Latest / The Marketing Meeting with Itir Eraslan / 35. Consumer Insights Beyond the Algorithm with Jason Fulton
Transcript
- 0:00Jason Fulton: We have all grown up with wanting to ask questions, find
- 0:03answers to questions, being curious about how other people live or why
- 0:09people behave in the way that they do.
- 0:11And I believe that with any people centric work, quantitative or qualitative, it
- 0:16should all start with the foundation, which is we are human beings.
- 0:20And this is one of the things that we are on earth.
- 0:23To provide for ourselves, answer some of those questions.
- 0:25Itir Eraslan: Hi, this is the Marketing Meeting and I'm your host Itır Eraslan.
- 0:30Every two weeks I meet with experts and we talk about topics related to
- 0:34brands, marketing and businesses.
- 0:36We sometimes add random lifestyle topics too.
- 0:39I hope you enjoy the show.
- 0:45Welcome to the Marketing Meeting podcast.
- 0:47I'm happy to host an old colleague of mine, Jason Fulton today.
- 0:52He's the founder of This Memento, a people centric insights and strategy agency.
- 0:58Come Jason.
- 0:59Hello
- 1:00Jason Fulton: there.
- 1:00When you say old colleague, it makes me feel old.
- 1:04Itir Eraslan: Or is there a better English saying to that?
- 1:08But when I say ex, it's just like I use ex for people who
- 1:13are dead or for ex boyfriends.
- 1:17What's the correct usage for an old colleague?
- 1:20Which is young.
- 1:21Jason Fulton: Yeah.
- 1:21No, it's a, it's an old colleague or an ex colleague.
- 1:24I don't think that, um, we found a better word for it, which is ironic,
- 1:29considering the work that we do.
- 1:32We should be thinking about better terms for this, but, but we're doing that.
- 1:36And thank you very much for, for having me.
- 1:38It's a, it's a pleasure that after all of these years that we've known each
- 1:42other, that you've invited me you.
- 1:45To your podcast.
- 1:46Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 1:47I think there are some people in the podcast that I feel like I need to get
- 1:51mature, uh, in the podcasting process.
- 1:54And I need to get better so that I can host these people.
- 1:57Uh, I'm trying to break that rule because like, for example, you have been always on
- 2:02my mind that I want to, uh, you know, host at the podcast and so on, but I was just
- 2:07like, there is a time for Jason because I want to, because that's the consumer
- 2:11insights is a important topic for me.
- 2:14It's not that I'm so anxious when I talk to you.
- 2:17No, actually, I just want to make sure that, um, I'm able
- 2:21to interview in the way I want.
- 2:23To, uh, so it's been a while, uh, but, uh, maybe you don't know, but you
- 2:29played an important role in my marketing career, Jason, uh, because my first real
- 2:35consumer insights project was led by you.
- 2:39Uh, and when I say real, uh, meaning that I was before I worked with you on
- 2:44a project, uh, on the project that we had in Turkey, uh, I was involved in
- 2:48qualitative, quantitative research, just like more of the traditional methods of
- 2:53Consumer research, like customer research, uh, but then there was this moment
- 2:57that, uh, we were about to launch a big campaign, like big change in the culture.
- 3:03And then I met you and the project in Turkey.
- 3:07Uh, so I would like to, first of all, ask you what is different when
- 3:13you do a qualitative or quantitative research and the work that you do,
- 3:17uh, and you provide in your project.
- 3:20Jason Fulton: Yeah, I mean, it's great to hear that you mentioned the project
- 3:24that we did because I think that that's really Indicative of the way that we work.
- 3:29And sometimes when I face the question that you're asking me, it's not only
- 3:35do I face this question from people who work in consumer insights, but I
- 3:39also face this question from people that work in marketing or product
- 3:43creation, which is what makes your work so unique within the industry now, how
- 3:52I would answer that question is that it all starts from what I believe.
- 3:57To be foundational human behavior.
- 4:01That's where it starts.
- 4:02And we all have the foundational qualities needed to do the work that we do.
- 4:10And what I mean by that is that as human beings, we have all grown up with
- 4:16wanting to ask questions, wanting to find answers to questions, being curious
- 4:23about how other people live, or why people behave in the way that they do.
- 4:29And I believe that with any people-centric work, be it quantitative or qualitative,
- 4:37it should all start with the foundation, which is we are human beings and this
- 4:42is what one of the things that we are on earth to provide for ourselves.
- 4:47Right?
- 4:47Answer some of those questions.
- 4:49So I, I would say from a big picture thinking, that's something that
- 4:53we all, um, as a team, there's six of us in the agency in Amsterdam.
- 4:58That's all.
- 4:58The things that we share as a team now, the other thing that we share as a team
- 5:04is this idea of a framework, right?
- 5:08So, yes, we have this curiosity.
- 5:11Yes, we have this sort of burning desire to have those big questions answered,
- 5:15but we also work within a framework.
- 5:19The framework that we work within is, um, I'd like you to imagine a tree.
- 5:25Itir Eraslan: Right.
- 5:26Jason Fulton: So if we think about the tree from.
- 5:29The bottom to the top, uh, every tree has its
- 5:33Itir Eraslan: roots,
- 5:35Jason Fulton: then the tree has the trunk, then the top of the
- 5:38tree are where the leaves are.
- 5:40Now, if you think about a tree in terms of a framework for understanding
- 5:46people, this is how I'm going to break the tree down for you.
- 5:49At the bottom of the tree, the trunks, these are things which I like to
- 5:54believe are Timeless behavioral culture.
- 6:00We're put on this earth or we've been put on this earth to share
- 6:05and tell stories with each other.
- 6:07This is timeless behavior from the cavemen to where we are today and where
- 6:13we will be in 50 to a hundred years time.
