Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Copyright Law at the Federal Circuit with Professor Clark D. Asay
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to Copyright Law at the Federal Circuit.
- 0:10I'm Alapoli Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly
- 0:12Hills Bar Association. Today, I am delighted
- 0:15to introduce our speaker, Professor Clark A .C.
- 0:19Professor A .C. has been professor at BYU Law
- 0:22since 2014. Prior to entering legal academia,
- 0:27he worked at Amazon's Lab 126 and supported the
- 0:30Kindle, Kindle Fire, and Amazon Fire teams. Professor
- 0:34A .C. has worked in private practice in the fields
- 0:36of technology, transactions, intellectual property
- 0:39licensing. His research and teaching interests
- 0:42focus on intellectual property law, technology,
- 0:46and innovation. He has authored publications
- 0:48relating to patents, copyrights, open source
- 0:51software licensing, and information privacy.
- 0:54He teaches courses in intellectual property law,
- 0:57information privacy, and contracts. We can't
- 1:00wait to hear what he has to share with us today.
- 1:01I'm turning it over to him. Great. Thank you
- 1:04so much for the introduction, Ala. Yeah, I'm
- 1:08really happy to be here. I wanted to give a little
- 1:13bit of background about this paper. It's close
- 1:18to publication, copyright law at the Federal
- 1:21Circuit. It really was sparked by an interest
- 1:26in the Supreme Court case in Google v. Oracle.
- 1:30That was a copyright law case that dealt with
- 1:37the issue of fair use with respect to copyrighted
- 1:46software that Oracle had acquired from Sun Microsystems,
- 1:50the Sun Microsystem API that Google had used
- 1:53in Android. As I mentioned, I did technology
- 2:01transactions in the past. And so a lot of the
- 2:05technologies in play were things that I'd worked
- 2:08on or had some familiarity with. And really the
- 2:14key thing that became of interest in this case
- 2:17was the court of appeals that the case came from.
- 2:22It was the court of appeals for the federal circuit.
- 2:25And people... thought that was curious and said,
- 2:28how did this copyright law case come from this
- 2:32Court of Appeals? The Court of Appeals for the
- 2:33Federal Circuit, as many of you likely know,
- 2:36is the Court of Appeals for all patent law appeals,
- 2:41not copyright law appeals. And so you have at
- 2:43the Supreme Court this case coming from the Court
- 2:45of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. It's a copyright
- 2:48law case. And like, how did this happen? Why
- 2:51did it come from Court of Appeals for the Federal
- 2:54Circuit? And a lot of folks, commentators, academics
- 3:02sort of poo -pooed the Federal Circuit as a copyright
- 3:05law court. They view it as a patent law court
- 3:10that had patent law expertise and specialization,
- 3:14but not a court that really should be deciding
- 3:17important copyright law cases. And in the Supreme
- 3:20Court case, there were two previous Federal Circuit
- 3:25cases, I'll use Federal Circuit short for the
- 3:27Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, that
- 3:31the Supreme Court was examining as part of its
- 3:34decision. The reason I wanted to do this paper
- 3:39was to really look at, rather than rely on anecdotal
- 3:44commentaries about the Federal Circuit and its
- 3:50expertise or lack thereof in copyright law, I
- 3:52really wanted to dig into Well, what is this
- 3:56court's role in copyright law? How often does
- 3:58it take copyright law cases, decide them? How
- 4:02does it decide them? Does, you know, the court,
- 4:05is it functioning well as a copyright law decision
- 4:09maker or are some of the concerns about it, some
- 4:17of the concerns about it justified? And, oh,
- 4:20I was just about to ask. About the slides I have
- 4:26just help us guide us through the Presentation.
- 4:30Let's see. Can I am I able to make these? Move
- 4:36I'll be assisting with a slide control. Okay,
- 4:40I'll just So you can go to the next slide, please
- 4:46And by the way, if you have questions or comments
- 4:50as we go through the presentation, please feel
- 4:54free to pose them. I'd love to hear your thoughts
- 5:00and comments as much as we can get to them. I
- 5:03should mention my co -author Dan Hinckman is
- 5:07not able to be with us. He was a student of mine
- 5:12here at BYU Law, and we worked on the paper together.
- 5:17He's now in practice in the Bay Area. but he's
- 5:21not able to be with us today. Okay, so the Federal
- 5:26Circuit, it's this patent law court that's occasionally
- 5:31deciding important copyright law decisions. And
- 5:34like I mentioned, the Google V Oracle decision
- 5:38at the Supreme Court really brought this, not
- 5:42really brought it to light, but really made people
- 5:44think more about, wait, why is this court, this...
- 5:48Federal Circuit deciding copyright law cases
- 5:53and a lot of people felt like the Federal Circuit
- 5:55had really messed up the copyright law issues
- 6:00In their decisions before it got to the Supreme
- 6:04Court You know the Supreme Court case was about
- 6:08fair use but the Federal Circuit had decided
- 6:10other issues as well including the copyright
- 6:12ability of API software in play. We won't get
- 6:20into those details, but a lot of folks really
- 6:23sort of upset with the Federal Circuit's role
- 6:26in copyright law in the preceding decisions.
- 6:30And so there's been a lot of commentary in light
- 6:35of the Google, the Oracle Supreme Court decision.
