Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #214 - Mayor Brenda Locke / Dr. Randeep Gill
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's Bontified culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight, let's focus
- 0:25on our province's second most populous city, Surrey, BC. Let's talk healthcare,
- 0:31policing and the relationships between BC municipalities and the provincial government. And who
- 0:37better to discuss these issues affecting Surrey than the woman at the center of it
- 0:41all, the former BC Minister of State for Mental Health and Addictions. In
- 0:45twenty eighteen, she was elected to Surrey City Council under the Safe Surrey Coalition
- 0:51led by then Mayor Doug McCallum. In twenty nineteen she left Safe Surrey and
- 0:56just over a year ago, in twenty twenty two, she was a as
- 1:00the Mayor of Surrey, representing Surrey connect. She is Mayor Brenda Locke,
- 1:06Mayor Lock. What an honor. Thank you, It's great to be with
- 1:08you, mol thanks for being here. First things first, in twenty eighteen,
- 1:12you successfully ran for Surrey City Council with the platform to bring in a
- 1:18municipal Regional Police Force or Municipal Police Force, which became the Surrey Police Service.
- 1:23In twenty twenty two. Last year you successfully ran for the Mayor of
- 1:27Surrey to do the exact opposite, which was to keep the RCMP and stop
- 1:34the transition to the Surrey Police Service. So clearly a lot happened in those
- 1:38four years, But what was your reasoning to have the position that you have
- 1:42today that Surrey must keep the RCMP and stop the transition to the Surrey Police
- 1:47Service. You know, everybody wants a simple answer to a very very complicated
- 1:53situation, so I thank you for that, But I will say this,
- 1:57no good plan can be done without first doing all the foundation things. They're
- 2:02doing those things like feasibility studies, cost benefit analysis, impact studies, and
- 2:08we are now on the road to doing that. Of course, the previous
- 2:13council refused to do that. They didn't even do Indigenous relations and indigenous consultation
- 2:20with the local land base or urban indigenous populations in Surrey. They did none
- 2:28of that. We have built, or they have attempted to build, this
- 2:32on a bet of sand. There is no doubt about that. And the
- 2:36more and more I get into it, the more and more I am absolutely
- 2:39convinced this is not the way to go for Surrey, and so that is
- 2:46why it's very clear to me, very clear to me when you call it
- 2:50a bed of sand and basically bringing in this municipal police force, the Surrey
- 2:53Police Service. Is this all about the cost, because I believe that you've
- 2:58estimated that it's going to cost an additional four hundred and fifty or four hundred
- 3:01and sixty million over ten years. The province is saying it's going to cost
- 3:05one hundred and fifty million over five years. But effectively, is the key
- 3:08issue the cost of transitioning to a municipal police service. Well, it is
- 3:15the cost, there's no doubt about it. But there's other things too.
- 3:19The Surrey Police Service, when they did have a friendly maryor to them,
- 3:23could not get it done. They could not get their benchmarks, the ones
- 3:27that they set for themselves. So they said they would be fully operational.
- 3:30So the POJ the Police of Jurisdiction, they said they would be that by
- 3:36April the first twenty twenty one. Never happened, as we all know sure
- 3:40we have never seen them reach their benchmarks. I think there's been a lot
- 3:45of change in the world since that decision was made, not the least of
- 3:47which was COVID, which just took a couple of years out of everybody's life
- 3:53and moving forward. But there's been many other things along the way that haven't
- 3:58been factor in. So it's not just about the money. It is also
- 4:02about public safety. They haven't demonstrated to me that they have the capacity to
- 4:10do it. The board of which I chair, by the way, full
- 4:14disclosure on that, has not demonstrated to me or to city Council quite obviously
- 4:20that they have the capability, the capacity, and the KSAs the knowledge to
- 4:27do it. So let me ask you a simple question, which I'm sure
- 4:29we'll have a complicated answer as well. Let's say, hypothetically, and I
- 4:31know this is not the case, but let's say hypothetically the province said,
- 4:34Okay, over ten years, we will give you four hundred and sixty four
- 4:38million dollars or whatever the additional cost is to transition to the Surrey Police Service.
