Latest / The Ball is Round / The Ball is Round - Episode 155 - Nations League Looms, Post Mortem Part 3
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, and welcome to another episode of The Ball Is Round. I'm
- 0:04Hadirafel and tonight on the show, Hernandezada released from his duties as coach of
- 0:10c F Montreal, the continuation of post Morten with midfielders and forwards, and
- 0:16Mara Biello chooses his squad for the quarterfinals of the CONCACAFF Nations League. That
- 0:22and a lot more on episode one and fifty five of The Ball Is Round.
- 0:47And here we are. We are back for another Sunday night where we're
- 0:53going to discuss c F Montreal, the beginning in the national teams and everything.
- 0:58I'm joined by my friends, Pal, Hey Eve, how are you
- 1:02doing well? Thanks? How are you? I'm fine, I'm fine.
- 1:04You're very happy today, which is very weird for me and the oders exactly.
- 1:12And then of course Elias gregoriatis Elias, how are you? Man?
- 1:18Not too bad? I mean, you know, Barcelona also one today,
- 1:19so I'm I'm in I'm in a good movie, yeah exactly. And we
- 1:26need we need also to because we do cover Montreal and you know, soccer
- 1:30in Montreal. But also it's always nice to see our city, you know,
- 1:34achieving something. And I just want to make sure that we we just
- 1:38underline the fact that the Aluett's qualified for the Great Cup Final yesterday and by
- 1:45beating the the Toronto's are Toronto Argos on the other football, So winning in
- 1:51Toronto on the m O field, so that's always a good Another went on
- 1:55more field. That's nothing new, right, exactly exactly, So yeah,
- 1:59congrats to them. To everybody that follows football. I'm not a big football
- 2:04fan, but you know, always appreciate a good story here in Montreal,
- 2:07and it's really nice to see one of our professional teams really going very far
- 2:13and trying to win another trophy against the Blue Members. I think the want
- 2:20to exactly I was asking Elias, I wasn't asking you. So yeah,
- 2:24so congrats for the Alouettes and yeah, that's about it. We're not going
- 2:30to talk about European soccer because I really don't feel like it because my team
- 2:34lost. So yeah, so guys, let's go straight into the first subject
- 2:40because we have a lot on our plate today. First, I want to
- 2:46apologize to our good friend tatebook Brooks that really sent us a question last week
- 2:52and we weren't really able to answer it, not able to forgot to answer
- 2:55it, and his question was that it seemed like the team is taking a
- 3:00long time to make a decision on coach Losada. You know what I answer.
- 3:04You got your answer. So on Thursday, the ninth of November,
- 3:08c F Montreal announced that it parted ways with head coach Hernando Sada, effective
- 3:15immediately following and that's the statement. Following the assessment of the season, it
- 3:20was determined the decision is in the club's best interest for twenty twenty four and
- 3:24beyond. Assistant coach Sevastian Seti has also been relieved of his duties. The
- 3:30club wishes to thank both Hernand and Sevastian for the contribution over the past year.
- 3:35The selection process for c F Montreal's next head coach for the twenty twenty
- 3:38four season is actively underway. Guys, Eve, let's start with you not
- 3:46talking not really surprising, but let's answer Tate's question in another way. Why
- 3:53did it take that long? In your opinion? I think, well,
- 3:59I mean, I'll be you need to actually announce to the employee that they're
- 4:03fired, right, and that's the only dignified way to go about it.
- 4:06So that conversation obviously had to take place, and I'm sure that there are
- 4:11probably negotiations, you know, because he did have a contract for next year,
- 4:15so I'm sure that there were certain negotiations that had to take place regarding
- 4:18what sort of compensation he would get for having his contract terminated by the club,
- 4:25you know, and those little behind the scenes machinations, if you will,
- 4:30that probably made things appear that they were taking longer. But I think
- 4:35you know, for the whether it was in the postseason media availability or in
- 4:42those other interviews that we have seen from whether it was GERVEI, whether it
- 4:46was Renard, I think the writing had been pretty much on the wall regardless
- 4:51exactly. And talking about media availability, I'm not sure if the Lias you
- 4:55were there at Tony as a pressor so, just tell us a bit about
- 4:59it. How was the mood there was everybody like kind of you know,
- 5:04nobody was really shocked, I believe, But what was the moods there between
- 5:09germanists? And of course tell us a bit more about the presser. No,
- 5:13I I nobody was too surprised. And you know, even when we
- 5:16talked about it and I said that I think he should come back, I
- 5:19wouldn't have been surprised if he had been let go, and Adrivian's reasoning for
- 5:24it kind of reinforced that. Right. He talked about how this philosophy is
- 5:30what the style he wanted to play, and that wasn't the case, and
- 5:33so Annosata went all in on his vision of the game. And you know
- 5:39what, credit to him, he believed in himself and and the way that
- 5:42he wanted to play. The thing is he went, he played his way
- 5:45and he lost. And I believe that if he had played you know,
- 5:48was way and lost, he would still be with the club. So that's
- 5:55it's as simple as that. And he really did know kind of reinforce that
- 5:59that was nine percent of the reason, right. Yes, you know,
- 6:03he could point out the issues with some of the players and stuff like that,
- 6:08but the main reason it was was purely down to philosophy. He didn't
- 6:12say he said that, you know, I had nothing to do with with
- 6:14with competence and his ability as a coach. And that's true because we've seen
- 6:18Rana Soda. You know, he understands tactics and he knows the game very
- 6:23well. You know, it's just that his style did not mix with you
- 6:27know, Olivia Renaldo's philosophy and clearly did not mix with you know, the
- 6:30the overall group. But yeah, you know, I've said something that was
- 6:35really interesting is that it's not only about results, and he had to take
- 6:40everything into consideration. He did talk about the players. He did speak with
- 6:44a few players, but they're not and he said they're not the ones controlling
- 6:49and deciding, but it's a part of the discussion, which is important.
- 6:54He also talked quite a few times about the style of play that doesn't suit
- 6:59his project and the product that c F Montreal wants to put a head on
- 7:02the page, which is something else. So not a lot of things went,
- 7:08you know, into Losada's way in a certain way, right like it
- 7:13feels like it feels like did he like, I'm going to be very blunt
- 7:17there, but did he lie in his interview saying you know, I'm able
- 7:23to play that way and then you know he wasn't able to put it in
- 7:27place after like is it a possibility because I see you that you're you're making
- 7:31me there making my face like well, I'm like because I think, yeah,
- 7:38But there's something when you embellish and then when you do completely the opposite,
- 7:43when you're saying that you're going to play posession game football and you're going
- 7:46to play like beautiful, the beautiful game and everything, and then during the
- 7:49whole season, during the whole year, you do not you don't do that.
- 7:55That there's it's a bit weird. Yeah, And maybe it's like my
- 7:59desire not to kick a guy while he's down or something like that. But
- 8:03you know, in the early part of the season, there were so many
- 8:05players who were injured. Obviously, there were players whose kind of question was
- 8:11a little bit in status and so or sorry status was a little bit in
- 8:13question, and so on and so forth. But yeah, I wonder if
- 8:18he didn't over sell himself, you know, I think outright lying because as
- 8:24a coach, at the end of the day, there are tapes of your
- 8:28tactics, you know, in evidence, right. Yeah, but like maybe
- 8:33he was able to produce something in Belgium with beer Scott that wasn't that wasn't
- 8:39able to produce in DC too, So I don't know. Yeah, I
- 8:46know what we produced in DC other than like discord and disharmony. The first
- 8:52year they made the playoffs, it was the second half of the season.
- 8:54Yeah, that's true. Now, now we do have a question from Roberto,
- 9:00and Roberto Roberto always tells us that we go too long on our pause,
- 9:05and then he asked questions and I'm joking, please continue on ask me
- 9:07questions. Begs the question why was he hired? Like Elias, can you
- 9:13answer ROBERTA. Look, I mean, first of all, I think that
- 9:16connection with the Belgian league is evident, right, deal does have a certain
- 9:22fondness for or his home country and his domestic championship. He played there,
- 9:26and he certainly knows the landscape very well. That's where he got you,
- 9:28he saying, that's where he got you knows all for and you know that's
- 9:33not where he got directly or Alosada, but both as a player and a
- 9:35manager, he evolved there. So I think that he has a pretty good
- 9:39idea of at least the Belgian version of an Alosada and maybe what he was
- 9:43kind of hoping what would be brought here. So I think that, you
- 9:46know, all that does kind of lean into why he may have had a
- 9:52leg up in terms of the in terms of any kind of considerations. But
- 9:56at the same time, you know, it's if you look at that DC
- 9:58team, they did they did have some some really nice spells of play,
- 10:03and I think that maybe, you know, there was this idea that with
- 10:07the right group, maybe something could be sparked. And I genuinely think that,
- 10:11you know, there was some potential there. I think that, you
- 10:13know, even from Anano Sada's perspective, he talked about the beginning of the
- 10:16season that he wants to play a possession style of play, and I think
- 10:20that, you know, maybe that disaster of the beginning of the season just
- 10:24made him completely re evaluate, you know, his his priorities and the way
- 10:28he wants to go about it. And it's very possible because remember and at
- 10:31that point they hadn't had they didn't have a full squad until yeah, but
- 10:37last like, you're right, you're right, But how do you explain then
- 10:41the last nine games is only one win? Like if it was if because
- 10:46we are pointing the beginning of the season, but we're not really thinking about
- 10:52the end of the season, where you should have found your groove in a
- 10:54certain way, right, So, and he did it, But I think
- 10:58the problem is that they didn't find the group because they never had the chance
- 11:01to. At the same time, because even you know, you have your
- 11:03home game, you find your form, but so poorly. This is not
- 11:09me being generous, This is me trying to find a reason. You asked
- 11:11me what the reason was. I think the reason is when you're you play
- 11:16so poorly on the road on such a consistent basis, it is impossible to
- 11:20develop momentum. It doesn't matter how good you are at home. When you
- 11:22play so negatively and so poorly on the road and half your games are on
- 11:28the road, it doesn't matter if you are amazing at home. Eventually that
- 11:31poor form on the road is going to bleed into your form at home and
- 11:35not the other way around. So I think they were kind of hoping that
- 11:39them playing well at home would kind of bleed into them maybe using some of
- 11:43that momentum on the road, But it was the other way around. You
- 11:46know that that that poor foam at the end of the season. It's because
- 11:50we start to see the away see if Montreal start with that started showing up
- 11:54Puto, which is you know, I think it's the exact we obviously the
- 11:58exact opposite of what they intend. Yeah. Interesting, Interesting, Now he's
- 12:01gone, That's going to be very interesting to see the rest uh and in
- 12:07the following weeks, because I'm pretty sure that is going to have to take
- 12:11a decision very quickly because you need to make sure to have a squad ready
- 12:15for January. Uh, and you know January is coming very very quickly,
- 12:20and you do have a lot of decisions right now to be to to take,
- 12:24of course, and that takes us directly to the other question that was
- 12:28asked to us from I mean Sabri, which is really interesting if you can
- 12:35just about that, I mean quick, oh did you okay? So what
- 12:48are your predictions for the options that will be activated or declined? Remember last
- 12:52year we were surprised at and pen Temis options were declined, but of course
- 12:58when Temis was resigned right after not Yao who went to Vancouver. So we
- 13:03do have I think seven players that have options. So we have Pantemis,
- 13:07we have Logan Keterer, we have Torkelsin, Zachbergia Usmanjabang Quizira, Sudizi Brahim
- 13:16and Johnnylasi. So eight players. Sorry, so you know, just we
- 13:22can go fast and just answer which options would you exercise alliances as such with
- 13:26you this line and which you wouldn't. I think it's easier to go through
- 13:31the ones that I wouldn't renew. I think that, you know, the
- 13:35only ones that I wouldn't take up are Quizerra and Dorkolsen. I understand that
- 13:41Dorkolsen does have a very unique position, given that you know, it's an
- 13:43international status, it's your twenty one status. But at some point, just
- 13:46for the good of both you and the player, if you are committee this
- 13:50player's development, you have to at some point cut your losses and let you
- 13:54know, you have to let go of that line. I think those are
- 13:58the only two that I think. You know, same thing with Jorge Quiza
- 14:01couldn't find any minutes. Now, it's it's two different managers. Where he
- 14:03was. Yeah, he had some bad luck with injuries, but the majority
- 14:07of the season he was healthy and he just did not play. And I
- 14:09think that this is two different managers with two different styles. Now where he
- 14:13did manage to break into the team, and you know, at least Underwood
- 14:16he managed to find some minutes of this ub but under it's you know,
- 14:22so I think that those are the two that you know, Thank you,
- 14:26but no, it makes no sense to continue with the club. Yeah,
- 14:30I agree with you. I would add two more with which are Pantemis,
- 14:35and for me, Pantemis is should be a number one. I don't think
- 14:41it's it's good for him to be a number two, And I don't think
- 14:43it's good for the group to have a number two like Pantemis who was the
- 14:48number one at one point. And the second thing is that I think he's
- 14:54just not going to be interested to be here anymore because he wants the number
- 14:56one spot and he's not iron Arise in front of him right now. So
- 15:01that's the other two that I will I would not exercise their options if anything.
