Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E012: MENA's Synergistic Embrace of Bitcoin with Ralph Gebran
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the.
- 0:20World of OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing. The role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. Welcome back to the next episode
- 0:55of Final Settlement. Been a few weeks, we're back in
- 0:58the horse. Michael and I were in Jackson
- 1:01Hole, Wyoming last week. I'm back home.
- 1:04I think Michael, you're back in Texas now.
- 1:06And we're joined by Ralph Gibran, who is actually in
- 1:09Cyprus right now, normally domiciled in Dubai, but is
- 1:13managing partner of On Ramp, sister company On Ramp MENA.
- 1:16And so really excited to have him on the show today and do a
- 1:19little inside On Ramp episode, talk through some of the
- 1:22opportunities in the MENA region, maybe talk through some
- 1:26of our takeaways from last week in Jackson, Michael.
- 1:30But gentlemen, nice to chat with you.
- 1:33Welcome back to the show. Yeah, welcome.
- 1:35Welcome Ralph and excited Brian to be back.
- 1:38I know it's been a little bit of spotty this summer.
- 1:41We had some special episodes that dropped and in place.
- 1:44Ralph had a really awesome episode.
- 1:46If anybody hasn't listened to with Harris Efron advisor
- 1:49honored Mina and Seifa Dean, but excited to get this humming back
- 1:54around into the fall, which should be which should be pretty
- 1:57exciting. We have another special guest in
- 1:59a couple weeks. So excited to be here.
- 2:01And Ralph, thanks for joining us today.
- 2:03Hey, thanks for having me guys. It's a pleasure to be here and
- 2:06yeah, really excited for this conversation.
- 2:09I think we can take this in multiple different directions,
- 2:13but maybe a good place to start is for folks who haven't been
- 2:16introduced to you yet, Ralph, as Michael mentioned, you also host
- 2:21a new podcast called The New Frontier with Harris Fran, where
- 2:25you guys are specifically taking a look at, you know, the Bitcoin
- 2:28opportunity in in the Middle East region, MENA.
- 2:31But maybe for the audience, it'd be helpful for you to kind of go
- 2:35through your background, how you got to Bitcoin and just sort of,
- 2:40you know, what you've seen on the ground, living in the region
- 2:44mostly. Yeah, for sure.
- 2:47So Ralph Jabran, managing partner on Ramp Mina, I've spent
- 2:52most of my life in the Middle East, so I'm originally from
- 2:56Lebanon. Sadly, we don't get, you know,
- 2:58good publicity in Lebanon with the current economic system,
- 3:02hyperinflation on official capital controls, but we'll get
- 3:05to that in a minute. But I am professionally and
- 3:08academically trained in finance. My entire career has been in
- 3:12traditional finance. I've worked as a trader on a
- 3:16brokerage desk, traded commodities, equities, fixed
- 3:20income, gold. I've also worked on a treasury
- 3:24desk of one of the biggest commercial banks back home in
- 3:27Lebanon, managing their foreign exchange reserves and exposure.
- 3:31On top of that, the last seven years, eight years I've been in
- 3:34Canada, based in Montreal, where I spent the most of my career in
- 3:38the institutional asset management space, specializing
- 3:42in sales enablement and institutional sales, working
- 3:46with two top five asset managers with a combined AUM of almost
- 3:51900, nine, 150 billion assets under management.
- 3:54And the last five years, I've been slowly grinding my way down
- 3:59the Bitcoin rabbit hole. And one of the triggers really
- 4:04was a personal one. So I mentioned earlier that I
- 4:07grew up in Lebanon, and while I was away, the economic crisis
- 4:13hit. The bank basically wiped out
- 4:16everyone's savings. So myself, my family, my
- 4:20friends, all of us have been affected, some more than others
- 4:26because of this. There's a tendency in Lebanon
- 4:28where, you know, the vast majority of Lebanese people are
- 4:31expats. There's more Lebanese outside of
- 4:34Lebanon than there are in Lebanon.
- 4:36And all of them were incentivized to send money back
- 4:39home. And the reason being is because
- 4:41the interest rates on term deposits were, you know,
- 4:47extremely high. You're talking about 8 to 10%
- 4:50when the US dollar interest rate was zero to 0.25%.
- 4:54So people rather than, you know, invest in equities, etcetera,
- 4:59you were getting comparable return in a supposedly very safe
- 5:04banking system. As Lebanese people, we had a lot
- 5:08of pride in our banking system. Our central bank governor at one
- 5:11point in time was on CNBC. When the great financial crisis
- 5:17hit, the Lebanese banks were unscathed.
- 5:20So they dealt with it extremely well and everyone thought it was
- 5:25the safest place to park your money.
- 5:26And Paine, as I like to say, is the best educator.
- 5:32When you see the system collapse onto itself, you start to
- 5:38question certain parameters. I mean with a 15 year track
- 5:43record working in finance, educated in finance, I never
- 5:47stopped to question the system. I was just part of it, and I
- 5:51thought that was just the way things worked.
- 5:53But when something as big as what happened in Lebanon effects
- 5:58you, effects people you actually care about, you start to
- 6:01question things, even things that you thought were real.
- 6:05And that's what really pushed me down the Bitcoin rabbit hole.
- 6:07And you know, you mentioned the episode with Say for Dean.
- 6:10So Say for Dean actually played a huge part in my Bitcoin
- 6:14journey. One of the things I picked up
- 6:17with the Bitcoin standard and I haven't looked back since.
- 6:21One thing about Saifuddin that a lot of people in the Middle East
- 6:26relate to is that he is from the region.
- 6:28He ironically, he was actually a teacher at the university where
- 6:31I got my banking and finance bachelor's degree.
- 6:34Sadly, I couldn't take a class under him.
- 6:37We, we didn't coincide in terms of I graduated before he started
- 6:41teaching there. But really that's what drove me
- 6:44to Bitcoin. I had unanswered questions.
- 6:47I wanted to understand what was wrong with the system, how could
- 6:50this happen? And also I was looking for
- 6:52alternatives because the way things are in Lebanon right now,
- 6:56we went through a black market on the US dollar.
- 6:58Lebanese # maintaining purchasing power was extremely
- 7:04difficult. Everyone has a high time
- 7:07preference because at one point in time you would go to the
- 7:10supermarket one day, two days later prices would change up
- 7:15until the point where now we've reached full dollarization.
- 7:18So the Lebanese pound is barely used at all.
- 7:21So all that to say that I found purpose.
- 7:25I found a reason to look for Bitcoin and it was a personal
- 7:29one. And that that's really how I got
- 7:31into Bitcoin. And I thought, you know, Lebanon
- 7:33is basically what's happening all over the world, but it just
- 7:37happened at hyper speed. Whereas in the West you can see
- 7:41the same kind of trend happening, but it's in slow MO.
- 7:45Bigger institutions, control over the reserve currency of the
- 7:50world, and all that kind of stuff really helps slow down the
- 7:54process of deterioration and hyperinflation.
- 7:58At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 8:01asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 8:05right. There are shortcomings with
- 8:07keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 8:10up your own self custody arrangement.
- 8:13On Ramp solves for these concerns.
- 8:15Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 8:19minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 8:22remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 8:25inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 8:28well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 8:30for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 8:33for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 8:36set up. For more information, check us
- 8:39out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, no, it's it's a
- 8:44fascinating story because as you're sort of alluding to, I
- 8:49think it's something, you know, at least sitting in the West,
- 8:52sitting in the United States, we often take for granted.
- 8:56And obviously, you know, Alex Gladstein's of the world talk
- 8:58about this and our financial privilege living here.
- 9:02We still, you know, deal with the Fiat currency, but it just
- 9:05happens to be the global reserve currency at present.
- 9:08And so we have to look a little bit harder to to, you know,
- 9:12identify those issues with Fiat money.
- 9:14Whereas, you know, growing up in Lebanon, like yourself, like you
- 9:18just have this visceral connection to money and how it
- 9:22can go really, really wrong in a, in a, you know, expedited
- 9:25fashion. And so I think, you know, it's
- 9:27always good to remind ourselves that, you know, as bad as we
- 9:33think the dollar is like we, we've got a pretty good relative
- 9:36to the slew of other Fiat currencies out there.
- 9:40And yeah, it so it's, it's always a refreshing point of
- 9:43view. Can you can you share, can you
- 9:47share where the realization for you with the frame of reference
- 9:53of having ties to the Middle East seeing what happened?
- 9:57But then I think if, if I'm tracking the timeline, you were
- 9:59in the West and safe on that pod had this interesting
- 10:04realization. I don't know if it was in real
- 10:05time or I think it was. Well, while you asked in the
- 10:09Middle East, in certain regions, because they suffer from
- 10:12hyperinflation, they don't necessarily have the disposable
- 10:14income to find Bitcoin. And then in certain other
- 10:17countries, it may be too nice. And so they don't also.
