
- 50:17They're frontier cities.
- 50:19They're frontier places.
- 50:21You need a frontier though.
- 50:23And frontiers currently don't really exist other than at sea.
- 50:27And seasteading is a phenomenal idea that may have a number of years still to go before the really influential things start happening.
- 50:35Or space.
- 50:36And space is coming.
- 50:37And space will come.
- 50:40I'm not sure it's going to be something I'm going to jump on board straight away.
- 50:44But these are the only frontiers left.
- 50:46or what, Liberland, you know, or there's one in the desert of Chad, there's a bit of unclaimed
- 50:51land there, but no one wants to live there because it's so hot. Or there's Liberland,
- 50:55you know, in Serbia, Croatian border, you know. There is no frontiers. I mean, the internet was
- 51:01a frontier. And that's why it was so free until now. They started to police it and they want to
- 51:06police this and they want to tell you what you can and can't look at in this new frontier, you know.
- 51:11So maybe we don't necessarily need a frontier. Maybe we just need a parallel
- 51:16space, the parallel economy that can be anywhere. Because regardless of where you are, regardless of
- 51:22how much state intervention there is, there are groups of free men and women pushing their path
- 51:29forward, despite all of the intervention. The free market is anywhere. And so potentially,
- 51:36we don't really need to have this plot of land with our flag, where we stand strong on the hill.
- 51:43because again that's that's quite a target maybe to go about it more subtly is at least in the
- 51:50meantime until new frontiers open up or the old tyranny falls this parallel system seems for me to
- 51:57be the more actionably doable in the short run i think that's a common experience in totalitarian
- 52:05places anyway yeah i've spoken to a lot of people you know in czech public and you know the kind of
- 52:10alternative world that runs parallel to clown world, which is kind of what we have now. We have
- 52:16clown world and we have our kind of world where everyone knows everyone and there's transactions
- 52:22that can occur outside of that system and there's business that can be done. And, you know, that is
- 52:28something that's very commonly reported on in, you know, former socialist countries at the end.
- 52:34there's this thing that they're saying on the TV
- 52:37and everyone's going, yes, yes, yes,
- 52:40and then no one's doing it
- 52:41when they're not being watched, I suppose.
- 52:44Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 52:46And that, of course, is risky
- 52:47because there are informants,
- 52:49there are mules, etc., right,
- 52:50that try to subvert these underground movements
- 52:53and very successfully so, right?
- 52:55This is not a new thing.
- 52:57The tyrants do have strategies
- 52:58to go against this type of movement,
- 53:01but at least it's something, you know.
- 53:04I don't know what. Yeah. I mean, do we have any examples, historical examples where people didn't amass together en masse like that? I mean, arguably, I suppose the digital nomad sort of revolution, which is a new thing because it's that's kind of who they are.
- 53:28they don't really have a state per se i mean ironically i went to a conference a digital
- 53:34conference recently and they were talking about that they were saying that as a as a group of
- 53:39people we all should there's a couple of things that really unite us all and that's looking for
- 53:44certain visas looking for a place to live you've got a good standard of living blah blah blah but
- 53:48we as an we're not a nation you can't ring anyone up and say hey tell the digital nomads to do this
- 53:55because they could be a powerful group.
- 53:57But I suppose they are one of the best examples of that,
- 54:01the largest examples.
- 54:03And they do feel an identity.
- 54:06Because then you've also got the kind of network stake type of people,
- 54:09but they're not as real to me.
- 54:12They don't appear to be doing it to the same degree as the digital nomads,
- 54:17who really are out there living in different cities,
- 54:21once every few months moving to another one
- 54:24because they're treated better or because it's a favorite place of theirs you know all that kind
- 54:28of stuff so yeah and here again like the internet really made this possible because we we like to
- 54:34have community right we want to continue working and continue talking to people to to get things
- 54:40done and without an instantaneous global transfer of information and not money with bitcoin this
- 54:46simply isn't possible so this idea of the digital nomad is a new and very exciting area of of
- 54:54design space for freedom fighters.
- 54:56It's also very costly to attack, the digital nomad.
- 55:01Exactly.
- 55:02And again, the de-escalation and evacuation is lived.
- 55:08As soon as someone makes you trouble, as soon as you have a bad gut feeling about the place,
- 55:13you just leave.
- 55:14As a nomad, the question of where do you want to wake up tomorrow?
- 55:18You actually have to ask yourself that seriously, because you could literally wake up anywhere
- 55:24on this planet in the next 24 hours if you really wanted to right and and so why would you choose to
- 55:29wake up in a place where where you are in under fear and under attack and under extortion well
- 55:36the reason is probably um to do with the reason why we stay long term anywhere family roots
- 55:46familiarity you know and these are all very strong things but but for example like i think bitcoin
- 55:54events are the perfect example because that feels to me like a family gathering right we all know
- 56:00each other we've seen each other for many years we know each other's stories we want to help each
- 56:04other we don't see each other all the time but we actually see each other frequently right maybe
- 56:09there a year or so in between but there people that i see like every every two weeks or something on the next conference well you bet you also see them online i mean exactly you feel i mean i i feel very
- 56:21in touch with most people that i only see once every two years yeah because i i'm watching what
- 56:27they're saying publicly anyway exactly and privately then you get all the good stuff yeah
- 56:33you know but you're yeah the yeah the digital nomad thing it's i'm gone you should say something
- 56:41and and one super common objection is i i don't always want to move to a new place
- 56:46and you really don't have to um digital nomadism works great if you have like i don't know two three
- 56:53four locations that you really like and you just travel in a circle from one to the next and you
- 56:59you know all the people there, you know the best restaurants, you know the nice spots in nature,
- 57:05and you can build a relationship there across years. And sure, you're not there all the time,
- 57:10but that just means that when you are there, you actually want to experience the place to the
- 57:15fullest. And arguably, that is the free cities dream. And, you know, it's almost like what you're
- 57:24describing is the parallel universe of free cities. Exactly. We need a network. Within the
- 57:29network. Yeah. You're right, actually. I've never thought of it like that. It really is
- 57:35one form of it. I wonder what, or you might know this actually, is the state cottoning on to digital
- 57:43nomadism, digital nomadism in that sense? I know they went through a phase of really
- 57:48trying to attract them. And quite quickly, they retracted all that. They didn't really,
- 57:53lots of places went yeah come and then they were like no now we're going to tax you a lot of money
- 57:57really really quickly but there will probably come a time if people move carry on moving as freely as
- 58:04possible and these ideas become more prevalent because it's something that like i just came
- 58:09i'm not even a digital nomad dude i live in um you know like a house an old house in which we own
- 58:16and we're going to be there for a long time and blah blah blah and all this kind of stuff
- 58:19but when i knew that there was a i was coming to honey badger i didn't come for three days i booked
- 58:25it i booked like 10 10 days because i knew i could work from here yeah and the this is a latvia is
- 58:31cheap much cheaper than where i live so the actual cost is not that much different and i'm not even a
- 58:37digital nomad so youngsters coming through now i've got have got to sort of like cotton on to
- 58:43this fact on the whole, unless you have a job which is very geographically specific,
- 58:49you have to stay site-specific or whatever, it would seem silly not to at least try that when
- 58:55you were young. But then, and the reason I know that it's a costly attack, costly to attack,
- 59:06you know, to tax people, for example, who are digitally nomadic,
- 59:09they're obviously going to try and clamp down on it.
- 59:13I mean, is that starting already?
- 59:15Or have you noticed that?
- 59:16Yes.
- 59:16Absolutely.
- 59:17I mean, one extreme example is Ukraine, right?
- 59:21A war zone where the state warmongers want to get more slaves to die for them, ultimately.
- 59:28And so there's conscription, right?
- 59:29If you're a male adult, you're going to get drafted.
- 59:34And so a lot of people fled this, obviously, and switched to the digital nomad life.
- 59:38but then Ukraine stopped
- 59:41reissuing new passports
- 59:42for people right so
- 59:44if your passport expires
- 59:46or your driver license expires or whatever
- 59:48you need to come back in order to do it
- 59:51right and then they kidnap you
- 59:53so that's a real thing
- 59:55right and
- 59:55could you in that moment
- 59:58claim refugee status somewhere
- 1:00:00do you think?
- 1:00:01probably not in the EU because they all support it
- 1:00:03right
- 1:00:04but do they support
- 1:00:07conscription, I suppose they do.
- 1:00:09Of course they do. And they're seriously
- 1:00:11thinking of adding this back in most European
- 1:00:13countries. Really? Yeah.
- 1:00:15Do you mean like, not in wartime,
- 1:00:17just you need to do, like in Israel,
- 1:00:19you have to do two years of
- 1:00:21military service or whatever. This used to be the
- 1:00:23case in Germany as well, like you have to
- 1:00:25go there for a year, then they stopped that, thankfully.
- 1:00:28Now they're thinking of doing it again.
- 1:00:29They will start in a voluntary way, and then if
- 1:00:31nobody signs up, which most likely will happen,
- 1:00:34they will say, no, you will have to.
- 1:00:35and and that's not wartime right and when wartime comes absolutely they're gonna draft their
- 1:00:40citizens that's what they're there for that's what the whole prussian outcome-based system
- 1:00:44literally was designed to do right to have obedient slaves that come to your calling and
- 1:00:49die for you on the front lines when you so choose god and you know every now and then i i i i'm from
- 1:00:57on Twitter or something, or you see those horrendous videos from Ukraine or Russia.
- 1:01:06It's either one side or the other.
- 1:01:08They're kind of these weird semi-propaganda things,
- 1:01:11which are basically drones killing people.
- 1:01:13And it's the most depressing, you know,
- 1:01:18this bit of technology that costs probably a hundred bucks flying in
- 1:01:24to this guy on the floor who's just given up.
- 1:01:26he's smoking a cigarette and then it's just, I mean, this is what we've come to.
- 1:01:32This is, I know war has always been hell, but when you see it like that,
- 1:01:37it's absolutely despicably disgusting and horrendous, you know.
- 1:01:42Maybe that's actually great for us because in the past,
- 1:01:45bullets didn't have cameras attached.
- 1:01:47You didn't see that fear and devastation and mode of giving up on the victim.
- 1:01:52Now with drones, you actually do see it.
- 1:01:54And I hope that that brings back a little bit of humanity, because it's actually hard to kill someone with your bare hands.
- 1:02:01Not physically, but spiritually hard.
- 1:02:05With a sniper rifle, that's different.