- 15:07No, I'm actually one hundred percent on your side on this one,
- 15:11Hattie. Maybe for Zachary Brokeiard, like I said, I could see him
- 15:13having enough attachment now like where he has a child here and so on and
- 15:18so forth to sticking around. But I agree that for James Pantemis to kind
- 15:24of have a hope of progressing his career beyond backup level, he absolutely needs
- 15:30a change of scenery. And if Zachary bro Giard does want a starting spot,
- 15:33then one hundred percent, once again, change of scenery is required.
- 15:39Let's wait and see what will be the decisions of Olivier. We do have
- 15:45one other question, and it's from Emil Actionable. The question that's going to
- 15:50be very, very tough to answer. What does Renard or need do to
- 15:54avoid a repeat of the losade of failure. Is it just a question of
- 15:58try again it right or does this c F Montreal need to do things differently.
- 16:03By the way, I haven't listened to the post war yet. Ignore
- 16:07if you've already covered it. We haven't covered yet. We're leaving it for
- 16:11next week. We're going to have a special guest hopefully next week, and
- 16:15we're going to be able to answer that the you know, the o you
- 16:22know performance this season. But I think we can answer at least this question
- 16:26from Emil Aschambo. If you can start, I'll jump in. Oh boy.
- 16:37I mean, I think finding kind of that magical formula with a coach.
- 16:42I mean, there's so many moving pieces when it comes to hiring our
- 16:45coach, because you have to look at the players that are available and kind
- 16:48of the general vibe of your locker room versus the style of football that you
- 16:53want to see displayed, versus you know, how much time you want your
- 16:56coach to give to those academy and up and coming players. Between know when
- 17:00Montreal is very very high, So it's really it's really difficult to say.
- 17:07I do think that I'm I'm hoping anyway that Renard is going to learn that
- 17:14kind of a coach who has more of a player first mentality compared to Lozada,
- 17:22and maybe who has a little bit better of a reputation in managing a
- 17:26locker room, in kind of controlling those those big personalities and those leaders who
- 17:30can kind of bring players onto their side for and against. The coach is
- 17:37looked at maybe a little bit harder because as we know, you know,
- 17:40Lazada came in with not the greatest track record in that regard, and we've
- 17:44seen other Montreal coaches who have also come in with similar kind of questionable histories,
- 17:48and there the other teams that they've coached also not succeed when they haven't
- 17:52been say, quote unquote a players coach. So that's one thing that I'm
- 17:57hoping that they look at a lot more going forward. But overall, I
- 18:02mean, I think at the end of the day, you do have to
- 18:03go back to the drawing board and say, like, what is our priority
- 18:07when it comes from your coaching. Of course, yeah, of course you
- 18:11need you need to make sure that you you go back to the drawing boards
- 18:15and you make sure to ask the right questions what went wrong? How can
- 18:18we not reproduce that again? For sure? As a person, Elias,
- 18:23you know, do you have a different answer than Eve? There are other
- 18:29metrics that you look at before, you know, taking a decision, if
- 18:33you had to take the decision to yourself. No. I just think this
- 18:37is a case of you know, they expected something from a coach that you
- 18:41know, they thought that they had seen. They thought they saw the style
- 18:44of playing and Losada, and clearly they were mistaken. I think that,
- 18:48you know, next time they should be if something like this were to happen
- 18:52again with a manager where they're starting to veer off course and not really following
- 18:59the full of the club, then they'll be a bit more proactive and try
- 19:03and get in front of it sooner, right than just be at the end
- 19:07of the season. Well, you know, he didn't play the style of
- 19:08play that we wanted him to play. You are the spoiling director and you
- 19:11meet with him, I'm assuming fairly often so the fact that you know that
- 19:18this this was not a surprise from you. In fact, you know after
- 19:21the first month, it should have been very clear that you know, they're
- 19:23not playing the same way when Annaci was playing. So I think that that
- 19:27has to be something, you know, I want to like see a bit
- 19:30more proctical. Again, we don't know about how often maybe reinforce the fact
- 19:37that's like, hey, you know, we are a club that wants to
- 19:38play possession football and want to play beautiful football, and you know, we
- 19:41were not aware and was not going to comment on on on on that kind
- 19:47of dynamic that he had with obviously not But I think that you have to
- 19:52go to the coach that has a proven track record of playing this style at
- 19:55a number of different clubs and also in a number of different situations. I
- 19:57don't want to coach that you know, played only with the best players and
- 20:03then walks through club because yeah, then you can play with our style you
- 20:06want when you have the best team in the league. So I'd love to
- 20:10say someone that has a poon track word of building up a club and then
- 20:14you know, enforcing the style of play. Interesting, I wanted to add
- 20:18something else to to to those answers because I agree with both of you,
- 20:23you know, looking at c F Montreal history since they joined MLS. You
- 20:30know, the only positive seasons that they had was one the one where we
- 20:37reached the conference finals. It was under Morabielo. We have the one where
- 20:45we reached the Champions League final was under Frank Klopas, and we had the
- 20:49one with Ulfrid Naci last year finishing second in the league also, And when
- 20:56I look at that, you see something that's very similar. First of all,
- 21:00someone that's adapted to North America and the MLS. They know the MLS,
- 21:07they know everything about the MLS already. They're they're not really surprised by
- 21:11the long trips, by by the mentality that's different, the way of play
- 21:17that's different, the fact that you go to RSL you're playing something complete,
- 21:21a different team that when you go into Columbus or you play completely you know,
- 21:25it's different, different way of playing soccer. So that's the first thing.
- 21:30And two of the three were in a certain way, people from Montreal,
- 21:37from the Montreal culture, from Montreal soccer scene. Okay, no,
- 21:41well Nanci and Morabiello. So in my in my opinion, I think we
- 21:47should go with someone that's really been here for a while. Nos skin Asian
- 21:53soccer knows MLS but knows MLS, not really coaching in MLS. I would
- 21:59go with it. You know, It's it's funny because Patrick Patrick Wright said
- 22:03it led the rumor, then the Bobby rumors begin and you know what,
- 22:07and for me, it shouldn't be only a rumor. You know, Bobby
- 22:11Spain it is. I think should be really considered for this job because he
- 22:15did build. He's gonna check all the boxes in a certain way. He
- 22:19did build Sigma f C from the ground up, right, So he did.
- 22:23And we know a lot of players that really went from Sega Sigma to
- 22:29the Canadian national team. Carol Leron is one of them. Second of all,
- 22:33he does have that culture of winning because he did win for UH four
- 22:40out of five CPL seasons. And third of all, he does have the
- 22:45local aspect of it because his assistant is none other than Kid Salidopolos that we
- 22:49got that we hosted here on the ball is around on one point UH and
- 22:53he knows everything about the Montreal and the Quebec soccer scene. So which is
- 23:00something that's very very interesting and very very important. And when you're building a
- 23:04project, let's see if Montreal is trying to do around the talent from here,
- 23:10the Montreal talent. I think you need that sort of of coach that
- 23:14believes in the talent here in Montreal, within the academy and so on.
- 23:19So I think it would be interesting to go with the choice that's not really
- 23:26bling blink, but you know, the kind of choice that usually brings results
- 23:30to to to to this team in MLS and in other competitions. I see
- 23:37that eve is sure is dying to answer or to add something. Am I
- 23:41am I wrong? No, not at all. I agree with you on
- 23:47the philosophy standpoint one hundred percent. It's invaluable that the coach has experienced and
- 23:52unfortunately Bobby Smyrinotist doesn't have a ton of like you know, CPL has a
- 23:57lot of grueling travel in and of itself. I mean traveling from you know,
- 24:02Halifax to whether it's Victoria, whether it's Vancouver, is you know,
- 24:07it's not a walk in the park by any stretch, and the other oddities
- 24:14of the league that I won't even start with. No, I wholeheartedly agree
- 24:19that he should be in consideration one hundred percent if he has any interest to
- 24:25leave a club where he has basically forged a dynasty by this point, No,
- 24:29pun intended a hundred percent. Yeah, I mean he's gotten forged to
- 24:34play extremely attractive football in the CFL. You shouldn't get me started on CFL
- 24:41in the CPL. In the CPL, you know, definitely brought out the
- 24:48best in a lot of players I think that have been under his tenure.
- 24:53So no, I'm all for those rumors, you know, one hundred percent.
- 24:56And like you said, if some of the assistant, which is such
- 25:00as kid who was a lovely guest on the ball is Round, come along,
- 25:04then they bring that Montreal knowledge and experience with them of the unique market
- 25:10that is Montreal, so all the better. But we'll see your more to
- 25:15words of Patty, let's wait and see. Let's wait and see exactly Elias.
- 25:18Uh, we do have, of course, you know Bobby Spenor It's
- 25:21I said, he checks all the boxes. Unfortunately he doesn't speak French.
- 25:26Uh. He does have an assistant that speaks French, so that might help.
- 25:29So let's wait and see. But do you have anything to add on
- 25:32on what you've just uh just added herself. Yeah, I mean Bobby Spiritis
- 25:37takes every box. He was my favorite after all, So you had left,
- 25:41and I think that you would be a great fit. Now. You
- 25:45know, one thing content of is is you know we all know and Love
- 25:48brought up two very very good points. One is at Forge, to see
- 25:52Bobby Spirialis is not only the head coach, but he's also the sporting director.
- 25:56What he says goes, and he completely control over the direction of this
- 26:00program. And he would have to make a lot of concessions, a lot
- 26:03of compromises in moving to Montreal and having to work with it. It could
- 26:08work, but you know, at the same time, people but heads.
- 26:11Even if you know people have the same philosophy of play, people sometimes don't
- 26:15agree. Another important, you know I point that Cante brings up is by
- 26:22CPL standards, Forge is top. They have you know, they have excellent
- 26:27players, you have the ability to play this beautiful style of play. Moving
- 26:33to Montreal by MLS standards, Montreal does not have as good a squad as
- 26:37Forge does by CPL centers, which means it does. It is going to
- 26:41be a bit of an adjustment and I'm very curious to see how he's going
- 26:45to do that, because we do know how good he is at building up
- 26:48a club. We saw it on a number of occasions. But that is
- 26:52also another and really important thing to considering. Callti brings up two very good
- 26:55points that you know, from a Montreal perspective, there's no boxes at Boyce
- 26:57smianitiz doesn't tick. Or from a Bobby Spirrial this perspective, there are certain
- 27:02things that he would need assurances on before he hops on board. That's interesting.
