Latest / Automotive State of The Union / A 10 Year Permit Process for EV Minerals, New Vehicles Sales Got Gains, a $30k EV Battery Replacement
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Hey, it's Thursday, and Kyle, I can't believe it's September. What? [laughs] It's September, man. [laughs] What do we do?
- 0:08Good news is, new vehicle sales seem like they might be coming back a little bit for Kia and Hyundai. Everywhere I go. It's a good way to start September. People really wanna know who I is and who I be.
- 0:17It is a great way to start September. They try put us down when they see me. And if I had to- Never gonna be, to repeat, to compete. I wanna make, like, a few calls today. Okay. Take my hill, now it's time for the kill.
- 0:24Like, what do you mean? Because- Oh, like a few predictions?... I have a sneaking suspicion- Predictions, is what- I have a s- Is that what you mean? No, no, no, not predictions. Oh.
- 0:30But a few calls across the industry- Okay... because I have a sneaking suspicion that there's a, there's a good amount of people that experienced some lift last month.
- 0:39Like, when I was talking to dealers mid-month and things like that, they, it was like, "Hey, things are looking, things are looking pretty good." So- Really?... I, I think, you know, p- yeah, yeah.
- 0:49That's, at least that was my perspective. And, uh, okay, so it's, like, maybe five to seven dealers that I had a one-on-one conversation on that. But you know a couple dealers- But-... is all I'm saying.
- 0:56I know at least a couple. Just, just two or three. You know? Two or three dealers. Two or tr- two or three. You got Bob's, Bob's Used Cars over there on the block, and Ralph's- Yep... Ralph's Rides around the corner.
- 1:06Those are two at least. [laughs] At least the guy across the street. He sold a few. Saw him roll 'em. 1997 Honda Accord he got. He's got, [laughs] yeah. It was perfect.
- 1:17Oh, well, today we're talking about, um, uh, we're not even gonna tell you what we're gonna talk about. One thing is the sales lift. Um, we wanna talk about a few things.
- 1:24Well, let's start, list things that are happening in September. If you live in the Northeast, school is gonna start, so we're a little behind our Southern friends, but school started like- Like a whole month...
- 1:32three years ago. [laughs] But school's gonna start, right? We got a holiday weekend. Um, the leaves are gonna start changing-ish, ish. Um, there's gonna be a little event called ASOTU CON- Oh, yeah... I think.
- 1:45Oh, really? Yeah, I think it's in Philly. [laughs] Wow. I think there's some people coming to that. We should go. [laughs] It is really weird that we are in the same month of September.
- 1:53And I've been seeing some text messages and messages- Whoa... and talking to some dealers that we know, coming through as being like, "Yeah, I know, like, 20 more people that are coming.
- 2:01They just haven't bought their tickets yet." I'm like, that's so automotive, right? Like, we're just gonna buy our- So automotive... tickets last minute.
- 2:07Um, so look, if you're a dealer and you are coming, just buy your tickets. Just buy your tickets. Let's go. Like, they need food- Just come on... and headcounts and all those things. Buy your tickets.
- 2:14We need to know who's coming so that, um, we can be ready for you. I mean, we're ready for you regardless, but, you know, do, do us a solid.
- 2:22There is one really amazing thing that is happening that unfortunately, Kyle, you and I won't be able to be a part of. And- I'm so frustrated about it. Yeah.
- 2:29You and I might have to go out on Sunday and do the same thing or something. That sounds- I don't know... that sounds really good. But there's gonna be a Rocky Run on Monday morning. Yeah.
- 2:38And if I can't think of a way to start out an awesome, like, 36 hours with all of your peers and industry partners and, uh, brilliant people, it's going on the Rocky Run that's gonna start at Center City, in City Hall, and gonna go to the art museum.
- 2:51It's about a mile, so, like, everyone can, can do this, and you're gonna go run the Rocky steps at the end. And just think of the photo ops. Ah, man. Right?
- 2:59Car Guys and Coffee, the Cert- Certified Solutionaries, Fred and Lou that- You got Kevin Jones going out there with them. Is he going? Oh. He was the o- Oh.
- 3:06[laughs] I think actually, Kevin was kind of the one that was like, "Hey, we should do this," and they were like, "We're gonna do it."
- 3:11And then they were in Philly last week, recorded a video all about what they're gonna be doing. Like, it's, the energy is unbelievable right now. Yes.
- 3:18Joe just commented, yes, the live hotel block is sold out, but there are two more hotels.
