Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Commercial Arbitration
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration, Commercial
- 0:06Arbitration. I'm Belinda McCauley, executive
- 0:08director and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:12I'm delighted to be here today to introduce our
- 0:14speakers, Erin Gotthelf and David Coher. Aaron
- 0:18is Vice President of the American Arbitration
- 0:21Association's Commercial Division for the Pacific
- 0:23region, overseeing California, Oregon, Washington,
- 0:26and Alaska. He serves as the National Chair of
- 0:29AAA's Entertainment Dispute Resolution Advisory
- 0:32Council and the Western U .S. Chair for their
- 0:35Health Care Dispute Resolution Advisory Council.
- 0:38Prior to joining AAA, he was the Northern California
- 0:41Regional Director for Judicate West. David is
- 0:44a mediator and arbitrator at Coher ADR with extensive
- 0:49experience in legal practice, corporate counsel,
- 0:52and legislative service. He's held key roles
- 0:54at Southern California Edison, Irvin, Cohen,
- 0:57and Jessup are across the street neighbors, and
- 0:59as legislative counsel to a US congressman. David
- 1:02also serves as an ADR panelist for the US District.
- 1:05Court, Central District of California, and has
- 1:08held numerous civic leadership positions, including
- 1:11chairing the Pasadena Board of Zoning Appeals.
- 1:14And now, let's get started learning all about
- 1:17commercial arbitration. OK, thank you so much,
- 1:20Belinda. I'm going to share my screen here. And
- 1:25David, let me know when you see it up. It's up.
- 1:31You're ready to go. OK, very good. Thanks, Belinda,
- 1:33for the introduction. Appreciate it. All right.
- 1:37Well, everybody, welcome to the Nuts and Bolts
- 1:38of Commercial Arbitration. I'm glad you're spending
- 1:40the afternoon with us here. A little bit about
- 1:43the program before we get started. This is a
- 1:46program that's going to take you kind of everything
- 1:49from the filing of the demand all the way to
- 1:51the issuance of the award. And it's going to
- 1:53be best probably for attorneys that are maybe
- 1:56a little bit more junior in their career that
- 1:58have actually never gone through a full scale
- 2:00arbitration, or just folks that are looking to
- 2:03kind of brush up on their skills and understand
- 2:04the process. This is part of a series of programs
- 2:07we're going to be doing with the Beverly Hills
- 2:08Bar Association. Today we're going to discuss
- 2:10commercial arbitration, but we have upcoming
- 2:13programs for education and construction that'll
- 2:17be a little bit later into 2026. So without further
- 2:21ado, let's go advance to the first slide here.
- 2:26So basically it all starts with the arbitration
- 2:28clause and today we're not going to be We're
- 2:31not selling a product or a service here. So I'm
- 2:33not going to focus on necessarily any one provider
- 2:35But pretty much the process is very similar between
- 2:38lots of the different providers and it starts
- 2:41with an arbitration clause arbitration clauses
- 2:43are the way cases end up in arbitration and I
- 2:47always like to say that the five parts of the
- 2:50arbitration clause that are most important are
- 2:53the rules to be used The location of the arbitration,
- 2:59sometimes referred to as the seat of the arbitration,
- 3:02whether it's going to be heard by a single arbitrator
- 3:04or a panel of arbitrators. And the governing
- 3:10law of the arbitration, not just substantive
- 3:13but also procedural law in California, we have
- 3:15the California Arbitration Act. And then lastly,
- 3:19if there's some sort of cost shifting provision
- 3:21where the winning sides entitled to recover attorneys
- 3:27fees arbitration costs etc and you obviously
- 3:29you want to be very specific about what constitutes
- 3:32attorneys fees arbitration costs etc oftentimes
- 3:36it's just attorneys fees that might be recoverable
- 3:38sometimes it's the cost of the entire arbitration
- 3:40and so the more clear you can be in an arbitration
- 3:42provision the easier the arbitrator will have
- 3:46understanding exactly what authority they have
- 3:48and I just on this slide here drafted a very
- 3:51basic Arbitration provision here that covers
- 3:55all the five things that I mentioned and So just
- 3:59in the materials here. It's something to take
- 4:00a look at Yeah, and I'll just note on this. You
- 4:04know what Aaron has here is it is basic, but
- 4:06it's also thorough I find in practice that unfortunately
- 4:11arbitration clauses are not always as thorough
- 4:14They will leave key pieces out and it's important
- 4:17that you bring those issues up early on in the
- 4:20arbitration and get those sorted out before the
- 4:23issues they present come full throttle into the
- 4:27into the hearing. And the reason I chose those
- 4:29five elements that are the most important parts
- 4:31of an arbitration provision because realistically
- 4:33you could put dozens or hundreds of different
- 4:35things into an arbitration provision but those
- 4:37five things tend to be the things that are the
- 4:39most commonly fought about and then when there
- 4:42is an issue or a disagreement as far as how what
- 4:45the arbitration clause says. Oftentimes, it asks
- 4:47to go to somebody like David to kind of interpret
- 4:50it. Or in a worst case situation, the parties
- 4:53don't even want to start the arbitration. They
- 4:54want to go straight to court. They're going to
- 4:56file a TRO to stop the arbitration. They're going
- 4:58to ask a judge to sort out. in this 100 plus
- 5:02page contract, why buried on page 87 clause 2a,
- 5:07there's a three -word arbitration provision or
- 5:10a one -sentence arbitration provision that makes
- 5:11absolutely no sense. So if you're going to spend
- 5:14all that time drafting that giant contract, spend
- 5:17a little time actually working on the arbitration
- 5:19provision. So this is basically the best overall
- 5:26synopsis I can give you in a single graphic or
- 5:28a single slide. with start to finish what a commercial
- 5:32arbitration looks like. Not just commercial arbitration,
- 5:35but a lot of other arbitrations kind of follow
- 5:37the same pattern. And what I like about this
- 5:41chart is it also kind of gives you a rough estimate
- 5:44on the number of days kind of each step takes.
