Latest / SWOP Behind Bars Advocacy from the Margins / The Mothers of the Cornell Seven: Are Women Responsible for the Men They Love?
Transcript
- 0:00I recently found myself in a signal
- 0:02conversation with a group of feminists discussing the Cornell Seven,
- 0:06seven young men named in a civil lawsuit involving allegations that a young
- 0:11woman was drugged and sexually assaulted at Cornell University in October 2024.
- 0:17Then the conversation took an unexpected turn.
- 0:20One of the women had close personal connections to a family associated with
- 0:24the case. She had decided to sit out Cornell-related demonstrations.
- 0:29She made clear that she opposed sexual violence and wasn't asking anyone to
- 0:34stop supporting the young woman who reported the assault.
- 0:37She asked that public statements use the word alleged while legal proceedings remained unresolved.
- 0:44What followed was a debate about whether her relationships called her feminist
- 0:48commitments into question, and eventually, whether she should remain in leadership.
- 0:53We have spent generations fighting the idea that women should be defined by the men in their lives.
- 0:59Yet here we were, in a feminist space, debating whether a woman should be judged
- 1:04by her relationship to a family connected to allegations of sexual violence.
- 1:09I started thinking about the mothers of the Cornell 7, their grandmothers,
- 1:14aunts, sisters, and the other women who raised and loved them.
- 1:19And I kept coming back to one question. When did loving a man who has caused
- 1:23harm become evidence that a woman has betrayed other women?
- 1:28I've seen these mothers in courtrooms.
- 1:30I have sat in courtrooms where men who committed terrible crimes against women were being sentenced.
- 1:36I have listened to survivors describe what happened to them.
- 1:40And I have watched the mothers of those men stand before judges and beg for leniency.
- 1:46Some cried. Some spoke about the little boys they had raised and the good they
- 1:51still believed existed in their sons.
- 1:53I could recognize the suffering of the survivors while also recognizing the
- 1:58anguish of the mother sitting a few feet away.
- 2:01Their pain was not the same, their circumstances were not equivalent,
- 2:06and the mother's grief did not erase the harm their sons had caused.
- 2:10But their grief was real. A mother begging for mercy is not necessarily a mother denying justice.
- 2:18Sometimes, she is simply a mother who knows exactly what her son has done and
- 2:23loves him anyway. Women are not extensions of the men in their lives.
- 2:27For generations, feminists have fought the assumption that wives were responsible
- 2:32for their husbands' behavior, that mothers were to blame for their sons' failures,
- 2:37and that women should carry the shame of men's misconduct.
- 2:41So why do we resurrect those expectations when the subject is sexual violence?
- 2:46If a woman's son is accused of rape, does she become suspect simply because she loves him?
- 2:52If she asks for fairness, is she undermining survivors?
- 2:56If she cannot bring herself to protest against someone she has known since childhood,
- 3:01does that make her less of a feminist? I don't think so.
- 3:05There is an enormous difference between loving someone who has caused harm and excusing that harm.
- 3:12Between asking for due process and discrediting a survivor, between declining
- 3:17to participate in an advocacy campaign and actively working to undermine it.
- 3:22When a man commits violence, someone inevitably asks where his mother was.
- 3:28Rarely do we ask the same question about his father, and we almost never examine
- 3:33the culture that teaches boys that masculinity is measured by dominance,
- 3:37sexual conquest, and the approval of other men.
- 3:41A young man can grow up surrounded by strong, feminist women and still absorb
- 3:46messages from his peers, fraternities,
- 3:48and social media that contradict everything he was taught at home.
- 3:52Accountability belongs to the person who caused the harm.
- 3:56It should not automatically extend to his mother, grandmother,
- 4:00aunt, sister, or wife simply because she refuses to stop loving him.
- 4:05When feminist solidarity becomes a loyalty test. Feminist organizations should
- 4:10never allow influential families or personal friendships to determine whether
- 4:15survivors receive support.
- 4:17Conflicts of interest should be disclosed and managed. But refusing to join
- 4:22a particular demonstration is not the same as interfering with another woman's pursuit of justice.
- 4:29And asking an organization to use accurate legal language is not the same as
- 4:33discrediting someone who reports sexual assault.
- 4:36The word alleged is not an insult to survivors.
- 4:40It describes the status of a claim that has not yet been legally established.
- 4:45What concerns me is how quickly a disagreement about participation can become
- 4:50a judgment about belonging.
- 4:52A woman should not have to publicly condemn someone she loves simply to retain
- 4:57her place in a feminist community.
- 5:00Nor should her love for that person give her permission to undermine someone
- 5:04else's pursuit of justice.
- 5:06Both things can be true. What about the other mother? There is another family in this story.
- 5:12Somewhere, the young woman who reported the assault has a mother,
- 5:16grandmother, aunt, sister, or chosen family member watching strangers debate
- 5:21her credibility, her decisions, and her private life.
- 5:26Or perhaps she has told no one in her family at all.
- 5:29We do not know. These women are not necessarily enemies.
- 5:33Their experiences are different, and their responsibilities are not identical.
- 5:38But we do not have to diminish one woman's experience to acknowledge another woman's humanity.
- 5:44What this has to do with swap behind bars.
- 5:47Sex workers understand these contradictions particularly well because we are
- 5:52routinely blamed for the behavior of men.
- 5:55When men purchase sex, women are blamed for creating the demand.
- 6:00When men commit violence against sex workers, we are blamed for putting ourselves in danger.
- 6:05Many of the women we work with are also mothers, daughters, sisters,
- 6:10and partners of incarcerated people.
- 6:13They know what it means to be judged for the behavior of men they love.
- 6:17And somehow, the proposed solution is almost always more criminalization.
- 6:22We cannot criminalize our way to better masculinity.
- 6:26We cannot arrest our way to consent, prosecute our way to empathy,
- 6:30or punish our way into a culture where men understand that women are autonomous human beings.
- 6:37If feminism is serious about ending violence against women, it must stop making
- 6:42women responsible for fixing men and start demanding that men take responsibility for themselves.
- 6:49A feminism big enough for the truth.
- 6:52I never confused those courtroom mothers' love with innocence.
- 6:56I never believed their grief erased the suffering of survivors.
- 7:00And I never thought they should have to stop loving their children to prove
- 7:05they cared about the women their children had hurt.
- 7:07I feel the same way about the women connected to the Cornell 7.
- 7:11The young woman who reported the assault deserves to be heard,
- 7:15supported, and treated with dignity.
- 7:18The allegations deserve a thorough and impartial examination.
- 7:22If responsibility is established, meaningful accountability should follow.
- 7:26But the women who love the accused deserve dignity too.
- 7:30They are not defendants. We cannot spend decades telling women they are not
- 7:35responsible for men's behavior and then make exceptions when the men behave badly.
- 7:40We cannot insist that women deserve autonomy and then dictate whom they must
- 7:45love, whom they must abandon, or how they must demonstrate their loyalty to other women.
- 7:51And we cannot build a movement committed to ending violence by turning compassion into a competition.
- 7:57A mother should not have to prove her feminism by abandoning her son.
- 8:02But neither should she have to prove her love by abandoning the truth.
- 8:07If we believe women are more than their relationships to men,
- 8:10then we need to practice that belief even when it makes us uncomfortable, especially then.