- 6:41So the way, I mean, the way that these cases
- 6:45get to the Federal Circuit primarily one of two
- 6:50ways, okay? First is court of federal claims,
- 6:54all appeals of that court's decisions go to the
- 6:58federal circuit, court appeals for the federal
- 7:00circuit. So court of federal claims is deciding
- 7:03when someone wants to sue the federal government
- 7:07for money damages, then that's the court they
- 7:11go through. And so if you have a copyright law
- 7:17claim against the federal government, you go
- 7:20through that court. And then if you lose that
- 7:22decision and want to appeal it, the appeal would
- 7:26go to the Federal Circuit. So that's one primary
- 7:29way that copyright law cases get to the Federal
- 7:35Circuit. This becomes an important piece of the
- 7:39Federal Circuit slash copyright law puzzle because
- 7:44in a lot of the results that we'll talk about
- 7:47later. The other way that perhaps people are
- 7:52more worried about in terms of how copyright
- 7:55law cases get to the Federal Circuit is the second
- 7:59one. And this was the case in the Google v. Oracle
- 8:04case, cases that initially include patent claims.
- 8:08So in Google v. Oracle, it was originally Oracle
- 8:12v. Google and then The plaintiff and the defendant
- 8:15switched once it got to the Supreme Court. But
- 8:20in that case, when Oracle sued Google for infringement
- 8:27of its copyright based on using the API, the
- 8:34Oracle API in Android, they also included a patent
- 8:40law claim. in their initial filings. That claim,
- 8:46the patent law claim, didn't have legs and was
- 8:53not part of the case from pretty early on. It
- 8:55got dismissed. But because the case initially
- 9:00included a patent law claim, that means any appeal
- 9:04of any subject matter within the case goes to
- 9:10the Federal Circuit. And so even though in Google
- 9:15the Oracle, the patent law claims went away pretty
- 9:21quickly, the remaining claims or copyright law
- 9:26claims, the appeal goes to the Federal Circuit.
- 9:29So this is, I would say, the more controversial
- 9:31way that copyright law cases get to. the federal
- 9:36circuit. The appeals of court of federal claims
- 9:41decisions hasn't really produced very many notable
- 9:47decisions. A lot of them are purcurium and relatively
- 9:54uncontroversial. And so that's why the court
- 9:57of federal claims opinions and some of the results
- 10:00I tend to separate. exclude from some of the
- 10:04results, um, just because it's, they're just
- 10:06a different beast. There's a lot of pro se litigants.
- 10:10Um, there might be really significant bias in
- 10:13favor of the federal government. Um, in those
- 10:16cases, um, that's just, um, speculation. I don't
- 10:21have, um, evidence of that. Um, but we'll get
- 10:26into some of how I differentiate between federal
- 10:29claims. opinions and the ones where a patent
- 10:34claim was involved earlier on. Okay, next slide,
- 10:39please. Thank you. Okay, so this slide just sort
- 10:50of lays out why are people worried about the
- 10:56Federal Circuit deciding copyright law cases?
- 10:59Again, a lot of this came to, you know, became
- 11:05bigger issue, I would say, during the Google
- 11:10via Oracle decision and the so before and after.
- 11:15But I would say there are four major concerns
- 11:18that I have found from scholars and commentators
- 11:22about the Federal Circuit's role in copyright
- 11:24law. First is bias toward rights holders. So
- 11:29the Federal Circuit is frequently accused of
- 11:34exhibiting biases towards patent holders, the
- 11:38rights holders. Now it's, I don't know, you read
- 11:45this quite often in academic articles and online
- 11:50news in particular. I don't know that there's
- 11:52really, there is some evidence backing this up.
- 11:57I mean, the federal circuit was instituted to
- 12:00bolster patent rights and make it a patent law
- 12:03more uniform because it was at the time the court
- 12:08was instituted in 1982 there was some amount
- 12:11of disarray in patent rights from one circuit
- 12:15to the next of course that disarray exists in
- 12:18a lot of different domains but there was a feeling
- 12:21that Patent rights are important and they're
- 12:24important to innovation They're important to
- 12:27innovators and so we need to do something here
- 12:29So the Federal Circuit was instituted as the
- 12:32Court of Appeals for all patent law claims and
- 12:35part of their mission was really to shore up
- 12:38patent rights and and bolster them in some respects
- 12:42and I think that happened and So the claim is
- 12:46you know given this mission this court has sort
- 12:51of a bias in favor of rights holders and having
- 12:57sort of strong IP rights in place. And so the
- 13:01worry is in copyright law that you're going to
- 13:04get a similar bias exhibited by the court, that
- 13:08copyright holders are going to fare very well
- 13:12in the federal circuit and those that are being
- 13:16accused of infringement are not going to fare
- 13:19well. And I think when the two preceding decisions
- 13:25before the Supreme Court's decision in Google
- 13:27v. Oracle were pointed to as strong evidence
- 13:31of, look, they're favoring Google. They're misconstruing
- 13:35copyright law to protect the copyright owner
- 13:39in this case vis -a -vis Google. So that's a
- 13:43significant concern that people have expressed
- 13:45about the Federal Circuit. and its role in copyright
- 13:51law. Related to this is the second point, which
- 13:55is, look, this is a patent law court steeped
- 14:01in patent law ideology. How are they going to
- 14:05decide copyright law cases other than through
- 14:09a patent law lens, right? Like and the two regimes
- 14:13are very are distinct even though the Supreme
- 14:16Court has said they have a historic kinship The
- 14:20Supreme Court has also said these are different
- 14:23regimes right patent law protects inventive ideas
- 14:26that otherwise satisfy the Patent Act requirements,
- 14:31whereas copyright law excludes protections from
- 14:35ideas no matter how creative or innovative they
- 14:38are and generally applies to the expression,
- 14:43the creative expression of ideas. Some have worried,
- 14:47they're going to be bias and favor rights holders.
