Latest / Politics with Paul / What Does it Mean to be an American? | Politics with Paul #100
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08It is episode 100 of this podcast, and I just want to take a moment to thank all of you who
- 0:15have been here at any point in this journey, whether you're just joining for this episode,
- 0:20whether you've been here since the beginning.
- 0:22Thank you so much for contributing to this, each and every one of you for helping to make
- 0:27this possible.
- 0:28And so with this one hundredth episode, I wanted to make a particular particularly
- 0:35special episode, something incredibly relevant to what I'm doing here and to all of us because
- 0:44this podcast about civic education and making politics more accessible and just diving into
- 0:52all these things in a more in-depth way and and with angles that people haven't really
- 0:59considered before.
- 1:02And so there's been a whole bunch of different topics and many of those unique, but I wanted
- 1:07something in particular to be as appropriate, I guess, for a one hundredth episode.
- 1:17And so I decided on that being the question of what does it mean to be an American?
- 1:23And it is very convenient that this episode just happens to fall right around the two
- 1:29hundred fiftieth anniversary of this nation.
- 1:32It was not planned like that.
- 1:34It just happened to work out that way.
- 1:37This is a question that I've thought a lot about over the years, and you probably have
- 1:43too, and it is something that we should constantly reevaluate.
- 1:48What does it mean to be an American?
- 1:50And I'm not talking about legal implications.
- 1:52I know we've got a lot of conversations about immigration going on, especially birthright
- 1:58citizenship, and that's that's not what I'm here to talk about.
- 2:01I'll let other people discuss that.
- 2:05And it's not a matter of trying to avoid those tough questions that unfortunately have a lot
- 2:11of partisanship and ideology tied into them.
- 2:14It's just that I want to get to more of the core of what an American is, something that we
- 2:19can all more discuss more reasonably compared to a lot of these highly emotionally charged
- 2:30discussions that are typical of basically everything in politics.
- 2:34And, of course, I'm not talking about anything pop culture either.
- 2:37So I'm not talking about fast food that we've exported or any of our celebrities that are
- 2:43known worldwide.
- 2:44Of course, I'm not talking about that.
- 2:45I'm trying to get to the philosophical values wise implication of what being an American is
- 2:54all about.
- 2:55And you also have to be careful with blanket statements and that's something I try to
- 2:59reiterate anytime I'm talking about any of these, whatever topic it is that I'm talking
- 3:05about.
- 3:05You don't wanna make too many blanket statements until you unless you can say with
- 3:10100% certainty, this is how it is every time for whatever it is.
- 3:15So it's it's really hard to make a clear, like, oh, this is what being an American is, but I'm
- 3:23going to attempt to try to dive into it anyways.
- 3:27And this is also an invitation for you to tell me and others that listen in what you think
- 3:35being an American is because it might be something different than what I talk about, but
- 3:40I will still try to put forth my own definition anyways.
- 3:45But before we get to that, I think it makes most sense to start off with this idea of can a
- 3:51list or criteria of what an American is.
- 3:55Can we even make that?
- 3:58Is there this checklist whether it's like an you one that you could actually make or an
- 4:03unwritten rule that says, oh, yeah.
- 4:06This is all the things that make somebody an American.
- 4:08It actually might be easier to list what is definitely not American, but even then, there
- 4:13are going to be arguments.
- 4:15And sometimes they're partisan or ideological in nature, and sometimes it's just a pure
- 4:20legitimate earnest difference in opinion.
- 4:24Not that partisan and ideological arguments can't be earnest, but a lot of times, they are
- 4:29more couched in those biases of what somebody's political views are and not recognizing those
- 4:38political biases.
- 4:39But we could at least start off with some more general American values and how people
- 4:48interpret them.
- 4:49You've got the maybe the most obvious ones are things like freedom, equality, justice, loyalty
- 4:55to the country.
- 4:56Of course, you would expect somebody who is a true American to be loyal to the country.
- 5:03I don't think that's exactly a controversial opinion, but what does that loyalty look like?
- 5:11And some people definitely have differences in opinion of what that loyalty looks like.
- 5:16Obviously, you can't sell secrets to a foreign entity.
- 5:20That is definitely not loyal to country, but a lot of times what loyalty is is couched in
- 5:26those biases.
- 5:27And a lot of times we get so upset that somebody thinks differently than us that we
- 5:33start to say that they're they're not loyal to the country.
- 5:35They're trying to destroy it when they really just have different ideas of what's best for
- 5:41public policy.
- 5:43And freedom is a seemingly obvious concept.
- 5:47Theoretically, we all believe that we should be free to express ourselves, to express our
- 5:52opinions.
- 5:55In practice, it doesn't always work out that way.
- 5:57And a lot of times when one group is in power, they try to suppress the ability of another
- 6:04group to be able to profess their own opinions that are contrary to what the majority and
- 6:12power is trying to promote.
- 6:16Equality can also be very fraught with political partisan and ideological arguments,
- 6:28especially when you talk about it in the context of DEI, diversity, equity, inclusion.
- 6:34But you don't have to talk about it in those terms.
- 6:37We theoretically all agree that we have equal rights.
- 6:42Now, of course, there are some people that definitely don't believe that.
- 6:45I'm not talking about those people.
- 6:46They like to separate people into an other and then our groups, that typical in group out
- 6:53group mentality.
