Latest / OUTBOUND with Petra Ehmann / Hedge Fund to Health: Ivan Vatchkov on Time, Wealth and the Future of Healthcare
Transcript
- Petra Ehmann: Those of us that know Bulgaria would know that it stopped being a communist country in nineteen eighty-nine, but we really weren't properly introduced to the concept of money until a few years later when the country went spectacularly bust. So I very quickly oriented myself towards the industry that at the time was paying the best. The hedge fund industry is one that is absolutely fascinating because you're exposed to the most interesting people you can find, the smartest, the most aggressive. It's not a very well trodden path. From Hetch from Portfolio Manager to Healthcare AI, I keep a diary of all the bad trades I've ever done. Because I said you learn from negative feedback loops, right? You write it down every time. Why did I lose money? What could I have done better? Do also do a diary of everything that worked? No. That took me down a path of self-improvement and incremental self-improvement that I actually found fascinating. And after a while, patterns emerged. I only have so much time on this earth. How can I make the best of it? And in that question, Kalibra was born. Welcome everybody to today's show. I'm excited to be here, live from Singapore. And it's more tropical outfits, but the Singaporean crab decided to go on my on my top, so that's why I'm sitting here in a in a blazer. but thank goodness air conditioning is you're wearing Singapore on your sleeve, it's wonderful. Exactly. Exactly. So I'm very happy to have Ivan Vachkov with me here today because we're gonna talk about a topic that's very dear to my heart and also his heart, which is health tech. just a few words about Ivan and then we'll jump right in because it's so exciting. We don't want to lose too much time. So Ivan, I've been knowing him from the Young Global Leaders community from the World Economic Forum. He comes originally from Bulgaria, moved to London, then to Singapore, and started off his career in banking. At Deutsche Bank, Credit Suisse, then Algebris, where he opened the Singaporean office, and then Gamma and now is a co-founder and CEO of Calibra.ai. So fantastic to have you here. Pleasure to be with you. Let's start with the first bucket. So we'll talk about his career, we'll talk about calibre, his startup, and then an outlook into health tech twenty fifty. So if we start right off there, like what made you choose banking? I think those those of us that know Bulgaria would know that it stopped being a communist country in 1989, but we really weren't properly introduced to the concept of money until a few years later when the country went spectacularly bust. So this was these were the formative years of my high school education. So we went from a a very flat society that had almost no classes as such, because the difference between the highest paid and the lowest paid was minimal. It was more a case of what access could you get with your money. To world where everything revolved around money. And I wanted to study abroad. I needed to pay for that education. So I very quickly oriented myself towards the industry that at the time, along with I guess the dot com industry, was paying the best. And I think that's a path that a lot of your a lot of my fellow Eastern Europeans took at the time. So that's how we ended up in in finance. And then you moved from banking to hedge funds. that seems close, nonetheless a different step and a different direction. What yeah, Ivan, like what drove you there? So you move from a very big and structured organization to a very small hunting pack type of mentality, but it was mainly an accident of history. during the financial crisis I happened to be a banking analyst who knew a lot about bank balance sheets. and there was a fund that was very interested in the financial services industry. They were just fresh from the success of having arranged the takeover of ABN AMRO in the Netherlands. and they were interested in their next project and it just so happened that they knew me quite well. And through a very unlikely set of circumstances that I don't need to go into, I ended up working for them. So this was a more an accident of history than a deliberate path on my part. But I don't regret it in the slightest. Yeah. I just wanted to ask, yeah, how how was your job life then afterwards? yeah, and how much did you enjoy it? There's a misconception out there, especially for those that enjoy the show billions and others like it, that you wake up in the morning as a hedge fund manager and you fall backwards into money. The truth is very, very far from that. The hedge fund industry is extremely cutthroat, the margins are very small. You're competing with the most intelligent and hungriest people around. So it's really, really difficult for one to actually break through and be incredibly successful. But those are the stories you hear about. Just like you hear about the really successful actors and you don't know about the ninety-eight percent of the others in Hollywood who, you know, are waiting tables, hoping for their chance to come through. So that dynamic is actually quite present in the hedge fund industry, of course, the minimum wage is higher, but the market is very efficient. You do get very, very long working hours. So for instance, if you're in Asia, Your working day can start as soon as New Zealand opens, which is six or seven in the morning in Australia, and often ends at two in the morning when New York closes. So if you're actually working Asian hours, your it's a 20-hour workday, not a not a 16 or or a 12-hour workday. So the the hedge fund industry is one that is absolutely fascinating because you're exposed to the most interesting people you can find, the smartest, the most aggressive. What I personally enjoyed the most and and probably what I missed the most about leaving is that if you are an investor that corporates want to impress or want to have on their side, you tend to have access to the smartest and most interesting storytellers in the industry. For instance, if you're interested about electric cars, you could ask to meet the CEO of NEO and of BYD and well, Tesla probably not these days, but and then next day you switch into the topic of, well, monetary policy and gold. And you can get up to speed by having access to the most interesting people straight away. That's a really fascinating setup that is not really to my knowledge available anywhere else. What is interesting is if you when you mentioned that, it reminds me a lot. last summer, on behalf of the company I was working for, I started talking to lots of VCs as potential LP. And that opened lots of doors. So yeah, I'm with you on that one. As soon as you come with money in the background, then you can Exactly. And in the hedge fund world you are speaking to the big corporates which have I mean the CEOs of the really big companies are perched in a in a beautiful place to get the prime access to information. In the venture capital, it's a lot more about discovering something early. Whereas I think at the top end of corporates it's knowing about what's happening in real time. So absolutely, I mean interest follows money, smart people follow money, but it's been a really, really huge benefit to me to get the intellectual exposure that I did, which I did not anticipate because that's not what you see in billions. Yeah. But it seems like yeah, in the hedge fund you mentioned there's it's cutthroat, it's where you're competing hardest, so you're probably also exposed to or it's more competitive. You're exposed to yeah, higher levels of performance quality where you have to keep up all the time. And so what I wonder now, Ivan, is it seems like you went into banking then to hedge fund. So it seems like a little bit in the finance industry where like in the a big corporate and now is was a bit more start up y And a bit more competitive. I wonder like what what was like a defining moment in your career where you say, Okay, wow, I took so many