Latest / Newcomer Pod / Shardul Shah — "I wired the money before knowing what they were building"
Transcript
- 0:00Acquisitions to be successful, my view is they should be small
- 0:03or they should be large like middle sized.
- 0:05Acquisitions are the most difficult for both sides to be
- 0:09successful. I have drunk the kool-aid of Wiz
- 0:13more than anyone on the planet, right?
- 0:16And so to then say I'm going to switch to iced tea is super
- 0:20hard, right? What's the way for somebody to
- 0:22sort of break into being in your awareness?
- 0:25Well, I'm not everyone's cup of tea.
- 0:27Am I crazy? Yes, sort of.
- 0:29I don't know. When Google announced it was
- 0:31buying Wiz for $32 billion, one name quietly became the talk of
- 0:35venture capital. Shardul Shaw, partner at Index
- 0:38Ventures, was one of the first checks into Wiz.
- 0:41And it wasn't luck. It was pattern recognition.
- 0:43Shardul has spent nearly 2 decades at Index building a
- 0:46reputation for finding the right founders before anyone else
- 0:49does. Datadog.
- 0:50Duo, Security Coalition. The list speaks for itself.
- 0:54Today we get into the Google Wiz deal, his human first approach
- 0:57to spotting the next generation of great founders and where he's
- 1:00looking for his next big bet. I'm Eric Newcomer, the author of
- 1:04Newcomer, the subsect that tracks the inner workings of
- 1:06startups and venture capital. Follow me and my team's writing
- 1:09at newcomer.co. And without further ado, here is
- 1:12my conversation with Shardul, one of the top venture
- 1:15capitalists in the Business Today.
- 1:24All right, super excited. This is a big week for you.
- 1:28I'm here with Shardul Shaw in the Newcomer Podcast.
- 1:31Thank you for joining me. Thanks for having me man.
- 1:33Did. So we're here, you know, in
- 1:36part, I guess it's we should have like, you know, party hats
- 1:38and stuff. Google's $32 billion acquisition
- 1:41of Wiz, the cyber Israeli cyber security startup.
- 1:44Clear, the checks cleared this week.
- 1:46Is that right? Yeah, closed on Wednesday.
- 1:48Yeah, and index and you are. You're the largest investor
- 1:53shareholder, right? Yeah, and so for the party hat,
- 1:56I'd prefer a Cerebral Valley cap.
- 1:58I mean, we could have been matching at least.
- 2:00Yeah, so I guess for for people just paying attention, like
- 2:05explain you know why Google is spending all this money to buy
- 2:09Wiz in the first place. Yeah, look, the the best
- 2:12companies are always bought, not sold, right?
- 2:14And, and it starts with the founding team.
- 2:17It it's a remarkable run over six years, but it took over 20
- 2:22for this to happen. The founders have had so much
- 2:25trust. They're such different
- 2:27personalities that when they came together to create Wiz,
- 2:30they created a culture that could move so fast in a existing
- 2:35category and really disrupt the market.
- 2:38So I think ultimately what you're acquiring, whether it's a
- 2:43small, medium or large acquisition, at the core is a
- 2:46group of people and a culture that comes with it.
- 2:49One person close to Google, when this announcement first came out
- 2:53mentioned to me, it was just like, in a world of AI, cyber
- 2:56attacks are going to become even more likely.
- 2:58Obviously, we need to be very aware of cyber security.
- 3:00In some ways, this deal is a sense that like Google needs to
- 3:03be ready if there is like a major massive cyber attack, if
- 3:07they need to defend their customers, obviously it's an
- 3:09offering that they can provide cloud customers.
- 3:12I mean, now, you know, since the steel closed, now we're at war
- 3:16with Iran and that's obviously increasing the risk of
- 3:19cybersecurity. So like explain, you know, where
- 3:22Wiz sits in terms of cyber defense, why and why Google
- 3:26would want and what what they're really.
- 3:27Delivering the customers, I think you nailed that.
- 3:29There's a a cloud tailwind, right?
- 3:32More and more workloads are going to the cloud.
- 3:34We've been on this transition for over a decade.
- 3:36Finally, for example, over the last five years, the pharma
- 3:38industry has moved all of their data to the cloud.
- 3:41Second, there is a security tailwind, right?
- 3:45There's more need to secure against risks for large and
- 3:50small businesses across the world and the amount of risk is
- 3:54varied. I'll come back to that in a
- 3:55second. And then third is AI right to
- 3:58everyone knows we live in an AI era and with more AI workloads,
- 4:03there is a demand for more security on the back of those 3
- 4:08tailwinds. It just so happens with is at
- 4:11the center and like that's not by luck, right?
- 4:14They've been intentionally crafting their business to be
- 4:18there. They started with a platform
- 4:20that serve large enterprises from the get go.
- 4:23And so it's really complementary with all of the resources and
- 4:27the AI infrastructure that Google has.
- 4:30So take me back to the beginning.
- 4:32I mean you what I think I was reading this was the Claude
- 4:36synopsis, so hopefully this is correct.
- 4:38But what you they stood you up for 45 minutes, the founder
- 4:41before your first meeting or what?
- 4:43What were you? What did you see when you first
- 4:45when Wiz was first on your radar and why?
- 4:47How? It felt like, have have you been
- 4:48to an Indian wedding? Not a not a huge Indian wedding.
- 4:52I've I've been to a 50% Indian wedding now that I yeah.
- 4:55OK, so this story is like 50% true.
- 4:58Like irrespective of the size, right, People are fashionably on
- 5:02time. Yeah.
- 5:03And so my reception of Asaf being a few minutes late was he
- 5:08was on time. So Claude's got it wrong and
- 5:10turns. Out you were not offended by the
- 5:13you, is it? No.
- 5:15And and I think a lot of individuals have had a similar
- 5:19experience with ASAF, but you know, what started late really
- 5:24escalated because in 72 hours we had a term sheet signed ASAF and
- 5:29I had this unusual kind of chemistry and click from the
- 5:34first moment that we met. I can't really like I can't
- 5:38explain it right and you can't like prepare for that.
- 5:43All VCs are salespeople. I'm not the best as you know,
- 5:48but you can great VC. Definitely at this point with
- 5:51Datadog and Wiz, we'll talk about that.
- 5:53But you're saying not you don't see yourself as a salesperson?
- 5:56Well, I think salespeople can be really prepared, but you can't
- 5:59prepare for serendipity, right? And so sometimes you just click
- 6:03with someone and it was both professional and personal.
- 6:06And we're finding ourselves completing each other's
- 6:09sentences. And so that was the first, that
- 6:14was the first moment for me. It was on the back of another
- 6:17friendship I had with Michael Sholoff.
- 6:20Michael was the, at the time, he was the founder of Lacun
- 6:23Security. Lacun, is this a pretty deep cut
- 6:28into Greek mythology that clearly Claude didn't tell you
- 6:31about, but I encourage you to look up afterwards.
- 6:34He's this like priest involved in the Trojan Horror Story.
- 6:38So Michael, who became a friend of mine, I invested in his
- 6:41company. I didn't know anything about
- 6:42security. And so he's like, I've got to
- 6:44make use of Shardul as a board member.
- 6:46So he sent me hunting for customer relationships and help
- 6:51building out his management team.
