Latest / The Events of 1848, Especially in Their Relation to Great Britain / Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00Section one of the events of eighteen forty eight, especially in their relation to
- 0:06Great Britain. This is a LibriVox recording. All LibriVox recordings are in the
- 0:10public domain. For more information or a volunteer, please visit LibriVox dot org.
- 0:19The Events of eighteen forty eight, especially in their relation to Great Britain.
- 0:24A Letter to the Marquess of Lansdowne by Richard Munkton Milns, Part one
- 0:33a letter, and so forth and so forth, My dear Lord, the
- 0:39large interest which your attentive observation and impartial temper have enabled you to take in
- 0:45continental politics, and the spirit in which you have of late combined your defense
- 0:49of the foreign policy of this country with an Englishman's sense of the blessings of
- 0:53liberty and a Christian's convictions of the duties of humanity, induce me to believe
- 0:59that it will not be displeasing to you to be invited to cast your mind
- 1:03over the European events of this last year, especially in their relation to the
- 1:08conduct and circumstances of Great Britain. I have no desire to recapitulate the occurrences
- 1:17which the powerful organs of the daily press have recorded and reviewed. And I
- 1:21am also conscious that there lie much too close to us to admit of the
- 1:25judgment of the historian or the illustration of the philosopher. But there remains an
- 1:30intermediate field of observation appropriated to the politician, whose attention must not be riveted
- 1:37to immediate events any more than directed to remote speculations. And it is to
- 1:42this point of view that I would ask you to accompany me. We may
- 1:47be sure that it is by no arbitrary singularity that the English people are indisposed
- 1:53to the consideration of foreign affairs, And a little reflection will convince anyone that
- 1:59the independent, place plitical existence of this country is in a great measure owing
- 2:02to the physical circumstances and the course of events which have separated its interests from
- 2:08those of the continent, and transferred its activity and its ambitions to the surrounding
- 2:14sea. Compressed within these limits, we have advanced, and are advancing,
- 2:20in all that constitutes national strength, with an even pace to which history affords
- 2:24no parallel. The most hostile settlements, the result of diverse immigrations, have
- 2:31been fused down into one compact people, a conquest the most complete ever effected
- 2:38by so small a body of men, as enlarged without weakening our language,
- 2:45and varied without impairing our natural character. In later times, the hand of
- 2:52the stranger has never arrested our growing liberties, nor degraded as by advantages bestowed
- 2:58not one. In all ages, Disputed frontiers and coveted territory have been the
- 3:04main causes of wars, and the ocean, which has protected us from foreign
- 3:08invasion, has gone far to secure other nations from our aggressions and placed salutary
- 3:15restrictions in the way of our extended dominion. Thus, with the exception of
- 3:22our civil contests, our hostilities have always had the character of a brave adventure
- 3:29or an occasional necessity, and war with us has never become, as with
- 3:32continental nations, the habit of the people. And while all these benefits have
- 3:39resulted from our enforced concentration and division from the great body of Europe, our
- 3:46chief difficulties and drawbacks have arisen from the diffusion and intermixture of interests which circumstances
- 3:53could not wholly control. The losses of Calais and Dunkirk, though belonging to
- 4:00the least honorable portions of our history, have not excited the regrets of one
- 4:05reflecting historian and hanover which mister Fox told us should be dear to us as
- 4:12Hampshire recovered its integral independence without a sigh from an English bosom. For with
- 4:19us foreign war has ever meant increased taxation, And while some rare spoils distributed
- 4:28subhaster have gratified the enduring soldier, and some additional territory has occasionally flattered the
- 4:34pride of the sovereign, no series of victories, and they have not been
- 4:40wanting, has ever repaid the original cost. And no continental possession has of
- 4:46itself increased the wealth or secured the permanent interests of this country. It is
- 4:54only as pledges of the security of our commerce in all seas, as points
- 4:59of communication and places of succor, that any reasonable men desire England to hold
- 5:04dominion over an inch of continental Europe. And we look for the justification of
- 5:11the exercise of British energy and valor in distant parts of the world, to
- 5:15the colonies in whose hands seems chiefly to rest the future destiny of mankind,
