Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Answering 9 Questions About The Michigan Sign-Stealing Scandal
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going? Oh, Tony,
- 0:10it's a Michigan Monday, and Michigan didn't play over the weekend, so
- 0:16you had a great idea, which is why didn't We didn't even ask people
- 0:20for Michigan questions. We just said what questions do you have? And it
- 0:23turns out, Tony, they have some questions about Michigan, the Michigan football
- 0:28program, the status of the Michigan football program, the potential future of the
- 0:32Michigan football program. Great days we get to talk about Michigan on Michigan Monday.
- 0:37Well there you go. And just because there's no game doesn't mean people
- 0:41still aren't interested in what is going on in the state up north. So
- 0:45oh yeah, let's get it started. Let's go all right? From at
- 0:48T. Kirkpatrick zero nine. No need for any more Michigan mondays, no
- 0:52need to enable what is being proven to be the biggest on field cheating scandal
- 0:57in college football history. I think I think the verb tense there is being
- 1:02proven is probably an important one to emphasize because I don't feel like this this
- 1:07is certainly not has not been proven. Let's you know, could potentially be
- 1:14proven, could be on the way to be proven. You know, I
- 1:19think I could get with all of those. You just want to make sure
- 1:23we're being real clear on our verb tenses here. Yeah, if all of
- 1:27this comes true, I think maybe another question is, if all of this
- 1:33is real and it is happening, is it the biggest on field cheating scandal
- 1:37in college football history? And you probably have to make it modern history because
- 1:42who knows what kind of There's all kinds of cheating going on in the days
- 1:46of let's bring in the coal miners, let's bring in the factory workers,
- 1:49and you make the thirty two year old men beat up on sixteen year old
- 1:52children like that was some on field cheating back in the day as well,
- 1:57But this one would be I mean, name something that even comes close.
- 2:01If everything that is being reported becomes is true and is fact, I what
- 2:10else is there? Yeah, it's I mean if everything that's being reported and
- 2:16this is a very big if, if everything that's being reported or rumored is
- 2:23then you might be at that level of I mean I have not done a
- 2:25great historical deep dive. There should be a great thing to talk to Matt
- 2:30Brown of the Extra Points newsletter about he is a great college football historian.
- 2:34He might have a better sense of some of this stuff. But you know,
- 2:37some of the stuff that has been rumored and again I will repeat has
- 2:40been rumored, is you know, in addition to all the stuff that Ohio
- 2:45State fans are probably familiar with, did, was there some sort of sharing
- 2:51of illegally obtained information with the South Carolina football program? And then this spreads
- 2:58it to now you're you're involving other conferences, You're involving other games, You're
- 3:04you know, I mean, this is this is a you know, it's
- 3:07like Wakey Leaks was kind of a you know, it was like a really
- 3:10stupid I mean, it was a really stupid scandal that you know, turned
- 3:15into a relatively big thing, but it involved wake Forest, so it was
- 3:19only kind of big. This is you know, if if this is what
- 3:23caused Tennessee to lose that game again out of South Carolina last year, if
- 3:28that, if that played some kind of role in that, then you're screwing
- 3:30with another school and another fan base, you know, And and I think
- 3:34there's a little bit of where else is this going to go? How far
- 3:38does this reach? Because this, you know, I mean, I know
- 3:40it feels like we've been talking about this forever, but it still feels like
- 3:45we're a little bit in the early days and all of this and none,
- 3:49well, I was gonna say none. Some of this has now been more
- 3:52or less admitted, so some of it's kind of proven to some degree,
- 3:55but a lot of the stuff, it feels like a lot of the more
- 4:00salacious stuff is not yet in the proven category or even the broadly proven category.
- 4:05So I'm gonna I'm gonna say, like, if if this all,
- 4:11all this stuff is true, and I'm not expecting everything to be true,
- 4:14because that's just kind of how this works, but if a broad swath of
- 4:19what has been reported or rumored is true, then you might be in the
- 4:25biggest cheating scandal in on field cheating scandal in college football history. Yeah.
- 4:30I'm looking back to see how long has this been going on in terms of
- 4:33being in the national news, And I don't even believe it's two weeks yet,
- 4:38because I went back and looked at the podcast that we've done, and
- 4:42there's one on October nineteenth that was like the first time when once this started
- 4:46breaking is when Mark Givler and I did a show, So it hasn't hasn't
- 4:53been that long. And I know when people are when the people have been
- 4:56when you get news like three days in a row and then you're like,
- 5:00oh man, this is crazy, and then you don't get any news for
- 5:01a while. You're like, oh, I guess maybe it's over. Oh
- 5:04well, and then you kind of move on, or when something else comes
- 5:08out, you're like, ah, that's old news, and it's like,
- 5:11well, it's old news, but there's confirmation there or there's clarification there.
- 5:16And I don't really think any of this is old because it is still happening
- 5:20and it's still, like I said, it's not even two weeks old necessarily
- 5:25in terms of what we've found out about this. So I think it's just
- 5:28our the speed at which we get accustomed to news is faster than ever,
- 5:33and so it's like, well, I need more news. Where's the news.
