Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Impact of US-UK Strike on Yemen | The World According To Irina Tsukerman (Ep 8)
Transcript
- 0:19Welcome to this episode of The World According to Irena
- 0:23Superman. This is a fresh episode for the
- 0:25first, the first one this year with Irena, so this will be a
- 0:28special one. This is a part of our special
- 0:31series on global politics on the KJ Master class live Irena
- 0:35Superman. She is an US based national
- 0:37security and human rights lawyer as well as a renowned
- 0:40geopolitical analyst. Writings and commentary have
- 0:43appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:46been translated to over a dozen languages every fortnight in the
- 0:50world according to IRENA Superman.
- 0:52We traversed the geopolitical landscape and delve into
- 0:55pressing international issues and gain insight from Irena's
- 0:58expert perspective. Welcome to the show once again,
- 1:02IRENA, and a very happy New Year to you.
- 1:05Thanks and same to you. Cooper You is off to a great
- 1:08start. Wonderful, wonderful.
- 1:11Great. Great start to a new year from
- 1:14the from coverage point of view in terms of geopolitics, we will
- 1:19understand from you how whether it has been a great start or
- 1:23not. Let's look at the impact of the
- 1:25US UK strike on Yemen. How do we understand this is the
- 1:30big topic that we will be covering today?
- 1:32So let us understand in full. What is this UN, US, UK strike
- 1:37on Yemen? Why suddenly human Yemen has
- 1:40come into the picture from a layman's perspective.
- 1:42Someone sitting say suppose in a village in India.
- 1:45How do they understand this part?
- 1:47Why Yemen has suddenly become the hotbed for US UK strike?
- 1:52Well, that general area has always been very important.
- 1:57About 1/5 of the world's maritime trade passes through
- 2:04Bubble Mandap, Strait of Hormuz, the Red Sea, the general Gulf of
- 2:08Oman area. Much of it is oil and gas that
- 2:12is, that goes on to Africa and to the Far East, to Japan, South
- 2:17Korea, countries that are heavily dependent on imports of
- 2:23energy from abroad. Yemen has been a complicated
- 2:30country for many decades, but in the last decade the biggest
- 2:34issue has been the uprising of the Iran backed who sees the
- 2:39minority Muslim family that expanded significantly through
- 2:45complex marriage and tribal networks and to conquest.
- 2:51The rules up against the official government of Yemen
- 2:55started a revolution that was supposed to be in favor of the
- 3:00greater inclusion in the government.
- 3:02But they have become so radicalized and so close to Iran
- 3:08that they actually want to have full control of Yemen, 100% of
- 3:13all of its territory and government.
- 3:15They do not want to be engaged in any power sharing agreements.
- 3:20Saudi Arabia was eventually invited by Yemen to to help
- 3:26address this uprising. It LED a long war of eight
- 3:30years. Unfortunately, it's a defensive
- 3:36maneuvers were cut short by by international diplomatic
- 3:40pressure. As a result, the port of
- 3:42Hodeidah, the biggest port in Yemen, was given over to the
- 3:46Hoochie control. Essentially, and this is where
- 3:49both the humanitarian aid flows into the country and it's
- 3:55supposed to be distributed everywhere.
- 3:57But unfortunately, most of it is stolen or divided up between the
- 4:03colonies and supporters over other hoochies.
- 4:07But it's also the port where Iran directs it's ammunition,
- 4:11it's weapons. And Iran, both through the RGC
- 4:14and Hezbollah has trained, who used to become an increasingly
- 4:18more sophisticated force. They used to be allied with the
- 4:22Saudis during the Cold War against the NASA backed Egypt
- 4:26and the Soviet Union. But decades later they moved
- 4:32closer to Iran and we engaged in assorted smuggling and criminal
- 4:37activity over the borders of them on and Lebanon, and
- 4:41eventually became a more politicized force.
- 4:46They engaged in numerous skirmishes with the government
- 4:49and overtime became quite good at war.
- 4:52And now they're in possession of long range and medium range
- 4:56ballistic missiles, various drones, both Iranian made and
- 5:01partially Chinese made drones, and assorted other sophisticated
- 5:07weapons. And they've become quite
- 5:08professionalized. They're more like a very serious
- 5:12paramilitary force similar to Hezbollah then to a group of
- 5:16random terrorists that you can imagine.
- 5:20And they've become quite adept at using the terrain of Yemen to
- 5:25hide their infrastructure, making it very difficult to get
- 5:28them to air strikes alone. And because they control most of
- 5:34the populated territory in Yemen right now, ground game has also
- 5:41become very complicated. US at one point was engaged in
- 5:46Yemen, but mostly encountering Al Qaeda and ISIS.
