Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP329: Measuring The Tangible & Intangible Impact of Website Rebrands and Redesigns
Transcript
- 0:04You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly E Comm strategy,
- 0:06technology and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital
- 0:09consultants and re platform specialist James Get and Paul
- 0:11Rogers. Get insights into E Comm
- 0:13strategy leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders
- 0:15and leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:18improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:23Well Pay and our topic today is about measuring redesigns and
- 0:28understanding how do you measure when measurements should be
- 0:32focused on tangible versus intangible and can you ever
- 0:34justify not have intangible commercial metrics as your
- 0:38success criteria. Now this is your conversation
- 0:41that Paul and I will come at from different angles because we
- 0:44work with different types of businesses.
- 0:45A lot of the the projects Paul's work so on are more premium
- 0:49fashion lifestyle brands. I work with really broad mix and
- 0:53there are different drivers in each of those projects and we're
- 0:57bound to I agree in some of this as well, which is good, healthy,
- 0:59healthy, healthy conflict on a morning podcast recording and
- 1:05Paul flag this to me yesterday, I thought it was really good
- 1:06idea that we do this is because there are lots of conversations
- 1:10a business about we want to redesign, but what does redesign
- 1:12mean? And when people talk about we
- 1:15want to elevate the brand, common terminology I've had in
- 1:18many projects. I want to elevate the brand.
- 1:19We want a more premium aesthetic.
- 1:22What does that mean? How can you define that
- 1:25objectively? Because how can you design and
- 1:27and and be and know something successful if you don't even
- 1:30know what it is you're delivering?
- 1:32So that's a set up. That was my ramble.
- 1:33Paul, what was the reason why you think this is an interesting
- 1:36month everyone's listened to? It so originally we were talking
- 1:40about, I suggested maybe we look at what is more in the context
- 1:45of RE platforming project and how you get the most value out
- 1:48of RE platforming project and whether nowadays it's easier to
- 1:53migrate. So therefore it's easier to
- 1:55manage potential change with a redesign.
- 1:58And then that kind of led to actually of a redesign.
- 2:01It's quite dangerous position for a brand to measure and
- 2:07understand what's changing and doing that at the same time re
- 2:11platforming as a risk. But I think your framing is
- 2:14right. So I think that yeah, I have a
- 2:16lot of conversations around this.
- 2:18I feel like often the way the the people that are signing off
- 2:22budget think about things is I'm vast 200K, therefore I should
- 2:27see X immediately. And I think it's, yeah, it's
- 2:31just trying to manage that. And I think for me, I think, you
- 2:35know, making an experience through usable and thinking
- 2:39about different kind of journeys and types of users and sources
- 2:44of traffic and everything else is really important.
- 2:46But I am also, I do think there is it's very important that you
- 2:52kind of, you know, you're looking at the brand side of
- 2:54things as well and thinking about users that have never come
- 2:59across the brand don't understand the brand and the
- 3:01content you're putting in front of them etcetera.
- 3:04So I feel like for me, if you're doing a redesign, I do think
- 3:08because I think we've probably both had very challenging
- 3:10creative and brand stakeholders in projects in the past.
- 3:14And I think, you know, a lot of the time you're right.
- 3:17Like, you know, there's a lot of rubbish that is factored into
- 3:21these projects or, you know, there's a lot of, to use your
- 3:24word, like vanity and these projects.
- 3:26But equally, I do think if you're in the right vertical and
- 3:33you've got buckets of people that, you know, come into the
- 3:35site and don't know the brand and you know, yeah, I basically,
- 3:40I think you should be thinking about how do you best position
- 3:43your brand, best position your product.
- 3:47And a lot of that is going to be photography and lifestyle
- 3:50content. And I think that should all be
- 3:52part of a redesign. And I think the big discussion
- 3:54point here will be how and can you measure that?
- 3:58And I think the really, I mean, we've had some challenging
- 4:02projects over the last couple of years where, you know, is really
- 4:06difficult to measure a redesign, especially if you're making
- 4:10bigger changes. And the other variable as well
- 4:13is like when you start to think about lead times and you start
- 4:17to think about, yeah, multiple sessions to purchase and
- 4:20multiple channels and everything else.
- 4:22So I think I'd imagine we'll come on to talk about like,
- 4:26yeah, when the right metrics are the right metrics and like
- 4:30softer conversion, all that kind of stuff.
- 4:34Yeah, I, I come to this from a, a, an almost puritanical point
- 4:39of view, which is it's not that I dismissed design because I
- 4:42think design is hugely important, design execution is
- 4:45fundamental to online success. But I come in from point of view
- 4:50that the projects are fundamentally E com projects and
- 4:53ecom is about selling. And yes, you have complicated
- 4:56user journeys and you have new customers discovering you have
- 5:00more considered purchase paths versus people are there to buy
- 5:03directly and just want to get to a check out.
