Latest / Consumerpedia / 83 - Tips for Buying a New, Used, or Electric Car
Transcript
- 0:02New car prices continue to go up.
- 0:04According to the latest data from Kelley Blue Book, the
- 0:07average new car buyer paid about $48,600 in February.
- 0:11The average electric vehicle buyer paid 55,000, And with the
- 0:16threat of tariffs looming, sticker prices could go even
- 0:19higher, thousands more per vehicle in the next few months.
- 0:23If you're in the market for a new set of wheels, you really
- 0:26need to do your homework. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:29Man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:32Welcome to Consumerpedia at checkbook.org.
- 0:35We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:38trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:41advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:45can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:48objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:51Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man Herb
- 0:55Weisspaum. In this episode, the top picks
- 0:58and the latest reliability ratings from Consumer Reports.
- 1:01Also, advice for anyone in the market for an electric vehicle.
- 1:05Do you still need to worry about charging stations and why used
- 1:08car prices are going to cost even more this year?
- 1:11We've got a lot of ground to cover.
- 1:13Let's start with my good friend Mike Quincy from Consumer
- 1:16Reports Autos. Hey, Mike.
- 1:17Hey, how's it going today? Great for those listening.
- 1:20I've known Mike for about 25 years now.
- 1:22You've helped us with all sorts of car stories and it's great to
- 1:26have you on the podcast again. It's good to be your Consumer
- 1:28Reports car guy. You helped me buy my last two
- 1:30vehicles, by the way. So for this year's auto issue,
- 1:33CR rated cars from 32 brands on reliability, owner satisfaction,
- 1:37safety and road test scores. This makes it easy for buyers to
- 1:40see which brands shine and which they might want to avoid.
- 1:43The top five remain unchanged from last year's results, but
- 1:47there is one significant shift. Subaru claimed the top spot from
- 1:51BMW by a single point in its overall score.
- 1:54Tell us about that. Subaru became really the number
- 1:57one brand and Consumer Reports brand reliability rankings
- 2:00mostly because they do pretty conservative redesigns.
- 2:03They're not bringing in new powertrains, they're not
- 2:06bringing in new platforms. The Subaru Forester has just
- 2:10been redesigned. And again, it's not a radical
- 2:12redesigned. They're using tried and true
- 2:14engines and transmissions. Certainly the styling looks the
- 2:17same. These are the things that have
- 2:19made Subaru do so well in Consumer Reports testing as well
- 2:22as reliability surveys because they're not bringing in a whole
- 2:25new engine, they're not doing lots of EVs, they're not doing
- 2:28plug in hybrids. So they're kind of sticking to
- 2:30what they know works. Lexus moves from 5th to 3rd
- 2:33place, CR says, not through its own improvements, but because
- 2:37Porsche and Honda slid slightly. Lexus is usually one of those
- 2:41top performers. The real stalwarts, the the
- 2:43Lexus RX, it only got an average reliability ranking, Consumer
- 2:47Reports reliability surveys. Now for a lot of car companies,
- 2:51they think average will that's not too bad, But for Lexus that
- 2:54is way below par. So that's one of the reasons
- 2:57that Lexus has dropped a bit. So Audi was a big mover this
- 3:00year, climbing 6 spots, has to be ranked number six and many in
- 3:03Acura lost positions due to lower predicted reliability
- 3:07scores. Yeah, Audi, in some ways is kind
- 3:09of taking a page out of the Subaru playbook, and that's
- 3:12they're not radically redesigning their cars.
- 3:14And a lot of their models are older designs, the A4, the A3,
- 3:18the A6. These cars have been around for
- 3:20a while, and this really allows companies like Audi to kind of
- 3:23work out the bugs. The general mindset among
- 3:26Consumer Reports reliability advice, I guess if you want to
- 3:29call it that, is don't buy a new car bar in its first design.
- 3:33And as you know, I mentioned a lot of the Audi lineup has been
- 3:36around for a while and has, you know, really worked the bugs
- 3:40out. A few more noteworthy changes
- 3:41this year. Buick slid 4 places to 17th
- 3:44because of lower Rd. test scores.