- 6:54Again, accidentally, Michael and I became friends after Fanny and
- 6:58he had their first kid. I, I was on the I was on the top
- 7:01three of of folks who got a phone call right because we
- 7:04really cared about each other. And so Michael by pure chance
- 7:08introduced me to Asaf and Asaf and I by pure chance clicked.
- 7:15Fast forward a decade, Asaf calls me on my birthday and he's
- 7:19like, hey, let's go and. It was much time for the deal.
- 7:23It was. It was done.
- 7:24It was clear like that this was going to be like it's you and
- 7:27Sequoia are doing the first round, right?
- 7:29Gilly, Doug Leoni. Well, no, Gilly, Doug Leoni and
- 7:33I all joined the board at the first round.
- 7:36And so when Asaf called, he's like, let's like we're working,
- 7:40we're working on a new company, let's go.
- 7:41I was like, I'm in. He's like, do you want to hear
- 7:43what we're doing? And I was like, it's a detail,
- 7:47which is a true story. And a week after we had wired
- 7:53the money, we were together in San Francisco, he said, hey,
- 7:55sure. We pivoted.
- 7:56I was like, OK, great. Like we didn't write a memo
- 7:59anyway. Like what, what are we working
- 8:01on? And, and and so there was the,
- 8:04the only, the only thing to invest in was like belief in the
- 8:09founders. And again, we had this the
- 8:10benefit of having a front row seat 10 years ago.
- 8:14So we knew their character. We knew the lessons they had
- 8:17learned within Microsoft after they sold the Adalim.
- 8:21And as a consequence, we knew how they were thinking about
- 8:23building a a culture and a platform from the gecko.
- 8:29How much do you remember? How much money you put in right
- 8:30at the beginning? No, I I couldn't give you dates.
- 8:33I couldn't give you numbers. It was like us.
- 8:35It was like, I imagine it was small relative to the overall
- 8:38investment over time. Yeah, exactly it, it was like a
- 8:41a standard seed investment. Later that year it was a we we
- 8:48led the series. A a few months later, we let Co
- 8:52led the next round and then like we kept going and, and so over
- 8:56time we broke a lot of rules, right.
- 8:58We invested out of four funds, which is the first time we've
- 9:01done that in in index's history. First time that many funds or
- 9:04across funds? First time that many funds with
- 9:09Datadog, for example, we'd also invested across funds with a
- 9:12number of. I realize this used to be out of
- 9:14vogue and venture, and now everyone's concluded you have to
- 9:16double down on your winners to succeed, right?
- 9:22I think it's more complicated. So let's see if I, if I break it
- 9:26down in the, in the industry, one of the things that's unusual
- 9:31about index is we have one team across strategies.
- 9:34So like many other large firms, we have a seed fund, a venture
- 9:37fund and a growth fund, right? But most other firms have
- 9:40specialization, which makes a lot of sense.
- 9:42Like, people who think about early stage risk are often
- 9:45different than those who think about late stage risk.
- 9:48And so for those businesses, often doubling down requires
- 9:53like convincing a different group of people, right?
- 9:56And they have a different apparatus to make decisions.
- 9:59And that's not all bad, right? Because when?
- 10:03When? Holds you, it makes you honest.
- 10:04It's like somebody else has to review and say, are we doubling
- 10:06down on sort? Of a bad investment.
- 10:08It's it's like a type of check and balance and it's a type of
- 10:11specialization that ought to support like high quality
- 10:15judgement calls. So it's a, it's a way of doing
- 10:17business doesn't work at index. At index every time we've had a
- 10:21silo, it hasn't worked. So we converged, I think in
- 10:242010, we converged our venture and growth teams into a single
- 10:28team. So all of us are responsible for
- 10:31all of our distinct fund strategies all over the world,
- 10:35globally, yeah. Because that's another area
- 10:38where firms also divide it up sometimes about.
- 10:40Yeah, absolutely. And we can come back to like why
- 10:42that's super hard and why we're like unusual in that dimension.
- 10:46And it's not for everyone. This is not like a pitch on like
- 10:48redesign your venture firm like it's just our culture supports
- 10:52one team across GI. Do you have?
- 10:54Given that you don't have separate growth investors, does
- 10:56that make you more reluctant to do this sort of multi fund so
- 11:00within? Within index it it's it's so
- 11:02personality driven, right? So for me, in order to develop
- 11:06deeper conviction time, I require contacts, right?
- 11:09So I spend a lot of time with the management team.
- 11:11I really like have a log into the product and I'm testing it
- 11:14frequently. I spend time with the go to
- 11:17market team. I spend time with the marketing
- 11:18team without crossing the boundaries of a board member
- 11:22kind of getting involved. And fortunately I'm not an
- 11:24operator, so I can't really tell anybody what to do.
- 11:26But I can learn a lot from contacts for a company that
- 11:30helps because I can make high quality judgement calls on like
- 11:33who to recruit, when and how and why, which can change the
- 11:37trajectory of businesses. But for index, it gives me more
- 11:40context now Second, as a personality, when I'm in the
- 11:44sausage making, I see the warts, right?
- 11:47And so as optimistic as I am as a natural born venture
- 11:52capitalist of a fair amount of skepticism, right?
- 11:55And as a consequence, I can get really close to warts.
- 12:00And when I see flaws, I really study them.
- 12:02So no, it's not easy for me to develop deeper conviction over
- 12:08time. It's it's actually really
- 12:10challenging right you? Understand what the potential
- 12:12risks are of the business. No.
- 12:14That's actually not true. I think far more about the
- 12:17opportunity in the upside than risk calculus.
- 12:20I actually think it's a fool's errand to to, you know, try to
- 12:23attempt risk calculus. I think it's overweighted in our
- 12:27industry, right? And it's like human nature, it
- 12:29make the. Bet you have to see sort of the
- 12:31big upsides, but I I thought you were saying by seeing the
- 12:33awards, that's that's what gives you this sort of yeah, but.
- 12:36When, like when you imagine if, if you start to see blemishes in
- 12:41the room and they start attracting your attention, all
- 12:44of a sudden it's harder to see beauty, right?
- 12:46So it, it can be more difficult and challenging to see the whole
- 12:50picture when you're attracted to awards because you want to talk
- 12:52about problems to fix them, right?
- 12:54So it's hard for me. However, the, the good news
- 12:58about index is I don't make any decisions.
- 13:01It's it's a true partnership. And as a consequence, at every
- 13:04single phase, we're having debates, right?
- 13:07We debated the market, we debated the product, we debated
- 13:11the quality of the execution and attraction.
- 13:14We debated gross margins, we debated strategy.
- 13:17We debated so many things. And very few of our investment
- 13:22decisions were actually unanimous.
- 13:25What does that tell you? It tells you we have a culture
- 13:27that promotes dissent because we want to get to the highest
- 13:31quality judgement calls. We shouldn't confuse like the
- 13:34judgement calls that we serially made with the outcome.
- 13:37Like that doesn't mean the judgement calls were right.
- 13:39But we went as a group into really high quality judgement
- 13:43calls, which unlocks the ability to double down against
- 13:47conviction. And you can see there were like
- 13:49the some of the best firms on the planet with the best minds
- 13:53that took a different view. They were not like wrong.
- 13:56They just took a different view. Right was.