- 5:46Now this is based off of a standard kind of large
- 5:50complex commercial case arbitration in the timeline
- 5:53attached here. And you know some people might
- 5:56say This seems like it takes a while. It's almost
- 6:00a year long, maybe this process. But we study
- 6:05kind of how long the federal district court takes
- 6:07in various state courts, county by county take
- 6:10to get your case from filing to an actual jury
- 6:13verdict. And oftentimes it's three or four years.
- 6:17So the simple fact that arbitration can resolve
- 6:20most disputes in under a single year. proves
- 6:23that arbitration is still a faster, usually more
- 6:25cost -effective way to resolve disputes than
- 6:27traditional arbitration. So again, filing initiation,
- 6:32the first step, and I'll have individual slides
- 6:33in each of these. Arbitrator selection period,
- 6:37the preliminary hearing, which is the first time
- 6:38the parties actually get to interact with the
- 6:40arbitrator and set out the course for the rest
- 6:42of the process. And then you can see on my chart
- 6:46here, The period that takes the most amount of
- 6:49time seems to be the information exchange and
- 6:51discovery period. Now, discovery doesn't have
- 6:53to take so long if there aren't lots of discovery
- 6:56disputes. And we're going to talk about how to
- 6:57handle discovery disputes a little later on in
- 6:59the presentation. But discovery disputes do sometimes
- 7:03really gum up the process if you will and kind
- 7:06of lengthen it. The mediation step at AAA we're
- 7:09really pro using mediation to resolve disputes
- 7:12and if the parties can use mediation at some
- 7:15point during the arbitration process to resolve
- 7:17the dispute prior to the evidentiary hearing
- 7:19taking place it's going to save the parties a
- 7:21lot of time and money. The hearing itself the
- 7:23evidentiary hearing which is like your your trial,
- 7:26if you will. The post -hearing submission period,
- 7:29which would be post -hearing briefing, as well
- 7:31as briefing on attorney's fees and costs if there's
- 7:33a prevailing party provision written to the arbitration
- 7:37provision. And then, of course, the award. And
- 7:40there's lots of different ways an award can be
- 7:42drafted. It can be as simple as a simple award.
- 7:46This is what the winning side gets. you know,
- 7:51essentially why they get it, to a more reasoned
- 7:55award where it can be very many pages long, where
- 7:58you explain the decision -making process between
- 8:01each of the individual elements of the claim
- 8:04or claims. Okay, so filing and initiation, and
- 8:10I'm going to go over the first couple slides,
- 8:11and David's going to be a little bit more towards
- 8:13the end of the presentation, because then we're
- 8:14talking about the more substantive stuff that
- 8:16David gets involved with. as an arbitrator. I'm
- 8:19an administrator, David's an arbitrator, so different
- 8:22roles here. So filing the submission and initiation.
- 8:26So the client basically submits their demand
- 8:27for arbitration, copy the arbitration provision,
- 8:31which is in the contract between the parties
- 8:32and the appropriate filing fee to AAA. It's really
- 8:35simple. And while you can... File and arbitration,
- 8:41just with these three elements, we usually prefer,
- 8:44and I'm sure David actually prefers, to get a
- 8:47full complaint drafted along with the demand
- 8:49for arbitration. Sometimes parties are trying
- 8:52to do their arbitrations relatively quick, and
- 8:56so they'll just fill out the demand for arbitration
- 8:58form, send in a copy of the contract with the
- 9:00arbitration provision highlighted, and pay the
- 9:02filing fee. But the demand for arbitration form
- 9:05is very basic. It just talks about fill in the
- 9:07blank who the parties are, who their counsel
- 9:10are, people's addresses, how much money you're
- 9:13seeking or whatever particular damages are, maybe
- 9:14possibly injunctive, and then basically a two
- 9:17or three sentence synopsis of what happened.
- 9:20That's not going to be enough information for
- 9:22David to process anything. So David, do you have
- 9:25anything to add to that? Yeah, I'll say, you
- 9:28know, I see I don't know what the split is, but
- 9:31I see a good number of cases where it is just
- 9:33a simple demand form because people want to get
- 9:36the process started quickly. And then other cases
- 9:39where the demand is much more akin to a fully
- 9:43drafted complaint. If it is something where it's
- 9:46not that fully drafted complaint, then that's
- 9:49going to be one of the first issues that we discuss
- 9:51really after the items of the arbitration clause
- 9:54in the preliminary hearing, because we're going
- 9:57to have to have time allotted for that. And then,
- 9:59of course, for an answer from the respondent
- 10:03regarding what is in that later amended demand.
- 10:09But at the end of the day, you know, there is
- 10:11going to be a need to specify what it is that
- 10:14if you're the claimant side, what it is that
- 10:17you're looking for, what has been done wrong
- 10:20here, why that is wrong, before you can really
- 10:24get into the meat of the information exchange
- 10:26so that there's some guardrails as to what information
- 10:30needs to be exchanged. All right, so the AAA
- 10:34acknowledges receipt to all the parties and sets
- 10:37a deadline for the respondent to answer or file
- 10:39a counterclaim. I would say the vast majority
- 10:43of answers filed don't initially include a counterclaim
- 10:49but again that's going to be something that David's
- 10:52going to discuss in his preliminary hearing call
- 10:54where he essentially is going to ask, can I anticipate
- 11:00a counterclaim being filed because that's going
- 11:02to obviously add to the timeline, to the process.
- 11:05It's also very important, steps one and two here.
- 11:09Any time anything's filed, so that initial demand
- 11:11for arbitration, arbitration provision, and then
- 11:14the filing fee, that demand for arbitration needs
- 11:18to be served at the same time also on the respondent.
- 11:21So occasionally we get submissions, situations
- 11:24where the claimant forgot to serve simultaneously
- 11:27the demand and sometimes the demand and complaint
- 11:29on the respondent. So the first time the respondent
- 11:33even knows about the case is when we reach out
- 11:35to them to set up an administrative call. It
- 11:37shouldn't be like that. They should know that
- 11:38there's been a case filed against them. If no
- 11:43arbitration clause exists or the AAA is not named
- 11:46as a resolution provider in the party's contract,
- 11:48it's a bit of a different process. So you use
- 11:51a different form called the Submission to Dispute
- 11:53Resolution form. And essentially, if we're not
- 11:57named as the provider or arbitration isn't named
- 11:59as a method of resolving the dispute, for us
- 12:02to handle the case, both parties have to agree
- 12:04in writing to perceive a AAA to administer the
- 12:07case. And that's what's on the Submission to
- 12:09Dispute Resolution form. There is a box that
- 12:11says, I shouldn't say both parties, I should
- 12:14say all parties, because sometimes there's more
- 12:16than two parties in an arbitration, but essentially
- 12:18all parties would have to sign off on the form
- 12:21that they agreed to proceed with a triple A arbitration.
