Latest / Language of the Soul Podcast / Art Versus Propaganda: In the Eye of the Beholder?
Transcript
- 0:45SPEAKER_03: Hi guys, and welcome to Language of the Soul Podcast, where life is story.
- 0:50SPEAKER_03: Our regular listeners know we've been kind of sprinkling in pop culture episodes while finishing up the chapters of the book.
- 0:58SPEAKER_03: So I love it because you know I'm I'm a thinker.
- 1:02SPEAKER_03: So during the week, when there's maybe a uh cultural zeitgeist, I keep saying that, but you know, Odyssey, how could we not do an episode about the Odyssey and disclosure day for that matter?
- 1:14SPEAKER_03: So it feels good to be able to do relevant, timely episodes in the moment.
- 1:18SPEAKER_03: So in that spirit, uh Virginia and I sometimes go back and forth during the week just about things that are going on in our lives or in the news, and we magically stumble upon a genius concept for an episode.
- 1:31SPEAKER_03: That's exactly what happened this time around.
- 1:34SPEAKER_03: So I'm gonna let Virginia tell you from her perspective how we arrived maybe at this topic and maybe the premise of today's episode.
- 1:43SPEAKER_03: Welcome, Virginia Grenier.
- 1:45SPEAKER_00: Thanks.
- 1:46SPEAKER_00: Um, yeah, we were just kind of talking back and forth uh because we both saw Disclosure Day and Odyssey.
- 1:51SPEAKER_00: And from that, it kind of led more into just what we've been seeing, um, be it on Reels or TikTok to the media.
- 2:01SPEAKER_00: And then of course, we've been talking about art um and forms of art as well on this podcast.
- 2:08SPEAKER_00: And so between the two, we kind of got on to art versus propaganda.
- 2:12SPEAKER_00: And um I guess the best play to kind of start is I want to start with the actual distinction between art and propaganda.
- 2:19SPEAKER_00: And this is totally Virginia's mentality, not Nick's, of where I'm coming from.
- 2:25SPEAKER_00: Cause as you all know, I draw stick feet people.
- 2:28SPEAKER_00: So but uh I don't think it's uh as clean as I think we would like to say, you know, one is art and one is not.
- 2:36SPEAKER_00: Um, so I kind of went back into my old fashion brain back when I was in marketing.
- 2:41SPEAKER_00: So this is back 1990s, early 2000s, and I was really thinking about this concept.
- 2:46SPEAKER_00: And I was like, you know, when we were creating things, um, they were artistic for um the purpose of the fashion world.
- 2:54SPEAKER_00: Um, we were trying to be creative for thinking, visually interesting, and sometimes even very inspirational.
- 3:00SPEAKER_00: But we were also trying to persuade people.
- 3:03SPEAKER_00: That was my job.
- 3:04SPEAKER_00: We were trying to sell a brand, a look, an image, and sometimes the ideal of what beauty or fashion was supposed to look like at that moment in time.
- 3:12SPEAKER_00: So for me, propaganda is definitely intentional ideology with that concept behind it in art.
- 3:20SPEAKER_00: Um, it is trying to move you toward a particular belief, conclusion, or behavior.
- 3:25SPEAKER_00: But I also think that's not necessarily mean everything propaganda is cannot contain art.
- 3:32SPEAKER_00: Um, so what brought kind of brought my mind frame to that is I started thinking a little bit more when I was a marketing, I was like, hey, you know, Norman Rockwell is actually a great example.
- 3:41SPEAKER_00: You can look at some of those old Saturday evening post images or wartime imagery and recognize the messaging that was happening within that time period.
- 3:50SPEAKER_00: And I think there's also appreciating the artistic skill he had and the creativity involved.
- 3:56SPEAKER_00: And now, decades later, when we experience some of that art very differently through more of that artistic lens, we're no longer the audience that was originally trying to influence.
- 4:06SPEAKER_00: So I think that time can change our relationship with art as well, and propaganda and seeing it as art, it all just depends.
- 4:13SPEAKER_00: So, with that mindset, I'm wondering for you, Nick, do you think persuasion ends with pro when propaganda begins?
- 4:20SPEAKER_00: Because almost every artist wants to move us somehow.
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: So, when does that become something different?
- 4:27unknown: Wow.
- 4:28SPEAKER_03: I'm glad we have hopefully an hour and a half to talk about this because yeah, it definitely merits a whole uh episode, if not more than one.
- 4:37SPEAKER_03: Um, and I do go into like a whole chapter of the book is devoted to this conversation.
- 4:42SPEAKER_03: So I have a lot to say, even just in your premise, you know, there's so much to react to.
- 4:47SPEAKER_03: But I will first say, yes, you know, our perspective changes and the lens through which we view art changes.
- 4:55SPEAKER_03: So I was kind of saying to you in the green room that A, Norman Rockwell was an illustrator, not a fine artist.
- 5:01SPEAKER_03: So there is a huge separation there that an illustrator who's kind of hired to paint an illustration that's meant to accompany an article or even go on the cover of a magazine.
- 5:13SPEAKER_03: It's not based on the inspiration of the artist and what he or she has to say in the world.
- 5:18SPEAKER_03: It is uh a commission.
- 5:20SPEAKER_03: And some people really distinguish between commercial art and fine art.
- 5:24SPEAKER_03: So I love Norman Rockwell, and uh largely what you're referring to is craft.
- 5:30SPEAKER_03: He's a great painter, man.
- 5:31SPEAKER_03: He knows his form and how light affects form, and he knows color and perspective and light logic, and he's as good as it gets.
- 5:40SPEAKER_03: He's also a technician, and we're talking about craft.
- 5:43SPEAKER_03: Now, in Greg Spalenka, who's come on, as you know, when conceptual editorial illustration came along, an illustrator was being paid to bring their fine art sensibility to the project or the commission and reinterpret the content of the text according to their artistic sensibilities, right?
- 6:02SPEAKER_03: So it was the first time fine art entered the commercial art realm or again the illustrative realm.
- 6:08SPEAKER_03: So there's a lot of parsing to go on here.
- 6:11SPEAKER_03: But I agree with you, and I think through a modern lens, one, especially young people, could easily look at Norman Rockwell or Meindecker or any of those guys and say, that's the white picket fence America that I have no category for, and it's an illusion.
- 6:26SPEAKER_03: And propaganda from top to bottom, left to right.
- 6:30SPEAKER_03: So when you look at constructivist art during World War II, you know, artists were basically erased and silenced, except those that were willing to get in step with right the Third Reich, frankly.
- 6:44SPEAKER_03: And so you had filmmakers making only propaganda films, and public art was only propaganda that idealized and glorified the agenda.
- 6:55SPEAKER_03: So, you know what I mean?
- 6:56SPEAKER_03: These are long conversations, but I think yes, time absolutely changes whether we view something as art or propaganda.
- 7:03SPEAKER_03: I think when there's a movement in motion like idealism, you don't recognize it as propaganda or you know, we're fish in boiling water.
- 7:13SPEAKER_03: We don't realize that the American dream is an agenda and that our image making, how could it not be affected by that?
- 7:21SPEAKER_03: So long conversations here, but um that's one aspect of it.
- 7:25SPEAKER_03: Time changes the lens through which we see all art, therefore, it changes the line we draw between propaganda and fine art.
- 7:32SPEAKER_03: I agree.
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: And I agree with you.
- 7:33SPEAKER_00: And I do love the fact that you brought up the younger generation because it also talks about how propaganda, even though the messaging was set, you know, again, going back to World War II, great, you know, great example of where a lot of that was happening.
- 7:49SPEAKER_00: That because when things start to mirror the past, we start to see how that propaganda transcends into the future generations.
- 7:58SPEAKER_00: So I love that.
- 7:59SPEAKER_03: So when we see the cycle, right?
- 8:01SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 8:02SPEAKER_03: Well, young people may not have the perspective to see that history repeats, but something might seem eerily familiar, right?
- 8:09SPEAKER_03: So they're more resistant in a way.
- 8:11SPEAKER_00: Yes, exactly.
- 8:12SPEAKER_00: And and like you said, that American dream of the white picket fence, and you know, you have the two kids, and mom gets to stay home and take care of the kids, and dad goes to work, and like this conventional family, nuclear family narrative that you know, we just don't subscribe to and doesn't fit our modern society now.
- 8:29SPEAKER_00: So when we do see those images, it does remind us how far we've come and how there are people who are still trying to desperately dig their claws in and hold on to that too.
- 8:38SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 8:39SPEAKER_03: Which is the definition of conservatism, right?
- 8:43SPEAKER_03: To a degree.
- 8:44SPEAKER_03: The other, and I don't want to, you know, we can't dive into everything all at once, but I guess my other reaction to the way you prefaced the question was that yes, every artist, I would well, we haven't even defined art yet, right?
- 8:56SPEAKER_03: Or defined propaganda, which I would love to take the time to do that.
- 9:00SPEAKER_03: Not that there is a clean-cut answer.
- 9:02SPEAKER_03: Uh, one reaction to your preface again was, yeah, everything's it's in the eye of the beholder.
- 9:07SPEAKER_03: That's why we're gonna name the episode that, but also everything is degrees, everything is a gamut.
- 9:13SPEAKER_03: That's why I think the traditional definitions are important.
- 9:16SPEAKER_03: So, one thing I want to point out is that I'll just give an anecdotal example.
- 9:23SPEAKER_03: When I did the episode with Anthony about disclosure day and the Odyssey, my mind was not at all on one of the reactions that trolls have been projecting on it, which is, oh, that's woke.
- 9:38SPEAKER_03: That's woke bullshit.
- 9:39SPEAKER_03: Wasn't even on my radar, really.
- 9:41SPEAKER_03: I was aware of it, but that wasn't the episode we were having.
- 9:44SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 9:45SPEAKER_03: And so it didn't occur to me to factor that in.
- 9:49SPEAKER_03: But, you know, after we did the episode, I looked at some of the online comments from conservatives, largely MAGA Republicans, who use Christian nationalism as a, I would say, a thinly disguised veil for misogyny, racism, xenophobia, all of it.
- 10:07SPEAKER_03: They see it as woke.
- 10:10SPEAKER_03: Because a trans actor was cast in a pretty pivotal role that Homer didn't create, but actually later, I think it was uh Virgil that introduced Sinon, which was the Elliott Page character.
- 10:23SPEAKER_03: Anyway, how dare a trans actor be cast in that role?
- 10:27SPEAKER_03: And then Helen of Troy, the most beautiful woman in the world.
- 10:30SPEAKER_03: How dare they cast a black woman?
- 10:33SPEAKER_03: So, in my mind, like none of that registered because, yeah, vaguely I thought, oh, what a cool choice.
- 10:38SPEAKER_03: Because beauty comes in all forms, and why not?
- 10:41SPEAKER_03: So, yes, I think it was a choice to level the playing field, call it um we're we are kind of tackling everything all at once here, but affirmative action.
- 10:52SPEAKER_03: I draw a parallel with affirmative action.
- 10:54SPEAKER_03: So if modern casting directors are smart enough to go, well, that's an incidental role.
- 10:59SPEAKER_03: It doesn't really matter if the security guard is brown, white, or black.
- 11:03SPEAKER_03: They think to yes, overcorrect.
- 11:07SPEAKER_03: I am on board for the overcorrection.
- 11:09SPEAKER_03: But to me, that has really very little to do with what Christopher Nolan's intentions were in honoring a 3,000-year-old story about the human condition.
- 11:19SPEAKER_03: So I jokingly said to Anthony during the episode, well, there are grievances looking for a cause.
- 11:25SPEAKER_03: And so there is that.
- 11:27SPEAKER_03: If you don't agree with the worldview being espoused on screen, you're gonna see it as propaganda.
- 11:34SPEAKER_03: Period.
- 11:35SPEAKER_03: If I I mean, I'm the one guy when I went and saw Passion of the Christ.
- 11:39SPEAKER_03: Um, Mel Gibson was already being accused of A, B, C, and D.
- 11:43SPEAKER_03: I walked away going, and he told an amazing, beautiful story, and he's technically an amazing filmmaker.
- 11:52SPEAKER_03: So I can separate the artist from the work, but I guess that's one thing I want to make really clear is that the worldview of the artist, there's no getting around it.
