Latest / Jewish History Uncensored / 31 | Rabbinic Letters
Transcript
- 0:06Speaker 1: Welcome to Jewish History Uncensored with Mark Shapiro. This is
- 0:09Speaker 1: season sixteen, episode thirty one.
- 0:31Speaker 2: I have so much to do. I try to do
- 0:33Speaker 2: within fifteen to twenty minutes just responding to people. Some
- 0:37Speaker 2: people have told me that's their favorite part. Others maybe
- 0:41Speaker 2: are annoyed because they want to cover more ground. It's
- 0:43Speaker 2: eon versus the kiyas. I guess you could say from
- 0:45Speaker 2: yeshivo lingo. But a lot of stuff is building up,
- 0:49Speaker 2: and at the end we'll probably have to have one
- 0:51Speaker 2: class just wrapping it up. In fact, I have a
- 0:53Speaker 2: big correction to do. Mel's going to be happy, but
- 0:56Speaker 2: thanks to Howard Handler. But I think it's a correction.
- 0:59Speaker 2: But we'll get to that next week because there's other
- 1:01Speaker 2: things I want to do, and I think since so
- 1:03Speaker 2: many of you were with me on the Christmas Eve talk,
- 1:06Speaker 2: at least I can spend just two minutes on that.
- 1:09Speaker 2: Because I do this. Why do I make these corrections
- 1:11Speaker 2: Because I'm a I guess perfectionist, and I want when
- 1:15Speaker 2: I say it to be perfect, so if I misspeak.
- 1:17Speaker 2: And I have a lot of sympathy for the politicians
- 1:20Speaker 2: because when you're just speaking straight, so sometimes you say
- 1:23Speaker 2: things that are incorrect. So I'd like to clarify you.
- 1:26Speaker 2: So just and I listened today to the talk. I
- 1:29Speaker 2: spoke about how we have this concept that even though
- 1:31Speaker 2: something was permissible in the past, because the idolators did it,
- 1:36Speaker 2: we can't do it. And I said it like a bumma.
- 1:38Speaker 2: You know, these altars, they used to be permissible now
- 1:41Speaker 2: there then they became not. Actually what I meant was
- 1:46Speaker 2: a which you also offer us. So here you see it.
- 1:49Speaker 2: For example, the pus it says you shall not sit
- 1:52Speaker 2: up for yourself a monument, save where it says which
- 1:55Speaker 2: God hates san so Rashi's quoting the tomorrow what's it's
- 2:01Speaker 2: a monument of one stone? But then the next Rashi
- 2:04Speaker 2: it says, God commands you to make an altar of
- 2:06Speaker 2: not just one stone, but a bunch of stones. Because
- 2:08Speaker 2: even though if you look into the Hummus you see
- 2:11Speaker 2: Yakov set up but sea others in ton off. But
- 2:13Speaker 2: once the idolators started setting it up, as it says,
- 2:17Speaker 2: it was dear timid Day's in the patriarch, but now
- 2:19Speaker 2: he hates it since these people, that.
- 2:21Speaker 3: Is the the the.
- 2:22Speaker 2: Eight idolators made it a statue for Idolatry, So Uh.
- 2:27Speaker 2: And this concept, by the way, that things that were
- 2:31Speaker 2: used to be okay are no longer. That's actually mentioned
- 2:34Speaker 2: in the Pakaditzkak. He mentions that's the lot of encyclopedia.
- 2:37Speaker 2: He quotes someone who says that do you know why
- 2:41Speaker 2: we don't pray with our hands up in the air? Uh?
- 2:47Speaker 2: For example, I think I have it here. Uh. Yes,
- 2:49Speaker 2: look in embraces in huff bays, impared your doll huff bays.
- 2:53Speaker 2: What does it say? It says uh Avram said to
- 2:57Speaker 2: the King of Sadon, I have lifted up my hands
- 3:00Speaker 2: to the Lord. And also in schmos I found in
- 3:05Speaker 2: perih tests pussa huff tests mosher Aben who says, uh,
- 3:11Speaker 2: here look in pussa huff tests a process cup pie lsm,
- 3:16Speaker 2: I will spread forth my hands.
- 3:17Speaker 3: Into the Lord. So we don't do that anymore.
- 3:21Speaker 2: We don't talk him like this with our hands up
- 3:22Speaker 2: in the air. And the explanation is given because the
- 3:25Speaker 2: non Jews do it. So that okay, that's the first
- 3:28Speaker 2: thing I wanted to do one of you, in speaking
- 3:30Speaker 2: about I said that Jesus had some good things, because
- 3:34Speaker 2: after all, it comes out of the Jewish environment. So
- 3:36Speaker 2: it's some good things. And I couldn't remember the expression
- 3:39Speaker 2: that was used. And what I meant to say was
- 3:44Speaker 2: what he said. What's is good he says, is not new,
- 3:48Speaker 2: and what's new is not good. But it actually I
- 3:50Speaker 2: first found it not said about Jesus. Hunoff Albert in
- 3:53Speaker 2: his studies on the Missioner says is follows. For those
- 3:56Speaker 2: of you who know Greek, no German, I don't know
- 3:59Speaker 2: if Howard's with us. He says about isaacah Avi's book,
- 4:03Speaker 2: he said, hell good, this annoyus nour iss So the
- 4:10Speaker 2: book has good and new. What's good is not new,
- 4:13Speaker 2: and what's new is not good. And this is how
- 4:16Speaker 2: we Fayak of Weinberg says it. In the Three d
- 4:18Speaker 2: As Volume four, page two twenty eight. He uses the
- 4:21Speaker 2: same expression. What he came up with novel ideas is
- 4:29Speaker 2: not good umashu tov and what's good is not uh
- 4:34Speaker 2: is not it's not something new. But and I in
- 4:40Speaker 2: speaking of this, we speak about the golden rule. So
- 4:43Speaker 2: I said the golden rule. It's not if you have
- 4:45Speaker 2: the gold you make the rules. It's Christians do unto others.
- 4:48Speaker 2: Now we have Hello says, don't do to others what
- 4:52Speaker 2: you don't want done to yourself. And Christians always say, well,
- 4:55Speaker 2: that's good, but it's not as good as a golden rule.
- 4:57Speaker 2: And there's so many drush us explaining why we have
- 5:01Speaker 2: the idea, what's paitful to you? Don't do to others?
- 5:04Speaker 2: Not do it not in the positive sense? And why
- 5:08Speaker 2: is the explanation is in the gold the negative golden rule.
- 5:12Speaker 2: But I just threw out that we also have in
- 5:15Speaker 2: our sources the positive golden rule do unto others. Incidentally,
- 5:19Speaker 2: Confucius also has the negative golden rule, so we're not alone.
- 5:23Speaker 2: But I threw out that we have a positive golden
- 5:26Speaker 2: rule in our sources also. So someone challenged me. I
- 5:29Speaker 2: like being challenged, but someone challenged me, where do we
- 5:31Speaker 2: see in our sources golden a positive golden rule? And
- 5:35Speaker 2: I get the challenge because you know, like I said,
- 5:38Speaker 2: you can go online all the people explain why, Dafka,
- 5:41Speaker 2: it's vital to have the negative golden rule, because the
- 5:43Speaker 2: positive golden rule, how can you ever really what it
- 5:46Speaker 2: says I have to How can you really love someone
- 5:49Speaker 2: as much as you love yourself?
- 5:50Speaker 3: It's impossible.
- 5:51Speaker 2: That's why they do the negative golden rule. What it
- 5:53Speaker 2: really means is don't do to others. But I threw
- 5:56Speaker 2: it out, and so let me tell you what I
- 5:59Speaker 2: had in my so hold on.
- 6:03Speaker 3: Here.
- 6:03Speaker 2: In Hilhos avel, Rabat writes it as avel. In uh
- 6:08Speaker 2: in chapter thirteen Halacha one, it's talking about how you
- 6:15Speaker 2: have to visit the sick, come for mourners, et cetera,
- 6:18Speaker 2: et cetera. And look at the end of uh Halaha
- 6:21Speaker 2: one where he says love your neighbor as yourself. This
- 6:25Speaker 2: charge implies that whatever you would like other people to
- 6:29Speaker 2: do for you, you should do for your comrade. In
- 6:31Speaker 2: tar amidstos called verchata harim assey at san la rimslos,
- 6:39Speaker 2: here the rumbum quotes the principle the positive golden rule.
- 6:45Speaker 2: And obviously the rumbam is part of our tradition. So
- 6:48Speaker 2: if you look in hilhost A a l chapter fourteen,
- 6:50Speaker 2: verse one, you see the rabam. And so where does
- 6:52Speaker 2: Ramum get this the rumbum? Usually he doesn't make things
- 6:56Speaker 2: up like this. Rahert Sog says he must have had
- 6:59Speaker 2: a rabbinic so, which we don't have because the standard
- 7:02Speaker 2: rabbinic sources they have to raff They give the negative
- 7:06Speaker 2: golden rule, and that's where you get all the drushes
- 7:07Speaker 2: about why the negative rule golden rule is better than
- 7:09Speaker 2: the positive, but the real mom posts they have to
- 7:12Speaker 2: and he quotes the positive golden rule, so he must
- 7:15Speaker 2: have had some sort of madrashic texts that so uh
- 7:19Speaker 2: for the one who challenged me, where do we have
- 7:21Speaker 2: a positive golden rule? I can't show you on hazab
- 7:24Speaker 2: and I show you the rumbam and that's in our tradition.
- 7:26Speaker 2: That's basically just as good. Just for those who weren't
- 7:31Speaker 2: with us Thursday Night, Robbie Hoodertz Hanking. If you recall
- 7:34Speaker 2: we had a number of to vote by him at
- 7:37Speaker 2: the beginning of our series. We're in class thirty one now,
- 7:40Speaker 2: but if you go back to classes one through ten,
- 7:44Speaker 2: he's dealt with him a lot. He passed away and
- 7:46Speaker 2: you can read about all sorts of uh interest and
- 7:50Speaker 2: a very interesting piece on Layerhouse. Look, he's been ill
- 7:53Speaker 2: for the last few years and it hasn't he wasn't
- 7:56Speaker 2: able to contribute. Next week, hopefully I will read you
- 7:59Speaker 2: something that he called my attention to and said I
- 8:02Speaker 2: would like it, something he wrote. I'll share it with
- 8:05Speaker 2: you hopefully next week, and but Rebbie David Spurling, I
- 8:08Speaker 2: think that's I think that's the name. Has a very
- 8:10Speaker 2: nice piece in layerhouse. I highly recommend it. Okay, A
- 8:15Speaker 2: couple more things. A rafa in Israel. He heard the
- 8:20Speaker 2: talk or we watched the talk that I said ram
- 8:23Speaker 2: we spoke ram as and ra meat that the women
- 8:25Speaker 2: use this title. They turned it into ra meat. And
- 8:28Speaker 2: he's even though it's an abbreviation, not to mention the diminutive.
- 8:31Speaker 2: He says, he's in the idea, or he's been the
- 8:34Speaker 2: last few years. He says the idea. He says, even
- 8:36Speaker 2: though it's incorrect. I don't know why he says incorrect.
- 8:38Speaker 2: If ISRAELI is toady, do what it's not incorrect. He
- 8:41Speaker 2: gave me a bunch of examples. Here are three examples
- 8:44Speaker 2: where Russia k vote in Israel and the Ideaf have
- 8:48Speaker 2: become they for women. They had the tough ending. So
- 8:52Speaker 2: for example, mefa cage aino katsin my shack. I guess
- 8:56Speaker 2: I had pronounced it. So if it's a woman, it's
- 8:58Speaker 2: ma shakite. And he have a few other examples, and
- 9:01Speaker 2: I guess the diminutive it's not uh. They don't. It
- 9:04Speaker 2: doesn't imply diminutive like we said, cough Copete and Sasaki,
- 9:08Speaker 2: et cetera. Daniel maybe Daniel Sperling. Thank you, Howard. The
- 9:12Speaker 2: check it out on their house. Okay, they forty already.
- 9:15Speaker 2: I promised you this, and I'm going to get to it.
