Latest / Bloomberg Law / What Happens When a Country Breaks EU Law?
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: The European Union has been in a legal fight with
- 0:11Speaker 1: renegades Poland and Hungary over respect for the rule of
- 0:14Speaker 1: law and the independence of the judiciary. The two countries
- 0:18Speaker 1: were singled out in an EU report this week that
- 0:21Speaker 1: pointed to the widening gap between their populist regimes and
- 0:25Speaker 1: the block's democratic standards. Poland Supreme Court is considering making
- 0:29Speaker 1: a U turn and halting a controversial disciplinary regime for
- 0:33Speaker 1: judges that would comply with the ruling by the EU's
- 0:36Speaker 1: top tribunal, But the Prime Minister of Hungary is proposing
- 0:39Speaker 1: a referendum to push back against EU pressure to change
- 0:43Speaker 1: a Hungarian anti lgbt Q law that sparked a furious
- 0:48Speaker 1: reaction in the Block. Will the EU's executive arms start
- 0:52Speaker 1: using recently one sanctioning powers to freeze funding including COVID
- 0:56Speaker 1: nineteen bailouts for the errant member states? Joining me is
- 1:00Speaker 1: Ronan McCrae, Professor of Constitutional and European Law at University
- 1:05Speaker 1: College London. So let's start with some basics. In the
- 1:09Speaker 1: United States, we have federal law and state law. How
- 1:12Speaker 1: does EU law work with the law of country members.
- 1:16Speaker 1: In some ways, it's actually not that different from the
- 1:19Speaker 1: situation in the US. So like in the US the preemption,
- 1:24Speaker 1: when the EU legislates in a particular area, the member
- 1:28Speaker 1: states lose their right to legislate in that area, and
- 1:30Speaker 1: EU law takes precedents. So under EU laws there's a
- 1:33Speaker 1: clash between national law and ELA. E law takes precedence,
- 1:39Speaker 1: and EULO will also be enforced by domestic courts, so
- 1:43Speaker 1: you don't have to go to the European Court for
- 1:45Speaker 1: every case. In theory, your local court will enforce your
- 1:49Speaker 1: EU law rights. In the United States, we have common
- 1:52Speaker 1: law and then we have statutory law. Is EU law
- 1:55Speaker 1: all statutory no, so the law it's really like a
- 2:00Speaker 1: constitutional system. So there's the Treaty, which is the founding
- 2:04Speaker 1: documents that's like the constitution that sets out the powers
- 2:06Speaker 1: of the EU, but also has a lot of constitutional principles,
- 2:09Speaker 1: mainly fundamental rights principles in it. And then there's also
- 2:14Speaker 1: then the secondary legislation that's produced by the EU legislature,
- 2:17Speaker 1: which is the States and European Parliament and the European
- 2:19Speaker 1: Commission together produce legislation in various areas of law in
- 2:24Speaker 1: which the EU has competence. So then if a country's law,
- 2:30Speaker 1: let's say Italy, if Italy's laws conflict with EU laws,
- 2:34Speaker 1: then Italy has to change their laws. Yes, there's two
- 2:38Speaker 1: things that can happen. First, the Commission can take Italy
- 2:41Speaker 1: to the European Court of Justice and get the declaration
- 2:44Speaker 1: that they've violated their duties under EU law. And if
- 2:48Speaker 1: Italy doesn't bring its law into line, they can then
- 2:51Speaker 1: be subject to repeat unlimited fine from the court. The
- 2:57Speaker 1: second way, and in ways the more important a is
- 3:00Speaker 1: that an Italian individual can go to their local court,
- 3:04Speaker 1: they have a case and insist that eulaways applied in
- 3:07Speaker 1: that case. And the Court of Justice has for a
- 3:10Speaker 1: really forty years, the Court of European Court of Justice,
- 3:13Speaker 1: the Supreme Court has ruled that in the case where
- 3:16Speaker 1: there's a conflict between national law and EU law, EU
- 3:21Speaker 1: law must take precedence and in the individual local national
- 3:25Speaker 1: judge must apply EU law to the case. That's what
- 3:27Speaker 1: makes the law so different from other forms of international law.
- 3:30Speaker 1: You don't have to go to the international court. It's
- 3:33Speaker 1: directly enforceable in your local court. How many EU courts
- 3:38Speaker 1: are there well, that's a good questions. So there are
- 3:40Speaker 1: two main EU courts to the General Court, which deals
- 3:45Speaker 1: with issues about kind of when you call antitrust law,
- 3:49Speaker 1: bearious other areas, and then there it's decisions can be
- 3:52Speaker 1: appealed to the European Court of Justice, which is the
- 3:55Speaker 1: supreme court. But because the European Court of Justice has
- 3:59Speaker 1: ruled that national courts have to enforce the law in
- 4:02Speaker 1: cases before them, in theory, all of the courts of
- 4:05Speaker 1: the Member States are also EU courts. And what happens
- 4:08Speaker 1: is the Court of Justice says that any national court
- 4:12Speaker 1: that has issue of EU law before it and doesn't
- 4:15Speaker 1: know how to interpret you law in the case, they
- 4:17Speaker 1: can stop the case, make a reference to the European
- 4:21Speaker 1: Court ask how should I apply EU law in this case,
- 4:24Speaker 1: and the court will give them the answer and then
- 4:26Speaker 1: they'll apply it. So there isn't a separate system of
- 4:29Speaker 1: federal and state courts like you have in the US,
- 4:33Speaker 1: just all the Member states have their own legal systems.