- 4:43Would it still be a no for you? Would you still want to
- 4:45keep the RCMP, you know? Well, the short answers yes, I
- 4:50would, and I'll yes, you would want to keep the RCAFP, And
- 4:54I'm going to tell you why. So it is more than costs it's more
- 4:57than cost, much more than costs. And when when we estimated that four
- 5:00hundred and sixty four million dollars, that did not include that did not include
- 5:05capital investment, it did not include the ability to hire. And you can
- 5:12ask anybody in policing and you can ask I mean the City of Vancouver's City
- 5:16of New Wes that have muni police departments. Hiring police frontline officers is very,
- 5:25very challenging. We're seeing signing bonuses of thirty million dollars in Ontario for
- 5:31frontline We're talking frontline constables. So it's very challenging to hire. People don't
- 5:38want to be police officers in twenty twenty three, and I don't see that
- 5:41changing moving forward. So I think there's lots of different reasons why this is
- 5:46going to be an immense challenge. But I come back to the Surrey RCMP,
- 5:55r Suri's police department. People in Surrey wanted to keep them. Council
- 6:00want to keep the RCMP. We were voted in to keep the RCMP,
- 6:04and I will honor as much as I can everything that the voter wanted me
- 6:11to do. And I can tell you when I'm in Surrey when I'm at
- 6:14events, and I'm at a lot of them. It's always keep going,
- 6:17Madam Mayoric. The Province of British Columbia does not want to keep the Surrey
- 6:21RCMP. I mean, they enacted Bill thirty six. They're basically saying that
- 6:27any legal action you bring, you know, will kind of be a waste
- 6:30of taxpayer money, whether you're right or not. Like whether you're right or
- 6:32wrong, it just seems like this has been imposed on you. So why
- 6:36keep fighting this when clearly the province has done everything possible to legally bind you
- 6:43to continue the transition to the Surrey Police Service because they're wrong. They're wrong,
- 6:48you know. So if we go back to Ian in the breach of
- 6:54law, if you didn't continue on with this now that they've passed this legislation,
- 6:58well we're in court to make that determination. That's not my determination anymore.
- 7:01It's before the courts, as everybody knows. So I will be very
- 7:05treading softly on what I'm going to say, but you know, I think
- 7:12moving forward, if we really really take a hard look at it. When
- 7:15Minister Farnworth, a Solicitor General, came out on July the nineteenth and said
- 7:19thou shal he was actually absolutely incorrect. Now, if he had a being
- 7:25correct, he wouldn't need to pass this legislation two months later, right,
- 7:29But what I'm saying is setting all of that aside, Like, even if
- 7:30you are in the right here, it seems like with this passing of Bill
- 7:34thirty six, you are now obligated to continue this on. And there's a
- 7:40lot of excess cost and having two police services basically running Surrey at the same
- 7:45time, and then also this legal matter how much that will cost. So
- 7:48why keep fighting this when clearly they've they might have won. Well, the
- 7:53costs aren't going to change just if we back off anyway, because the costs
- 7:58are there because they can hire police officers. So we still have the POJ.
- 8:03The police of jurisdiction is still the RCMP regardless of the decision right now,
- 8:07but this is in front of the courts. If the soul Gien had
- 8:13said to me in December, no, no way you're doing this, You're
- 8:18staying the course, he didn't say that, and neither did the premiere He
- 8:22said to me at that time, and everybody remembers because it's on record everywhere
- 8:26he said to me. It is a municipal decision. Well, we made
- 8:30our decision, not once, not twice, probably three. So does the
- 8:33conclusion happen after this legal proceeding. Well, we've got a petition before the
- 8:39courts and we'll see where that all comes to. And just to be really
- 8:43clear, that petition is on two fronts. It's on the Police Act,
- 8:48it's also on the municipal Charter and the so's It's not as defined. Again,
- 8:56nothing is as simple as people may want it to be sure. Yeah,
- 9:00well, Mary Lock, we got to pay the bills around here.
- 9:01But after the break, I want to ask you a little more about the
- 9:03slicer general himself. Welcome back to this as Van Color. We're back with
- 9:15the woman who was ranked number twenty on Vancouver Magazine's Power fifty list, the
- 9:20list of Vancouver's most powerful people. For reference, I was number forty two.
- 9:24Of course, we're back with the mayor of Surrey, Mayor Brenda Locke.
