Latest / Her Journey: Women, identity, culture & modern life / Why I Keep Falling for Girls Who Look Like My Younger Self | Her Journey
Transcript
- I told a man on our third date that I went to Yale. It wasn’t true, but it felt safer than admitting I didn’t go at all. Let’s sit with that for a second. It was three years ago, or maybe four. I can still remember the exact shade of blue in his eyes, and the way he stirred his coffee like he was trying to solve a complex equation. We were at this tiny café in Brooklyn, the kind where the music is too loud and the chairs are uncomfortable. He asked me about my college days. Just casually, between questions about my job and whether I liked hiking. "Where did you go?" he said. And in that split second, my brain short-circuited. I didn’t want to say Community College. I didn’t want to say I worked full-time while studying part-time. I didn’t want to explain the debt, the shame, the feeling that I was always playing catch-up to women who had grown up with trust funds and legacy admissions. So I said Yale. I said it with such casual confidence that even I almost believed it myself. He smiled, nodded, and said, "Oh, I’ve heard great things about their writing program." And just like that, I was invited into a world I didn’t belong in. But here’s the thing about lying on first dates: it’s not really about the school. It’s about the version of yourself you think you need to be to be loved. We talk so much about authenticity in dating, don’t we? Swipe right on your real self. Be vulnerable. Show your scars. But when has anyone ever taught us how to show our inadequacies without fear of rejection? For many of us, especially those who came from working-class backgrounds or non-traditional educational paths, our credentials feel like armor. When you strip them away, what’s left? Sometimes, nothing. Or at least, that’s what the anxiety whispers. I realized later that I wasn’t lying to trick him. I was lying to protect myself from the assumption that I was less than. In that moment, I believed that if he knew the truth—that I went to a local state school, that I drove a car with a dent in the door, that I ate ramen for dinner during finals week—he would see me as less interesting, less intelligent, less worthy of his time. It’s a brutal calculation, isn’t it? One that we make constantly, often unconsciously. We curate our histories like museum exhibits, polishing the rough edges until they gleam. But the problem with curated history is that it leaves no room for the person you actually are. It builds a pedestal, sure, but pedestals are lonely places. And they’re incredibly fragile. Let’s talk about imposter syndrome for a minute, because it’s not just a workplace issue. It’s a relational one. When you lie about where you went to school, you are essentially signing a contract of perpetual performance. Every conversation after that becomes a minefield. You have to keep track of the lies. Did I say I majored in English or History? Do I know what a tutorial system is? Can I discuss the campus architecture without sounding like I’m making it up? The cognitive load is exhausting. I spent weeks terrified that he would call my alma mater, or ask for a yearbook photo, or mention a professor I hadn’t studied under. The anxiety became its own relationship. It sat between us at dinner, it whispered in our conversations, it kept me awake at night. And here is the uncomfortable truth: I started to hate him for being so easygoing. He seemed so comfortable in his own skin, so secure in his background. I felt small. I felt fake. I felt like a fraud in my own life. This is what happens when we tie our worth to external markers. We lose touch with our internal compass. We start navigating by stars that aren’t there. Where does that live in you? That constant low-grade hum of fear that you’ll be found out? Eventually, the truth came out. Not in a dramatic confrontation, but in a quiet moment over takeout Thai food. He mentioned an old friend from undergrad, and I froze. I couldn’t lie anymore. The energy required to maintain the fiction was too high. So I told him. I told him I went to community college. I told him I transferred later. I told him everything. I waited for the judgment. I waited for him to look at me with pity, or worse, disappointment. Instead, he shrugged. He said, "That’s impressive, actually. You made it work." And then he shared his own struggles—his family’s financial stress, his own feelings of inadequacy in grad school. In that moment, the dynamic shifted. The pedestal collapsed, and in its place, something real emerged. A connection based on honesty, not performance. It was terrifying and liberating. I realized that the lie hadn’t protected me; it had isolated me. By hiding my past, I had hidden my resilience. I had hidden the strength it took to navigate a system that wasn’t built for me. I had hidden the very thing that made me strong. It’s complicated, isn’t it? How our vulnerabilities, once exposed, become our greatest assets in connection. But let’s zoom out for a second, because this isn’t just about me and that one guy. It’s about a culture that equates educational pedigree with human value. We live in a society that obsesses over labels. Ivy League vs. State School. Private vs. Public. These distinctions feel massive, but do they really define who we are? No. They define where we spent four years. They define who paid our tuition. They define the network we accessed. But they don’t define our capacity for love, for creativity, for kindness, for growth. Yet, we internalize these hierarchies. We believe that some stories are more valid than others. We believe that certain traumas are more legitimate. We believe that some versions of womanhood are more desirable. This is a systemic issue, not just a personal insecurity. It’s a cultural script that tells us we must earn our place at the table. But what if we didn’t need to earn it? What if we could just sit down? What if we could admit that we are figuring it out, just like everyone else? That admission is radical. It disrupts the hierarchy. It creates space for other people to be honest too. When you drop the mask, you give permission for others to drop theirs. So, how do we reclaim our narratives? How do we stop lying about our universities, our salaries, our heights, our exes? It starts with recognizing that the lie is a symptom, not the disease. The disease is the belief that you are not enough as you are. The remedy is not just telling the truth, but believing that the truth is worthy of being heard. Practice small truths. Tell your date about the mistake you made at work. Admit that you don’t know the answer to a question. Share the story of the time you failed. Watch what happens. Most of the time, nothing bad happens. Sometimes, something beautiful happens. Connection deepens. Trust grows. You realize that you are lovable not despite your imperfections, but because of your humanity. It takes practice. It takes courage. But it is worth it. Because living a lie is a heavy burden. Living the truth is light. It might be shaky at first, like learning to walk again. But it is yours. And eventually, you will stand tall on your own two feet, without the crutch of a fabricated identity. You will find that the people who matter don’t care about the school on your diploma. They care about the heart behind it. Thank you for listening, for trusting me with your time today. I hope you feel a little lighter, a little more seen. Until next time, be gentle with yourself. You are doing better than you think. Bye for now.