- 27:07We'll see. He also knows a lot the Canadian Premier League and that
- 27:12might help with the budget of CF Montreal, saying, you know what,
- 27:17I know this player, this period displayer, they can play at a higher
- 27:22level and you know they can beat some good rotation players and he can help
- 27:26also give some some tips and to to Olivevana and his team. So that's
- 27:30also a possibility. But let's wait and see. As Eve mentioned a few
- 27:36seconds ago, and I think let's move on to the post mortem and the
- 27:40rest of the evaluations of c F Montreal players that played in twenty twenty three.
- 27:45Let's start with none other than Bryce Duke. So we're gonna do midfielders
- 27:51and strikers. So Bryce Duke that we had also on the ball this round
- 27:55on an interview. If you guys want to go listen. Please feel free
- 27:59to do so. It's it's always available. Bryce. Do you guys,
- 28:04is he or is he not the next big thing? If do you think
- 28:11that you could take the place of Georgia Mihailovich at one point? Of course,
- 28:18yeah this year, but does he have that potential in your opinion?
- 28:22And how do you rank him this season out of ten? Of course?
- 28:27I mean I always feel I really, I really really really really hate trying
- 28:36to kind of shoe horn one player into you know, being almost an identical
- 28:42replacement, if you will, to another player, because at the end of
- 28:47the day, there are two different individuals with two different not only playing styles,
- 28:51but you know, just experience in general. So I at the end
- 28:55of the day, like, there's a part of me that really hates it,
- 28:57but I understand why the question and gets asked like do you think he
- 29:02can have the same impact? Yes, I mean we saw flashes, you
- 29:11know, we saw flashes of a player who has that IQ, who has
- 29:18that vision, and who has you know, the creativity, he has,
- 29:23passion, range, he has technique, he has he has so many of
- 29:27the tools already in his toolbox. It's just a matter of kind of you
- 29:33know, honing them and sharpening them and making things work. And I think
- 29:38probably the musical chairs situation in the striker position also didn't necessarily help a player
- 29:45like Bryce Duke this season because trying to serve, you know, players who
- 29:49weren't informed, players who are coming and going from the lineup. I don't
- 29:53think that helps players who are trying to establish their place in a lineup.
- 30:00So I mean to like to answer your question with like a yes or no.
- 30:03I feel like we kind of need to know what's going on up ahead
- 30:07of Bryce Duke before we can say interesting, yeah, before we can say
- 30:11definitively. And I know that it kind of sounds like I'm equivocating it and
- 30:15not trying to give an answer. So at the end of the day,
- 30:18I'm going to say yes with the caveat if Montreal can stabilize their their attacking
- 30:23line. Interesting and all, my great, you're great, very important.
- 30:30I will go for a five and a half out of ten. I think
- 30:36interesting, that's a good grade, I think, in my opinion, for
- 30:41I was a really nice teacher back when I taught my children. Go ahead,
- 30:48Elias, give us your take on Bryce Duke. I'm going to uh,
- 30:53I'm actually going to surprised you guys can give him only a five oh
- 30:59wow number for a number of reasons. I do think he brought a lot
- 31:03of really good stuff, and I do think that there's a very high ceiling
- 31:06for him. We've seen what he can do at his best. The problem
- 31:10is that there still is the issue of consistency that we haven't seen from him
- 31:14that we've seen from younger players and less MLS experienced players, which is the
- 31:18most which is the bigger reason why his grade is that low. For me,
- 31:22I think that you know when he's on it, and we've seen it
- 31:23a number of times that says to put it. When he's on it,
- 31:26he is on it, and he is virtually unlayable when he's feeling good.
- 31:30The thing is, we haven't seen him feel that way in a while,
- 31:34especially in the final runs of the games where he saw his position basically vanish
- 31:40right. They just didn't play with the ten anymore. And you know,
- 31:42when when the team is playing better without your position being even in the formation,
- 31:49then obviously you're going to struggle for minutes and obviously it's not going to
- 31:52look that great on you. So I think that with a new coach that
- 31:56maybe wants to bring back a ten or maybe even an inside forward kind of
- 31:59thing where you know, we saw it Underwood for now, see where Jorge
- 32:01Mahalovich and Joaquin Tourist played almost as inside forward sometimes and they played as both
- 32:08tens and wingers, you know, just in those half spaces. I think
- 32:13Bryce too could find something that that suits them well because there's not a lot
- 32:15of running. It's a lot of judging the spaces, which he does very
- 32:19well. It's a lot of very close, very tight space's work, which
- 32:23is you know, in his wheelhouse. So I mean eve him a five
- 32:27for this year. But that's also because you know, information was just not
- 32:32for him. He's not an eight, he's a ten, and they weren't
- 32:35playing with a ten Interestinguah. I like Tate's comment. Agree Duke was not
- 32:40consistent, but that can happen with younger players looking forward to him growing completely
- 32:45agree with you. And I think one thing that you guys didn't didn't talk
- 32:51about. I think he needs to work on his physicality. I think he's
- 32:55a bit it's it's hard for him to accept rate with the ball. He
- 33:00needs to be better accelerating with the ball. When he gets the ball,
- 33:05he needs to go faster, but also he needs to make sure when he
- 33:08loses the ball to do that extra effort to go and you know, you
- 33:14know, will win that ball back in a certain way, and also making
- 33:19sure to play a bit faster. I felt that at times the play was
- 33:24a bit too fast for him. MLS was a bit too fast for him.
- 33:29But you know, his technical abilities are there, and as you said,
- 33:32if his vision is really really interesting, he's very creative. That's really
- 33:37nice. But he needs to make sure that he works on his physicality during
- 33:43the off season and comes to the training cap in January really prepared faster.
- 33:49Maybe work on his legs a bit more because he needs he needs to have,
- 33:52you know, quicker acceleration. That's going to be very interesting. Migrde.
- 33:57I would agree with Elias with the far out of ten, but I
- 34:02do see potential. I do see potential, and I can't wait to see
- 34:06him next year, to see him grow. As State says, so fire
- 34:08out of ten. That's the grade of uh T B I R for Bryce
- 34:14Duke. Mark your calendars. This is the day that Eve was the nicest
- 34:19of the three of us. Yeah, exactly, thanks man, Elias,
- 34:22thanks for the for the moving on. I ham had Handy, I have
- 34:28had Handy this year. Got five hundred minutes, Yes he did. He
- 34:32did get five. He had those like two or three starts. I remember
- 34:37that probably did a yeah exactly, probably right. So Elias your turn.
- 34:42What do you think about Ahman Handy? I mean I feel bad for him
- 34:46because the second he got into good form, he con sided that penalty in
- 34:51the Canadian Champion Final against Vancouver, and then he was not seen from again
- 34:54until like Atlanta. I think, wow, so wow, it was it
- 35:01was a while, which is why a lot of people are, including myself,
- 35:04are probably surprised he played five hundred minutes, but he did five and
- 35:07seventy three all competitions included. So just just just yeah, look, I
- 35:14think that you know, there's some good stuff, but the problem is there's
- 35:17just not enough good stuff to make him stand out. I think he's the
- 35:22problem is that we've seen it from a lot of players, and most notably
- 35:24like you know what you'd sing and Bryce do when he first got here.
- 35:29Is this lack of complacency when it comes to just like treading water, right,
- 35:36and I'm at Humdi is perfectly fine treading water. He doesn't make too
- 35:38many mistakes, but he just doesn't stand out. And when you have a
- 35:40ten, especially in MLS, you can have a ten that just is there.
- 35:45You know, he's more, he's more facil there. But yeah,
- 35:52he's played as a ten though, right, you're right, all right,
- 35:54So regardless of what he is, what he was played as, he was
- 35:58played as a ten, and and he wasn't bad. He just wasn't good.
- 36:02He was just there, right, And yes, rel's the mistake free,
- 36:06which is why you're not going to give him a zero. But when
- 36:09you're invisible, you're invisible, and as a tenant, as an attacking player,
- 36:13especially if you don't have too many purely attacking players, if you're not
- 36:15standing out, then you're not doing a job. I'm giving him three and
- 36:19a half. And it's purely on lack of time, right, because when
- 36:24he did play, we saw some good things. But the thing is often,
- 36:28man, who are you? Man? Where's the lias? Like,
- 36:30usually he's the generous one that's going on, Well, I'm gonna I'm getting
- 36:36a generous letter. I know I know who, I know he's coming up.
- 36:39So you're the guy that gave Liza a six. Right, So we're
- 36:45not going to get into this. We're not going to get into this because
- 36:49we'll be here all night. Yeah, but it's a three and a half
- 36:52purely because, like you said, five hundred and seventy three minutes, right,
- 36:55if we had had a thousand minutes of Medhamdi, it'd probably be higher.
- 37:00But the things we saw only that many minutes, and he was,
- 37:04you know, just there for so many of them that, you know,
- 37:08interesting, interesting. I'm just gonna say just a few words on Ahmed Handy.
- 37:14I think we didn't really see the Unfortunately we didn't have we'd have a
- 37:21chance to see the real Amad Handy. In my opinion, I feel that
- 37:25yes, he got his chance, but every time that he had a good
- 37:30game, either with Nancy or with Losada, unfortunately he wasn't back on the
- 37:36pitch for two, three, four or five games. Every time again he
- 37:39had a chance, he did well. The game after he didn't, he
- 37:44wasn't really good. Then the third game he was off and he didn't have
- 37:47those consistent minutes in order to prove himself. And also, you know,
- 37:52I don't think he was fit most of the time, which is really not
- 37:57good. I think Ahmad Handy needs to be meaner. I feel that he's
- 38:00just too nice. And unfortunately, when you play in midfield as a midfielder,
- 38:05as a number ten, nice doesn't cut it. Unfortunately, like you
- 38:08need to make sure that you know you take your place, that you need
- 38:14to to push players, you need to be able to make your place there.
- 38:17And I don't think he had it in him to be to be a
- 38:22bit meaner in MLS, and I think that's why he never really was able
- 38:27to to up his game in a certain way. My grade would be a
- 38:30four out of ten. Again, too many minutes. But again I think
- 38:37that if he finds another club, he's out of contract right now, so
- 38:40if he finds another club within MLS, maybe he can be a good a
- 38:45good player. But I don't think he's a bad player either, So four
- 38:52out of ten for me. Eve. Yeah, by and large, I
- 38:55do agree with the points supposed to be made. You know, being played
- 38:59out of his probably true position didn't necessarily do him any favors. But that
- 39:04being said, when he was given an opportunity, you know, he he
- 39:08played it rather safe and he kind of just blended in with the scenery,
- 39:10which agree is not going to be a difference maker player and Montreal needs to
- 39:15get the most out of its players. He is one of the higher higher
- 39:19paid players on the squad at the end of the day. So yeah,
- 39:25as state said, he was paid a dollar a minute, more than a
- 39:31dollar a minute. He made more than five hundred and seventy three dollars this
- 39:35season. I would sincerely hope, yeah, thousand dollars minutes. Yeah,
- 39:40he said a dollar, but I think he meant a thousand dollars. Yeah,
- 39:43I agree with you. Yeah, I need to sign up. I
- 39:46clearly need to sign up. I've joined the wrong the wrong professional Yeah.
- 39:53Anyway, Yeah, and you know, I think ever since really he joined
- 39:58Montreal, unfortunately only you know, fitness and injuries have kind of been a
- 40:01little bit of a concern for him, and you know, part of that
- 40:07probably has contributed to his ability to find consistency or lack thereof. But you
- 40:15know, you're judge on your performances. You have to show up when you're
- 40:19called upon. If you don't get called upon, you know, you may
- 40:22not get three or four or five matches in a row to kind of build
- 40:27yourself up. If you will right, you have to take the moment that
- 40:30you're given, and unfortunately he didn't do that. So for me, it's
- 40:34going to be a four out of ten. Okay, so far out of
- 40:37time. Now we're agreeing too much, I think. Sorry, So four
- 40:42out of ten for Ahamed Handi for sure moving on will be chain' on.