- 5:35Where's the news? I'm looking for the news, and sometimes you just
- 5:40gotta wait. Yeah. And I mean I've mentioned this before on this show
- 5:45at other shows, but you're getting into some of the stuff that is being
- 5:48rumored and being reported right now has potentially legal implications and beyond just like hey,
- 5:55that's cheating in a football sense. So that's when you end up getting
- 5:59legal departments in evolved in a much more direct way in some of your reporting
- 6:02and stuff has to get proven out and you have to have, you know,
- 6:04maybe a higher standard of proof before you can report something. So yeah,
- 6:11I think you need to recognize that you're not going to just get your
- 6:14little dopamine hit of new news, you know what, you know, the
- 6:17meme like wake up Honting New Michigan News just dropped. Like that's not just
- 6:21going to happen every three hours. This is I mean it was I think
- 6:25a Thursday night, So we're talking like what ten days, eleven days something
- 6:29like this. So this is still very early days in all of this stuff.
- 6:31And if you think this is slow, oh friends, wait till the
- 6:34NCAA has to take control of things. You think this is slow, we'll
- 6:39see it in twenty twenty eight. Next one from at All Underscore Pete,
- 6:45nineteen twenty six. And just based on this, I thought, based on
- 6:48the way this question is phrased, I thought I need to look up whether
- 6:51this person is in an Ohio State fan or a Michigan fan. He is
- 6:55an Ohio State fan. His bio Twitter bio a tremendous Twitter bio, incredible
- 6:59named up at the end here Buckeye since the days of Archie Cardinal, since
- 7:02the days of Vinigar Bend Mizel, former Mets pitcher, owner of one of
- 7:06the great names in baseball history, Vinigar Bend Mizelle. He says, here's
- 7:12my legal defense. Sure, we were getting great intel from Stallions, but
- 7:15we had no idea he was using improper means to gather the information. Does
- 7:18not work. If people start talking coaches access the video files, a money
- 7:23trail goes back to Michigan. Yeah, the attempt to or perhaps the reality
- 7:31of keeping Jim Harbaugh out of the loop of this, or even keeping the
- 7:36coordinators out of the loop of this, kinder Stallions looks like he was trying
- 7:44or like you're trying to keep the head coach from being aware of this.
- 7:47But when you are on the sideline talking to the coordinators, talking to the
- 7:51head coach, the lack of awareness meters have to be like you got to
- 7:58goose them to believe them. I think I think it's not I don't think
- 8:03it's believable that the coordinators were just accepting of the intel and not asking where
- 8:11did it go? And if the answer is I got it from TV and
- 8:16the ALL twenty two, every single coach watches ALL twenty two. They know
- 8:22what's available there what isn't and all of the coaches have seen television, so
- 8:26they know what's available there as well. Now what it could mean or what
- 8:31the reasoning could be, and is that well, it's not, it's not
- 8:39one hundred percent accurate, but it's still you know, I'm able to get
- 8:41sixty percent of the signals. Let's use that information as sixty percent of the
- 8:46signals from without going to games, just from the ALL twenty two and the
- 8:52TVs. If that's what he's telling the coaches, and it's still, hey,
- 8:54you know what, that's information. That's the term we're hearing lately that
- 8:58is being thrust upon us as code breaking rather than sign stealing. So you
- 9:03know, that's just breaking the code getting stuff from the ALL twenty two and
- 9:07a TV. And if the coaches are like, well, you know what,
- 9:13and he's you know, sixty percent of the time, it works every
- 9:16time, that sort of thing. If kinder Stallions is actually I won't go
- 9:20into the Colonne name, but if it's more like that where yeah, we
- 9:24know it's not gonna be one hundred percent accurate, but hey, if you
- 9:28see something that you recognize, you tell us. And then I think there's
- 9:33some plausible deniability for the assistance in that regard, in terms of accepting the
- 9:39intel and asking where it comes from and being told TV and all twenty two.
- 9:48And then then it gets into a little bit of the well, you
- 9:50know, the assistants are like, well, this is a military guy,
- 9:54so you know, I'm sure he's deciphered much more difficult codes than football a
- 10:00sidelines. Yeah, I mean, unfortunately, I love I love the idea
- 10:05of code breakers instead of sign stealers, like like this is like the Navajo
- 10:09code talkers on the sidelines from Michigan. That's tremendous. This does have a
- 10:16real if you didn't you know, you didn't want to ask too many questions
- 10:22kind of vibe because like you said, you know what's available on TV,
- 10:26and you know what's available on the old twenty two because you're watching the old
- 10:31twenty two, you know. I mean, I've seen a lot of people
- 10:33online saying, hey, you get all from the All twenty two. If
- 10:35you have watched ALL twenty two, you know you know you cannot get everything
- 10:37from the All twenty two. You can probably get something. And there was
- 10:41one of the one of the reports that very obviously was sourced from the Michigan
- 10:43side of things, made it real clear, oh boy, well he was
- 10:46stealing stuff from TV copies in twenty seventeen. Okay, has he gotten substantially
- 10:52better at it since twenty seventeen. It feels like the answer is probably yes,
- 10:56because now he's on the sideline and talking to the coordinators. So it
- 10:58feels like a relatively natural follow up question was like, hey, you seem
- 11:03like you're way better at this than you used to be. What are you
- 11:05doing differently? Because they're not showing any more signs on the old twenty two
- 11:09than they did a few years ago, or on the TV copy than did
- 11:11a few years ago. How did you get so much better? And if
- 11:13the answer is oh, you don't want to know the answer, then that
- 11:16feels like that's kind of an answer. So again, this is something where
- 11:22the you gotta sort of you know, we'll see. I think there's gonna
- 11:26be a lot of you know, as they go through emails and stuff,
- 11:30and they go through texts and they go through computer access logs or whatever else,
- 11:35you may have more firm answers on you know, this happened, this
- 11:39didn't happen. Gotta remember Jim Tressel, the whole the whole case against Jim
- 11:43Tressel hinged on one email that he had just sort of acknowledged from someone that
- 11:48was That was it. That was the entire thing. So it'll be interesting
- 11:52to see what information comes out there was he mentioned the money trail at the
- 11:56end of this. That is the old journalism follow the money. That's generally
- 12:01the old journalism rule of thumb. This time, according to some of the
- 12:05stuff that has come out again the sort of Michigan side reporting. I think
- 12:09it was the Dan Murphy ESPN report from the with the Division three coach that
- 12:13I'm I mean sure felt like it was coming from the Michigan side of things.
