Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Morality, the Monarchy, and the Protests of Peter Hitchens (with Alex O'Connor)
Transcript
- 0:01Under STEMI the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the room,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. There
- 0:56is video of this conversation. YouTube link is in the description box of the
- 1:00show. So glad to talk today to the host of the Within Reason podcast.
- 1:08His YouTube channel has more than six hundred and fifty thousand subscribers. He
- 1:14has spoken to amazing guests on his own show, everybody from Neil de gras
- 1:19Heissen to some apologists like William Lane Craig and Frank Turk and others. And
- 1:27he's also engaged with Catholic bishops and people like Ben Shapiro from The Daily Wire,
- 1:34Alex O'Connor. Great to have you, brother, Seth Andrews. I
- 1:38believe this is our first tango. I've met you before, but I think
- 1:42this is the first time we've done the show together. Right, Yeah,
- 1:44what are you doing here? You're slumming, Like, why would you be
- 1:46on this show? I mean you've sat across from Ben Shapiro dun dunte know.
- 1:52I got to talk about Ben in just a second, because he is
- 1:55a thorn in my side and perhaps one of the banes of my entire Every
- 2:00time he speaks or tweets, I literally feel the vein in the middle of
- 2:05my forehead. Popot, I'm going to get to him. You and I
- 2:08have some things in common, at least two things. I think we both
- 2:12believe that Jordan Peterson is word salad in human form. And we both I
- 2:19think agree on the British monarchy that it's sort of an expensive accident of birth
- 2:24club. I don't know. I just finished watching All of the Crown on
- 2:30Netflix, an amazing series. It's great drama, masterful storytelling. Didn't change
- 2:36my opinion on the Royals. I know it's old hat for people who live
- 2:39in the UK, but you are anti monarchy. Let's start there. Yes,
- 2:46and as far as I know, it is still technically illegal in the
- 2:49United Kingdom to call for the abolition of the monarchy. So I come to
- 2:53you now, risking life and limb an imprisonment for the rest of my life.
- 2:57Of course, the point that I like to make about this law is
- 3:00that, of course nobody actually takes it seriously. It's just a strange vestige
- 3:04of our constitution that even the government refuses to take seriously these days. And
- 3:09I suppose this is how I see monarchy itself. It's something, it's kind
- 3:14of an echo or something that people used to think was important. I agree
- 3:17with you about the Crown, by the way. It's a wonderful piece of
- 3:20I would say. I mean it's strange. I sometimes described it as a
- 3:23great bit of conservative television. I mean, it's quite clearly an exercise in
- 3:25nostalgia. And that's why I think people got bored of the later seasons.
- 3:30They've performed worse, at least colloquially from what I've heard and watching the show
- 3:35myself. I didn't quite make it through the last season. But I think
- 3:38that's because people enjoyed a sort of cinematic look at what life was like in
- 3:42the good old days, and so there's a sense in which it has that
- 3:46conservative vibe. However, I have seen it criticized in right wing media as
- 3:51having a strong Republican agenda, probably because the show sometimes takes liberty in criticizing
- 3:58the monarchy, at least implicitly. So I enjoyed the show too, but
- 4:02I think part of the reason for that is to help with the continual recognition
- 4:06that people are making in my country that the royal family are just that a
- 4:10family, They're just Homo sapiens like any of the rest of us, and
- 4:14that defending their institution has become, i would say, almost impossible in the
- 4:18twenty first century. All right, well, let me play Devil's advocate.
- 4:23They're part of the cultural, the national identity. I guess it's hashtag tourism.
- 4:29People love the monarchy. Why would you kill their dreams? You know,
- 4:32the fairy tale? So they do. I mean, the monarchy are
- 4:35quite clearly an emblem of British identity, just like the London Eye or Paddington
- 4:41Bear. For what it's worth, I think that the London Eye should be
- 4:43ripped down to the thing was supposed to be temporary, and it's this sort
- 4:46of ugly stain on an increasingly ugly city that is London, you know,
- 4:50putting it next door essentially to the Palace of Westminster, I think is an
- 4:55aesthetic disgrace and is the most principle other than the barber and the principal challenge
- 5:00to my view that beauty is in fact subjective. If you want to test
- 5:04that intuition, just go and stare at the London I for long enough and
- 5:08you'll be shaken. To you a very core Paddington bear as well the differences
- 5:12that people grown adults don't pretend to take it seriously or believe in its existence
- 5:15anymore. I have no problem with people saying that the monarchy are a sort
- 5:18of representative icon of British society. But the interesting thing is that if I
- 5:23ask you to think of the royals, if I ask you to think of
- 5:26the monarch, chances are you're picturing Queen Elizabeth. Indeed, if I ask
- 5:30you to think of the Queen of England, if I asked you to picture
- 5:31the Queen of England right now, who are you picturing? You're probably picturing
- 5:34Elizabeth. I can't be certain of it, but you're not picturing the Queen
- 5:38of England. The Queen of England is Camilla. Nobody thinks of Camilla,
- 5:42and it seems interesting to me that if it is true that the monarch serves
- 5:46this emblematic role, that this is a role that can be served at least
- 5:51as well and probably better by a dead woman and by a living one.
- 5:56I think that has a lot to say about the institution itself. We also
- 6:00mentioned tourism. Tourism has brought up a lot. There are a few things
- 6:01to say on this. I mean, everybody likes to talk about tourism as
- 6:05if our decision about who the head of state should be should be subject to
- 6:13the whims of tourism. I mean, I pointed out before that Chester Zoo
- 6:18in the United Kingdom is a bigger tourist attraction than Buckingham Palace or Windsor Castle.
- 6:24And I've commented before that I wouldn't therefore be in favor of having its
- 6:27executives or the animals which are kept within its cages elected as head of state.
- 6:33People like to say that, well, the reason why people come to
- 6:36the country is because the monarchy is still in action, and I'm afraid I
- 6:42just can't believe that this is true. My colleague in this matter. At
- 6:45least. Graham Smith once sat down with the chair of Visit Britain, who
- 6:48told him that there's absolutely no evidence that the UK would make any less money
- 6:53in tourism if the monarchy were to be abolished. It's not like people are
- 6:56going to stop visiting Buckingham Palace. At the time of the corone of King
- 7:01Charles. I messaged a friend of mine. I said, hey, what
- 7:04are you doing. I'd love to just go down into London, into where
- 7:09it's all happening and look at the events, just see the spectacle. And
- 7:12he said, oh, I'm sorry, I'm actually on holiday at the moment.
- 7:14I'm in France. I said, what the hell are you doing in
- 7:15France? What could you possibly want to do in France as a tourist now
- 7:19that they've abolished their monarchy. I can't understand why a single person would want
- 7:21to go and visit the beautiful, architecturally impressive city of Paris without it being
- 7:29ruled by an unelected head of state. It just doesn't make any sense.
- 7:30I mean, come on, can anybody actually take this argument seriously? I
- 7:34don't know. I struggle to see it. Even if they did bring enough
- 7:36money in to make it sort of worth the amount that we're paying them.
- 7:41I still don't think that's a good enough reason to justify them being the head
- 7:44of state in our country. I mean, imagine if somebody tried to say
- 7:46that we should keep our current prime minister because you know, extra tourists come
- 7:49down, because he's quite a character. You know, people want to catch
- 7:51a glimpse of Boris Johnson through the window of ten Downing Streets, so let's
- 7:55keep him as the prime And it would be a ludicrous way to try to
- 7:58determine who the head of state is. And I think that's apply to the
- 8:01monarchy too. I think the divine right of kings or queens is probably at
- 8:05this moment my biggest objection. You know, you're born better. I mean,
- 8:09they would dispute that at its surface, but given how they are perceived
- 8:13and treated, I mean, the idea is that they are divinely ordained,
- 8:18born better than the commoners. Would you agree with that. I'd say the
- 8:22idea was that I don't think anybody can actually take it seriously anymore, which
- 8:26is why you don't tend to see this attitude taken even by the royals himself.