- 3:46They don't. Have a super exciting lineup.
- 3:48They did introduce a few new models and with that comes some
- 3:51teething issues that you know a first model your design is going
- 3:55to bring. But if you're kind of rooting
- 3:56for Detroit, you're rooting for the home team.
- 3:58Buick is the top. Domestic brand Cadillac tumbled
- 4:02seven spots, landed 21st and that was due mainly to the well
- 4:05below average reliability of its Lyric EV.
- 4:07Yeah, that is really a problem that is throughout the General
- 4:11Motors lineup. They're having just a devil of a
- 4:14time working out the bugs with their electric vehicles.
- 4:17Certainly in Consumer Reports experience, the Lyric and the
- 4:21Blazer EV in Consumer Reports test fleet, we've seen a lot of
- 4:25issues. But just a reminder for all of
- 4:26your listeners out there, Consumer Reports does not base
- 4:29reliability on our one, you know, sample people of our test
- 4:32car. Instead, based on hundreds of
- 4:35thousands of responders in Consumer Reports reliability.
- 4:38Surveys and at the back of the pack, and I mean back, the
- 4:41lowest rated brands, GMC, Land Rover, Rivian and Stellanis
- 4:45brands, Alfa Romeo, Dodge and Jeep.
- 4:47Well, in some ways it's not too surprising with Rivian, they are
- 4:51still a pretty new startup. They have not mastered the art
- 4:54of mass production. When we're talking about new
- 4:57designs, usually showing to have more reliability issues, every
- 5:02thing in Rivian is new. So if you want to be an early
- 5:05adopter, that's one thing. You want to be the first on your
- 5:08block to have the brand new Rivian or the brand new
- 5:11whatever. You kind of got to roll the dice
- 5:13here because it's better to wait a couple more years before, you
- 5:17know, a company like Rivian figures out the methodology of
- 5:20building reliable. Models.
- 5:21When we've talked about this before, you've always reminded
- 5:24me that even high scoring brands can have low scoring models.
- 5:27For example, the Toyota Camry is a clear winner, while Toyota
- 5:31Tacoma poorly for Rd. tests and predicted reliability.
- 5:34Right now, I don't. I don't mean to sound like a
- 5:36broken record, but the Tacoma is a brand new redesign and it
- 5:40turned out to be below average in our reliability surveys.
- 5:44The BZ 4X, which is the weirdest name for an electric vehicle
- 5:48I've ever heard of, is Toyota's EV that is also turned out to be
- 5:51below average. And while the Tundra, Toyota's
- 5:54big pickup truck, has been out for a couple years, they're
- 5:56still having issues with their reliability.
- 5:59So kind of uncharacteristic of Toyota to have even any models
- 6:03in our below average ranking. So let's move on to what
- 6:05everyone looks for every year in the annual auto issue.
- 6:08The top models of the year, your top picks.
- 6:10First of all, let's explain how these are picked.
- 6:13When you test cars. I've watched you do this up at
- 6:15the test track in Connecticut. You really push vehicles to
- 6:18limits for steering and braking and check those safety features
- 6:22as well as just drive them around for a long time.
- 6:24Yeah, that's kind of the how we get things done here.
- 6:27As as you and everyone out there knows, Consumer Reports buys its
- 6:30own test cars. We don't get get anything free
- 6:32from the manufacturers. We put about 2000 break in miles
- 6:36on all of our test cars to make sure they're operating at peak
- 6:38efficiency. Then we take them off the road
- 6:41and bring them to our track. All of our over 50 instrumented
- 6:44testing and including handling breaking fuel economy, we
- 6:48measured noise. We get a jury of of testers
- 6:51together. We talk about seat comfort, we
- 6:53go over the controls and infotainment system.
- 6:55And really what we're looking at with Consumer Reports top picks
- 6:59is the best of the best. These are the vehicles that
- 7:02really rose to the top of our rankings.
- 7:03So some of this is subjective, such as comfort judged by a
- 7:06number of people, and some of this is clearly objective, how
- 7:09well the brakes did, the acceleration, that sort of
- 7:11thing. Exactly.