- 1:02:08You're way more disattached from it.
- 1:02:11And I don't know.
- 1:02:13The thing with a drone is you can do it on the other side of the planet.
- 1:02:16So there is a certain amount of physical separation, but at least you see the devastation coming close.
- 1:02:21Do you know what I heard the other day? I don't know who told me, but it was even more depressing was that apparently drones that are operated from base are under the threat of being intercepted with radio waves or whatever. I don't know how they control them.
- 1:02:39So the new thing was just pop an AI in it, an independent AI in it and send it off on its way.
- 1:02:46I mean, it just got even more depressing.
- 1:02:48There's something out there that's job is to hunt you down.
- 1:02:51You could be anyone.
- 1:02:52It's going to try its hardest to kill the opposition, which is bad enough anyway.
- 1:02:56But you could just be some guy walking along the road mistaken.
- 1:03:01And that's, you know, that used to be something we would laugh about predicting.
- 1:03:06like you know this is skynet or i know it's not run by skynet but this is autonomous drones going
- 1:03:13out and massacring people and slaughtering people this is this is like um this is like a
- 1:03:21this is disgusting and evil and oh i can't even i don't know yeah this tyranny sucks it's the
- 1:03:31It sucks so much.
- 1:03:32It's the abstract nature of it that's the most disturbing.
- 1:03:36I hate it when machines do things to living things.
- 1:03:40It really irks me.
- 1:03:41It really, because it's just this.
- 1:03:43Because someone designed that machine.
- 1:03:44Yeah.
- 1:03:44Yeah.
- 1:03:45Do you know what?
- 1:03:46That's, I was really, when I was young, this is going to sound like a strange story, but I just came to mind then.
- 1:03:53When I was quite young, I used to go to the library and sometimes I used to sit in the library and just pull books off the library and just look at them.
- 1:03:59And I ended up looking through this agricultural book.
- 1:04:04And in it was, for the first time in my life, it was so disgusting.
- 1:04:08I saw a slaughter line of, you know, and it just, I wasn't ready for it at age, whatever, nine.
- 1:04:14And it was just like chickens hanging up on this thing, going through an automatic system of getting stunned, getting killed, getting their throats cut by a spinning blade.
- 1:04:25And I was so disgusted by it.
- 1:04:27I still to this day can't stop thinking about it.
- 1:04:30This is like 50 years ago.
- 1:04:33It's still something I think about.
- 1:04:35And it was that fact that someone, I thought that exact thing.
- 1:04:40I thought somebody sat down on a drafts board, you know, drafting this machine.
- 1:04:46Optimizing it.
- 1:04:47That kills things.
- 1:04:49And they had to stay with it for all that time.
- 1:04:54you know because after things you know the spinning disc that cuts their throat doesn't
- 1:04:59always get it it misses slightly and just injures them and and i was like oh my god this is like what
- 1:05:06how do people do that this abstract force that you just send out into the world and it does your
- 1:05:14bidding and it doesn't know about emotion it doesn't know about doesn't care it doesn't do
- 1:05:20And that's where, you know, we're getting a long way down that route with humans now.
- 1:05:25There's a scary book that talks about exactly that called Ordinary Men.
- 1:05:30I know it Is it the people the Nazi Germany the people that killed were sent out to just kill people They were a regular police battalion basically civilians you know firefighters butchers whatever
- 1:05:45And they were created, ultimately, like, got the mission to, hey, we need to exterminate this village, right?
- 1:05:53And interestingly, on the very first order that was given, the general said, hey, if that's not for you, you can leave, right?
- 1:06:01and a couple people put up their hands and like hey i'm out and sure right you you can go nobody
- 1:06:06thinks worse of you you go to the kitchen i do whatever um and then they started killing right
- 1:06:13and and most people stopped the killing after a couple deaths like um and it's worth saying this
- 1:06:20was women and children as well this wasn't like soldiers this was take that woman over there and
- 1:06:26put a bullet in her head take this child over there and put a bullet in its head yeah
- 1:06:30and that just escalates
- 1:06:33and you get used to it
- 1:06:34and there's propaganda
- 1:06:36dehumanizing the victims etc
- 1:06:38like this is real
- 1:06:40I think also in that situation
- 1:06:42I can understand
- 1:06:45the emotion behind those guys
- 1:06:47if we're a band of brothers
- 1:06:49all on the same team
- 1:06:51and one of us says
- 1:06:53look we've got to do this
- 1:06:54you kind of default to your band of brothers
- 1:06:58right let's do it
- 1:06:58it's going to be horrible
- 1:06:59but let's do this you forget that this is a person you think we have got to do that we've
- 1:07:04got to suffer because you will you'll suffer intensely forever basically the person at least
- 1:07:11that you killed dies they don't carry that you know memory with them but i can understand the the
- 1:07:17the the power that drove those people to do that and then after you've done it once i can imagine
- 1:07:25that you could probably do it again.
- 1:07:28Once you've committed that, you know, that taboo,
- 1:07:32once you've done that taboo, it's like, whatever, bang, whatever, bang.
- 1:07:36Because same thing happens to me when I have something,
- 1:07:39when I have to resist something.
- 1:07:41I'm fine as long as I resist it forever.
- 1:07:44The moment I go, all right, just one, then it's 100.
- 1:07:48You know what I mean?
- 1:07:48Because you devalue that moral stance that you just took.
- 1:07:54and then you know obviously the killing of innocent people is the ultimate taboo i would
- 1:08:01have thought i don't know there may be more but but i don't know it's it's it really yeah it we
- 1:08:09really are entering some bizarre times the weird thing is many more people many more good people
- 1:08:15exist than bad many more i would i would hazard a guess it's like 95 5 99 1 i don't know and yet
- 1:08:26we still end up in this situation which is really bizarre we've got it we it's it's we're a we're a
- 1:08:31strange species yeah when you think about it i think there's there's some very small percentage
- 1:08:37of actual psychopaths people who who just don't have the empathy don't care they'll kill if they
- 1:08:43detail and are fine with it. And then there is a much larger percentage of people who get easily
- 1:08:51influenced by psychopaths and who do what they say, right? And who just need that authority to
- 1:08:56tell them, no, no, it's all right. You should do that. And that is a scary large percentage of
- 1:09:00number. And that's where propaganda becomes so dangerous because they're influenced by whatever
- 1:09:07propaganda is out there and then go with it. And I would say a very minority of people
- 1:09:15actually would resist a compelling psychopathic authority telling them to do bad stuff.
- 1:09:24Do you know what? Something I've been thinking a lot about recently.
- 1:09:27You know the meme that, oh, if you lived in Nazi Germany, you would have been a Nazi.
- 1:09:34There's quite a common meme, isn't it? And people like myself think, I won't do that. I wouldn't have done that. I would have been the guy defying it. And people say, yeah, but would you? Do you know what I'm noticing happening, which is absolutely crazy and bizarre, is when you look at the, um, the filification of Israel and Jewish people, I don't know whether you've noticed it, but it's becoming much more of a meme again.
- 1:10:03you know and when you look now you get to look at it as that person you really do like when you're
- 1:10:11online and you look at some propaganda saying you know something in the palestine israel and
- 1:10:18it's really pro-palestinian and it's showing israelis knocking on people's doors and
- 1:10:23you know and taking property and stuff like that that's the moment that you are now being tested
- 1:10:31as you know the that's the propaganda that's deciding whether you go oh they're the bad guys
- 1:10:38or they're the bad guys you know it's really interesting because i it you really do get to
- 1:10:43to test your your ability because i've noticed there's a there's a massive i don't know whether
- 1:10:49it's just on my social media or what but it's back the village the vilification of jewish people
- 1:10:55for example, appears to be back. There's lots of people coming out quite openly and saying this,
- 1:11:03that, and the other. And there may be truth in what they're saying. They may not. I don't really
- 1:11:06know. But what is happening is you're being offered an opportunity to vilify a whole group of people.
- 1:11:13And are you taking it? Do you know what I mean? It's absolutely fascinating because you think,
- 1:11:19when you think of it, when you think of things like, you know, Nazi Germany, you think, well,
- 1:11:22when's that ever going to happen to me right it's happening now it's happening in the the internet
- 1:11:29the internet is the nation in which that thing is happening what are you doing who are you you know
- 1:11:34it's it's unbelievable the times we're living through it really is bizarre what's going on you
- 1:11:40know but um yeah and and you know like it's it's it extends to to just regular like european
- 1:11:48nations right like because like we know that printing money is bad right um we know that
- 1:11:55using printed money is bad as well and whenever you pay someone with printed money you're continuing
- 1:12:00that kantion effect right you're stealing from all the people who received his newly created
- 1:12:04money after you um it's still we all do it right we we know that all the taxes go to fund wars and
- 1:12:12and pedophiles and whatnot, and we still do it, right?
- 1:12:16It's just a very easy excuse to keep proliferating this system of theft and slavery.
- 1:12:24And most people don't care, right?
- 1:12:27Most people don't care enough to do something about it.
- 1:12:30For most people, it's just way easier to just go along with the mainstream, right?
- 1:12:34And that includes radicals, right?
- 1:12:37Like, I mean, I'm pretty radical about this.
- 1:12:39I still use fiat sometimes, right?
- 1:12:41If you were really consistent about it, I could be much more radical.
- 1:12:48But it's hard, right?
- 1:12:49And not convenient.
- 1:12:52So there really is, it's hard to, when you're in it, to stop the bad things that you're doing.
- 1:13:00That's hard work.
- 1:13:03Convenience is the word.
- 1:13:04It's a really, it's the word of our time, isn't it?
- 1:13:08Convenience.
- 1:13:08It's like we are in the most convenient time in history, probably.
- 1:13:14I mean, you can literally sit here, press a button,
- 1:13:18and a car appears and takes you places or delivers food to you.
- 1:13:21I mean, we've gone...
- 1:13:24I get that probably if you look deep into the psyche of the human being,
- 1:13:28you realize that the desire for convenience is a good desire.
- 1:13:32It's the desire to save energy almost, isn't it?
- 1:13:35It's like, and when you're a Neanderthal, you don't, if someone, if there was a machine that killed, that killed wild animals, so you don't have to strangle them with your own arms, of course you're going to take it.
- 1:13:48But we've just created this world.
- 1:13:50We've gone, we've gone so far.
- 1:13:53I mean, I don't, I really don't know what, what the future holds anymore.
- 1:13:56I don't, I, I, I used to have a bunch of ideas about where we were going and there've been such radical changes recently in things like that.
