Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / The Americans with Disabilities Act: Disability Rights & Mental Health Advocacy
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine being... fired from your job, completely
- 0:03stripped of your civil rights, and then being
- 0:05told by a federal judge that the whole situation
- 0:08is perfectly legal. Right, and all just because
- 0:11the psychiatric medication you're taking is actually
- 0:13working too well. Exactly. I mean, in the 1990s,
- 0:16that was the genuinely twisted reality of the
- 0:18American legal system for people with mental
- 0:21disorders. Welcome to the psychology undergrad.
- 0:24Where we are two psychology students cracking
- 0:26open our textbooks for a deep dive into the source
- 0:29material. Yeah, today we're looking at a chapter
- 0:31called Disability Activism and the Rights of
- 0:33People with Mental Disorders. And our mission
- 0:37today is really to explore how the US legal system
- 0:41evolved to handle psychiatric disabilities, especially
- 0:44when you look at the, well, the pretty unforgiving
- 0:47environment of the criminal justice system. addressing
- 0:50you, the listener, directly here. You probably
- 0:53know that the Americans with Disabilities Act,
- 0:55the ADA, means things like wheelchair ramps or
- 0:58accessible parking. But did you know it also
- 1:01completely governs how a police officer is supposed
- 1:04to conduct an interrogation with someone experiencing
- 1:06schizophrenia? It's wild, right? So today we
- 1:09are breaking down the psychology, the history,
- 1:12and... the laws that changed literally everything.
- 1:17But, you know, to really understand the mechanics
- 1:19of those laws, we first have to look at the psychological
- 1:21and moral shift that even made them possible
- 1:24because laws don't just change until the mindset
- 1:27of a society changes first. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:29And for, like, most of modern history, society
- 1:33operated strictly on what's called the medical
- 1:35model of disability. Which is basically the framework
- 1:38that views a disability as a personal impairment,
- 1:41right? Like, a deficit that's entirely located
- 1:43within the individual's biology. Exactly. The
- 1:45medical model dictates that the individual needs
- 1:47to be cured or fixed, or, in a lot of cases,
- 1:50just hidden away. Every challenge a person faces
- 1:53is blamed directly on their specific physical
- 1:55or mental condition. OK, so I am struggling with
- 1:59this a bit, I have to admit. Because as psychology
- 2:02undergrads, I mean, we spend a massive amount
- 2:04of time studying the DSM to diagnose and treat
- 2:08symptoms. Oh, for sure. We rely heavily on the
- 2:10medical model in psych. Right. someone has severe
- 2:14treatment -resistant schizophrenia, no amount
- 2:17of societal acceptance is going to just make
- 2:19those terrifying hallucinations disappear. The
- 2:22impairment itself is intrinsically causing suffering.
- 2:26How does this new framework even account for
- 2:28that? Well, that tension right there is kind
- 2:30of central to modern psychology. The newer framework,
- 2:34the social model of disability, it actually doesn't
- 2:36deny that impairments exist or that medical treatment
- 2:39is valuable. It just differentiates between an
- 2:42impairment, which is the biological reality,
- 2:44and a disability, which is the social exclusion.
- 2:46Oh, I see. Yeah, so the social model argues that
- 2:49the environment and our societal structures are
- 2:52what actually create the disability. It shifts
- 2:55the focus from fixing the person to fixing the
- 2:59environment. Relying solely on the medical model
- 3:01becomes this huge moral issue because it places
- 3:05the entire burden of being excluded onto the
- 3:07individual. Okay, so looking at this through
- 3:10a moral lens, the medical model basically allows
- 3:13society to wash its hands of the problem entirely.
- 3:16Exactly. It just says, hey, you're broken and
- 3:18therefore you being excluded is just an unfortunate
- 3:20natural consequence. Whereas the social model
- 3:23forces society to actually take moral responsibility
- 3:27for the barriers that it builds itself. Yes,
- 3:29that is the exact shift. You know, a common memory
- 3:32trick I use for this is the concept of the left
- 3:34-handed world. Oh, I love this analogy. Right.