- 5:06But fundamentally, you cannot lose the fact that you're there
- 5:09to sell because unless you are a content website, you're a
- 5:12transactional website. And if you're a transactional
- 5:15website, you you've got to maintain a focus on the
- 5:17conversion path as well. And I guess the, the thing that
- 5:19I get frustrated by is when, when ECOM projects get hijacked
- 5:24into brands projects and the decision making compromises ECOM
- 5:30decisions that, that are in the best interest of, of the ECOM
- 5:33team. But I'm also open to the fact
- 5:35that I'm not a design expert at all.
- 5:37And therefore I'm always open to listening and understanding
- 5:40where the I guess the more designing creative LED people
- 5:43want to take a project. Yeah, I think, I think the, I
- 5:47mean, without trying to conclude this episode right at the start,
- 5:52I do feel like kind of what you said, I think you should never
- 5:55deviate away from like core best practice, usability and UX in
- 6:01most areas of the site. And then it's about layering
- 6:05your content on top of it. And I actually think, you know,
- 6:08nowadays content is going to be like everyone talks about CRO
- 6:12and whatever else. Like realistically, content is
- 6:14the thing that's going to, you know, have the biggest impact in
- 6:17my opinion. And yes, brand content and
- 6:21things like that. The one thing I would say is I
- 6:24think that nowadays I think you can build for both types of
- 6:30user. So bottom fan or someone that
- 6:32knows what they want, always repeat purchase and go through
- 6:34buy as quickly as possible. And then someone that has
- 6:37probably not been to the site before is unlikely to have, you
- 6:42know, high intent is unlikely to know the brand.
- 6:45And I think that's where you start to build out more purpose
- 6:48built landing pages that make it easier to navigate the catalog
- 6:52and also start to introduce the brand as, you know, more
- 6:55lifestyle content like because I think the other thing is if you
- 6:58were to look at conversion for that subset of traffic, it's
- 7:02going to be super, super, super low.
- 7:03So optimizing towards conversion is probably not the right way of
- 7:09necessarily measuring. And again, this is a suit like
- 7:13based on I think high AOV and yeah, kind of premium brand.
- 7:20But I think for me, if you're selling a considered item, I
- 7:24think you should have a purpose built landing experience that
- 7:29then gradually takes you through to there's more optimized like
- 7:33PDPS and potentially PLPS. But I think like, I think if I'm
- 7:38completely new to a catalog, like just being forced to go,
- 7:43you know, into APLP and using kind of core navigation, I think
- 7:46that's probably not as good a journey as you could build if
- 7:51you were building specifically for that, like that type of
- 7:55user. Ready to grow your business
- 7:57online? With World Pay E-commerce you
- 8:00can deliver fast, secure payments your customers love,
- 8:04backed by global reach and real people powered support.
- 8:08Scale with confidence and enhance your customers
- 8:10experience with World Pay E-commerce.
- 8:14Yeah, and This is why I want the the the first question I've got
- 8:18I want us to RIP into after let's let's just preface it with
- 8:22the reasons that we normally see people driving into redesign
- 8:24outside of re platform it. But then I want to get into the
- 8:27this brand elevation, what it means, because I my concern is
- 8:31that I've seen projects where a focus on brand elevation and
- 8:35create a premium feel then stops people thinking about the core.
- 8:40What you just talked to makes perfect sense, right?
- 8:41You've got you've got a core set of users who are in purchase
- 8:45journeys and they need those purchaser needs to be really
- 8:48efficient, really fast, as frictionless as you can get.
- 8:52It's that's all the E com stuff, right?
- 8:53It's I I've got pen NAV. I've got simple add to car.
- 8:56You know, I can add, add from the PLPI can quick add upsells
- 9:00on the PDPI can I've got fast checkout methods, all of that
- 9:04stuff, right? And brand content shouldn't
- 9:08disturb that. It should lay around it and on
- 9:11top of it. So let's let's get the two of
- 9:14the two of the areas where I see a lot of a lot of times people
- 9:17invest in money is on brand refreshes and that's when the
- 9:20overall business is rebranding. One of my clients heels at the
- 9:23moment is going through that. They they're repositioning the
- 9:26brands. Part of that's brand evaluation,
- 9:28part of it is about redefining the message and the story and,
- 9:31and, and so that it can talk to the younger audiences better.
- 9:36And part of that is visual changes.
- 9:37And that's like it can be colour palette refreshes, logo tweaks.