- 12:25Again, typically the filing party submits a formal
- 12:29complaint with the demand for arbitration, but
- 12:31not always, and it's very useful to David because
- 12:34if he actually gets a formal complaint along
- 12:37with the demand for arbitration, he can read
- 12:39that and start studying that in advance of the
- 12:42preliminary hearing so he might know what questions
- 12:44to ask you. It makes his life a lot easier as
- 12:46the arbitrator. You know, this is a common source
- 12:50of confusion. If the respondent fails to submit
- 12:53an answer by the AAA established deadline, their
- 12:57non -response is just treated as a general denial
- 13:00of all claims. You don't automatically win your
- 13:02arbitration just because the respondent never
- 13:05responded to your demand for arbitration in your
- 13:08claim. It's treated as a general denial of all
- 13:11claims. And sometimes the arbitrator at the preliminary
- 13:15hearing might actually say, like, I really could
- 13:17use an answer. It would help me with the process.
- 13:21David, do you ever ask them at the preliminary
- 13:23hearing if they haven't actually submitted one?
- 13:25Yeah, it's sometimes it's a preliminary hearing
- 13:28sometimes that's at a follow -up hearing if it's
- 13:31a later submitted demand, but That that's gonna
- 13:35help minimize issues later on right having that
- 13:38answer having me the explanation on file of why
- 13:42as the Respondent your client did not do something
- 13:46wrong as alleged in the demand I mean, that's
- 13:49really what it boils down to is just telling
- 13:53that initial part of the story and more so than
- 13:56necessarily trying to guide the presentation
- 13:59of the hearing at the evidentiary hearing or
- 14:01something like that. These are, it's a helpful
- 14:04phase to help set the limits on what is going
- 14:09to be the subject of the arbitration because
- 14:13even though it's arbitration, even though it's
- 14:15designed to be more efficient, You know, there's
- 14:19a lot of emotions can run high and that can mean
- 14:22that parties can get carried away and so these
- 14:25Limits on what is the subject of the dispute?
- 14:28That's before me as an arbitrator is important
- 14:31for me to be able to provide those Guardrails
- 14:35that are going to keep the proceeding efficient
- 14:37and keep it from turning into you know, a three
- 14:40four year litigation affair Yeah All right, so
- 14:45the next stage, so essentially once the arbitration
- 14:47has been filed and assuming it's been filed properly,
- 14:50a case manager at AAA will reach out to the parties
- 14:53and set up a basic administrative call. And this
- 14:57administrative call is basically to make sure
- 15:00the parties are in agreement, if they are in
- 15:01agreement on what the terms of the arbitration
- 15:03provision say, confirm location, confirm claim
- 15:07amounts. all that kind of stuff. And sometimes
- 15:10in the arbitration provision it actually lists
- 15:13a fairly detailed process and how an arbitrator
- 15:14is going to be selected. For example, sometimes
- 15:16it might say the arbitrators are to be party
- 15:18appointed arbitrators, right? And each side selects
- 15:20their own arbitrator and the two arbitrators
- 15:22would select a neutral arbitrator. Sometimes
- 15:24it actually says the good old -fashioned rank
- 15:26-and -strike method. It might say a single arbitrator
- 15:28to be selected by the rank -and -strike method
- 15:30and the AAA will put together a list of resumes
- 15:34that the case manager thinks are appropriate
- 15:37for the case and the parties will do their ranking
- 15:38and striking. Sometimes it's completely silent
- 15:42and then when it's completely silent the case
- 15:45manager basically says how do you want to go
- 15:47about selecting an arbitrator for the case. If
- 15:50the parties are not in agreement on the process
- 15:52then you usually have to default to the traditional
- 15:54rank and strike method. When you're discussing
- 15:58with the case manager or case administrator what
- 16:03you're looking for in arbitrator, I always like
- 16:05to say that the right arbitrator for your case
- 16:06is the arbitrator with the correct subject matter
- 16:08expertise. So every once in a while, I run into
- 16:10a situation where I'll get one party that says,
- 16:15I don't care what the background of the arbitrator
- 16:19is. They just have to be a retired state or a
- 16:21federal judge. And I sometimes dig down a little
- 16:24deeper into that because I might say, you know,
- 16:26this is a fairly complex IP dispute involving
- 16:31semiconductors. And are you telling me you'd
- 16:35rather have a judge that has no experience in
- 16:38the technology space and knows nothing about
- 16:40semiconductors, as opposed to, let's say, an
- 16:43attorney arbitrator that's practiced for 30 years
- 16:45at an AMLaw100 firm in the technology practice
- 16:48and has wrote the treatise on every single semiconductor
- 16:50book out there. So essentially, I really encourage
- 16:56people to, when they're selecting an arbitrator,
- 16:59say, you know what? I can move a little bit away
- 17:01from titles and things like that. Maybe it doesn't
- 17:04have to necessarily be a retired state or federal
- 17:06judge. I could go with the subject matter expert
- 17:07or an attorney arbitrator if I really feel like
- 17:10their experience is spot on. Because that's going
- 17:12to give you the best result. Oftentimes when
- 17:14an arbitrator is selected that does not have
- 17:16the correct experience to match the dispute,
- 17:19they are going to spend a lot more time trying
- 17:21to learn the law. And because arbitrators charge
- 17:25hourly, they're going to be billing you all these
- 17:27extra hours to learn stuff that they should already
- 17:29know if they were an expert in the field. All
- 17:32right. So I say think beyond the rank and strike
- 17:34list. If you have a good working relationship
- 17:36with the posing council, why not select the arbitrator
- 17:38together? If you're getting along with the posing
- 17:41council, The best way to select an arbitrator
- 17:44is to ask the ADR provider or the case manager
- 17:47to say, hey, who do you think would be good for
- 17:49this? You don't have to send the resumes in a
- 17:52formal strike and strike kind of format, but
- 17:54just send us a bunch of resumes, and we're going
- 17:56to exchange those resumes with each other and
- 17:58kind of talk it out. Absolutely use the ADR provider