- 5:50They did provide support to the Saudi LED Arab coalition, mostly
- 5:55with logistics and intelligence. That support overtime waned for
- 6:00political reasons. Since then US withdrew any
- 6:05support. The Saudis decided to engage in
- 6:09peace talks with the hoodies which have so far led nowhere
- 6:14but as a result of normalization with Iran.
- 6:17The Saudis backed away from trying to confront hoodies
- 6:20militarily and even asked US not to engage in any offensive
- 6:25activity since October 7th. So previously because who
- 6:32designed Iranian proxy, they have been they have essential
- 6:35approach TLT to the Tehran regime and they have become
- 6:41increasingly integrated and interchangeable with the various
- 6:45other Iran backed militias and organizations and movements in
- 6:49the region. They have in the past offered
- 6:52the help and support to Hamas, which Hamas at the time
- 6:56previously had declined. And they have also provided very
- 7:01positive political support to the Taliban in Afghanistan.
- 7:07So they've become quite known in the region the fundraised for
- 7:12Hezbollah inside the territory. After October 7th, they became
- 7:18Iran's most potent weapon because they were once more
- 7:22where previously they focused them military strikes on Saudi
- 7:27Arabia and UE, now they're reoriented towards trying to get
- 7:32to strike Israel and eventually when is they focused?
- 7:39They did manage to get close to reaching Israeli territory
- 7:44because they now have long range rockets, but most of them starts
- 7:48with directed at commercial ships.
- 7:50Israel redirected most of its traffic around Cape of Good
- 7:54corn, good coal in Africa. So then they started attacking
- 8:00any Western vessels that pass through the region, avoiding
- 8:07Russia and Russian and Chinese ships.
- 8:09However, all of that was coordinated with Iran that
- 8:14renewed its past habit of abducting oil tankers and
- 8:22hijacking its crews. And there was also apparent
- 8:26possible coordination with Somali pirates who hijacked one
- 8:30of the ships and were intercepted by the in
- 8:34apprehended by the United States.
- 8:36US ended up moving a lot of a number of warships to the area.
- 8:42Iran responded by moving intelligent spy ships there as
- 8:47well as occupying local Yemeni islands.
- 8:51That made it very difficult for US to worship one of the US
- 8:56warships to leave leave the area.
- 8:59So those all of these continuing strikes and attacks were
- 9:03coordinated between Iran and Houthis, with the Iran giving
- 9:07orders. At one point it even had an
- 9:09ambassador in Sanaa, The capital were occupied by the Houthis,
- 9:13and it became such a big problem that this W Canal, where much of
- 9:19this traffic was directed, lost 40% of its revenue.
- 9:23Shipping cost rose 250%. All of that obviously had an
- 9:28impact on energy prices, on economies of the country's most
- 9:32dependent on these things, and it just made freedom of
- 9:38navigation impossible in this highly strategic region.
- 9:42US had warned who this multiple times, along with the United
- 9:46Kingdom and a coalition of defensive ships that strike,
- 9:50striking down these missiles and drones without engaging in
- 9:55offensive action. But after a while, it became the
- 10:00cookies became engaged in deliberate provocations, pushing
- 10:04the envelope farther and farther.
- 10:08Now, the first thing that the President Biden did when he came
- 10:10to office in terms of foreign policy was remove the cookies
- 10:15from the Foreign Terrorist Organization list, where
- 10:19President Trump praised them just right before leaving
- 10:26leaving the White House. Now, there was an ongoing
- 10:30discussion about redesignating them.
- 10:34A lot of the media today reported that they would be
- 10:38placed back on the FTO after President by the Quantum
- 10:41terrorists. But former Trump officials say
- 10:45that it hoodies will be sanctioned as a group that but
- 10:49not placed on that specific top level designation.
- 10:54Regardless US engaged in symbolic strikes.
- 10:59They gave the hoodies a warning about the timing of the strikes,
- 11:04which they claimed would prevent regional escalation.
- 11:08The hoodies had an opportunity to remove much of their weapons
- 11:12and fighters from the area, and they renewed the strikes as soon
- 11:17as it was over. And today US you know after
- 11:22repeats of this of the strikes of the US had to do repeat runs
- 11:26this time specifically signaling to Iran that Iran that's it's
- 11:32behind it the whole discontinued nevertheless.