- 10:20But there's just like a nice middle ground where like in the
- 10:23US, maybe Canada, where you have some disposable income, but you
- 10:25have the opportunity to learn. Can you share like if that had
- 10:28any influence on you being able to see it versus others that may
- 10:32be right in the middle of it? Because I think that's kind of
- 10:34the common knowledge outside of a very on the margins.
- 10:37It's still not understood in the region, even though
- 10:40theoretically it should be understood very easily given the
- 10:43monetary policy of the local currency.
- 10:46Yeah. So it's ironic in a way, because
- 10:50the places that need it the most are the ones that adopt it last.
- 10:55And Safe made a really good point about that balance.
- 10:58So having that disposable income and that stability, not just
- 11:03financial stability, but geopolitical stability also
- 11:07factors, factors into play. So I was lucky to be in the West
- 11:12when this happened. So I could quickly shift and I
- 11:15had a stable job, I had a stable life.
- 11:18Everything is, you know, we take these things for granted in the
- 11:21West, having stability. But someone, for example, in a
- 11:26conflict zone or in a very tense geopolitical area like the
- 11:31Middle East, their their time preference is very different
- 11:35than someone in the West. Being in the Middle East, you're
- 11:38constantly worried about war, you're constantly worried about
- 11:43corruption, safety. There are bigger issues at play.
- 11:47So taking the time to go deep into something like Bitcoin,
- 11:52which fairly does take time to comprehend and to assimilate,
- 11:57you don't have that time in the Middle East.
- 11:59And people have a tendency to especially in areas such as
- 12:02Lebanon, not all Middle Eastern countries, but countries that
- 12:05are suffering like Syria, Lebanon, Palestine, etcetera.
- 12:11There is an issue of time preference.
- 12:15So they have bigger problems is how I would say it.
- 12:18They have bigger problems than to worry about how am I going to
- 12:20store my wealth. Most of them will just revert to
- 12:24old school habits, which is real estate, buying gold or even just
- 12:28keeping U.S. dollars under their mattress.
- 12:32So the US dollar is considered kind of the prime currency over
- 12:37there. It's the most liquid.
- 12:38You can take it across borders if you are immigrating outbound,
- 12:43even better than gold, because gold is difficult to move across
- 12:47borders. If you're immigrating or leaving
- 12:49the country really fast, most people would rather have U.S.
- 12:52dollars. Easier to hide and it's easier
- 12:54to carry and bigger amounts. So it is something that very few
- 13:00people take into account. Where you are actually does
- 13:03matter and the stability of your environment makes a huge
- 13:07difference in how you perceive Bitcoin.
- 13:10It's just a matter of whether you have the time and you know,
- 13:13the, the, the free conscious to think about it.
- 13:16In these countries, things are happening so fast.
- 13:20You're I'll just tell you the problems of Lebanon.
- 13:24You know, there is no electricity.
- 13:26So they have all generators. They need to make sure they can
- 13:29get oil for the generator. Sometimes they don't import
- 13:32enough oil. So there's like this problem of
- 13:35acquiring oil and then people have to ration the oil they have
- 13:39and sit there with no electricity for longer periods
- 13:42of time. A lot of imported things don't
- 13:47make it anymore because the exchange rate just too weak.
- 13:50People want things, you know, upfront.
- 13:52Not everyone can pay. Real estate has become a cash
- 13:55economy. You can't buy a house on credit.
- 13:58You can't take a mortgage. You have to carry 100,000 two
- 14:01$100,000 in cash to buy a property in Lebanon.
- 14:05Paperwork is extremely difficult.
- 14:06If you need to update your passport, if you don't know
- 14:09someone, you're not well connected or you don't have
- 14:12enough money to actually pay for the service, it's going to be a
- 14:15problem. So water, there's no drinkable
- 14:18water in Lebanon. You have to buy actual bottles
- 14:21of water. So the infrastructure is just
- 14:23not there. You have way too many things
- 14:25that are basic needs that you need to fulfill before you can
- 14:30start thinking about, OK, I need to save for the future, Yeah.
- 14:36That's really helpful context. And you know, I'd be interested
- 14:41to get your thoughts on how that sort of compares and contrast to
- 14:45a place like Dubai where you've been living recently where
- 14:48little different circumstances, but still, you know, right next
- 14:52to right, you know, a neighboring neighboring area of
- 14:54the region. And, you know, I'd like to hear
- 14:57a little bit about what's going on there.
- 14:59And, and you know, we've talked about in the past, you know, we
- 15:03were in Dubai earlier this year visiting you and, and just
- 15:08getting sort of acclimated with the region and, you know,
- 15:12thinking about our strategies, sort of trying to, to move in
- 15:14there. But what what's, you know, was
- 15:18one of my sort of core takeaways is that they've been very
- 15:23forward thinking, both from sort of a regulatory perspective and
- 15:27also just trying to attract, you know, generally businesses to
- 15:30come domicile and Dubai and and being very open sort of towards
- 15:34crypto digital assets. And so in some sense that feels
- 15:38like it's sophisticated. It feels very forward thinking
- 15:40and innovative. But my take away was really
- 15:43like, it's almost, you know, too forward thinking for their own
- 15:46good in the sense that they sort of go down the path of these
- 15:50other protocols, which and this was, you know, something that
- 15:53was really sort of codified and solidified for me last week at
- 15:57the Wyoming Blockchain Symposium in Jackson Hole.
- 16:00It's like all of these other protocols are still sort of
- 16:03searching for why they exist and and sort of the best that anyone
- 16:09can really come up with on that side is stable coins or, you
- 16:12know, tokenizing real world assets.
- 16:15And so I think there's this interesting sort of progression
- 16:18that's occurring at least on the edges that a lot of people in
- 16:22the sort of quote UN quote, digital asset crypto space are
- 16:25coming to terms with. Like, you know, why do these
- 16:27things exist? They're sort of looking for that
- 16:29product market fit, you know, looking for ways to explain, you
- 16:33know, sort of the utility, the different narratives at play and
- 16:37sort of trying to rationalize why these other protocols need
- 16:40to exist. And I think that is something
- 16:42that we saw on the ground in Dubai.
- 16:44And I think it's just a function of trying to be a little bit too
- 16:47forward thinking and too innovative when like someone
- 16:49wants to sort of admit to themselves, if you're in either
- 16:51like the VC or venture space, that like, it could just be as
- 16:54simple as buying and buying and holding this one asset.
- 16:57And so they try to sort of overcomplicate things and push
- 17:02these other these other protocols.
- 17:04But you know, I think there's some merit to, you know, maybe
- 17:10just curious your thoughts on like why that distinction sort
- 17:12of exists and why, you know, they're still sort of viewing
- 17:16this entire bucket as this super innovative risk on type of
- 17:22venture where has like just focus on Bitcoin.
- 17:25It's the most risk off asset you could own.
- 17:27Like it's just that, I guess, why hasn't there been as much of
- 17:31that realization? Is it just a function of, you
- 17:34know, wanting to attract people to the region so they feel like
- 17:37they have to be this sort of very forward thinking innovative
- 17:39place or, you know, curious your thoughts that made me about.
- 17:43Yeah, so Dubai and the UAE in general has really transformed
- 17:50over the last 20 years. I mean, if you've visited 20
- 17:54years, you wouldn't recognize the UAE as it is today.
- 17:59They've taken a lot of good decisions.
- 18:02They've made a lot of good decisions, especially when it
- 18:05comes to incentivizing smart individuals to come live here.
- 18:10The system allows you to be forward thinking because you
- 18:13don't have to worry about almost anything.
- 18:16The service level is amazing. I've never seen anything like
- 18:20this. The digitization of government
- 18:25is something that's also super impressive.
- 18:29Everything can be done through an app, through WhatsApp, and it
- 18:32happens really fast. So they've really made it so
- 18:36that anyone who wants to come here is incentivized to do so
- 18:40with no income tax, with incentives to start companies
- 18:45here with free zones that facilitate and that hold your
- 18:49hand throughout the whole process to actually set up the
- 18:51entity. They've really made themselves a
- 18:56poster child of, you know, forward thinking innovation now
- 19:00up until the whole Defy craze and blockchain.
- 19:04That was a good thing in my personal opinion, because it did
- 19:08grow. Every big, you know, traditional
- 19:10financial institution, every big tech company wanted to be here.
- 19:14Because if you look at the current trends, a lot of people
- 19:18are leaving the West to come to Dubai or Abu Dhabi, the UAE in
- 19:25general, because conditions here, standards of living are
- 19:28much higher. There's no poverty, there's no
- 19:31crime. It's extremely well regulated.
- 19:34It is strict, it's open. They've, you know, opened up to
- 19:37accommodate foreign cultures as well as long as people are
- 19:40respectful of the local population.
- 19:43Keep in mind there's only 1012% that are actually locals.
- 19:48The vast majority of the UAE is foreign expats that come here
- 19:52and a lot of them are specialized labor that come here
- 19:56to build businesses and to help the economy.
- 19:59So they are extremely forwarding.
