Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - Kicking the Bucket Down the Road
Transcript
- 0:06This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 0:08an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:10discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:12education.
- 0:13We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:15ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:16and everything in between.
- 0:18And because this conversation will almost
- 0:19certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:21we'll end up covering just about
- 0:22everything else.
- 0:24And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 0:30For December fifth, twenty twenty five,
- 0:31it's the best sounding and most
- 0:33emotionally relevant podcast in higher ed.
- 0:35This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:37Episode number one hundred and twenty
- 0:39eight.
- 0:40Broadcasting live from coast to coast
- 0:42where the calendar says December,
- 0:44but the season hasn't quite committed to
- 0:46Christmas.
- 0:47Just enough twinkle lights to stress you
- 0:49out,
- 0:49but not enough to justify completely
- 0:51giving up on your work productivity.
- 0:54It's kind of like that.
- 0:54It's that magical time of year where like
- 0:56every meeting begins with.
- 0:59Do you think you can do this before
- 1:00the break?
- 1:00And every project updates with, well,
- 1:02we'll just check back in January.
- 1:05And yet here we are,
- 1:06cheerfully ignoring our inboxes,
- 1:08pretending we're not all thirty seconds
- 1:09away from just putting on an ugly sweater
- 1:11and calling it good for the year.
- 1:13But there's some good news.
- 1:15The calendar has officially crossed into
- 1:17the legally acceptable time frame for you
- 1:19to put up your Christmas decorations.
- 1:21No HOA citations.
- 1:23That's like weeks, brother.
- 1:25No way.
- 1:25December first or you go to jail.
- 1:28Anyway, I'm Chris Dexter.
- 1:29Jail's bad.
- 1:30Friday afternoon podcast adventure with
- 1:32the AV super super super for those with
- 1:36AV super friends.
- 1:37And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:39AV super friends with this one.
- 1:46Here it is.
- 1:48Our first panelist is not even here,
- 1:50so let me skip him there.
- 1:51Jerk didn't show.
- 1:52Our second panelist leads cross-functional
- 1:55initiatives to make sure that every device
- 1:57on the network is emotionally and
- 1:59operationally compatible.
- 2:01He's a chief endpoint harmonization
- 2:02strategist from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 2:04Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolosinski.
- 2:05You hear that?
- 2:08That is the sound of all the bits
- 2:10and bytes in unison singing holiday carols
- 2:13out there.
- 2:14Can you hear them?
- 2:15When you don't hear anything,
- 2:16it's perfectly in sync.
- 2:16Because they're out of phase perfectly?
- 2:19Yes.
- 2:20All right.
- 2:20One positive, one negative.
- 2:23Our next panelist maintains peaceful,
- 2:24balanced Feng Shui aligned equipment racks
- 2:30that reduce outages through good vibes
- 2:32alone.
- 2:32He's an associate director of Proactive
- 2:34Rack Serenity from Greensboro,
- 2:36North Carolina.
- 2:36Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:38Yep, heaviest burdens on the bottom,
- 2:40just push them all the way down.
- 2:43Those are called amplifiers.
- 2:44Yeah, that too.
- 2:45Those are shelves for all the other stuff.
- 2:49And our last panelist oversees the
- 2:51delicate art of aligning organizational
- 2:53synergy fields across all conferencing
- 2:55platforms.
- 2:56He's a vice president of distributed
- 3:00synergy calibration from Bowling Green,
- 3:02Kentucky.
- 3:02Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 3:05When I see five departments doing things
- 3:07wrong,
- 3:08I make them go back and do it
- 3:10once correctly.
- 3:12Just one of them?
- 3:14All together.
- 3:15Not sure if that was legit good advice
- 3:17or not.
- 3:17Synergy.
- 3:19Synergy.
- 3:20It's one of those energy drinks.
- 3:21Oh,
- 3:21I thought by synergy it was the ability
- 3:23to send your mouse cursor to other
- 3:24computers.
- 3:26That's...
- 3:26Like five people just got that joke.
- 3:28I got that.
- 3:29Well, you're one of them.
- 3:30Four of them on this call.
- 3:32Four others, yes.
- 3:32They make weird USB shit.
- 3:35They make software shit.
- 3:36Weird USB shit.
- 3:37They used to make weird USB shit.
- 3:38Now they make software that does weird
- 3:40stuff.
- 3:41On today's show,
- 3:41we're going to discuss who is or at
- 3:43least who should be managing the PCs in
- 3:45our classrooms.
- 3:46And we're going to talk about where we're
- 3:47getting those PCs.
- 3:49And we're also going to talk about our
- 3:50preferred deployment of PTZ cameras or
- 3:52maybe not PTZ cameras or maybe not
- 3:54cameras.
- 3:55But first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 3:57Yes.
- 3:58So before you plug in that questionable
- 4:00string of Christmas lights that you've
- 4:01been using every year since nineteen
- 4:02ninety seven, remember,
- 4:03we do stream live every Friday at about
- 4:05three fifteen Eastern or twelve fifteen,
- 4:07twelve fifteen Pacific or whenever I get
- 4:09my crap together because today is my
- 4:11fault.
- 4:12I decided to update all of my stuff,
- 4:16and it was working fine a week ago,
- 4:18and now it wasn't,
- 4:18and I didn't touch anything,
- 4:19and it was a whole thing.
- 4:20That sounds like a Justin problem.
- 4:23It usually is a Justin problem,
- 4:24but I touched many, many,
- 4:25many things today.
- 4:27to get where we are today i rolled
- 4:28back to a good old uh just one
- 4:30in one out that's it it's got one
- 4:32gazinta one gazouta that's that's the
- 4:34correct but i don't have any fancy
- 4:37schmancy stuff which i had working so we
- 4:39can't do that so um
- 4:44You can catch us live on Twitter,
- 4:46LinkedIn, YouTube, et cetera.
- 4:47And remember, never mind.
- 4:50I'll screw that.
- 4:51Okay.
- 4:52Sorry.
- 4:52I'm skipping through things here.
- 4:54If you are listening to this later as
- 4:55a recorded MP three,
- 4:56while you're out there hanging your
- 4:57Christmas wreaths or debating the ethics
- 4:59of inflatable lawn decor, it's wrong.
- 5:01Please stop doing that.
- 5:02You can follow us on all the socials,
- 5:04Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, Blue Sky.
- 5:05Larry popped it.
- 5:06Well, I saw Larry's reaction there.
- 5:07Larry has inflatable lawn decor.
- 5:08I have an inflatable Santa.
- 5:10Are they like DMX controlled,
- 5:12like Wi-Fi enabled, all that fun stuff?
- 5:13Do you have dancing Santa?
- 5:15I do not have that yet,
- 5:16but there is a guy,
- 5:17first year he's done this,
- 5:20he did one of those like National Lampoon
- 5:23Christmas vacation house lighting things.
- 5:26It's on the drive-in.
- 5:29dude it makes you feel bad every time
- 5:30you drive past it no it makes you
- 5:31just like wreck and pull off the road
- 5:33it's horrible it's just shining lasers
- 5:35into the streets i've always wanted to do
- 5:39that but you you start to like do
- 5:41a little bit of lights and you're like
- 5:42how do people have time to do this
- 5:44stuff like where did i mean this is
- 5:46you led wall like where does he find
- 5:49the time no idea it's nuts
- 5:55If you're committing to that level of like
- 5:56holiday lighting decor,
- 5:58you might just be independently wealthy
- 6:00and it doesn't matter.
- 6:01Going back to Raul's comment,
- 6:03that random comment for Raul.
- 6:04So if I scream during the podcast,
- 6:08it's not from excitement, it's from pain.
- 6:10I got like this.
- 6:12Oh, you muted my mic.
- 6:13I'm trying to jack with your audio because
- 6:15you were blown out, sir.
- 6:17I'm blowing out.
- 6:18And you weren't before,
- 6:19so you're either getting angry or...
- 6:22That's just a new problem.
- 6:23I don't need that kind of problem this
- 6:24weekend.
- 6:25Are you back on the IR again, Justin?
- 6:26Is that what you're telling me?
- 6:28The IR?
- 6:29Injured Reserve.
- 6:30Oh.
- 6:30I don't know.
- 6:33Maybe.
- 6:34All right.
- 6:35Well, let's move on.
- 6:36Okay.
- 6:38I'm trying to take some pain pills.
- 6:40Tell people about the show,
- 6:41leave a rating, and please donate.
- 6:43I had a whole thing here about getting
- 6:45Larry a new duck for his Jeep,
- 6:46but see, we've ruined it, so.
- 6:47Duck?
- 6:47Really?
- 6:48It's a whole thing.
- 6:50See, I got all this stuff written up.
- 6:51If I see you parked out here later,
- 6:52I'll give you that.
- 6:52You guys are interrupting my flow,
- 6:54and the whole thing's a mess.
- 6:55I'm going to start over.
- 6:57Hold on.
- 6:58Hold on.
- 7:00All right.
- 7:02Now I'm all out of sorts,
- 7:02so we've got other stuff to do.
- 7:03I'm going to take a quick break.
- 7:04We're going to come back and we're going
- 7:05to talk about, what are we talking about?
- 7:06Oh, our news.
- 7:07But first,
- 7:08this and how to fix all your conference
- 7:10room audio.
- 7:12Are you tired of immersive spatial and
- 7:14multi-channel audio systems that make
- 7:16voices sound like they're sneaking up
- 7:18behind you?
- 7:19Do you long for a simpler time when
- 7:22sound came from one place and that place
- 7:25was dead center?
- 7:27Introducing Reality Audio,
- 7:29the most advanced single-channel audio
- 7:32experience ever engineered.
- 7:34At last,
- 7:35every listener in your conference room,
- 7:37classroom,
- 7:38or hybrid space hears exactly the same
- 7:40thing.
- 7:41at exactly the same time.
- 7:44No fancy panning.
- 7:45No virtual positioning.
- 7:47No, where's that sound coming from?
- 7:50Just pure, authentic, centralized realism.
- 7:53With Reality Audio,
- 7:55you won't feel surrounded anymore.
- 7:57You'll feel centered.
- 7:59Because the real world isn't surround.
- 8:02It's right in front of you.
- 8:04Reality Audio.
- 8:06One channel.
- 8:07Infinite simplicity.
- 8:09By Independent Amalgamated.
- 8:14Or twenty-seven channel spatial whatever
- 8:16nonsense.
- 8:16Sounds so simple and nice.
- 8:18Yeah.
- 8:18Harking back to the good old days.
- 8:20Everybody here is the same thing.
- 8:21It does just freaking work.
- 8:22All right, and that's with that.
- 8:23And now, you've waited for it all week,
- 8:25or like two weeks,
- 8:26or however long it's been.
- 8:27Time for Justin to sing along live with
- 8:29his theme.
- 8:29Here it goes.
- 8:30Ready?
- 8:30Do it.
- 8:31Yeah.
- 8:35Yeah.
- 8:37uh today's news and link is in the
- 8:38show notes uh comes from rave pubs find
- 8:41folks over there covering all the news of
- 8:42the industry and this one is the headline
- 8:45is barco secures damages in click share
- 8:48patent case against yay link that sounds
- 8:51like a lot of lawyers yes so it's
- 8:54another you know av manufacturer suing a
- 8:57different av manufacturer and i understand
- 8:59you have to protect your patents and all
- 9:00that stuff but
- 9:02So what did they steal?
- 9:03What did they claim?
- 9:04Who steeled?
- 9:05They invented circles.
- 9:06The buttons that share your screen.
- 9:09So they're suing Yealink?
- 9:12Yeah.
- 9:12So Yealink,
- 9:13and we were talking about it before the
- 9:14show.
- 9:14Does Yealink make a button?
- 9:18Who else has one?
- 9:19Panasonic.
- 9:19Monoprice.
- 9:21Well, there's just Gennaro, you know,
- 9:23trying to best price.
- 9:24Yealink button.