- 18:02staff. We spend a lot of time putting together
- 18:05arbitrator lists. We know who's probably best
- 18:09for your dispute based on our experience. One
- 18:11thing I'd like to point out is sometimes an arbitrator
- 18:15may have the experience you're looking for, but
- 18:17because arbitrators can't have 10, 15, 20, 30
- 18:21page long resumes, no one's going to read past
- 18:23page two. The experience might not be listed
- 18:27on their resume. So if based on where they've
- 18:31practiced law, or some of the subject matter
- 18:34you see in their resume, you think they might
- 18:36have the right expertise for your case, but you're
- 18:38not quite sure, just give the case manager a
- 18:41call. Say, hey, can you reach out to this arbitrator
- 18:43and ask them if they have experience with X,
- 18:45Y, and Z? Because we're considering bringing
- 18:48them on board. And lastly, and this is. unfortunately
- 18:52not utilized enough. Sometimes interviewing an
- 18:55arbitrator jointly, where all the parties get
- 18:57together and they ask the arbitrator questions
- 18:59about their experience, arbitrating particular
- 19:01types of cases, is a really great way to get
- 19:04to know the arbitrator and really kind of look
- 19:07beyond just a paper resume and kind of into whether
- 19:10they'd be right for your case. Obviously, all
- 19:13parties have to be in the interview at the same
- 19:15time, so there's no ex parte communication. And
- 19:18it's also, this isn't the opportunity for you
- 19:21to start arguing the merits of your case. You're
- 19:24simply interviewing the arbitrator about their
- 19:26experience. Okay, and then I'm going to bring
- 19:30David in in just a second to kind of discuss
- 19:32the process, but as David mentioned, or as I
- 19:35mentioned a little bit earlier, the first step
- 19:37is the preliminary hearing in the process. So
- 19:40the preliminary hearing is when the parties in
- 19:43the arbitrator actually come together, and the
- 19:46point of the preliminary hearing is to obviously
- 19:49set out the timeline for the case so the arbitrator
- 19:51can draft a scheduling order. but also to discuss
- 19:55any possible wrinkles or disruptions along the
- 19:59way that might be encountered. Everything from
- 20:02potential discovery disputes to now the respondent,
- 20:07which has already filed an answer, would like
- 20:08to file a counterclaim, whether some sort of
- 20:11emergency relief or declaratory relief has to
- 20:14be made kind of right away within the case, and
- 20:17things that the arbitration provision might say.
- 20:19A lot of times arbitration provisions might have
- 20:20things like accelerator clauses in them and stuff
- 20:23like that, where it gives a certain timeline
- 20:25to complete the arbitration. Obviously it's important
- 20:28to have the discussion with the arbitration arbitrary
- 20:30to what their timeline looks like to make sure
- 20:32everything can go along that timeline or if an
- 20:35extension has to be asked for at that time. So
- 20:38you'd want to meet and confer with opposing counsel.
- 20:41And again, if it's more than two parties, all
- 20:43parties together on at least two or three mutually
- 20:46convenient sets of final hearing dates. I understand
- 20:48that oftentimes respondents like to kick things
- 20:50out further than claimants because claimants
- 20:52are trying to get their award relatively soon.
- 20:55But it's always good to have a good number of
- 20:57dates. You should always have a general idea
- 21:01of witness availability in addition to the hearing
- 21:03dates. That's going to be obviously very important
- 21:06if you're going to be presenting witnesses. Confidentially
- 21:09and possible protective order requests. Sometimes
- 21:11protective orders are worked out after the preliminary
- 21:15hearing, but if they can be worked out beforehand
- 21:17and just ready for the arbitrator's signature,
- 21:20literally right at the preliminary hearing, that
- 21:22might be great or even in advance. Cybersecurity
- 21:25issues, I should mention that David and I did
- 21:27a presentation actually on cybersecurity issues
- 21:32just yesterday. And David's a certified information
- 21:36security professional. So David knows all about
- 21:38this. And how electronically stored information
- 21:41will be transferred and stored. Obviously what
- 21:43happens if... information is inadvertently disclosed
- 21:47and what kind of clawback provisions will be
- 21:49worked in. And of course, the type of award you
- 21:52expect. For most large complex cases, I would
- 21:55say a reasoned award is to be expected. It doesn't
- 21:58have to be a 40 or 50 page long award, but it
- 22:01has to be enough pages for the parties to understand
- 22:04what happened. And you really want a reasoned
- 22:07award if you anticipate any enforcement actions,
- 22:09because it's very hard when you go to court and
- 22:12ask a judge to enforce an arbitration award against
- 22:14a non -paying party if it's just a simple award
- 22:17and the judge can't actually follow the timeline
- 22:19of the case, or the reasoning behind the arbitrator's
- 22:21decision. Which states govern? Which states laws
- 22:25govern the choice of law provision? This is particularly
- 22:28important if you're dealing with parties in multiple
- 22:30states. Every party is going to say their state's
- 22:33laws govern, and that may not necessarily be
- 22:35true. Of course, if you had written into the
- 22:36arbitration provision in the first place, you
- 22:38wouldn't have this dispute. Procedural issues,
- 22:41are we going by the FAA, the CAA, which act are
- 22:44we going to use for procedural issues? And then
- 22:46lastly, are there any jurisdictional issues proceeding
- 22:49in arbitration? Occasionally on the preliminary
- 22:50hearing call, we're going to get one party that
- 22:54says, my client's not a party to this contract.
- 22:59For x y and z reason therefore the arbitration
- 23:02provision doesn't apply to my contract. They
- 23:04shouldn't have to go through this arbitration
- 23:06You know, we want the arbitrator to make a determination
- 23:09on that and somebody like David is through the
- 23:12AAA rules is impaled with the authority to rule
- 23:16on jurisdictional issues now occasionally There's
- 23:18going to be somebody that's really really upset
- 23:20that doesn't believe the law allows The arbitrator
- 23:23to make these decisions and wants to again run
- 23:25to court file a TRO get lots of people involved.