- 6:16That timeless behavior is we all want to tell stories, right?
- 6:20That's our timeless behavior.
- 6:22All want to tell stories.
- 6:24Now, the trunk of that tree is the behavioral culture.
- 6:30Now, depending on the cultures that we are from, you and I have different cultures,
- 6:35you and I have different genders.
- 6:37So, the culture changes the way that we like to tell stories.
- 6:42to each other, be it through spoken word, be it through
- 6:46written word, be it through music, storytelling, rap music, folk music.
- 6:52So the actual behavioral culture is changing, right?
- 6:57So the route is still the same.
- 6:58We still want to tell stories, but the cultural difference changes
- 7:03the way that we tell stories.
- 7:05And at the top is the material culture.
- 7:08what we use to tell stories.
- 7:11So as I said before, in my example, we used to tell stories around the campfire.
- 7:17Now, stories are being told via TikTok, Instagram, ChatGBT, and AI
- 7:23tools, enabling us to tell stories.
- 7:25And those things change.
- 7:27Those things change more frequently, like the shedding of leaves of a tree.
- 7:31One season we're green, the next season they're gone, and the following
- 7:37season it's a different color again.
- 7:39So, our framework of even thinking.
- 7:42Is always remember we have a timeless influence, we have behavioral
- 7:46culture and we have material culture.
- 7:49So that's the foundation of the way that I would like our team and also our
- 7:57partners, our clients, our collaborators to think within that framework.
- 8:05Itir Eraslan: Within that tree, for example, when you go deep in your
- 8:07projects, do you start the truth like the trunk and the leaves, but
- 8:13there's only like one part that you are interested in understanding?
- 8:17Jason Fulton: Well, I would say the behavioral culture, the trunk is probably
- 8:22the most important when we establish a project with a client or a partner.
- 8:29The trunk of the tree is probably the most important.
- 8:32The material culture, how it ends up being told is probably more
- 8:37to do with the recommendations.
- 8:39How should our insights come to the marketplace is probably the
- 8:45top, but we seem to concentrate more on the trunk of the tree.
- 8:50And again, just kind of coming back to human behavior, one of the things that
- 8:55we like to work with, and we like to, uh, encourage in our own behavior, but also
- 9:01the people that we work with, is this idea of applying Empathy and that empathy
- 9:09again, that's part of human behavior, but when you apply empathy to finding out
- 9:17answers to the big questions that already helps to establish putting you in the
- 9:22right frame to get to the right insight.
- 9:26And that empathy, I believe, are things such as having an open ears to listen
- 9:32Itir Eraslan: to
- 9:32Jason Fulton: what's being said to you, having an open mind, you know,
- 9:37being prepared to not just believe in the way that you have always done
- 9:42things, be, you know, be open minded to have an open heart, to really
- 9:48connect with the person that you're trying to discover insights from.
- 9:53And then an open will in order to change the way that.
- 9:58You or the client has behaved in the past to fertilize new ground, go to new spaces.
- 10:04So even fundamentally, we set our cells up with these two elements, which is
- 10:12again, this tree focus more on the trunk, I would say, but also an open.
- 10:18Is mind, heart and will.
- 10:21That's the foundation for everything.
- 10:23Now, when it comes to directly answering, what do we do best?
- 10:28I would say by using those two things.
- 10:30And over the years, we've worked with yourself in Turkey, Istanbul.
- 10:36I worked for Nike for 10 years, I've had my agency for 15 years, so I've been
- 10:41working within the qualitative consumer insights business for the last 25 years.
- 10:50So I've seen many, many changes, um, and what I've seen, what has been
- 10:55successful in the way that we work, is it's moved from just being quant,
- 11:01To qual to more ethnographies, you
- 11:06Itir Eraslan: know,
- 11:07Jason Fulton: anthropological ways of working, which means really going deep
- 11:13and immersing yourself in the world and the culture of the people that you want
- 11:19to impact or change or be inspired by.
- 11:24I would say the way that we work is really the sort of ethnographic ways of working.
- 11:31Um, And we've been doing that certainly for the last 15 years within this company.
- 11:37Itir Eraslan: And for people that doesn't know of quantitative, qualitative,
- 11:41and ethnographic transition, if you think about surveys, it's quantitative.
- 11:47Or like polls or so on, and then qualitative is all the focus groups
- 11:53and, uh, those type of work, but ethnographic and also like more of a
- 11:58consumer insights thinking, just like you mentioned, it's more going deep down and
- 12:04understanding that trunk of a consumer.
- 12:07So, uh, my question for you, because when you start the project, you have to.
- 12:12Select the trees that you, you will listen to, uh, because like in a forest, uh,
- 12:18the same trees, uh, like different trees, but like same thousands of the same tree.
- 12:23How many do you select?
- 12:25And yeah.
- 12:25How do you define which one do you select?
- 12:30Jason Fulton: Yeah, and that's a great question.
- 12:31Um, I mean, just going back to what you're, what you were
- 12:34saying about quantitative, right?
- 12:36So quantitative is, you know, we could argue big data.
- 12:40These are surveys of, um, a percentage of the population.
- 12:46Uh, and these surveys could be 2, 000, 20, 000, 60, 000, 100, 000, uh, people.
- 12:53Okay.
- 12:53Surveys and they get you to answer the, you know, how many people
- 12:59are thinking this way, right?
- 13:01But there is no behavior in that.
- 13:03It's just answering a simple question.
- 13:06Whereas the qualitative tends to get you the emotional data.
- 13:11How are people feeling about a certain Issue or a challenge or the
- 13:16way that they are living their lives.
