Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Advanced Trial Tactics: How Do You Get Those Punitives: Learn From The Pros with Paul Kiesel & Melanie Palmer
Transcript
- 0:06I'm Lori Krip -Martin, the vice chair of the
- 0:08Beverly Hills Bar Association litigation section.
- 0:12I'm delighted to introduce you to today's speakers,
- 0:15Paul Kiesel and Melanie Palmer. Paul Kiesel is
- 0:18a managing partner of Kiesel Law. His practice
- 0:22is devoted to representing consumers in personal
- 0:24injury, class action, environmental, and toxic
- 0:27tort litigation. Mr. Kiesel has repeatedly been
- 0:31selected as one of the top plaintiff's attorneys
- 0:33in the state of California and the country. The
- 0:36Los Angeles Business Journal recognized Mr. Kiesel
- 0:39as one of the top 50 lawyers. The Daily Journal
- 0:42named Mr. Kiesel as one of 100 most influential
- 0:47attorneys in the state of California. He has
- 0:50also been selected as one of the top 500 attorneys
- 0:53in the United States by law drag. Melanie Palmer
- 0:57joined diesel law LLP in 2014. Her practice focuses
- 1:03on mass tort litigation, pharmaceutical medical
- 1:06device liability, consumer class action, and
- 1:10catastrophic personal injury. Ms. Palmer was
- 1:13recognized as a Southern California rising star
- 1:16from 2019 through 2022 and a super lawyer in
- 1:202023. She has tried eight jury trials to verdict,
- 1:25including a four -week product liability trial.
- 1:28in which the jury awarded her client $6 .18 million,
- 1:35and his client was a single plaintiff for the
- 1:38life -altering injuries that he sustained. And
- 1:43now let's get started with today's lunchtime
- 1:45program. Take it away. Perfect. Well, and I almost
- 1:50shut you down because it went like two seconds
- 1:52too long, but you ended before I got to do that.
- 1:55So thank you for the introduction. Happy to join
- 1:57the Beverly Hills Bar Association for today's
- 2:00program. And Melanie, why don't we start a second
- 2:04by identifying what's the name of the program?
- 2:06Melanie, why don't you pull up your slides? You
- 2:08can look at the name of today's program. Pulling
- 2:10up now. Do we see them here? Okay, so it says,
- 2:15how do you get those punitive damages? How do
- 2:18you get those punitive damages? The truth is
- 2:20what it really should say and what our panel
- 2:22today is about is how do you keep those punitive
- 2:26damages? Because sometimes you get them and you
- 2:28have a hard time keeping them. So a lot of what
- 2:30we're going to talk about today is how do you
- 2:32keep those damages if you're fortunate enough
- 2:36to get them. Sorry, back to you, Mel. You're
- 2:38going to run the ship today. Yeah. OK, so first
- 2:41we'll start by talking about the legal standards
- 2:43and definitions. And some of this is, I'm sure
- 2:47everyone knows, but let's do a little refresher,
- 2:49OK? So the jury may award punitive damages where
- 2:53it's proven by clear and convincing evidence
- 2:55that the defendant has been guilty of malice,
- 2:59oppression, or fraud. And malice is despicable
- 3:02conduct with willful and conscious disregard
- 3:05for the rights and safeties of others. Oppression
- 3:10is similar conduct causing cruel and unjust hardship
- 3:15in conscious disregard for the plaintiff's rights.
- 3:19And then fraud, of course, is the intentional
- 3:21misrepresentation, deceit or concealment of a
- 3:25material fact known to the defendant. And just
- 3:29as a reminder, when you have a corporate defendant,
- 3:31you really need to keep in mind that you have
- 3:34to prove a managing agent or director knew or
- 3:38ratified the conduct. So we'll talk about this
- 3:41a little bit more specifically as the presentation
- 3:44goes on. So before we jump in to our tips and
- 3:49recommendations for working up your case, not
- 3:52only through discovery but trial presentation,
- 3:56we need to discuss, as Paul said, how do we keep
- 4:02punitive damages, right? And so part of our discussion,
- 4:06a significant portion of our discussion has to
- 4:08do with constitutional considerations that the
- 4:11courts will analyze when determining whether
- 4:14a punitive damage award is excessive. So said
- 4:18another way, we're really starting our analysis
- 4:21at the ending, our ideal ending of upholding
- 4:25a punitive damage award. So we're going to work
- 4:28backwards to make sure you end up where you want
- 4:31it to be, where you want to be. Okay. To step
- 4:34back even further, right, today's presentation
- 4:37is going to talk about number one, when you're
- 4:40going through jury selection, when you're looking
- 4:44to pick your jury, what are you looking at with
- 4:47regard to a punitive damage award downstream?
- 4:52And then if you achieve that punitive damages
- 4:55award, what are your limitations that you must
- 5:01comply with in order to prevent losing those
- 5:04awarded damages or keeping them? Go. Right. So
- 5:09on that point, to keeping our punitive damages,
- 5:12right? So to securely... or to truly secure a
- 5:15punitive damage award, one that would survive
- 5:18appeal, we need to understand these constitutional
- 5:21factors and be guided by them during our pre
- 5:25-trial workup and our trial presentation. So
- 5:29the California Supreme Court and the US Supreme
- 5:31Court have been very clear. A punitive award
- 5:34is arbitrary. and violates due process where
- 5:38it is grossly excessive in relation to the state's
- 5:43legitimate interest in punishment and deterrence.
- 5:47So if you want punitives, you need to stack your
- 5:50evidentiary record to these key factors. And
- 5:53these factors are what's going to drive our presentation
- 5:56today. So the first factor, I have them all lay
- 5:59out here, and I'll just briefly touch on them.
- 6:01The first factor, and this is the most important
- 6:03factor that the courts weigh, is the reprehensibility
- 6:06of the defendant's actions. The more reprehensible
- 6:10the act, the greater the appropriate punishment,
- 6:14assuming all other facts are equal. So maybe
- 6:18a good way to describe that would be to look
- 6:21at the OJ Simpson. example of the egregiousness
- 6:25that the jury found, that civil jury, and awarding
- 6:29punitive damages, perhaps murder is the most
- 6:32reprehensible of actions a defendant can engage
- 6:36in, and therefore the prison, the jurors, and
- 6:40the court are going to look at is, if it's murder,
- 6:42and you found it's murder, and you're going to
- 6:45award punitive damages, that is perhaps the worst
- 6:49type of conduct that would allow an award of
- 6:52punitive damages that would not be, open quote,
- 6:55grossly excessive, but we'll talk about that
- 6:57in just a second. Right. So, well, like going
- 7:02to Paul's example of murder, clearly reprehensible,
- 7:05right? The most heinous of crimes. Sometimes
- 7:08we're not dealing with defendant's conduct that's
- 7:11not so obvious. So it's important that your case
- 7:15workup establishes the evidentiary record you
- 7:18need to later justify a substantial award. So
- 7:22we'll go into discovery more specifically about
- 7:25that, but reprehensibility. The second factor
- 7:29is the relationship between the amount of compensatory
- 7:33damages versus punitive damages. This is where
- 7:36you'll work up an understanding of the plaintiff's
- 7:39damages really come in. And the court The U .S.