- 23:30Listen, anytime you go to court, whatever confidentiality
- 23:33provisions that kind of existed in arbitration,
- 23:35being a confidential process, are completely
- 23:37out the window. Now it's all in the public court
- 23:39docket. And going to court, as you know, is very
- 23:42expensive and not for it quickly. So David, you
- 23:43want to add anything to this slide? Yeah, so
- 23:47I'll say first off regarding this slide, I think
- 23:48this is an excellent outline for either, ideally,
- 23:54A pre preliminary hearing call with opposing
- 23:58counsel or councils to review what are the issues
- 24:02that are going to need to be addressed by the
- 24:04arbitrator and also to identify those issues
- 24:07so that you can bring them forward for the arbitrator
- 24:11to set an appropriate schedule for resolving
- 24:15whether it's something regarding something as.
- 24:20Fundamental as a jurisdictional issue or a choice
- 24:24of law provision, which states laws apply, things
- 24:29of that nature. Oftentimes, these are issues
- 24:32that if you spend a little time working it through
- 24:34with opposing counsel, you can identify. I don't,
- 24:39as an arbitrator, expect you to come to the preliminary
- 24:43hearing with all these issues sorted out. Obviously,
- 24:47there's a dispute underlying this, that it's
- 24:50not reasonable. But what is reasonable, I think,
- 24:53is that when there's a situation where you're
- 24:55able to work with opposing counsel to identify
- 24:58the issues, and that way you can both succinctly
- 25:01present, here's our brief view of the situation,
- 25:07then the other sides, any... third parties or
- 25:10beyond and then we can figure out what's needed
- 25:13to resolve those issues and what order to resolve
- 25:17them in in an orderly fashion because the alternative
- 25:20is if you show up at the preliminary hearing
- 25:23and you haven't had that discussion it's gonna
- 25:26take longer to have the pulmonary hearing. But
- 25:29for me, it's really key to get these issues sorted
- 25:32out. Or I'll point out just the worst case scenario,
- 25:33not to cut you off, is yes, it'll take longer
- 25:35to do the pulmonary hearing, where worst case
- 25:38scenario is you have to do the pulmonary hearing
- 25:40all over again, right? Because you didn't have
- 25:43enough information even to do it. That's exactly
- 25:44right. So go, sorry David. And that's exactly
- 25:47where I was going, Aaron. It can end in a situation
- 25:52where you're doing multiple iterations because
- 25:57if folks don't go through this list and be thorough
- 26:02at the preliminary hearing, and so I think this
- 26:05is a great list of items. And again, your clients
- 26:10want you to go through one preliminary hearing,
- 26:12not two. They want to pay for one, not two. Exactly.
- 26:15We're in arbitration, largely for efficiency,
- 26:19and to deliver that, that means having to think
- 26:22ahead and just plan right and be prepared so
- 26:26all right so i'll continue with other things
- 26:28to go over uh steps to take when you're meeting
- 26:30conferring before the plenary hearing um is the
- 26:32case proceeding under the correct rules Oftentimes,
- 26:36unfortunately, and this happens with AAA clauses,
- 26:39jam clauses, et cetera, that it just says, according
- 26:42to the American Arbitration Association rules.
- 26:45And that's not a lot of help, because we've got
- 26:48commercial rules, and construction rules, and
- 26:50consumer rules, and all sorts of different types
- 26:52of rules. And all the rules kind of handle things
- 26:55differently. So you want to confer. with the
- 26:59other side to make sure they're in agreement
- 27:00on the type of rules, especially if the term
- 27:02commercial or construction or employment is missing
- 27:05from the provision. Can the scope of the arbitration
- 27:08be narrowed? You'd be surprised how many issues
- 27:11can be resolved prior to an arbitration just
- 27:13by talking to the other side, including potentially
- 27:15the entire case itself. Some of these things
- 27:17might be misunderstandings and easily corrected.
- 27:22Are there any issues that can be resolved prior
- 27:23to the preliminary hearing? Again, if someone's
- 27:26submitting a complaint with 15 causes of action
- 27:29and you can knock off five of those causes of
- 27:32action just with some quick partial settlement
- 27:35or something like that, it might make sense to
- 27:37do it at that juncture. Has an early neutral
- 27:40evaluation session taken place, also known as
- 27:42an ENE? For those of you that don't know what
- 27:44an early neutral evaluation is, this would be
- 27:47somebody akin to a mediator. coming in that's
- 27:50a subject matter expert on your particular type
- 27:51of dispute, and they're going to study your dispute
- 27:54for a little while, and they're going to basically
- 27:57give you their opinion on how this would shake
- 28:00out if it went to a full -blown arbitration award
- 28:02or if it went to trial or something like that
- 28:05based on their experience and what they've reviewed.
- 28:07I don't think early neutral evaluations are utilized
- 28:11enough in litigation in America. I think early
- 28:15dispute resolution, particularly E &Es, are very
- 28:17useful. Will a counterclaim be filed? Again,
- 28:21it's going to change the timeline if one's going
- 28:23to be filed. And if you're the claimant and the
- 28:25respondent's filing a counterclaim, now it's
- 28:27going to change a little bit of your timeline
- 28:29in the sense that now you have to not only pursue
- 28:31your claim, but you have to defend your client
- 28:33against the counterclaim. So you need to prepare
- 28:37your client. It's going to be maybe a little
- 28:38bit more expensive and a little bit more involved
- 28:40than it was prior to the counterclaim being filed.
- 28:43Is a motion for summary disposition likely to
- 28:47be sought? So if there's going to be any type
- 28:48of dispositive motion, MSJ, whatnot, it's good
- 28:51to let the arbitrator know at the preliminary
- 28:54hearing so they can bake kind of that time into
- 28:56the timeline. And additionally, it would be useful
- 29:01to know if the respondent, let's say, is planning
- 29:04to try to knock the entire case out with an MSJ
- 29:07or just certain causes of action or individual
- 29:11parts of a claim. Will there be subpoena requests
- 29:14and will those be challenged? Depositions, subpoena
- 29:17requests, challenging subpoena requests, arguing
- 29:21about how long depots should be and who should
- 29:23be deposed and all that are some of the most
- 29:27timely and costly discovery issues that have
- 29:30to be dealt with. So if they can be dealt with
- 29:32upfront, that's going to save your client some
- 29:34time and money. Has a mediation been scheduled?