- 13:58There so you end up in the largest position even though
- 14:00there are three investors there Yeah absolutely right so that's
- 14:03key So what was the next key decision like was there a
- 14:06particular round or when do you think you really like put more
- 14:10money in a way that others might have missed or that you're
- 14:13you're proud of every single. One right?
- 14:15Just like. Continuing.
- 14:16Yeah, well. So so the Series A, what's the
- 14:19context that maybe I rotated against?
- 14:22There were two key customers, one of the two I had introduced
- 14:27and the the buyer at that company is a he'll remain
- 14:32unnamed, but he's an intellectual snob, right?
- 14:35And, and he doesn't do any, do me any favors, right?
- 14:38So when he made $1,000,000 purchase order decision in four
- 14:42weeks and sent me a voice message that sounded like a
- 14:46country song, I had distinct asymmetric information.
- 14:52And I read into the qualitative of that signal more than the
- 14:56quantitative #2. Soon after that company received
- 15:03like conventional wisdom, which is like, hey founders, you guys
- 15:06have sold some, some customers, right?
- 15:09That's great. Now you should hire a couple
- 15:10sales people, right to see if we can scale the apparatus of the
- 15:13business and right place, right time.
- 15:17There's an individual Colin Jones.
- 15:19He was previously at Duo Security, a company I had
- 15:22happened to invest in many years prior.
- 15:24And I knew Colin Jones's mentor Jim Sib and I knew Sib's mentor,
- 15:28Zac Urlacher. Urlacher is now a venture
- 15:30partner with Index. Sib had joined another one of
- 15:34our companies subsequently and I knew both Urlacher and Sib were
- 15:38telling CJ don't join a company. Pre product market fit the way
- 15:43to define pre product market. If it is $10 million of revenue,
- 15:46I was like CJ they are wrong. Asaf was being told hire 2 sales
- 15:52people and I was like Asaf that is wrong.
- 15:55And so I got involved and CJ joined, right.
- 15:58That gave us asymmetric information because we need the
- 16:01personalities that unlocked the next round of financing.
- 16:06I continue to spend a huge amount of time with, you know,
- 16:08Kostick and, and, and AMI Ludwick.
- 16:11AMI is this like genius who lives in the future, right?
- 16:15And it's so challenging to talk to him because he's, he's like
- 16:19always, right? But it's like Socratic and he's
- 16:22like trying to lead you to truth because he's such a teacher.
- 16:25What's what's? His role, What's he do?
- 16:27He's ACTO. OK.
- 16:29And Kosticka is world class product, right?
- 16:34Like top 2-3 product leaders I've ever come across.
- 16:38He's able to shape a promise that is current that he will
- 16:43deliver on. He's also challenging.
- 16:46And so there's there's constantly tension between the
- 16:49two. And when I started talking to
- 16:51them in depth about what the product road map and what the
- 16:55product vision would be, the opportunity that was present for
- 16:59Wiz just kept expanding. And so my view of what was
- 17:03possible for the business continued to grow.
- 17:05So we had to get more involved and, and like I can keep going
- 17:10with like individuals like Dolly Rajeek who have been trying to
- 17:13recruit for a decade when he joined the company, the impact
- 17:17he made on the business or Fossil Merchant who literally
- 17:21had introduced us off 2 years before he joined.
- 17:24Like I, I knew the inflections of the business, the.
- 17:28I'm going to stay on Wiz, but I want to digress for one second
- 17:30for sure. I mean, you're clearly like, I'm
- 17:33convinced, like a scholar of the people like has this, has this
- 17:36like a sort of philosophy of really just like analyzing the
- 17:39team ever LED you like a stray or like, I imagine it's tempting
- 17:43to be like, these are great people, the numbers.
- 17:46They don't say what the people should or like what, yeah.
- 17:50What do you do in sort of other investments where you've have
- 17:52you found this sort of disconnect between the people
- 17:55and the money, you know? Where where I've I've been wrong
- 17:59and I'm most insecure is making judgements of people over Zoom.
- 18:05I think I have a really hard time finding connection and like
- 18:10feeling someone over Zoom. And it's reciprocal, I think.
- 18:13I mean, I think the first time we were on together, it was over
- 18:15Zoom. This is way more fun, right?
- 18:17Yeah. Exactly.
- 18:18You sort of, yeah. And I, I think it's like body
- 18:21language, it's micro expressions.
- 18:24I have more comfort with pregnant pauses and like space
- 18:28in a room. And so it's very interesting
- 18:31Craddock for me. I have partners who are
- 18:33phenomenal at like reading people over Zoom.
- 18:36And so I don't make decisions now like I won't, I won't invest
- 18:40in a founder over Zoom. An example, Asaf introduced me
- 18:44to someone. Actually, I met them on Thursday
- 18:46morning over Zoom. And I was like, guys, you know,
- 18:49there's something here, but I don't make decisions over Zoom.
- 18:52And I had some health stuff going on in the family.
- 18:55So they were like, we're on the next flight.
- 18:58And I was like, whoa. And they're going through Italy.
- 19:01I'm like, I could just buy you a better flight.
- 19:02And they're already in air. And so they land in New York
- 19:06City. And 6:00 AM on Saturday we start
- 19:10with a walk around Central Park. We hang out, lunch, you know,
- 19:16drinks, etcetera. 2:00 AM we finish at Mckittrick Hotel.
- 19:19Oh my God. I don't know if you've been.
- 19:20To is that. What?
- 19:21Isn't that where they used to do the those live shows?
- 19:24The am I crazy? Yes.
- 19:26Sort of. I don't know, but you are.
- 19:28Crazy, but I'm not sure. About this story I'm thinking.
- 19:31Of sleep no more. But Oh yeah, no.
- 19:32That's totally that is that is I thought that.
- 19:34Was called the Mckittrick. Maybe I'm.
- 19:37Mckittrick hotel became sleep no more that I would not recommend
- 19:42as like founder dating or like dating in real life.
- 19:44Don't even talk. It'd be terrible.
- 19:45Just found new dating dude my. Wife was so creeped out when I
- 19:48took her there. I mean, for some people it's
- 19:51like a it's a terrific experience.
- 19:54Not your not not my scene. Yeah, but it's shut down now.
- 19:57Kit trick, what I'm referring to, OK, has this incredible,
- 20:00like Speakeasy bar, OK, where you walk up and they don't have
- 20:03a menu and you tell them the direction of the drink that you
- 20:06walk. OK, OK.
- 20:07And then you walk next door and you you get into this like full
- 20:11laundromat and you walk through the laundromat to get to the
- 20:16like basically a mahjong parlor in the back, which has an
- 20:19incredible mood and ambiance. And you get to see five
- 20:22different. I think it's about 5 different.
- 20:24Acts of close up magic through the night.
- 20:27So I'm a nerd. I love you guys.
- 20:29Love magic I. Absolutely do this is 1.
- 20:32Of the things I definitely know about Index, you were like
- 20:34magicians at parties. I love it at our.
- 20:36Opening at our office opening in New York, I insisted that we
- 20:40have a magician from Mckittrick come over.
- 20:43So we finished the night at 2:00 AM at Mckittrick, my favorite
- 20:48place perhaps on earth. And we shake hands on working
- 20:52together, right? The day of the next day, we talk
- 20:56about numbers, like, what is the deal?