- 1:14:05I mean, take convenience to its natural end.
- 1:14:09It's AI and robots basically doing everything for you.
- 1:14:15And at that point you have a choice.
- 1:14:18Do you let them?
- 1:14:19And what happens if they don't let you let them, you know, like, like what, where does it, you know, what's your, are you, are you a fan?
- 1:14:26fan of AI? I mean, do you even think AI is a thing? I know a lot of techie people who just say,
- 1:14:32look, it's good, but it's not what you think. I mean, AI is definitely a buzzword, right?
- 1:14:39If like we think, for example, with coding, the code that actually runs on the machine is called
- 1:14:46like assembly, right? It's just ones and zeros that come in. Humans cannot really read that.
- 1:14:51So we use programming languages that compile into assembly and those programming languages are much more human readable.
- 1:15:00English words in there, right, with some weird syntax and stuff, and the semicolon has to be
- 1:15:04exactly in the right place and this type of stuff. But ultimately, humans don't code in assembly.
- 1:15:10And to a large extent, I think large language models are an extension of this, because now you
- 1:15:16can code not in a programming language, but just English, like verbal, logical English,
- 1:15:23compiles into source code now, and that compiles into assembly now.
- 1:15:27so I think we've just walked up on the stack of making it easier to build code per se right if
- 1:15:34so if we're looking at LLMs just for coding and that I think is incredible like even a bloke like
- 1:15:40you and me can can now write code that that does something that we wanted to do so that's that's
- 1:15:47really exciting especially because that now increases the number of people who can build
- 1:15:52freedom tech right like I can build freedom tech now that's ridiculous I never really programmed
- 1:15:57and I never wrote a line of code
- 1:15:59other than like some little bash script
- 1:16:01or whatever.
- 1:16:02I just got a button in there for a second.
- 1:16:03But that's not intelligence, is it?
- 1:16:05Like you say, that's just coding.
- 1:16:08Yeah.
- 1:16:08Like all it is,
- 1:16:09do you remember,
- 1:16:09like I started my coding,
- 1:16:12I'm not a coder at all,
- 1:16:13but when I was young,
- 1:16:14I coded in BASIC.
- 1:16:15Do you remember?
- 1:16:15I don't know,
- 1:16:16are you old enough to know BASIC?
- 1:16:17Yeah.
- 1:16:18Right.
- 1:16:18And I did it on a ZX Spectrum.
- 1:16:20I don't know whether you know that computer.
- 1:16:21It was like a 48K computer it was.
- 1:16:25There was a 24K one and a 48K.
- 1:16:27I had the 48K one.
- 1:16:29But the point was that you were using a language
- 1:16:32to make the computer do something.
- 1:16:34So using English to make the computer do something
- 1:16:37is not some crazy...
- 1:16:39It just got more convenient.
- 1:16:40Yeah, exactly.
- 1:16:40But it's not even a crazy advancement.
- 1:16:43It's basically just teaching a computer
- 1:16:47to convert English to code.
- 1:16:51Right.
- 1:16:52So is that what you think AI is?
- 1:16:54or is it bigger than that that's a big part of of the current technology and and i think the most
- 1:17:01exciting one because like code is either correct or it isn't like either it compiles or there is a
- 1:17:06bug you know so we can get really really good at optimizing the large language model to write great
- 1:17:12code and so there was massive massive improvements in the last i know five years and it will basically
- 1:17:20be perfect in the next five years like any code that you want to write you will get it from english
- 1:17:25on the first shot all the time for basically free or like compute you reckon in five years yeah
- 1:17:31absolutely absolutely we're almost already there like there's a website called shakespeare.xyz
- 1:17:37or something or.diy whatever and it's a website with a chat interface and you type in whatever
- 1:17:45nostre client you would like to develop and literally five minutes later you have a website
- 1:17:51that people can use where they can log in with their private keys yeah then start posting messages
- 1:17:56and whatever nuance you want right um that's that's here right and it costs you like i don't
- 1:18:03know 10 bucks an hour to use it right for um and that will you know it's a buggy the software is
- 1:18:10aren't perfect and but in in five years most maximum that your phone will be able to do it
- 1:18:17i designed my own app it's already been designed but i just wanted to see i i wanted to see if it
- 1:18:23could do it and it did i designed a calculator that that is basically an inter an interface for
- 1:18:30private message uh private things i want so if you type the right code into the it looks like a
- 1:18:35calculator and you can use it as a calculator but if you type a certain number in you get to
- 1:18:39a bunch of you get to an encrypted box full of secret things and stuff and it did it pretty much
- 1:18:45first time i had to change the ux a little bit but that is it is it is quite amazing that's wild
- 1:18:51right and and then so on the other hand we have for example robotics right robotics made also in
- 1:18:57the last five years in an insane amount of progress like if you look at robots five ten years ago they
- 1:19:03could barely stand and keep themselves balanced right now they do backflips and cartwheels right
- 1:19:09And they can run fast.
- 1:19:11Now, they're still incredibly inefficient, consume an insane amount of electricity and all of this.
- 1:19:19But in five years, they won't.
- 1:19:21They will get extremely efficient.
- 1:19:23We can engineer this.
- 1:19:24Humans are really good engineers.
- 1:19:26And we can engineer the killing machine to work like 99.999% of the time.
- 1:19:32And the same will happen with robotics.
- 1:19:34And then we put large language models into the robots.
- 1:19:37and all of a sudden we can talk to them about anything
- 1:19:39and have deep philosophical conversations
- 1:19:41and they can code for you, right?
- 1:19:45That's wild, right?
- 1:19:46I'm not sure if that is artificial intelligence,
- 1:19:50but I guess if you would ask any researcher
- 1:19:52like 10, 20 years ago,
- 1:19:54if we would have this in the future,
- 1:19:56would you say that we have reached a singularity
- 1:19:58in artificial intelligence or whatever?
- 1:20:00They probably say yes,
- 1:20:02but now that we're here,
- 1:20:03doesn't really feel like it, right?
- 1:20:05There's still a lot of stuff that isn't really there.
- 1:20:10John Verveke is really good on this topic.
- 1:20:13And I think one of the aspects that these AI models cannot do is have good taste.
- 1:20:19To decide what to do and what not to do.
- 1:20:23To make this value judgment.
- 1:20:25They will do whatever you put on the input side.
- 1:20:28It's just an algorithm that returns you an output.
- 1:20:31But the question of what should I put in the input side?
- 1:20:33Do you know what really helped me understand it was someone said, and I mean, somebody said, look, go on to the best AI you've got and ask it to generate a picture with all the clocks saying 20 past four or something.
- 1:20:56And it comes back with a picture of all the clocks, but all the clocks are set to four o'clock.
- 1:21:03And the reason is, is because most clocks on the internet are set at that time, because that's what looks best when you sell a watch, right?
- 1:21:13So that shows you they have no understanding.
- 1:21:16There's absolutely no understanding there at all.
- 1:21:19It's purely what's most likely to be the correct answer to what I'm being told.
- 1:21:25But I wouldn't say that's intelligence.
- 1:21:28It's just incredible how far this goes if you scale it up.
- 1:21:32I think that's the very surprising thing that researchers didn't really get of, hey, the simple prediction model, right, of what is the next word, what is the next pixel, right?
- 1:21:42We just need to increase compute power in training, inference, and so on.
- 1:21:48And we'll get outcomes that are surprisingly good.
- 1:21:52But is that how intelligence works, do you think?
- 1:21:54No, probably not, right?
- 1:21:55But maybe it does.
- 1:21:56I don't know, yeah.
- 1:21:57Right?
- 1:21:58And that's kind of the crazy thing of like you as a baby, you can learn language just by observing it.
- 1:22:04And it seems likewise computers did that.
- 1:22:06They just observed language.
- 1:22:08They just observed pictures.
- 1:22:10We didn't tell them this is the grammar written out.
- 1:22:13These are the rules.
- 1:22:15But there's a visceral feeling of understanding, isn't there, when you look at a picture.
- 1:22:19there's a difference between generating a picture based on likelihoods and understanding
- 1:22:25that's a fat cow or something you know and isn't there is there i don't know i don't know either
- 1:22:34that's really deep questions i don't know well it would be sad to think that all we're doing
- 1:22:40is when we're thinking and when we're conscious it's just like error correcting or you know like
- 1:22:46it would it would be a sad insight into human intelligence i think to to think that it's like
- 1:22:53a guessing game it's a bit like it's a bit like hashing in a way isn't it it's like you chuck as
- 1:22:58much compute at something until the correct the correct result comes you know and the way you
- 1:23:05understand the result is getting feedback from you know your teacher or something you know you know
- 1:23:12I don't know.
- 1:23:13Maybe we are really that brutal as a species
- 1:23:16and there's nothing deeply, you know.
- 1:23:19What is impressive is how energy efficient we do it.
- 1:23:23That really is something.
- 1:23:24If you compare the energy consumption of the human brain
- 1:23:27and of like an AI supercomputer GPU cluster,
- 1:23:30it's insane.
- 1:23:32Like these machines are so, so, so inefficient at the moment
- 1:23:36that there's no short-term path
- 1:23:39where we can get to the same efficiency as the brain
- 1:23:42anytime soon for sure.
- 1:23:43Do we know how the brain computes?
- 1:23:46Is it something like quantum?
- 1:23:47Sorry, something like, what's it called?
- 1:23:50What's the next iteration of computers,
- 1:23:52the one that everyone says is going to break?
- 1:23:54Quantum computing?
- 1:23:55Is it quantum computing?
- 1:23:56Yeah.
- 1:23:56Is that how we think then?
- 1:23:58Is that?
- 1:23:59I'm not sure.
- 1:24:01Certainly not how I think.
- 1:24:02My brain's all over the place.
- 1:24:05I don't know.
- 1:24:06Yeah, I'm, I, at the moment,
- 1:24:09And like I say, my theory at the moment is AI is intelligent if that's how we think.
- 1:24:16If that literally we just don know it that we are way advanced down the line but the human mind began life in the same way Like you imagine language began like that
- 1:24:28You and me have no language between us.
- 1:24:31So what we do is we make sounds to each other and we look for the response to see whether it works.
- 1:24:37So if I do that or if I'm like pointing and you move that way, I think, all right, that's pointing because it works.
