Latest / Beyond the Ballot AZ / Arizona School Money: Where does it go?
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Beyond the Ballot AZ.
- 0:03I'm your host,
- 0:04Tom Collins,
- 0:05Executive Director of the Arizona Citizens Clean Elections Commission.
- 0:08And I'm Gina Roberts,
- 0:09Voter Education Director for Clean Elections.
- 0:12Today,
- 0:12we're talking about how money and schools and buildings converge.
- 0:17You know,
- 0:18we're just coming off of a November 4th election.
- 0:21About 10 out of our 15 counties had elections.
- 0:24And so voters saw a lot,
- 0:26especially here in Maricopa County.
- 0:28of items related to schools,
- 0:30to public schools.
- 0:31We saw everything from looking at maintenance and override elections to districts seeking bond approvals to districts seeking authority to sell or lease property.
- 0:45And so voters had to make some important decisions here.
- 0:48And what's interesting is when you look at the results,
- 0:51which are available,
- 0:52and you can go to our website for those,
- 0:54you know
- 0:55not every district voted the same way.
- 0:57So we actually did have some districts where their voters rejected those bond measures.
- 1:04And now those districts are going to have to figure out what to do with those potential shortfalls that they have in that funding that the bond approval would have provided.
- 1:12And then we have several districts where voters said,
- 1:14yes,
- 1:14let's go ahead and do it.
- 1:16So it's really interesting to see how voters across the county,
- 1:20across the state,
- 1:21made their voice heard on education.
- 1:27We're here with Glenn Farley.
- 1:28He's the Director of Policy and Research at the Common Sense Institute.
- 1:32He spent eight years with Governor Ducey's administration as Chief Economist and Policy Advisor,
- 1:37and recently he's led research on school capital financing at CSI.
- 1:42Glenn,
- 1:42thanks for joining the show.
- 1:43Thanks for having me,
- 1:44Tom.
- 1:44Pleasure to be here.
- 1:45So,
- 1:46Glenn,
- 1:46I read your report that was published on the Common Sense Institute's website.
- 1:51I believe it was in August.
- 1:53A lot of great information in there.
- 1:55You know,
- 1:56it took me a bit to read it,
- 1:57but I thought it was very interesting.
- 1:58And
- 1:59I learned a lot.
- 2:00And it seemed like the main takeaway here was that your research found that school capital finance standards are outdated.
- 2:07So can you walk our listeners through that?
- 2:09And really,
- 2:10what does that mean?
- 2:11Why are they outdated?
- 2:12And what do we need to do about it?
- 2:15Recall,
- 2:15if you will,
- 2:16what kind of the state of Arizona looked like in the late
- 2:201990s, and particularly in the early
- 2:222000s before the Great Recession.
- 2:25This was a period of rapid growth and our school districts were growing extremely rapidly at the time as well.
- 2:31And the sort of foundational assumptions that policymakers made at the time is this growth would continue more or less in perpetuity.
- 2:39So the systems were designed in that environment with that assumption.
- 2:43Given perpetual rapid growth,
- 2:46how do we fund that growth quickly,
- 2:48efficiently and in perpetuity?
- 2:50What they never really contemplated was the possibility that...
- 2:54student enrollment growth or state growth generally would plateau or even decline.
- 2:59What happened in 2008 with the Great Recession and every year since is exactly that.
- 3:04District enrollment in Arizona peaked in 2008.
- 3:08It's declined every year since.
- 3:10During and after the pandemic,
- 3:11that decline really accelerated.
- 3:14Enrollment more or less fell off a cliff in the 2020 to 2021 period,
- 3:18recovered somewhat before resuming decline.
- 3:20Despite
- 3:22those long-term declines,
- 3:23though,
- 3:24the school system has continued growing.
- 3:26Total funding has continued growing,
- 3:28and the number of capital assets,
- 3:30buildings,
- 3:31square footage have continued growing.
- 3:33And the report you talk about flags that gulf,
- 3:36that today we've got roughly twice as much space and assets in the district school system in Arizona than are needed given current enrollment levels.
- 3:48We think...
- 3:49The cause of that gap is exactly those formulas that were designed
- 3:5325 years ago.
- 3:55I know since COVID,
- 3:56personally as a parent,
- 3:57my perspective on education has changed.
- 4:00But are we seeing those low enrollment rates come from just families doing what's best for them in terms of school choice?
- 4:06Is this private schools,
- 4:07charter schools?
- 4:09With those enrollment rates you just mentioned,
- 4:11do those include charter school figures?
- 4:13You're sort of getting to the crux of the issue,
- 4:16which is...
- 4:17what happened back in 2008,
- 4:20A,
- 4:20and then what really happened,
- 4:22if you will,
- 4:23after the pandemic.
- 4:24So the long-term trend
- 4:252008 on is slow demographic change.
- 4:29First declining birth rates,
- 4:31and now,
- 4:32as of 2022,
- 4:33declining school-age populations.