- 8:30I mean, Charles talks about serving his nation rather than ruling it,
- 8:33because of course nobody actually believes this anymore, even they themselves can't seriously believe
- 8:39that, especially if you take the I mean, the Church of England is
- 8:43England, but that the king is the king of the entire United Kingdom,
- 8:46which includes Whales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. If I'm expected to believe that
- 8:50the reason why he has the right to rule over these nations is because some
- 8:54god ordained from time immemorial, god whose true nature was of course only fully
- 9:01understood when coincidentally Henry the Eighth got bored of his wife, as kings will
- 9:09sometimes do, that this God ordains through some kind of you know, specific
- 9:16desire, that this man is to rule over Great Britain as well as a
- 9:20few of its surrounding islands, including the top sort of fifteen percent of one
- 9:24of those islands, and that the history of abdications and wars and invasions and
- 9:30infighting and assassinations don't count towards thinking that maybe there might be a bit more
- 9:35arbitrarianis in this process than people like to talk about. No, this is
- 9:39just sort of the method that I suppose God chose to bring his rightful king
- 9:43to the throne. It just doesn't seem serious to me. And the problem
- 9:46is that we're in an international world now. It's quite easy to forget that
- 9:52there are people existing and living outside of your own country when you're living in
- 9:56the Middle Ages. I mean, you'd never think about other countries really,
- 10:00if you're just a common subject of the king. But now we're constantly confronted
- 10:05by the fact that there's an entire world out there, and it just seems
- 10:07very strange. I think to people that God would ordain that this king rules
- 10:11over this particular you know, allotment of territory. It just seems strange.
- 10:18It just seems absurd, and so I don't think anybody can take it seriously
- 10:20anymore. Segue to Ben Shapiro, who I mentioned just a few moments ago.
- 10:26He is a right wing I would call him a journalist, commentator,
- 10:30activist. He is a founder of the co found I can't remember the Daily
- 10:33Wire. He is hugely popular. He is also astoundingly, alarmingly, jow
- 10:41droppingly wrong almost every time he says something. He just did a rant about
- 10:48the female feminist documentary filmmaker who is going to Helm the next Star Wars and
- 10:54they've now decided to turn over the universal a person named Charmin obeyed CHINOI.
- 10:58So who exactly is this person? Well, she's mostly famous for having made
- 11:03a couple of nonfiction documentaries that one oscars about feminism and anti feminism in Pakistan,
- 11:11which that's fine, but what is that? What does that have to
- 11:15do with Star Wars? What makes you think that you can transition from making
- 11:18a terrific documentary about say, honor killings in Pakistan to now you're in charge
- 11:24of the Star Wars universe? Like, where is that? How? How
- 11:26does that happen? Well, she then was a director, one of the
- 11:31directors on Miss Marvel, the twenty twenty two series from Disney Plus that literally
- 11:35no one watched and that no one wanted to watch and then no one cared
- 11:37about because it looked not good. And they've decided to put her in charge
- 11:43of the next Star Wars movie, which we'll focus in on Ray. You
- 11:46remember Ray, or maybe you don't. She is the star of the last
- 11:50Star Wars trilogy, in which they killed off all the characters you love in
- 11:54favor of characters that no one gave any hoots about whatsoever. And Ben Shapiro
- 11:58says that producer Kathleen Kennedy is one of the or legitimately the worst entertainment executive
- 12:05of his lifetime. We're talking about someone who's produced some of the biggest films
- 12:09of the last half century. He predicted the Barbie movie was going to die
- 12:15of wokeness. It would crash and burn like the Hindenburg. Now we're looking
- 12:20at what one point four billion dollar global revenues, and he's gotten into morality
- 12:26with you. This was a post from Ben Shapiro. I'll just read it.
- 12:30The Bible is rooted in distinctions, that which is holy and that which
- 12:35is unholy. The entire goal of religion is to separate good from evil.
- 12:41Secularism insists on the exact opposite, by dissolving all boundaries and distinctions in a
- 12:48vain and naive hope of a better world. I guess this is a play
- 12:54on what the objective moral standard argument. Let's talk about Ben Shapiro's tape on
- 13:00morality versus yours. Well, I must say my experience of Ben Spiro wasn't
- 13:07particularly bad, at least on that day. Well, you guys had a
- 13:09very agreeable exchange. I thought there would be more fireworks, but you two
- 13:15were remarkably even voiced, and props to you for that. Oh I don't.
- 13:18I don't enjoy battle for battle's sake. Really. I don't find it
- 13:24to be productive. I don't find it to even be particularly entertaining, at
- 13:28least not when you're actually in it. It can be fun to watch,
- 13:30of course, but it turns you into something of a drama channel, which
- 13:33I don't think anybody wants. I don't watch much of Ben Sapiro's content,
- 13:37so I don't really know what to say about him more generally, but I
- 13:41will say I didn't know what I was to expect when he walked in the
- 13:45room, knowing he's about to come in and sort of debate me and I.
- 13:48You know, a lot of people say this kind of thing about Ben,
- 13:50so for all I knew he was about to walk in and sort of
- 13:54be a bit sort of hostile, or a bit on edge or sort of
- 13:56sitting down and right, right, let's get on with this kind of thing.
- 13:58But no, he walks in, he shook my and he was perfectly
- 14:00amicable. You know, we had a we had a chat before everything was
- 14:03rolling. I you know, I got on with the guy. It was,
- 14:05it was, it was fine. I had a lot of people messaging
- 14:07me afterwards being like, you know, was he you know, was he
- 14:09an ahole? All of this kind of stuff, And I was like,
- 14:11I'm sorry, but no, he just he just wasn't. I actually quite
- 14:15enjoyed the conversation, and as you say, I think it was quite sort
- 14:18of civil and even handed, and there wasn't any real sort of gotchas exactly
- 14:24might be an example of getting adversaries or opponents. So we're even just interlocutors
- 14:28in the same physical space, and perhaps it's a little easier to maintain a
- 14:33level of I don't know, an even voice and an even temper. But
- 14:37you were talking about good and what is good and your own struggles with the
- 14:43word good. And I've heard apologist religious people say, well, if you're
- 14:46not religious, how could you know what was good? But you said you
- 14:50may be uncomfortable with the word. Can you explain, well, I don't
- 14:56believe in objective ethics. The view that I'm I'm most closely aligned with is
- 15:01a BW called ethical emotivism, which you'll probably have heard of. Perhaps your
- 15:05audience haven't. It's just the idea that ethical statements are essentially expressions of emotion.
- 15:11What this means is that when somebody asked me how I ground good,
- 15:13I can't tell them. The principle objection that I had with Ben Shapiro was
- 15:18that whatever criticism he made of atheism, well, without God, you can't
- 15:20have free will. Without God, you can't have ethics. I'm happy to
- 15:24just agree with that, to say, sure you can't, but I don't
- 15:26see why it is that by believing in the existence of God that changes.
- 15:31If you see what I'm saying. That was the principal criticism. So when
- 15:35I was asked how do you ground good? I have to just say,
- 15:35like, I can't, at least not in a way that's going to be
- 15:39satisfactory to either Ben or or the Christians or religious people who are listening.
- 15:45I mean, it's a Christian show, despite neither of us being a Christian.
- 15:50Probably what I meant by saying I have a problem with the term.