- 9:17Speaker 2: But I do also have to deal with what I
- 9:19Speaker 2: said Mike, uh, his issue about tom Wood. But let
- 9:24Speaker 2: me just read this quickly. We have someone who lives
- 9:27Speaker 2: in Israel, although I think he might call it the
- 9:29Speaker 2: Zionist state, not Israel, and he's been listening to us
- 9:33Speaker 2: for many, many years, and he he's not sometmer. Is
- 9:41Speaker 2: there the quasi Zionist the ones that does. But I
- 9:46Speaker 2: spoke if you were called about Rabbie Greenbutt and that
- 9:48Speaker 2: he fought in there y'asu, and I mentioned that he
- 9:53Speaker 2: I asked it, did you see any killings? He said not.
- 9:55Speaker 2: I mentioned Bagan denies that there is a massacre, but
- 9:58Speaker 2: I'm assuming there was a master. I mean, that's uh,
- 10:01Speaker 2: that's the Israeli authority, the Jewish agency authorities acknowledged this.
- 10:07Speaker 2: And I said, so that's the massacre. We can be
- 10:10Speaker 2: able to compare that has quoted me one versus all
- 10:13Speaker 2: the massacres from the other side. And obviously it's not
- 10:16Speaker 2: just Scuscia cial and there's many and look he continues
- 10:19Speaker 2: to our day, Yeah, there have been plenty of massacres.
- 10:22Speaker 2: If you want to get your innate yourself a square
- 10:25Speaker 2: named after you in Ramaala or something, killing one, two
- 10:28Speaker 2: or three is not enough. You have to, like let
- 10:30Speaker 2: off Obama and Sparrow or something, you killed ten. Then
- 10:33Speaker 2: you'll get your your name and lights and everything. So
- 10:37Speaker 2: what he writes to me is that, uh, that's only
- 10:41Speaker 2: one of the massacres, and he mentions a couple others,
- 10:45Speaker 2: a village da Wa Yema in which there was it
- 10:49Speaker 2: seems uh no reason to doubt it that the number
- 10:53Speaker 2: of people uh innocence were executed. He quotes cases of
- 10:58Speaker 2: a lot of cases of rape that happened in forty
- 11:00Speaker 2: eight war. This is all documented by Benny Morris and
- 11:04Speaker 2: his book and Terrible Things done in the nineteen forty
- 11:07Speaker 2: eight war. So all I would say is is follows.
- 11:11Speaker 2: First of all here a sound. First of all, war,
- 11:16Speaker 2: as they say, is hell, and every war has had
- 11:19Speaker 2: terrible things. If you what's the most just war, you
- 11:23Speaker 2: can imagine the war of the allies against the Nazis,
- 11:26Speaker 2: and yet there were war crimes carried out by American soldiers,
- 11:30Speaker 2: by British soldiers, by French sols, obviously by Soviet soldiers.
- 11:33Speaker 2: I mean the amount of rapes that went on with that.
- 11:35Speaker 2: So I don't feel I need to defend blindly if
- 11:39Speaker 2: the evidence is there, and Benny Morris in his book
- 11:42Speaker 2: nineteen forty eight and others has documented there's no it
- 11:45Speaker 2: wasn't just Darius, you know, though that was the biggest.
- 11:47Speaker 2: There was other things, and there were there was all
- 11:50Speaker 2: sorts of rapes and things that were not proper. We
- 11:53Speaker 2: don't need to defend that that that's wrong, and they
- 11:55Speaker 2: had things happen in war, and I do believe that
- 11:58Speaker 2: the other side it's worse. But this doesn't undermine I mean,
- 12:04Speaker 2: the person who writes to us referst to in October
- 12:06Speaker 2: the nineteen forty eight, the Zionist militia. I mean, we're here,
- 12:10Speaker 2: we do with an idea for already, but I don't.
- 12:13Speaker 2: I mean, all this talk about bad things, that doesn't
- 12:16Speaker 2: undermine the justice of the cause anymore than the justice
- 12:21Speaker 2: of the cause against the Nazis was undermined because that
- 12:24Speaker 2: you had soldiers who did things that are improper, and
- 12:28Speaker 2: so the you don't undermine Zionism by pointing out that
- 12:31Speaker 2: you had soldiers who did to evil things and wrong things.
- 12:34Speaker 2: You're going to have that in every war. That's my
- 12:37Speaker 2: only response I can say to the person who wrote
- 12:40Speaker 2: this about I can have a list, double triple as
- 12:43Speaker 2: long as what the Arabs did. So that's all I
- 12:48Speaker 2: would say. And I also there's one more point. I
- 12:50Speaker 2: think people forget it. The actions of terrorism carried out
- 12:54Speaker 2: you're good and and these were terrorism. In some cases
- 12:58Speaker 2: they were terrorism against innocence and soldiers or anything. These
- 13:01Speaker 2: were never advocated by the great rabbis we have, These
- 13:04Speaker 2: were condemned. These and I don't feel we need to
- 13:08Speaker 2: defend some of these things. Bombs, hand grenades thrown into
- 13:11Speaker 2: crowded groups, which happened in the thirties in particular. These
- 13:17Speaker 2: are wrong and we're not. I don't think any of
- 13:18Speaker 2: us say that we're perfect and most perfect. The wars,
- 13:21Speaker 2: of course, were fought differently. Then we can't be anachronistic.
- 13:24Speaker 2: People drop bombs and civilians that's what they did. But
- 13:26Speaker 2: we can acknowledge my correspondence. I say to you that
- 13:31Speaker 2: there were things that were done which were improper. And
- 13:33Speaker 2: what I can tell you also is that if right now,
- 13:37Speaker 2: when Israeli were to go into an arid village and
- 13:39Speaker 2: shoot up three people everyone, we'd all be shocked. And
- 13:42Speaker 2: yet if it happens the other way, they hand out candy.
- 13:44Speaker 2: So I you know the idea that that there's a
- 13:49Speaker 2: that there's an equivalence here. And also when it comes
- 13:53Speaker 2: to Marie, I have no Marie are a bunch of Marxists.
- 13:57Speaker 2: Basically you can know about were they were pro Soviet
- 14:02Speaker 2: after the founding of the state. Lechi was a pro
- 14:04Speaker 2: Soviet organization. Chamir did sort of like a double and
- 14:08Speaker 2: about face on that. But these are people with many
- 14:11Speaker 2: of these people and including in their good I don't
- 14:13Speaker 2: have por values. The Lech was pro Soviet and so
- 14:19Speaker 2: they're not our heroes. So we can acknowledge there were
- 14:23Speaker 2: some bad things there. But this doesn't by any means
- 14:27Speaker 2: create an equivalents. And I don't want to play the
- 14:30Speaker 2: game of citing all the terrible things that because, like
- 14:33Speaker 2: I said, you can cite terrible things that American soldiers
- 14:36Speaker 2: did and French soldiers did against the Nazis, what does
- 14:38Speaker 2: that show you chose that people are human and they
- 14:40Speaker 2: do and they do bad things. That's all I would say.
- 14:45Speaker 2: And I encourage everyone to read Benny Morris's book. Benny
- 14:48Speaker 2: Morris's had left this who became a right winger even
- 14:51Speaker 2: in he even believes that the forty eight and even
- 14:55Speaker 2: later there should have been complete separation of citizens, ause
- 15:00Speaker 2: it would have had to peace in the end, so expulsion.
- 15:02Speaker 2: But he's an honest historian, and he some of the
- 15:06Speaker 2: stuff he writes about it is very difficult to read.
- 15:08Speaker 2: But okay, I'm gonna leave for next week something not
- 15:13Speaker 2: sent me and some other stuff about Trump. I just
- 15:15Speaker 2: want to end with one more thing before we again,
- 15:17Speaker 2: because I promise. Oh, and I do have to say,
- 15:20Speaker 2: I apologize to well thinking about doctorates, I apologize to
- 15:25Speaker 2: read Biselli Achik. Here's his doctoral dissertation. Unlike the others
- 15:29Speaker 2: I said, I think it was like eighty pages. Lo,
- 15:31Speaker 2: and behold it's not. It's a hundred and what is it?
- 15:36Speaker 2: One hundred and ten pages, so a little bit bigger,
- 15:39Speaker 2: but again not the size of a doctor dissertation that
- 15:44Speaker 2: today you'd expect in America or in Germany for that matter.
- 15:47Speaker 2: Here it is. Here's the if you go to the
- 15:51Speaker 2: Wikipedia page or for by cell of a Chick, you
- 15:53Speaker 2: can find what I discovered in East Berlin before it
- 15:58Speaker 2: was West Berlin from myself. So me and the last
- 16:01Speaker 2: thing I want to speak about and then we'll go
- 16:03Speaker 2: right into it is that I I and this really
- 16:07Speaker 2: continues with what we did last class, because we're going
- 16:09Speaker 2: to get toakha couple Schwarts. For those who want to
- 16:14Speaker 2: see the great couple of Schwartz, here he is again.
- 16:20Speaker 2: I showed you the picture of him speaking before them
- 16:23Speaker 2: groups from the twenty first of kiss Lev which was
- 16:27Speaker 2: three weeks ago or something like that, and no one
- 16:30Speaker 2: had masks. And someone said, well they all sot Mao
- 16:33Speaker 2: has a immunity, but apparently not everyone because the Rebbie
- 16:37Speaker 2: in Williamsburg they have two rebbies. He got COVID this week.
- 16:41Speaker 2: So what can I tell you?
- 16:42Speaker 1: But he he.
- 16:44Speaker 2: We spoke about it a couple of strange stories in
- 16:46Speaker 2: the tomorrow and I gave my theory that this maybe
- 16:50Speaker 2: was not intended for everyone to see, that this is
- 16:53Speaker 2: like an internal book from rabbis to other rabbis, so
- 16:55Speaker 2: they can criticize other rabbis in a way that surely
- 16:59Speaker 2: not for ours to hear, and that that explains why
- 17:03Speaker 2: some of these unusual passages. So I was challenged by
- 17:05Speaker 2: a night the Talmud is it's supposed to be for everyone.
- 17:09Speaker 2: I'm making a seam likeg it's only for elites. So
- 17:11Speaker 2: let me just say a few words about this and
- 17:13Speaker 2: I well, first of all, when when various godobling were
- 17:18Speaker 2: asked about translating the Talmwood, many of them opposed it.
- 17:22Speaker 2: Then many of them, in particular when it came to
- 17:24Speaker 2: the adot, said not to because the masses are not
- 17:27Speaker 2: supposed to see this. Now, they were referring in particular
- 17:30Speaker 2: to passages that dealt with anthropomorphism, god wearing to fill
- 17:33Speaker 2: in that sort of thing. But I think it's the
- 17:34Speaker 2: same idea that the masses would not be able to
- 17:38Speaker 2: understand these agadot, and therefore it's not for them. So
- 17:41Speaker 2: this isn't really my hiddish. The idea I just applied.
- 17:46Speaker 2: I just extended a little to other areas. But what
- 17:49Speaker 2: do I mean when I say the Talmwood is obviously
- 17:52Speaker 2: everyone started with Talmud. In fact, you can see sources
- 17:56Speaker 2: that tell you we'll see the rama minutes and more
- 17:58Speaker 2: others that you have to teach your children. Viewer of law,
- 18:02Speaker 2: you have to teach him gamara. That's not what we're
- 18:04Speaker 2: dealing with. Obviously, you have to teach everyone has to
- 18:06Speaker 2: be talking tomorrow. The question is what happens to the
- 18:09Speaker 2: people who don't continue in the gamara and then they
- 18:12Speaker 2: they they're educate, their gamora education remains what it was. Well,
- 18:16Speaker 2: in Europe, it would be when you're twelve years old,
- 18:18Speaker 2: because that's basically when you finished later and went to work. Obviously,
- 18:21Speaker 2: everyone has to be given the opportunity to learn gamora
- 18:24Speaker 2: because that's really how you enter into intellectual Judaism, the
- 18:28Speaker 2: whole tradition. But historically that was only for the elites.
- 18:33Speaker 2: What we have in modern times is a popularization of
- 18:37Speaker 2: tom Woods study, which we never had before. It didn't
- 18:41Speaker 2: start with art scroll. Don't forget Rabbi Steinzeltz's translation had
- 18:45Speaker 2: the huskma of Ramosha fine steam. And not only that,
- 18:48Speaker 2: let me share with you something that people don't even realize.