- 20:01It is just. That is their strategy with to
- 20:04buy Expo and, you know, just wanting to be the top at
- 20:08everything. A testament of that is Burj
- 20:11Khalifa. They made sure they had the
- 20:13tallest building here. And that was just a testament to
- 20:16showcase their ingenuity. And you're talking about
- 20:19building skyscrapers on desert land that is 10 times as hard as
- 20:26building it on, you know, your typical landscape that we are
- 20:32familiar with in the West because we have to build
- 20:35foundations way deeper. It just takes more engineering
- 20:38to get it done properly. And they built the tallest
- 20:40building on sand, pretty much. So now that's great and all, but
- 20:47when the blockchain craze happened, the Middle East,
- 20:51especially countries like the UAE, Saudi Arabia, which are
- 20:56constantly in competition with each other, Bahrain, Qatar,
- 20:59everyone's trying to be better than the other and they're also
- 21:02trying to be better than the West at something.
- 21:06So they were some of the first to actually create regulatory
- 21:10frameworks for the whole blockchain crypto space.
- 21:13And what happened is that incentivize so many companies
- 21:17from the West, the east to come set up shop here because you
- 21:22could go through it and you'd be on the right side of the law,
- 21:27even though from a regulatory point of view, they just looked
- 21:31at it, you know, point blank without really looking into the
- 21:35potential repercussions of this. So they were the first to do it
- 21:39and they're quite strict in the way they do it.
- 21:42But what has LED what this has led to is vast majority of
- 21:47people will be traders, short term thinkers.
- 21:52No one really questions money. Everyone's trying to get into
- 21:56the most trendy thing, whether it's NFTS, web three projects,
- 22:01tokenization, all that kind of stuff.
- 22:05It's just something that will take time.
- 22:10Typically, what happens in the West takes five to six years to
- 22:14transfer over into the Middle East.
- 22:17That is my experience at least from living in the Middle East.
- 22:20Certain trends, cultural trends, ideologies take time to be
- 22:24imported here. And over time, you know, the
- 22:28Middle East is looking more and more like the West.
- 22:31So I think what the West learned with the Defy bubble and the
- 22:36blockchain craze, all that pain, slowly but surely they will
- 22:42learn it here. I was on a call today with
- 22:44someone actually who works with a lot of locals.
- 22:47He's somewhat of a consultant, and a lot of them have felt the
- 22:51pain from the last cycle in altcoins.
- 22:55Some of them are holding on to, you know -200,000 losses because
- 23:00they have a portfolio filled with shit coins, really,
- 23:05projects that promise to deliver certain solutions.
- 23:08But that never came to fruition. And some of them are actually
- 23:12turning over slowly but surely now.
- 23:15They want to learn more than just jump on the bandwagon and
- 23:19hope for the best. SO from that point of view,
- 23:22forward-looking is, you know, a double edged sword.
- 23:26If you go too far, you might actually hurt yourself.
- 23:29It's somewhat of a balance and I think we'll adjust back to a
- 23:34mean where things will be revisited.
- 23:38And the problem is they've bucketed Bitcoin under digital
- 23:43assets. So Bitcoin is categorized the
- 23:45same way as all the other tokens.
- 23:48So when you look at it from that point of view, people here will
- 23:52see Bitcoin, as you know, first of all, unit bias, it's too
- 23:54expensive. They see its performance slowly
- 24:00erode over time. They, they don't see it as
- 24:03something that's going to make them really rich.
- 24:05And one thing that's prevalent in the region, people like to
- 24:08make a quick buck. And that's, that's a common
- 24:11Middle Eastern trade. So that's, that's currently
- 24:14where we stand. And those are my thoughts on it.
- 24:16Yeah, thanks for for sharing that, Ralph.
- 24:18Maybe, maybe. So I guess one statement and
- 24:24just thought is, and it could be wishful thinking, but I think we
- 24:26when we talk with a lot of financial institutions here in
- 24:30the US, whether it's an RAA or or a, you know, bank.
- 24:37The. Notion of having not been in
- 24:39like being behind sometimes can be a positive versus a negative
- 24:42in the sense of you, you, if you can skip the defy summer, right?
- 24:47If you don't have to catch up to that, then you may have an
- 24:49opportunity. And so I think part of like what
- 24:52our hope is that there's some learnings we can, you know,
- 24:55basically transmute over that. Maybe there's individuals still
- 24:59have to touch the stove, but can kind of leapfrog.
- 25:02And I think that's what we see a lot in like Africa, in certain
- 25:05parts of Africa when it comes to like fintech, right?
- 25:07There's this notion of you even have to like go into, you know,
- 25:10if we're at, you know, towards the tail end of the alphabet,
- 25:13consider the Fintech applications and it took us a
- 25:16while to get here in the West. It's like we can we just jump
- 25:19directly to mobile banking and different things like that.
- 25:23But going back to your the market structure in the Middle
- 25:28East. So we'd love to hear kind of
- 25:31where how in the Middle East how assets are stored, what does the
- 25:39market structure look like from a generalistic point of view?
- 25:43Where do people with wealth park assets?
- 25:45How is the relationship with stocks, equities and other
- 25:49alternative investments? And then basically how did that
- 25:52tie into you? You've seen what we're doing
- 25:57with on ramp and seeing multi institution and how that fit or
- 26:01into why now for the Middle East?
- 26:03Because like your backgrounds very you have a lot of accolades
- 26:09similar to Brian and being in traditional finance, seeing the
- 26:12market structure, realizing the brokenness.
- 26:14But also there really hadn't been a lot of institutional
- 26:17grade options for investors to be able to reduce counterparty
- 26:21risk, have the education and all the things to get you to a point
- 26:24where you can actually materially allocate.
- 26:26So just curious on like how does the landscape look today?
- 26:29And then where do you see what we're working on and what had
- 26:32you gravitate towards MIC Multi institution custody and
- 26:35specifically for the region and why right now is a good time?
- 26:39Yeah. So overall, the region from a
- 26:43asset allocation point of view, they have their local markets,
- 26:47their local stock markets, which have been growing over the
- 26:50years. More and more Western
- 26:53traditional asset managers have been investing in Middle Eastern
- 26:56stock markets just because countries like Saudi Arabia and
- 27:01the UAE have kind of proven themselves as legit, safe and
- 27:07secure for them to, you know, import assets into them now from
- 27:12a high net worth individual. For example, a lot of Middle
- 27:16Eastern people, especially the wealthy, will park a lot of
- 27:19their assets, for example, in Switzerland, just because of the
- 27:23nature of the economies and the structure of the country itself.
- 27:29I mean, you have to keep in mind that Middle Eastern people have
- 27:35one through a period where they were viewed very negatively as
- 27:40well, especially after what happened in the United States.
- 27:44So a lot of them were worried that their accounts might be
- 27:47associated with something that was off.
- 27:49So there's a tendency to park money in Switzerland due to
- 27:54their privacy laws. They are one of the most secure.
- 27:57So a lot of wealthy Middle Eastern people will park a lot
- 28:00of money there and they'll park money in real estate, especially
- 28:04for example, in Europe, London. And the reason being because a
- 28:09lot of these economies, what they will do, they will
- 28:12subsidized education for locals. So for their national people,
- 28:18they will send their children purely subsidized to London to
- 28:22get an MBA, to get a master's on the condition that they come
- 28:25back and work locally to build the country.
- 28:30So they've been really pushing for high levels of education and
- 28:35that's why you see this huge development taking place.
- 28:39They don't need to import as much foreign talent now they are
- 28:42producing that talent themselves.
- 28:44So when these individuals have worked abroad, have studied
- 28:50abroad, their lens has expanded. So they diversify their holdings
- 28:55and some of them will buy real estate in foreign countries such
- 28:58as London, Paris, etcetera, and really high quality real estate.
- 29:03You're talking about luxury real estate in, in, in surrounding
- 29:07European countries on the Western Front and Switzerland.
- 29:10So a lot of them will hold commodities, actual gold, and
- 29:16they will hold a standard portfolio of public equities.
- 29:20I would say the vast majority of their allocations would be in
- 29:23international equities more so than local equities, just
- 29:28because you know you won't get the fangs in UAE or Saudi Arabia
- 29:36in terms of growth and maintaining purchasing power
- 29:39into the future. So they will invest in the
- 29:42leader of the technology, etcetera, some of the biggest
- 29:45banking names as well, just because they're more
- 29:48comfortable. There's more trust there that
- 29:51these companies have been around for a while.
- 29:52So we're just going to stick to what works.
- 29:56So that's kind of from a asset allocation point of view and
- 29:59where people park their monies now from a Bitcoin point of
- 30:03view. So one of the hurdles I would
- 30:06say is that traditional family offices, high net worth
- 30:10individuals, even sovereign wealth funds because of the way
- 30:14Bitcoin is categorized as a digital asset.
- 30:17So it's viewed like all the other stuff.
- 30:21So, and there needs to be this breaking of the noise, cutting
- 30:25through the cloud to kind of explain the actual value
- 30:29proposition of Bitcoin and to showcase it more like it is a
- 30:32actual portfolio asset. Similar to you having exposure
- 30:36to gold, You would have exposure to Bitcoin.