- 15:54But what I really wanted to get into was my critique of the idea that
- 15:56believing in God makes that problem go away, I think, and don't let
- 16:00me misrepresent you, But I got the vibe that you asserted god belief actually
- 16:06made the problem worse. I'm sort of conjecturing that it can. I mean,
- 16:11like where a religious person might want to say, well, if you
- 16:15don't believe in God, you know, is there anything stopping you from murdering
- 16:18somebody? And to be honest with you, I just don't know. I
- 16:21don't know. This seems to be a somewhat empirical question, you know,
- 16:23what actually happens to somebody's brain depending on what they believe. But it's very
- 16:27easy to just say if God doesn't exist, then everything is permitted. But
- 16:32the most famous inversion of that Dostoievskian phrase is that if God is real,
- 16:37then anything is permitted. So the question I raised in return is to say,
- 16:40well, look, can't you just as easily say that if you believe
- 16:42that God is telling you to murder someone, then there's nothing I can do
- 16:47to talk you out of it. It may even be more difficult to talk
- 16:49you out of it if you believe that God is telling you to do it.
- 16:52There are problems I think with trying to ground morality in the existence of
- 16:57a God, especially if it's done so on the grounds, but it essentially
- 17:00can't be done anywhere else. I mean, as far as I'm concerned,
- 17:04the religions of the world are false. I think that they are incorrect.
- 17:10That is, I don't think there really is a supernatural authority. And what
- 17:12that means is that the inventions of religious morality are just those inventions and inventions
- 17:18of a human mind. Now, if you have a human morality that recognizes
- 17:22that it is essentially a series of compromises between the history of mankind trying to
- 17:26get along with each other on a planet, then what happens is sometimes these
- 17:30ideas and these philosophies rub up against the real world, and we can adapt
- 17:37them as necessary. Now, there is a deep problem with this, and
- 17:41that is, if I meet a man who wants to kill me or a
- 17:45friend, and he says that he doesn't believe in God, there's very little
- 17:48I can do to talk him out of that, except I can threaten him
- 17:52with legal sanction. I can threaten him with moral reproach, exclusion from the
- 17:56moral community, but there's not much more I can do. However, if
- 18:00a person says that he wants to kill me, and he believes that he
- 18:03wants to kill me because God has told him to do so, then I
- 18:04don't even have that minimal approach reproach available to me, because there is no
- 18:10law written by any man of any time that could ever count one iota against
- 18:14the dictates of the Creator of the universe. Therefore, if that God in
- 18:18fact does not exist, and if these moralities are in fact human inventions,
- 18:22then what you have in the grounding of an ethical system in the dictates allegedly
- 18:29of the Creator of the universe. It's all of the arbitrariness and subjectivity and
- 18:34failure and faults of nihilism and human invented morality, with all of the certainty
- 18:41and all of the faith and all of the unanswerability of the Creator of the
- 18:47universe. That to me seems a dangerous cocktail that we drink at our peril.
- 18:53Can atheism justify human rights? And how would you even define human rights?
- 19:00With Alex O'Connor next, I'm doing some traveling this year and I would
- 19:11love to be able to meet you on the road. I'm speaking March seventeenth
- 19:14in Orlando, April seventh, Kansas City, May nineteenth, Los Angeles,
- 19:19California. University of Arkansas got the Secular Student Alliance Conference that's the weekend of
- 19:26June fourteenth, Denver. I'll be out there June twenty ninth, Sarnia,
- 19:30Ontario, the second weekend of August. Seth Andrews dot com. Slash Events
- 19:38has all the details. Continuing now with my special guest Alex O'Connor. I've
- 19:47heard, in fact, I heard Ben Shapiro mention it. Our own Speaker
- 19:51of the House speaks about it. There have been sermons preached nationwide about the
- 19:55United States founded on Judeo Christian values, and I've been struck by the term.
- 20:00We just throw it out there. Some people say that it marks Judaism
- 20:03sort of segueing into Christianity. Some say that Judaism and Christianity are kind of
- 20:08equal partners Judeo Christian. Some people they reject it because, you know,
- 20:15Judaism is sort of Jesus free, right, I mean, how does a
- 20:18Christian embrace Judaism whenever they don't really embrace christ I don't know. Help me
- 20:23out. What's your take on Judeo Christian from your vantage across the ocean.
- 20:29Well, it is interesting how people have just sort of accepted this term and
- 20:32the lexicon. One of the great interests if you believe in it. Of
- 20:36One of the great criticisms if you don't of the Christian story is it's a
- 20:41seeming contrast and friction with the Old Testament, and people talk about them as
- 20:45if they're different characters, the New Testament God and the Old Testament God.
- 20:49That makes sense in a literary sense, but as a theology, this has
- 20:52to be the same, the same God. The interesting thing is that when
- 20:56people say Judeo Christian values, I don't think they're talking about what's in scripture.
- 21:00They're not talking about what's in the Bible. I think this has a
- 21:02lot to do with Tom Holland's thesis his book Dominion, which tries to claim
- 21:07that specifically Christian values have so embedded themselves into Western culture that we consider Christian
- 21:12ideas to just be these self evident moral truths that the West is based upon,
- 21:17and we don't even recognize that it's Christian. I suppose the problem I
- 21:19have with this is that it may be the case that what people have claimed
- 21:25are self evident, you know, life, liberty in the pursuit of happiness,
- 21:29maybe property, these kinds of things, These are not self evident.
- 21:32They are only self evidence of people who have sort of adopted these views as
- 21:36at a sort of depth of societal construction that they become sort of ethical truisms.
- 21:42The problem is that even if this might be true, and even if
- 21:45this might have come out of nominally Christian societies, it seems to conflict with
- 21:51what's actually written in the scripture. I mean, when you ask someone like
- 21:53Tom Holland what kind of Western civilization values you to talking about, I mean,
- 22:00what are the archetypal values of Western civilization? I mean, I don't
- 22:06know, things like equality of genders. And you look at what Saint Pool
- 22:11has to say about women, and a question Mark has raised. Maybe it's
- 22:14about the idea that everyone's born free and the idea of human rights. And
- 22:18then you look at what the Old Testament has to say about the ownership of
- 22:21other human beings as private property. And indeed the New Testament also at least
- 22:26implicitly condones slavery as well. That seems to be out of accordance. Western
- 22:32civilization is built upon a capitalist economic system, which seems to be out of
- 22:37accord with the kind of the kind of sort of say moral worldview of Jesus
- 22:42and his asceticism and sort of communal living. In other words, I don't
- 22:48actually think that what people are calling Judeo Christian values Judeo Christian society is anything
- 22:52to do with Judaism and the Old Testament or Christianity and the New Testament.
- 22:57What they're talking about. It's just the history of view of the past few
- 23:00hundred years or something like that. What's that line, Let's play a game,
- 23:04open the Old Testament to any verse and do exactly what it says,
- 23:08last one to go to jail wins. I always thought that was, you
- 23:11know, kind of interesting. I don't mean to be labor Shapiro, but
- 23:15this was part of your discussion. Then I'll move on. You got into
- 23:18Old Testament slavery, and he leaned into this kind And I've narrated an audiobook
- 23:23by a seriologist, doctor Josh Bowen did the Old Testament endoorse slavery where he
- 23:29really really sort of unlayers the onion. But you know he seemed to lean
- 23:33into well, you know, this was the system in place at the time.
- 23:37Therefore, yahweh had to condescend and use the system. He didn't want
- 23:41to disrupt the order. If you believe, as I do, in a
- 23:44god who spoke to human beings in some form of fashion and has to speak
- 23:48to them on a level that they can understand in ways they can understand.