- 18:52Speaker 2: This popularization began in the nineteenth century. Even well, you
- 18:57Speaker 2: had the translation of Pinner of the Talmud with the
- 18:59Speaker 2: hustband suffer for gave an approbation for here you see
- 19:02Speaker 2: a book Ha Madrich, which appears in the early part
- 19:06Speaker 2: of well the early part of the twentieth century. This
- 19:09Speaker 2: is basically like a copy of Gamara, and you can
- 19:13Speaker 2: see it here. It's so this is what the pages
- 19:15Speaker 2: look like. You have the the Gamara and it's it's
- 19:20Speaker 2: basically a raw It's like Shrinze. So you might say, well,
- 19:24Speaker 2: why is who says this is significant?
- 19:26Speaker 3: Look?
- 19:26Speaker 2: Who uh gave the approbations for this? Well, first of
- 19:30Speaker 2: all it begins the first page of Vitil Inspector of
- 19:33Speaker 2: Coveno and some Sparta crabbis, and then you continue. It
- 19:37Speaker 2: took a while they were where is it? Have it here?
- 19:42Speaker 3: Ah?
- 19:43Speaker 2: The uh?
- 19:44Speaker 3: There are other husk.
- 19:49Speaker 2: You see of all these rabbis printed, because there was
- 19:53Speaker 2: a second edition, and among them you have here Remo Liver.
- 19:58Speaker 2: You see down here real health Deeseimer. So you did
- 20:03Speaker 2: have popularization of the tone. What have you have people
- 20:05Speaker 2: who believed that we should encourage the masses to learn
- 20:10Speaker 2: and make it easier for them, although these masses are
- 20:12Speaker 2: not even the bar masses, because at least they can
- 20:13Speaker 2: read Hebrew. However, there also was a different tradition. Let's
- 20:17Speaker 2: not forget what the Rombum says. The Rombum says in
- 20:21Speaker 2: the introduction of the Mission too, there is here here.
- 20:26Speaker 3: What does he say?
- 20:27Speaker 2: He says that when you when you study that when
- 20:32Speaker 2: he wrote this book, the Mission Tara, a person should
- 20:35Speaker 2: first study the original law, and then study this text,
- 20:37Speaker 2: the Mission Tara, and comprehend the entire or all firm
- 20:40Speaker 2: it without having to study any other text. So the
- 20:43Speaker 2: rom Bum tells you that for the typical person, you
- 20:47Speaker 2: won't need to study anything other than the Mission of
- 20:51Speaker 2: Tora and the Torah itself, Ummish, you don't need to
- 20:56Speaker 2: learn Gamara? So who needs to learn gamarra? Obviously the
- 20:59Speaker 2: rom bumming knowledges that to tell me Hami the big
- 21:03Speaker 2: people need to learn because any of the pasta Shai
- 21:05Speaker 2: was But the Rambum's already telling you that the average
- 21:08Speaker 2: person is not going to need to learn gamar And
- 21:09Speaker 2: now how this stims with what we're going to see
- 21:12Speaker 2: in the rambamb himself in a second, we'll see. Furthermore,
- 21:18Speaker 2: we know that Satahadrek tells you that before Mayor Biluffi
- 21:22Speaker 2: and Spain who started writing commentaries, they only study the
- 21:26Speaker 2: Riff And I say, only the average people to tell
- 21:29Speaker 2: me Jamim only studied the riff. Only the super people
- 21:32Speaker 2: would study otherwise, So we see this as a tradition.
- 21:34Speaker 2: And now I want to read you something from Vadiosa
- 21:38Speaker 2: appears in his response in the Cavadas, volume six, number
- 21:42Speaker 2: fifty two. It's actually summarized by his grandson. You can
- 21:45Speaker 2: just google this she or Daffiomi or Vadiosif. And here's
- 21:48Speaker 2: the question. If someone learns every day at dafiomi Shir,
- 21:52Speaker 2: does he fulfill his obligation of learning tone every day?
- 21:56Speaker 2: And he begins by citing the gamara, which we'll see
- 21:59Speaker 2: from the rambum in a minute, that everyone should split
- 22:01Speaker 2: their day into three, which is Mikra, Mishna and talmud
- 22:05Speaker 2: and the ram inside in the second. But then he
- 22:08Speaker 2: goes on to say that the the Ahronim doubt the
- 22:11Speaker 2: dealt with this, and he quotes the shop. You're not
- 22:17Speaker 2: gonna believe me, but here here it is. It's in
- 22:19Speaker 2: the shop and you're a day race memvov and it's
- 22:24Speaker 2: Simon hey. The shot quotes the drisha. He says, some
- 22:32Speaker 2: bala bats him every day learned Gamara rashu tosos the
- 22:36Speaker 2: low sharp post game. They don't warn any halasa, and
- 22:39Speaker 2: then he goes on they bring a proof for this.
- 22:41Speaker 2: Then if you learn halafa every day, move to the
- 22:43Speaker 2: b Olamhaba. And but then he goes on lee near
- 22:47Speaker 2: y Sifria post scheme Dina Taraka, Moharif and Wai rush
- 22:52Speaker 2: the ze Karatar, saying he says that we I think
- 22:55Speaker 2: you have to learn the halafas halfa far they call
- 23:00Speaker 2: believe in Gamara perishosis. He says, you don't fulfill the
- 23:03Speaker 2: midst of learning terror if you just learn Gamara Rashi
- 23:06Speaker 2: and tostiv Us, there's no practical hallafa thing there. And
- 23:09Speaker 2: therefore vad Yosef concludes, if if you're able to, you
- 23:15Speaker 2: should learn every day Daffyomi and also share in halaha.
- 23:19Speaker 2: But if you only have time for one share, oh, wellhalaka,
- 23:24Speaker 2: you shall learn halafa king. But if you only can
- 23:29Speaker 2: learn one, you should do halaha. Now it's obvious why
- 23:32Speaker 2: this won't work, because Hala for most people is dry
- 23:35Speaker 2: and and Daffioli has become a whole social experience and
- 23:39Speaker 2: it gives strength to Orthodoxy. But RACHAMAVADYOSIV says he doesn't
- 23:43Speaker 2: like it. He thinks that if you can only learn one.
- 23:45Speaker 2: Shear it should be halasa, because that's not for you
- 23:48Speaker 2: to learn tomorrow. If you only have one, you should
- 23:50Speaker 2: una if you have time for both. But obviously, like
- 23:52Speaker 2: you said, it doesn't work. And Daffyomi is able to
- 23:55Speaker 2: inspire people and give them something which Alaka couldn't, and
- 23:58Speaker 2: Uh in the lithuani Yeshiva world would not follow over
- 24:01Speaker 2: values approach. They obviously believe everyone who can should wear
- 24:04Speaker 2: in goamorrow.
- 24:05Speaker 3: What I.
- 24:07Speaker 2: Just want to conclude with though, well let me show
- 24:10Speaker 2: you the tomorrow so that you see what I'm talking
- 24:13Speaker 2: about here it's it's an amazing run bomb. Here he says,
- 24:17Speaker 2: as follows. So here the rum mom says a person,
- 24:21Speaker 2: this is from the gamar, can you shoot? You have
- 24:23Speaker 2: to divide your study time to three. One third should
- 24:25Speaker 2: be the written law, one third ural law, and one
- 24:27Speaker 2: third conceptualizing. So SoRs things like that, and drum says
- 24:32Speaker 2: in twelve, how is this express if you're a worker
- 24:35Speaker 2: three hours a day in work and nine hours a
- 24:37Speaker 2: day in tourist study. Many people have commented today we'd
- 24:40Speaker 2: be happy if people who are workers spend nine hours
- 24:44Speaker 2: working in three hours learning. But he says three so
- 24:47Speaker 2: you're supposed to spend three hours reading the written law,
- 24:49Speaker 2: three of the ural law and three of scars, et cetera.
- 24:54Speaker 2: And then later when you're advanced, you can really just
- 24:57Speaker 2: focus on gamorrow itself. You don't even need to spend
- 25:00Speaker 2: I'm really on the written to our regis occasionally. The
- 25:03Speaker 2: point is, though, that this is for people who are
- 25:05Speaker 2: already advanced. What I was speaking about was people who
- 25:09Speaker 2: never made it for whatever reason. So you do with
- 25:12Speaker 2: a fifty five year old and you'll have time to
- 25:14Speaker 2: learn an hour a day, what should you do? I
- 25:16Speaker 2: think in the Yeshiva world you should learn gamar, and
- 25:19Speaker 2: that's the American approach. But others have a different approach.
- 25:23Speaker 2: And I'll end with an example of this.
- 25:27Speaker 3: Here.
- 25:28Speaker 2: I have a little book here. This is a book
- 25:31Speaker 2: that it's an attack here published by smart types all
- 25:34Speaker 2: against art scroll popularization. And there's an article and also
- 25:38Speaker 2: on the journal or you, sirall, if you look in
- 25:41Speaker 2: volume fifty, there's an article there by a Rabbi MORTEHAILI Guerrillik.
- 25:45Speaker 2: He's rubed by garlk of yu Son, and he goes
- 25:48Speaker 2: off into how the whole idea of that the masses
- 25:51Speaker 2: are not supposed to learn. He says, in the earlier
- 25:54Speaker 2: years there was a fever for riff lere Mishnayas Gabran Yakov,
- 25:58Speaker 2: and that's what they should do. Even he says Daffi
- 26:00Speaker 2: only to have its time only agreed with it because
- 26:03Speaker 2: of the musculium and the reformers, And it was just
- 26:05Speaker 2: that the people would get a sense that Talmud is
- 26:08Speaker 2: so important, but not really that they should Rabehaian Rappaport
- 26:12Speaker 2: has a very long response to this, This idea of
- 26:14Speaker 2: this elitist idea to talmut is only for the elites.
- 26:18Speaker 2: So well even at that, But that's what I meant,
- 26:20Speaker 2: Mike when I said this idea had something that I
- 26:24Speaker 2: think it's clear that many people do share this idea
- 26:28Speaker 2: that Talmud study is not for the masses, that everyone
- 26:33Speaker 2: should enter. We hope that everyone becomes a tumultus or reality.
- 26:37Speaker 2: It's not going to happen in there. For what are
- 26:39Speaker 2: you supposed to do with your time? In the run bomb,
- 26:41Speaker 2: there is speaking about someone who's able to learn. But
- 26:44Speaker 2: if you're not able to learn, what's better to sit
- 26:46Speaker 2: with a or to sit with the You know, this
- 26:50Speaker 2: was unimaginable before our day because we didn't have English commerce.
- 26:53Speaker 2: So you have many people who are even the book
- 26:57Speaker 2: I showed you the Madrich, a bunch of Hungarians came
- 27:00Speaker 2: out opposing this popularization of the Talmud. But I have
- 27:04Speaker 2: to say that with all art, stroke can be supported
- 27:07Speaker 2: because if you look at the Godoli who gave the
- 27:09Speaker 2: Huskama to the bo Camadrich, you see that these were
- 27:12Speaker 2: the greatest of Lithoeni. You don't have the Hungarians there,
- 27:15Speaker 2: but you have the lifshore world, you have the started world,
- 27:18Speaker 2: and it's basically the first steinsold. So we I think
- 27:21Speaker 2: that's the mainstream tradition today. It doesn't take away from
- 27:24Speaker 2: the fact what I said, however, that I do think
- 27:26Speaker 2: that some of these stories in the Talmud, like were
- 27:28Speaker 2: never meant for everyone to sing. Remember the riff doesn't
- 27:35Speaker 2: have a gun ta, he only has a lot. Okay, everyone,
- 27:38Speaker 2: we'll get to the other thing next week. Let us continue.
- 27:45Speaker 2: I mean, move my books over here. I'm gonna show
- 27:52Speaker 2: you some great stuff today. Incidentally, I don't know if
- 27:59Speaker 2: any of you know this book. This is the work
- 28:03Speaker 2: of the Rumbum, at least we think it's the Rambum
- 28:05Speaker 2: and Rebi Retsabi has a commentary on it. He deals
- 28:09Speaker 2: with the names of God and Sukhim, and he thinks
- 28:12Speaker 2: that Bethel is a holy name. I wasn't able. I
- 28:17Speaker 2: was looking and looking find any explicit hector to erase
- 28:22Speaker 2: God's name. This goes back to last week when it's
- 28:24Speaker 2: written in transliteration that is a Hebrew name in English characters.