- 1:24:44and and and and you know ai is kind of the same right it's it's looking at everything that's ever
- 1:24:50been done and from that predicting what should happen next according it according to to you know
- 1:24:58like what it's computing you know like so maybe maybe yeah maybe we're just really simple beings
- 1:25:07you know yeah might might well be but i think out of simplicity comes a lot of beautiful complexity
- 1:25:13on top and so there's not there's not much nuance if you zoom in close enough right like dna
- 1:25:20turns out to be super simple building blocks but what you can do with it is wild
- 1:25:24yeah i don't i i'm i'm i'm at a loss with all that stuff something i wanted to talk about actually
- 1:25:31and you almost certainly already know this um but i discovered this for the first time
- 1:25:38yesterday and it really blew my mind um i was supposed to be interviewing a jacomo zuko
- 1:25:45yesterday but he he didn't turn up whatever but i did some research to to sort of i was thinking
- 1:25:52what we're going to talk about because i want to talk about freedom and he'd done a really
- 1:25:55interesting talk about freedom for plan b forum and he explained something to me on this video
- 1:26:02that I'd never heard of before.
- 1:26:05And it was to do with the Lockean theory of ownership.
- 1:26:10So John Locke says, you know, like homesteading,
- 1:26:13if you go to a place, a frontier, that's not owned, let's say,
- 1:26:18it's just nature, it's just nothing, whatever,
- 1:26:21and you add your labor, it becomes your property, right?
- 1:26:24You know about this, obviously, right?
- 1:26:26now bitcoin's basically the most perfect example of that you have and i i can't believe i've lived
- 1:26:36this long and not thought that thought that you have the miner basically has this frontier of
- 1:26:43nothing adds work creates the bitcoin and the bitcoin is property yeah that's amazing like how
- 1:26:53Why did no one ever tell me that before?
- 1:26:55That's the best way to explain proof of work and ownership and why Bitcoin is perfect ownership.
- 1:27:04And I think on top of that, similar applies actually to private keys, which I think is even more mind-blowing.
- 1:27:11Because the private key is just a number.
- 1:27:14It's literally a number.
- 1:27:17Numbers are not scarce.
- 1:27:18If I tell you number 4729, I didn't lose it.
- 1:27:22I didn't give up.
- 1:27:23control over it. You got a copy. So there is not really ownership in ideas. Stefan Kinsella
- 1:27:30is fantastic on this. His book Against Intellectual Property, great read. So he's basically saying
- 1:27:35ideas are not scarce. Therefore, we don't need to allocate our resources because we can just
- 1:27:40copy it. Therefore, we don't need property rights. Therefore, there is no exchange. There is no IP.
- 1:27:46With ideas, though.
- 1:27:47With ideas specifically.
- 1:27:49And that idea includes the number, whatever your private key is.
- 1:27:54And that's what my new book actually is about.
- 1:27:58That when the ideas itself cannot have property rights, but access control or coordination of these ideas, there are scarce aspects in here.
- 1:28:11like if I have a secret like my private key right then I can exclude you from knowing this private
- 1:28:17key by not telling you the secret right so there is a a rivalrousness either you know it or you
- 1:28:24don't and it's all in my hands because I'm the only one who knows the secret that is a scarce
- 1:28:29aspect and that behaves like a property right right like if you would hit me with a five dollar
- 1:28:35wrench until I give you the secret, then ultimately that would be unjust acquiring of the access
- 1:28:42right to this information with physical coercion on top of that. But ultimately, you're trying to
- 1:28:48get something that I don't want to give you. And so that's a violation in property rights.
- 1:28:53So I actually think we homestead not just land on the frontier, not just Bitcoin as a miner.
- 1:28:58I think we actually homestead private keys as well.
- 1:29:03And then we do have the power to open up what we've homesteaded and make it a public good simply by telling others about it.
- 1:29:11And then the secret becomes worthless.
- 1:29:14A secret is worth a lot if it's only kept in the mind of one person because then he has exclusive ownership of it.
- 1:29:22but when it is shared with others and then some things that we could do before are no longer valid
- 1:29:28specifically in cryptography like if i am the only one who knows my nostril private key i can make a
- 1:29:34post and you can be very sure that this comes from me if i would send my private key to someone else
- 1:29:40all of a sudden you no longer have these assurances so when we are in this uniquely homesteaded
- 1:29:47concept of private keys and ideas specifically where only one person knows them, a secret,
- 1:29:53then cryptography works. And as soon as we have the drone flying over you as you're making your
- 1:29:59backup, that's where it breaks apart. What blew my mind about what Giacomo said, though, was that
- 1:30:08it implies that john locke's theories of ownership on are real are naturally a real are a real
- 1:30:17naturally occurring thing because in the digital world of bitcoin the only way to create private
- 1:30:23property is to add your work to it isn't it yeah that's that that's literally blown my mind
- 1:30:30because when i when you think about you know like i mean john locke's theories have given rise to
- 1:30:37property right legal spiel all over the world really haven't they and and but when i when i
- 1:30:43thought about it before i thought this is just a guy this is a philosopher who's had some ideas
- 1:30:48and it's become part of um you know the way we the way we'd work and the way we do business and
- 1:30:53the way we have contracts and all this kind of stuff but the truth is his theories on property
- 1:30:59are like physics they just exist that's amazing mate that's absolutely amazing
- 1:31:06That's why I'm such a huge fan of praxeology, right? Because it's evident, it's self-evident, right? We assume a couple things, like we assume humans act. That was Mises' grand assumption, like the axiom, the action axiom of humans act purposefully, right?
- 1:31:24we have a problem and then we strategize on how can we allocate our resources available now
- 1:31:30so that the problem is gone in the future. And then we act and we manifest a temporal change
- 1:31:35of solving a problem that we have, not just for us, also for others, right?
- 1:31:41If from the starting point, we can deduce a bunch of stuff on top, right? And so Mises went
- 1:31:48incredibly far with deducing economic reason out of a simple axiom of humans act purposefully
- 1:31:54and and and then we get property rights right that's that's the thing like i have own self
- 1:32:00ownership is is a conclusion of of this very obvious starting point and the thing is it's a
- 1:32:06self-evident starting point like if you would tell me that hey i am not acting like i cannot
- 1:32:13act right now right i'm not acting purposefully well you're just forming the words right that's
- 1:32:18that actually tried to convince me that you're not acting purposefully,
- 1:32:22but that itself is an action.
- 1:32:23So it's this tautology where you cannot really deny it.
- 1:32:28Hoppe added on top of this the axiom of argumentation,
- 1:32:32and also quite similar of humans have the ability to, with reason,
- 1:32:36come to the truth and to argue and to try to convince the other person of that sad truth.
- 1:32:42And from this point, Hoppe argues that we can actually deduce an ethics.
- 1:32:46and he comes to the conclusion that property rights are not just a value-free logic from
- 1:32:52action. It's inherent in saying basically what ought not to be done. So you shall not steal
- 1:32:59is a objective rationale, a response or like a conclusion from the action axiom and the
- 1:33:07argumentation axiom both applied. And then what I think the third addition to this trilogy of
- 1:33:14axioms is from Eric Voskule, a contemporary economist and
- 1:33:18bitcoiner, who introduces the axiom
- 1:33:22of resistance. Meaning a system can be designed
- 1:33:26to resist external control. We can
- 1:33:30have a system that, and if the user
- 1:33:34resists the attacker, he will be secure.
- 1:33:38And that allows us to build technologies that enshrine this property right in reality in an unfuckwithable way Cryptography is perfect If you resist the attacker and you do not share your private key
- 1:33:56then encryption is secure and bulletproof and cannot be violated. And so all of these three
- 1:34:02things together, I would say, is a proof that freedom exists. Freedom is a good thing. And we
- 1:34:08can engineer freedom into existence. And that's wonderful. That's amazing, mate. I mean, that's,
- 1:34:17I'm just astonished that I kind of only just having these thoughts that even that the idea
- 1:34:25of property rights might be as natural as one plus one equals two. You know, like it's encoded
- 1:34:35into the framework within which we live.
- 1:34:38And you know, it's really interesting because I had a great discussion with a space scientist
- 1:34:44about a year ago, and we were talking about Mars.
- 1:34:50And when you get to Mars, who's going to own Mars?
- 1:34:54Because it's true.
- 1:34:55Who's going to own, when Elon gets to Mars, who's going to own?
- 1:34:58And the UN in the 60s came up with an agreement that nobody owns Mars.
- 1:35:05In fact, they said nobody owns the universe, I think, outside of the Earth.
- 1:35:09Typical communists, right?
- 1:35:11It's like they do, right?
- 1:35:13But the truth is, and he said this, he said, look, it's the John Lockean principle.
- 1:35:19If you get to Mars first and you build a city, of course it's yours.
- 1:35:22You know, it's not anyone else's.
- 1:35:25That's theft.
- 1:35:27But it was just really mind-blowing to realize yesterday morning that this isn't some made-up idea.
- 1:35:39This is an idea that has been discovered.
- 1:35:43It's like a bit of physics that got discovered or a bit of math theory that got discovered.
- 1:35:47It was always there.
- 1:35:49We didn't just really know how to phrase it and how to look at it.
- 1:35:52And then some guys just come and put the reality into verbal thoughts that just make sense, that adequately describe it.
- 1:36:01Well, in the case of property rights, the digital realm offers you the possibility to create like the purest form of property.
- 1:36:11Because property is quite an intangible thing, really, isn't it?
- 1:36:16When you actually talk about what is yours.
- 1:36:18but in in the digital realm property is a very specific thing and i'm not even sure
- 1:36:26that that say take bitcoin for example bitcoin's not property really but your ability to access it
- 1:36:34is the property exactly you know what i mean yeah but what is that what what is that that's like well
- 1:36:39in my book i call it coordination just make me what's your book i didn't know you had a new book
- 1:36:43Is it written and published already?
- 1:36:45Well, kind of.
- 1:36:47So it's called The Praxeology of Privacy.
- 1:36:50And the idea of the book is to bridge Austrian economics,
- 1:36:55Praxeology, with cypherpunks, cryptoanarchy, and privacy,
- 1:36:59and to make that synthesis.
- 1:37:00Because I first fell down the Austrian rabbit hole.
- 1:37:03I'm an economist first and foremost.
- 1:37:06Later, I discovered software and freedom tech and technologies.
- 1:37:10And that turned me into a cypherpunk.
- 1:37:14And so I would like to bridge that gap and to show that there is incredible support between those two ways of thought.
- 1:37:22So far that privacy, Mises, Hoppe, Voskule, they assume privacy to be the case.