- 9:28Brenda, thanks for sticking around. Thank you. I had to put
- 9:31you higher than forty. Thank you for that. I appreciate that endorsement.
- 9:33The think should put you higher than twenty. You should at least in the
- 9:35top ten. I got to ask you about some comments you made back in
- 9:41June. You called the slicer general the Minister of Public Safety, you called
- 9:45him a bully, You said that he was engaging in misogyny. What exactly
- 9:50did he do to warrant those very harsh labels? Well, I think you
- 9:54know, it's pretty obvious this minister has never ever picked up the phone and
- 10:00called me. We haven't had you know, we haven't had any meetings over
- 10:05this right from the get go. It's all being letters and you know at
- 10:09all, No, we haven't. We haven't had any sit down. Let's
- 10:13put crayons on the on the table and write this thing out. Never have
- 10:18you tried to meet with him. I've tried several times to meet with him.
- 10:22I have written them. But both him and to be fair, the
- 10:26premiere, have made it their ploy to do all this negotiation in the media.
- 10:33They they don't seem to want to have a face to face with me.
- 10:37Now would that have happened with previous the previous mayor? In fact it
- 10:41did not? In fact it did not, So how what else am I
- 10:46to think? Give me a call? I mean, he knew it can't
- 10:50just be an ideological difference. You think it is based and rooted in sexism.
- 10:54Well, I don't know, but I know he wouldn't have done it
- 10:58to the former mayor who was a male. So I don't I can't read
- 11:01his mind. I just know how I feel, and I can feel how
- 11:05I feel. But I can tell you that the Solicitor General knew full well.
- 11:13He knew full well that was the platform I ran on. He knew
- 11:16that was what Surrey wanted. He knew that there were flags on cars and
- 11:20signs on people's lawns to keep the RCMP. And he knew that the previous
- 11:26premier called the whole thing that he had been a part of a hornet's nest,
- 11:31So he knew that's what mister Horgan called it. So he knew when
- 11:37I came in what I was coming in to do, and he never ever
- 11:41contradicted it. I have. I have so many letters I've sent to him,
- 11:46and I have letters back from him in the very beginning that always said
- 11:50this is the city's decision, and the city made their decision. Now,
- 11:54I heard a rumor that this past weekend, I believe it was Friday night,
- 11:58the premiere was booed out of an event in Surrey that you were also
- 12:01attending or perhaps even hosting. First of all, is that true? And
- 12:05then secondly, do you think that the province understands the political ram ramifications of
- 12:11the stance that they've taken. So I had a mayor's night of giving.
- 12:16It was for the firefighters and and it was a very large event, and
- 12:20the Premier came and there were a lot of people in that room that didn't
- 12:24appreciate his stand on policing. And I would say, you're absolutely correct in
- 12:31the assumption there is not a good, warm fuzzy for the way that this
- 12:37government, that both the Premier and the Solicitor General are foisting this on the
- 12:43residence as Surrey. They know the cost, and I will make it crystal
- 12:46clear to the residents as we move forward that this is the province's decision.
- 12:52They will wear it. I will make sure of that, and they will
- 12:54know the cost. This cost will be in sixteen point read on their tax
- 13:01form saying the Surrey Police Service, Provincial Government's Surrey Police Service is going to
- 13:07cost you this much money. What are the lessons for other BC municipalities.
- 13:11There's only one other municipality that is bigger than Surrey, But for everyone else,
- 13:15what does this say about the relationships between municipalities and the provincial government.
- 13:18Well, I think I think it's starting. You know, cities are starting
- 13:24to understand it. This has a big impact on anybody with a municipal police
- 13:28force, and we've heard that recently from New West. There is going to
- 13:33be costs. This is going to and that's why the impact study was so
- 13:35important. It's going to impact anybody with a municipal force and it's really going
- 13:41to impact all the other RCMP jurisdictions. So small town BC and larger towns
- 13:48like Burnaby and Richmond. It's called DIVIDMN is going to go up, go
- 13:52way up, and they're going to be they're going to be paying more.