- 6:54And a lot of times we like to say, oh yeah, we believe in equality.
- 7:00We believe in equal rights, but those people don't.
- 7:03And that's a lot of times that's not true.
- 7:06And then this concept of justice, a lot of people also turn into a political argument.
- 7:12But if we boil down justice to its essence, I think most of us would actually support the
- 7:21idea of justice.
- 7:22Now how that actually plays out can be a lot different, but the very essence of it, I think
- 7:30the vast majority of people in this country would agree on.
- 7:36And another front of this whole what our American values is this individualistic versus
- 7:42collectivist tug and pull where you have a lot of countries, especially over further east that
- 7:51have more of a collectivist mindset, and they tamp down a lot more on the individual, whereas
- 7:58America can sometimes too much veer into the individualistic territory.
- 8:06But both of these things are important.
- 8:08Individualism is a very core part of being American, but you also still have this concept
- 8:13of a melting pot of cultures and everybody else being able to share in the promise of America
- 8:21and what America is all about.
- 8:23And that is inherently collectivist.
- 8:26So in a in a funny way, this whole individualist mindset, there's a there's a
- 8:32collectivist mentality where we all actually or a lot of us agree on the need for
- 8:38individualism.
- 8:39And there there's this fine balance that you have to strike.
- 8:43And I think for the most part, America and American politics does a pretty good job of
- 8:49balancing balancing those two because you need to have the individualistic ability to profess
- 8:56your own views and not be forced to go along with a group or whether it's your group that
- 9:05you most identify with or just this, you know, this general problem we have with groupthink
- 9:12where people can't step out of line supposedly with what others think.
- 9:18And a lot of people would agree that we should have an individual mindset or that the
- 9:25individual should be respected.
- 9:27But a lot of times, don't think we really do.
- 9:30I mean, you look at how many times a republican has tried to take a different approach to
- 9:37something than the republican party at large agrees with and how much they're excoriated or
- 9:43how much a democrat has tried to step out of the typical line of what a democrat is normally
- 9:50considered, and they get excoriated.
- 9:52And you see that a lot more when that party is in power.
- 9:57Back when democrats were more in control of the government, it was a lot less tolerated by by
- 10:04the greater democratic apparatus for that democrat to step out of line.
- 10:08Now that republicans are more in charge, now it's if you're a republican and you try to step
- 10:13out of line, now you're going to get blasted.
- 10:18And that's just not how things should be.
- 10:20Yes.
- 10:20There has to be some level of party cohesion for you to be an efficient party.
- 10:24I get that.
- 10:25But this idea of, you know, trying to tamp down on dissent.
- 10:30This is the exact thing that we one of the things we fought against back in the eighteenth
- 10:36century against the British crown was the fact that we could not voice our opinions about
- 10:43British policies and that we didn't have a say.
- 10:47And so a lot of those things that we, you know, supposedly support about American independence.
- 10:55Now those same things about being able to tolerate dissent and freedom and the ability to
- 11:03profess your own views.
- 11:04Now we're suddenly when it's threatening our power or our influence, then suddenly we don't
- 11:10care as much about those values, and that's just not how it should be.
- 11:16But I think that also is a good segue into this idea of there's a difference between un
- 11:21American actions versus actually having anti American values.
- 11:28Because really, any one of us can act in an un American fashion.
- 11:32If we take the idea that American being an American means respecting people's freedoms and
- 11:39allowing them to make their own choices for their lives as long as they are not infringing
- 11:43upon other people's rights.
- 11:45Well, a lot of times when we are the ones in charge or people that we support are in charge,
- 11:53we become a little bit more tolerant of trying to infringe upon the freedom of expression of
- 12:00people who have different opinions on public policy and the direction of the country.
- 12:08I would argue that that is a very un American action.
- 12:10Doesn't necessarily make you un American.
- 12:13It makes you biased.
- 12:14It makes you human, but it doesn't necessarily mean you're anti American.
- 12:19Otherwise, I don't know if any one of us could be considered American at that point because a
- 12:24lot of times or at some point, all of us go against the ideals of what America is in the
- 12:32first place.
- 12:34And you see a lot of times in American history, how much there was a dictation of who was a
- 12:42quote unquote true American or who was really patriotic and that that concept was overly
- 12:47dictated.
- 12:48And one of the most obvious examples of that is during the McCarthyism era, during the Red
- 12:55Scare where Joseph McCarthy, a senator from Wisconsin, basically without evidence or at
- 13:04least at most flimsy evidence, accused all these people of being communist, of being so
- 13:10fundamentally anti American that he was purging them from all sorts of places in government and
- 13:19in the military.
- 13:20And eventually, people got tired of it, but it went on entirely too long.
- 13:25And there were people that did speak out about that.
- 13:28One particular example of that was Arthur m Schlesinger's juniors writing about what is
- 13:34loyalty, a difficult question, and basically called for both conservatives and liberals at
- 13:43the time to cool it here because this this whole when you look at communism and and all
- 13:50these other countries, how much they tamp down on dissent.
- 13:53And yet, in a democracy, we were emulating a lot of those same tactics that a communist
- 14:00government was doing, especially like in the Soviet Union back then.
- 14:06And you see a lot of times now in places like China and North Korea and Iran and Cuba.
- 14:13And yet we were doing a lot of those same things even though we ostensibly talk about how
- 14:19vile and corrupt and oppressive those governments are, and yet we've done the same
- 14:24thing.
