Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Shawn Fain’s Re-Election Campaign, The Pricing Ownership Problem, Valar Goes Critical
Transcript
- 0:01Good morning. It is Friday, June 19th. This is the automative- m- Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. I'm with the one and only Steve Greenfield today.
- 0:08We're talking about Shawn Fain, compliance, and a little startup that generated some nuclear power yesterday, so- Where I go. The people really wanna know. Fun, fun Friday story Who I am and what I be.
- 0:17They stop and stare when they see me. Perfect story to have you on, Steve. Welcome to Friday. How's the week been for you? Consider the source when they listen to me. Tips for the poor to your needs.
- 0:22Tiptoe- Uh, really good. I was in, uh, Virgin- or, uh, Pennsylvania on Monday for the West Virginia, Kentucky, uh, a- a- auto dealers association- Oh, yeah... annual meeting. Fun people.
- 0:32Then I flew from there to Vienna and, uh, presented at a conference over there for, uh, automotive collision. And got back yesterday, and here I am back in Atlanta for the weekend.
- 0:41Wha- [laughs] What's Vienna like this time of year? It's great. I, I actually hadn't been to Vienna. I've been to a, a bunch of different cities in, in, in Europe, but I was like, "I've never been to Vienna before."
- 0:50It's beautiful. I mean, it was at one point, with the Hapsburgs, the epicenter of commerce, you know, in, in, in, in Europe. So extreme affluence and opulence there, right?
- 0:59And then right, right in the middle of the, the Renaissance, so incredible museums- Okay, yeah... and art and such. Did you get to see anything- And architecture... while you were there? I, I, I did. I did. I, I went...
- 1:07You know, my, my typical MO is to go for runs if the weather's nice. And I went for a run, and I had a chance to see a lot of the architecture and go into a few- the city center, et cetera. So yeah, it was ve- very nice.
- 1:17But yeah, highly recommend it. And this, this time of year in Europe's great 'cause the, the weather's perfect and all the plants are in bloom and yeah. Whenever I think of Vienna, I just think of spy movies, right?
- 1:27Yeah, exactly. Right. [laughs] Spy movies. Right. Yeah, yeah. Exactly. I didn't know you were a runner. Nathan, did you know Steve was a runner? We've talked about it a little bit, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Oh, yeah.
- 1:34We, we, we share running stories. We share running stories. Yeah, runner, runners find one another, I guess. I understand- Yeah... how that goes.
- 1:39Uh, well, today's show is brought to you by our friends at Wide Whale, who can show you where your dealership stands on issues. The FTC is currently scrutinize- scin- sizing very tightly, we know.
- 1:49Watch their webinar on the topic. Go to widewhale.com/ftc. The webinar just dropped, uh, late just yesterday, was it? Yesterday or two days ago.
- 1:57So, um, it's very fresh, and they, they're really revealing some data and some insights they have on how the FTC may be approaching identifying people who they wanna send maybe letters to in the future. Um- Mm...
- 2:09so we have all... We went to the CBT Fair Pricing and Compliance, uh, Summit on Tuesday. Nathan and I were there on site. And we recorded a bunch of content. We released it all.
- 2:18So now you can go, uh, listen either on our Auto Collabs podcast.
- 2:21Or probably one of the best places to get this content is to go to our YouTube channel, which is SOTUbe, S-O-T-U.B-E, and you can see interviews with, uh, Scott Painter, Kevin Frye, Zach Shefska, John Fitzpatrick, Lars Pratta, uh, president of New Jersey, uh, Dealer Association, Sam Weaver, a lot more.
- 2:39Great event, uh, great insights. Um, we tried to get as much of it as we could out there to you. Let's talk about some news. This is a fun one.
- 2:45As the UAW heads toward another leadership election, Shawn Fain, we said his name, it's been a while, is no longer the outsider. He's the establishment now, touting some major victories and an ambitious future agenda.
- 2:58He's also facing a lot of criticism from reformers who say the union still has unfinished business.
- 3:04So, uh, Fain laid out his vision, calling AI a threat to workers, promising a renewed push to restore pensions and arguing the UAW should expand its influence across multiple industries.
- 3:15Um, he's running with a revamped leadership slate after breaking with several of his allies who helped bring him to power in 2023, including current Secretary Treasurer Margaret Mock.