- 9:41That's that simple execution that doesn't fundamentally
- 9:44change the site. That is just updating brand
- 9:48delivery. The big, the big one for me is
- 9:51when people say we want to elevate the brand, we want to
- 9:54create a more premium experience.
- 9:55So first of all, I'm devil's advocate on this because I think
- 9:59a lot of times people don't really know what they mean by
- 10:01that. They, they, they have a concept
- 10:03in the head of what it might be, but they can't, they sometimes
- 10:06it's struggle, they struggle to articulate it clearly in terms
- 10:09of what it should look like. Whereas the projects I have
- 10:13worked with on heels, real clarity, great brand guidelines,
- 10:16really good visual clarity about what this means that plays out.
- 10:20So what to you is a premium experience?
- 10:22How do you objectively define premium online experience?
- 10:26Well, I think it it to be honest, I think the two things
- 10:28you just described in my opinion are the same.
- 10:31So I think for me, elevating the brand or elevating how you're
- 10:36presenting a product is, I think it's, yeah, really considered
- 10:42consistent brand guidelines all the way through.
- 10:45I think it's the front end being built in a very kind of, again,
- 10:53considered and performing ways. So like, you know, really
- 10:56polished theme. Yeah, kind of really kind of
- 11:01clean rendering, etcetera, etcetera.
- 11:04And then I think it's, you know, purpose built templates to house
- 11:08your best content. And for me that is what like a
- 11:13premium brand should be doing. It's like you as a brand
- 11:16hopefully will know what content your customer or what content
- 11:22your customer resonates with the most, what best sells your
- 11:25product, everything else. So it's really like thinking
- 11:28about how you use that content alongside, you know, other
- 11:34content that but like put it in a really yeah, purpose Bill
- 11:38performing template. And then I think in terms of
- 11:41premium experience, for me, that's more is entirely about
- 11:46the kind of stylistic side of things and the theme being built
- 11:53in a very premium, consistent, tidy way.
- 11:59And I think, yeah, I mean, I can in my head like imagine 2
- 12:03examples like straight away. And I feel like you see these
- 12:07like premium brands that will have really good photography,
- 12:11but like, and, you know, their themes are built really poorly.
- 12:14Like their content is just shoehorned into, you know,
- 12:18standard kind of PDP templates. And, you know, they're kind of
- 12:21hiding a lot of their best content.
- 12:23Like everything's just very standard.
- 12:25And then also you can kind of feel that they're kind of brand
- 12:30guidelines are like lost in the way that the kind of themes
- 12:33build. Yeah.
- 12:36And I think it's for me, the premium experience is just end
- 12:40to end considered styling and the theme being built with an
- 12:48objective of getting the most out of the content and also
- 12:52being consistent with kind of other channels as well.
- 12:56Because I think that's another thing like, you know, there's so
- 12:58many examples of brands and I will, I'll use Strathbury as an
- 13:04example actually. So someone we put out the other
- 13:06thing, their previous site that you'd go into their store and
- 13:08they're very consistent. They're great.
- 13:10Like, you know, everything is really kind of considered in
- 13:15terms of like colour palette and you know how they're kind of
- 13:18merchandising and like all of their displays and everything
- 13:21that's all very consistent, every single piece.
- 13:24And before you'd look at their site and it was just like, it
- 13:28felt like a Shopify theme. You'd have like bits of content
- 13:32that like around like what sits in the bag and everything else
- 13:34that were kind of just put in a little block on the PDP and like
- 13:38it hadn't really been consider like, how do we get the most out
- 13:41of this content versus they were up for a redesign.
- 13:44And now I feel like the theme is just like a lot more end to end.
- 13:49It just feels like it's been, yeah, kind of built with around
- 13:55brand guidelines and content. And I think that to me is what a
- 13:58premium brand experience is. Yeah.
- 14:00So that's interesting. I almost think I'm going to set
- 14:04us a challenge. We're not allowed to use the
- 14:05word premium or elevated for the rest of this episode to
- 14:09describe, describe what being premium is.
- 14:13But the I think that point is spot on actually it's execution.
- 14:17You have you start with really good brand guidelines, one of
- 14:20those broad garden lines do colour palettes, visual
- 14:23topography, use of logos, example of lifestyle, the values
- 14:29and the look and the feel, etcetera and the the like the
- 14:32the psycho. I can't even say that word
- 14:34psychographics around the core customers, all that piece that's
- 14:38really useful. But the bit where I see people
- 14:41struggling online is it will be a flat design of we need to, we
- 14:46need to look what a home page looks like or a category landed
- 14:49page, you know, one of your richer content experiences for
- 14:52like, you know, new, new customers being guided through
- 14:54whether it's a sofas or a beauty range.