- 12:16Made a point, you know, hey, he paid me with his
- 12:18own Venmo. It was it was just him, and you know how traceable
- 12:24is that money? Can that money be traced back to Michigan. I think
- 12:26that might not be as fruitful a and a path for people to pursue.
- 12:31But well, we'll see as this all plays out in terms of the coaches
- 12:35not wanting to know. I think what counter stallions could just start saying,
- 12:39is well, the algorithm. And as soon as you say algorithm, the
- 12:43coaches are the eyes glaze over to like whatever. Just continue to do your
- 12:48nerd stuff, that sort of thing that's that is always a possible. Just
- 12:52just say AI and not only then will well the coaches leave you, leave
- 12:56you alone. You'll have a bunch of like venture capital people like swinging through
- 13:00the windows like a like a swat team trying to give you money. So
- 13:03yeah, it could be could be win win for Runner Science. There,
- 13:07NBA fans, the wait is over. Basketball is back. In DraftKings sports
- 13:11book, an official sports betting partner of the NBA, is celebrating with an
- 13:13unbeatable offer. New customers can score two hundred dollars instantly in bonus bets for
- 13:16throwing down five dollars on the NBA winner lose, it doesn't matter. You'll
- 13:18start the season with an instant dub. And with DraftKings parlays, everyone's got
- 13:22a shot at even bigger basketball wins. String together multiple bets from the same
- 13:24game, or build your parlay across multiple games for a shot at making your
- 13:28payday even sweeter. Basketball is more fun when you're in on the action.
- 13:30Download the DraftKings sports Book app now and use code huddle up. New customers
- 13:33can get two hundred dollars and bonus bets instantly for betting just five dollars only
- 13:35on Draft Kings sports Book with code huddle up. The Crown is yours.
- 13:37Gambling problem called one hundred gambler or visit www dot twenty hundred gambler dot net
- 13:41New York Call eight seven seven eight hope and why, or text hope and
- 13:45why. In Connecticut, help is available for problem gambling. Call eight eight
- 13:48eight seven eight ninety seven seven seven seven or visit CCPG dot org. Please
- 13:50play responsibly on behalf of boot Heel Casino and Resort, Kansas license partner Golden
- 13:54Nugget La Charles, Louisiana twenty one. Over Age varies by juristiction, void
- 13:56and Ontario btist Bets expire one hundred and sixty eight hours after issuing. See
- 14:00sportsbook dot Draft Kings dot com. Slash Basketball see sportsbook dot Draft Kings dot
- 14:03com slash basketball terms for eligibility and deposit restrictions, terms and responsible gaming resources.
- 14:09Next one at VW chad w the opposite of win win Do you see
- 14:13guys? Do you guys see vacated wins in Michigan's future? And a related
- 14:16one from at jerk zeus. If they vacate Michigan wins, do the Ohio
- 14:20State players get the gold pants for the previous two years? So I think,
- 14:24you know, if this sort of proceeds to the point where this is
- 14:28an NC DOUBLEA case in the NC DOUBLEA, feels that they have, you
- 14:33know, enough proof that hey, this happened, you know at that point,
- 14:37and hey this happened, this had a material impact, It was a
- 14:41clear violation of the rules. At that point it becomes a real Jim Harbaugh
- 14:45program problem because Jim Harbaugh is responsible for all the people below him. That's
- 14:48a relatively new NC double A rule that the head coach is responsible for,
- 14:52you know, violations that happen for people below him. So at that point
- 14:56that becomes his issue. I think, you know, the vacating of wins
- 15:00seems like that's if this is all proven out, that does feel like a
- 15:05fairly likely at least part of what could be the punishment again if this all
- 15:09plays out. But if that all plays out, it doesn't mean O higher
- 15:13State one. It just means Michigan didn't win according to the official rules.
- 15:18So I don't I would assume there would be no There would be no gold
- 15:22pants given out to those those teams. It would just be, you know,
- 15:26like the twenty ten O High State Michigan game. Officially no one won
- 15:30that game. Yeah, And I'm just thinking now you're saying that, I'll
- 15:33just ask Jim Lashee when I see him on Saturday at the game, because
- 15:37he's part of that gold Plant gold Pants a leadership council, and I'll just
- 15:41be like, hey, you know, is just because the answer is going
- 15:46to be no, But I would just like to hear it from him,
- 15:48because I think I asked him one other time. Would would would Ohio State
- 15:52players get two pairs if they beat Ohio, if they beat Michigan in the
- 15:56regular season then in the conference championship game? Yeah? I think even when
- 16:00when Legends and leaders started, I'd probably sent him an email saying, hey,
- 16:03would they would you get two pairs of gold pants? And I think
- 16:07the answer was at that time, like we need to talk about that and
- 16:11this is not something and maybe they have, maybe they talked about it and
- 16:15there's never any need. But yeah, I wouldn't expect any gold pants.