- 4:36Speaker 1: And then there's on top of it at the European
- 4:38Speaker 1: Court of Justice, who answers all EU law queries, but
- 4:42Speaker 1: which expect the Member of state courts then to apply
- 4:44Speaker 1: its rulings. When is it that the courts enforce laws
- 4:48Speaker 1: and when is it that the European Commission enforces laws?
- 4:53Speaker 1: So the courts will enforce the law in a concrete
- 4:56Speaker 1: case before it. So what happens is you know you
- 4:58Speaker 1: might be fired from your of work and you think
- 5:01Speaker 1: that there's a lot of the laws, a lot of
- 5:03Speaker 1: competence in labor law. You may take the case to
- 5:05Speaker 1: the court and insist that the law is applied in
- 5:09Speaker 1: that case. What the European Commission can do is where
- 5:11Speaker 1: there's no case just in period as a breach of
- 5:14Speaker 1: the EU law, they can they can then take a complaint.
- 5:17Speaker 1: So for the Commission to act, they don't need a
- 5:19Speaker 1: concrete violation in an individual case, they can follow up
- 5:23Speaker 1: any abstract one. But for national courts they would need
- 5:26Speaker 1: an actual dispute in front of it. And the Court
- 5:28Speaker 1: of Justice is rude, but they they won't rule on
- 5:31Speaker 1: theoretical disputes, and national courts they have an actual dispute
- 5:35Speaker 1: involving in the EU law issue before it before the
- 5:37Speaker 1: national court can invoke EU law. So tell me what
- 5:40Speaker 1: happened last year when the e use General Court ordered
- 5:44Speaker 1: the annoyment of the thirteen billion euro tax order against Apple.
- 5:50Speaker 1: Why did that happen? Well, what they found was because
- 5:53Speaker 1: the EU has quite limited competence in matters of tax,
- 5:57Speaker 1: but they do have a lot of power in areas
- 5:59Speaker 1: could of what's called state aid, which is where states
- 6:02Speaker 1: giving subsidies two companies, and the European Commission had argued
- 6:08Speaker 1: that Irelen's favorable treatment of Apple in relation to tax
- 6:13Speaker 1: matters was so favorable that it effects the amounted to
- 6:16Speaker 1: a subsidy state subsidy. And so because EU look Bay
- 6:19Speaker 1: prohibits state subsidies, the European Commission imposed that fine and says,
- 6:25Speaker 1: you can't do this. Apple has to pay back the
- 6:27Speaker 1: tax is amounts to a subsidy. But the general courts
- 6:31Speaker 1: that actually, no, this is a matter of tax, not
- 6:33Speaker 1: a matter of subsidy policy, and so they annulled the
- 6:36Speaker 1: imposition of that thirteen billion. So tell me how Germany's
- 6:41Speaker 1: Constitutional Court took the EU Court of Justice on in
- 6:46Speaker 1: and what happened there. As part of the kind of
- 6:49Speaker 1: economic crisis, the European Bank is not allowed to fund
- 6:57Speaker 1: to give money to states to kind of fund their spending,
- 7:01Speaker 1: but it is allowed fixed interest rates, and the European
- 7:04Speaker 1: Bank Central Bank. During the kind of economic crisis the
- 7:08Speaker 1: last ten years, the bank bank has decided that although
- 7:11Speaker 1: they're allowed directly financed governments, they can buy unlimited amounts
- 7:16Speaker 1: of state debt in order to ensure that the interest
- 7:19Speaker 1: rate states are charged is not doesn't deviate much from
- 7:23Speaker 1: the interest rates set by the European Central Bank, and
- 7:26Speaker 1: the German court says this is disguised financing of the
- 7:30Speaker 1: states by the European Central Bank and that that's something
- 7:34Speaker 1: that the EU Bank does not the power to do so.
- 7:37Speaker 1: When Drum politicians took this case, saying the European Central Bank,
- 7:41Speaker 1: by funding member states in this way buying their debt,
- 7:45Speaker 1: has gone beyond its powers. The German Constitutional Court after
- 7:49Speaker 1: the European Court of Justice, does the European Central Bank
- 7:52Speaker 1: have the power to do this under the EU treaties.