- 40:47So for we're going to do do wese a big field that we're just going
- 40:52to do that randomly. We'll give them in the list that they appear in
- 40:55our images here, so it's going to be surprised for everyone exactly. So
- 41:00you're not so for I'll start, oh god, this is the one I've
- 41:07been jutting the most. To go for it, I would go with a
- 41:10four hour of ten. The reason behind it is that, yes, you
- 41:15know, the main job of a striker is to put the ball in the
- 41:19back of the net, which he doesn't do enough of course, and he's
- 41:22not very very good at it. But the other things that he does are
- 41:29kind of interesting and he needs to build on that. He needs to build
- 41:31on that physicality, the heading abilities that he has, but also he needs
- 41:37to build on his movement off the ball. If he's able to learn a
- 41:42thing or two about movement off the ball, like without the ball. I
- 41:47think he can be some very interesting striker because at the end of the day,
- 41:53if you want to put the ball in the back of the net,
- 41:55you need to make sure to be in the right positions at the right times,
- 41:59which is not most of the time. Now I'm asking myself the question,
- 42:05maybe the Sada ball was not really the kind of play that he's used
- 42:12to and very you know, he didn't really understand the way Thosada wanted him
- 42:17to move. That's a possibility too, But I don't think that it's a
- 42:22player that doesn't have a future as a striker in Montreal or elsewhere. I
- 42:29think he has some very interesting abilities. He just needs to hone them in
- 42:32a certain way and he needs to learn a thinka two about positioning and of
- 42:38the ball work where he has a lot of work to do, a lot
- 42:44of work to do. And four out of ten disappointed. I was hoping
- 42:51for better for him, But I'm interested in seeing him last next season to
- 42:55see if he can grow, if he can learn a thinga too. But
- 43:00I'm a bit skeptical, to be honest, so but I'll give him the
- 43:05benefit of the doubt for next season. Ef Okay, I'm trying to follow
- 43:14you up without like eviscerating someone. Everybody's saying yeah and ga, yeah,
- 43:22and that's gonna be The number that I work with is three, and that
- 43:25is the number that I'm going to give to the and so for so once
- 43:30again, there is a part of me that feels a bit bad because he
- 43:34was thrust into that starting striker position early in the season with romel Kyoto's injury
- 43:39and other departures from the team, and it's abundantly clear that he's not ready.
- 43:45I'm not I'm not convinced he'll ever be ready for that role in MLS.
- 43:51To me, the foundational elements, you know, ball to feet are
- 43:55just so far behind that I don't see it. Like if another club is
- 44:02willing to sign the player, like even on a free whatever, you know,
- 44:09let him go. Quite frankly, is my opinion. I'm not necessarily
- 44:15invested in watching him try to develop further next season. The number of chances
- 44:22that he missed his just general awareness, it just it got more and more
- 44:29frustrating. Like I feel, early on in the season, we were trying
- 44:30to be really gentle, we were trying to be a bit kind We were
- 44:32kind of clutching at straws a little bit and being like, oh, but
- 44:37the hold up play and you know, oh, like back to goal and
- 44:39so on and so forth. But like you said, pretty tragic. Yeah,
- 44:47And to me, that's just so basic, so fundamental, especially with
- 44:52the growth of MLS, Like you can maybe get away with the first touch
- 44:55like that seven years ago, but unfortunately not this, not in this day
- 45:02and age. So for me, it's a three out of ten. And
- 45:06I expect he will be in Montreal next year because he is under contract.
- 45:09But if anybody wants to sign him, then I would hope that Olivia Renard
- 45:14would listen to their offer. Lie. Yeah, I have to disagree with
- 45:22Hattie and I kind of agree with Eve. Wow, thank you. I
- 45:27think I think that arguably not in terms of score, but in terms of
- 45:34in terms of just reasoning. I think that I believe his off ball play
- 45:38was the best part about him. I think that he often found himself in
- 45:43good spots. The problem was the finishing. And with regards to you know,
- 45:46his hold up play, protecting the ball is ten percent of the job,
- 45:51right, could you have an issue you could protect the ball but now
- 45:54what do you do with it? And more often than not the ball would
- 45:58go backwards, so you acomplished nothing by holding up playing as a target man.
- 46:04He was always in the right spot. The problems was, you know,
- 46:07finishing consistently. Even when he would get you know, but he wasn't
- 46:10close enough to the goal and he had to lay it off to someone else
- 46:14or control the ball. So you know, he got a brace against Toronto.
- 46:17I think that's that's a puto, right, But how many chances did
- 46:20he have? Right? Yeah, at least a half dozen. So it
- 46:22also comes down to conversion rate and if you're going to be a team like
- 46:27Rosada was last year, where the chances are few and far apart, if
- 46:30you don't finish, you're going to get destroyed. So I think that I'm
- 46:34going to settle on a four because I do think, you know, if
- 46:37I give I'm at Hamdia three and a half, I'm going to give us
- 46:39all four to four. That's the way I'm go about it. I think
- 46:45that I think that ultimately, you know, it's it couldn't be any higher
- 46:50than that. I don't think he'll be at the club next year. I
- 46:52think that, you know, if he is at the club, it'll be
- 46:55you know, somewhat limited roles, especially if they are trying to play possession,
- 46:59because if you have someone coming up like John let's see, and you
- 47:01have some like students to hear him, who was getting along so well with
- 47:06Mahalo Poku, then there may just not be in a from him other than
- 47:08as a substitute, you know, looking for at or, which I believe
- 47:13was his best role. Anyway, I didn't think he was anywhere near as
- 47:15go to start as he was off the bench, off the bench, he
- 47:17was, you know, forced to be right, I would be I would
- 47:22be curious like if if his role had been limited to a sub role,
- 47:24I would be really curious as to what our assessment would have been. It
- 47:28would be much. And that's why I say, like it's a little bit
- 47:30unfair, a little bit in interesting. I don't disagree with you, guys.
- 47:36Honestly, I think he had a bigger role than what we thought he
- 47:38would at the winning of the season. So there's a small job here from
- 47:45Chan to myself. So I'm just gonna say it. Oh for equals betrol
- 47:51Blue when he was at M I agree with you Jan, if you guys
- 47:53have netrole is a national hero, yea, we have now. But he
- 48:00was really bad national he really bad. That's what I am. I don't
- 48:07care. I don't care how I don't care how bad he was national hero
- 48:10China. I have now he is, he is a hero. He is
- 48:15a natural hero for Greece of course, Yeah, you just made the alliance
- 48:20really really mad now so sad. He has Greek origins, so so be
- 48:25careful, be careful and answer trans question though, because he did ask a
- 48:30question how much? So it was three hundred and twenty five thousand dollars of
- 48:36gam and then an additional two hundred and seventy five thousand was based on performance
- 48:40based metrics. I would be kind of surprised if he met those performance based
- 48:47metrics as well. But just as on a side, Chicago I think paid
- 48:53for salary in twenty twenty two, which is kind of a movizone three anyway,
- 49:00so you know, not much. He didn't pay a lot for Chin
- 49:02and so for if we if we do the math together, so yeah,
- 49:07so the final grade for Chin and so forth is a four out of ten.
- 49:13Moving on with the next girl, and that's Elias Tern and it's Samuel
- 49:19Pierre, the team captain. It's very it's it's no look at the end
- 49:29of the day, at the end of the day, this is what he's
- 49:31been a constant in this team forever. And I think that you know,
- 49:37short of short of he was the team's best midfielder, just in terms of
- 49:45consistency, in terms of you know, grinta, in terms of being there
- 49:52as a leader too, as a cap and just as a leader. Right
- 49:53at the end of the day, it doesn't matter what kind of termoil there
- 49:57is, you can always, you know, you can always look at Pier
- 50:00as the quintessential leader both on and off the field. So he always leaves
- 50:05by example. He always you know, gets gets everybody ready. And you
- 50:10know, there's not much to say about Simon pit that we haven't said over
- 50:14the course of the season. I am disappointed in the fact that, you
- 50:16know, Losada ball did limit his usage. We saw that Underwood Fred and
- 50:22I'll see he had much more freedom going forward and he was able to showcase
- 50:27a very impressive long ball ability and kind of very strong crosses. So I
- 50:31think that you know, him being relegated to a ball winner wasn't as great,
- 50:37but his talent is still there, and his talent is not deniable.
- 50:40I am I'm giving him a seven and yeah shy of Mattressrno, he was
- 50:45the best midfielder of the season by far. For me, interesting, I'll
- 50:50just s you're great seven seven out of ten. I'll give my grades six
- 50:54out of ten. Okay, sorry I didn't hear it. I'll give my
- 50:59grades six out of ten. The reason behind it is very simple. Samuel
- 51:06Piet is you know exactly what you're going to get from Semilps. Don't expect
- 51:10him to dribble or to do whatever like. It's very simple what he does.
- 51:15He recuperates the ball, he just he wins the ball, he gives
- 51:19a small pass, he does a nice you know, he does switch to
- 51:22play very well from time to time too. And this is what you get
- 51:27from Samuel pet and he did just that. I think when you see a
- 51:32very good samuelpet is when the team is very very good, which is what's
- 51:37not the case this year. So for me, six out of ten because
- 51:40he did exactly what was asked from him. Unfortunately, he got injured,
- 51:45which doesn't really help his performance. But six out of ten for me,
- 51:49EF, I'll also go for six out of ten as well. Unfortunately,
- 51:54I think injury did also hamper him a bit this season definitely didn't help.
- 52:00And yeah, Losada's style of play was I don't think it showcased too many
- 52:06players' best abilities at the end of the day, But I will give him
- 52:09credit for speaking out and saying that he didn't feel that the team was adequately
- 52:15prepared, because that is what you need a captain to do at the end
- 52:17of the day sometimes is to rattle at cage and to come out publicly and
- 52:22use your time with the press judiciously, which I think he did so I
- 52:27believe he does to deserve credit for that. But yeah, at the end
- 52:30of the day, I think we kind of saw a step back with sam
- 52:32Piet and he kind of got relegated to say the classics Sam Piet that we
- 52:37had known kind of from today twenty seventeen to twenty twenty interesting. So six
- 52:44out of ten for Samuel and Kitt I think he where we are going to
- 52:50see him for a few years here in Montreal, which is going to be
- 52:52always very euchl. I would hope more than a few myself, exactly.
- 52:58So moving on, if your turn Ramel Kyoto. That's what you know.
- 53:04You can go full Eve. You can go full Eve when you talk about
- 53:08all right, So, I mean his season obviously, we've come to expect
- 53:14injuries from Ramel Kyoto. It's what we've known every single year that he's played
- 53:17in Montreal, with the exception of twenty twenty two, really right, and
- 53:22this year was no exception. I mean he was called out by Bernard for
- 53:27kind of just disappearing when he got injured, essentially, although he was very
- 53:30active on social media, so we did all know where he was. I'm
- 53:35going to give him a four out of ten. You know that contributes a
- 53:38bit to professionalism. You know, he was extremely impactful in that one match
- 53:45versus Philadelphia. Otherwise, yeah, I'm not sure. Actually, you know
- 53:49what, I'm gonna go for a three. He missed the majority of the
- 53:54season because he was injured, and I think after the whole whatever the phrase
- 54:00Bernard used was like his tour of the world or whatever. I think at
- 54:06the end of the day, there was always going to be a question about
- 54:07his mentality and if his mind was really in Montreal. And again, I
- 54:15think we're not our Losada's football didn't necessarily seek to take anybody's best out of
- 54:23them, but I don't know, it just didn't feel like it was there
- 54:29this year with ramel Kyoto. So I'm gonna land in the middle actually,
- 54:32as you enjoy my stream of consciousness grading here, and I'm going to go
- 54:37for a three point five out of ten because he was absent so very very
- 54:40much this season. When he returned after injury, we didn't see the whole
- 54:43heck of a lot of them Lias. Yeah, I'm going to give him
- 54:47a four for the same reason. Right when he was healthy, all the
- 54:51players were talking about how especially the forward, we're talking about how great of
- 54:53a of a leader for the fowards he was and this big brother and this
- 54:58mentor role, and he kind of brought the best out of a lot of
- 55:00them. He kind of he pushed them forward and it was very good.