- 23:52Then that immediately is going to discount the ability to do a lot of very
- 23:56radical things that have that would have appeared radical in twelve hundred BC but now
- 24:00appear to be calm inplace. Well, so many things to say. I
- 24:03mean, one is to say, even if it were true that God for
- 24:07some reason couldn't abolish slavery as a practice, he certainly could have put some
- 24:11regulations on it. And this is what a lot of I don't know what
- 24:15to call him Christians Jews like to like to say, is that, well,
- 24:21look, at least we can see that God seems to be regulating slavery,
- 24:22so he's trying to sort of ready people for one day abolishing slavery.
- 24:26The problem is that those regulations are still proactively immral and it's not like,
- 24:30I mean, I can understand if God says, you know, stop doing
- 24:34this or stop doing this, and he doesn't tell you to stop doing everything
- 24:37because maybe people aren't ready for that yet, or maybe he doesn't think to
- 24:41mention absolutely everything you shouldn't be doing. But there are times when God gives
- 24:44explicit permission to do particular things. If you have if you sort of take
- 24:49a city, if you see your city in war, and the Old Testament
- 24:52of the Hebrew Bible says that if you find a woman that you find attractive
- 24:57amongst the captives, then you can take her your wife. You take her
- 25:00home, you shave her head, you cut off her fingernails in this kind
- 25:03of bizarre ritual, and after thirty days mourning the loss of her husband,
- 25:07who you might have just killed, you take her as your wife. Now
- 25:11that seems immral to me. I might be in a minority there. I
- 25:15don't know. The problem is that if you want to say that, well,
- 25:18God just couldn't have abolish slavery altogether, you have to contend with verses
- 25:22like this, what's going on here? Then this isn't him sort of you
- 25:25know, slowly condemning and putting restrictions on things. It's like, no,
- 25:27here's here's a proactive way that you can take a wife your from your from
- 25:33your captors. It just seems impossible to describe it in the terms that you're
- 25:38talking about. In other words, the other thing to say is that If
- 25:41it were the case that God could only ready people for one day abolishing slavery,
- 25:45wouldn't the New Testament have been the perfect time to do that. That
- 25:48is, if it's true that God couldn't just abolish slavery altogether because people weren't
- 25:52ready for it, why not give them a few thousand years and then by
- 25:56the time of the New Testament maybe they'll be ready for an explicit condemnation.
- 26:00But it never comes. No, God leaves it not to the logos incarnate
- 26:04to tell us that slavery is wrong. He leaves it to some Christian preachers
- 26:10hundreds you know what, like hundreds over a thousand years later, to work
- 26:15out by reading between the lines of what Jesus says. Despite the fact that
- 26:18Paul says, slaves be obedient to your masters, not just the good not
- 26:22just the good ones, but also the cruel or the fruid is the king
- 26:26James has it, Despite the fact that Jesus sort of casually mentions slavery in
- 26:32a story that he's telling, which seems he wouldn't He could have chosen anything,
- 26:36but he seems like he wouldn't do if he had a problem with it.
- 26:40No, like if you see what I'm saying. We're expected to believe
- 26:45that God sort of designed this so that slavery would be abolished by people reading
- 26:49between these lines and getting out what God really wanted all along. Forget the
- 26:52fact that he doesn't mention it in any of the books of the Old Testament,
- 26:56which is a library of books, not a single book. You know,
- 27:00it pays to remember. And then when people say, well, they
- 27:03just weren't ready for it, well, guess what, We've got a whole
- 27:06New Testament. But I guess they weren't ready for it then either no,
- 27:08it was only sort of in Christian Europe or something that people were ready for
- 27:15it. It just seems strange to me. In other words, I don't
- 27:17actually understand what people are saying when they say this. What are you saying
- 27:22about your God? What are you saying about your scripture? What are you
- 27:23saying is the point of the New Testament? I don't know. It doesn't
- 27:26make sense. I don't get the generational context. How is sex slavery on
- 27:32any level acceptable thousands of years ago? But it's not today? I mean,
- 27:37it's sex slavery right, It does seem to be sex slavery in a
- 27:41few places that perhaps the most common example is number thirty one, where moseses
- 27:45instructs his armies to kill the Midianites, to kill all of the men and
- 27:51the women who haven't slept with a man. But you keep for yourselves the
- 27:55women who haven't slept with a man. Look, it's not sort of explicit,
- 28:00it's not like keep them as your sex slaves, but it's quite clear
- 28:02that they're at least supposed to be taken as wives as captors of war.
- 28:06And there are other areas too, the one I've already mentioned, for example,
- 28:08that do seem to indicate at least taking wives, and I don't know
- 28:15if that would be sex when we think of sex slavery. Indeed, one
- 28:18of the points that does need to be recognized, and it's something that Christians
- 28:25and Jews will say that I think is true, is that when we say
- 28:26things like slavery, we tend to think of like Antebellum United States slavery,
- 28:32that kind of thing, and slavery if the Old Testament wouldn't have looked like
- 28:34that. But the problem is that even when you understand what kind of slavery
- 28:38we are talking about, it still seems morally problematic to us. People like
- 28:41to say, for example, that you have to understand that this is a
- 28:45society where women can't survive on their own if their husbands have been killed in
- 28:48war. There's no way that they're able to survive on their own. You
- 28:52know, they don't have any property, they don't have any rights to speak
- 28:55of. You know, they need a man to look after them. And
- 28:56that's why the Bible says, well, take these women and as your wives
- 29:00is essentially a protective measure for them. And that sounds quite convincing. It's
- 29:03like, oh, you know what, there enough, if my husband had
- 29:07just been killed in war and I wasn't going to be able to survive,
- 29:10then maybe I'd like to be to become someone's wife just so that I'm protected.
- 29:15Okay, fine, But then the question becomes, why does this only
- 29:18apply to the virgins. Why is it only the virgins that get that kind
- 29:22of protection. If the woman is married to the man that you've just killed,
- 29:26oh you just kill her too. It seems to have maybe something to
- 29:30do with sex. That's not to say that they're sort of kept in a
- 29:33basement tied up in the worst form of sexual slavery the picture in sort of
- 29:37modern human trafficking conditions or sor something like that. But it still seems morally
- 29:42problematic, and it's something that because it's written explicitly and it's explicitly condoned and
- 29:47permitted in scripture, the option isn't available to essentially reinterpret these texts. It
- 29:52has to have either been morally permissible at the time and not now, which
- 29:56turns God into something of a moral relativist, or God to have permitted something
- 30:00immoral, which brings a whole bunch of problems of its own. Well,
- 30:03I'm here speaking with Alex O'Connor on human rights. You did a debate at
- 30:07Oxford with an Islamic apologist, a guy named Sibor Ahmad. The title was
- 30:15can atheism justify human rights? Now? From an atheistic perspective, all you
- 30:22have is spacetime, matter, energy, and chance. Using those building blocks,
- 30:26how can you come up with the idea of right and wrong and impartiality?
- 30:30You can't. But from a theistic worldview, you have the idea of
- 30:36justice as an ontological principle, which is real and true. Alex is saying,
- 30:41but I can't touch it. But again he's got this limited physical idea
- 30:45of if I can't touch it, it's not there, right, But that's
- 30:48a very limited, crude way of actually thinking about reality. Well, let
- 30:52me play apologist. If Alex O'Connor says, I don't like murder, but
- 30:57you don't have an active standard. You are an atheist, you're godless.
- 31:02Why don't you like murder? Well, I don't know, but it doesn't
- 31:04matter because what we've done is we've sort of psychologized here. It's exactly the
- 31:10same as if you know, if a bit of rain falls on your head
- 31:12and you sort of recoil a little bit and you sort of go, oh
- 31:15God, and I go, hold on, why did you go? Why
- 31:18didn't you like that? Why did you react in that way? Why did
- 31:21you recoil? You just go, I don't know, I just don't like
- 31:23it. It's just a fact. I just don't like it. I almost
- 31:26didn't choose to recoil in that way. I just did. It was just
- 31:29an expression. It was just a reaction to what I've seen. And that's
- 31:32what the ethical emotivist does. They don't claim that they're saying anything true.