- 7:12And we're also looking at high levels of standard safety
- 7:16features for, for a vehicle to be a top pick, it has to come
- 7:19standard with automatic emergency braking that works at
- 7:21both low speeds with pedestrian detection and at highway speeds.
- 7:25So it it isn't so much that a vehicle might do well in our
- 7:28testing, it still has to come through in the safety front.
- 7:31And these vehicles on the top ten pick list all had high
- 7:34scores for owner satisfaction and predicted reliability.
- 7:36And it's interesting to note that you don't have to break the
- 7:39bank to get many of these models.
- 7:41I was really surprised me this small car winner Nissan Sentra
- 7:44starts MSRP at 21 five. Exactly.
- 7:47You shouldn't just have to pay through the nose to get a great
- 7:50car. And the Sentra is one of those
- 7:52great examples. It got about 32 miles per gallon
- 7:56overall in Consumer Reports testing, which is, you know,
- 7:59great because it is a small sort of economy car.
- 8:01But what Nissan did is they put a lot of time and effort into
- 8:05tightening up the chassis. It handles really well.
- 8:08I'm not going to say it's like a BMW3 series sports sedan, but it
- 8:11will definitely surprise you just how responsive the steering
- 8:14is. The controls are super easy.
- 8:17It's a simple car to live with. And I'm really glad that in our
- 8:20world of super complicated cars, you have a vehicle like the
- 8:24Nissan Sentra that just anyone could get in and in within 30
- 8:27seconds they can operate all the controls.
- 8:29The top pick for mid sized car, the Toyota Camry.
- 8:32This should be a. Surprise to no one, the Camry
- 8:34has been a top performer for decades.
- 8:36But the big news of the Camry is that all models are now hybrid
- 8:40powered. That's a great way for people to
- 8:42kind of ease into electrification.
- 8:44And the the magic number here is 48 miles per gallon overall and
- 8:49Consumer Reports testing about $32,000 for like an SC trim like
- 8:54we tested that comes really well equipped and the handling will
- 8:57surprise you. People think Camry is boring?
- 9:00Definitely not a boring car to drive.
- 9:02If you're in the sedan market, definitely give the Camry a try.
- 9:05It'll probably surprise you just how good it is.
- 9:07Well, I have a Camry. Actually, I have two because of
- 9:09you. Best people I've ever had.
- 9:11Glad it didn't steer you wrong. I get it.
- 9:13Steer me wrong. That was very clever, Mike.
- 9:16You know. Let's move into the SUV
- 9:18category. Sub packed SUV.
- 9:19The top pick was the Subaru Crosstrek.
- 9:22Yes, Subaru is all over Consumer Reports top picks, as well as
- 9:25the brand reliability rankings. The Crosstrek got a recent
- 9:29redesign and it continues to be a solid sort of urban runabout.
- 9:34There's a little bit higher ground clearance, so if you live
- 9:36where it snows, you've got standard all all-wheel drive to
- 9:40pull you out about 29 miles per gallon.
- 9:42Over on Consumer Reports testing a decently equipped model comes
- 9:46at around $28,000, which really isn't bad considering that the
- 9:50price of a new car hovers around $48,000.
- 9:54So when you're looking for a vehicle that's comfortable and
- 9:56really good in all kinds of weather, I definitely check out
- 9:59the Cross. Track and for compact SUV it's a
- 10:01Subaru Forester. And here we are with Subaru once
- 10:04again. Subaru was very careful in their
- 10:06redesign to the Forester. They didn't want to break what
- 10:09was really working. And one of the great things
- 10:11about the Forester is it has really superb visibility when
- 10:16you're sitting in the driver's seat.
- 10:17The front roof pillars are not very thick, the rear roof
- 10:20pillars are not very thick. There's lots of glass area all
- 10:22around, and the seat is sort of at hip height when you go to sit
- 10:26into it. And the reason I'm bringing this
- 10:28up is if people in in your audience have parents that are
- 10:31getting a little bit older, but they're still driving.