- 11:36And so today US and UK engaged in a pre emptive strike for the
- 11:41first time but given the fact that a lot of this
- 11:46infrastructure is hidden deep inside the country it's not
- 11:50clear what impact is going to have.
- 11:52It's literally just happened today.
- 11:56Right, right. I don't know in terms of
- 11:59Houthis, if you look at it, what is it that they want?
- 12:03Are they are they going to get anything in the long term in
- 12:08terms of their standing because the US and Iran, they their
- 12:14their relationship might change. Houthis, do they have a long
- 12:19term objective as a group also in terms of you know what is the
- 12:25Yemen government doing? Do they have a proper structure
- 12:29where they can control? Because last week when the
- 12:33strikes happened, Iran put it, as you know, these attacks as
- 12:37violation of Yemen's sovereignty and territorial integrity and
- 12:41breach of international laws. Why is it that the US is not
- 12:46putting pressure on the Yemen government?
- 12:49How? And earlier on also the Houthis
- 12:52were there and but now before because of this Middle East
- 12:58crisis, because of the Gaza Strip and all that stuff is it
- 13:02has become much, much more What is the Houthis role here?
- 13:07Do they want a very active role into these thing?
- 13:11Is it now how much control does Iran have?
- 13:14Because does their existence only fully rely on Iran, or is
- 13:18it that they have their own agenda in that whole region?
- 13:23Well, Iran has evolved its role from a regional partner to the
- 13:30Hodges to completely controlled to be completely in control.
- 13:34They would not have started any of this without Iran's
- 13:37direction. And while they claim that the
- 13:40impetus for all of this is the war in Gaza, and that they're
- 13:43trying to help commerce, in reality this is just an excuse.
- 13:50Justification for Iran to expand regional war, to humiliate US,
- 13:55to push to test the waters of US commitment, and to try to push
- 14:00US and its allies out of their area and to expand its own
- 14:04neighbour comparabilities. As for the cookies, their agenda
- 14:07is a local power and they want to have complete control of
- 14:11Yemen. The legitimate Yemeni government
- 14:15does not recognize them. However, US and Saudi Arabia
- 14:19have been pushing the the government to include who is in
- 14:23into a they were structure but who just want complete control.
- 14:27They don't want to power. Sure.
- 14:29And they're also extremely radical.
- 14:31They're more radical in terms of their views then the Iranian
- 14:34regimes. They have essentially erased
- 14:37women from public space altogether, similar to what the
- 14:41Taliban has done, much more so than Iran by the way.
- 14:45They have been killing journalists quite openly,
- 14:48torturing them, abducting people of various backgrounds,
- 14:52recruiting child soldiers similar to what Hamas and
- 14:55Hizbullah and Poly Siren North Africa, all Iran linked
- 15:00organizations have been doing. So they're a very extreme group
- 15:04and they are, they consider US and Israel and and and Jews
- 15:12enemies to be eliminated and destroyed and in by all means
- 15:16possible. Obviously we do not have the
- 15:19means to rely fight the United States other than to information
- 15:22wars, but that they are quite adept in the spreading
- 15:27propaganda everywhere they're brainwashing their populations.
- 15:31Yemen government has been part of the talks with Saudi Arabia
- 15:36for months. Saudi Arabia is leading that
- 15:38effort, but it hasn't gone anywhere because the footies
- 15:44have made ridiculous, absurd demands.
- 15:48They required $100 billion from the Saudis, plus they wanted all
- 15:53the salaries of their officials paid.
- 15:55And they they've been smuggling oil from the South.
- 15:59So the situation is very complicated, very bad.
- 16:03There's not much US can do to put any more pressure on the
- 16:06Yemen. They should be putting more
- 16:09pressure on the cookies, but they have been reluctant to do
- 16:13much. They've been sanctioning
- 16:15financial networks that provide assistance to the cookies, but
- 16:19the Pujis are still not fully designated as a terrorist
- 16:23organization like the RGC, Hamas or Al Qaeda, for instance.
- 16:29So they still have a fair degree of international legitimacy.
- 16:34The officials travel back and forth, including to Iran, quite
- 16:37quite openly. They they follow Irans
- 16:42directions because they get full support from Iran and because
- 16:45they they have a common goal in radicalization, taking over the
- 16:50country. For Iran, the ultimate goal is
- 16:53Saudi Arabia. They want to be seen as a
- 16:56primary religious states in the region.
- 17:00They want to dismantle the monarchy, which they do not
- 17:04consider as legitimate. They want to be the custodian of
- 17:08the two Holy Mosques. So there was a very doctrinal
- 17:12religious war going on here, and the hoodies are a means to that
- 17:17end. Who?