- 9:25There's like thirty of these things out
- 9:26there,
- 9:27and these are the wireless dongles you
- 9:28plug into, you know,
- 9:29it's HDMI on one side and the other
- 9:30one's usually HDMI that I've seen USB-C as
- 9:32well.
- 9:33You push a button,
- 9:34it does a point-to-point connection.
- 9:36You don't have to be on Wi-Fi or
- 9:37any of that stuff.
- 9:38It just sends your screen from one place
- 9:39to the other.
- 9:40Very convenient.
- 9:41I understand the advantage to having that.
- 9:45You also have a company coming in and
- 9:46just suing the crap out of people for
- 9:48doing it.
- 9:49Which I wouldn't mind, except for like,
- 9:51just take the ViewSonic one, for example.
- 9:54That's like a hundred and fifty bucks.
- 9:56I can add this feature to a room
- 9:57for a hundred fifty bucks or I can
- 10:01check the click share price and not do
- 10:03that.
- 10:04You sound like Jamie.
- 10:06Or look at the thing you can't afford
- 10:07legally and not get it.
- 10:10It's a feature I'd like to have.
- 10:11It's not one I have to have.
- 10:13It sounds more problematic to add a...
- 10:15And this is just like the little Sherry
- 10:17buttony thing.
- 10:18Sherry dingly-dangle-dongle.
- 10:20I've never been a huge fan of those.
- 10:22No, I agree.
- 10:24I mean, I don't want them everywhere,
- 10:25but they do have a place in those
- 10:28public-facing venues or something.
- 10:30Just be like, oh, plug this in,
- 10:31hit the button, and you're done.
- 10:32yeah like for the office where the
- 10:36architects have to come in and share their
- 10:38laptop i don't want them on the network
- 10:39i don't want to have to deal with
- 10:40all that you don't want their kind on
- 10:42your network seriously they bring in their
- 10:44their consultant friends i don't want them
- 10:46on the network either like this they're
- 10:47dirty consultant laptops on my wi-fi oh no
- 10:50yeah it's like spreading your diseases
- 10:53give them this
- 10:55They can click it and share it,
- 10:57and then I can burn it after the
- 10:58meeting.
- 10:58They can click it and share it?
- 11:00You're about to get sued.
- 11:01I'm not really sure if you're serious
- 11:03about that or not, Larry.
- 11:04I don't know.
- 11:05Oh, he's serious.
- 11:07Are you?
- 11:08Do you really want to keep architects and
- 11:10consultants off your network?
- 11:11No,
- 11:12but I'm saying there are use cases for
- 11:16this type of appliance.
- 11:18Where?
- 11:19I haven't heard of it.
- 11:20No, that wasn't one.
- 11:21That was not valid.
- 11:22I'm not going to get everybody who shows
- 11:25up on the network.
- 11:26Do you have any public-facing venues,
- 11:27maybe a conference center or something?
- 11:29Yes, there's guest Wi-Fi,
- 11:31but how many people can seem to never
- 11:33figure out how to get on that while
- 11:34you connect to it all day long?
- 11:36and can your guest wi-fi get to your
- 11:38wireless sharing appliance that's a
- 11:40different issue the answer is no never we
- 11:42don't we don't put those in yeah this
- 11:43is i don't put audio in i would
- 11:47imagine your production venues are just
- 11:49like there's your vga you're asking for
- 11:54yeah wireless check your cell phone
- 11:59Like if you bring your own wireless
- 12:01doohickey thing,
- 12:02you could plug it in this HDMI and
- 12:04walk around and that's you to support.
- 12:07You're on your own.
- 12:08Point to point all day long.
- 12:10Don't ask me.
- 12:10Bring your own.
- 12:11We don't do the hockey putt thing just
- 12:13because we know they're going to get
- 12:14stolen, walk off, disappear, get lost.
- 12:20Nobody knows how to store anything
- 12:22anymore.
- 12:23Keep things organized, you know.
- 12:26We had that question today from a
- 12:28department who has their own, like,
- 12:29limited...
- 12:30It's an old classroom that they've taken
- 12:32offline.
- 12:32It's only their space.
- 12:33Only they can use it, whatever.
- 12:34And they walked over to our office to
- 12:36ask if we had the microphones for their
- 12:38room.
- 12:38I'm like, first of all,
- 12:40you're the only ones who can use that
- 12:41room.
- 12:42Secondly,
- 12:42why would we be collecting your
- 12:43microphones from a different building?
- 12:45Did you?
- 12:45Just to make sure they're safe.
- 12:47Well, we do, but no.
- 12:49I think this...
- 12:52the core of the story when we go
- 12:53back to the original news piece here to
- 12:55me is what was the question what was
- 12:57the question with like innovation oh
- 12:59lawyers yeah maybe it's not innovation but
- 13:02just this definitely legal conquest going
- 13:06on in av nowadays where it's like you
- 13:09can't do that that's our thing and well
- 13:12you know what the problem is mark people
- 13:14can't figure out what the new product is
- 13:15because we kind of hit this plateau so
- 13:17they get bored and like i'm gonna sue
- 13:18you because i'm bored
- 13:21Well, if you have patents,
- 13:22you have to vigorously defend said
- 13:24patents.
- 13:25And to that point,
- 13:27if we've capped out on a lot of
- 13:29stuff,
- 13:29we haven't had anything innovative lately
- 13:32in the past few years,
- 13:33people are going to start making the same
- 13:34thing that are similar to other people.
- 13:36Could I interest you in four K-thirty?
- 13:38Ceiling microphone.
- 13:39You stole my patent for a ceiling
- 13:43microphone.
- 13:43I'm going to sue you.
- 13:45No, it wasn't the ceiling microphone.
- 13:46They stole the patent for the shape of
- 13:48the microphone.
- 13:50Can't be a square.
- 13:52Whatever.
- 13:52It doesn't.
- 13:53Okay.
- 13:54But it still is a square,
- 13:55so I don't know.
- 13:57I still buy the squares.
- 13:59Whatever.
- 14:00Sure does.
- 14:02And Sennheiser.
- 14:03Both.
- 14:05Great product.
- 14:05And Yamaha.
- 14:06Not sponsors.
- 14:08Who else?
- 14:08Audio Technica?
- 14:09No, theirs doesn't fit in a two-by-two.
- 14:11But anyway.
- 14:12There's lots of options out there,
- 14:14and they all are two feet by two
- 14:16feet or six mil by six mil.
- 14:17And somehow they haven't been sued.
- 14:19That's the microphone.
- 14:20What about these buttony, clicky,
- 14:21sherry thingies?
- 14:24So let me ask this question to you
- 14:25guys.
- 14:25I'm just more curious.
- 14:26I want to get the panel's thought on
- 14:27this.
- 14:29When you see something like this where
- 14:30someone is suing over an existing property
- 14:33and there's many other options or many
- 14:34other examples of the same thing out
- 14:35there,
- 14:35and I understand legal things take time
- 14:38and all that, but...
- 14:39Do you think less of the company who
- 14:41seems to be aggressively defending their
- 14:43patents?
- 14:44I don't want to buy their stuff because
- 14:45now I'm going to get involved in this
- 14:47nonsense.
- 14:47Here's the interesting part.
- 14:49I knew where you're going with that
- 14:49question.
- 14:50My answer is yes.
- 14:51But what's weird is all these people suing
- 14:53each other.
- 14:55I don't buy any other shit anyway.
- 14:57Well, but so I've never did before.
- 14:59And then I'm like, well, yeah,
- 15:01but take the next step.
- 15:01Let's say that one of these companies
- 15:03things came up.
- 15:03Are you in?
- 15:04Are you like, well, no,
- 15:05they're just it depends.
- 15:07It's diapers.
- 15:08It depends.
- 15:09I don't like companies that are like,
- 15:13out there always picking the legal beagle
- 15:15road for every little thing all the time.
- 15:17Like I just did.
- 15:18It's a bad culture thing to me like
- 15:21I don't
- 15:22Seems exhausting.
- 15:23Yeah, if that's your avenue for like,
- 15:26we have to make sure every penny,
- 15:28we're not losing anything for
- 15:29infringement.
- 15:29I guess there's always going to be an
- 15:31exception to the rule, but I don't know.
- 15:33Make a quality product.
- 15:35Provide good service.
- 15:37Hey, maybe we're going to be sued next.
- 15:38Be a good manufacturer.
- 15:39I'm just talking about this.
- 15:39I'm sure there's four or five other
- 15:41knuckleheads out there talking about
- 15:42technology that want this property.
- 15:43That's fine, but I don't know.
- 15:46Just do well.
- 15:48We own property?
- 15:49Do better.
- 15:49Yeah, I mean,
- 15:50there is that argument to be made, Mark,
- 15:51that like,
- 15:53I am no longer an attorney.
- 15:56I was disbarred years ago.
- 15:57But I think the crux of this argument
- 15:59comes that the infringement was on the
- 16:03application of the technology,
- 16:05not necessarily like a one-for-one of the
- 16:06product.
- 16:06But to your point,
- 16:08if your product was superior to theirs
- 16:10anyway,
- 16:10then you wouldn't have anything to worry
- 16:11about.
- 16:12And so if someone's coming along and
- 16:13eating your lunch and, Larry,
- 16:14to your point,
- 16:14it's a hundred fifty bucks instead of
- 16:16fifteen hundred bucks,
- 16:17that's a ten to one.
- 16:19Maybe there's something to be said there.
- 16:20I mean, I got a stupid question.
- 16:22Did car manufacturers go through this?
- 16:24Like, oh, you have a touchscreen.
- 16:25I'm suing you because you stole my idea.
- 16:28You have four wheels in your car.
- 16:29You have a touchscreen.
- 16:30I'm suing you because that's terrible.
- 16:31Give me knobs on my radio back.
- 16:33Well, I mean, either whatever.
- 16:34Did that ever happen?
- 16:37I can't remember that happening.
- 16:38It's probably going on right now.
- 16:40They're making millions and millions.
- 16:41We just don't pay attention to the car
- 16:43news.
- 16:43Just directly in front of you and slightly
- 16:45to the right,
- 16:46isn't there like a giant glass thing that
- 16:48has a computer behind it?
- 16:50It's a window.
- 16:51It's a window.
- 16:51That's what he's going to say.
- 16:53Anyway, okay, well.
- 16:54It's my tree.
- 16:56Legal AV is the trend of the year,
- 16:57allegedly.
- 17:01Yeah.
- 17:01All right.
- 17:02See, here we go.
- 17:02That's my other tree.
- 17:03Our local lawyer.
- 17:06Well, look, where's Raoul Clement?
- 17:08What's he saying about Netflix?
- 17:10Raoul says Netflix has filed countless
- 17:12patents with the U.S.
- 17:13Patent Office, but they're immediately...
- 17:15I think he means immensely.
- 17:16He said immensely,
- 17:18but he said they're immediately.
- 17:19Immediately reversed, not reserved.
- 17:21Raoul, slow down on your typing.
- 17:23They're immediately reversed when it comes
- 17:25to suing over infringement.
- 17:26No, it's reserved.
- 17:29Reserved?
- 17:29Really?
- 17:29Okay.
- 17:29Yeah, they're reserved over suing.
- 17:30It means they're reserved when it comes to
- 17:31suing over infringement.
- 17:33He's using big words.
- 17:34Netflix is reserved when it comes to
- 17:36actually suing over those.
- 17:37Okay, now I understand.
- 17:39It's more about protecting themselves from
- 17:40being sued by others.
- 17:42That I respect.
- 17:44I'm good with that.
- 17:45That's it.
- 17:46You don't sue me, I'll sue you.
- 17:48You don't sue me,
- 17:50or I don't sue you,
- 17:51just know that I own this.
- 17:53Who fired the first shot?
- 17:54You better be on your best.
- 17:57And to Chris's question,
- 17:58this doesn't make me necessarily think
- 18:00worse of either one of them.
- 18:01Oh, I do.
- 18:02But what it does do is it makes
- 18:05me go out and buy a bunch of
- 18:07the products that are currently out there
- 18:09of the things I like before they get
- 18:12sued.
- 18:12You get sued, right?