- 14:50And they're going to be so biased because they're
- 14:52not going to be able to apply copyright law without
- 14:56letting their patent law expertise affect their
- 14:58decision making. Okay. Is sort of the second
- 15:03main concern that I've seen scholars and commentators
- 15:08express. The third one is a big one. And again,
- 15:13this is This concern is something folks expressed
- 15:18in the context of Google v Oracle, which is,
- 15:26look, litigants are smart. Plaintiffs or plaintiff
- 15:29lawyers are smart. They're going to see that
- 15:32this court favors rights holders and that they
- 15:37let patent law ideology and doctrine sort of
- 15:41affect their view of copyright law. And so enterprising
- 15:47plaintiff lawyers are going to, if they have
- 15:52a copyright law claim and they're in the Ninth
- 15:54Circuit and they feel like, you know, the Ninth
- 15:56Circuit, it's a bad history here. They're beholden
- 16:01to the tech industries or the tech companies.
- 16:07Now, this is not what I think. This is just might
- 16:10be some of the thinking that goes into this gamesmanship.
- 16:13We're in the Northern District of California.
- 16:15We got Judge Alsup. We think he's pretty favorable
- 16:20to uses of copyrighted works and finding those
- 16:26to be what's called fair use. So how do we get
- 16:31out of the Ninth Circuit if this comes to an
- 16:34appeal? We stick a patent law claim in there.
- 16:37Any patent law claim will do. Doesn't matter
- 16:39how strong or weak or trivial it is. just included
- 16:44in the initial claim, somewhat plausible, it
- 16:48gets dismissed. Okay. We lose the, you know,
- 16:53we lose with Judge Alsop or, you know, in the
- 16:55district court within the Ninth Circuit. Well,
- 16:58the appeal is going to now go to the Federal
- 17:03Circuit and maybe that's better than the Ninth
- 17:05Circuit judges. We think our chances are better
- 17:09in with the Federal Circuit. And this, you know,
- 17:15patents have been exploding for decades. There's
- 17:19explosion and utility patents, design patents.
- 17:24Any patent law claim will do to ensure that our
- 17:28copyright law appeal, the real heart of the matter
- 17:32in many cases, will go to the federal circuit.
- 17:36So there's that gamesmanship concern. that is
- 17:40linked to the first two concerns as well. Sorry,
- 17:44can you go back to the previous slide? Thanks.
- 17:50The last concern is this legal uncertainty and
- 17:53precedent inconsistency. So again, this was raised
- 17:57in the Google V Oracle case. The Federal Circuit
- 18:01was supposed to be applying Ninth Circuit law
- 18:07when it was deciding making the decisions that
- 18:10ultimately were appealed to the Supreme Court.
- 18:13And many people looked at its application of
- 18:17Ninth Circuit case law and said, this isn't Ninth
- 18:21Circuit case law. This is like the Federal Circuit
- 18:24doesn't know what it's doing. And it's creating
- 18:27this weird precedent that technically isn't binding
- 18:29on the Ninth Circuit, but then litigants with
- 18:33this sort of confusion or confuse themselves
- 18:38and don't really understand what is Ninth Circuit
- 18:41precedent. Do we just ignore the Federal Circuit
- 18:44decision? We have to take it into account in
- 18:48some respects, perhaps just creates this like
- 18:51legal uncertainty that is not good for decision
- 18:56makers in business and elsewhere. So those are
- 19:00the four. big, I think. I mean, there are others,
- 19:04but I think categorizing the four main concerns
- 19:07that folks have expressed about the Federal Circuit
- 19:10as a copyright law decision maker and what is
- 19:15motivating me and Dan to say, okay, let's, you
- 19:21know, we've got Google v. Oracle or Oracle v.
- 19:23Google decisions, fine. What else has the Federal
- 19:26Circuit decided in terms of copyright law? What
- 19:29can we learn from those decisions? about the
- 19:32Federal Circuit as a copyright law decision maker.
- 19:38Next slide, please. Okay. So we, that's basically
- 19:45what we did. We went into Westlaw and we wanted
- 19:49to fetch all of the Federal Circuit copyright
- 19:54law decisions that we could find. Okay. And Perhaps
- 20:00not surprisingly, there are not a ton on there.
- 20:07Now, we found 56 majority copyright opinions,
- 20:11I think three concurrences and six dissents included
- 20:14in those decisions. Unless I state otherwise,
- 20:21when I'm referring to results, I'm referring
- 20:23to the majority opinions in those decisions.
- 20:27throughout the remainder of the presentation.