- 20:58Yeah. The next day, I tell my partners
- 21:00I've done this right? And I ask for forgiveness, not
- 21:03permission. And like, I think approximately
- 21:052 two weeks later, the company actually incorporates.
- 21:08And what company is this? It's still in style.
- 21:11Wow, it's the next one people should be chasing.
- 21:13If if a founder gets you to be out till 2:00 AM, they're gonna
- 21:16get your money. They're like, what, what, what
- 21:19time in the day? You're like, this wouldn't still
- 21:21be going on. If he's not, he's not ready to
- 21:23check. Like I I want to learn that from
- 21:26Olivier A a dated dog. He told me about the concept of
- 21:30a no battery. Okay, right, So like at the
- 21:32beginning of the day, your no battery is completely full.
- 21:36By the end of the day, it's like wiped out.
- 21:38So the way to get money for me, you try to get.
- 21:40Information at the end of the day.
- 21:41Exactly, exactly. Just keep talking.
- 21:43To me, and eventually I just can't.
- 21:45I can't hold it. So, so we're, we're sort of
- 21:48telling the Wiz story. We, we learned the lesson of
- 21:51like, you know, keep investing and sort of the firm deciding on
- 21:55conviction. Like I guess another key point
- 21:57in the company's history, which maybe you fit in as a board
- 22:00member, I don't actually know, is sort of the will they won't
- 22:03they with Google and sort of like, oh, do they go public?
- 22:06Do they sell at a lower price? Like what?
- 22:08What can you share about sort of that decision and how you
- 22:11thought about things? Yeah.
- 22:13You know, at a high level I've been on both sides right on on
- 22:17supporting Wiz, for example, with acquisitions, supporting
- 22:20Datadog with acquisitions, supporting Coalition with
- 22:23acquisitions. And on the other side, 10 plus
- 22:27companies of mine have been acquired by other businesses,
- 22:30Duo by Cisco Signal Sciences by Fastly and and and and many
- 22:34more, right. So I've seen both sides.
- 22:37I, I think for acquisitions to be successful, my view is they
- 22:42should be small or they should be large.
- 22:44Like middle sized acquisitions are the most difficult for both
- 22:48sides to be successful, right? And I think it's really
- 22:52important for there to be a shared concept of success,
- 22:56right. So small, small and large is
- 22:58kind of the most important zip code to plan mid size.
- 23:02Just because people don't get excited and they just walk away
- 23:05or I'm trying to understand, you're asking what are the
- 23:07common reasons that mid size yields fail or how come?
- 23:12Yeah. So the most common reasons are
- 23:14like integration #2 is notation. Enough to the company or
- 23:19exactly? It's neither here nor there,
- 23:20right? So it doesn't reserve the does
- 23:23receive, excuse me, the, the TLC needed to make it successful #2
- 23:28because it's neither small nor large, the acquired entity
- 23:33doesn't have the space to make an impact, right?
- 23:36Those are the two most common failure modes.
- 23:38And, and so as you can tell, it's more human psychology than
- 23:42like how does the product fit into the, you know, the, the
- 23:45strategy. So small and large is #1 #2 I,
- 23:50I, I learned this from Roy Resnick, who's one of the other
- 23:54Co founders of, of Wiz a decade ago at Adelum.
- 23:59One of his mentors is a is who's now passed is Zohar Zisopel.
- 24:05A, a legend in like the early tech scene of Israel.
- 24:09And when Adelum had an acquisition offer from
- 24:12Microsoft, the first question Zohar asked the founders was,
- 24:16what do you want to do? And I actually think it's a
- 24:19profound, profoundly important question.
- 24:22And I do subsequently tell founders what I think.
- 24:27But the first question is always what do you want to do?
- 24:29What? I mean, you know, Datadog is
- 24:32public, you know, that's your one of your other huge
- 24:34investments. It's I just checked, it's like
- 24:3744 billion right now or something.
- 24:39I have to check. Yeah, 4044.
- 24:42I mean, at some level, yeah. It's, I mean, it's bigger than
- 24:45the price we're talking about with Wiz, but I assume you make
- 24:48more money off, I don't know how much you're still letting things
- 24:51ride with data Datadog, but you know, a clean acquisition, you
- 24:54get paid in cash as a venture capitalist.
- 24:56That's a very desirable outcome. Or how do you think about the
- 25:00advice that VCs give of, you know, go public, go the distance
- 25:03versus everybody getting paid is, you know, a a great outcome.
- 25:07Oh. I so I don't think about
- 25:09optimizing exit like obviously from a fiduciary standpoint, as
- 25:13a board member, one of your responsibilities is to try to
- 25:16maximize shareholder value. So you see, you think about
- 25:19that, but I wouldn't confuse that with the shareholder
- 25:22interest of in what period of time, how much return do you
- 25:26generate? I think that's you have to be
- 25:28used as a founder. You should be really
- 25:30conscientious if a partner, an investor, a board member that
- 25:36you involve cannot distinguish the two.
- 25:40I'm not sure I can, so you have to dumb that down a little bit
- 25:43for me. What do you say as a board?
- 25:44Member, I'm responsible for everybody, OK, right.
- 25:47As a shareholder, I'm responsible for myself, right?
- 25:50Different OK, So you, you have to be able to acknowledge like
- 25:57your own interest and what's in in the collective interest.
- 26:01But it's it's which is speaking to one part of your question,
- 26:06right. One part of your question is
- 26:07like, well, for your, for the investor, like it can, it can
- 26:10look very different. You know, part of I think the
- 26:16job of an investor board member is to push entrepreneurs past
- 26:21their limits, right? And remove anything that's in
- 26:26the way to really experience the fullness of ambition and even
- 26:32sometimes, you know, kind of bring the goal posts further
- 26:37apart. And so the same has been true
- 26:40for for Datadog, right? Like years ago, they actually
- 26:45years ago we we talked about like a billion in revenue as a
- 26:49far off milestone. Right now we're talking about
- 26:53like a completely different level of revenue as a achievable
- 26:58milestone. So you're constantly kind of
- 27:02pushing where the company can be, whether it's AM and a or an
- 27:07IPO is more of like a moment versus a strategic, you know,
- 27:11direction to push ambition. Does that make?
- 27:13Sense it does, but they're also, you know, there's subtlety to it
- 27:16in that. So it's like, OK, you, you're
- 27:19like a shareholder, you're a board member.
- 27:21You also, you know, I imagine being an index and like a you're
- 27:25playing a repeat game. So even as a shareholder with
- 27:28LP's, you're like, listen, doing great by founders and like
- 27:31honoring the founder of vision in some ways is also in our like
- 27:34fiduciary interest. So you have that sort of
- 27:37complicated calculus. They're like the founders
- 27:41themselves have like how much more do I want to keep working
- 27:43on this versus exit? And then they also have the sort
- 27:46of obligation of like, well, is this so much a better deal?
- 27:49I mean, it's just is do you try to turn this into like a math
- 27:52calculus or like how much is it pretty soft?
- 27:55This sort of oh, how much more is this than I would have
- 27:58thought first? How much do I want to do it?
- 28:00You try and turn that into numbers or you just sort of live
- 28:02in this sort of soft squishy thing it.
- 28:05It, it does depend on the relationship with each
- 28:07entrepreneur. So last year, there's one
- 28:11entrepreneur who's got a terrific business that's growing
- 28:13super well that was, was attracting acquisition interest.