- 1:37:31If you want to act purposefully, you need to have a private space for your mind to come up with your decisions.
- 1:37:39If that private space is not there, then we don't have purposeful action, actually.
- 1:37:45Things turn into behavior.
- 1:37:47If someone else can spy on you and see what you're thinking, and he can interfere with you before you make your decisions,
- 1:37:54then you're no longer for yourself deciding on how to act.
- 1:37:57You're behaving according to someone else who has told you.
- 1:38:01And so action, argumentation, resistance, they presuppose that privacy exists.
- 1:38:07and I think that's a powerful realization.
- 1:38:11And then on top of that,
- 1:38:13we can actually build systems of interaction
- 1:38:17both in meatspace as well as in cyberspace
- 1:38:20that follow economic reasoning,
- 1:38:23that follow economic laws.
- 1:38:25So like for example homesteading a private key
- 1:38:27to the later use to encrypt your communication.
- 1:38:30You're not claiming ownership in the number itself
- 1:38:33but you're claiming ownership in the access right
- 1:38:36to that information.
- 1:38:39And so this opens up a large amount of coordination markets
- 1:38:42that I think in traditional Austrian literature
- 1:38:45has been dreadfully underdeveloped.
- 1:38:48Stefan Kinsella's Against Intellectual Property
- 1:38:50is probably the main book that covers this quite well.
- 1:38:54And then the cypherpunks are not bullish enough.
- 1:38:58They don't understand of how fundamentally,
- 1:39:01deeply correct they are
- 1:39:03and the technologies that they build are.
- 1:39:05so we need that bridge that's the book privacy and property it was almost like privacy is the
- 1:39:13that's why it's called privacy is the property privacy is the property though isn't it yeah it's
- 1:39:20like the the property isn't the thing it's the access to the thing and deciding what to do with
- 1:39:28And privacy is kind of stopping people having access.
- 1:39:33Yeah, exactly.
- 1:39:35Eric Hughes defines privacy as the ability to selectively reveal yourself to the world.
- 1:39:41That's a choice.
- 1:39:42That's you choosing what to say when and to whom.
- 1:39:46Do you think that anything to do with the reason why privacy is such a bad word at the moment?
- 1:39:51Do you think that's anything to do with people trying to...
- 1:39:55So, of course it is.
- 1:39:59That's the communism versus individualism.
- 1:40:02That's the battle that goes on.
- 1:40:03It's private versus public.
- 1:40:04Yes, it is.
- 1:40:05A private, sovereign individual versus the public common good.
- 1:40:08Yes.
- 1:40:09This is fundamental at the pivot point between freedom and slavery.
- 1:40:14A slave does not have privacy.
- 1:40:16A slave has to tell the master what he has done.
- 1:40:19Otherwise, he gets whipped until he tells him.
- 1:40:22It's fundamental, isn't it?
- 1:40:24It is extremely fundamental.
- 1:40:25But it's probably as old as we are as well.
- 1:40:30And it's probably a cycle that will continue forever.
- 1:40:35It's just what side are you on, isn't it?
- 1:40:37It's like, who are you?
- 1:40:38Are you the collectivist or are you the individualist?
- 1:40:43Yeah.
- 1:40:44And again, I think it's just clearly articulating these everlasting truths
- 1:40:50and seeing if this is actually a correct articulation thereof.
- 1:40:55and then adjusting your behavior to be in accordance with what we know to be true.
- 1:41:02And I'm pretty convinced at this point that property is a thing.
- 1:41:07Like you own yourself.
- 1:41:09It is.
- 1:41:10It is.
- 1:41:10I think cryptography and Bitcoin proved it.
- 1:41:15It's proven.
- 1:41:16And it's also proven that the way to create property is to add work to it.
- 1:41:22Proof of work.
- 1:41:24It's so amazing.
- 1:41:25It's so amazing that someone in the 17, John Locke's like 1700s or something, realized this.
- 1:41:34Because he didn't have a kind of, I mean, all he had was what it felt like in real life.
- 1:41:40That's mine.
- 1:41:41Because it's not intuitive to think that just because I add my labor to this piece of land, it's now mine.
- 1:41:51I suppose it becomes more intuitive when someone comes to take it.
- 1:41:54And they're like, what did you do?
- 1:41:56Well, I'm now just, this is a separate thing.
- 1:41:59I'm now just bigger than you.
- 1:42:01This is, the land is now mine, not because I toiled on the land, but because I'm bigger than you.
- 1:42:07And it's, yeah, my mind is, my mind, it's just been blown a bit more, actually.
- 1:42:13It was, I don't think, I thought about it yesterday and I thought, that's incredible.
- 1:42:17I'm just realizing now it's deeply incredible that as an understanding.
- 1:42:22Yeah.
- 1:42:23Yeah. And it's a difficult understanding to reach and it's easy to make mistakes there.
- 1:42:27Like Locke made a lot of mistakes, right?
- 1:42:30Menger cleaned up some of his mistakes.
- 1:42:32Like Locke still assumed that value is intrinsic to the good itself.
- 1:42:35So did Adam Smith, right?
- 1:42:37Like actual Marxism is in line with Adam Smith's thoughts, basically.
- 1:42:43Like Adam Smith made mistakes that if consequentially applied leads to Marxism, ultimately, right?
- 1:42:48So that's where Carl Menger comes in with subjective individualism, right?
- 1:42:52or subjective value theory and individualism as a methodology.
- 1:42:58And still, Menger made mistakes that Mises fixed,
- 1:43:02in terms of time preference for example Rothbard makes mistakes or Rothbard fixes some of the inconsistency of mises like mises was still a statist right rothbard is is way more radical in in his anarchism
- 1:43:14right and and rothbard makes mistakes that that hoppy fixes and hoppy makes mistakes that that
- 1:43:19voskiel fixes and so on um it's really really difficult to to come up with with a proper actually
- 1:43:27correct statement but it's not impossible and you might not have a fully correct magnum magnus open
- 1:43:34theory but but some parts of those are correct and then you just have to be careful to to not
- 1:43:39apply the mistakes continuously right which which certainly happens and will probably lead to some
- 1:43:44some suffering but but ultimately when we when we're serious with ourselves and we don't lie to
- 1:43:50ourselves we realize that some of these things are actually correct and it's scary like if to to
- 1:43:57To realize that freedom is correct, the state is evil, that's a scary thing because it literally subverts hundreds, thousands of years of propaganda.
- 1:44:07It's not scary.
- 1:44:09I think sometimes it's hard to act on an intuition or on a feeling, but on a provable theory like that.
- 1:44:20And I know all theories are falsifiable potentially, I suppose.
- 1:44:24But really, things like that do help.
- 1:44:27Like if you know those things, you carry their abstract power with you into your interactions with the world. You really do.
- 1:44:39And to some extent, you're just not ashamed anymore to be free.
- 1:44:45You realize that, hey, I'm standing on solid ground here.
- 1:44:48This is correct.
- 1:44:50I don't need to be ashamed for living and acting freely.
- 1:44:55This is just how it's supposed to be.
- 1:44:57And I'll do it.
- 1:44:57And if someone doesn't like it, so what?
- 1:45:00Yeah, it's justifiably a reason to exist in that state, in that way.
- 1:45:07And that is really powerful.
- 1:45:08I mean, that is the power of abstract ideas that can propel human beings to stand strong.
- 1:45:17It's not even that it makes you angry and to want to fight.
- 1:45:19It's the opposite.
- 1:45:20It's like standing your ground.
- 1:45:22It's like when something comes at you, you just stay as you are because you believe so deeply in this, in who you are and the ideas that you hold.
- 1:45:33It's really amazing, mate.
- 1:45:34Do you know, I never thought about that before.
- 1:45:40It's weird.
- 1:45:41I'm 54.
- 1:45:42I've been alive a long time.
- 1:45:44And you've been interested in freedom for a long time, right?
- 1:45:47Yes, yes.
- 1:45:47So that just shows you stuff is unintuitive.
- 1:45:53Or maybe that's part of the intelligence is that humans are so good at ignoring stuff.
- 1:45:59what what i what it is though is it's like i i didn't think to i didn't realize how powerful it
- 1:46:09was i didn't realize how powerful it was that's all it's like if you if you told me one plus one
- 1:46:14is two and i go yeah i know and then someone comes in and says no one plus one is three i'll
- 1:46:19i'll fight that battle if they're not insane obviously it's very easy to fight that
- 1:46:24because you're like, dude, I'm going to win.
- 1:46:27I'm definitely going to win.
- 1:46:29Probably not, actually.
- 1:46:31I was about to say, I met a guy who was very, very confident
- 1:46:35that 1 plus 1 is actually 3.
- 1:46:37Come on, I think I read about this.
- 1:46:39What is the theory behind it?
- 1:46:42I have no idea.
- 1:46:43No, but there was a guy that went on.
- 1:46:48I can't remember how he justified it.
- 1:46:50It was something to do with negative numbers as well.
- 1:46:52and abstract maths, you know.
- 1:46:59I don't know.
- 1:47:01It all sounds very confident,
- 1:47:03but then probably if you get an actual mathematician
- 1:47:05to argue with him, it will get confusing very quick.
- 1:47:09That's probably the gist of it.
- 1:47:10I don't know, real foundational mathematics is weird.
- 1:47:15Yeah, of course it is.
- 1:47:16I mean, I think at some point everything just collapses as well,
- 1:47:21doesn't it?
- 1:47:21it's a bit like physics you know you can learn a bunch of stuff but then at some point
- 1:47:26it's all it's all wrong you know the the theory is it's almost like the theory is it's all wrong
- 1:47:33you know the theory is there's no theory well there's the map and the territory and the territory
- 1:47:38is not the map and vice versa right and we're trying to reason about and articulate this crazy
- 1:47:45reality that we find ourselves in and obviously words don't do it justice um we probably need
- 1:47:53way more bandwidth like we probably need some terabytes of data being between us
- 1:47:58so that we get a more serious grip on the situation so i'm we don't know all that much
- 1:48:05what else is going on in your new book then and where can people buy it or is it still so right
- 1:48:11Now I'm mainly asking for review.
- 1:48:13That's the main thing.
- 1:48:14So it's version 0.1.0 is released.
- 1:48:16I started writing this like five years ago,
- 1:48:19and then I didn't do anything for like 4.9 years.
- 1:48:23I get that.
- 1:48:24I get that.
- 1:48:25I really do.