- 17:18The hoodies consider themselves legitimate descendants of the
- 17:21Prophet Muhammad and as such they consider themselves the the
- 17:28the tribe that should be ruling Yemen.
- 17:31Even though Yemen has been a a Republic for for a long time
- 17:35now, they haven't had a king in a long time.
- 17:39But the cookies want to go back to that structure and they only
- 17:43recognize Muslim monarchs who are descended from who are
- 17:49Hashemite in origin who are descendant from the same time.
- 17:53So they don't have an issue with Morocco, they don't have an
- 17:55issue with Jordan, but they do have an issue with Saudi Arabia,
- 17:59UE and so forth. Right, right.
- 18:02Irina, in terms of the Houthis, you know position there they are
- 18:08not attacking Chinese ships, Russian ships and but others.
- 18:14Now they want to put an impact for whatever reasons it is on to
- 18:18the Western powers and maybe as as it looks like maybe on the
- 18:22because of the Israel Hamas war. But as as one of our you know
- 18:28viewers has this particular question that did the Houthis
- 18:32attack on the Red Sea hurt Israel and Westmore or poorer
- 18:35countries in the region dependent on the trade.
- 18:38How do you look at this because almost every country is impacted
- 18:44if we look at it that ways how what is your analysis Even India
- 18:48came into the picture. India has nothing to do there.
- 18:51Even Indian aligned ships were you know targeted Indians have
- 18:55have to look at that. So help us understand in terms
- 18:58of the question that we are getting from one of our viewers
- 19:02is on to the this that it is impacting more poorer countries
- 19:06and the world can see through it, that there is a bigger
- 19:10agenda and not purely in terms of, you know, purely in terms of
- 19:15Israel or any other thing, but much more related to political
- 19:19power. And this is what again, why
- 19:21can't people see who these are doing this right because of Iran
- 19:24and to achieve their political goals and not because of Gazans?
- 19:28How do you see these sort of views?
- 19:30How do you see the impact on poorer countries from your point
- 19:34of view? They having quite a very limited
- 19:37impact on Israel to be honest, other than optics and you know
- 19:41just an additional annoyance. Israelis have been preparing for
- 19:45potential for such threats for very long time because they're
- 19:49aware of the Fuji capabilities and it's also very far away.
- 19:53So even with the long range missiles it's still difficult to
- 19:56reach. Now with the traffic redirected
- 19:59it's taking longer to deliver the goods, but it's you know,
- 20:03it's inconvenience but it's not a huge problem.
- 20:05The problem is with poorer countries and it's the problem
- 20:09is with the commercial ships that have been damaged and also
- 20:13with countries that. More dependent on trade and
- 20:18cannot get it through other routes.
- 20:21But we have also seen that there is a different reason.
- 20:26So the official reason that the hood stated this because they
- 20:30want to use the situation as a pressure on Israel to withdraw
- 20:35from Gaza. How?
- 20:37But how is attacking some, you know, European ships that have
- 20:42nothing to do with India, with Israel for that matter, don't
- 20:46may may not even agree with what Israel is doing.
- 20:49That doesn't really make any sense because yes, you know,
- 20:52there's already international pressure on Israel.
- 20:55Yes, maybe the situation could stroke some fears among some
- 20:59people. But overall, everybody knows
- 21:01exactly what the situation is and the they understand who this
- 21:05should have been dealt with a long time ago and that Iran is
- 21:08calling the shots and Iran is instigating this violence.
- 21:11And the only reason US nuclear responded is after very
- 21:15prolonged period of trade disruption became because it's
- 21:19becoming impossible to pass through the region.
- 21:22And there's also some other issues going.
- 21:26But there's another agenda besides simply galvanizing this
- 21:31output and showing Iran's strength and trying to kick
- 21:35everyone out and the, you know, force them to choose sides.
- 21:40Iran attacked the Indian tanker directly, and it was the first
- 21:46time that the attack from that direction.
- 21:49Now, quite frankly, Iranian meddling in India has been
- 21:53growing in recent period, but for a long time.
- 21:58Previously, the relations were fairly stable.
- 22:01India and Iran have had economic trade over energy, ports in
- 22:08tourism and various other projects, and India was not seen
- 22:14as part of this Iran's primary agenda.
- 22:17Iran's primary agenda was the Middle East.
- 22:19It wasn't India, Not that it didn't have interest there, but
- 22:22it was just not their primary interest.