- 14:24And not just during the McCarthy era, we've done it at multiple points throughout American
- 14:31history.
- 14:32And it just goes back to this whole concept of we can take un American actions, but that
- 14:38doesn't necessarily mean we have un American values.
- 14:41We sometimes forget what being American is all about.
- 14:44We get blinded by our ultimate wants and desires for public policy, but we don't it
- 14:53doesn't mean that we're actually against what America stands for, but it also takes a lot of
- 14:59self awareness to be to be able to recognize that.
- 15:04And so with those things in mind, because of all these different concepts of what an
- 15:12American is, there is arguably a lack of a clear answer as to what it means to be an
- 15:20American.
- 15:21And that can be both a strength and a weakness.
- 15:26It means that we can truly have a marketplace of ideas where we legitimately consider other
- 15:33people's points of view much more than you would see in any other country, but that can
- 15:41also lead to a lot of arguments, and it can lead to a lot of violence that we've seen in
- 15:49American politics, especially as of late.
- 15:53And you you find a lot a lot of things can be both a bane and a weakness when it comes to
- 16:00American politics.
- 16:01But there are still a lot of shared values that we have.
- 16:04It's just that we have differing opinions of whether they are being realized.
- 16:10Right now, a lot of Republicans would say that those shared values are being realized of
- 16:15freedom and justice, but a lot of Democrats wouldn't because of who's in the White House.
- 16:20And then when it inevitably flips in the future, you're gonna see a lot of Democrats
- 16:24that start saying all these values are being realized, and Republicans Republicans are going
- 16:29to say that it's not being realized.
- 16:33But we still do have a lot of core values that are still the same.
- 16:39It's just easy to forget or to not see it because of the loud polarized minority that
- 16:44doesn't actually really respect freedom and equality for other people who think of other
- 16:51people as less than themselves.
- 16:56Conservatives, moderates, and liberals, if that's the spectrum that you wanna use, no
- 17:03matter how conservative or liberal somebody is.
- 17:08Vast majority of us do support do believe in the core value of freedom.
- 17:14We do believe in the core value of justice and equality and the importance of the family.
- 17:22Might have different ideas of what family is, but we still believe in the importance of
- 17:27family.
- 17:28And vast majority of us believe in the importance of The US constitution even if we
- 17:34have different ideas about how to make it better.
- 17:38But when you really try to boil down things, when you actually try to listen to other
- 17:43people, you find a surprising, perhaps surprising amount of agreement on things.
- 17:51And that's one of the themes that you've seen in a lot of episodes of this podcast that we've
- 17:56talked about.
- 17:57Like, when I talk to doctors Guy and Heidi Burgess about constructive political
- 18:02discussions, you actually find, well, okay.
- 18:04You know what?
- 18:05There's a lot of common ground there.
- 18:06Or Nathan Smolensky talking about common ground in politics.
- 18:10It's easy to we're we're hardwired to look at what we consider threats, and we often consider
- 18:17threats to be things that are foreign to us, that are different to us.
- 18:22So when we have these this very strong tie to all of these political beliefs that we have and
- 18:31somebody else has different political beliefs, we oftentimes think of them as like completely
- 18:37off the wall.
- 18:38These are people that are are crazy, but really if you try to boil down a lot of what they
- 18:44believe in, it looks a lot like what we think is important.
- 18:49It's just we have different ideas of how to get there.
- 18:54And like I said before, this is not a new thing, and you see a lot of historical writings
- 19:00about the meaning of being American.
- 19:02And there's really just too many to list here.
- 19:07And not not all of these writings outright say, oh, this is what it means to be an American,
- 19:14but it does ultimately have a lot of relevance to that question, and you could apply it to
- 19:21that question because they're still incredibly How many things have the founding fathers
- 19:26written that you can apply to what it means to be an American?
- 19:29Thomas Paine's common sense before The United States even became an independent nation or the
- 19:36Federalist Papers talking about the core tenets of the American system of government and by
- 19:41definition, American values.
- 19:45But then, of course, even with the hopeful stuff that you have, you have some of the more
- 19:50pessimistic opinions of what it means to be an American, but ultimately, they do still have a
- 19:56glimmer of hope, especially with the, to put it lightly, checkered history of race in this
- 20:04country.
- 20:05And a couple of the really seminal works that you can look to are by scholars and and
- 20:17brilliant thinkers like Frederick Douglass, who was once a slave, and then it became
- 20:22emancipated and was largely self educated.
- 20:27He wrote, what is a slave to what to the slave is the July 4?
- 20:33And it was all very, very critical of American history up to that point and with good reason.
- 20:41The idea that all men are created equal.
- 20:44Well, for one, that idea leaves out women, but it also was applied more to white men.
- 20:50And not just white men, white men with property.
- 20:53And you see that same through line with how much the right to vote was expanded over time.
- 21:00But with Frederick Douglass, as much as he lambasted American history and America not
- 21:06realizing its promises up to that point that he had written this, he still wrote about that
- 21:12glimmer of hope about how America still has the capacity to improve and that it had been
- 21:18improving up to that point.
- 21:20And in a similar vein, you have former supreme court chief justice Thurgood Marshall talking
- 21:25about the when he wrote reflections on the bicentennial of the US constitution.
