Latest / Teachers Talk Radio / "Reward Over Sanction" - The Headteacher who says he cut suspensions by 85%: The Twilight Show with Tony Harwood and Yannick Berland
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to TKO Talk Radio! Thank you for listening!
- 0:20Ready to make an impact beyond the classroom? AQA is looking for teachers like
- 0:25you to become examiners this summer.
- 0:28You'll build your CPD, strengthen your understanding of the mark scheme and
- 0:32gain fresh insights to enhance your teaching.
- 0:35It's flexible paid work that fits around your commitments with full training
- 0:39from our experts and ongoing support from an experienced team leader.
- 0:44Whether you're an early careers teacher or have years of classroom experience,
- 0:48examining with AQA is a valuable way
- 0:51to develop your knowledge and join a community of subject
- 0:54specialists join AQA as an examiner this
- 0:58summer visit aqa.org.uk forward
- 1:02slash apply today this show is brought to you in partnership with hash it learning
- 1:06publishers are professional development books and resources that support great
- 1:10teaching and learning in schools around the world level up your professional
- 1:14development today and visit hashitlearning.com to explore the full range of titles.
- 1:19Good evening educators and welcome to The Twilight Show here on Teachers Talk Radio.
- 1:26I've been looking forward to this one guys because it gives me an opportunity
- 1:30to catch up with a former colleague and someone who I admired.
- 1:34Yannick is with me as usual as my co-host and we're with you for the next hour
- 1:40guys and we're just going to be getting into a couple of juicy topics and things
- 1:45that can be a little bit divisive and controversial.
- 1:48We don't like to be deliberately divisive and controversial but it is interesting to provoke debate.
- 1:56If you're watching this thank you and welcome. Obviously if you're an educator
- 2:00or somebody with a vested interest in education, a parent, a governor,
- 2:06a teacher, a consultant or whatever your role is, welcome and I hope there's
- 2:13something for you that you can take away this evening.
- 2:16So there's no particular script this evening, it's just three gentlemen talking
- 2:23about their experience in education.
- 2:25I'm going to introduce our guests
- 2:29as I've mentioned Jono Jonathan Sands
- 2:32is our guest today head teacher and former
- 2:36colleague of mine and yeah with what's going to be interesting because Jono's
- 2:43strength as far as I can remember working with Jono was this sort of people-centered
- 2:50approach I quite liked your people-centred approach,
- 2:53Jono, and how you used to think about the best way and the best balance when
- 2:58it comes to managing students.
- 3:01Obviously, those management skills extend beyond that as well.
- 3:06And, yeah, I don't know which is easier to manage.
- 3:09Maybe we won't go there tonight, but we'll see what comes up.
- 3:13So it's just one of those things, guys. We're just going to be talking about our opinions.
- 3:18And I just want to thank Jono very much for coming on I know that you're a head
- 3:23teacher and it goes without saying that you have a packed calendar but I've
- 3:27really looked forward to this one because I know you know knowing,
- 3:30what I know about yourself you will have some really interesting
- 3:34things to bring to this topic so what
- 3:37we're getting into guys just going to give a little sort of intro about
- 3:40what we're getting into I mean you might well have already seen hopefully
- 3:43the things that I've put out on socials and
- 3:46the guest card and everything that's on there so
- 3:49there's two sort of main things I want to get
- 3:52into really and the first one which we're going
- 3:54to start to touch on a minute in a minute is this
- 3:58well binaries was the main sort of thrust but
- 4:01the first one was this idea and it's a debate that
- 4:04will go on and on and on the best way to manage
- 4:07students if that's if that word
- 4:10is even allowed language can be a bit of an issue when you're talking about
- 4:14these things when you're on x and i do spend a bit probably a bit too long on
- 4:20x if i'm honest but it can generate some interesting things i mean through x
- 4:25i met yannick i met tom rogers i met the ttr guys.
- 4:30And we started doing and when i started doing this a year ago and it's just
- 4:34interesting to get into these things i know that some people are a little bit
- 4:37worried about saying the wrong thing,
- 4:40but i just want to sort of say to people if you would like to come
- 4:43on to speak and give your opinions you're
- 4:47more than welcome if you are watching this
- 4:50now and you would like to comment there is a comment function so
- 4:53whether you're watching this on linkedin or facebook or
- 4:56youtube or x we're across those
- 4:59four platforms live and even after the
- 5:02event you can find me on socials if you'd like to sort of pick up the thread
- 5:07of what we're saying put your opinion across but we can if you'd like to comment
- 5:11live that you and you're watching this there'll be a comment box down somewhere
- 5:15underneath the screen we're watching this you can put a comment in i can bring
- 5:18that comment up on the screen and we can maybe address that live.
- 5:22So anyway, I'm going to be speaking
- 5:24to Jono in just a minute because I'm interested to learn a bit about,
- 5:28what Jono does at his school because I know something that you described as
- 5:33a reward over sanction, I believe, Jono.
- 5:37So again, thank you so much for coming on.
- 5:40Do you think that will upset quite a few people rewards over sanctions?
- 5:44Some people might be upset by that.
- 5:46Well, it seems to me that whichever direction you go in,
- 5:50some people are going to be a little bit upset by
- 5:53that and obviously yeah right yeah it will
- 5:56i don't know i i wouldn't like to think that
- 5:59we up upset people but you never really know
- 6:02so what's your
- 6:04feeling Jono then in terms of the fact that
- 6:07we have this balance to strike between
- 6:11well what some people might call punitive rules
- 6:14and a more like restorative or
- 6:17therapeutic sort of approach and understanding students where
- 6:20they're coming from particularly set needs and so on yeah so
- 6:24where do you think we should sit
- 6:27sort of on that schools should sit on that continuum yeah
- 6:31i think it's a really good question firstly just thank you for having me on
- 6:34it's a privilege to catch up with you again and to just talk about you know
- 6:40something that's actually quite dear to me i think if i if you were to ask me
- 6:44that question maybe in the sort first 12 years of my.
- 6:50My career, I would probably sit somewhere quite centrally in that debate.
- 6:56I would say actually there are things that should be sanctioned and there are
- 7:00things that maybe shouldn't be, and we should look at other approaches.
- 7:05My own school went through lots of different approaches for behaviour and restorative
- 7:12justice came in when it was all the rage and we did our circle time and all
- 7:17of the other things that come along with that.
- 7:20But I think probably since becoming
- 7:24a head teacher, I think the key thing always is context, isn't it?
- 7:28It's the context of your school and what your school needs at that particular
- 7:32moment. And it doesn't necessarily mean that it's going to be forever.
- 7:36You know, it's what's right now in order to achieve what we need to achieve
- 7:43with the cohorts that we've got.
- 7:45And I think in my current setting, you know, I sort of picked up a school that
- 7:52had maybe been through quite a few different, you know.