- 28:18And I was like, Hey, ask yourself 2 questions.
- 28:20Like 1. Can you 10X your company and #2
- 28:25do you have the stamina to do so?
- 28:28If the answer to both questions is no, you should probably sell,
- 28:32right? If the answer to the first one
- 28:34is yes and the second one is no, maybe we think about building,
- 28:38you know, a succession plan. If the answer to both is yes,
- 28:42what are we even talking? Stop wasting my time.
- 28:43Interesting. And those were.
- 28:44Sincere. It wasn't like, oh, I'm leading
- 28:46him to what I want. You were like, it depends on
- 28:48which one. Well.
- 28:50It can be, it can still be a conversation, right?
- 28:53Which is like you sort of have a.
- 28:54Theory, of which it is. The starting point is like,
- 28:57well, what is again? What do you think?
- 28:59Like, OK, you think it can be 10X, right?
- 29:03Like let's talk about that. What what is the plan to like
- 29:0510X? And I might disagree and say
- 29:07like, well, I don't think the opportunity is here.
- 29:09I think it's there or at you're staying at 10X.
- 29:12That sounds to me like 50X, right?
- 29:15So it's still a conversation, but the starting point is like
- 29:18it's AI think it's a sincere and useful framework.
- 29:21If someone does not see the opportunity, right, then it's
- 29:25like, OK, we need to like search for the opportunity.
- 29:29Like it's a again, it's always a conversation in terms of
- 29:32stamina. It it's so introspective, right?
- 29:35Like, you know, we, we debate like how much is our job to
- 29:40listen to and not to put an intention, but how much of our
- 29:43job is to inspire entrepreneurs? Super interesting question,
- 29:48right? When someone doesn't have
- 29:50energy, what do you do right? And I think you have to like see
- 29:56the whole person. And that's why to me, it's
- 29:58really important to understand someone's flaws, right?
- 30:01And and have context and have like a real relationship so that
- 30:05I can be more objective about. Have you had founders who lost
- 30:09steam that you were able to resuscitate?
- 30:11Or it feels like once they've sort of lost the energy, it's
- 30:14like, OK, we need to change gears.
- 30:17That's a really interesting question.
- 30:19I'll have to think about that. OK, Yeah, the.
- 30:22All right. So I mean people care about this
- 30:26for a lot of reasons with the money being so large is
- 30:28obviously a piece of it. What's it like?
- 30:31So it's $32 billion sale, right? It is cash.
- 30:35What does that? And is 2.8 billion the number
- 30:39coming to index? No, I don't think we've talked
- 30:42about it. I I saw is that the larger
- 30:44numbers, larger numbers that we're talking about the?
- 30:48All that money, it goes into a bunch of different bank accounts
- 30:52or it first goes into like one bank account and then you
- 30:55disperse it. So yeah. 32 billion gets sent in
- 31:02a number of a number into a number of different places.
- 31:05We have, you know, a group of limited partners, largely great
- 31:10causes, right, that receive distributions.
- 31:15We have a team including inside of index rather that receives
- 31:22distribution. So ultimately, there's lots of
- 31:24so it goes. To like if you're some
- 31:26foundation isn't limited partner in an index, they get it sort of
- 31:30directly. You get sort of the carry or
- 31:32whatever the fund and so it goes.
- 31:35You're not like routing. It's not like some billions of
- 31:38billions comes into one pool. You should probably talk to Jan
- 31:43or Martin about like payment. Infrastructure like money flows
- 31:46and it's just fascinating that it's like I have an employee
- 31:49much smaller scale, you know, it's like she just started, she
- 31:52wired, you know, the 70K. It's just funny, like the actual
- 31:54money movement when it gets so large, like I have friends in
- 31:58private equity, you know, they'll send the actual check
- 32:00and it's like you got to like make sure I think it's.
- 32:03A really relevant question, but like, I was at I went to
- 32:06Carbone's last night, OK. And I'm.
- 32:08I'm with a colleague of mine from San Francisco who had flown
- 32:11in and we're having dinner with an entrepreneur and I'm.
- 32:14And it's her first time at Carbone.
- 32:16I'm like, what do you think? She's like, it's great.
- 32:17This neighborhood's really cool. And I'm like, I have no idea
- 32:19what neighborhood we're in. She's like, sure, do it.
- 32:21We're in Greenwich Village. And I was like, OK, cool.
- 32:24Where is that? I've lived in New York for the
- 32:26last four years. Yeah.
- 32:27I'm explaining this to one of my other partners.
- 32:29This morning. OK.
- 32:31And she's like, is this consistent for you, like across
- 32:35countries and geographies? Like do you know if you're
- 32:38flying out of JFK, Newark or LaGuardia?
- 32:41I'm like, I don't like I just take the Uber and I get to the
- 32:45airport and I find my gate like it.
- 32:48It drives Jan crazy because he's maniacal about knowing like
- 32:52every single flight alternative and uses FlightAware to like
- 32:55pinpoint which flight is his on the way to the airport.
- 32:58But the logistics? I I live in your world as well,
- 33:02or I'm not proud of this. I'm like geographically inept,
- 33:06but I think it speaks to like sometimes like logistics and
- 33:09movements are are are just not very interesting to me.
- 33:12And and so similarly like how the money flows.
- 33:14Like we got a great team that, you know, watches and and makes
- 33:18sure it's appropriately handled and I trust them.
- 33:21But did you? I've been to.
- 33:24I went to Carbone one time. We went too late at night and,
- 33:29you know, it's so it's hard to get into.
- 33:30So then I was like, all right, like we got to really make the
- 33:32most of it. We way over ordered.
- 33:34We treated I Lilia is probably my favorite restaurant.
- 33:37Have you ever been to Lilia? And like, that's like small
- 33:39place of town. So we ordered Carbone as if it
- 33:42was Lilia. So we had like, my wife and I
- 33:43had way too much food at the end of the night.
- 33:45We had like, espresso martinis. I literally thought I was gonna
- 33:49like have a heart attack over that meal.
- 33:51It was like the IT was just like the most.
- 33:53It was, you know, yeah, gluttony to the point of real like
- 33:56suffering over. Yeah.
- 33:58Did you? But do you?
- 33:59Do you like Carbone? Do you like I love the spicy?
- 34:01Rigatoni yeah it's A and the dessert, like the the the way
- 34:05they demonstrated right is is hard to resist that was the.
- 34:09Other element, it was my birthday and they didn't bring
- 34:12the first dessert with a candle and so then my wife was like,
- 34:15oh, it's his birthday. Anyway, yeah.
- 34:19Are you celebrating a lot or was your birthday September 7th?
- 34:22Yeah, noted the candle's. Coming your way.
- 34:28What is it? Can you say?
- 34:30How do you stay motivated after like such a huge exit?
- 34:34It's all. About the next relationship, OK,
- 34:37We don't think in terms of deals by the way, right.
- 34:39Like I think most of the industry is geared around deals.
- 34:43They talk about like the number of deals, the amount per deal,
- 34:46like they talk about chasing the next deal.
- 34:50We think in terms of relationship that the next
- 34:53relationship that we build depth in is the most important
- 34:57relationship. And that will lead to accessing,
- 35:01assessing, winning, supporting and exiting great investments
- 35:05that generate terrific returns for LP's.