- 29:37If so, when? Oftentimes, it's very refreshing
- 29:40to me when I get on administrative call of parties,
- 29:42even before an arbitrator has been selected,
- 29:44the parties let us know that there is a date
- 29:47for a mediation on schedule and that should that
- 29:50mediation be successful, we can close the file
- 29:53on the arbitration. Sometimes they don't even
- 29:56want to go through the arbitrator selection process
- 29:58until the mediation has taken place to see if
- 29:59they can resolve it at that juncture. So again,
- 30:03very pro. mediation here at AAA, and we want
- 30:08folks to be happy with the result of their case.
- 30:11And lastly, draft a proposed joint scheduling
- 30:14order if possible. Again, I know it's very hard,
- 30:18especially maybe if you don't have the arbitrators
- 30:20full availability, to put in all of the discovery
- 30:24deadlines and counterclaim filing deadlines and
- 30:26MSJ deadlines and... evidentiary hearing dates
- 30:30and things like that. But if you can kind of
- 30:33get a very rough outline to David of all this,
- 30:36David's going to do his best to kind of work
- 30:37with what you've come up with. David, you want
- 30:39to add anything to that? Yeah, no, I'll say,
- 30:41I mean, that's what makes me happiest in a preliminary.
- 30:44If I get an email before we get on the call,
- 30:48usually the day before, but nonetheless, where
- 30:51there is a joint scheduling order. And it doesn't
- 30:54even have to be that everybody has agreement
- 30:57on the dates. I've seen joint scheduling orders
- 30:59where the council were not, it wasn't the most
- 31:05friendly of relationships. But nonetheless, they
- 31:08understood that it made sense to lay out where
- 31:11they stood and what the choices were, and to
- 31:15put that into a cohesive document, which made
- 31:18my job much easier in that regard. So again,
- 31:25it's not necessarily that you're going to reach
- 31:27agreement on all of these issues. I understand
- 31:30that. I appreciate it. I appreciate that there
- 31:33are very real and sometimes deep differences,
- 31:36but the fact that you've thought it through is
- 31:39helpful for me as the arbitrator in knowing that
- 31:42we are on the right path. And one last thing
- 31:45I want to add on to what Aaron said about discovery
- 31:48and that information exchange process. The motions
- 31:52practice around that can sometimes be the least
- 31:56efficient part of an arbitration. And because
- 31:59if you set up what it is that the case is about,
- 32:04what is the subject of the case early on, then
- 32:06you can really set those guardrails in place
- 32:10so that the whole proceeding can move along efficiently.
- 32:14All right. During the plenary hearings, so discuss
- 32:17page limits and any briefing. And I always say
- 32:19this. Any briefing in exhibits, right? Because
- 32:23we've all seen five page limits on some sort
- 32:25of brief, and then they send in 300 pages of
- 32:29exhibits that they somehow expect the arbitrator
- 32:31to all read. So let's include exhibits in that.
- 32:35And then discussing page limits on briefing can
- 32:37be done at any point during the process. It's
- 32:39basically the best thing to have an efficient
- 32:41process. If your legal secretary keeps your calendar,
- 32:45they need to be on the call with you. We get
- 32:48in these situations where the parties are arguing
- 32:51over dates and they get into a situation where
- 32:57one side says, you know what, an attorney says,
- 33:01I can't decide, I can't tell you when I'm available
- 33:03for an evidence hearing because my legal secretary
- 33:05keeps my calendar and she's not here today or
- 33:08he's not here today. That's not very useful.
- 33:10Right? You want to set the hearing within a reasonable
- 33:13time frame, even if dispositive motions have
- 33:15been planned. This is what I like to discuss
- 33:17here. It is very common to, especially, I'm beating
- 33:22up on respondents today, but I'm just trying
- 33:24to pick someone to beat up on. So it's very common
- 33:27on the plenary hearing for evidence your hearing
- 33:31dates to kind of being discussed when they should
- 33:33be. And the respondent says, I don't think it's
- 33:38appropriate today to discuss evidence of your
- 33:40hearing dates because I plan on filing a dispositive
- 33:43motion of some type. And I'm convinced that in
- 33:47totality, my dispositive motion will be granted
- 33:49and I'm going to get rid of this case. And I'd
- 33:51like to wait to see what the ruling is on my
- 33:54dispositive motion before we discuss any dates.
- 33:56Well, now we have to do the preliminary hearing
- 33:58kind of all over again, right? And we have to
- 34:00have a second one of these calls. So if you're
- 34:02going to file an MSJ, what makes the most sense
- 34:05is just kick the dates out for the evidentiary
- 34:09hearing a little bit, but get some dates on calendar
- 34:11and say, listen, I'm going to add some time into
- 34:14the timeline to get a ruling on your dispositive
- 34:17motion. And it's not going to impact the evidentiary
- 34:20hearing based on where I put it in the timeline.
- 34:24Yeah. And I'll say that when I'm dealing with
- 34:27a case, I'm going to lean very heavily. on setting
- 34:32those dates from the start so that we all have
- 34:34that understanding. It's much easier to take
- 34:37dates off of calendars than it is to add them
- 34:41on later. And it's just going to extend. And
- 34:44David, your schedule is just going to get busier
- 34:46and busier as it goes on because you get more
- 34:48new cases coming into your schedule. Not just
- 34:50my council. Everybody's. Yeah. All right. Discovery
- 34:53should be tailored to the dispute's complexity
- 34:55and issues. Now, I've just got to say this. The
- 34:58whole point of arbitration being a faster, more
- 35:00cost -effective way to resolve disputes is this
- 35:02is not general court -style discovery where we
- 35:06can do 27 depots for $100 ,000. case, right?
- 35:13I mean, that's just absolutely ridiculous. There
- 35:16has to be some proportionality to things, right?