- 55:04And the fact that, look, you heal the way you have to heal
- 55:07at the end of the day, right your your body is your most important
- 55:09asset as an athlete, and you have to heal it the way that you
- 55:14feel best. But at the same time, you're absent for more over three
- 55:20months, you're you're you will be you know it'll be noticed. Right,
- 55:24we talked about in other episodes, this is a very young forward core without
- 55:30him. Mason Toy is the oldest one at like twenty twenty five I think,
- 55:34right, twenty fourteen, yeah, right, And he's the oldest one.
- 55:38And even he doesn't have a lot of less experience, he has the
- 55:42Moslim less experience as forwards, and you know, so they had to do
- 55:45a lot of growing on their own and that and that showed there was a
- 55:46lot of moments where there's lack of experience and someone we'real Kyoto, even if
- 55:52he was just on the bench, you know, or in the adrestroom at
- 55:54halftime, could have helped them a lot. So I think that because of
- 55:58that, you know, your best quality is availability, and he wasn't available.
- 56:02So four interesting, I'm gonna be a lot harsher. For me,
- 56:10it's a two out of ten. And for me, the professional the unprofessionalism
- 56:17of Roma Kyoto for me is a big no no. You are loved by
- 56:24the fans, You are loved by the club. The club has done a
- 56:30lot of things for you. The fans loved you, loved you and you
- 56:35know, really followed you everywhere, and you know, and the way he
- 56:45behaved during the year is unacceptable for me. And you look at his stats
- 56:51and you know what, I'm just going to give you a few stats.
- 56:52In twenty and twenty, his first year with US, he played won sorry,
- 57:00twenty five games all competitions included. He was able to score ten goals.
- 57:08In twenty twenty one, he played twenty three games twenty four games.
- 57:15Sorry, he was able to score three goals too. In twenty twenty two,
- 57:22he played thirty some games. He was able to score fifteen goals.
- 57:27This year he played fourteen games. He was only able to score three goals
- 57:31with one assist, which is for me unacceptable. At the end of the
- 57:37year, when he came back from injury, we were expecting romel Kyoto to
- 57:40be that to have that finishing touch to push us, you know, to
- 57:46push us, to push us over the redline for a playoff spot. He
- 57:51was supposed to be that player. Unfortunately, he wasn't there. He wasn't
- 57:55good, he wasn't fit, he wasn't anything. He was anonymous most of
- 58:00the time on the pitch and off the pitch. So for me, it's
- 58:05unacceptable. You are the main striker and you haven't been and you haven't behaved
- 58:12like a main striker. You haven't behaved as a good player either. We
- 58:15haven't seen anything from him in the past nine games when he was back,
- 58:21or six to seven whatever games that he was back. And for me,
- 58:24this is unacceptable because I understand that you're injured, but when you're back,
- 58:29I want you to give one hundred and ten percent and I want you to
- 58:31be to have a clinical touch in front of goal, which he didn't.
- 58:37So two out of ten for me, I was very very disappointed by Ramel
- 58:43Kyota this year. So that's my grade. So we have a two four
- 58:47out of ten from Elias and even with a three point five, so I
- 58:52think we're safe to go with a three out of ten. Yeah for romel
- 58:55Kyoto, which should be the average. Moving on with the next player,
- 59:02and that's your turn, my friend, Elias with Sean Reya, go at
- 59:08it. This is yeah exactly. This is a very similar, very similar
- 59:16reaction to Bryce Duke's right, where when they're confident and he's feeling good.
- 59:22You know, we saw a lot of moments, especially the in the year
- 59:24when everyone was injured, that he really did step up and he played in
- 59:30a much more mature way than we had expected, especially in the Canadian Championship.
- 59:34But you know, uh, we'll we ever find out what happened between
- 59:38him and Alisada. I doubt it. Let's just hope that this next coach
- 59:44does have a bit more room for him, because we know how good Chenre
- 59:46is. Everybody knows how god Chanre is. He's shown it right, and
- 59:50not just at a CPL level, but you know, he's shown that his
- 59:53ceiling is so much higher, and he's done it at the MLS level as
- 59:58well in glances. So I'm gonna go with I'm gonna go with a four,
- 1:00:02and that's purely because we just didn't see enough genre and you know,
- 1:00:08there were some moments where I found that he he just like I'm at Himdy
- 1:00:13kind of slid back into the shadows a little bit and didn't really maybe assert
- 1:00:19himself enough. But for the most part, I think that you know,
- 1:00:22with a project, with a homegrown project like this and the club that you're
- 1:00:27in kind of club that you're trying to be, he needs more minutes.
- 1:00:30So I think that it's a four purely on lack of minutes. Interesting I'll
- 1:00:36go next, by the way, he got nine hundred and seventeen minutes all
- 1:00:39competitions included. So how many that was in the first half of the season,
- 1:00:43though, it's I just gonna say how many ca th July exactly,
- 1:00:49you know what, I'm gonna be a bit more generous. I would give
- 1:00:52him a five out of ten for Chenrea. The reason behind it is that
- 1:00:57unfortunately he didn't click. But are not a sad after whatever that fire that
- 1:01:02famous game when he was subbed off, and he wasn't really pleased to be
- 1:01:06subed off. But his play on the pitch was very interesting for first year
- 1:01:13rookie. I think it was very interesting. He's only twenty one. I
- 1:01:16think he has a lot of potential. I think he's fast, He's faster
- 1:01:21than Juke. He has good vision, he has a good shot on goal.
- 1:01:24The thing is, he just needs minutes. He needs confidence, he
- 1:01:28needs his coach to have confidence in him, and of course he needs a
- 1:01:34bit more experience under his belt. So of course at times he was a
- 1:01:38bit lost on the pitch, and that's something that he needs to learn.
- 1:01:44He needs to grow from and learn from it in a certain way. I'm
- 1:01:51very confident in the future of Seanre. I feel that he can be a
- 1:01:55complete player very very quickly in MLS starting twenty twenty four if he has the
- 1:02:01backing of his coach. So I would give him a five out of ten,
- 1:02:07and I'll end in the middle just for fun, I'll go four and
- 1:02:09a half out of ten. You know, it is his first pro season,
- 1:02:15and so obviously there was going to be a little bit of growing pain
- 1:02:21for this player. You know, although I think it was really really ridiculous
- 1:02:27that we didn't see him at all after the first week of July, you
- 1:02:35know, part of it is as well that you do need to manage your
- 1:02:38emotions to a degree, and you do need to to comport yourself with a
- 1:02:43certain degree ofism. And so although I definitely think that the response was very
- 1:02:50heavy handed and not warranted, I also hope that that was a valuable learning
- 1:02:54experience for him as a player. Obviously, you know, he's coming from
- 1:03:00loans and CPL and from the academy, so he is of course adapting to
- 1:03:05MLS. And like you said, Hattie, I do see a lot of
- 1:03:07potential. I do see a lot of a lot of growth ahead of this
- 1:03:12player. So I'm going to roll with a four and a half out of
- 1:03:14ten. Unfortunately, like maybe I could give a better grade, like or
- 1:03:17better. I would feel more confident in my assessment if we had seen him
- 1:03:21in the last three months. Yeah, but we didn't, Okay, so
- 1:03:24we don't have a four and a half thing. So by the way,
- 1:03:30it's it's so much worse than just like you know, first week of July.
- 1:03:34So froming from early June, the last twenty one games in all competitions
- 1:03:39at seef went, I had guess how many minutes you played twenty one games?
- 1:03:44Get so many minutes played? He plays seventy one p one hundred and
- 1:03:51I look it up. I had already looked at up beforehand. Seventy one
- 1:03:58minutes he started against NYCF see, yeah, and that's that was it he
- 1:04:03played. He played on the fourth of June, twenty six minutes, yes,
- 1:04:08and then yeah once early yeah, July second, exactly seventy one minutes
- 1:04:15in the last twenty one year. But you know what again, as Eve
- 1:04:17said, I think it was very harsh from Losada. You know, it's
- 1:04:20a young player, you know, Yeah, I think I think that's that's
- 1:04:27not the way you teach young players. Okay, you put him on the
- 1:04:31bench for or out of the squad for four or five games, okay,
- 1:04:35but then it's an interesting player. You play him, you need results and
- 1:04:42yeah, no, I don't know. So for four point five out of
- 1:04:45ten for Sean Reya. Moving on with the next player, and that's going
- 1:04:50to be me that's going to start, and it's Nathan Saliba. I think
- 1:04:56he's one of the good stories of the Losada era. I think he's someone
- 1:05:01that honestly, I was very skeptical of what he was able to do at
- 1:05:06the beginning of the season and how he would improve, but he proved me
- 1:05:11wrong. This player has gone so much in the season. Of course,
- 1:05:15he has a lot to learn still, he's not a finished product yet,
- 1:05:18but I think he's very very interesting. He could grow into a very dominant
- 1:05:25MLS player, in my opinion, as an eight or a six and a
- 1:05:28half in a certain way. I love his play, I love his vision.
- 1:05:33I love his ability on the ball, which is very interesting. He
- 1:05:41needs to maybe try to shoot the ball a bit more. He needs to
- 1:05:44learn how to shoot the ball. Maybe we haven't seen him shoot the ball
- 1:05:48enough. That's something that he needs to add to his game. Physicality.
- 1:05:54He's got a lot better you know, during the season, which is really
- 1:05:58interesting. I think we have a gem of a player for the next few
- 1:06:02years. I think he can develop into a very dominant player. I would
- 1:06:06give him a six out of ten because I was very, very surprised of
- 1:06:11his groove throughout the year. Lies. Yeah, I agree with everything,
- 1:06:17including the grade. I think that, you know, it was a It
- 1:06:21was a perfect example of how to manage a player that's going through a rough
- 1:06:26spell. Right, he was kind of thrust in the starting role at the
- 1:06:28start of the season, clearly wasn't ready, took some time off, came
- 1:06:31back, won his confidence, and has it looked back since. Right.
- 1:06:34And on top of that, I think he's kind of made himself the front
- 1:06:39runner for this you know, this air to similar Pietz role. You know,
- 1:06:42we saw a lot of really good things, especially in the balling department,
- 1:06:45and then you know, going forward, that goal against Columbus on decision
- 1:06:49Day is the perfect example. You know, you press high, you win
- 1:06:53the ball. He plays a perfect through ball into space into Brogiard that creates
- 1:06:57the first goal. So I think that that you know, ten second clip
- 1:07:01is a perfect microcosm of what we saw from Natas Saliba and what we could
- 1:07:08hope to see developed. So just a very well rounded you know. And
- 1:07:11if him and Metter Shornia can both get going and they can and he can
- 1:07:15kind of follow this progression that had, then you could be looking at,
- 1:07:18you know, two of the best homegrown eights in the league potentially, and
- 1:07:24so yeah, the sky's a limit and hopefully sticks around. Yeah, I
- 1:07:30will also land on a six. I don't think I really have anything to
- 1:07:35add you on what you guys said. You know, I kind of wish
- 1:07:39we could go back to like our third or fourth episode of the season and
- 1:07:43be like, oh wow, we've eaten our words. So I think you
- 1:07:48guys overall covered it, and I'll agree with your grade of a six out
- 1:07:50of ten. Goot. Moving on the next player, and that's yours,
- 1:07:57Eve, and it's Ariel Lasster of contract. Yes, I would not be
- 1:08:03against seeing him back in Montreal again next year. I think he offers a
- 1:08:08degree of versatility and his work rate is very, very very excellent. You
- 1:08:15know. He for me, he was kind of like the unsung hero in
- 1:08:18the Kamal Miller, Brice Duke and gam And Lassiter trade I think I almost
- 1:08:27felt like he was thrown in as like an afterthought of sorts, and he
- 1:08:30actually wound up being very useful for Montreal this season. You know, I
- 1:08:34think it left wing back is not necessarily his dream position, but he has
- 1:08:39been extremely serviceable in that position, and he has answered the call when he's
- 1:08:44been called upon. And truly, what more can you ask in that regard?
