Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 10 - Diagnosis)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey deserve listeners. This is chapter ten and our deep dive on the psychology
- 0:04of Josh Powell. This is the final episode in this series in which I
- 0:09provide my conceptualizations of both Stephen and Josh my hypothesized diagnoses. I can't diagnose
- 0:17from afar, of course, but I can hypothesize based on the data available
- 0:23to us. But first I want to talk about something I forgot to talk
- 0:27about in the previous episode. So you remember the nine to one one operator
- 0:31that took the call from Elizabeth Griffin Hall, the supervised visitation worker who was
- 0:38outside Josh's house calling frantically, and how the nine to one one operator seemed
- 0:45indifferent, incompetent something. Well, an update on that individual, that nine
- 0:52to one one operator is that apparently now he is teaching classes on how not
- 1:00to do what he did. He's teaching classes to other nine to one one
- 1:03operators, and specifically he talks about compassion fatigue. You know, for us
- 1:08non psychopaths, we have empathy, we care about others, we have altruism,
- 1:15and we have compassion. And typically people who enter certain careers have even
- 1:21more empathy and more compassion, like a nine to one one operator or a
- 1:25therapist or a first responder. These people tend to choose these jobs because they
- 1:30want to make a difference and they care and they do their job, and
- 1:37there's a lot of opportunity to experience some intense situations where people are suffering and
- 1:46you care, so you're trying to help. But over time, and there's
- 1:49a lot of different pathways to this, and there's protective factors and da da
- 1:53da, But you could imagine somebody becoming fatigued in their can passion. They
- 2:01don't have any more compassion left by Wednesday. Say, you know, they're
- 2:07working Monday and Tuesday, and by Wednesday they're all compassioned out. And when
- 2:14we measure that in terms of behavior and the reports from the individuals and their
- 2:19measures and this sort of thing, But what happens is we become overloaded and
- 2:25we might be experiencing secondary PTSD, or it might just be burnout, just
- 2:30the feeling of I'm overwhelmed, it's too much, I keep trying to help,
- 2:38and that there's so much suffering and you know, so apparently for him,
- 2:43he is focusing on that with nine one one operators, and I think
- 2:46what that says is that he thinks that's why he was so indifferent on the
- 2:53phone with Elizabeth Griffin Hall, And yeah, I think that that's that's a
- 2:57good possibility. But upon listening to it, I don't blame him as much
- 3:02as I did when I first heard that phone call. Having said that,
- 3:07I think he absolutely could have been more compassionate, right, He could have
- 3:14been more inviting of information, less off putting, Like right from the beginning,
- 3:21he just seemed like he was being bothered, like he was on his
- 3:23lunch break, He's like, oh, what do you want? Uh,
- 3:25yeah, that kind of stuff. I mean, I'm exaggerated, but anyway,
- 3:29So that's a positive ending to that story, right, But that's great.
- 3:35Another thing I want to do is watch a video that I came across
- 3:39recently, because when I started this Deep Dive, I thought I had done
- 3:44all the research I needed to do because I had already spent I don't know
- 3:46a couple months looking into stuff, and as we've been recording these episodes,
- 3:51I've just been interested, Okay, well what about that thing? What about
- 3:54that? Well? I came across an interview with Alena, Josh's younger sister,
- 4:00the one that was in Josh's corner and in Steven's corner, and Alena
- 4:06gave an interview, and I want to watch it because it provides a very
- 4:11different perspective on the whole situation. On this watch, there is a side
- 4:16to Susan that you know, the other side doesn't want you to see,
- 4:20doesn't want to expose. Do something good for the video content too. So
- 4:25this is on the YouTube channel called Oxygen No, I'll do this. We
- 4:32saw glimpses of that. I just remember I was like I was actually hanging
- 4:38out with dad. So basically, the case that Alena is making is that
- 4:45Susan did, in fact flirt with Stephen. And we'll'll rewind it. We'll
- 4:49watch that little clip there and I'll give my opinion about all this in the
- 4:55end. But because there's a number of possibilities here, but I just I
- 5:00wanted you to see this, this information, because if we're going to conceptualize
- 5:04Stephen's personality, you know, the more data there is, the better do
- 5:09something good for the video camera to I'll do this. We saw glimpses of
- 5:15it. To me, it's just kind of nice to see her alive and
- 5:19smiling. She just seems like a positive, happy person. But I think
- 5:26off camera is Stephen, at least that's what they're implying. We don't know
- 5:30that, but it sounded like Steven and he is taking pictures and someone else's
- 5:36videotaping, maybe Josh's, and Susan is posing and playing around and then she
- 5:45unzips her vest. Is that some sort of reference to her body kind of
- 5:51looked like that again, I'll give my analysis then, because there's a possibility
- 5:58that it is the way that it looks, and there's a possibility that this
- 6:00is funny if you're familiar. But let's watch that. I just remember I
- 6:06was like, I was actually hanging out with dad, and she came bounding
- 6:10in and she was all like excited, and she totally bypassed me, like
- 6:14just ignored my existence, went straight to my dad and started being like,
- 6:17look, I just love I just waxed my legs, and she threw her
- 6:19leg up and she's like, here, feel my leg I just waxed it.