- 35:19So you need to be prepared at the plenary hearing
- 35:21to argue for and against and set limits on certain
- 35:23types of discovery. Again, the depositions tend
- 35:26to be the most complicated. How many depots are
- 35:29we going to take? How many hours is each one
- 35:31going to last, et cetera, et cetera? Obviously,
- 35:35you want to identify issues capable of early
- 35:37resolution to narrow the scope of the hearing.
- 35:40And then, of course, set a reasonable deadline
- 35:42for filing dispositive motions. David absolutely
- 35:47likes nothing less than somebody filing an MSJ
- 35:50two days before the evidentiary hearing or something
- 35:52like that. And David won't even allow that because
- 35:55he's going to put a deadline for that MSJ well
- 35:58in advance of the evidentiary hearing. Consider
- 36:00a joint stipulation of facts. One thing when
- 36:03David is discussing, you know, what to do when
- 36:06there's a discovery dispute between the parties
- 36:08at the plenary hearing and kind of setting up
- 36:10a procedure for dealing with discovery disputes,
- 36:12the first thing he's always going to say is the
- 36:13parties should meet and confer with each other
- 36:14and see if they can work it out on their own
- 36:16before they come to him asking for resolution.
- 36:20And he will ask, say, if you can't resolve something,
- 36:25at the very least, I want to know what you can
- 36:27agree on. So you're going to have to present
- 36:28to me some sort of Joint stipulation of facts
- 36:31and then of course you want to set hearing limits
- 36:34in a mediation cutoff earlier in the process
- 36:37Here's the thing. Well, I'd like to think every
- 36:41mediation is successful resolving the case the
- 36:43day of the mediation We all know sometimes the
- 36:46parties Need a couple of days sometimes a couple
- 36:49of weeks after a mediation session to evaluate
- 36:51how that mediation session went and maybe Pass
- 36:55back and forth a few more offers and counter
- 36:57offers and whatnot So you want to make sure the
- 37:01mediation takes place Far enough in front of
- 37:05the evidentiary hearing so that it can be successful
- 37:07if it's going to resolve The the case and also
- 37:11you want to be mindful many arbitrators have
- 37:13a cancellation period Sometimes it's 14 days
- 37:17out. Sometimes it's 30 some arbitrators have
- 37:19a 60 or 90 day cancellation window There's absolutely
- 37:23nothing worse than settling a case prior to the
- 37:26evidentiary hearing And then finding out that
- 37:29you went five days into an arbitrator's cancellation
- 37:32period, and now you've got to pay for the entire
- 37:35evidentiary hearing or whatever their penalty
- 37:37is. All right. So all right. We're running a
- 37:40little bit behind, so I'm going to speed up the
- 37:42process a little bit. So information exchange
- 37:44and discovery. The parties work within the time
- 37:47frame set forth in the plenary hearing to exchange
- 37:49information and prepare the presentations. That's
- 37:51pretty straightforward right there, right? And
- 37:53then as I mentioned in the last slide, David
- 37:56or the arbitrator was going to set up a process
- 37:59for resolving any discovery disputes or if you're
- 38:01at some sort of impasse from a challenge. Again,
- 38:05discovery disputes are going to be the most sometimes
- 38:07the most costly and time -consuming part of the
- 38:09process, as David mentioned. So the parties should
- 38:12make every effort to meet and confer and resolve
- 38:14issues themselves. If the parties cannot reach
- 38:18a resolution, then they should figure out what
- 38:23they agree upon, produce that joint stipulation
- 38:26of facts. And you can even just have it on the
- 38:27same sheet. Basically, you can have one column
- 38:30that says, we agree on the following issues.
- 38:32These are the issues that we disagree on. Then
- 38:34another sheet that says, This is what party A
- 38:37thinks. This is what party B thinks. Possibly
- 38:39what party C and D think if it's a really complicated
- 38:42matter. That's going to be useful to the arbitrator
- 38:43when they're deciding how they're going to go
- 38:45about resolving the discovery dispute. And remember.
- 38:50Oftentimes these discovery disputes can be resolved
- 38:53with just basic briefing. You don't always have
- 38:56to have a full oral argument scheduled. Oral
- 38:59arguments add time to the process. People have
- 39:03to find time in their schedule to do them. A
- 39:06busy arbitrator might not have time to get your
- 39:08oral argument scheduled relatively quickly. So
- 39:12again, if it can be handled during the briefing,
- 39:15it should be handled during the briefing. David,
- 39:16you want to add anything to this slide? Yeah,
- 39:18let me add on this that I've seen it happen regularly
- 39:21where just putting together the documentation
- 39:25of what each position is from the parties and
- 39:29combining that together, working on that joint
- 39:31document, that that can end up causing for the
- 39:35parties to reach an agreement. Oftentimes it's
- 39:38an extension of time. There's some narrowing
- 39:41of what's gonna be exchanged, but the parties
- 39:44figure it out. One thing, I've been focusing
- 39:46on, look, there's gonna be disagreements and
- 39:48whatnot, but one thing that's great about arbitration
- 39:50is at the end of the day, you can agree with
- 39:54the other party or parties to change virtually
- 39:58anything. So if you guys, while working it out,
- 40:03come up with a better solution, for the discovery
- 40:07process. You can work together, present that
- 40:10to the arbitrator and ask for a change of the
- 40:14schedule, ask for a change of most any piece
- 40:19of the arbitration. And usually the arbitrator
- 40:22is gonna grant it because again, we're here to
- 40:26help move this along efficiently. So you're working
- 40:29together and finding those points of agreement.
- 40:32can narrow the issues, that's what's going to
- 40:35help move things along. And I'll just add to
- 40:38what David said. So it's a party -driven process,
- 40:41at least at AAA. So the first thing we look to
- 40:46is the law. The law supersedes anything that
- 40:49happens with our rules or the process. But beyond
- 40:52the law, the second most important thing is what
- 40:54the parties want to do. So if the parties have
- 40:57some sort of process that even if it conflicts
- 41:00with AAA's rules, if the parties are all in agreement
- 41:04and they stipulate to using whatever process
- 41:06they've created, 99 % of the time the arbitrator
- 41:10is going to agree to it and that's just fine.