lessons away that helped you then afterwards, now in your current job as a CEO and founder of Calibr AI, what were those moments or what was this one moment that shaped you and your character? It's an interesting question because I mostly learn through negative experiences, like most of us. So I can as we were talking earlier before the show, I said I could document the catalogue of my suffering. So but I think to to to keep this sort of on point, I would say that the unique thing about the banking industry is that it teaches you discipline and structure. Because the bank is a fairly rigid place to work. it doesn't necessarily encourage entrepreneurship, although on the investment banking side it does, which is where I was. But it's that's it does teach you discipline, it teaches you to show up on time and most importantly it teaches you to be accountable. When you take that to the hedge fund world, it's a lot more entrepreneurial because there really isn't a fixed playbook. In banking, generally, tenure and effort correlate with outcomes. So if you are at a bank for 10, 15 years, unless you do something really stupid, eventually you will be a managing director. Eventually you will be in charge of lot of people. Eventually you'll be paid very well. That's not the case in the hedge fund industry at all. Hedge fund industry is much more entrepreneurial, much faster. a lot of the highest earning people can be very, very young or they can be very, very old. you can leave the the pool of the hedge fund industry on the back of just one bad trade, which is generally not the case in banking. So it teaches you to be more entrepreneurial and it also teaches you how to handle being wrong, which I think is absolutely critical to one's career development. So to answer your question, once you have the discipline, what you really need is the ability to self-reflect in a way that's not delusional. because success has many fathers, failure it typically has none. And I learned through bad trades and obviously the volatility of the financial crisis and the politics that came after it. The most potent learnings for me was to prevent self-delusion. so having ownership of your actions, which can be a tough thing to do because in the markets you can get all your analysis right, you could get your timing perfectly right, and then a tweet from an US president can send your entire portfolio reeling for reasons you could not have anticipated. And there's two paths you can take. You can blame somebody else and you can say, actually I should have prepared for this. I should have hedged. I should done something else. So I think that's sort of the the the the the most important learning for me was discipline and being accountable. And I think that puts you in a really good step to be an entrepreneur. Yeah, definitely. I'm with you for for discipline and accountability, especially as entrepreneur, like you have almost no constraints anymore and you gotta figure out how to get there. But just with accountability, some it's also sounds a bit unfair to a certain degree if you're hold accountable for something you can't actually influence. True. And that's the that's the bit that you don't see in billions, right? The nature of the market is to make fools out of the biggest number of people possible. And very often you're one of those fools. But at the end of the day, the client that entrusted you with their money. It could be a pension fund, it could be an investor, it could be, you know, your boss. At the end of the day, they don't care the for the reasons why an outcome happened, but they care whether you made or lost money. Right? Just like Maradona in the nineteen eighties, he scored with his hand, but they won the World Cup. And that's been forgotten, so now he's a world champion. There's a very, very simple similar ethic, right? Win win at all costs. And if you if you lose Crimea River, but that's tough. Do you think banking and hedge fund made you more risk averse as a person? it's a great question. I think it did, on balance, because normal people don't experience the volatility that we do, right? I mean, even gamblers, they are in a structured environment where the game is known, the rules are enforced, and more or less you're playing a probability game. The markets are different every day. Today we care about events in the Middle East, tomorrow we care about AI. And we can change our opinion back and forth three times in a day, and it's really difficult to pinpoint exactly why things happen. So being exposed to this day in, day out is the equivalent of receiving about six thousand performance reviews every day. Because every time the market ticks up or down, you see the value of your portfolio. And for the benefit of your of your listeners, there is a psychological paradox where losses hurt twice as much as Winning actually gives you pleasure. So even in a market that's flat, you would still be taking a lot of psychological damage because everything is always very obvious in retrospect. So I can always speak for myself. I mean, look, if you if you don't like risk and if you don't like volatility and and nerve-wracking sort of daily patterns, you probably shouldn't be a hedge fund portfolio manager. there's better careers for that. But in my case, it just showed me the real nature of risk. Which can be described as more things can happen than will happen. And that can make you a little bit paranoid because you're taught to look around corners. You're taught to look for the saber-toothed tiger. Because when it does show up, you will lose money and you might get fired. So there is definitely a risk aversion and everybody gets what they want out of the market. In my case, he taught me quite a lot, but it did tell me that longer term, it isn't beneficial to my health to actually unless you absolutely addicted to the dopamine hits of the market. there is a time to step away and transition either from a player to a coach or just find something better to do. So you already started the segue perfectly because I wanted to talk obviously about health tech and your startup. So you're the co founder of Kalibra AI. now you were opening the Singapore office of a hedge fund and at one point you stu decided to step out and start your company. From the outside it looks like a huge step. you come from a corporate, you go into a startup, and now you come from finance and go into health tech. Can you walk us through like how did that change happen and what gave you the courage to jump? Yes, it's not a very well trodden path from hedge from performance manager to healthcare AI. why not? But why not? It's not a very well trodden path. Otherwise it's it's too boring, no? If you just continue the same or do something that is not healthy or you don't enjoy it. Exactly. Yeah, and then you regret, why didn't I even try? There were two factors. One is I mentioned health. my father had a health issue around the time where I left the industry. and so given I'm half his genetics, I figured, you know, I have to pay attention to this. So that's sort of the the the push. The pull is that this introspection that I mentioned earlier led me down a very interesting path. So for instance, I keep a diary of all the bad trades I've ever done. I stopped at some point, but bad trades in the hedge fund world because I said you learn from negative feedback loops, right? So you keep a diary. What does that mean? Why did I lose money? What could I have done better? Do also do a diary of everything that worked? No. No, because the logic is if you flip through it, it's so negative. Correct. But that's what I'm saying, at least in my case, but I think most people learn from negative feedback loops, right? If you were successful, there's not a lot to be learned, arguably, but you have to keep figuring out the mistakes because the thinking is if you take care of the downside, if you don't do anything stupid, the upside will take care of itself. So you want to learn as much as possible. Exactly, you want to learn as much as possible. Well the