- 31:36They don't claim that they're making a claim about the world. They're just expressing
- 31:40an emotion, and crucially, they think that everybody's doing this when they talk
- 31:42about morality. So ethical emotivism is really a philosophy of language rather than a
- 31:48philosophy of morality. So you're not making a false equivalent statement. Forgive me
- 31:52the interruption, but you're not making a false equivalence a value statement that murder
- 31:57or not murdering are the same because someone may have a subjective reaction to it.
- 32:02The important thing to note is that people talk about morality is if it's
- 32:07either objective or it's subjective. Ethical emotives say that it's neither. It's not
- 32:12subjectively true, it's not objectively true. It just doesn't have this truth value,
- 32:16right saying I like murder or I don't like murder. That has truth
- 32:22value. That can be true. It can be true with that I don't
- 32:24like murder, but just going boom murder can't be true or false. And
- 32:30that's the difference between ethical emotivism and like ethical subjectivism. Ethical motives say that
- 32:36they just can't be truth value. It's the same so other forms of non
- 32:38cognitivism. For example, so emotivism is after emotions, you're expressing an emotion.
- 32:44But some people think I think R. M. Hair is a proponent
- 32:46of this view. If I'm not mistaken that ethical statements are more like commands,
- 32:52that when I say murder is wrong, what I really mean is something
- 32:55like don't murder. That that's what I'm saying. And the phrase don't murder
- 33:00can't be true, it can't be false. It's just a command. And
- 33:05so if somebody says, well, are you subjectively saying that murder is wrong?
- 33:10Like no, there's no truth to be objective or subjective. It's just
- 33:15a command. It's just an expression. If you see what I'm saying,
- 33:17philosophers, you always you're so complicated, Alex, I'm just saying it's a
- 33:23headache. I saw on your channel near the end of twenty twenty three something
- 33:30I have never seen before. Now I've seen walkouts in debates, and I
- 33:34wouldn't call your exchange with Peter Hitchins a debate. Really, it was just
- 33:37a discussion a couple of interlocutors in a room. And for those who don't
- 33:42know, Peter Hitchins is brother of the late Christopher Hitchens. And before I
- 33:46talk about Peter, Christopher and Peter actually debated each other, like back in
- 33:51two thousand and eight. That debate is on YouTube and it's fascinating. Peter
- 33:55is a Christian, and I would call him a Christian apologist with some very
- 34:00problematic ideas, and they were at the time debating in the Iraq War.
- 34:05This is one of the things, one of the very few things that I
- 34:07sort of disagreed with hitch On was he was very hawkish about taking out Saddam.
- 34:13And of course we all saw the debacle of the WMD claims and the
- 34:16vacuum that appeared after Saddam was dispatched. But you have taken issue with some
- 34:24stuff that Christopher Hitchen said, and you know, that's a pretty gutsy move.
- 34:30You know, he's pretty beloved in the free thought community. What's your
- 34:34problem with hitch Well, I've accused Christoph Hitchins as being a sophist. There
- 34:40are times when you watch Christopher Hitchens speak, including the debate that you mentioned,
- 34:45where some of the greatest speeches that have been given in perhaps the past
- 34:50hundred years, But a lot of the time they're essentially stand up comedy routines.
- 34:54And look, there's no problem with this. Debates are essentially just theater.
- 34:59But if I asked you to take Christopher Hitchins's arguments that he makes and
- 35:01to formally syllogize them, you know, to take them, to put them
- 35:06into your own language, and to put them into sort of premise, premise,
- 35:07conclusion form. I think if you publish those arguments, as you know,
- 35:12a compendium, people wouldn't even come close to being convinced by them.
- 35:15I'm not sure that that's the case. There might be a few that people
- 35:19like, but in my view, there were too many occasions where the things
- 35:22he was saying would just we're just sort of void of argumentative force. Now,
- 35:29like I love Christopher Hitchins, anybody who is familiar with my work will
- 35:31know how much he was an influence on me. You know, his writing
- 35:37and his speeches have had such a profound influence on everything that I do that
- 35:40it's even seeped its way into the way that I talk. And this sort
- 35:45of happened unintentionally, But people sometimes comment that it's like I'm imitating his cadence,
- 35:50which I think when I'm actually at a podium giving a talk, I
- 35:52can sometimes do this speech at the Oxyord Union that I gave I saw some
- 35:55comments saying the same thing. In fact, one of my friends who was
- 35:59at the debate told me that when I was speaking, somebody sat behind him.
- 36:04He was sat there with a girl, maybe his girlfriend or something,
- 36:07and he hurt. This person turned to this girl when I was speaking.
- 36:09And this guy doesn't know who I am. He just saw me at this
- 36:12debate and say something like he's doing a Christopher Hitchins or something like that,
- 36:16And I thought, okay, fair enough. That can be a compliment or
- 36:20an insult, depending on who it's coming from. So, you know,
- 36:22throat clearing love the guy. However, it does seem quite strange to me
- 36:27that there is this attitude of you know, wow, you know, I
- 36:31can't believe that you criticized Christopher Hitchins like you say, he's a beloved figure.
- 36:36You know, what a brave thing for you to do. I think
- 36:37to myself, how low is the bar for our discussions. I mean,
- 36:39the whole freethinking atheist skeptic community is supposed to pride itself on the idea that,
- 36:44you know, nothing is beyond criticism and we're trying to get to the
- 36:47truth. But the moment you even think about criticizing somebody from your own side,
- 36:51as it were, he's sort of getting congratulated on how much of an
- 36:53open thinker you are. You know, how much of an open mind that
- 36:55you have. I think how low is the bar that simply by saying,
- 37:00you know, this guy that's almost universally revered in this community. Some of
- 37:02the things he said, I'm giving three examples in this video, I think
- 37:07weren't very good, and people sort of accuse you of an intellectual bravery and
- 37:10uniqueness. I think that's got to be a problem. Right, Well,
- 37:14you mentioned there were three things. I mean, give me one or two
- 37:17examples of disagreements. There are a number, I mean, so I can't
- 37:21remember exactly which examples I gave in the video, but so, for example,
- 37:23I think the first one I gave was talking about the moral argument.
- 37:28And it's also something that you seem to have alluded to yourself earlier, this
- 37:30idea that religious people will claim that you can't know what's right and wrong.
- 37:35I think you said that earlier in this discussion. I don't actually think that's
- 37:37generally true. I don't think religious apologists, at least, you know,
- 37:42ones whose arguments I would take seriously say that, So what would happens?
- 37:45Somebody would say to Christopher Hitchins, if you're an atheist, how do you
- 37:49ground morality? How can you say that moral things, that moral claims are
- 37:52true and false? What are you what are you basing that in? And
- 37:55Hitchins would say, how dare you say that I can't teach children right and
- 38:00wrong without subscribing to your celestial dictator? You know, how can you possibly
- 38:06say that we can't be moral without God? This kind of thing, which
- 38:09is a subtle but really crucial misunderstanding of the question. This religious apologist isn't
- 38:15claiming that Christopher Hitchens can't know what's right and wrong, that he can't teach
- 38:20his children what's right and wrong, that he doesn't have access to what's right
- 38:23and wrong. He's saying that you can't justify your belief in the rightness and
- 38:28wrongness of those actions, which is true, by the way, because if
- 38:30you ask Christopher Hichens how he actually grounded them, he'd say, Oh,
- 38:34I think we just have a sort of you know, common humanity. You
- 38:37know, I think we just sort of evolved as a community, and so
- 38:42we need to learn how to get along with each other this kind of thing,
- 38:45and that doesn't do anything to prove that moral claims are actually true and
- 38:49false. It just means that humans seem to have are generally shared which also
- 38:54may not be true. Generally shared sense that certain things have right and wrong.