- 4:35So school-age population in Arizona,
- 4:37the growth rate peaked prior to the Great Recession.
- 4:40Total population of 5 to 17 year olds peaked in 2022,
- 4:44and we've lost five to 17 year olds.
- 4:46ever since.
- 4:47So that simply means there are fewer children total than we anticipated back in the
- 4:532000s. But there's a second part of that,
- 4:54which you also allude to.
- 4:57Demographic change alone can't explain the scale of the enrollment gap.
- 5:01It's much larger than the either slowdown or subsequent decline in the number of kids.
- 5:07That is something we call sort of the preference shift.
- 5:10And for sure,
- 5:11many folks picked up on this preference shift during and after the pandemic.
- 5:15But I think there's some evidence that it's been sort of occurring slowly,
- 5:20steadily over time.
- 5:21You asked,
- 5:22were those enrollment figures specific to the districts or they include charters.
- 5:26When Arizona talks about total public K-12 enrollment,
- 5:29we're talking the sum of district and charters combined.
- 5:32They're both in there,
- 5:34which is why I think the district phenomenon specifically has been sort of hiding in plain sight since 2008.
- 5:40Total public K-12 enrollment in Arizona has grown every year since 2008.
- 5:44That didn't start shrinking until 2021.
- 5:47All the growth,
- 5:48though,
- 5:48between 2008 and 2021 was on the charter side.
- 5:51District enrollment peaked way back in 2008.
- 5:54That...
- 5:54is a consequence of the preference shift.
- 5:56You know,
- 5:57several weeks before the election,
- 5:59we had another inflection point,
- 6:00which was the state judge found that the state side of this formula was not being kept up to the state constitutional standard for a general and uniform school system.
- 6:15How do you see that case fitting into this as a policy matter?
- 6:18Is this an opportunity?
- 6:19Is this a threat?
- 6:20Is this,
- 6:22you know?
- 6:22I mean,
- 6:23the judge obviously is bound by the existing case law.
- 6:25I'd say clearly,
- 6:26depending on your perspective,
- 6:29it's a threat in the certainly fiscal sense of the word in that the historic response to this,
- 6:35whether it was the litigation back in the
- 6:3790s or the litigation following the Great Recession and the legislature's decision to suspend certain formula elements,
- 6:44the historical solution to these problems,
- 6:46yes,
- 6:46has been new formulas,
- 6:47but also new funding,
- 6:48right?
- 6:49And new funding comes with new costs at a time when the legislature is already grappling with record high funding and a slowdown in revenue growth,
- 6:56right?
- 6:56So it's a risk from that perspective.
- 6:58And I want to just disclaim at the beginning that I'm certainly not an attorney,
- 7:02and this is just sort of my lay opinion given the data.
- 7:05But what's unequivocally true is the system that was designed in the
- 7:1190s in response in part to litigation at that time was intended to address in part equity issues.
- 7:18the balance the legislature struck,
- 7:20and this was really a political balance driven by,
- 7:23in many cases,
- 7:24the asks,
- 7:25wants,
- 7:25and desires of the school districts themselves,
- 7:28was to maintain the option for what we're calling the bonds and overrides for sort of local control over their school district funding while still establishing almost a floor,
- 7:40a basic bare minimum that the state would guarantee regardless of whether your voters would want to approve um,
- 7:47um,
- 7:48Approve additional funding,
- 7:49if that makes sense.
- 7:50That was the balance that the legislature tried to strike.
- 7:54It's arguable,
- 7:56and I think the argument is ongoing,
- 7:57whether the legislature succeeded or not.
- 8:00What is inarguably true is the amount of money that's been invested system-wide over the last two decades is far in excess of what enrollment growth alone should have demanded.
- 8:11And the result should be that we have a lot of excess facilities and a lot of facilities
- 8:17We should see it showing up on the quality side.
- 8:19And this is where I think there's a massive data gap that's fueling litigation and public angst and things like that.
- 8:29We don't really have a good sense of the quality of the school facilities in
- 8:34Arizona. We have anecdotal sense.
- 8:36And this is when districts,
- 8:39particular districts with particular issues,
- 8:41call attention to their particular issues,
- 8:43but on sort of a system-wide basis.
- 8:45There's very little sense,
- 8:47in my opinion,
- 8:47of the quality of the facilities.
- 8:49But just looking at the gaps between the enrollment numbers and the funding numbers,
- 8:54to me,
- 8:55as an outsider looking in,
- 8:56that money had to go somewhere.
- 8:58My suspicion is that money has gone to renovating and improving the facilities,
- 9:04not just building more empty buildings.
- 9:05So I think the facilities are probably a lot nicer than we think.
- 9:08What I would like to see is some sort of an inventory,
- 9:11some sort of an objective look at what exactly we have.
- 9:14And what is its quality on an objective and sort of holistic basis?
- 9:18But I think that's missing at the moment.
- 9:20And what about Prop 123?
- 9:22Does that play a role here?
- 9:23We know voters approved that in,
- 9:25I believe it's 2016.