- 13:18And what's really important about that qualitative part and then going deep
- 13:21into their lives is that you don't need a huge amount of people to talk to,
- 13:29to get to, uh, some of the pain points of what's happening in their lives or
- 13:34their community or whatever it may be.
- 13:37What's important is the quality of the people that you're talking to.
- 13:42Let me give you an example.
- 13:42A lot of the projects that we have worked on, especially over the
- 13:46last 15 years, have been driven sometimes by consumer segmentation.
- 13:54Now what is consumer segmentation?
- 13:57It's an interesting question.
- 13:59Consumer segmentation.
- 14:00So let's go back to that quantity of numbers that I was talking
- 14:02about, 2000, 20, 000, 60, 000.
- 14:05So consumer segmentation.
- 14:08Tends to start in this area.
- 14:11A big survey has been done and a broad picture or even a broad outline of
- 14:18what a person's life is like, what they are interested in, what they
- 14:22do, how frequently they do something is broken down into segments.
- 14:29So let's take 60, 000.
- 14:31You can break that into segment.
- 14:33A are high network individuals.
- 14:37Their demographics are between this age group in this age group.
- 14:40They do this.
- 14:41They spend money on this.
- 14:43Um, and they do this.
- 14:45This frequently, then you have another segment, how much they
- 14:48earn is not as high as the previous segment, but they earn this amount.
- 14:53Their age group is this and you can break that 60, 000 people into
- 14:58six or seven different segments.
- 15:01And those segments are very useful when it comes to having a broad picture of
- 15:09what is happening within the marketplace or a sector based on big numbers.
- 15:15Right.
- 15:17And that can help to steer a marketing team sometimes, or a sales team in terms
- 15:23of, hey, we need to focus on, we want high network individuals, or we want first
- 15:28jobbers, for example, another segment.
- 15:31Over the years, our clients have said to us, we did a huge segmentation
- 15:37piece and we understand a little bit about who our consumers are.
- 15:43are, but there is no emotional data.
- 15:47There is no feeling of why they choose our brand, how, and why they choose to
- 15:56spend the money the way that they do.
- 15:59There is no emotional connection for a brand to be able to.
- 16:05Connect with them.
- 16:06Brands, as we know, are moving much more towards being, um, a character,
- 16:13a personality, and with those brand characters and personalities,
- 16:18each brand has an emotion.
- 16:22Itir Eraslan: And
- 16:22Jason Fulton: in order to connect with a consumer or an audience, they
- 16:27want to understand their emotions.
- 16:29Quantitative doesn't give you the emotion.
- 16:32Qualitative gives you the emotion.
- 16:36Ethnographic work, anthropological studies, give you even deeper
- 16:42layers to that emotion.
- 16:45And the way that we work is by using those kind of tools, ethnographic work,
- 16:52which means spending a day with the consumer, spending time in their homes.
- 16:58The project that we worked on, which was Turkish athletes, I think
- 17:02it was, I think it was football players, I think it was runners.
- 17:05Basketball players, even going into their world, observing their world
- 17:11from the outside, not interfering, just observing their world, seeing how they
- 17:17behave as individuals, as a group, as a community, but actually being part of
- 17:24their world for a certain amount of time means that you're immersing yourself.
- 17:29In that world, and you're immersing yourself in their behavior, but as
- 17:36a researcher, you're able to step out, observe, and then step in
- 17:42and say, we noticed this happened.
- 17:45Can you explain to me why this happened?
- 17:49Please tell us your story about what we just saw.
- 17:53Can you explain to us why you behave in this way?
- 17:58And the way that we work enables us to observe, to ask the questions, to go
- 18:06deeper, and very often shed light on behavior that the people that we talk
- 18:14to didn't even realize themselves.
- 18:18And this is insight.
- 18:19Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 18:20And this is a very important part of it because it's not only about understanding
- 18:25emotion, which is like, um, I usually wake up quite angry in the mornings.
- 18:30This is an emotion and there's a timeframe and you get it, but it's not the insight.
- 18:36There is a reason why this person is waking up angry in the morning.
- 18:41And also sometimes that emotion also changes when.
- 18:46That person is alone or when they are together with someone else.
- 18:50And they say that I'm really having fun when I'm with my certain friends.
- 18:55But there is a reason to that emotion, why he or she is having fun.
- 18:59Then she is with those certain friends, which she, she, or he may not know.
- 19:03I mean, that's, that's the beauty of insights.
- 19:06And I think the part that I love most about projects.
- 19:11Jason Fulton: One hundred percent.
- 19:12Right.
- 19:13100%.
- 19:14And I think I just want to go back to, I'm not sure I have fully answered
- 19:18one of the questions that you asked me, which was when we do this work,
- 19:22how many people do you talk to?
- 19:25And it's not necessarily about the number of people that you talk to.
- 19:29It's the quality of the people that you talk to
- 19:33Itir Eraslan: and
- 19:33Jason Fulton: also what you want to talk to them about.
- 19:37For example, there are certain projects that we have spoken to six
- 19:42people, eight people, twelve people.
- 19:45But how you talk to them and the experience that you have with them
- 19:50allows you to get under the skin of what they're doing and to understand.
- 19:56But I want to put some things into some context, right?
- 20:00It may appear that when people do qualitative work
- 20:03that it's completely random.
- 20:03It may appear that when people do qualitative work
- 20:04that it's completely random.
- 20:06Right?
- 20:07So, the six people that Jason was talking about, or these twelve people
- 20:11that Jason was talking about, it's completely random people that you talk to.
- 20:14That is not the case.
- 20:18When it comes to quantitative work, it's very clear that there is a process.
- 20:21There's a questionnaire, 30 questions, 50 questions, 60 questions, people
- 20:26answer A, B, C, or with a scale, and then the numbers come out at the end.