- 21:30Because for all the amazing things that The US constitution did for how forward thinking it
- 21:35was, there were still very clear obvious defects in it, namely that it didn't solve
- 21:43slavery.
- 21:43Though you had the three fifths compromise, which counted slaves as three fifths of a
- 21:48person for the purposes of population.
- 21:51But, of course, those slaves didn't get to enjoy that even those three fifths.
- 21:57It was their their owners that got to have that power of the three fifths of a person.
- 22:03And you look at all those things that are a huge stain on the history of America, but you
- 22:13still see how much of the promise of America was still there, how uniquely suited America
- 22:21was to be able to improve with how The US constitution can be amended over time, with how
- 22:29ideas can be debated earnestly in a public forum.
- 22:34And you don't really get that in most, if any countries.
- 22:39Some countries, yes, you do get to debate that, but not to the extent and in the same vein that
- 22:44America gets to.
- 22:48At least from a legal standpoint now, sometimes people still have their ability to express
- 22:56themselves trampled over, but the fact that we still can improve over time and we have
- 23:03improved over time and a lot of those means of suppression have been severely mitigated still
- 23:12speaks to just how unique America is and how politics in this country have for all its
- 23:22defects that it still has, how much it still has vastly improved over time.
- 23:27And you can see that even with the countless speeches by American presidents over time, both
- 23:32republican and democrat, and of the the parties that are no longer here, federalists and and
- 23:42whigs.
- 23:45And so that just speaks to the or is is one of the many things that I think speaks to the
- 23:50uniqueness of being American.
- 23:53Because most, if not all other countries, they have a distinct cultural identity that makes
- 24:00them that country.
- 24:01That's, oh, this is what it means.
- 24:03And this this might be out of pocket.
- 24:06So I forgive me.
- 24:07And if if I am wrong, please educate me on this.
- 24:11But there's a certain identity that that makes somebody much more clearly French or German or
- 24:20Spanish or Portuguese or or Brazilian or Mexican or any other case.
- 24:28Not to say that they don't have any variety or that they don't have some sort of legitimate
- 24:37debate about what their identities can include, but they are still pretty overall distinct in
- 24:45their culture and in their identity.
- 24:47But America's not like that.
- 24:49It is very unique in how it is not really a specific culture that everybody agrees on or
- 24:55that the vast majority of people agree on, but it's a blend of cultures.
- 25:00The fact that it's not uniquely distinct makes it uniquely distinct because there is this and
- 25:06sometimes it could be a source of tension, but this whole there is some level of agreement on
- 25:14what being American is, but there also isn't.
- 25:17And there still is a whole pluralistic mindset of all of these cultures living side by side
- 25:25that you really just don't get anywhere else.
- 25:28Not to the same level, not to the same degree.
- 25:30And you also have to imagine how vast America is compared to most other countries.
- 25:40It's one of the most populous countries in the world.
- 25:44And certainly amongst the most populous countries, it is much more culturally varied
- 25:48when you compare it to something like a Russia or a China or India.
- 25:54And again, that's not to say that none of these countries have some level of variety or
- 25:59anything like that.
- 26:00They're all seany, but America has a certain level of diversity that you really don't find
- 26:09anywhere else.
- 26:10It's one of the few countries, if not the only one, where you can actually become a citizen of
- 26:15the country coming from any other country and be treated as such, at least by most other
- 26:21Americans without having to be here for generations.
- 26:24And a lot of other countries, even when you become a citizen of that country, you're not
- 26:28seen as a citizen there.
- 26:30It takes you generations or your family generations to be recognized as a quote unquote
- 26:36real citizen of that country.
- 26:38You don't get that here in America, even if there are some people that would like to see
- 26:44things that way.
- 26:46But how many first generation, second generation, third generation, fourth generation
- 26:50Americans do you find here?
- 26:54There's a considerable number of those people, and it's part of what makes this country so
- 27:01fascinating.
- 27:02I mean, it would be very, very boring if we were all the same.
- 27:07Wouldn't it?
- 27:09I know it can be sometimes for some people it's scary or or can be make somebody anxious to see
- 27:18like, oh, wow.
- 27:19There's I don't know what these other cultures are like.
- 27:21But when you get to know these people, it is a very it could be a very eye opening experience
- 27:28to say, oh, wow.
- 27:30You know, these people, there's so much about them that's just like me.
- 27:34Even if they're not Americans, there's still a lot of things that they can respect about
- 27:40America when they encounter us, and we can respect about their cultures when we encounter
- 27:44them.
- 27:45Because anybody has a capacity to become an American.
- 27:50And so that's that's another important thing to think about is our real our relationship with
- 27:56the world.
- 27:59And the World Cup going on right now is a prime example of showing The US at its absolute best
- 28:06where we're welcoming people.
- 28:08We're celebrating cultures like how was it Manhattan, Kansas, I think, has taken in
- 28:14Algerian fans or how you have I'm trying to think of other specific cities that have had an
- 28:22influx of fans of a particular country coming to see their team.
- 28:25But or Japanese people coming to Texas and just all of these things that people are from other
- 28:33countries are blown away by about America.
- 28:36And not necessarily about American politics, but about American culture in general.
- 28:41I mean, people are smuggling ranch, something that we take for granted, and trying to smuggle
- 28:46it back to their home countries.
- 28:48And so so many foreigners are shocked at what America is really like because so many of them
- 28:53have been told about how rude Americans are and how stuck up and and obnoxious we could be.