- 35:08But what's motivating is like it's all about the people,
- 35:11right? And so I just go back to the
- 35:14this impossible art of, you know, studying, you know, people
- 35:19like human beings. I'm less of a sociologist and
- 35:21anthropologist than like a psychologist.
- 35:24Yeah. But it's like there's nothing
- 35:26better. It's it's the most fun.
- 35:27How did I have? If I'm a start up founder, how
- 35:31do I sort of get on your mind or like how do I sort of start this
- 35:34relationship where like it needs to be?
- 35:37I was at a company that you respect through somebody you
- 35:39know, or like what's what's the way for somebody to sort of
- 35:42break into being in your awareness?
- 35:45Well. I'm not everyone's cup of tea,
- 35:47right? So it it should not be
- 35:49everyone's mission statement to like get into my awareness.
- 35:53The fastest path right is through a warm introduction
- 35:57right, right. Think I don't know how you met
- 35:58your wife but like we went to. College together.
- 36:01Yeah. I I.
- 36:01Went to high school together with my wife.
- 36:04I took her to homecoming. And so, you know, it just so
- 36:07happened we had the same last name, not because we're second
- 36:09cousins or anything, but you know, we, we had lockers next to
- 36:12each other. So we knew each other for our
- 36:13lifetime. But when a friend introduces a
- 36:16friend, you, you just have many more priors.
- 36:19You likely you're more likely to have shared values and alignment
- 36:23around a range of different opportunities in the world.
- 36:26And and so there's it's easier, I think, to find connection,
- 36:29right, going back to how Michael connected me with this off.
- 36:32And so it's it's not for me in terms of like being efficient,
- 36:36right? Cold e-mail me cold LinkedIn me
- 36:38like I, I like I'm on it. But a warm introduction is, is
- 36:44the most efficient path. And, and it, it's, it's usually
- 36:47also the best way for someone to figure out if they even want to
- 36:50spend time with me. Like, you know, again, most
- 36:53venture capitalists are terrific salespeople.
- 36:56The the best thing an entrepreneur can do is
- 36:59reference, right? So go talk to entrepreneurs that
- 37:03I've worked with, Like hear, hear what like.
- 37:06What their side of the story is and then decide like, do you
- 37:09actually want an introduction to me or or to anyone else totally
- 37:13changing gears. What, what categories are you
- 37:16hunting for now? Like you've sold a cybersecurity
- 37:19startup. Does that mean, oh, I'm free, I
- 37:20can do the category again, like reinvent it?
- 37:23Like what? What are you chasing right?
- 37:25Like in terms of themes, like what?
- 37:27Are you really looking for it? Yeah, I'll try to.
- 37:29Parse it into two dimensions. One, obviously we're in the AI
- 37:35era and everything is related to AI and so I think it's a really
- 37:40relevant question to think about what categories are interesting.
- 37:43I'm not a top down thinker. Like it's just not my skill set.
- 37:47I'm a bottoms up person like and as a consequence, I start with
- 37:51the people when I met June at simile, right, which is aiming
- 37:56to simulate. Yeah, you wrote about so like
- 37:59he's he's got the imagination to simulate the entire planet, yet
- 38:03he's so focused on delivering value to fortune one hundreds
- 38:06like in the second sentence and he's talking me through like
- 38:09Pocs and MO us and different terms like that contradiction in
- 38:14June was so compelling and then it got like there's so much
- 38:21depth to the portrait when I learned more about him as a
- 38:25studio artist, but also his Co founders, Percy and and Michael.
- 38:29And then I learned even more when I spent a significant
- 38:33amount of time with Lanie and then he pulled in Mihika, who
- 38:35we've known for years. And so like the enrichment of my
- 38:40enthusiasm or on simile starts with the people.
- 38:43And it just so happens I think it's going to dominate a
- 38:45category because they have moral authority When when I invested
- 38:49in Parag at parallel. I don't know if you've had a
- 38:52conversation with him yet. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:54He announced one of his stations on stage right, But I.
- 38:57Wasn't sure if you guys were like one-on-one.
- 38:59Yet actually I think yes, at a dinner.
- 39:01I've no, I don't know. We haven't like hung out, but
- 39:03I've spent time with him so. Prague's amazing.
- 39:06I love him. When we invested like first we
- 39:11went on a walk, right? And it was supposed to be 45
- 39:13minutes instead. Instead it was like an hour and
- 39:15a half, two hours. And I was like, I don't know
- 39:17what's going on, but we just like clicked.
- 39:21I asked him like, how do you learn?
- 39:23And he's like through adversarial conversation.
- 39:26And I was like, I can do that. And so we've, we've had a
- 39:30phenomenal relationship, but leading up to our investment, I
- 39:35did a lot of references. I, I, I hadn't known him as
- 39:37like, you know, beyond the, the celebrity of like CTO of
- 39:40Twitter, CTO of Twitter, like I, I didn't know the human being.
- 39:43And so I did a huge amount of like referencing, including
- 39:46talking to his wife when I wrote the memo internally.
- 39:50There's nothing about his business because he didn't even
- 39:53know what he was going to work on.
- 39:55So it's just like 5 pages about notes on Prague full conviction.
- 39:59We invest together with Vinod and and and Josh in the first
- 40:03round and and then I, I, Josh a couple minutes ago at.
- 40:08First round, OK. In the first.
- 40:10Round at first round, yes. It's a commercial for Josh.
- 40:14I do. I'm a big fan of both.
- 40:15But after we invest the wires in the bank, I I ask Prague, I'm
- 40:20like, hey, like, why'd you let me in?
- 40:23Like we've known each other for six months.
- 40:26You've had relationships for a decade, right?
- 40:28So like, how did I receive this honor?
- 40:31And he's like, sure, duel, like you made it so painful.
- 40:34And he's like, if you take an easy decision this seriously, I
- 40:38want you on my side. We subsequently Co led the
- 40:43Series A with Mamoon and now he's working on web search for
- 40:47AI agents right. And as the world has become
- 40:51agent 1st and agentic web search is such a natural requirement
- 40:56for the best companies in the world.
- 40:58And so the company has taken off.
- 41:00But sincerely, it wasn't a category.
- 41:03It wasn't like a story. I'm.
- 41:05Following the people. I'm not chasing categories.
- 41:07Yeah, I don't know. How now the inverse, the second
- 41:10part of your question, which is like, are you going to do
- 41:11something else in cloud security?
- 41:13You know, it's something I, I, I worry about like I've, I've had
- 41:17so much, I've had such a front row seat that what I think is
- 41:22the market leading company in cloud security that I'm actually
- 41:25riddled with bias. So I'm not sure I can be
- 41:29objective in taking a view on who can.
- 41:35Now you're like too much of the expert.
- 41:37You're like, I'm used to trusting that the founder is the
- 41:39expert. Now you've developed expert.
- 41:41It's not, it's not expertise, it's bias.
- 41:44OK, Like I have drunk the kool-aid of Wiz more than anyone
- 41:49on the planet, right? And so to then say I'm gonna
- 41:52switch to iced tea is super hard, right?
- 41:55So the beauty of Index again is we it's a partnership model
- 41:59right there, super talented investors like Johanvi, who's
- 42:03also focused on security that can compliment me, right?