- 3:25Five candidates are challenging him this fall with opponents arguing federal watchdog reports raise concerns about his transparency, internal governments, and reform efforts.
- 3:35Scott Hodelson, Ford Chicago assembly plant worker, said, "Shawn's the best president I've ever experienced at the UAW. You have to go back decades to find one who's been as important to the labor movement at large."
- 3:47So Shawn Fain, back in the news, Steve. Yeah, I, I mean, uh, g- good for him. He was very pugilistic, right, uh, I think in the last- That's a great word... couple years and, uh, rose to fame.
- 3:57Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly, right. Great word. And, uh, you know, he, he and Trump didn't often see eye to eye. So I mean, I, I imagine that's also, you know, uh, headwinds against him right now.
- 4:06But look, I mean, the perspective is the UAW's kind of in a tight spot.
- 4:10You know, w- with the pressure of the Chinese and all the automakers looking at other Tesla, Rivian, or the Chinese and saying, "How do we dramatically re- redefine what a vehicle is, being software defined, and how do we drive costs out of the production?"
- 4:24Um, then you got the UAW here fighting for, for, uh, employee rights. And in, in, in the middle is really, you know, puts, uh, the OEMs in a tough, tough predicament here, right?
- 4:33They've gotta figure out how to, uh, build faster cars and, or cars faster, I should say- Mm-hmm... and cheaper to compete with the Chinese globally.
- 4:40But, you know, that, that, that's w- they're directly in conflict with, you know, paying your employees more and giving them more benefits.
- 4:47So it'll be interesting to see how this plays out right now and how receptive the market is overall, and h- how sympathetic it is to, to, to the UAW and, um, how, you know, this presidency, um, plays out as, as a result of all those, you know, uh, uh, conflicting- Yes...
- 5:02uh, priorities within the industry. A lot of conflicting priorities. And, you know, just even, I'm thinking back to when all of the, you know, the big comeuppance was a- around the strike and the rhetoric and all that.
- 5:13And I'm just thinking about how different the technology landscape is today than it was back then. I don't even know if we were mentioning the AI in, in that era. I don't think we were. Right.
- 5:24Or maybe a very early adopter. So technology going to play a much bigger part. Uh, he mentioned it in his comments.
- 5:30And, um, you know, I think when you are the UAW and you, you represent labor, I think you naturally have to take a defensive stance against technology that would replace people.
- 5:40So, um, it, it's certainly gonna be interesting to see how it unfolds, but this is kind of like, uh, the first, the first chapter in the, in the second volume of Shawn Fain- Right... perhaps. Right.
- 5:51[laughs] Right Uh, speaking of volumes My button didn't work Segway. Time. Volumes of legislation. The summit on Tuesday, one of the big topics of conversation was: who owns pricing vehicles?
- 6:04Who owns the pricing and the display of pricing and the fact, and how that gets through the whole tech ecosystem, uh, was one of the biggest themes.
- 6:11And all speakers pointed to shifting prices as one of retail auto's most pressing operational challenges.
- 6:18Uh, John Fitzpatrick of Force Marketing described the growing complexity of managing pricing across all the technology, the websites, OEM programs, third-party marketplaces.
- 6:27Uh, he said that is one of the challenges, is the complexity of that.
- 6:30Aaron Baldwin of Automotive Mastermind discussed the challenge of keeping tech systems aligned so pricing incentives and compliance requirements, uh, can all stay i- in line as compliance requirements evolve.
- 6:42Lauren Perro- Mm-hmm... Laura Perrotta, uh, president of New Jersey Coalition of Auto Retailers, said the need for stronger coordination between dealers, manufacturers, vendors, and listing platforms is needed.
- 6:53While panelists approached the issue from different perspectives, the consensus was that dealers need a clearly defined process for where pricing originates, who approves changes, and how those updates are verified across every customer-facing channel.
- 7:07Steve, if this isn't a problem that technology should be able to solve, I don't know what is. Yeah. And, and the finger-pointing is gonna really begin here, I think.
- 7:16If the FTC, as you said earlier, is gonna, um, you know, issue more letters to dealers, warning letters, and potentially come after dealers, then the dealers are gonna po- uh, point fingers at the vendors, many of the vendors that you just mentioned that were up on stage, and say, "Hey, you know, they, they're telling me they're selling me a solution that helps me have one unified price and protects me."