- 38:59Cool. But the quesquestion is how do you know that that sense is
- 39:00actually sensitive to the truth? And he couldn't answer it. All he would
- 39:05say is, how dare you say that I can't know right and wrong?
- 39:07Which isn't what he was being accused of, but was enough to give him
- 39:10an applause from the audience. I mean, here's one other example for you.
- 39:14If you're familiar with Christopher Hitchins, you'll know that at one point he
- 39:21says, he says, well, if you want to believe in God,
- 39:28then you have to believe that for thousands of years, for thousands of years,
- 39:31Heaven watches with folded arms. For one hundred thousand years, humans are
- 39:36born as a primate species. Expectation of life what twenty five years for the
- 39:43first two one hundred thousand years, first few tens of thousands, infant mortality,
- 39:49rife, microorganism, disease, terrifying earthquakes, volcanoes, extraordinary, and
- 40:00fights over land, over territory, over food, over women, over tribalism,
- 40:07frightening too. For ninety five ninety six thousand years. Heaven watches this
- 40:15with folded once with indifference, with coldness, and then around three to four
- 40:22thousand years ago. But only in really barbaric illiterate parts for the Middle East,
- 40:29not in China, not in China or where people can read or think
- 40:32or do science. No, no, no, in barbaric, illiterate backward
- 40:37parts of the Middle East. Is decided, we can't let this go.
- 40:40Only better intervene, and what better way than by human sacrifices and plagues and
- 40:47mass murder. And if that doesn't make them behave morally, we just don't
- 40:52know what it does. And he's sort of saying as a joke, you
- 40:58know, people would laugh because he's he's parodying it. He's saying, oh
- 41:00and oh, and I know, you know, let's not intervene in China
- 41:05where people can read. No, let's intervene in an illiterate backward part of
- 41:09the Middle East where, or at least one recording I have him saying,
- 41:13you know, he says, where they're essentially living like animals, you know,
- 41:16let's do it there. Okay, fine, rhetorical point, yeah,
- 41:22interesting, why would you do it to these people? But five minutes ago,
- 41:24when I was asking you about morality, you were saying, well,
- 41:28we don't need God to be moral. We don't need God to know what's
- 41:30right and wrong. You know, we don't need divine intervention to understand ethics.
- 41:35But now the criticism you're making is that this intervention happened in a weird
- 41:38time in human history where people were living in backwards conditions, living like animals,
- 41:44you know, where they were essentially illiterate and ignorant and living incredulity.
- 41:49Well, hold on, which is it? You know, these two don't
- 41:51seem to gel very well together. Either we need religious guidance and divine intervention
- 41:57to know what's right and wrong, or we don't. And if we do,
- 42:00then your first point doesn't seem to work about you know, knowing morals
- 42:06without God. But if we don't, then that second point you make about
- 42:08the weirdness of him intervening at a time where people are illiterate and credulous and
- 42:15ignorant and living like animals, doesn't work. Okay, Alex O'Connor interviewed Peter
- 42:22Hitchins. It did not go well. Do I call it a rage quit?
- 42:29I don't know. I mean, I'm going to play you some audio
- 42:30in the next segment and you tell me more with Alex O'Connor next. Thanks
- 42:39so much for listening. I'm speaking here with Alex O'Connor. He is host
- 42:45of the within Reason podcast. At long Last, allow me to draw me
- 42:52draw the conversation back to Peter Hitchins. You're sitting in the room. You
- 42:57end up agreeing on two topics. I believe it was legalization of drugs in
- 43:00God and you got about forty minutes in you were still speaking about the legalization
- 43:07of drugs. I thought you were hugely reasonable. You were just asking questions,
- 43:09you were citing some information, statistics from various nations. You were challenging,
- 43:15but not in a rude way. And he gets up and calls you
- 43:21on a lot of pejoratives and says you're acting in bad faith and you are
- 43:27a propagandist and you were luring him there under false pretenses. And he just
- 43:31leaves and did he go what was the aftermath? Did he go on social
- 43:37media and set fire to you or what happened. Well he did. He
- 43:40did go on social media. I mean, look, I'm trying to I
- 43:45try to make sense of this, and I try to do it fairly,
- 43:46because of course, being in the seat when that happens, it's easy enough
- 43:51to just sort of be stunned and say to everybody, oh, look what
- 43:53this crazy guy just did. But like you got to think about it for
- 43:57a moment. You got to think, well, this must have happened for
- 43:59a reason. Let's try and work it out if I may, very quickly,
- 44:00though, I need to do my due diligence. The reason that he
- 44:05left before we talk about how you retreated afterwards, But what were the precursors
- 44:09that caused him to stand up? Well, this is this is what I
- 44:15was sort of trying to work out the best. What he says is that
- 44:19it's because he became convinced that I had lured him into a conversation under the
- 44:25false pretense of wanting to interview him and instead I'm a propagandist for drug decriminalization,
- 44:31like that's my thing, and I wanted to lure him into a conversation
- 44:36thinking it's about a bunch of different topics, But really it was just to
- 44:37sort of catch him out on this, and that was my that was my
- 44:40goal. Yeah, you don't. I mean, you don't need to encourage
- 44:44drug use here to decriminalize it. In fact, most decriminalization campaigns go hand
- 44:46in hand with something like a re education. I think it is actually I
- 44:51think, I think if this is going to be about drug decriminalization, I'm
- 44:53bored. If you want drug decriminalization, good luck. I enjoy the society
- 44:59bec as a result. Frankly, I'm sick of the subject, and I'm
- 45:01also sick to death of the people you promoted. So yeah, will you
- 45:12be all right? You're entitled to use that, by the way, if
- 45:14you free to use if you want to. But I think you've had me
- 45:16here on false pretenses. What if you run this sort of you, I
- 45:20shall say you have me here, I'm sorry, which which false pretenses?
- 45:22Well that this is just this is going to be an interview about several subjects.
- 45:25Just have been nothing but drugs. Yeah, I mean, this is
- 45:29the this is the first. This is the first topic of meny You're obsessed
- 45:31with drugs. This is I had I think I had planned to. I
- 45:42have, I've written about you. You're not read what I've written. I
- 45:45have, I have read well, you have well, you are reading it
- 45:50with you with with with the lights off. You're not aware of anything that
- 45:53I've said. I haven't number, you haven't read well. I've written about
- 45:57portion, which is easily I've read that too. Well again I had it.
- 46:02You won't put to me any of the things that I said. It's
- 46:07now I've been here for a par and we've discussed nothing of drugs. Well,
- 46:12I had plans to move on to other subjects. And I'm sorry,
- 46:15I don't think you're insight into rhumans. I was you do run it,
- 46:20I shall say, I didn't. You've got me here. I was just
- 46:23I was just interested in fact, you think it's extremely bad mats. Of
- 46:29course, Peter Hitchins doesn't really like he doesn't know who I am, right,
- 46:32He's sort of he's not come across my work before anything, so he's
- 46:36got no way of knowing this. But I think my audience will will know
- 46:37that that can't be true. I mean the idea that I wouldn't want to
- 46:40talk to him about other topics religion for example. I mean, look,
- 46:45anybody who knows me, anybody knows the sort of Alex O'Connor within reason cosmic
- 46:50skeptics thing knows that obviously, I want to talk to him about God and
- 46:52religion. That's like my thing. Of course I wanted to talk to him
- 46:55about that, but he's not going to know that, right, so I'd
- 47:00emailed him. As I email all of my guests with an invitation to the
- 47:05podcast, I just say my name, I say that I host a podcast,
- 47:07I say how many subscribers it's god, I say who the previous guests
- 47:10are. And then sometimes I say I want to talk to you about this
- 47:15particular topic because sometimes you know that that's relevant. And in the email,
- 47:20which I have, I have here in my inbox, I can I can
- 47:23make sure I'm getting this right. Yeah, I said to him, you
- 47:25know, dear mister Hitchins, I told him about the channel, and then
- 47:28I said, I'm writing to invite you to appear as a guest on the
- 47:30podcast. This is an email that he shared on Twitter. By the way,
- 47:34to discuss your work in areas of interest, in particular issues pertaining to
- 47:37drug decriminalization, whether we're experiencing a moral decline in society, and the influence
- 47:42of secularism on that question. And the state of monarchy in the United Kingdom.