- 7:57Methods, structures, and behavior that perhaps hadn't been particularly successful.
- 8:02And I think they were more along the lines of zero tolerance.
- 8:06And I think the school that I inherited, the whole community,
- 8:10you just were not bought into that, didn't understand it, and were quite against it.
- 8:15And you've got to really, as a leadership team, you've got to look at that and
- 8:20think, how are we going to work together?
- 8:22What is it? What is that that's going to shift it.
- 8:25And for us, it was that reward over sanction policy.
- 8:30It's quite a brave move, I think, to be fair.
- 8:34And just to explain what that might be, you know, because I think it might baffle
- 8:39some people, but reward over sanction for us means that we have a house system,
- 8:45just like every other school, I'm sure,
- 8:48where they collect house points, reward points.
- 8:52But rather than sanction the
- 8:55things such as if a student doesn't
- 8:59bring their PE kit we don't give them a
- 9:01detention if they do bring their
- 9:04PE kit we give them house points if they
- 9:07haven't done their homework we don't give them a detention but
- 9:10if they have done their homework we give them reward points and what
- 9:14this is really is positive reinforcement it's saying
- 9:18we want to reward the students that
- 9:21do the right things every single day and we
- 9:25want to center the majority of our
- 9:27attention and that's really hard on those kids and we want to put so much attention
- 9:35on those kids that other kids want to do the same thing because they see how
- 9:39much teacher attention they're getting you know and positive attention as well
- 9:43but to have a successful system like that you need to.
- 9:49Good they've got
- 9:52to be good it's in can you can you sustain
- 9:55that kind i've i've worked in schools where the
- 9:58rewards were just silly we were talking
- 10:01about mp3 players and all
- 10:04all that kind of things is that what you're talking about no we
- 10:07don't first of all we have a progressive approach so
- 10:10obviously the year seven rewards are
- 10:14I would say much lower cost than the
- 10:18rewards in year 10 and year 11 and
- 10:21what we do is we sort of build up that as we go through
- 10:24so it's never the same thing as they go through the
- 10:27year groups but and Tony will know this because I did try
- 10:31and do something very similar with him but bronze silver
- 10:34gold platinum and then diamond in
- 10:37terms of the number of points so it's 1500
- 10:40for a bronze it's 5000 for diamond and at
- 10:44each point so diamond in year seven eight
- 10:47nine and ten is the reward trip so if
- 10:51they get that they get to go at the end of the
- 10:54year and we will pay for that trip but leading
- 10:57up to that obviously in year seven they're motivated for something
- 11:01as simple as a badge you know and and want
- 11:04to get their bronze silver gold when we start to sort of get into year.
- 11:06Eight we're offering sweet boxes pizza parties
- 11:10queue jumps when we sort of get into year nine and year 10 we're starting to
- 11:16sort of head into sort of vouchers the biggest voucher we give is in year 10
- 11:21and that's for a platinum award when that's a 20 pound voucher now when we get
- 11:27to year 11 and this is the most interesting one And again,
- 11:30this is going to split your listeners down the middle, I'm sure, and parents.
- 11:35But year 11s need to get gold to go to prom.
- 11:39So they need 3 000 points but if they
- 11:42get platinum then they get a vip
- 11:45treatment at prom and if
- 11:49they get a diamond we will pay for their ticket to go
- 11:52to prom and for a community like
- 11:55ours and we we have quite a high level of disadvantage that
- 11:59that is real reward and it is sustainable it
- 12:03is sustainable because we're not just giving these points out willy-nilly they
- 12:06they have to work for them and they really do and
- 12:09again we're able to use this system because
- 12:12the students are so bought into the system we're able
- 12:15to use it strategically as well so if we
- 12:18notice let's say that later the lessons is
- 12:21starting to pick up we can do reward weeks where
- 12:24we say if you're on time for all your lessons this week
- 12:27you'll get bonus points you know if we
- 12:30are doing anything particular that we think
- 12:32actually we really want to engage with it we will incentivize it
- 12:36through giving sort of bonuses for those things so
- 12:39again it's a real strategic tool that
- 12:42has kind of helped and and i guess the proof's in
- 12:45the pudding right so we've reduced suspensions by 85 percent amazing we yeah
- 12:51and it's significant it's significant and you know we are talking at our highest
- 12:58sanction for sort of what you would call your everyday behaviors is a half an
- 13:02hour at after school detention.
- 13:05Now, that's it. Now, obviously, we have a reflection room or an isolation room
- 13:10or whatever you want to call it.
- 13:12But they are only really for those very high-level babies.
- 13:16And after-school detention, you know, you'll be lucky if you've got 12 kids in there.
- 13:22Wow. I mean, that's brilliant, everything you said there.
- 13:27What sort of came to mind as you were talking there, Jono, was this idea,
- 13:31what came into my head, was the students who don't get rewarded for always doing
- 13:36the right thing every single day.
- 13:38And then the students who those kids
- 13:42have to see getting rewarded for doing
- 13:45something they should have been doing for one day yeah but
- 13:48the rest of the term they've been disrupted lessons
- 13:51so it's yeah i mean the first
- 13:54thing that comes to me is sort of psychologically and also
- 13:58you're platforming the students for doing the
- 14:01right thing rather than platforming
- 14:04the ones who aren't doing the right thing in a more
- 14:07dare i say punitive way um so
- 14:11yeah i mean i think that's that's fantastic and as
- 14:14you said people might then say well
- 14:17that won't work in context a context b and it
- 14:20is context dependent i don't know for a fact john though
- 14:22that you've worked in contexts that are not straightforward as well
- 14:26let's say if we can say that much um but yeah so yeah that's really interesting
- 14:32I think the the other thing to add there is that obviously this was all implemented
- 14:37pre new Ofsted framework and now with you know inclusion at the heart of that framework.
- 14:47This is very inclusive. And actually, punitive approaches are largely centred
- 14:54on disadvantaged or double disadvantaged students because, you know,
- 14:59say they haven't brought their PE kit.
- 15:01There could be reasons for that, you know, and they haven't done their homework.
- 15:05There could be reasons for that.
- 15:06And equally, you know, we talk about this sense of belonging.
- 15:10I mean we've had Essex County in doing an
- 15:13inclusion review just this this year
- 15:17and one of the things they said was that sense of belonging the kids are completely
- 15:21bought into it and it is one of the things that keeps them coming into school
- 15:25and feeling that sense of pride so again it you know we need to build those
- 15:31positive relationships it is an inclusive policy and,
- 15:35But it is a daring one as well. And I think there's lots of people that feel
- 15:39that there's perhaps taking an element of control away. And it really isn't.
- 15:43So it's quite interesting because obviously we don't hear enough of those stories, actually.
- 15:50Do you think, so why can't everybody do what you're doing?