- 12:03SPEAKER_03: Some films, like a Quentin Tarantino film, are his psyche splattered across the screen, and I find it kind of sophomoric.
- 12:10SPEAKER_03: I'm not down for his revenge fantasies.
- 12:13SPEAKER_03: There, that sophomoric need for revenge is not part of my worldview.
- 12:17SPEAKER_03: So he's hit and miss for me.
- 12:19SPEAKER_03: But I guess what I'm saying is, I think most people find it distasteful when they sense a line has been crossed, and now it's not a human agenda about the human condition, it's a political agenda.
- 12:33SPEAKER_03: There's a long conversation about has art always been a key player in social reform?
- 12:39SPEAKER_03: And then where does each individual draw the line?
- 12:42SPEAKER_03: So I will say, I mean, I have a list of people.
- 12:44SPEAKER_03: Woody Allen has been accused of even his penchant for underage girls.
- 12:49SPEAKER_03: You can see it in Manhattan, you can see it in a lot of his films.
- 12:53SPEAKER_03: Is that okay or not?
- 12:54SPEAKER_03: You see Mel Gibson's ultra-conservative worldview over and over again, no matter what he's depicting.
- 13:00SPEAKER_03: Apocalypto, is that the name of it?
- 13:03SPEAKER_03: Was a world very removed from ours, and you could still see Braveheart, total different time and place and context, and yet you see a direct parallel with his conservative views.
- 13:15SPEAKER_03: So that's like one conversation.
- 13:17SPEAKER_03: Where do artists have to strive for the universal and temper their own worldview?
- 13:24SPEAKER_03: And then when, which is I think it's in the eye of the beholder, when does an agenda lapse from a human agenda to a political agenda?
- 13:33SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I get what you're saying.
- 13:35SPEAKER_00: Um, and I I'm completely comfortable with diversity in storytelling.
- 13:40SPEAKER_00: I think it's needed in stories, that representation of the different cultures, races, identities, experiences, and ways of seeing the world.
- 13:47SPEAKER_00: Um, I do think there that artistic intention does matter.
- 13:51SPEAKER_00: Um, so I'm gonna go from a writer's standpoint of on this.
- 13:55SPEAKER_00: Um, when I create a character, I have an image right in my head of what that character looks like.
- 14:00SPEAKER_00: And sometimes there's race, culture, gender, sexual identity, and appearance that matters, and sometimes it may not matter at all to the story.
- 14:08SPEAKER_00: Um, if it does matter, I think there can be a lot of freedom in interpretation when it comes to someone else picking up that art, you know, that that book and deciding, hey, I want to turn it into a film.
- 14:20SPEAKER_00: Um, but sometimes I think it it does matter, and I think that's where understanding the creator behind the the art form is important um to understand like why it mattered to them and and if you should mess with that interpretation.
- 14:33SPEAKER_00: So if I'm writing something based on like actual like adolescence growing up and people I knew, um so that demographic of the world, the part of my reality that I'm pulling from, I feel like that matters.
- 14:46SPEAKER_00: Um, and that is where I think adaptation can become kind of interesting when that gets messed with by somebody else who's like trying to modernize it and bring it forth and forward.
- 14:55SPEAKER_00: So talking like, you know, bringing the Odyssey, you know, um when that was written long time ago, I think it wasn't really clear what you know.
- 15:06SPEAKER_00: I mean, Helen of Troy, we do we do have some relevant idea of of her background.
- 15:13SPEAKER_00: However, I loved an Odyssey when and when I saw it because she talked about, well, her sister was also married, you know, to to to another brother.
- 15:24SPEAKER_00: And you started going, hmm, I wonder if this was maybe to now go back into history.
- 15:29SPEAKER_00: And if you wrap your mind this way into the concept of, well, you had people who had marry from Spain into England, and people in England marry into um, I don't know, some some East Asian, you know, country or whatever, because they're trying to bring alliance.
- 15:47SPEAKER_00: So, how do we not know that wasn't the case there?
- 15:49SPEAKER_03: Well, here's where I'm gonna jump in and say, yeah, it's a myth.
- 15:53SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 15:54SPEAKER_03: There's a whole episode about whether the Trojan War is based on history and to what degree, but every time you find somebody up in arms and clutching their pearls about the ethnicity of a character.
- 16:07SPEAKER_03: How dare Snow White be told with the brown person in the lead role?
- 16:11SPEAKER_03: How dare the little mermaid have a black why would Disney cast a black per?
- 16:16SPEAKER_03: She's a fucking mermaid.
- 16:18SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 16:18SPEAKER_03: The Odyssey is based on a myth.
- 16:21SPEAKER_03: We could talk till the cows come home about reconciling history with mythology.
- 16:27SPEAKER_03: That's a dead end road.
- 16:29SPEAKER_03: It's understood to be a myth.
- 16:31SPEAKER_00: I agree.
- 16:31SPEAKER_00: No, it is a myth.
- 16:32SPEAKER_00: That's what I'm saying.
- 16:33SPEAKER_00: But if you if if you but if you take historical context of like how back, you know, in the early times, how there were those bridges of amongst countries, it's very feasible for that to happen constantly.
- 16:49SPEAKER_03: Look at art history.
- 16:52SPEAKER_03: Things get written out of history.
- 16:55SPEAKER_00: That's what I'm saying.
- 16:56SPEAKER_00: So to me, it it didn't bother me.
- 16:57SPEAKER_00: I was one of the people that didn't bother me because that's what I'm saying.
- 17:00SPEAKER_03: If you go back and you actually think historically what we know, the only people it bothered were racist.
- 17:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 17:07SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 17:08SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 17:10SPEAKER_03: Sorry, I didn't mean to twist your arm, but I'll I'll die on this hill.
- 17:13SPEAKER_00: No, no, that's no, that's what I'm saying.
- 17:15SPEAKER_00: Because that's what I'm saying.
- 17:16SPEAKER_00: If you look back historically, we had a lot of that happening where, you know, there were cross cross, you know, cultures and cross countries all the time.
- 17:24SPEAKER_00: So none of that bothered me because we've seen that since, like you said, you know, pretty much since the dawn of time.
- 17:30SPEAKER_00: So if it's bumping up against you, there's there's a reason for it.
- 17:33SPEAKER_00: And so I think filmmakers, casting directors, producers, when they're doing that, they're bringing in that artistic intention into the interpretation because they want to expand the mind and have you realize we're not isolated into these little bubbles of culture and people.
- 17:50SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 17:51unknown: Yeah.
- 17:51SPEAKER_03: And I think there's a separate conversation too between aspirational storytelling that gives us new tropes and new models.
- 18:00SPEAKER_03: And yes, that can include diversity and inclusion.
- 18:03SPEAKER_03: I really respect filmmakers like Inbrose, Gilly Eichner, chose every cast and crew member was from LGBTQ community.
- 18:13SPEAKER_03: That's a concerted effort to level the playing field.
- 18:16SPEAKER_03: Uh, Nicole Kidman will only cast female cinematographers.
- 18:20SPEAKER_03: There's a percentage, there's a formula she goes by just to even the play.
- 18:24SPEAKER_03: So that's kind of a separate conversation, but in my book, much needed.
- 18:28SPEAKER_03: I think when people respond to the DEI casting or the woke agenda of a given filmmaker, it's specifically because it doesn't align with their political andor worldviews.
- 18:39SPEAKER_03: So I have my own line that I draw.
- 18:42SPEAKER_03: In terms of, let's go back to the idea of whether it's a mythic character or a historical character.
- 18:48SPEAKER_03: I have a problem when Quentin Tarantino plays fast and loose with, I don't know, Hitler.
- 18:55SPEAKER_03: Like, I that's too precious to me and it's too important.
- 18:58SPEAKER_03: If you agree that we need to remember the horrors of history, lest they repeat themselves, we can't muddy the waters, in my opinion, by squandering that very precious to some people bit of history.
- 19:12SPEAKER_03: So he'll turn something into a revenge fantasy, right?
- 19:15SPEAKER_03: And in his mind, he might say, Oh, that's aspirational, that's empowering.
- 19:18SPEAKER_03: Django Unchained is empowering.
- 19:20SPEAKER_03: A revenge fantasy about Hitler, like Inglorious Bastards, that's empowering.
- 19:25SPEAKER_03: I'm sure he thinks that.
- 19:27SPEAKER_03: I think, eh, let's reserve the important stuff to the facts.
- 19:31SPEAKER_00: I and I do see the point there, and I've had that conversation because my children, um I say my children, they're like not that young.
- 19:38SPEAKER_00: Um, but we went and saw Hamilton and they love Hamilton, and Hamilton has a very diverse cast.
- 19:45SPEAKER_00: And I had a family member who who wasn't thrilled because they're like, wait, um, these are founding fathers, and we know that they were white.
- 19:53SPEAKER_03: And they had slaves.
- 19:54SPEAKER_00: And they had and they had slaves.
- 19:56SPEAKER_00: And I'm like, okay, but this is this is a musical.
- 20:00SPEAKER_00: And so I so I I was faced with that question, like, should that have stayed historically accurate to who those people were versus the diverse cast I had?
- 20:11SPEAKER_00: It didn't bother me.
- 20:12SPEAKER_00: However, I do think it's important because in certain it's depending on what you're doing when it comes to historical facts.
- 20:20SPEAKER_00: Because I think unfortunately, sometimes when we are told, oh, this is based on a true story, and you go in and something has been shifted a little bit with that creative freedom.
- 20:32SPEAKER_00: If someone doesn't do their due diligence and go look it up, they walk away thinking, oh, this was 100% fact, and you're like, not quite.
- 20:40SPEAKER_03: Yeah, you know, all the fairy tales, the Disney version becomes ingrained in pop culture moving forward.
- 20:49SPEAKER_03: You know, uh, the Little Mermaid didn't end well, and so maybe the cautionary tale is a bit lost when the Disney version becomes the quintessential version, right?
- 20:58SPEAKER_03: On the radar of pop culture, there's a lot of responsibility in these, I think, historical retellings.
- 21:05SPEAKER_03: Again, reiterations of a myth or retellings of a myth are not as precious to me.
- 21:11SPEAKER_03: But I'm with you 100%.
- 21:12SPEAKER_03: Don't mess with history because you there's a lot of responsibility in that your version could become the quintessential version.
- 21:19SPEAKER_03: And if you erase a pivotal character or if you tell an empowering story, then the cautionary tale is lost.
- 21:26SPEAKER_03: Another filmmaker could come along and show the injustice that existed then and now.
- 21:31SPEAKER_03: I read 12 Years a Slave recently, and it was more persuasive than any fictionalized story because it came from the horse's mouth, and it felt like it was written yesterday, if that makes sense.
- 21:43SPEAKER_03: I I think we're a little bit down a rabbit hole.
- 21:46SPEAKER_03: And in the green room, I said, let's not repeat former episodes, but this is exactly what I meant.
- 21:51SPEAKER_03: We're talking about revisionist history and silencing and erasing, and we're talking a little bit about whitewashing, and we already did that episode.
- 22:01SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I agree.
- 22:02SPEAKER_00: So I guess that's that's an interesting take when it comes to because sometimes art does talk about and is inspired by true events.
- 22:12SPEAKER_00: So how how does that keep it from going propaganda versus being more introspective and the artist literally taking what and and the best way for me to to articulate this is I feel like when when it's really inspirational from the artist, it's like you're literally like Hemi Way said, you know, you're literally opening up your vein and your blood's bleeding on the page.
- 22:37SPEAKER_00: You're you're literally taking the insides of who you are and you're trying to externalize them into whatever creative art form that is, be it.
- 22:45SPEAKER_00: Sculpture, canvas, illustration, film, photography, whatever, you know.
- 22:53SPEAKER_00: Um, how how does that stay within the art realm versus going into the propaganda realm when it is culturally relevant to what the artist is experiencing?
- 23:06SPEAKER_03: Well, again, long conversations, but I'm glad we're having them.
- 23:09SPEAKER_03: So I think it is a good moment to backpedal and define some of these terms because you know, we're getting a little off in the weeds and getting a little specific when as two individuals with the podcast and our listenership, we all need to be on the same page if if we're gonna, you know, have a conversation about this.
- 23:27SPEAKER_03: When we considered the title of this, you know, you went away and did your research, and your worldview is going to play into the prompts you come up with, and I did the same.