- 16:18I do think wins are going to be vake. Wins will be vacated just
- 16:22based on honestly, I could see it happening, just based on what has
- 16:30it, what we know, you know, what has been reported in terms
- 16:36of this. Sure seems like this was happening, and so I think it's
- 16:40a I think it will we'll seem more. But I think it's an easy
- 16:45enough punishment that sounds severe by the NCAA, but also everybody still got to
- 16:52play the games, and it's like, well but you know you have to
- 16:56take give the trophies back and things like that. So it always pretend weight
- 17:03in the eyes of the NCAA where and then the program just continues on.
- 17:08You know, it's like it happened. We all like the way we talked
- 17:11about the two thousand and ten Ohio state season. We all saw it.
- 17:15You know, so what is X what exactly has been vacated? So I
- 17:21do expect vacated whence to happen but I don't know that it's really going to
- 17:23materially destroy anybody. Yeah, And I guess the interesting question is is that
- 17:30the big chunk of this is this just Jim Harbaugh gets a show cause and
- 17:36they vacate some wins or does the punishment go beyond that? And the tricky
- 17:41part of this, in addition to the fact that we don't know what's actually
- 17:44to get proven out as the investigation moves on, is that there is no
- 17:48prescribed penalty in the rule book for this type of violation. It doesn't say
- 17:52and if you do this, you get fill in the blank punishment. So
- 17:56the NCAA is going to be kind of making it up as they go,
- 18:00so that that's that's one of the reasons that this is all kind of it's
- 18:03all kind of one big gray area in some ways. Next week from at
- 18:07Dane one seven seven one one zero five seven. We all know Jimmy is
- 18:11a huge mel Gibson guy. Was it a mistake to refer to the film
- 18:15where a rule breaker was caught and severely punished. Instead, he could have
- 18:18compared himself to a broken man who protected his family from outside threats by defeating
- 18:22them with a common beverage. This is one of my favorite questions of all
- 18:29time. Now I don't even I didn't hear the Brave Heart reference. I
- 18:33just saw other people referencing it because I was gonna actually go back and check
- 18:37it out. But then I got distracted by the idea that Jim Harbaugh is
- 18:41Mel Gibson from Signs, which is one of the great scary jump movies of
- 18:47all time. And then it got me wondering, you know what, what
- 18:49other Mel Gibson movies could he be? I think I think there's a conspiracy
- 18:56theory was the movie that Mel Gibson was in that seems to be maybe the
- 19:00Michigan fan base is seeing some images some mirroring there between the conspiracies being thrown
- 19:07around and that Mel Gibson movie What if the Winds are kidnapped and Jim Harball
- 19:15yells, I'll give me back my wins something like that from Ransom? What
- 19:21else? I don't want to get into the post apocalyptic, dystopian mad Max
- 19:26realm of this, but I could see it, Tony. I was just
- 19:30trying to go through the Mel Gibson IMDb list, and he's been in a
- 19:36whole bunch of stuff. Recently that I'm sure was great and I'm deeply regretting
- 19:38that missing it. I'm just going to read you two from two movies that
- 19:44came out in the Year of Our Lord of twenty twenty two featuring Mel Gibson.
- 19:47You're ready, band It seems potentially potentially relevant, and one more Tony
- 19:53hot Seat might maybe be somehow. No, maybe I haven't seen either of
- 20:02those, so I can't really provide any specifics on how the plots might might
- 20:06be related. At least the movie posters look good. Here's one of from
- 20:08twenty sixteen maybe for Kirk Farrance called blood Father, Rip to a real one.
- 20:15The Brian Farrens era Gone before It's time, Tony. Do you think
- 20:21do you think the haters and the Iowa administration were just terrified that Brian was
- 20:25right on the verge of turning this baby around and getting this to a get
- 20:29it getting over that twenty five point mark. It feels like it was so
- 20:33so close, just right right there, just one more week and the haters,
- 20:38the haters would not be denied. You hate to see someone who has
- 20:42worked so hard to get to the position he has attained have that all taken
- 20:47away from him, Tony by the haters, next one from at Jordan in
- 20:51three some three. How many teams have both offensive and defensive coordinators who call
- 20:56plays from the sideline and neither in the box. And this is, of
- 20:59course because of the twenty twenty two Ohio State Michigan game where you had Sharon
- 21:06Moore and the defensive coordinator whose name is now escaping me for some reason,
- 21:11I can only think of Matt Weiss, who is the other co offensive coordinator,
- 21:15Jesse Minter. There we go, I came up, but eventually both
- 21:18Sharon Moore and Jesse Minter were on the sidelines. That is kind of unusual.
- 21:22Jim Knowles, for example, up in the box for Ohio State,
- 21:26and so it's it is a little unusual to have both offensive and defensive coordinators
- 21:30there on the sideline. You do remember, you gotta remember Matt Weiss was
- 21:33up in the box for Michigan last year, I believe, because I think
- 21:37Sharon Moore was the only offensive cooridinator down on the fields, so they did
- 21:41have someone up in the box. But that is unusual enough that I think
- 21:44it's a little, you know, that's a little intriguing. I guess,
- 21:49because you know, the implication here that if you want to read between the
- 21:53lines, is Connor Stallions as not you know, he be due to his
- 21:57position, he's not allowed to be a headset, so he could not relay
- 22:00that information upstairs. And if he you know, if you're standing right next
- 22:04to the guy, you could relay that information immediately and then have it immediately
- 22:08signaled in or called in from the sideline. So that's that's the reason that
- 22:11question is getting asked, just in case you're not reading between the lines.