- 22:25It was just focusing mostly on the Middle East and also on the
- 22:29Western Europe, the United States causing problems there
- 22:32but with India joining the quads and with India increasingly
- 22:37strengthening its relations with Israel and the United States and
- 22:40with India becoming a global player.
- 22:43And we've seen the discussion of the Middle East corridor with
- 22:47Saudi Arabia, whatever you may call it.
- 22:50It's starting to become a problem for Iran as a member of
- 22:53the coalition, not because of it's specifically targeting Iran
- 22:57in any way. Politically, getting involved in
- 23:00any anti Iran action, simply as a member of this alliance, as an
- 23:04important potential member because of its resources,
- 23:08because of its shared size and important political role, it's
- 23:16being seen as a problem. And this attack on the ship was
- 23:19a signal. It was a strategic communication
- 23:21to say choose your sides carefully otherwise you'll be
- 23:26suffering along with the other countries.
- 23:28You could be like China and Russia who can pass without any
- 23:32problems or you could be like these western ships.
- 23:35So you you need to think that's the message that Iran is sending
- 23:40India. Choose your sides.
- 23:42You can be with us in BRICS or you could be with the West, but
- 23:45you can't, you can't be with both.
- 23:47And we're going to see a lot more of that sooner because
- 23:53India is trying to play an independent political role.
- 23:57It is working on various projects with BRICS countries,
- 24:00but it's also doing a lot both in the security and economic
- 24:04business fronts with the US, NATO countries and so forth.
- 24:09So we will see that they will be this effort to pressure India to
- 24:13choose size. Right, right.
- 24:17Arena. In terms of Russia, in terms of
- 24:20China, how should we look at their role in the Middle East,
- 24:26role in this Houthis role that they are playing in the Red Sea?
- 24:32How do should we look at that that is also becomes then it
- 24:35becomes apparent about if their ships are not getting attacked
- 24:39and if there is it is it they are who instigating them or is
- 24:43it that they have a they're they're trying to give tacit
- 24:46support on? Well, no, I would say that the
- 24:49the support is more than tacit. Russia Channel and Iran have
- 24:53absolutely a military alliance. They've done multiple military
- 24:57trainings including naval exercises.
- 25:00Both the you know the three of them, yeah in pairs.
- 25:04And also the they've done things with North Korea as well And
- 25:09China's have supplied engines and drones in various parts for
- 25:13Kuchi ammunition. It's also sold weapons all over
- 25:16the Middle East as Russian and Russia's had the role.
- 25:20Both Russia and China were two of the only countries with the
- 25:23remaining at one point embassies open in Yemen.
- 25:28Russia at one point has tried to play all sides in Yemen because
- 25:32it wanted to be seen as a power program.
- 25:35It had ambitions for military base there.
- 25:38Ultimately it started with the hoodies over the legitimate
- 25:41government and certainly against the Saudi elements quite openly.
- 25:46They've grown significantly closer to Iran and founded
- 25:51helpful to coordinate the actions.
- 25:52They have their differences. One of the differences is over
- 25:56particular Yemeni islands that Russia is has an interest in and
- 26:01Iran has occupied as as mentioned.
- 26:03And that they also have interest over UAE because UAE and Iran
- 26:09have also disputes over over some islands.
- 26:12And Russia has sided with the UAE because they have very
- 26:15significant financial investments in the UAE and they
- 26:18need the access to the Gulf as part of the geopolitical agenda,
- 26:23economic agenda. So sometimes it's been difficult
- 26:27for them to navigate these relationships, but they have
- 26:30tried to kind of retain access to all of these parties to
- 26:35faster economic and political relationship with them and
- 26:39overall to join them firmly in the anti western agenda.
- 26:43With China, the institution is a little bit different.
- 26:46China does not play as much of A security role directly.
- 26:50They actually try to stay out of all these external skirmishes.
- 26:54Most of them military activity has been focused on South China
- 26:58Sea, but they have built a base in Djibouti.
- 27:02They've been looking to build another base in Africa with
- 27:05limited success due to US pressure.
- 27:08They've been looking to. They have had an interest in
- 27:14Syria and building up their military presence.
- 27:18They've been working on projects in Saudi Arabia and especially
- 27:21in UAE as well, military, drone, drone production and so forth.
- 27:27So, but still for them it's more of a power projection and
- 27:31economic interests and political interests more than an interest
- 27:35in direct military environment. They're not at the stage when
- 27:39they're ready to project that much power external because
- 27:43their main focus is they want closer areas.