- 23:37SPEAKER_03: So I'll just speak from my worldview.
- 23:40SPEAKER_03: I learned literally in fifth grade, I learned the propaganda techniques, and I've never forgotten them.
- 23:47SPEAKER_03: Well, I guess I could rattle some of them off, but I devote a whole again chapter to this in the book.
- 23:53SPEAKER_03: You have ethos, pathos, and logos.
- 23:56SPEAKER_03: Those are the persuasive techniques that have been around forever.
- 24:00SPEAKER_03: Separate from that, I would say modern advertising has made a science out of right, playing or manipulating using logos, pathos, and ethos.
- 24:12SPEAKER_03: So true propaganda techniques, and I promise you, from fifth grade, they all stuck with me.
- 24:17SPEAKER_03: And we we can't go into all of them, but they'll make sense just hearing them.
- 24:21SPEAKER_03: Testimonial.
- 24:23SPEAKER_03: That's when you get, I guess I'm uh it's hard to not define them, but that's when you get a celebrity to talk about your toothpaste, right?
- 24:32SPEAKER_03: Stereotyping.
- 24:33SPEAKER_03: We see it all over in advertising, especially when the stereotyping makes you feel part of a group or alienates somebody and makes them the scapegoat.
- 24:41SPEAKER_03: And that leads to fear appeals.
- 24:44SPEAKER_03: Fear goes a long way.
- 24:45SPEAKER_03: So when you try to get somebody to buy your club because, right, somebody's gonna steal your car or you know, get a home alert system because, god forbid, you know, somebody out there dying to do a home invasion might target you.
- 24:58SPEAKER_03: You appeal to fear, the bandwagon.
- 25:01SPEAKER_03: Oh, do this because all your neighbors are doing it, keep up with the Joneses.
- 25:05SPEAKER_03: It's what it sounds like.
- 25:06SPEAKER_03: Plain folks.
- 25:07SPEAKER_03: Oh, folks just whenever I see a commercial that says folks just like you, I'm like, where the fuck are these people?
- 25:13SPEAKER_03: I don't know those people.
- 25:17SPEAKER_03: They think you're gonna want to not just keep up with the Joneses, but conform, plain folks, and even uh Tim Allen, I use him as my example, you know, he's the everyman.
- 25:29SPEAKER_03: But when I see somebody like Tom Hanks on the one side or Tim Allen on the other, I'm like, that's not everyman to me.
- 25:38SPEAKER_03: You know, I don't live in a bubble, but that's not my everyman.
- 25:41SPEAKER_03: Um, in a very diverse metropolitan area like LA.
- 25:45SPEAKER_03: Um transfer, that's when you make false correlations and you, you know, either create positive associations with your product and or political campaign, or make negative associations, which would be name-calling and mudslinging and otherizing.
- 26:02SPEAKER_03: Um, then there is name-calling, which a lot of these you see more in political campaigning than in advertising.
- 26:10SPEAKER_03: Card stacking, glittering generalities, and then ad nauseum.
- 26:16SPEAKER_03: That just means you know, kids will sing jingles before they learn to speak.
- 26:20SPEAKER_03: Uh, the sheer volume with which you bombard people with your product means they're going to reach for it on the shelf for sheer familiarity over another brand.
- 26:31SPEAKER_03: And that's it.
- 26:32SPEAKER_03: Those are all 10.
- 26:34SPEAKER_03: Do they click for you, Virginia?
- 26:36SPEAKER_00: They do.
- 26:37SPEAKER_03: I guess I should probably get back to your question.
- 26:40SPEAKER_03: The reason I went into that is I think we know those when we see them.
- 26:44SPEAKER_03: Again, from my perspective, when we were formulating this topic, those have been in my brain since the late 70s in elementary school.
- 26:53SPEAKER_03: Then, of course, I went to Art Center, one of the top design schools in the world.
- 26:57SPEAKER_03: And I have a lot of had a lot of ideologies pounded into my head.
- 27:01SPEAKER_03: Some of them are romantic notions about the creative process and what art serves in society, and some are a little more lowbrow or pedestrian, but that's where I really cemented my understanding of art.
- 27:13SPEAKER_03: Way later, life alone taught me what component that you were hinting at earlier, what component in the creative process infuses the product with that artistic merit, that artistic integrity, that literary value.
- 27:31SPEAKER_03: In my world, it's inspiration.
- 27:34SPEAKER_03: And again, without losing anyone just yet, if you're creating something for the Almighty Dollar or for political persuasion, and that's the desired outcome, it's not based on inspiration.
- 27:46SPEAKER_03: You might employ the same creative process toward you know that end, but it didn't come from the universe.
- 27:53SPEAKER_03: The universe, call it collective consciousness, knows what's needed in our dialectic.
- 27:59SPEAKER_03: That's why you have pendulum swings, that's why you all art, for good or bad, like it or not, contributes to social reform.
- 28:07SPEAKER_03: It might be the biggest player in social reform.
- 28:10SPEAKER_03: So, again, without repeating everything, it's well documented that we change minds by touching hearts.
- 28:17SPEAKER_03: When we're faced with persuasion of any kind, somebody standing on a soapbox, and these are the no-nos in art, in my understanding.
- 28:25SPEAKER_03: If it's too didactic, if it's meant to be persuasive and it doesn't show all sides of an issue or all sides of a thematic coin, if it's there to persuade or manipulate, it the artistic integrity is by definition eroded.
- 28:42SPEAKER_03: Right?
- 28:42SPEAKER_03: So that's the line I draw.
- 28:44SPEAKER_03: And this is over years, do you know what I mean?
- 28:46SPEAKER_03: Of living in this milieu, and my understanding has evolved.
- 28:50SPEAKER_03: But that said, the worldview of an artist is inseparable from the product.
- 28:57SPEAKER_03: So it becomes in the eye of the beholder.
- 29:00SPEAKER_03: If you agree with the worldview they seem to be espousing, you don't experience it as didactic or preachy, right?
- 29:08SPEAKER_03: You just see it as, oh, that's life-affirming.
- 29:11SPEAKER_03: Oh, that's about the human condition.
- 29:13SPEAKER_03: That's what you and I on this podcast often call a human agenda over a political agenda.
- 29:20SPEAKER_03: But if you disagree with Woody Allen's worldview or uh Mel Gibson's worldview, or even Christopher Nolan's worldview, which is hard to imagine, then you squirm, then you clutch your pearls, then you call it an agenda because it feels political.
- 29:39SPEAKER_03: I'm kind of all over the place here, but though that's where I'm coming from a little bit.
- 29:43SPEAKER_00: No, and I and I get that.
- 29:44SPEAKER_00: And and what comes up for me is I think of um the concept then of well, if if you're seeing something that is coming from literally, you know, externalizing from the inspiration of the artist being externalized.
- 30:02SPEAKER_00: And you know, as you say, someone's collecting their pearls, then it's like, well, that's where the curiosity needs to come in.
- 30:09SPEAKER_00: And you need to ask yourself, well, why am I having this reaction?
- 30:13SPEAKER_03: So that's your therapist mind talking now.
- 30:15SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's my therapist mind talking.
- 30:17SPEAKER_00: And so when I go into that, so for example, so we went and saw the Odyssey, and I took my 16-year-old to go see it.
- 30:24SPEAKER_00: Um, she has not read the Iliad, she has not read the Odyssey, so she has, she's never, but you know, she's there's the YouTube um out there if you go look it up, where a bunch of illustrators, and I don't remember the name of the uh of the musician who wrote a bunch of music to the Odyssey through, you know, through the chapters of the Odyssey to tell the story.
- 30:49SPEAKER_00: So it eventually could become a musical, it never happened.
- 30:51SPEAKER_00: Um, anyways, a bunch of different fan fan artists compilated and put it all together with the music and told the story.
- 30:59SPEAKER_00: So she played it for me.
- 31:00SPEAKER_00: She's like, so I really want to go see Nolan's, you know, um film because I love this so much and the music and it moves me.
- 31:07SPEAKER_00: Anyway, so I took her to go see it, and it's like her favorite movie now.
- 31:11SPEAKER_00: It's like in her top two movies of all time.
- 31:14SPEAKER_00: Yeah, love, love, love that she loves it that much.
- 31:17SPEAKER_00: Um, so but I I, you know, same thing.
- 31:20SPEAKER_00: You know, I knew there was a few people who won't go see it for various reasons that we've already talked about.
- 31:25SPEAKER_00: And so it made me kind of go into that mindset of well, but the the cinematography in this is just amazing.
- 31:33SPEAKER_00: And I actually watched the 30-minute and I can't remember where it was at out there in streaming, but the making of the Odyssey, and it's just amazing the camera angles and just how everything went into this thing, and little, very little um special effects are used um in the movie, which is amazing um that they did that.
- 31:58SPEAKER_00: So, you know, I think that's amazing and and just the technique in itself, and so it goes to that whole question of you know what makes something great or you know, great art, as we like to say.
- 32:10SPEAKER_03: That that's craft, that's all craft, yeah.
- 32:12SPEAKER_00: And it is it is craft, I agree.
- 32:14SPEAKER_03: And technique, it's technique.
- 32:16SPEAKER_00: So um sorry.
- 32:18SPEAKER_00: Oh, yeah.
- 32:20SPEAKER_00: Do you have a thought?
- 32:20SPEAKER_00: No, go ahead.
- 32:22SPEAKER_03: Yeah, well, I'm sure you're headed somewhere, but I think I'll give one example.
- 32:27SPEAKER_03: There's a film from Gaspar No called Irreversible, and I've talked about it before, and I don't want to go too far into it, but it's a very disturbing film.
- 32:38SPEAKER_03: And I prefer films that provoke that you think about for a week.
- 32:43SPEAKER_03: That is largely one of the functions of art that I cherish.
- 32:46SPEAKER_03: If it provokes you or haunts you, then usually the storyteller has done his or her job, but it's so demoralizing that you you you really have no will to live.
- 33:00SPEAKER_03: I joke, like, okay, to my students, I would say you can watch it, but give yourself a weekend to recover the will to live.
- 33:05SPEAKER_03: You'll be in the fetal position, like it's that dark.
- 33:09SPEAKER_03: And I won't go into why, but a lot of people really walked away going, oh, he's trying to habituate people to violence, he's just another Nazi.
- 33:18SPEAKER_03: And there is that argument that things that don't have any redemption thematically or don't have much to say can just cement an addiction to cortisol and adrenaline on the macro level, or glorify something unintentionally, glorify violence.
- 33:35SPEAKER_03: So these are all separate conversations.
- 33:38SPEAKER_03: But I just know I had the same reaction, like, oh my god, he's too good technically.
- 33:44SPEAKER_03: Let's not just accuse him of being a Nazi, he's too good for that.
- 33:48SPEAKER_03: So my mind looked for what is he trying to say?
- 33:51SPEAKER_03: What is the redemptive thematic content that he's imparting?
- 33:55SPEAKER_03: And all I can come up with is like, you want to just cherish life.
- 33:59SPEAKER_03: It was very life-affirming.
- 34:01SPEAKER_03: You walk away, I guess I you have to explain what it was about to get there, but it's you just walk away going, everything's futile.
- 34:08SPEAKER_03: You throw your hands in the air.
- 34:09SPEAKER_03: Well, he just illustrated to me for two hours that damned if you do, damned if you don't, you're gonna fall victim to your demons.
- 34:17SPEAKER_03: And so all I could come up with is eh, it makes you want to cling to every bit of beauty and every puppy and daisy and rainbow that crosses your path because life is here and now.
- 34:28SPEAKER_03: Does that make sense?
- 34:29SPEAKER_03: So I tend to give credit to the artist with Mel Gibson.
- 34:32SPEAKER_03: Same thing.
- 34:33SPEAKER_03: Trust me, I had when Passion of the Christ came out, it was at the height.
- 34:37SPEAKER_03: You know, his father had just come out as a KKK member or whatever, and it was very controversial.
- 34:44SPEAKER_03: Trust me, I had a Jewish friend say, Why are you not boycotting that film?
- 34:49SPEAKER_03: And I said, Well, I separate the artist from the work, and I it almost ended the friendship.
- 34:56SPEAKER_03: I said, I actually saw the gospel being told in a way that showed all humans are faulted.
- 35:03SPEAKER_03: There was, it was an equal opportunity human basher.