- 22:15Well. And I remember saying, I don't know ten days ago when this
- 22:21stuff was coming out in terms of the electronic equipment that was used, Like
- 22:25I could see Stallions being on the sideline talking to somebody and then having the
- 22:30plays relayed, whether it goes from somebody else to him. It's like I've
- 22:34handed this off to somebody who could now use the electronic equipment. He was
- 22:40kind of a middleman in terms of the plays. But I wish I had
- 22:45more time to like go through and look because we started recording just a few
- 22:49minutes before we got this question, And I looked at Penn State and their
- 22:55defensive coordinator, Manny Diaz, is on the field, Mike Sitchy offensive coordinators
- 23:00up in the booth. I was just looking to see, like I looked
- 23:03at for Georgia to see and looked in their game notes to see where they
- 23:07were, and they're they're not listed, So like if you had some time
- 23:10to just go through and see how many play callers are both on the field,
- 23:14I don't think it's a lot for either for both of those guys to
- 23:18be on the field, but it is an interesting question. And this whole
- 23:22thing just sparks interesting questions with that, which then takes you down other rabbit
- 23:26holes, which then gets the conspiracy theory movie placed over our own head,
- 23:33and which case you might want to use the tinfoil hat from Signs. That
- 23:38was the other Mel Gibson movie mentioned there. And then once you get that
- 23:42tinfoil hat, you're free from anybody. I don't know. I don't even
- 23:48know where to go with a hacking into your brain to get your thoughts.
- 23:52I'm sure Mel Gibson has been in a hacking movie at some point. He's
- 23:55He's been a prolific actor for a long enough time that I'm sure he's done
- 23:59something some movie where people are typing furiously in a dark room and yelling in
- 24:03hands at their TVs, at their commuter monitors. It must have happened at
- 24:07some point there. He wasn't a hacking movie. It's called The Patriot where
- 24:11he famously hacked up a bunch of people with his hatchet. Take that British
- 24:17next one at Tangentle to the allegation, how did Michigan's future opponents move forward
- 24:22preparing for them knowing how much has been stolen? I think that's a fascinating
- 24:29question that each opponent will have to answer, and they should be free to
- 24:34answer it, or they should want to answer it freely so they know what
- 24:37it's like to go through this. But so much of this is hidden behind
- 24:41the veil of the coaching profession and not wanting to throw other programs under the
- 24:48bus or even talk about other programs. But it's something that everybody is going
- 24:52to have to deal with and something that they are dealing with. And I
- 24:56mentioned this shoot a Sunday morning. I tweeted out, like the fact that
- 25:00people are Michigan fans are dismissing the ordeal of going through new plays, of
- 25:10opponents having to come up with new signals or whatever, and they're like,
- 25:14ah, you know, just everybody changes a week to week. Anyways,
- 25:15if you don't, then you know you're an idiot. And it's like you're
- 25:18dismissing the fact that what Michigan has seemingly done and what the big done is
- 25:23warned to Michigan could be doing, you know, with the signal stealing and
- 25:30the fact that hey, now you've been warned you might want to change things.
- 25:33It's like it ignores the fact that they have to go and change things.
- 25:37And so I think that this is obviously just creates more work, and
- 25:41it creates more focused work, and with a focus more on this, it's
- 25:47taking some focus off of the actual preparation and so it's unfortunate for the programs
- 25:52have to go through that. And if you say that, then you are
- 25:56considered a well, I don't know what you're concering. I guess you'll just
- 26:00get a lot of responses to your Twitter saying cry harder. Yeah, Tony,
- 26:04how is your cope level right now? I feel like epic amounts of
- 26:08copium? That does feel. I was about to diagnose you, but I'm
- 26:12not actually a medical doctor, so I didn't want it to make any put
- 26:15anything officially on the record, but I I was definitely getting that vibe from
- 26:18you. Yeah, it feels like this is this is an opportunity for Ohio
- 26:22State to you know, no disrespect to Rutgers and Michigan State and Minnesota,
- 26:29but they are Michigan State, Minnesota, and Rutgers. So it feels like
- 26:33Ohio State has an opportunity to like just go go to wristbands like change it
- 26:38up, like mix it up. You have some time to you know,
- 26:41if you spend an hour of practice each of the next three weeks, or
- 26:45two hours of practice each of the next three weeks, you are probably still
- 26:48going to beat those three teams. Now, that is an hour or two
- 26:51that you could be putting towards Michigan Prep and they normally probably would be putting
- 26:53towards Michigan Prep. But you can, you know, you can probably get
- 26:59it. You can probably figured out you can use meeting time to go through
- 27:02stuff. You're just gonna have to switch it up a little bit, and
- 27:04you know what, have a different risk band for every quarter so that by
- 27:07the time they figure out what you're doing, you're changing risk bands again and
- 27:11whatever. Like it. There are way, there are workarounds here. Yes,
- 27:17it is a you know, it is a pain, and yes you're
- 27:18spending time that that is a you know, that is a limited resource.
- 27:22You only have so much time in the day, so many days in the
- 27:25week, so many hours in the day to do stuff, and you're spending
- 27:27time doing this stuff. But you know, now, you know, you
- 27:32really you have to get it kind of straightened out this year, so you
- 27:34know, And it's going to be fascinating to see what happens with Michigan's defensive
- 27:41you know, defensive stats and especially defensive stats as they move forward, because
- 27:45they have looked so dominant this year, and it's just going to be so
- 27:48interesting to see how does you know, how much of this changes, if
- 27:52any, in the coming weeks as they're playing better competition. But also people
- 27:56are probably a little more up to speed on what they need to do to
- 28:00potentially combat what Michigan has maybe been doing over the last couple of years.