- 5:21and to the various races gradually ascending to a higher civilization by the maintenance of
- 5:28peace, or wiser jurisprudence and a purer religion. This comparative isolation cannot fail
- 5:38to have produced its moral effects, and they are by no means of unmixed
- 5:43good. Our disregard of the political condition of other nations is always liable to
- 5:49be proud, selfish, and unjust. At one moment, we reprobate every
- 5:56disturbance of social order in foreign countries, as if our own order and freedom
- 6:01had not been won by civil war, by resistance to power, and by
- 6:05the punishment of evildoers in high places. At another, we exhaust our indignation
- 6:13and scorn against the meanness and effeminacy of men who submit to lie under the
- 6:18terror of brute force, or still more under the oppression of an alien rule,
- 6:25and justify the tyranny by the nature and habits of the slave. Forgetful
- 6:30of our own ancestors, who, in the field of battle, on the
- 6:32scaffold, in exile or captivity, have raised stone by stone the edifice of
- 6:40our civil life. We mock at the sacrifices, the labors, and the
- 6:44martyrdoms of other patriots who have not succeeded in realizing at once all their hopes
- 6:49and aims, but whose blood and tears may be just as fruitful as those
- 6:55of our progenitors. Unconscious or careless of the many fortuitous circumstances and natural advantages
- 7:02to which we owe our independence and our blessings, we look with contempt on
- 7:09all other less favored nations, and, by a curious confusion of ideas,
- 7:14assume them to be incapable of freedom, simply because we do not see them
- 7:19free, and too often, thankless to Providence for all he has enabled us
- 7:26to do, we seem to regard the blessings of self government as the especial
- 7:30property of Englishmen, and are more safely secured to our possession in proportion as
- 7:35they are denied to the rest of mankind. So far, indeed, are
- 7:43we from falling into the delusions and dangers of a political propaganda that we seem
- 7:47to grudge to every other people. All that experience has taught us to hold
- 7:53most precious for ourselves, and precisely those persons who assume the most positively the
- 7:59perfection of the British Constitution refuse the most earnestly to encourage its extension to other
- 8:05countries and its adoption by other masses of men. And yet we can be
- 8:11as enthusiastic for an abstract notion of liberty as any other people. If we
- 8:15choose, We can be nobly lavish of our hard won wealth and thoughtless of
- 8:20the gravest political and social consequences to large classes of the community. We can
- 8:28intrude the inspiration of our humanity into compacts with which it has nothing to do,
- 8:33and demand its recognition by government's indifferent and even hostile And we can find
- 8:39consolation for frequent failure and indemnity for apparent wrong in the consciousness that we are
- 8:46advancing the dignity of human nature, repairing the injustice of past ages, and
- 8:52erecting a world of free action and responsibility out of the chaos of disordered will.
- 9:01Our pursuit of the cause of the emancipation of the Negro race has had
- 9:05about it as sacred extravagance, which assimilates it rather to those old crusades that
- 9:11brought the East and West of the world together and had so much to do
- 9:16with the civilization of Europe, rather than to the more modest political sympathies of
- 9:22modern times. Did we only feel for Poland and for Italy as we have
- 9:28done for the nations of the coast of Africa, of what generous follies should
- 9:31we not be capable If then these interferences in behalf of humanity are wholly unwise
- 9:39and unjust. Let us never forget that England has been guilty too, Admitting,
- 9:46however, as undeniable, the customary indifference of the English people to the
- 9:52political condition of other nations. The strange contradiction ever rises before us that it
- 9:58is problematical whether the strongest sympathies and the closest communion of interests, which our
- 10:03physical isolation permitted, could have entailed on us a heavier financial burden, and
- 10:09have imposed on us severer sacrifices than we have submitted to for the purpose of
- 10:15preserving the balance of power in Europe, of defending territories with which we had
- 10:20a merely dynastic connection, and in maintaining principles which were believed at the time
- 10:26to be essential to good government and public order. The general ignorance of foreign
- 10:31affairs has taken them out of the range of parliamentary supervision, and empowered any
- 10:37government to act in this department very much as if no constitutional checks existed on
- 10:41its caprices or its power. Even now, as Secretary for Foreign Affairs,