- 28:29Speaker 2: I'm thinking, maybe you could say Bethel. You don't have
- 28:31Speaker 2: in mind God's name, you haven't mind the synagogue. So
- 28:35Speaker 2: I guess maybe that's the hector. Thank you Barrie late
- 28:37Speaker 2: for sending me that the the author of the Kitzer
- 28:41Speaker 2: the he wrote a book Bushkasa Sofa. He does say
- 28:44Speaker 2: that you can't say all he can't write it, and
- 28:49Speaker 2: he quotes of Zieberstein. So unless you come over with
- 28:53Speaker 2: the hector that Bethel doesn't refer to God, it just
- 28:57Speaker 2: revers to the place. I think it's a problem, but
- 29:00Speaker 2: we'll leave that. We're in the middle of now where
- 29:03Speaker 2: I a couple of shorts. I introduced you to him
- 29:08Speaker 2: last class, and I want to now we're gonna deal
- 29:11Speaker 2: with something with Yako Kamenetski. Yakov Komenetsky. He really was
- 29:16Speaker 2: very unusual. He wasn't he was a Lithuanian roseshiva, U
- 29:21Speaker 2: a great roseshiva. But all you have to do is
- 29:24Speaker 2: look at his commentary on and Maslakov and you see
- 29:28Speaker 2: that he's not a typical uh Lithuania torrescat or the
- 29:32Speaker 2: stress on Dick Dook on Trump and everything like that.
- 29:35Speaker 2: In fact, let me show you something now that will
- 29:37Speaker 2: blow you away. I mentioned it in Limits of Orthodoxology.
- 29:41Speaker 2: But uh, for those who don't remember, don't uh, I'm
- 29:44Speaker 2: gonna show you something. He has this great, great commentary.
- 29:50Speaker 2: Just I'm just giving you as an example of one
- 29:53Speaker 2: example of how unusual he is. You will never find
- 29:56Speaker 2: anything like this in you know the uh Gadoli worried
- 30:00Speaker 2: about humish, certainly from Lithuanian world. The Pussak says in
- 30:04Speaker 2: uh perakhoff luff gimmel in vaikra It says you should
- 30:10Speaker 2: not go don't uh, don't follow the practices of the
- 30:15Speaker 2: non Jews and uh Rebe Kamenski points out that when
- 30:20Speaker 2: the Rambam cites this Pussok in the Missionatara, what does
- 30:23Speaker 2: he called for? Cited as hukos hog you not how go?
- 30:28Speaker 3: How go you?
- 30:30Speaker 2: So he goes on he discusses this and then he
- 30:32Speaker 2: comes to the end. Here he says that I'll just
- 30:36Speaker 2: read it to you the fourth half on I saw
- 30:40Speaker 2: in the addition of thea from which have the notes
- 30:44Speaker 2: from kiss te Kim and who put this together Huff Dollard, Ginsburg, London,
- 30:49Speaker 2: nineteen oh nine. We'll get back to this in a
- 30:50Speaker 2: second Shahevi Nuska.
- 30:52Speaker 3: He brought a.
- 30:54Speaker 2: Source in from the Samaritan Hummish that it does how
- 31:00Speaker 2: you and also combat Targooming, which seemed to have the
- 31:06Speaker 2: word how go you? Not how going? As the text
- 31:09Speaker 2: there the why should can't I accustom safer Rambam, And
- 31:12Speaker 2: he's saying, maybe the Rambam's text was different than our
- 31:16Speaker 2: Tara text and had the word go you, how go you?
- 31:20Speaker 2: Not hag you? That's pretty incredible to make that sort
- 31:24Speaker 2: of insight. What he's referring to is this book ramiche
- 31:29Speaker 2: kumche Tora. Here's the English title page were Latin by C. A. Ginsburg,
- 31:38Speaker 2: which has the different notes. Here's the the page we're
- 31:41Speaker 2: looking at. So in here it is plus twenty three.
- 31:46Speaker 2: You see, so if you go down to the bottom
- 31:50Speaker 2: in the note here verse twenty three, it says other
- 31:55Speaker 2: books have, How go you and what does he give
- 31:57Speaker 2: an example? Well, that's a manuscript. Then Kretschen is the
- 32:03Speaker 2: m and then this is the Sivim, the Seituagint and uncles.
- 32:10Speaker 2: This is a critical pentitude lower criticism, and Rabayaka of
- 32:14Speaker 2: Kamenetski is using it.
- 32:17Speaker 3: Not only is he using it, but uh, do you
- 32:20Speaker 3: know who C. D. Ginsburg is?
- 32:22Speaker 2: A second? I think I have where did I have it? Here? Around?
- 32:26Speaker 3: And and and he knew this as well too. Uh,
- 32:31Speaker 3: this is what I think.
- 32:34Speaker 2: Again, I D pushed you out a mistake here?
- 32:37Speaker 3: Who is C. D.
- 32:38Speaker 2: Ginsburg? His name is Christian David Ginsburg. He's an apostate
- 32:42Speaker 2: who was an experta. So here we have Ravaka of
- 32:46Speaker 2: Kamenetski offering that perhaps the Rombums version of the Torah
- 32:50Speaker 2: is different than ours, because because he cites the Pustle differently,
- 32:56Speaker 2: and maybe he had the version that's preserved in the Samaritan,
- 33:00Speaker 2: the Tuk and the different Targo meme. And had Dosranko
- 33:02Speaker 2: Fromski knows this. He knows this because he's using a tanach,
- 33:06Speaker 2: which is a critical tanah, you know, lower criticism, providing
- 33:10Speaker 2: alternate texts put together by a Mashulman named Christian David Ginsberg.
- 33:15Speaker 2: That is not the sort of thing that the typical
- 33:17Speaker 2: roast yeshiva is due. I do have to say, however,
- 33:20Speaker 2: that it's it's unfortunate that Rivyakov fell into this trap
- 33:27Speaker 2: here because the rumbumb doesn't have that at all. If
- 33:32Speaker 2: you look in the good rom bombs, which I guess
- 33:35Speaker 2: weren't around his day, for example, the the Mishnatura of
- 33:40Speaker 2: the Franco edition, you see that it's the same puss Hugoi.
- 33:44Speaker 2: It's not hog And that's all the different to the
- 33:48Speaker 2: important text of manuscripts. In fact, the famous one that
- 33:53Speaker 2: has the rahmbam. I'll show you right now his signature
- 33:55Speaker 2: at the end of it. The Oxford manuscript that also
- 33:57Speaker 2: has AGOI. So yes, we have texts that have am,
- 34:01Speaker 2: but that's not what it was before the rumba. Here here,
- 34:05Speaker 2: I have a beautiful volume here and you see it here.
- 34:08Speaker 2: This is it's a text. It's the This is the
- 34:11Speaker 2: text which has the rumbum. I'll show you his yeah,
- 34:17Speaker 2: hold it up.
- 34:17Speaker 3: For you.
- 34:24Speaker 2: Right right, Who got miss free on the motion? This
- 34:32Speaker 2: is a a reproduction of that's safer Mada and save
- 34:37Speaker 2: for Alva of the manuscript. The Ramam didn't write the manuscript,
- 34:41Speaker 2: but he says it came from it was copied from
- 34:45Speaker 2: his own manuscript. And that's we have more signatures than
- 34:48Speaker 2: the rumbum. But that's the that's the famous one. Okay.
- 34:57Speaker 2: So why do I mentioned this about Ryaka Kamenetski because
- 34:59Speaker 2: ri he says an amazing thing, which like how thet
- 35:04Speaker 2: he is going to deal with We have a puzzle
- 35:07Speaker 2: in devartment to our where we hear Deuteronomy chapter four,
- 35:16Speaker 2: verse nineteen. What do you make of this puzzle? Care
- 35:20Speaker 2: that says, and let's now lift up thine eyes into heaven,
- 35:23Speaker 2: and when you see the sun and the moon and
- 35:24Speaker 2: the stars, even all the hosts of heaven, you be
- 35:27Speaker 2: drawn away and worship them and serve them, which the
- 35:30Speaker 2: Lord thy God has allotted into all the people's under
- 35:33Speaker 2: the whole heaven. And he's gonna say, you can't do that.
- 35:35Speaker 2: What do you mean God has allotted unto all the
- 35:37Speaker 2: people that they should worship them. That means that they're
- 35:41Speaker 2: allowed to do this. What does it mean God gave
- 35:43Speaker 2: it to them? If you look in Rashi, Rashi explains, well,
- 35:49Speaker 2: God sort of gave it to them. They can make
- 35:51Speaker 2: a mistake on it and he doesn't care. They can
- 35:54Speaker 2: worship idolatry. But if you look in the Rashbomb and
- 35:56Speaker 2: other commentaries, what they seem to be saying is whereas
- 36:00Speaker 2: I have a rush bomb, I think here rush bomb,
- 36:07Speaker 2: what I uh here? If you look in nineteen sha
- 36:12Speaker 2: means well one that's the shot to light up I
- 36:16Speaker 2: guess no, no, no no, that's one version to that.
- 36:19Speaker 2: They gave him the sun to as they could see. Well,
- 36:22Speaker 2: if the ecrep shot, what's the mame shot? Rush Bomb says,
- 36:27Speaker 2: I mean loved on God gave them the stars and
- 36:29Speaker 2: the sun to worship, because he's not really that concerned
- 36:34Speaker 2: to what they worship. But not like in the Rashi
- 36:38Speaker 2: sense that it's negative. Here it seems that it's uh,
- 36:41Speaker 2: He's allowing them to worship. It's not a concern for
- 36:45Speaker 2: him and the the Xavoca Bobo uses this pussle to
- 36:50Speaker 2: prove that the concept of Sheeto that we spoke about
- 36:53Speaker 2: that as long as the nations recognize that there's some
- 36:56Speaker 2: higher power, they can use these intermediate forces. That's how
- 37:00Speaker 2: Xavakabola they justifies the idea of she took that we
- 37:03Speaker 2: spoke about that nanjows are allowed to the Pussic is
- 37:06Speaker 2: almost explicit on it. Rush Bomb's almost explicit on it.
- 37:09Speaker 2: Uh in what he's saying. So what does Reacha Kaminski
- 37:16Speaker 2: say If you look at his msli alcohol on persius
- 37:19Speaker 2: veskana this pus he says. He says, this follows he
- 37:25Speaker 2: thinks that there is a fundamental dispute about a jotasar
- 37:28Speaker 2: foreign worship. Now, according to the Rambam, it's it's all
- 37:33Speaker 2: nonsense idolatry. But according to ain't ba Mama, she car
- 37:38Speaker 2: they alkohakal they idol said that yourship the stars all
- 37:42Speaker 2: that they have no value and not when you worship them,
- 37:46Speaker 2: you're also wasting your time. But he says, the ramband
- 37:49Speaker 2: holds that God has put into the structure of the
- 37:52Speaker 2: world that every nation has a has like a a god.
- 37:58Speaker 2: It's not a god, a god with a small g
- 38:00Speaker 2: I don't know what you call it. A force, a power,
- 38:03Speaker 2: mush be a he calls it in the and that
- 38:06Speaker 2: has coohmass powers that could affect and benefit its nation.
- 38:13Speaker 2: That is, every nation worships certain gods, and those gods
- 38:16Speaker 2: have authority and can benefit them as long as it
- 38:19Speaker 2: doesn't refer to Israel, so what is but it's forbidden?
- 38:25Speaker 2: The issor of Lodizara is that the nations are forbidding
- 38:28Speaker 2: to worship these forces rather because their power comes from God.
- 38:35Speaker 2: So the nations have to worship God, and then the
- 38:38Speaker 2: powers will be given to these idols. But he says,
- 38:43Speaker 2: in o them. But if nevertheless, they don't worship God,
- 38:48Speaker 2: but they worship these powers, who is poly must be these?
- 38:54Speaker 3: If you worship let's say.