- 28:06So it'll be interesting to see how much stuff changes, and then if stuff
- 28:10changes, how much is attributed to better competition versus Hey, the intel thing
- 28:14is not working as much as it used to, so well, yeah,
- 28:18and just to remind people it's not just stealing signs. Everybody steals signs.
- 28:25This is going to various venues and recording signs and then using that information to
- 28:30steal signs and to interpret them to break down I'm going to say code breaking,
- 28:37because it's that's just it's it's that part of it is a joke,
- 28:41that kind of messaging as a joke. Don't forget like it. It's not
- 28:47just sign stealing. It's much more involved than that, much more. It's
- 28:53sign stealing is free. What they were doing was not in terms of what
- 28:57kind of stallings was doing it. That is costing him money seemingly out of
- 29:02his own pocket. Yeah, that that well, Yeah, I'm going to
- 29:06be so interested to see how that all, how that all shakes out moving
- 29:08forward, because if if you see a significant change, there's going to be
- 29:14a real you know that, that's going to be a real interesting to see
- 29:17how that narrative plays out nationally. And if there's no change, it'll be
- 29:19interesting to see how that narrative plays out nationally. That oh see it wasn't
- 29:23a big deal, or O see it was a huge deal, or oc
- 29:26they're just playing better teams now. So that'll be that'll be fun. Finally,
- 29:30something to talk about in the week in the month of the Michigan game.
- 29:33Speaking of talking about stuff to talk about? From Professor John Frank,
- 29:36what should we make of the Harball contract news? The Harball contract news,
- 29:40of course, being that there was a report in the Wall Street Journal that
- 29:45Michigan had pulled Jim Harbaugh's a new contract offer that would have made him the
- 29:48highest paid coach in the Big Ten. They sin, did I believe was
- 29:51the word that they used? Jim Harball then said it was not accurate,
- 29:56that it was. You know that our tweet from our buddy Marcoon says Jim
- 30:00Harbaugh says, the report of the rescinded contract is not accurate. So I
- 30:03guess then the question is, Okay, well, how is it signed yet?
- 30:10No? Is it still on the table? We don't. They don't
- 30:12think we have an indication that really like if he wanted to sign that today,
- 30:17that's necessarily so you know, maybe this is more a little bit more
- 30:21of a semantic argument that it rescinded, is like, well, it was
- 30:25taken off the table and is unavailable, and the implication is forever and maybe
- 30:29it was you know, maybe really it was temporarily withdrawn from the table,
- 30:34but still could go back on the table. I mean to me, you
- 30:40can. You can play word games all you want, and like no,
- 30:42no, no, no, no, that's not accurate, Like, well,
- 30:44what about isn't it? You know? What set the record straight for
- 30:47us? What happened? Well, no, I don't want to go into
- 30:48details, like okay, that's fine, but you know, I think I
- 30:52think my best read of the situation is if Jim Harbaugh decided today that he
- 30:59wanted to sign that tract, a copy of that contract would not necessarily be
- 31:03made available to him by Michigan for him to sign. So therefore, whatever
- 31:08word you want to put on that, it is not necessarily there right at
- 31:14this moment, which represents it seems like a change of status of that contract
- 31:18offer. And I think what you would get from the Michigan side is that
- 31:23the contract was never exactly ready just yet, and then once this comes down,
- 31:30they put a hold on finalizing it and you'll just wait. But we
- 31:37had been hearing four weeks that a contract was ready or was going to be
- 31:40put in front of Jim Harbaugh and an extension, big extension, and now
- 31:45that is no longer happening, and so yeah, maybe rescinded, put on
- 31:51hold the it's all semantics. I think it's much of it as semantics.
- 31:56But even even Jim Harbaugh's quote on that, and it's I wouldn't say that's
- 32:00accurate, and we say that that that that is also a phrase that we
- 32:07use when there are half truths, half lies, that sort of thing,
- 32:09where well, that's only ninety two percent accurate. So I wouldn't say that's
- 32:15entirely accurate. And so there's some wordplay in this as well, I think.
- 32:20But I'm with you there. I don't think he could sign a contract
- 32:23right now, but also I don't know that there was a contract to sign,
- 32:29like a finished contract to sign, and I think the finishing of it
- 32:32is maybe what got delayed. But also maybe the thing that got rescented was
- 32:40the desire to finish the contract, to put it in front of him,
- 32:45and it's just levels and steps that you know, first this, then this,
- 32:47then this. Well it's like, well, we're not going to do
- 32:50this part right now because we want to see how this plays out. So
- 32:52yeah, that's a bunch of semantics, I think, And if they're if
- 32:55if you wanted to sign a contract right now, I'm with you. I
- 32:58don't know that he could, right And you know, does that has the
- 33:01plan for the plan or the schedule for the contract changed in any way.
- 33:07It feels like there's probably something to the fact that it has. So,
- 33:12Yeah, at that point, it's just kind of us, you know,
- 33:15using whatever words you want to use. And Jim Harbaught does have a way
- 33:19with words, Tony, because the next question from row one four, five,
- 33:22six, seven, six thoughts on Harbaugh's presser and his discussion of field
- 33:25corn versus house plants. Yeah, he was asked about playing at night in
- 33:35I guess what will be November, and he said, they've got a team
- 33:38that can play at you know, twelve o'clock, three thirty, seven,
- 33:40thirty nine or whatever, all conditions. And he said it's like field corn
- 33:45as opposed to being a houseplant. Nothing against house plants. Obviously, he
- 33:50doesn't want to get the houseplant lobby angry with him. This is a man
- 33:52of the people. He knows what he's doing. Nothing against house plants.
