Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CAMELS Treading Water: What the Insurance Fund Numbers Reveal
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another
- 0:04episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:06Last Thursday, the NCA Board, also known as Kyle Halman Chairman, held
- 0:12a board meeting and they talked about a few different topics and
- 0:16they had one item on the agenda.
- 0:18The item on the agenda was a briefing of the on the insurance fund, and
- 0:25I'll talk a little bit about that because if you've listened for a while.
- 0:29You realize that the insurance fund briefing is the only time
- 0:33NCA gives any type of snapshot on camel codes and or camel's codes.
- 0:39I call 'em camel 'cause that's what they were when they first instituted it.
- 0:43Of course, they added the s for sensitivity, but the camel codes, and
- 0:47I'll jump to that right now because there wasn't a whole lot of information.
- 0:51Essentially code fours and code fives as a percentage of insured
- 0:54shares went down slightly.
- 0:56And there was a corresponding increase in code threes.
- 1:00The percentage of insured shares that are in code threes, fours, and fives
- 1:05is just under 10%, which they took as a show that the insurance fund was strong
- 1:10and healthy, which makes sense, but a slight improvement in fives and fours.
- 1:16A slight worsening in threes, but that's because the fours and
- 1:19fives moved into the three basket.
- 1:22So really a little bit of treading water.
- 1:24I think what we're going to see moving forward is Camel Codes will get better.
- 1:27One of the reasons Camel Codes will be getting better is that Kyle Halman
- 1:31in passing made reference to the fact that 27% of NCOA staff two seven took
- 1:38the buyout and that those people are not being a able to be re replaced.
- 1:42They made a plea if you will, to the Trump administration that whenever the.
- 1:48Hiring is turned back on, that they be notified th 90 days ahead of time, which
- 1:54I would be shocked if that happened.
- 1:56But the reason he wanted had a public request relative to that was that
- 2:01you can't just turn the spigot on and that NCUA and other agencies,
- 2:05once they hear that the hiring freeze is off, they're going to have to.
- 2:10Get the announcements out, go out and say which jobs do we need to fill?
- 2:13Et cetera, et cetera.
- 2:14And then go to usa jobs.gov,
- 2:16which will be overwhelmed all at one time with all the agencies coming to them.
- 2:20It would be great if they had a little lead time relative to that.
- 2:23He did point out that in the first Trump administration, if the timeline
- 2:27for the freeze remains the same.
- 2:30That, that would be June of next year that they might be able to start
- 2:33hiring again, which was interesting.
- 2:36My guess is that they'll keep the freeze in longer.
- 2:38They talked, he talked a little bit or alluded to the fact
- 2:41that NCOA cannot make final.
- 2:44Promotions, they can put people in acting roles.
- 2:47And I'm seeing that in my conversations with credit unions,
- 2:50that is creating some chaos because there's a lot of moving pieces.
- 2:53And when there are moving pieces at NCUA, you get people unwilling or unable to make
- 2:58big decisions, which can complicate exams.
- 3:01Now, I've said here previously, and this is me going on a ramble on the
- 3:05impact of the chaos of this 27% NCUA is.
- 3:10I, and I believe we'll be being a little bit more friendly on the Camel codes
- 3:14because they just don't have the staff to do the Code Threes and the Code Fours.
- 3:17They've changed their policies on Code Fours and code threes on when
- 3:20they need to go in, and they're going to, be, I think, a little bit more
- 3:24reasonable in many instances on Camel Codes just because they can't do what.
- 3:29What NCUA off the books calls a wake up call code three or code
- 3:33four to get somebody's attention.
- 3:34They'll still do some of those, but they'll be more inclined to upgrade
- 3:38quicker and downgrade less quickly just 'cause they just don't have the resources.
- 3:44To do all that comp those contacts yeah, that code three would require
- 3:48or they'll code you a three and then they just won't show up because for
- 3:51the follow up exam, because they've changed their policies, which all in
- 3:55all is a net win for credit unions in the short term and in the long term.
- 4:00Could cause some impact to the insurance fund.
- 4:03But time will tell as to how that all plays out.
- 4:06I'm sure there were things NCOA could cut, and I'm sure this is a well received
- 4:11reprieve in the credit union industry to have less examiners show up less
- 4:15frequently, because then you can go about the business of serving your members.