- 13:56So, you know, thank you very much. Residents of Richmond, residents
- 14:01of Williams Lake, you're going to you're going to get more costs because of
- 14:07this decision by this lister Jent. I think this is why what's happening in
- 14:09Surrey is so important for the rest of the province. Mayor Locke, Brenda,
- 14:13what a pleasure, what an honor. Thank you so much for your
- 14:15time tonight. Thank you for having me. Absolutely Folks she is certainly a
- 14:20force to be reckoned with the Mayor of Surrey, Brenda Locke, now after
- 14:24some business. Despite being the second largest BC city in terms of population has
- 14:28healthcare and Surrey being chronically underfunded, doctor Randeep Gill says he's done with the
- 14:33double standards and he's here to talk about it up next, Welcome back to
- 14:43this As Van color As one of the fastest growing cities in Canada and the
- 14:46second largest city in British Columbia by population, Surrey, BC obviously requires proactive
- 14:52planning to meet its growing demands for public services, from education, to transportation
- 14:58to healthcare. One vocal doctor claims that Surrey's healthcare has been chronically underfunded for
- 15:03decades, resulting in a decline in the quality of healthcare services and such a
- 15:09lack of capacity that thousands of Surrey mothers are actually being forced to go to
- 15:13Vancouver just to give births. An emergency physician at Surrey Memorial Hospital, he
- 15:20is doctor Randeep Gill. Doctor Gil, thanks so much for being here tonight.
- 15:24Thank you for friend so we know that healthcare has issues across the provinces,
- 15:28whether it is staffing shortages, capacity issues, emergency room shutdowns. So
- 15:35in terms of what we're seeing in Surrey, is it just amplified because Surrey
- 15:39is that much bigger and has such a larger population, or is the case
- 15:43of Surrey slightly different than perhaps the rest of the province. No, I
- 15:46believe it's slightly different because Surrey is a large city and is the only large
- 15:52city in Canada that cannot treat the three leading causes of death, which is
- 15:54stroke, heart attack, and trauma. They can't treat those, soals cannot
- 15:58be treated. All of those patients need to be going north of the Fraser,
- 16:02so either they go to Royal Columbia or VGH. So those capacity,
- 16:06that infrastructure does not even exist in our hospital. So I can see the
- 16:10case that you're making in terms of chronic underfunding, because you would think that
- 16:12the second largest city in BC would have those capacities. Now, absolutely,
- 16:18and not only Surrey doesn't have it, south of the Fraser all the way
- 16:22to Boston, Bard does not have that. So there's no neurosurgical interventions,
- 16:26there's no cardiac interventions, there's no trauma capacity. All of those patients need
- 16:30to be transferred. And the reason why we're making this case is that every
- 16:34single one of those disease processes have a very finite amount of time in order
- 16:40to intervene to have good outcomes, and usually it's the golden hour. So
- 16:45now if we're stuck in traffic waiting for Patello Bridge, we're waiting for Massy
- 16:48Turnent tunnel, those patients are innately going to have poorer outcomes. How did
- 16:53we get here? Because I know, obviously you've been very vocal, You've
- 16:56been leading public rallies as well to raise awareness, but it just feels like
- 17:02we've really let this go as a province for so long. So how come
- 17:06people were not vocal beforehand? I believe people, especially in the healthcare community,
- 17:11have been vocal, they just falling on deaf fears. Nobody's listening.
- 17:15And even the solution. Now, when we heard, you know, back
- 17:18in twenty nineteen that the new hospital was going to come right, there was
- 17:21a hope that there was some solution here. But when we dissect it,
- 17:23when we look at the walls within, within the what services, what net
- 17:27new services are going to be offered in the new hospital, We're really not
- 17:30seeing any solutions. Wow, So even this new hospital not really satisfying the
- 17:37projected growth and the demands and the needs of Surrey's what you're saying. If
- 17:41magically we opened the doors of that hospital today and we opened up one hundred
- 17:45and sixty eight beds, we would still be three hundred percent less a bed
- 17:48capacity than Vancouver today. Wow today Wow. So now we're looking at so
- 17:55we should be building like three more hospitals in Surrey, is what you're saying,
- 17:57or a much larger one. Now if you look at that that's still
- 18:00so that's in twenty three. That hospital is projected to be built in twenty
- 18:04thirty hopefully, So that's seven years now. If you multiply the twelve hundred
- 18:10patients twelve hundred new people coming into our city, that's one hundred thousand more
- 18:15people patients, families that are going to be coming into this community. And
- 18:18So when we look at that trajectory and we see that, what is the
- 18:22solution the province is offering right now? What is the funding model? Is
- 18:25mat is the funding model matching the population growth? And it is not.