- 20:31Okay, there's a very robust, tried and tested process when
- 20:36it comes to qualitative work, qualitative insight work.
- 20:40There is also a process that takes place.
- 20:43And this process is very key to understand that this is not random.
- 20:48It's a process that can be followed.
- 20:51The process that we use, we've decided to call DIG.
- 20:55That's D, that's I, and G.
- 20:58The D part stands for discover, the I part stands for ideate,
- 21:04and the G part stands for go.
- 21:07I'm going to break DIG down for you into those three elements, and then you see
- 21:11how much of a process It's part of that.
- 21:14Let's start with D.
- 21:16The D part tends to come in when the client says, Hey, we've
- 21:21got some quantitative work.
- 21:23We've got some consumer segmentation, but now we really feel like we
- 21:26need to understand the emotional part of our consumer and where
- 21:31some of their pain points are.
- 21:32Can you help us?
- 21:33Yes.
- 21:35We're going to dig with you.
- 21:36The D part comes into, okay, can you explain to us what is
- 21:42your main research question?
- 21:44What are you looking to find out through this whole research project?
- 21:50Is it to do with product?
- 21:51Is it to do with, um, community engagement?
- 21:54Do you want to learn more about their pain points?
- 21:56So we tend to spend a lot of time with our clients.
- 22:02Digging deep into what are you actually looking to find out?
- 22:06What are your objectives of this project?
- 22:08Part of that is also, can you share any previous work that
- 22:13you've done on the consumer that you want to connect better with?
- 22:19And quite often, this is where they share the segmentation.
- 22:24Uh, and then when we see the segmentation, and they say, Yes, but we really want
- 22:28to know, More feeling and emotion about segment A or segment B or segment F.
- 22:35We really want to get deeper into that.
- 22:37Can you help us?
- 22:38We start by saying, okay, explain to us who segment A, B or E is.
- 22:44Give us the sketch of who they are.
- 22:48And we start to look at that sketch and we start to say, okay,
- 22:53let's sort of amplify that person.
- 22:56Okay.
- 22:56Be it A, C, or E.
- 22:58Let's amplify that person.
- 23:00You've said that they are aged between here and here, and that
- 23:04they do this particular activity three or four times a week.
- 23:08But let's start to apply some more questions to that.
- 23:13All right, which is why do we think that they're doing it this many times a week?
- 23:17Why do they are they buying those brands?
- 23:20Why are they part of this type of community?
- 23:26And we start to basically flesh out the consumer segment
- 23:30in terms of more criteria.
- 23:33We want to know.
- 23:34Not only what they're doing, but why they're doing it.
- 23:36And so we start to actually ask already more questions of the segmentation and
- 23:42those questions start to create what we call a qualitative consumer survey.
- 23:49And that qualitative consumer survey is about recruiting people.
- 23:53Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 23:54Um, just one question there, because they already come up like in your
- 23:58example, They already come up with, like, this is segment A, and I want
- 24:02to understand more of the segment A.
- 24:05Is there also incidents that the segmentation is not there
- 24:09and you are able to still work?
- 24:10Or also, sometimes the segmentation is so broad that they have to, Nietzsche's
- 24:16down, uh, because usually when we talk about segmentation, there's
- 24:21also a problem that people tend to do segmentation based on demographics only.
- 24:26Uh, or like it's so wide or so narrow, then is it possible still to work with
- 24:33you then in that case, or they have to make the segmentation, uh, before upfront?
- 24:37No,
- 24:39Jason Fulton: no, no, no.
- 24:40They, they, they don't have to have a segmentation, um, before they,
- 24:46they approach us to do some work.
- 24:48Um, We've had examples where we've had some segmentation, which are, um,
- 24:54extremely broad, that they literally, as you've mentioned, they've just given
- 24:59some demographics, um, and they've given things such as, you know, the
- 25:04shops that they go to, the people that they follow, or how much they spend,
- 25:09but it's so broad that there is nothing that the team can use to really work on.
- 25:17You know, the, the teams that we tend to have come to us tend to be
- 25:22brand teams or tend to be product teams and they, and they want to have
- 25:27something more tangible, something more concrete to work with mostly.
- 25:34A problem that the team want to solve.
- 25:37And if it's too broad, then there is nothing to, to create from equally.
- 25:44We've had something which is very narrow, which is, it's a very sort
- 25:48of definitive consumer segment, but it's so narrow that the team feels.
- 25:54Like they're in shackles that they can't really be flexible
- 25:59within that consumer segment.
- 26:01So you do have these two camps that sometimes things fall into.
- 26:07Um, sometimes people come to us and say, we don't know who our consumer is.
- 26:13We have a vague idea of who our consumer is, or we have an idea of the
- 26:18consumer that we want to connect with.
- 26:21Can you help us to construct a consumer that would fit with our
- 26:28brand or our brand aspiration?
- 26:30So there tends to be these three camps that we commonly come across, but coming
- 26:37back to the question of, you know, the number of people that we speak to.
- 26:43Once we get the segmentation, sometimes, sometimes not.
- 26:47We try and look at, okay, you as a brand.
- 26:52What's the type of person that you want to connect with?
- 26:56Why do you want to connect with this type of person?
- 26:59What is it that connecting with this type of person will give you?
- 27:04What solutions do you think that the consumer needs solving?
- 27:09So quite often it's a consultation with the brand and the ideas that
- 27:16the brand have about who their consumer could or should be.
- 27:21In combination with looking at the segmentation that they have, and then
- 27:26reconstructing it all together to say, okay, this is your hypothesis, your
- 27:31assumption of who the consumer is, this is the data that you have, but
- 27:36this is the place that you want to be.