- 7:43Supreme Court has rejected the imposition of
- 7:46any rigid benchmark or any set mathematical formula
- 7:49for actually establishing an approved ratio between
- 7:53actual and punitive damages. But the court. They
- 7:57say yes or no. gotten away from a, this is not
- 8:02an unlimited field that we're playing in. And
- 8:06we'll talk about that today, but there are limits
- 8:08in terms of the ratio of compensatory versus
- 8:11punitive damages. And what are compensatory damages?
- 8:17How do you evaluate compensatory damages? Well,
- 8:20just like in a personal injury case, it would
- 8:22be general damages versus special damages. Special
- 8:26damages are going to be medical expenses, lost
- 8:30profits, loss of income. That's going to be your
- 8:33special damages. And compensatory would be your
- 8:36general damages in terms of your pain and suffering,
- 8:39the loss of love and companionship if it's a
- 8:42wrongful death case. And that's the damages side
- 8:46or special and general damages on the compensatory
- 8:51side versus the punitive damages on the other
- 8:53side. Right. So Paul's perfectly right on that.
- 8:58So the courts have not set a bright line rule
- 9:00of what ratio is appropriate, but they have been
- 9:03very clear that ratios significantly greater
- 9:06than nine to one are suspect and generally cannot
- 9:09survive appellate scrutiny without special justification.
- 9:14OK. So said another way, courts have regularly
- 9:16said few awards exceeding a single digit ratio
- 9:20will satisfy due process. In fact, many courts
- 9:24have said a one -to -one ratio is appropriate
- 9:27in cases where it's low reprehensibility conduct
- 9:30and substantial compensatory damage awards. So
- 9:34can you give us an example, Melanie, what that
- 9:36would look like? What does that mean? Yeah, so
- 9:39sure. And this goes back to what Paul was talking
- 9:43about, about compensatory damages. Compensatory
- 9:46damages are not treated equal when the court
- 9:49is considering this ratio. For instance, courts
- 9:53have upheld higher ratios when they're egregious
- 9:58acts with small economic damages. And in a case
- 10:03called Nickerson v. Stonebridge, the courts upheld
- 10:07a 10 to 1 ratio, which is significantly high.
- 10:12It's on the upper, upper, upper scale of what
- 10:15would be reasonable under the due process clause.
- 10:19Do you know what the compensatory damages were
- 10:22that were awarded in that case? Yeah, it was
- 10:24$35 ,000 were the compensatory damages. So the
- 10:29punitive damages ended up being $350 ,000. $350
- 10:33,000, right. So it's $35 ,000 versus $350 ,000,
- 10:36but it's low compensatory, but a substantial,
- 10:39arguably, punitive award. Right, and then on
- 10:43the flip side, the courts have given lower ratios
- 10:47when non -economic damages are substantial. So
- 10:50for instance, in the Roundup litigation where
- 10:54the jury is awarded millions of dollars in compensatory
- 10:59damages, the higher courts upheld much lower
- 11:03ratios. So in California, there have been four,
- 11:07cases that went to verdict successfully for plaintiffs.
- 11:11And the first one, the Johnson case, the higher
- 11:14courts upheld the one -to -one ratio. And in
- 11:18the Hardiman -Montanto trial, 3 .8 to one ratio
- 11:23was upheld. In Pileod, there was a four -to -one
- 11:27ratio upheld. And that's because we're talking
- 11:29about significant non -economic awards. And then
- 11:34the courts than used a lower ratio. The notion
- 11:38that higher non -economic damages warrant a lower
- 11:41ratio, and I was really interested by this, so
- 11:43I researched it further and tried to understand
- 11:45why the court will give a lower ratio when non
- 11:49-economic damages are involved. And generally,
- 11:54in regards to this issue, the courts have explained
- 11:56that substantial awards for pain and suffering
- 11:59may innately contain a punitive element. based
- 12:03in part on indignation at the defendant's conduct.
- 12:07So according to the courts, they say that these
- 12:11higher substantial pain and suffering awards
- 12:16therefore serve as a deterrent in and itself
- 12:20and then justify these lower ratios. So in another
- 12:24way, when I've tried cases where punitive conduct
- 12:28has been at issue, I have found that the jury
- 12:33awards sometimes significantly more general damages
- 12:40to the plaintiff or their family than might otherwise
- 12:45have existed had there not been. punitive conduct
- 12:49that's occurred. So the punitive conduct, even
- 12:52where there's been a bifurcation, we'll talk
- 12:54about that in just a minute, but even where there's
- 12:56been a bifurcation of general damages versus
- 12:59punitive damages, there are still issues that
- 13:02will inflame the jurors, but they're still not
- 13:06based upon passion, prejudice, or sympathy. They're
- 13:09still looking at the evidence, will tend to award
- 13:11a higher amount of general damages where punitive
- 13:15conduct is alleged than even before you get to
- 13:20the punitive phase of the trial. And I think
- 13:21that's what your research bore out, right, Mel?
- 13:23Great, exactly. OK, so let's go to the third
- 13:27factor, the difference between the punitive damages
- 13:30award and any civil criminal penalties authorized
- 13:34or comparable or comparable, depending how you
- 13:38say it, in comparable cases. So this factor is
- 13:45more relevant in labor law actions, business
- 13:48code violations, or maybe even in conduct involving
- 13:52physical acts of aggression where criminal penalties
- 13:54could be involved. But in the product liability
- 13:57space, this analysis is more focused on comparable
- 14:01claims and injuries with the same device. So
- 14:05pick your master art litigation where there had
- 14:07been trials where penal damage awards were rendered
- 14:11by juries. Subsequent trials will point to the
- 14:15other jury's findings and whether those findings
- 14:19were upheld by the higher courts. And the fourth
- 14:22factor that we're really going to focus on too
- 14:25is the wealth of the defendant. This is not a
- 14:28factor that was identified by the U .S. Supreme
- 14:30Court, but it's been one that is very much discussed
- 14:34in our California case law. So it's very important
- 14:37to keep in mind. An award of punitive damages
- 14:42cannot be sustained on appeal unless the trial
- 14:46record contains meaningful evidence of the defendant's
- 14:49financial condition. So it is the plaintiff's
- 14:53burden to introduce this evidence of the financial
- 14:55condition. And you have to keep in mind, the
- 14:57courts are really concerned about these runaway
- 15:01verdicts. And the mantra that they have for this
- 15:04is that the purpose of punitive damages is not
- 15:07served by financially destroying a defendant.