- 18:13And you can't use them.
- 18:14Oh, so they're...
- 18:15so their marketing and advertising gimmick
- 18:18is learn you're in and you're buying more
- 18:21like this like the specific device that is
- 18:23that is the infringing device is
- 18:25immediately pulled from the market anyway
- 18:26which in this case it was years ago
- 18:28so you can't even go buy that one
- 18:29from yaylink but there's other ones out
- 18:31there so yes if this is something that
- 18:32you deploy uh to larry's point then yeah
- 18:35i would go buy ten of them and
- 18:36stick them on the shelf yeah because now
- 18:38you sell for black friday so you go
- 18:39stock up
- 18:40That's just kicking the bucket down the
- 18:42road.
- 18:42But now you've basically empowered the
- 18:45other companies to know that they can just
- 18:48sue people.
- 18:49It's the whole bucket.
- 18:50You're mixed metaphors.
- 18:52All right, nuts to this.
- 18:53We've dug this one to the ground.
- 18:54Change the metaphors.
- 18:55Let's take a quick break,
- 18:56and then we'll come back,
- 18:57and we'll yell about PCs,
- 18:59which will also be very, very passionate.
- 19:00Buckets are bigger than cans.
- 19:02It's a bigger thing.
- 19:05The AV Superfriends are sponsored by
- 19:07Computer Comforts Incorporated.
- 19:10CCI has been building tech furniture for
- 19:12the education market since nineteen eighty
- 19:14seven.
- 19:15Instructor lecterns, computer lab tables,
- 19:17collaborative tables and active learning
- 19:19clusters are just a few of the many
- 19:20innovative products made by CCI.
- 19:23Speaking of lecterns,
- 19:24Computer Comforts has just released
- 19:26Evolve.
- 19:27If you're looking to future-proof your
- 19:29classroom,
- 19:29Evolve is the Swiss Army knife of
- 19:31lecterns.
- 19:32Seriously,
- 19:33this flexible lectern does it all.
- 19:35Not only is Evolve sit-to-stand and ADA
- 19:38compliant,
- 19:38it's also packed with tech-friendly
- 19:40features.
- 19:41And the best part?
- 19:42It ships fully assembled and ready for
- 19:44action.
- 19:45Check out the ninety-second video to see
- 19:47all the options.
- 19:48Visit ComputerComforts.com slash Evolve.
- 19:59To change up that commercial,
- 20:01they've won a bunch of awards.
- 20:02It's no longer just introduced.
- 20:04Well,
- 20:05don't we have to do some updates to
- 20:07that anyway?
- 20:08We do.
- 20:08Yeah.
- 20:09The term future-proof has been funny the
- 20:11last couple days here.
- 20:13Future-proof.
- 20:13There's like two interpretations of
- 20:14future-proof.
- 20:15One is, oh, we're doing this,
- 20:16and it's going to be great to work
- 20:18on in the future.
- 20:19Or...
- 20:20You can really future-proof something,
- 20:21so it is not possible to work on
- 20:23in the future.
- 20:24Like concrete over it?
- 20:26More like future-protected?
- 20:27Yes.
- 20:28You cannot change this thing,
- 20:30no matter how hard you try.
- 20:31It is in here.
- 20:32It is going to be here for eternity.
- 20:33It is protected from the future.
- 20:35Yes.
- 20:36Okay.
- 20:37that's an interesting type terminators and
- 20:39stuff that will always be that size yes
- 20:45the joke was we had a technician he
- 20:46used to work here and he and he
- 20:48was it was it me was it me
- 20:50are we still doing maybe i've found some
- 20:52things that have been left in your wake
- 20:55um that used to do installations of like
- 20:57back when you just have to run like
- 20:59direct bespoke klingon cables weird stuff
- 21:01like there was no extensions justin what's
- 21:03that called yeah yeah
- 21:05Oh, the big, thick cave?
- 21:07Yes.
- 21:08And he would be like, oh,
- 21:09this is zip-tied off to all these rafters.
- 21:10And you'd have to, dude, he's like, oh,
- 21:12it's future-proof.
- 21:13It's never coming out.
- 21:15It's like, damn it.
- 21:17Oh, it's concreted over.
- 21:18This is the third time I've had this
- 21:20conversation today.
- 21:20No,
- 21:20you can remove those because we did that.
- 21:22If you pull hard enough.
- 21:23We've had that too.
- 21:27I'm just going to jump off the ladder.
- 21:29Do you remember the time that it was
- 21:31in PV Hall,
- 21:32Keaton grabbed the cable and he went off
- 21:34the top rope in that auditorium?
- 21:36Top rope?
- 21:37Like Tarzan style?
- 21:38Yeah.
- 21:39Tore down the entire grid.
- 21:42We've done demos with things.
- 21:44So background,
- 21:46not only were we demoing the equipment,
- 21:47the building was being demolished in about
- 21:49a month.
- 21:49Oh, dude, that would be fun.
- 21:52I'd be swinging around there like Tarzan,
- 21:55too.
- 21:56No,
- 21:57he grabbed all the cables at the projector
- 21:58location and was up on a table,
- 22:00and he just off the top rope and...
- 22:02Yeah.
- 22:03The whole grid.
- 22:04Oh, it was awesome.
- 22:05I've got high hopes for him.
- 22:07Yeah, he's in your time zone, man.
- 22:08You could have him as one of your
- 22:10technicians.
- 22:10Where is he living at?
- 22:12Your neighbor.
- 22:13That's all I'm going to tell you.
- 22:14He's next door to you right now.
- 22:15You yell right now, he'll hear you.
- 22:17Let's get into it.
- 22:18So the first topic we want to talk
- 22:20about today is it came up in discussion.
- 22:22Well, it's a constant topic of discussion.
- 22:24But it came into discussion specifically
- 22:26on the PCs that we generally put in
- 22:29our classrooms because it is the ninth
- 22:31commandment, I think.
- 22:32It's in the Constitution.
- 22:33It's in one of those documents.
- 22:35You have to put a PC in every
- 22:36classroom.
- 22:37In one of the tablets.
- 22:37Or in every conference room in every one
- 22:39of your systems,
- 22:39there should be a computer in there.
- 22:44Because it's faster to say compute
- 22:46appliance than it is to say computer.
- 22:47Unless you're at Iowa State.
- 22:50But the question comes up,
- 22:51who's in charge of those PCs?
- 22:53We have hundreds of them out there in
- 22:55every conference room, classroom,
- 22:56event space, and all the rest.
- 22:58Who's building those?
- 22:59Who's deploying those?
- 23:00Who's responsible for them?
- 23:01Who has oversight over the software
- 23:03selection?
- 23:03Oversight over the security and
- 23:05maintenance?
- 23:06And as we kind of talk into this,
- 23:08it's like, well, there's...
- 23:09many, many,
- 23:10many facets going on here and lots of
- 23:12variables.
- 23:12And it's not a simple answer to who's
- 23:15doing that.
- 23:15And then the follow up question of who
- 23:18should be doing that for all of us.
- 23:20So there's also that it is playing a
- 23:22very important role in that teaching and
- 23:24learning space.
- 23:25And it's like,
- 23:26I use mine strictly for caption.
- 23:29It's a whole stack just for capture.
- 23:32Yeah.
- 23:32Nice.
- 23:33And what really, it was me giggling.
- 23:36You've heard me giggle on live around
- 23:38there when Chris refers to the computer
- 23:41people.
- 23:42And that's,
- 23:42that's where this conversation came from.
- 23:44No, I said the PC people,
- 23:45the PC people all the time.
- 23:46And I always laugh like,
- 23:48who are these like cloak and dagger PC
- 23:50people that come in and do all this
- 23:52work?
- 23:52And it,
- 23:53their work seems to be very critical to
- 23:55the success in your teaching and learning
- 23:56environment.
- 23:56So why are we so distant from these
- 23:59computer people?
- 24:00Well, they don't own shoes,
- 24:02so they're not able to actually go out
- 24:04and investigate.
- 24:05So it's technology in a classroom.
- 24:07Therefore,
- 24:08it is classroom technology like that's
- 24:11what our name is.
- 24:11Right.
- 24:13And so let me let me describe my
- 24:15scenario first and then we'll get into it
- 24:17from there.
- 24:17So
- 24:19I purchase the PCs.
- 24:21Now,
- 24:21it's from a pre-selected list of here are
- 24:23the approved computers we can image and
- 24:25deploy.
- 24:26For every project, I go buy the computer,
- 24:28the PC.
- 24:30I hand it off to the PC people
- 24:32who load the image on it.
- 24:33Wait, wait.
- 24:34It gets better.
- 24:35They hand it back because they are not
- 24:37qualified to go out and plug it in.
- 24:39I've literally been told this.
- 24:40We don't want to mess anything up,
- 24:41so you go put it in your lectern.
- 24:43If they discover an issue with it...
- 24:47We have to unplug it and take it
- 24:48back to them because, you know,
- 24:50you can't troubleshoot.
- 24:51So you don't deploy images over the
- 24:53network?
- 24:54No, no.
- 24:54Well, they can, but they don't like to.
- 24:56For whatever reason,
- 24:57it's always running it back to their labs.
- 24:59Right.
- 24:59They can deploy images over the network
- 25:01and they will do it before every semester
- 25:03because they will blanket select all image
- 25:06go regardless of whether or not the room
- 25:07was in use or it has the right
- 25:08updates or any of that stuff.
- 25:09And then these guys get to go fix
- 25:13it all.
- 25:14Yes, it's a continuous thing.
- 25:16Are you like in there fixing images,
- 25:19build software when you say fix it?
- 25:21unpack that for me a little bit what
- 25:22are you fixing so yes usually it's because
- 25:25you know invariably somehow all the other
- 25:27stuff plugged into the pc is the problem
- 25:28even though that stuff's been there for
- 25:30seven years but whatever um the last
- 25:32windows ten to windows eleven rev broke
- 25:34lots of things that they wanted to have
- 25:37addressed not from the pc side never mind
- 25:40the fact that an equation has one variable
- 25:42and when said variable changes the outcome
- 25:44then there's your answer but anyway
- 25:47Yes,
- 25:47so we have admin access to the computers.
- 25:49We can go in and change software settings,
- 25:52driver settings, any of that stuff,
- 25:53whatever, as needed.
- 25:54It sounds like you're the PC people.
- 25:55But we're not building the image,
- 25:57and that's where the frustration comes in,
- 25:59is we're not responsible for the entire
- 26:00thing soup to nuts.
- 26:01So we have no oversight on, oh,
- 26:04we removed, for example, the camera app.
- 26:07We used the crap out of the camera
- 26:09app.
- 26:09Please put that back.
- 26:10So it's things like that.
- 26:13Advanced troubleshooting.
- 26:14Where do these computer people sit in your
- 26:16office?
- 26:17your organization or any organization in
- 26:18which they visit?
- 26:19They sit at home.
- 26:20Not physically, but in the org, roughly.
- 26:23Can you show me on the door?
- 26:25Parallel.
- 26:25This is so weird.
- 26:27Yeah, and it is.
- 26:28This is the first place I've ever had
- 26:29this level of back and forth.
- 26:31Because in past at other schools,
- 26:33I've either been entirely responsible,
- 26:35soup to nuts, building the image,
- 26:37selecting the software,
- 26:37all that all the way through,
- 26:38deploying hundreds of PCs, or...
- 26:41Not at all.
- 26:41No touch.
- 26:42And the magic elves show up.
- 26:44And if there's a problem,
- 26:45the magic elves come over and do their
- 26:46magic elf work to to fix and solve
- 26:49the issue and then leave.
- 26:50But here it's this weird handoff.
- 26:52Now,
- 26:53my understanding is prior to my arrival,
- 26:55there was a lot more of the as
- 26:58Mark likes me to say,
- 26:59the PC people would go out and do
- 27:00troubleshooting in the field, you know,
- 27:02on installed systems.