- 10:34The Forester is one of those models where we always recommend
- 10:36for older drivers because of good visibility, because it's
- 10:40easy to get in and out of. It's super reliable at 29 miles
- 10:43per gallon. Overall, the Forester is really
- 10:46an easy vehicle to recommend. And for mid sized SUV it's a
- 10:49Toyota Highlander Hybrid. The Highlander hybrid has long
- 10:53been kind of a really good family vehicle and my family, I
- 10:56mean, it's bigger than a Rav 4, but it's not so big that you're
- 11:00driving around a huge tank. We got 35 miles per gallon
- 11:03overall for the hybrid model. And if you're a road trip guy
- 11:07like me, what that translates to is to a near 600 mile day of
- 11:11driving before you have to fill up.
- 11:13And that really gets me going. I love the highway cruising
- 11:17ability of this model. It has tons of safety features.
- 11:21Yeah, every year. It's just always seems to come
- 11:23around to be a top pick. If you need a family sized
- 11:26vehicle, definitely check out the Highlander.
- 11:28Small pickup. It's the Ford Maverick and
- 11:30Maverick Hybrid. Ford has definitely figured this
- 11:32out. We love especially the hybrid
- 11:35model still puts out about 190 wood horsepower so it can get
- 11:39out of its own way, but this is the real kicker. 37 miles per
- 11:42gallon overall in Consumer Reports testing for even a small
- 11:45pickup truck that's amazing. It has simple controls, very
- 11:49easy to live with. The last time I checked Ford
- 11:52just can't even keep these in in stock.
- 11:54So if you want a small I mean not everyone needs a huge 2500
- 11:58series or 1500 series pickup truck.
- 12:00For most homeowners, a small pickup truck like the Maverick
- 12:03will absolutely get everything you need to get done on the
- 12:06weekends. And finally, electric vehicle.
- 12:09That was the Tesla Model Y, the model.
- 12:11Y is the lone electric vehicle on consumer ports top picks
- 12:14list, not the. The weren't other worthy models,
- 12:17but none of them combines the performance and the reliability
- 12:20of the model. Y gets about 311 mile cruising
- 12:24range. Of course, depending on the
- 12:25weather. If it's colder, you're going to
- 12:27get a little bit less, but for about $50,000 you're getting a
- 12:30dose of luxury. Practicality.
- 12:32Tesla really knows how to dial in a superb chassis.
- 12:35This This car has really good handling.
- 12:37Feels more like a sports car than a sedan.
- 12:40You have lots of convenience items inside.
- 12:43There's lots of places to store things.
- 12:45If you want to go all electric, definitely check out the model
- 12:48Y. And Mike, I need to say this
- 12:49because some people just don't want to buy Tesla's right now
- 12:52for political reasons. There are five other EVs on CRS
- 12:55recommended list that earned higher overall scores than the
- 12:59Model Y. The BMW I4 and I5, Porsche Tycan
- 13:03Ionic 6, Genesis GV 60 and the Kia EV9 had the same overall
- 13:08score as the Model Y73. Excellent point, glad you
- 13:12brought. That up, we couldn't cover all
- 13:1310, but you'll find all the top picks at Consumer Reports
- 13:16website, consumerreports.org, or in their new auto issue,
- 13:20something I look forward to every year.
- 13:22Up next, more about EVs, a look at what's new and electric
- 13:25vehicles, CRS, latest advice on range anxiety, and an update on
- 13:29EV reliability. I'm Herb Weisbaum, and this is
- 13:32Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 13:35Sooner or later, your car will need some repair work.
- 13:38Checkbook has ratings for hundreds of auto repair shops in
- 13:41these metro areas, Boston, Chicago, Minneapolis, Saint
- 13:45Paul, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Seattle, and
- 13:49Washington DC. If you live in or around one of
- 13:52these seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us
- 13:54out. Get a free 30 day subscription
- 13:57with access to all of our ratings by going to
- 13:59checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. So as we just discussed, the
- 14:04Tesla Model Y was CRS top pick for electric vehicle, but there
- 14:08are a dozen 2025 EV models on your recommended list.