problem is you lose those reflections through time because maybe maybe you were lazy. Maybe you didn't do your analysis. Maybe there's something you didn't check. But after you lost money, well, it was the wrong tweet from the president or financial crisis, et cetera, et cetera. So so I made a very specific point to catalog my failures so that I can look for patterns. And after a while, patterns emerged. So it was really helpful for me to correct those elements of my psyche that would because our psychology doesn't change that easily. Therefore, most of our mistakes or most of our bad behaviors or character traits or whatever you want to call it, they tend to be loops. And it's very difficult to see it from here. But if you actually abstract it on paper, it's helpful. So long segueing to answer your question. But the the answer is that that took me down a path of self improvement and incremental self improvement that I actually found fascinating. Some might call it Selfish, some might call it stoic, but I thought, I only have so much time on this earth, how can I make the best of it? And in that question, Kalibra was born. Because you realize that you cannot make more time. You can make your experiences of life a little bit denser by having a lot more novelty, but you it's really difficult to make time unless you vastly improve your health. And from a financial background, I thought, well, how do I know what to invest in? And you probably see this as a consumer a lot. Should I be taking vitamin D today or should I be going for a faster run? Should I call my sleep better? Yeah, do I sleep better? Should I call my mom? Should I do my mindfulness practice? Should I be drinking hydrogenated water, whatever it is? Well, all of these things have one thing in common, which is they have a cost in a currency we'll understand, which is time. And I would argue I learned that time is the only currency that matters. So if you've set out to improve and if you And many people have not learned that currency yet. Well we tend to learn it too late. I think you have a saying in German, let's let's hope we are wise before we are old, right? I tried to answer the question. If I want to be more productive with my time, how should I invest it? And you very quickly from that transition into, well, I need to be healthier to be around longer so that I can compound my learnings better. And you can take this into all sorts of directions. Brian Johnson has taken one extreme, there's all sorts of other ones. But to answer the question, if I want to be healthy at 80, and there's a fascinating Harvard study we can talk about later on that topic, what are the actions I need to take in my forties? Because you cannot take all the actions. You've no doubt read the amazing morning routine of BioHacker X who wakes up, you know, at four in the morning, stands on their heads, yeah, journals, then takes a very cold shower, then writes out their values, then has a green shake, etc. etc. And when you add up the time on this, it might easily be a two and a half hour morning routine. Well I changed my morning routine and to be frank, it is taking so much time. Correct. And the problem with that approach is that you're investing a very valuable resource. Your time when you're in your thirties, forties, and fifties today. For a very uncertain pension down the line, because one, we don't actually know with certainty the causal effect. I mean, we have a broader directional pulse of how things are going. But you don't know that if you do that headstand for three more seconds, you're gonna get four more seconds of life. As a result, you're investing very valuable time. You could be playing with your kids, you can be doing your podcast, you could be writing a book, reading a book, you could be having your favorite coffee in your coffee house. You could leave life tomorrow, right? One bad turn from a bus could end it. So you need to be very, very clear about the payoffs of investing that time today. Otherwise, you're gonna be flying like a kite in the wind. I'm gonna be taking NAD today, I'm gonna be doing mindfulness tomorrow, the day after that's gonna be high rocks and whatever the latest fad is. So to bring this back to finally answering your question, please I set out to devise a framework of understanding the return on my time invested in the time domain. Meaning, if I am going to be doing these five things today, how will I know that these are the correct five things? Is there a system I can devise that is personal to me? Because you and I, we share the same functions, but we need different things at different times in different proportions. So how do I know? And that sort of took me down the initial project of Kalibra. I set out to say, I want to know have my personal operating system of health that is about me and takes all of my data into consideration in real time, including my lifestyle, which didn't exist at the time and arguably exists today. So that's that's the answer. Thanks, I Well the TED talk of an answer rather. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But exciting. It sounds like CFOs would be the perfect customer for you because they probably always wanna know what is D R I if I do this or do that or buy this or buy that. CFOs of insurance companies in particular, right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. But what I find interesting is you're describing something that I think becomes more and more trendy just about now. And you started your company In twenty twenty. Yeah, in twenty twenty, no, so almost six years ago. Six years ago. So you were wa way ahead of that time. Let's just call it blind luck. and look, many attempts were made to do this a long time ago because health is obviously of paramount importance to the really wealthy people. So they always wanted to devise the fountain of youth, the Formula One car for health, and then eventually spread it to the general population. I think where we got lucky on timing, but sh also showed a little bit of foresight with my partner. Is that we realized that the definition of health we use is wrong. So when I say health, most people mean physical health. Something clinical, a checklist of some sort that documents the absence of disease. So how do you define But actually health is much more than that? So the World Health Organization defines health as physical, mental, social, and emotional, right? So that's already four dimensions of it. At Kalibra, we're action oriented, so we broke it up into six categories. And they three of them are what we call our hardware. And they are all verbs, how we rest, how we move, and how we nourish. They are all inputs into health and can result in outputs. And the other three are the physical, the mental, and the social elements of health. We call them connect, reflect, and grow. Why is that interesting? It's interesting because if you break health up into those pillars, you realize that most of our health lives in our blind spot. For most people, health, at least until they're fifty or sixty, means go get a checkup, you're alive, great, you have a pulse. Can you fog a mirror? Off you go. And it turns out that we start aging the day we're born, processes start in our bodies that actually have a very strong compound impact. And on top of that, these are things that we can measure, the things we can't measure, things like trauma, things like having strong social connections, having a good relationship with yourself, having a good relationship with your future self. All these things are now proven, as of the Harvard study, which we'll get to, to have a profound impact on health. So insight one was if I am interested in having more time, how can I get it and how do I invest? But second one is do I have a clear, holistic picture of what my health looks like? Because below the neck, I could be very, very I'd be looking pre-diabetic and I have high high glucose because I just had a sugary drink, or because I was just told that my wife is leaving me. Below the neck, the stress responses are