- 3:37So if a society only manufactures right -handed
- 3:39scissors, a left -handed person is obviously
- 3:41going to struggle to cut paper. Now, the medical
- 3:44model would say that the person's left hand is
- 3:47defective, but the social model says the scissors
- 3:50are designed exclusively for the majority, which
- 3:52creates this totally artificial barrier. Which
- 3:54makes perfect sense when you apply it to psychology.
- 3:57Right. Like, if we build an education system
- 3:59that requires eight hours of silent, motionless
- 4:02sitting every single day, we're actively creating
- 4:05an environment where a child with ADHD is inherently
- 4:08disabled by the architecture of the classroom
- 4:10itself, not just their neurobiology. And, you
- 4:13know, overturning that architecture... required
- 4:16overcoming some deeply, deeply entrenched ableism,
- 4:19which is the systemic devaluation of disabled
- 4:22people. Because the medical model dominated for
- 4:25so long, this discrimination was just entirely
- 4:27legal and completely socially acceptable. Which
- 4:30is horrifying to think about now. It really is.
- 4:32I mean, children with mental or physical disabilities
- 4:35were routinely denied public education. Adults
- 4:38were excluded from jobs. Society wasn't going
- 4:41to just voluntarily spend billions of dollars
- 4:43retrofitting buildings or rewriting policies
- 4:45because of some, you know, philosophical shift
- 4:47in a textbook. No, of course not. The transition
- 4:50to the social model required intense, relentless
- 4:53collective activism. Which brings us to the first
- 4:56major legal domino in our deep dive into the
- 4:59source material, which is Section 504 of the
- 5:02Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Right, 1973. This
- 5:06was the very first legal recognition of the civil
- 5:08rights of disabled people. Yeah, it basically
- 5:11stated that any entity receiving federal funding
- 5:13could not discriminate on the basis of disability.
- 5:16Which sounds great, right? Yeah, but Congress
- 5:18passed the law and passing a law and actually
- 5:21enforcing it are two entirely different things.
- 5:23Exactly. The executive branch looked at the massive
- 5:26economic implications of this mandate and just
- 5:28completely stalled. It's wild that it wasn't
- 5:30just one president either. Three different presidents,
- 5:33Nixon, Ford, and Carter, all just refused to
- 5:36sign the specific regulations required to actually
- 5:39implement Section 504. Three presidents. The
- 5:42government's refusal to act just created this
- 5:44massive pressure cooker. Disabled citizens realized
- 5:47that polite lobbying was totally failing. It's
- 5:50like a macro level stimulus and response, you
- 5:52know. The stimulus of systemic ableism finally
- 5:55triggered the response of undeniable physical
- 5:57protest. And that culminated in 1977 with a historic
- 6:01month -long sit -in at a federal office building
- 6:04in San Francisco. Activists like Judy Heumann
- 6:07and Kitty Cohn organized people with a really
- 6:10wide range of disabilities to literally occupy
- 6:13the building, demanding the regulations be signed.
- 6:15And all month. Yeah. And the logistics of this
- 6:18protest are just staggering, if you think about
- 6:20it. You had a marginalized group, many of whom
- 6:23required specialized medical equipment, daily
- 6:26assistance, accessible facilities, none of which
- 6:29were available in that government building. And
- 6:31they just refused to leave. And the intersectionality
- 6:34of that protest is such a crucial detail, too.
- 6:36Like, Kitty Cohn had muscular dystrophy and was
- 6:39an openly gay woman. Judy Heumann was a wheelchair
- 6:42user who had literally been denied entry to kindergarten
- 6:44because the school deemed her a fire hazard.
- 6:47A fire hazard. Just unbelievable. Unbelievable.
- 6:49And they survived that month -long occupation
- 6:52in large part because of the Black Panthers.
- 6:54Oh, right. Bradley Lomax. Yeah. Bradley Lomax,
- 6:57who was a prominent Black Panther leader and
- 6:59also had multiple sclerosis, he saw the direct
- 7:02link between the civil rights struggle for Black
- 7:04Americans and disabled Americans. The Panthers
- 7:07actually provided hot meals and supplies to the
- 7:10disabled protesters every single day. It's just
- 7:13incredible solidarity. And that physical occupation
- 7:16finally forced the government's hand. The regulations
- 7:19for Section 504 were signed. But there's always
- 7:21a but. Always. Section 504 only applied to federally
- 7:24funded entities. So private businesses, public
- 7:27transit, local municipalities, they were still
- 7:30legally allowed to discriminate all they wanted.