- 6:23It's so smooth. This is a leak after waxing, no hair.
- 6:29That's really pretty clear. Now, in all likelihood, Alena is biased.
- 6:34She was on Steven's and Josh's side the entire time. I don't know if
- 6:39she had any kind of nuances going on, but it's biased. So there's
- 6:44that. But here's the video. And it's interesting that in all the other
- 6:48reporting none of these clips were included. Why not, Well, I think
- 6:55they're trying to make a case. I also think that they don't want to
- 6:58muddy the waters. They don't want to give the defense, you know,
- 7:01the people who are defending Steven and Josh. They don't want to give them
- 7:05any kind of ammunition and any kind of credibility because the bottom line is is
- 7:14even if Susan was being flirty with Steven, it doesn't justify anything that was
- 7:18happening. Yeah, so I'm thinking, like, that's really weird, like
- 7:25why is she doing that? And then I'd start over time, I'd start
- 7:29seeing her kind of, you know, do like little flirty movements, flirty
- 7:34expressions and different things like that. At first, my dad was oblivious.
- 7:39So they're showing these little clips. Who knows what's happening there, what she's
- 7:46thinking or communicating or or what's going on the implication from Alena is that Susan
- 7:53is being sexually displaying, if you will, she's fosturing sexually forest, even
- 8:01which okay, which I'll again, I'll get to the options later. But
- 8:05those little clips right there, you know, that very first one seems more
- 8:11understandable, but it's hard to know. That second one with the waxing of
- 8:16the legs, okay, But then these ones where she's just moving, I
- 8:18mean, who knows what's going on there, And then she's bouncing up and
- 8:20down on a chair. I think they're trying to imply that she's simulating having
- 8:26sex, which is, you know, possible, but there's a lot of
- 8:28other options. You know, he just had no idea what she was doing
- 8:31at first. But then over time, when I started seeing him actually clew
- 8:35into it and respond, then I started to get worried that he might be
- 8:39taking this seriously. I pulled him aside one time and I said, look,
- 8:46this is a game. She's not into you. You're giving her attention,
- 8:52and she wants the attention, and that's all. Today he was kind
- 8:56of like this this okay. It's kind of interesting that we're hearing from Alena's
- 9:01account that she noticed that Stephen was starting to flirt back. And you know,
- 9:09when I think about so Elena's story is, yeah, so I went
- 9:13to Stephen. My dad, and Josh's dad and Susan's father in law.
- 9:18I went to my dad, my father, and I told him to not
- 9:22respond to Susan because it's just a game. To Susan, you would think
- 9:28that you would go to him and say, regardless of what my sister in
- 9:33law is doing, you'd think Elena would go, Dad, what are you
- 9:37doing? Okay, maybe she's being a little flirty, but knock it off.
- 9:41You're her father in law. It's notable that Alena is going to someone
- 9:48like to a friend at school, right, I mean, because even if
- 9:50Stephen was her brother. Right again, you would think Elena would go to
- 9:56Stephen brother and say, even if Susan is flirting with you like you can't,
- 10:01what are you doing? That's your brother's wife, stop it, right,
- 10:05So it's the her tone is the way you would go to someone at
- 10:09school and be like that girl across the classroom. She's not into she's just
- 10:13flirting. She's just playing a game, you know what I mean. Puppet
- 10:18at first, you know, he was kind of just being played along at
- 10:20first, and then he started to clue it. I'm gonna walk past you
- 10:24now, so you'll have to turn. She was playing a game with him,
- 10:28So that's notable. I'll rewind that one because that's different, I think
- 10:33from the other clips that she is saying, I'm gonna walk past you now,
- 10:37now you got to turn the camera off. Maybe, you know,
- 10:41is that flirting could be? Or is that her saying can you please stop
- 10:45filming my ass? Yeah? And getting into dangerous territory. Okay, So
- 10:52I can think of five different possibilities. There are more, but the five
- 10:58worth mentioning are the five regarding what we just watched. Number one is that
- 11:03those clips of Susan were cherry picked and taken out of context. We can't
- 11:07know the full context of what was happening. We don't even really know who
- 11:11she was looking at. It seems like it was Steven, but maybe it
- 11:15was Josh actually using the I don't know, but it could be cherry picked.
- 11:18The second possibility is that she was just generally open about her body.