physiological. So these are things that you start learning about very quickly, and these are things that these are parameters you have to be able to account for. And back then we were talking about machine learning. Now everything is called AI, but we tried to harness some of those signals which were previously being ignored. That's how we ended up down this path. And so Ivan, you like to analyze things, you like data and you like to make sense out of it and give actions. Now you talked about the six buckets and the your broad definition of health. Like take one of them or walk walk me through like calibra AI, how do you collect all that data? And how frequently can you collect that to actually then make sense for your customers? So it's a great question and it's one that we get very often. There's two ways of answering it. First, you start where you're at. So even five years ago, most of us wouldn't have these things on our hands. So there is already a small health coach living on your wrist, on your finger if you're wearing an aura ring, sometimes in your bed, because eight now produces beds that actually measure and capture your sleep. Right. I've seen Amazing technology that can do a selfie through your morning mirror when you're brushing your teeth and take a few visible markers. So the future of collecting data is actually quite bright. But in the here and now I would say But the actions is very weak still. Like okay, I can track a lot. I can see, my sleep score was, I don't know, eighty nine or ninety-two or whatever, but but then so what? It's exactly the question we ask. So what is that's literally if you had read our presentation in the twenty twenty twenty one, we what is so what problem? So to to finish answering your question, there is objective data that exists about this, about us. It's very scattered. So surfacing this is an easy win for all of us. Because if I have your blood work and your wearable data, there's a lot of stuff we can do. That's the short answer. The longer answer is that we are constantly producing health signals that are not being captured, right? In the abstract, my pulse, my speech, am I slurring, am I movements actually discrete or or continuous? There's a lot that we can collect. Problem is that you need a framework. Right now, health does not have a an operating system that anybody agrees on, which is why we started with the six pillars and we said, look, at the end of the day, we're not here to do do diagnostics. That's the doctor's job. but before you end up in the doctor's office, it's worth knowing the rough picture of how you're performing across those six pillars, because that will guide you to what we call your best next action. So if we could build a perfectly hierarchical system of health for Petra. And build a 3D avatar of hers that's digital, we can pull that avatar and see which is the action that will have the highest impact and try to back it up with science. It's still gonna be highly uncertain, but what is certain is that your highest action can lie in a domain that you're not that familiar with. And we'll talk about the connect pillar in a second, because I think that's where the conversation should go next. So we start with collecting what there is. We digitize it. Because at the moment, even in the most advanced countries, unless you're in Israel, the US or Singapore. Your health record is not fully digitized. In the UK, they have many, many different trusts that don't share data. And on top of that, consumers don't usually have the data or are not necessarily able to get it. So if we can digitize a blood test, marry that with your wearable data, and do a sample survey, what your lifestyle is, maybe even take a body composition so that we can actually see the accumulated damage to your body, that would be an amazing place to start. And that's kind of where the industry is going now. In how do you collect that data? So blood value you probably send your clients to a lab, they take it, okay. But that's probably you don't do that every day. You do it maybe every s three month or every six Exactly. Dear listeners, if you haven't done it yet and you're over thirty, please take a blood test. Public service announcement. In in one of the speeches that I saw from you actually, you mentioned at the very latest, 39 is where you gotta get started. Yes. And Because of the environmental damage that we're exposed to now, both because of environment but also because the nutrients in our food are becoming less available. We're seeing incidences of all sorts of problems earlier and earlier. But typically the way one one the one would start, and again, in the US it's very different because the US is very quickly consumerizing health. that's not gonna be the case in Europe for a while because it's a public publicly funded system so they're really not interested in paying for your blood test unless there's an obvious problem. I have I have just a question around that. So health tech is a notoriously slow moving industry. Yeah. So how do you pace it with the speed that you have and the energy that you have, the regulatory framework, and also user trust. So how do you balance that? It's great question. So regulation is an absolute a rev limiter to the engines of everybody, less so than most people say, in the sense that if the rules are clear, you can pick your geography, you can pick your vector of attack, and you can also pick how close you want to go into regulatory capture. For instance, for Kalibra, if we're not careful, we can be might have to become a medical device at some point. So we get around this problem by partnering up with doctors who use their medical license so that we are decision support for them. So you have to respect regulation. And in health tech, just like in finance, complex, heavily regulated, and you know, danger comes from everywhere. So we you have to respect it, and there's no way around it. AI is blowing up a little bit of the regulatory framework and is blurring the lines. But that's a necessary evil, and that by the way applies almost to everybody. Those that skirt the rules eventually have problems. Now, the way you solve the problem in of speed in healthcare and in health tech is By going where things move the fastest. Ironically, that's not where you make your money, but if you consumerize your approach, consumers, yes, they are fickle. Yes, they don't like to pay. Yes, it's very difficult to build a model around them. But if you can get over the problem of healthcare, which is the incentive problem, which is the person ordering health the healthcare service is not the person paying for it, who is not the person consuming it. That's why things are slow. Because everybody's trying to work out what the hell is going on all the time, right? The insurers are chasing the PBMs, the PBMs are chasing the pharma companies, the pharma companies are chasing the the providers. So if you can abstract away from that and say, hey, in the future, what are some of the things that we know for sure? Well, we know that health is consumerizing. We know that people want more real-time advice because they're becoming less patient. We know that people are now increasingly aligning health with wealth and health with well-being, which wasn't necessarily the case for my father's generation. They thought they were bulletproof and They did all sorts of things that we probably wouldn't do today. So if you align yourself with this, then all of a sudden you have a very quick feedback loop. You publish something on your app, people will either use it for a day and drop it, or they'll actually catch on to it. You publish a new and set in your set of new analytics, are doctors adopting it or largely yawning and ignoring it? you you deliver a service that is helpful to people, it catches on very quickly. You have a market signal, and that's where my background as a hedge fund manager helps. And finance because if the signal's not there, we just drop it and move on. We have a saying in the in trading, you can be wrong, but you can't stay