- 14:57And then we've got our core PLP with hero content, additional
- 15:00stuff and our PDP, our default temper, plus an enriched version
- 15:05for more considered product selling.
- 15:07And it's all flat designs and people looking and go, that
- 15:10looks great, that looks great. But actually it might look great
- 15:15on a flat sign on the screen. But less thought goes into what
- 15:21I'm going to call 5 key areas. Number one is content section,
- 15:26functional capability, flexibility and extensibility.
- 15:31So we've got a layout and it it is a text plus an image plus a
- 15:35button, whatever it might be. And it looks great.
- 15:38Then all the sudden you think, how does that play into these
- 15:41other four or five types of content that we're going to want
- 15:43to create? Is that now we're going to
- 15:44maintain a consistently elevated, I can't use that word
- 15:49consistently strong execution of content and messaging or we
- 15:54actually limiting ourselves. And we're going to have to this
- 15:57kind of actually want to shoe on it in because we've got 10
- 16:00sections now we're going to have to reuse those.
- 16:02And actually, oh, we'll make a compromise by using this section
- 16:05to do this on this page because we didn't think it through
- 16:08enough that not thinking end to end site pieces is one of the
- 16:12areas. Then it's the transition
- 16:14animation piece. And I've seen this before where
- 16:17there might be a simple transition done.
- 16:20I, you get a bit of text that that fades into the page or a, a
- 16:24slight bit of movement animation as you go from one section to
- 16:27the next. But then that's repeated ad
- 16:29nauseam through an entire site. And as a, as a user, when you're
- 16:33going through the same thing, it just becomes really quite
- 16:35repetitive and jarring. And then that doesn't, that
- 16:38looks quite cheap in the end because it's, it's repetitive.
- 16:42But the, the two areas I think really fall down.
- 16:46And it's not necessarily this is projects I'm working or other
- 16:50brands that I've looked at is the consistency of the visual
- 16:56storytelling and the content that sits within it and that
- 17:00tonality and the psychology of how the copy is positioned and
- 17:04how it appeals to the the audience.
- 17:07I often find that a site can start really beautiful and then
- 17:10within three to six months of trading those principles have
- 17:14have started to be eroded in parts of the site as people try
- 17:17and get stuff live. I think to me everything you
- 17:21just described I think is because I mean, all of this
- 17:24comes down to I guess like how you manage a process, but I
- 17:28think all of that needs to be part of the scope of the
- 17:31redesign. So I think when you're, I mean,
- 17:33one thing as you said that always comes up is like, I think
- 17:36going into redesign, you have to take a series of let's say
- 17:40products is the obvious one that where they've got more content,
- 17:46richer content, more complex content, longer descriptions,
- 17:50different types of content. And you kind of need to give
- 17:53those as the example. And I'm a big advocate of using
- 17:55real content when you are going through designs because I think
- 17:58that makes a huge difference because it's easy to design
- 18:02something with dummy content that really kind of fits, you
- 18:05know, across kind of different components.
- 18:09I think that's one thing. Second version of that would be
- 18:12other languages as well. So you often see people design
- 18:15for English, but actually, you know, they've got Japanese
- 18:18version of the site or, you know, whatever, whatever other
- 18:22languages that you know, hard to design for.
- 18:24And I think you need to design around that.
- 18:27German's a great, sorry to remember.
- 18:29German's a great example because it's much longer words and you
- 18:32have, it looks brilliant in English and you Chuck all the
- 18:34German text and you're like, whoa, that's blown the template.
- 18:38Exactly. I think the other one is like
- 18:41really considered widgets. When you're using a third party
- 18:46like again, you'll often see people design without actually
- 18:49really putting any thought into what can actually be done within
- 18:52the third party. Or when it comes to like
- 18:55development and it's been rushed because you know, you need third
- 18:58party CSS or like a bit of extra development work that people
- 19:02launch with at least some elements of like default
- 19:06stylings. I'm trying to remember the other
- 19:09bits that you that you said about it there.
- 19:12That point, that point you just mentioned is really, really good
- 19:15one actually. And it's something I have to
- 19:16keep reminding myself about because I had this with, with a
- 19:20customer review provider and the, the design was all lovely.
- 19:26Like it was a, a brand whose colours were pretty much
- 19:29monochrome on knives. So it's very subtle aesthetic,
- 19:32but the PDP and the PLP fit with the review snippers, all nice,
- 19:37really nice image. And then you play, you put the
- 19:39third party plug in and it looks utterly shit because the third
- 19:42party plug in is the limitation. It's you don't have full
- 19:45control. It is a widget that's controlled
- 19:48through styling within their back end.