- 27:38Now, let's construct the type of person that you should be speaking
- 27:43to in order to get insight.
- 27:46And once we have this sort of description, then we really flesh it out.
- 27:51And then we build a survey, we call it a recruitment survey that helps us to
- 27:58get some initial answers to this sort of new profile that we're starting to
- 28:04create, gets us some initial answers.
- 28:09And then even the quality of the answers that we start to get from those surveys
- 28:15starts to give us an indication of who do we want to talk to, how talkative
- 28:20are the people who are answering these surveys, how willing are they
- 28:25to participate in a type of research that we want to set up for them.
- 28:30So.
- 28:31Quite often in our dig phase, where we, we're starting to understand
- 28:34the segmentation, we're starting to understand the client, we're starting to
- 28:38understand, you know, what the client is looking for in terms of the objectives.
- 28:42We then start in that discover phase, start to say the best
- 28:47ways to really get to some areas of deep insight will be to do.
- 28:55These things, it could be a focus group.
- 28:57It could be, um, a duo, which is, you know, two people talking to each other.
- 29:02It could be a triad, three people talking to each other.
- 29:06It could be a day in the life of one of these consumers.
- 29:10It could be a weekend in the life.
- 29:12It could be a week in the life of the consumer.
- 29:15It could be digital diaries, for example, where you follow that consumer, you
- 29:20ask them to complete exercises over a weekend or a week or even a month.
- 29:26So you have all of these sort of different methodologies that
- 29:31allow you as a researcher to go really deep into their lives.
- 29:38So you need to understand what you're looking to discover.
- 29:42You need to leverage methodologies that allow you to discover those things.
- 29:49And then you need to create the questions and the exercises that enable
- 29:55you to get answers to those questions.
- 29:58And then you need to go in the field, meet with those people, depending
- 30:03on the methodology you're using.
- 30:05As I said, we tend to really live their lives with them,
- 30:09and that is our discover phase.
- 30:12It's very thorough, it's very methodical.
- 30:15Who are we looking to find out, how are we going to do it, and then let's do it.
- 30:19And that can take four weeks.
- 30:21To find those people.
- 30:22And sometimes it's six people, sometimes it's 12 people, sometimes it's 18.
- 30:27It's not about the number of people that you speak to, it's about the quality of
- 30:32the people that you find and asking them the right questions and experiencing
- 30:37the lives, their lives, uh, through their eyes, but with your eyes as a
- 30:42researcher to ask the right questions.
- 30:46on the discover phase anyway.
- 30:48Itir Eraslan: So then the next step, next phase is the ideate.
- 30:52Uh, ideate is where you distill, I guess.
- 30:56Jason Fulton: Absolutely.
- 30:57So here's what's super interesting about the way that we work.
- 31:01When you're in the field and you're discovering, you're being put into
- 31:07New places, you're meeting new people, you're doing new things, and you're
- 31:11putting yourself in the world of the consumer that you want to connect with.
- 31:16Right.
- 31:16And you're usually with that consumer that you want to connect with.
- 31:19But what you're doing, you are observing, you're an observer of what they are doing.
- 31:25This word, observing, is really key, because in that discover
- 31:30phase, that's all that you're doing.
- 31:31The ideate phase, is observing.
- 31:33Is where you start to look for the patterns of observations that you've
- 31:39done from being in the infield.
- 31:41So for example, you've designed the project with us where you've
- 31:45done focus groups, or duos, or immersions into their lives.
- 31:49And you, you're observing all of these things with the six
- 31:53people, or the 12, or the 18.
- 31:56And you've seen, okay, with these people, I've done these observations.
- 32:02But now.
- 32:03I need time to be able to analyze what have I observed.
- 32:11And the observations and explaining the observations, making sense of the
- 32:17observations, is where you start to move from observation into insight.
- 32:26And the way that we do it is we have our team that go in field, each person
- 32:33doing the observing are seeing their consumer from a different perspective.
- 32:37If you work in sales, the way that you observe the person, you're seeing
- 32:41them from a, maybe a, how much they spend perspective, like really sales.
- 32:46If you are somebody comes from a product perspective, the way that you observe
- 32:50the consumer is the way that they.
- 32:53You know, put their product on or use that product.
- 32:55So you're seeing things from a different perspective.
- 32:58The IDA phase is when you bring everyone who have observed that
- 33:03consumer together and you start to share information, you start to tell stories.
- 33:09What did you observe from the time that we spent with the consumer?
- 33:12Oh, you observed this.
- 33:15you know, observation A, which is quite similar to your observation A.
- 33:20And what you start to do by sharing your observations, you start to see
- 33:26that there are specific patterns that emerge, which are important to, Either
- 33:34that individual who has been the observer and eventually the team, because you
- 33:40start to say, Hey, this observation keeps coming up from person a person B
- 33:45person C, this is obviously an important thing that we've observed as a team.
- 33:52Hey, let's put that up there, right?
- 33:53An important observation.
- 33:54And ideation is about methodically going through the observations, telling
- 34:02stories about why you think that this observation is important over this
- 34:07observation, and with these patterns, you start to create specific themes.
- 34:13Yeah.
- 34:13Now, how you get to an insight is when you start to look at
- 34:18the themes that are emerging.
- 34:20And if theme A, B and C keep coming back as themes, you start to look at
- 34:27how can theme A and B come together as a description of, we can see what
- 34:33is happening, but now we need to try to describe why this is happening.
- 34:39And this is the key component of what makes an insight.
- 34:44And an insight is a description of what is happening, a collection of themes with
- 34:50the description of why it is happening, because the why that it is happening.
- 34:57Is what starts to get the team to create something new to solve, it could be a
- 35:04problem that the consumer is facing, which is why they're behaving in this way.