- 14:11Quite a selection now, Mike, from the Key and Nero in the
- 14:14$40,000 price range to the Porsche Tican that starts at 100
- 14:18grand and goes up to $230,000. You can get an electric BMW,
- 14:22Audi, Hyundai and Genesis and they all had overall scores
- 14:26higher than the Tesla. So a lot of selection coming to
- 14:28this marketplace, Mike. Yeah, I mean, the trick that the
- 14:31automakers are facing thing is how can they actually make a
- 14:35profit selling EVs? The development costs are very
- 14:39high and that is one of the reasons why most EVs are super
- 14:44expensive. Now, as we talked about the
- 14:46Tesla Model Y being a top pick, you can get into an EV for less
- 14:51money. For example, the Tesla Model 3
- 14:53starts around $42,500 before tax credits and that could drop it
- 14:58down to the mid 30s. And we just bought a Chevrolet
- 15:01Equinox EV for our Tesla fleet, which costs us about $35,000.
- 15:05So there's definitely something for everyone.
- 15:07A lot of people who want to go electric have range anxiety.
- 15:10Will they be able to find a charger on the road when they
- 15:13need 1? And in the new auto issue, see
- 15:15our editor Keith Berry writes Those worries are not unfounded.
- 15:19Although most modern EVs have a range of over 250 miles on a
- 15:22full battery, and the number of public chargers has more than
- 15:25doubled since 2020, charging 1 still requires more time and
- 15:28planning than filling up a gas tank.
- 15:31The pros at our Auto Test Center in Chester, Connecticut have
- 15:34been driving and evaluating EVs for more than a decade.
- 15:37Their first piece of advice? If you can't charge at home and
- 15:40EV might not be for you. I was greatly surprised to read
- 15:43that. I think a lot of people get
- 15:45wrapped up with the idea of an EV because you're not buying
- 15:50gasoline and they want to do something different.
- 15:53But Keith is is right on the money.
- 15:55I mean, one of the reasons to consider buying a Tesla is they
- 15:59have a supercharging network throughout the country, which is
- 16:03really good. It's very robust.
- 16:06But the public infrastructure is definitely an issue.
- 16:10There are a number of places where you can publicly charge
- 16:13your EV, but there might be a waiting line.
- 16:16Half the time the chargers don't even work.
- 16:19You're kind of walking a tightrope if you're just relying
- 16:22on an EV for your sole means of transportation, especially if
- 16:26you go on any kind of a road trip.
- 16:28It's kind of a big ask. But if you're going to have an
- 16:30EV in your household, it's probably a good, good idea to
- 16:33also have an old fashioned internal combustion engine
- 16:36vehicle as well, just in case you want to go on a longer trip.
- 16:40We're getting there, but we're not.
- 16:42There yet and something folks should know.
- 16:44EVs are getting more reliable but based on your tests they
- 16:47still lag behind hybrids and gas only cars for reliability. 100%
- 16:52correct. On average, EVs now have about
- 16:5542% more problems than internal combustion cars, but that is
- 16:58down from 79% from the previous year.
- 17:02So as we talked about, when we consider vehicle overall
- 17:06reliability and we go then to EV reliability, it's still not as
- 17:11good as internal combustion, but it is getting better.
- 17:14It's interesting because they're not as many parts, but I guess
- 17:17it's just because it's a totally new design for an engine is that
- 17:20that's why we're having the problems.
- 17:21In Consumer Reports reliability surveys, owners are reporting
- 17:24powertrain issues and EV charging malfunctions.
- 17:28I mean, the ability, for example, for the vehicles
- 17:30themselves to accept the charge, not the EV.
- 17:33These charges, reliability, they're also non EV components
- 17:37that are giving owners fits. There's infotainment, electronic
- 17:40features, and that's endemic to all kinds of vehicles, whether
- 17:44they're hybrids, plug in hybrids or regular gas metal cars.
- 17:47Electronic gremlins are one of the biggest complaints in
- 17:50Consumer Reports reliability surveys, and EVs aren't immune
- 17:53to that. Yeah, that's a really important
- 17:55point. These cars today are rolling
- 17:56computers and everything in the cockpit is electronic.
- 17:59You're finding a that they're not always easy to use when each
- 18:02sort of them out with your own people and #2 that in real life
- 18:05they're having reliability problems and the.