- 19:49And their back end styling is basic.
- 19:53Yeah, that's that's a real gotcha.
- 19:55That's a really interesting one as well because that's where
- 19:57like I think you in my opinion, benefit from like some element
- 20:02of like doing a redesign we would always do for every
- 20:05component and build like a component library.
- 20:09And I think you've almost got to do some level of functional
- 20:11discovery. But before you give that brief
- 20:14to designer because. Like in a lot of cases with
- 20:17reviews, you might want to use the API which gives you, and
- 20:20again, this is just from us naturally working with brands
- 20:24that want the flexibility and like don't want to show reviews.
- 20:27They just want to like aggregate data and stuff like that.
- 20:30Or they want to use bits of review data and build like a
- 20:34little custom component. But I think in that scenario,
- 20:38you've kind of got to know that you're going to use the API and
- 20:42give the design of that brief because otherwise, and like you
- 20:46see it all the time where you've got like pretty nice, nicely
- 20:49designed sites and then you know, they'll just be using the
- 20:51standard yacht PO widget. And even where it looks fine,
- 20:54it's like you click on write a review and it's all just, you
- 20:57know, like kind of off brand and you know, typographies all over
- 21:01the place. And also like the front end dev
- 21:04hasn't kind of finished all of the their kind of work on in
- 21:08that side of things. And there's a you see that a
- 21:10lot, I think with different kind of base widgets.
- 21:14And I think that's something that needs to come out a bit
- 21:17more before design. So we've talked about that the
- 21:22the brand innovation of premium thing, what that means, how can
- 21:25you define it? How do you measure redesigns
- 21:29that are brand focused? And yeah, I've got my own views
- 21:34on it. I know you do a lot of work with
- 21:35this. There are there are some sites I
- 21:39think that just put out a redesign and the success
- 21:44criteria is brand execution not specifically tied back to
- 21:48success metrics from an econ point of view.
- 21:50So what is your advice? What do you look at and how do
- 21:53you measure the impact? So I think I, I think it's
- 21:57increasingly, it's always been really complex to make her a
- 22:01redesign because I think there's just so many different metrics
- 22:04and there's so many potential variables, biggest one being
- 22:07tracking. So usually people will rebuild
- 22:10all of their tracking as part of a redesign and that can be a
- 22:13major variable straight away. So I think it's really important
- 22:16that someone essentially is accountable for this and has
- 22:19takes full responsibility for reporting back on change.
- 22:24I think that it is really hard to measure and I think you know
- 22:29if you've got an AOV above £300 you've also got like you know,
- 22:34you're not going to see an impact straight away as well.
- 22:37Factored into that, I think for me having a like for lights
- 22:42subset of traffic is really important.
- 22:44So we would often use like branded search and looking at
- 22:49like conversion, AOV, etc. And then where we can, we would
- 22:53also pull out like new customer conversion, right and look at
- 22:56different metrics specific to new customers because a lot of
- 23:00the time that's going to be where the impact is.
- 23:03And then I think looking at like engagement metrics on kind of
- 23:07some of the higher level landing pages, I think is a like
- 23:10secondary KPII mean realistically what you know
- 23:13commercial stakeholders are going to want from a redesign is
- 23:17improvements in. I mean, I, I think global
- 23:21conversion rate can be the worst metric to look at because it
- 23:24causes so much friction in businesses and there's just so
- 23:27many variables. So I would say conversion rate
- 23:30with like some isolated views on it against yeah, different types
- 23:36of customers or different channels, etcetera.
- 23:40So I think that's going to be your number one and then
- 23:42supported by a of a global revenue, revenue per user,
- 23:49etcetera. And then I think realistically
- 23:52you should be looking at, yeah, kind of some deeper metrics as
- 23:56well, but probably not like management leadership level, but
- 24:00I think most redesigns are justified based on uplifting
- 24:03conversion and uplifts in AOV. Yeah, I think the, the new the
- 24:11new customer I think is really important, but equally important
- 24:15is keep an eye on existing customer segments that are the
- 24:19strong converters, the people who are repeat purchases.
- 24:22People are coming in from campaign sources that are yeah,
- 24:25correlate to more immediate conversions rather than longer
- 24:29journey paths to make sure you're not doing anything to
- 24:31alienate those. And I, I, I think it's critical
- 24:35to to protect existing metrics as well as look at the impact on
- 24:41I get that more content and new customer piece.
- 24:45But you're right, it is, it is tough because like let's let's
- 24:49say you, you're launching a, a brand redesign, but that's in
- 24:52the middle of like a, a big campaign cycle and you've got
- 24:58all sorts of marketing tests and variation changes going on.