- 7:56Speaker 1: The Court of Justice said yes it does and send
- 7:59Speaker 1: the case back to the Constitutional Court. But the German
- 8:01Speaker 1: Constitutional Court said, actually, we don't think you've exercised a
- 8:06Speaker 1: strict enough review of the limits of the powers of
- 8:09Speaker 1: central bank. We disagree. Therefore, the German Central Bank, which
- 8:13Speaker 1: is part of the European central bank system, and provide
- 8:16Speaker 1: some of the money cannot participate in this project. Now,
- 8:20Speaker 1: the issue with that is it was the first time
- 8:22Speaker 1: that a national court had refused to accept the ruling
- 8:26Speaker 1: of the European Court of Justice on what were the
- 8:28Speaker 1: limits of the powers of the EU institution. European Court
- 8:32Speaker 1: Justice has always said, if we have twenty seven states,
- 8:35Speaker 1: we have to have one court, European put a justice
- 8:38Speaker 1: which provides a definitive answer to what are the powers
- 8:41Speaker 1: of the institutions. And here the German court was refusing
- 8:44Speaker 1: to accept that, and that went against fifty years of
- 8:47Speaker 1: e U k S law, where they've been saying any
- 8:50Speaker 1: conflict in national law and EU law is resolved in
- 8:53Speaker 1: favor of you law. This is a problem in itself
- 8:55Speaker 1: because they were worried about the European Central Banks bomb
- 8:59Speaker 1: buying program, but they've they've kind of faded recently. But
- 9:02Speaker 1: it's a bigger structural issue because if national constitutional courts
- 9:08Speaker 1: start refusing to accept the primacy of EU law, then
- 9:11Speaker 1: the whole system, the illegal system, begins to fall apart.
- 9:15Speaker 1: And that's particularly important because the EU is in the
- 9:19Speaker 1: midst of and very heated clashes with two members states
- 9:23Speaker 1: Hungry and Poland over the independence of their courts tell
- 9:27Speaker 1: us about the conflicts between the EU and Hungary and Poland.
- 9:32Speaker 1: So the Hungarian government and the Polish government have an
- 9:35Speaker 1: act that a series of performs, the substance of which
- 9:39Speaker 1: is to undermine the independence of the judiciary, and the
- 9:42Speaker 1: European Court of Justice has issued several rulings saying because
- 9:47Speaker 1: EU law requires national judges to implement the EU law,
- 9:51Speaker 1: the EU requires the judges are independent, so they're able
- 9:55Speaker 1: to enforce the EU law against the government. Therefore, your
- 9:58Speaker 1: measures which under find the independence of the courts in
- 10:02Speaker 1: Hungary in Poland violated U law and you have to
- 10:05Speaker 1: you have to disapply them. Now, this means when the
- 10:07Speaker 1: German Constitutional Court is kind of reasonably why you respected
- 10:10Speaker 1: in Europe, ruled that it was not accepting a Court
- 10:13Speaker 1: of Justice ruling. The Polish and Hungarian governments were delighted
- 10:16Speaker 1: because they were like brilliant. Our courts now will say
- 10:19Speaker 1: they don't have to accept Court of Justice rulings in
- 10:21Speaker 1: relation toudicial independence, which is what happens. Last week. The
- 10:25Speaker 1: Polish Supreme Court or Constitutional Court has rules that it
- 10:28Speaker 1: does not accept the European Court of Justice ruling which
- 10:32Speaker 1: said that the Disciplinary Chamber they have for judges, where
- 10:35Speaker 1: government appointees can discipline judges for ruling against it. European
- 10:40Speaker 1: Court of Justice has said that disciplinary chamber is against
- 10:43Speaker 1: the EU law and must be shut down, and Polish
- 10:45Speaker 1: Constitutional Court has now said, well, just like the Germans,
- 10:49Speaker 1: we retained the right not to accept Court of Justice
- 10:52Speaker 1: rulings if we think they go against our constitution and
- 10:55Speaker 1: therefore we don't accept this ruling. So this is a big, big,
- 11:00Speaker 1: kind of slow burned threat to the European Court adjustice
- 11:03Speaker 1: because over the years there's been some gray areas about
- 11:06Speaker 1: whether their national courts accepted that EULA always took primacy,
- 11:10Speaker 1: but by and large they have accepted the primacy of
- 11:13Speaker 1: the law, and without the primacy of you law. If
- 11:17Speaker 1: national courts are not going to follow you law and
- 11:20Speaker 1: are going to disapply it when they feel like it,
- 11:23Speaker 1: or if they think they're sufficiently important reasons to do so,
- 11:26Speaker 1: then the legal unity of the EU is really undermined.
- 11:30Speaker 1: The EU of two things. It's a sit on political
- 11:32Speaker 1: cooperation between member states and the system of shared legal rules.
- 11:37Speaker 1: Once the shared legal rules go, if national courts stopped
- 11:42Speaker 1: enforcing them, then the EU retreats doing something much more
- 11:46Speaker 1: like a classic international organization rather than what it is now,
- 11:50Speaker 1: which is something which is halfway between a state and
- 11:53Speaker 1: an international organization. So where does the situation now with
- 11:57Speaker 1: the German Constitution Court. Well, the German Constitutional Court gave
- 12:02Speaker 1: itself a kind of way out. It said that, well,
- 12:06Speaker 1: we don't accept that the European Court of Justice has
- 12:08Speaker 1: been strict enough than policing the boundaries of the powers
- 12:12Speaker 1: of European Central Bank. But if the German Bank can
- 12:16Speaker 1: provide us with various factual information about how this bond
- 12:19Speaker 1: buying program works, then we might be happy to accept
- 12:23Speaker 1: that it's within the powers of the European Central Bank.
- 12:26Speaker 1: And the europ German Central Bank did issue various clarifications
- 12:29Speaker 1: and gave the courts and factor information and the Court
- 12:32Speaker 1: has said okay, well now Germany can participate. So on
- 12:36Speaker 1: the fact the kind of danger to the bond buying
- 12:39Speaker 1: program has disappeared. But that level of principles, the damage
- 12:44Speaker 1: is done because now the threat to the authority of
- 12:48Speaker 1: the European Court of Justice is established when a well
- 12:50Speaker 1: respected founding Member States Supreme Court goes against the Court
- 12:54Speaker 1: of Justice. Because remember there's no national Guard in the EU.