- 4:21Other things that were talked about was that there will be no NCA board meeting
- 4:24in October because they will be inward focused, was the words that were used.
- 4:29They will be inward focused.
- 4:31I think that's because they're putting their budget together.
- 4:33I think that's because they're deciding what they're gonna put
- 4:36in their five year strategic plan, which they made reference to.
- 4:39He also made reference to the last NCA board meeting to have an action.
- 4:44By one board member was 2005 and Joanne Johnson, and that a final
- 4:48rule on Fidelity bond is, was put in place by Chairman Joanne Johnson,
- 4:53and that rule is still on the books.
- 4:55He didn't say, I'm here and I can act, but he implied in my opinion, saying, Hey.
- 5:01The last time there was one board member, there was a regulation, the
- 5:04regulation was a final approval by Joanne Johnson and I think implying
- 5:08that he has the ability to act going forward, he did say their budget will be
- 5:13coming out soon, as soon as this week.
- 5:16When that comes out, I'll do a podcast on it, most likely.
- 5:19I'm curious about this one, just because when you reduce the budget, 27%.
- 5:24That creates some opportunities to reposition reduce expenses.
- 5:29He did say that last year there was a slight increase in the operating fee,
- 5:33not one that anyone would even notice.
- 5:35But that this year, if you took the average that you could potentially
- 5:40see about a $9,000 reduction in the average cost of the average exam.
- 5:45And of course, nobody is exactly average, but it's more material.
- 5:48And that's because 27% of their staff took the buyouts, the 27% that could take the
- 5:55buyouts were the people who'd been on.
- 5:5730, 35 years at least 25 to take the buyout for, I believe it's 25 unless
- 6:03they did some special program to take the buyout for early retirement.
- 6:06So those are the higher paid people that have been there for
- 6:09a long time because salaries are like a snowball going downhill.
- 6:12The longer you've been there, the, if you're at one grade, your pay
- 6:14is gonna be higher, so there's a substantial saving there.
- 6:18But he also talked about the fact that they haven't reaped those
- 6:21benefits yet because that'll be 2026 budget that will play out.
- 6:25They seemed seemed a little focused on how that's gonna all play out.
- 6:29The staff budget will be coming out and as soon as this week when that
- 6:33comes out, I'll take a look at it.
- 6:35They talked, they used to do two slides on camel codes, and I would get on LinkedIn
- 6:40and circle some numbers and point out, what the changes were relative to them.
- 6:45They've changed from a PowerPoint to a, an.
- 6:48Interactive tool that they indicate has more information on it, on its face
- 6:54without going on and clicking on it.
- 6:55I will take them at their word that there's more information there,
- 6:58but what they present is less.
- 7:00So the public presentation about what they say about the camel codes is less,
- 7:04not materially, but it is less because.
- 7:07There used to be the two slides that showed number, and then there
- 7:10was a slide that showed shares and it broken into certain buckets.
- 7:13Now maybe that's all there, maybe it's even more granular now.
- 7:16I haven't had the time to go out and play with their tool a little bit.
- 7:19I will do that and I'll likely record a podcast while I'm doing it to show
- 7:23my take on whether or not there's better or worse information there.
- 7:27They did ask the acting CFO CFO Melissa.
- 7:31What was triggering the losses in credit unions?
- 7:34There were four credit unions that had failed at a cost of $17 million
- 7:39to the insurance fund, which is not that material in light of things.
- 7:42They are an insurance company.
- 7:43Remember, there will be losses on occasion.
- 7:46She talked about risk management high operating expenses.
- 7:50Corporate governments and operating losses that were contributing to the losses that
- 7:55were happening to the insurance fund.
- 7:58The percentage of assets that had been lost relative to those four was
- 8:03consistent with what the norm is.
- 8:04So there was nothing really out of character there.
- 8:08But the fact that this budget is gonna be coming out it might reveal a
- 8:13little bit about what they're doing.
- 8:14Are they going to do less fair lending exams?
- 8:16Probably which positions will they be filling in an acting role,
- 8:21which divisions will get smaller.
- 8:24I've talked here about how they.
- 8:26They may wanna do some reorganizations, collapse some offices into other groups.