- 1:08:49Yeah? For me, he's hard working, he has the m loss
- 1:08:53experience. He knows what you're getting into in this league, and in a
- 1:09:00league like MLS, especially with all the myriad competitions that are thrown in season
- 1:09:04after season, you need players who can be versatile and who can spot in
- 1:09:09at multiple positions. What more can you ask? I am there for Ariel
- 1:09:12last year. I'm going to give him a six out of ten. And
- 1:09:15holy Gail is also a team laster. Okay, I would say exactly the
- 1:09:23same thing as you said. I really liked the player. He was unsunggree.
- 1:09:27He will completely agree. He can play in multiple positions, which is
- 1:09:30really interesting. Also for a coach. I would bring him back, of
- 1:09:35course, but with of course, a contract of one hundred and fifty thousand
- 1:09:40or something like that. And not too expensive. For sure. I would
- 1:09:44bring him back no problem at all. The only thing that I disagree on
- 1:09:47is the grade. I would give him a fly five out of ten because
- 1:09:53I don't think he's a starter. I don't think he's a starter, but
- 1:09:56he's a very good backup. Yeah, be a rotation. I think I'm
- 1:10:00allowing his persatility to kind of like, Yeah, I'm just like, because
- 1:10:03you can be so many places. Yeah, I don't. I'm not against
- 1:10:08your grade, Elias. One more to say, you know exactly, nail
- 1:10:15on the head, you know, six on ten and bring it back,
- 1:10:19keep it up. You know, he's absolutely was the bright side of the
- 1:10:23trade. Love it six out of ten for our lassiter. So the generous
- 1:10:29people, Eve and Elias, which is very weird. Eve is in the
- 1:10:32generous people won this game for this player. Moving on, our good friend
- 1:10:41that Sunousi Ebrahim, Elias tell us more about the performances of Sanusi the roller
- 1:10:50Coaster season. He turns into you know, R nine whenever the Canadian Championship
- 1:10:57logos flashed, and then the rest of the season is kind of a coin
- 1:11:01toss. So it's it's very, very very weird, you know. Patrick
- 1:11:05made a very good point. He had a good finish of the season.
- 1:11:09He did. He developed a really strong partnership with Mahala Opoku and he seems
- 1:11:13to be getting along well with Withchnaldbusse. And you know, if the three
- 1:11:16of them can kind of get going as a front three, then it would
- 1:11:19look great and it would give a lot of a lot of different ways that
- 1:11:24this attack can look next season. So he's still extremely young. People forget
- 1:11:30that, and I think that he doesn't get enough credit for, you know,
- 1:11:34putting his head down. Yeah, but he doesn't get enough credit putting
- 1:11:38his head down and working. Look he's been with the club. That what
- 1:11:42his third season with the club, And look, if he keeps on getting
- 1:11:47the minutes, it keeps on getting the chances, and he keeps and he
- 1:11:49gets into that you know, plays to his strong suits. I think he's
- 1:11:55going to be in for for a very very impressive season. I'm going to
- 1:11:58give him a five and a half this year year just because he did not
- 1:12:01have enough consistent minutes to make it stick. But you know, the minutes
- 1:12:04that we did, we saw a lot of good. We saw we saw
- 1:12:06some nuts good. But even if it's just for Canadian Championship and it helps
- 1:12:11you win a trophy. You know what, I completely agree with everything that
- 1:12:15you said. The only thing is that what you said extremely young, twenty
- 1:12:19one is the same age, extremely young, So that's that's the only thing.
- 1:12:24It's he's young. He's young, and I think I would still bring
- 1:12:29him back five and a half. Completely agree with you. I just need
- 1:12:32to see him get more stats next year, more goals or assists. I
- 1:12:38need him to be more decisive, that's the only thing. But yeah,
- 1:12:41I'll bring him back, no questions, asked EF. Yeah, I mean
- 1:12:45we've seen him kind of like Elia said, like against CPL teams or so
- 1:12:50many pro teams, he can be so dominant and so clinical and so effective.
- 1:12:57He needs to really level up his game. No, I am to
- 1:13:00be consistent in MLAs, although there are lots of players I think in many
- 1:13:05leagues around the world who have just been tournament players and like that's kind of
- 1:13:10when they show up and they just have like that weird magic in them.
- 1:13:15But yeah, no, I'll roll with your grade and I'll say I would
- 1:13:18be I would be interested to see another season of Sunusi with some more maturity,
- 1:13:23with maybe a little bit more of a level head on his shoulders.
- 1:13:28Yeah. Interesting, So it's we said five and a half, right,
- 1:13:34yeah? Five? Next next year, we're gonna have to make decimals for
- 1:13:40sure. Moving on Mahala, OK, I'll start with Mahala. Honestly,
- 1:13:49he's my player of the year this year in a way. Of course,
- 1:13:57you didn't play the whole year with us, but I was very very surprised
- 1:14:00of the impact that he had on the game, on the team altogether.
- 1:14:05I love his personality, very posite, positive. I love his play.
- 1:14:09He's able to run with the ball but also score goals. That he's a
- 1:14:15complete player, and I really loved what he showed. I think he still
- 1:14:20needs to work on his shooting abilities, but doesn't shoot a lot from outside
- 1:14:28the box or you know, he's more of a poacher. But I think
- 1:14:30he can develop this thing a bit more. I'll give him a six point
- 1:14:36five out of ten because he did change the whole offensive mindset of the team
- 1:14:45when he joined the team in a certain way. And I can't wait to
- 1:14:47see him for a full season with c F Montreal. I'm very excited to
- 1:14:53his potential studying next season. So six point five for me, if go
- 1:15:00with the six and a half, Like you said, I think there's there's
- 1:15:04a lot of really interesting potential in this player, and I think he can
- 1:15:09be a huge standout among the Montreal squad. I think maybe the LAFC he
- 1:15:15might have been like a medium sized fish in a big pond, but I
- 1:15:17think here he can be a big fish in a medium sized pond, and
- 1:15:25so I'm really really hoping that he can lean into that if he does have
- 1:15:28aspirations for his career to go beyond MLS. I also agree with Patrick's take
- 1:15:34that I'm seeing in our comments here that he can be better, not necessarily
- 1:15:40as a central striker, but he's been extremely interesting as a winger or playing
- 1:15:46a little bit more deep lying as a false nine. I one hundred percent
- 1:15:49agree with that, because he does have a lot better dribbling capability and a
- 1:15:55lot better ball to foot technique. So I am there for that as well,
- 1:15:59and I would hope that the new coach of Montreal will kind of seek
- 1:16:03to work to maybe deploy him in a role. And I understand as well.
- 1:16:10Probably you know, it was a little bit of a needs must scenario
- 1:16:13for Montreal ast year because it wasn't working with a four and so on and
- 1:16:15so forth. So yeah, six and a half for me, and I'm
- 1:16:19really, really really interested to see what he can bring next season with a
- 1:16:23full season under as well. I would just add agree with the Dean false
- 1:16:29nine. Don't agree on the winger side. I think we need his finishing
- 1:16:32abilities. He needs to be in the middle. That's for me. He's
- 1:16:39a false nine. That's the best position. That's where I saw the best
- 1:16:43in it as a false nine, not as a winger. I think he's
- 1:16:46going to be too far from goal in my opinion. Lies. I actually
- 1:16:54prefer him as a winner. I agree, I agree, and I don't
- 1:16:57agree. Because we're talking about you know, having those inside forwards. You're
- 1:17:00gonna play with a three back and you have those those overlapping wing backs.
- 1:17:03You could have your inside forwards where you know him Bryce Duke, because you
- 1:17:08know what if he's saying can play in the half spaces and mahala poku if
- 1:17:12he's playing on the right wing, he cuts into the middle anyway, so
- 1:17:14he will get his playtime in the middle. And he just feels he talked
- 1:17:17about it right, and you know he always has a huge spell in his
- 1:17:19face, but he had an extra huge mount in his face the first game
- 1:17:21he played as a first full game as a winger, because he just you
- 1:17:26could tell he just felt at home. So I think you were talking about
- 1:17:29a replacement for Jeorjia Mahalovich and in Bryce Duke, and I think that in
- 1:17:31terms of pure production of both goals and assists, the real the real air
- 1:17:39for Jeorjia Mahalovich, or the real replacement is Mahala Poc if you're looking at
- 1:17:42a pure goals and assistant goal contributions, someone that could take on with the
- 1:17:46dribbles, someone that could link up, play, shoot from distance, finish,
- 1:17:50get into spaces that you know you should no forge should be getting into.
- 1:17:55I think that that's his spot. I'm going to give him a six
- 1:17:58because again not a full season, but absolutely I can't wait to see a
- 1:18:02full year with him and under a manager. Interesting, So six out of
- 1:18:09we said six point five out of ten, so no Decimalso six point five,
- 1:18:14so we'll put six and then we'll put a five right after That's it.
- 1:18:19Moving on, Mason Toy, go ahead. Is it the elive Stern?
- 1:18:27I think it is Eli Stern. So Mason. I have no idea.
- 1:18:30I feel so bad for Mason Toy because it's really just been like a
- 1:18:35war of attrition with this guy. And he's he is, you know,
- 1:18:41he is the supposed to be this year. He was kind of thrust into
- 1:18:44this role as the eldest and most senior, most forward. But fitness and
- 1:18:49form, it just couldn't find it consistently. You know, there was he
- 1:18:54would get hot, and then he would have enough game, and then he
- 1:18:56wouldn't play for a few weeks, then he'd get hot, then he'd have
- 1:18:59a game. Anyway, it was just a very very vicious cycle. And
- 1:19:04it kind of falls back into the similar trend with a lot of forwards.
- 1:19:09I'm gonna give him a five because of the fact that we saw a lot
- 1:19:14of good stuff and we saw a lot of not good stuff. And the
- 1:19:16problem is that when you play so infrequently, you don't always remember the good
- 1:19:23stuff. You remember some of the bad stuff, and you think yourself,
- 1:19:25why hasn't he played in a bit, because you know, he went the
- 1:19:28game and a half and you know they asked him to play the same way.
- 1:19:30You know the four played, but they're very different players, right,
- 1:19:32He's much better with the ball at his feet. He's better taking people on
- 1:19:35with the dribble in open space and forwards back to goal play, so a
- 1:19:41good You know, at least a third of the season was spent with his
- 1:19:45with him being asked to play back to goal, which is not his style
- 1:19:46of play. So I think that I'm gonna give him a five purely victim
- 1:19:50of circumstance and nothing more interesting. Eve I, I'm gonna go with a
- 1:20:00four for my grade. I do feel a little bit mean in making this
- 1:20:03because we did have him on the pod, but that's my choice. It's
- 1:20:10been several seasons that that Mason Toy has been with Montreal, and you know,
- 1:20:15twenty twenty one he did get off to a flying start and then his
- 1:20:16season got ended by injury. And then obviously he came back in twenty twenty
- 1:20:20two after injury and that didn't and you know, he never caught form after
- 1:20:26that, and then twenty twenty three, once again injury, came back,
- 1:20:30had a hot minute, didn't catch form. So unfortunately, the inconsistency has
- 1:20:35become what's consistent with him. You know, it's been under more than one
- 1:20:41coach by this point, so I feel terrible. I really like the guy.
- 1:20:46I really like the player. I really wish things could work out for
- 1:20:50him, but it just hasn't appeared to work out. I think a lot
- 1:20:54of I think he's very cebrebral. I think there is a lot in his
- 1:20:57head that maybe holds him back. But for me, it's going to be
- 1:21:01a four other ten. I agree with you if quick guy, but unfortunately
- 1:21:08on the pitch wasn't enough because of his injuries and even when he was playing,
- 1:21:14I think he wasn't clinical enough, like ninety nine of the forwards that
- 1:21:19we had this year. So yeah, four out of ten for me.