- 3:24One is, like, just a, a few blocks from the venue that has plenty of space, and also there's a DoubleTree by the airport we have a really special rate at if you're going to, like, get in, get out, um, on the cheap, 139 a room.
- 3:34Actually, the most expensive [laughs] rooms we have are, like, 165, just because we did it right. And they're nice rooms too. Let's go. And they're nice rooms.
- 3:41So if you wanna go to the Rocky Run, oh, what's the best way to get to it? You gotta go search Lou Ramirez on LinkedIn- [laughs]... and look at his last post.
- 3:49Actually, I shared it this morning because I was so excited about it. But they're gonna run the Rocky steps. Go run the Rocky steps. Even if you're in Philly, go run the Rocky steps.
- 3:55Even if you're not coming to the ASOTU CON, because I can tell you, the view from the top of the steps is amazing. It is an awesome- Agreed, yes... spot to catch some pictures.
- 4:04Uh, got some Auto Collabs episodes streaming again today. Is today Doug Miller? Yeah. Is, is that today? Doug Miller, Jocelyn Buday, yeah. Oh, man. That's today. We got two, two great ones coming up for you.
- 4:13Doug Miller, I'll tell you what, talk about someone who is just poised and experienced from multiple industries and bringing that wisdom, and he's telling some stories about exp- It's just great.
- 4:22It's just a great interview. Yes. Uh, check it out. And Jocelyn, uh, new, kind of new to the ASOTU crew, um, so you can come and meet her for the first time.
- 4:28That was actually, I met her for the first time on this podcast interview, so you can check that out as well. But, um, it's Thursday, it's September 1st, and Kyle, we have some news to cover.
- 4:38We got some news to get through, and a lot of automotive stuff today. So a lot of times- Funny thing about that... we touch, like, other retail, but it's like, we're just full on automotive.
- 4:47So if you're in the industry and you're like, "These guys, sometimes they talk about Target," [laughs] not today. No Target today. We're coming at you. Yes. All right.
- 4:56So, uh, first one, actually, this is Automotive News' top story today. Inventory shortage is easing as Hyundai and Kia see their first year-over-year growth since summer of 2021. So is, could this be- Let's go...
- 5:10the tides are turning? Kia, with the lowest day supply of vehicles according to Cox data, uh, said it set an August record with 66,089 deliveries, signaling the company's lineup continues to churn at a high rate.
- 5:23Um, S&P Global Mobility- Wow. It set a record in new car deliveries last month. That's incredible, actually. No. An August record? Yeah. Oh, an August record? An August record. An August record.
- 5:33I didn't realize it was a record. But August is a big month. It's not just year-over-year growth. They set a record? Right. Yeah. So, like, for- What?
- 5:39And, and to be honest, like, Kia has been growing as a brand and, and people are getting- It's a good brand... a, you know, more attached to the brand.
- 5:46They've expanded their model lineup, which, you know, th- they don't have, like, that full model lineup like a Toyota or a Ford or something like that.
- 5:53So anytime you're expanding a model lineup and people are getting, you know, more attracted to the brand, you're gonna see growth. But to see that...
- 6:00in an inventory shortage and, and acknowledging, like, "Hey, look, we've got a little bit more stock, uh, coming in."
- 6:06Um, now overall, from, from an overall perspective, so Hyundai and Kia obviously seeing growth, but we're see- uh, th- we saw growth overall last month.
- 6:16Um, it, it looks like, uh, the, the light vehicle percentage of, of growth has gone up over, uh, just over a percent.
- 6:23And S&P Global Mobility last week re- r- uh, but, and then, like, the, the con- contrast to that is S&P Global said, "Hey, look, we are, we're gonna reduce our total overall sales growth, or sales i- in 2022 down from 14.6 to 14.1."
- 6:42So again, it's like up over here, down over here. [laughs] Up over here, down over here. I just think that there's, it's, it's tough.
- 6:50Like, there's not a consistent, uh, measured approach, but it's ex- it's encouraging to see some automakers making some strides. It really is. Um, according to J.D.
- 6:59Power and LMC Automotive, uh, August marked the 10th consecutive month that retail inventory closed be- low 900,000. So less than a million inventory units. Like- On ground.
- 7:11Now, here's my question, [laughs] 'cause I've been past a couple dealers. I've talked to a couple dealers. I'm like- Ralph... so okay, 900,000 divided by 17,000. Where are all those cars, y'all? [laughs] In transit.
- 7:25I don't know, in a port. I'm just real- No, I'm just really wondering, like, where... No, that's retail inventory. That, I mean, uh, the way I read that- So wholesale. Yeah...