- 11:24Some people in general, regardless of who they're talking to, are just more
- 11:30accustomed. Maybe their family was more open about it, not in an abusive
- 11:33way, but in a way that's just more body positive and not shy about
- 11:41that kind of stuff. So that's another possibility. Another is that she liked
- 11:45to joke in a variety of ways, including this way, and you cherry
- 11:50pick those scenes and it looks the way that looks. The fourth possibility is
- 11:54that she actually was flirting with Stephen. It's hard to imagine that, but
- 12:01you know it's possible. It's within the realm of possibility to be strange,
- 12:05but it is possible. The fifth option is fawning. So we have fight
- 12:11or flight, right, fight, fight, freeze, fawn and faint.
- 12:16Sometimes they say freeze and appease, but I'm saying fun So fawning or appeasing
- 12:24is a learned response to victimization, typical to children that have been sexually abused.
- 12:31Not all the time, but often they will learn to survive by appeasing
- 12:35and fawning and saying thank you and let's do that again, or I love
- 12:41you, even though they're terrified. Right, It's a way to survive.
- 12:43It's a way to lessen the abuse. It's a way sometimes to get a
- 12:48little bit of attention, like love from the abuse, because if the abuse
- 12:52or as a family member, you also depend on that person for attutement.
- 12:56Also, you might just convince yourself that you want to do it. Because
- 13:01it will lessen the pain from it. It's still painful, but it's like,
- 13:05well, if I want to do it, then maybe it's a little
- 13:09less painful. You know, there's a still or your gas lit into believing
- 13:11that you want to do it, that kind of stuff. So it's possible
- 13:13that she learned that behavior going up and she was just playing that out.
- 13:18She might have fond with any man that looked at her in a certain way,
- 13:22we don't know. The other layer to this is that the clips in
- 13:26the video are we don't know in space and time where they're happening. So
- 13:33for the first few years, Stephen or however much time, Stephen might have
- 13:37been very creepy with her. We could imagine that. And in the beginning
- 13:43she was like this, she was freezing and didn't like it and didn't know
- 13:48what to do. But then eventually she started to learn, well, you
- 13:52know, and maybe she tried various different ways to get out of it.
- 13:56She talks to Josh, she tries to avoid the camera or something, but
- 13:58over time she's like, well, there's no way out, so maybe I'll
- 14:03just make a joke. It's akin to when Aberdo talks about how when he
- 14:09came to the United States from Colombia and everyone was making jokes about the drug
- 14:16cartels for him, and he learned early on, I think in life,
- 14:22really, but also in this period, that there's a number of lesser evils
- 14:26to choose from, one of which is to act like you enjoy it and
- 14:33just play along with it, maybe even make a joke at your expense,
- 14:35and never show that you're hurt or that you're upset, because then people might
- 14:41reject you, or they might feel uncomfortable, or they might start bullying you
- 14:46even more. You might even start acknowledging to yourself that you're going through a
- 14:52racist victimization or a microaggression, and that's too painful because there's no way out.
- 14:56So you just convince yourself fun the racism. He just say, thank
- 15:03you, May I have another. I've been there myself. There was one
- 15:07moment when my white friends, well most of them, I grew up in
- 15:11an almost entirely white community. Like when I say all usually like Seattle people
- 15:16people say Seattle is just like very very white. But I think Seattle is
- 15:22maybe like seventy percent white or something, So I'm talking about like literally ninety
- 15:28nine point eight percent white in my community, there was another Asian kid that
- 15:35eventually came to the school later on, like maybe in seventh grade or something.
- 15:41There was one black kid, and I think that's it for hundreds of
- 15:48kids. So when I had my friends, and they were good friends,
- 15:52and there they're good guys, but you know, it's the it's nineteen eighty
- 15:58and they haven't learned better, and they we would all make fun of each
- 16:03other. That was the way. And I'm spending a night at my friend's
- 16:06house and we're all about to fall asleep. I think, I don't know,
- 16:10maybe we're like fourteen fifteen, and one of my friends starts making a
- 16:15song. It was like a quintessential stereotypical Asian song. Like if you're younger,
- 16:26you might have never heard this stereotype stereotypical little tune. But growing up,
- 16:33it's sort of like the gong, you know, like whatever Asians enter
- 16:38like long duck dong on sixteen candles. Every time this this gong, there's
- 16:42certain racist, stereotyped cues that we were very used to growing up, and
- 16:48that was one of us. That little song and my friend, who's a
- 16:53good guy, but you know, racist, because when you grow up in
- 16:56a racist society, they're going to be racist. So he says this this
- 17:00song and then and then everyone starts laughing because they know what he's doing.