- 30:39No different than that it's a bearer asset and it's a
- 30:42commodity. The problem is these family
- 30:46offices design it with individuals.
- 30:47They are conservative in nature, so they won't just take risk on
- 30:52it. What happens is, you know, once
- 30:54you build that trust within the region, you explain Bitcoin the
- 30:57way it needs to be explained and the way it needs to be viewed
- 31:00within a portfolio, things will change.
- 31:04And here when something change, there's a lot of word of mouth
- 31:08in the region. So if you manage to secure one
- 31:11aspect, one big family office, others will be curious to
- 31:15understand, someone just needs to take the first leap of faith
- 31:19and then others will start to follow.
- 31:22That is my personal view and that's based on my cultural
- 31:25experience back home. So that's just how we are.
- 31:28Someone takes a leap of faith and if it works out, people will
- 31:32start to question and follow. So that's the general idea.
- 31:35Now also from a security point of view, so they need to feel
- 31:40comfortable to hold something. Now a lot of them will look at
- 31:44just getting a little bit of exposure through, for example,
- 31:47an ETF. But I believe a solution that
- 31:51will allow Bitcoin to scale, especially within the region
- 31:54that I think would fit perfectly is the multi institution custody
- 31:57solution. And the reason being is because
- 32:00once you have multi institutional and multi
- 32:02jurisdictional capabilities, they'll feel more comfortable as
- 32:07being conservative as long as no one can freeze their assets.
- 32:10You give them redundancy and where the assets are being held
- 32:13and you give them comfort that they can move the asset whenever
- 32:16they want. That's a solid product market
- 32:18fit within the region, especially from a cultural point
- 32:21of view. And that's excluding the fact
- 32:23that also there's a lot of people here who are Muslim
- 32:27practitioners, they are seeking alternatives not just from an
- 32:32asset class point of view, but also from a custody point of
- 32:36view to reduce counterparty risk, to share risk among
- 32:39various counterparties. So from that lens, I think once
- 32:45the market groks Bitcoin as an asset, not as a digital asset,
- 32:50but as an asset like gold equities, etcetera, they
- 32:53understand it's risk return properties and the value that it
- 32:56can bring if stored the right way.
- 33:00Adding the fact that you have control over it.
- 33:03I think we'll see a lot of adoption trickling, but it is a
- 33:08lot of work to breakthrough that noise and, and, and, and, and
- 33:13help. But that's why we're here,
- 33:15right? So we talked to a lot of people
- 33:17and they understand it. They understand the model, but
- 33:21also from a regulatory point of view, there needs to be a lot of
- 33:23conversation to explain why this is a better alternative.
- 33:26And I believe we can achieve that just because it, it aligns
- 33:32so well with the cultural element, you know, reducing
- 33:35risk. People in the Middle East,
- 33:38they've dealt with so much, you know, things out of their
- 33:41control geopolitically, all that stuff that inherently we try to
- 33:47reduce risk where we can. If there's an option that is
- 33:51less risky but doesn't reduce return, we're going to take that
- 33:57and we're going to spend more time learning about it.
- 33:59So that's how I see multi institution fitting into the
- 34:02region and Bitcoin being a part of a traditional portfolio.
- 34:07Yeah. One quick thing just to call out
- 34:10is there's a there's a thing that we don't talk about enough
- 34:13about the inevitability of what Ralph just said on multi
- 34:16institution and risk. It's in the same way we think
- 34:19about Bitcoin and the dollar. If the dollar stopped printing
- 34:23and we had a conservative fiscal and monetary policy, maybe
- 34:26Bitcoin wouldn't be needed. The problem is that's impossible
- 34:29and that will not happen. And when I think about multi
- 34:32institution custody, if all things considered, there was
- 34:35never another loss in in digital assets, there was no more
- 34:39rehypothecation. There was no, you know,
- 34:41trickiness behind whoever was holding the asset.
- 34:43There was transparency, segregated wallets and
- 34:46ultimately there was no hacks that occurred.
- 34:50Then there's a case to be made we we would not need multi
- 34:52institution custody, but because that is nearly impossible, if
- 34:56not impossible for the next call it 24 months, let alone 24 years
- 35:01and on to the future. That is why it's necessary if
- 35:04you want material exposure. So I think it's just an
- 35:07important part that feel very confident to hang back because
- 35:10the market will take care of the rest.
- 35:12We're just kind of putting, you know, gas on the fire.
- 35:14We're having conversations. And I think the biggest just to
- 35:18add on that, Michael, one thing that's underestimated within the
- 35:23multi institution setup is the reduction in geopolitical risk.
- 35:28I mean, how many times do you see tags World War three has
- 35:32started or all the stuff that's been happening, The world is
- 35:36moving in, you know, in a very tense direction.
- 35:40Everywhere between what's happening in the Middle East,
- 35:42between what's happening in Europe, Russia, Ukraine, there's
- 35:46just this tension around the world.
- 35:48And if you have a solution, and I think this is the first time
- 35:51ever where you have a solution that allows you to reduce
- 35:54counterparty risk because if you invest in U.S. stocks, well,
- 35:58your counterparty in terms of geopolitical risk is the United
- 36:01States. If you invest in Middle Eastern
- 36:03stock, your counterparty risk in terms of geopolitical risk is
- 36:06the is the country like people who invested in Lebanese stock
- 36:10market got wiped even though it seemed great.
- 36:13But if that custody of the asset, if it's a decentralized
- 36:18asset, it just makes total sense that the custody of that asset
- 36:22is also decentralized, not just from a, you know, institutional
- 36:27point of view, but also from a geopolitical point of view
- 36:29because the asset allows you to do so.
- 36:32So multi institution custody in my view is really the next
- 36:37generation of custody in general, not just, you know, and
- 36:41it's suitable for Bitcoin. Yeah, it's a, it's a really good
- 36:45point in that, you know, Bitcoin is this decentralized asset, the
- 36:51value prop is inherently tied to its distributed nature.
- 36:56And you know, the fact that by and large over the past 15
- 37:00years, we've sort of just been OK with the asset centralizing
- 37:05both at a, you know, a single entity, but also to your point,
- 37:08Ralph, in a single jurisdiction. It's like, well, that kind of
- 37:11that kind of goes against that value prop at its core, right?
- 37:14It's like you shouldn't have any geopolitical risk necessarily
- 37:18with this global asset that is Bitcoin.
- 37:20It's an open protocol. Anyone on earth can participate.
- 37:24You shouldn't necessarily have your ownership of the asset be
- 37:29inherently tied to anyone particular jurisdiction or any
- 37:33geopolitical risk in a region. So I think it's a really good
- 37:36point. And I think, you know, going
- 37:38back to what you were saying about, you know, sort of the,
- 37:42the region and it's, you know, it's proclivities for
- 37:46understanding an asset like this where, you know, whether it's
- 37:50moving assets to Switzerland or just being generally aware of
- 37:54counterparty risk to a greater extent than, you know, someone
- 37:57living in the West. I think that's a really
- 38:01interesting dynamic that would, you know, the 1st order thinking
- 38:04is like, OK, that, that would mean that, you know, this region
- 38:08should, should see the value in Bitcoin more readily, but maybe
- 38:13that maybe it hasn't fully clicked yet.
- 38:16So I'm, I'm like trying to drill down into why that hasn't
- 38:19clicked. Is it because of the
- 38:22distractions, the noise that we've referenced of these other
- 38:25assets, these other protocols that, you know, on the surface
- 38:30seem like potentially higher returning, but also, you know,
- 38:34inherent in that is higher risk. And, and so I'm just curious,
- 38:38like, you know, how do we get people over that hump?
- 38:41And, and maybe part of it is, and you just put out a report
- 38:46about this, but you know, Bitcoin and its relation to
- 38:50Islamic finance and being halal and being Sharia compliant.
- 38:55I think that's maybe that's how we more directly make that
- 38:59linkage to this is the most conservative asset you could
- 39:02own. It is actually risk off if you
- 39:05think about it deeply and own it in the right way.
- 39:08And so it's actually very sort of on the opposite end of the
- 39:11spectrum as something you could own in the Fiat denominated
- 39:14world, whether it's a, you know, a stock or a bond or something
- 39:17that's inherently credit based. So maybe you could talk a bit
- 39:21about that report that we'll we'll link in the show notes.
- 39:24But maybe that's a way, at least in my mind, to sort of get
- 39:30people going down that path of realizing this is actually the
- 39:33most conservative thing you could own.
- 39:35Yeah. And before I touch on that, just
- 39:38one thing I'd like to add. So why do people put their money
- 39:41in Switzerland? Like people don't think about it
- 39:45really. Is it because it's neutral?
- 39:48Is it because the governance is decentralized?
- 39:51Is it because it has strong privacy?
- 39:54Well, Bitcoin is the asset class that is, it's it's the
- 39:59Switzerland of asset classes when you compare Bitcoin to
- 40:02Switzerland. All the reasons why people put
- 40:05their money in Switzerland apply to Bitcoin, and I think that's
- 40:09what people struggle to see. People don't question why they
- 40:11put their money in Switzerland. They just know Switzerland has
- 40:14been neutral, has not participated in any wars.