- 7:32maybe we need to del- dig a little bit deeper, but, like, the way I read that is that's units in, like, on ground, um, at this point- Is it produced?... which is kind of surprising. No.
- 7:41I mean, well, I guess, I mean, if you, if, if the numbers are, you know, predicting, like, 13.1 to 13.3 million vehicles, I guess 900,000 right now makes kind of sense. Yeah.
- 7:52Assuming that's not a full month's supply, right? A full month's supply would be about 1.2 million as far as, like, vehicles that are moving. So I guess- Yep... it's less... Yeah, I guess it makes sense, right?
- 8:01It's, it's less than a, it's like a 26-day supply or something. I don't know. Yep. It's all, it's all numbers. I think that's about right, actually. It's all numbers. That's about right. But August- It's all numbers...
- 8:09was also the fourth consecutive month when average incentive, cumulative incentives average less than $1,000. So- [laughs] I love the head look around, too. Everyone's like, "Thank goodness. Keep them low."
- 8:24Man, let, may they stay that way, right? Uh, you know, if we w- we were, if we were, if there was, like, a DraftKings [laughs] for automotive- [laughs]...
- 8:32I would certainly be betting on incentives going up at some point in the next 12- Definitely, uh, yes... 18 months.
- 8:38[laughs] Um, you know, there was an extra selling day if you take out the Sundays in the month, so that may have been a contributing factor. But, you know, months are different.
- 8:45Anyone who runs a business and has payroll knows, like, sometimes, ev- four times a year, you get that five-week payroll m- week. And you're like, "Oh, man." Yeah.
- 8:52I mean, look, everybody wants to be paid, but at the same time, when you're looking at the P- uh, the P&L, like, you're like, "Oh, we're gonna, we're gonna eke out a profit this month."
- 8:59And then that fifth payroll hits, and you're like, "Well, at least everybody's happy." [laughs] There you go. [laughs] Um, so, um, yeah. So that's a little, uh, recent news. I think it's good news.
- 9:09It's a great way to start September. It's a great way to start September. We're seeing automakers make strides, growing, uh, growing retail volume.
- 9:18And, you know, September for, for many dealers is still a, a very up month. You know- Yeah... it's not that- Oh, yeah... like October, November lull. And so August, September are super up months.
- 9:27I'm encouraged going into this month. And, uh, I think, I think we're gonna, uh, hear those stories of dealers and automakers, uh, continuing to go up.
- 9:35And we'll, we'll keep an eye out as more of these monthly reports kind of roll, monthly and quarterly reports kind of roll in. Heck yeah, man.
- 9:41And in the Northeast, and then any, probably any snow, like September, October, like kind of right up to Thanksgiving, everyone's like, it's go time. It's go time. Yeah. So, you know, winter's coming.
- 9:52People are trading in their vehicles, SUVs, snow tires, the whole things. You know what snow tires are, right? Yeah, you lived in Ohio. [laughs] Snow tires. No, Ohio, we don't do snow tires. No.
- 10:01[laughs] Are you kidding me? You kidding me? You think these- I found out about snow tires like four years ago. I didn't even know that was a thing that existed.
- 10:06They got storage things all over the place- Did- [laughs]... storing your snow tires... did you know- Had no clue... that in Canada it is mandatory that you put snow tires on your car? I know, it's ridiculous.
- 10:14It's like- I had no clue... it's like a certain day- That's a crazy thing... like if you don't have snow tires on, you're getting a ticket. Ticket from a Mountie.
- 10:20All, all- [laughs] All Canadian dealers are like, "Yeah, uh, ch- we're gonna be fine when EVs come around. We change tires twice a year for people." [laughs] Right? "We got service, full service." 68% of our revenue.
- 10:31[laughs] Gonna be burning through those babies like crazy. Oh, I can imagine with an EV weight versus snow tires. Speaking of EVs- Oh, my God. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] We needed to pull out of that one.
- 10:41[laughs] We did. We were like, "Ah, I'm falling." [laughs] Now we're talking about snow tires in Canada. [laughs] Like, where are we, where have we gone?
- 10:48Ford and Rivian have separately petitioned the US Department of the Interior to speed up the permitting process for EV materials that are essential for domestic battery production.
- 10:58The letters urge the department to restrict the permitting process to no longer than three years because the current... I was like, "Three years? That sounds like forever."
- 11:08Well, the current process apparently could take up to 10 years. And if you thought- So if you're counting- If you, like, wanted to put a-... the year 2030- [laughs]... is before- The year-... 10 years... 2032.