- 8:31Like the ethics office was rolled out of General Counsel, like The
- 8:34Economist was rolled out of ENI.
- 8:36There's a previous full podcast on that.
- 8:39And at this juncture, I'm not gonna get into the what ifs.
- 8:41We'll just see what staff proposes.
- 8:43And by, by the way, staff proposal is a bit of a wink
- 8:47and a quotation mark the board.
- 8:50Historically has been quite involved in that budget and it just becomes
- 8:54a little bit of gamesmanship.
- 8:56Recently they've made some changes more changes and in my opinion, it's
- 9:00likely we'll put this in and we know we'll knock it out later and that'll
- 9:03show that we're listening now.
- 9:04That's just my take.
- 9:05I believe there's a little bit of that goes on.
- 9:08Now, ultimately does one board member have the ability to vote?
- 9:12You can argue that he does, you can argue that he doesn't Todd
- 9:15Harper and Tanya Osco would say they don't have the ability to act.
- 9:19There's a delegation that says they can act on essential items.
- 9:22Would a budget be essential?
- 9:24It probably would be in general, right?
- 9:26How could it not be?
- 9:27But they have a two year budget, they could rely on their other budget and
- 9:30then just control the cur, control the purse strings relative to it.
- 9:34So I'm mostly curious about what actions might be taken at the.
- 9:39Meetings coming forward, assuming or presuming that there's no board member
- 9:44added, either the other ones come back on or someone replaces those who are
- 9:48taken off it'll be very interesting to see what they determine to be essential,
- 9:52what they decide they can act on.
- 9:54And again, if nobody challenges it, it doesn't matter because if no one
- 9:57challenges it and they take the action, then the action is the action, right?
- 10:00It would take an action challenged by somebody.
- 10:04That you didn't have the authority to do this 'cause you didn't have a quorum
- 10:07and you were only one board member.
- 10:08And I just don't I don't see that playing out.
- 10:10'cause in the grand scheme of thing, who's gonna, who's gonna contest a lower budget?
- 10:15Who's gonna contest regulations possibly going away because that's
- 10:19more likely under a Republican LED board that regulations will go away.
- 10:24In particular since.
- 10:26Donald Trump administration wants regulations to go away.
- 10:29They've put clamps on the independent agency saying, you
- 10:31can't do this without contacting us.
- 10:33There shouldn't be a lot coming forward in that regard.
- 10:37There was also a message pivoting.
- 10:39There was a message that went out to CEOs that saying that
- 10:43the NCA exams will not have.
- 10:46The risk ratings that go along with them.
- 10:48And if you're a CEO, you saw that, I'll probably do a separate podcast on that.
- 10:52I've talked about doing that with Todd Miller and my team.
- 10:55We just have had so many other calls and things going on that I haven't
- 10:59sat down and walked through that, but they've stopped doing that risk rating,
- 11:03which will make the report shorter.
- 11:05It frees up some time for the examiners.
- 11:07Again, going back to the fact that they reduced staff by 27%.
- 11:12So that was pretty much it.
- 11:14They.
- 11:16Staff is down, that's gonna create some challenges for 'em.
- 11:18It's gonna create some opportunities that you're not gonna be bothered
- 11:21quite as much by the exam process.
- 11:23Of course, if there's something real prominent that in your
- 11:28exam that comes up they're still gonna probably dealing with it.
- 11:30You'll still be seeing doors examiner findings and camel downgrades.
- 11:33They'll just be a little bit more judicious about
- 11:36throwing that weight around.
- 11:38All right I've got some other exciting podcasts coming up.
- 11:41I wanted to give you a quick update on what I.
- 11:44What I heard in listening to the board meeting and when the budget comes out
- 11:49here shortly, I'll do a deep dive on that and do a podcast on what it might
- 11:53mean for credit unions based on what they say in the staff proposed budget.
- 12:00As always, I wanna thank you for listening.
- 12:01We've got some exciting e episodes and guests coming up soon that
- 12:05typically will drop every Tuesday.
- 12:07Not so much over the summer, but I'm back on my Tuesday drop of a podcast rhythm
- 12:11here, and I appreciate you listening.
- 12:13As always, I hope you will listen again soon.
- 12:16This is Mark TriCal signing off with flying colors.