- 15:54Because actually, I think deep down, that's what I would want.
- 16:00And I've never seen it work. And I don't believe that it works.
- 16:05Obviously, I'm wrong because you are someone who's doing it in your school.
- 16:08Do you think everybody can do that?
- 16:11I think so. I think there's a balance. Don't get me wrong.
- 16:14It's not that we are a zero-sanctioned school. So we still have the lesson behaviors
- 16:20of verbal warning, word outside, relocation if it goes wrong.
- 16:26And they get behavior points for that.
- 16:29Now, again, we use behavior points in a strategic way.
- 16:34So you know if you have a number of behavior points and you want to go on our
- 16:40ski trip you won't be going yeah and so we we build that as part of and parcel of what we do so it is.
- 16:48The thing that we always talk about in school is currency the
- 16:51currency of a reward point the currency of a
- 16:54behavior point if you get the currency right and
- 16:58the balance right then that's how it can work
- 17:01in any school but the currency will be
- 17:04different the currency will be different in my school as it is to
- 17:07yours and it's for the leadership team to
- 17:10find that that tipping point that break-even point of where each of those need
- 17:16to sit in order to achieve what you need to achieve with your community so you
- 17:20said um it's quite interesting so before you became the head of that school
- 17:24did you did you have an idea of what you were going to do and did it change Thank you.
- 17:30Do you know what? I certainly didn't join this school with a view of implementing this policy.
- 17:36But I think as soon as I hit the ground running and I started to understand
- 17:41and to listen to our students,
- 17:43to listen to our parents, to listen to the local community, it was clear that
- 17:48that sort of zero tolerance approach was never going to work.
- 17:53Now obviously you could say well you've gone from hard right to hard left.
- 17:59And there may be some rebalancing to do at some point but
- 18:02at this stage I've got no evidence to suggest that we
- 18:04will need to do that because we've got
- 18:07happy students we've got improved behaviors we've got
- 18:10improved outcomes we've got improved attendance our PPG
- 18:13attendance has improved beyond belief this
- 18:16year our send attendance is the best it's been since
- 18:20COVID so something is
- 18:23is right and something's happening for those kids and
- 18:26i say is it just i don't think it'd just be this school you
- 18:30know as i say it could be any school but i
- 18:34don't want to preempt but one of your listeners has
- 18:37asked logistically how can it be recorded and monitored we record it on edulink
- 18:43edulink is a platform that links to we have arbor here but it does link to sims
- 18:49And it's very easy to upload and put on points for your classes,
- 18:54but it's a one-stop shop.
- 18:56I don't want to advertise it on here, obviously, because I'm not on commission,
- 18:59but it certainly works for us.
- 19:01It's not burdensome for staff at all to put them on. It's very quick and can
- 19:05be done with their register.
- 19:07Okay, thank you for that, Paul. And yeah, thanks for picking that up, actually.
- 19:11Yeah, that saved me a job there, Jono. But yeah, I suppose, yeah,
- 19:15the issue can be if there's a lot of students to put on.
- 19:19But at the end of the day, I am really feeling for those students who every
- 19:24day are doing the right thing and unnecessarily getting those rewards.
- 19:27So I just want to mention before we go on, there's another couple of comments on there.
- 19:32Somebody's not too happy with
- 19:34the word inclusion there. So we'll maybe look at that one in a minute.
- 19:37And inclusion is very much part of the focus
- 19:40for the new off-step frameworks i think and there's
- 19:43been stuff recently in the press about that as well
- 19:46i just want to mention before we move on that this show has two sponsors that
- 19:52i'd like to just talk about just briefly before we move on with our discussion
- 19:56and the first one is aqa because if you're interested in perhaps becoming an
- 20:01examiner it might be something that will strengthen your understanding of mark scheme.
- 20:06And gain fresh insights to enhance your teaching so
- 20:09if you'd like to be an examiner it's flexible paid work
- 20:12that can fit around your commitments you'll get full training from
- 20:15experts ongoing support from an experienced team leader so
- 20:18whether you're an early careers teacher or have years of
- 20:21experience examining with AQA is a valuable way to
- 20:24develop your knowledge so if you'd like to are
- 20:27you interested in doing that and visit aqa.org slash
- 20:30apply our second uh long-term
- 20:33sponsors of teachers talk radio is
- 20:36hashette learning and this show is
- 20:39also brought to you in partnership with their they publishes professional development
- 20:43books and resources that support great teaching and learning in schools around
- 20:48the world so level up your professional development today and visit their website
- 20:52www.hashettelearning.com where you can explore the full range of titles.
- 20:59So, yeah, there was a few things that I was going to mention.
- 21:02Again, yeah, it's just trying to sort of get.
- 21:06My thoughts together on what actually I want to ask, because time goes so quickly on these shows.
- 21:11You mentioned something that you touched on, which we might mention later,
- 21:14Jono, if we get a chance, is you mentioned right wing, left wing.
- 21:17And I want to pick up on that at some point, because there's a bit of a push
- 21:23to suggest that rules in themselves are,
- 21:29I don't know, I wouldn't want to say right wing, but somebody said to me,
- 21:34centralised detention systems.
- 21:35This is something i wanted to ask both of you but someone
- 21:40actually said to me online and i'm not going to mention any names
- 21:43at this stage but there's certain people who do who
- 21:46i do interact with online and it's
- 21:49not always people who i always agree with and i find that
- 21:51can be useful if that person wants to engage in a
- 21:54constructive way but someone said to me that they think centralized behavior
- 21:58systems in themselves are behaviorist and
- 22:03that centralized systems take away the opportunity for
- 22:07restorative type conversations and
- 22:11that kind of struck a bit of a chord with me because i've
- 22:14been i think for for quite some time now i've worked in schools where behavior
- 22:19has been moved centrally and there's a centralized system my feeling's always
- 22:24been that that probably is the best way but the argument that people might make
- 22:29is that takes away the opportunity and the ownership that.
- 22:33And the relationship that that teacher might have with the students.
- 22:39So I thought I might ask you that, Jono, and maybe see if Yannick,
- 22:42see what you think as well. But what's your thoughts on that?
- 22:45Is a centralised behaviour system the way to go, do you think?
- 22:51I think, you know, before I had a teacher and still now I'm a music teacher.
- 22:57So, you know, when detentions are not centralised and I'm teaching 400 kids
- 23:04a fortnight and I've got to logistically organise,
- 23:09However many detentions out of those 400 kids that haven't met expectations
- 23:13in my classrooms during that week, it's very different to perhaps an English
- 23:18teacher, a maths teacher, a science teacher that might have a vastly reduced number.