- 27:04But apparently that broke things,
- 27:06and so they were told to stop,
- 27:07and so now they don't,
- 27:08to the point where we will simply get
- 27:09a ticket that says, please go out,
- 27:11recover said PC,
- 27:12bring it all the way back across campus
- 27:13so we can troubleshoot it.
- 27:14So now you're enabling labor service for
- 27:17the computer people.
- 27:18You're the gophers.
- 27:19Yes.
- 27:20Yes, we are in a lot of cases.
- 27:21And it causes quite a bit of friction
- 27:24on my team.
- 27:24So, yeah, it's fantastic, let's say.
- 27:28Now, I will happily,
- 27:29as Mark also will now suggest in a
- 27:30few moments, you should own that service.
- 27:32Why don't you just absorb them and do
- 27:34that too?
- 27:34I would happily do that if I get
- 27:36the people.
- 27:38So you give me those FTEs and I'll
- 27:39own that service.
- 27:41You need some computer people.
- 27:43I need some PC people.
- 27:44Some PC people.
- 27:47I just think it's such a fascinating thing
- 27:49with it becoming so much more relevant for
- 27:52that software level delivery.
- 27:53It is critical.
- 27:54That thing is a critical component to
- 27:56every system we build.
- 27:58so when it when it goes wrong larry
- 27:59you brought this up when something goes
- 28:01wrong with that which isn't under my
- 28:03control but it affects the experience in
- 28:05the conference room classroom whatever
- 28:07that reflects on my team that the comp
- 28:10the classroom is broken again and we had
- 28:12one the other day where someone managed to
- 28:14set the not managed to they set the
- 28:15computer to extended and windows the
- 28:18secondary screen on extended the login
- 28:20screen is a black image and so
- 28:22everything is broken because they were
- 28:24looking at the extended screen,
- 28:25not the primary screen.
- 28:27Again, an easy fix,
- 28:28and I hear people out there shouting,
- 28:29an easy fix through group policy,
- 28:31through multiple options for deployment
- 28:35scripting.
- 28:35The old school,
- 28:36here's a batch file that has,
- 28:38what is it, display.exe backslash clone.
- 28:43You can run that at any point at
- 28:45user level to set that back to clone
- 28:46mode all the time,
- 28:48and it would not have a problem,
- 28:49but
- 28:52those pesky PC people though.
- 28:54I'm so glad that's so one of the
- 28:56few problems I don't have.
- 28:58Do you have one of those fancy?
- 28:59Like?
- 29:00Are they like your end point team or
- 29:02something along those lines?
- 29:03Is that that name?
- 29:05I think I think they're actually called
- 29:06lab lab team.
- 29:07Because lab Oh,
- 29:08it's in your lab because their focus is
- 29:09computer labs.
- 29:10Yes.
- 29:11Okay.
- 29:11So ours is separated from computer labs
- 29:13versus classroom computers.
- 29:15Wait, so you have two separate PC teams?
- 29:17Yeah.
- 29:18See,
- 29:19good grief yeah so it's it's interesting
- 29:25we might have three we love pcs here
- 29:29we love dell pcs that whole thing well
- 29:33it's do you see a world where maybe
- 29:36that is going to come home to roost
- 29:37in your work or do you think there's
- 29:39i would like i would be happy to
- 29:41own that serve right now there's big
- 29:42separation church estate and it's it's
- 29:44there's historical reasons for it and all
- 29:46the rest i understand you know
- 29:49would be happy to own that service but
- 29:50i need to own that service not like
- 29:53sort of be involved or like give me
- 29:55those ftes i'll put them to work the
- 29:57other thirty nine hours of the week you
- 29:58know there's there's there's lots of that
- 30:00sort of like back and forth which causes
- 30:02some challenges and a lot of it's just
- 30:04historical sort of like that's the way
- 30:07it's always been which then leads to
- 30:09challenges on who's responsible for
- 30:11actually ensuring this is working um you
- 30:14know day to day and larry again you
- 30:15bring it up
- 30:16It's in a classroom.
- 30:18Shouldn't you be responsible for it?
- 30:20I don't disagree with that,
- 30:21but it's not there.
- 30:23I'm assuming somewhere in your,
- 30:26wherever your documentation of
- 30:29organizational structure and bylaws,
- 30:32is it thou shalt have PCs that are
- 30:35delivered by this group only?
- 30:37Is that how this works?
- 30:39Because you've brought up a couple of
- 30:41different...
- 30:42You mean like,
- 30:42could I just go rogue and start doing
- 30:43my own thing?
- 30:44Yes.
- 30:44Could you do it?
- 30:45Would you be allowed to do that?
- 30:46Are you getting your chocolate and
- 30:48somebody else's peanut butter here?
- 30:50In the short term, yes.
- 30:52I would be getting,
- 30:53you got your chocolate and my peanut
- 30:54butter.
- 30:54That would absolutely be happening.
- 30:56Long term, maybe.
- 30:57I don't know.
- 30:57But it's one of those things.
- 30:58Is it replication of services at this
- 31:00point?
- 31:00Yeah,
- 31:00it's definitely duplication of services at
- 31:02this point.
- 31:03And it's not to say that that isn't,
- 31:06I don't disagree with that in the sense
- 31:07where if there's going to be that service
- 31:09provided,
- 31:09I think it needs to be a comprehensive
- 31:10service.
- 31:11But it only you're speaking to it's like,
- 31:14if you're providing a service that's not
- 31:15actually doing me any good.
- 31:17Why should I continue to use your service?
- 31:19Yeah, even if you flip it around, this,
- 31:21that one service gets this far,
- 31:23and then the next service takes it beyond
- 31:24that, or vice versa,
- 31:26I have to wait until they get certain
- 31:27point,
- 31:27and then it's the handoff of the baton.
- 31:29So I want to change the words here.
- 31:31Let's take away that term service.
- 31:33So what capability for a minute?
- 31:35Would you have the capability to do this
- 31:37in the secured way in which it needs
- 31:39to be done to be within criteria and
- 31:40support and security as per best practice
- 31:43of your campus currently with you?
- 31:45Don't tell me about how busy you are.
- 31:46That's not what I'm talking about.
- 31:48Could you do this and capability in the
- 31:50know how to do this?
- 31:53Because you said you need the FTE that
- 31:55that implies you need time.
- 31:56Is there subject matter expertise coming
- 31:58along with that?
- 31:59There should be ostensibly but no.
- 32:04I mean, not... Let me rephrase.
- 32:05Yes, there is.
- 32:06Absolutely.
- 32:07But not that can't be picked up very
- 32:09quickly.
- 32:11Okay.
- 32:11Because like I said...
- 32:12It sounds like there's an organizational
- 32:13structure here that is actually what's
- 32:15creating this.
- 32:15Well, right.
- 32:16My personal frustration with this,
- 32:17and I know this is... You guys...
- 32:20would echo this as well i did this
- 32:22in the past i was responsible both for
- 32:24the classroom systems and the pcs and this
- 32:26was almost twenty years ago and we had
- 32:28to build the imaging system from the
- 32:29ground this is the old days of clonezilla
- 32:31and and um uh ghost consoles and deploying
- 32:35stuff through print servers and you know
- 32:37which low bandwidth stuff over ten meg
- 32:40networks it was ridiculous but we had it
- 32:41all figured out with batch scripting for
- 32:43dual boot
- 32:43PCs, even triple boot,
- 32:45we had some Macs that went Mac, Windows,
- 32:46Linux and all this stuff.
- 32:47We had this all dialed in and this
- 32:49was years ago.
- 32:49And so because I have that background,
- 32:51even though I really don't enjoy doing it,
- 32:54and I'm happy to hand off that service
- 32:56to somebody if it's meeting the needs.
- 32:58The frustration is I know it can be
- 32:59done in a more cohesive method.
- 33:02So do you take any measures to
- 33:06to say nurture that relationship with said
- 33:09computer people we it is not an adversary
- 33:13relationship at all we work very well with
- 33:15them it's just this kind of like but
- 33:17we only go to here and then you
- 33:18go to there and it's like there's a
- 33:20line in the sand yes it's always that
- 33:21invisible connection between between the
- 33:23wire and the device and it's it's entirely
- 33:26just based on inertia well that's the way
- 33:28it's always been that line is really thick
- 33:30over there in wyoming
- 33:33It's literally in a different room.
- 33:35It's a big run.
- 33:39And we are making inroads.
- 33:41We are making baby steps towards improving
- 33:43that service,
- 33:44but there's still some challenges with it.
- 33:48And we should see some changes as we
- 33:49move from one deployment platform,
- 33:53I believe it's SCCM still at this point,
- 33:56over to Intune,
- 33:56where it's much more modern in that.
- 33:58So we should see much less impact on
- 34:02direct actual services and more, you know,
- 34:04streamlined deployments and things like
- 34:05that, which should address some of that.
- 34:06In reality, you guys will just,
- 34:07you'll just take it out of the box,
- 34:08put it in place,
- 34:09and your IP will then say,
- 34:10this is the package that needs to be
- 34:11there.
- 34:11Correct.
- 34:12And that's where it's going is, oh,
- 34:13we've detected this new Mac on the
- 34:17network,
- 34:17and it knows what system it's supposed to
- 34:19have and all that,
- 34:19and it pulls it on the packages and
- 34:20deploys it on the rest, but yes.
- 34:21then you can be the service you've always
- 34:24aspired to be,
- 34:24which is just boots on the ground.
- 34:26It's going to be so great.
- 34:27Yeah,
- 34:28that's all I want to be is sneakers.
- 34:29We're just sneakers.
- 34:30Sneakers.
- 34:30Okay.
- 34:33So I think you've given a version of
- 34:36that, Larry.
- 34:36I think you
- 34:38You own a little more of this, yes?
- 34:39I own significantly more.
- 34:42The only thing we don't own is developing
- 34:45the image,
- 34:45but we put in a demand of what
- 34:48the image needs to be.
- 34:49A demand?
- 34:50Not a request?
- 34:50You think, hey, Will,
- 34:52give me this is what I want.
- 34:53I don't care what you think.
- 34:54If it's right, wrong, secure,
- 34:55or totally malicious.
- 34:56And the service now terminology,
- 34:59it is a demand.
- 35:00Do you have a story about this?
- 35:02Oh, no.
- 35:03It could launch a story.
- 35:04This is going to be epic.
- 35:05Is there an epic I can reference?
- 35:08No, but the summer,
- 35:09twenty twenty six refresh would include
- 35:11the story of re-imaging that.
- 35:13Yeah.
- 35:14Coming soon.
- 35:15By the way, I just want to know,
- 35:16because this came up offline,
- 35:18and we'll bring it up at some point
- 35:19about different project management
- 35:20methodologies,
- 35:21and Larry was talking about ServiceNow
- 35:22methods and whatnot.
- 35:23Do you start every story,
- 35:24as you probably should,
- 35:25with once upon a time?
- 35:28That is going in my template.
- 35:29Because I would do that just to be
- 35:31a schmuck to people.
- 35:32If you're going to make me write stories,
- 35:34ooh, story time.
- 35:35It's either once upon a time or always
- 35:37I don't know what happened, but.
- 35:40Because that sets the stage for any
- 35:42natural catastrophe that could probably
- 35:44come now.
- 35:46I get a call that starts,
- 35:47I don't know what happened, but.
- 35:48That's what's coming.
- 35:49We do buy the computers.
- 35:50We spec the computers.
- 35:51We install the computers.
- 35:53You specify the computers?
- 35:54You're not qualified for that, sir.
- 35:55We specify the computers,
- 35:57but we do have to go through Dell,
- 35:59and we do have our standards we go
- 36:02by.
- 36:04But, like,
- 36:04if somebody needs a unique graphics card,
- 36:07we can— You're selecting the appropriate
- 36:08one from a preselected list, then?
- 36:10For the most part.
- 36:11Like, our cars program,
- 36:13if they need an upgraded graphics card,
- 36:16we will work with them to get the
- 36:17appropriate one.
- 36:18Gotcha.