- 7:34And who, who's to blame at the end of the day, right? Mm. So I, I don't know if suddenly vendors are going to indemnify the dealer. Maybe that's a dirty word- No, it won't...
- 7:41but indemnify the dealer and say, "Hey, look, you know, we're, we're gonna stand by the fact that, you know, we've certified the, your, your, your pricing is consistent across all channels."
- 7:50That would be an interesting, you know, maybe an entrepreneur out there could do that with AI now.
- 7:54But, um, you know, to, to, to remove the burden fro- uh, of proof from the dealer to the vendors is a huge leap, and I don't know that we're gonna get there.
- 8:03But it, it would be cool to think about a, a future where some vendor's able to step up and actually indemnify the dealer. I don't think that that is... I mean, personally, I don't think that that's ever going to happen.
- 8:13Uh, the, the FTC, they did make it really clear, this came up several times in the conversations across panels, w- where that it's very clear that the liability lies with the dealer. Right.
- 8:24And I don't think there's g- ever gonna be a vendor that steps in front of the FTC and says, "No, no, no, no, wait. We'll take the blame." Right. And so I don't think anybody's ever going to do that.
- 8:33Um, I don't know why they would h- why they would, because they don't, no one has to. And usually people step out of the way. Um, there is- Mm-hmm...
- 8:41this is where we get into the legacy technology of the industry, and, and one of the challenges that technologists and startup companies are trying to navigate.
- 8:49You and I were just talking about kind of, you know, when you step out of, you know, these Y Combinator, you know, cohorts and, and there's like, "Oh, automotive. Old industry. They don't know anything about tech.
- 8:59We're gonna overlay this vibe-coded thing and we're gonna so- I can't believe they haven't found this yet." And then they, we watch them step into the industry and, and start to ask, they're like, "Well, wait.
- 9:08Why does that... Can... How come I can't access? How come this doesn't talk to?" Right? And you realize- Right, right, right... it's, it's a totally different ballgame. Um- Yeah...
- 9:16so, I mean, this is, this is a problem that technology should be able to solve, and there are a lot of really smart people working to figure it out.
- 9:23Thanks to Jim and, Jim and Bridget for putting on this summit, because, you know, you and I both believe that the way you find solutions is by people discussing the problem. You know- Yep...
- 9:31smart people discussing the problem. And, uh, you know, we're big believers in entrepreneurs and the ability for them to find solutions to problems that, you know, people haven't found before, which is- Yep...
- 9:42why, why we love this game so much. Indeed. There's no doubt. Speaking of entrepreneurs- Segway... this is a fun one. I'm trying to find a picture. I found it.
- 9:50All right, I'm gonna send this picture to Nathan right now so he can have it ready to put up in this story. Let's see how... He's got his fingers ready, I can tell. All right, I just texted him a picture.
- 10:00But, uh, it, it applies to this story. The US nuclear industry just hit a milestone that hasn't happened.
- 10:06Startup Valor Atomic successfully brought its Ward 250 small modular reactor into criticality in Utah, making it, uh, the first next-generation nuclear power that ever has happened outside a lab, outside a facility.
- 10:19It was assembled in Utah just months after being airlifted on a C-17, uh, from their El Segundo headquarters in LA out to Utah. They put a nuclear reactor on a C-17, flew it out to the site, stood it up, put it together.
- 10:32They're one of 10 companies selected for the Department of Energy's Advanced Reactor Pilot Program, and, uh, only the second to complete this phase of testing.
- 10:40But they were the first to do it at a site that they're about to make real energy from by July 4th. Uh, the company was founded by Isaiah Taylor. He's 27 years old. He dropped out of high school at 16.
- 10:52His grandfather worked on the Manhattan Project, so he's got nuclear- [laughs]... in his blood. Um, but- Mm-hmm... he, he kind of reminds me of, I don't know, he's, he's like a, a, um, I won't even say less crazy.
- 11:04He's a, a much less eccentric Elon Musk, is how I would say it. [laughs] Wow, there you go. That's, uh, very flattering. Yes, very much.
- 11:11Uh, he says, "When I started this company less than three years ago, our guiding principle was metal beats paper." And they said, "All nuclear startups live and die on paper with, you know, models and theory."
- 11:22He says, "No." He's like, "We're building stuff." So they've taken the metal beats paper approach, and, uh, they ha- it stood up. Nathan, you have the picture? Did I get it? He's trying. He's saying, "Wait."
