Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Mere Exposure Effect Shapes Office Favoritism
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, I was reading through some old research the other day, and I stumbled on this concept that I think explains a lot of the weird office dynamics we talk about on this show. It's called the mere exposure effect. Luna: Mere exposure effect. That sounds like something straight out of Psych 101, but I have a feeling you're about to make it depressingly relevant to your everyday cubicle life. Lucas: Exactly. The idea is simple, almost embarrassingly simple: we tend to develop a preference for things just because we're familiar with them. The more you see something, the more you like it, even if you're not consciously aware of the exposure. Luna: And I'm guessing this applies to people, not just pottery or abstract art. Lucas: It applies to everything, but for our purposes, yeah, it applies to people. Psychologist Robert Zajonc ran a bunch of experiments back in the late sixties showing that people rated Chinese characters, faces, even nonsense words more positively the more often they'd seen them. And critically, this happened even when the exposure was subliminal, too fast for conscious recognition. Luna: So your brain is basically keeping a tally of 'seen this before, probably fine' without you even knowing it. Lucas: Right. And in an office, that tally is running constantly. Think about who you instinctively trust or like at work. It's often the people you pass in the hallway, bump into at the coffee machine, sit next to in meetings. Luna: The people who are just there, day in and day out. Not necessarily the ones with the best ideas or the most impressive track record. Lucas: And that's where it gets tricky, because this bias operates below the radar. Nobody's going to say, 'I promoted Sarah because I see her in the break room every afternoon.' They'll say, 'Sarah's a great fit for the team,' and genuinely believe it. Luna: But the real reason might just be that her face is familiar. That's honestly a little unsettling. Lucas: It is, especially when you look at the data. There's this fascinating analysis from 2017 of about one point seven million performance reviews across a large company. The researchers found that after controlling for actual productivity, the employees who logged more face time with their managers got systematically higher ratings. Just being around more often, even without obviously working harder, moved the needle. Luna: One point seven million reviews. That's not a fluke. So your visibility is literally baked into how your boss sees your performance. Lucas: And it's not just about performance reviews. It shapes who gets picked for the interesting projects, who gets mentored, who gets the informal feedback that helps people improve. All those little interactions that happen because someone happens to be in the right place at the right time. Luna: Which is basically a huge chunk of office politics, just driven by a subconscious quirk. Lucas: But here's the key nuance: the effect has a ceiling. It's not like more exposure always equals more liking, forever. Zajonc's work and follow-up studies suggest there's a sweet spot. Initial exposure creates a strong positive shift, but after a certain point, the returns flatten out. And in some cases, if the context is negative, repeated exposure can actually breed contempt. Luna: So there's a limit to 'out of sight, out of mind', but also a limit to 'familiarity breeds affection'. Lucas: Exactly. And that has huge implications for hybrid work, which is where I think this gets really practical for a lot of our listeners. In a remote or hybrid setup, the exposure effect cuts unevenly. People who come into the office more often get the benefit of the bias, while remote colleagues are literally out of sight, and therefore out of the mental tally. Luna: So the person who lives close to the office or just prefers coming in has an automatic edge, regardless of their actual output. Lucas: Right. And you see this in the data on remote work. A bunch of studies from the pandemic era showed that remote employees got fewer promotions and lower performance ratings, even when their productivity was equal to or better than their in-office counterparts. The exposure gap is one of the main suspects. Luna: But not everyone can just decide to come in five days a week. So what's the move for a genuinely remote or mostly remote employee? Lucas: The move is to create exposure through other channels. And this is where a little deliberate strategy can counteract the bias. For instance, if you can't be there in person, you can be there in the digital space. Contribute visibly in Slack, ask thoughtful questions in the company-wide Q&A, volunteer for the presentations that are recorded. Luna: So it's not about just being seen for the sake of it, it's about being seen in a way that signals competence and adds value. Lucas: Exactly. But you have to be careful not to overdo it. Remember the ceiling we talked about. If you're constantly posting or commenting, people can start to perceive you as annoying or performative. The goal is to be a reliable, familiar presence, not a constant noise. Luna: Kind of like the office equivalent of a good neighbor. You know they're there, but they're not blasting music at 2 AM. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And that also applies to the in-office crowd. Just showing up isn't enough. You need to be present in a way that's genuine and useful. The mere exposure effect works best when the exposure is positive. If every time your boss sees you, you're complaining or looking frazzled, that repetition is going to work against you. Luna: So the quality of the interaction matters as much as the quantity. Lucas: And it also matters who you're exposed to. The effect is strongest for the people who are in positions to make decisions about your career. So being visible to your boss is important, but also to your boss's boss, and to the influential peers who get tapped for cross-functional teams. Luna: So it's not just about racking up facetime with everyone, it's about strategic visibility with the right people. Lucas: Exactly. And there's one more twist I want to mention, because I think it's really relevant for anyone who identifies as introverted. The mere exposure effect doesn't require you to be the loudest person in the room. It just requires repeated, low-stakes interactions. That means you can be quiet and still benefit. A nod, a smile, a brief 'how's the project going' in the elevator, those add up. Luna: So it's actually good news for introverts. You don't have to become a different person to play this game. Lucas: Exactly. And this is where I think the ethical piece comes in. Some people hear about this effect and think, 'Great, I'll just make sure my face is everywhere.' But that can backfire if it's transparently self-serving. The people who benefit most are the ones who genuinely engage with others, because the exposure is paired with real positive interactions. Luna: So the takeaway is to be genuinely present, not just performatively present. Lucas: And speaking of genuinely present, I've been thinking about this effect in my own career. And I have to say, it's made me more intentional about how I show up, especially since Luna and I are often recording these episodes remotely. But you know what, if you've been nodding along and thinking, 'Okay, I need to be smarter about my visibility,' and this episode helped you see that, then it's worth a coffee. Luna: And you can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's just a small way to keep this show running without ads. Every little bit genuinely helps us keep digging into these topics. Lucas: But anyway, back to the exposure effect. There's one more angle I want to hit, which is how managers can unintentionally create a two-tier system without realizing it. They gravitate toward the people they see the most, and then those people get more opportunities, which leads to even more exposure. Luna: A vicious cycle. Or a virtuous cycle, depending on where you're standing. Lucas: And it's a real problem for diversity and inclusion efforts. If the exposure effect is driving who gets mentored and promoted, then you're naturally going to favor the people who are already in the majority, because they're the ones you're most likely to encounter. It's a subtle form of systemic bias. Luna: So it's not just about individuals learning to be more visible, it's about managers and organizations recognizing this bias and actively working against it. Lucas: Exactly. Some companies are starting to address this by deliberately rotating meeting attendance, or making a point to include remote employees in informal conversations, or even using software to track whose voices are being heard in virtual meetings. Luna: It's a start, but I imagine it's hard to change a bias that's so baked into our wiring. Lucas: It is hard, but awareness is the first step. And that's what we're here for. So next time you're in a meeting, take a second to notice who you're naturally drawn to. Ask yourself if it's because of their ideas or because they're familiar. And if you're the manager, make a point to seek out the quiet voices, the remote people, the ones you don't see as often. You might be surprised at what you've been missing. Luna: That's a good note to end on. The mere exposure effect is a force, but it's not destiny. Once you know it's there, you can start to work with it. Lucas: And that, my friend, is the kind of subtle office politics that actually moves the needle. Thanks for spending this time with us.