- 28:59And sure, some of us can be because every country has those people, but it just goes to
- 29:05show you just how much, hey, when you actually encounter these people, there's they're human
- 29:12just like us.
- 29:13They have all these other hopes and dreams and and likes and dislikes that we have.
- 29:19Even if you put put aside the question of what an American is for a second.
- 29:27It's it's really just a heartwarming thing to see, and it's really showing America at its
- 29:32best.
- 29:32And one of those key ingredients, those key values of being an American is that respect for
- 29:40cultures coming in to this country.
- 29:44Even if they're not actually becoming a part of this country that they're still visiting, that
- 29:48should be what America is about or one of the things that America should be about.
- 29:52And it also goes to show you and this is also something that we need to remember for our own
- 29:59countrymen and women, our own fellow Americans.
- 30:02Citizens are not their government.
- 30:05Even when they vote for these people, they sometimes have just a different conception of
- 30:10what these people are like compared to you.
- 30:11Now, it doesn't mean that they can't be criticized for their choices in voting, but you
- 30:19see there there's there's this way too often, we treat an entire country as in one homogenous
- 30:32entity, and it's just not like that.
- 30:34Russian people are not the same as the Russian government.
- 30:37Chinese people are not the same as the Chinese government.
- 30:40North Korea's government and people, not the same.
- 30:42Iran's people and government, not the same.
- 30:45Cuba's people and government, not the same.
- 30:47America's people and government, not the same.
- 30:49Every single country, the citizens are not the government no matter where you go.
- 30:55And sometimes we can treat other people in the world like that, and then we can treat each
- 31:00other like that when we don't agree with the politics of the current administration in the
- 31:08federal government or in the state governments, and we encounter people who did support that
- 31:15ruling governments.
- 31:16We we start to see them all as the same exact thing, and it's it's not how we should see
- 31:23things.
- 31:23Yes.
- 31:23There is a very loud, vocal, obnoxious minority that thinks they're way smarter than they
- 31:30actually are, that are very much like the people they put in government, but we should
- 31:35not start treating everybody like that.
- 31:40And that's another important question about what it means to be an American is our
- 31:44relationship with each other because far too often, we are mixing patriotism with
- 31:51partisanship.
- 31:53We're not seeing each other as, quote, unquote, real Americans.
- 31:57We think the, unquote, other side is not patriotic, that they are un American, that
- 32:04they're immoral, that they're out to destroy the country and completely reshape it in their
- 32:09image.
- 32:10Well, funny thing about that is they think the same thing about you, patriotic, that you're
- 32:15not a real American, that you want to destroy the country, and that you want to impose your
- 32:20views on other people.
- 32:22But being an American means you have to truly respect each other's freedoms of fellow
- 32:28Americans, the differences of opinion.
- 32:31And theoretically, we we all support the freedom of speech, but far too often, we only
- 32:36support it for people that are like us.
- 32:38You know, basically joke that I support the freedom of speech unless it's something
- 32:43different than what I think, except for a lot of people, it's not a joke.
- 32:47And for some people, it's it's just a lack of self awareness.
- 32:50And if they really stop to think about it, they would realize, oh, wow.
- 32:53You're right.
- 32:54I I am doing that.
- 32:55That's not what an American should do.
- 32:58But, unfortunately, you have a lot of vocal people that aren't like that.
- 33:04They they don't really reexamine themselves.
- 33:11But we have such a melting pot of cultures that you're inevitably going to encounter somebody
- 33:18different than you.
- 33:19Even if they are somebody who has some similar viewpoints to you.
- 33:24Not every republican is gonna be the same.
- 33:26Not every democrat is gonna be same.
- 33:27Not every independent is gonna be the same.
- 33:31You have this melting pot of cultures, and they're rooted in origins both inside and
- 33:36outside of America.
- 33:37And you're just going to have this pluralistic culture, which is how it should be.
- 33:42The strength of America is the fact that there are so many different backgrounds of people
- 33:49that can become American, that come to be part of America.
- 33:53Rich, middle class, poor, black, white, Asian, Hispanic, Native American, multiracial, male,
- 34:02female, or if you if if you see things as nonbinary, whatever your opinion about gender
- 34:08is, whatever your opinion about sexuality is, all of these people can be American.
- 34:16And far too often, we treat these people as less than American, that they're less than
- 34:22human, and that's not how things should be.
- 34:24We have civic responsibilities to each other, and that includes respecting each other's
- 34:29freedoms and ability to express themselves and to be able to voice their own opinions without
- 34:36having to be shouted down or even violently suppressed.
- 34:41That's not how things should be, and we should not be supporting that because we are all
- 34:48Americans at the end of the day.
- 34:49And that I I know doesn't mean that everybody in the world is an American.
- 34:53Not saying that.
- 34:55But of people who are definitively part of this country, even if you put aside all the politics
- 35:01about immigration for a second, of people who are unequivocally American.
- 35:08This is not how we should be treating each other, and it's not how we should be treating
- 35:11people even if they aren't American either.
- 35:15Even if they are not a citizen of this country, and we agree that they're not citizens of this
- 35:19country, that doesn't mean we should be treating them that way too because these are
- 35:25still human beings at the end of the day that we're talking about.
- 35:28You can disagree with things they say and they do and believe, but that does not mean that you
- 35:36get to suppress their who they are.