- 17:04He's making fun of me being Asian. And then another guy like because we're
- 17:11all in the dark, right, and another guy starts singing, and then
- 17:14even bigger laughter. So at that point, I'm thinking, well, what
- 17:18do I do? And what I did is I leaned into it and I
- 17:22started laughing. I started singing the song, and it hurt less. It
- 17:26would have hurt more if I fought back or packed up my shit and went
- 17:30home, like what am I supposed to do in that situation? And that
- 17:36joke was an ongoing joke for years after that, and you know, it
- 17:41wasn't devastating. It was the end of the world, but it didn't feel
- 17:42good. And it's very othering, and it was hurtful. And the way
- 17:48it was the way that they laughed, you know, because we would make
- 17:51fun of each other, and when we made a joke about someone that was
- 17:56kind of real, kind of like it's getting too personal, it's too close
- 18:02to home, then the laughter would get it would sound different. And that's
- 18:06that's the way the laughter was so I appeased. I what I say,
- 18:11I fond in that instance? You know, so was that what Susan was
- 18:18doing? I don't know. I don't know, but you know it's interesting.
- 18:22All right. So let's go on to Steven's analysis here, but first
- 18:27let's take a break. All right, we're back from the break. So
- 18:33let's talk about Steven's conceptualization. Now we don't have as much information about Steven
- 18:41as we do for Josh, but we have a lot of information, primarily
- 18:45because of his journals and all the confiscated information that we have available to us.
- 18:53And Steven couldn't stop talking. So there's that, all right. I
- 18:56thought that for both Steven and Josh, we would talk about the Dark Tetrad.
- 19:03You might have heard about the Dark Triad, but the Dark Tetrad I
- 19:07prefer because it includes sadism. The tetrad the dark four are psychopathy, narcissism,
- 19:15Machiavelianism, and sadism. And I thought I would evaluate Steven and Josh
- 19:21on all four. I'm going to use other perspectives when looking at each of
- 19:25their personalities, but I thought I would start there because I don't know,
- 19:30it captures a lot so with psychopathy. When we look at Steven's behavior,
- 19:36we have the following data that is in this category. One is that he
- 19:41abused his family. Now, not every parent who abuses their spouse and their
- 19:47kids has a lack of empathy. In fact, most have empathy. They
- 19:52might have impaired empathy, but they usually do have empathy. So that's not
- 19:57a huge indication. But if we look at the rest of this maybe it'll
- 20:02all start to coalesce. He violated the rights of Susan, two young girls,
- 20:07and many many others with the voyeuristic crimes that he went to prison.
- 20:11For the amount of times that he would come to a y in the road
- 20:17and make a decision between respecting other people's boundaries and rights and not harming them,
- 20:23not creeping them out, not violating them, and doing so, he
- 20:30chose to violate over and over and over and over and over again. So
- 20:34that doesn't lend itself to the conceptualization that he did have at least typical empathy.
- 20:41But let's move on. So the thing is is we don't know what
- 20:45he believed. That's my main question with Stephen. Did he believe that the
- 20:52individuals that he was victimizing did he believe that they wanted it to happen,
- 20:57because with Susan there was evidence of that, which I'll get to more in
- 21:02a second. When I talk about narcissism overall, I wouldn't conceptualize him as
- 21:07being primarily psychopathic. I would say he was primarily narcissistic. But given what
- 21:12he did, I would guess that he was on the spectrum. You know,
- 21:17other people with voyeuristic urges don't act on them, or don't act on
- 21:21them as much as he did, or don't act on them with children,
- 21:25and yet he did so I'm guessing he had to have been somewhere on the
- 21:30spectrum of actually lacking empathy independent of his narcissism to be able to do those
- 21:36things. Right now, I'm guessing some people would say, how can you
- 21:41possibly say that Stephen wasn't a full blown psychopath? Well, when you study
- 21:47psychopathy and you treat psychopaths, then you can see the difference. There are
- 21:53true psychopaths that are very similar to one another, and there's no ambiguity about
- 22:00their lack of empathy for other people's feelings. With Stephen, we either don't
- 22:03have as much data, or the data that we have it's ambiguous about it.
- 22:10Like I said, he in all likelihood did lack a significant amount of
- 22:14empathy, again independent of impaired empathy from narcissism. But I'll just take my
- 22:19word for it now. Might you find other clinicians that would say differently,
- 22:23Yeah, because this isn't a hard science. It's based on research and experience.
- 22:27But there's a lot of opinion in the gray zone, all right.