- 20:34Now, prior to the e -government act of 2002,
- 20:41judges, courts were not required to publish their
- 20:48unpublished decisions or opinions. They weren't
- 20:54required to make them available electronically
- 20:56anywhere. It may be that there are unpublished
- 21:01opinions lurking somewhere in the shadows of
- 21:06the federal circuit that Westlaw has not been
- 21:08able to get access to. But that's just a limitation
- 21:14of the study in terms of, is this the universe
- 21:18of opinions? We think it's most of it. Westlaw
- 21:22is in the business of Getting everything and
- 21:26posting everything they can find and get access
- 21:29to so We trust their business incentive means
- 21:33that what we found is Most of what the Federal
- 21:37Circuit has decided in terms of corporate law
- 21:39now, of course, you know You might the question
- 21:42might arise in your mind. Well opinions are one
- 21:45thing right opinions are sort of rare occurrences
- 21:48there what about just filings and things that
- 21:51are settled and don't make their way into an
- 21:54opinion. The federal circuit and the patent sphere
- 21:57has been accused of making a lot of decisions,
- 22:02or not just accused, there's evidence of they
- 22:04make a lot of decisions without issuing an opinion.
- 22:06So you could also have that as a factor too.
- 22:08So these are all like imperfections of the study,
- 22:12could do an additional study to look at filings
- 22:14rather than just opinions. But that's not what
- 22:18we've done here. So there's just some things
- 22:21to think about in terms of what exactly we're
- 22:25looking at, the universe of things that we're
- 22:26looking at. And I have in this slide, we reviewed
- 22:30for party outcomes, citation pattern, patent
- 22:34law influence, jurisdictional trends. We extracted
- 22:37other information from each opinion that's pointed
- 22:42to in the paper. But these are just some of the
- 22:45highlights. that we were reading and digging
- 22:50through these opinions, this type of information,
- 22:53we were trying to gather. Next slide, please.
- 23:00Okay. So I think, I mean, a number of important
- 23:07findings, I think, with respect to the Federal
- 23:10Circuit as a copyright law decision maker. I
- 23:13think you could sum up a lot of what we're going
- 23:16to talk about in the remainder of the presentation
- 23:18as Federal Circuit seems to be doing just fine
- 23:23as a copyright law decision maker, finding relative
- 23:28like compared to other circuits. And I'll point
- 23:31out some comparisons as we go through this. But
- 23:35they seem to be doing similar to other courts.
- 23:38And they have similar volume of copyright law.
- 23:43decisions as other circuits. And so I think that's
- 23:48the overall finding is I think they're doing
- 23:50okay. And there's no sort of basis. Some people
- 23:53have said we should change the federal circus
- 23:56jurisdiction so that copyright law appeals are
- 23:58not so easily making their way into the federal
- 24:01circuit. And I just don't think based on what
- 24:04we were able to review, as imperfect as it is,
- 24:08that there's a strong basis for that. So one
- 24:12interesting result, I think, is that there's
- 24:18this worry I mentioned in the beginning. There's
- 24:21this worry that the Federal Circuit unduly favors
- 24:24rights holders and decides in favor of them.
- 24:29In the majority opinion, it's just not the case.
- 24:32Defendants actually win much more frequently
- 24:35than plaintiffs do. Now, some of this, this percentage
- 24:40is a little bit hard to trust. And I go into
- 24:43this in the paper. There's different ways you
- 24:45can split this. But when you take out federal
- 24:51claims decisions, because those are overwhelmingly
- 24:55in favor of the defendant, the government, then
- 25:01the percentage Goes down right in terms of defendants
- 25:06win percentage And and so it starts to look kind
- 25:13of like a normal core I think in terms of Expectations
- 25:19of who win and who who wins and who loses the
- 25:21famous arrow Klein hypothesis the win rate should
- 25:25be about 50 % because You know if if a case is
- 25:31clearly in favor of one party the other probably
- 25:33settle or it will resolve earlier. It's only
- 25:37where you have kind of a coin flip type of scenario
- 25:40that parties are willing to continue to forge
- 25:43ahead and fight it out. And so I think we're
- 25:47close to that in terms of what we were able to
- 25:50find from the opinions. And so the Federal Circuit
- 25:53kind of looks like another court in terms of
- 25:56who wins and who loses. We didn't... We also
- 26:05found that in some domains, there's this worry
- 26:09that Federal Circuit, again, is really pro rights
- 26:13holders. But in DMCA cases, for instance, Digital
- 26:18Millennium Copyright Act cases, there are very
- 26:22few of these among all of the circuits, decisions
- 26:26that courts have written. But the Federal Circuit
- 26:29has articulated in its DMCA cases the most pro
- 26:35-defendant interpretation of the DMCA that is
- 26:39available. So we just didn't find evidence of
- 26:44systemic bias toward copyright holders and you
- 26:47might actually say it points in the opposite
- 26:51direction, although I think honestly the evidence
- 26:56is inconclusive. in some respects too, but I
- 27:01just don't think based on what we were able to
- 27:03discover that there was just a lot of evidence
- 27:06of this court acting in the way that, you know,
- 27:11headlines and anecdotes suggest. Next slide,
- 27:18please. This second finding is interesting so
- 27:27When we read the opinions we looked for explicit
- 27:33references or comparisons to patent law because
- 27:36again You might not expect if the court is deciding
- 27:40copyright law case that they would why would
- 27:44they refer to patent law? But there is this narrative
- 27:49as I was suggesting at the beginning out there
- 27:52that That's what the court is doing. Like they're
- 27:58pulling in patent law to decide copyright law
- 28:01issues and that can't be a good thing. So we
- 28:04read through the opinions and we found about
- 28:07a quarter of the copyright law majority opinions
- 28:13referenced, however fleetingly, sometimes it's
- 28:16literally just like a citation to a patent law
- 28:20case to bolster their reasoning. but that a quarter
- 28:24of them explicitly reference patent law in some
- 28:27form or another. That might actually seem high.