- 38:55Speaker 2: Zeus, not supposed to these social worship gods, and then
- 38:59Speaker 2: they don't go through Zeus. But if you do worship Zeus.
- 39:05Speaker 3: It will help you king. And he says this is
- 39:08Speaker 3: the meaning of the puss that God.
- 39:15Speaker 2: Must be and then he quotes a Pussic in chaf
- 39:18Speaker 2: Team where as a proof for this, here's the pus
- 39:24Speaker 2: Key quotes, where is it your cheft? This is a
- 39:30Speaker 2: Pussic in chapter eleven where uh Gift our own is
- 39:37Speaker 2: making war against them. So Gift sends to uh them,
- 39:43Speaker 2: don't you know, don't make war with us? What would
- 39:45Speaker 2: happen to all the other nations? And he's telling the
- 39:48Speaker 2: story and in in pussa huff doll it he says,
- 39:55Speaker 2: will doubt not possess you. Know, as he's saying, keep
- 39:59Speaker 2: to yourself. You don't know to worry about uh going
- 40:01Speaker 2: to war against us. Willout not possess that which Ramosh
- 40:04Speaker 2: thy God giveth thee to possess you. Now it's keep
- 40:09Speaker 2: what you have, whatever your God gave you, and anyone
- 40:14Speaker 2: who fights with us will destroy them, et cetera. Soakov says,
- 40:19Speaker 2: although the Raal Balgan that interprets this as derek halag
- 40:22Speaker 2: like it's a mocking thing. It's like they say, you know,
- 40:25Speaker 2: you're God, but not a real god, but a phony god.
- 40:29Speaker 2: But Rivakov says, according to the view of the Ramban
- 40:32Speaker 2: lo Isa coven Us.
- 40:36Speaker 3: Hella coven Us, so he wasn't mocking them. He was
- 40:40Speaker 3: saying the shot.
- 40:46Speaker 2: Mash that that your God uh Kamosh does have the
- 40:53Speaker 2: power to uh help you and give you things in
- 41:01Speaker 2: all the tins, et cetera, et cetera. The point being,
- 41:05Speaker 2: Rizakov holes that the world is created in such a
- 41:08Speaker 2: way that there are these forces out there that are
- 41:12Speaker 2: connected to the different nations, and the nations are benefited
- 41:18Speaker 2: through these forces through God, that is, the God provides
- 41:23Speaker 2: these powers with their ability and Therefore, the benefit of
- 41:29Speaker 2: the nations goes through these powers, but the benefit of
- 41:32Speaker 2: the Jews comes directly from Russiam. However, the powers already
- 41:36Speaker 2: exist there there, and if the nations choose to short
- 41:39Speaker 2: circuit and not worship God, go directly to the intermediaries
- 41:45Speaker 2: or the the the underlings. They have powers. Just like
- 41:48Speaker 2: if a king, there's a there's princes or dukes. You
- 41:51Speaker 2: can go directly to the duke. Maybe the duke has
- 41:54Speaker 2: independent power. Rivyakov says, I know this might strike some
- 41:58Speaker 2: of you as even blasphemy, but he says that these
- 42:01Speaker 2: and he says, this is the shot of the Ramban,
- 42:03Speaker 2: that these forces that are created by God have independent
- 42:07Speaker 2: ability to respond. It's built into nature that although it's
- 42:13Speaker 2: a sin to approach them without going to God, if
- 42:15Speaker 2: you do, it'll work. It's no different than like a
- 42:20Speaker 2: magnet or something that God created the magnetism. But you
- 42:24Speaker 2: can do the magnet on your own, or you can
- 42:26Speaker 2: light fire on your own. And this is part of
- 42:28Speaker 2: the structure of the world. Just like we have free will,
- 42:31Speaker 2: these powers can act, et cetera. That's what he says.
- 42:36Speaker 2: I first heard this concept when I was in high
- 42:39Speaker 2: school in tenth grade and a teacher Riiseman.
- 42:43Speaker 1: And.
- 42:44Speaker 2: Since it's passed away, I don't know if he's related
- 42:46Speaker 2: to the rise the famous Raby Risemon. And I remember
- 42:49Speaker 2: in class him saying once that you couldn't why did
- 42:53Speaker 2: all these nations out there worship these idols if they
- 42:57Speaker 2: didn't get anything from it? So he said that he
- 43:00Speaker 2: thinks that there must have been something. There must have
- 43:03Speaker 2: been something in nature that by worshiping the idols something
- 43:07Speaker 2: there was some return by definition built in no different
- 43:12Speaker 2: than like if you eid a matchine the lights up
- 43:14Speaker 2: the fire. So too that if you worship the idols
- 43:17Speaker 2: that they had this authority, you shouldn't do it, but
- 43:19Speaker 2: if you do it, it it exists. And I remember thinking,
- 43:22Speaker 2: this is the craziest thing. This is the Rambuan would
- 43:25Speaker 2: say this is complete heresy, but that's what he said.
- 43:27Speaker 2: And then I find I don't know if he was
- 43:29Speaker 2: a Termads person, but Ravyakov says the exact same thing.
- 43:34Speaker 2: And that's what this letter is about, because I had
- 43:38Speaker 2: sent Rabahai Rappaport wrote a piece about this. How it
- 43:45Speaker 2: really what he's saying, what Yakov is saying, it's not
- 43:47Speaker 2: what it's not in the Ramban on the surface it seems,
- 43:51Speaker 2: but it's really not there. And Rabbi Schwartz agrees that
- 43:58Speaker 2: Rubbert Upward's correct. Not is this not found in the Rumban,
- 44:01Speaker 2: but the Rumban in another place explicitly speaks differently. He
- 44:05Speaker 2: quotes the Rumban in Yusro, where the Rumban says that
- 44:09Speaker 2: the nation's hush food. They thought that the gods, yesham
- 44:14Speaker 2: Nihois like Teva, they thought this, but it's not true.
- 44:18Speaker 2: They never had this ability. So it's a fundamental dispute
- 44:22Speaker 2: between Rabbi Schwartz. Although Rabbi Kamenevsky is reading the Ramban
- 44:26Speaker 2: this way, which is very difficult to read because the
- 44:28Speaker 2: Ramban is and any. He sits another plussic where the
- 44:30Speaker 2: Ramban Mishbuting says that they thought this. They thought that
- 44:34Speaker 2: the the the the gods with the small gi had
- 44:38Speaker 2: this power. But that's so, I don't know what you do.
- 44:41Speaker 2: So let's say you show to your satisfaction that the
- 44:44Speaker 2: Rumban doesn't say it, but does Rizakov still thought it.
- 44:48Speaker 3: So even if he's.
- 44:48Speaker 2: Wrong about the Rumban, he still thought that this was
- 44:51Speaker 2: a kosher opinion. Maybe the Ramban never said it, but
- 44:54Speaker 2: he thought this is a kosher opinion to explain the
- 44:57Speaker 2: way the world functions, that there's forces, and really, when
- 45:00Speaker 2: you think about it, I don't. I don't have the
- 45:01Speaker 2: reaction to here when I was in high school. What
- 45:03Speaker 2: if you believe in demons. Let's say the people believe
- 45:05Speaker 2: in demons or astrology. They believe that these were created,
- 45:09Speaker 2: these things or demons. Let's say we're created, but then
- 45:12Speaker 2: they have powers. You have all these traditions about angels rebelling. Fine,
- 45:17Speaker 2: the ron mom sees this as superstitions, but you have
- 45:20Speaker 2: it in sources. It doesn't take away from God, from monotheism.
- 45:23Speaker 2: It doesn't take because God is still the ultimate authority.
- 45:26Speaker 2: But just like humans can go around and kill people,
- 45:29Speaker 2: they are free will and they are created, so too,
- 45:31Speaker 2: God created forces that if people choose to go to them,
- 45:36Speaker 2: they're sinning. But the forces at power, just like you
- 45:38Speaker 2: can go to an evil person and ask you to
- 45:40Speaker 2: hire and to go kill someone. So Ravakov believes the Ramban.
- 45:44Speaker 3: I don't.
- 45:44Speaker 2: Vakov personally believes that he believes the Ramban held that
- 45:47Speaker 2: not just in this world is their free will that
- 45:49Speaker 2: goes against God. That even in the opera worlds you
- 45:53Speaker 2: have this, and raus Schwartz thinks absolutely not. But the
- 45:57Speaker 2: very interesting position of of of Dako Kamenetsky, Well, there's
- 46:04Speaker 2: been a lot written on the Ramban, his view of
- 46:08Speaker 2: the Scapegoat and what he has. He has some passages
- 46:11Speaker 2: there that it's really it comes very close to like
- 46:15Speaker 2: a sort of alternate powers. This has been written about
- 46:20Speaker 2: who someone recently wrote an article on this and on
- 46:26Speaker 2: the the the other powers in the in the Ramban.
- 46:32Speaker 2: It's very it's very cabitalistic. It's if you're not into that,
- 46:36Speaker 2: it's it strikes you as as dualistic, almost almost idolatrous even,
- 46:41Speaker 2: but you have to understand it's a different perspective of
- 46:45Speaker 2: the universe than we're usually taught in ours. When you
- 46:50Speaker 2: send out the scapegoat, what are you sending it for?
- 46:52Speaker 2: Where where you sending it? To the idea you have
- 46:55Speaker 2: these ideas that there's some sort of other like power
- 46:57Speaker 2: in the desert sort of thing. I don't need to
- 47:00Speaker 2: into that. I'm going to skip number one seventeen in
- 47:04Speaker 2: the in the Safer that just deals with an issue
- 47:08Speaker 2: I asked them about. I was wrong. I misinterpreted something
- 47:12Speaker 2: that the Hassam Sofer said, so he corrected me and
- 47:16Speaker 2: the Rambo. But I want to get to now number
- 47:18Speaker 2: one eighteen, which is on page two forty five, and
- 47:23Speaker 2: this is Rabbi Rappaport. Back to Rabbi Rapaport now, and
- 47:27Speaker 2: I need to give an introduction here. The title of
- 47:30Speaker 2: this is what is the words referring to secular knowledge? Me,
- 47:36Speaker 2: what's he talking about? Well, the Rumbum wrote a letter
- 47:40Speaker 2: to the scholars of Southern France. The scholars of Southern
- 47:44Speaker 2: France a page up here. We're basically sympathetic to the
- 47:51Speaker 2: rumbumb to the study philosophy, most of them, but not
- 47:54Speaker 2: all of them. And they didn't they didn't have I mean,
- 47:58Speaker 2: some like the me Erie, were more than others. We
- 48:00Speaker 2: spoke about the Rabbino Yona, although he was he studied
- 48:04Speaker 2: under an unusual person who was really the great opponent of.
- 48:08Speaker 1: The rum Bum.
- 48:09Speaker 2: But they were not many of them were not totally
- 48:13Speaker 2: on board with even if they were sympathetic philosophy to
- 48:16Speaker 2: everything the rum Bub stood for. And he wrote a
- 48:21Speaker 2: series of letters. See he responds that he explained certain
- 48:24Speaker 2: problematic elements in the mission of Tara that they had
- 48:27Speaker 2: asked him about and he wrote a very long letter
- 48:31Speaker 2: to the scholars, and the premier scholar was Jonathan of Unel.
- 48:37Speaker 2: Just last year by Charles Sheer translated this. He calls
- 48:41Speaker 2: it the Grand Epistle to the Scholars of Unel, where
- 48:44Speaker 2: the rumbumb before getting into the the objections that they had,
- 48:49Speaker 2: the alt of objections, well, there wasn't so much objections
- 48:53Speaker 2: often as explaining what the Ramba meant. He has this
- 48:57Speaker 2: very long letter in which very malitsa poetic and in
- 49:02Speaker 2: this letter, among other things, he says as follows, I
- 49:08Speaker 2: believe I pulled it up here the original, So yeah,
- 49:16Speaker 2: maybe maybe I didn't. Well, I'll tell you, yeah, I
- 49:21Speaker 2: don't think I made the hold it up. Okay, I'll
- 49:24Speaker 2: tell you what he says. D Rumbum says, calls us out.