- 22:32So the second trait within the dark tetrad that we want to talk about is
- 22:37narcissism. So narcissism refers to being self centered, unable to notice or intuit
- 22:45other people's inner lives or emotions or states, and being very focused on your
- 22:51own experience, your own thoughts, your own needs. Also the need to
- 22:53be superior. I need to be better, and I need to be admired,
- 22:57and also impaired empathy. You know, people with narcissism have empathy,
- 23:03a primitive form of empathy that has been underdeveloped, but it's there. Although
- 23:08their need for their narcissistic supply will often supplant or eclipse their empathy, and
- 23:17thus they will act in ways that are very harmful to others. And it
- 23:21looks like they have no empathy, but they are capable of it. So
- 23:26with Stephen, we ask ourselves did he have traits of narcisism. The answer
- 23:32is, oh, my god, yes. Now I can't diagnose him even
- 23:37with the data before us, and I'm not super confident, but this is
- 23:41the top hypothesis that I would have. I mean, the amount of yamoring
- 23:45that he exhibited, and the way he talked in his journals, and the
- 23:49way he shot himself in the foot. People with personal disorders, people with
- 23:53narcissisic precise order, almost always shoot themselves in the foot. I mean,
- 23:57all you have to do is look at certain politicians that may or may not
- 24:02suffer from narcissis personality sort, who were constantly shooting themselves in the foot with
- 24:06their constant yamoring and tweeting and everything. It's something that shooits people in the
- 24:11foot. There can be benefits to it societally apparently, but it always presents
- 24:15problems. And for Stephen it literally put him in prison. It might have
- 24:19even killed him, because he died shortly after going to prison after being released
- 24:23from prison, and who knows, but did the stress of prison take a
- 24:29toll on him or the stress of the who knows, but definitely that the
- 24:32yamoring and how he inserted himself into Josh's interview and that ABC interview believing that
- 24:40Susan wanted him. Also, he seemed to yammer a lot about how certain
- 24:45things were below him, like women or the church, you know, this
- 24:48kind of stuff. It was also abusive. Not all people with narcissistic personality
- 24:53or abusive, but he was. And I think it, given how much
- 24:59narcism we saw, it likely derived at least in part, if not entirely,
- 25:03from his self centeredness and his impaired empathy and his need to be superior.
- 25:08You know, if the kids challenged him in some way, whether real
- 25:12or imagined, he might have a narcissistic supply deficit and thus have to establish
- 25:19his dominance by interacting with the kids to humiliate them or to possibly abuse them.
- 25:26He was particularly abusive to Josh reportedly, so maybe he had a particular
- 25:30competition with him, Who knows. There's a lot of options here. He
- 25:34might have seen since Josh was the oldest boy, he might have seen Josh
- 25:38as a competition for narcissistic supply from Stevens's wife, Teresa. I don't know,
- 25:45but he was abusive his singing, all the stuff that he did regarding
- 25:52his music. You know, God bless people they can create their art.
- 25:56But I was getting the impression that he was one of the those musicians that
- 26:00just thought he was a rock star. When yeah, again, art is
- 26:06art, but it was not appealing to me, and I imagine not appealing
- 26:10to a lot of people. I don't know that, but he did caucas
- 26:15Also, the way he talked about his website seemed narcissisic, like he just
- 26:19he wanted to get his word out all the time when he wasn't even let
- 26:23me just think about that his son and daughter in law and grandkids are involved
- 26:30in this thing, and he just he made himself the story. Frequently,
- 26:36that's narcissistic, So we can definitely say yes to that. The third trait
- 26:42within the dark tetrat as machiavellianism. So this is when people tend to develop
- 26:51plans to manipulate others or to get what they want out of life in spite
- 26:56of others. You know, they will be very calculating and deceptive. They
- 27:03plan in advance. It's one thing to step on other people's rights and other
- 27:07people's needs. It's another thing to plan well in advance, while you're calm,
- 27:14while you're able to think straight, and then to not change that plan
- 27:18later. You know, many psychopaths will impulsively harm others, and when you
- 27:22get in their way, they will trample you. But they don't sit at
- 27:26night going Okay, tomorrow, I'm going to do this. They're they're more
- 27:30impulsive. Right. Well, people who are Machiavellian are planning in advance.
- 27:34Now, you can have a psychopath that's also magi. By the way,
- 27:37all four of these traits within the dark tetrad are correlated but not always present
- 27:44with each other. So you can have someone with psychopathy but not narcissism and
- 27:48Machiavelianism and sadism and all the combinations, or you can have someone with all
- 27:52four. So with Stephen, did he have any evident Do we have any
- 27:57evidence to support a conceptualization that he did plan and deceive and calculate. I
- 28:04would say that the only behavior we have is that he planned out seemingly.
- 28:11He planned out a lot of his voyeuristic behaviors, right, But he didn't
- 28:14plan particularly well. When he's inserting himself into the press seem very impulsive,
- 28:21and he doesn't fit in terms of the data available to us. He doesn't
- 28:25fit the profile of someone who's Machiavelian. Josh does, which we'll get to
- 28:30in a second. So I'm going to say, given the evidence, you
- 28:33know, not a strong signal there for machiavellanism. So to review, we
- 28:37got psychopathy. I would say somewhere on the spectrum narcisism boom, and then
- 28:42the fourth in the dark tetrad is sadism. So often people will think that
- 28:48psychopaths or people with any social are automatically satus in that they take pleasure in
- 28:55harming other people, and research does not support that. I adhere to the
- 29:00personality disorder lingo that includes sadistic person I disorder because it's worthy of having its
- 29:10own category, you know, and people with any social personise sorder are you
- 29:15know, everyone in my field understands that you can have any social precise order
- 29:18and it could mean a wide variety of things. It could mean you're a
- 29:22monster who is sadistic, or it could mean that you tend to just steal
- 29:26stuff that's around and you don't care about getting in trouble. So that's a
- 29:33simplistic way of putting up anyway. So sadism this is the trait of enjoying
- 29:38hurting others or seeing others be hurt or humiliated. But typically sadists want to
- 29:45be the one inflicting it if they can't do that, because that causes them
- 29:49to get in trouble too much that they'll settle for watching other people get hurt,
- 29:53like videos, this kind of stuff, and it could be physical,
- 29:59but often it's emotional. They want to see people being hurt emotionally. So
- 30:04Stephen, did he have signs of sadism? I would say yes, he
- 30:10has signs of specifically sexual sadism, which is a subset of sadistic personality.