- 18:29If there's pure inequity today then and that hospital and that's not a hospital like
- 18:36I'm just I'm saying, we're three hundred percent less today if that hospital was
- 18:38magically built right now, but this is seven years from it's going to compound
- 18:42on itself. And absolutely wow, absolutely so is the issue basically then building
- 18:48out more capacity, either building a larger hospital, building more hospitals, building
- 18:52care centers, like, what else should the province be doing at this point?
- 18:56Well, they have to look at where the disease burden is all this,
- 19:00they have every single piece of data. Right So in the South Asian
- 19:03community, which is predominantly in South Surrey or in Surrey and south of the
- 19:08Fraser, we have high high blood pressure, diabetes which leads to strokes,
- 19:12heart attacks, renal failure. Now none of those can be managed south of
- 19:17the Phraser. Everything has to be north. So we have to bring services
- 19:21that match the disease process in the community that requires it. So instead of
- 19:26taking patients to physicians, it should be the opposite. You should be building
- 19:29institutions that's going to supply and support our community, which then can intervene in
- 19:33timely fashion and people can have proper and good outcomes. Doctor all of this
- 19:38makes sense, It seems to be very irrational. It seems to be based
- 19:41in terms of evidence and demographics. Why is it being Why aren't why isn't
- 19:47the province listening? Why has this been neglected for so long? You know,
- 19:52I don't know the why, and I'll tell you so. Even as
- 19:53physicians, we make mistakes. Okay, I've made my fair shares mistakes.
- 20:00I've been practiced for twelve years. You make a mistake, you have a
- 20:03poor at trutment plan, and you look at the evidence and you pivot,
- 20:07you hope to make you then try to change your approach. So that is
- 20:11why we're hoping that the province will change their approach in this look. This
- 20:15was you know, John Horrigan promised a new hospital in twenty nineteen. The
- 20:19plan was is that there would be better care locally at home. Now I
- 20:23will challenge the government saying, what net new service are you adding with this
- 20:29new hospital other than one hundred and sixty eight beds in an emergency department.
- 20:33But you are not adding a single life saving intervention we have. You know,
- 20:37we have growing community which is going to have pediatrics, maternity need.
- 20:41There's not a pediatric ward, there's not a maternity, there's no OBI.
- 20:48So in new births we'll be in exactly the same, and you're just thinking
- 20:49about the demographics of Sorry, and we know that it's an immigrant heavy community.
- 20:53Do you think that has any role in terms of the province's continued neglect
- 20:59when it comes to health care services and perhaps even other things like schooling and
- 21:02education in Surrey. I truly hope not, but I do feel that those
- 21:07voices do get you know, it just gets blended out, like our voices
- 21:11will get blended out because you know, the standard of care in other countries.
- 21:14People are leave. People don't just leave their countries, they don't leave
- 21:17their homes. They come for a better area, a better place, and
- 21:19so they may not be getting the standard of care that we know what standard
- 21:23of care based on evidence based medicine that we have today, and so they
- 21:27may not be able to advocate for themselves and saying hey, we should be
- 21:30having standard care because they don't probably know what the standard of care is.
- 21:33And that's why we come on these shows and say, listen, we know
- 21:37what the standard of care is. You are absolutely not meeting the standard of
- 21:38care. We are constantly standing patients over the bridge with the hopes that they
- 21:42will have a good outcome. But if there is an accident, there's road
- 21:47blockages, if there's you know, you know, a natural disaster, these
- 21:52patients are inevitably going to have a worse outcome. Absolutely, doctor Gil,
- 21:55I appreciate you being a vocal advocate for the city of Surrey and for healthcare
- 22:00s. So thanks so much for your time tonight. Thank you absolutely,
- 22:03folks, what a show. Thank you so much to our guest tonight,
- 22:06doctor Randip Gil and Surrey Mayor Brenda Locke. I'm sure they had a few
- 22:11BC Cabinet ministers Keen Lee watching tonight. Of course, we will be back
- 22:15next week. For now, though, this is Van Kuller and I'm o
- 22:18emir telling you that in a province where you can be anything, be colorful. Peaks