- 35:42You get to suppress what they believe because that is a very un American thing to do even if
- 35:47it does happen a lot of times in this country.
- 35:50When you talk about feelings about America as an American, and I've even said some of my own
- 35:58feelings about that.
- 36:00I think you need to make clear distinctions between patriotism and nationalism and jingoism
- 36:08because patriotism is a deep and healthy pride in your country.
- 36:14You and really, every country should have pride in not not their governments.
- 36:22You should never have pride in your government.
- 36:24I'd or at least I don't think you should have pride in your government.
- 36:27I don't care what the government is.
- 36:29Maybe your system of government.
- 36:31I have pride in the American system of governments despite its many flaws because of
- 36:36how it is able to make itself better.
- 36:39And that's what being a patriotic person really is about.
- 36:42You're yeah.
- 36:43Pride in your country, but you also see how it can be so much better, and you work to improve
- 36:49it.
- 36:50You recognize its flaws and you can even feel shame about a lot of those flaws, but you also
- 36:58have a strong belief in how that system can be better.
- 37:05That's what patriotism is about.
- 37:08Nationalism takes things a step further, and it starts to be the national it believes in
- 37:14national superiority and just says, oh, we're superior because we're x country, and it
- 37:20disdains any critiques.
- 37:22You are not allowed to critique the country unless conveniently the country is being run by
- 37:27people you don't agree with.
- 37:28But then you get your jingoism, which is the height of this.
- 37:33It's it's aggressive, if not outright hostile toward other nations.
- 37:37You can be proud to be an American.
- 37:39You can be proud of what this country is, and you and you should be, but we'll get to that in
- 37:44a minute.
- 37:45But it doesn't mean you have to trash other countries, especially not allies.
- 37:52It does not mean that you have to put down other people because of their countries.
- 37:57That's not what we should be doing.
- 38:00You can be prideful about your country while still being respectful of other countries.
- 38:07You can be prideful about your country while still wanting to see it get better.
- 38:11Because patriotism and I'm as reluctant as I am to say what patriotism is because there's so
- 38:20many people that's lecturing others about, you know, being patriotic.
- 38:26But patriotism is not lecturing people about being insufficiently patriotic or deeming only
- 38:32people like you as real Americans.
- 38:35That's not what being patriotic is.
- 38:39Now, you can say that some people that, hey, I think you should have more pride in America
- 38:46because blah blah blah, but to act to just completely trash other people because they have
- 38:54some grievances with America.
- 38:56I don't think that's necessarily the right way to go either, and you're not going to convince
- 38:59other people.
- 39:01But at the same time, being frustrated with America doesn't mean that you should hate this
- 39:05country either.
- 39:07Because if you're gonna get mad at a country because of the flaws of its history, well,
- 39:12guess what?
- 39:12You're gonna be mad at every single country that has ever existed and that currently
- 39:16exists.
- 39:17Because no country is without blemishes because they are all comprised of human beings, and no
- 39:25subset of human beings is inherently better than another.
- 39:29Doesn't matter what your religious creed is, your political creed, your your race, your
- 39:34gender, your whatever it is.
- 39:38Doesn't matter if you're American or not.
- 39:41We should not be treating any subset of people as inherently superior because they're not.
- 39:47So we should be proud to be an American, but we need to be careful about we should not be
- 39:54dunking on other people because they're not American.
- 39:57And if we if people aren't proud of being an American, you need to respect that too.
- 40:03Now people who aren't proud to be an American should not be excoriating people who are proud
- 40:09to be an American just because they don't agree with them either because that is that's not
- 40:16solving anything either.
- 40:17And that is ironically what you're doing is a lot of the things that you complain about
- 40:22America being as well.
- 40:26You can be an American while being prideful of the country.
- 40:29You can be American while being very frustrated with the direction of a country, especially
- 40:38because you see how in polling about people when they talk about whether they believe the
- 40:44country is heading in the right or wrong direction, a lot of times that's influenced
- 40:48heavily by who's in charge and Republicans thinking that the country's in the wrong
- 40:54direction because Democrats are in charge or Democrats thinking the country's in the wrong
- 40:57direction because Republicans are in charge.
- 40:59And pride in a country can dip because of whether or not you support the people in
- 41:05government.
- 41:05And I don't think that that's how it should be either.
- 41:08But at the same time, you should also be able to have a conversation about that.
- 41:16Because holding government accountable for its policies is a completely different thing than
- 41:23just hating America.
- 41:25You should be able to hold America accountable regardless of who's running it.
- 41:30I don't care if it's a republican or a democrat or an independent.
- 41:33It is not above criticism, and we should not be criticizing things purely because they are
- 41:38things that we don't support.
- 41:41Because guess what?
- 41:42Every policy that a government could ever come up with that you have ever thought of, it's
- 41:46going to have a flaw.
- 41:48There are no perfect policies.
- 41:49Does not exist.
- 41:50I hate to break it to you.
- 41:54We should be trying to make all these policies better and be willing to take legitimate
- 41:59constructive criticism.
- 42:01We should also not just be critiquing for the sake of critiquing and just lambasting things
- 42:08just because because a lot of people just like to trash everything.
- 42:12But we should be able to have actual conversations about how to improve American
- 42:18politics.
- 42:19Because America is and has always been a work in progress, and it's probably always going to
- 42:25be a work in progress because you're never gonna have a perfect country.