- 30:15So a major question that we'll never know is did he know that his voyeuristic
- 30:23victims were not consenting? It sounds silly, but there's evidence that he didn't
- 30:32know that they weren't consenting. So let's talk about the possibilities. He knew
- 30:34that they were not consenting and he didn't know, So the first one is
- 30:37that he knew. Let's just go with that, and that would mean that
- 30:41he's a sexual sadist because he knew that his victims didn't want him to be
- 30:45watching them and taking pictures of them, and that was part of the turn
- 30:51on. That's why he did it. Okay, So in this person,
- 30:56if in this reality he's like other sexual sadists, serial rapists, Harvey Weinstein,
- 31:03Bill Cosby, Jeffrey Epstein, this kind of thing, now, this
- 31:07would also be a pretty high indication for psychopathy, a true lack of empathy
- 31:11right for him. If he was sadistic and he did know that the victims
- 31:17didn't want to do that, then that would bump up the psychopathic personality trait.
- 31:22The second option is what I'll call the narcissistic option, in which he
- 31:26has a semi delusional belief that his victims actually wanted it and liked it.
- 31:32We saw evidence of this, which I'll get into in a second. So
- 31:37for people with narcissist for anyone with a personal disorder, they have distortions,
- 31:41they have semi delusional beliefs, they perceive wrongly. That is the hallmark of
- 31:48a personality sorder. With passive aggressive personality disorder. If you've listened to my
- 31:52deep dive, let's say you have a passive aggressive person who is cheating on
- 31:56their spouse. Well, for this individual, in all likelihood, they have
- 32:00a semi delusional belief that they deserve to cheat on their spouse. And listen
- 32:07to about how deep dive on why they have that the semi delusional belief or
- 32:13someone won't someone with avoidant personal disorder. Let's say you have someone with avoidant
- 32:16personalage sorder who rarely leaves the house. So for this individual, they in
- 32:22all likelihood have a semi delusional belief that if they walk out of the house,
- 32:27everyone will notice how weird they are and will be judging them. Okay,
- 32:31you'll hear that from avoidant personage ordered individual. They'll they'll say, oh,
- 32:36everyone knows just how ridiculous I look, even though they don't look ridiculous.
- 32:40Or with skizoid precise order, I recently did a deep dive in that.
- 32:44So let's say you have a skeezoid individual who goes to work and their
- 32:49co worker asks them how's your weekend? And the skeizoid person gets very upset
- 32:54that their co worker is asking them about their weekend. So for the skizoid
- 32:59individual, they have a semi delusional belief that their coworker is being grossly invasive
- 33:06of their life, just massively invasive of their personal life. Like if the
- 33:10coworker were to stand up and just announce that they had found your journal and
- 33:15was just reading it out loud. That's how it feels. That's the curse
- 33:20of a precise order is it changes their perceptions, not because they're delusional,
- 33:25not because they're schizophrenic or psychotic, but because of the traumas they went through.
- 33:30They see things that aren't actually happening, and they will react to things
- 33:37that aren't actually happening, and it'll feel very real to them. So to
- 33:40the narcisstic individual, they do to their adaptation growing up, believe that they
- 33:47are the center of the universe and that everything they do is awesome. They
- 33:52need to believe that. They don't deep down really believe that, but they
- 33:55are convincing themselves of this. And when he was watching these women, and
- 34:02I'll talk about my conceptualization as to the attachment jury that could lead to all
- 34:07this stuff, and it does make some sense to me. But just talking
- 34:09about this, you know, sadism versus not sadism. He's voyeuristically harming the
- 34:16women, the girls, and because he believes he's so special, he thinks,
- 34:22well, of course they would love this attention because it's me giving it
- 34:27right. And if he believed that, then it doesn't necessarily mean that as
- 34:31sadistic. He thinks he's in a mutually consensual relationship. You know, I
- 34:37gave the analogy in an earlier chapter of a boy on the playground who has
- 34:44a crush on a girl and he is behind a tree watching her play soccer,
- 34:50and he you know, let's say that the girl at lunch throws away
- 34:55like a note, like she gets a note from a friend and throws it
- 34:59away, and the boy goes over the garbage can and run. I mean
- 35:02that sound kind of silly, but you know, kids rummage to the garbage
- 35:07can. Or maybe something more mundane is the girl is reading a note and
- 35:13he kind of walks by and looks over her shoulder to kind of read the
- 35:16note. That's invasive, and the girl is not consenting to that. And
- 35:22if you ask the boy, does the girl know that you're watching her play
- 35:27soccer or does the girl consent to that? Is the girl okay with that?