- 18:07Problem is that so much of the car's functionality is centered
- 18:12around this big screen. I mean, it can control your
- 18:15climate system. It can control your navigation
- 18:17system in some models, it controls your adjustments for
- 18:21all the active safety features. So relying on a screen and
- 18:25people are kind of dazzled by like, oh, I want a car that has
- 18:28what looks like an iPad. And it doesn't really matter if
- 18:31it makes sense or not, but they're all doing it anyway.
- 18:34So we've got all these touch screens and some work better
- 18:36than others. But the question in my mind, I
- 18:39think is, are these touch screens going to be functioning
- 18:42in 10 years, In 20 years? People keep their cars longer.
- 18:45If there's anything you want to know about cars, new used,
- 18:48hybrid, electric, gasoline powered, how to buy one, what to
- 18:52look for, head to consumerreports.org, the
- 18:55Consumer Reports website. You will find it there.
- 18:57Mike Quincy is with Consumer Reports autos.
- 19:00Michael, it is always a pleasure to talk to you in a lot of fun.
- 19:02Thanks spending time with us. Thanks for having me on.
- 19:04You know, for some a new car is a budget Buster.
- 19:07They need to buy a used vehicle straight ahead.
- 19:09A look at the used car market with an expert at Edmunds and
- 19:12how to make sure you're getting a good pre owned vehicle.
- 19:15I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumer Pedia
- 19:19powered by checkbook.org. Consumer Pedia.
- 19:23Fast Facts. These come from
- 19:25historyfacts.com. German engineer Carl Benz is
- 19:29credited with designing the first practical modern vehicle
- 19:32back in 1885, the Benz Patent Motor Wagon, a three Wheeler
- 19:37with a 1 1/2 horsepower internal combustion engine, top speed 10
- 19:41mph. Back in the 1920s, when cars
- 19:44were still a luxury item, a brand new Model T Ford sold for
- 19:48$290.00. That would be about $5000 today,
- 19:52a century before the Toyota Prius debuted in 1990, 27
- 19:55Ferdinand Porsche, who later founded the venerable sports car
- 19:59company, developed a hybrid gas electric vehicle.
- 20:02It was called the Semper Vivus, Latin for always alive.
- 20:08Used car prices are also getting more expensive.
- 20:10The average price paid for a three-year old vehicle in the
- 20:13fourth quarter of last year was $29,700 according to Edmonds 29
- 20:19seven. And used car prices are expected
- 20:21to continue going up this year. Here to discuss the used car
- 20:24market, the director of insights at Edmonds, Ivan Jewelry, who is
- 20:27joining us from Hawaii. Hello, Ivan.
- 20:29Aloha, hey. Eric, how you doing?
- 20:31Good. Thanks so much for being with
- 20:32us. No problem, I'm happy to be on.
- 20:34So you recently wrote for used car shoppers who held off on a
- 20:38purchase with hopes of a more stable market and stronger
- 20:41discounts, 2025 could prove to be a challenging environment
- 20:44from both selection and pricing perspectives.
- 20:47What's going on? Well, we've got a few things to
- 20:49contend with when it comes to used car shopping.
- 20:51I mean it hasn't been, let's call it normal since 2019, like
- 20:56many things in life. But in 2025, just when we think
- 20:59things are going to become, you know, kind of normal, we've got
- 21:02a supply side issue that is rather huge.
- 21:04There's going to be a deficit of off lease vehicles into the tune
- 21:08of millions of units. And then there's The X Factor of
- 21:12will there or won't there be tariffs?
- 21:14And on top of that, if so, how high are we talking?
- 21:18So we have a few different dynamics that really could shake
- 21:21up the used market and make buying a vehicle a lot more
- 21:24difficult. You know, you really have to do
- 21:26a lot more homework. And when it comes to homework, I
- 21:28mean really penning out, how much can you afford and is this
- 21:31the right time to buy? People have been holding on to
- 21:34their cars longer and I would assume as the prices of new cars
- 21:37go up and especially if there's a gigantic increase because of
- 21:40tariffs, they'll hold on to their cars longer, which will
- 21:43mean even fewer used vehicles on the market.