- 23:23It also, I think, if you don't have central systems,
- 23:28then you do disadvantage a number
- 23:31of your colleagues that may be the ones
- 23:35that are taking the lower sets the middle sets the
- 23:38ones that may be taking a you know a bit of a
- 23:41hit in the department you know in certain year groups
- 23:44and their time is taken up and time is
- 23:47precious right time is precious now the
- 23:50argument here is is a detention effective without
- 23:54the conversation that's really what we're saying is it
- 23:58is a detention effective if you don't have
- 24:00that restorative conversation with a member of staff now
- 24:04for me I think there's
- 24:07there's lots of different and very quick ways to solve
- 24:10that I mean we do have a centralized half an hour detention after school we
- 24:14do invite staff to come down and and make that have that conversation and lots
- 24:19of them do take up that opportunity but if they're in a meeting or if they're
- 24:23in a you know a CPD or if they're somewhere else that time is precious too.
- 24:28So actually just a very quick conversation
- 24:31on the door the next lesson to say look I know things
- 24:34didn't go well last time but it's going to be better this time
- 24:37this is what we're going to do I think you know often we
- 24:40just need to kind of forgive and forget we've got to remember these are kids
- 24:44and you know we know from our own children that they don't always make the best
- 24:51decisions they're not the most considerate at times they are selfish by nature
- 24:55and we sometimes forget that in this kind of.
- 25:00I think there's a, there's a, I think among some staff, there is this need to win.
- 25:05There is a need to win and we win by sanctioning heavily and making them feel
- 25:12the weight of that poor decision that they made in my lesson,
- 25:15which I'd spent so much time planning.
- 25:18Whereas actually it doesn't mean that much to the kids and actually, you know,
- 25:23it will go a much bigger way if you just kind of
- 25:26caught up with them in the corridor and next break time and said
- 25:29look i didn't want to send you out can we
- 25:32try again i mean that
- 25:34to me is all that's needed but again it's
- 25:38just where you sit on that there must be a conversation
- 25:41yeah and i think it's obviously that that's controversial in itself i did have
- 25:46a little look at the restorative practice because one of the things i was aware
- 25:50of is that it seems to be a thing more of a thing in scotland and I think the
- 25:56truth of that is it's just something that maybe started or was done first in Scotland.
- 26:01So some people will say Scotland is a mess because they're all doing restorative
- 26:05practice, which I don't think is necessarily true, but I think it's something that maybe started off.
- 26:10I just want to thank Barry because Barry's communicating with us and put a few
- 26:14comments in and some of them, yeah, he's got some quite clear sort of opinions.
- 26:21So thank you, Barry. That is what it's all about.
- 26:24Now, one of the ones that I wanted to just bring up that Barry's put in was
- 26:28this idea of left and right.
- 26:31It's not left and right to me. Centralized is not behaviorist.
- 26:35I mean, yeah, I mean, I agree with that. I mean, this idea of labeling things
- 26:39can be counterproductive as well, actually.
- 26:42I think just the general labels that we give things that then become either good or bad.
- 26:48And then the discourse, you know. I agree, Tony.
- 26:51I think people label things to be able to criticize, it's easier if you label
- 26:56something, then you can criticize it, it works your way, which you're right,
- 27:00you need a system, whatever you call it, you need a system that works.
- 27:03I agree, centralized system just does make sense, something that makes sense for everybody.
- 27:11I mean, I particularly like the way, you know, a few things that you've said,
- 27:16which is quite refreshing, really, because, you know, I kind of consider myself,
- 27:20I'm actually feeling really bad listening to you because I tend to be quite
- 27:26strict and quite on that line.
- 27:30So, you know, the things like staff need to win. I do think you're right.
- 27:37I think what you're doing though does does
- 27:42need must require quite some
- 27:45work in terms of communication because you're right you need
- 27:48to change your mindset i absolutely love the
- 27:51way what you're saying in your school your inclusion in your
- 27:54school basically your school is inclusive and
- 27:56if students don't want to be included they really
- 28:00have to make an effort to opt out of that i really love
- 28:03the idea where you flip things around actually you know what if you
- 28:06don't really want to be part of this that's gonna
- 28:10take some effort from you and of course you know
- 28:13the the second thing rewards and i mean i was i was asking you on the you know
- 28:17like is it sustainable but actually i you know i know that kids always love
- 28:24rewards and you're right a reward is a stamp i got stamps and kids always ask
- 28:29me for a stamp that goes up to year 11 stickers so.
- 28:34You know the only thing that people could
- 28:37challenge you and I'm going to ask that challenging question
- 28:40why are you rewarding kids for things that really are expected because that's
- 28:46not how life works I'm not rewarded for being a good citizen so why are we doing
- 28:51that in school why are you why have you decided to do this I guess it's that I think,
- 28:58Your counter-argument there is basically that we have certain expectations of
- 29:03students when they come into school and they should just do them. Yeah.
- 29:08And the problem then falls is if they don't do them, what do we do?
- 29:14Yeah. And that's it, isn't it? And I agree with you to some extent,
- 29:20but then if we're not going to spend time actually teaching the students why
- 29:26we're doing certain things and what's the purpose, we're just going to expect it.
- 29:31I mean, you must know, like from all of the one plans that are probably that
- 29:36you have for each of your classes, there is not there's not one of them that
- 29:41says, don't worry, they will just meet your expectations.
- 29:47Is that it's not none of them say that what they'll say is you need to explicitly state,
- 29:54what it is you need them to do and then
- 29:57re-explain it and then come back and check on them
- 30:00in five minutes time to make sure that they they still understand it so again
- 30:04you're you're basically saying yes there look there probably are 70 70 percent
- 30:11of kids that will come in and just meet expectations regardless of what policy
- 30:15you put in place but what you've got to decide,
- 30:19in your community in your context is how do I want to shift the 30 percent.
- 30:25Do I want to do it through positive reinforcement or do I want to do it through
- 30:30sanctioning or do I want a bit of both?
- 30:34And obviously you need to lay that out from the beginning, don't you? Yeah, sorry, Yannick.
- 30:41You're incredibly right. And I think, you know, you said how you shift the 30%.
- 30:44Actually, it's probably a lot less than that. Wouldn't you agree?
- 30:48We're probably talking about 15%. And I think there again, it's a very important
- 30:53point. I think it's our human nature or teacher nature to focus on punishing
- 30:59those, actually, rather than... I love that.
- 31:03And yeah, I really like hearing that because it's not something that's in my
- 31:10blood, if you know what I mean. So that's quite interesting.
- 31:15I don't think it's many people's blood. And I think, you know,
- 31:18those that have been in education for longer than five minutes have probably
- 31:22been through so many alliterations of varying different policies that,
- 31:26you know, we've probably kept the best bits of what we think is right.
- 31:30And we implement that, you know, in what we would deem to be an experienced,
- 31:35as an experienced practitioner.
- 31:38But I think that on a friendly level of just in the classroom is fine.