- 42:07And so is there more opportunity in and around cloud security?
- 42:11Maybe, right. Am I going to be the biggest
- 42:14bull on competing against Wiz? Absolutely not.
- 42:18What? Yeah.
- 42:18What did what did you want index to be?
- 42:22I don't know in 20 years or like what's we're, we're in such an
- 42:25odd time in venture. You know, the mega firms like
- 42:28keep getting bigger. Like there are firms clearly
- 42:31pursuing sort of AUM and and dollars that they're managing.
- 42:36Like how do you think about sort of that trend and how much is
- 42:39index chasing sort of scale of capital and like how do you
- 42:42really want to distinguish the firm over the next couple
- 42:46decades? So the.
- 42:47The core of index is. It's like a machine, right?
- 42:54We create a culture that can recruit, nurture and develop
- 43:03great people, meaning investors, right?
- 43:06And strategists like we can do that with our team.
- 43:09The consequence is we can attract and nurture and develop
- 43:14greatness in entrepreneurs. I want to make that machine more
- 43:21and more effective and outlive me.
- 43:24That's the most important thing Now, the consequence, I believe,
- 43:29of raising more and more capital.
- 43:31It's it's like supply, demand. I'm, I'm a youth Chicago
- 43:34economist. Like, I get it, right, public
- 43:37market investors can't access private market companies, right?
- 43:41You've written about this and therefore the Russell 2000 is
- 43:43now these private companies. And to get access to that, you
- 43:47can, you know, invest in, in, in mega funds.
- 43:49That's part of the the like. Thrive.
- 43:51I mean, with the rumors, they're like telling on a Brewer, stay
- 43:53private. Like we we'll just keep doing
- 43:56rounds. You know, there's like, almost
- 43:57even even the investors who might want to see an exit seem
- 44:00to be encouraging founders to say private in certain ways.
- 44:04Yeah, I don't know. Yeah, that's.
- 44:06Interesting, but that's. Interesting.
- 44:08It, it, we can talk about that, but there's a, there's a place
- 44:13in the world for that, right? And I totally have respect for
- 44:16individuals who see their business model as like AUM
- 44:20collection, right? Like respect and and there's an
- 44:23opportunity and you should go chase that.
- 44:24I think for us to succeed in attracting, developing and
- 44:29building greatness. It's about the craft, right?
- 44:33It's about a the focus on the individuals internally and the
- 44:37entrepreneurs that we recruit. And so not scaling it is is kind
- 44:41of the point. But it what what is the fund
- 44:48size right now or we have like? A few 100 million seed fund, a
- 44:52billion dollar venture fund, $2 billion growth fund.
- 44:54So we're like large enough to be really relevant across multiple
- 44:58stages to some of the best companies in the world, right?
- 45:01But I think focus, sufficiently focus to attend to the craft.
- 45:06Have you? Do you do SP VS on top of it or?
- 45:09I have not I I'm not a fan of SP VS personally.
- 45:14It's like it's confusing to me, you know?
- 45:17Like is it my main business or not is how I think about it.
- 45:20If yes, then like I have high conviction.
- 45:23I want to invest, set up my main funds.
- 45:27The SPV is like, well, I've gotten access, right.
- 45:30Should I monetize it right and make some economics off of it
- 45:33that that's like how it feels? And so it's like it's it's
- 45:37satisfying, like, and I don't mean this pejoratively, but it
- 45:41like it satisfies the greed in me, right, right, more than the
- 45:44artist in me, right. So I'm in service of the artist,
- 45:46right? I think that might, yeah.
- 45:51I think that's one of the challenges covering venture
- 45:53capital overall. It's like sometimes it's like
- 45:55it's a money game. On some level.
- 45:57You're like, oh, shouldn't you be optimizing for the money?
- 46:00But then there is sort of this aspiration of like, oh, there's,
- 46:03there's still an art to it. And like that's sort of like the
- 46:06crass way to make money. But there's an argument some of
- 46:09these firms, I mean, I don't think it's.
- 46:10Crass. OK, I I mean, I, I don't think
- 46:12it's crass at all. OK, I, I, I'm just saying it's
- 46:16my, it's my personal style and preference, right?
- 46:19Like if you want to raise SPVS, like God bless, it's totally
- 46:23cool with me, but there's a limit.
- 46:24To how much you'd put of a single company in a fund, right?
- 46:28I mean, at some point, you know, that's.
- 46:29A it's a really important question and it's still
- 46:32something I'm trying to develop skill in, right?
- 46:33This is the question is like asset allocation.
- 46:36So how much do you concentrate within a given fund?
- 46:39And, and I've talked to a lot of different folks from Thrive and
- 46:42Lightspeed and Sequoia, like a bunch of my friends about this
- 46:46concept of, of how much to concentrate.
- 46:51I, I, I actually like, I'm still developing that skill, you guys.
- 46:55Have sidestep the big foundation model companies, is that right?
- 46:59Or sidesteps? Maybe not the word yeah.
- 47:00Sidesteps not the not the right word.
- 47:04We've definitely participated in labs and like Foundation labs
- 47:08and Neolabs, but we aren't playing statistics with like put
- 47:14a small or large amount of money into every, you know, team that
- 47:18comes out of Anthropic or open AI or other maybe labs.
- 47:22I mean just. So we sidestep, I mean, I guess
- 47:24portfolio theory. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot, you
- 47:26know, like Lightspeed, I mean a huge percentage of their fund I
- 47:30think isn't anthropic now really.
- 47:32And a lot of their. Yeah.
- 47:33So you just made me think of that with this sort of
- 47:36anthropic. Also, you know, in terms of this
- 47:38SPV conversation, I understand there are firms where they got
- 47:42in early like, and you don't have to weigh in all this, but I
- 47:45think like, you know, like Spark I think got in, in my senses.
- 47:47They didn't necessarily use the allocation in every way they
- 47:50could have. And then you have other firms, I
- 47:52think like Menlo, where they're fairly aggressive and like
- 47:55having access and doing SPVS. And so that venture capital has
- 47:59just become in some ways like a different business in that like,
- 48:02yeah, that because there's so much growth investing happening
- 48:06adjacent to to venture capital. There are no sacred cows, right?
- 48:11So maybe I revisit the concept of SP VS in a in a couple years
- 48:15when I'm exposed to like the next Anthropic, I don't have
- 48:19enough money. Usually what I do when I go to
- 48:21my partners and I'm like Max conviction, I'm like, tell me
- 48:24the maximum amount of dollars we can invest in this company,
- 48:27double that. That's what I want to do.
- 48:29And they're like. The do you guys, does everyone
- 48:35in index have to or what's the level of agreement that you need
- 48:38across the firm to do a deal we're?
- 48:40Consensus oriented, OK. So like just majority or yeah,
- 48:44it's like a it's. A little bit so we can vote one
- 48:47through 10. You can't vote 5 or 6 if it
- 48:49passes a certain threshold. The answer is yes.
- 48:51So if someone were like it's a one right that that makes like
- 48:56the calculus a little bit more challenging.
- 48:58Largely it's consensus which largely follows like simple
- 49:02majority. Can you?
- 49:03Revote or it's like it's one vote and then it's over.
- 49:06Great question. We do do revotes.