- 1:21:25I hope that I think that his future is not in Montreal, so hopefully
- 1:21:30he'll find a better club for him. So let's wait and see if he
- 1:21:33has some opportunities elsewhere. But four of ten for Mason Toy moving on after
- 1:21:43Mason Toy, who started Mason Toy. So your turn, I think Eve
- 1:21:54with June Antoni Vilsa go ahead. So there's a part of me that's super
- 1:22:00comfortable giving him a grade because he didn't play that that much. But I'm
- 1:22:04really I have been really excited by what I've seen from him in his appearances.
- 1:22:11I do think he has a striker's instinct. I think, you know,
- 1:22:14his times has run so very well. He's obviously very young, very
- 1:22:19inexperience, and on occasion we can see that, you know, when he
- 1:22:25when he does miss a chance, that maybe we would consider to be a
- 1:22:28sitter. And of course we're not out there, we're just sitting on our
- 1:22:30butts. But yeah, no, I'm really excited to see what he can
- 1:22:36do. I think I think he does have the potential to be a gem
- 1:22:41if he is surrounded by other examples of players, and as well, if
- 1:22:47he has a coach who can manage his minutes appropriately and who can really kind
- 1:22:53of help mentor him into becoming the best version of himself. Do I have
- 1:23:01to give a number, Hattie, Oh, you don't have to, because
- 1:23:05he played under five hundred minutes, So thank you. I feel better if
- 1:23:10I stain okay, good, Yeah, I agree with everything that you said.
- 1:23:17I wasn't too. I wasn't on the hype on the train, on
- 1:23:23the Hype train, on the Hype train, the high train of Vilcade.
- 1:23:27First, I think it's interesting. I just need to see him a bit
- 1:23:31more consistent on the pitch, for sure, And I think it's a project.
- 1:23:40So I let's wait and see how he's going to grow for next year.
- 1:23:43But if he continues on growing, he's going to be very interesting with
- 1:23:46the club. So hopefully we'll see that growth beginning up twenty twenty four Live.
- 1:23:55You've you've all said it all. You know, hopefully please think fit.
- 1:24:00You know the rock apt of times where he got some knocks, but
- 1:24:03no, he's still a young player and still has a huge, super high
- 1:24:06ceiling from what we've seen, so bring on the next season. Interesting.
- 1:24:12Interesting, So we're all very excited to see our good friend jel Antony Vinza.
- 1:24:17Last, but not least of course, Victor. I'll start or five
- 1:24:29out of ten, five out of ten. My grade is five out of
- 1:24:32ten. I think I think he was very gutsy to go against his coach
- 1:24:43quite a few times. We all know that that was he did go against
- 1:24:48his coach in the dressing room. We all heard the rumors and the stories.
- 1:24:55He also did that at the end of year. Presser h that's that's
- 1:25:01a double edged sword in a certain way, like if you do that,
- 1:25:06you need to make sure that when another coach comes in, you are the
- 1:25:11best and you are very very good. So for me now, Victor wan
- 1:25:16Yama, I'm going to watch him very very closely because he needs to show
- 1:25:23that it was only the coach that made his performance a bit subpar from what
- 1:25:30we were used to because he wasn't really good on the pitch. So I'll
- 1:25:35give him a five out of ten because he was able to show up and
- 1:25:41to address the issues and be that leader in a dressing room and even after
- 1:25:47after the season, be that leader, be the one that really took the
- 1:25:51charge and went ahead and really said we have a problem. And that's that.
- 1:25:59On the bitch, he wasn't bad, but he wasn't as dominant.
- 1:26:02So can't wait to see more from Victor wan Yama and see if he's going
- 1:26:06to be able to back to back you know, his yeah, his words
- 1:26:14in a certain way with a different coach next year. So five out of
- 1:26:18ten lies, yeah, I mean, Ce, I agree with you five
- 1:26:24out of ten, and I think that if it's any other player, you're
- 1:26:26getting a six. But because we know the standard at which Victorjuanyama can play
- 1:26:30and what we saw on the field, yes, I understand that you don't
- 1:26:33get along with the coach and you don't get along with the tactics of the
- 1:26:36coach more specifically, But you've played with a number of different clubs in a
- 1:26:41number of different styles, and you are still by far the most technically gifted
- 1:26:46player on this team. So he should have had He should have still been
- 1:26:49able to to work his magic in that in that system. Granted, maybe
- 1:26:55not as effective as under Sie, but you had to. I would have
- 1:26:59hoped to see more and hopefully will see more under a new coach that obviously
- 1:27:03has you know, tactics more closer with seas where we saw him play so
- 1:27:09incredibly well, He's still the best player on the team, I think,
- 1:27:12And I'm looking forward now that you know, we can start to move on
- 1:27:17from this, from this very ugly breakup. He can kind of focus on
- 1:27:23football again. He doesn't have to worry about all this nonsense behind the scenes,
- 1:27:28and I'm looking forward to a much higher grade next year. But yeah,
- 1:27:30five, yeah, really complicated, I think to assess Victor Whyama.
- 1:27:36But at the end of the day, I mean, he is one of
- 1:27:39the leaders on this Montreal team and lo and behold, I mean he is
- 1:27:43technically still with Montreal and l a Zada is not so you have to say
- 1:27:48that at the end of the day, he was right to probably go against
- 1:27:55his coach, and yeah, that's that's a pretty ballsy choice. But in
- 1:28:00this case it appears to have paid off. Of course, it does remain
- 1:28:03to be seen whether or not he's actually going to be with Montreal next season,
- 1:28:06because things can certainly change. Yeah, it's hard. Yeah, I'll
- 1:28:15give him a five out of ten as well, just because again I don't
- 1:28:17think we saw enough play from him to properly like grade him only Gale,
- 1:28:26Yeah, you know what he does kind of Yeah, I do feel like
- 1:28:29we do almost have to grade his postseason presser because we've had Victor in Yama
- 1:28:33on the Ball is Round and he was so soft spoken, so gentle,
- 1:28:38so kind, like I mean, you know, his joy at learning about
- 1:28:43Sam's mom, and then like the side of him that we saw on that
- 1:28:47pressor, I did not know he had that in him. Yeah, so
- 1:28:51anyway, I'll go with Yeah, just to mention holy Gail said Victor gets
- 1:28:58seven out of ten based on his end of season's spiel alone. So he
- 1:29:02said five out of ten. Two. Yeah, I'll go for five out
- 1:29:05of ten. I'm trying to lean more towards what's on the pitch. So
- 1:29:09we're all agreeing on a five out of ten. So that's it for our
- 1:29:15players post mortem, like next week, we'll do we'll have a few more
- 1:29:21information in order to to to rate him very well for the twenty twenty three
- 1:29:28season. So that's gonna be next week and that will be the end of
- 1:29:31the post mortem for the twenty twenty three season. Next week. Moving on,
- 1:29:36we do have some national team news with morab Yellow really announcing his squad
- 1:29:44for the CONKA CAV Nations League quarterfinals against Jamaica. So that's gonna be two
- 1:29:50games. For people that don't really know, you're gonna have two games,
- 1:29:55So we're gonna have one that's gonna be there. It is one it's going
- 1:30:00to be on the seventeenth of November and the other one that the second leg
- 1:30:03will be on the twenty first of November. Of course, you can see
- 1:30:05on the screen the other quarterfinals between Costa Rican, Panama, United States enterning
- 1:30:12that in Tobago and Honduras and Mexico. Very big, you know, it's
- 1:30:19it's it's gonna be interesting to see what the team is going to be able
- 1:30:24to do during that that competition. We all know that, you know,
- 1:30:30Workoup didn't go as well as we hoped for Gold Cups go as well as
- 1:30:34we hope for. So now it's a chance to redeem themselves in a certain
- 1:30:40way. Do you see it like that? Guys like themselves to a degree.
- 1:30:46Yeah, I do feel like this is kind of when you have to
- 1:30:49start turning your head towards the next phase, which is obviously twenty twenty six,
- 1:30:54which is where I think the attention needs to be focused. But maybe
- 1:30:59for the players who were part of those adventures that you mentioned, who you
- 1:31:03know, have probably some not so fond memories. Yeah, a chance to
- 1:31:08reading themselves. But also it should emphasis on should because we'll talk about the
- 1:31:13reality in just a sec. It should be the opportunity to start looking for,
- 1:31:17Okay, who are going to be my difference makers in twenty twenty six?
- 1:31:21I agree, But it's also a chance to win silverware. And if
- 1:31:26you want to grow into a very dominant, dominant, a good team within
- 1:31:30the world scene, you need to start winning those those you know, maybe
- 1:31:36not as good trophies and small trophies in a so, I think when you're
- 1:31:41Canada, you have to take what you can get. Take the trophy,
- 1:31:44if they like bust out some sort of like tin Plate Cup, we'll take
- 1:31:48it. Elias, How important is it to to have that winning mentality and
- 1:31:58to start really winning sche thing ahead of in the build up of twenty twenty
- 1:32:03six and the new cycle that is standing in front of Canada soccer right now.
- 1:32:13My problem isn't with twenty twenty six. You've already qualified for twenty twenty
- 1:32:16six. My biggest problem is if you go into the World Cup with only
- 1:32:23a Gold Cup under your belt, not a title, a Gold Cup appearance
- 1:32:28under your belt. When there is the potential of a Copa America, when
- 1:32:32there's a potential of playing against the best teams in the world in a competitive
- 1:32:35setting, that is magic experience you cannot find anywhere else. Yea, Canada
- 1:32:42got it and for three games at the World Cup and every other game they've
- 1:32:47played competitively has been against teams they play multiple times a year. So my
- 1:32:56problem now is not with the World Cup. There's going to be a World
- 1:33:00Cup. There's going to be a dynamite team that that will be available to
- 1:33:03be selected there and hopefully by then the coaches started out. My problem right
- 1:33:09now is I am worried about Cobo America qualification and we're going to talk about
- 1:33:15it more next week after they've played the first leg. But with the way,
- 1:33:19with the form that Jamaica is in, with the quality of players that
- 1:33:23Jamaica has, and with the habit that Jamaica's national team has made of upsetting
- 1:33:28the order of the established order in conker CAF, this is not as dry
- 1:33:34as it should be, and it should be, you know, very much,
- 1:33:39the same vein that we saw with the women's team, where you just
- 1:33:42you go there, you get the job done. You're not gonna win eight
- 1:33:45nothing on aggregate, but you go there and you should see it through.
- 1:33:47And now there's way more doubt than there should be. And I think now
- 1:33:51the big problem is qualifying for Copa America, because missing out of Copal America,
- 1:33:56it's tough to verbalize just how disastrous missing on this tournament is going to
- 1:34:00Oh yeah, y, that's gonna be disastrous, But don't forget that.
- 1:34:02Yes, of course they need to win the quarterfinals. But if they don't,
- 1:34:05there's a plane after between the two between the four losers of the of
- 1:34:14the of the quarterfinals, and two of them can't qualify still for the Copa
- 1:34:17America. I think I agree with you one hundred percent. I think the
- 1:34:21main focus is the Nations League, because if you're focused on the Nations League,
- 1:34:27then obviously you're going to go through the quarterfinals, go to the semifinals,
- 1:34:31so it's hand and hands. Obviously you're qualified for the Cup of America,
- 1:34:35so I think we need to win a trophy. And I think also
- 1:34:41and that's something that's very interesting. We know that Morabiello is an interim head
- 1:34:45coach. If he has any intent on staying the head coach of that team,
- 1:34:53he needs to prove that he can go win those games. And you
- 1:34:58know, we might I want him to be the head coach or not.