- 31:43But what we're talking really here is about whole school approaches.
- 31:46And you know yes it does
- 31:49take a little bit of staff buy-in it does take training it
- 31:52does take you know re-educating staff
- 31:55on some times where they perhaps have tried to win in a situation and you've
- 32:01had to sort of take it back with them and say look this is why we have this
- 32:04approach you've tried to win with this student let me just tell you a bit about
- 32:09what's going on at home with that student right now do you still want to win?
- 32:14Or you've already won, as far as I'm concerned.
- 32:18You are a middle-class teacher earning a decent salary. That's controversial as well.
- 32:27You know, you've won. You've already won.
- 32:31What I really like as well, what you said that I really like,
- 32:35and I think that's maybe perhaps some of the people who tend to be on the rest of the team,
- 32:41you do accept actually that they are
- 32:43kids and they don't always make the right decision and they don't
- 32:46always have the best intention and i think that is also very important to recognize
- 32:50because i think some people like tony you will agree with me some people think
- 32:54the kids can never make any they they always get things right so i can't i mean
- 32:59i think that's the balance that you have which is quite interesting is one recognizing
- 33:03actually that they are kids and ask as kids they
- 33:06do make bad decisions.
- 33:08And I just want to... You are meeting the needs actually as kids that they're
- 33:19not going to be punished, but they're going to be encouraged to... To do the right thing.
- 33:23To obtain, yes, to do the right thing. So that's quite refreshing I think.
- 33:28Refreshing. I think what I like about... I'm loving how much this is affecting you, Yannick.
- 33:35But it is yeah what i
- 33:38think trying to get inside a student's head is they're
- 33:42used to getting told off but i don't i think sometimes they do
- 33:45genuinely not always know why and i find little things like if you give a student
- 33:51a warning or whenever it is a c1 or whatever it is if you just just add or you
- 33:57say c1 is he talking you're talking over me or something like that and you've
- 34:01just given a little bit of context.
- 34:03Because I think what sometimes is missing is students just think,
- 34:07oh, we're teachers, we tell them off.
- 34:08They don't really fully understand why. I'm not saying they need to understand
- 34:11why, because they may not have the capacity to fully comprehend certain rules.
- 34:17But there is certainly something to be said for them having a little bit of
- 34:22context to what we're trying to achieve and seeing the bigger picture of that.
- 34:26And I don't know if students always have that. the other thing i wanted to ask
- 34:30though uh jonno was just a bit of devil's advocate,
- 34:34do any parents come to you and say if my
- 34:37son or daughter's not getting on this reward trip that's
- 34:41not inclusive or what if my son or
- 34:44daughter has a particular need that might make it more difficult for
- 34:47them to get to the standard of going on that
- 34:50trip what would you sort of do or say in a
- 34:53situation like that i mean
- 34:56that is headship what you've
- 34:59just described there's always you know
- 35:02but essentially what you're saying is can you
- 35:05align a community of thousands of parents
- 35:08to accept every decision that you make as gospel that's an impossible task there
- 35:17are always going to be people within community that don't fully align but i
- 35:21think one of the things that we do really well is we pre-communicate.
- 35:28What we are and what we do so if you come to
- 35:31my open evening i invite you all to
- 35:34my open evening in september you will hear
- 35:37the same message that i've delivered for the
- 35:40last two years it will be the same powerpoint i
- 35:44might change my picture because i probably look a bit older now but
- 35:47the you know it will it will basically say this
- 35:50is what we are and this is what we do and if that is
- 35:53going to fit with you and align with you come please come
- 35:56and be part of it because we want you join a longer family i think
- 36:00it's where you have this chop and
- 36:03change and i think you know i mean we've spent
- 36:06a lot on a time on sanctions and
- 36:09rewards and i know tony you wanted to discuss literally
- 36:12the whole of education in this hour but the that i
- 36:17think the point here and the point i would like to make about binaries
- 36:20altogether is you know where do
- 36:23they come from and i've been really thinking about
- 36:26this since you invited me on you know where why
- 36:30do binaries exist why do we have to go that
- 36:33side or that side why is it not okay to be in the center and my answer is and
- 36:41I think it all comes down to that a word it's accountability and the accountability
- 36:48pressures that are put on results.
- 36:52The accountability pressures that are put on KPIs, the accountability pressures
- 36:58that are put on you as an individual.
- 37:02Let's say, Tony, I appoint you as my new assistant head of teaching and learning.
- 37:07I don't have a vacancy. But if I did, you'd come in and you are going to want
- 37:14to make impact. How do you make impact?
- 37:18How do you show impact immediately?
- 37:20Well, you go in the complete opposite direction of what's just happened.
- 37:25In school, you change things up, you freshen it up, and it looks really good
- 37:30for the next couple of years.
- 37:32Because all of a sudden, you know, you've brought in this direct instruction,
- 37:37we're all doing it in class, we're all doing as we're told, you're coming around
- 37:40and monitoring it, you've done all of your, you know, quality assurance to make
- 37:45sure that we're doing it, you've proved that.
- 37:48You know, rightly so, I'm paying you to do a good job, well done.
- 37:53You would hope that outcomes follow but that's
- 37:58largely what I for me why we end up with these binaries
- 38:01we have I would say as a profession
- 38:04we are quite insecure about one
- 38:08our own beliefs two about what everyone thinks
- 38:12others are thinking and three
- 38:15what perhaps the community and the school need we're
- 38:18very insecure about these things and actually it's much
- 38:22better to go do you know what we're going down this way because I've
- 38:25read this book it's research informed therefore this
- 38:28is why we're all doing it this is how I'm going
- 38:31to prove impact and it's going to give that sense of
- 38:34safety of me that I am making impact in this school and
- 38:38I think that's largely where these binaries do come from I think when you're
- 38:42safe in your skin when you're safe in a in a supportive SLT structure perhaps
- 38:47with a supportive trust who give you the autonomy that you need in a school
- 38:52I think you can start to shift these around towards centre.
- 38:58And back out again, depending on what's needed within the school context.
- 39:02Yeah, that's a really good point. Yeah, everything you've said there,
- 39:06basically, is a pretty good summary in a nutshell of what goes on on social media.
- 39:12And you can understand headteachers. I've never done the job,
- 39:16Jono. I'm pretty sure I probably never will, if I'm honest.
- 39:20But I don't know what it's like. I think I put a comment.
- 39:23I was reaching the other day for what it might be like, and I think I'd said
- 39:26something like, it's a job where,
- 39:28everyone else always knows better than you do so yeah
- 39:32everyone who's never done it wants to tell you how to do
- 39:34it it's basically a bit I suppose it's a bit like a football fan criticizing
- 39:38a football manager but I mean I'm just while I I just want to mention our sponsors
- 39:42again and while I'm doing that I'm just going to put this comment on the screen
- 39:45and then we might start to talk a little bit about DI and direct instruction
- 39:49discovery and then things like that as well because obviously, yeah,
- 39:54we've got 20 minutes to go. We can obviously go a little bit over if we need to.