- 36:19uh we do all the computer labs so
- 36:21when you just kind of separated computer
- 36:24labs from classrooms we take care of all
- 36:26the learning space with computers yeah we
- 36:30take care of the software that lets the
- 36:32instructors see all the computers in the
- 36:34computer do you have computer labs without
- 36:36av larry no monitors no nothing just
- 36:41computers wait wait and this is the truth
- 36:43this is a real thing do you have
- 36:44computer labs without computers
- 36:48No, but I have built some of those.
- 36:50I built those at Butler University.
- 36:52Then it's not a computer lab.
- 36:53Where everyone brings in a laptop or
- 36:55something.
- 36:55There are laptops there that they can use
- 36:57or they can use their own.
- 36:58A laptop's a computer.
- 36:59What are we talking about?
- 37:01It's weird.
- 37:02It's a whole thing now.
- 37:03Then it's not a computer lab.
- 37:05A hot dog's not a sandwich.
- 37:08Like, what are we talking about?
- 37:09I have the blueprints for hot dogs.
- 37:11Use your words.
- 37:13Say what you mean.
- 37:15I did.
- 37:15If I take a hot dog bun and
- 37:16cut it into two pieces.
- 37:18Hot dog's a hot dog.
- 37:20Isn't that a sandwich?
- 37:21No.
- 37:21Didn't I just make a sandwich?
- 37:22It's a hot dog.
- 37:26That's what it is.
- 37:27We will schedule the images,
- 37:29and then we'll go out and check them,
- 37:30and if anything doesn't work,
- 37:32we will re-image them.
- 37:32Schedule the images.
- 37:34Yeah.
- 37:35We don't do what Chris's team does,
- 37:37where they just push them all at once.
- 37:39We schedule, okay,
- 37:40we're going to do this building and this
- 37:41building over these next twelve hours at
- 37:45night.
- 37:45To be fair, I think they do that,
- 37:47but it's usually over a short, like,
- 37:48over these next three days, wham,
- 37:49all of campus.
- 37:50And it's like, well, but still, come on.
- 37:52And if there's an issue in the classroom,
- 37:55it's our boots on the grounds,
- 37:56but we'll swap it with one that we
- 37:58have on our imaging desk.
- 38:00But because you own both services, yeah.
- 38:01Yeah.
- 38:03Do you have to get into that, like,
- 38:04prove that it's broken conversation?
- 38:07Oh.
- 38:08Because that's always the fun one, right?
- 38:09It's not our stuff.
- 38:11It is not the computer.
- 38:13I'm telling you that right now, Larry.
- 38:14There's nothing on this PC.
- 38:15Well, I mean, with us,
- 38:16we own those services,
- 38:17so we're not proven.
- 38:19We do have a couple of techs who
- 38:20are Dell certified,
- 38:21so we can work with Dell to say,
- 38:23yeah, this is broken,
- 38:24and this is how we know.
- 38:25Explain that.
- 38:26Come get it.
- 38:26Give me another one.
- 38:27So how many on your team, Larry,
- 38:29and I'm assuming these people also do
- 38:30other things.
- 38:30I feel like I've gotten made in this
- 38:31category.
- 38:32How many people on your team are, like,
- 38:34dedicated or primary on the PC side of
- 38:37things versus the AV side?
- 38:39Or is it you cross-train for everything?
- 38:41It's cross-train for everything,
- 38:43but I do have one team member who
- 38:45is our lab manager.
- 38:47And she pretty much owns the image.
- 38:50She owns...
- 38:52Most of the computer issues that happen,
- 38:55she's like the tier two for that.
- 38:56She just goes and...
- 38:57So what happens when she quits and gets
- 38:59a new job?
- 39:00She's told me she'll never quit and get
- 39:02a new job.
- 39:03That's what I believe at this point.
- 39:06Oh, man.
- 39:08We'll see if that works out.
- 39:11Justin,
- 39:12you seem to think you have it made
- 39:14here.
- 39:14What was that all about?
- 39:15Hell yeah.
- 39:16We got it made.
- 39:17Simple.
- 39:18So our support team...
- 39:21Remember how I talked about there are a
- 39:23bunch of computer people?
- 39:25There are a bunch of computer people,
- 39:26right?
- 39:27This is the good news about that.
- 39:29So we have, and it happens so magical.
- 39:34I don't know all the details,
- 39:36but I don't think we're using images
- 39:38anymore.
- 39:38I think we're using group policy and all
- 39:40of that stuff.
- 39:41And we have the computer lab people that
- 39:43sit over in a different department because
- 39:46they're working on virtualizing software.
- 39:48They're doing some really unique things.
- 39:49Our support arm,
- 39:53our project manager orders the computers
- 39:55if it's a project.
- 39:57um we put it in with the av
- 40:00um our support team handles all the
- 40:02computers so whenever they go out and
- 40:04troubleshoot an av problem they're the
- 40:05ones deciphering if it's a computer av
- 40:07problem so if they can't solve the av
- 40:10problem uh if it's advanced or you know
- 40:13advanced qsys or crestron problem or
- 40:15something they send it to the engineering
- 40:16group which that's us um we don't
- 40:20I don't deal with a lot of computer
- 40:22things other than like,
- 40:24we'll collaborate on a few things.
- 40:26Like I had a conversation with the manager
- 40:28of that team.
- 40:29Like,
- 40:30so what's your thoughts on two monitors
- 40:32versus one on lecterns?
- 40:35like uh i don't like it but you
- 40:37know this is what we do and this
- 40:38is how we can you know so we
- 40:40i mean that's a it's a great relationship
- 40:42and the way we procure things um we
- 40:45have a top shop you know hill toppers
- 40:47top shop go to top shop it lists
- 40:49all the dell computers we're a dell shop
- 40:51if it's not dell we don't support it
- 40:53period um
- 40:56we have dell doing super secret stuff to
- 40:58bio stuff that we can track them if
- 41:00you steal things or whatever too and
- 41:02there's some wild things going on oh track
- 41:04them yeah bio track them and uh theft
- 41:08seems to be like a real thing on
- 41:10your campus like it used to be it's
- 41:12not i just think that it's just everything
- 41:14like it used to be and then we
- 41:15put all these policies in and then it's
- 41:17gone and we still do the policies so
- 41:19i don't know
- 41:21I'm fascinated by the,
- 41:21if it's not a Dell,
- 41:22we're not going to touch it,
- 41:23work on it.
- 41:23No.
- 41:24Like there's no Macs at all.
- 41:26And you're talking about this.
- 41:26Well, yes, we have Macs, sorry.
- 41:28We have a Mac team,
- 41:30but here's the weird part.
- 41:31Now that you bring that up.
- 41:33But Macs are weird and stupid,
- 41:34so we don't use those.
- 41:35Not really.
- 41:36The classroom support people,
- 41:40I don't think handle the Mac side because
- 41:43that...
- 41:44expertise lives on the computer lab side
- 41:47because we have Mac computer labs.
- 41:48So whenever there's needs to get Mac
- 41:51support.
- 41:51How many support teams are there?
- 41:53I'm in the same question bucket as you
- 41:55here, Chris.
- 41:56I'm imagining just like,
- 41:58do you have one support desk?
- 42:00Yeah,
- 42:00we have one support desk except for the
- 42:03AV.
- 42:04No, back it up.
- 42:07Everything that we do is support.
- 42:10That's how,
- 42:11that's the culture here is the,
- 42:13this service is support.
- 42:15This AV is support.
- 42:17We are, this is support.
- 42:18We're supporting this client,
- 42:20client facing.
- 42:20Yeah.
- 42:21So we use support very,
- 42:22very globally to describe everything that
- 42:26we do pretty much.
- 42:29So I've lost track.
- 42:32Pardon me.
- 42:33Okay.
- 42:33Is there a classroom team that just like
- 42:35does classrooms?
- 42:37That's the AV team.
- 42:40So it's like, it's everything.
- 42:41Our support wing under the AV team handles
- 42:45classroom computers.
- 42:49You said there was a PC team.
- 42:51No, it's the support team.
- 42:53There isn't a dedicated PC team.
- 42:55There's a classroom computer team that
- 42:59handles PCs.
- 43:01Then there is a computer lab,
- 43:03open lab team that handles all of that.
- 43:06Which was the group at the beginning you
- 43:07said that the support people are all
- 43:08computer people,
- 43:09and I love that because I don't have
- 43:10to deal with the computers.
- 43:11That's under AV.
- 43:12How?
- 43:13Remember how I talk about our support team
- 43:15doesn't know AV.
- 43:17They know computers.
- 43:18I've always said those things.
- 43:20I've always talked about that.
- 43:22You guys never listen to me at all
- 43:23about things that I say or talk about.
- 43:25Sorry, I wasn't listening.
- 43:26Start from the beginning.
- 43:27Okay.
- 43:28So your general support group is the one
- 43:31that's doing your pieces.
- 43:32What do you mean by general support?
- 43:34I don't know what you mean.
- 43:35What do you mean?
- 43:36You elaborate.
- 43:39We have an AV team.
- 43:39If I call in, I'm in this space.
- 43:42Either the PC or the AV has gone
- 43:44awry, sir.
- 43:45Where am I going?
- 43:46You're coming to the AV team.
- 43:48How about if you're in a conference room
- 43:49with a computer?
- 43:50Do I need to know that, though,
- 43:51as the client?
- 43:52Do I need to pull my directory out?
- 43:54You call seven thousand,
- 43:56and the first thing that picks up is
- 43:57if you're in a classroom,
- 43:59you've got two seven oh, seven four five,
- 44:01seven thousand.
- 44:03in a classroom please hit one and then
- 44:06that reroutes directly to us how about if
- 44:08you're you like you you or this other
- 44:11the av support team us okay and then
- 44:14say me it's not all right how dare
- 44:17i can confuse us listen to my words
- 44:20that i'm saying okay go ahead i'm
- 44:24answering your questions
- 44:27So what, where did we leave off?
- 44:29I don't know.
- 44:30I don't know.
- 44:30You're still answering.
- 44:31Yeah.
- 44:32So you asked me where the phone call
- 44:35comes into that support group.
- 44:37That is the, the computer people,
- 44:39or is it a cloak and dagger team
- 44:41within that group?
- 44:42That is the, no,
- 44:43it's the same people that are
- 44:44troubleshooting HD based T that develop
- 44:47images,
- 44:47but they don't know how to do that.
- 44:49They do to a certain point,
- 44:51not at an advanced level,
- 44:52like the engineering team does.
- 44:55Nobody on the support team has Q-SYS,
- 44:58BIAMP, or Crestron certifications.
- 45:00Those all live in the engineering team.
- 45:02We try to teach the support team those
- 45:06things as things come up and learn from
- 45:10each other.
- 45:10Wouldn't they be doing your job then?
- 45:12I don't know, Mark, at this point.
- 45:15I'm not sure.
- 45:16Yeah, I get it.
- 45:18All right,
- 45:19but it sounds like you've got some rigid
- 45:21guardrails around.
- 45:22You will be using these bells.
- 45:23The people that deal with classroom
- 45:25computers make our lives easy because
- 45:29they're good at what they do.
- 45:31And they live under audiovisual.
- 45:36I think that's where your success comes
- 45:37in.
- 45:38Yes.
- 45:39And they work really well with the other
- 45:42people doing open computer labs.
- 45:44And they collaborate a lot on ideas and
- 45:48those kind of things.
- 45:49That's why I asked Larry,
- 45:50do all your open computer labs have AV?
- 45:53Because ours don't.
- 45:54A lot of them don't.
- 45:55Most of them don't.
- 45:56Yeah, thank you, Raul.
- 45:57Stop picking on me.
- 46:00Just because I got the best setup.
- 46:01Okay, you don't have the best setup,
- 46:03but I still have a question for you.
- 46:04I do.
- 46:06You mentioned the computer people.
- 46:10PC people.
- 46:11Which ones?
- 46:12I have no idea.
- 46:13We're just going to say PC people.
- 46:14The AV support team or the open lab
- 46:17team?
- 46:18Whoever was approaching you about putting
- 46:21two computer monitors on the lectern.
- 46:23I approached them.