- 12:58Speaker 1: You know when the European Court of just just rules
- 13:00Speaker 1: while their case is clear that the legal obligation to
- 13:03Speaker 1: enforce their ruling, they have no way of forcing a
- 13:06Speaker 1: national court that doesn't want to enforce a ruling to
- 13:10Speaker 1: do so. The only thing that can happen is they
- 13:12Speaker 1: can impose financial sanctions on the member states, and they
- 13:15Speaker 1: are now. The European Commission this week has said that
- 13:19Speaker 1: they're going to go for financial sanctions against Poland. But
- 13:21Speaker 1: there is no national guard. There's no way that the
- 13:25Speaker 1: European Court of Justice can enforce compliance with rulings. It's
- 13:28Speaker 1: dependent on the cooperation of national courts. So then if
- 13:32Speaker 1: Poland or Hungary says we're not going to pay the sanctions,
- 13:35Speaker 1: nothing can be done. Can they be kicked out of
- 13:37Speaker 1: the EU? No? Well, so they can. This natural sanctions
- 13:41Speaker 1: are real, and not least because Pope. Both Poland and
- 13:44Speaker 1: Hungary receive very significant substitutes in the EU. So the
- 13:48Speaker 1: EU is lucky and that the two countries that are
- 13:50Speaker 1: kind of creating the most trouble at the moment are
- 13:53Speaker 1: both big net beneficiaries of EU spending, so that they
- 13:56Speaker 1: will have to pay the fine. There is new EU
- 13:59Speaker 1: legislation says when judicial independence is not respected, if that
- 14:03Speaker 1: threatens the integrity of the EU budget, you can cut funding.
- 14:06Speaker 1: So they may lose funding, but there is no way
- 14:09Speaker 1: to expel a member states from the European Union. In fact,
- 14:11Speaker 1: in that regards to the unhelpful case came up during
- 14:14Speaker 1: the Brexit process where some pro EU British politicians took
- 14:18Speaker 1: a case to the European Court of Justice asking if
- 14:21Speaker 1: Britain could withdraw its notification that it wants to leave
- 14:26Speaker 1: the EU, and in a wider ruling in passing, the
- 14:29Speaker 1: court said, well, there's no there's no mechanism for kicking
- 14:32Speaker 1: a member state out of the European Union against its will,
- 14:35Speaker 1: so you can't kick them out of the European Union.
- 14:37Speaker 1: The one thing that can happen is, I mean the
- 14:40Speaker 1: EU because it legislates in so many areas now labor, loan,
- 14:43Speaker 1: by mental law, agriculture, economic policy. You know, there's an
- 14:47Speaker 1: awful lot of ways in which member states can make
- 14:52Speaker 1: other member states lives uncomfortable. So over the next few
- 14:55Speaker 1: months will be hundreds of issues that the E will
- 14:57Speaker 1: be deciding on. If put in the home, we really
- 15:00Speaker 1: look like they're kind of in danger of bringing down
- 15:03Speaker 1: the whole system. The other member states can extract long
- 15:07Speaker 1: low revenge by blocking every single initiative that's important to them.
- 15:11Speaker 1: So that is a possibility. It's not a very dramatic one,
- 15:15Speaker 1: but member states are aware that there is long term
- 15:18Speaker 1: cost for going against but the member states. And the
- 15:21Speaker 1: one thing we learned from the Brexit process was how
- 15:24Speaker 1: much the Union means to the political elites in Europe.
- 15:27Speaker 1: In fact, we saw this again the financial crisis to
- 15:29Speaker 1: there are a lot of commentators in the US like
- 15:32Speaker 1: Paul Krugman and Just Stiglets who are wondering why the
- 15:35Speaker 1: Eurozone didn't collapse. You know, the order doesn't really make
- 15:37Speaker 1: sense to have a single currency without a single economic policy.
- 15:41Speaker 1: But what they underestimated is the political commitment of EU
- 15:45Speaker 1: leaders to maintaining the union. They would do whatever it
- 15:48Speaker 1: takes to keep it together. And in the Brexit process,
- 15:51Speaker 1: despite all the fights between different member states, when one
- 15:53Speaker 1: member state left, the other twenty seven member states formed
- 15:57Speaker 1: kind of a block and negotiating there was no deviation.
- 16:01Speaker 1: There was no picking one member state off by the British.
- 16:04Speaker 1: So you member state governments are very committed to protecting
- 16:07Speaker 1: the union. There will be a high political price for
- 16:10Speaker 1: Poland and Hungry to pay if they're seen is threatening it,
- 16:13Speaker 1: but there is no way of expelling them even if
- 16:16Speaker 1: they reach YOU law. What may happen if courts may
- 16:19Speaker 1: start national courts may start saying that they don't recognize
- 16:23Speaker 1: Polish and Hungarian decisions. So a lot of you law
- 16:26Speaker 1: is the duty to recognize the judgments and decisions of
- 16:29Speaker 1: other member states. And what may happen is over time
- 16:32Speaker 1: other courts may start saying, well, actually, we don't think
- 16:35Speaker 1: your courts are independents, so we won't give you that benefit.