- 40:18Even the governance is really a citizen democracy where it's a
- 40:24country that is built on nodes and nodes make decisions.
- 40:30So Bitcoin is the same thing. So I think getting that message
- 40:34across, explaining Bitcoin in a different way, more so aligning
- 40:40it with things people can relate to is, is how we get the message
- 40:43through before we get into how it maintains its neutrality, how
- 40:47it stays decentralized. Just getting the message through
- 40:51that it is these things and then working through the technical
- 40:54side is is the right way to go. Now what you just said about the
- 40:58report is Bitcoin halal is what it's entitled.
- 41:03So we're lucky to have Harris Irfan as an advisor to unwrap
- 41:08Mina to make sure, you know, we are always saying things that
- 41:13are accurate and respectful towards Muslims all over the
- 41:18world. Full disclosure, I am not
- 41:20Muslim. So this was something that we
- 41:23worked on together. Now, it's not just about Sharia
- 41:28compliance. As the Muslim community, if you
- 41:30really take out the word Islamic finance, you can replace it with
- 41:34moral finance, basically Islamic finance.
- 41:37If you take out some of the Muslim component, it could be
- 41:43really just honest, transparent and fair finance because those
- 41:48are the foundations on which Islamic finance is built on
- 41:51being transparent, having no asymmetry between, you know, the
- 41:56borrower or the lender. There's no rebar, so there's no
- 41:59risk is shared. It's not a symmetrical risk
- 42:02where one person or one party carries more risk than the other
- 42:06or one party has guaranteed returns and the other does not.
- 42:10So it's really a moral, ethically honest form of
- 42:16finance. Now, I think from a conservative
- 42:21point of view, it would appeal to a lot of conservatives and
- 42:25the Muslim community in particular, because Saifuddin
- 42:30gave a really good example on our previous podcast.
- 42:34There's an argument to why people use Fiat and, and, and
- 42:38Muslims use Fiat. And the reason why is because
- 42:40there's no better alternative. Living outside of the Fiat
- 42:45standard before Bitcoin was almost impossible and it it
- 42:50affected your survival, affected how you take care of your
- 42:53family, it affected every aspect of your life.
- 42:56But now that there is a more honest, transparent, fair
- 43:01alternative, then I think over time we'll see more and more
- 43:05people who are Muslim, even Christians, all religions,
- 43:11people who are founding their life on sound principles of
- 43:15morals and ethics. And you know, doing the right
- 43:18thing will transition to Bitcoin.
- 43:21It's something you notice. People who are more attuned to
- 43:24the religious beliefs tend to find Bitcoin easier and
- 43:31understand it easier than those who don't.
- 43:34I'm not saying that they won't, but it's just because when you
- 43:38understand its foundational principles of honesty,
- 43:40transparency, fairness, and the fact that there is no one who is
- 43:45manipulating it or using it to take away your energy and the
- 43:51fruits of your labor by taxing you indirectly, subtly, then you
- 43:56realize that you know what? Maybe I do want to allocate a
- 44:00larger and larger portion of my assets to this asset that is
- 44:04actually protecting my, protecting my wealth and
- 44:10protecting the generate, protecting the wealth of my, of
- 44:14my future generations. That that's just how I view it.
- 44:17And it's a really interesting take when you start reading
- 44:20about Islamic finance, it, it really does make you think.
- 44:25And I think we don't, I think it's a, it's a, it's a different
- 44:30lens to look at Bitcoin through because in the West we hear the
- 44:35same kind of narrative over and over again about, you know, it's
- 44:39decentralized, it's a store of value.
- 44:41There's only 21 million, no one can control it.
- 44:44But I think when you look at it also from a religious point of
- 44:47view and you dive deep into Islamic finance, because there's
- 44:50no other religious finance, there's only Islamic finance, it
- 44:54makes it clear it, Ashok, is a lot of the deeper values
- 45:00associated with Bitcoin as well, which are appealing to a vast
- 45:03majority of people. Yeah.
- 45:06Yeah, there, there's a lot to unpack there.
- 45:09I think Harris of Ron, there's a few podcasts he's recently done
- 45:13that I think are worth you going and taking a look at because
- 45:16what Ralph just outlined is really spot on in multiple
- 45:19fronts. One of them is like I joke
- 45:21around and say whether it's individuals coming into on ramp.
- 45:24We invest on the early writer side, acquaintances and I'm sure
- 45:27a lot of people listening to this have experiences when you
- 45:29meet somebody that really deeply groks Bitcoin and it's it's need
- 45:33to be the substrate of effectively humanity when it
- 45:35comes to, you know, capital allocation, formation, social
- 45:40allocation or formation. Once they understand they just
- 45:44want a form of money that they don't want somebody else to take
- 45:46from it. Everything else on the is on the
- 45:47margin. Like you can figure out the rest
- 45:49you already have like this nice alignment and this notion of
- 45:54Islamic finance, as Ralph mentioned, it's like it's
- 45:57ethical finance. It kind of reminds me of
- 45:59Austrian economics. It's like when anybody looks at
- 46:01anything related Austrian economics, it's just like common
- 46:03sense. There's, there's nothing like, I
- 46:05think they even come back to it wasn't necessarily foreign in
- 46:07Austria. It was just more of like some of
- 46:09the academics that were kind of codified there.
- 46:14And so when you look at that and then you start to think about
- 46:17how you've been living, you know, Harris is working on some
- 46:20interesting products on the ethical finance side.
- 46:24And we looked at what we were doing with early writers and our
- 46:28Bitcoin denominated fund. And you know, this notion of
- 46:31profit sharing and risk sharing are inherent into ethical
- 46:34finance that the there cannot be an asymmetry when you allocate
- 46:38capital that you have to be in it together or there's some form
- 46:41of misalignment that will ultimately occur at any kind of
- 46:46product. And we see this in the
- 46:47traditional debt based system and the Bitcoin denomination is
- 46:51important because if you have a dollar denomination, well, you
- 46:54can know it. Returning dollars is the easy
- 46:56part. They make more of them.
- 46:58And so you have this asymmetry where you can participate in the
- 47:00upside, but the downside. And so that ultimately leaves a
- 47:02misalignment from the general partner and where the allocation
- 47:05goes versus if you don't get paid, if you don't return more
- 47:08of the underlying. It's very nuanced, but it's
- 47:10fundamentally different. And that's part of that risk
- 47:14sharing and alignment that is just been it has not occurred.
- 47:18So I think it's just fascinating that what Islamic finance has
- 47:21been trying to get back. It's it's the perfect asset.
- 47:24And I think that's part of this excitement from Harris and where
- 47:27we see the region really adopting Bitcoin.
- 47:30Does your? Bitcoin custody setup keep you
- 47:32up at night. Maybe you still have coins
- 47:34sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 47:37Or maybe you've set up your own self custody.
- 47:38But don't feel safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a
- 47:41little plastic device in your desk drawer.
- 47:44Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp and our multi institution
- 47:47custody solution. Here's how it works.
- 47:50On Ramp creates a dedicated multi sig vault just for you. 3
- 47:54separate institutions each hold a key on ramp bit go and coin
- 47:58cover, but none can move funds unilaterally.
- 48:01Instead only you have control over your coins.
- 48:05With on Ramps multi institution custody you'll sleep better at
- 48:09night knowing your Bitcoin is stored with best in class
- 48:11security on chain with fault tolerant multi sig.
- 48:15If you believe. Your Bitcoin is going to be
- 48:17worth a lot someday. Don't jeopardize that future by
- 48:20exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 48:24in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 48:27you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 48:30custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 48:33eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 48:37attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 48:40financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 48:43Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 48:46warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 48:50and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 48:53asset, secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 48:59Yeah, all great points. You know, I did want to maybe we
- 49:04can talk a bit about, you know, as I mentioned, Michael and I
- 49:09were in Jackson Hole last week. We were there for the Wyoming
- 49:14Blockchain Symposium, Senator Cynthia Lummis was there,
- 49:18Senator Tim Scott, were there a lot of other sort of notable
- 49:21speakers? And you know, Michael, I'm
- 49:24curious to get your thoughts. We haven't fully unpacked and,
- 49:27and caught up on it, but you know, some of my sort of core
- 49:31takeaways are related to what we've talked about on this call
- 49:33already and that, you know, I think there's this huge sort of.
- 49:42You know. Call it just the broader digital
- 49:44asset industry that is has grown very large, you know, heavily VC
- 49:48funded, but I think they're struggling to to really
- 49:53rationalize product market fit and why these protocols need to
- 49:56exist. And that was, you know, one of
- 49:59my large takeaways from watching a lot of the panels of the
- 50:01conference last week, you know, there was, I think there was 24
- 50:06panels total. Five of them talked specifically
- 50:09about Bitcoin. The rest of them were about
- 50:13broader crypto. Tokenization was a hot buzzword.
- 50:17Real world assets was a hot buzzword.