- 39:58I just want to mention that AQA sponsor our show.
- 40:02They're looking for teachers like you to become examiners this summer.
- 40:05You'll build your CPD, strengthen your understanding of the Marks Game,
- 40:08gain fresh insights to enhance your teaching.
- 40:11It's flexible paid work that fits around your commitments with full training
- 40:16from our experts and ongoing support from an experienced team leader.
- 40:20So if you want to get involved in being an examiner with AQA,
- 40:24it doesn't matter if you're a new teacher or if you had years of experience,
- 40:27because full training is given, so you can go to aqa.org.
- 40:32Dot uk slash apply and you can look into becoming
- 40:36an examiner with aqa this summer
- 40:39the other one i want to mention is hashette
- 40:42learning because this show is up to you in partnership with these publishers
- 40:46but professional development books and resources so this is hashette learning
- 40:50if you'd like to get involved and look at some books and do some leveling up
- 40:55for your professional development but when you do take jono's advice and don't
- 40:58just implement everything you read make a contextual.
- 41:03Decision which is very good advice i would say but
- 41:06if you'd like to have a look into hash at learning there's
- 41:09some great stuff in there's several books i have had a
- 41:12look at myself in there and that's hash
- 41:15at learning.com and you can have a look at
- 41:17the titles that they've got there so i'll just obviously thank
- 41:21you paula who's commented from linkedin
- 41:24behavior management sometimes focus on what not to do if
- 41:27we focus on being explicit about what we want to see
- 41:30from our students and explain our expectations are
- 41:33not fully met we can create the condition for students to get
- 41:35it right i mean do we yeah maybe we don't narrate our
- 41:39expectations and the reasons for those expectations enough
- 41:43perhaps so yeah so
- 41:46if we just we've got because we're running
- 41:49a bit short time we did touch on this idea of
- 41:52what we got 17 minutes we did
- 41:55touch on this idea of progs and trads i don't really
- 41:58know if i want to go there i don't think i'm quite ready to go there yet but
- 42:02direct instruction i've wanted to talk about this for quite some time because
- 42:07i follow some big names on twitter i'm not going to mention any names at this
- 42:11point in time but direct instruction or explicit instruction i'm not really
- 42:16sure what the correct name is,
- 42:18is becoming very popular some people are sort of saying it's the only way to
- 42:24teach if you're not doing it, you're wasting all the students' time.
- 42:29And so on discovery learning and student-led
- 42:32learning is a complete waste of time again i think it
- 42:35goes back to what you touched on already jonah where
- 42:38you said about things going in cycles and
- 42:41opposites and people wanting to make impact and therefore wanting
- 42:44to do the opposite of what's happened before because i
- 42:47remember a time when people were saying you need to make lessons as student-led
- 42:51as you possibly can and there's too much teacher input too much teacher speak
- 42:56like some of you just go round and round and round as we all know but and and
- 43:01i suppose the other thing is
- 43:02if you get teachers in a room and you sit them down and you talk to them,
- 43:06you're generally not that far off a consensus are
- 43:09you that's the other thing i don't know whether people exaggerate for
- 43:12effect but what are we thinking so so
- 43:15what's your thoughts jonah are you a fan of direct instruction and i suppose
- 43:21rose and rose and shine's principles and all the other things that go with that
- 43:24or do you believe there's still a place for discovery learning what's your your
- 43:29overarching feelings on that i'm a fan of teacher autonomy,
- 43:36yes i like it that's it in a nutshell yeah.
- 43:43Look again i'll come back to my own background i'm a music teacher now there
- 43:48are elements where I can use direct instruction to teach music,
- 43:54of course I can, you know,
- 43:57It's right or wrong whether that note is an E or not. It's right or wrong whether
- 44:01that note is a minim or not.
- 44:03Okay, and I can teach that information explicitly.
- 44:06I can use Boson Science Principles till I'm blue in the face,
- 44:11bringing it back week after week, month after month, and making sure that it's
- 44:15fully embedded. Of course I can.
- 44:17But let's not forget that there is an element of my course that is composition,
- 44:23which is basically you've got to create your own piece of music.
- 44:27Now, if I use direct instruction, I'll be breaching JCQ guidelines because I
- 44:34can't tell them what to write.
- 44:35I can't tell them what to compose. I can tell them how, and I can show them
- 44:40how, but that's going to be different and unique for everyone. And if I'm too direct...
- 44:46Then all of my compositions are going to sound the same. And then I'm also going
- 44:50to get a phone call from the examiner to say, why all your coursework sounds very similar?
- 44:55And I think, you know, you've touched on the fact that actually within science,
- 44:58there are elements where there should be some form of discovery.
- 45:02Because I don't know about you, but I love discovering things and I love doing
- 45:07it myself. And I don't want, with respect, some bloke in a lab coat telling me all the answers.
- 45:16You know give me something like give
- 45:19me something to do myself and um i think
- 45:22the the analogy i'll probably use is that
- 45:25of um a marathon my i'm not a runner but my uh my wife is and she's done a couple
- 45:30of marathons now and it's been like a learning curve just to watch what it takes
- 45:35because education is always talked about as a marathon right it's not it's not
- 45:39sprints a marathon And we talk about that in terms of examinations, year 11,
- 45:44you know, we've got to make sure that, you know, we're preparing as if we're
- 45:48preparing for a marathon.
- 45:49You can't just run a marathon without doing the preparation.
- 45:52And we use it all the time and we use the synology. But I think it's important
- 45:55in this context is when we're learning, we can't always, every single hour, do a long run.
- 46:03And we've got to take those, you know,
- 46:07I hate to say it, rest days, or those walk-run days, or those days where actually
- 46:13we need a bit of recovery, we need a bit of time, we need to go a little bit
- 46:17deeper into actually looking after ourselves and our physique. We...
- 46:23We can't always go gung-ho. And actually, it's in those moments.
- 46:29Where we can then start to inspire and when we can start to get that sort of
- 46:35passion for learning that we all say that we are going to give our kids a passion
- 46:40for learning, but then have no time to do it.
- 46:43And I think that's really what I... So I come back to my original point.
- 46:48I'm for teacher autonomy. me I don't want every
- 46:52single lesson in my school to look and sound
- 46:54the same as every other hour how boring how
- 46:58boring and do you think maybe just trying to pick up on read between the lines
- 47:03of what you're saying there Jono do you think maybe when we've started to trust
- 47:08teachers less you know we we pay teachers to stand in a room with however many
- 47:13students 25 30 we trust them we've.