- 11:32Oh, here, here it comes What's this? Who is this? Oh, that's me and Kyle- Oh, look at that... standing in front of the reactor while it was being built [laughs] in El Segundo.
- 11:41Um, that's, that's like a little receipt that I hope to have for my grandkids one day. Like you see- [laughs] Right... SpaceX there, yeah, when they were building the first rocket.
- 11:47Um, so, uh, Steve, this is an entrepreneurial story through and through. Um, I know you're not in energy, but um, certainly production of electricity is something that interacts with your world quite a bit.
- 11:57Um, what, what are your thoughts on what's going on here? Yeah. We, we actually do see a lot, a lot of startups in this really energy and a- adjacent space. So two things come to mind.
- 12:04One is, you know, Elon Musk's un- been under a lot of heat recently for these six, uh, gas turbines that he's running full fa- at full capacity, uh, do- down in, in Mississippi, uh, to feed data centers, right- Ah...
- 12:15uh, for xAI, and then he's sell- he's selling that capacity it looks like to other like hyperscalers.
- 12:20So interesting if we move from like burning fossil fuels to be able to drop these things adjacent to data centers across the US, it may remove some of the resistance that these communities are having to building new data centers if the power is effectively free, right?
- 12:34That's interesting.
- 12:35And then I can imagine from a Department of Defense standpoint, one of the challenges is even if, you know, the, the, you're gonna electrify tanks and you're gonna electrify Humvees or whatever, you're still gonna have to air- airlift diesel generators into these, you know, battlefields- Hmm...
- 12:50to be able to p- power the, the, the electricity generation overall.
- 12:53So be very interesting if, if these things become small enough and, uh, li- lightweight enough that they're a good alternative to dropping in diesel generators, where then you have to have mechanics and you have to have gas, fuel, uh, pumped in all the time.
- 13:07Yeah.
- 13:07If you could drop these out behind e- enemy lines and they could power, you know, your army of drones or your ar- army of autonomous robots or whatever the future of the, the battlefield looks like, that, that could be very interesting, too.
- 13:19So, um, you know, ch- cheap, cheap energy, almost free energy, ubiquitous and flexible is, um, gonna, gonna be the future, and it's very interesting, um, as, as a good competitor to say, you know, wind and solar and other sort of like renewables.
- 13:33This is, uh, fa- fascinating and exciting to see. It'll be, it will be interesting to see how small they get. I mean, this is very small.
- 13:40Obviously saw in the picture Kyle and I are standing that the main unit fits inside a shipping container, and then- Right... the control room will also fit inside a shipping container.
- 13:48Some other considerations, right, like the, the concrete shielding, um, you know, obviously takes in.
- 13:53I think people being comfortable with the stability and safety of nuclear technology because when people think nuclear reactors, you think big industrial complex things that like, if something goes wrong, right- Right...
- 14:06like no one within 50 miles is really safe. This is a much different- Right... story, but a lot of times, you know, the education, uh, of what it is. The fuel that they use is different. It's called TRISO fuel.
- 14:16It's like a ceramic. It's almost like a ceramic beads. It's, it's, and the- Hmm... uranium or whatever it is, is kind of locked in there. But again, leave it to the entrepreneurs to figure something out.
- 14:24I don't think anyone saw a 27-year-old high school dropout kinda winning this race. Uh, but these things are pretty powerful.
- 14:30Like for reference, one of these reactors, they can chain them together, right, and, and produce megawatts of power, but one of these would power pretty much like the city of Syracuse, that little thing that you- Wow...
- 14:40saw there. Yeah. So I mean- Wow... like Air Force Base Andrews would need like one of these or maybe two, [laughs] you know, so. Wow.
- 14:47So I mean, maybe they can make them smaller, like I don't know, maybe they can fit them in, you know, a mug and we can chone- charge all our dr- [laughs]... charge all our drones. There you go.
- 14:54[laughs] Well, I think we've had enough fun on the show for one day.
- 14:58It's Friday, so whether you're going into the, uh, big sales weekend or if you're gonna unplug and relax a little bit, or if you're gonna keep hustling on that startup, uh, s- on behalf of Steve and I, take care of the people, take care of this industry.
- 15:09We'll see you. [upbeat music]