- 50:22And I think, you know, there's there's just not a ton of great
- 50:27ways for these folks to articulate why these protocols
- 50:30exist. I think the best that they've
- 50:31come to is people like the dollar.
- 50:35And so we need stable coins and stablecoins is really just the
- 50:38first instance or first example of tokenizing real world assets.
- 50:43And so that's sort of the the narrative path they've gone
- 50:46down. People on various panels like
- 50:49even admitted like nobody's really interested in Defy
- 50:51anymore. Vitalik had a tweet, I think a
- 50:54couple days ago where he was actually just like sort of
- 50:57outing himself being like, well, where's the yield come from?
- 51:01Like a a question that Bitcoiners have been asking for
- 51:04many years. The Dalek, the, you know,
- 51:07founder of Ethereum kind of just put that out into the world is
- 51:10like, yeah, like this all of this defy activity.
- 51:14These protocols are just based on basically degenerate gambling
- 51:18and trading. Like that is where the yield
- 51:20yield comes from in theory. So I think there's this slow
- 51:23realization that, you know, it's really this barbell of use cases
- 51:29for broader crypto, right? It's pure degenerate gambling,
- 51:32meme coins or stable coins, real world assets, which like if you
- 51:38break it down, it's not all that innovative.
- 51:39Like do you really need a decentralized blockchain to
- 51:44issue existing assets on a faster database?
- 51:47Like probably not. And, and realistically, a lot of
- 51:50these issuers would probably rather do it on private block
- 51:53chains as opposed to public block chains.
- 51:57And part of. That is just because, you know,
- 51:59the public blockchain has a native token.
- 52:01It's like, well, why does that token exist if you're just
- 52:04recreating other assets on this blockchain?
- 52:06So I think there's, there's a lot of open questions that were
- 52:09sort of solidified for me in terms of, you know, as I watched
- 52:13these panels play out, I could tell that the people on them
- 52:16didn't feel super confident about talking about, you know,
- 52:20really the, the reason that these protocols exist and, and
- 52:23the best they could do was we're going to recreate these other
- 52:26assets on a faster database. And it was just, you know, it
- 52:29was sort of, you know, it's something I, I sort of knew
- 52:33inherently, but just seeing it play out on stage with a lot of
- 52:36these panels was, it was interesting to see.
- 52:39But Michael, I'm curious if you had similar takeaways or you
- 52:43know, I talked, I know you talked to a lot of different
- 52:44folks last week. Yeah, this will be an
- 52:47interesting tape for, I think I shared a little bit with Brian
- 52:50for Ralph for you to hear. This is what's kind of fun.
- 52:54It's like some of this stuff is maybe meant to be talked about
- 52:57behind closed doors, but I don't.
- 52:59You get on these pods and you just start kind of going.
- 53:02I think what Brian just described is ultimately a
- 53:04feature, not a bug of all of this.
- 53:07And what I mean by that is the whole notion, a lot of these
- 53:10things and tropes that we talked about in Bitcoin, I think have
- 53:12these underlying real important implications.
- 53:16And, and the one that I'm referring to is everyone gets
- 53:17Bitcoin at the price they deserve.
- 53:19And ultimately there's been a lot of misallocation of capital
- 53:23and movement of assets for the past hundred plus years.
- 53:26And this idea that people are missing, the most obvious thing
- 53:30is, is very beautiful part of the whole setup.
- 53:33And so it's it's something that we have to like embrace.
- 53:38It's this notion of Bitcoin being a get rich slow scheme
- 53:43disguised as a get rich quick scheme.
- 53:46In the same way that we, we are picking up what is happening
- 53:51here while others are missing it in digital assets lets you build
- 53:56it's a, it's basically the, the corollary from a reputational
- 54:00perspective is Bitcoin is a, is a, you know, get wealthy from a
- 54:06personal, from a reputational slow scheme just dressed up as
- 54:11a, as a get wealthy, you know, from a reputational personal
- 54:16fast scheme. In the sense of like people burn
- 54:18their relationships, they burn their business reputation by
- 54:23doing these things, by going in and tokenizing, doing all of it.
- 54:26But the reality is those firms are probably not going to exist
- 54:30in 10 to 50 years because of all the different tailwinds in the
- 54:33market structures just fundamentally different, right?
- 54:35When you think about if it's not growth at all cost, if it's not
- 54:38all of these things that have been baked into the system, well
- 54:41then it makes kind of sense that they're not going to pick up on
- 54:43it first. And the ones that maybe our
- 54:45family owned is an interesting dynamic.
- 54:47You start to see them picking up because actually have more to
- 54:49lose versus like an academic nature building that doesn't
- 54:52really have an allocate, doesn't have any material exposure
- 54:54outside of, you know, some of this equity that they have
- 54:58investing or being granted. So that's kind of like the the
- 55:01overarching take, I think where this ties into you asked this
- 55:06question to Ralph about the Middle East and its adoption.
- 55:10And while I think Islamic finance is a component, what I
- 55:13think is more. I think.
- 55:16Important or from my experience is this is all just like a very
- 55:22slow methodical like blocking and tackling game from what I've
- 55:27seen, because when I got into space right there wasn't, you
- 55:30know, back in 17, there's a few podcasts and the market
- 55:33structure starts to evolve. I moved back to Texas.
- 55:36We were part of a very small meet up that had a couple people
- 55:39in there and naturally grew a lot of covet things macro forces
- 55:42had people moved to Texas and we, you know, on the road just
- 55:46hustling right driving around all over the country, all over
- 55:49the state. We like to think of it as a
- 55:50country, but the US still recognizes the state and and you
- 55:55know, up early in the morning, sleep, wait, do it again and
- 55:58again. And you're just building
- 56:00reputation. You're you're, you're telling
- 56:02people that it's, it's a slower round, right?
- 56:04You're going to hold your keys, you want them offline, you want
- 56:07Bitcoin only. And everybody looks at you and
- 56:09some get it. And the real, the sound money,
- 56:11the people that understand opportunity, understand
- 56:15counterpart risks, the things that are inherent to just like
- 56:17civilization that existed. They're like, OK, they get in,
- 56:20others don't. And some take a little bit
- 56:22slower, but that compounds year over year.
- 56:25And whether it's your business or your reputation, it grows
- 56:29until you're naturally like the default.
- 56:31And it just takes time. And I don't think you have to
- 56:33get more than call it 5 to 10%. It's just that entrenched
- 56:36minority. And so that ties into the middle
- 56:39the Middle East and how our initial exposure got out there
- 56:41was there were diligence in us from the region.
- 56:45They were setting up an advocacy group.
- 56:47They knew, they went and, you know, talked to a bunch of
- 56:49people. They didn't not only need
- 56:51Bitcoiners, they needed people that had some kind of
- 56:53professional experience and all the things associated.
- 56:56They looked at us and and we looked at an opportunity.
- 56:59We're like, look, maybe this, this is interesting.
- 57:02I'm obviously like accelerating the story, but we went out there
- 57:05and realized that similar to Texas in most places that you're
- 57:11starting at 0. And so you have to have the
- 57:14vision that this has an opportunity to grow here, that
- 57:17the market, there's a market need.
- 57:19You obviously do not want to be too early because being too
- 57:21early is wrong. And then you need to find the
- 57:24right individuals to go out and and help grow that.
- 57:28But I think that's a that's a key component that there is no
- 57:30real like silver bullet. It's more of like building
- 57:33education, reputation, having the right products that map to
- 57:36it. And then it's just everyday, you
- 57:38know, like putting 1 foot in front of the other, one
- 57:40relationship in front of the other until over time you're
- 57:44naturally like now competing with the forces of wool as a
- 57:46crypto, as a defy is at the next hot thing.
- 57:49Or do we separate the two conversations and one is a store
- 57:53value similar to how Ralph spoke of gold real estate in these
- 57:56other assets. And then the other is this
- 57:59speculative asset that people can always trade and whip around
- 58:02if they want, but they're just fundamentally different versus
- 58:05right now in the West or the East are still inextricably
- 58:08late. And this is again, our greatest
- 58:10asymmetry is that we know that they're not.
- 58:13Yeah, Yeah, it's really well said.
- 58:16Go ahead, Ralph. Yeah, just.
- 58:18To add on that and I think what you mentioned Michael about the
- 58:22timing is spot on. Now there is one thing that is,
- 58:26you know, to, you know, Bitcoin's advantage in the
- 58:30Middle East. So I mentioned earlier, things
- 58:33happen a bit later in the Middle East.
- 58:34They get imported from the West. But what got hyper accelerated
- 58:39in the Middle East is all the blockchain and all the crypto
- 58:43stuff. But there's a silver lining to
- 58:46that because now the conversation is less technical
- 58:51in nature because you don't need to understand.
- 58:54Most of the people here, especially the ones we deal
- 58:57with, are crypto savvy. They understand blockchain, they
- 59:02understand hashes, they understand mining, certain
- 59:05concepts that you know are usually time consuming to get
- 59:09through with. So the idea here, the priority
- 59:13is just to, like you said, detach them.