- 10:46may involve at his good pleasure the country in war, almost without the complicity
- 10:52of his colleagues, and the commencement of our great hostilities have always been so
- 10:56popular that it would only be owing to novel influences to which I may presently
- 11:01allude, if he were thwarted in his intention. The demands upon the character
- 11:07and abilities of a foreign secretary are therefore proportionably large. And although this exceptional
- 11:13power in a free country has not only its attractions to the possessor, but
- 11:18its advantages in administration, yet it is necessarily accompanied with so much suspicion,
- 11:26and its action is so likely to be mischievously or stupidly misrepresented, that I
- 11:31think a wise minister would do all in his power to dissipate the reserve in
- 11:37which his office is usually veiled, and to force both the House of Commons
- 11:41and the country into some share of his responsibility. Keeping them in mind,
- 11:48these characteristics of English thought, and these circumstances of our past relations with continental
- 11:54states, I would wish to apply them to the later occurrencies of Europe,
- 11:58and to deduce the leading principles on which our present foreign policy should be conducted,
- 12:03so as at once to satisfy the better instincts of the English people,
- 12:09to promote solid and permanent English interests, and to accomplish, as far as
- 12:13innus lies, our providential destiny in the history of the world. The destruction
- 12:22of the French Empire and the subsequent peace of Europe were purchased by so heavy
- 12:28and lasting a charge on the industry of this country that any alteration of the
- 12:33Great Settlement, involving as it must do a possibility of future effort and outlay,
- 12:39must awaken serious anxieties, not unmixed with disappointment. And it will be
- 12:45well to consider for a few moments how far reasonable men were justified in considering
- 12:50the arrangements of eighteen fifteen as definite and satisfactory. The Treaty of Vienna and
- 12:58its annexes comprised the territorial arrangement of the whole of Europe. For the rights
- 13:03of those nations that were not immediately parties to the compact were secured by the
- 13:09limitations imposed on the coast signatories. After so many changes and transferences of dominion,
- 13:16the settlement was as satisfactory as the pride of conquest and the contest of
- 13:20ambition would permit. Compared with the peace of Lunarville, the distribution was singularly
- 13:26just. For not only was the infamous principle of carving compensation for losses out
- 13:33of neutral territories never admitted, but respect was shown even to the vanquished,
- 13:39and Saxony retained her place among the more important states of Germany. Yet,
- 13:46when the calm politician surveyed this new disposition of Europe, the result of the
- 13:50most fearful struggle the civilized world had witnessed and endured, he must have been
- 13:56conscious that there were weak points in the system which, in the natural course
- 14:01of events, would generate disease and disturbance, and that it would require great
- 14:07skill and much temperance of power to preserve the healthy state and growth of the
- 14:13political frame. There was nothing, indeed, that under certain conditions might not
- 14:18prosper. There was no difficulty, absolutely insurmountable France, who, at the
- 14:24commencement of the Congress appeared almost as a criminal at the bar of the enemies
- 14:28and victims of her revolution, but whom the adroitness of Prince Talleyrand and the
- 14:35wiser second thoughts of the governments soon raised to inequality. With the highest deliberating
- 14:39powers. France might indeed, receiving a right spirit the severe lesson that had
- 14:46been dealt to her aggressive ambition, might find an ample field both for her
- 14:50national pride and her national advancement in the varied and extensive territory she still retained,
- 14:58and might cease to regard the frontier of the Rhine as an important or
- 15:01even as a desirable object. Belgium might happily develop her young nationality in constitutional
- 15:09union with the monarchy, which retained much of the spirit of one of the
- 15:13oldest and best of European republics. And while she shared the colonial dominion of
- 15:18Holland might be preserved from absorption into France. Poland, under the scepter of
- 15:26a still young and generous emperor, might become the herald of the liberties of
- 15:31the Slavonic nations. And while the turbulence imputed to her by history was awed
- 15:37by the huge force of Russia, she might enjoy her portion of freedom,
- 15:41at least secure from the jealousies of stronger neighbors. The Republic of Krakau might
- 15:48remain as a solemn pledge on the part of the petitioning powers, that nothing