- 16:37Speaker 1: It's already in the case of Ireland years ago, where
- 16:40Speaker 1: a Polish prisoner EU law makes the transfer prisoners between
- 16:43Speaker 1: states much easier. A Polish prisoner was meant to be
- 16:46Speaker 1: sent for trial in Poland, the Irish court said, we're
- 16:50Speaker 1: not sure we can send you actually, because we don't
- 16:52Speaker 1: think the Polish courts are independent. And tell us a
- 16:55Speaker 1: little about the conflict with Hungary and it's LGBT law.
- 17:01Speaker 1: The Hungarian government has really for the last ten years
- 17:04Speaker 1: being undermining judicial independence. They've placed the wife of a
- 17:08Speaker 1: rooting party politician as head of the judiciary. They gave
- 17:12Speaker 1: her the power to promote and fire judges allocate cases.
- 17:15Speaker 1: I think variously they've suddenly dropped the retirement age of
- 17:19Speaker 1: judges by ten years to get rid of once they
- 17:20Speaker 1: didn't like. So they've been attacking the independence of judiciary
- 17:24Speaker 1: in Hungary for a while. But there's also been a
- 17:26Speaker 1: cultural clash, and recently they passed the law that would
- 17:32Speaker 1: be abandoned the provision of any information about gay more
- 17:36Speaker 1: transgender people to people under eighteen and links it by
- 17:39Speaker 1: implication to be the fedia that hast gone down very
- 17:42Speaker 1: poorly in Western European states and in the Baltic states.
- 17:48Speaker 1: So there's a real divide on this issue, and the
- 17:50Speaker 1: European Commission is trying to sue Hungry for that. The
- 17:53Speaker 1: difficulty they face is, you know, the European Union only
- 17:56Speaker 1: has competence in certain areas, and that kind of area
- 18:00Speaker 1: is something that the EU have fairly limited competence in
- 18:04Speaker 1: relation to. But they're trying to think creatively about areas
- 18:09Speaker 1: which might be touched by this law, like some elements
- 18:12Speaker 1: of broadcasting law or things like that, where the Union
- 18:14Speaker 1: does have competence and there they're going to try and
- 18:17Speaker 1: take a case on that basis. So interesting. Thanks for
- 18:20Speaker 1: being on Bloomberg Law. Ronan. That's Ronan McCrae, a professor
- 18:23Speaker 1: of Constitutional and European law at University College London. The
- 18:29Speaker 1: pandemics test of telework for office workers has reached an
- 18:33Speaker 1: inflection point as returned to work mandates are put in
- 18:37Speaker 1: place and legal battles loom over employee request to stay
- 18:41Speaker 1: at home. Joining me is Aaron mulvaney, Senior legal reporter
- 18:44Speaker 1: at Bloomberg Law. Are a lot of companies mandating that
- 18:48Speaker 1: workers returned to the office or is there a split
- 18:51Speaker 1: among major companies? There absolutely are a lot of companies
- 18:56Speaker 1: that do you want a returned to the office UM
- 19:00Speaker 1: for their workforce? UM, while they're being cautious, there's been
- 19:05Speaker 1: a there have been CEOs that have come out like
- 19:07Speaker 1: JP Morgan or UM Microsoft CEOs that have said office
- 19:12Speaker 1: culture is very important to how they operate and UM.
- 19:18Speaker 1: Then there have been other companies that have been more
- 19:20Speaker 1: flexible and our suggesting permit hybrid options. And there are
- 19:24Speaker 1: really big names in that group to like Twitter, Facebook,
- 19:28Speaker 1: City Group, UM have considered kind of more flexible options
- 19:32Speaker 1: as well. So there's definitely a divide among even major
- 19:36Speaker 1: corporations of how they're responding to kind of this new
- 19:40Speaker 1: normal which workers have to go back to work, have
- 19:44Speaker 1: no excuse, and which workers can make a legal case
- 19:50Speaker 1: right and and to be clear, since you brought this up,
- 19:52Speaker 1: we're of course talking about office workers who were kind
- 19:55Speaker 1: of teleworking during the whole the entire pandemic. And the
- 19:59Speaker 1: reason that's been important is because of course there's a
- 20:01Speaker 1: lot of workers out there that you know, we're essential
- 20:04Speaker 1: and needed to go in and there was a business
- 20:06Speaker 1: necessity to being actually in person, and so there is
- 20:11Speaker 1: a case to be made. So by and large, an
- 20:13Speaker 1: employer can fire anyone who doesn't follow a return to
- 20:17Speaker 1: office handate. Most private employers have that right, um. But
- 20:23Speaker 1: there are exceptions to that because there are protections under
- 20:27Speaker 1: the American Disabilities Act, and if you that's probably the
- 20:29Speaker 1: most powerful one. Um. If there is a legitimate reason
- 20:34Speaker 1: and a concern that a person with a disability can't
- 20:37Speaker 1: return to an office, there could potentially be an accommodation
- 20:41Speaker 1: that's made, and there's kind of a balancing test that
- 20:43Speaker 1: comes into play if that makes it up to the court.