- 59:16Like you can't say Bitcoin is crypto the same way you can't
- 59:21say a blue chip company is equivalent to a penny stock.
- 59:26Both of them are stocks, but they're they're not the same
- 59:28things. So even though they're digital
- 59:31assets, Bitcoin is in a category of its own.
- 59:34And even I wouldn't even call the other digital assets.
- 59:39I call them, you know, tech companies, unregistered
- 59:43securities, whatever you want to call them.
- 59:45But at the end of the day, they have a very different profile
- 59:48than Bitcoin. And I think the messaging over
- 59:51time as we educate, as we showcase that Bitcoin is
- 59:56different from multiple angles, whether it's to from Islamic
- 59:59finance, ethical finance or as a commodity asset, as a portfolio
- 1:00:06asset, it changes the dynamic. Rather than categorize,
- 1:00:09categorize it as this tech play that you're that you're playing
- 1:00:13with, it's, it's more of a legit brand.
- 1:00:17So that's the idea. And I think, yeah.
- 1:00:21Well, there's one one thing to call out that well, the the
- 1:00:25other side to the token of, you know, there's no silver bullet
- 1:00:30is if there is one region, and I think we all believe this to
- 1:00:34accelerate and jump past everyone is the Middle East
- 1:00:38because there's the the cherry on top.
- 1:00:41The gasoline is the religious nature and what we talked about,
- 1:00:44but the underlying part is the energy money because they're a
- 1:00:48commodity based civilization in the of the the amount of assets
- 1:00:54that they hold is disproportionate from an energy
- 1:00:57perspective to the rest of the world.
- 1:00:59And in this is speaking from experience, because if you look
- 1:01:02at what happened with Texas and the amount of hash rate that
- 1:01:04exists there, because ultimately, when you're taking
- 1:01:08your energy and you can transmute it into local currency
- 1:01:11or or a digital currency and go back to local currency, that
- 1:01:15crosses a barrier versus any altcoin or anything else.
- 1:01:18Because you can't mind that you can't turn real world energy
- 1:01:20back. And what generally happens is
- 1:01:22individuals with that energy just want to get into the unit
- 1:01:25and then get into dollars or their local currency.
- 1:01:28But then that's just the first like little taste of it.
- 1:01:31And then you naturally start to question over time.
- 1:01:33And this is like, it's no, you know, it's no coincidence.
- 1:01:36Brian brought up the the event he was held in Wyoming, which
- 1:01:39has been one of the most forward, if not the most forward
- 1:01:41thinking. I think they are the actual most
- 1:01:42forward thing to say so far. And there's a lot of reasons
- 1:01:45similar going back to the energy side.
- 1:01:47And Texas is probably second there.
- 1:01:49And so I think that's the the interesting part about the
- 1:01:51Middle East is the energy nature and the conservative nature,
- 1:01:54which is I think also underscored or under appreciated
- 1:01:59that there's just this notion of conservatism across the board
- 1:02:04maps very nicely to Bitcoin. And between that and the
- 1:02:08religious side, now you're really prime to for growth.
- 1:02:11Yeah. And I think just spot on
- 1:02:14conservative side of cover, but the energy side in itself, the
- 1:02:18amount of sun that there is in the Middle East and the amount
- 1:02:21of oil that is being dug out of the ground, all that can sync up
- 1:02:28with Bitcoin mining and allow development, subsidizing huge
- 1:02:34projects within the area. I mean, it's just like a
- 1:02:37matchmaking heaven. It's it's something that hasn't
- 1:02:41been fully explored. And we don't know.
- 1:02:44There are rumors that there has been projects that are underway.
- 1:02:48But maybe in the next 2-3 years, everyone's going to be surprised
- 1:02:54and we might take the lead over Texas.
- 1:02:57So something to look out for. I think here, if the right
- 1:03:01people are talking to leadership and those who are ruling the
- 1:03:07country, I think we can see a really bright orange future for
- 1:03:11the Middle East. And it's just it's just geared
- 1:03:14for Bitcoin in every aspect, like you said.
- 1:03:17So that's why we're here, and that's why we're pushing the
- 1:03:21Bitcoin message not from a get rich quick, but more from a
- 1:03:25conservative energy and ethical lens as well.
- 1:03:32Yeah, I think the, I think the global hash rate wars have
- 1:03:35already begun. But to your point, Ralph will
- 1:03:38probably have a better sense for how that's actually playing out
- 1:03:43in a few years. I mean, I think the one, well,
- 1:03:46we sort of get little pieces of information or evidence beyond
- 1:03:51an some of the anecdotal evidence that you that you
- 1:03:54reference. But, you know, I think it was
- 1:03:57king of Bhutan that was like, referenced in some litigation,
- 1:04:02the bankruptcy of Celsius. And so that sort of forced their
- 1:04:06hand tip their hand to say, oh, yeah, by the way, we've been
- 1:04:09mining Bitcoin for a while now, accumulating sats.
- 1:04:13So, yeah, I think there's going to be more examples of that and
- 1:04:15then sort of, you know, just some of it playing out behind
- 1:04:19the scenes. But yeah, it's fascinating
- 1:04:23times. And I think I agree with
- 1:04:25everything that that both of you said in terms of just the
- 1:04:27inherent alignment of Bitcoin culture in the region and, and
- 1:04:32the proclivity to understand energy, money and you know, just
- 1:04:36this ethical form of investment more or less.
- 1:04:40And there's one component we didn't really touch on, sorry
- 1:04:43Michael, to interrupt you. But one thing from a cultural
- 1:04:47point of view is inheritance, which is a big factor in Middle
- 1:04:53Eastern culture. You have extremely wealthy
- 1:04:55families and even the non wealthy families, it's a top
- 1:05:00priority for them on how they're going to inherit their assets to
- 1:05:03their children. So it's a big component and
- 1:05:08there is no other solution that will make anyone feel
- 1:05:12comfortable in transferring asset.
- 1:05:14I I mean, it's unrealistic. I know there's some people who
- 1:05:17constantly say, you know, self custody, not your keys, not your
- 1:05:22coins and all that stuff. But when you're talking to a
- 1:05:27royal family or a family office from this region, you cannot
- 1:05:31expect them to, you know, put their wealth and then to rely on
- 1:05:37their children to be able to go through a treasure map to pull
- 1:05:40it out. One thing that I mentioned at
- 1:05:42the start of this service here is huge and things get done
- 1:05:49through efficient service. And to add to that, I don't see
- 1:05:54any other custody model that solves the risk sharing,
- 1:05:58reducing counterparty, minimizing single points of
- 1:06:00failure because they can put it at a custodian, but that's not
- 1:06:05the most efficient way for them. They're not solving for the
- 1:06:07problem. Even from that point of view.
- 1:06:09I'm not sure how inheritance would be facilitated, but multi
- 1:06:13institutional custody, multi jurisdictional custody, I think
- 1:06:17will be extremely appealing for family offices.
- 1:06:20Once they understand Bitcoin as a value proposition, I think it
- 1:06:26will be very quick to transition from I understand Bitcoin now
- 1:06:30and I want to hold it the right way to.
- 1:06:33I don't want to do it multi institution custody versus, you
- 1:06:37know, for them qualify custodian ETFs, probably the same thing or
- 1:06:42keep it on and exchange the same thing.
- 1:06:44And the reason why is that because they don't understand
- 1:06:47Bitcoin properly. But as soon as they understand
- 1:06:51it, I think it will automatically click the jump
- 1:06:53from I want to own Bitcoin to multi institution custody makes
- 1:06:57sense for me. It's going to be really fast
- 1:06:59simply because of the risk sharing and the cherry on top,
- 1:07:04which is inheritance, because it's seamless.
- 1:07:07Yeah, 100% inheritance is like one example.
- 1:07:10The one that I've been having fun with is, you know, when you
- 1:07:13explain what we do or multi institution, whether you're in
- 1:07:15Wyoming or the Middle East and you're like, oh, so you hold
- 1:07:18your own keys, collaborative custody.
- 1:07:20Did you bring your keys? And they're like, well, that's a
- 1:07:23problem, right? And then it's like, did you did
- 1:07:25or if you did, you bring keys? If they didn't bring, it's like,
- 1:07:27well that's a problem, right? It's like just it's you're kind
- 1:07:30of damned on either side and where it's funny, but it kind of
- 1:07:34isn't. It's like this idea of like six
- 1:07:38or seven years stuck with me. Ralph, you mentioned early about
- 1:07:41it takes a few, you know, a while before it gets over to
- 1:07:43Middle East, which kind of like tracks and makes sense to, you
- 1:07:46know, a Bitcoin only company being there because I think, you
- 1:07:48know, honor it mean is probably the first while, you know, six
- 1:07:52years ago, this was probably just about the same time that,
- 1:07:55you know, the unchains and different firms like that were
- 1:07:57really standing up on a Bitcoin only side or even on the like
- 1:08:00multi sig side. That multi sig, you know,
- 1:08:03started it was used 10 years ago from an enterprise perspective,
- 1:08:06but it wasn't until about 6-7 years that it was built for like
- 1:08:09consumer grade usage in collaborative custody.