- 33:57They have their function. They can be beautiful in the home. They can
- 34:00bring great beauty and value to a home. But the field corn just drop
- 34:05a seat and a crack of a sidewalk and a little burrow down and come
- 34:07up with any energy that it can find and then rise up in a stalk
- 34:12like fashion and just start producing. I would say that's what our team is
- 34:15more like to my first bit. As I'm reading through this, I disagree
- 34:21with calling a stock of corn stalk like. It's an actual stalk. It
- 34:27is an actual stock. Yeah, it's like that car is car like like
- 34:30Yeah, I technically yes, I just I find his different ways of talking
- 34:37about stuff so fascinating. We were up in Arbor for the press conference the
- 34:42week the Monday before the Ohist Michigan game last year, and he talked about
- 34:46them, his team as I think it was a happy band of warriors on
- 34:51a happy journey, and that was it was. It was like, I
- 34:53don't think I've ever heard of college football coach use either of those halves of
- 34:59that phrase. Let alone together, let alone the week of the biggest game
- 35:02of the season, and you know, I mean, they came out and
- 35:06won the game, so I guess they were. They had reason to be
- 35:09happy warriors and to be that their journey was happy until they got to the
- 35:13Fiesta Bowl and then it was less happy, but you know they they had
- 35:16you know, they had a good roadmap for that game. It sounds like,
- 35:20so you know that's reason enough to be happy. Yeah, He's just
- 35:23he has such a unique way of talking and communicating and it's like how many
- 35:34how many coaches do we cover where it's like, you know, you have
- 35:37the complete football robots, and you put those kind of to one side,
- 35:42and you have the people who are just kind of like the normal people where
- 35:45you feel like you could sit down and just have a conversation with them and
- 35:50you would, you know, not feel like you were talking to a robot.
- 35:53And then there are just the people who are just a little different.
- 35:57And Jim Harvol's not a football robot necessar necessarily, He's just he's just a
- 36:02little different. And you talk to people who cover the team and you hear
- 36:08the word weird a lot, and that's you know, I think there's a
- 36:13you know, maybe more of a judgment to that word than you might you
- 36:17know, people would necessarily put their names on publicly, but it's just he's
- 36:22a different cat and that comes out in all sorts of different ways, including
- 36:29our team is Field Corn instead of a house plant. You wonder, Tony,
- 36:35who does he think? Which team does he think is a houseplant?
- 36:37I have thoughts that's that is very interesting. I that's a great thought.
- 36:45Tom. I wouldn't have expected to go down this rabbit hole. But in
- 36:51terms of his robotness, it is, he's kind of like a robot if
- 36:58it was designed and programmed by the Old Farmer's Almanac with a lot of these
- 37:02things that he says with the nervous bird and the birds worms wouldn't be afraid
- 37:09of birds with guns or whatever. You know, worms with guns aren't afraid
- 37:14of birds or perhaps muskets. If we're talking about the Old Farmer's Almanac,
- 37:19I do. I would like to know what he is reading, because he
- 37:22does come up with some stuff that's like, that's really interesting, and the
- 37:27field corn one is because it just is. And he has a lot of
- 37:31isms that I would like to know where they come from, whether it's an
- 37:35ism of the day calendar, which that's a fantastic idea. I should look
- 37:38into that and just steal like old farmers Almanac stuff and throw it into chat
- 37:45GBT and be like, fancy it up, modernize it if you will.
- 37:49But I get a kick out of some of the stuff he says. Other
- 37:53stuff is like when he's talking football or talking about his players, talking about
- 37:59his team, unless he uses these analogies, I get and I gloss over
- 38:05a lot of it, you know, because it's it is stunted and stilted
- 38:10and like the very coach like answers. But when he goes into this stuff
- 38:15that to me provides more insight, the happy warrior stuff. This stuff.
- 38:20Every now and again, I'll throw something in and it's like, Okay,
- 38:22this guy has a personality. Yeah, it's a personality. It's just it's
- 38:30just very off the beaten path for a college football coach. And that's not
- 38:35necessarily bad. It's a little off the beaten path for a non college football
- 38:38coach too, So it's just it is a very different It is a very
- 38:43different experience to cover a Jim Harbaugh press conference. We go to those Big
- 38:45Ten media days every summer and we hear, you know, all fourteen Big
- 38:51Ten coaches talk, and there's a wide variety of personalities and levels of conversational
- 38:59comfort and all that kind of stuff, and Jim Harborough was always on like
- 39:02one end of that range of coaches in terms of what it's like talking to
- 39:07him, and so, yeah, you never he is a little Tony like
- 39:12a box of chocolates because you never know what you're gonna get a last one
- 39:19from d shake it Watson. I know you all quote don't want to speculate
- 39:23close quote parentheses still true, exclamation point close parentheses. But it's what the
- 39:29fans want Tony. So okay, So, assuming things go the way they
- 39:31are appearing to be headed in ann Arbor, are there any recruits in this
- 39:35class or twenty twenty five that would be of interest to Ohio State? So,
- 39:39you know, I mean, I guess for the purposes of this question,
- 39:44let's assume that after this season, and you know, maybe before the
- 39:50end of the season, it becomes a parent of the Jim Harboro is not
- 39:52going to stay at Michigan. So for the purposes of this conversation, the
- 39:55class of twenty twenty four, every Michigan recruit is potentially open for, you
- 40:00know, for Ohio State to pursue. It feels like Ohio State doesn't have
- 40:07that many spots they need to fill in the class. They need to add
- 40:10another offensive lineman or two. Maybe, you know, I think they'd like
- 40:15to add, maybe what another corner or maybe I mean they're the class is
- 40:20in relatively good shape, another safety, maybe, I mean there's not.