- 20:46Speaker 1: The first thing that happens is the worker says, I
- 20:50Speaker 1: don't want to go back to work because or I
- 20:52Speaker 1: can't go back to work because and is there an
- 20:55Speaker 1: internal process first? Absolutely, So the way it would work
- 21:00Speaker 1: is that if there's a mandate to return to the office,
- 21:04Speaker 1: there could be and really this is for any kind
- 21:06Speaker 1: of accommodation, like even if you want a more ergonomic desk,
- 21:10Speaker 1: like the entire interactive process happened UM first with your
- 21:15Speaker 1: company doesn't always go immediately to the court obviously, but
- 21:19Speaker 1: so this would be a pretty big request or request
- 21:21Speaker 1: for telework UM when everyone else is going back. UM
- 21:25Speaker 1: would be something that you first from to your company
- 21:27Speaker 1: and then they would go through an interactive process to
- 21:29Speaker 1: see if that's an accommodation they can make and if
- 21:32Speaker 1: that would be appropriate UM and not be an undue
- 21:35Speaker 1: burden on their business operations. What kind of workers have
- 21:38Speaker 1: brought lawsuits? A lot of these cases that do rise
- 21:43Speaker 1: to the level of courts. Of course that you know
- 21:45Speaker 1: a little early in the process, but we are already
- 21:47Speaker 1: seeing lawsuits in charges filed UM arguing that the company
- 21:52Speaker 1: should have granted a telework request. There are different categories
- 21:56Speaker 1: of them. You know. Initially when there were kind of
- 22:00Speaker 1: mandates to return to the office, some people were concerned
- 22:03Speaker 1: with the immediate if they had UM, say asthma or
- 22:07Speaker 1: a disease, that would made them more AMUNO compromised and
- 22:10Speaker 1: more vulnerable to the actual coronavirus, you know, fearing going
- 22:15Speaker 1: back while the virus is still very active and raging
- 22:18Speaker 1: and before vaccines were widely available. UM. And then there's
- 22:22Speaker 1: there's also the types of UM lawsuits were where people
- 22:28Speaker 1: say that you know, the pandemic exacerbated their mental health
- 22:31Speaker 1: and going into an office would increase the anxiety and
- 22:34Speaker 1: that capacity. UM. There are absolutely those cases as well.
- 22:38Speaker 1: And there's the other type of case where UM, somebody
- 22:43Speaker 1: might have difficulty coming to the office because of a
- 22:45Speaker 1: mobility issue or the like, and that would be something
- 22:50Speaker 1: they could request and say it would just be I
- 22:52Speaker 1: can work just as well from home because I've proven,
- 22:56Speaker 1: you know, our whole office proven proved that we can,
- 22:59Speaker 1: and trying to make that request so there, and that
- 23:01Speaker 1: would be something that might happen more in perpecuity potentially, UM.
- 23:06Speaker 1: I take it the request due to physical disability is
- 23:09Speaker 1: easier to prove than the request due to mental health disability.
- 23:14Speaker 1: I think typically a doctor would be involved in giving
- 23:19Speaker 1: the information, you know, providing a note or you know,
- 23:22Speaker 1: a recommendation for what would be an appropriate accommodation for
- 23:25Speaker 1: somebody with stahts D or an anxiety disorder or depression.
- 23:29Speaker 1: So it would be similar. And I think it's always
- 23:32Speaker 1: about the remedy. You know, what is the remedy for
- 23:36Speaker 1: making you more comfortable at work? Like what can the
- 23:38Speaker 1: employer do? They could come back and say, Okay, you
- 23:41Speaker 1: don't want to be around people, will give you your
- 23:43Speaker 1: own office away from people, as opposed to having you
- 23:46Speaker 1: telework with people with mobility issues, the issue might be
- 23:50Speaker 1: the lack of public transportation available or the risk that
- 23:53Speaker 1: there would be at this time maybe using those So
- 23:56Speaker 1: they're the A D A cases always have this kind
- 23:59Speaker 1: of interactive process where all these different factors are balanced,
- 24:04Speaker 1: and then when we're talking about when they make it
- 24:06Speaker 1: up to the court level, the court will weigh those
- 24:08Speaker 1: factors as well and kind of try to determine what
- 24:11Speaker 1: would be an undue burden on the company. Was there
- 24:14Speaker 1: a decline in productivity during the work from home during
- 24:18Speaker 1: the pandemic, A lot of companies still reported UM positive numbers,
- 24:25Speaker 1: you know, and there was even a study that Price
- 24:28Speaker 1: Waterhouse Coopers did that said productivity didn't see a decline
- 24:32Speaker 1: during the pandemic. Office workers you know, effectively worked from
- 24:35Speaker 1: home um. And I think there was kind of um
- 24:39Speaker 1: for the pandemic that built in bias or fear um
- 24:42Speaker 1: that people would slack off for be lazy if they're
- 24:46Speaker 1: at home, like it's a day off. And so many
- 24:49Speaker 1: office workers were forced all at once to work at home.
- 24:52Speaker 1: It kind of automatically removed that stigma, at least potentially. UM.