- 35:06SPEAKER_03: You know, they made it anyway.
- 35:08SPEAKER_03: I don't want to defend him at all, but she opened my eyes and she said, Do you not realize that Christ killer has been used for centuries, way back to the plague when you know Jews would take in the orphaned babies because nobody else would.
- 35:23SPEAKER_03: Suddenly they became bloodsuckers and vampires.
- 35:26SPEAKER_03: And like she schooled me, but I still got, I guess, a little swept up in the technique because it was so well done on a craft level.
- 35:36SPEAKER_03: So I gave him maybe a little too much credit, if that makes sense.
- 35:39SPEAKER_03: So I do separate between craft and yeah, Christopher Nolan made a beautiful film.
- 35:44SPEAKER_03: I will also say, if you because I've seen every single film about, yeah, everything was practical on set, very little effects.
- 35:51SPEAKER_03: I've seen every video out there, seen every interview with every cast member, everything that he's said publicly, and it's a beautiful film.
- 35:59SPEAKER_03: I will also say he honored Homer's version 99% of the way.
- 36:05SPEAKER_03: And it's testament to the fact that it's really universal, it transcends time, as we talk about on here, you know.
- 36:13SPEAKER_03: The Greek tragedies still speak to the human condition, Shakespeare still we evolve pretty slowly.
- 36:19SPEAKER_03: So I feel like sure, Christopher Nolan might have, and sorry, I'm going on and on, but he might have absolutely made it a little more relevant to all the wars that are being waged right now.
- 36:28SPEAKER_03: Oh, you come home with PTSD, you can't unsee that shit.
- 36:32SPEAKER_03: How do you return home to use the symbolism?
- 36:35SPEAKER_03: How do you return home to innocence when you've seen too much?
- 36:39SPEAKER_03: That film was about the horrors of war and it what it does to people.
- 36:43SPEAKER_03: So that was in the original text.
- 36:47SPEAKER_03: All of this hoopla, I've never said that word in my life, hoopla around this film made me go back and watch Clash of the Titans.
- 36:55SPEAKER_03: I grew up on, I think it was 1981, I grew up on the Harry Hamlin version and I loved it.
- 37:00SPEAKER_03: I kind of missed out on, I guess it was 2010, maybe.
- 37:05SPEAKER_03: Like I I did see it, but it didn't stick.
- 37:09SPEAKER_03: So I went back and saw that one.
- 37:11SPEAKER_03: Do you know the one I'm talking about?
- 37:12SPEAKER_00: With uh I yeah, I do I and I and I like the one from our 80s year too.
- 37:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I can't.
- 37:18SPEAKER_03: Oh, um, I can't think of his name.
- 37:22SPEAKER_03: Well, it had Ray Fines and it as Zeus.
- 37:25SPEAKER_03: Do you happen to remember who that was?
- 37:27SPEAKER_00: Um, I don't, but I do remember where they redid it because I was like kind of Liam Neeson.
- 37:34SPEAKER_03: Sorry, it just yeah, there you go.
- 37:35SPEAKER_03: I need more coffee.
- 37:36SPEAKER_03: Anyway, really beautiful film, really well done.
- 37:40SPEAKER_03: Yes, way more effects than Christopher Nolan would have used, and obviously, it was about you know the mythology that comes chronologically long before the Trojan War and all that, but I just was swept up in uh the mythic fiction aspect of it, and I watched it.
- 37:56SPEAKER_03: Same thing.
- 37:57SPEAKER_03: Oh my god, and he did make it more concise, kind of like you know, Wizard of Oz became more concise in the screenplay, and I would say the same of Wuthering Heights, it actually becomes more impactful in its condensed version somehow.
- 38:11SPEAKER_03: But I watched that one and I'm like, it couldn't be more of an encapsulation of the human condition, and yeah, it's relevant now, but not because he made it that way, because it inherently is, because the human condition evolves very slowly.
- 38:26SPEAKER_03: Sorry, am I making any sense?
- 38:28SPEAKER_00: You are, and that's and I was going into that because you because even though yes, there's that technique that you're talking about, Nolan.
- 38:34SPEAKER_00: When I was watching, because I had already watched all the making of Odyssey before as I was noticing, because you know, I was looking for those specific things that were talked about in those different interviews.
- 38:44SPEAKER_00: Um, like you said, it was going back to what to me I feel like made it what I would consider great art, and I think it's gonna transcend um over the generations, is because it did embrace Homer's story and the cinematography that was tied to it enhanced the story, therefore making it the great art because it resonated within your soul and then it visually was effective at the same time.
- 39:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 39:15SPEAKER_03: If you don't have the technique to pull off your vision, sometimes the messaging doesn't land.
- 39:21SPEAKER_03: Messaging is a tricky word too, right?
- 39:24SPEAKER_03: But of course, if a somebody has a lot to say in the world, but they're tone deaf, they may not reach people emotionally because they lack, right?
- 39:35SPEAKER_03: The um form uh the form to to to uh get to the point of it being what was the word I mentioned earlier, um, contextualism.
- 39:46SPEAKER_03: Like, yeah, you gotta have the technique in some cases for the messaging to land.
- 39:51SPEAKER_03: But um, I do want to go back to uh I was kind of headed somewhere when I said, you know, the propaganda techniques stuck in fifth grade, then art center taught me the definitions, romantic or not, about what art actually is.
- 40:05SPEAKER_03: Then much later I came into the view that inspiration may be the thing that delineates art from propaganda.
- 40:13SPEAKER_03: But the reason I went into that is I guess to say we'll never be able to define art.
- 40:20SPEAKER_03: I think we've been trying, but I know that uh again, I'll tell a story that's the best way.
- 40:27SPEAKER_03: Um about seven years ago now, somebody said, Oh my god, this poet's amazing, you gotta check out this YouTube video.
- 40:34SPEAKER_03: And I checked it out and I was like, ugh, I feel like I was just preached to from a soapbox for 20 minutes.
- 40:41SPEAKER_03: Is that art?
- 40:42SPEAKER_03: And so we've all felt that way, you know.
- 40:46SPEAKER_03: It's manipulative, it's dot dot dot.
- 40:49SPEAKER_03: But I very much had to do a reality check, and I thought, well, maybe the definition of art is evolving.
- 40:56SPEAKER_03: People that weren't raised on some of the elitist, you know, viewpoints that I was exposed to at Art Center might actually mistake preaching or didactic messaging for art.
- 41:09SPEAKER_03: Not what I was raised on, but I do I saw a trend.
- 41:13SPEAKER_03: I kept my eye on it.
- 41:14SPEAKER_03: Ooh, for colored girls by Tyler Perry.
- 41:18SPEAKER_03: Largely political grandstanding.
- 41:21SPEAKER_03: You know, you could go.
- 41:22SPEAKER_03: I mean, it's in the eye of the beholder.
- 41:24SPEAKER_03: I think Maya Angelou, you could say, well, she was the forefront of social reform, but it's agenda-ridden.
- 41:30SPEAKER_03: Is it art?
- 41:32SPEAKER_03: So I think art is always evolving.
- 41:35SPEAKER_03: The public, the mainstream, might be mistaking didactic content for art.
- 41:45SPEAKER_03: And so I did a reality check.
- 41:46SPEAKER_03: I like you.
- 41:47SPEAKER_03: I went to Chat GPT, and this is just hopefully to get us all on the same page, and thought, am I crazy?
- 41:53SPEAKER_03: Am I a dinosaur?
- 41:54SPEAKER_03: Are all of these things obsolete in this current climate?
- 41:57SPEAKER_03: I'm gonna give you the response.
- 41:59SPEAKER_03: Hold on one second.
- 42:02SPEAKER_03: And here's a hint I was validated, I'm not a dinosaur.
- 42:07SPEAKER_03: Okay, so here's what I wrote in a single paragraph, please, and I would rather just say it in my own words, because there's entire chunks of my book I could be reading, but just in the interest of time, I wrote to Chad GPT, and I can't read it all, but I wrote in a single paragraph, please describe the academic and vernacular distinction between art and propaganda.
- 42:28SPEAKER_03: Be clear about art in all its definitions versus propaganda in its many forms.
- 42:35SPEAKER_03: The answer was in both academic discourse and everyday usage, art is generally understood as a form of creative expression whose primary purpose is to explore, communicate, or evoke aesthetic, emotional, intellectual, or experiential meaning, even when it advances, even when it advances a particular viewpoint.
- 42:59SPEAKER_03: While propaganda is communication whose primary purpose is to persuade, mobilize, or manipulate an audience toward a predetermined ideological, political, religious, commercial, or social objective.
- 43:14SPEAKER_03: I love the wording because you could write, parse every single one of these words.
- 43:20SPEAKER_03: The distinction, therefore, is not whether a work contains a message, virtually all art does, but whether its central aim is open-ended inquiry or directed advocacy.
- 43:32SPEAKER_03: I highlighted that in red and I made it bold.
- 43:36SPEAKER_03: Whether its central aim, its intention, its impetus, its inspiration, I'm kind of just giving you uh some synonyms there, is an open-ended inquiry or directed advocacy.
- 43:50SPEAKER_03: So that is what I understood for a lifetime.
- 43:54SPEAKER_03: That if you're a true artist, inspiration strikes.
- 43:58SPEAKER_03: And if you're a seasoned artist, you honor that and execute that inspiration by largely showing all sides of that thematic coin.
- 44:06SPEAKER_03: Because when the patron has to resolve cognitive dissonance without being spoon-fed the answer, if it evokes or provokes or invites conversation, the cognitive dissonance happens within.
- 44:22SPEAKER_03: You come to your own conclusions, if that makes sense, and you're transformed.
- 44:27SPEAKER_03: When people are preached to, as we've talked about endlessly, the ego steps in, they dig in their heels, they fall back on confirmation bias, identity politics, um, even cherry picking of facts to resist at all costs.
- 44:43SPEAKER_03: You talk about that a lot resisting change.
- 44:45SPEAKER_03: Or paradigm shift at all costs.
- 44:48SPEAKER_03: When you catch them by surprise using all the chemicals that story can, you know, employ, they're taken off guard despite themselves on an emotional level, not on an intellectual level.
- 45:03SPEAKER_03: So it sounds very hallmark and very silly, but that's how you change minds by touching hearts.
- 45:09SPEAKER_03: So persuasion is one of the big no-nos.
- 45:12SPEAKER_03: Attachment is one of the big no no's in the definition of art I was raised on.
- 45:16SPEAKER_03: If it's too sentimental, you're out.
- 45:19SPEAKER_03: Because it's cloying, because it's manipulative.
- 45:23SPEAKER_03: If you have an agenda or an outcome in mind, it automatically erodes the artistic integrity in what I was raised on.
- 45:32SPEAKER_03: And so you show all sides of the thematic coin.
- 45:34SPEAKER_03: And if it's interactive on the part of the patron, that's a lasting change.
- 45:38SPEAKER_03: That's a paradigm shift.
- 45:40SPEAKER_03: Is any of that making sense?
- 45:42SPEAKER_00: It absolutely does.
- 45:43SPEAKER_00: Because what's coming up for me, and and I can, you know, again, on an artistic note, with writing, um, you know, we all know there's there's books that are definitely written out there that are written for a very, you know, using very formulaic method because they know it's gonna sell.
- 46:00SPEAKER_00: So to me, I feel like it very much falls into that category.
- 46:04SPEAKER_00: Not that it's propaganda, but you know, when it's formulaic and you're just doing it because you know it's gonna bring you in your paycheck, it's not, I don't feel like it's inspirational when it's something you just feel like you have to write.
- 46:16SPEAKER_00: Again, it's it's really taking what's happening within you and trying to externalize it the best way you can for other people to understand the the perspective of which you're seeing you know the world through.
- 46:30SPEAKER_00: Um I I feel that I feel that is where artistic integrity comes in, and that is art.
- 46:38SPEAKER_00: Um so here's a thought for you.
- 46:41SPEAKER_00: And I and and this this is gonna maybe throw you a little bit, but growing, you know, growing growing up in LA County in the LA area, right?
- 46:50SPEAKER_00: We see graffiti everywhere.
- 46:52SPEAKER_00: And when we grew up, it was vandalism, tagging, destruction.
- 46:57SPEAKER_00: It was seen as horrible.