- 7:32Right. So activists knew they needed a much broader,
- 7:36sweeping civil rights law. Which birthed one
- 7:38of the most visceral demonstrations in American
- 7:40history, the 1990 capital crawl. Talk about a
- 7:44physical response to a stimulus. The capital
- 7:47crawl was just the ultimate, undeniable physical
- 7:49protest. It really was. Dozens of disabled activists
- 7:53left their wheelchairs and mobility aids at the
- 7:55bottom of the U .S. Capitol steps, and they physically
- 7:57dragged themselves up the stone stairs to demand
- 8:00the passage of the ADA. I mean, just imagine
- 8:03the sheer physical and moral endurance required
- 8:06to do that. Yeah. Eight -year -old Jennifer Keelan.
- 8:09who had cerebral palsy, and Maria Palacios, a
- 8:12young disabled immigrant, they literally forced
- 8:15the entire country to look directly at the reality
- 8:18of systemic physical barriers. And the visual
- 8:21impact of that protest provided the final push.
- 8:24The Americans with Disabilities Act, the ADA,
- 8:27officially passed in 1990. Finally. Yeah. Modeled
- 8:31really heavily on the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
- 8:34And it defined disability as a physical or mental
- 8:36impairment that substantially limits one or more
- 8:39major life activities. Right. And this broad
- 8:41definition explicitly included major life activities
- 8:44like walking, but also cognitive functions, like
- 8:47thinking, reading, learning, and communicating.
- 8:49Which is where we really need to unpack the legal
- 8:52mechanics, because applying a law that was so
- 8:54inspired by physical barriers, like crawling
- 8:56upstairs to invisible mental disorders, it just
- 8:59created massive judicial confusion. Yeah. I mean,
- 9:02if the text clearly included mental impairments,
- 9:04how did the courts in the 90s manage to strip
- 9:06civil rights away from people who were just seeking
- 9:08psychiatric treatment? They fixated entirely
- 9:10on the phrase substantially limits. Their legal
- 9:14logic was that an impairment had to be evaluated
- 9:16in its current present state. Okay. So if a person
- 9:20with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia was taking
- 9:22psychiatric medication, and that medication successfully
- 9:26managed their symptoms, the court basically reasoned,
- 9:29well, your major life activities are no longer
- 9:32substantially limited. Oh, wow. Yeah. So by that
- 9:35logic, the person was no longer legally disabled,
- 9:37and they completely lost all their ADA protections
- 9:40against discrimination. That is such a horrific
- 9:43catch, 22. To help remember the absurdity of
- 9:46this legal logic, I use a psycho - memory trick
- 9:49called the glasses rule. Right, the glasses rule.
- 9:51Yeah. If you have terrible eyesight but you wear
- 9:53prescription glasses, no one in their right mind
- 9:56would argue that your eyes are naturally perfect.
- 9:59If you take the glasses off, the impairment is
- 10:01obviously still there. Exactly. But the courts
- 10:03were essentially looking at someone wearing psychiatric
- 10:06glasses, meaning their medication, and ruling
- 10:09that because they could see clearly at that exact
- 10:11moment, they had no fundamental impairment. It
- 10:14was a total trap. It really was. It's completely
- 10:17twisted morality. If you took your meds, you
- 10:19lost your legal rights and could be fired for
- 10:22your psychiatric history. But if you didn't take
- 10:24your meds just to keep your ADA protections,
- 10:27you were considered willfully impaired and they
- 10:29denied you accommodations anyway. Right. The
- 10:32Supreme Court's totally flawed interpretation
- 10:34required Congress to actually intervene. The
- 10:37ADA Amendments Act of 2008 explicitly closed
- 10:41this loophole. Thank goodness. Yeah. Congress
- 10:43mandated that conditions must be evaluated in
- 10:46their unmitigated state, meaning without considering
- 10:49the ameliorative effects of medication, therapy,
- 10:52or any coping mechanisms. Which is vital for
- 10:55you, the listener, to know whether you or maybe
- 10:58someone close to you manages ADHD, PTSD, or an
- 11:01autism diagnosis with medication or therapy,
- 11:04you are fully protected under the ADA to request
- 11:06reasonable accommodations at work or at university.
