Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Industry Is Shrinking
Transcript
- Lucas: So you work in an industry that's shrinking — retail banking, say, or regional newspapers, or brick and mortar retail — and you actually want a raise. Not a cost of living adjustment, a real raise. Is that even realistic? Luna: I think a lot of people hear 'industry is shrinking' and assume the answer is no. But I know a branch manager at a regional bank who got a 7 percent raise last year, even though her bank had cut 20 percent of staff in her region. Lucas: That's exactly the kind of case I want to dig into. Because the conventional wisdom says: when there are fewer jobs, you have less leverage. But that's only true if you treat leverage as something the market gives you, rather than something you construct. Luna: Right. So how did she construct it? Lucas: She didn't lead with 'I deserve this because I've been here five years' or 'inflation is up.' She led with a number: the revenue her branch generated year-over-year, and specifically the portion of it that came from a new small-business lending initiative she designed. Luna: So she tied her raise to a concrete financial outcome she owned. That makes sense — it's harder to say no to someone who's pointing at actual dollars. Lucas: Exactly. And she also framed herself as a cost-saver. The bank had closed three branches in the region, and she absorbed two of those customer bases without adding headcount. So she basically argued: 'I'm doing the work of what used to be 1.5 managers, and I'm doing it for less than 1.5 salaries.' Luna: That's smart. She's not asking for a reward — she's asking to be paid closer to her actual value. Which is a totally different conversation. Lucas: And it's the conversation that works in a shrinking market. Because when the business is contracting, management is hyper-focused on two things: protecting revenue and cutting costs. If you can show how your raise actually supports both, you've got a real argument. Luna: Let's talk about what doesn't work. I think a lot of people lead with 'I need a raise because everything is more expensive.' Lucas: That's the weakest argument in any environment, but especially in a shrinking one. Inflation affects everyone — including your employer, whose costs are also going up. Saying 'I need more money because my rent went up' is a personal problem, not a business case. Luna: It also signals that you're thinking about yourself, not about the company's situation. And in a shrinking industry, the company is already anxious. They want to hear that you understand their constraints. Lucas: Exactly. So the framing should be: 'I know the industry is under pressure. Here's how I'm helping us navigate that pressure. And here's why paying me more is actually in the company's interest.' Luna: What about the threat of leaving? I know in a strong job market, people often say 'I have another offer' to get a raise. But in a shrinking industry, there may not be other offers. Lucas: That's the trap. If you bluff and they call it, you're stuck. And even if you're not bluffing, the alternative might be a lateral move to a similar company that's also shrinking. So the threat loses its power. Better to build a case that doesn't rely on an ultimatum. Luna: So what's the actual script? If someone's listening right now and they're in a shrinking industry, what should they say in their next one-on-one? Lucas: I'd start with something like: 'I've been looking at our numbers and I see that we're managing to hold revenue steady despite the market contraction. I want to make sure I'm compensated in a way that reflects my contribution to that resilience. Specifically, I've identified X, Y, and Z that I've done — and I'd like to discuss adjusting my base salary by X percent.' Luna: Notice what's missing: no apology, no 'I know times are tough.' Just a direct link between performance and pay. Lucas: And you need to have your numbers ready. Don't go in with vague statements. Have the revenue figure, the cost savings, the efficiency metric. If you can't quantify your impact, you're just asking for a favor. Luna: What about timing? Is there a best moment to ask when the industry is shrinking? Lucas: Right after you've delivered a visible win. Maybe you just finished a project that saved the company money, or you landed a client that others thought was lost. That's when your leverage is highest. Don't wait for the annual review cycle — the company might not have a budget then, but they might find money for someone who just proved their value. Luna: You know, this kind of advice is exactly why we do this show. We don't have ads, we don't have sponsors, and we keep it focused on practical, real-world help. If you find that useful, and you want to support the show staying ad-free, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep this going. Lucas: Yeah, we really believe in that model. Okay, back to the raise conversation. One more thing I want to flag: don't compare yourself to people who were laid off. I've heard people say 'I'm still here, so I deserve a raise.' That's a terrible argument — it sounds like you're glad others lost their jobs. Luna: Yeah, that's tone-deaf. And it also doesn't work because the company might think 'well, we kept you, isn't that enough?' Lucas: Exactly. The keep your job is the raise argument. You have to preempt that. Acknowledge the layoffs briefly — 'I understand the company had to make tough decisions' — and then pivot to your value. Luna: What about asking for a promotion instead of a raise? In a shrinking industry, titles might be frozen. Lucas: Titles are cheap. If the company can't do a promotion, they might still do a salary adjustment. And sometimes a title change without a raise is actually a bad deal — it locks you into more responsibility without compensation. I'd rather have the money. Luna: So focus on base salary. And if they say no? Lucas: Then ask what it would take. 'What metrics or milestones would make a raise possible in the next six months?' Get them to commit to specific criteria. That gives you a roadmap. And if they won't commit to anything, that's useful information — it tells you this company may never pay you what you're worth. Luna: And that might be a signal to start looking at adjacent industries, even if your current industry is shrinking. Skills transfer. Lucas: Right. But that's a different episode. For today, the takeaway is: you can get a raise in a shrinking industry, but you have to build the case from the company's perspective — revenue, cost savings, efficiency. No inflation whining, no ultimatums, no survivor's guilt. Just cold, hard numbers. Luna: And a little bit of strategic timing. Great advice, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. That's all for this edition of Office Hours with Fexingo. If you've got a career question you want us to tackle, email us at the show. We'll see you next time.