- 15:52more should be done to oppress Polish nationality, but that, on the contrary,
- 16:00and nucleus should be preserved where this feeling might expend itself without offense,
- 16:06round the tombs of its ancient kings. Lombardy, resuming the Ghibellina tradition,
- 16:12might submit without dishonor to the Austrian though no longer Roman Caesar, and with
- 16:18an Italian administration and the continued use of the cold Napoleon might not be unwilling
- 16:23to mingle her soldiers, whose worth had been tried in the Campaign of Moscow,
- 16:29with the Imperial army, and to contribute liberally out of her abundant national
- 16:33resources to the necessities in exchange for a share in the dignities and emoluments of
- 16:38the Empire and venice of whose commonwealth our Harrington wrote, it is immortal in
- 16:45its nature, and to this day she stands with a thousand years of tranquility
- 16:51on her back. He adds, notwithstanding that this government consists of men not
- 16:55without sin, might find in the commercial advantages which would make her the Hamburg
- 17:00of the South, some consolation for the loss of an independence. No longer
- 17:06supported by colonial domination or domestic wealth. Such were the possible results of the
- 17:14more difficult combinations of the Treaty of Vienna. It required but a short lapse
- 17:19of time to test their strength and efficiency. The Polish Revolution, provoked by
- 17:26the outrages of a military viceroy, perhaps hardly responsible for his own actions,
- 17:32brought the whole weight of Russian vengeance on that unhappy country. The most heroic
- 17:38courage of an army of nobles and gentlemen was beat down by the sheer force
- 17:44of numbers. Europe was covered with exiles whose patriotism and poverty excited the liberality
- 17:51of constitutional governments rarely aroused to foreign sympathies, and France, regretful of the
- 17:57lost opportunities of founding an independent Poland evinstant interest which no prudence of king or
- 18:04minister could effectually suppress, Poland became and has since continued, a dependency of
- 18:11Russia held by military occupation. The protests of powers cosignatories of the Treaty of
- 18:18Vienna have been made in vain. In England, the language of Lord Palmerston
- 18:23has not been more explicit than that of Sir Robert Peel In declaring the present
- 18:29condition of Poland and infraction of the engagements of eighteen fifteen, and in France,
- 18:33each annual meeting of the Chambers under all phases of administration has reiterated its
- 18:40declaration of the rights of Poland. A less formal, but still more earnest
- 18:45demonstration in favor of Polish nationality took place in eighteen forty eight on the fifteenth
- 18:49of May, and the use that was made of that excitement by a few
- 18:53designing men, in no way effects the sincerity of the movement. Having been
- 19:00accidentally a witness to the whole events of that day in the National Assembly,
- 19:03I can testify that the treason against the majesty of the nation which followed the
- 19:08Polish petition was as great a surprise to the motley multitude that filled the hall
- 19:15as to the members of the Assembly. The destiny of the Republic of Krako,
- 19:19though less tragic, has not been unlike that of the Kingdom of Poland.
- 19:25The provocation to the breach of treaty engagements, however, was still less
- 19:30and the infraction required the consent of the three protecting powers. The protests of
- 19:36France and England were equally disregarded, and here too the Compact of Vienna has
- 19:41been no security against the supposed interests of the parties who had the desire and
- 19:47the power to effect the change. The separation of Belgium from Holland, although
- 19:53in a different political sense, is not the less a divergence from the dispositions
- 19:59of eighteen fifty. The powers of a secondary rank, who formed part of
- 20:03the Committee of Eight to whom the general arrangements of Europe were then entrusted,
- 20:08had no share in the conferences that decided the repeal of that union. Russia
- 20:14still declines to acknowledge that ultimatum. Although the effect has been advantageous to both
- 20:18countries, and as regards Belgium, eminently successful in the cause of public order,
- 20:26the incompatibility of these two nations is now undeniable, and the only effect
- 20:32of a longer duration of the connection would have been that Belgium would have increased
- 20:36in forced intelligence, would have secured the Catholic sympathies of Brabant, and that
- 20:41Holland den would have been clamorous for separation. By opportune concession, the peace
- 20:47of both people has been preserved, and the little monarchical experiment with which Lord
- 20:52Palmerston was twitted in Parliament remains a signal monument of his energy and his discretion.