- 47:45So there I've sort of given three vague subject areas. When he arrived
- 47:51at the at the at the shoot, I guess i'd call it. I
- 47:55said to him, Okay, mister Hitchins, there are there are three things
- 47:58that I wanted to talk to you about. That drug decriminalization, God and
- 48:02religion and the monarchy. Now he said at that moment, the monarchy's a
- 48:08bit boring, and I said, okay, final, well, we won't
- 48:13talk about that. I agree. Actually, okay, we'll cut that,
- 48:15leaving two subjects. By the way, he didn't take that opportunity to tell
- 48:19me that he didn't like talking about drugs, even though later when he was
- 48:22shouting at me, I said, well, how long would have been too
- 48:23long to talk about this? And he said, well, frankly, one
- 48:24minute is too long. I'm sick of talking about this. He didn't take
- 48:28the opportunity to tell me that before the interview, when he told me that
- 48:30he didn't want to talk about the monarchy. Okay, fine, So as
- 48:32far as I'm concerned, we've got two topics, drug decriminalization and God.
- 48:37Now, before the interview had started, I was questioning to myself, what
- 48:39shall I open with? Shall I open with the God stuff? Shall I
- 48:42open with the drug stuff? And I thought, well, because I talk
- 48:45about God all the time, it would be great to open with something a
- 48:47bit different. So that's why I decided to shoot the drug thing. And
- 48:51that's what it was. As far as I'm concerned, we've got two subjects
- 48:54now, drug decriminalization and God and the religion. Now, I didn't expect
- 48:59to spend that long on drug decriminalization. I'm not sure. I didn't know
- 49:01how long. I never predicted these things, but my podcast, he asked
- 49:05how long they go. I said, they go for about an hour,
- 49:07but if the conversation is particularly lively, sometimes it's an hour and a half,
- 49:09even two hours. Sometimes they're three hours long. He said, well,
- 49:13three hours is a bit long, but we'll see how it goes.
- 49:15Fine, so I'm thinking maybe an hour, hour and a half. Now,
- 49:21I have seen people claim in the comments, to be fair to Hitchens,
- 49:23the interview was a bit boring. It did go around in circles.
- 49:27Yeah, I agree with that it was a pre boring conversation, but I
- 49:30don't think that was my fault. I think that that Peter Hitchins had in
- 49:35the conversation a sort of I know this one attitude that when I asked a
- 49:37question, he wouldn't let me get to the end of the question. He'd
- 49:40interrupt with his answer, and his answer would be the stock answer, as
- 49:44if, oh, I know this question, I've had this question one hundred
- 49:45times, let me answer it. I felt like he wasn't listening to me,
- 49:47you know. I'd ask him about all kinds of things and he would
- 49:52just give me the stock answer. And when I try to sort of say,
- 49:53well on, a hold on, I don't think you I didn't say
- 49:55I don't think you've understood my question, but I'd try to phrase it in
- 49:59a way that they made him realize that I'm asking something else, and he
- 50:01would just sort of say, well, do I waste my time? You
- 50:05know? Are you not listening to my answers? The reason that I was
- 50:07asking about this was to was to get to the question of whether we are
- 50:14in favor of the criminalization of something because of a moralistic objection to it.
- 50:17That is, can't there be things that are immoral? I don't care what
- 50:22legal I'm telling you what I think. Yeah, and I have moral actions
- 50:24to it. But I don't care if you don't have moral objections to it,
- 50:27because I can also provide you with perfectly good, utilitarian, non moral
- 50:30objections to it. I think becoming mentally ill is a bad thing. Taking
- 50:36a risk which has which appears to have that likelihood, is therefore a bad
- 50:40thing. It doesn't take much argument to get through that. You don't need
- 50:44to have puritanical personal morals to think that. I don't. Don't you want
- 50:47to discuss the basis of my morality? We've got time. I don't think
- 50:52most people will be interested. I have moral objections to it. Like most
- 50:57moral objections, I find they have good props reasons beneath them. Maybe my
- 51:01question isn't clear here. The question is granting that it's an immoral practice,
- 51:07granting that it's an a moral thing to what do you to grant that?
- 51:09Because you obviously don't think so and so I understand that it was a bit
- 51:13sort of circular, and it did say on the same subject for a while.
- 51:15Is because I felt like he wasn't listening to me. He said that
- 51:17if we decriminalized cannabis, we'd have to issue drug tests every single time pilots
- 51:24went to fly a plane. Every single time somebody goes to fly a plane,
- 51:28we'd have to test them for cannabis. And I'm thinking, well,
- 51:30hold on, we don't do that for drinking. It's alcohol is legal,
- 51:37but we don't test pilots every single time they get on a flight. We
- 51:39sort of have random alcohol testing, and that's enough to deter them from trying
- 51:44to I'm trying to fly a plane while they're drunk. Now, wouldn't the
- 51:47same be enough to deter people from doing it while they're smoking cannabis, to
- 51:51which Peter Hitchins thinks that all I'm saying is something like what about alcohol,
- 51:55which is what people do all the time on the question of cannabis. It's
- 51:59a quite boring point, and people just go, oh, what about alcohol?
- 52:00What about tobacco? I get it, that's a boring thing to say,
- 52:04but that's not what I was doing there. So when he accuses me
- 52:07of just sort of going, well, what about alcohol, I have to
- 52:09be like, no, hold on, that's not actually what I was doing.
- 52:13I'm asking you a specific question about random drug testing. I'm responding to
- 52:16something you've just said about the necessity of testing people every single time is that
- 52:21actually true? We don't do it with alcohol, And to be honest,
- 52:24I can't even remember if I don't, I don't know. I don't know
- 52:27if he answered that or not, but it just seemed like he wasn't listening
- 52:30to what I was asking him, and so, yes, it goes around
- 52:31in circles, but I think that's why. And then eventually, about forty
- 52:36minutes in, he says, you know what, I'm sick to death of
- 52:39this. I'm sick to death of the people who try to who are the
- 52:44people who promoted At one point he implicitly called me a moron. That was
- 52:47later on he told me that he doesn't like me, that he actively dislikes
- 52:52me, that he never wants to see or hear from me again. He
- 52:53told me that I'm a propagandas for drug decriminalization, he told me that I
- 52:57lured him on false pretenses and I said, look, if I put this
- 53:00out, I don't think people are going to agree with you here, and
- 53:02he said, yeah, I'm sure all your druggy friends are going to love
- 53:05it, at which point I sort of laughed to myself and thought that there's
- 53:09there's nothing else I can really say. She even waffled on the release.
- 53:12At first he said go ahead, release it into the wild, and then
- 53:15he was like, you shouldn't release this, and then he would say,
- 53:17fine, go ahead and release it, but you shouldn't. I couldn't tell
- 53:21exactly. It just sounded like just untethered emotion. I suppose there's nothing American
- 53:27say. Hear run it if I like, right, if you like,
- 53:30and what can I got to stop you? I think people would be interested
- 53:31to see your views morally, I don't think you're entitled to run. I
- 53:35think people would be interested to hear entitled the right word. You just aren't.