wrong. Well, in traditional healthcare, the feedback loops are very slow and they're very, very muddled by this triage of people paying and not consuming and expecting somebody else to provide it. When you're a standalone startup, you have a very, very quick feedback loop. So if you can capture that feedback loop and actually harness it to your benefit, then you have a chance. Otherwise you become a statistic. So The regulatory ceiling is there. We all have to bump against it. It's changing. But I think what most people get wrong is they misunderstand human behavior, right? Nobody really wants to be told to do three squats and not eat the ice cream. So how do you work around that? And two, where are people already paying for the kind of stuff that you are offering? Those are two very strong signals that you can use. And we can reform this a lot more. Yeah, no. So as long as you let's not talk too much about governance, but as long as you stay you you need to know fur first of all where is the border, what can you do? And then as long as you stay in that circle, you can go very fast. Exactly, because it's we call this a digital event, right? If you touch regulation on the wrong side, you're dead. So it's it's an absolute Or it becomes a moat. yeah. Like if you really If you can harness regulation, but that typically happens with f much bigger corporations. Once they're older, they use regulation as a mode to defend themselves. But in the here and now, if you're having a regulatory issue, you're as good as gone. So we have taken enormous costs, frankly, disproportionate costs, to comply with regulations that we don't necessarily even have to, because we operate in the US. So you in the USFIDS you have HIPAA. Right. So we have an automated compliance system that we use for that, which produces an amount of work that I could not begin to describe because it's cross security, compliance, and legal. Then you have GDPR in Europe, you have PDPA in Singapore, and so on and so forth. So you have to hold yourself to the highest standard if you're global like us, which imposes enormous costs. That's not to say that it can't be done. You just have to recognize early enough that There are places where you can't be and non compliant is one of them. So it's a very, very sad story because I have to satisfy the same standards as a really big corporation with arguably infinite resources. But necessity is the mother of innovation. You you incorporate this into your workflows and you can actually you can actually make it quite productive. But yes, it is what it is. Look, it's people's health we're talking about. So Yeah, yeah, yeah. people talk told me actually, don't ever go into health tech because it's so regulated and so slow and yeah, it's just a terrible place and more more complicated place if you're coming from simpler business models, etcetera. Yeah, not untrue, but I would counter that with but I I yeah, I truly enjoy doing this day to day. So for me it's less of an issue. I chose this role because frankly if I could I would do it for free. I'm enjoying everyday shipping new features, talking to people, helping people get healthier. So for me it's it's a necessary evil, but I can see how that can be off putting to those who are just watching the AI industry or all sorts of other industries monetize in hours and not days, and here we are five years on with Kalibra, you know, trying to make sense of how to best how to best monetize. Yeah, but I see yeah yeah, the purpose. You you see a strong purpose in that field. Wouldn't do it otherwise. It would Dear listeners, Helltech is not the place to go unless you really, really love it. But but honestly, I was talking to a lawyer recently about MDR, medical device regulation in Europe. And it's actually not then bad. I learned that because everyone's like, whoa, stay away from it, super dangerous and whatever. you you gotta you gotta educate yourself. But it introduces a loop. So for instance, if your medical device is a software company, you might have to send your code for review to somebody. If you fulfill certain criteria. And I think you gotta go there once you're more established. Correct. And once you're sending them code, you're moving at their speed. Exactly. And that's that's the challenge. They don't have their respective employees. They're vastly under resources. Exactly. And then you wait eighteen months and in eighteen months' time, yeah, yeah. You got chat GPT. Exactly. I would like to talk with you because you mentioned that you alluded to it, like a health tech is a very different industry in one sense that you have somebody who pays, you have somebody who uses it, and you have lots of intermediaries. So can you make sense for us about how that actually all fits together? It's a really interesting question because if you if you there's an inherent conflict. Let's look to the future for a second. There's an inherent conflict, which is if I can socialize the costs of my bad behavior. Then the rational thing to do is to go out, drink, smoke. Yes, I will suffer, I'm gonna have a great time, but eventually one day when I have a disease, society will pay for it, right? So there is a inherent conflict between the well-being of the full swarm or the full community and the well-being of every individual. There can be prisoners' dilemmas and other conflicts. So you can imagine two futures. You can imagine a future where the individual is strictly kept in check. about their behaviors. And already in Europe, I am told, I haven't verified it, that there are countries in Europe that will not allow you to have certain elective surgeries if you smoke. Because your chance of recovery is smaller, and therefore why should the spate state spend money on somebody who hasn't done their own homework? Right? Why should we mow your lawn if you yourself won't sweep your own doorstep? And that's very much the philosophy that Singapore is adopting, which is individual responsibility as a deference to the collective. So that's sort of one Track. The problem with that track is where do you draw the line of personal freedom? Maybe Petra and I want to go for a cognac and a and a cigarette after this, right? We should be free to do so. So you can see that it becomes very quickly a moral and regulatory quagmire that is not easily going to be resolved. Resolved it will be, because s healthcare is going to sink most government finances in the developed world in a time frame that's much shorter than people think. Mm-hmm. Because population peaking in wealthy countries and starting to collapse quickly and healthcare costs exploding and pensions switching from dependency of four to one to two to one will force things mathematically. So that's one world. The other world is to get the healthcare system to be so efficient that the cost of delivering marginal care is negligible. Therefore, we can all do and go out and do what we like and eventually we'll pay the price, but at least our fellow countrymen and country women won't be on the hook for it. There are approaches being developed in both of these extremes, and I don't know where the chips are gonna fall, but there's a common thread between them, which is in both cases the individual should be informed of the approximate consequences of their actions so that they cannot plead ignorance. And I still meet people who eat fat-free yogurt and tell me that that's a healthy thing. Turns out that that fat-free yogurt is full of glucose and sugar, right? And so There are still a lot of people that are vastly misinformed about the state of their hydration, the state of their nutrition, what they should be doing. So if we can deliver cheaply and effectively the education so that each of us has a health coach in their pocket and knows what the next best action is, we've kind of done our job from a moral perspective. From then on, it's a government and democratic issue. Where do you want to go? Do you wanna go full nanny state? or do you wanna go strictly individual? and I don't think that's gonna be resolved in the