- 46:58SPEAKER_00: However, we have seen where there are photographers and even um people who do watercolors, uh, oil paints and stuff, painting the scenery of this gritty inner city, you know, graffiti, and it's become art.
- 47:16SPEAKER_00: And so I I kind of was thinking of that.
- 47:19SPEAKER_00: Like, I'm sure the people who are tagging, you know, they're usually because whatever, you know, I was a kid, I've been there, um, grew up during the time, you know, we want to, I would, you know, Virginia was here, whatever.
- 47:32SPEAKER_00: There's those tags, you know.
- 47:33SPEAKER_00: Obviously, the gangs also put their their tag out there to to show that it's their area.
- 47:39SPEAKER_00: Some people would do it from very specific messaging that they want to let people know so it's their viewpoint.
- 47:46SPEAKER_00: So it's a very, you know, idealistic message that's that gets put out there.
- 47:53SPEAKER_00: And then there's people who s who can see the whole framework of this culture and want to capture it in an artistic form, which is when we see the photography and the different, you know, um illustrations and paintings and stuff that are out there.
- 48:14SPEAKER_00: And so I what I'm wondering is in that, what do you think allows certain art to transcend a generation and have it disappear from the moment it was created and to create that more visionary inspirational piece from what could be seen as vandalism or destruction or propaganda.
- 48:42SPEAKER_03: Well, so you're equating vandalism, which some would call beautification, as propaganda?
- 48:50SPEAKER_00: Because well, no, it's it's it's vandalism's vandalism, propaganda is different, but I'm saying, but we've seen people take pictures of this, you know, this inner city, and they're amazing photos and they're very inspirational.
- 49:01SPEAKER_00: So I'm just kind of wondering when you see that happen.
- 49:06SPEAKER_03: Okay, so I have a problem with like art of art, like representation in art school.
- 49:15SPEAKER_03: I won't say any names, but I had a friend that for her graphite or charcoal, I don't remember which charcoal rendering, which was a big assignment in this one class that everybody had to do, like a huge oversized charcoal rendering, she rendered her Mickey Mouse telephone.
- 49:30SPEAKER_03: And I immediately was like, You can't do art of art.
- 49:33SPEAKER_03: Like I just cringe.
- 49:36SPEAKER_03: So you're saying people painted narrative scenarios of people tagging, and that was seen as art.
- 49:43SPEAKER_03: Yeah, but whereas some patrons would say tagging in and of itself is not art, it's low bro, it's vandalism, it's not art, but yet the images, the what beautiful watercolor paintings they saw as art.
- 49:54SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 49:55SPEAKER_03: Okay, so there's too much there, and I don't see any of it as related to propaganda conversation.
- 50:01SPEAKER_03: I I won't go into all the different art forms, but I think you're kind of hinting at just to get this one off the table for now.
- 50:09SPEAKER_03: The definition of art is always evolving.
- 50:12SPEAKER_03: And I use Piss Christ as an example, or the bisected cow, or the the moment when a urinal was put on a pedestal and called art.
- 50:22SPEAKER_03: You know, the definition of art is evolving.
- 50:25SPEAKER_03: Some things just have to happen in that dialectic so we can get it out of our system and move on to the next definition of art.
- 50:32SPEAKER_03: I joke, yeah, well, a pedestal just had to be put, I mean, a urinal had to be put on a pedestal at some point.
- 50:38SPEAKER_03: Uh, now whether the NEA wants to direct public tax dollars toward these things that are controversial is another story.
- 50:47SPEAKER_03: But I hope that makes sense.
- 50:48SPEAKER_03: Like, I think I appreciate art history and I appreciate how the definition evolves.
- 50:54SPEAKER_03: And suddenly, when representation was replaced by photography, then conceptual art took the forefront.
- 51:02SPEAKER_03: It was the logical progression of the dialectic.
- 51:05SPEAKER_03: I don't know if that's making sense, but to me, those are all separate conversations, and the end of that dead end road is always it's in the eye of the beholder.
- 51:15SPEAKER_03: Right?
- 51:16SPEAKER_03: Aesthetic.
- 51:17SPEAKER_03: So I think maybe something worth talking about is sometimes the definitions of art veer toward appreciated solely for its aesthetic value.
- 51:28SPEAKER_03: So utilitarian efforts are seen as craft, a beautiful spoon.
- 51:34SPEAKER_03: Remember uh when Brian came on and talked about his love of whittling spoons.
- 51:41SPEAKER_03: I see craft like Wahawk and wood sculpture or a useful jewelry box that's really intricately embossed.
- 51:49SPEAKER_03: Like that's the most beautiful art to me.
- 51:51SPEAKER_03: And yet, elitists would call it craft or utilitarian.
- 51:56SPEAKER_03: So that dead end road, it's always in the eye of the beholder.
- 52:00SPEAKER_03: But I will go to my grave saying, kind of what we just talked about uh is the line universally, traditionally, between art and propaganda.
- 52:10SPEAKER_03: It boils down to the desired outcome.
- 52:14SPEAKER_03: In modernism, the second half of this century, uh, you know, post-mid-century modernism, you have a lot of movements like process art or um performance art.
- 52:31SPEAKER_03: A lot of them say you just honor the inspiration and execute it.
- 52:36SPEAKER_03: You're not responsible for how it lands or for the contextualism or for the projections or attributions of the patron.
- 52:43SPEAKER_03: You're honoring a process, and your job kind of ends right there.
- 52:49SPEAKER_03: So I don't know really what I'm saying, but the impetus, I'm gonna just throw a bunch of words out the inspiration for doing something, the impetus for doing it, the desired outcome, which is completely irrelevant in some schools of thought, that is the determining factor of what most people will experience as art versus propaganda.
- 53:11SPEAKER_03: So, again, I don't expect anyone to follow me on this one, but it took writing a 360-page book about it to formulate this view.
- 53:22SPEAKER_03: And again, it would take a while.
- 53:24SPEAKER_03: But if you agree there is something called collective consciousness, if you agree with epigenetics and quantum mechanics, that we don't just have a lizard brain, we have a prefrontal cortex.
- 53:36SPEAKER_03: We have a lot of internal messaging, whether you want to go romantic about it and call it, you know, the reservoir of collective unconscious that Jung would talk about, or that it's all tropes that we internalize through social conditioning.
- 53:51SPEAKER_03: None of that matters, but I think all of us would agree that we have a sphere, a conceptual sphere.
- 53:57SPEAKER_03: It's called the Noah Sphere, it's called the invisible realm of our ideas.
- 54:01SPEAKER_03: That includes thought forms, paradigms, codes that we live by that become laws.
- 54:07SPEAKER_03: All of those ideas must evolve.
- 54:11SPEAKER_03: If our ideas didn't evolve, we would have perished a long time ago as a species.
- 54:16SPEAKER_03: So if you agree with any of that, what is at the forefront of those evolving thought forms?
- 54:24SPEAKER_03: Artists, poets, storytellers, philosophers, eh, sometimes politicians.
- 54:32SPEAKER_03: But I think I'm not the first one to say, and many schools of thought support this, that art is in bed with social reform.
- 54:42SPEAKER_03: So it's going to be propaganda always in the eyes of the beholder, if that beholder doesn't share the worldview.
- 54:52SPEAKER_03: If they share their worldview, oh, it's just a human agenda.
- 54:55SPEAKER_03: It advances, it's aspirational, it advances us in our march toward human potential.
- 55:01SPEAKER_03: Am I making any sense at all?
- 55:04SPEAKER_00: You are.
- 55:05SPEAKER_03: So inspiration is the, for me, the dividing line.
- 55:10SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 55:11SPEAKER_03: Um, it is about outcome.
- 55:13SPEAKER_03: Again, we call it manipulative, we call it preachy, we call it a number of things.
- 55:16SPEAKER_03: If it's political campaigning, it has an end game that seems less admirable.
- 55:21SPEAKER_03: If it's to get in your pocketbook and it's for the almighty dollar, it somehow seems less distasteful.
- 55:27SPEAKER_03: Inspiration ensures that the content you create is not vapid, it's not vacuous, it's not glorifying, it's not perpetuating disempowering tropes, for example, but it's actually possibly contributing to our forward march toward human potential.
- 55:47SPEAKER_03: So, yeah, inspiration, having something to say in the world, developing your voice, connecting that voice with a sense of purpose, all of that is kind of synonymous.
- 55:55SPEAKER_03: And I'm preaching, and now I'm on a soapbox, but this is this is not art, this is discourse.
- 56:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 56:05SPEAKER_00: Um, it's yeah, so it's it's for again going back to it's very much externalizing what what is passionately moving you in terms of yeah, and I'm just calling that inspiration and I'm assigning it a lot of value uh by saying that it comes from the universe.
- 56:25SPEAKER_03: But I'm not again not the first one to say that either.
- 56:28SPEAKER_00: No, you're not.
- 56:29SPEAKER_00: And I love the fact too that you've that you've also have reiterated multiple times that art in itself is by the is in the eye of the beholder because we're not saying everybody has to sit down and go, this is great art.
- 56:42SPEAKER_00: You can have maybe a third of the population that's saying this is art, and two-thirds not sure and not maybe not even know knowing what to call it.
- 56:52SPEAKER_00: Um which is which is valid.
- 56:54SPEAKER_00: So I'm I'm wondering and and I know I know how I feel, and I'll share that in a second, but when when because it is, it's very vulnerable when art's put out there by the creator.
- 57:08SPEAKER_00: Um I mean, I literally feel like we're we're peeling back our our skin and exposing our nerves to to the outside world, right?
- 57:17SPEAKER_00: So when someone doesn't understand and or again clutches their pearls, right, and starts judging it and feels um opposed to it.
- 57:33SPEAKER_00: As artists, I I I think at least for me, I stop and think, okay, well, why why are they having that reaction versus taking a person like, oh, I did something wrong?
- 57:46SPEAKER_00: It's like, well, what what is it about what I did?
- 57:48SPEAKER_00: So it's like having that curious mind.
- 57:50SPEAKER_00: I know it's hard to do.
- 57:51SPEAKER_00: Um and the reason why I bring that up is I'm wondering for you, do you ever have that like so how how do I help them go to be able to to meet to meet the art where it's at versus pushing against it because they don't know how to react to it because they because they don't see that there's multiple vantage points in into looking at what I'm trying to say or do to get them to question.
- 58:21SPEAKER_03: Well, one reaction is I don't think it's your job to lead a horse to water or to hold hands, you know.
- 58:29SPEAKER_03: If it's it's not for them, it's not for them.
- 58:33SPEAKER_03: So that's one reaction.
- 58:34SPEAKER_03: Like, I actually don't create to please all the folks all the time.
- 58:39SPEAKER_03: Uh with everything I write, it could be a very specific elite readership that I'm speaking to or intending to speak to.
- 58:48SPEAKER_03: And I never want to speak to the masses.
- 58:51SPEAKER_03: I'm not that I don't have that cape in my closet.
- 58:54SPEAKER_03: Do you know what I mean?
- 58:55SPEAKER_03: I don't have any delusions about my ability to change the trajectory of pop culture or human dialectic um in that way.
- 59:04SPEAKER_03: I usually have a readership in mind, so I'm pretty lucky.
- 59:07SPEAKER_03: I mean, you said a lot there.
- 59:08SPEAKER_03: I want to backpedal a little bit and say I can be passionate and I'm Italian, so I sound like I'm pretty opinionated, and I am about what matters in my world.
- 59:20SPEAKER_03: You know, the things we're talking about are the core issues.
- 59:23SPEAKER_03: It's it's why I'm here, you know.
- 59:25SPEAKER_03: But I do want to reiterate like, even when you have discourse about what is art, oh, that's not art.
- 59:33SPEAKER_03: Uh you know, a crucifix suspended in urine is not art.
- 59:37SPEAKER_03: That's why I brought up that example.
- 59:39SPEAKER_03: Because it was very controversial when the NEA was giving money to a bisected cow and Piss Christ, it was called.
- 59:46SPEAKER_03: So the cultural conversation was about what is art and what should we be publicly funding?
- 59:53SPEAKER_03: So I love that you have kind of like in politics, we have a two-party system because it keeps things in check.
- 1:00:01SPEAKER_03: So please know, listeners, as passionate as I sound, I say amen to all the forces that contribute to social evolution, if that makes sense, to social reform, toward forward movement, even the backlashes, even the backswings of the pendulum, even the differing experiences of what is art and what's propaganda.