- 21:45This is 100% true. We've seen that the holdout
- 21:47buyer has essentially stayed on that sideline since, you know,
- 21:512020-2021. The average age of the vehicle
- 21:55being traded in just keeps going up and up and up.
- 21:58And that's because people are coming back to the market
- 22:00whether or not their loan is paid off.
- 22:02You know, it's been 6 years, five years, whatever.
- 22:05They're seeing stuff they don't like.
- 22:06For those who have an option, the best decision has been not
- 22:10indecision but staying away. But they can only hold out for
- 22:13so long. Now, the problem is that when
- 22:15you come back to the market today, it's nothing like you've
- 22:18seen before, right? You are not going to get the
- 22:21same vehicle, the same price as what you're accustomed to.
- 22:24This is something in which first time buyers, no context, things
- 22:28don't feel as bad. But if you've been buying for,
- 22:31you know, two or three decades, you have a certain set of
- 22:34expectations on price. Those won't be met.
- 22:36And let's factor in the cost of borrowing money.
- 22:39NerdWallet just released a report that in the fourth
- 22:41quarter of 2024, the overall average auto loan interest rate
- 22:45was 6.35 for new cars and 11.62 for used cars.
- 22:50Yikes. Yeah.
- 22:51I mean, when you're talking about interest rates, these are
- 22:54rates that people not seen in a very long time.
- 22:57And especially when you look at the average transaction price,
- 23:01you know of a new car close to 48, $8000.
- 23:04When you look at how much you're going to spend in interest over
- 23:07the life of the loan, you're looking at like 9 to 10K in
- 23:10finance charges alone. And then on the used end, right,
- 23:14with interest rates being higher, and even though
- 23:16transaction prices are lower, it's still in some cases, we're
- 23:19looking at the average nearly 10 to $11,000.
- 23:22So, you know, when you're buying a car, how much car are you
- 23:25actually buying versus are you just paying for the right to
- 23:28borrow? What about used electric
- 23:30vehicles? Is there much of A supply of the
- 23:32used EV market? We are seeing quite the uptick.
- 23:35Back in 2021-2022, there were starting to see some vehicles,
- 23:40you know, hit the market that weren't just Teslas, right?
- 23:42You start to have the Korean automakers, you have Ford,
- 23:45Volkswagen, Porsche. So as far as selection goes, not
- 23:50only is it a volume thing, but it's a brand thing.
- 23:53Like if you are very loyal to a certain brand, then now you can
- 23:56actually get a vehicle from that automaker.
- 24:00It's one of those things where the residual values too, they've
- 24:03never been good used vehicles, especially EVs.
- 24:06It's one of those things where, you know, automakers, they know
- 24:09this too. You know, it's like any other
- 24:11piece of tech out there. The better things get, the worse
- 24:15they are for the used version. EVs come with at least a 10 year
- 24:19100,000 mile warranty on the battery pack.
- 24:21Even so, would it be a good idea to have that battery pack
- 24:24checked before you buy the vehicle?
- 24:26And is that something that's easy to do?
- 24:28Yeah, that's something in which depend, depending on what
- 24:30vehicle you're looking at, it could be something that's
- 24:32already within that infographic large screen that you can kind
- 24:36of check right off the bat. One tells you how much can it
- 24:39charge to how reduces the range versus when it was new.
- 24:42It'll vary in complexity depending on the vehicle type,
- 24:45but for the most part, you want to know those numbers anyway.
- 24:49You want to know how close you are to flirting with a full
- 24:52battery replacement or if you're looking at something like, oh,
- 24:55you know what? We could be going like another
- 24:57eight years, 10 years, 12 years, things of that nature.
- 25:00So, you know, it's something that you don't consider as much
- 25:04when it comes to an ICE vehicle. But when it comes to EVs, yeah,
- 25:09there is that kind of known element that the more I use this
- 25:12vehicle, the way I charge it, the type of charging that I
- 25:15apply to it, the conditions I drive it in does have an adverse
- 25:20effect on its longevity. So really it is something that
- 25:24you do want to be kind of top of mind because replacing
- 25:27batteries, it's not cheap, it's not easy.