near future. But what we do know is that unless you place an individual burden of taking care of oneself and one's family in particular, just like with the pension system, you're socializing a problem, and that is problematic. You mentioned before yeah, that your your customers, you mentioned clinics. I was joking about CFOs being your best customers. And we're talking now about all the different players in the field. Who actually make the health tech space or complicated because everybody carries a certain accountability. So who's your customer? Is that the the doctors that you mentioned? Is it the CFOs that I dropped in? Is it the health insurances? Is it employers? Like, well, fortunately, I have graduated to not to a world where I don't have to work with CFOs, for which I'm grateful. You would do great. The short answer is our client is the business. Usually it's the provider. Why? Because the medical provider is incentivized to deliver a high quality service at a decent price, and with that we are strictly aligned. The consumer is just as motivated, so we're essentially a B2B2C company. Because if we cannot get the consumer to passively give us the data that we need and participate in the process. We're in this strange world where you expect the doctor to fix you in the third person and that's not a kind of business we want to run in. Exactly. You can scale faster because these are already established relationships. It's gonna be very, very different if Petra's doctor tells her to download an app and start connecting with them and managing those workflows than if I had to find Petra on Instagram and convince her that we are the right environment. So our client is typically the provider, but it's a provider within a narrow band. It's either preventive, chronic, longevity, or Some form of very data heavy healthcare business. So not your GP. Mm-hmm. But then still the question is like who pays for that? So why so you could actually also team up many Well, because the doctor already charges the consumer. Yeah. I'll give you I've I'll give a very I mean we we shouldn't turn this into some form of promotion of calibre, but I I'll I'll say this. At the moment, doctors and even the best doctors spend an inordinate amount of time doing things that they are vastly overqualified for. Managing notes, doing discovery, comparing the units of your previous blood work with the current one, because guess what? You did it in two different labs and there's two different units. Collecting patient context, processing that in their brain, trying to take notes, and in the twelve to fifteen minutes that they meet you, they have to do all this. Right. So in the world that I want to underwrite, doctors should be paid for their judgment and not their time. For their collective experience, for the individual experience. For the context that they can generate. So the way that we you solve this problem is by freeing up time for the doctors, because that time is incredibly expensive. So if they can go from seeing in that time period three patients to five, you have delivered enormous value in already a well-established workflow. The doctor has a fee for service. And that's sort of stage one. Where the world is going, and this is a really interesting topic we should explore later. I'll mention it, we can come back to it, is If the government starts getting involved in preventive health care, which in Singapore happened a few years ago with something called healthier SG, where they actually are beginning to what do what in the US they call call value based care, and in Singapore they call it outcome based care, where you don't pay the doctor for the work they do, they pay them to keep the patient healthy. Sounds very similar. That is interesting. But a completely different proposition. you love that. Yeah. well, it works very well for us because the government all of a sudden is subsidizing the data acquisition. So in Singapore under healthier SG, you can get a very heavily subsidized blood test for the six components that people generally look at, which is your fats and your sugars, right? Your glucose and fats and everything else. And then the doctor can review it with you and give you a lifestyle intervention plan. Now, doctors are not trained to be health coaches. So they're not gonna be able to talk to you about your aura ring or your VO2 max or all sorts of other things. But all of a sudden we're s working off a baseline that is vastly superior to you discovering that something hurts. So there's a lump somewhere at fifty five. And starting that process. So this is the kind of business we want to align with. And if I was a betting man, I would say that's gonna be in the future because eventually governments will realize that keeping Petra and Ivan healthy through the right incentives is much cheaper than dealing with stuff on the back end, when things get, you know, a lot more complicated. We've known this for thirty, forty years, but now financial reality is going to force those changes in behavior. So look to Singapore. Look to China, look to Israel, look to the countries that have already got good consolidated data structures that can move quickly. They are starting to poke around these problems quite aggressively. Can you say more about I love that. That sounds so interesting. Wanna learn more about It's called healthier dot SG if anybody's interested. Healthier dot SG. Okay. and actually they pay for you learning more about the current state of your body and then doing something now. Correct. Subsidized, don't pay. Singapore is very smart. Singapore always wants you to have skin in the game. So they will always make it too neat to tango structure. But you can have a blood test for a fraction of its actual cost if you are a Singapore permanent resident or a Singapore citizen. And they start incentivizing you more and more the older you get. so they are turning the GP network from a reactive to a proactive system. Now it's gonna take time and Doctors don't love being health coaches because if you come to me with a problem and there's a particular pain or an issue, I'm trained how to resolve it and get you back on your way. Preventive healthcare can take many dimensions and can be a very interesting conversation, but it may not necessarily have an impact in the near term. So if you the measurements are how many people did you heal today, the incentive structures start, you know, start changing. But anyway, Singapore has forged this path, Singapore gets it. And it feels to me like this will be happening a lot more because two Big forces will meet. One is the digitization of health and all of us wearing these things and asking questions about them and polling Chat GPT. So all of a sudden the average consumer is very informed, very interested, and wants to know. And a system where the government is drowning in the effective cost of healthcare, and consumers are demanding that they be empowered to actually manage it. So these two will result in a better outcome than we have at the moment. And also, I mean, the entire doctor patient relationship changes. Nobody we we're You mean a GP or Dr. Google? A GP. Yeah, because we might have a question and in that moment we want an answer. So why can't we message our doctors? Why can't we have like instant calls with our doctors? why do we have to have an appointment, go to the doctor's office, sit there, wait in the waiting room, and then have the question asked. I mean that changes from from a time perspective and also from a quality perspective. We I I think patients go way more informed to a doctor. They just don't doctors don't get away with a standard answer anymore. Well so it was interesting. I was listening to an open AI to an open AI employee who's in charge of health, and they were saying that most of the queries in terms of time for open AI Health, which is the biggest doctor in the world effectively now, tend to come out of doctor's office hours. But to answer your question, there's an enormous capacity issue with doctors. Doctors make an