- 46:24okay as long as you're bringing that up
- 46:26i'm okay with it do you like the
- 46:27real you okay i did we got some
- 46:31weird ass from some faculty i wanted to
- 46:34get some research done quick so i went
- 46:35to the source man that's all it was
- 46:37i just wanted to make sure that like
- 46:40they weren't driving how the lectern
- 46:42looked what they do to a point because
- 46:45i value their opinion i mean let's unbox
- 46:51that for a moment no further questions
- 46:52they're on our team
- 46:56at value how the lectern looked like
- 46:59whether it's graphite or wood veneered or
- 47:01what the hell you're talking about like
- 47:02how many monitors are on the top how
- 47:05many thingies well i wanted to know from
- 47:06a support perspective like how many
- 47:08tickets are they getting because somebody
- 47:09left you don't support sir you're in the
- 47:11engineering group
- 47:12exactly i don't want to why do you
- 47:14care i don't want to make a decision
- 47:16that's going to tax my support team
- 47:17they're going to be pissed at me and
- 47:18be like justin why are you specking two
- 47:20monitors when did we talk about this like
- 47:22well we didn't i just made a choice
- 47:23because i'm king i don't want that so
- 47:25like i need their buy-in to to do
- 47:29different decisions based upon certain
- 47:30requests from faculty like fact they're
- 47:33hey it'd be nice to have two monitors
- 47:34i'm like okay would it not be nice
- 47:36to have two markers
- 47:37What would I just want to make sure
- 47:39when two monitors that you're doing three
- 47:40for it never stops.
- 47:45It's a gateway.
- 47:46Maybe it's an active learning lecture.
- 47:49Sure,
- 47:49different pods of computers surrounded by
- 47:51sound and monitors.
- 47:52Okay, so yeah, I'm just curious.
- 47:55That whole philosophical approach,
- 47:58we're just going to do mono display
- 48:00because it's easy.
- 48:03even though folks may need it or not,
- 48:04this is open question, not just you,
- 48:05Justin's like,
- 48:07when does the when we have changes with
- 48:09computer configurations?
- 48:10How are we?
- 48:11Where are those requests being ramped?
- 48:12And how does that happen?
- 48:13Does it start at dial seven thousand and
- 48:17press one get transferred over to the
- 48:18support group?
- 48:19the request usually coming to me through a
- 48:21new project because we did some kind of
- 48:23needs analysis and then i've got to go
- 48:25back and go this weird request came in
- 48:27like what do you guys feel about this
- 48:29like are you guys having tickets because
- 48:30this happens or do you have do you
- 48:32see problems with this no no it's fine
- 48:36you don't have standards so this isn't
- 48:38like your standard room you're rolling
- 48:40this is
- 48:41No, I got, yeah.
- 48:42I mean,
- 48:44there is no centralized classrooms on
- 48:45campus.
- 48:46We have to go to each department and
- 48:48figure out what the hell they're trying to
- 48:49do.
- 48:49Do you have different builds on said
- 48:52lockdown Dells or is it one size fits
- 48:54most?
- 48:55We've got, we have the mini one.
- 48:58We've got the regular size one.
- 48:59We've got about three or two,
- 49:01three that are approved for classroom
- 49:03conference room usage.
- 49:04Maybe depending on the scenario,
- 49:06maybe two.
- 49:08maybe three two three max i don't know
- 49:11somewhere in there images that can be used
- 49:15again don't care because okay problem
- 49:18solved by other people doesn't bother me
- 49:19why would you i usually request like hey
- 49:21we're gonna need a small one this time
- 49:22everybody's like yeah we got you that's
- 49:24all image oh computer no small computer
- 49:26because i'm gonna cram it in somewhere you
- 49:28know it's not gonna be an electron it's
- 49:30gonna be behind a tv you know what
- 49:32they say
- 49:35long and thin short and fat anyway um
- 49:40sure cool okay uh what about software
- 49:44requests open category for that mark you
- 49:48haven't done your your okay yeah so yeah
- 49:50we're we we are responsible for deploying
- 49:52that at the computer computer's end spaces
- 49:54we do have an endpoint team that helps
- 49:57manage and build those what does the
- 49:58endpoint team do versus yeah somebody
- 50:00picked on mark they manage the tool
- 50:03then which is used and shared amongst the
- 50:05groups for deploying those images and all
- 50:07that piece uh we are still buying internet
- 50:10specking them no they're the admins at the
- 50:13higher level we still buy them speckham
- 50:15boots on the ground them put them out
- 50:16there and maintain the support of them by
- 50:19way of our call center so requests come
- 50:21in we do have software request form if
- 50:22you want to have new software just vetted
- 50:24and then it's put into a package and
- 50:26deployed not in the middle of term
- 50:27unless absolutely critical,
- 50:28and there's some extenuating circumstance,
- 50:30but usually it is a cadence of updates.
- 50:33And so...
- 50:35there was a Mr. Raul here,
- 50:36he helps with a lot of that.
- 50:37And then Todd helps with a lot of
- 50:39that piece of it,
- 50:40labs and learning spaces,
- 50:42and a bunch of other spaces,
- 50:43thousands of endpoints.
- 50:44Does your team,
- 50:46on the more AV side of things,
- 50:48does that team, not the endpoint team,
- 50:50does that team build the base image?
- 50:52Or are they taking an existing campus
- 50:53image and modifying?
- 50:55Yes and no.
- 50:56We'll take a base image as long as
- 50:57we have to,
- 50:58and then we help
- 50:59rebuild core images.
- 51:00Now,
- 51:00that whole concept of base image and
- 51:02packages,
- 51:02that's all changing when we go over to
- 51:04Intune anyway.
- 51:05So that's a different philosophical
- 51:07approach than it used to be.
- 51:09But yes,
- 51:09we had images that were put together based
- 51:12on the feedback and provided that we would
- 51:14do, they would then store those images,
- 51:15and then we would use their tool to
- 51:16deploy them and image them across campus.
- 51:20They're kind of administering the
- 51:21platform, the endpoint team, right?
- 51:23They do builds for other organizations as
- 51:26well,
- 51:26but they're providing the tools that we're
- 51:28using for fleet management.
- 51:31So if there's an issue,
- 51:32an issue physically with one of the units
- 51:34out there.
- 51:34The PCs.
- 51:36Computes, as you would say.
- 51:39It's the AV side team who goes out
- 51:41and pulls out because it's all basically
- 51:42handled within that, right?
- 51:43Yeah.
- 51:44For the most part, yeah.
- 51:45Okay.
- 51:46So here's another benefit to controlling
- 51:48that.
- 51:48I went to the computer people and said,
- 51:50guess what?
- 51:51Everything's going to be sixteen nine
- 51:52monitors now.
- 51:53None of this sixteen shit.
- 51:54What do you mean now?
- 51:56Oh, back in the day.
- 51:58Two or three years ago.
- 52:00Four years ago.
- 52:00Because that's when that switch started to
- 52:02happen.
- 52:03But I think there is that I think
- 52:04there's incredible value for the groups
- 52:07that are responsible for those learning,
- 52:09teaching, learning, classroom technology,
- 52:12that those folks be critically involved
- 52:14for the overall experience, the build,
- 52:17the configuration, deployment,
- 52:18the testing and the support of all those
- 52:19things.
- 52:20I think it's too crucial to that learning
- 52:22experience to leave it up to chance from
- 52:24some other computer people to come in
- 52:26there
- 52:26and do these things.
- 52:27Justin, you just said it.
- 52:27The overall experience.
- 52:29Because if I'm in a room,
- 52:31if I'm in a space, classroom,
- 52:32conference room, whatever.
- 52:33I know, Larry,
- 52:33you kept bringing up conference rooms.
- 52:35To me, they're the same freaking thing.
- 52:36I don't care.
- 52:37If you're in a technology-enhanced
- 52:39space...
- 52:40and I'm there to have my meeting or
- 52:42teach my physics class or whatever,
- 52:44I don't care who's responsible for X, Y,
- 52:46Z thing.
- 52:46I just want it to work,
- 52:47but I know generally I'm in a classroom.
- 52:50So the classroom- They see it as an
- 52:51IT problem.
- 52:52Right.
- 52:52And when your guys show up, they're like,
- 52:54they're the problem.
- 52:55And so it's exactly right.
- 52:57We're the only ones visible doing that.
- 52:58Um,
- 52:59but I think even if we don't own
- 53:01a service,
- 53:01I think we need to have a deep
- 53:03amount of insight into it.
- 53:04And it's beyond just the computers and the
- 53:06software and the deployment and the
- 53:07timelines and the support models and all
- 53:08that.
- 53:09But it goes to the LMS and it
- 53:11goes to software selected and it goes to,
- 53:12there's many other facets to that,
- 53:15but we're,
- 53:16we often find ourselves boxed in like, no,
- 53:18you just, you do this.
- 53:20People on campus think you do this,
- 53:21but no, you do this.
- 53:22So.
- 53:23It's too important now,
- 53:24and it's kind of a capability that spans
- 53:26all these different things, right?
- 53:28And I truly believe that as you move
- 53:31forward and everything is more software
- 53:33enabled,
- 53:34the clients don't care about the computer.
- 53:36They really don't.
- 53:37They could care if it's Dell or if
- 53:38it's whatever.
- 53:39They really do not care about any brand
- 53:41of that.
- 53:41So I think that does speak to your
- 53:43use case, Chris.
- 53:43You're really trying to find a cost
- 53:44effective means to deliver that
- 53:46capability.
- 53:47Clients will know the software that they
- 53:48want to use is going to open that
- 53:50application level is going to work for
- 53:51them.
- 53:52And they hope that it's going to be
- 53:53configured all the way through the porting
- 53:55and through all the spigots on that to
- 53:56the system and environments going to work
- 53:58on.
- 53:58And it's going to actually work the way
- 54:00they need it to and interact the way
- 54:01they need it to.
- 54:02You missed one thing, Mark.
- 54:03Did I?
- 54:04I'm sure I missed a lot of things.
- 54:05Only one.
- 54:07One thing that's been a problem for us
- 54:08is
- 54:09Boot time in class.
- 54:11They care immensely about the boot time in
- 54:13class.
- 54:13Yes, they do.
- 54:14They do.
- 54:14That's been like you have an update and
- 54:16then all of a sudden it's like two
- 54:19minutes, two minute boot time.
- 54:21We lost two minutes.
- 54:22First time profile builds a bear.
- 54:25We've heard up and down complaints about
- 54:27that throughout the years.
- 54:28That is one challenge that.
- 54:30I'm not getting rid of these print drivers
- 54:31though.
- 54:31We're keeping them.
- 54:32i don't care if you're using them or
- 54:33not they're staying you might need them
- 54:36but i think as that whole kind of
- 54:39piece unfolds and it becomes more critical
- 54:41like it's less about let me get you
- 54:45over to the person who does that thing
- 54:47Yeah, right.
- 54:48The person doesn't want to hear that.
- 54:50Right.
- 54:50So how is your organization doing?
- 54:52That is a weird thing.
- 54:53And in the way we're structured,
- 54:56even though it's completely different
- 54:57teams,
- 54:58it's the PC people and all that stuff.
- 55:01From a client standpoint,
- 55:02they only ever are interacting just IT.
- 55:05No, no, no, no, no, no,
- 55:06let me see it as it.
- 55:08Correct,
- 55:08but the people they're interacting with
- 55:10are only ever my team.
- 55:12It's rare that they get to interact with
- 55:15the PC team on any of that stuff
- 55:17because the request comes in,
- 55:20comes to my team,
- 55:21we're the boots on the ground doing a
- 55:22swap or troubleshooting or whatever.
- 55:24If there's a follow-up or, like,
- 55:25can we meet because we figured out what
- 55:27was going on here,
- 55:27it's my team doing that.
- 55:29So they may not even have insight into
- 55:30that there's another team involved at all.
- 55:33It's just further removing them from that.
- 55:35So it's a bit of a strange arrangement.
- 55:38So I heard vehemently across the board,
- 55:41we're going all BYOD.