- 25:29The number one tip I have shared for decades, based on years and
- 25:34years of experience of dealing with people who've had horror
- 25:37stories, is you cannot buy a used vehicle, even if it's
- 25:40called certified pre certified, whatever it's called, unless you
- 25:44have a check by an independent mechanic first.
- 25:46You have no idea what kind of problems you might be buying,
- 25:49and once you buy it, it's yours. Yeah, this is true.
- 25:51I mean, Peace of Mind should be top of mind.
- 25:54And it's one of these things where a little bit of money
- 25:57upfront, let's let's call it a lot of it money, right.
- 25:59If 2 or $300.00, like depending on who's your mechanic, you know
- 26:03how long it's going to take them complexity vehicle, how
- 26:06thoroughly you want them to check it.
- 26:08You know, it's one of these things that buying a used car is
- 26:11a gamble, It's a risk. Every single one of them is
- 26:14different. I don't care where they're
- 26:15sourced from. It doesn't ever get treated the
- 26:18same. And that is something that you
- 26:20want someone else who knows more than you do to have a look at a
- 26:24minimum to assuage some of your fears and your some of your
- 26:27concerns. It can stop you from making a
- 26:30decision that can become very costly down the road.
- 26:33I know people who have bought vehicles that were relatively
- 26:36new but were mishandled upon their first go around with their
- 26:41owner or owners, and even vehicles below 60,000 miles that
- 26:45have had full motor rebuilds, transmission replacements.
- 26:48And we're not talking about cheap stuff either.
- 26:50So it's something in which independent inspection is good.
- 26:54It's not going to catch every single thing under the sun, but
- 26:57it's going to catch most stuff. And don't assume a car fax check
- 27:00is enough because if it wasn't reported to insurance it
- 27:03wouldn't be on Carfax. So that car could have been in
- 27:06an accident which makes it safe to drive, and you'd never know
- 27:09unless a mechanic took a look and spotted the problem.
- 27:11This is 100% true. There are so many instances in
- 27:15which you can see that someone would not want to report
- 27:18something right? They don't want to Ding their
- 27:19insurance. It might be deemed too minor by
- 27:23their mindset, but they're probably not somebody that works
- 27:26in the automotive industry and has intricate knowledge of the
- 27:29sensors and the safety equipment around that.
- 27:32They say well visually it looks fine but in reality there could
- 27:36be a lot of damage back there. So you know looking at Carfax
- 27:40supports while it is very helpful, you have to remember it
- 27:43can't 100% rule out any potential damage.
- 27:47I've seen conflicting reports in the past where even a vehicle is
- 27:51broken into and it was reported to the police it was on a one
- 27:55company's report and not on another.
- 27:57I've even bought a vehicle that I knew was salvage titled in one
- 28:00state but was not deemed salvage title in another state where I
- 28:04was driving it. But you really do have to get
- 28:07used cars vetted. And if they won't let you do it,
- 28:09run away from the lot as quickly as you can.
- 28:11Yeah, I mean, there's always something when someone's not
- 28:14willing to be forthcoming or, you know, really upfront with
- 28:18you. It's it's the whole Spidey
- 28:19census thing. Ivan Drury is director of
- 28:21insights at Edmunds. If you're looking to buy a new
- 28:24or used vehicle or sell your used car, you want to head to
- 28:27edmunds.com to get a whole lot of information.
- 28:29Ivan, it was really nice talking to you.
- 28:31Thank you for spending time with us today.
- 28:33Yeah. I had a great time and love to
- 28:34come back. Looking forward to it.
- 28:36Well, that's it for this edition of Consumer Pedia.
- 28:38We hope you'll rate the episode and follow us on Apple Podcasts,
- 28:42Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 28:45Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 28:48Another way you can support this show is to follow us on Consumer
- 28:51Pedia on Facebook book and Instagram and at my
- 28:54Consumerpedia on X, formerly Twitter.
- 28:57I'm Herb Weisbaum. Thank you for listening.
- 29:00Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 29:03We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 29:06smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 29:08help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 29:12ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 29:15If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 29:17Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 29:22Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Seattle, San Francisco, and
- 29:26Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 29:28subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumerpedia.
- 29:32Consumerpedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 29:35money and make smarter choices.