- 15:11The purpose is to deter, not to destroy. As you're
- 15:16talking Melanie, it reminds me, it just hit me.
- 15:19There was a great Jerry Spence trial that I read
- 15:22about in his book 30 plus years ago. It was where,
- 15:26I think the name was Karen Silkwood, who got
- 15:28radiation poisoning from Kermage. And he referred
- 15:32to radiation as the lion. So his theme was, if
- 15:36the lion gets away, Kermagee's got to pay. That
- 15:39was his theme. If the line gets away, Kermagee
- 15:42gets to pay. But he talked about a paper boy.
- 15:46And if the paper boy every morning hit you intentionally
- 15:49in the face with the paper every single day,
- 15:54but the paper boy got $10 a week, if you only
- 15:58took like a penny from the paper boy, it wouldn't
- 16:01deter him from hitting you in the face with the
- 16:03paper every single day. But I think he said like,
- 16:06but a nickel would or 25 cents would in comparison
- 16:09to what his income was to justify making an award
- 16:12of damages. This was before the Supreme Court
- 16:15set standards on what excessive, grossly excessive
- 16:19numbers were. He was trying to take the wealth
- 16:22of the defendant. in this case, it was a paperboy,
- 16:26how much he was earning each week versus how
- 16:28much money he should pay out of his own pocket
- 16:31to deter him from engaging in that conduct. And
- 16:33so the wealth of the defendant does play a role
- 16:36in having an award of damages that's high enough
- 16:39that the defendant's gonna feel the pain of the
- 16:43punitive award, right? Yeah, exactly. I mean,
- 16:46that's exactly a great segue because... a punishment
- 16:50is ineffective if it is not felt, right? So whether
- 16:53the message intended by punitive damage award
- 16:56is felt hinges on this particular defendant's
- 17:00financial condition. And I will say based on
- 17:04my review of the case law, this is an aspect
- 17:07that I think can be developed more when the cases
- 17:10are right. So. even in the Monsanto situation,
- 17:14where the defendant is a multi -billion dollar
- 17:17corporation, it needs to always be emphasized
- 17:19that if you reduce to certain lower ratios, then
- 17:24how is that going to be felt? constitutional
- 17:31factors in mind. We're really going to focus
- 17:32on the first two and the fourth and how we need
- 17:36to keep those factors in mind as we not only
- 17:40go through discovery in a case, but also present
- 17:42evidence at trial. So a few nuts and bolts case
- 17:48evaluation. Early evaluation is critical because
- 17:52not every case qualifies for punitive damages.
- 17:56You know, first of all, keep in mind, if you're
- 17:59the primary source of recovery is insurance,
- 18:02insurance is not going to cover a punitive damage
- 18:04award. Why not? Why doesn't it? Why does insurance
- 18:06cover that? Question for me? Well, yes, that
- 18:11was true. I can't just see what's here. Yeah,
- 18:14well, because the insurance does not cover intentional
- 18:17willful misconduct. And that's exactly what punitive
- 18:20damages is. Got it. Thank you. Okay. See, Paul
- 18:24always has a Socratic method. I should always
- 18:27be pretty. Okay. So the common cases that we
- 18:31usually see punitive damages in involve obviously
- 18:35willful misconduct. So think assaults, batteries,
- 18:39DUI crashes, intentional infliction of emotional
- 18:42distress, wrongful termination, premises liability,
- 18:47product liability, and also insurance bad faith.
- 18:50So what you really need to do is look for patterns
- 18:52that suggest repeated and willful misconduct.
- 18:57So think repeated violations, ignored warnings,
- 19:00and reckless regard. And really, this goes to
- 19:03the ratio. You need to consider your plaintiff's
- 19:06damages. What are your plaintiff's damages? What
- 19:09are you going to prove? And how are those ratios
- 19:12going to play out? And periodically, throughout
- 19:15the case, obviously, you're not going to know
- 19:17much until you get through discovery. But as
- 19:20discovery unfolds, you need to weigh the evidentiary
- 19:24strength. Because later on, and Paul will talk
- 19:26about this, you don't want the jury to think
- 19:28you're overreaching. Because if you're overreaching
- 19:30for some things, it's going to suggest maybe
- 19:32that you're overreaching to the jury. It's going
- 19:34to suggest you're overreaching on other things.
- 19:36And you don't want to lose that credibility.
- 19:40So plead with specificity. Courts will always
- 19:43scrutinize vague or boiler point language. So
- 19:48amend early if you need to, if you don't have
- 19:51the facts just yet, and anticipate demurs and
- 19:54motions to strike. No insurance carrier is going
- 19:58to agree for leave to amend to add punitive damages.
- 20:01Take this opportunity as a way to educate the
- 20:05court on the importance and severity of your
- 20:07case. Let's do it another way. Sometimes you
- 20:11might not want to plead punitive damages at the
- 20:15outset because you want to develop an evidentiary
- 20:18record that supports an amendment to include
- 20:22a claim for punitive damages because the level
- 20:24of specificity you need to overcome a motion
- 20:29to strike or a demurrer is substantial. So to
- 20:35the extent you have enough facts to allege punitive
- 20:38damages, I'd say you do so because that'll give
- 20:41you even more opportunities during discovery
- 20:43to get additional information, but to the extent
- 20:46you don't have a clear enough record to initially
- 20:51plead. a claim for punitive damages. That will
- 20:54not prevent you, obviously, from filing an amended
- 20:57complaint to include punitive damages and allow
- 21:00you to get the discovery that you're going to
- 21:02need, either directly from the defendant or from
- 21:04other sources that you'll put together to amend
- 21:07to include a claim for punitive damages in the
- 21:10future. Right. So about that with strategic discovery,
- 21:15you need to use your discovery kind of Precisely.
- 21:19You're not just proving bad behavior. You're
- 21:21really proving the defendant's mindset here.
- 21:24So you need to establish that the defendant's
- 21:26mindset by building your evidentiary record.