- 35:31The boy might say I don't know, So that we wouldn't say that's
- 35:36great. We would want to pull that kid aside and help them out.
- 35:39With this, but you wouldn't think that they were like a psychopath or that
- 35:43they're sadistic. Right, Well, it's possible that that's where he was coming
- 35:46from, where Steve developmentally where he was coming from, which I'll get into
- 35:52more in a second. So it's hard to say, you can let me
- 35:55know what you think. Do you think he was legit sadistic? There's a
- 35:59lot of evidence there and I certainly couldn't argue against it. But if we
- 36:05believe his primary foundation, personality wise was narcissism, that also can explain his
- 36:12behavior without sadism needing to be present. So the data that we have in
- 36:19this area of sadism narcisism is when he would talk in his journal about Susan,
- 36:25and when he confessed to Susan, we heard in the recording him saying,
- 36:30maybe I'm wrong, but I kind of I'm getting a signal from you.
- 36:35So in his journal he would also say thing, you know, he'd
- 36:37say, I don't know, maybe I'm getting the wrong signals, and then
- 36:40he would say yeah, but no, no, she loves me, you
- 36:43know, she's into this. But there was kind of a question mark there
- 36:46for him. And if there's a question mark. Then there's a possibility.
- 36:52I think he genuinely believed that these women Susan they were into it. So
- 36:59it for for sadists. They know their victim does not want to be into
- 37:04it. They need their victim not to be into it. There wouldn't be
- 37:07a question if a sadist, a sexual sadist were trying to get their sexual
- 37:12sadism needs met and they had a question mark as to whether or not their
- 37:16target was consenting or not, they would make sure that it wasn't consent,
- 37:22or they would amp up the assault to make sure that there's no way that
- 37:25she's consenting to this right, or he would just pack up and move on
- 37:30to another victim because he doesn't. He's not looking for someone that wants to
- 37:32consent. That's what the sadist wants. They don't want consent, They need
- 37:37the individual to not want it. So that really flies in the face of
- 37:44what we saw in the journal and what we heard him say. At least
- 37:46there was a question mark. Now I think there's some nuance here, which
- 37:51I'll get to you in a second. But on the other hand, he
- 37:52targeted children. It's hard to imagine that even he could believe that children would
- 37:58consent to that right. Also, the shear fact that he even targeted the
- 38:02children is a tick in the column of sadism because sadists will often target children,
- 38:08like a sexual sadist might not be attracted to children, but because children
- 38:15are so easily victimized. Sometimes, depending they might say, well, I'm
- 38:21not attracted to kids, but it'd be really satisfying to get my sadism needs
- 38:27met easily through a child that's easily victimized, So they're willing to overlook their
- 38:35natural attraction to get their sadism needs met. Was that happening with Stephen,
- 38:40you know? Could be. There was also evidence that he legit was attracted
- 38:45to children, as evidenced by his journal talking about how he's attracted to his
- 38:47own daughter. Now, a tick in the non sadistic column is that he
- 38:53yammered about his relationship with Susan to a lot of people, including the press.
- 39:00For typical sadists, non narcissistic statists the very least. But for statistic
- 39:06people, they know what they're doing. They want the target to not consent,
- 39:12they want to commit the crime, and he was yammering about it and
- 39:19tempting the press well, he would just flat out tell the press, but
- 39:22he was tempting the police and everyone, and he knew it because I'm pretty
- 39:24sure Michael was telling him, like, you got to stop. So the
- 39:28fact that he was flaunting it, I think points in the direction that he
- 39:32semi delusionally believed that him and Susan had a mutual consensual relationship. So I
- 39:39was just taking that column. The other thing is is he definitely suffered from
- 39:44narcissistic personality according to the data, so at the very least he had some
- 39:50semi delusional beliefs. So you know, that's a ticking the column of the
- 39:53non sadism. But given the entirety of the data, I think he mostly
- 40:00believed or suspected that his victims were consenting, even though they weren't. But
- 40:04I think he did get off on not being sure because if he truly believed
- 40:10that they were consenting, then he would have said so in his diary.
- 40:16And with Susan Wright, he always was wondering. And if he's wondering,
- 40:22then how does he continue doing it? Because you know, if we go
- 40:27off the premise of he's only doing it because he thinks that they're consenting,
- 40:30well, he didn't really know that they were, so how could he get
- 40:34How could he have so much energy around something that he had a major question
- 40:38mark about and no data around There was no confirmation as to the consent.