- 35:09And that opens up the creative space for the brands to provide
- 35:14a solution to that problem.
- 35:16Itir Eraslan: And it's
- 35:17Jason Fulton: really important.
- 35:17People use the word insight quite casually sometimes, but the word
- 35:22insight is a very precious word.
- 35:25Because it is about shedding light into a consumer world, if you can
- 35:32help to understand what that light is, then you can actually help to
- 35:38provide a solution to that consumer or that person or that community.
- 35:43Uh, and then the last piece is relatively easy, the go phase.
- 35:47It's where you start to take those insights and you start to say, okay,
- 35:52if we understand now the behavior and why that behavior is, how as a
- 35:56brand, how as a company, how as an organization do we address those needs?
- 36:03Um, and that's essentially how the dig phase comes together.
- 36:08The discover, knowing what you want to find out, going into the field,
- 36:11doing it, the idea coming together.
- 36:13You know, getting to the themes, the go phases.
- 36:16Okay.
- 36:16How do we provide the solution?
- 36:18And then putting together of the decks or the films or the recommendations.
- 36:24And that's how we use this dig process to get everything done.
- 36:28It's quite complex, but it's something that we've been
- 36:31working with and on for years.
- 36:34Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 36:34Yeah.
- 36:35And I like my, uh, sudden reaction when I hear about a theme
- 36:40and I'm coming to an insight.
- 36:42So that you can, the brand can work on a tangible goal.
- 36:45My reaction would be, can you give a simple example of a team and an
- 36:51insight out of that team based on maybe a recent work that you've
- 36:55done or like the work that we've done together at Turkey, let's say.
- 37:01Jason Fulton: Yeah.
- 37:01Well, here's, here's, here's one example.
- 37:03So we worked with a global sportswear brand, which is very well known
- 37:10within the world of football.
- 37:11This brand was very curious about knowing the behavior of a particular
- 37:18young football age group who, during the summer, did something which
- 37:25was called pre season football.
- 37:28What we did on this particular project, we spoke to young football teenagers in,
- 37:35I think it was Berlin, London, and Paris.
- 37:40And we did focus groups with them, we saw them play football, quite often we
- 37:45played football with them, we saw them with their team, we spoke to coaches, we
- 37:50spoke to their parents, we spoke to other football experts, all around this topic
- 37:56of, what are these kids doing, Within their preseason and why are they doing it?
- 38:03And one thing which kept coming back as a theme was a formal preseason is six weeks.
- 38:12But the kids that we were speaking to were actually starting two weeks
- 38:17earlier and doing a pre preseason.
- 38:22And when we were asking, why are you doing that?
- 38:26And they were saying that they actually wanted to get ready for
- 38:31their pre season, the first day of pre season, because they believed
- 38:36that this is when the coaches were already starting to make the judgments
- 38:41of who was going to make the team.
- 38:43It wasn't made at the end of six weeks.
- 38:46It was made on the first day of pre season.
- 38:49So these kids were doing pre season.
- 38:51Two weeks before, so that their first day, they were already
- 38:56shining in front of their coaches.
- 38:59One of the first big insights was around pre, pre season was about
- 39:05impressing the coach on day one.
- 39:08The other thing that we learned was that a lot of goals, winning goals,
- 39:14deciding goals were scored in the last 10 minutes of football matches.
- 39:20Then we started to put some patterns together.
- 39:23So they start early, two weeks, they then do six weeks.
- 39:26So actually they're doing eight weeks of pre season, but it's
- 39:29actually for the most significant part of the match was 10 minutes.
- 39:36So our insight was that they actually spend eight weeks working
- 39:42for 10 minutes, for the last 10 minutes of games, the hardest eight
- 39:46weeks for the final 10 minutes.
- 39:50And this insight helped the brand to change how they launched their preseason.
- 39:59So they were no longer doing it over six weeks.
- 40:02They actually extended their preseason, like when they launch products,
- 40:07when they launch services, they extended it by an earlier two weeks.
- 40:12They were providing services for these kids, new product, new services for the
- 40:18coaches as well for the pre pre season.
- 40:22Um, and so we helped to sort of re establish the whole process that
- 40:27the brand had in order to connect with these young football kids.
- 40:33Itir Eraslan: That's the perfect, always.
- 40:34I love any example related with sports, uh, because that's usually
- 40:39full of insights and not meaning that all the other products or so on, they
- 40:44don't have insights, but like, it's very, it's a very emotional thing.
- 40:48Doing sports is an emotional thing.
- 40:50So, uh, thank you for sharing that.
- 40:53Uh, Jason, my.
- 40:54One of my last questions is about you are someone very deeply involved in insights.
- 41:01It can be like wide variety of insights from wide variety of
- 41:05customers that you are working with in the future, in the near future.
- 41:10Do you see some emerging trends happening in the space in marketing, uh, or
- 41:16in the consumer insights part also?
- 41:19Jason Fulton: I would say I would say it's probably something that
- 41:23you've been hearing through your podcasts and also through the
- 41:27people that you are networking with.
- 41:30And everybody's been talking about it in one shape or form,
- 41:33which is, of course, it's AI.
- 41:36And one thing that we have been facing, is it competition?
- 41:43Probably.
- 41:44Is it, um, other methods to use?
- 41:47Possibly.
- 41:47But one thing that we have been noticing is that there are companies,
- 41:54organizations, which are using AI to start to observe the answers to surveys.
- 42:01For example, to then create insights.
- 42:07So, I mean, we've been talking through this conversation about quantitative and
- 42:12we've been talking about qualitative.
- 42:14And in my personal experience is the quantitative doesn't
- 42:18necessarily get you to the insights.
- 42:20It is either too broad, too narrow, but it doesn't quite get you to the emotions.