- 24:57Speaker 1: It is interesting though, because I think companies still hold
- 25:01Speaker 1: on to and say despite that office culture is important,
- 25:06Speaker 1: being around people is important. Our company is well on
- 25:09Speaker 1: about personal relationships and we can't do that over zoom
- 25:13Speaker 1: and so that's why it's kind of an interesting cultural
- 25:16Speaker 1: class right now. UM. But you know there's when we
- 25:21Speaker 1: when we talk about people with disabilities. Um, there's an
- 25:25Speaker 1: extremely low employment rate um for people with disabilities, and
- 25:32Speaker 1: some experts day that remote options and being like widely
- 25:36Speaker 1: available could potentially help that down the line. And I
- 25:40Speaker 1: suppose that now that workers can point to, look what
- 25:44Speaker 1: I did during the pandemic, everything worked out fine, that
- 25:47Speaker 1: that is you know, an added boost to their cases.
- 25:52Speaker 1: I had a lawyer teld me that it's just you know,
- 25:56Speaker 1: she doesn't know the full legal landscape yet. We'll see
- 25:58Speaker 1: how these cases turn out and or but it'll be
- 26:01Speaker 1: so much more challenging for an employer to show that
- 26:03Speaker 1: working on site is an essential function of the job
- 26:07Speaker 1: because that didn't happen for so many office workers for
- 26:11Speaker 1: you know, more than a year UM, so that that
- 26:14Speaker 1: could be a potential silver lining for you know, uh,
- 26:17Speaker 1: either people have disabilities or even people with caregiving responsibilities,
- 26:21Speaker 1: which you know, so it could be a bit of
- 26:24Speaker 1: a silver lining from the pandemic for for certain groups
- 26:27Speaker 1: that actually benefited from teleworking. Being a caregiver, that's not
- 26:32Speaker 1: what I normally think about when I think about the
- 26:34Speaker 1: Americans with Disabilities Act. Is there a provision for caregivers? No,
- 26:40Speaker 1: that's kind of a can of worms. To be honest
- 26:43Speaker 1: with you. What I would say about caregivers is we
- 26:48Speaker 1: saw an unprecedented amount of women drop from the workforce,
- 26:52Speaker 1: and many of them were mothers um according to you know,
- 26:57Speaker 1: data from the pandemic, and I think that there will
- 27:01Speaker 1: be consequences from that. And it's still really hard to
- 27:06Speaker 1: actually make a claim UM for caregiver discrimination because that's
- 27:12Speaker 1: not an inherently protected um characteristic at least under like
- 27:16Speaker 1: the main federal civil rights laws like UM. I guess
- 27:20Speaker 1: the closest claim would probably be something under Title seven
- 27:23Speaker 1: if there was a sex discrimination claim UM. But but no, UM.
- 27:27Speaker 1: Actually caregiving is not covered under the the A d A,
- 27:30Speaker 1: even if there is a UM there. There was one
- 27:33Speaker 1: case that I mean, it's also being debated in the
- 27:36Speaker 1: courts about whether UM, you you have a claim for
- 27:42Speaker 1: UM if you have an amino compromised person that is
- 27:44Speaker 1: living in your house and you didn't want to see
- 27:46Speaker 1: bringing the disease back to them. UM. And that's that's
- 27:50Speaker 1: also a very unclear area of the law. UM. The
- 27:54Speaker 1: the ADA doesn't explicitly protect UM people in your household
- 27:58Speaker 1: that may have a disability. You write that before the
- 28:02Speaker 1: COVID pandemic, employers generally one the majority of rulings about
- 28:09Speaker 1: disability accommodations tell me about that and what may be
- 28:13Speaker 1: shifting there, right, and so we don't. We do have
- 28:18Speaker 1: some indication that it's a harder case for a company
- 28:21Speaker 1: that employs a lot of office workers to make. But
- 28:25Speaker 1: we we did see generally employers won these rulings because
- 28:30Speaker 1: I think it was that idea that cords were really
- 28:35Speaker 1: sympathetic to a company's argument that work needed to happen
- 28:38Speaker 1: in person, even if it was office work and computers
- 28:41Speaker 1: can be um. You know, the the e o C
- 28:44Speaker 1: actually fought a case on that and they kind of
- 28:47Speaker 1: had an opposite point of view or and we're trying
- 28:50Speaker 1: to say that like telework should be considered, especially in
- 28:52Speaker 1: these office environments, and they lost um because and you know,
- 28:58Speaker 1: if you look at courts, they happened in person so often,
- 29:02Speaker 1: and you know, and that obviously changed during the pandemic
- 29:05Speaker 1: as well. So there's there's there's potential for a shift
- 29:10Speaker 1: on on that question and how it will be interesting
- 29:14Speaker 1: to see how courts respond to it. Um. There was
- 29:18Speaker 1: a case that happened last fall and in a Massachusetts
- 29:22Speaker 1: a Massachusetts federal court allowed and asthmatic workers telework accommodation
- 29:27Speaker 1: to move forward um, you know, siding with the worker
- 29:30Speaker 1: over the company. And a lot of attorneys were pointing
- 29:32Speaker 1: to that case and saying that's an early indication that
- 29:36Speaker 1: courts may be more sympathetic to those arguments. And you know,
- 29:39Speaker 1: in that case, there was a worker who's feared going
- 29:41Speaker 1: back into the office because it would she'd be vulnerable
- 29:45Speaker 1: to the virus and courts. You know, a court I
- 29:49Speaker 1: thought that was a reasonable request and she clearly proved
- 29:52Speaker 1: that she could work from home for a year was
- 29:54Speaker 1: something that was cited. That case did settle, so we
- 29:56Speaker 1: didn't see it moving, you know, all the way through
- 30:00Speaker 1: the process. But um, but yeah, it should be a
- 30:04Speaker 1: really interesting shift right now. Tell me about Conrad Reynoldson.