- 40:44So you know, it's maybe a little bit of sadistic or a type of
- 40:49sadism light, you know, diet sadism if you will, and that he
- 40:54wanted to play sadism, but not be full statistic. I don't know,
- 41:00but if I were to put it into percentages, I would say the behavior
- 41:07was eighty five percent narcisism based and fifteen percent sadism based. All right,
- 41:13So that's the dark Tet trad Now let's conclude Steven's conceptualization with my conceptualization or
- 41:22my hypothesis about the attachment injury that I think he might have gone through.
- 41:25Now, in this section, it's highly speculative. We just don't have much
- 41:30data to go off of, or any data about his childhood. But when
- 41:35I started to gravitate towards this conceptualization, it felt satisfying. It could be
- 41:44psychobabble, but I wouldn't be surprised if there's something along his lines. So
- 41:47I'm guessing that his childhood Steven's childhood was not pleasant. I don't know how
- 41:53it you know exactly the configuration was, but I wouldn't be surprised if his
- 41:58dad was a narcissistic and abuse like himself, and that his mom was cold
- 42:04and withholding but not abusive. If that's true, then it's possible that he
- 42:10split his mom. If you're familiar, it's a defense, and all children
- 42:15start off this is the default way that children enter the world is that they
- 42:20can't handle gray zones. So they see their parents as two different people,
- 42:25the all good version and the all bad version. And there's all this psychodynamic,
- 42:30psychoanalytic object relations, you know, concepts I could get into, but
- 42:36just go with me on that. And so for Stephen, he might have
- 42:40idolized his mother because she was the non abusive one, but she was distant,
- 42:45but she was a container for his all good hopes. You know.
- 42:51It's like, well, I can't really I can't really look at my dad
- 42:53and see any or much goodness, but I can with my mom. Even
- 42:59though my mom is very distant, but she's not harming me, So I'm
- 43:02going to worship her. She's all good, she is wonderful, but she's
- 43:07at a distance, and I want her, but I'm I'm way over here
- 43:12emotionally, maybe even physically, and I'm or I'm at the window waiting for
- 43:15her to come home. Did she just drive by? And it starts to
- 43:20create this ongoing relational theme of worship watching from afar, longing, believing that
- 43:32salvation is just around the corner, having fantasies that, oh, mom wants
- 43:38to spend time with me, but she's too busy with dad or with work.
- 43:42But I know that. I mean, you know, when I describe
- 43:45this, it sounds really really sad, right, But if true, it
- 43:52really translates to the stocking and the spying and the voyeurism that he committed,
- 43:58particularly on Susan. Because I can't know, but I've worked with cases like
- 44:06this. Sometimes it's thematically similar, but it looks a lot different. But
- 44:13anyway, so it's possible that that's what he was doing when he was young,
- 44:16and then it locks in this association. And also he recreates it later
- 44:21in life because that's what we tend to do. And so he has his
- 44:24wife Teresa. Oh so that's the other thing is he splits his mom,
- 44:30so his mom has an all good version and an all bad version. The
- 44:34all good version is think of the Susan in his mind. You know,
- 44:37he was infatuated with not Susan, but the Susan in his mind, which
- 44:45points in the direction that there was some object that he had locked in on
- 44:49early in life. Then the all bad object, the all bad mother object,
- 44:54was Teresa, his wife. He attacked her, he abused her,
- 44:59he put her down, and she's evil, she's withholding, she's stupid.
- 45:07Because naturally, if your mom is not being there for you and you feel
- 45:10very bad about yourself, you have a lot of anger at her too.
- 45:14But you can't hold on to that and the same person because they will annihilate
- 45:17each other. And children have a hard time with gray zone anyway. And
- 45:22the way that healthy development happens is children learn how to integrate those two parts
- 45:30where they can see their mother as mostly good with a little bit of bad,
- 45:35and I and themselves it's mostly good with a little bit of bad.
- 45:38But if you aren't allowed to go through the developmental steps emotionally, well,
- 45:45then you retain that all bad all good, that black and white thinking and
- 45:51the splitting. So it just kind of makes sense to me, But it's
- 45:55a lot of speculation, of course, but it does make sense to me.
- 45:59All right, Well, that does it for that consumtization. Let's take
- 46:04a break. When I get back from the break, I'm gonna give my
- 46:07full Josh analysis, but that'll be for the patrons of the podcasts, and
- 46:13this will be if you're not a patron, this will be the end to
- 46:15the whole series. And if you've watched all the free versions, listen to
- 46:19the free versions. I thank you. It's nice that you've paid attention and
- 46:28let me know what you think about all the things that we've talked about.
- 46:30You know, it's been quite a journey. There's a lot of information,
- 46:34a lot of twists and turns, a lot of details. It's been a
- 46:38really fascinating story to look into and to digest and to coalesce into an outline
- 46:45to talk about anyway, So take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 46:49You really really do.