- 28:31We don't have great points of comparison. I haven't
- 28:33done this sort of analysis for other courts of
- 28:37appeal, and so it might be quite a bit lower
- 28:39than found here. But the other thing we did is
- 28:45we actually read through the references and read
- 28:49the opinions and when we found a patent law reference
- 28:53or we did a qualitative assessment. And none
- 29:03of them stuck out as like, oh, this is an egregious
- 29:05application of patent law, which I think you
- 29:07would expect to be the case, right? These are
- 29:10very competent, high -level lawyers deciding
- 29:14the cases and they're doing their homework and
- 29:18they might refer to patent law here or there.
- 29:20here or there. But when they do, they're doing
- 29:24so in a reasonable way, it seemed to, based on
- 29:30our qualitative reading of the cases. Now, this
- 29:36is limited, right? Like the judges on the federal
- 29:39circuit might be influenced in all sorts of ways
- 29:42by patent law that just looking in the opinions
- 29:46can't account for. So there's other pieces of
- 29:51evidence that you might gather and look at to
- 29:54further address that question. But for the scope
- 29:57of our project, we didn't go beyond that. We
- 30:00were just reading the opinions to see what we
- 30:03could discover on this front. And we just didn't
- 30:06see a lot of, like, patent influence, at least
- 30:09explicitly. Now, you know, in the back of their
- 30:12minds, they might be thinking about patent law
- 30:14all day every day when they're addressing copyright
- 30:16law issues and just not putting it in the opinions.
- 30:19Um, so we can't really account for that, but
- 30:22that's, that is a limitation of, um, of, of this
- 30:27finding. Next slide please. So I think, um, you
- 30:37know, in further this point of the, of the federal
- 30:41circuit being a relatively, um, decent copyright
- 30:48law court, they have some key advantages. They
- 30:54hear cases from nearly all circuits except the
- 30:56DC circuit. They have opinions that they've written
- 31:00interpreting and implying copyright law from
- 31:04every other circuit. Why is that an advantage?
- 31:08Well, they have in some ways broader exposure
- 31:10to copyright law than other circuits, frankly.
- 31:14Some of the circuits, 10th Circuit, 8th Circuit,
- 31:17just have very little copyright law activity.
- 31:21In the case that they do have, they're applying
- 31:26and trying to come up with their approach to
- 31:28a particular copyright law issue. And that might
- 31:31be great, but it's also constrained in terms
- 31:34of exposure. Whereas the Federal Circuit, they
- 31:39have their own... copyright law precedent that
- 31:43they develop in the context of the claims from
- 31:48the, or sorry, the court of federal claims. So
- 31:51that's like their original jurisdiction where
- 31:54they're deciding copyright law cases. But even
- 31:57there, in those cases, they're pulling in second
- 32:00circuit, ninth circuit, the two big copyright
- 32:02law heavyweights. And just, they have more familiarity
- 32:07and exposure to all the different circuits because
- 32:11they have cases from the different circuits.
- 32:14And they're also developing their own copyright
- 32:17law and relying on other circuits, copyright
- 32:20law decisions. One area that they develop niche
- 32:28expertise in is software copyright. And I would
- 32:32say DMCA, they have a... Uh, there's only, I
- 32:35did a DMCA project as well and there's just very
- 32:38few copy or DMCA opinions out there and the federal
- 32:42circuit happens to have several of them. Um,
- 32:47but software copyright, that was the subject
- 32:49matter of Google V Oracle. And, um, the federal
- 32:53circuit decides that that's, that's the highest
- 32:56number of opinions they have deal with software
- 32:58copy. So, you know, people might be dissatisfied
- 33:03with. how they handled software copyright in
- 33:07the Oracle v Google cases. But they actually
- 33:11have a decent amount of exposure to software
- 33:13copyright overall, which might lend credibility
- 33:20to how they approach software copyright cases.
- 33:25Um, and I guess I will say on that, it's not
- 33:28terribly surprising that the highest number of
- 33:31S it's another thing we coded for, but subject
- 33:33matter and that software copyright cases are
- 33:36there. Um, they have the highest number of, um,
- 33:41decisions in that area because right software
- 33:45subject to copyright, but also obviously, uh,
- 33:49uh, place for patents, um, to apply to now that
- 33:54leads to the concern of some that the federal
- 33:59circuit's going to create mischief in software
- 34:04copyright. They're getting all these cases. There's
- 34:06this gamesmanship possibility, just easy to throw
- 34:10in a patent claim for a software copyright case.
- 34:15I'll come back to that. But for now, I'm just
- 34:18saying They actually have a decent amount of
- 34:21exposure to number of circuits, number of subject
- 34:25matters, copyright law issues. We also coded
- 34:29for that. And they have pretty broad exposure
- 34:32in that regard too. And they are a patent law
- 34:37court primarily. And so they have a very strong
- 34:41technological edge vis -a -vis some other courts
- 34:45of appeal. when dealing with something like software
- 34:49and a copyright case dealing with software. So
- 34:54I think these factors might suggest that actually
- 34:58the Federal Circuit has some competencies that
- 35:04other courts of appeal may not possess in terms
- 35:09of applying copyright law in certain domains.