- 27:48Japan, South Korea, Philippines, not necessarily the Middle East
- 27:53other than through political and economic pressure.
- 27:58Still, they find it to be an important alliance.
- 28:02They have a top trading relationship in terms of oil
- 28:05with Iran. They have a growing trade,
- 28:09energy, trade relationship with Saudi Arabia as well.
- 28:13They've been selling surveillance technology all over
- 28:16the Middle East, particularly to Iran and Saudi Arabia.
- 28:20And they they, they find it important to show this sort of
- 28:26backing in in this Ave. And in turn, Iran gives them and
- 28:31Russian ships preferential treatments because they're
- 28:34allies. They are allies, even if they
- 28:36have different agendas, sometimes complementary,
- 28:40sometimes completely independent of each other, sometimes
- 28:43overlapping and sometimes diverted or even potentially
- 28:46clashing in the future. At the moment, the big task is
- 28:50to oppose the West, and for that reason you are also seeing
- 28:54Russia and China meddling with Hamas, showing support to Hamas
- 28:58now to the hoodies. Not because necessarily they
- 29:02need you know they want to be the best friends, but they find
- 29:05them useful against the West and to achieve their own goals.
- 29:11Right. So where does this all seem to
- 29:14be going? Is it all related to the Middle
- 29:18East at the moment or is it beyond that here?
- 29:22The whole world, almost half of this world is moving towards
- 29:25elections this year. Russian elections, India
- 29:28elections, US elections, Taiwan elections just ended and China
- 29:33has all its own problems to deal with.
- 29:36How do you see this problem moving out?
- 29:39Is it going to end with, you know with the end end of the
- 29:44fight in in in Gaza? Is it going to end with the end
- 29:49of fight with Russia and Russia and Ukraine?
- 29:53Some sort of a decision comes in.
- 29:55How does this all look like to be panning out?
- 29:59Will the world see more stability in the going days,
- 30:02going days forward because Iran has just, you know, the latest
- 30:06is that Iran has had its own strikes in Iraq as well as in in
- 30:11Syria. So does this look like to be
- 30:14much more getting wider or or is it going to be much more
- 30:18peaceful going forward? How does it look look to you in
- 30:222024? I I think we are going to see a
- 30:25lot more skirmishes, a lot more efforts to push the envelope.
- 30:30China is watching closely. They were hoping for a political
- 30:34win because that would save them the trouble of having to plan
- 30:39any military operations. They will still try to push the
- 30:43new, the, the new government, the DPP government against any
- 30:48full independence as much as possible.
- 30:51They've already gotten a win from President Biden, who said
- 30:54he opposes Taiwan, Taiwan's independence and certainly many
- 30:58other countries around the world, for various political
- 31:01reasons, view Taiwan as an issue of China's tutorial integrity.
- 31:06But I think that's going to change because I think sooner or
- 31:09later people will will see that for China, it's not just about
- 31:13Taiwan. Taiwan is only a first step,
- 31:15just as Ukraine is an important first step for Russia.
- 31:19And quite simply I don't see much of A political difference
- 31:24between those two countries. Russia does not see Ukraine as
- 31:27an independent state, even though Ukraine has had a
- 31:31separate government. Yes, it has had various close
- 31:35relations with Russia over decades, a lot of intermingling.
- 31:38There's been a Russian influenced parties but the rule
- 31:41is been an independent country with its own separate economy,
- 31:45politics and social issues and trajectories.
- 31:49Similarly Taiwan has not been any real part of China in so
- 31:54many decades that it's it's it's completely different society and
- 32:00culturally and you know it has some historic similarities but
- 32:04also a gradual difference because of a very different
- 32:07political system, democratic, much more open, much more
- 32:11accountable and much more pro western in many ways.
- 32:15And China is very much moving in a different direction.
- 32:18So I don't I I I see that China will be watching closely and
- 32:22seeing how it can coordinate some sort of effort.
- 32:26I think if it sees that there is a real possibility of a regional
- 32:31conflagration in the Middle East if Iran hoodies and so forth
- 32:36succeed in blocking the navigation completely, they see
- 32:39US becoming more embroiled and having to develop a strategy to
- 32:46respond to these threats. Unsuccessful and most likely for
- 32:50the time being, because this administration still is hoping
- 32:55for some sort of a diplomatic breakthrough with the run,
- 32:57whatever that means. And while Iran is also, by the
- 33:00way, pursuing its nuclear ambitions, Chan, it will be a
- 33:05good time for China to take action, either by blocking the
- 33:08South China Sea in a similar manner as what Iran is trying to
- 33:12do, or by simply attacking Taiwan or Philippines, or
- 33:18engaging in some sort of asymmetrical hybrid warfare that
- 33:24may step short of a full confrontation with Western
- 33:27militaries. But we will certainly stretch
- 33:29them thin The more conference there are that US needs to
- 33:35respond to in some way the easy it is for to start new
- 33:38conference and for each aggressor to kind of succeed and
- 33:42make moves because there's only so much that US can be doing
- 33:46diplomatically in terms of strategically providing weapons,
- 33:50you know, paying attention, you know gathering intelligence and
- 33:53so forth. Absolutely.