- 1:00:24SPEAKER_03: That's how this works.
- 1:00:25SPEAKER_03: This is why we have a podcast.
- 1:00:27SPEAKER_03: Am I making sense, Virginia?
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_03: It all has value.
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it does.
- 1:00:31SPEAKER_03: It all has value.
- 1:00:32SPEAKER_03: So please believe me.
- 1:00:33SPEAKER_03: But I guess one way I qualify or try to say it in a cleaner way is the art I appreciate, dot dot dot, the filmmakers I appreciate do A, B, C, and D.
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_03: You know, and but there's value to all of it, truly.
- 1:00:48SPEAKER_03: Even the preachy stuff that we're talking about, it's serving a purpose, and there is room for all of it.
- 1:00:55SPEAKER_03: So I don't know if I'm answering your question at all, but in my own work, I rarely feel that I'm losing people.
- 1:01:03SPEAKER_03: My most ambitious, uh, you know, some some would say agenda-ridden, if I'm trying to normalize homosexuality by exposing people to what just exists in the world, frankly.
- 1:01:15SPEAKER_03: Oh, that's normalizing.
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_03: Sure.
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_03: Plenty of conservative people would say that about my one overtly gay themed film.
- 1:01:22SPEAKER_03: My one overtly gay.
- 1:01:24SPEAKER_03: So I identify as an artist.
- 1:01:26SPEAKER_03: You know, Jay Levy came on, and you may remember he said, Oh, I'm not a gay storyteller.
- 1:01:31SPEAKER_03: I'm a storyteller who happens to be gay.
- 1:01:34SPEAKER_03: That's how I identify.
- 1:01:36SPEAKER_03: So I strive for the universal.
- 1:01:38SPEAKER_03: I know when I'm going to lose some people, and it's an elite readership or viewer, you know, I guess public that I'm trying to reach with a film, and that's all fine.
- 1:01:48SPEAKER_03: I'm not interested in reaching the people that have such ingrained prejudices that they're gonna experience an LGBTQ film as anything but a human story.
- 1:02:00SPEAKER_03: I mean, I watch a lot of interviews about people, are still up in arms about um what's it called?
- 1:02:07SPEAKER_03: I'm gonna have to edit this.
- 1:02:08SPEAKER_03: My favorite film of all time, Brokeback Mountain.
- 1:02:13SPEAKER_00: Love that film.
- 1:02:14SPEAKER_03: People are still talking about Brokeback Mountain, and I watch old interviews with Heath Ledger, and I couldn't love what he has to say more.
- 1:02:22SPEAKER_03: Which is this is a beautiful human love story.
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_03: If you can't let it in, just don't watch the film.
- 1:02:32SPEAKER_03: That's fine.
- 1:02:33SPEAKER_03: That's my stance.
- 1:02:35SPEAKER_03: If you are so subhuman that you can't experience my content on the level it's intended, I don't care to speak to you, and I've given up on you.
- 1:02:47SPEAKER_03: And I I throw in the towel.
- 1:02:49SPEAKER_03: Yeah, truly.
- 1:02:50SPEAKER_00: And I love that you brought brought up uh broke my mountain.
- 1:02:53SPEAKER_00: So actually, last night, uh, my 16-year-old, again, my musical lover, we went and saw um Falsetto.
- 1:03:03SPEAKER_03: You don't know what that is, no.
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_00: It's a it's a music.
- 1:03:05SPEAKER_00: Oh, okay.
- 1:03:05SPEAKER_00: I'm gonna have to send you the link.
- 1:03:08SPEAKER_00: Um, so Falsetto is a musical.
- 1:03:11SPEAKER_00: It is set in 1979.
- 1:03:14SPEAKER_00: And what I I first time I saw it, my daughter has there's it's out on um YouTube, and uh guys we'll put it, we'll put it into the notes for for anybody who wants to go see it.
- 1:03:26SPEAKER_00: Anyways, it's very much about the um the the family structure, but not the family structure of like what you and I grew up in, Nick, of you know, the 70s and going into the 80s.
- 1:03:38SPEAKER_00: It focuses on this family in New York, and they are the outlier of the nuclear family because he's married, has a child, divorces his wife, moves in with his gay lover.
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_00: Um, and this is of course right on to the the HIV pandemic.
- 1:04:00SPEAKER_00: So the the lover does end up dying of AIDS in in the musical.
- 1:04:05SPEAKER_00: But what I love about yeah, um, because we're talking about how because that was obviously at the the beginning of it, which is why they have that in there.
- 1:04:15SPEAKER_00: But what I love about it is it's about this family who is trying to be a unit that is unconventional in a time where this ideological nuclear family conventional thought process existed, and them finding love, loss, and unity within this unique situation during this you know time period between 1979 and 1985.
- 1:04:47SPEAKER_03: So home is where you make it, mm-hmm.
- 1:04:50SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and and just and again, you know, no matter who you are, everybody has struggles, everybody has loss.
- 1:04:59SPEAKER_03: Well, I mean, again, I I can't say much because I am not familiar with it, but just in listening to you, to me, the you because you know, my little animated film, Home, yeah, was largely about what is the definition of family?
- 1:05:15SPEAKER_03: Well, it's where the love is.
- 1:05:17SPEAKER_03: You know, Tarzan was about that, it's not about the color of your skin or whether you're an ape or human in that case, it's where the love is.
- 1:05:24SPEAKER_03: So I would say the universal human part of that equation is that theme.
- 1:05:30SPEAKER_03: And then somebody that doesn't align with it or has a hood in their closet is gonna say, Oh, well, that's an agenda.
- 1:05:37SPEAKER_03: You're trying to normalize a non-traditional home.
- 1:05:41SPEAKER_03: I mean family.
- 1:05:42SPEAKER_03: Do you remember when family values was used to marginalize the gay community?
- 1:05:47SPEAKER_03: Like, do you remember those two and a half, three decades?
- 1:05:49SPEAKER_01: I do.
- 1:05:50SPEAKER_03: People still say family values.
- 1:05:52SPEAKER_03: So that's exactly what I was hinting at earlier.
- 1:05:55SPEAKER_03: If the intentions of the I separate the artist from the work, but in a given piece, if the intention strives for something universal about the human condition, you're only gonna resist it as a patron if it challenges or threatens your well-entrenched worldview.
- 1:06:15SPEAKER_03: And if if if you're clutching your pearls, yes, like you said, examine your those beliefs and own the ones, you know, until the cows come home.
- 1:06:24SPEAKER_03: Own the ones that you find commendable, and then maybe discard the ones that are a product of socialization, of the hatred you were raised with in your household for the other.
- 1:06:33SPEAKER_03: It's your job to redeem yourself.
- 1:06:36SPEAKER_03: And this will now I'm preaching again.
- 1:06:37SPEAKER_03: I don't know how I ended up on this tangent, but maybe it's our jobs to, like you're saying, take these opportunities to examine our beliefs.
- 1:06:45SPEAKER_03: If we feel threatened or challenged.
- 1:06:47SPEAKER_03: Every day the universe throws us opportunities to grow and learn.
- 1:06:51SPEAKER_03: But I just sorry, whenever I people find things objectionable, I think, take a look in the mirror.
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_03: This is a human story with a human agenda.
- 1:07:00SPEAKER_03: And again, maybe for our listeners, go listen to those Heath Ledger interviews.
- 1:07:05SPEAKER_03: He articulates it beautifully.
- 1:07:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:07:08SPEAKER_00: And I think it goes right back to what we've been saying.
- 1:07:10SPEAKER_00: What's the difference between art and propaganda?
- 1:07:13SPEAKER_00: And art really makes us sit and question and should be making you question.
- 1:07:16SPEAKER_00: So if you're not, then you're not understanding the art in front of you or having the open mind too.
- 1:07:22SPEAKER_00: And you're just seeing it as propaganda.
- 1:07:25SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:07:26SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:07:26SPEAKER_03: It I think the intention of the artist does matter.
- 1:07:30SPEAKER_03: And I think they can employ craft and technique to honor that intention.
- 1:07:35SPEAKER_03: But I think really the dividing line might be if the intention is political persuasion or the almighty dollar, the cart is effectively before the horse.
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_03: The universe will only use you as an antenna and solicit a creative effort from you if it contributes to our evolution, our propagation, our persistence as a species.
- 1:07:59SPEAKER_03: And sometimes maybe that is a conservative backlash or a backswing of the pendulum.
- 1:08:03SPEAKER_03: We don't know.
- 1:08:06SPEAKER_00: So so here's here's an interesting thought, because this was something that that that I thought of when I was putting my notes together, and just because of where we're at, so talking about representation and um feeling inspired, and so okay, I'm just I'm gonna just read kind of what I threw into chat GPT, um, my ramblings, not not what it said because I didn't care what it had to say.
- 1:08:31SPEAKER_00: Um because it went into being a long diet tribe of its own.
- 1:08:35SPEAKER_00: But anyways, yeah.
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_00: Um, but this I was just like, you know, when if we think carefully about how representation can unintentionally become another form of stereotyping, um, can there be a completely true story about a particular community group or um or culture of people?
- 1:08:53SPEAKER_00: And then and the story deserves to be told, but then if we repeatedly tell that group, can people start to perceive that as um the experience of the whole of a group versus a portion of it, so a fraction of a group?
- 1:09:12SPEAKER_00: And so therefore start to put us into a confirmation bias.
- 1:09:15SPEAKER_00: So with that in mind, I'm just gonna throw this.
- 1:09:19SPEAKER_00: This is the the thought I put with it too.
- 1:09:21SPEAKER_00: If the majority of the stories we see about a particular community show like poverty, trauma, violence, discrimination, oppression, even when those experiences are real, can we start to unconsciously assume that the dominant experience of everybody is that and within the community, even though it's not?
- 1:09:39SPEAKER_03: Okay, I gotta start talking, or I'm gonna lose.
- 1:09:42SPEAKER_03: I think I understood all of that.
- 1:09:44SPEAKER_03: I think.
- 1:09:45SPEAKER_03: And I'm gonna, but I might be mistaken.
- 1:09:49SPEAKER_03: I'll answer by telling a little anecdote.
- 1:09:51SPEAKER_03: I I saw a little short form video, probably on Insta, of a comedian, and it was very funny but very poignant.
- 1:10:00SPEAKER_03: And he he basically was showing clips as he was talking to the audience and said, Well, in the 90s, representation was very interesting.
- 1:10:10SPEAKER_03: In and I can't remember the names of the shows, but in NCIS, for example, they introduced a lesbian character a week later.
- 1:10:18SPEAKER_03: She was shot, then they went to the next show, whatever it was, and this lesbian lasted into season two, and then she, you know, the bullet found her, and he went property by property, they all it they all ended tragically.
- 1:10:33SPEAKER_03: So I kind of smirked a minute ago when you said uh the AIDS storyline.
- 1:10:38SPEAKER_03: So, you know, we've done this episode, but all the identifiers of gay content were cautionary tales.
- 1:10:46SPEAKER_03: It's an old tired trope that you're gonna, it's gonna end badly.
- 1:10:50SPEAKER_03: You know, there's you know the book that I reference in my memoirs about, oh, then you know, you'll you'll die sad and lonely.
- 1:10:59SPEAKER_03: And uh it it had a lot of predictions for my life as I was coming into my sexuality at age 11.
- 1:11:06SPEAKER_03: Oh, you know, all those Freudian tropes, all the gay boys played with dolls and had a distant father and an overbearing mother, and you're gonna die alone, and it was uh a done deal.
- 1:11:19unknown: Yeah.
- 1:11:20SPEAKER_03: Uh nope, I rejected all of it at age 11.
- 1:11:23SPEAKER_03: I knew better.
- 1:11:24SPEAKER_03: So again, it's it's very unexamined, but most people that don't have a horse in the race will unknowingly employ old tired tropes that are disempowering.
- 1:11:38SPEAKER_03: Even if you think, well, AIDS needs to be addressed in storytelling.
- 1:11:41SPEAKER_03: It it was a you know, a couple decades of existential terror.
- 1:11:46SPEAKER_03: Of course, it needed to happen.