- 40:24And you know, several of the offensive linemen in that Michigan class are from
- 40:30Ohio and don't have Ohio State offers, So you know, you get the
- 40:32sense of Ohio State probably doesn't you know, has kind of looked and considered
- 40:37it and not decided that was something that they were going to be, you
- 40:42know, interested in poaching. You know, I mean, I'm just looking
- 40:45at the list right now. Andrew Sprague from Kansas City, Missouri is their
- 40:47highest ranked recruit. He has a tackle number fifty five nationally. I mean
- 40:52that Ohio State could probably use a tackle in this class. I don't have
- 40:55any idea. I am not one of the recruiting guys, so I don't
- 40:58have any I sense, for know, is that someone who is camped at
- 41:00Ohio State and there's any kind of relationship, I don't know, But you
- 41:04know, you go down the list and Jaden Davis, Ohio State has a
- 41:07quarterback in the class, Aaron Oland, who's ranked I think higher than Jayden
- 41:10Davis's Jordan Marshall running back he's from Ohio. Ohio State has at least one
- 41:16running back, maybe two that are ranked higher than Jordan Marshall right now.
- 41:21Yeah, and they're they're in relatively good shape at most spots. I know,
- 41:25Josiah Edmond is a name that we had sort of heard in terms of
- 41:29cornerback. But I don't I don't think that there's Ohistate just doesn't have that
- 41:35many holes to fill for twenty twenty four that that, you know, they
- 41:37would need to do the like Tim Beckman like camp outside Penn State thing and
- 41:43and just try and recruit people from, you know, from campus. Twenty
- 41:46twenty five, Michigan only has two commits, so that's a relatively short list.
- 41:50One of them is an in state defensive lineman, a cornerback out of
- 41:52the state of Florida. So, you know, I don't think Tony I
- 41:55see anything that between Ohio State's relatively short of needs through twenty four at Michigan's
- 42:00relatively shortlist of commits for twenty five, I don't know that I necessarily see
- 42:06a ton of opportunity here. Yeah, and the corner is Chris Euld from
- 42:10Shamana and Madonna, So that's where you know Ohio State has some inroads there
- 42:15with Jeremiah Smith. But if you if you look at the cornerback situation next
- 42:21in the twenty twenty five class, they already have a commitment from Blake would
- 42:24be but then three of the top four corners in that class. I'm just
- 42:29going to read some names to you, Toms. Tell me if these are
- 42:30familiar. Trey McNutt, Bucket Legacy, he's the number four corner. Dorian
- 42:36Brew who was from Ohio but moved to Texas, so that may be a
- 42:39little tougher he was, He's number three. Devin Sanchez the number two corner,
- 42:45number seven player in the nation. I know Ohio State and those who
- 42:47cover recruiting feel pretty good about the buckeyes chances with him. So they've got
- 42:52some guys that are more likely, you know, more likely than somebody that
- 42:59has already committed to Michigan in terms of that situation, and who would we
- 43:02be surprised, probably be surprised if there is anything that comes out about this
- 43:07or there's any punishment handed down before signing day. And I would also be
- 43:10surprised if anybody puts off signing day from December to February. You know,
- 43:15that's becoming more and more rare. If you're committed now, you're generally going
- 43:20to sign in December, right, And you know, if you do have
- 43:23a whole coaching staff leave and again, Lord, this is purely speculative.
- 43:28This is purely based on the hypothetical from the question. If you did have
- 43:32Jim Harbaugh leaves and both coordinators leave, and you know there's there's some looming
- 43:37something or other from the NCAA, you can get out of your letter of
- 43:42intent. We have seen people get out of letters of intent with coaching here
- 43:45it changes and that kind of thing in the past that is no longer.
- 43:49You know, as soon as you sign it you have to sit out a
- 43:51year if you The rules have changed in a lot of that stuff. And
- 43:53you know, so, I don't think that's necessarily I'm not I'm not expecting
- 44:00a neutron bomb to fall on Michigan, you know, anytime between now and
- 44:02signing day. So I think this is purely a hypothetical, as you know,
- 44:07but it is possible. I just I'm with you. I don't think
- 44:15that there is a real high likelihood that there's going to be such a massive
- 44:20earth shattering whatever it is that comes down between now and signing day that this
- 44:24is any kind of a short term situation that we will need to deal with
- 44:29in something other than a hypothetical. And we had a few other questions that
- 44:34we will pars off to other shows and we'll answer likely on Tuesday anyway regarding
- 44:39some of this stuff, but we just had so many of the Michigan questions
- 44:44that we just wanted to keep it focused to that. So I want to
- 44:45thank you all for tuning in a reminder, please find us at buckeheadle dot
- 44:49com if you want to become a member. That's a great way to support
- 44:52what we do. It's a great way to show support and it's an encouraging
- 44:55thing for all of us. And this time of the holidays that are coming
- 44:59up, specifically tom Halloween and Thanksgiving, the two fall holidays. Halloween the
- 45:07traditional gift for Halloween and membership to bucke huddle dot com and then Thanksgiving you
- 45:14you thank the people by giving another membership. So that and also YouTube dot
- 45:19com slash bucket Huddle if you want to go ahead and like this video that
- 45:22you're watching right now, that would be great. And of course hit the
- 45:23bell to be notified, and if you have not subscribed to the channel yet,
- 45:27please do so. Helps the algorithms find us and as we know,
- 45:30algorithms an important word in the football sphere right now. So thank you all
- 45:36for tuning in and we'll talk to you guys later