- 33:55Resources are finite and, you know, there's also been a lot of
- 33:58mistakes made over the years, a lot of talent, talent lost and
- 34:02not enough people recruited specifically for all these
- 34:06separate and growing tasks. So I think there is going to be,
- 34:11you know, a greater chance because I don't see this
- 34:14administration taking any really big daring steps against any one
- 34:19of these parties. And I think a blow to any one of
- 34:24them would be send a very strong message to the rest.
- 34:28This is why we're seeing North Korea dismant actively
- 34:31dismantling its communications infrastructure with the South
- 34:35Korea. This is a signal that they are
- 34:38besides the usual, you know, testing of missiles and so forth
- 34:42that we are all used to. They are now actually moving
- 34:45towards unfreezing the conflict and towards a potential a hot
- 34:50face because this is a good time.
- 34:52There's only so many conflicts, yes, you know, Venezuela and
- 34:55Guyana, Venezuela's you know, threatening to grab a chunk of
- 35:00that various conflicts in Africa.
- 35:03So the overall picture is all these fires are being
- 35:07instigated, Russia, China certainly stalking these
- 35:11tensions in their interest to do so.
- 35:13Iran is galvanizing its proxies in throwing everything it can to
- 35:19see what sticks. They are not necessarily
- 35:23committed to anyone. Proxy how much for them is not
- 35:27an end game. Who gives for them are not an
- 35:30end game. Yemen even is not a end game.
- 35:32For them. The end game is Saudi Arabia.
- 35:34For them, the end game is access to Eastern Mediterranean.
- 35:38For them, the end game is extreme level of influence
- 35:42throughout Europe. But all of these proxies are
- 35:45tools, so they are thinking what they are able to sacrifice at
- 35:50the moment and how they can get the read the US and UK and other
- 35:56allies response and where they can gauge and and find an
- 36:00opening. Right, right.
- 36:02Irena, one last question about India.
- 36:05What are the options here for SA, a neutral country like
- 36:10India? How do you see that?
- 36:13How do you see India's role till now and how do you think what is
- 36:17the best way India can look at its interest in that region
- 36:20without looking to take sides much?
- 36:24Well, for the time being, it has not yet come to a point where it
- 36:27needs to necessarily actively choose, although it's going to
- 36:31be pushed by all sides to do so. But it will need to take steps
- 36:36to actively, first of all, protect its interests from
- 36:40immediate tactical assaults. And we have seen it already
- 36:43doing so by sending warships into Indian of Ocean.
- 36:49It will probably be engaging in more active exercises with the
- 36:52other members of the Quad. Probably will be looking to
- 36:56discuss a greater intelligence and security and defense
- 37:00coordination bilaterally as well with various countries probably
- 37:06looking towards more advanced technologies, more advanced
- 37:10training. I think it eventually it will
- 37:13need to start shifting towards more western weapon system and
- 37:17away from the Russian systems simply due to quality and
- 37:21amount. India and the former Soviet
- 37:24Union have been closed for historic reasons.
- 37:27They have been very dependent on each other in terms of these
- 37:30systems. But today India is a country of
- 37:33a billion, nearly and a billion and a half people.
- 37:37Russia simply does not have what it takes to supply what needs to
- 37:42be in in the field of Modern Warfare.
- 37:45We have seen that the war in Ukraine has exhausted its
- 37:48capabilities. It's significantly stretched by
- 37:51the sanctions. It is barely able to provide for
- 37:54its own war. It will not be able to produce,
- 37:58practically speaking, the amount of various highly advanced
- 38:02technologies that India will need if it wants to become a
- 38:06very modern superpower. And that's where I think it's
- 38:11leading. So if you'll have to look to
- 38:13diverse other countries, mostly Western countries, it will need
- 38:18to restructure its military to to come to comply with the
- 38:24demands of of operating in this very advanced and hybrid threat
- 38:29environment. That's simply a practical
- 38:32reality, not for any ideological reasons, but because that's
- 38:35where it's all heading. You know it will probably draw a
- 38:39great deal on Brazil capabilities and other books
- 38:42member with very highly advanced technology.