- 1:11:48SPEAKER_03: And in film festivals, you have festival programmers and organizers thinking, well, if it's not identifiable for gay audiences because of the coming out struggle, the marginalization, um, the silence and erasure, the uh AIDS academic, epidemic, the coming out theme.
- 1:12:09SPEAKER_03: It was a very small, narrow list of what they thought audiences would identify with.
- 1:12:14SPEAKER_03: And then if it's a crossover, mainstream film, is it universal enough?
- 1:12:19SPEAKER_03: So these are ongoing conversations, but frankly, I think I can answer your question by saying I never bought even the inculcation, one could say, the gay agenda, as Jay and I said over and over again, there is no gay agenda, we're just trying to get you to be human.
- 1:12:35SPEAKER_03: And a mind your own business, and B, see the humanity in somebody that's a little bit different than you.
- 1:12:40SPEAKER_03: So, anyway, but there are definitely tropes that I was kind of spoon-fed, like, oh, you're not, I'm trying to be specific.
- 1:12:48SPEAKER_03: Oh, we get to make up our own rules, we don't need to adhere to traditional relationship models because the world is our oyster.
- 1:12:56SPEAKER_03: There are gay people that think the whole reason that I'm so thrilled to be part of this subculture is because I get to reject notions that the human heart is the same, straight or gay.
- 1:13:06SPEAKER_03: No, it's not, it's totally different.
- 1:13:08SPEAKER_03: We don't have to, you know what I mean, get hung up in those horrid heteronormative relationship models.
- 1:13:16SPEAKER_03: We're free to create our own.
- 1:13:17SPEAKER_03: And I love that, and yet I think the human heart is the same, straight or gay.
- 1:13:22SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 1:13:23SPEAKER_03: So I didn't buy a lot of that if that's making any sense.
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_03: So if I see a trend like, you know, I think there's plenty of gay, I'm gonna really lose my card here, but the LGBTQ2 plus, if they just keep adding and adding to it.
- 1:13:39SPEAKER_03: I don't have much in common with half of those.
- 1:13:44SPEAKER_03: Um, I don't like the word queer.
- 1:13:47SPEAKER_03: I don't relate to that, I don't feel queer.
- 1:13:49SPEAKER_03: I feel pretty boring and normal, you know.
- 1:13:53SPEAKER_00: No, I I I I I get it.
- 1:13:55SPEAKER_03: I mean, so I so isn't that what you mean by like I'm being told I need to identify with this and that I should that I should subscribe to the identity politics and be on board.
- 1:14:05SPEAKER_03: It's kind of like people, the blind allegiance you see within a party.
- 1:14:09SPEAKER_03: Like, I'm gonna overlook my own ethics and morals and just step up and step in line.
- 1:14:17SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that ain't me.
- 1:14:18SPEAKER_03: So that's a one answer.
- 1:14:20SPEAKER_03: You got the wrong guy.
- 1:14:21SPEAKER_03: Sorry.
- 1:14:21SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and so I'm wondering for you, and I and I'll give you an example and I'll I'll use myself in this to help.
- 1:14:28SPEAKER_00: Um, so again, you know, where art maybe starts off where it's supposed to be inspirational, it's trying to be representate, you know, have that representation.
- 1:14:38SPEAKER_00: It starts going down those tropes, those stereotypes.
- 1:14:41SPEAKER_00: And then I'm wondering ultimately, even though that wasn't the thought process was for it to become propaganda, it it does to a degree.
- 1:14:50SPEAKER_00: And here's why I'm gonna, and I'll use myself why why I'm wondering this.
- 1:14:54SPEAKER_00: So divorced parents, you know, my parents were divorced when I was 10, so it's like freaking the beginning of the 80s to mid-80s.
- 1:15:03SPEAKER_00: I'm, you know, so not not normal.
- 1:15:05SPEAKER_00: That was a very unnormal thing back then, even though there was a lot of people getting divorced, but I was being told that.
- 1:15:11SPEAKER_00: And so here I am, fast forward in my 50s, and every time I hear about back then, um, and even now, because I know because I do this in couples counseling and co-parenting counseling when parents are divorcing, there's this there's this thought process, especially with girls, like, oh, they're gonna have daddy issues and they're gonna be more sexually uh promiscuous, and the chances of me being sexually assaulted, being a you know street worker, um whatever, you know, selling my body to to find love because it's the only way I think I can be loved.
- 1:15:48SPEAKER_00: And I'm going, and I see these in stories, I see these in books, I see these in movies where they where there's this this thought.
- 1:15:55SPEAKER_00: I'm going, that was so not me.
- 1:15:57SPEAKER_00: And I remember being told that again when I was tense, and not much younger than you, when my parents divorced, thinking I'm not that kid, and I'm normal am I gonna be that kid, and that's not gonna be who I am when I grow up.
- 1:16:08SPEAKER_00: However, I'm going, but does that become propaganda?
- 1:16:11SPEAKER_00: Because it becomes this like, no, this is this is this is why this person's messed up, and it's like, I don't think so.
- 1:16:19SPEAKER_03: Is that a false correlation in your opinion?
- 1:16:21SPEAKER_00: Or I think so.
- 1:16:22SPEAKER_00: I mean, I'm not gonna say that there aren't people that that that isn't true for, but I don't think it's you know, obviously everybody, and so that's why I kind of throw it out there.
- 1:16:32SPEAKER_00: So I'm wondering, can art in that way, when it's trying to be representative, go into more of a propaganda spill without it realizing it because of course has signing to something.
- 1:16:43SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think what my book and maybe this podcast is trying to impart is just an awareness of how this all works, all of this, including a trendy, right?
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_03: I think a lot of people virtue signal too.
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_03: You have artists and actors that speak publicly, and it just sounds like the most, and we can't even say politically correct anymore, right?
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_03: But they step in line and say what they think people want to hear when maybe it's not an authentic align, uh, alignment or a what do you call allegiance?
- 1:17:19SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and so you have a lot of virtual signaling too.
- 1:17:23SPEAKER_03: So I will go back to amen to all of it.
- 1:17:26SPEAKER_03: You know, I think if the aspirational storytelling idea, I think, again, we're repeating other episodes, but I can only I'm just trying to use vivid examples that are directly from experience.
- 1:17:38SPEAKER_03: Every gay man I know remembers the moment on Glee where everything we were deprived of in terms of role models was on full display.
- 1:17:47SPEAKER_03: Very empowering and yet bittersweet.
- 1:17:50SPEAKER_03: Like, oh my god, if if I had somebody other than Jack Tripper back in the 70s, wouldn't life have been quite different?
- 1:17:58SPEAKER_03: And now you have Darren Chris just singing his heart out on glee, feeling so empowered and free.
- 1:18:07SPEAKER_03: It's there's a little envy there.
- 1:18:09SPEAKER_03: I'm giving examples.
- 1:18:10SPEAKER_03: So now I think I told you jingle all the way.
- 1:18:13SPEAKER_03: Oh, it's the first time I saw a movie.
- 1:18:15SPEAKER_03: Who would have thought?
- 1:18:17SPEAKER_03: Where not only is the sexuality of the character a complete non-issue, but all the secondary characters, the family members, are championing his happiness within the context of a relationship.
- 1:18:29SPEAKER_03: What beautiful, you know, and then bros, you keep seeing like the progression.
- 1:18:36SPEAKER_03: And I've said I never thought things would have come so far during my lifetime, never imagined it when marriage equality was on the table or Prop 8.
- 1:18:44SPEAKER_03: I thought I don't care because it wasn't on the menu for me, so I'm not invested.
- 1:18:50SPEAKER_03: Of course, eventually I came around and I realized, well, in theory, of course, you can't extend certain rights and privileges to one subsection of the population and not another, just in principle, I got on board, of course.
- 1:19:03SPEAKER_03: But I don't know if I'm going off on a tangent here, but I do say amen to all of it, and I do see trends that create new tropes, but I think an awareness is what's important.
- 1:19:17SPEAKER_03: If you catch yourself and you go, Oh, I'm telling an aspirational story, again, like um uh heated rivalry.
- 1:19:27SPEAKER_03: A lot of the feedback has been you think it's gonna go badly, and then oh my god, when he's unintentionally outed to his parents, it's the most beautiful conversation he has with his mother, and it doesn't go south.
- 1:19:41SPEAKER_03: It gives you a new model to aspire to.
- 1:19:44SPEAKER_03: There is a monologue in Call Me by Your Name, as problematic as I find that film.
- 1:19:50SPEAKER_03: There's a beautiful monologue where the father just opens up to his son and they bond.
- 1:19:55SPEAKER_03: Uh, and it's empowering, it's aspirational.
- 1:19:59SPEAKER_03: But I do see how these aspirational tropes could replace the less empowering ones, like that lesbian must have a bullet in her abdomen by the end of season two, or that gay guy must, and it's unexamined.
- 1:20:13SPEAKER_03: The gay guy must die of AIDS because that's how that story ends.
- 1:20:16SPEAKER_03: That's the story we need to tell people.
- 1:20:19SPEAKER_03: Gay, bad, ends badly, cautionary to hell.
- 1:20:23SPEAKER_03: And there's a moral aspect, you will pay for your perversity.
- 1:20:28SPEAKER_03: Do you know?
- 1:20:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no, I I get it because as you're talking, actually, the movie Pretty Woman came into my mind, and the reason why it came to my mind is right, she has comes from a broken home, doesn't really have a family, work works, is working on the street, you know, as a sex worker, and yet she has to find the rich white guy to save her.
- 1:20:46SPEAKER_01: Right, right, right.
- 1:20:47SPEAKER_00: And I mean, can I just tell you how much that storyline as a female bugs me, especially coming from a broken home?
- 1:20:53SPEAKER_00: Oh, and was a single and was a single mother, right?
- 1:20:56SPEAKER_00: So I was told I had to be safe, or if I was a single mom and worked my way up in corporate America, then I was gonna be like bitch on wills.
- 1:21:02SPEAKER_00: Like, what?
- 1:21:03SPEAKER_00: No, right.
- 1:21:04SPEAKER_03: Well, the corollary is you know, every downtrodden African American that could go into, you know, join a gang, but instead find sports, it's usually a white woman that pulls them up by the bootstraps, right?
- 1:21:18SPEAKER_03: That uh that white woman who gets assigned to a uh a school district in South Central, for example.
- 1:21:26SPEAKER_03: It there's always a rescue fantasy on the part of uh the privileged uh with gay people.
- 1:21:31SPEAKER_03: There was a whole decade where the poor gay character didn't have the courage to come out, but their straight allies rallied around them and gave them the courage to come out.
- 1:21:40SPEAKER_03: You've heard me say this before.
- 1:21:42SPEAKER_03: It's the opposite.
- 1:21:43SPEAKER_03: The gay character overlooks the limitations, the boundaries, the discomfort of the family members and friends around them, and is the most courageous person in that story.
- 1:21:54SPEAKER_03: So I share your frustration, by the way.
- 1:21:56SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I do because I haven't thought about it much though.
- 1:21:59SPEAKER_03: Let me ask you uh, do you ever listen to Love Line in the 90s or the 2000s?
- 1:22:05SPEAKER_00: Oh, yes, Love Line.
- 1:22:07SPEAKER_03: One segment, and I loved Adam Corolla and I loved Dr.
- 1:22:10SPEAKER_03: Drew.
- 1:22:11SPEAKER_03: Um, they weren't really that progressive, they were kind of backwards in some ways, but I just loved it.
- 1:22:17SPEAKER_03: And they did a segment.
- 1:22:19SPEAKER_03: Well, there was Germany or Florida, I don't know if you remember that.
- 1:22:23SPEAKER_03: But they would, whenever they had a female caller, without discussing it, they would hang up and then, or even while she was still on the line, if she had a baby voice like a Marilyn Monroe voice, they'd go, All right, without, but they're the listeners all knew what they were doing, but the caller may not.
- 1:22:40SPEAKER_03: They would just pick a number, they'd say seven or six, and they were guessing at the date, the age at which she was molested.
- 1:22:49unknown: Yeah.
- 1:22:50SPEAKER_03: So if they got stuck, remember, yeah, if they had a baby and it was pretty much accurate.
- 1:22:56SPEAKER_03: So, do you find any of those like, oh, you're more likely to be on the poll if you if your dad abandoned you, any of those tropes ring true at all?