- 11:08Absolutely. But let's shift to an environment
- 11:11where requesting an accommodation isn't just
- 11:13about getting extended time on an essay. It's
- 11:17about surviving an encounter with law enforcement.
- 11:19We know Title II of the ADA strictly regulates
- 11:23state and local governments. But how does this
- 11:26apply when a person is stripped of their liberty
- 11:28and enters the criminal justice system? Well,
- 11:31there's a really widespread misconception that
- 11:33constitutional and civil rights just evaporate
- 11:36the second you're arrested. Right. People assume
- 11:38you lose everything. Exactly. But the source
- 11:41material quotes future Supreme Court Justice
- 11:43Katanji Brown Jackson on this. She clarified
- 11:47that while incarceration obviously relinquishes
- 11:49many privileges, prisoners actually retain their
- 11:52civil rights against disability discrimination.
- 11:55The criminal justice system is legally obligated
- 11:58to modify its policies and procedures to accommodate
- 12:00psychiatric and cognitive disabilities. So let's
- 12:03break down the mechanics of what that actually
- 12:05looks like on the front end, like during a police
- 12:07interaction. In the sources, we encountered the
- 12:10legal concepts of wrongful arrest and failure
- 12:12to accommodate. Suppose a police officer responds
- 12:15to a disturbance and arrests someone for public
- 12:18intoxication or resisting arrest. But the individual
- 12:22is actually experiencing a schizophrenic crisis.
- 12:25The erratic behavior is just a symptom of their
- 12:27impairment. Isn't that a failure of the system's
- 12:30training? How does the ADA framework apply there?
- 12:33Under the ADA, that scenario absolutely constitutes
- 12:36a failure to accommodate, which can lead straight
- 12:39to a wrongful arrest claim. The legal mechanism
- 12:42really hinges on whether a reasonably trained
- 12:44officer should have recognized the signs of a
- 12:46disability. If an officer misinterprets the symptoms
- 12:50of an unaccommodated disability like, you know,
- 12:52disorganized speech or an inability to follow
- 12:55rapid shouted commands as willful criminal defiance,
- 12:58they are effectively punishing the disability
- 13:00itself. profound moral failure. Exactly. True
- 13:03justice requires recognizing the psychological
- 13:06reality of the individual rather than just applying
- 13:09a one -size -fits -all assumption of malicious
- 13:11intent. And when we move past the arrest phase
- 13:14and into the prison system itself, the accommodations
- 13:18take different forms. Like the Department of
- 13:21Justice recently found the state prison system
- 13:23in Minnesota in violation of the ADA. Oh, right.
- 13:26With the GED tests. Yeah. They were refusing
- 13:29to provide testing accommodations like extended
- 13:32time or quiet spaces for incarcerated individuals
- 13:35with cognitive disabilities who are taking their
- 13:38GED exams. I mean, denying an inmate the ability
- 13:41to earn an education because of their neurobiology
- 13:43actively sabotages their rehabilitation. It totally
- 13:47does. But having these rules on paper brings
- 13:50up kind of the harshest reality of our deep dive
- 13:52today. How does the system correct itself when
- 13:55the institution itself is the violator? That
- 13:58is the big question. Enforcement really relies
- 14:00on two primary avenues, government intervention
- 14:02through the Department of Justice and private
- 14:05lawsuits. On the government side, Congress passed
- 14:08the Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons
- 14:10Act, or CRIPA, back in 1980. CRIPA essentially
- 14:14empowers the DOJ to investigate and sue state
- 14:17-run facilities like prisons, juvenile detention
- 14:21centers, and state psychiatric hospitals that
- 14:23exhibit a systemic pattern of violating civil
- 14:26rights. And CRIPA was born out of profound moral
- 14:29outrage, to be clear. Oh, absolutely. It followed
- 14:32the public exposure of facilities like the Willowbrook
- 14:34State School in New York, which Senator Robert
- 14:37Kennedy famously toured. and called a snake pit.