- 38:47But you know, also it's been working with friends with
- 38:51Israel. Probably eventually it will get
- 38:54to the point where US we'll be able to solve technology.
- 38:58President Trump made a mistake, in my opinion, strategically,
- 39:02because he demanded that the India would shift completely to
- 39:06all of American weapons or not at all.
- 39:08That's not, you know, practicable for anybody in that
- 39:12in that position. Hopefully in future
- 39:14administrations will be more, you know, practically minded
- 39:19with that respect. But regardless that trend is
- 39:22likely to persist economically. It has been experimenting with
- 39:27different financial systems and it's interesting.
- 39:29I think the market ultimately just will show what option is
- 39:35winning. So far the going of trade in
- 39:38lupus has not worked out that well.
- 39:40It's a combination of different currencies has you know, is 1
- 39:47possibility. But if India wants to distance
- 39:50itself from China, it will probably want to rely on
- 39:54something other than Yuan for the time being.
- 39:57And the you know, China's economy is not very stable at
- 40:01the moment and probably will continue to be even less so if
- 40:05it's continuous with the current course of action.
- 40:08So it may have to. Kind of figure out where it
- 40:13wants to go. But this financial each aspect
- 40:17is something it will have to look at if it wants to protect
- 40:20its interests. I think it's trying hard to
- 40:24balance these relationships, but a lot of it means also
- 40:27transitioning from away from some towards others.
- 40:31And I think eventually, you know, states with other
- 40:36geopolitical ambitions, such as China, will make it impossible
- 40:40not to make the choice. When that's going to be,
- 40:43exactly, I don't know. In the past week, we have seen
- 40:47China launch a miniature, an experimental charm offensive by
- 40:51publishing a positive up and about Prime Minister Modi and
- 40:55about India's governance in its propaganda.
- 40:58But in reality, it will take a lot more than that to improve
- 41:02relations. And quite frankly, I think there
- 41:06are geopolitical rivals this. They're not going to be able to
- 41:09occupy the same space simultaneously with the same,
- 41:12with very competing and different visions of the future.
- 41:16And I don't think China's current leadership is amenable
- 41:20to any sort of compromise. I think they want to be #1 and
- 41:23the only one, whether it's India or the United States or anybody
- 41:29else. So I think India will probably
- 41:32be strengthening its relations with other in the Pacific
- 41:36countries, especially with we're seeing growing relations with
- 41:39the Japan. We will probably see a lot more
- 41:42with South Korea as well, a lot more in terms of technology
- 41:46space, communication space. There's also growing bilateral
- 41:53relations with Middle Eastern countries such as UEA, lot of
- 41:56investments flowing back and forth.
- 41:58So that sort of diversification is going to happen.
- 42:01I think there's also evidence of India looking to expand its
- 42:05economic reach into Africa. So it already has a significant
- 42:10bridge there. But I think it will look to
- 42:12build on that foundation in light of our critical minerals,
- 42:18in light of investments, in, in light of defence interest and
- 42:25trade of that sort. So we will probably see a lot of
- 42:30that going on and all without necessarily any direct
- 42:33confrontations. But but what India does
- 42:38voluntarily, which is all these things that they I, I, I see
- 42:41already happening, does not mean that adversarial actors will be
- 42:46content with just letting it move ahead at its own pace
- 42:50without bothering anybody. I think we will see that there
- 42:54will be various unwelcome moves to force it to to make the
- 43:00choice and I think it needs to be prepared for it.
- 43:02I think it's allies, historical allies of convenience and
- 43:07otherwise may not be ready to share India with others.
- 43:11And I think that will come at the point where India will be
- 43:16forced to shift away. I know that there's a big point
- 43:20about being independent, but I think part of being independent
- 43:23is also understanding who your allies are and who are countries
- 43:27that want to limit your interest based on their own concerns in a
- 43:32very hostile way. I think.
- 43:36I think those pragmatic decisions will be made when the
- 43:39time comes. Well explained, well explained.
- 43:44It is indeed a very difficult world, a different world than it
- 43:48was some years back, and all countries will need to be
- 43:51prepared for this. And as it happens, we will
- 43:54continue to get your analysis to the to the audience with this.
- 43:59It's a wrap on this very special edition of The World According
- 44:02to Irina Superman. Thank you so much indeed for
- 44:06joining us. Thank you so much.