- 1:48:26You know, that journey into a book,
- 1:48:29especially when it's about this kind of stuff,
- 1:48:33you can't just say, right, this morning I'm going to,
- 1:48:35you know, I'm going to write the chapter.
- 1:48:38you might need to go and spend days hiking up a mountain and just meditating the whole way before
- 1:48:46you even get anywhere near what you want to talk about and then you gotta find the words you know
- 1:48:50so i the i the title came to me first like i was the praxeology of privacy i was like
- 1:48:56someone needs to write a book about that um and nobody did for i'm not sure i even really
- 1:49:01understand it can you explain praxeology to me praxeology to me twice and it's one of those things
- 1:49:08where you go okay but then what is it but i still don't really know what it is well i like it almost
- 1:49:15literally it means the the logic of human action yeah but but that's just that's not a thing is it
- 1:49:22well it's it's like what what can we what can we deduce what can we say with certainty based on on
- 1:49:29the fact that humans act right like what is the consequences of human action maybe one one
- 1:49:34interesting way of saying is like a very praxeological statement is if we introduce a
- 1:49:41minimum wage that leads to unemployment and that is a logically correct statement
- 1:49:48once we define our terms and and assumptions etc but ultimately if we forbid merchants or
- 1:49:56entrepreneurs to pay people less than a certain amount then they will simply not hire them because
- 1:50:01that person has a marginal benefit to the business that is less than the marginal cost,
- 1:50:06and therefore it's not profitable, right? And so people will not get employed.
- 1:50:09But why is that praxeology? Why isn't that not just...
- 1:50:14It's almost like you don't need to put a word on it. It's just logic, right?
- 1:50:17Well, but there's different types of logic, right? And maybe one other way of differentiating is,
- 1:50:23and I'm not even sure if that's correct, but that's how I have it in my mind, is that so
- 1:50:26Praxeology is about the consequences of human actions, like what happens when we act in a certain way.
- 1:50:33And psychology, for example, is the reasons for acting in a certain way.
- 1:50:38Like why do people act this way rather than what is the consequence of whatever particular way people have acted.
- 1:50:46And so it's this maybe praxeology also is so weird because there was like the war of the methods, Mises called it.
- 1:50:55der Methodenstreit,
- 1:50:57where it really,
- 1:50:59a hundred years ago,
- 1:50:59it was not clear
- 1:51:00how should we think
- 1:51:01about economics.
- 1:51:03There was the historicism
- 1:51:04out of Germany,
- 1:51:06I think.
- 1:51:06Popper.
- 1:51:07Yeah, exactly.
- 1:51:08Who was basically,
- 1:51:09well, we can deduce
- 1:51:10historical activity.
- 1:51:12We can deduce economic loss
- 1:51:15based on historical activity.
- 1:51:16It has always been like this,
- 1:51:17therefore it will be like that
- 1:51:18in the future.
- 1:51:19Sorry, that wasn't Karl Popper,
- 1:51:21was it?
- 1:51:21I think it was Popper.
- 1:51:22Well, you wrote a book
- 1:51:23called The Poverty of Historicism.
- 1:51:25didn't he which is that you can't prove anything you can only disprove it which is slightly different
- 1:51:31to what you're talking about i think but anyway um yeah so so and mises basically said that no
- 1:51:37they're humans act right so or in other words maybe humans act differently right we we're we're
- 1:51:45all we're ever changing it's not like we pick up a rock we drop it and it falls with the same speed
- 1:51:51at the same time all the time, like physics, right?
- 1:51:54Economics is not really like that
- 1:51:56because humans do weird stuff all the time.
- 1:51:59We're not really predictable that much, right?
- 1:52:02So instead of seeing how things were in the past
- 1:52:06and then trying to figure out
- 1:52:07how they're going to be in the future,
- 1:52:09let's instead come up with some foundational assumptions, right?
- 1:52:16Axioms like human action, like time preference, et cetera.
- 1:52:19And then from there on out we simply use logic, right?
- 1:52:24Like, and logic similar to as mathematics or physics but not applied to these
- 1:52:30and eight objects that just behave,
- 1:52:32but applied to human ingenuity and creativity
- 1:52:36to come up with different solutions in different situations.
- 1:52:41How do you describe then something like property rights,
- 1:52:45the theory of property rights?
- 1:52:47So the gist is humans act,
- 1:52:52meaning we use our body and other resources that we have available
- 1:52:57to solve our problems, to remove our uneasiness, as Mises would say.
- 1:53:02And for this, we need to have control over scarce resources like our body,
- 1:53:09like clothing, like food, like fire or fuel, etc.,
- 1:53:15in order to solve these problems.
- 1:53:17And the thing is that humans have an infinite amount of problems.
- 1:53:21We're really a troubled creature.
- 1:53:24And there's a lot of humans, right?
- 1:53:26but resources are limited and scarce meaning we can only if we have a steak and in front of us
- 1:53:35either you eat it or i eat it there's a potential conflict over who can allocate these resources
- 1:53:41according to his own problems and and so we need to address this conflict in in any shape or form
- 1:53:48right and and there is a couple different ways that we could go about it we can do it like the
- 1:53:53un nobody owns it neither of us gets to eat it it will rot on the table and we both starve so that's
- 1:54:00not a great solution but when they say nobody owns it they mean we own it basically that's the second
- 1:54:05thing of both of us the plebs don't own it but there's a priest over there right and he's a
- 1:54:11special human so he actually owns it he gets to decide who gets it right and you know he chooses
- 1:54:18whichever of us gets to eat it or maybe he just takes it all for himself right so here we have a
- 1:54:22priest class, different quality of human. And that doesn't seem right. This guy is just a dude like
- 1:54:29you and me. So we would like to have a rule that is defensible across all the categories, right? So
- 1:54:36to make sure that it just makes sense for everyone involved ultimately. And so this
- 1:54:42slave and master differentiation doesn't seem to be right. There's also economic reasons why this
- 1:54:49leads to all types of misallocation of resources but that's kind of a later part of the conclusion
- 1:54:53and then the third way would be well either you or i own it specifically whoever homesteaded it
- 1:55:01right who raised the cow right who butchered it who cooked the steak that was intermingling your
- 1:55:07labor with scarce resources and that were previously not owned and therefore the person
- 1:55:14who did it gets it. And that is a property right, right? The right of how to allocate the scarce
- 1:55:21resource that can only be allocated in one place at one time in one way. And that is property rights
- 1:55:28based on homesteading. And this is one of the three options of how we can allocate those resources.
- 1:55:34And it's clearly the most defensible from common sense logic, but also from the consequences that
- 1:55:41rise out of that because obviously if nobody owns it we all die right because nobody gets to eat
- 1:55:46anything if we have a priest class then naturally all the capital will flow to them and so we will
- 1:55:51have insanely rich slave masters and very poor and suffering slaves um obviously not great and
- 1:55:59and and so the third way is that whoever is productive gets to choose how to allocate the
- 1:56:05fruits of his labors in his continual quest of productivity and this means that we reward those
- 1:56:10who create and to some extent we punish those who who don't right if if you cannot raise your
- 1:56:16own meat and butcher it and and and cook it then you will go hungry because you cannot go to your
- 1:56:21neighbor who did it correctly and just hit him until he gives you the steak and what i just my
- 1:56:29mind is blown and it's reeling what happens to ownership when and this may not happen but i think
- 1:56:38probably will when ai takes scarcity away because then we we live in a really great world
- 1:56:46because we'll have abundance right abundance is having scarce resources that can only be
- 1:56:52allocated for one specific task by one specific person at one specific time but we have so many
- 1:56:57goods available that we simply don't care about it like ownership so ownership doesn't even become
- 1:57:04a thing. Ownership is a solution
- 1:57:06to a problem of a conflict
- 1:57:08of allocating resources. Of scarcity.
- 1:57:10Yes. Ownership
- 1:57:11is the solution to scarcity.
- 1:57:14Yes. So without scarcity, you don't
- 1:57:16need ownership. One great example for this.
- 1:57:18It's a bit communistic, mate.
- 1:57:19It is, but
- 1:57:21it's a good type of communism.
- 1:57:24So, for example,
- 1:57:25I'm a communist of air
- 1:57:27here, right? There's air in this room.
- 1:57:30And it's
- 1:57:31abundant, right? You can breathe as much
- 1:57:33as you want we won't run out of it i can breathe as much as you want there is no real conflict over
- 1:57:38who gets to breathe this air in this room it's abundant our atmosphere is amazing right now let's
- 1:57:44go underwater on a scuba diving session and we have one bottle of compressed air right and we're
- 1:57:50very far down and it'll take us a long way to come up and we have only so much air and it's not enough
- 1:57:55for the both of us, right?
- 1:57:57Now, all of a sudden,
- 1:57:58we've reintroduced the unabundance,
- 1:58:02like air is abundant above water.
- 1:58:05It's very much not abundant below water, right?
- 1:58:08And as soon as it's not abundant and scarce,
- 1:58:11then we need to allocate the resources
- 1:58:13and there needs to be a way that we figure it out, right?
- 1:58:16So in the scuba diving example,
- 1:58:18whoever packed it gets it.
- 1:58:20Maybe out of the goodness of your heart,
- 1:58:22you decide to sacrifice your own use of error and give it to someone else but it's still your
- 1:58:28property it's still your property yeah that's incredible oh my god i'm so retarded sometimes
- 1:58:35there's a lot of things that i i i wish i'd thought about a long time ago um but
- 1:58:41property it's such a it's on the face value it's such a boring subject but actually it's a
- 1:58:49deeply, deeply, deeply interesting thing. And, um, and it's funny because economics is the same and
- 1:58:59it's all wrapped up in the same, you know, value transfer property, all this kind of stuff. You,
- 1:59:04you'd never know as a young child that this is, could be as deeply fascinating as it is,
- 1:59:10but it is. And they don't teach that. I mean, I'm already thinking about how I'm going to broach
- 1:59:15this subject with my kids because because i'm gonna and it's it's it's completely important
- 1:59:21because it solves all kids have a real problem with property don't they it's like a it's a real
- 1:59:27issue for kids oh it's my stuff or it's this or kind of and and this is really helping me
- 1:59:33mediate it's really helping me understand the best way to mediate these things you know
- 1:59:39I started my economics career as a kid.
- 1:59:43And the main reason why I got interested in this was because I had to work.
- 1:59:47Work is a great teacher on a lot of aspects, specifically about, let's call it entrepreneurial logic.