- 30:09Speaker 1: It's he's got an interesting case. Yeah. So Conrad Um
- 30:15Speaker 1: is a disabilities rights attorney in Seattle and he um
- 30:24Speaker 1: he is someone who has a disability and a mobility disability.
- 30:30Speaker 1: And he actually said he really likes going into the
- 30:33Speaker 1: office and he's really looking forward to the return um.
- 30:37Speaker 1: And he said his staff wants to return Um. He
- 30:41Speaker 1: currently can't for his health because he needs the US
- 30:44Speaker 1: to reach a higher level of immunity according to his doctors,
- 30:47Speaker 1: and he's currently allowing his staff to have the option.
- 30:50Speaker 1: But he made a really interesting point. He said, you know,
- 30:53Speaker 1: he was able to do a full argument before a
- 30:57Speaker 1: federal appeals court um during the pandemic, and that I'm
- 31:00Speaker 1: previously possible. And he said that right now, is the
- 31:04Speaker 1: courts all shut off and refused to go remote, he
- 31:07Speaker 1: wouldn't be able to really argue anymore. And she said,
- 31:12Speaker 1: but that's clearly clearly the argument against being remote and
- 31:17Speaker 1: being flexible in that way or being undermined. And he
- 31:19Speaker 1: was kind of interesting because he was a person who said,
- 31:21Speaker 1: I totally get it, I want to be in an office,
- 31:23Speaker 1: but he's not the right time. UM. So I think
- 31:27Speaker 1: I think he did have a really interesting point. And UM,
- 31:32Speaker 1: it'll be interesting to see if how how things change
- 31:35Speaker 1: moving forward. In the April hearing of the e o
- 31:39Speaker 1: C on COVID discrimination issues, did anything come out at
- 31:43Speaker 1: that hearing? That's that was you know important. At the
- 31:47Speaker 1: April hearing, there were stakeholders, there were attorneys and experts, um,
- 31:54Speaker 1: kind of talking about this clash that we're talking about
- 31:56Speaker 1: right now, and UM, they definitely did focus a lot
- 32:00Speaker 1: of the themes that we've been talking about today about
- 32:03Speaker 1: the disabilities and the A d A and the legal
- 32:05Speaker 1: cases that would come up moving forward, and what the
- 32:09Speaker 1: pandemic would mean for the future of these civil rights
- 32:12Speaker 1: UM cases and courts. UM. You know, we I there
- 32:16Speaker 1: was an attorney who talked about what we were talking
- 32:19Speaker 1: about about how sixty percent of the cases that he
- 32:21Speaker 1: has coming in from the last year related to the pandemic,
- 32:24Speaker 1: or about an employer rejecting telework accommodation. I think a
- 32:28Speaker 1: lot of the attorneys on both sides were we're saying
- 32:34Speaker 1: that there's kind of an inflection point right now for
- 32:36Speaker 1: employers making these decisions, but what they're going to do
- 32:39Speaker 1: for a return to office keeping all of the the
- 32:42Speaker 1: civil rights issues in their minds moving forward? And UM,
- 32:47Speaker 1: the e e O C S. You know, guidance has
- 32:50Speaker 1: been slowly kind of evolving as the pandemic UM has
- 32:54Speaker 1: has gone forward, and UM they've acknowledged that UM this
- 32:59Speaker 1: time could serve as a trial period UM to show
- 33:03Speaker 1: whether or not an employee the disability could perform all
- 33:06Speaker 1: their essential functions while working remotely. UM, and employers should
- 33:10Speaker 1: consider all new requests in light of disinformation. So it's,
- 33:14Speaker 1: you know, it's somewhat vague what they're what they're recommending,
- 33:17Speaker 1: and their guidance is only guidance, But a lot of
- 33:20Speaker 1: employment attorneys pay really close attention to how the e
- 33:23Speaker 1: O s UM advises on these issues. So UM, some
- 33:28Speaker 1: of them even asked for clearer guidance and more definitive
- 33:34Speaker 1: UM point of view. But UM, we'll see, you know,
- 33:38Speaker 1: the EOC is also the one who can bring lawsuits,
- 33:41Speaker 1: so I think that's one reason they pay attention to them.
- 33:43Speaker 1: But guidance is just guidance um from from that agency.
- 33:47Speaker 1: Thanks Sarah. That's Aaron mulvany of Bloomberg Law and that's
- 33:51Speaker 1: it for the Bloomberg Law Show today. Remember you can
- 33:54Speaker 1: always at the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 33:57Speaker 1: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and www
- 34:01Speaker 1: dot Bloomberg dot com slash podcast Slash Law. I'm June Grasso.
- 34:05Speaker 1: Thanks so much for listening, and please tune into The
- 34:08Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten pm Eastern right
- 34:11Speaker 1: here on Bloomberg Radio.