- 42:30Humanity is never going to be perfect.
- 42:32There's not gonna be a subset of humans that ever are perfect.
- 42:36So we need to be careful about this distinction between frustration and despair.
- 42:42And I think that's a line that a lot of people cross.
- 42:45And I'm I'm still reluctant to say that to say we should criticize people who are despairing
- 42:53at America America and what they think it's becoming because I don't think that's
- 42:58necessarily the right course of action too.
- 43:01And you're not gonna be bringing people over to your side by doing that.
- 43:06But I think people do also need to be careful about it's okay to be frustrated with your
- 43:13government, and you should be frustrated with your government to some extent.
- 43:18You should be looking to try to improve things and finding blemishes.
- 43:26It should never get to the point where you hate your country, though.
- 43:31But at the same time, the freedom of speech allows you to do that as well.
- 43:36It allows you to burn an American flag.
- 43:39That's not something I support, but it is part of the freedom of speech.
- 43:47But just because you can do it also doesn't mean you should do it.
- 43:52It's like what doctor Ian Malcolm said in Jurassic Park.
- 43:56You thought so much about whether you could, you never stopped to think about whether you
- 44:00should.
- 44:02Now you can still disagree with me about whether you think those kinds of things are
- 44:09like burning a flag are appropriate or that they should be done, but that's okay.
- 44:15We should still be able to have a conversation about it.
- 44:19And so my ultimate take on what being an American means, and not going to say that this
- 44:27is the correct answer, unless it's something that's just so unequivocally objective.
- 44:32I'm very reluctant to say that this is how something is.
- 44:40But here's my attempt at talking about what being an American means, at least to me.
- 44:48It's respect for your fellow country people from all walks of life, and it's respecting
- 44:54their differences even if you vehemently disagree.
- 44:57Whatever they think about abortion, guns, LGBTQ policies, education, the economy, any anything,
- 45:11you should be able to respect those people even if you can get very frustrated with them.
- 45:15Doesn't mean that you can't be frustrated.
- 45:17Doesn't mean that you can't be angry, but you need to use that frustration and anger in a
- 45:22more constructive way.
- 45:25And you should be able to talk to people that aren't like you.
- 45:29Being an American means you believe in the basic promise of The US constitution and the
- 45:35declaration of independence.
- 45:36The declaration of independence was a very flawed document because when Thomas Jefferson
- 45:41wrote it, he was thinking of white men and perhaps only white men that had property.
- 45:47But with the way it's written and the way that America has gone and how The US constitution
- 45:52was was created and how the framers of the constitution and the founding fathers created
- 45:57this country and founded it, they found it in a way where it could it had a certain basis that
- 46:04was American, but what America means and what it includes could be expanded over time.
- 46:11It could go along with the times to some extent so that that that core part of what being an
- 46:18American is and what an American system of government is was the same, but it could still
- 46:23be vastly improved over time.
- 46:26And that has vastly improved over time.
- 46:29We've expanded voting rights for two other races or besides just white people to people
- 46:36that don't have land to 18 year olds to women.
- 46:42It should have been like that at the beginning, but at least it eventually did become that way.
- 46:48And even though we don't always emulate those ultimate core values like we should, the fact
- 46:57that we could still talk about those things and make things better and work towards fully
- 47:04realize realizing those ideals.
- 47:07That is what being an American is.
- 47:10It's that belief in the in the freedom of expression, especially those that are shown in
- 47:16the First Amendment of speech, religion, press, assembly, and petition.
- 47:22Did I miss one?
- 47:23Speech, assembly, petition, redress, grievances, religion.
- 47:28Yes.
- 47:29So those First Amendment beliefs and all the beliefs or or the other bill of rights of the
- 47:39ninth amendment of the any rights not expressly set stated in the constitution belong to the
- 47:49people.
- 47:50You look at the preamble of the constitution.
- 47:52We, the people, in order to form a more perfect union.
- 47:57It's the belief in the ability to critique our government without reprisal.
- 48:03It's the belief to in the ability to expand on the basic promise of the declaration of
- 48:08independence so that it can apply to all people regardless of race, religious creed, political
- 48:14creed, gender.
- 48:17It's a belief in that marketplace of ideas so that we can continue to improve as Americans
- 48:23because you don't improve when you shut out other ideas because you're never going to reach
- 48:31perfection.
- 48:32So you have to hear other opinions about how to make this nation better, especially with how
- 48:40many different cultures are living side by side.
- 48:44Because America is not about a political or religious belief.
- 48:49It's a spirit and you see it in The US constitution and the declaration of
- 48:55independence in countless writings since then.
- 49:00And all these different concepts of how to make America better, but still that ultimate belief
- 49:06in America and what it can be.
- 49:11And so if you have your own take on what being an American is, I'd love to hear those ideas
- 49:20too because this is not something that should just be a one off in a podcast.
- 49:24It should be something that we constantly think about because it's just too important of a
- 49:30question to consider that it's been fully answered because it might not ever be fully
- 49:35answered, but it's something that we should still consider.
- 49:38And in fact, some ideas or some concepts of what being an American is, and I'll just read
- 49:45some of them from what I found on the Internet.
- 49:48And I'll actually have a link to a couple of these as well so you can see the full answers.
- 49:53But one idea was that Americans often have the privilege of being a part of many communities
- 49:59to help define themselves as complex, individuals.