enormous sacrifice. To go through much longer education than anybody else, and absolutely brutal post-educ training, and a fairly archaic system of actually making it through to a place where they can actually start earning good money. And then they're in in demand all the time. Sometimes prices are regulated in certain countries. We have public service. So we have an enormous capacity issue with doctors, which is going to be mechanically impossible to resolve. I've seen estimates globally of we're short 30, 40 million doctors. So this doctor in your pocket thing is going to happen sooner or later. completely because we don't have the capacity to serve. Now, the problem with that is that there are s a lot of things that machines can't do or shouldn't do and will be regulatorily prevented from doing. So it's a very trite saying that you the AI will not replace you if you're a doctor but an AI empowered doctor will embrace you. I go back to my point. If you paid doctors for their judgment, where they had the full context and used all of their lived experience to make a decision, then we have a system. If you keep using them as very, very expensive data clerks, what little capacity we have is being wasted. So I've looked at and I'll probably butcher the statistics, but more than half of your time with your doctor is spent collecting information and then after you leave he spends another 10 minutes documenting this. With ambient scribes and full AI context, then systems like Kalibra they can give you a 3D profile of all your longitudinal data already pre-chewed for the doctor with deterministic AI, then we're cooking. But that future is arriving very, very slowly and it's very unevenly distributed. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I I recently had a conversation with the doctor and like the minute I left I got all the transcribes. Yeah. That was interesting. so hopefully that saves them some time because yeah, we definitely need them for Yeah. and now part of the health picture is digital, which is awesome. That is now permanently somewhere where it can be retrieved and the next doctor that treats you will have the full context. And I still believe people want to talk to a person. it's good to have an answer instantly. but somehow people also want to talk to a person. So if we can make that doctor more efficient and more available when we actually need them, that'd be very good. Yeah, and there's a very important part to to mention there, which is when you have a cancer diagnosis. There is actually a statistical probability of what's going to happen to you. But that's not how a cancer diagnosis should be communicated ever, right? So that's one element of it, which is there is an intimately human experience when it comes to health and mortality and everything else. And that should remain a contact sport. But there's also another dimension, which is accountability. You you're not inherently going to be as accountable to an application like Kalibra. Then you will be to the GP who lowers their glasses and says, Hey, Ivan, you really need to stay off the Nutella. I won't, but you can try. so so I think those are two elements that hopefully will never be replaced. And you can look star Star Trek had its medbay, but there was also a counselor and a doctor on the team. So Or have like a community effort. Automate the mundane, the repeatable, the boring, the discovery. But leave the decisions to the humans because they're always going to be subjective. You don't know, even if the computer can give you a probability of recovery five years and and health five years from this diagnosis, without a human to couch it in the right terms and help you how to handle it, it's n it's not going to be productive. So I think that's that's the bit that we at Kaliber at least look to empower. but I think that's the journey that hopefully health systems will take. The incentives are and you mentioned insurance, I've got a lot to say on the topic, but that's not how insurance is structured to function today. There's so much more so much more to cover, but I glanced at your watch. That watch there took off. So we should actually almost move to our last block, but before we move to our last block, the Outlook, how can we get in touch with or experience Calibra.ai? Well calibra.ai, if you go to the website, you can download the app. it's a very simple onboarding journey. We ask you twelve questions and we ask you to connect your wearable and it's free for everybody, for now at least. and then the health coach is gonna pick up that information and actually start giving you not only insights every day, but specific actions for you to take. And we score everything. So you have a journey that you can follow. and the challenge will be the first time he tells you to do something you don't feel like doing, like do a breathing exercise or call your mom or restrict carbohydrates. And that's the first time you're gonna face this human behavior issue that we all talk about, which is we we know the right stuff, we just don't necessarily want to do it. But yes. Get in touch with us, take a look. and if you don't care, please get a blood test. but so I can just use the app. I don't have to go to a GP. You don't have to. The app is designed to be your wellness and health coach within the limitations of the regulatory framework. We So if I live in in Europe, can I use it or in any geography other than China you can use it. The way we've structured it is that it'll give you wellness and preventive health advice. on the things that are not deemed medical. It will also serve as your health wallet because one day you might change your Garmin, you might change your aura. We pull all of that data, we consolidate it. You may switch providers. In the US, we have full healthcare record integration. So you can pull data from all your providers and have it safely in your health wallet and share and unshare it with one toggle. So the minute you start sharing data with a doctor, additional features are enabled that a doctor needs to approve when it comes to blood work. And genetics and epigenetics and other things. We allow the data to flow, we make it very safe and very secure. You can toggle and untoggle. So if you don't want to share data with somebody, you can toggle straight away. That's a unique thing that we do. But there are a lot of limitations on what we can do. And again, it goes back to the philosophy is I don't want to replace doctors. I want to empower them. So there's a lot of technology we could use today to build an entire health intervention for you, just off the back of the data that we have. But we're not sure this is the right approach. Fantastic. Unless we live with functional health, for instance. Okay. So Yvan, let's move to our last block. I think it's also very exciting. This was cool. I could have gone for so much longer. especially listening to your health in twenty fifty. Mm-hmm. We briefly talked about AI. So what do you think in twenty fifty will preventative health have become mainstream because of AI or not yet? I should qualify my statements with first I'm not in the predictions business because I've been in markets long enough to know that you can't predict the future, but you can picture scenarios. And the second thing is I'm unsure about the twenty fifty timeline, because as of six months ago, I'm reminded of Lenin's saying that there are weeks when decades happen. And I think we've just experienced one of those weeks. It just hasn't fully sunk in yet. The future that I see is I think we're gonna go through two phases. I think the first phase is going to be the full on quantified self, AI ready, prepared to be obliterated by data in real time, so that I know what to do. And this will solve a lot of problems. But eventually human nature will push back against it because we don't we're more than just a complicated bag of bones with with skin on top of it. and people will start, I think, hopefully transcending towards the more interesting aspects of health, which is personal growth