- 21:28I mean, this really goes to factor one, the reprehensibility
- 21:32of the defendant's actions. It's not just the
- 21:34bad stuff that they did. It's about how they
- 21:37knew they were doing something wrong and chose
- 21:40to do it anyway, often for profits or whatever
- 21:44margins that they are trying to uphold. So in
- 21:47determining the reprehensibility of the defendant's
- 21:50conduct, the court will consider many factors,
- 21:53but more relevant to our discussion here, one
- 21:56is the defendant's indifference to or reckless
- 22:00regard of human or the health and safety of others.
- 22:07And second, if the conduct involved repeated
- 22:09actions or was just an isolated incident. And
- 22:13then third, whether the harm was the result of
- 22:16intentional malice, trickery, deceit versus an
- 22:19accident. So here in California, intentionally
- 22:23marketing a defective product knowing that it
- 22:27might cause injury or death is highly reprehensible.
- 22:32So repeated misconduct is also considered more
- 22:35reprehensible and evidence of great profit. also
- 22:40may be relevant to showing a greater degree of
- 22:43reprehensibility. So those are important things
- 22:45to keep in mind. You really want the inner workings
- 22:49of the corporation. So in terms of discovery,
- 22:52think of their internal emails, internal policies
- 22:55and procedures regarding testing, their internal
- 23:00reviews of testing reports. relevant scientific
- 23:04literature, the company's review of that literature
- 23:07and what was done in response to that literature,
- 23:10complaint history, prior similar incidents, and
- 23:14more importantly about the prior history and
- 23:16prior complaints, what was done after that? What
- 23:19corrective action reports were created and what
- 23:23actual actions were taken after these prior complaints?
- 23:27and how high up the corporate food chain to all
- 23:30this go. Because if it's all done at a low level,
- 23:34even if it's a record in the discovery, but it
- 23:37doesn't show it's risen to the point of being
- 23:39an officer or a director or someone who's got
- 23:41the ability to ratify the conduct, it may be
- 23:44punitive behavior, but it's not going to get
- 23:46the corporation on the hook for punitive damages.
- 23:49Right, exactly. Exactly what Paul just said.
- 23:52We need a managing agent who knew or ratified
- 23:55that conduct, right? So you need to find out
- 23:57who was in the room when decisions were made
- 24:00and depose those agents early. Again, this goes
- 24:03to the reprehensibility of the defendant's action.
- 24:07So a common issue that comes up in the case law
- 24:09is that the plaintiff simply refers to the corporate
- 24:12defendant as it or they, without specifically
- 24:17identifying or linking the conduct to a director
- 24:20or agent. So you don't want to fall into that
- 24:22trap. You need to use PMQ depositions effectively
- 24:26to establish what the company, through its agents,
- 24:30specific agents and directors, knew, did, and
- 24:34didn't do. So this really involves getting or
- 24:37identifying the right individuals early. So get
- 24:40an organizational chart. Find out who was in
- 24:43the room or who was responsible for making the
- 24:47ultimate decisions. So common PMQ topics here
- 24:51would be, again, safety and testing and training,
- 24:55prior complaints, employee personnel files, like
- 24:59who's responsible for maintaining that and who
- 25:01can talk about an employee's personnel file,
- 25:03because oftentimes, personnel files can establish
- 25:07prior knowledge of a particular employee's unfitness,
- 25:10for instance. And that's imparted to the corporation.
- 25:16And then a key too in a lot of our product liability
- 25:18cases are policies and procedures for evaluating
- 25:22and approving marketing claims. Okay. Great marketing
- 25:26claim. It's safe. Great for XY user. Well, was
- 25:31that run through legal? Was that run through
- 25:33research and development? How was marketing able
- 25:36to approve this claim? Is it backed by science?
- 25:41Is it backed by the law? Is it backed by any
- 25:43of the reasonable measures that we think a responsible
- 25:46corporate defendant would take when marketing
- 25:50a product? By way of example, we were COLEE Council
- 25:54on the Juul e -cigarette litigation. And when
- 25:57we get into the discovery of what they did to
- 26:00ensure the safety or efficacy of vaping e -cigarettes,
- 26:06it would not shock you that there was a lack
- 26:08of true protocols followed. to establish the
- 26:13safety for a product that they were selling as
- 26:16being a healthier alternative to combustible
- 26:19cigarettes, which is a broad statement because
- 26:21combustible cigarettes are like the most dangerous
- 26:23things you can have in the world. They're cancer
- 26:24-causing agents. But that's not to suggest that...
- 26:28inhaling liquid nicotine that's been superheated
- 26:32deep into your lungs is a safe behavior. And
- 26:35so when you get into what they actually did to
- 26:38determine the safety of that, you might find
- 26:41there was an absence of any true studies to determine
- 26:43the safety of that conduct. Didn't go to trial,
- 26:46but that would have been an important issue had
- 26:48it gone to trial with regard to what was done
- 26:51to determine the safety of electronic cigarettes.
- 26:55Right, and to Paul's point, I mean, when you
- 26:57really start peeling the onion on these issues,
- 26:59so for instance, in Jewel, depositions were had
- 27:02and we were starting to realize there really
- 27:03wasn't a mechanism for safety and that... you
- 27:08will find too, if you start really peeling the
- 27:11onion on your defendant's corporate structure,
- 27:14how things are run, and maybe they have core
- 27:17values and mantras, but how are those upheld?
- 27:21When you start really questioning, then you'll
- 27:23find the fodder for a potential punitive damage
- 27:27claim if it's there. So just remember, your PMQ
- 27:31categories need to be very broad. and you can
- 27:34have lots of them. Remember, it doesn't have
- 27:35to be one person. You can have a person most
- 27:38qualified notice that has 25 different subject
- 27:42matters, and they may need to produce 25 different
- 27:45witnesses that address each of those different
- 27:47subject matters, but be as broad as you can in
- 27:50the PMQ notice to make sure you cover all the
- 27:53categories you need to establish your claim.
- 27:59Okay, so the next step in our analysis is really
- 28:03establishing defendants' net worth. So this is
- 28:06the fourth constitutional consideration that's
- 28:08really been highlighted in the California case
- 28:10law. So the California - Let me just start by
- 28:13identifying one particular problem is you can't
- 28:15really do net worth discovery during the underlying
- 28:19case that you're handling. Because until there's
- 28:20been an award of punitive damages, you can't
- 28:23find out how much someone, how much money they
- 28:25have, how much money they earn, how much money
- 28:26they've got. Unless they're a public corporation,
- 28:29you can't do that discovery traditionally until
- 28:32after you've gotten a punitive damages award
- 28:35to then find that information out. Sorry, Mel,
- 28:38I took the thunder from you. No, no, no problem.