- 35:13Next slide, please. So the gamesmanship issue,
- 35:23this is probably, well, I don't know. This finding
- 35:27is inconclusive at best. I don't have any really
- 35:34strong feelings or thoughts about whether this
- 35:41is happening or not based on what we are able
- 35:43to gather. So overall, a little less than one
- 35:49non -federal claims court copyright cases per
- 35:53year. Now, that's, it should say opinions per
- 35:57year, which means there might be a lot more cases
- 36:02that are sort of headed to the federal circuit,
- 36:07copyright law cases, and they're just settled
- 36:09or they're dismissed or whatever, right, early
- 36:12on. So again, the limitation that arises because
- 36:17we're focused on opinions is a real one, but
- 36:20it is what it is in the context of what we're
- 36:24doing in this study. Now, that number rises to
- 36:30a little over one opinion a year when you exclude
- 36:36the years where the e -government act did not
- 36:38apply. If you recall, the e -government act is
- 36:41this act that requires courts to make electronically
- 36:46available all opinions that they produce, whether
- 36:51published or not. And so once that act applies,
- 36:56the number does rise. That might be just because
- 36:59litigation has been increasing too, or it might
- 37:03be because prior to the government act, there
- 37:06were actually more opinions that just weren't
- 37:09coming to light. And after it, they're... there
- 37:12were. But I don't know that based on this study,
- 37:19we get a very great answer to this question of
- 37:23forum shopping. And you might think actually
- 37:28one opinion per year is decent evidence pointing
- 37:33towards forum shopping. And when you look at
- 37:36other courts of appeal, we did some comparison.
- 37:41And yeah, there are some other courts of appeal
- 37:45that don't have a heavy copyright law caseload
- 37:49are similar in terms of the number of opinions
- 37:52those circuits are producing with respect to
- 37:54copyright per year. So it might actually be like
- 37:59we wouldn't expect them to be producing one opinion
- 38:01per year. That's actually evidence of forum shopping
- 38:04by plaintiffs. Again, I think this study doesn't
- 38:10really have great evidence one way or the other,
- 38:16but it's, I think, something to continue to track.
- 38:21It is one of the major concerns about the federal
- 38:23circuit as a copyright law court. The reason,
- 38:27by the way, in case it wasn't clear, the reason
- 38:30we exclude non -federal Court of Federal Claims,
- 38:35or sorry, the reason why we exclude Court of
- 38:38Federal Claims opinions from the analysis here
- 38:40is because those cases are not relevant to the
- 38:47gamesmanship issue, because all appeals of that
- 38:51court go to the Federal Circuit, whether or not
- 38:55they include a patent law claim as well. I mean,
- 39:00so there's no gamesmanship going on with those
- 39:02cases. Okay, next slide, please. Now on the last
- 39:12concern about, oh, you know, the Federal Circuit,
- 39:16they do these, make these erroneous decisions.
- 39:21They misapply Ninth Circuit law, case law, and
- 39:24then the Supreme Court comes and cleans up. some
- 39:27of the issues, but some of the issues the Supreme
- 39:29Court did not address. And so we have this lingering,
- 39:32like, what is the standard for copyright ability
- 39:36with respect to software? We thought we had the
- 39:39Ninth Circuit standard and other circuit standards
- 39:42that had been around for decades. Now Federal
- 39:44Circuit has muddied the waters, so to speak,
- 39:48and misapplied Ninth Circuit law in that regard.
- 39:51And the Supreme Court didn't clean up that issue.
- 39:53They left it. They didn't address it. So the
- 39:57concern is Federal Circuit is taking all these
- 40:00cases from different circuits, misapplying the
- 40:02circuit's case law, messing everything up. I
- 40:06think it's an overblown concern. I think the
- 40:11primary reason is that although the Federal Circuit
- 40:14has taken and written opinions applying and interpreting
- 40:19case law from each circuit, with the exception
- 40:22of the D .C. Circuit, It's like one or two cases
- 40:26per circuit. I forget off the top of my head
- 40:31which circuit it might've been. It's probably
- 40:32either the ninth or the second circuit where
- 40:34they've had a few more than that, but still not
- 40:38very many. There may be some high profile missteps
- 40:43as some people claim in Oracle v Google. I tend
- 40:47to agree on one of those opinions in particular.
- 40:51Um, but I don't think that's any different, I
- 40:55guess I would say from other courts of appeal.
- 40:58I recently did a study on the substantial similarity
- 41:02doctrine in copyright law, read thousands of,
- 41:06um, opinions from different, from every circuit,
- 41:10every, um, in the United States and came away
- 41:14from that study, um, feeling like most circuits
- 41:19are struggling in this area. Um, and so I don't
- 41:24think the federal circuit is, is, uh, I don't
- 41:29know that they're doing spectacularly in copyright
- 41:32law on this front, but I also don't know that
- 41:34they're doing any less or worse than other courts
- 41:39of appeal for the federal circuit. Okay. And
- 41:42again, I think they do their homework. Um, they're,
- 41:45they're most free. The, the, we also counted
- 41:47like citations to different sources of authority.