- 1:23:07SPEAKER_00: So here's here's the thing, and and I think we can say this for for all art form propaganda.
- 1:23:13SPEAKER_00: There's usually some truth, stereotypes, tropes.
- 1:23:16SPEAKER_00: There's usually some truth.
- 1:23:18SPEAKER_00: There's a grain of truth behind it all.
- 1:23:21SPEAKER_00: Um because it has to pull from something, right?
- 1:23:23SPEAKER_00: I mean, it goes back to that typical thing that we all hear.
- 1:23:27SPEAKER_00: Um, anybody who goes who who's a creative, write or paint what you know, right?
- 1:23:34SPEAKER_00: You pull from what you know.
- 1:23:36SPEAKER_00: So there's always an element of of truth in there, just to what degree is it, and and when it's and when it's being put out to the populace, how much of it is still true to a generalization versus an outlier.
- 1:23:55SPEAKER_03: Yes.
- 1:23:55SPEAKER_03: Yeah, sorry, I gotta jump in because we can bring things 360 here.
- 1:24:00SPEAKER_03: This actually relates to some things we said earlier, which is if something is truly inspired, you're not effectively putting the cart before the horse, you're honoring inspiration.
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_03: That is what saves you from being derivative, right?
- 1:24:15SPEAKER_03: That's what saves you from just regurgitating old tired tropes that are less than empowering.
- 1:24:22SPEAKER_03: Somebody that writes a screenplay because they have nothing to say in the world, but you know what?
- 1:24:27SPEAKER_03: They want to mimic Quentin Tarantino, they just want to be part of that tradition.
- 1:24:32SPEAKER_03: What are they going to draw on but old hackneyed tired tropes?
- 1:24:37SPEAKER_03: So, did you see what I'm saying?
- 1:24:39SPEAKER_03: Inspiration is still the answer to that.
- 1:24:41SPEAKER_03: And as you were hinting at, uh, being as authentic as possible from personal experience is what's going to make it land universally.
- 1:24:50SPEAKER_03: It's what's going to make it a force for social evolution and not just a regression, right?
- 1:24:57SPEAKER_03: Or a stagnation of our Noah Sphere.
- 1:25:00SPEAKER_03: Sorry, I'm getting a little technical, but I think that's what we're talking about.
- 1:25:05SPEAKER_03: If you are telling an inspired story from personal experience, it might be the next thing that's needed.
- 1:25:11SPEAKER_03: It might be the genius, right, in this moment's cutting edge thought forms.
- 1:25:16SPEAKER_03: If you don't have anything to say and you're probably telling the story for the wrong reasons, like Bank at the Box Office or bestseller status, right?
- 1:25:26SPEAKER_03: Then you're just gonna rely on old tired tropes.
- 1:25:32SPEAKER_03: Because that you're a hack at that now, you're a hack at that point.
- 1:25:36SPEAKER_00: Well, no, and I I think you'd done something, and I just want to add on to that to bringing propaganda into it.
- 1:25:40SPEAKER_00: And I think you know, when if you feel like you have to say something, I think the first thing is to stop yourself and go, why is it that I need to say something?
- 1:25:48SPEAKER_00: And if you're coming from it from fear, I think that's when you got the agenda, and that's when it's gonna be more propaganda-based.
- 1:25:57SPEAKER_00: Um 100%.
- 1:25:59SPEAKER_03: Like if you feel your mission is to save the world from A, B, C, or D, if that's a fear-based impulse, then probably examine it a little bit.
- 1:26:09SPEAKER_00: Examine it because it's gonna be it's gonna land in the propaganda.
- 1:26:14SPEAKER_00: It's it's gonna it's gonna cause that, you know, the diversity that h uh not diversity.
- 1:26:21SPEAKER_00: Oh my gosh, the division between us, right?
- 1:26:24SPEAKER_00: Um, and where uh going back to what you said, you know, inspiration comes from the heart, it comes from this core of who you are and this needing to share and connect, that's gonna actually not make us decisive.
- 1:26:39SPEAKER_03: It's gonna be divisive.
- 1:26:41SPEAKER_00: Divisive, thank you.
- 1:26:43SPEAKER_03: You did that, you did that in another episode.
- 1:26:46SPEAKER_00: Yes, thank you.
- 1:26:48SPEAKER_00: It's it's guys, it's been a week.
- 1:26:50SPEAKER_00: I know.
- 1:26:50SPEAKER_03: Um, no, but there's a huge difference.
- 1:26:52SPEAKER_00: Decisive, yeah, yeah, yeah, divisive.
- 1:26:55SPEAKER_00: Anyways, but you know, because because then it's gonna do exactly what we say.
- 1:26:58SPEAKER_00: It's the heart and mind, it's gonna actually bring that connection, it's gonna put you.
- 1:27:02SPEAKER_00: So that's that's what I think really separates art and propaganda is does it connect, does it reach for, does it ask for connection, ask for curiosity?
- 1:27:11SPEAKER_00: Propaganda, I think, is fear-based, it wants to separate other, and it's coming from a place of protect, like I'm protecting myself and and and and putting walls up and not seeking connection.
- 1:27:25SPEAKER_03: It's a very interesting connection you've made, and I'm scrolling because I'm gonna say the most controversial thing that I'm gonna probably ever say on this podcast, and it's gonna get me in trouble.
- 1:27:37SPEAKER_03: It's definitely the most controversial thing I'll say in this episode, but I think there's a reason, like when the Kennedy Center became the Trump Kennedy Center, it was so wrong to me because um fascism or authoritarianism is the complete opposite of the personal liberty and freedom that art espouses.
- 1:28:04SPEAKER_03: So I don't think the orange asshole would know art if it slapped him in the face.
- 1:28:10SPEAKER_03: It was a complete usurping and bastardization of an institution that he had no business getting his hands in, and it ended the way it should end, with his name being taken off of it.
- 1:28:21SPEAKER_03: But that says it all to me.
- 1:28:24SPEAKER_03: In my book, I reference this really beautiful speech by the goddess Meryl Streep.
- 1:28:30SPEAKER_03: I think during the first Trump administration, where she never mentioned him by name, not once, but she talked about the function of art, and still the right wingers were up in arms about what she said.
- 1:28:42SPEAKER_03: I write a whole segment in my book.
- 1:28:45SPEAKER_03: About how then they don't understand art or storytellers because you're identifying her at an Oscar ceremony as you know, giving a soapbox sermon when every role she chooses, she chooses because of her worldview and what she wants to contribute back to the collective.
- 1:29:03SPEAKER_03: So you're going to separate the artist from the art to the degree you reduce, reduce her to a dog and pony show, and you pick and choose what you want from her, right?
- 1:29:13SPEAKER_03: While ignoring who she fundamentally is.
- 1:29:15SPEAKER_03: It's like a day without gaze.
- 1:29:17SPEAKER_03: We'll wear your clothes, we'll watch your films, but just remain silent and invisible.
- 1:29:22SPEAKER_03: So it's a it just betrays a huge misunderstanding of art and the role it serves in society.
- 1:29:28SPEAKER_03: I'm talking too fast for that to make much sense.
- 1:29:31SPEAKER_03: But I think what you're talking about, the fear-based storytelling, there's a reason you have so few storytellers, especially in the arts and entertainment, that are Republicans.
- 1:29:44SPEAKER_03: Kid Rock, the only one that will fucking show up.
- 1:29:48SPEAKER_03: Tim Allen, Home Improvement, Last Man Standing, because nobody wants to hear that shit.
- 1:29:53SPEAKER_03: Clint Eastwood, I think he's an amazing filmmaker, but among his many beautiful films, I think people agree Grant Torino had an agenda, and it is a fear-based agenda.
- 1:30:04SPEAKER_03: Republican content is like, here's what to be afraid of.
- 1:30:08SPEAKER_03: The other, your neighbor.
- 1:30:09SPEAKER_03: It's all about divisiveness.
- 1:30:11SPEAKER_03: Here's what to be afraid of.
- 1:30:13SPEAKER_03: That's fear-based storytelling.
- 1:30:15SPEAKER_03: Mel Gibson, love his work.
- 1:30:18SPEAKER_03: Um, technically, as I said, on a craft level, he's amazing.
- 1:30:21SPEAKER_03: I don't hate him as much as a lot of people.
- 1:30:24SPEAKER_03: Did you ever watch um Dame Edna back in the day in the 90s?
- 1:30:28SPEAKER_00: I didn't.
- 1:30:29SPEAKER_03: Uh you check her out if you or him.
- 1:30:31SPEAKER_03: It was he didn't identify as a female.
- 1:30:33SPEAKER_03: Um, Dame Edna Google and watch some insta uh shorts.
- 1:30:39SPEAKER_03: Amazing.
- 1:30:39SPEAKER_03: And he mel Gibson went on, it's basically a married man.
- 1:30:44SPEAKER_03: He's heterosexual and straight, but in Australia for years, he has this amazing character called Dame Edna and um in full drag, and it anyway, an amazing property.
- 1:30:55SPEAKER_03: And he went on Dame Edna's show in a towel.
- 1:30:58SPEAKER_03: So maybe he was the first gay baiter, but Mel Gibson seemed like a cool guy back in the day.
- 1:31:05SPEAKER_03: Anyway, I think Apocalypto and Braveheart, especially Braveheart, where they throw the limp-wristed homo from the window.
- 1:31:13SPEAKER_03: I don't know if you remember that.
- 1:31:14SPEAKER_00: I do remember that, yeah.
- 1:31:15SPEAKER_03: Yeah, now and there you get glimpses of the dark side of Mel Gibson.
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_03: But I'm just gonna say there's a reason there are so few self-professed storytellers or artists, at least in the arts and entertainment in the Hollywood version of that, that identify as Republican.
- 1:31:34SPEAKER_03: Because you could argue there's a lot of ego there and there's a lot of fear-based storytelling there.
- 1:31:41SPEAKER_03: Yeah, no, I've said it all.
- 1:31:43SPEAKER_00: You've said it all.
- 1:31:45SPEAKER_00: Um I was agreeing with you, by the way.
- 1:31:47SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I know, I know.
- 1:31:49SPEAKER_00: And and it's it's true.
- 1:31:50SPEAKER_00: Because here's the thing: this is what I think artists are supposed to do.
- 1:31:54SPEAKER_00: And correct me if I'm wrong.
- 1:31:59SPEAKER_00: Okay, I think it should be uncomfortable.
- 1:32:02SPEAKER_00: I think the discomfort is not always goal driven.
- 1:32:07SPEAKER_00: I think it can be beautiful and comforting.
- 1:32:10SPEAKER_00: I think it can make us sad.
- 1:32:12SPEAKER_00: I think it can make us laugh, it can feel familiar, and it should ask us the question.
- 1:32:18SPEAKER_03: Beautiful.
- 1:32:19SPEAKER_03: Beautiful.
- 1:32:20SPEAKER_03: I agree with all of that.
- 1:32:22SPEAKER_03: Yeah, beautiful.
- 1:32:23SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and I think that's maybe a good note to end it on.
- 1:32:25SPEAKER_03: What do you think?
- 1:32:26SPEAKER_00: I think so.
- 1:32:27SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I really love how you put that.
- 1:32:29SPEAKER_03: Uh I do think art should provoke.
- 1:32:32SPEAKER_03: And um, yeah, and and then the reason we went into the reasons, you know.
- 1:32:36SPEAKER_03: It's if there's cognitive dissonance and you're being haunted by something, or maybe if it's inviting conversation, the goal would be to resolve that cognitive dissonance, and it's called a paradigm shift.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_03: The emotional version of that that's less analytical and intellectual is you have an emotional catharsis and you probably purge something.
- 1:32:59SPEAKER_03: I made it real technical.
- 1:33:00SPEAKER_03: You gave us some inspiring words, and then I gave the technical reason behind it.
- 1:33:05SPEAKER_00: No, I think that's great.
- 1:33:07SPEAKER_03: Anyway, I hope it all lands, and uh I think we got into some good stuff.
- 1:33:13SPEAKER_00: I do too.
- 1:33:14SPEAKER_03: Okay, well, thank you.
- 1:33:15SPEAKER_03: And um, to our listeners, remember life is story, and we can get our hands in the clay individually and collectively.
- 1:33:24SPEAKER_03: We can tell a new story.
- 1:33:26SPEAKER_03: See you next time.