- 21:00No experience can furnish a stronger proof of the advantage of accepting, in
- 21:06time a distinct manifestation of national feelings and the good practical working of the constitutional
- 21:11system in a country exposed to much danger from religious excitement and little protected from
- 21:17confusion by the interest of any dominant class. Has done more service to the
- 21:22cause of order and liberty throughout Europe than many more ostentatious demonstrations. Belgium had
- 21:30no independent traditional history. She had been a province transferred by heritage or by
- 21:37conquest, from power to power. No clearly defined frontier of hill or stream
- 21:42disparted her from other territories coterminous to her. Lay a great European power,
- 21:48which attached the highest importance to the possession of her chief maritime city, and
- 21:53which had long treated her as a department of its empire. She had been
- 21:59for ages a battlefield of contending armies, inured to outrage and insult, and
- 22:04accustomed to prostration. Before all forms of rule, self respect, self control,
- 22:11the independent mind, and the devoted heart were here as far extinguished as
- 22:17force can effect and God will permit. And yet out of this, by
- 22:22the wise application of constitutional influences and the free action of a national spirit,
- 22:29rises up one of the most happy and healthy of modern communities, resolute against
- 22:34violence from without and against disorder from within. Understanding and recognizing the character of
- 22:41a constitutional king, and checking the encroachments of an ambitious hierarchy. By analogy
- 22:49and by contrast, the mind naturally passes to the history, the physical position,
- 22:55the relations and the destiny of the portion of Italy submiss to the power
- 23:00of Austria by the Treaty of Vienna. The relation of the Lombardo Venetian Kingdom
- 23:06to the Austrian Empire can hardly have realized the hopes of the founders of the
- 23:11New Order of Europe. It certainly was not intended that one of the richest,
- 23:17most accessible, and most improvable of the districts of the earth, inhabited
- 23:21by a frugal and industrious people, an intelligent and active middle class, and
- 23:26a wealthy and polished nobility, should be permanently held in subjection to the authority
- 23:33of a strange and distant capital by the sole tenure of military rule. It
- 23:38surely was not contemplated that the pleasant land between the Alps and the Poe,
- 23:44the line of historic and decorated cities leading to the wondrous one, which had
- 23:49of old been wedded to the sea, and all the hosts of gay towns
- 23:55and villages that border the most beautiful lakes and most fruitful plain means of the
- 24:00Italian Peninsula should be compressed beneath a German and Slavonic soldiery and regulated by officials
- 24:07speaking an alien language and referring to a far and unknown center of dominion.
- 24:14Such a destination could not reasonably form part of any scheme which pretended to public
- 24:19equity and did not profess to disregard the welfare of mankind. It is,
- 24:25however, no secret that the cool judgment of the Emperor Francis anticipated all the
- 24:30evil results of this unnatural connection. He personally expressed to the British Commissioner,
- 24:37Sir Robert Wilson, his determination not to accept of an inch of Italian territory,
- 24:44and authorized him to communicate this resolution to the authorities then composing the Kingdom
- 24:49of Italy. In the same spirit, when the first Belgian envoy was presented
- 24:53at Vienna, the Emperor expressed its gratification that the independent establishment in Europe of
- 25:00the old dependency of Austria, and his satisfaction that he had not the responsibility
- 25:06of the government of a province which could not add to the compact power of
- 25:10his empire. At the opening of the Congress of Mannheim in November eighteen thirteen,
- 25:15the Allies proposed that the independence of the states of Italy should be secured
- 25:22under princes of native families, by whatever diplomatic representation of pressure. This sagacious
- 25:30decision was overruled. The unwillingness of Russia and Prussia to enlarge the boundaries of
- 25:34Austrian Poland was probably an important element, and the British commissioner, with that
- 25:40purity of honour which assimilates his character to the models of ancient chivalry, conceived
- 25:45that his word at least was pledged to the independence of the Italian states,
- 25:52and resigned his office. Accordingly, One Barby Brin Roberts Kings, Winford,
- 26:03September twenty twenty three,