- 41:51And the Federal Circuit is pretty normal in terms
- 41:54of who they cite. They're citing Supreme Court,
- 41:57the Feist decision. Second and ninth circuits
- 42:00are the two behemoths in copyright law. And they
- 42:04rely on those circuits. Case law, even if you're
- 42:10like, let's say you're doing an eighth circuit
- 42:12or a fourth circuit or a fifth circuit case,
- 42:15they will still incorporate and rely on just
- 42:19a wide variety of legal sources from other circuits
- 42:23just to, you know, I think is evidence of them
- 42:27doing their homework. And so I don't, again,
- 42:31this is not a really strong finding, but just
- 42:36based on like the numbers, I just don't think
- 42:40it's a huge concern at this point. With the federal
- 42:47circuit as I copyright law decision maker. Okay.
- 42:52Next slide, please. So, I mean, the basic conclusion
- 42:59is sort of what I've been talking about all along.
- 43:02I think the Federal Circuit is a competent copyright
- 43:05court currently. Its decisions, at least in written
- 43:10opinion form, do not did not strike either me
- 43:14or Dan in our review of them as just an outlier
- 43:19or egregious in any sort of way. It seems to
- 43:22be they're doing their job here similar to other
- 43:25courts of appeal. In fact, they might have some
- 43:29pretty significant advantages over other courts
- 43:36of appeal. because of their tech expertise and
- 43:40IP law experience in general. They do patent
- 43:45law, they do some trademark law, they do copyright
- 43:47law. The way to make an IP scholar or practitioner
- 44:00grumpy is to have a news article that refers
- 44:04to a trademark thing and it's actually a copyrighted
- 44:07thing or a patented thing, just the mixing up
- 44:10of the terminology. But the federal circuit mixing
- 44:14up with the different legal regimes, which is
- 44:16pretty significant, but the federal circuit is
- 44:19familiar, has familiarity with all of these different
- 44:23legal regimes. And I think that's actually a
- 44:26relative advantage for in terms of navigating
- 44:31thorny copyright law issues. And I think that
- 44:36comes into play particularly for its software
- 44:39copyright law decisions, its most frequent subject
- 44:44matter and its opinions. And maybe its advantages
- 44:52in that regards tech expertise and IP law expertise.
- 44:56actually make it a much more suitable court of
- 45:00appeals for deciding those types of cases than,
- 45:03say, the 10th Circuit, so where I live, my home
- 45:06circuit, where basically copyright law opinions
- 45:10are almost nonexistent, or the 8th Circuit, some
- 45:14of these other sort of low volume circuits in
- 45:17terms of copyright law decision -making. Now,
- 45:21I do think it's, and this is what I sort of conclude
- 45:24with in the paper, I do think it's really important
- 45:30to continue to monitor its role, particularly
- 45:33with respect to software cases, because I think
- 45:37if the Federal Circuit became what you might
- 45:42call the de facto Supreme Court of software copyright
- 45:48law cases, that could be good in one respect.
- 45:53You might create a lot of uniformity and and
- 45:59eliminate some of the from circuit to circuit
- 46:03lack of clarity with respect to software copyright
- 46:05law issues. Although that was one of the main
- 46:11complaints about the court's oracle be Google
- 46:14decisions was that we had clarity, we had uniformity.
- 46:19I don't know. I think folks might have exaggerated
- 46:22the amount of uniformity, but there was some
- 46:26precedent that being an industry at the time,
- 46:30we advised clients, both internal and external
- 46:35when I was at a law firm, about software copyrightability
- 46:39issues all the time based on that seeming sort
- 46:44of accepted standard or uniformity with respect
- 46:47to software copyright. And after the Oracle v
- 46:53Google decision to the federal circuit level,
- 46:56that sort of upended things. So I think this
- 47:01is in terms of the Federal Circuit as a copyright
- 47:03law decision maker. If really most important
- 47:08software copyright decisions are going to the
- 47:10Federal Circuit and that court becomes sort of
- 47:13the de facto Supreme Court of that subject matter
- 47:17with respect to copyright law. Could be a good
- 47:20thing useful thing in terms of creating uniformity,
- 47:23but it also depending on that uniformity and
- 47:27what they do with copyright law might it might
- 47:32actually You know get in the way of Software
- 47:37innovation Depending again on how they what they
- 47:41do with copyright and again some people think
- 47:44that's that was that was what happened with the
- 47:48the Federal Circuit's Oracle v. Google decisions.
- 47:52But I think there's no need present time to alter
- 47:56the jurisdiction of the court. He gets a steady
- 48:00diet of copyright law decisions from the Court
- 48:03of Federal Claims, and is writing about one opinion
- 48:11per year from other circuits. And so it seems
- 48:14to be functioning relatively well. on that front,
- 48:19but again, the software copyright law thing I
- 48:22think is the major thing to continue to monitor
- 48:26going forward. I can stop there for now, and
- 48:31if people have questions or comments that they'd
- 48:36like to offer, I'd be happy to entertain those.
- 48:42All right. So it does look like we had a few
- 48:44questions coming in through our email help desk.
- 48:49So regarding findings or your methodology, you
- 48:56note reviewing quite a few majority copyright
- 48:59opinions. How do you control for selection bias,
- 49:01especially in less reported or unpublished opinions?
- 49:05Yeah. That's a good question. I think so Westlaw
- 49:10There there's absolutely selection bias here.