- 55:41Is that what I heard?
- 55:42Yes.
- 55:43Is that what you came away with?
- 55:43That was the decision.
- 55:44It's easier.
- 55:45Yeah.
- 55:45It's easier.
- 55:46Okay.
- 55:46But only BYOD if it's Dell,
- 55:48or we're going to fight you, I guess.
- 55:50But our BYODs are not computers, Justin.
- 55:52These laptops are not computers.
- 55:54No.
- 55:55And it's supported by a different group.
- 55:58All right.
- 55:58So I think we have now found that
- 55:59the four of us have four very different
- 56:01approaches to this.
- 56:02Mine's the best.
- 56:05Let us know.
- 56:05Vote for it.
- 56:06Okay.
- 56:07Mine is not.
- 56:08You know why?
- 56:08Because I don't have any PC problems.
- 56:12That you know of.
- 56:13Exactly.
- 56:15They're there,
- 56:16but I don't get to deal with any
- 56:18of it.
- 56:18So they're great.
- 56:18They're not assigned to you.
- 56:19Love it.
- 56:19Therefore, they are not your problems.
- 56:22All right.
- 56:22Well, let's take a quick break.
- 56:23And speaking of things we're all going to
- 56:24vehemently agree about,
- 56:26let's talk about cameras for a few minutes
- 56:28based on a listener email.
- 56:30So let's take a quick break, come back,
- 56:31talk about that.
- 56:32But first,
- 56:33let's hear about a product that will solve
- 56:34all your display problems.
- 56:36Ooh.
- 56:38Tired of smart displays that think they
- 56:40know better than you?
- 56:42Sick of constant firmware updates,
- 56:44surprise app crashes,
- 56:46and pop-ups begging you to log into
- 56:48someone else's cloud service?
- 56:50Introducing the world's dumbest displays.
- 56:54That's right.
- 56:55Our new line of LCD and DVLED panels
- 56:58are so dumb,
- 56:59they don't even know what Wi-Fi is.
- 57:02no operating system no streaming apps no
- 57:05wireless casting not even any tiny tinny
- 57:09speakers just pixels that shine all day
- 57:13and nothing else hook up a laptop with
- 57:16hdmi and boom instant presentation just
- 57:21like the good old days no bloat no
- 57:24nags no whoops teams needs an update
- 57:28They're so dumb,
- 57:29they'll disable those features on your
- 57:31other gear and make your entire AV system
- 57:34act like it's two thousand seven again.
- 57:37And that's just glorious.
- 57:40Dumb displays because sometimes the
- 57:43smartest thing is going dumb by
- 57:46Independent Amalgamated.
- 57:51Tired of... Whoops,
- 57:53hit that one a second time.
- 57:54The future.
- 57:56Yeah.
- 57:56The past is the future.
- 57:57By the way, that reminded me,
- 57:58we had a ticket recently from someone
- 58:00about... They said it was...
- 58:02The initial complaint, of course,
- 58:03is the room projector isn't working or
- 58:05whatever it was.
- 58:06I think it was actually this...
- 58:06Nothing's working, Chris.
- 58:07Nothing's working.
- 58:08Everything's broken.
- 58:08Yes.
- 58:09The phone's even broken.
- 58:10What it came down to was...
- 58:11And a bit of troubleshooting on it.
- 58:13What it came down to is everything...
- 58:14Trying to figure out what's going on and
- 58:15meet with the person.
- 58:17the background image used for the login
- 58:19screen on the computer,
- 58:20which of course is the thing they see
- 58:22as soon as they turn on the system,
- 58:23there it is, it's up there.
- 58:25It has a bunch of dark fade to
- 58:28black at the bottom.
- 58:30The image,
- 58:30the photo itself is actually dark fading
- 58:32to black,
- 58:33which a lot of compression artifacts show
- 58:37up very easily in that sort of area.
- 58:40And so what they were seeing was those
- 58:41compression artifacts,
- 58:42and they thought that that was causing
- 58:44issues with the system,
- 58:45and they were convinced that was carrying
- 58:46through to everything on the screen.
- 58:48It's kind of interesting.
- 58:49Nothing works.
- 58:50Nothing works.
- 58:52Cancel class.
- 58:52Paratroopers, send them in.
- 58:54Copying the dean.
- 58:56All right.
- 58:57Fixed by tomorrow, though, right?
- 58:57This last topic here is about cameras,
- 59:01or maybe not, PTZ cameras in specific.
- 59:03And we got a listener email that we'll
- 59:05respond to on this because I thought it
- 59:06was good for the show.
- 59:09This is Jamie's topic.
- 59:10And this was a topic for Jamie,
- 59:11who then decided to not show up today.
- 59:13But I'll take this one.
- 59:14I'll take it.
- 59:14We'll backfill.
- 59:16All right, so email is, hi, guys.
- 59:18Wondering if any of you lads have had
- 59:19experience with bird dog PTZ cameras in
- 59:21your classroom builds and would be willing
- 59:24to share about it.
- 59:25Right now,
- 59:25we're in an unenviable situation.
- 59:27We've never standardized on a camera
- 59:29brand,
- 59:30so we've got about eight different brands
- 59:31deployed out there,
- 59:32along with various SDI, HDMI, HDBaseT,
- 59:35and USB options for transport.
- 59:37I'd like an Ethernet-based solution
- 59:39because it's the easiest to deal with in
- 59:40the field,
- 59:41but there ain't such a thing as an
- 59:42HDBaseT USB capture interface that I can
- 59:45find.
- 59:46So that pretty much leaves NDI at this
- 59:47point.
- 59:48And he's not wrong there.
- 59:49For whatever reason, and they do exist,
- 59:52but not as many, the HDBaseT in,
- 59:55USB out.
- 59:56It's hard to find.
- 59:57Big giant dock I have right over there
- 59:59has an HDBaseT on it.
- 59:59Well, yeah,
- 1:00:00it usually becomes a bigger thing.
- 1:00:01Where's the little widget one that does
- 1:00:03that?
- 1:00:03We've been calling for that for years.
- 1:00:04We always wanted that.
- 1:00:05Anyway.
- 1:00:06So he says,
- 1:00:06so that pretty much leaves NDI at this
- 1:00:08point.
- 1:00:08I'd be interested to know how much hassle
- 1:00:09you've had for your network groups using
- 1:00:11NDI.
- 1:00:12Open to other ideas as well.
- 1:00:13Our deployments are very simple.
- 1:00:14A PTZ direct to the in-room PC for
- 1:00:16Zoom and Teams.
- 1:00:17Single camera as a rule.
- 1:00:18Cheers.
- 1:00:21I did respond to him and we shared
- 1:00:22kind of how we're doing.
- 1:00:23We talked back and forth.
- 1:00:24He's got some other interesting stuff that
- 1:00:25I'd love to have him come on and
- 1:00:26talk about how he did some interesting
- 1:00:28camera control stuff.
- 1:00:28But...
- 1:00:30does raise a good point like there are
- 1:00:32specialized systems out there and in some
- 1:00:34cases where i'm using for example like a
- 1:00:36like a qsys nc series camera it's a
- 1:00:38straight single cable straight into the
- 1:00:40network it is a network transport feed
- 1:00:42that the that the uh the system can
- 1:00:43read and share around and route to any
- 1:00:46number of devices simultaneously or also
- 1:00:48so it gives you all the options that
- 1:00:50he's describing here with ndi and i think
- 1:00:51we're all interested in ndi jamie has
- 1:00:53deployed a good amount of ndi on his
- 1:00:56network
- 1:00:57uh and there is a new well there's
- 1:00:58there's several of them out there but the
- 1:00:59new one that caught our eye we talked
- 1:01:01about at infocomm is from magewell they
- 1:01:02have the their little capture box but it's
- 1:01:04just it's a an rj-forty-five on one side
- 1:01:07and hdmi on the other and his ndi
- 1:01:09it acts as an ndi endpoint now that
- 1:01:11will mean depending on your network
- 1:01:13deployment you have to give up another
- 1:01:14port for that device so you could have
- 1:01:16two three four five six cameras whatever
- 1:01:18computers with ndi encoders all built in
- 1:01:21This just gives you that output as,
- 1:01:23you know,
- 1:01:23straight to convert that to baseband
- 1:01:26video,
- 1:01:27at which point then you can do whatever
- 1:01:28you want, video and audio.
- 1:01:29Do whatever you want with it.
- 1:01:30It also, apparently,
- 1:01:31and Jamie was talking about this the other
- 1:01:32day,
- 1:01:34It does have a control API,
- 1:01:35and that control API seems to be a
- 1:01:37little quirky,
- 1:01:37but does seem to be working.
- 1:01:38He's had some issues with USB,
- 1:01:40and I think that's stuff that will get
- 1:01:41worked out in a firmware revision.
- 1:01:43But I think that the potential,
- 1:01:45and to the question in the email here,
- 1:01:49the potential for NDI with the appropriate
- 1:01:51network configuration or appropriate
- 1:01:53NDI-friendly network has a lot of runway
- 1:01:56for it.
- 1:01:57Fraser Cain, Yes,
- 1:01:58I think maybe mileage will vary.
- 1:02:02Yeah, I think at some point,
- 1:02:04the world you just described Chris,
- 1:02:06being camera,
- 1:02:08Ethernet into my managed switch in my
- 1:02:12lectern with
- 1:02:14widget breakout ndi to usb right that's
- 1:02:17probably the safest way to do that that's
- 1:02:19probably the safest which is probably what
- 1:02:20people that jamie would probably had also
- 1:02:22play with that and i would think his
- 1:02:23switch is probably also his network is it
- 1:02:25fair to say that anybody who's looking at
- 1:02:26ndi for a solution is probably that's
- 1:02:28probably something a build they're
- 1:02:30familiar with it no they woke up in
- 1:02:31a hot sweat at night going oh i
- 1:02:33have the sdk kit i can just install
- 1:02:35the the ndi thing on my computer and
- 1:02:37the computer people are going to let me
- 1:02:38bring the ndi in
- 1:02:41Yes, on the brochure,
- 1:02:42it will lead you to believe that.
- 1:02:43And yes,
- 1:02:44that's probably how your church is doing
- 1:02:46it,
- 1:02:46but that's not going to work in your
- 1:02:48classroom.
- 1:02:49No.
- 1:02:49It can,
- 1:02:50but you have to get all the people
- 1:02:51aligned to make that work.
- 1:02:53It is a very elegant.
- 1:02:55I think we can all aspire to be
- 1:02:57there.
- 1:02:57I don't think everybody's there yet.
- 1:02:58That takes a much larger conversation for
- 1:03:00your computer to also reside on that NDI
- 1:03:03network that that camera's on at the same
- 1:03:04time.
- 1:03:05It's a lovely world,
- 1:03:06and I think in a completely converged
- 1:03:08world, that is the way things will go.
- 1:03:10I'm not a hundred percent sure it'll be
- 1:03:11NDI.
- 1:03:13I don't think it will.
- 1:03:14No, probably not.
- 1:03:15So, well, let's step past that.
- 1:03:19There are challenges with NDI.
- 1:03:24Long-term reliability seems to be an
- 1:03:25issue.
- 1:03:26NDI loves to be rebooted.
- 1:03:29Jamie's are fine, though.
- 1:03:30So he says,
- 1:03:32I don't believe a word he says.
- 1:03:33I don't either.
- 1:03:34He's not rebooting them.
- 1:03:36He's taking and turning off PoE.
- 1:03:37I've got a question.
- 1:03:38I'm not rebooting them.
- 1:03:39I'm sending someone over to reboot them.
- 1:03:41I have some mixed feelings about those
- 1:03:44cameras, like away from the NDI,
- 1:03:47just bird dog in itself.
- 1:03:48This is like years ago.
- 1:03:49You were out and bought some of those.
- 1:03:50I deployed.
- 1:03:51This started as a question,
- 1:03:52have you used bird dog cameras?
- 1:03:54Yeah, I've used bird dog cameras before,
- 1:03:56and we've had some bad tastes in our
- 1:03:58mouth, and that was from my business.