- 25:01It does become more and more complex to to basically isolate
- 25:04pure impact. The big thing that I've seen, so
- 25:08for a lot of the fashion brands, again their peak is sale and
- 25:15that is fairly consistent for my kind of seasonality or like
- 25:20calendar year perspective. But there are significant
- 25:24variables in assortment of product, level of discount,
- 25:29availability of sizing like blah, blah, blah.
- 25:32And I think one thing I've seen is because it's actually come
- 25:35out of a redesign, performance is great or flat, whatever,
- 25:38people have it going to say all performance is bad or good, one
- 25:43or the other. But actually that there's kind
- 25:46of major variables and the fact that people want to launch pre
- 25:50peak suddenly then there's a lot more question marks going into
- 25:54sale period. Yeah, and I was, and to be fair,
- 25:58this applies to performance marketing as well.
- 26:01It's the way it's going to be the case like you're always
- 26:03going to look at anything that kind of has changed.
- 26:06But yeah, I think that's something I've seen a lot of and
- 26:11essentially because that's your change, that's the thing that's
- 26:14kind of then looked at. But yeah, I think I mean, to be
- 26:18honest, it is really hard to measure.
- 26:19And I think nowadays you've kind of got to go going into a
- 26:23redesign. You've got to have a proper, you
- 26:25know, agreed set of KP is and agreed approach to reporting.
- 26:31And you've got to have someone that can communicate everything
- 26:33that's changed as a result of tracking and navigation,
- 26:37whatever else, so that you can then you come out of the project
- 26:41and if there are issues, there's like clarity and reliable data.
- 26:45Because I think that I've seen a lot of fashion brands go for a
- 26:49redesign that, you know, a creative agents who are here up
- 26:51here, if they then think numbers of tanks and they're just
- 26:56panicking and making crazy decisions and, you know, like,
- 27:00yeah. And I think that's that can be a
- 27:02really difficult position to be in for those brands.
- 27:06Yeah, the the tactical piece I think is really important as
- 27:10well. So you pulled out like
- 27:12navigation. A lot of these redesigns involve
- 27:14structural changes to navigation and some of that is data-driven.
- 27:20Some businesses are very good at looking at click pass, looking
- 27:24at the essay implications, looking at where they have
- 27:28issues with customers finding products, doing some like
- 27:32customer research and insight and overlaying different data
- 27:35points to go right. Do you know what?
- 27:36We need to consolidate some categories.
- 27:37We need to introduce new ones for SEO.
- 27:40We need to simplify navigation because people get slowed down
- 27:44and then test it, you know, the good scientific approach.
- 27:47And that then leads to a, you know, not it's never perfect,
- 27:51but a better execution. And then you can objectively
- 27:54measure, click pass, you know, you can measure time and
- 27:57journeys, you can measure the like product outcomes from it
- 28:01versus others who just make loads of changes.
- 28:04And then it's really, really would not, it's not, you know,
- 28:07as in we want to as a business change to this and this is what
- 28:10we think's right. Without having the data behind
- 28:11it then it becomes really hard to unpick.
- 28:16Yeah, I can. I completely agree.
- 28:18And I think the other thing we haven't really talked about
- 28:20testing, but I do I mean, I personally think there's a role
- 28:24for testing for bigger for like not, not for everything and not
- 28:28necessarily you know split test. I think it can be quite
- 28:31dangerous to split test 2 completely different experiences
- 28:34as well. But I think if you're making
- 28:36like we worked with a brand that was probably quite, it was, it
- 28:42was a considered purchase and there's a lot of like content
- 28:46that would influence people. And there was a lot of
- 28:49suggestion to change a lot of things from an agency.
- 28:52And we just tested a few different versions of the PDP.
- 28:55And I think that can be really valuable.
- 28:57And I think the same can apply to navigation.
- 28:59Like if you're trying to make wholesale change, I think it's
- 29:02quite easy to test that. So I feel like there is and if
- 29:07if you are making quite a lot of like structural change to
- 29:10product information or navigation, I feel like it's
- 29:12quite a bit of room to test that.
- 29:16Yeah, IA 100% you should always test if you can, if you have the
- 29:20race or some bandwidth. I guess some for some people
- 29:23they don't they either they don't have the expertise in
- 29:26house or they don't have the budget to invest in a third
- 29:29party to run the test for them. And I'm not, I'm not advocating
- 29:32that as a great approach, but you know, we, we all live in, we
- 29:36all work with in businesses where there are constraints on
- 29:39what we can and cannot do. And that's why I think come back
- 29:43to your point is always aim to test.