- 47:17Appointed them are we too prescriptive
- 47:21is what you're saying that is is the trust and and
- 47:25the expectations of being professional not there to
- 47:28some extent and do you think that's a
- 47:31bit of an issue again it comes down to
- 47:34how secure you feel as
- 47:36a senior leadership team and as a staffing body isn't it
- 47:40that's that's really what it is you know if you're
- 47:43if you're coming in if you're coming into work
- 47:46and you want to try something new
- 47:49with your classes and you don't feel that it's a safe environment to
- 47:52do it then you're not going to do it if you
- 47:55think there's going to be an observer who comes in and wants to see and
- 47:58make sure that you know at least every 10 minutes there's
- 48:01some kind of recall activity and I've got to get on it
- 48:04you know I know that they're really interested in what I've
- 48:07just said but I've got to do some recall quick because they've just walked in
- 48:10you know you it comes down to to that no and again it's about that slt member
- 48:19that senior leadership team you know that trust team whoever it is you know
- 48:24they're trying to justify their wages.
- 48:28And so they need to make sure that they're having their impact and this is where
- 48:32sometimes what's going on in the classroom and what perhaps career ambition
- 48:37comes in just doesn't align,
- 48:41um and it you know it's a i'm trying to you know rapidly improve a school and
- 48:47this is how i want to do it and i'm i'm going to bulldoze every good aspect
- 48:51of school because i'm just going to be dictating what everyone should do in
- 48:55order for me to meet those benchmarks which means that I can get that promotion,
- 48:59move on, and then not have to deal with consequences in three years' time.
- 49:05I'm over-egging it. But you get the idea. It's that, you know,
- 49:09we all have bad lessons. Have you had a bad lesson today?
- 49:14I definitely have. Yeah, I have. I've taught today.
- 49:20You teach, Jonathan. Yeah, I do teach. I'm teaching business studies at the
- 49:25moment, GCSE, and music still.
- 49:28But I do think it's important for teachers to teach, but that's a different conversation.
- 49:32But the, the, I think the thing for me is that, you know, it's okay for me as
- 49:38a head teacher on, you know, this radio station to say I've taught today and
- 49:43it wasn't a great lesson.
- 49:46And I don't think that that means that we're not having the right impact with our students.
- 49:53Am I having an impact? Yes, of course I am. Can I just say that?
- 49:55It's a much longer phase of impact, isn't it?
- 49:59I just want to mention about, sorry, it's something I'll ask you in a minute
- 50:03what you think on the debate of DI and Discovery Act.
- 50:07But, yeah, what else was I going to say? Yeah, I don't, I hope you don't mind
- 50:12me saying, Jono, But I don't find you like a lot of SLTs and leaders that I've known.
- 50:18And it's quite in a very refreshing way in that I think there is, it's showing weakness.
- 50:26There's a fear. And I think it probably does come from fear.
- 50:29And I do understand the fear, what's riding on this.
- 50:33The stakes are so high, aren't they? That you've got to be seen to always be right.
- 50:38That you've got to be seen to always be in control.
- 50:42And you've got some obviously some people are ambitious and they know the well
- 50:49results speak for themselves or whatever and what you're saying is that's not
- 50:54really compatible always,
- 50:56with running a sort of I don't know with having a happy ship I suppose really
- 51:02so it's an interesting one because I've known all sorts of different head teachers
- 51:06and obviously everyone brings their own style in a different way.
- 51:10So what are you thinking sort of Yannick along those lines of discovery versus DI?
- 51:17I mean obviously we've said I've said loads of times before and I think,
- 51:22the teach to the bell the do now the the sort of relentlessness of it all you you're right.
- 51:30It's that expectation that in a 60 minute lesson in a well-known school there's
- 51:3859 minutes of learning not a single minute is wasted and we are obviously very
- 51:45pressurized of teaching,
- 51:47delivering a curriculum as well so i've i've
- 51:50got to be careful and actually this year
- 51:53was the first year actually i did something that i was a bit worried out of
- 51:57out of my curriculum i thought i'm going to do a poem which i used to like when
- 52:00i was a teacher because i don't i don't know about you but when i was at school
- 52:04i had teachers with very different styles i had teachers who because they liked
- 52:09something they decided to be in class and that's that's how you got a passion for a subjects.
- 52:13That's the kind of stuff I remember. Oh yeah, I did this with that teacher.
- 52:17But now it's all about consistency as well.
- 52:20I mean, to answer your question, yeah, obviously I'm a fan of direct instruction. No surprise there. And.
- 52:27But you plan your lesson. So when you say discovery, well, you know what the
- 52:31student, you know, there's the theory that actually, well, actually they don't
- 52:37need to discover anything because you teach them.
- 52:39So I agree with what you've said again. You're right.
- 52:41You want to feel that you've discovered something as a student.
- 52:44Yeah, it's exciting, isn't it? That's why you do experiments in science.
- 52:48But they're not going to discover anything because you know the result.
- 52:53However, your lesson is planned in such a way that, I mean, when I teach friends,
- 52:58sometimes, you know, look at patterns. What do you see?
- 53:00And they come up with what you want them to discover. That's really what it
- 53:05is. And, yeah, you should do some of that, of course.
- 53:08They're not going to discover anything. But you're right that if they always
- 53:13talked up, well, there's not much fun in that as well, is there?
- 53:18Well, I don't think adults, if you went for CPD and then there was five solid
- 53:23hours where not one minute,
- 53:25they were allowed to have a brain break and have a conversation and
- 53:28have a coffee or it's like but do
- 53:31you know i think we forget we we don't see things through
- 53:34the eyes of the students enough i don't think one good
- 53:37i mean that was a one big piece of advice my first head of
- 53:40department gave me because he did yeah he he
- 53:43supported me in so many different ways my first head of department but
- 53:46one of the things that he always used to say what you know was exactly
- 53:50that see plan a lesson through the eyes
- 53:53of the students try and see it from their point of view and i
- 53:56just i don't know because we're being pulled in
- 53:59so many different directions that i
- 54:01don't think we always do that very well and obviously
- 54:04yeah tom did come in i think you'd probably i think
- 54:07you've already addressed that earlier about the importance of head teachers
- 54:11teaching i mean whether it's possible for you know you to if you're a head teacher
- 54:18that doesn't teach whether that has any implications i'm not really sure i think
- 54:23it's in the title isn't it head teacher,
- 54:25And I think if you're going to have policies that directly impact a class teacher,
- 54:32then you need to live them and breathe them and model them.
- 54:36I don't mean you need to have many, many hours on your timetable,
- 54:39but I think you need at least to have a go.
- 54:43Well, respect for that as well. You know, another thing I must say, absolutely, you know,
- 54:50and even when I worked at your college,
- 54:54which was a very long time ago, the principal then he was the biggest place
- 54:58i've ever seen and she did manage to teach a couple of hours music and other
- 55:03really and you know that that that to me i mean i think and to staff does mean
- 55:08a lot actually because you you are in their shoes you're you're you're one of us.