- 53:39A very good example with my powerfulself was saying that I haven't actually sworn
- 53:44you anyway, don't if you've got any senseful matters, don't run that.
- 53:50I want to run this just you have. You're not entitled to run.
- 53:54You are no moral entitled to run it. You're probably here a false pertences
- 53:58to be very very badly. Obviously. I didn't intend for this to happen.
- 54:01I mean like, like, sure you know it's dramatic and it gets
- 54:04a lot of views and this kind of stuff. Sure you know it's good
- 54:06for the channel, it's lots of views, but like, yeah, I
- 54:07really, I just I couldn't. I couldn't believe it. You know,
- 54:10when it looked like he was about to get up, I remember thinking,
- 54:13like go on then, like serious, you're seriously going to do this right
- 54:15now? Like go ahead, this is going to get way more views than
- 54:19it would have done otherwise. And I don't think I've done anything wrong here,
- 54:22so sure, yeah, go ahead, don't let me stop you.
- 54:23I thought the temperature of it was you were the adult in the room,
- 54:27for sure. Can I showed me you can go ahead. I know he
- 54:31accused me of sort of of all kinds of things on Twitter, and it's
- 54:34a little bit, I want to say, it's a little bit. I
- 54:37think there was some confusion, Like you say, I mean he was saying,
- 54:39I don't think you should post this. And to be clear, if
- 54:42I have a guest on my podcast, generally speaking, if they don't want
- 54:44me to post something, I won't post. You know, they've given me
- 54:46their time. You know, they could say, look, I was having
- 54:50a bad hair day and I'd rather you didn't post that. You know,
- 54:52it would be disappointing, but you know, fine, you've done me a
- 54:54favor, so sure, but he sort of had this moralistic objection and then
- 55:00he would say, look, I can't stop you from posting it. You
- 55:01have every right to post it. I just don't think that you should.
- 55:06And it was sort of the moralistic objection that made me think, Okay,
- 55:09maybe I should post this. And then he started saying, well, if
- 55:12you do post it, I'm going to start tweeting about it. And I
- 55:15think he got I was basically saying, look, I have to post this,
- 55:19which is why he then goes, well, I'm going to start tweeting
- 55:21about it then, which is something that I'm not sure I understood at the
- 55:23time because I said in my intro, like, well, he's been tweeting
- 55:25about it, so this is my right of reply. But I think he
- 55:29might have only started tweeting because he thought that I was going to post it,
- 55:31if you know what I mean. But there was a tweet. There
- 55:32was a new tweet coming out once every two to four minutes for like two
- 55:37days straight from Peter Hitchens about this interview. He said, you know,
- 55:39I was at one point he says, I'm like guru like in the way
- 55:44that he in the way that he's sort of storming out. It's like he
- 55:46wanted to fight because he kept going, I'm going now, and he'd sort
- 55:51of go to the door and he'd be like, I'm going. He had
- 55:55this attitude of sort of like hanging by the door, sort of rocking back
- 55:59and forth, as if he wanted something out of me. Well, I
- 56:02don't want to see that. Okay, I know, I'm sonished to you.
- 56:07Heavior shatt and I'm thinking, like, you're either leaving or you're not.
- 56:10If you want to go, the door's there, you know, your
- 56:12weigh out, like off your pop. But he spent seventeen minutes, seventeen
- 56:15of them, stood at that door telling me how much he personally dislikes me.
- 56:20So I don't know. I thought, let me just post it and
- 56:22see what the world has to say about it. As we get close to
- 56:25the end here, we're talking about the legalization of drugs. It's funny.
- 56:29When I was a devout Christian, and I was for many decades, I
- 56:32knew it was wrong. Drugs are you know alcohol? Okay, we knew
- 56:36it was immoral, but it's legal. It is what it is. But
- 56:39drugs, marijuana, etc. Everything was a gateway, and of course I'm
- 56:45not remotely a libertarian. I would call myself a proud liberal, but I
- 56:50do have very libertarian views on drugs. Where do you draw Do you have
- 56:53a line legalization of drugs? Does it go beyond cannabis for you? What
- 56:58do you think? I mean? Look, I will the thing about drugs
- 57:04is, I don't really know what I think. I made a video once
- 57:06about cannabis do criminalization because the then Home Secretary of my country was considering upgrading
- 57:14cannabis to being a Class A substance. I don't know if you have the
- 57:17same sort of class system in the United States, but you know, we
- 57:22classify our drugs differently, and the punishments are more or less severe, and
- 57:30so I made a video about cannabis specifically, and actually in that video I
- 57:32sort of took it as a given that drugs like cocaine and MDMA were more
- 57:37harmful. I didn't think about that carefully enough, because, of course,
- 57:43as far as I understand, MDMA is not dangerous at all. The thing
- 57:45that's dangerous about MDMA really is that when you buy it from the street,
- 57:49it might not just be MDMA. I know that. I want to speak
- 57:52to Professor David Nutt, who was a former advisor to the government on drugs,
- 57:58and he's a drug expert. He's written a number of books about how
- 58:00bad drinking is and about how, you know, a lot of drugs aren't
- 58:02as bad as people think they are. And I think he got fired from
- 58:06the government or from being a government advisor after saying something like taking MDMA is
- 58:10safer than riding a horse or something like that. So maybe that was a
- 58:15mistake. But obviously some drugs are more harmful than others, and obviously some
- 58:19drugs are completely different kinds of experience experiences to others. Like the idea that
- 58:25commonly people say, well, you know, well caffeine is a drug,
- 58:29and they're trying to make a point, but you know, it's true,
- 58:30and if you consider the effects of something like caffeine and the effect of something
- 58:34like cocaine, these seem to be much more similar to each other than say,
- 58:37cocaine and like LSD. The idea that people sort of put cocaine and
- 58:43LSD in this category illegal drugs and have caffeine alcohol and then maybe also things
- 58:47like cannabis in a different category of like, oh, they're not so bad.
- 58:52It just seems really strange to me, because there's such different kinds of
- 58:55things, different kinds of experiences, you know what I mean, And so
- 59:00broadly speaking, I would say that it seems to me that I'm I'm broadly
- 59:07in favor of people's autonomy, right, And there's a complication about some drugs
- 59:12maybe affecting the affecting other people, But the same can be said of alcohol.
- 59:15I think I have to say that intuitively, if alcohol is legal,
- 59:19I can't see why other drugs shouldn't be legal too. But the main thing
- 59:22to say is that I'm not sold on this question. I don't know.
- 59:24That's why I thought it might be interesting to talk someone like Peter Hitchins and
- 59:27see if he could give me an opinion, But unfortunately that didn't go very
- 59:30well. So maybe David Nuttill will do so in future, but I really
- 59:34don't know. But the position as it stands intuitively is that at least if
- 59:37alcohol is going to be legal, then yes, other other drugs probably should
- 59:42be too, all right, Alex O'Connor, How do people find your work?
- 59:46Within Reason is the name of the podcast. You type in my name
- 59:49Alex O'Connor on most platforms, and it should come up. I'm still at
- 59:52Cosmic Skeptic on most platforms. It's been an hour and I haven't walked out.
- 59:57Some must be refreshing for you, Alex. I appreciate us taking a
- 1:00:01chance to talk to me from all the way over at the UK, and
- 1:00:06we'll watch the channel and the debates and discussions to come and all my best
- 1:00:09good stuff. Thanks for having me. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and
- 1:00:14Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t
- 1:00:19shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and
- 1:00:23details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The
- 1:00:29Thinkingatheist dot com.