- 1:35:01Either way, it is a challenge for him and it is an opportunity to
- 1:35:06prove himself to the Canada Soccer deciders. So that's also a test for him
- 1:35:13and hopefully he'll do better than his son that got sent off during the U
- 1:35:15seventeen World Cup. Now that was not a very fair Joe, absolutely a
- 1:35:23card. It's it's it's it's it's a joke. Of course, you know
- 1:35:26he's youngest, he's he's sixteen. Alexander Beello, but yeah, got sent
- 1:35:30off for people that don't know. Of course, Canada is playing the U
- 1:35:35seventeen World Cup. Lost the first game against Spain only to zero with a
- 1:35:41red card around the twentieth twenty third minute, if I'm not mistaken from Alessandro
- 1:35:45Riello. So it's still a good result knowing that you're playing against s Pain,
- 1:35:49which is like with of course the Barcelona player Mike Mark. I don't
- 1:35:55know how to pronounce his his name, Guyu Mark, Guyu, who scored
- 1:35:59a goal and is really really dominant. So yeah, so a good job
- 1:36:02from Andrew Olivieri and his team in the I think it's Oliviy. Yeah,
- 1:36:09I think that's the coach of the U seventeen Canada a Canadian national team.
- 1:36:15Let's look at the squad that Mari Biello chose for the quarterfinals against Jamaica.
- 1:36:21So as goalkeeper Milan Borian, Maxim Crepo, Dame Sinclair, as defenders samuel
- 1:36:29A de Coupe, direct Cornelius, Alfonso Davis, Luketafugal Alistair Johnston, Richie
- 1:36:34Laria, Kamal Miller, Steve Vittoria, midfielders Ari Ahamed, Stephen Estakio,
- 1:36:40Mark, Anthony k Ismile Cony, Jonathan SiO, Samuel piet Tji and Buchanan
- 1:36:45as an attacker, along with Lucas Cavalini, Jonathan David Junior, Hoilett Cavalaren,
- 1:36:53Liam Miller. Looking at that squad, we have quite a few comments
- 1:36:58from the list there is here. So first of all, we have Patrick
- 1:37:02White that says, wise Kate here should be Schwanier. And we have Roberto
- 1:37:08Tieranardi that says my two concerns with kenn Adian Matt Men's national team, the
- 1:37:13Booran dependency has to end and who will score our goals? So let's talk
- 1:37:19about this squad selection and also at the same time answer the questions of Patrick
- 1:37:25and Robbie Elias. I'll let you start taking a big pause. What more
- 1:37:36do we some passionate feelings while you were away, Hattie about the Booran call
- 1:37:42up so well, not just the Boran call up again, but the fact
- 1:37:47that my biggest beef. And again we are we cover the national team,
- 1:37:53but this is a this is a Montreal based podcast. Was not selected because
- 1:38:00since CF Montreal didn't make the playoffs, he was worried about match readiness.
- 1:38:10What like, what do you mean half the people on this team. Half
- 1:38:15the most players on this team didn't make the playoffs. Yes, Kamal Miller
- 1:38:19is a shoeing, but Jonathan Osorio Toronto have not played a competitive game since
- 1:38:25like July. So I need a better excuse because that is not the great
- 1:38:30excuse. Marobiello. You need to find a more convincing excuse other than I
- 1:38:35forgot to include him or I didn't want to there. There's no valid reason
- 1:38:41as to why Metronal is not in this group. I've said it a million
- 1:38:45times, Melan Borian San Vittoria, people like that, thank you for your
- 1:38:48service, even you know, Junior Horlet's getting up there. Thank you for
- 1:38:51your service. But at some point you have to have than you are to
- 1:38:58establish itself. And these guys, with all due respect, are just holding
- 1:39:03up the line. And yes, in terms of in terms of pure quality,
- 1:39:08they may as they may be, you know, still able to play.
- 1:39:13But if this is a club trying to rebuild after the World Cup and
- 1:39:15get ready for Copa America in a year when realistically I don't know if Neiland
- 1:39:21boy and or Stein Victoria will be there. Junior Holla probably will be,
- 1:39:24but those two who are key Coggs in this team won't be there, and
- 1:39:30why are we not using every single possible opportunity to find out who's going to
- 1:39:35replace them? Because we still don't know. Right between Dance and Claire,
- 1:39:39Tom McGill, Maxim people. Even you know Jehan talks why he keeps up
- 1:39:44this formal insert himself into that conversation. Who's your go to? Who is
- 1:39:47your go to to replace Steven Victoria? Derrik Cornelia has had a couple of
- 1:39:50games where he was okay, but he also some games where he wasn't.
- 1:39:53He wasn't great at all. A lot of defenders had games where they weren't
- 1:39:56great at all. And we still don't know if you are going to move
- 1:39:59beside Mexico Plon Miller, who's going to be that second and or third defender?
- 1:40:03We don't know because you keep on playing the same guys that won't be
- 1:40:06there in the big tournaments. So, I mean, I've said it a
- 1:40:13million times. I'm not going to repeat myself. Play the youth, right,
- 1:40:15all that stuff. It's just it's disappointing to see the same old faces.
- 1:40:18And even I talked about this a while back, where we compare some
- 1:40:21of these guys to made men in the mob where it just like you get
- 1:40:27in there and you are made for life, and you are getting selected come
- 1:40:30hell or high water, you know, and some of them, regardless of
- 1:40:34performance or age or what the what the project is. For some of the
- 1:40:38younger players, you are getting called up and it shows that, you know,
- 1:40:42these guys just keep on getting in and if they keep on getting the
- 1:40:45same results, then what are we doing here? Even I'll let you rebound
- 1:40:53on that and at the same time, you know, and tell us your
- 1:40:59thoughts about this school chosen by more of Yellow. I was nonplussed, honestly.
- 1:41:04I I echo much of what Elia said for sure. You know,
- 1:41:11I didn't attend Yellow's presserre obviously, but I can read so, you know,
- 1:41:17I know rationale for certain players being selected over others, just like it
- 1:41:21seems really discordant or it just didn't necessarily make sense, like you know,
- 1:41:26so and so was not in season. But then we do have players whose
- 1:41:30competitive seasons ended in October who were called up. So it's just like,
- 1:41:36okay, yeah, yeah, there are players who are aging out of this
- 1:41:46squad, and I I am all for you know, when it comes to
- 1:41:50players who have given so much to this this team and this federation, and
- 1:41:56you know, have been repaid with so little and often with disrespect from the
- 1:42:00federation. And you know, played in front of virtually empty stadiums and carried
- 1:42:05this team to guitar. I'm all for them getting like a proper send off,
- 1:42:10any proper thank you. But in a competitive context, you know,
- 1:42:18I'm trying to word it in like a way that doesn't sound like I just
- 1:42:21want to shove him out the door. In a competitive context, you do
- 1:42:28need to you do need to be forward looking at the end of the day.
- 1:42:32Yeah, yeah, And I think that's where I'm gonna end my sentence
- 1:42:35in the hopes of ending it gracefully. Okay, I'm gonna be a bit
- 1:42:40more aggressive in a certain way, and maybe not aggressive, but I don't
- 1:42:46know. I'm going to take maybe a bigger stand in a certain way.
- 1:42:50First of all, men Borian, I understand that he's old, thirty six,
- 1:42:56but he's still playing with Flow and Bratislava just doing very well, uh
- 1:43:01with in europe A Conference League right now. Drew Lil a couple of times,
- 1:43:06the lost one, but drew little the second time around it. So
- 1:43:10it's funny because it was David against Boorian in that game in the europe Acorn
- 1:43:15for Conference League. So he's still in a very good club playing in Europe.
- 1:43:18Yes, of course, not in the Champions League anymore, but still
- 1:43:21in the europe A Conference League, which is not a bad tournament. So
- 1:43:28that's that's pretty good. So I kind of understand the Boyan call. What
- 1:43:32I don't understand is the Steven Victoria's call, the Lucas Cavalini call. Uh.
- 1:43:40You know, these call ups for me are what's are really the problem
- 1:43:45for Canada soccer. And you know what, instead of really you know this,
- 1:43:55like really being being hard on the players, I'm gonna be hard on
- 1:43:59Moro Yellow. I'm sorry, but you had you had a chance to prove
- 1:44:04yourself, to see that you're different, to show that you're different, to
- 1:44:09show that, you know what, my predecessor did something which was really good.
- 1:44:15But at one time, I think, you know, we need to
- 1:44:18turn the page. And he had the chance to turn the page and he
- 1:44:23did it. And for me, that's the biggest problems that I have right
- 1:44:26now. You're trying to prove yourself as being the next head coach of the
- 1:44:30Canada soccer and you're just continuing in the same in the same road, on
- 1:44:35the same road that John Herdman had was already. And what you need is
- 1:44:41to prove that you're a different coach, that you're something different, that you're
- 1:44:44better, and you're not proving that you're doing exactly the same things that he
- 1:44:48used to do and taking doing taking exactly the same calls that he used to
- 1:44:54make, which is for me unacceptable because unfort the world is moving, Canada
- 1:45:03is getting better and better. You have a bigger national pool that you had
- 1:45:08before. I see Patrick mentioned Joel Waterman. I think he should have been
- 1:45:13in there. He had a very good season with c F Montreal. You
- 1:45:16know, Stephen Victoria is gone. I'm very happy to see Luke Defugalt.
- 1:45:20I think he's going to be very very interesting and he can play in a
- 1:45:23couple of positions. But that's one problem. The second problem is, you
- 1:45:29know, Ma Kathy k has been very good. Of course with the Revolution,
- 1:45:33since he got traded, he's been he's been a starter most of the
- 1:45:36time. He's been good. He you know, I kind of understand that,
- 1:45:43but at the same time, you do have a player that's Victor Lutouri,
- 1:45:46that's playing so well in Scotland, being in the Team of the Week
- 1:45:51a couple of times already, you know, why does it have Why don't
- 1:45:58why don't what are we not seeing him in that in that roster? Why
- 1:46:01are we not seeing that's doing very good? With c F Montreal, Ali
- 1:46:08Ahmad has been very good, but most of the time on the bench,
- 1:46:10and he's an excellent player, but he hasn't been as consistent on the on
- 1:46:15the field that and up front. I'm sorry, but Lucas Cavalini, you
- 1:46:20know what, you don't really need him. You already have Kyle Aaron,
- 1:46:24You already have Jonathan David. You can and Leanne Miller, like, you
- 1:46:29don't need to call Lucas Cavalini. Just get another midfielders on the on the
- 1:46:32on the squad, like you can take decisions. You're the boss now.
- 1:46:38And for me, this is unacceptable. It feels like it was very safe
- 1:46:42selection more than no no no, but it was like don't rock the boat.
- 1:46:46Like but I'm sorry, I'm gonna be even more strict. He doesn't
- 1:46:51have balls, I'm sorry, but like he's he's scared, he's scared of
- 1:46:58what, Like it's Nations League. Like you're playing against Jamaica, you're higher
- 1:47:04ranked than Jamaica, you should be confident and show confidence in your selection.
- 1:47:12But he didn't do that. So hopefully we'll be able to go through and
- 1:47:16to win against Jamaica. But even if we do, my point was still
- 1:47:21stand. He was scared and this is not what we need to see from
- 1:47:28the next national team coach. And again I love more of Yellow, but
- 1:47:31we need to see more. We need to see someone that's not afraid to
- 1:47:35take decisions and to take his own decisions and to make his own squad and
- 1:47:40up following the steps of the price British sess. So sorry for being that
- 1:47:45mean, but that's what I believe in the stance. It is a stance
- 1:47:54good. So I think I generally think to say on what I just said,
- 1:47:58I think to add I gave my comment that was a stance got perfect.
- 1:48:04That's it. That's all, guys. So I hope you guys liked
- 1:48:08our content today. I think we covered a lot of things. We tried
- 1:48:13to go as short as possible. Unfortunately there's too many things that we needed
- 1:48:16to talk about. Eve thanks a lot for being here this week, and
- 1:48:21Elias too. Thanks a lot, everybody, Thanks a lot for staying with
- 1:48:26us for an hour and fifty one minutes. Right now, we'll tell it,
- 1:48:30we'll tell you, thank you again, and we'll see you next week
- 1:48:33for another episode of The Ball Is Round