- 1:59:55I wanted to understand why do we have to work in the first place because it sucks.
- 2:00:02But that's scarcity as well, right?
- 2:00:04That's the reason we have to work.
- 2:00:06Scarcity.
- 2:00:06And the reason, and work creates property.
- 2:00:10Yeah.
- 2:00:11And work creates abundance, right?
- 2:00:13Which cures property right Yeah No Oh no The solution of how can we reach communism is really hard work oh my god uh i don know i don know i i i just reached the edge of my um my sort of
- 2:00:36psychological aura i think you know how you've got this kind of bubble of knowledge i'm sitting
- 2:00:43on the edge yeah and my feet are dangling into chaos i can feel it i'm that's a great place to be
- 2:00:49in that's where the fun starts it is where the fun starts but if in my case it's where i just go
- 2:00:54i look like i'm looking at the tv as a young child yeah no but like that's that's the thing
- 2:01:01man when when i so after i started working i i picked up like keynesian bullshit economics books
- 2:01:07from the library ultimately, right?
- 2:01:10And I didn't get it at all.
- 2:01:12It was so weird.
- 2:01:13It didn't make any sense.
- 2:01:15It was not useful, right?
- 2:01:16I came there with a problem of like,
- 2:01:18why do we work?
- 2:01:19How do I become a better entrepreneur?
- 2:01:21Basically, none of that was discussed.
- 2:01:23So I kept looking
- 2:01:24and eventually found the Austrian school.
- 2:01:27And compared to the crap of Keynesianism
- 2:01:30and communism and that economic theory,
- 2:01:33it's so obvious.
- 2:01:34It's so naturally obvious
- 2:01:37that you don't need fancy words to describe it.
- 2:01:40You don't need crazy math formulas or whatever.
- 2:01:43You need like a paragraph of logic, basically.
- 2:01:47Why are communistic ideas so prevalent, though, in the West?
- 2:01:51What's that all about?
- 2:01:53I mean, really, you have to think of it like that.
- 2:01:57You have to look at Western civilization in its current form and go,
- 2:02:02there's a lot of collectivist ideas absolutely in control.
- 2:02:07Yeah. Well, propaganda, brainwashing, and mind control.
- 2:02:12Yeah, but why?
- 2:02:13Why?
- 2:02:14Because the slave masters profit from it.
- 2:02:17But how come they manage to profit from it? It's insane.
- 2:02:21I mean, if the slave thinks that his current situation is just and good and proper, then why would he ever rebel, right? Or do anything about it?
- 2:02:31Yeah, I'm thinking more about the motivation of the slave master.
- 2:02:35I mean, he gets to keep the slaves. That's great for him.
- 2:02:37I don't think there's many of them compared to the other ones.
- 2:02:41It's a really weird quirk.
- 2:02:42That's why the psychology is so important.
- 2:02:46Today's slave masters are master psychologists.
- 2:02:50They might know nothing about economics,
- 2:02:52but they do know psychology deeply, deeply well.
- 2:02:57And how to twist the mind into doing something
- 2:03:02that is anti-human and anti-the person who does the actions.
- 2:03:06right but there is thousands tens of thousands year of years of of wisdom tradition built up
- 2:03:14on how to make sure that the king stays the king right that is the number one concern of anyone
- 2:03:20in power with power over others of how do i make sure that the slaves don't rebel against me and
- 2:03:25kill me because they have every reason to it's the asymmetry of it though that doesn't seem
- 2:03:30sustainable. Do you know what I mean? Like the fact that we often trend towards this
- 2:03:37arrangement of a couple, a small number of people in charge of masses of people,
- 2:03:45just, it seems illogical. There's this weird asymmetry, but it's, but it's obviously part of
- 2:03:51the human condition, isn't it? I don't know what, I mean, maybe we're evolving out of it. Maybe we
- 2:03:56Maybe this is a journey. Maybe these ideas of freedom, free market are this time. There's an evolutionary step there. I don't know. Is it possible or is this just a merry-go-round that just keeps going around and around and around?
- 2:04:12I think a lot of the old tricks still work very well. And technology has made new tricks work way better. I mean, if the masters of propaganda would have today's technology available, back in the days, you could make maybe a radio broadcast and everyone had the same propaganda.
- 2:04:35And, you know, people were probably talking about it and in their own club saying, you know, how this is BS or whatever.
- 2:04:42Nowadays, we can make tailor-made propaganda specialized for that one individual where we have terabytes of data of what are his preferences, what are his weaknesses, how can we control him and manipulate him.
- 2:04:55And then on top of that, if there is anyone resisting, then we will catch that in our surveillance efforts and we can exclude that person, call him a racist anti-Semite terrorist and single him out so that his influence of getting other people out of the propaganda will be tragically diminished.
- 2:05:14I spoke to a guy a few months ago about AI and he pointed out that probably in the not too distant future, like TikTok-like platforms, if not TikTok itself, will just be 100% AI generated content in the moment, specifically for you.
- 2:05:34It'll be like, you know, you think social media is addictive now.
- 2:05:39You wait till in real time an AI is generating lifelike videos specifically for your brain and pumping them out at you.
- 2:05:49And what kind of dystopia is that, man?
- 2:05:52That is unbelievable when you think about it.
- 2:05:55Well, but there is a chance that we use this tech for good.
- 2:06:00And we just need to put our freedom propaganda and ship it first.
- 2:06:03you know maybe that's how we get everyone no i don't think it is because i don't think people
- 2:06:09want that yeah you have to want it like the the way the algorithm works is on your attention is
- 2:06:16it spots what you like very very quickly and it could be a microsecond that you pause that it's
- 2:06:21aha you know and then it pulls that thread and then it goes for it and if you're not interested
- 2:06:26in freedom mate there's no way they're going to show you freedom freedom content and i don't think
- 2:06:31many people are. I think it's 15, 20% of the world at any one time, probably less.
- 2:06:37Probably less.
- 2:06:38Yeah. And I don't think that's going to change. That's what makes me, I don't know.
- 2:06:43You know, like the dream would be, especially if you believe in freedom, is I want everyone to be
- 2:06:47free. And I think if you go down that path for a number of years, you realize actually,
- 2:06:54whilst I still would like everyone to be free, I'm not fighting for that. I'm fighting for myself
- 2:06:59and my family and probably right at the end you're just fighting for yourself you know and and some
- 2:07:04people just actually don't want it so who are you to tell them what they would like that that's why
- 2:07:10i love the second realm and crypto anarchy so much because we're not trying to force anyone to join us
- 2:07:16like we're not trying to take down the old system and and and make it stop those systems can continue
- 2:07:23we're not fighting against them we're building something better that we think is better right
- 2:07:28Maybe you disagree and that's totally fine and sure you can try to stop us, but we will continue building something that we prefer and then we'll use it.
- 2:07:37And it seems to me that the value created, the capital accumulated in a free system will be so outrageously larger than whatever the slavery system can produce that over enough time it will be clear which system is more beneficial to more and more people.
- 2:07:56and then people will move at that point.
- 2:07:59That was what first got me interested
- 2:08:02in the Free Cities movement.
- 2:08:04Titus was talking about something on a stage and he said you know we going to build this thing right And if you like it great come If you don don And people kept saying opt in to me opt in opt in And it really started making sense
- 2:08:16And I had a very funny conversation recently on this podcast
- 2:08:20where we were discussing the notion of free cities
- 2:08:24as thousands of competing jurisdictions.
- 2:08:27And the natural conclusion you draw from that is,
- 2:08:30sure, a free city can be anything.
- 2:08:33it's just that it's competing right so you can have a communist free city if you want
- 2:08:39but what's going to happen is it's going to attract the people that want the free shit
- 2:08:43and no one's going to go there and it's going to collapse and what free cities if they really did
- 2:08:49evolve into a competing set of places slowly but surely they would show what governance works best
- 2:08:56they'd literally be a signal yeah it's incredible really and you know it's a little bit
- 2:09:02similar to what happened with with cryptocurrencies right like cypherpunks tried to build online money
- 2:09:08for decades right satoshi figured something out that still works today which is a miracle but
- 2:09:16what he mainly figured out was that he started the age of anarchy in money
- 2:09:21where back in the day it was outrageous to even think or contemplate that a private person could
- 2:09:28issue his own money right that would be ridiculous only the central bank can do that it was highly
- 2:09:33restricted of who can start a new money and if you were the one starting a new money you got killed
- 2:09:38straight away right um even if you dare to for example use gold right like gaddafi or whatever
- 2:09:44um straight to gulag um then after satoshi we've decreased the cost of creating a new money
- 2:09:51like tragically like you there's literally a website to it now is there there's a website
- 2:09:57where you with a couple clicks and a nice pretty user interface can create a fork of bitcoin that
- 2:10:02has whatever parameters you want you know two minute block time five megabyte blocks and you
- 2:10:09know whatever hundred million tokens in total circulation whatever right it's it's super easy
- 2:10:14to do it's just code and we can now do it not once but a million times every day it's so cool
- 2:10:22So hardcore anarchy free money in a free market in the production of new money.
- 2:10:29And that started a competition of money that is something that we've never seen before.
- 2:10:36And sure, Bitcoin is still to this day the best one that we found so far, right?
- 2:10:43And that's great.
- 2:10:44But the fact that there is competition will make sure that we will find a solution.
- 2:10:50like i'm not married to bitcoin people think that if bitcoin fails for whatever reason that that was
- 2:10:55it i don't think so at all right we've we finally are over the hump where individuals can anonymously
- 2:11:02even create a new money and design it however they see fit and then publish it and people on the
- 2:11:08market will will choose it to use it or not isn't it that the free market can only exist in a place
- 2:11:14where people aren't making decisions in a way.
- 2:11:17Not making decisions, but like a free market
- 2:11:20can't really occur in the world.
- 2:11:22There's always going to be some limitation
- 2:11:25because to be human is to sort of meddle a little bit
- 2:11:30with the free market.
- 2:11:30Whereas online in code, without the human element,
- 2:11:35you get pure free market principles, don't you?
- 2:11:40Is that true?
- 2:11:40Well, I guess free market is an absence of coercion, right? And I guess specifically if we want to pin down on one thing that makes a free market, it's the non-existence of monopolies. So a monopoly, according to Austrian economics, happens whenever someone can prevent a new market participant from providing a service.
- 2:12:03Which is coercion, though.
- 2:12:05It's coercion, exactly.