- 11:19[laughs] So that's 2032. So they would struggle, I think. I think that's the point, that the year 2030 is- Unless someone builds-... coming... build a time machine.
- 11:28I mean, I don't know if you've ever had to submit for, like, a permit for, like, you know, like, to put a deck on your house [laughs] or something like that, and you thought that took a while.
- 11:36I, can you imagine a 10-year permitting process? I kind of just imagine the scene from, uh, what's that movie with all the animals? Uh, Zoo- do- Zootopia, when they're in the DMV. [laughs] I was like- And-...
- 11:47all the animals with glasses on... uh, you're like, any Disney movie- [laughs]... any Pixar movie, right? [laughs]... Jungle Book. And so I just imagine the sloth in there, right? Like, "How may I help you?"
- 11:59[laughs] To, right, that must be- It's the same thing... that's what a 10-year permitting process must be like- It's the same thing... if you want to s- open a mine.
- 12:05So today's, uh, this is a quote from Chris Smith, Ford's chief government affairs officer, "Today's lengthy, costly, and inefficient permitting process makes it difficult for American business to invest in the extraction and processing of critical minerals in the US."
- 12:17He continues, "In contrast, Canada and Australia have adopted mineral permitting pro- policies," say that fast, "that enable producers to complete the process in two to three years while maintaining stringent environmental standards."
- 12:31So we gotta go from t- 10 years to three I mean, that's impressive, and I think it's necessary, and we're hearing reports that Australia is a massive mining field for- Heck yeah... uh, the minerals needed for EV.
- 12:40And so, you know, I thi- like, if we're gonna do this EV thing, which i- in my- Seems like we are... at least from my perspective, it's coming, right?
- 12:48Then we need to, th- this just needs to be a pr- it's probably, honestly, it's probably just a process that hasn't been focused on because it hasn't been necessitated- There's one guy... and we are behind.
- 12:57It's got one guy in it right now. Yeah, there's one guy. [laughs] He's like, he's like, "Okay, so what you're telling me is..." You know.
- 13:02[laughs] And so, I, it's just, it's one of those things that we just have to get better at, and, and I can appreciate it, and, um, you know, that, that use of public funds for, for researching m- m- like, how to geomap and identify m- uh, all the mineral deposits across the US was mentioned in this, uh, in this- Yeah...
- 13:20request.
- 13:21And so I, you know, I think that, like, if, if, if on one hand it's like, "Hey, by 2030 or by 2035, all, all of the cars need to be EVs," or a certain percentage have to be, then you gotta play ball on the game of, like, getting us there, right?
- 13:36Absolutely. It, we can't just, it, like Brian Bensack has been famous for saying, we can't just depend on foreign minerals for EB- EV produc- production.
- 13:44So I appreciate Ford and Rivian kinda petitioning the US government to, to, to play ball here. Yeah. It's gonna be, man, it's just gonna be interesting. Have you ever seen an EV mineral mine?
- 13:54I mean, they all look different, but it- They all look different. It, it doesn't- [laughs] I mean, some- [laughs] What, what- Somet- well, sometimes- The, the-... they literally- The, the really funny part [laughs]...
- 14:03pump water from underneath salt flats, and they get it to the surface, and it's like mineral-rich water, and then it kind of evaporates, leaving the minerals, right? Right.
- 14:12Which could be, I mean, obviously could be a challenge in places where there's already freshwater issues. But, and then some of them just look like a giant, like, it looks like Steve from Roblox made it. Right. Right?
- 14:25[laughs] Yeah. It's just like some- It's the same thing... dumped down. Yeah. I mean, it looks just like that. Here's my question.
- 14:29I just j- I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna lob this one out there, and then we can move to the next story. [laughs] Is there, is there a pin in this grenade, or is it, like, a softball pitch over the plate?
- 14:36[laughs] What are you lobbing? I think it's a pin. [laughs] Okay. Okay. So my question is just, you know, for the, for these mines- I don't know...
- 14:46are they, are the, are the things that are pulling all these, all these minerals out, are they electric- They're all EVs... or gas-powered? Kyle, Kyle, don't even go there. Woo! [laughs] They're all EVs.
- 14:55There couldn't possibly be anything bad about strip mining an acre of land to make one EV battery at all. [laughs] Not at all. We're good. Not at all. [laughs] We're good. That's fair.
- 15:03And, and who generates the electric? I'm just kidding. Let's just move on. No. Speaking of- Speaking of EV batteries... generating electric. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] That was the first,
- 15:12that was easily our first double segue where we both said- Double segue... something different. [laughs] But they all, they, they both made sense. They do. And we got out.