- 49:27Speaker 2: D Rumbum says that he studied all the secular studies
- 49:31Speaker 2: he did were like catabajot O folks were perfumers and
- 49:38Speaker 2: uh cooks and and bakers. And he says that these
- 49:45Speaker 2: were not they're they're not the essential My essential thing
- 49:48Speaker 2: is Torah. These are sort of like the secondary things,
- 49:51Speaker 2: and they make tower look good in the eyes of
- 49:52Speaker 2: the nations. He's downplaying the significance of secular studies as
- 49:58Speaker 2: the secondary. Actually, this would be what we would say
- 50:02Speaker 2: in Toromanta probably or maybe some forms of Toromanta. Actually
- 50:08Speaker 2: I don't know and not not not Norman Lambs, Toromano,
- 50:11Speaker 2: others so others Uma. But that's the problem is which
- 50:15Speaker 2: I raised, is that if you look in the mission
- 50:21Speaker 2: of Torah, and you look in the Morenauchi, these secular studies,
- 50:26Speaker 2: at least some of the secure studies science, philosophy, metaphysics, physics. Uh,
- 50:31Speaker 2: these are not secondary things. These are essential. We've spoken
- 50:35Speaker 2: about this already essential for Tonra's study. You can't fulfill
- 50:39Speaker 2: the midst of if you don't know science.
- 50:43Speaker 3: This is basic.
- 50:43Speaker 2: Look in hil Is Sodia Toner the first four chapters.
- 50:47Speaker 2: And that's not my submarracis my sco my subracis. That's
- 50:51Speaker 2: the big thing, he says, Uh, the little things really
- 50:54Speaker 2: is the other forms of tom was starting the thing
- 50:56Speaker 2: we do every day, daffi only.
- 50:57Speaker 3: But philosophy is higher.
- 51:00Speaker 2: How could the Rambams say in writing to them, the
- 51:03Speaker 2: secular studies it's sort of like a side interest of him.
- 51:06Speaker 2: It doesn't define him. So what Professor Torski and his
- 51:11Speaker 2: introduction to the Codamimonodes. He says, what the Raman's referring
- 51:14Speaker 2: to there is not metaphysics, physics, chemistry, that sort of
- 51:18Speaker 2: thing that helps us understand the world. He's referring to,
- 51:20Speaker 2: let's say logic and mathematics. Maybe, but I don't seem
- 51:24Speaker 2: the language in the rombamb My argument, and I wrote this,
- 51:27Speaker 2: and this is what right Reports responding to, is that
- 51:30Speaker 2: I think the Rambam's letter is written with an eye
- 51:33Speaker 2: towards who's receiving it. That although the people in that
- 51:37Speaker 2: he's writing to were sympathetic to the study of philosophy,
- 51:41Speaker 2: but only as like a secondary thing. They were were
- 51:45Speaker 2: open minded people who believe that when you reach a
- 51:49Speaker 2: certain age, even the Rushbah, the band against the study
- 51:53Speaker 2: of philosophy, was like under twenty five, when you reach
- 51:55Speaker 2: a certain age, you can study it. But they didn't.
- 51:57Speaker 2: They didn't buy into the romans whole idea that my
- 52:00Speaker 2: Rati's and Lisa Markova is the Secrets of the Tonra
- 52:03Speaker 2: I mean is for his science, physics and metaphysics. So
- 52:07Speaker 2: I think the Rahmbam's letter and I have an article
- 52:10Speaker 2: which I give a number of examples in which the
- 52:13Speaker 2: Rambam writes things that seem to appeal to certain people,
- 52:18Speaker 2: they're not necessarily affecting his his inner feelings. So I wrote,
- 52:23Speaker 2: Report is responding to me, and he says that, well'sk
- 52:32Speaker 2: at the beginning of it. What he what he says
- 52:34Speaker 2: basically is that.
- 52:37Speaker 3: He says that.
- 52:39Speaker 2: I call He says, you called this a munajrat a
- 52:42Speaker 2: necessary belief and not a true belief for the Rombum.
- 52:46Speaker 2: And he says, I don't think that's the case. He says,
- 52:50Speaker 2: What I think is the case is that the Rumbum
- 52:53Speaker 2: is writing the FDA in accordance to the opinion of
- 52:59Speaker 2: the people who is writing to. And as the point is,
- 53:02Speaker 2: though I said that exact same thing, I don't know
- 53:04Speaker 2: where Robert Report got this. I sent them an essay
- 53:06Speaker 2: of mine to read. What I did is I have
- 53:08Speaker 2: a whole article like it's send to anyone where I
- 53:10Speaker 2: speak about the idea of necessary beliefs in the rom Bum.
- 53:13Speaker 2: The Rambum says that there's a concept of necessary beliefs
- 53:16Speaker 2: versus true beliefs. A necessary belief is what you want
- 53:18Speaker 2: people to believe, even if it's not true, but it
- 53:21Speaker 2: has certain value. Religious value, political value. The Rumum thinks
- 53:25Speaker 2: the tower itself has necessary beliefs. The Rumbum speaks that
- 53:28Speaker 2: says that the tower speaks of God being angry, and
- 53:32Speaker 2: he says it's important for the masses to believe that
- 53:34Speaker 2: God really gets angry, even though God doesn't have emotions
- 53:38Speaker 2: that the intellectuals understand. When it says God gets angry,
- 53:41Speaker 2: it doesn't mean it in a literal sense. But the masses,
- 53:45Speaker 2: the ram Mom says, before they are supposed to take
- 53:47Speaker 2: it literally. Later, if they can, they'll be able to
- 53:50Speaker 2: expand themselves and understand that it's not really literal. But
- 53:54Speaker 2: God responds in a way that you would think he
- 53:57Speaker 2: has anger, because humans would respond that way if they
- 54:00Speaker 2: had anger, you know, they destroy a city or something
- 54:02Speaker 2: like that.
- 54:03Speaker 3: And the.
- 54:05Speaker 2: There's a whole of type of analysis the Rombum that
- 54:10Speaker 2: focuses on necessary beliefs, because the rom Bum sometimes writes
- 54:13Speaker 2: things and elsewhere writes things differently, So why was he
- 54:17Speaker 2: writing it one way and writing in some of his
- 54:19Speaker 2: letters he says things that he says differently in the
- 54:21Speaker 2: Morn and the ram Moum hints in a number of
- 54:24Speaker 2: places that what he says is the necessary belief. That is,
- 54:26Speaker 2: it's not as true belief. It's not the belief for
- 54:28Speaker 2: the intellectuals, it's the belief for the masses. And the
- 54:31Speaker 2: rur Mom tells us that the masses are not supposed
- 54:33Speaker 2: to be let into the true beliefs. That he tells
- 54:36Speaker 2: us explicitly in the moreno Vouchim that there are certain
- 54:39Speaker 2: things that the masses can't be given the truth that
- 54:41Speaker 2: by definition that means that they're being given something which
- 54:45Speaker 2: is what we call it necessary truth, that it's necessary
- 54:48Speaker 2: for them to believe it, but it's not really the truth.
- 54:52Speaker 2: And in discussing this concept in the rom Bumb I
- 54:55Speaker 2: gave other examples where the rombumb expresses himself in a
- 54:58Speaker 2: way that doesn't really reflects his true view. I'm calling
- 55:02Speaker 2: a necessary belief, because a necessary belief is a belief
- 55:04Speaker 2: that people, let's say, the masses are really supposed to
- 55:07Speaker 2: believe until they're able to move beyond that. He wasn't
- 55:11Speaker 2: writing to the scholars of France and saying that they're
- 55:14Speaker 2: supposed to believe this. He wasn't trying to indoctrinate them
- 55:17Speaker 2: like in other places will try to indoctrinate the masses
- 55:19Speaker 2: in certain ideas, because he feels without this, they won't
- 55:22Speaker 2: be able to stay on the proper path.
- 55:24Speaker 3: I think rabbis today do the same thing.
- 55:26Speaker 2: Rabbis will speak very differently from the pulpit than they
- 55:29Speaker 2: will in private groups. There are certain things you don't
- 55:32Speaker 2: want to say publicly, because raf Cook himself says Raff
- 55:35Speaker 2: Cook says that you shouldn't say something publicly, even if
- 55:38Speaker 2: you know it's true, if it will negatively affect the
- 55:41Speaker 2: faith of someone, that someone's not sophisticated, they can't understand
- 55:44Speaker 2: about evolution power, he says, don't speak about it. So
- 55:48Speaker 2: for that person, you give them a certain truth. In Buddhism,
- 55:53Speaker 2: this is called necessary means. That is, the simple people,
- 55:58Speaker 2: you need to teach them a certain way that they
- 56:00Speaker 2: can appreciate.
- 56:01Speaker 3: The intellectuals, you do.
- 56:03Speaker 2: It in a different way. This this parallel, and we
- 56:06Speaker 2: have that's the exact parallel with the rob is doing
- 56:09Speaker 2: necessary means. We teach our children differently than we treat
- 56:12Speaker 2: that teach adults. So what I was saying is that
- 56:15Speaker 2: when he wrote to the scholars of France, because they
- 56:17Speaker 2: are not thought, they're not philosophally in calling the way
- 56:20Speaker 2: he is. He writes a certain way. In another article
- 56:24Speaker 2: I post, as I point out Cook Roff Cook is right.
- 56:27Speaker 2: He has this letter where he writes to the leaders
- 56:29Speaker 2: of to try to explain why he's why he supports us, say,
- 56:35Speaker 2: the settlement of the irreligious, and we all know off
- 56:37Speaker 2: Cook's opinion. Of Cook's opinion is that the eureligious have
- 56:40Speaker 2: much to gain, have benefit us, and that they provide
- 56:44Speaker 2: the physicality and we're the spirituality, but they're they're also
- 56:47Speaker 2: vital for the creation of the rebuilding of this new land,
- 56:50Speaker 2: et cetera, et cetera. And that they are going to
- 56:53Speaker 2: teach the religious about strength because we the religious, have
- 56:56Speaker 2: forgotten what it means to have strong bodies and we
- 57:00Speaker 2: only have the spirituality, but the irreligious have the physicality.
- 57:03Speaker 2: So we're gonna give them spirituality, They're going to give
- 57:05Speaker 2: the physicality. This a whole dialectic, it's basic, drific What
- 57:08Speaker 2: does he do when he writes to the rabbis that
- 57:10Speaker 2: he says, we need to encourage he's irreligious because they're
- 57:13Speaker 2: the ones who can build the roads, and they're the
- 57:15Speaker 2: ones who can, you know, build things, because that's what
- 57:19Speaker 2: they do. And without any relevance to the theological significance
- 57:24Speaker 2: that he sees in the irreligious. So I think the
- 57:26Speaker 2: same with the rumbum that he writes to the scholars
- 57:30Speaker 2: of France. He's saying to them that in words they
- 57:33Speaker 2: can understand. And that's exactly where the rabbitport says. So
- 57:36Speaker 2: if he does a show only and he goes on,
- 57:39Speaker 2: he says, we find in other places Shathilgdolistro, even great
- 57:43Speaker 2: rabbis didn't attempt to convince the recipient of a letter
- 57:48Speaker 2: what they were saying. Rather, a shoemol hamofi mal rather
- 57:52Speaker 2: wrote to them in accordance to with how they their perspective.
- 57:56Speaker 2: And he said, by report says, and he's correct that
- 57:58Speaker 2: this has not do with necessary beliefs. And and he says,
- 58:07Speaker 2: because what that means that the rambo thought he could
- 58:09Speaker 2: uh convince them of it, that he would try to
- 58:12Speaker 2: convince them and they he wouldn't have any reason to
- 58:15Speaker 2: keep them in their their their beliefs. But that's not
- 58:20Speaker 2: that that's not what it means at all. Uh. And
- 58:23Speaker 2: I point out in the note that this is exactly
- 58:26Speaker 2: what I said in my article. I pointed out the
- 58:29Speaker 2: same thing. And my rapport must not have seen the
- 58:31Speaker 2: final edition of my article. But the concept is the same,
- 58:36Speaker 2: that they're not everything great rabbi is right, reflects their
- 58:41Speaker 2: true opinion all the time. I know this is radical
- 58:43Speaker 2: maybe for some people. One with this that you often
- 58:46Speaker 2: find great rabbi saying things that are are for the audience,
- 58:51Speaker 2: or that they contradict themselves. They're in a certain circumstance,
- 58:57Speaker 2: they'll respond a certain way. You have stories, robs Acheck,
- 59:00Speaker 2: he responded different ways to different people. Well, some people,
- 59:05Speaker 2: some people are not ready for a certain SoC Let's say,
- 59:08Speaker 2: let's speak in terms of holakau. Some people whereby salivate
- 59:11Speaker 2: chiku in nefasherav or chefter quote. I think it's afterever.