- 49:09I recently studied and I don't think we're that great at
- 49:11revoting Interesting. I think what no matter I don't
- 49:15know why it is, but our first impressions are pretty are
- 49:18pretty good like the. Revote, I imagine is like the
- 49:20partner who likes the deal, like is like, how do I get more
- 49:23people around this? And no, it's not.
- 49:25Politicking. It's like, hey, the discussion
- 49:27we had was based on a set of inputs and two things happened.
- 49:331 is like I studied and I think the inputs are slightly
- 49:38different or we are significantly different and so
- 49:41we should revote with a different set of inputs, right?
- 49:46The, the second is, Hey, this is how you interpreted the input,
- 49:52like partner XYZ, like I want to talk to you about that.
- 49:56And two things can happen. 1 is like, oh, I hear you now.
- 49:59And I, you know what, like, I think that's totally right in
- 50:02terms of this judgement call, like not going to revote, not
- 50:04going to move it forward. Sometimes in that conversation,
- 50:08it's, it's a discussion and the person's like, oh, I didn't see
- 50:11that point of view. Like we, we didn't have that
- 50:15discussion in the investment committee.
- 50:18And as a consequence, I want to change my view because now I, I
- 50:21misunderstood. So we have that like ambiguity
- 50:25of like conversation. We have a culture that again
- 50:29supports like dissent, right? And you can only have dissent
- 50:33and ambiguity when there's a lot of conversation.
- 50:35Going back to one of the points you made, like one of the
- 50:37reasons I think most firms have not been successful across
- 50:41geographies is it requires communication, right?
- 50:45And and our business is so trust based that you have to
- 50:49constantly communicate For many people in our industry,
- 50:52communication feels like a tax. Communication feels like a tax.
- 50:56You should not join index because we communicate a lot and
- 51:00we like each other. So it's fun.
- 51:01But that that supports like dissent and ambiguity and
- 51:04conversation. I still think though, like
- 51:07despite those re votes based on like good intent and more
- 51:11inputs, the first time we vote we're usually right, right?
- 51:14The I got asked on my last podcast episode by Barry McArdle
- 51:19at Hex whether I thought the best venture capitalists like,
- 51:24you know, roughly put, were like obvious at the time or not.
- 51:27And I'm curious what you obviously know this much better
- 51:29than I do. Like, I mean, you you look at
- 51:32Wiz. I mean, it's like you guys, you
- 51:34know, you're more storied now in the rearview mirror, but like
- 51:37it's a good set of investors from the beginning.
- 51:39Like how much do you think your best?
- 51:41And Prague obviously was already sort of like Twitter famous when
- 51:46you did that investment. Like how much do you think your
- 51:48best deals? It's like those were like, it
- 51:50wasn't clear maybe the price, but they were obviously like
- 51:53strong deals at the time. Or there are ones where you're
- 51:56like, people didn't see it. And what's your philosophy on
- 51:59the sense of like the hot deal? I don't think there's anything
- 52:03that's obvious to. I'll give you just two examples
- 52:07of evidence. Right.
- 52:08Like thank God 20 plus firms passed on Datadog before I
- 52:12called out the Series A like right?
- 52:16Not obvious Wiz. There's one investor who
- 52:22increased ownership at every single opportunity, obviously.
- 52:26I'm not saying there's no skill, like no, I'm just saying.
- 52:29If it were obvious, everyone would have behaved in the same
- 52:32way, right? And everyone didn't.
- 52:34And again, I'm not confusing those judgement calls with being
- 52:37right. Let's not.
- 52:40Let's like there's confidence and humility.
- 52:42We can both and not crossover to Eric, so if it were obvious, the
- 52:48counterfactuals would be different, right?
- 52:51The and I I assume they're all there's plenty of.
- 52:53Deals where it's like I'm not an investor in HECS, right?
- 52:57So maybe that one's obvious. Like I, you know, I've never
- 53:01met. Right, yeah.
- 53:02And there are lots of deals that are hot.
- 53:04You have to pick like, you know, which like hot deal also, you
- 53:07know, pans out because they're a lot, you know, I I feel like
- 53:10covering venture capital. I mean, this is a consumer, but
- 53:12far from it. But like I broke the seed in
- 53:15Series A of B real. There was also like hop in those
- 53:18were both deals where it's like those could sort of like, you
- 53:21know, they were sort of like, you know, strong signal.
- 53:23You got it at the time and then it doesn't last.
- 53:26And so, yeah, the the sense of like a hot deal doesn't always,
- 53:30you know, obviously live the test.
- 53:32Yeah. You, you know, look, one of one
- 53:34of our, I think we've talked about it before.
- 53:37We've talked about like sins of omission, right?
- 53:40And one of the sins of omission is don't argue with traction,
- 53:45right? Another way of saying that is
- 53:47like, when there's momentum, like there's there's a higher
- 53:50probability that the company might be successful.
- 53:53And so that expressed in investing is this potentially
- 53:57like deal heat hot deal like FOMO thing I feel like?
- 54:02Sometimes there are stories that I should write that they almost
- 54:05feel like too straightforward. You know, it's like, oh, that if
- 54:08I did that story, it's just like, Oh yeah, that'd be, it'd
- 54:10be easy. You know where it's like.
- 54:11Just mixing it up but like. In some ways it is the same sort
- 54:15of thing. It's like, no, I need to do the
- 54:16hard story that sort of like, you know, causes turmoil.
- 54:19Like I really. Yeah, anyway, but sometimes.
- 54:22Yeah, like having a point of view can still be differentiated
- 54:25when there's a common understanding, right?
- 54:27And so you can still express the significant returns right into a
- 54:32terrific company, even if there's a consensus view.
- 54:34So that that's where I'm, I'm being a little flip, but I'm
- 54:38trying to become more precise and not so binary in terms of
- 54:43like, oh, every, everybody sees it, right.
- 54:45Last question for entrepreneurs like what do you think they
- 54:48should learn from the Wiz journey?
- 54:51Oh, I. Think imagination is stretched
- 54:53now, right? Like more is possible in a
- 54:56shorter period of time from anywhere in the world.
- 54:59You can approach large enterprises and deliver value
- 55:02in, in unforeseen moments. Like I, I, I think that not just
- 55:08in Israel, right, like globally, we're going to see more ambition
- 55:12on entrepreneurs. You're seeing from new countries
- 55:14or just like? Any entrepreneur who studies Wiz
- 55:19will know that more is possible today than was five years ago.
- 55:23Great. Sure.
- 55:23Duel, thank you for coming on the Newcomer podcast.
- 55:26It's so fun. Thank you.
- 55:27Thanks man. That's our episode.
- 55:29Thanks, Chardul Shaw for coming on the show.
- 55:31I'm Eric Newcomer. You can follow my writing and my
- 55:33teams writing at newcomer.co. Please like, comment, subscribe.
- 55:38Excited to be a YouTube hustler now, so, you know, give us your
- 55:42comments, ask me, you know, whatever it is.
- 55:44Tell us guest suggestions if you're hungry for more podcasts.
- 55:48I'm also one of the Co hosts of the Through Valley show with my
- 55:51friends Max and James. Otherwise, see you in this feed
- 55:55in a couple days. Fine.
- 55:56Probably in a week. We're publishing.
- 55:58Yeah. How's the cup?
- 55:59All right. Thanks so much.