- 14:40Just horrific conditions. Thousands of children
- 14:42with cognitive and psychiatric disabilities were
- 14:45essentially warehoused in unimaginably filthy
- 14:47conditions and even subjected to unethical medical
- 14:51experiments. CRIPA was designed specifically
- 14:53to dismantle that kind of systemic state sponsored
- 14:55abuse. And unfortunately, that tool is still
- 14:58heavily utilized today. The DOJ recently concluded
- 15:01a massive CRIPA investigation into the Parchman
- 15:03State Penitentiary down in Mississippi. The mechanics
- 15:06of the abuse they uncovered there highlight exactly
- 15:08why the ADA is so necessary in prisons. The DOJ
- 15:11found a complete failure to provide adequate
- 15:14mental health care, zero suicide prevention protocols,
- 15:17and the rampant use of prolonged solitary confinement.
- 15:20Let's dive into the psychology of that for a
- 15:22second. We know that prolonged solitary confinement
- 15:25is psychologically devastating, even for a neurotypical
- 15:28brain. Completely devastating. But for an individual
- 15:31with a pre -existing condition like schizophrenia,
- 15:33Solitary confinement isn't just a timeout. It
- 15:37actively exacerbates psychosis, paranoia, and
- 15:40hallucinations. It is the structural equivalent
- 15:43of throwing gasoline on a psychological fire.
- 15:45It really is, and the human cost is just staggering.
- 15:48Since 2019, those specific conditions at Parchman
- 15:51resulted in at least 10 homicides and 12 suicides.
- 15:54Wait, really? Just since 2019? Yes. And the DOJ
- 15:57also highlighted this really grim intersectionality
- 16:00there. 70 % of the population at Parchman is
- 16:02black, despite making up only 37 % of the state's
- 16:05population. Wow. It's just a brutal collision
- 16:08of systemic racism and the absolute criminalization
- 16:11of untreated mental illness. So legally challenging
- 16:14these catastrophic conditions often invokes the
- 16:16Eighth Amendment, right? which prohibits cruel
- 16:19and unusual punishment. Right, but to win an
- 16:22at the amendment claim regarding mental health
- 16:23care, lawyers must prove a standard known as
- 16:26deliberate indifference. Okay. This requires
- 16:30proving two components, an objective component,
- 16:33meaning the deprivation of care was sufficiently
- 16:35serious to cause real harm, and a subjective
- 16:38component, meaning the prison official actually
- 16:41knew about the substantial risk of harm and consciously
- 16:44disregarded it anyway. And proving that subjective
- 16:47knowledge that a guard or warden knew about the
- 16:50risk and just chose to do nothing is an incredibly
- 16:53high legal bar. It's notoriously difficult. I
- 16:56always link the concept of deliberate indifference
- 16:58to the moral and religious concept of the sin
- 17:00of omission. Oh, that's a really good way to
- 17:01frame it. Right, like an active sin, a sin of
- 17:04commission, would be a prison guard physically
- 17:06assaulting an inmate. Deliberate indifference
- 17:10is the sin of omission. It's not just about an
- 17:12official actively harming an inmate. It's the
- 17:14moral failure of walking past a cell, seeing
- 17:17a human being in the throes of a severe psychiatric
- 17:21crisis, knowing they are a danger to themselves
- 17:24and choosing to just look the other way. Yeah,
- 17:26you are failing to act when you have a direct
- 17:29moral and legal duty to act. Exactly. And when
- 17:32plaintiffs successfully prove deliberate indifference,
- 17:34it forces massive systemic overhauls of prison
- 17:37healthcare systems, but the DOJ does not have
- 17:41the resources to investigate every single facility.
- 17:43No, of course not. So frequently, individuals
- 17:45must fight for their own rights. Which brings
- 17:47us to a landmark moment in disability law, a
- 17:50Supreme Court case that totally redefined how
- 17:53society handles mental disorders. Olmstead, VLC.