- 1:03:59How do you like putting those firmwares on
- 1:04:01those cameras?
- 1:04:02So you have to get a big-ass ladder
- 1:04:04and set it up over the church benches
- 1:04:07because the only way to update the
- 1:04:08firmware on those is USB to your laptop.
- 1:04:13Church benches.
- 1:04:15It's a bench and a church.
- 1:04:17Pew.
- 1:04:19You and your words.
- 1:04:21Okay.
- 1:04:21I'm with you.
- 1:04:22I'm on your side.
- 1:04:22Let's go.
- 1:04:23And also...
- 1:04:25make sure the system's off for like three
- 1:04:26hours before you get up there and touch
- 1:04:28them because they're five hundred degrees.
- 1:04:30You burn your fingerprints right off your
- 1:04:32hands.
- 1:04:33First time I touched one, I was oh,
- 1:04:35my God,
- 1:04:36I called the fire department ambulance or
- 1:04:38something.
- 1:04:39I don't know.
- 1:04:40was hot, burned, left a mark.
- 1:04:43So that those were the P one hundreds.
- 1:04:46That was a long way.
- 1:04:47Five, five years ago,
- 1:04:50there was the first was like pre COVID
- 1:04:52days.
- 1:04:53Yeah,
- 1:04:53it was like the first gen of these
- 1:04:56cameras.
- 1:04:56So I'm wondering,
- 1:04:58and maybe Jamie can tell us but
- 1:05:02Have they improved any of that, Jamie?
- 1:05:04Nothing.
- 1:05:04Oh, wait, he didn't show up today.
- 1:05:05No, he didn't show up.
- 1:05:06He pulled a Larry.
- 1:05:07If I was going to go down this
- 1:05:08road and try to find a standard,
- 1:05:10I think there's also that question about
- 1:05:11standards in this.
- 1:05:14SDI?
- 1:05:14I like SDI, but that's a bias.
- 1:05:16I'm feeling old because of that.
- 1:05:17I've standardized on SDI with a Cat-Six.
- 1:05:20But that's two cables.
- 1:05:20Bottom line.
- 1:05:21It's I don't care.
- 1:05:22I don't care.
- 1:05:24What I'm saying is one can go to
- 1:05:25the idea if I don't care.
- 1:05:26The listener question was,
- 1:05:28if they're looking for a one cable
- 1:05:29solution, and they're looking at NDI,
- 1:05:31are there other network capable protocols
- 1:05:35that might be a replacement for NDI,
- 1:05:37SMPTE, or etc?
- 1:05:39I would look at the options out there
- 1:05:41where you're getting the cameras that come
- 1:05:45with all the basket of fun.
- 1:05:46like the SRT is nd is all that
- 1:05:48there's many of them out there and PTZ
- 1:05:50optics and all that if you need that,
- 1:05:51or you can license them for those things,
- 1:05:52play with all those things,
- 1:05:53understand what it means on your network.
- 1:05:56If nothing else,
- 1:05:57use this as a vector to learn more
- 1:05:58about this stuff, right?
- 1:06:00This is this is the opportunity to do
- 1:06:01that.
- 1:06:03You didn't kind of get into what your
- 1:06:04your network stack looks like in your
- 1:06:06learning space with this is that your
- 1:06:07network is your computer, your computers,
- 1:06:10PCs,
- 1:06:11people that Chris has running in there.
- 1:06:12So I think this is that larger
- 1:06:14conversation.
- 1:06:15But there's a lot of different ways that
- 1:06:16are very intriguing.
- 1:06:17I think the the market and the industry
- 1:06:19is kind of figuring out how to get
- 1:06:20these things to blend.
- 1:06:21So the chocolate and peanut butters do
- 1:06:22play well together.
- 1:06:23It's just a matter of
- 1:06:25What do we really like?
- 1:06:27NDI has very specific multicast things
- 1:06:29that it needs to deal with.
- 1:06:30So you have to be well versed on
- 1:06:31that.
- 1:06:32If you're not managing your switches,
- 1:06:34who is?
- 1:06:34And are they ready to allow that for
- 1:06:35you?
- 1:06:36Along with all the other host of AV
- 1:06:37over IP protocols.
- 1:06:38And here's the thing is what Mark's
- 1:06:40talking about in plain English is when you
- 1:06:42plug up that camera and you got an
- 1:06:43image and then you walk away and then
- 1:06:45faculty says, my image is gone.
- 1:06:47What are you going to do?
- 1:06:49Mm-hmm.
- 1:06:50Who are you going to call?
- 1:06:51Call the support team.
- 1:06:53Or the network team.
- 1:06:54Or the computer team.
- 1:06:56Or shit, maybe it's the AV team.
- 1:06:59I don't know.
- 1:07:00We ended up on SDI solely because of
- 1:07:02COVID.
- 1:07:03It was just far easier for us to,
- 1:07:05through low voltage contracts,
- 1:07:07pull in those without having to bring in
- 1:07:08an electrician so we can do POE.
- 1:07:10So it just was very utilitarian for us.
- 1:07:13It just worked.
- 1:07:14Yeah, and for us,
- 1:07:15we're not putting these on our network.
- 1:07:18So SDI allows me to take my video,
- 1:07:21send it to my computer,
- 1:07:22and then put the camera on the network.
- 1:07:25So then I can control it.
- 1:07:27I can monitor it and all through that.
- 1:07:32But I'm not sending video through my
- 1:07:34network.
- 1:07:34That just doesn't work.
- 1:07:36I think we're all hopeful of like the
- 1:07:38twenty one tens of the world to see
- 1:07:39what's going to become of all this.
- 1:07:40But it's everybody's kind of waiting for
- 1:07:44everybody to do something first.
- 1:07:46Yes, we see it in broadcast.
- 1:07:47But now we're trying to say, OK,
- 1:07:48where does this broadcast technology
- 1:07:50trickle down or not?
- 1:07:51And I think that's the same hope that
- 1:07:52with with, as you mentioned,
- 1:07:54by the cameras that have like here's five
- 1:07:56outputs on the back,
- 1:07:57because then there's you have options.
- 1:07:58Also, then by one line,
- 1:08:00one model camera and use it.
- 1:08:01And make sure you buy in cameras that
- 1:08:03all five outputs work at the same time.
- 1:08:06Good point.
- 1:08:07That does happen.
- 1:08:11SDI definitely has its place.
- 1:08:12It works all day long,
- 1:08:13as long as it's terminated correctly.
- 1:08:14By the way,
- 1:08:15you may find a lot of,
- 1:08:16especially if you're doing larger building
- 1:08:18projects,
- 1:08:19integrators who aren't as familiar with
- 1:08:20SDI these days.
- 1:08:22Make sure your team is.
- 1:08:23If they say, what's SDI?
- 1:08:26You may have a problem.
- 1:08:27Usually they'll say, yeah, we can do that,
- 1:08:29and then they do a crappy job of
- 1:08:30it,
- 1:08:30and you get to go back and re-terminate
- 1:08:31most of it.
- 1:08:32And they run it off the end,
- 1:08:33and you're like, wait, what?
- 1:08:34That's not how this works.
- 1:08:35When they use compression crimpers,
- 1:08:36it falls right off.
- 1:08:36This is not an old-school coax.
- 1:08:38Have you ever seen somebody try to run
- 1:08:41regular coax with the RF ends and then
- 1:08:43have an RF to BNC adapter?
- 1:08:46Dude.
- 1:08:47Yeah, it runs RCA all day long,
- 1:08:48or component.
- 1:08:49I think that's not going to work.
- 1:08:51Yeah.
- 1:08:52But be aware of that.
- 1:08:53There are some tricks to it.
- 1:08:54Make sure you get comfortable with the
- 1:08:55one-piece or the three-piece terminations,
- 1:08:56all that.
- 1:08:57Know how to do that stuff because it
- 1:08:58does have utility still because it does
- 1:09:00just freaking work all day long.
- 1:09:02It is uncompressed and it's unencrypted,
- 1:09:05but you can get that right off of
- 1:09:07your camera to switchers and other things.
- 1:09:08It opens up a lot of different
- 1:09:09opportunities,
- 1:09:10but it does require you pulling an
- 1:09:12additional cable.
- 1:09:13And so I see where, you know,
- 1:09:14from our email, they're again asking like,
- 1:09:16is there single cable solutions?
- 1:09:17The answer is yes, but...
- 1:09:19And there's always kind of like this other
- 1:09:21thing with it,
- 1:09:22like what's the network set up as?
- 1:09:22Your organization will depend if it's
- 1:09:24going to work for you.
- 1:09:25Or if I go with a baseband option,
- 1:09:27do I have some sort of crazy breakout
- 1:09:28box at the other end?
- 1:09:29And yes, those solutions are out there.
- 1:09:32I would love to find a really easy
- 1:09:34and reliable one, too,
- 1:09:35because it's one of those things where it
- 1:09:37streamlines our deployments.
- 1:09:38It makes the systems that much easier to
- 1:09:41deal with.
- 1:09:42And you don't have to worry about,
- 1:09:43you know,
- 1:09:44different types of cables and boxes and
- 1:09:45all sorts of things.
- 1:09:45I don't agree with that.
- 1:09:47well i don't think they i don't think
- 1:09:49going down to one cable makes systems
- 1:09:50easier to support if you have the same
- 1:09:54deployment everywhere yeah but it's easy
- 1:09:55but if i have the same deployment on
- 1:09:57two cables it's not any more labor okay
- 1:09:59if you have if you have a two
- 1:10:01cable solution in every room you you do
- 1:10:03you sir that's what i'm saying like what's
- 1:10:05wrong with two cables it's fine two cables
- 1:10:09are got to be better than one i
- 1:10:11think we'll get there i think we will
- 1:10:12see it um
- 1:10:13and it may not be ndi maybe something
- 1:10:15else it might be something else i think
- 1:10:17and sorry just people probably listening
- 1:10:18screaming i do it all the time yes
- 1:10:20you can okay great but you you it
- 1:10:22does take awareness of all those other
- 1:10:24services and capabilities that it's not
- 1:10:25just about maybe the thing you've just
- 1:10:27gotten lucky so far maybe your ndi is
- 1:10:29blinking right now you don't even know it
- 1:10:31could be off it's not what about that
- 1:10:34We just set up a script in the
- 1:10:35control system to ask the network switch
- 1:10:37to just bounce that PoE port every six
- 1:10:39hours.
- 1:10:40It works fine.
- 1:10:40Works fine.
- 1:10:41No problems.
- 1:10:42Between classes,
- 1:10:43every time you shut the projector down?
- 1:10:44Projector off.
- 1:10:44Pow!
- 1:10:44Thanks.
- 1:10:45All right.
- 1:10:50I think we've about run that one in
- 1:10:51the ground,
- 1:10:51and I think we would all agree then
- 1:10:52that if you want the ideal solution for
- 1:10:54doing your cameras,
- 1:10:54just extend USB with some sort of Amazon
- 1:10:57widget.
- 1:10:57Oh, God.
- 1:10:59I puked a little bit just now.
- 1:11:00Sorry.
- 1:11:00All right.
- 1:11:02Well, enough of that.
- 1:11:04We'll leave it there.
- 1:11:05We'll call that an end to this nonsense.
- 1:11:09We'll be back next week with a different
- 1:11:11type of show.
- 1:11:11I can't remember what we're doing.
- 1:11:12Get ready for the call-in show.
- 1:11:14It's coming soon.
- 1:11:22Well,
- 1:11:22we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:11:24of AV Superfriends Off the Rails.
- 1:11:26You can contact us with questions,
- 1:11:28topic ideas,
- 1:11:28or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:11:30avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:11:32If you complain loud enough,
- 1:11:33we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:11:38Nice work, everyone.
- 1:11:40Sharp broadcast.
- 1:11:41Really good.
- 1:11:42Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:11:44Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:11:45I liked it.
- 1:11:46The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:11:47Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:11:49individuals and do not represent their
- 1:11:50respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:11:52companies, or clients.