- 28:40Actually, that's the next item. We can jump to
- 28:42that because that's a very good point. So we're
- 28:45looking at civil code 3295, right? That's a limit
- 28:50in protection concerning the discovery and admissibility
- 28:53of a defendant's financial condition. So that's
- 28:57a long way of saying a defendant's financial
- 28:59discovery of a defendant's financial condition
- 29:03is permitted only once the court finds a substantial
- 29:06probability of success. on the punitive damages
- 29:10claim. So the point here is you can make this
- 29:13motion early and uncover their punitive or I'm
- 29:18sorry, their financial condition, or you could
- 29:22also uncover public documents or stipulations
- 29:26from counsel. Ultimately, it is your burden.
- 29:29And so let me go back to the constitutional analysis
- 29:32here. But the California courts are really clear
- 29:38of that an award of punitive damages in California
- 29:41cannot be sustained on appeal unless the trial
- 29:44record maintains meaningful evidence of the defendant's
- 29:48financial condition. So in light of the fact
- 29:51that we're not allowed to do the discovery until
- 29:54we get a court ruling, what does that mean for
- 29:56us? It means we need to be proactive, right?
- 29:59And there are ways to get information regarding
- 30:05the defendant's financial condition outside of
- 30:08just discovery. For instance, we can retain experts
- 30:14right to do business evaluations of the corporate
- 30:19defendant. There are public filings. So the 10K
- 30:23filing for any publicly traded corporation plus
- 30:27secretary of state filings have been noted to
- 30:30establish whether a particular defendant owns
- 30:32certain assets. Commonly in our product liability
- 30:37cases, there are stipulations that will be entered
- 30:40into because when you're dealing with a large
- 30:42recognizable defendant, it's clear that there's
- 30:46substantial company with substantial means behind
- 30:49them. So stipulations are a little bit more easier
- 30:55to obtain from counsel. To be clear, it could
- 30:59be a situation where you go to trial, They bifurcated
- 31:05liability damages for punitives. And when you
- 31:09get the award, you actually need to take a recess
- 31:12from the trial, which I've done, to engage in
- 31:17the punitive damages discovery that you now are
- 31:20entitled to do. Because the jury finds punitive
- 31:22conduct. Once the jury's made a determination,
- 31:25you now have the opportunity, if they haven't
- 31:28stipulated to what they're... net worth is, and
- 31:31there's no independent information you have,
- 31:33you actually then have to do discovery to figure
- 31:36out what their net worth is. And you can actually
- 31:39have, engage in depositions post -initial phase
- 31:44of trial before you get to the punitive damages
- 31:46phase to acquire this information. Not desirable,
- 31:49but sometimes necessary. Right. And oftentimes,
- 31:52especially in the bifurcated scenario, the plaintiff's
- 31:57counsel will subpoena just using CCP 1987 to
- 32:01subpoena the production of financial records
- 32:04and witnesses at trial. So the CFOs or accountants
- 32:09of the corporate entity. So there are ways to
- 32:13ensure that you have the record you need. And
- 32:18now that you understand the limitations around
- 32:21actually getting discovery, let's talk about
- 32:23what discovery you need to get ultimately. Commonly,
- 32:32net worth is the most used measure for determining
- 32:36a defendant's financial condition, but it's not
- 32:39the only measure in determining whether punitive
- 32:42damages are excessive. Net worth typically works
- 32:45with most corporate defendants, but it can be
- 32:48adjusted to include depreciation, which represents
- 32:51a loss for accounting purposes, but doesn't impact
- 32:55the defendant's actual ability to pay. So going
- 32:58back to Paul's example about the OJ Simpson case
- 33:00and the civil case, the court of appeal actually
- 33:03upheld the punitive damage award of $25 million.
- 33:07even though it determined that Simpson's estimated
- 33:10net worth was $15 .4 million. So almost $10 million
- 33:14less. His net worth was $10 million less than
- 33:19the punitive damage award. But the evidence demonstrated
- 33:22that defendant was a wealthy man with prospects
- 33:26to gain more wealth in the future. So that damage
- 33:30award was upheld. And I think just to drive a
- 33:34finer point home, because when you hear someone's
- 33:36got a net worth of 15 million and gets a punitive
- 33:40award of $25 million, the first thing that you
- 33:43think of is, well, then you're bankrupt. And
- 33:46doesn't a bankruptcy filing then eliminate your
- 33:50claim to punitive damages? Mel, can I file bankruptcy
- 33:53if I get a $25 million punitive award against
- 33:55me? You can, but I believe that punitive damage
- 33:59award is not dischargeable in bankruptcy. Exactly.
- 34:02Thank you. Yeah, same with restitution orders.
- 34:05So when you do willful misconduct, then you cannot
- 34:08use the bankruptcy system to evade or avoid your
- 34:13responsibilities. Well, and look, restitution,
- 34:15which I know you've got a really subspecialty
- 34:17in, let's take a moment to talk about what restitution
- 34:20is in the criminal context versus a civil award
- 34:22of damages, because I think that plays into a
- 34:25punitive award. How does that work, Mel? Well,
- 34:28restitution in the criminal context, just for
- 34:30everyone's background, I was a prosecutor before
- 34:32coming to Kisa Law. And restitution awards victims
- 34:38the economic damages they suffered as a result
- 34:40of being a victim of a crime. So it's a little
- 34:44bit different in that, yes, they're victims of
- 34:46a crime, but California Constitution awards victims
- 34:53restitution for the actual economic injuries
- 34:55that they incurred. It's not tied to the punitive
- 34:59conduct of the defendant. Yes, he's or she is
- 35:01found guilty for the crime, but it is very much
- 35:04tied. So I would say it's more of a compensatory
- 35:07recovery. But you can't file bankruptcy. If you
- 35:10get a restitution award, you, the defendant,
- 35:13can't file bankruptcy to avoid the payment of
- 35:15restitution, right? Right, exactly. And going
- 35:18back to abilities to pay, right? Net worth versus
- 35:23ability to pay. In a case called Zaxis, the Court
- 35:28of Appeal affirmed a punitive damage award of
- 35:31$300 ,000, where it was shown that the defendant's
- 35:35net worth was negative $6 .3 million. Because
- 35:40the evidence, which included financial statements
- 35:43and CFO testimony, showed ultimately that the
- 35:47defendant had the ability to pay the award. So
- 35:51what does this mean? In the context of the defendant's
- 35:53ability to pay, these cases really teach us the
- 35:57importance of discovering information about the
- 36:00defendant's broader financial picture, both retrospective
- 36:05and prospective evaluation. So let me break that
- 36:09down. The retrospective evaluation in the context
- 36:13of a defendant's ability to pay would include
- 36:16analyzing things like a defendant's attempt to
- 36:20secure credit and loans. This is a source of
- 36:25documents where the defendant is portraying its
- 36:30financial condition in the light most favorable.