- 42:25But what we've been finding is that increasingly the sophistication of AI Is
- 42:32starting to look at the results or the questions being answered within those
- 42:37surveys and they're now starting to try to create insight based on surveys.
- 42:43Now that is absolutely competition for us.
- 42:46Why I see it as.
- 42:49It's competition because it's another service out there.
- 42:52It's another methodology of sorts, which is out there at the same time.
- 42:57I don't see it as competition.
- 42:59And the reason being is that I believe coming back right away to
- 43:03the start of our conversation, which is about human behavior, right?
- 43:08Yeah.
- 43:10Open ears, mind, heart, will.
- 43:14As a human being, when you're engaging or interacting with a consumer face to face,
- 43:21in their space, with their community, with their friends, there is something
- 43:27about that human interaction that you're observing and that you're part of,
- 43:32which cannot be replicated by something Automated or something which is digital.
- 43:40There's just something which is special about those moments
- 43:45that you have with someone.
- 43:48And I believe anyway, at this moment in time, no matter how sophisticated
- 43:53an AI can be, or a program or an algorithm can be, I don't think it
- 44:00truly gets you, it can give you an idea of where the insights can be.
- 44:07But the interaction with people gives you the direction that
- 44:11you should be looking to follow.
- 44:14And then the insights that come out of that interaction fused
- 44:19with where the brand wants to go.
- 44:22Because an insight is yes, absolutely.
- 44:24It's about understanding the consumer needs of behavior and why, but a true, A
- 44:31brilliant insight is one which is applied to where the brand also wants to go.
- 44:37So again, going back to the example, the global brand wanted to improve the
- 44:43relationship with a teenage football player during a particular period of time.
- 44:49Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 44:51Jason Fulton: Now, the time that we actually spent with them and
- 44:54we saw their problems cannot be seen through a quantitative survey
- 44:59and an AI creating some insights.
- 45:02It can't be seen.
- 45:03Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 45:04Jason Fulton: It can be speculated on, but it can't be seen.
- 45:07The time that you spend with the people in the community, then you can see it.
- 45:10Then you can ask them directly in that moment
- 45:13Itir Eraslan: and say,
- 45:14Jason Fulton: I saw this.
- 45:14Is this true?
- 45:15Why is this true?
- 45:18Itir Eraslan: I think like what AI can replace very well is the quantitative
- 45:22part, which is like you send a survey to someone and you ask them questions.
- 45:27And now you get to like, as you said, a broader segmentation, because answering
- 45:32questions When someone is asking your online is a different thing, whereas an
- 45:37AI can really monitor the behavior online and then get out of segmentation, which
- 45:43is better than the traditional methods of doing a survey or quantitative methods.
- 45:47So I.
- 45:48Yep.
- 45:49Yep.
- 45:49I'm with you on that.
- 45:50It's can, especially for the broader segmentations can be like a good thing,
- 45:56but going deeper is something else.
- 45:59Um, I have a very recent thing that happened yesterday.
- 46:02My niece, she's 12, one of my nieces, and she's in between, you know, when
- 46:06you are 11, 12, you are becoming like a teenager, not a kid anymore.
- 46:11And she's still playing some games that she used to play when she was a kid.
- 46:15But when you look at her online behavior, she's probably spending three
- 46:20hours playing the same girly game.
- 46:23That she actually doesn't want to play.
- 46:26And I, yesterday she was asking my sister, who's also a psychiatrist.
- 46:30I don't know how she didn't do that until now, but mom, I have been
- 46:35asking you to put me screen limits and you haven't been putting that,
- 46:40and I don't want to play the same.
- 46:42Stupid girly game anymore.
- 46:44Within that time, I would maybe even prefer to play volleyball with my niece,
- 46:49with my aunt, who's here for four days.
- 46:52That is something, well, if you look at AI, probably this 12 year old.
- 46:57still playing this three hours game, a girly game, and she's quite online and
- 47:02she's quite active, although in the inner side, she wants screen limits from her
- 47:07mom, especially for that game, because she doesn't want to, you know, use that.
- 47:11So, I mean, I'm, I'm sure that everyone has this type of, um, examples in their
- 47:16life, but I think this is something that you can only Do with like a in
- 47:21size project that you have been, uh, that you are living in your work.
- 47:26Jason Fulton: And I think that, you know, kind of going back to how you
- 47:29structure a piece of research, right.
- 47:32You know, I like to think that some of the best research comes
- 47:36from diverse perspectives, right.
- 47:39And some of that is the diverse perspectives of who is it that you want to
- 47:44connect with from a consumer perspective.
- 47:46So one of those diverse perspectives is the consumer.
- 47:49Yes, even within that perspectives, there's a diversity of consumers
- 47:53in terms of, um, gender or fluid identity or ethnicity or race or
- 48:00so you have a diversity of the consumer, but the consumer is one
- 48:03perspective that you can look at, but on top of that are the other things.
- 48:08around their world.
- 48:09It could be the people who are influencing that consumer.
- 48:13So even from your example, the person who is influencing your niece is her mother.
- 48:18So bringing them into the conversation and asking them, how do you see it as a parent
- 48:25or as a partner of the target consumer?
- 48:29Tell me how you see things.
- 48:31Um, and another perspective is internally, from a client perspective.
- 48:35How do you see things within the company?
- 48:38And I think that the beauty of the ideation part, and the inside
- 48:42part, is when you start to put all of those perspectives together.
- 48:47Together, yeah.
- 48:48And again, it could be dependent on how AI is structured.
- 48:53Um, But what we tend to find when you create a quantitative piece,
- 48:58it's usually just the consumer.
- 49:02But when you do a qualitative piece, it's the consumer, plus it's this, plus it's
- 49:07this, plus it's this, plus it's this.