- 59:14Speaker 2: The next one quotes him as saying, in those days
- 59:16Speaker 2: are solvation. You see kraft cheese. And he held that
- 59:21Speaker 2: the vinasakum, there's no issue. It's a vegetarian. But if
- 59:24Speaker 2: Salik told the Yeshiva students the Snagel students, don't tell
- 59:27Speaker 2: your Ballabat team that this is permissible, because the Ballabat
- 59:30Speaker 2: team it's alchave mowering king. That's a principle that not
- 59:34Speaker 2: everything you should be made public for everyone. So you
- 59:37Speaker 2: respond differently to different people. That's that's sort of like
- 59:40Speaker 2: a uh, the rabbi is listening to me. I probably say, well,
- 59:43Speaker 2: I'll duh. Of course we know we can't say everything
- 59:46Speaker 2: the same thing instead of saying everyone. But it's sometimes
- 59:50Speaker 2: problematic when you see people writing in letters. I saw
- 59:53Speaker 2: of Weinberg. He writes one way to someone from the
- 59:56Speaker 2: Ayeshiva world in a different way, not necessarily always a
- 59:59Speaker 2: kind tradiction, but just the different stress. So when he
- 1:00:02Speaker 2: writes to someone in the Yeshiba world, he'll talk about
- 1:00:05Speaker 2: the problems that the state of Israel, you know, the
- 1:00:08Speaker 2: Secui re Zionists, and he just had that. You think
- 1:00:12Speaker 2: he's an a gouddiest. But then you see him ryan
- 1:00:14Speaker 2: to a Msraki person about in the state of Israel
- 1:00:16Speaker 2: is the greatest gift given to us from God? It
- 1:00:18Speaker 2: is it a contradiction now, But when he's writing to
- 1:00:22Speaker 2: one person, so where does his heart really lay. Maybe
- 1:00:25Speaker 2: it's the a gouddist or maybe with the Masraki that's
- 1:00:27Speaker 2: what I read about in the book. But this is
- 1:00:29Speaker 2: you see this with the Rambam. Also, lat says it,
- 1:00:33Speaker 2: anyone who studied the Rambam knows that you have different
- 1:00:36Speaker 2: stresses and sometimes even perhaps contradictions. So with this will
- 1:00:41Speaker 2: end what we're going to pick up next class. We're
- 1:00:45Speaker 2: going to go to the ballatonia. Wait, do you see
- 1:00:47Speaker 2: what the balatonia says totally in opposition to what the
- 1:00:51Speaker 2: Hasidium at least many Hasidim will hold today. Then we'll
- 1:00:56Speaker 2: get into what I thought we might get to the
- 1:01:01Speaker 2: very troubling passage with the tour, and if we get
- 1:01:03Speaker 2: to it next pass we'll get into a little bit
- 1:01:06Speaker 2: of a batte din appeals courts whatever, Well, where do
- 1:01:10Speaker 2: we have our lawyers here? You're often told in Yeshiva
- 1:01:13Speaker 2: that this whole conception of appeals courts and the Israel
- 1:01:17Speaker 2: bote did system is taken from secular because tour doesn't
- 1:01:22Speaker 2: know about appeals courts. And so we'll hear what was
- 1:01:25Speaker 2: going on in Prague?
- 1:01:26Speaker 3: And what's.
- 1:01:29Speaker 2: Let me get the question, is now time really flies?
- 1:01:32Speaker 2: Let me see we have a nice big crowd tonight
- 1:01:36Speaker 2: over sixty, Thank you all for coming. iPad says in
- 1:01:42Speaker 2: pre war the pre war army may not have been perfect,
- 1:01:46Speaker 2: but it was not an army of a state till
- 1:01:47Speaker 2: after independence, an underground organization. Most of fighting Arab size
- 1:01:51Speaker 2: or former armor is often trained by the British. Yeah,
- 1:01:54Speaker 2: but in May already have forty eight. You have the
- 1:01:56Speaker 2: idea as along with I have to say with irregular
- 1:02:00Speaker 2: because it took a while to get Lachi and they
- 1:02:02Speaker 2: are good and joint into it. But we do have
- 1:02:04Speaker 2: I am not going to deny it. There were some
- 1:02:06Speaker 2: incidents where there were human rights violations, there were killings,
- 1:02:10Speaker 2: there were rapes that happens, happens in every war, and
- 1:02:13Speaker 2: it happened in the idea of it happened in nineteen
- 1:02:16Speaker 2: forty eight. Much more, I don't know of any cases
- 1:02:19Speaker 2: like this where in sixty seven or the other wars
- 1:02:24Speaker 2: they weren't really you know Ebanon. I don't know if
- 1:02:27Speaker 2: cases like this. In nineteen forty eight. There was a
- 1:02:30Speaker 2: lot of chaos, and unfortunately you had terrible things happen.
- 1:02:34Speaker 2: The things that were not were supposed to be above that,
- 1:02:36Speaker 2: but it was a difficult circumstance. There was a lot
- 1:02:40Speaker 2: of hatred and not justifying it. And some of these
- 1:02:43Speaker 2: people were men of volume and were selling who did
- 1:02:45Speaker 2: these sort of things. Some of these if you read
- 1:02:47Speaker 2: some of these people, these were founders of State of Israel.
- 1:02:50Speaker 2: They had no Jewish values. There had no helpe. I'm
- 1:02:53Speaker 2: not sounding like an anti Zionist, but they had no
- 1:02:55Speaker 2: Terra values. Toror was the furthest thing. They had no
- 1:02:58Speaker 2: Jewish values. They for the many of them human life,
- 1:03:02Speaker 2: I mean some of them even in the underground a
- 1:03:06Speaker 2: civil war. They could have imagined a civil war they
- 1:03:08Speaker 2: you had in the underground. Some killed Jews who they
- 1:03:11Speaker 2: thought were collaborators. There's no question that members of the
- 1:03:14Speaker 2: underground not Bigan, because by the time he got involved
- 1:03:17Speaker 2: with it, mostly things were kept were carefully and they
- 1:03:22Speaker 2: weren't throwing bombs just into crowded markets or things like that.
- 1:03:27Speaker 2: The King David Hotel was a military target, and as
- 1:03:31Speaker 2: long as you assumed that military targets are valid, it's
- 1:03:34Speaker 2: a valid target. They even called and they they they
- 1:03:38Speaker 2: warned them to leave. They're true their work cases where
- 1:03:42Speaker 2: they are good and killed British soldiers that they had
- 1:03:44Speaker 2: kidnapped in response to the execution of Jews who were captured,
- 1:03:50Speaker 2: and they warned them, if you're gonna kill these, we're
- 1:03:51Speaker 2: going to kill yours again. Today I think we'd have
- 1:03:54Speaker 2: a problem with that, but that's and I don't know
- 1:03:56Speaker 2: if that's immoral in wartime as part of response. But
- 1:04:00Speaker 2: I but my whole point is I don't think we
- 1:04:02Speaker 2: need we don't need to defend if someone in forty
- 1:04:05Speaker 2: eight did a terrible thing, he did a terrible thing
- 1:04:07Speaker 2: to simpose that, but that doesn't We've never advocated this,
- 1:04:11Speaker 2: and we don't glorify this, and we don't think this
- 1:04:13Speaker 2: is a great thing. We don't build monuments for people
- 1:04:15Speaker 2: who do things like this, and we don't cheer when
- 1:04:17Speaker 2: we see this. In fact, we're embarrassed if we'd find
- 1:04:19Speaker 2: out something like that happened. And so they all that
- 1:04:23Speaker 2: talk about this and that it doesn't a terrible thing
- 1:04:25Speaker 2: that this person did that person, that it doesn't destroy
- 1:04:28Speaker 2: the it doesn't really uproot the Zionist idea. One thing
- 1:04:32Speaker 2: is going to do with the other. And really, if
- 1:04:33Speaker 2: Israel wanted to act, they could have killed them all.
- 1:04:36Speaker 2: They could have uprooted them all. And so these are
- 1:04:39Speaker 2: sort of exceptions. That's my feeling. Small You're good left.
- 1:04:44Speaker 2: The stern Gang actually stern gang. They don't like the
- 1:04:46Speaker 2: words stern Gang, stern group. Stern Gang is a negative.
- 1:04:50Speaker 2: You can call them terrorists. But they were also formed
- 1:04:52Speaker 2: because the British failed to protect Jews in their territories
- 1:04:54Speaker 2: as they were supposed to. That's really the Hagan Nah
- 1:04:57Speaker 2: you're good and is stern gang. They were about getting
- 1:05:03Speaker 2: rid of the British. That was enemy number one, imperialism.
- 1:05:07Speaker 2: And I have to say not that you're good. During
- 1:05:09Speaker 2: World War two, they are good.
- 1:05:10Speaker 3: Stop the war.
- 1:05:11Speaker 2: They say, the most important thing now is not the
- 1:05:13Speaker 2: war against the British, it's the war against the Nazis.
- 1:05:16Speaker 2: And they believed in joining together. Lehchi refused to call
- 1:05:18Speaker 2: off the war. Lechi sent people into be Route to
- 1:05:21Speaker 2: meet with the Nazis. Lechi was willing to ally themselves
- 1:05:25Speaker 2: with the Nazis to fight the British. And after the war,
- 1:05:29Speaker 2: Lehchi became pro Soviet, not pro American, pro Soviet because
- 1:05:35Speaker 2: they thought that Soviets would Now there were people like
- 1:05:38Speaker 2: uh Cohen who who didn't have this perspective, but El
- 1:05:42Speaker 2: Dodd and Yell and these were all in the Soviet camp.
- 1:05:45Speaker 2: So I shed noh, I have none. There's no soft
- 1:05:48Speaker 2: spot in me for Lehi. You're good is different though
- 1:05:52Speaker 2: you're good. They they fought with dignity and honor, and
- 1:05:57Speaker 2: I believe and that was but it was you know,
- 1:05:59Speaker 2: the British. Surely imperilss and British were That's really what
- 1:06:02Speaker 2: it was. It wasn't it was to force the British out.
- 1:06:06Speaker 2: Now did it force them out? Eventually they would have left,
- 1:06:09Speaker 2: but they probably wouldn't have left till later. Most of
- 1:06:12Speaker 2: the colonies of the India they didn't leave till good
- 1:06:15Speaker 2: fifteen years later. Susanna says that even when speaking about
- 1:06:27Speaker 2: young israel I, guess it's new Rochelle. If you have antibodies,
- 1:06:29Speaker 2: everyone was there there must wear a mask. Well, you
- 1:06:32Speaker 2: were gonna have to wear masks because until we assume
- 1:06:35Speaker 2: that until everyone has until everyone has had a chance
- 1:06:39Speaker 2: to get the vaccine, we have to wear masks because
- 1:06:44Speaker 2: we have to protect them. But for these people who
- 1:06:47Speaker 2: are gonna say I'm not gonna wear a mask because
- 1:06:48Speaker 2: I don't believe it. If everyone has had a chance
- 1:06:50Speaker 2: to get it, we don't have to go around with
- 1:06:53Speaker 2: masks because some idiot decides they don't want to get vaccinated.
- 1:06:56Speaker 2: If that's the case, that's I don't have to then
- 1:06:58Speaker 2: be inconvenienced my whole life, like I says. Not only
- 1:07:02Speaker 2: the British not protect Jews, they often actually worked with
- 1:07:04Speaker 2: Arabs the target Jews.
- 1:07:05Speaker 3: That is true.
- 1:07:05Speaker 2: They did not protect the Jews, and that was the
- 1:07:07Speaker 2: in the Haganah focused on that. The the air gun
- 1:07:10Speaker 2: and the lechi really did hitdn't protect the Jews as
- 1:07:13Speaker 2: much as they did the reprisal attacks when Jews were attacked.