- 29:45If you can't, you're 100% right, then what you've got to do is
- 29:49have a set of metrics and those metrics have got to be
- 29:52measurable, even if somebody else could disagree with your
- 29:55metrics. And as long as you've agreed
- 29:57that set and you've got reliable data and you can track what
- 30:00happens before, during, and after, then at least you're
- 30:03doing something in a measurement.
- 30:06Yeah, great. Is there ever a case to not
- 30:10measure? Have you ever worked on projects
- 30:11for people? Don't they just what they
- 30:12basically believe so wholeheartedly in the visual
- 30:15changes that they're not looking at what the impact is?
- 30:19Yeah, I think, I think there is. I I mean, I definitely think
- 30:22there is. I think, I mean, I wouldn't
- 30:24necessarily say not in fact, no, not, not measure.
- 30:27I think you have to you have to look at the impact of things.
- 30:32But I think, and I think you have to understand, I mean,
- 30:35sometimes you don't if it's absolutely flying, I think you
- 30:38can see people just saying like, you know, this has been a
- 30:40success based on these. Therefore, we're not going to
- 30:43put as much time into really understanding the change, not
- 30:46necessarily saying it's right. But you know, if you've got a
- 30:48lean team and lots of things to do and lots of work to manage
- 30:52off the back, I think I can understand that.
- 30:54I think through a project, if you mean more like is can you
- 30:59just make decisions based on non data LED things?
- 31:04I think you can, as long as you're not making big decisions
- 31:08in my opinion, and you've got the right people involved.
- 31:10I think if you've got people in the project that have done this
- 31:13loads of time before and I've seen something work and it's
- 31:16very clearly kind of fundamental best practice UX.
- 31:19I don't think you have to always have data, but I think you do
- 31:24have to rationalize what you're doing.
- 31:25And I think it's just yeah, being comfortable that there's
- 31:29no risk. And I think in a lot of cases, a
- 31:34lot of it depends like, you know, if you're literally just
- 31:36taking the goal is performance based and you know, modernizing
- 31:42and you know, giving yourself more like tooling to trade the
- 31:46site and you don't manage content and everything else.
- 31:49And you are just literally building a best in class theme
- 31:54or like best in class, I guess. So kind of making sure that you
- 31:58know, again, having your experience, people say that
- 32:02they've seen a positive impact of X and then you've kind of
- 32:04just got a very unsure to usable theme.
- 32:06I don't think you'd need to have absolutely loads of data, but I
- 32:09think if you're, you know, more complex journey, so made to
- 32:13order, for example, or you know, other kind of complex
- 32:18configuration or multi step processes, all of that kind of
- 32:23stuff. And I think the more date you
- 32:24can have, the more the less risk and the more likelihood of
- 32:28uplift you're going to have. But I don't, I feel like you do
- 32:32see a lot of brands go into a redesign of no data and you
- 32:36know, it's it performs very well and I don't judge people for not
- 32:40having that data, but I think the more complexity, the more
- 32:43you're going to benefit from the data.
- 32:45I don't know if you're free with that.
- 32:48For me, nobody should ever do a redesign without measuring it.
- 32:52I think I personally think it's a bonkers thing to do.
- 32:56And if the measure, sorry, even if the measure, yeah, measure,
- 33:02measure an impact because you're spending money and you're making
- 33:05changes to an environment can impact customers positively or
- 33:08negatively and can impact your commercial metrics.
- 33:10So number one, you fundamentally have to measure.
- 33:12But I, I, I do, I do understand your point, which is how
- 33:17detailed and granular do you measure and how much is the
- 33:19measure based on pure commercial metrics versus wider?
- 33:22So, so we, the sentiment piece I think is also important,
- 33:25especially if you are trying to renovate your brand or you're
- 33:31trying to increase engagement with newer customers and educate
- 33:36them around the brand and get them bought into who you are and
- 33:40why you are. So that will influence future
- 33:41purchase journeys, even even just looking at engagement
- 33:46metrics on the site and you know, the classic heat scroll
- 33:49mapping, looking at engagement content and how that correlates
- 33:53into product journeys. But I think the sentiment bit is
- 33:56also important. So where where companies are
- 33:59reviews is obviously a good one, but that's for purchases.
- 34:05The sentiment around that as well of of how are people
- 34:08finding their journeys on the site and some people have exit
- 34:12intent pop ups, which is like how, you know, how would you
- 34:15define the site today tracking that and changes in that.
- 34:19But then the post purchase on the site like MPs style stuff of
- 34:22like you know how likely you to recommend us tracking positive
- 34:25changes in that is also quite a useful one, yeah.