- 9:26We didn't see it on the ballot this year in 2025.
- 9:29Not sure if or when it's going to come to voters again to consider.
- 9:33But what sort of impact does Prop 123 have here?
- 9:36Yeah,
- 9:37so for a little bit of background for your listeners,
- 9:39Proposition 123 was itself a solution to another round of litigation.
- 9:45This time,
- 9:45it was litigation related to decisions the legislature made during the Great Recession.
- 9:50There was a funding crisis,
- 9:51a revenue crisis in Arizona during the Great Recession,
- 9:54so there wasn't enough money to meet the state's expenditures.
- 9:57The legislature suspended some elements of the K-12 formula to balance the books.
- 10:01The litigation was over the legality of those suspensions.
- 10:04It was ultimately settled.
- 10:06with the school districts.
- 10:07The settlement required the state to put in a bunch of new and one-time,
- 10:14a combination of new ongoing and one-time monies to sort of compensate them for those recessionary cuts.
- 10:20One of the tools that the state used to pay for that settlement was Proposition 123,
- 10:25which temporarily for 10 years increased distributions from the land trust.
- 10:29As you alluded to,
- 10:30Gina,
- 10:30that had a 10-year sunset date.
- 10:32It is now sunsetting.
- 10:34If the legislature does nothing,
- 10:35which as of now they've done nothing,
- 10:37because the formulas,
- 10:39this is exactly what gave rise to the Great Recession litigation,
- 10:42the formulas are what we call voter protected.
- 10:44It means that the state is sort of constitutionally required to fund these formulas.
- 10:50The expiration of Prop 123 doesn't result in any cuts to the K-12 system.
- 10:56The state must continue to pay the same amount.
- 10:58It'll just shift it from the state's land trust to the state general fund.
- 11:02So the consequence of doing nothing,
- 11:04Gina,
- 11:05is the funding stays exactly the same,
- 11:07but how we pay for it shifts from the land trust to the general fund.
- 11:12The good news is the general fund is much larger today than it was in 2016 when we were settling this lawsuit.
- 11:18So it's much more able to absorb that cost than it was a decade ago.
- 11:24And so I think that status quo is affordable and sustainable.
- 11:28But again,
- 11:28if that's the right call policy-wise is a different question.
- 11:35We're talking a lot about,
- 11:36you know,
- 11:37the policy,
- 11:37the funding,
- 11:38right?
- 11:39We're talking about the money.
- 11:41But then,
- 11:42to me,
- 11:42what's missing is,
- 11:43well,
- 11:43who's making the decision on where those monies are going to?
- 11:47And how do I have a say in that as a parent,
- 11:49you know,
- 11:50as a resident?
- 11:51And so to me,
- 11:52this is where I think,
- 11:53you know,
- 11:53it's important to get involved with your local governing board.
- 11:56And,
- 11:57you know,
- 11:58as we go through and we see future elections and paying attention to those elections,
- 12:02you can vote on them,
- 12:02but also
- 12:03School's in session right now.
- 12:05Your governing board is probably meeting once a month.
- 12:07Look up those public notices and agendas.
- 12:09Go attend those public meetings.
- 12:11Look at what's on the agenda and have a say in what your local leaders are deciding on how to spend those monies.
- 12:18The other thing that
- 12:19I would add about what we're trying to do is to put voters in a position where when they go to a school district meeting,
- 12:27they can listen to the content we have and read the materials on our website.
- 12:32And understand some of the bureaucratic shorthand that a school board or a legislator might speak in that doesn't necessarily naturally translate to how regular people talk or think about things,
- 12:45right?
- 12:45So when somebody says a bond,
- 12:47they're probably talking about a building.
- 12:49When somebody says M&O,
- 12:50they're probably talking about something related to personnel or programs.
- 12:55You know,
- 12:55when somebody talks about a state formula,
- 12:59you know,
- 12:59they're talking about,
- 13:00you know,
- 13:01money that's coming.
- 13:02from state taxpayers when somebody talks about,
- 13:06you know,
- 13:07the federal government,
- 13:08you know,
- 13:08where's that money?
- 13:09And because if you're trying to understand why your legislator votes a certain way or what the issues that your school district is wrangling with,
- 13:18it's helpful to at least,
- 13:19if you're going to follow that discussion,
- 13:21have some understanding of the terminology they're using and what that means practically.
- 13:27And we hope that through our website,
- 13:29this podcast,
- 13:30our newsletter
- 13:31You know,
- 13:33all those products are designed to,
- 13:36you know,
- 13:37build up to our role in educating folks about our statewide candidates and election in 2026,
- 13:45where we know that whether it's a candidate election,
- 13:49whether there is something on the ballot or not,
- 13:52you know,
- 13:52voters are going to be thinking about how does this affect my student and how does this affect my school and how does this affect my bottom line.
- 14:02Thanks for listening to Beyond the Bell at AZ.
- 14:03I'm Tom Collins.
- 14:05And I'm Gina Roberts.