- 1:07:16Speaker 2: And but that was the mains, the mainstream was the Huguanah.
- 1:07:21Speaker 2: That was their job or the and then then yet
- 1:07:23Speaker 2: the Palmach of course Paul March incidentally also had a
- 1:07:25Speaker 2: lot of leftists and the U palm groups. But the
- 1:07:28Speaker 2: job of the year gun and the Lachi was to
- 1:07:30Speaker 2: drive the British imperiodalists off the land of Israel. Safer
- 1:07:36Speaker 2: ing Aco of popular as a got into particular for
- 1:07:38Speaker 2: the masses, yes, time's correct, and and but that those
- 1:07:42Speaker 2: won't be arm masses. These are at least masses who
- 1:07:43Speaker 2: can read Hebrew, who can understand it. iPad says, if
- 1:07:48Speaker 2: you should have had lost, make no mistake, both Syria
- 1:07:50Speaker 2: and Egypt would have gained territory, but there would not
- 1:07:52Speaker 2: have been a new Arab Muslim state. And wore no,
- 1:07:54Speaker 2: of course not there wasn't a conception of the Palestinian
- 1:07:57Speaker 2: national identity. Then that would have been mh. They were
- 1:08:01Speaker 2: living from nineteen forty eight to nice sixty seven. There was,
- 1:08:04Speaker 2: they were. It was part of Jordan's so uh, there
- 1:08:06Speaker 2: wouldn't They would have probably split it up. I mean
- 1:08:11Speaker 2: Jordan would have taken a lot. Uh, yeah, there wasn't.
- 1:08:14Speaker 2: I agree with that. Or cite some in Hebrew that
- 1:08:25Speaker 2: we'repe Jews are above them of astrology and above the stars.
- 1:08:29Speaker 2: But there's Kuote, there's co hosts and the tuma, et cetera.
- 1:08:36Speaker 2: He's reading, Actually, I think you're reading directly from I
- 1:08:43Speaker 2: think you're reading directly from I can't. I don't have
- 1:08:46Speaker 2: it here is are you reading? I don't know what
- 1:08:48Speaker 2: you're quoting. If you're quoting from yarkom Nesky, but he's
- 1:08:51Speaker 2: not the Yes, yes you're reading. Yes, I think you're
- 1:08:55Speaker 2: reading from Narco komensk Uh.
- 1:08:57Speaker 3: No you're not.
- 1:08:58Speaker 2: You're not dreaming.
- 1:08:58Speaker 3: So but did you find this deeper?
- 1:09:00Speaker 2: Charitable Dove says, can we then justify hagiographies because they
- 1:09:05Speaker 2: perhaps necessary beliefs, at least according to those authors. That's
- 1:09:09Speaker 2: in my book on the censorship. That's what I was
- 1:09:12Speaker 2: accused of doing, and I believe so. I believe that
- 1:09:16Speaker 2: for certain communities don't we do this with our children.
- 1:09:19Speaker 2: When you tell your children's stories, do you tell them
- 1:09:22Speaker 2: all the facts? My father always gave the example that
- 1:09:26Speaker 2: you know in in elementary school, in high school, we
- 1:09:29Speaker 2: tell them that the Civil War is for to free
- 1:09:30Speaker 2: the slaves. Then now, when you get more advanced, you
- 1:09:34Speaker 2: realize that I was much more complicated than that, that
- 1:09:36Speaker 2: Lincoln was not an abolitionist. So yes, when we tell
- 1:09:39Speaker 2: our children, we tell don't tell them all the facts.
- 1:09:41Speaker 2: We don't tell them all the all the details. So
- 1:09:44Speaker 2: in certain communities, if the if the if the leaders
- 1:09:47Speaker 2: in those communities believe that the individuals should be kept
- 1:09:50Speaker 2: ignorant and should be kept at the level of children.
- 1:09:53Speaker 2: I'm sophisticated. I it doesn't bother me. These biographies do
- 1:09:57Speaker 2: not bother me at all, because in those communities that's
- 1:10:00Speaker 2: what they feel is necessary. So the Rambum wasn't necessary.
- 1:10:05Speaker 2: An elitist, No, that Rambum was definitely an elitist. He's
- 1:10:10Speaker 2: an overt elitist. He says explicitly in a Missiontara that,
- 1:10:13Speaker 2: for instance, the philosophy, it's only people who have filled
- 1:10:16Speaker 2: their bellies with tomwood, so it's only for the elites.
- 1:10:19Speaker 2: So he's definitely an elitist. However, the rambum is a
- 1:10:21Speaker 2: community leader. He's not an ivory tower person like you
- 1:10:24Speaker 2: take these other philosophers. You have the Islamic philosophers of
- 1:10:28Speaker 2: Arrowize Alfarabi people like that. The Rambam is a communal leader.
- 1:10:35Speaker 2: So the Rambam has to be on two levels. He
- 1:10:37Speaker 2: has to be for the people, but he's also writing
- 1:10:40Speaker 2: for the elites. And as I said, he's overt. He
- 1:10:42Speaker 2: says it explicitly that the certain things are only for
- 1:10:46Speaker 2: the elites. And how do you write only for the elites?
- 1:10:50Speaker 2: Because if you're writing and anyone can read it, especially
- 1:10:52Speaker 2: since he wrote the more Lui in Arabic. So he
- 1:10:54Speaker 2: says in the introduction of the morning, he's going to
- 1:10:56Speaker 2: contradict himself. He's going to write like in a code.
- 1:10:58Speaker 2: He's going to contradict himself so that only the elites
- 1:11:01Speaker 2: will be able to see what he's saying. The masses,
- 1:11:03Speaker 2: it will go right over their heads. They won't even
- 1:11:05Speaker 2: notice the contradiction. So that's how the rom bomb came
- 1:11:08Speaker 2: up with his approach.
- 1:11:10Speaker 3: Buru says, not.
- 1:11:11Speaker 2: Everyone can be can handle being told to abavach Rebi
- 1:11:14Speaker 2: is Mashiah. So the Rebbe's proceeding don't always reveal it.
- 1:11:18Speaker 2: I don't think that's the parallel Burro. I think the
- 1:11:21Speaker 2: ones who don't reveal it, it's because there they think
- 1:11:25Speaker 2: that they won't the people will stop donating money to
- 1:11:27Speaker 2: them because they won't realize that their local rabbat houses
- 1:11:34Speaker 2: is Messianic. But I have to say that I am
- 1:11:37Speaker 2: certain that the abbot houses I know that I'm in
- 1:11:40Speaker 2: my town and others are not. So. I know some
- 1:11:43Speaker 2: people are cynical, but not all Aabaud believe that. Does
- 1:11:50Speaker 2: anyone have a link er of hankin Slavaya on YouTube?
- 1:11:53Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 1:11:53Speaker 2: I didn't see it. I would like to see it.
- 1:11:55Speaker 2: Nell says, the PLO was established a few years before
- 1:11:57Speaker 2: sixty seven. Yeah, the PLO was established. It was created
- 1:12:01Speaker 2: by the Arab countries as a as a as a
- 1:12:04Speaker 2: proxy to destroy. It was created to destroy Israel. There
- 1:12:10Speaker 2: has nothing to do with the West Bank occupied territories
- 1:12:14Speaker 2: or anything uh our factor. These were all created. These
- 1:12:17Speaker 2: were created by the Arabs and really by the KGB.
- 1:12:21Speaker 2: The whole, the whole, this whole Palestinian movement is created
- 1:12:24Speaker 2: by by the Arabs and by the KGB to try
- 1:12:27Speaker 2: to basically destroy Israel, and for the sake of historical accuracy,
- 1:12:34Speaker 2: had the idea. It's often bandied about, however, that there's
- 1:12:37Speaker 2: no conception of Palestinian nationalism before. That I think is incorrect,
- 1:12:41Speaker 2: because you already see Hajomina Husseini, he was the leader
- 1:12:46Speaker 2: of the Palestinian national movement. There was a sense, even
- 1:12:49Speaker 2: if these people were Syrians and others. We have on
- 1:12:54Speaker 2: record the Syrian Foreign Minister saying that we created the
- 1:12:57Speaker 2: Palestinian people as a as a as a proper and
- 1:13:00Speaker 2: a tool. However, there was at least the beginnings of
- 1:13:03Speaker 2: a Palestinian national identity. I mean the Haja mean now
- 1:13:06Speaker 2: Husseini is uh is really the founder. We're one of
- 1:13:10Speaker 2: the founders of the whole Palestinian national movement. So it's
- 1:13:13Speaker 2: not well, what would have happened is the Arabs where
- 1:13:15Speaker 2: Jordan would have taken over Syria, and then they would
- 1:13:18Speaker 2: have had to put down the Palestinian national stories. I
- 1:13:21Speaker 2: think it's historically inaccurate to say that there was no
- 1:13:25Speaker 2: Palestinian nationalism before, you know, before the sixties, and that
- 1:13:31Speaker 2: it's all creation of the destroy all creation in the
- 1:13:36Speaker 2: nineteen sixties. But and I'll just add do well, if
- 1:13:41Speaker 2: you don't know hajjaman Osani. Of course he spent the
- 1:13:45Speaker 2: war years in Berlin and Hitler maybe the only non
- 1:13:51Speaker 2: German that the plan to reveal was revealed for the
- 1:13:54Speaker 2: plan of the final solution. It was revealed, and we
- 1:13:56Speaker 2: have a complete protocol of this. It's it's significant that
- 1:14:01Speaker 2: Hitler chose to reveal this to hajjo Mina Hossein, who
- 1:14:05Speaker 2: was not an Aryan. But as they say, he had
- 1:14:07Speaker 2: the same goals as the arguing, you know, uh killed
- 1:14:11Speaker 2: the Jews and destroy the democracies. So that's an important point.
- 1:14:16Speaker 2: David Dowen the one with this, David Dollen, professor in
- 1:14:22Speaker 2: in Florida. He wrote a book. It's actually it's the
- 1:14:27Speaker 2: two things. It's a defense of Pope Pious. He thinks
- 1:14:31Speaker 2: that and David Dallin's a deserved rabbi as well, that
- 1:14:33Speaker 2: Pope Pious was given a bad rap and there's all
- 1:14:36Speaker 2: this attacks on Pope Pious for what he didn't do
- 1:14:38Speaker 2: during the Holocaust. His argument is he did more than
- 1:14:41Speaker 2: people think, and that it wasn't that he's evil, maybe
- 1:14:43Speaker 2: he's incompetent, but he says all these attacks against Pope Pius,
- 1:14:47Speaker 2: we forget the true villain, the real villain, and that
- 1:14:49Speaker 2: is no other than Hajjo Mina Hosseini, who really was
- 1:14:53Speaker 2: an ally of the Nazis. When you think about it,
- 1:14:55Speaker 2: the founding father of the Palestinian National Movement was an
- 1:14:59Speaker 2: ally with the allied with the Nazis. And okay, we
- 1:15:05Speaker 2: will end uh with this ipats Is hit We're awarded
- 1:15:08Speaker 2: honorary Orion stars and some Japanese who's saying yes. You
- 1:15:11Speaker 2: can see a video of hajo min Hosseini visiting. They
- 1:15:14Speaker 2: brought in there were you had Bosnian. The officers were Serbian,
- 1:15:22Speaker 2: but Bosnian. They raised a poncer division of Bosnian SS troops,
- 1:15:27Speaker 2: so you had Bosnians.
- 1:15:29Speaker 3: The Muslims.
- 1:15:30Speaker 2: They ever bring him in from all over the Muslim
- 1:15:33Speaker 2: world to fight on the side of Hitler. This is
- 1:15:36Speaker 2: sort of like the Unknown Story.
- 1:15:40Speaker 1: This series was originally recorded in twenty twenty and twenty
- 1:15:43Speaker 1: twenty one as part of an ongoing lecture series. To
- 1:15:46Speaker 1: sign up to attend the electure on zoom, please visit
- 1:15:48Speaker 1: torenmotion dot org. Please rate and review us in your paper,
- 1:15:52Speaker 1: podcast that, or even better, tell a friend to give
- 1:15:54Speaker 1: a podcast to listen. The thing then tacked their name