- 36:34And plus, any substantial lines of credit also
- 36:37show that a lending institution has already made
- 36:41a determination that this particular defendant
- 36:43is capable of paying back substantial sums, perhaps
- 36:47even in excess of the punitive damage award.
- 36:50And this is analysis from case law. And as to
- 36:54a prospective evaluation, this is like OJ. You
- 36:58have to look at things. like the defendant's
- 37:01future anticipated stream of income. So similar
- 37:05for corporate defendants, what their viability
- 37:08is as a corporation cannot be disregarded, because
- 37:11that is really going to be your strong footing
- 37:13in establishing a higher ratio of punitive damages
- 37:18to compensatory damages. So really, the bottom
- 37:22line here, and Paul, I know you want to jump
- 37:24in, so I'll let you jump in. The bottom line
- 37:26is earnings reports, profit reports may not be
- 37:32sufficient alone. You need to develop a record
- 37:36of their assets, their sources of income, and
- 37:39their liabilities. Paul, do you want to jump
- 37:42in? No, I enjoyed that. Thank you. OK. So we're
- 37:49talking about, we've talked about the OJ case
- 37:51and that Zax's case where the punitive damage
- 37:55award exceeded the net worth. And there is a
- 37:59line of cases that discuss that net worth ratio.
- 38:03So I think it's important to mention. These cases
- 38:08are literally older than I am. And they suggest
- 38:12that punitive damages should not exceed 10 %
- 38:16of a defendant's net worth. But again, there's
- 38:19no bright line rule here. Clearly, there are
- 38:21cases when the facts are appropriate warrant
- 38:26punitive damage awards in excess of a defendant's
- 38:29net worth. So if someone argues in a motion,
- 38:33that's still good law, that this 10 % should
- 38:36be a general limit. Those are still cases that
- 38:39are good law, but keep that in mind. The modern
- 38:43case law has evolved to focus more on the defendant's
- 38:46financial condition. And we had already covered
- 38:51this, the limits and protections of civil code
- 38:553295. Again, make those motions early. If you
- 38:59have the evidentiary record to explain that there's
- 39:05a substantial probability of success on your
- 39:08punitive damages claim, make your motion. Educate
- 39:10the court and get your discovery early. You can
- 39:13rely on CCP. 1987 to subpoena documents and witnesses
- 39:19for trial, but there's always a gamble there.
- 39:23And, you know, in terms of jurors, if you're
- 39:26going to have a bifurcated trial, phase one,
- 39:28phase two, it's nice to be able to quickly transition
- 39:32rather than to either take a hiatus or to do
- 39:37that additional discovery. So let me just say
- 39:39it's really going to be on the defendant to affirmatively
- 39:42request the court to bifurcate trial. Plaintiffs
- 39:45are probably not going to want to ask for bifurcation.
- 39:47So the defendants are going to be the ones who
- 39:49want to bifurcate the trial. first on damages
- 39:52and then on punitives. And they'll want to get
- 39:55a finding of punitive damages before they go
- 39:57to the punitive phase. Doesn't always happen
- 39:59that way. For example, in our Monsanto trial
- 40:01and roundup, they did not bifurcate the trial.
- 40:04We went right through the whole trial and we
- 40:06didn't need to worry about limiting the financial
- 40:09information in the underlying case and waiting
- 40:11for the second phase. It was all done in one
- 40:14phase, but that's not typical. Okay. And then
- 40:21Paul, you want to take it away with trial themes
- 40:23and trial development? Sure. So look, let's assume
- 40:25for a minute that they bifurcate the trial. The
- 40:29trial, the defense have made a motion pre -trial.
- 40:31They want to bifurcate liability from punitive
- 40:34damages. They want punitive damages to be a separate
- 40:36phase of the trial. Does that mean when I'm doing
- 40:41voir dire? that I can't ask the jurors any questions
- 40:45about their feelings with regard to punitive
- 40:49damages. Mel, you're shaking your head. Does
- 40:53it? No. Why not? Because if punitive damages
- 40:58are ultimately going to be at play, you have
- 41:00the right to question and vaudeer the jury or
- 41:03potential jury on those issues. Exactly. In other
- 41:06words, there is not going to be a separate trial
- 41:09with a separate jury that makes determination
- 41:12on punitive damages. So I've got an absolute
- 41:14right and need when I'm questioning the jurors
- 41:17in phase one, even though we're not yet in phase
- 41:20two, to make sure that the jurors are comfortable
- 41:23in awarding punitive damages. So you really have
- 41:27to take your time in voir dire to discuss the
- 41:31idea of punitive damages and what the jurors
- 41:34views are. on that element of damage, because
- 41:37if they say, we could never award punitive damages,
- 41:39regardless of what the evidence is, that juror,
- 41:43even though they may never get to that point
- 41:44in the trial, cannot sit as a juror in your case,
- 41:49because they reject the notion, which by law,
- 41:52you're entitled to recover if the evidence supports
- 41:54it. And so when you would phrase that question
- 41:56to the jurors, you would say, assuming for a
- 41:58moment that the evidence presented to you suggest
- 42:02that there should be punitive damages, that the
- 42:05conduct was despicable conduct, and I'm gonna
- 42:07ask you on behalf of my client for an award of
- 42:10punitive damages. If the evidence supports that,
- 42:14and it's important that you say those words,
- 42:16because it's gotta be based upon what the evidence
- 42:17is. If the evidence supports that, can you award
- 42:21punitive damages? Perfectly fine question, perfectly
- 42:25appropriate in your vaudeer of an even bifurcated
- 42:28case. that answer has got to come to you to know
- 42:33whether or not that is a juror you're comfortable
- 42:36with, for your client's sake, having participate
- 42:38in this trial. And so if a judge says to you,
- 42:42hey, listen, you can't ask that question now
- 42:44because that's for the next phase of the trial,
- 42:46it doesn't work that way because you're only
- 42:48going to have one jury that decides this issue.