- 49:13There's no way to really I mean when you're when
- 49:15you're picking written opinions You are biased
- 49:19like your selection is biased And so I've tried
- 49:23to address that in the paper just by noting like
- 49:28I have a Discussion in the paper about this very
- 49:32thing that you know written opinions tell us
- 49:35might tell us certain things, but they might
- 49:37actually mask a lot of other things that we're
- 49:39curious about. And so I've tried to not overstate
- 49:43the findings in light of this bias. The other
- 49:49thing about that question that I would respond
- 49:52to is just that unpublished decisions, the difference
- 50:00between published and unpublished decisions is
- 50:03still a very real one. But since the E -Government
- 50:07Act and where everything is now like opinions
- 50:09just in general are electronically available
- 50:11and Westlaw and other services sort of suck them
- 50:17all up, put them all, you know, post them, include
- 50:20them in their database. That aspect of the bias
- 50:25I think is not really, is no longer just because
- 50:30they're all effectively in a different definition
- 50:36of the word published by these services. That
- 50:39wasn't the case prior to the government act,
- 50:42which went into effect as 2002. And then I think
- 50:45the effective date was 2003 to 2004. So before
- 50:52that, there definitely was like even more bias
- 50:56and difficulty because unpublished decisions
- 51:00were not available. But since at least the government
- 51:05act, I think that concern lessens or has diminished
- 51:11quite a bit. Okay. I have another one. If the
- 51:19federal circuit leans pro -defendant in most
- 51:22DMCA cases, what factors might you think explain
- 51:25this or do you expect this to persist as digital
- 51:27enforcement issues of all? It's a good question.
- 51:33So it was both decisions were written by Judge
- 51:41Rader, who is no longer with the court. And it
- 51:47was just an interpretation of the DMCA that I
- 51:51don't think most other circuits, particularly
- 51:54the Ninth Circuit, has followed. And I think
- 51:58when you read most case books and talk to most
- 52:02people, the federal circuit position is definitely
- 52:07a minority one that most folks don't follow.
- 52:12Maybe because people look at it and think, well,
- 52:15you've just misapplied the underlying circuit
- 52:19law. That's not actually how it should be interpreted.
- 52:25So the DMCA is interesting there there are I
- 52:31Did a study on the DMCA as well and tried to
- 52:33find all the relevant Opinions out there and
- 52:38there's there's literally like in terms of Court
- 52:41of like appellate decisions like I'd have to
- 52:44look I don't remember the numbers on the top
- 52:46of my head But there's just so little out there
- 52:50And I have some sort of suppositions in the paper
- 52:53as to why, why there hasn't been more, I don't
- 53:00know if there's not robust enforcement. I think
- 53:03it's just, it's a curious piece of legislation
- 53:06that just hasn't resulted in much interpretation
- 53:12or decision -making. I think the second part
- 53:15of the question was, Can you repeat it? Do I
- 53:19expect that to, in the digital sphere, to, like,
- 53:23increase? Yeah, let me find that again. I think
- 53:26it was to... I expect it to persist as digital
- 53:31enforcement issues evolve. Like what to persist?
- 53:37Sorry, I just want to make sure I understand
- 53:38the question. Just the lack of decisions? I think
- 53:46it... may refer to the circuit leaning pro -defendant.
- 53:54Oh. It's a good question. I'm not sure. I mean,
- 54:02I think it's been some time since anyone has
- 54:05really followed the federal circuit on its DMCA
- 54:08interpretation. I tend to agree with the Federal
- 54:13Circuit on its interpretation of the DMCA just
- 54:16because I think it's, its interpretation is basically
- 54:20you have to have a predicate copyright infringement
- 54:25offense, like underlying copyright infringement
- 54:27offense for the DMCA to apply. Ninth Circuit
- 54:29has applied or interpreted differently, just
- 54:32say the DMCA is its own beast, like it doesn't
- 54:34necessarily require copyright infringement happening.
- 54:38And so I sort of side with the interpretation
- 54:44of the federal circuit. But the Ninth Circuit
- 54:49is sort of the leader in terms of it and the
- 54:52Second Circuit, but the Ninth Circuit even more
- 54:53is the leader in terms of copyright law issues.
- 54:57Other circuits follow it. And so my, if I had
- 54:59to predict, I would think that probably folks
- 55:03will continue to follow the Ninth Circuit going
- 55:05forward. The DMCA was in act in 1998, that's
- 55:10like ancient history now. And so it's probably
- 55:14due for, I mean, they have the, the, the biennial
- 55:19or the, the, the, the triennial, I'm forget annual
- 55:28like where they approve new exceptions to the
- 55:30DMCA, which is useful in terms of updating it
- 55:34in light of current developments in technology
- 55:39but I think the DMCA itself could use an update
- 55:43like many other pieces of legislation that basically
- 55:47when they're by the time they're enacted the
- 55:49world has moved on and so trying to keep up with
- 55:52technological development is often difficult
- 55:53to do legislatively and it I think is one reason
- 55:58why we sort of sometimes leave it to the courts
- 56:02to try to keep up with with what's changing.
- 56:06But my prediction would be Ninth Circuit position
- 56:09is pretty entrenched and it will probably continue
- 56:11to prevail. All right. Great. Thank you. It doesn't
- 56:17look like we appear to have any more questions
- 56:19in the Q &A regarding your presentation. So I
- 56:22would say that this concludes today's presentation.
- 56:25Thank you so much, Professor Acy, for your time.
- 56:27And thank you so much to our audience for joining
- 56:29us today. Yeah. Thank you. Appreciate it. You
- 56:33may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 56:36visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.