- 17:56The story of Lois Curtis is absolutely central
- 17:59to this. Lois was a black woman with diagnoses
- 18:01of schizophrenia and an intellectual disability.
- 18:04She had actually been voluntarily admitted for
- 18:06psychiatric treatment at a state -run hospital
- 18:09in Georgia when she was just 11 years old. Just
- 18:12a kid. Yeah. And the really tragic mechanism
- 18:15of her case was that her treating physicians
- 18:17eventually determined she was stable. They said
- 18:20she was fully capable of living in the community
- 18:22with support. But the state of Georgia just refused
- 18:25to fund community -based care programs. They
- 18:28opted instead to keep her literally locked in
- 18:31the institution for years after she was medically
- 18:34cleared to leave. Which is essentially warehousing
- 18:36humans. So Lois Curtis, along with Elaine Wilson,
- 18:40sued the state commissioner, Tommy Olmsted, under
- 18:43Title II of the ADA. And their legal argument
- 18:45was so profound. They argued that keeping individuals
- 18:48segregated in a psychiatric hospital, total removed
- 18:51from everyday society when they were completely
- 18:53capable of community life, was a form of systemic
- 18:56disability discrimination. And in 1999, the Supreme
- 18:59Court actually ruled in their favor. Yeah. Justice
- 19:01Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote the majority opinion,
- 19:04and the psychological insight in her ruling is
- 19:06really striking. What'd you say? She stated that
- 19:08unjustified institutional isolation perpetuates
- 19:12the unwarranted assumption that people with disabilities
- 19:15are incapable or unworthy of participating in
- 19:19community life. Wow. Yeah, the Supreme Court
- 19:22essentially ruled that warehousing human beings
- 19:24for administrative convenience is not just bad
- 19:27policy, it's a direct violation of their civil
- 19:30rights. The Olmstead decision really mandated
- 19:33that public entities must provide community -based
- 19:36services to persons with disabilities when those
- 19:39services are appropriate, the affected persons
- 19:41don't oppose it, and it can be reasonably accommodating.
- 19:45It fundamentally established that people with
- 19:46mental disorders have a right to integration,
- 19:49not segregation. And if you look at what Lois
- 19:52Curtis did with her freedom, you see the ultimate
- 19:55moral victory of this legislation. After leaving
- 19:58the institution, she became an artist. I love
- 20:00this part of her story. She even presented one
- 20:02of her paintings to President Barack Obama at
- 20:04the White House. And when she was asked what
- 20:06she wished for all the people she helped free
- 20:08from institutionalization, her answer wasn't
- 20:10about complex legal precedents or policy. She
- 20:13simply hoped they could have their own place,
- 20:15learn new things, visit friends, drink coffee,
- 20:18and have a good breakfast every day. Her fight
- 20:21wasn't just for a legal precedent. It was for
- 20:23the simple human right. to live in the community
- 20:26and participate in the mundane beauty of everyday
- 20:28life. Which is just incredibly powerful. The
- 20:32evolution from the medical model's focus on isolation
- 20:35to the social model's demand for integration
- 20:38really demonstrates that the law is not static.
- 20:41It's this living mechanism that must be constantly
- 20:44sharpened and wielded to protect vulnerable populations,
- 20:47particularly when their neurobiology intersects
- 20:50with systems designed primarily for punishment
- 20:52rather than rehabilitation. Which really brings
- 20:54us to a final lingering thought for you to mull
- 20:56over as we wrap up. We've tracked the shift from
- 21:00blaming the individual's biology to holding the
- 21:03environment accountable. Yep. The shift to the
- 21:05social model. Right. So if the social model of
- 21:08disability teaches us that the environment is
- 21:11what actually creates the disability, what does
- 21:13it say about the architectural and psychological
- 21:16design of our entire society that so many people
- 21:19with mental disorders inevitably end up in the
- 21:21criminal justice system? That's a heavy question.
- 21:23Are our overcrowded prisons simply evidence of
- 21:26a society that refuses to build the necessary
- 21:28psychological ramps? Thank you for joining us
- 21:31on The Psychology Undergrad. Keep questioning
- 21:33the systems around you.