- 49:09And it's that beauty of the diversity of all of those different perspectives,
- 49:13Itir Eraslan: looking
- 49:15Jason Fulton: at more or less the same question, but all from a different angle.
- 49:19That's when you start to get different layers, which
- 49:23again, go towards the inside.
- 49:27So, and, and the AI in our example, anyway, or our perspective could
- 49:32be that the AI only gives you one perspective, the consumer perspective.
- 49:37Itir Eraslan: And it might enhance the work, the way we work, uh, but not
- 49:42replace, but But either transform it.
- 49:45That's how I want to see it.
- 49:46Actually, uh, I coming into our world.
- 49:49Yeah.
- 49:50Jason Fulton: I mean, wouldn't it be great when and if, as you've
- 49:55mentioned it before, when and if I already start to give, um, more
- 50:00dimensions to a consumer segmentation.
- 50:04Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 50:05Yeah.
- 50:05I mean,
- 50:05Jason Fulton: that would be great.
- 50:06Or it gives an agency like ours more to work from.
- 50:12Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 50:12Right.
- 50:12And even
- 50:13Jason Fulton: the client more to start creating from and thinking
- 50:16differently because that I think that that is all of our responsibility as
- 50:20marketers or researchers or strategists, which is how do we help our clients.
- 50:29To think differently because they want to create a different experience, a
- 50:35memento of sorts to their consumer.
- 50:40So our responsibility is to contribute to that thinking differently, not
- 50:46doing the same thing over and over and over again, that changes, nothing.
- 50:50Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 50:51Jason Fulton: But when we all hold hands on and align on what is our
- 50:56responsibility as people within marketing, it is to provide something, you know,
- 51:01amazing and unique and moves people.
- 51:06This is what we should be doing.
- 51:07This is why we're in this profession, right?
- 51:09Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 51:10Jason Fulton: Uh, and if we're not, maybe we're in the wrong profession.
- 51:15Maybe it'd be terribly provocative.
- 51:18Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 51:19Uh, to wrap up with, I have two questions that I usually ask to all of my guests.
- 51:24Uh, if you could recommend one book, what would it be?
- 51:28Jason Fulton: Yeah.
- 51:28This was really tricky question because I was thinking of a book
- 51:33that I've just been reading and I thought, oh, maybe Along those lines.
- 51:37And then, then I thought, oh no, she could be wider.
- 51:40Um, and actually it takes me to a book that I'm reading now, which is
- 51:45now the second time I'm reading it.
- 51:47I don't know whether you know Wild Swans?
- 51:50Um, it was a book written in 2019, it's about three generations of Chinese
- 51:56women, grandmother, mother, and by a woman, I have the book here and I
- 52:01want to get it right, it's Yung Chang.
- 52:04Itir Eraslan: Oh, okay.
- 52:05I haven't heard about that before, wow.
- 52:08Jason Fulton: Yeah, I remember reading it, I think, 2019, maybe
- 52:12even earlier, and what I think is so wonderful about, about this book, it's
- 52:17three generations of Chinese women.
- 52:19Itir Eraslan: It's
- 52:20Jason Fulton: written by, let's say, Not the last generation, but the most recent
- 52:25generation of Chinese looking back at their lives of their lives How they were
- 52:31informed by their mother and how the mother was informed by the grandmother
- 52:37all through the lens of You know this huge change in China from 1912 right to yeah
- 52:47at that time 2019 so it's autobiographical Through the views of these three
- 52:53women or three daughters of China.
- 52:56Wonderful book.
- 52:57Itir Eraslan: I'm gonna, I'm gonna try that.
- 53:00So, uh, when you have that book, what's your favorite coffee place in Amsterdam
- 53:05then to read that book, let's say?
- 53:08Jason Fulton: Ah, that's also a great question.
- 53:10I like to go to a place called Plek.
- 53:13P L E K K.
- 53:16I think.
- 53:17Oh, no, I think it's.
- 53:19P L L E K, PLEK.
- 53:24So PLEK is in Amsterdam North.
- 53:29It overlooks the river.
- 53:31They have a, you know, sort of man made beach.
- 53:35But the thing that I love most about it is that it has DJs.
- 53:40So on the weekend and sometimes during the week, it also has the DJs playing.
- 53:46Sort of outside on the beach,
- 53:49Itir Eraslan: so it
- 53:49Jason Fulton: gives you in Amsterdam a feeling that you're not in
- 53:52Amsterdam, that you're more like in some sort of Mediterranean country.
- 53:58And it's a wonderful place, the people are super nice.
- 54:01Yeah, a little bit.
- 54:03And if you've lived in Amsterdam where it rains.
- 54:06a heck of a lot.
- 54:08It's nice to feel like you're somewhere else.
- 54:10When I woke up this morning, it was bright sunshine.
- 54:13And then it's been raining ever since.
- 54:17Itir Eraslan: I wish.
- 54:17This is
- 54:17Jason Fulton: Amsterdam.
- 54:18Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 54:19I wish tomorrow and the other day, you're going to have a little bit of
- 54:22sunshine at least, uh, in the week.
- 54:25Me
- 54:25Jason Fulton: too.
- 54:27Itir Eraslan: Thanks so much, Jason, for being in this call.
- 54:30And, um, there are so many other questions that I want to ask you.
- 54:34And then even the insights part was like, it can, like, I had some
- 54:38other, so many questions actually.
- 54:40I couldn't bring up the words, uh, but maybe on the next
- 54:44call we are going to do that.
- 54:45Thank you so much.
- 54:46Jason Fulton: Yeah.
- 54:47Thank you.
- 54:47Thank you very much for having me.
- 54:49And I hope that your listeners are finding it