- 50:02And the past few years have demonstrated that our communities define America, a prospect that
- 50:08could be concerning and hopeful.
- 50:11And many other groups both intersecting and not also came to sit in solidarity reminding me
- 50:17that American values are rooted in communities that uphold understanding inclusivity and
- 50:22respect.
- 50:25And to me being an American means being free.
- 50:28I am free to embrace my Japanese and Filipino heritage.
- 50:31I am free to learn and celebrate other cultures.
- 50:34I am free to express myself through my physical experience or appearance and my words.
- 50:39I am free to speak another language and learn many more.
- 50:41I am free to take advantage of the opportunities in America.
- 50:45But those are just a couple of the other answers that people have.
- 50:50And so in in these questions, even though a lot of them can be different, you still see a
- 50:54similar through line through all of those.
- 50:57And ultimately, I hope that this two hundred fiftieth anniversary of American independence
- 51:07leads to this to to a civic renewal to it to this ability to be able to earnestly reappraise
- 51:16this question of what it means to be an American and for us to be a lot more respectful
- 51:21of each other and each other's opinions and cultures because that's what being an American
- 51:26really is about.
- 51:30So we'll end things here for this episode of the podcast.
- 51:35As always, thank you so much for watching and listening, and it's amazing to think that a 100
- 51:42episodes of this podcast have already come out.
- 51:45But I just want to take the time to thank all of you.
- 51:50And in fact, I wanna go ahead and also thank all of the people that I have had on this
- 51:57podcast.
- 51:57And, of course, plan to have many more guests as well and about all sorts of different
- 52:03things.
- 52:04So we'll talk about or list them right here.
- 52:07So and you, of course, you can look back on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts to look at
- 52:12all these episodes.
- 52:12But we have episode nine American Schism, which was Seth David Radwell, Mary Noon episode 29 on
- 52:19gerrymandering, Loora Forkham episode 33 about the psychology of independence, Jack Moore
- 52:24episode 35 about the JFK files, Sillaavjil episode 39 about open primaries.
- 52:31Graham Bernstein and Jacob Kaplan, episode 49 about bipartisan legislative advocacy.
- 52:36Guy Burgess and Heidi Burgess about episode 51 with constructive political discussions.
- 52:41Alex Vassar, episode 52, preserving political history.
- 52:45Shaka Mitchell, episode 53, education and civic engagement.
- 52:49Luis Enrique Marquez, episode 55 about protesting.
- 52:53Lauren Hall, episode 56, radical moderation.
- 52:57Nathan c Smolensky, episode 61, finding common ground.
- 53:01Lisa Eckman, episode 62, reevaluating our own beliefs.
- 53:05Shannon Watson, episode 63, Americans in the middle.
- 53:08Ronica Matheny, episode 64, accessibility of civics.
- 53:12Cromp Carmichael, episode 65, historical thinkers and the present.
- 53:16Doug Kaplan, episode 66, polling, informing conversations.
- 53:21Travis Mizorel, episode 67, empowering citizens.
- 53:25Peter Cohen, episode 68, supreme court of the United States and presidential power.
- 53:30Liz Vogel, episode 70 about pluralism.
- 53:32Dan McMillan, episode 71 about campaign finance reform.
- 53:36Alex Patton, episode 74, misunderstandings about campaigns.
- 53:40Claire Shirell, episode 76, about an app about revolutionizing civic engagement.
- 53:46Felicia Kolaros, episode 77, about encouraging and incentivizing depolarization.
- 53:52Stephanie Houghton, episode 78, improving youth voter turnout.
- 53:56Daniel Yudkin, episode 79 about civic renewal.
- 54:01Episode 80 was Bert Ralston Ralston, excuse me, mobilizing political supporters.
- 54:06Ramon Perez, episode 83 about an app to revolutionize government accountability.
- 54:12Michael Lee, episode 86 about what political civility really is or in fact, civility in
- 54:18general.
- 54:19Mettin Pecken, episode 88, the potential of a party less future, and Tom Joseph episode 89
- 54:26about a new way to nominate candidates.
- 54:28And that includes Democrats, Republicans, and independents because this episode is not or
- 54:34this podcast is not about favoring any one particular group.
- 54:39I want a whole array of opinions on a whole array of different topics because a, I find it
- 54:51interesting to hear other opinions.
- 54:53B, I wanna learn more about all these other topics that I may have some knowledge of, but
- 54:59there may be other things I haven't considered.
- 55:01But also, again, that's what America's about, this marketplace of ideas to be able to express
- 55:07ourselves.
- 55:08It should not be about siloing ourselves and not hearing other people's opinions.
- 55:13We really respect the freedom of speech and the freedom of expression.
- 55:17We should be trying to hear people out more.
- 55:21And so that's what I'll leave you with.
- 55:24So links in the show notes, my other works which include my book on political
- 55:30independence, which you can buy on Amazon and several other retailers, my five day
- 55:35educational email course about how we can all more effectively mitigate toxicity and
- 55:40polarization in politics, my medium.com profile, which I write on from time to time,
- 55:46and then my other links, my Facebook, LinkedIn, website, and email.
- 55:52So once again, thank you all so much for listening.
- 55:54Thank you all for making 100 episodes of this podcast possible and for making future episodes
- 56:03of this podcast possible.
- 56:05So we'll see you next time.