and and connections with others and all the things that actually take care of our longevity. So I think we will go through this initial burst where everybody will be obsessed with quantifying, everybody's gonna have more and more wearables. And soon your toilet your tampon, your toothbrush, they will all be measuring things that are critical for saving you. But eventually that's gonna fade into the background. Eventually it'll become of maybe when you do your morning pee in your toilet, that's your pee. you have something floating you're like a floating in your bloodstream which beams things, you know, for ninety days. And this will largely become passive. So it'll be just like a car that goes in for servicing, you're gonna go in somewhere. probably have your supplementation changed or medicine delivered, but that will be kept largely in the background. and And that can happen then all the time, right? You don't have There'll have to be continuous care. Because I mean we work with an Alzheimer's business in the US now. The early signs of Alzheimer's arrive decades before the s the real symptoms of the disease appear. And there's a lot you can do to block and tackle, which is really the benefit that Brian Johnson brought us all by putting Health so front and center. You may disagree with his philosophies. I do. Hi, Brian. but what he did was to help us design the Formula One car and the protocols and the thinking, the N of one thinking that we can eventually use for each of us to have it's probably gonna be something really, really unobstructive that beams the objective data. Think of a scenario where your glasses take pictures of your food or automatically connect by the hidden QR code to know the exact macros. Which then connects with your body composition. So assuming we want to go in that direction and we really have no choice because governments can't keep paying for healthcare this way, that's going to be phase one. But phase two is going to be a lot more interesting, which is when we transcend from I want to live for a really long time, okay, why? Because that's where it becomes really tricky. I know a lot of people who are dying to live an extra 10 years but don't know what to do with themselves on a Sunday afternoon. And this is where health and wealth will start blending, because if we can give you more time, that's awesome. But how will you use it? And that's why I'm saying twenty fifty is a little bit tricky, because we we should be able to solve a lot of the chronic the four horsemen, you know, cardiovascular cancer, the cognitive diseases, we should be able to make enormous progress on those. But that will reveal the second problem, which is and I think that's what Maslow was on about when he did the hierarchy of human needs. This self actualization is gonna become a much bigger problem if you remove, you know, the fact that you're taken out of the genetic pool twenty years early because of health, right? So that's where I am really, really unsure where things will head, because there really isn't a playbook for it, right? The very benefit of life is that it's finite. And it's, it's ephemeral and you have to make the best of it. So this this longevity question is hiding a bigger challenge. I mean, look, I'll be the first one to be happy about it. But that's sort of where I'm a little bit unsure. So I think preventive health for sure. Eventually, if consumer doesn't buy it, the government will force the incentives. Like everything else, AI will destroy the cost of that delivery by bypassing outdated incentive systems, wiping out intermediaries. And empowering those that are actually in a decision making po position to help us instantly. So that's all good. What that means for society and what that means for us individually is is T B D. Hm. I have two more questions. So the second last question and we could go on for a long time. Wealthy people still have or still can afford the highest the most premium healthcare services today. than anybody else. They can go to the best doctors, fly wherever they want, spend as much as they want. there is no limit. Now in twenty fifty, what do you think is it that wealthy people can do that everybody else can do? It's a great question. I think given that health is probably gonna be eventually designated or health service a basic human right, I think the ability of the wealthy to have an Elysium like structure where they get radically different quality of care, I think that'll flatten out over time. Because right now it's access to information, access to treatment and the financial resources, but I think the deflationary forces that AI will unleash and in the individual power, I think that's that's going to take care of a lot of it. What wealthy means in twenty fifty is also to be discussed. Is it the guy with the most bitcoins or the guy with the most guns and bunkers? I mean, I don't know. But what intrigues me, And I'll answer the question obliquely because I I genuinely don't know. Is that my wife used to work in wealth management? I know a lot of people that manage money for the wealthiest people. I, you know, I've I I've worked for two incredibly wealthy people. The Harvard study taught us that it's the relation the strength of your relationships at 50 that determines your health at 80. And you can buy happiness. So the wealthy have an advantage there. But the challenge is that if you're very wealthy and very public, the quality of your relationships changes. And you're A lot of very wealthy people don't know who their real friends are. They have a lot of deal friends. And there is a lot of anxiety that comes with the pressure of being very the people handle it differently. But I'm saying that the wealthy may have a disadvantage in that if you are one of a few, you don't have the sense of community. You know, if look at religion, if you look at organized societies, if you look at high high highly hierarchical societies, they have phenomenal health outcomes because they craft Community as a healing structure. I know this sounds very woo-woo, but it's very real. That's what Dan Butner's work on the blue zones revealed. That it can be religion, it can be community, but as long as you're tethered to other humans and you belong to a community, you are broadly healthier. And most wealthy people tend to stand, as of now at least, a little bit apart from society. Right? They are on blue origin and they are at the very expensive clinic in Switzerland and they are in St. Barthes, you know, getting their latest rejuvenation treatment. So I don't know where that's gonna go. My prediction is that the wealthy will pay for the Formula One car, so they will be the on the bleeding edge of the treatments that one day will be democratized for all of us. But I'm hoping that the price will fall enough where that won't matter. Because it's a finite problem. beyond this, it's gonna be really hard to know. Now we come to the last question. It's like a summary question. I think it's it's a good good wrap-up. So if you think about the Healthcare system of twenty fifty. How should it look like? So the healthcare system of twenty fifty should be a system of continuous care where data flows all the time and we can take evasive action very early. Just like in space, you see a comment coming from far away and you take evasive action. I think AI will underpin this. I think we will solve the privacy issues. And I think beyond that, a lot of it will be delivered in the home. Not in specialist places. I think that'll be the biggest change. There will be a lot more things done where you are, a lot more treatments delivered, a lot more procedures than having to go. someone who I don't remember gave me, I think, a great closing line, which is healthcare used to be something you visited, then it was on you, and soon it's going to be in you. So I think that's a great place to close. This is the perfect words, the perfect ending words. I enjoyed this conversation so much. Thank you, Ivan, and I'm very sure you also enjoyed it so much. See you next time.