- 1:08:13And there's this idea that or not idea was very important to
- 1:08:17keep assets off of Celsius as the block fest of the world.
- 1:08:20Multi institution didn't exist. And you can make the case that
- 1:08:23it was path dependent. Multi sig needed to be more kind
- 1:08:25of used by individuals. But where I'm going with this is
- 1:08:29to your point now, do you need to go and go through all the
- 1:08:32pains and troubles of figuring out harder devices and see
- 1:08:35phrases and all the things like that in this next wave of
- 1:08:38adoption? Or can you jump directly into a
- 1:08:40more resilient form of custody where ultimately if a bad actor
- 1:08:44goes down or something happens, they can't move your assets.
- 1:08:47So the worst case scenario is assets are moved.
- 1:08:50I think that that's one of the areas where we go back to maybe
- 1:08:54not being first is a is a positive in the sense that you
- 1:08:58can go and talk with these individuals and explain why the
- 1:09:01case for Bitcoins existed, why it's been the Wild West.
- 1:09:04And you've been right to maybe look at it a little bit slower
- 1:09:07because you you ultimately could have ended up on, you know, a
- 1:09:10slide that had $500 billion or $400 billion worth of losses.
- 1:09:13But now here's a solution. I think I think it's a very
- 1:09:16compelling discussion point that we find success with.
- 1:09:19And I think you're finding success as well in the Middle
- 1:09:21East. Yeah.
- 1:09:23And I think, I think to get to that level, Michael, I think we
- 1:09:29need it like you said, the vast majority of people to start
- 1:09:33considering self custody because I think Bitcoin adoption happens
- 1:09:39in two opposite ways. So in traditional finance, for
- 1:09:43example, usually they label it the smart money does something
- 1:09:47and then retail follows. And Bitcoin is taking on a
- 1:09:49different approach where retail took self custody, started
- 1:09:54testing multi sig, etcetera. And then institutions were late
- 1:09:59to the game and then they had to follow a new approach.
- 1:10:04Because the reason why they're late to the game is because when
- 1:10:07you look at investment committees, pension plans,
- 1:10:09endowments and foundation, people underestimate the amount
- 1:10:13of bureaucracy and the amount of checks that you need to go
- 1:10:16through. Like without these large capital
- 1:10:19allocators, Bitcoin will not scale in my opinion and will not
- 1:10:25grow to what most people expect it to grow into a multi
- 1:10:29$1,000,000 per coin type of asset.
- 1:10:31You need that large capital flows.
- 1:10:34And the problem with these, a lot of what's happened over the
- 1:10:37years with centralized exchange, it's left a bad taste in their
- 1:10:40mouth. So it's extremely difficult for
- 1:10:42them to be like, sure, let's invest 5% into Bitcoin or even
- 1:10:461% into Bitcoin. So when multi institution comes
- 1:10:50along now it starts to makes more sense for them.
- 1:10:54They don't have to manage private keys.
- 1:10:56They don't have to be concerned about one single custodian.
- 1:11:00And you have to keep in mind that most custodians qualify
- 1:11:03custodian within the ecosystem haven't been around for much.
- 1:11:08I mean, Bitcoin's been around for 15 years.
- 1:11:10No one is a BNY Mellon who's been around for 100 years, 150
- 1:11:15years. So when you you talk about a
- 1:11:18traditional custodian, you know they're going to get bailed out
- 1:11:21if they need to, but they've been around for so long.
- 1:11:24So as a pension plan, like even the term, most of them go
- 1:11:27through Coinbase Prime, right? But what Coinbase hasn't been
- 1:11:30the best company. They have constant tech issues,
- 1:11:34etcetera. So you're relying on that single
- 1:11:36entity and it's not a brand name.
- 1:11:39Coinbase is associated with a lot of ship coins, with a lot of
- 1:11:43coins that get unlisted, relisted, etcetera.
- 1:11:46So it's not a clear cut approach.
- 1:11:49Whereas multi institution will solve that problem for them
- 1:11:53because they have more security. If one of these is fraudulent,
- 1:11:58mischievous, or doesn't know how to run a business, well, there's
- 1:12:01two others. And on top of that, if you're
- 1:12:04still not comfortable with the model, then at that point you
- 1:12:07can do kind of a code red type of emergency where someone in
- 1:12:10the investment committee has been given the authority to
- 1:12:13actually move from the vault to a separate wallet or someone on
- 1:12:18the tech side, chief tech officer to their tech personal
- 1:12:23hardware wallet until they resolve these issues.
- 1:12:25So I think multi institution custody will facilitate pension
- 1:12:29plans, endowments and foundation to enter the space.
- 1:12:31And once they enter the space, that's when we're going to see
- 1:12:35Bitcoin scale because there's going to be so much money in it.
- 1:12:38It's going to allow the ecosystem to flourish.
- 1:12:40It's going to allow more investors to come into the space
- 1:12:42to build on top of Bitcoin layer one rather than distract from
- 1:12:46the noise. When Bitcoin hits 120, a $150.00
- 1:12:50per coin, there's going to be a lot of eyes on it and it's going
- 1:12:53to become an institutional asset class and no longer, you know, a
- 1:12:58grass root asset class. Yeah.
- 1:13:01I think just hitting on one point that you mentioned in
- 1:13:05there in terms of the custody itself, you know we just put out
- 1:13:09a report, a report on the on ramp side called the the
- 1:13:12evolution of Bitcoin custody. And and you know, one of the
- 1:13:14things that we speak to in that is how multi institution custody
- 1:13:18shifts the incentives. So not only to your point, does
- 1:13:22it create a more fault tolerant and redundant approach to
- 1:13:25custody, which allows you to think longer term about the
- 1:13:27asset, but it actually materially shifts the incentives
- 1:13:32of the participants, right? Because if you're a coin base,
- 1:13:35if you're a single entity, it's pretty easy for you to act
- 1:13:39unilaterally with the assets, whether that's re hypothecating
- 1:13:42the coins or just mismanaging keys.
- 1:13:45And and maybe that isn't even purposeful, but it could happen.
- 1:13:50The concept in the framework of multi institution custody that
- 1:13:55allows other participants to come in, none of which have
- 1:13:57unilateral control, just naturally shifts the incentives
- 1:14:01of those players to be better actors.
- 1:14:02And so I think that's something that's going to play out over
- 1:14:05the next decade or two is, is people recognizing that this is
- 1:14:09just a better way to to store the asset.
- 1:14:11But we are coming up on time. Any, any final thoughts from
- 1:14:16either of you? Ralph, where can people find all
- 1:14:19the work that we've referenced? I'll put I'll put those reports
- 1:14:22in the show notes, but how can people follow you in particular?
- 1:14:24And any other final thoughts before we wrap?
- 1:14:29Yeah, so people can follow us across all social media
- 1:14:32platforms. The website onrapmena.com, we're
- 1:14:36on LinkedIn, we're on X as well at onrampmena.
- 1:14:41Make sure to follow us. We post three to four times per
- 1:14:44day, a variety of types of content.
- 1:14:46Also have a newsletter, the Bitcoin Observer, that we send
- 1:14:51out on a monthly basis. It's your quick recap of
- 1:14:54everything that's happened. Bitcoins if you're a
- 1:14:57professional, you don't have time to dive deep into Bitcoin.
- 1:15:01This should do it for you. Takes about an hour to fully
- 1:15:04read. And the New Frontier, make sure
- 1:15:07to follow Harris Erfan as well. And we have an upcoming episode
- 1:15:14as well this week, so stay tuned.
- 1:15:20Awesome. Yeah, I think I think on my side
- 1:15:24is one of the core tenets that Ralph and Brian focus on and
- 1:15:28that have been transformative for the for the firms is the
- 1:15:31education. A lot of the stuff we talk
- 1:15:32about, it takes a lot of time looking at the space even to
- 1:15:35rock why multi institution custody would matter.
- 1:15:37So there's a lot of great content coming out and I think
- 1:15:40reaching out to Ralph for us, if you're interested in getting
- 1:15:42involved in the region, there's a lot of market structure that's
- 1:15:44going to have to develop as Ralph hit the price hits, you
- 1:15:48know, greater than 100 KA, lot of this stuff becomes more
- 1:15:53obvious and then more products services are going to be needed.
- 1:15:57So whether it's we're hiring or you're thinking about building a
- 1:16:01project in the region, we all want to speak with you.
- 1:16:03I know Ralph always has a time available to figure out how we
- 1:16:05can get involved, so please reach out.
- 1:16:08Very well said. Well, thank you, boys.
- 1:16:11Thank you, Ralph for joining us today.
- 1:16:13Great conversation as always and we'll see you guys next time
- 1:16:17we're having a settlements. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:16:19week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:16:22valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:16:24rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:16:26All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:16:29notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:16:31reminder that on Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:16:34entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:16:37investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:16:40your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:16:42Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:16:46one of our private Client advisors.