- 34:30Yeah, I completely. And we whenever we launch a PSY,
- 34:34we've obviously got sensors. We'll have a feedback for the
- 34:37first week and we'll ask for feedback on the order
- 34:40confirmation page as you say. And I think that sometimes that
- 34:43can be super helpful, like if nothing else, just for fixing
- 34:46bugs, you don't, you don't usually get anything like crazy
- 34:49valuable to be honest. But yeah, I think anything like
- 34:53that can be really good. And like also a lot of brands
- 34:56have got like a WhatsApp group of top customers, like getting
- 34:58feedback, like it's part of UAT and all of that stuff I think
- 35:02can be or even just, you know, designs for a design process and
- 35:05that can be really useful as well.
- 35:09Yeah, that's, that's a great point actually.
- 35:11I'd completely forgotten about that and I'd already thought
- 35:13about talking about it yesterday.
- 35:14Then that shows how good my memory is.
- 35:16Is that part of, and this sees a lot and re platforming is, is
- 35:22having a group of super users who at the point before you're
- 35:26going live as part of your UAT, you stress test a couple of user
- 35:31journeys and key design changes just to get like instant
- 35:35visceral feedback to help you refine your kind of your, your
- 35:39bug fixing phase. I think that's that's hugely
- 35:42important. And if you're doing like you
- 35:44said before, if you're doing minor changes where maybe you're
- 35:47fixing one particular path, it unless that's a critical
- 35:51conversion path, there's, there's less benefit.
- 35:53But if you're making big changes that are site wide, too visual
- 35:57aesthetic to layout to the type of content, then yeah, that's
- 36:01really helpful. Yeah.
- 36:05So that brings us to the end of our our core questions around
- 36:10measure and sign. I guess the last, the last point
- 36:13I wanted to cover was what are the gotchas for E Com teams?
- 36:16An E Com team that is in a redesign process where the
- 36:19redesign has been led by a brand team, a creative team that so
- 36:23it's not owned by E Com, but the execution is what are the
- 36:27gotchas? What do they need to watch out
- 36:29for? What guardrails do they need to
- 36:30put in place to ensure that they're not compromising the
- 36:34ECOM channel because of design decisions?
- 36:37I think to be honest, it's the measurement side.
- 36:39Like I think upfront knowing what the KPIs are and really
- 36:44thinking about how you're going to identify negative change in
- 36:50any area that's commercial. I think the more granular, not
- 36:54necessarily the more granular you can go, the better.
- 36:56But like thinking about things like new and return and thinking
- 36:59about measurement by traffic source.
- 37:02Because realistically if you want to know if there's an issue
- 37:04like you need a like for like comparison data, I think just
- 37:09getting that whole piece right is the big 1.
- 37:13And I think yeah, beyond that and to be honest, it all comes
- 37:16back to that. But designing for like different
- 37:20types of users and really making sure you're thinking about like
- 37:24what their journeys are as well. But it still comes back to the
- 37:27same point, which is just getting those KPIs and metrics
- 37:30right. And yeah, making sure you're
- 37:35kind of thinking about all of those things when you're making
- 37:37decisions as well. Yeah, Yeah.
- 37:41I think this is the for me, the most important thing from a
- 37:44Garbrail is somebody to have an E com technical oversight in
- 37:48terms of usability, interaction design, accessibility.
- 37:53Don't compromise in those areas. If you know that a, a piece of
- 37:57content, a section, a visual design fundamentally breaks
- 38:01accessibility guidelines or the way that journeys are being
- 38:07designed from a a conceptual point of view is not going to be
- 38:11great from usability and doesn't pay well into like, you know,
- 38:14mobile transitions interactions, then just protect that, flag
- 38:18that back in a collaborative and productive way, but help the
- 38:21designers maintain their creative control, but don't
- 38:24allow them to make decisions that that will adversely impact
- 38:27execution. Yeah.
- 38:30Well, I hope every I've enjoyed that I I I love it because, you
- 38:34know, design is something I always have lots of opinions on,
- 38:36but I always know that there are people who have far smarter than
- 38:39I am making decisions around it, which is why I enjoy working
- 38:42with the creative teams. Anyone listening who, anything
- 38:47that you want to challenge or anything you disagree of or
- 38:49anything that you would advise, like how do you make redesign
- 38:53successful? How do you measure it?
- 38:54What's the right way of getting this balance?
- 38:57Do reach out. Do you let us know.
- 38:58We'd love to hear it. And keep your ears peeled for
- 39:01next week's episode. Take care everyone.
- 39:05You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 39:08experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 39:11Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 39:13featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 39:16industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 39:19explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 39:21and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 39:24really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 39:27help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and tech stack.
- 39:30Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 39:33like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 39:35We hope you enjoy the latest episode.