- 2:12:06You can, at point of force, stop someone from doing a service because you need a license, because you need to pay some taxes, because you need to have special education or whatever.
- 2:12:17But all those things are human interactions.
- 2:12:20You can't do that in code, can you?
- 2:12:23If everyone is using, say Bitcoin, if everyone's using the same software, you can try, you can introduce a bit of malicious code that does that, but it doesn't have an effect.
- 2:12:33It only has effect on your version of it.
- 2:12:36Well, I mean, maybe one example for this is the cookie banner bullshit that the EU put upon us, right?
- 2:12:41That every website now has to declare that it's using something as basic as a cookie and annoy users with stupid pop-ups.
- 2:12:47And you have to say yes or no or whatever.
- 2:12:48Exactly. Right. So that is an intervention, a triangular intervention where the state says to people, you can only have a website if you put up the stupid cookie banner. And if you don't, you go to jail.
- 2:13:00Do you?
- 2:13:01Probably. Right. I mean, that's the thing.
- 2:13:03I've got one of those. We're not in the EU, am I? Probably the same in the UK.
- 2:13:07Okay, but that's with any time where you're violating a state law, ultimately death is the consequence.
- 2:13:14Like if you would consistently resist and say, no, I will not do a cookie number or cookie banner, whatever, then they come by your door and say, hey, you have to do this.
- 2:13:23And say, no, then we'll take you to jail.
- 2:13:25And when you still say no, then they will threaten to shoot you.
- 2:13:28And if you still say no, they will shoot you.
- 2:13:30Right.
- 2:13:31The ultimate tool of the state is death.
- 2:13:34Always has been.
- 2:13:35And the threat of death is usually enough to get people to do what they want.
- 2:13:44I was going to say, let's end it there.
- 2:13:47We've been talking for a really long time now.
- 2:13:49And I would go on for another five hours.
- 2:13:52But I need to process some stuff because you've really just helped me to discover a whole new avenue that I'm going to pursue.
- 2:14:04It's funny.
- 2:14:04I'm still in shock that there is, once again, another aspect of thought that I just didn't bother thinking about.
- 2:14:14Which is weird when you think about it.
- 2:14:16We're so great at ignoring stuff.
- 2:14:18Like really deeply, we ignore so much of the sensory input that we get.
- 2:14:23And the same goes for ideas.
- 2:14:24I mean, there's too many ideas to ever contemplate, even partially, right?
- 2:14:29I know what you mean.
- 2:14:30I feel like I'm entertaining too many at the moment.
- 2:14:33I need to go and lie down.
- 2:14:34let's end on a really positive note mate um um what is there like let's go back to your book
- 2:14:45because i think and by the way can i call this episode the praxeology of privacy is that is that
- 2:14:50cool yeah sure because i think that's a really interesting set of words and i think it would be
- 2:14:54interesting people would see that and go what the hell does that mean i think it might draw people
- 2:14:58in i'm not stealing it i i'm i'm borrowing it like the the good thing is uh you can't steal ideas yes
- 2:15:05and i published this book in the public domain like have you yeah like so you can get the book
- 2:15:11on towards liberty.com slash pop um will be in the show notes as well i'm sure and um there is
- 2:15:19just all the chapters all the pdfs etc do whatever the fuck you want with it um i'm gonna print it
- 2:15:25after some round of review already some people started printing the book you know great um but i
- 2:15:31i want to make sure those ideas are at least not terribly wrong i know what you mean it is it is it
- 2:15:37is scary isn't it committing a bunch of especially if you took a long time to to come up with them
- 2:15:43it's quite scary to commit them to a piece of paper or or a tome and then think uh you know a
- 2:15:51year later going oh my god at least if it digital you can kind of edit them a bit but i mean i i i think certainly in its in its core is quite a bit like well my john locke experience it like it it using extreme logic i can prove that thing so so there
- 2:16:14is a limit i mean we're talking about if in order to disprove certain things you need to enter some
- 2:16:19weird quantum realm of of brand of madness or whatever and i don't think that people are going
- 2:16:25there you know but you're pretty sure you've you've got it cornered all right with praxeology
- 2:16:32of privacy yeah yeah it's it it's a it's a really cool topic and like i i know there's a lot of
- 2:16:38austrian economists listening to your to your show i mean there's a lot of other people as well
- 2:16:41which is great but especially the austrian economists it's such a shame that they don't
- 2:16:47get the cypherpunks like there was i don't know why do you say that though what what is it they
- 2:16:52don't get about the cypherpunk. I mean, cypherpunks tend to be Austrian economists, right?
- 2:16:59Exactly. That's the thing. So many cypherpunks are Austrian economists, and a lot of them make
- 2:17:06quite big economic errors, but still, there's way fewer Austrian economists that are actually
- 2:17:13cypherpunks. And I'm not exactly sure why that is. It might be that the Austrian economists are
- 2:17:20just a bit boomers.
- 2:17:21No, yeah.
- 2:17:22It's like a suit and tie event.
- 2:17:24I think cypherpunks are too edgy.
- 2:17:25Yeah, they're a punk.
- 2:17:26I think your average Austrian,
- 2:17:28that I know anyway,
- 2:17:29I mean, would see, yeah,
- 2:17:33you know, someone with a hoodie at a computer.
- 2:17:35That's a cypherpunk.
- 2:17:36Whereas an Austrian economist
- 2:17:38is like gliding around Vienna
- 2:17:42who is spitting facts, you know?
- 2:17:46Yeah.
- 2:17:46And so there are a lot of great Austrian economists that did get Bitcoin, etc. early on.
- 2:17:54Stefan Kinsella, Conrad Graf, etc.
- 2:17:58And so they did a tremendous benefit of getting Bitcoiners up to speed with what the economic facts underlying Bitcoin are.
- 2:18:08And so I just want to be part of that tradition to bridge that gap and to tell economists that
- 2:18:15maybe the thing i had a really depressive period in my life when i deeply understood economics and
- 2:18:23the evils of inflation and intervention and i had no i could not see a way out of it right that is
- 2:18:31unspeakably depressive of seeing how the world is systematically collapsing
- 2:18:36and not knowing how to fix it and i feel like that that is the mindset of most austrian economists
- 2:18:42even mises was like yeah we can try it with ideas you know maybe if we talk about it enough we can
- 2:18:49fix it that's such a bullshit solution i mean obviously it's important right but that's not
- 2:18:56gonna help us they're just gonna burn the books and then that to to get out of that um out of that
- 2:19:05kind of depression you need to have a a golden future an orange future to look forward to it's
- 2:19:11something where you can see that hey actually we have it in our power to fix this not not just
- 2:19:17to stop the pain but to make it work so incredibly well like the amount of capital that we can
- 2:19:24accumulate in this new world in this new cyberspace is is outrageous it's it's baffling like look at
- 2:19:33bitcoin what we achieved in what 15 years i mean damn like it's now larger than most companies are
- 2:19:40It's larger than most fiat currencies are.
- 2:19:43And it was just a bunch of dudes in hoodies on their laptop.
- 2:19:46That's insane, right?
- 2:19:48That is the most mind-blowing, actionable improvement in the human condition for thousands of years.
- 2:19:55And we just did it, right?
- 2:19:58And we did it knowing the underlying economic reasoning for why this is going to work.
- 2:20:03and the theoretical and cryptological underpinnings of these are the cryptographic tools we can deploy
- 2:20:11to make sure that it becomes unfuckwithable right it will succeed to resist right the cost
- 2:20:18of resistance is now so low in fact resistance has become profitable if you resisted fiat inflation
- 2:20:24in the last 10 years you're a billionaire right so resistance is no longer just this dangerous
- 2:20:34thing that only weird people do right people that we shun from society no it's the people who
- 2:20:40resisted now have the treasury the capital to build new nations ultimately so this really is
- 2:20:47is an incredible success and bitcoin is just the beginning right we have so much more that
- 2:20:54the cypherpunks can build for us that especially if the cypherpunks understand just how deeply
- 2:21:01correct they are right we can give the cypherpunks even as economists we can give the cypherpunks
- 2:21:07even more wind in their sails by showing them how how how deeply correct and and how
- 2:21:14foundationally solid they are that they don't have to apologize for hey like we're working on
- 2:21:22this new privacy technology, please don't put us in jail, right? But rather, we're working on
- 2:21:28something that helps people express themselves to the fullest, that leads to them being able to
- 2:21:34calculate their allocation of resources, right? If we don't have perfect privacy, we have the same
- 2:21:41calculation problem as socialism had. We don't have adequate prices that tell us how much things
- 2:21:47are worth in a state of surveillance that is quite equivalent and so we we really have a massive
- 2:21:54theoretical underlying foundation that cypherpunks can build on top of and become even more radical
- 2:22:00i like we're not radical enough by far we can go even harder and i hope this book is is part of
- 2:22:08saying thanks to the economists for for what you did and look at what the cypherpunks did and it's
- 2:22:14perfectly in line and likewise to the cypherpunks i keep going even harder max that was a beautiful
- 2:22:20monologue wait um we've got to end it there that's just perfect really really thank you again
- 2:22:28appreciate it you blew my mind last time it took four hours this time it only took two hours so
- 2:22:33you must be getting better but but um i really appreciate you and i'm always thankful that
- 2:22:38whenever i send you a message you just turn up and we sit down and have a conversation i i i and
- 2:22:43Thanks for that.
- 2:22:44And I really hope other people can listen and go the same route,
- 2:22:48because that's why I do this.
- 2:22:50I want people to hear what I'm thinking.
- 2:22:53And because I'm learning it in real time,
- 2:22:56and my mind, my clogs are turning,
- 2:22:58and I'm really starting to understand a new level of stuff.
- 2:23:04And you're part of that journey, mate.
- 2:23:06So many, many thanks indeed.
- 2:23:07And yeah, thanks for coming over and see you next time.
- 2:23:10Thanks.
- 2:23:11No, I'm really looking forward to all of our conversations.
- 2:23:14I'm looking forward to the next one, which might be in the Gulag, you know, when they put you in jail for thought crime.
- 2:23:19I'll come visit if I'm not locked up by that point.
- 2:23:22You'll be locked up, mate.
- 2:23:23You'll be locked up before me.
- 2:23:26We'll have so much fun in the Gulag.
- 2:23:29We will.
- 2:23:29We'll orange pill the captors.
- 2:23:31It'll be fun.
- 2:23:32Great to talk to you anyway.
- 2:23:33Thank you very much.
- 2:23:41Thank you.