- 42:51It's also important not to let the jurors know
- 42:56ever that there's going to be a second phase
- 42:59to the trial because you don't want the jurors
- 43:02to think that by awarding punitive damages that
- 43:05somehow it's going to extend out their jury service.
- 43:10So typically what the judges will do that I've
- 43:12tried cases with, if we're starting trial June
- 43:141st and we think the underlying case is going
- 43:17to probably take on 14 days, the judge will ask
- 43:21the juror, are you available to stay till July
- 43:241st? the judge, he or she won't tell them there's
- 43:27going to be a multi -phase to the trial, but
- 43:30will clear the entire month of June. So that
- 43:32if there is a finding of liability and punitive
- 43:36damages, you'll be able to have a punitive phase
- 43:39without losing that juror for time constraints.
- 43:43So again, voir dire is an important time to explore
- 43:46these issues. and make sure that you build into
- 43:50this the time necessary to get to a punitive
- 43:53phase if you get there. But again, don't point
- 43:56out to the jurors there is going to be another
- 43:59phase to the trial because that might discourage
- 44:01them from awarding punitive damages that they
- 44:03think it's going to prolong their time enough
- 44:06to sit as a juror in the case. And I can think
- 44:10of lots of different examples that you want to
- 44:12talk to the jurors about, but you'll want to
- 44:14work with either your jury consultant or just
- 44:16sort of the facts themselves to figure out what
- 44:19questions you want to ask the individual jurors
- 44:21during voir dire to see how they would respond
- 44:24to a certain set of facts that would justify,
- 44:29if appropriate, an imposition of punitive damages
- 44:32in this case. And then you want to look at sort
- 44:37of And this goes to what is oftentimes called
- 44:40the reptile approach. I don't use reptile when
- 44:43I try my cases, but it's the idea of violating
- 44:47the law. This is a simplification of it, but
- 44:49you violate the norms, you violate the law. in
- 44:53terms of just a community impact on what you've
- 44:57done and whether or not the jurors are comfortable
- 45:00with awarding damages if someone has violated
- 45:03that community standard, which would essentially
- 45:07be hopefully despicable conduct that would allow
- 45:11you to get that punitive award from the particular
- 45:14defendant. And then you constantly want to really
- 45:19emphasize for the jury that the behavior of the
- 45:22defendant or defendants in this case really is
- 45:26outrageous, is despicable. You want to kind of
- 45:29use those words if you can to just frame the
- 45:33behavior of the defendant. So if there's a question
- 45:35that their conduct, in fact, did not violate
- 45:39the standards, by using those standards in the
- 45:42questions that you're asking and framing it that
- 45:44way, both in voir dire, when you're looking to
- 45:47pick the jury, and as you're putting the evidence
- 45:49on, will help support the court's comfort level
- 45:53in hopefully sustaining your award of punitive
- 45:57damages that you get from that trial or fact.
- 46:06So throughout the course of the trial, you want
- 46:08to create the themes that continue to get the
- 46:11jurors focused on, the defendant's behavior,
- 46:15either through the witnesses that are testifying
- 46:17or the evidence you're going to be presenting
- 46:19to the jury, constantly put that thread together
- 46:22because that thread will tie in all of the different
- 46:25elements of the case necessary for you to ultimately
- 46:28hold on to, really hold on to an award of punitive
- 46:32damages that the jury awards you. Right. And
- 46:36what I will say here, too, is Paul does a really
- 46:38good job when he presents evidence. Sometimes
- 46:40it's very uh scientific or or nuanced material
- 46:46and and long chains of emails but i think what
- 46:49paul does is really at trial he's able to synthesize
- 46:53uh the story so that the the jurors understand
- 46:57what happened in a very simple way that the jurors
- 47:01understand okay well this plaintiff was harmed
- 47:04and it's because of a series of the defendant's
- 47:07bad acts and i think through um Paul's presentation,
- 47:11he really gets the jurors on his side almost
- 47:15because he's telling a story, he's direct, he's
- 47:18straightforward about the facts. So Paul, do
- 47:20you want to talk about anything about how you
- 47:23present to the jury in terms of the storytelling
- 47:26and making sure it's relatable? Well, I think
- 47:29ultimately there's lots of ways to do this. One
- 47:33of the ways I like best, honestly, is doing a
- 47:37focus group because focus groups taking ordinary
- 47:41potential jurors together in a group to discuss
- 47:45the facts of the case is very, very powerful
- 47:49in helping you understand how to frame the issues
- 47:52you're going to present to the jury. In almost
- 47:54every trial I've done recently, we've done focus
- 47:57groups with either virtual or in -person to really
- 48:02gauge jurors' responses to the issues that are
- 48:05presented to them. And it's so critical because,
- 48:08quite frankly, a number of times, jurors pick
- 48:11up on themes and look at issues of evidence that
- 48:14we didn't even pay attention to. There might
- 48:16be a photograph that has something in the picture
- 48:18that we never even looked at before. And when
- 48:21these focus group jurors did, we're like, oh
- 48:24my God. How do we miss that? So you're able to
- 48:28really play out your themes with potential jurors
- 48:32in advance of the trial to really get a sense
- 48:34of what works, what doesn't work, and how to
- 48:37reframe the issues themselves, right? No? Right
- 48:42exactly and I also I think Paul's favorite jury
- 48:45consultant is his wife right because you always
- 48:48practice your opening and she'll tell you and
- 48:50that's what I do too with uh with even with my
- 48:52spouse trying to explain what the issue is and
- 48:54he'll quickly tell me well I don't know that
- 48:57it's not really making sense so I have to retweak
- 49:00and I think uh Paul's wife Dana does something
- 49:03similar. I would not have Dana as my juror to
- 49:07be clear she would not be on one of my panels
- 49:09she would not be. and she'd listen to, she'd
- 49:12agree. But it's good to have individuals. You
- 49:16know, like your office is a good place to have
- 49:19ideas passed around, not a good idea to use as
- 49:21a focus group. You need to have really independent
- 49:23thoughts shared with you in a way that you can
- 49:27rely on as opposed to people who are just maybe
- 49:29saying to you what they want to hear, what you
- 49:31want to hear. Was that about KC 3940? Sure, sure.
- 49:42So just with the jury instructions, I mean, these
- 49:44jury instructions are very straightforward, right?