- 15:20It's like each story today, we kind of, like, at some point- Oh... start falling from the air and someone has to- We're in some kind of mood... snatch us out. We're in some kind of mood today.
- 15:27[laughs] A $30,000 dealership quote for a battery replacement has been circulating around Facebook and other platforms. The replacement's on a 2012 Chevy Volt, and it was indeed fact-checked to be accurate by USA Today.
- 15:42The post reads, "A Chevy Volt with just 70,000 miles needed a new battery and some coolant." Don't forget the coolant. "That'll be $30,000 please."
- 15:51And it was confirmed by Gary Herman, service director of Roger Dean Chevrolet in Cape Coral, Florida, as he explained, "Hey, the battery's out of warranty.
- 15:59It's been discontinued by GM, and we had to pay a whole lot to get the battery from a third-party supplier. Like, we don't set the prices. We just found it for the customer."
- 16:08So, um- I mean, y- so the original 2012 cost of a Chevy Volt, 39,000. [laughs] That's, I mean, that driver's like, "Well-" That's in 2012. Average- Oh my gosh, right. Yeah.
- 16:21Oh my gosh, right, that is in 20- I mean, the value of that car now is probably six grand, right? Maybe. Like, real- realistically- No... at best. It, no, it's six grand. Well- With an operational battery...
- 16:31it needs $30,000 in the trunk if you're gonna pay six grand for it. Right. Because [laughs] you gotta put a new battery in it, right? Like, that car is- Unbelievable... crap, man. That's a clunker. That is a clunker.
- 16:40The average battery replacement though- Well, I think this, this is like, yeah, this is the pro- this is, like, a, a thing that we've questioned for a long time, and we had this question when I was originally selling the, the Leaf, is like, you know, when, when, when, when you've got new iPhone batteries coming out, it's like they don't, they don't just take the old batteries.
- 16:57There's a whole recycling process that goes into this.
- 17:00But, you know, creating a standard for a, a replacement mechanism for these older vehicles, because that's like, it's, it's an, it's an engine, but it's an engine that gets discontinued essentially.
- 17:12And so it's, it poses a major problem. Single p- right, a single-piece engine that gets discontinued. Right. Yeah.
- 17:19And, and so with average battery replacement already being high at around $6,300 for non-discontinued el- items that are coming from the manufacturer- Just the new stuff. Yeah... you know.
- 17:29And then, and then things like the Mach-E battery costing as much as 20 grand, you know, I, I, this is, this is a, this is a piece of, like, insurability or battery warranty or- Financing...
- 17:42yeah, financing these things, of questions of, like, what's the, you know, is everybody gonna be forced to get into lease renewal or, or, or product turnover type scenarios.
- 17:53You know, I, I think about someone that, you know, I've known a couple people that still got, like, an o- iPhone 5, iPhone 6. Really?
- 17:59And those people struggle to get anything done on that, and it's like, "Ah, I guess I gotta get a new phone," you know? [laughs] So. But that's just a phone, not a car that gets you places.
- 18:09[laughs] Well, I mean, we're optimistic that obviously the more of these are made, more batteries are made, they're gonna get standards, there's gonna be third-party replacements, and the whole thing is gonna go, and hopefully they find a way quickly to recycle materials.
- 18:21But the best way, obviously, is not to recycle materials. It's just make batteries that last longer. I don't know. Yeah. There you go. It's just easy.
- 18:27Well, and I, I also think- Let's just solve our problems here this morning... you know, I read through a lot of the comments early when this story came out, and I th- I can't remember who actually found the story.
- 18:35It wasn't US Tody- USA Today. No.
- 18:37But, um, you know, I think, like, as a, as any dealership, as you start to run into these new problems in service that people haven't experienced before, is practicing a very high level of empathy when you're communicating what needs to be done, how it needs to be done, the cost of replacement, because it's not just, "Hey, here's your oil change.
- 18:59Here's your tire rotation. Here's your alignment," those conversations that you've been used to and the customers have been used to for a long time.
- 19:05So you have to exercise a whole nother level of empathy and education in order to move these conversations along- Truth... and not end up on US T- USA Today. Truth.
- 19:14[upbeat music] Well, we hope you have an amazing, fully charged September 1st today. We're in the fight with you. Don't ever let anyone tell you it's a lost cause, because it isn't.
- 19:23Got a lot of work to do, though, and it's September. Air is crisp. Feeling good.
- 19:26[upbeat music]