- 55:15That that's very important you're something else but you're also
- 55:18i mean you know i think that fits in totally with
- 55:21your with your inclusion so that even that
- 55:24i'm starting to be really annoyed at that actually that's
- 55:27you know that's that that really that is really well it's kind of challenges
- 55:31me to be to be perfectly honest so it's nice and that that fits in with your
- 55:37inclusion so even even in that kind of even in your staff you you are you are
- 55:44making yourself a member of staff,
- 55:47when you're also a headteacher and at staff, we obviously, we see this,
- 55:54you know, it's like nobody can ever say anything, but well, he doesn't understand.
- 55:57He doesn't know what he's like. Well, of course, of course you do.
- 56:00So that cuts that, you know, short, you know?
- 56:05Yeah. Thank you to anyone who's put comments in.
- 56:09Carl, I can't read the last part of that, but it looks like I can see a Carl in there.
- 56:14So thank you, Carl, for that. The heads who teach is, I mean,
- 56:19I don't know what the statistics say in terms of heads who still teach and so on.
- 56:24Yeah, well. Yeah, covering lessons, that's great as well. If you don't teach,
- 56:28but actually you go in there and the kid's face, oh, oh, God.
- 56:34Oh, no, right. Yeah, that I think does make a big difference.
- 56:40When the students see you as well, you're not only, you're right,
- 56:43not making policies, but just, yeah.
- 56:46Being visible and so on which is
- 56:49why i've i've thought recently about well the learning
- 56:52walks thing i'm going a little bit off the topic and i think you know
- 56:55we might have to do another show at some point on this
- 56:59but support walks over learning walks this
- 57:01is something this is a little thing that has been in
- 57:04the back of my mind don't call it a learning walk because if
- 57:07you call it a learning walk people are already on the back foot and
- 57:10they're thinking well what are you looking for what you're expecting and what
- 57:13you're checking up on if you call it a support walk can i
- 57:16help you with anything is there any and then you you
- 57:19know you can do maybe a little bit of undercover note a couple of things that
- 57:22are going on or whatever but it's just sometimes with anything it's just the
- 57:26implementation and the intent and the buy-in perhaps i mean i'm i'm rambling
- 57:32on like i know what i'm talking about now but it's which is why it's excellent
- 57:37i mean thank you so much again Jono for coming on.
- 57:39We are reaching the end of the hour. I know you've got to go and do some stuff with your PTA.
- 57:45So, yeah, it just makes it all the better that you've actually given up your hour for us.
- 57:52And I think, you know, certainly you've made an impression on Yannick.
- 57:55And I'm pretty sure that, I mean, a lot of what you said, I know that I've always
- 57:59admired for the short time we worked together, your people-centred approach.
- 58:04And, yeah, it's really refreshing.
- 58:07So, yeah, it's really good to see you again, Jono.
- 58:11We didn't really get very deep into the into the
- 58:14stuff that the really controversial stuff unless
- 58:18you guys either of you had any sort of comments on
- 58:20that the trans and the progs i just want to mention that i
- 58:23said to someone this probably answers my
- 58:26own question if anything but i spoke to a young teacher at
- 58:29our school or she or she she became
- 58:33part of conversation i was having with another more mature
- 58:36member of staff let's say about trans and
- 58:39progs and she was like what does that mean i've not heard of that probably because
- 58:42she's been too busy just doing her job and not um and not wasting time like
- 58:48i do on social media and arguing with people who are never going to agree with
- 58:52me anyway but the trad and the prog thing just a final sort of,
- 58:58comment on that if you wouldn't mind jono do you think we have trads and progs
- 59:03or do you think we just have teachers with different opinions.
- 59:07Is that something you've heard of Trad and Pro? Yeah, of course.
- 59:11You know, we've all read the articles, we've all read the Bump, we've all... I think...
- 59:19We have, what's wonderful about our profession is that we have teachers that
- 59:26have had multiple different experiences.
- 59:30Some of them have had experiences in some of our roughest schools.
- 59:35Some of them have had the joys of being in perhaps some of our top performing
- 59:40schools where there are different challenges to that.
- 59:43And each of them have been exposed to the different approaches that have been
- 59:48sold to them in CPD programs for decades.
- 59:53And so, yes, of course, there is an argument either way.
- 59:58But again, I think one of the things that we're missing in this binary thing,
- 1:00:04and perhaps to summarize it all, is that it's not necessarily about being central.
- 1:00:09It's actually about being brave enough to accept that actually difference is
- 1:00:20something really workable and difference of approach,
- 1:00:26opinion is something to be celebrated and worked with and not ignored.
- 1:00:32And almost trying to dispel anything that isn't necessarily seen as consistent.
- 1:00:40I think consistency, the word consistency, the most overused word in education.
- 1:00:48It's not about consistency. It's about being brave enough to say to a teacher, do you know what?
- 1:00:54Just do your best for them and use the approach, use the wealth of knowledge
- 1:00:59that you've got with those children and do your very best with it.
- 1:01:05And equally, if someone's new to the profession, it's not necessarily about
- 1:01:10either of those things because, as you say, they're told how to do stuff.
- 1:01:14It's actually those that do have those wealth experiences are actually coming
- 1:01:18to them and saying, look, I know you've been told to do it like this.
- 1:01:21This is what we were trained to do. Come and see me do it in my class and see what you think.
- 1:01:27And it's that sharing without any judgment that I think is one of the things that is missing.
- 1:01:36And if we could just get that right, as a sector, we could thrive.
- 1:01:41I tell you what, why don't we do a show on that in the future?
- 1:01:46That's yeah i mean that's yeah that that's really
- 1:01:49good yeah a device isn't it it's and
- 1:01:51i think you know we don't watch each other's teaching i
- 1:01:55think slt watch lots of lessons i always
- 1:01:58think i learn more from watching a lesson than i
- 1:02:01do teaching a lesson and having feedback on
- 1:02:04the lesson that i've done i mean it may be just because i'm awkward and
- 1:02:07i don't always listen to people and i'm bloody minded but um
- 1:02:10yeah it's probably an element of that but yeah
- 1:02:13it's been a really great show I think that's probably a
- 1:02:16good sort of place to wrap it up I just want to thank once again
- 1:02:19John Owen I hope you've enjoyed your debut on
- 1:02:22the teachers talk radio and it's just honestly it's been
- 1:02:25really interesting illuminating it's been nice to speak
- 1:02:29to you again I do really hope thank you to read for reaching out and for joining
- 1:02:33us and I really hope to see you again on a future show and yeah i think that's
- 1:02:39a good place to leave it so from us everyone i'm gonna say to you have a very.