- 49:45The series that you want to focus on is the 3940
- 49:48series. Really, again, you're just emphasizing
- 49:51the clear and convincing burden, how it's been
- 49:53established, and really connect your legal language
- 49:57to your theme that you've developed throughout
- 50:00the trial. And what I'd like to do here is I
- 50:03always have the jury instruction presented to
- 50:08the jury. I use typically an iPad and we're using
- 50:14wireless connection to the screen, either a TV
- 50:20or a projector, and discuss the clear and convincing
- 50:25standard and then show how the evidence that
- 50:28you presented so far establishes the clear and
- 50:31convincing proof that you need to show. So what
- 50:35you're doing here is two things. Number one,
- 50:37showing to the jury why they should award punitive
- 50:41damages to you. And number two, creating a record.
- 50:45So the trial judge, when he hears the inevitable
- 50:49motion for new trial, or the appellate court,
- 50:53who hears the inevitable appeal, why you've met
- 50:56the standards of the case instruction by taking
- 51:00the jurors through that and showing the facts
- 51:04that support the jurors' findings. Closing arguments.
- 51:12Well, here's the thing. If you have a really
- 51:16good case and you want to maximize your compensatory
- 51:25damages, which are easier to hang on to than
- 51:30punitive damages. I don't disagree with the Court
- 51:33of Appeal and the Supreme Court's decision that
- 51:36jurors tend to increase the amount of general
- 51:40damages where there's punitive conduct that has
- 51:43occurred. I guess the Dennis case in Roundup
- 51:48is a pretty good example of the jury awarded
- 51:51$7 million in non -economic damages. which was
- 51:55a substantial recovery was for this individual's
- 51:59claims and yet gave 325 million on top of that
- 52:04for the punitive damages award. So by really
- 52:09tailoring your claims for your client to the
- 52:12jury in your closing arguments, you will likely
- 52:17enhance your total economic and non -economic
- 52:21damage recovery, which at the end of the day
- 52:24is gonna be a whole lot easier to hang on to,
- 52:27bottom line, than punitive damages are. I rarely
- 52:31view punitive damages as much of an incentive
- 52:34to ultimately force the defendant to pay more,
- 52:40they might, on the underlying damages that you're
- 52:45asking for. It's more like an opportunity to
- 52:49get something in addition to your special and
- 52:54general damages. But I would rather hold on to
- 52:59those damages by having a reasonable punitive
- 53:03award. But for example, on a one -to -one ratio,
- 53:07I would rather the jury potentially award me
- 53:11$7 million in underlying general and special
- 53:15damages, and then $7 million in punitive damages,
- 53:20because that shows that the jury wasn't acting
- 53:22out of passion, prejudice, or sympathy. It's
- 53:25a reasonable one -to -one ratio. And you sustain
- 53:29your $7 million underlying recovery versus the
- 53:34$7 million in punitive recovery that you might
- 53:37receive, but will ultimately be challenged. The
- 53:39closer it is to one -to -one, the greater the
- 53:44reliability is that the court of appeal will
- 53:48hold on to that verdict at the end of the day.
- 53:52Not to say it doesn't happen, that you're asking
- 53:54for substantial punitive damages, but having
- 53:57a closer ratio further supports your ability
- 54:02to keep that element of damage that you recover.
- 54:05One point, though, it's important to note. Punitive
- 54:09damages. are totally taxable to your client.
- 54:15So for example, if it was a $10 million punitive
- 54:18award and your attorney's fees hypothetically
- 54:21were 40%, but if the jury awarded $10 million,
- 54:27your client would be taxed on $10 million, not
- 54:31on $6 million, but would be taxed on $10 million.
- 54:35So the client would pay you $4 million in fees.
- 54:38Your client would then have to pay taxes on $10
- 54:41million. So that's $5 million hypothetically
- 54:43in taxes. So at the end of the day, on a $10
- 54:47million award of punitive damages, your client
- 54:51might only actually recover net $1 million, really,
- 54:55at the end of the day. Punitive damages play
- 54:59a heavy burden on the plaintiff potentially in
- 55:02receiving that recovery authority to be paid.
- 55:05That was a mouthful. No, it's a very important
- 55:08point. And I think this goes to the basis of
- 55:13our whole presentation is how we keep our punitive
- 55:17damages. What's reasonable? What we need to establish?
- 55:20Would we love a $325 million punitive damage
- 55:23award? Of course. But is that going to be upheld?
- 55:26Even with the most egregious conduct and an established
- 55:30record, we've seen that time and time again,
- 55:35punitive damage awards are cut down and to what
- 55:38ultimate benefit to our clients. So these are
- 55:40all very important considerations. We're almost
- 55:44two minutes from the end, so keep going. Yeah,
- 55:46well, we do only have two more minutes, so I'm
- 55:49happy. Paul, there are common pitfalls and final
- 55:52tips if you want to give, and then we can open
- 55:53up to questions. Well, if we have some questions,
- 55:58I think there may have been a few that came in.
- 56:00It might be tough to get into. The others, let's
- 56:05see, Nickerson. Is that a personal entry case,
- 56:08Nickerson versus Stonebridge? I don't recall
- 56:10what the Nickerson underlying case was. Let me
- 56:12pull that up really quickly. And Elizabeth will
- 56:15get to the answer in two seconds. And meanwhile,
- 56:20Paul Levine asks, I have a default entered against
- 56:23a corporate defendant and its individual owners.
- 56:26Do I still have to show their financial condition?
- 56:29If so, how can I conduct discovery under 3295?
- 56:32And the answer is you should not. If the court
- 56:34has found, in my view, that the default. judgment
- 56:38that you're seeking to enter is appropriate.
- 56:41That's the judgment piece of it. The judge may
- 56:43not enter a judgment of that amount of money.
- 56:45He may require, she may require you to, but I
- 56:48had a case where a Lear jet fell out of the sky
- 56:51when there was a problem with the maintenance
- 56:54of the aircraft. And I believe the judge gave
- 56:58us a default judgment of over $75 million based
- 57:02upon the record of underlying damages without
- 57:05having to go through a 3295 analysis. The judge
- 57:08entered that order and entered a judgment against
- 57:10the defendant for that amount of money without
- 57:12having to go through those steps. Mel? Going
- 57:16back to Nickerson, Nickerson was actually a bad
- 57:18faith claim against an insurance provider. I
- 57:23can give you the site if you want it. It is 63
- 57:26Cal 4363. Perfect. And it is now 1 .30 on the
- 57:34nose. So well done, Mel. Thank you for the time.
- 57:36Beverly Hills Bar, thanks for giving us a chance
- 57:37to spend lunch with y 'all. And we're out. Thanks
- 57:41all. Thank you very much. Bye. You may be eligible
- 57:45for CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba .org
- 57:49slash podcasts for more information.