- 41:12We usually only have to default to the AAA rules
- 41:16when the parties are not in agreement. Okay.
- 41:20You know, I just really quickly wanted to go
- 41:22over this slide here. Again, because discovery
- 41:25is so costly and takes a long time, at AAA we
- 41:28came up with a couple different options to try
- 41:30to make it go quicker or at least make it cost
- 41:32less money. And the single best way to save money,
- 41:35especially if you have a three arbitrator panel,
- 41:38is to have simply one arbitrator appointed to
- 41:42handle all discovery issues. That can be the
- 41:45chair. It can be a wing that the chair has delegated
- 41:48the work to, whatnot. And there's a couple of
- 41:51different options with streamlining an arbitration
- 41:53panel you can work with. Sometimes you're going
- 41:56to appoint all three arbitrators and they'll
- 41:58all take place in... take part in the preliminary
- 42:00hearing, and the two wings kind of disappear
- 42:02in the background until we get to the evidentiary
- 42:04hearing. And let's say the chair handles all
- 42:07the discovery disputes up until the hearing.
- 42:09And then there are situations where you don't
- 42:11even appoint the two wing arbitrators. You just
- 42:15literally appoint a single arbitrator, the chair
- 42:17at this point, to handle everything. And if it
- 42:20goes to an evidentiary hearing, then at that
- 42:22point, you can add on the wings. But these are
- 42:24both great ways to save money on discovery. All
- 42:28right. At AAA, and I believe other providers
- 42:31have a similar rule or kind of a process, for
- 42:36claims or counterclaims that exceed $100 ,000,
- 42:38we require the parties to make a good faith attempt
- 42:42at arbitration in advance of the evidentiary
- 42:44hearing to hopefully save them the time and cost
- 42:47of going through a full -blown evidentiary hearing.
- 42:49pre -hearing briefing, post -hearing briefing,
- 42:52attorney fee applications, paying the arbitrary
- 42:55draft of the award, et cetera, et cetera. Any
- 42:58party can unilaterally opt out of this. And it's
- 43:02always very sad when a party chooses to do that.
- 43:04But I think most parties, in my experience, are
- 43:07choosing to do some sort of mediation. Obviously,
- 43:11I mentioned it saves considerable time and money.
- 43:14The arbitrator should set the deadline for the
- 43:16mediation to be completed in the initial scheduling
- 43:19order. And they should make sure that there's
- 43:23enough time in between when that mediation is
- 43:25scheduled and when the evidentiary hearing is
- 43:27scheduled so that we're not running into anybody's
- 43:29cancellation periods and stuff like that, especially
- 43:32if the case is not resolved the day of the mediation
- 43:35and the parties need some time to think after.
- 43:38Very important. A common misconception here is
- 43:42that if I have a mediation on calendar that somehow
- 43:46acts as a stay to the rest of the arbitration
- 43:48process, including delaying the arbitration hearing,
- 43:52evidentiary hearing dates, mediation does not
- 43:54act as an automatic stay to the rest of the arbitration
- 43:57timeline that's been set forth in the initial
- 43:59scheduling order or a revised scheduling order.
- 44:02So just something to be aware of. Yeah, but I
- 44:07will say that it may not be an IMAX tape, but
- 44:09it may be a very good reason for extending out
- 44:13the dates in the arbitration. And again, if that's
- 44:15something that the parties are agreeing upon,
- 44:17we want more time for mediation, you're going
- 44:21to get that nine times that time. Exactly. So
- 44:25if both parties are in agreement or all parties
- 44:28in agreement to extend the evidentiary hearing
- 44:30dates or extend the process because they really
- 44:32think they want some time to work on the aftermath
- 44:34or the result of this mediation, then that's
- 44:38fine if that's what everybody agrees to do. All
- 44:40right. Drafting effective pre -hearing filings
- 44:42and briefs. Obviously, you want to set the stage
- 44:44for your case. a succinct, strong preliminary
- 44:48statements, the best way to start out. And you
- 44:50want to set forth your expected proofs, obviously
- 44:53stuff that, evidence that you have, right? And
- 44:57don't over promise in these situations. It's
- 45:01also really important for both sides to learn
- 45:03from MSJ's disposition rulings. You can learn
- 45:07a lot about your case, especially if you're on
- 45:09the losing end of an MSJ, potentially reading
- 45:12through what the arbitrator wrote about why you
- 45:14lost and how that might impact the evidentiary
- 45:16hearing. Obviously, state the law, focus on key
- 45:19factual issues. When you're providing case sites,
- 45:22you're going to want to provide e -links so the
- 45:24arbitrator can very quickly click on the link
- 45:27and read the case. And I think it's a good idea
- 45:31to have hard copies of key statutes and cases
- 45:34just if you're going to put together a trial
- 45:36binder for the arbitrator and whatnot. I know.
- 45:39You know, it's not the greenest thing to print
- 45:42so much stuff. And sometimes David might just
- 45:45ask for this to be an electric form, electronic
- 45:47form, and that's fine. But you should ask what
- 45:50the arbitrators are thinking about. Then, of
- 45:52course, consider eliminating motions as far as
- 45:55a process goes. David, do you have anything to
- 45:57add to this slide? No, I'll just say, I mean,
- 45:59I've had situations. So I personally prefer to
- 46:02have it in electronic format myself. But I will
- 46:06say that sometimes the other party will want
- 46:08a hard copy. And I'm not opposed to having that
- 46:12be part of the order for the evidentiary hearing.
- 46:16Again, it's much easier and better to discuss
- 46:19the issues earlier on. All right. The hearing
- 46:26presenting witnesses and evidence. All right,
- 46:28so. Obviously we talked about the importance
- 46:30of a joint stipulation of undisputed facts that's
- 46:33going to make the process go a lot faster and
- 46:34the arbitrator isn't going to have to wonder
- 46:36if the parties are in disagree about something
- 46:38and have to question the parties on that. You
- 46:40should decide usually in advance whether fact
- 46:43witnesses are going to be examined by direct
- 46:46testimony, live, or by sworn statements. If you
- 46:50already have the sworn statements, it's probably
- 46:52going to be a quicker, more cost -effective process
- 46:55to move through the case, as opposed to actually
- 46:58having witnesses travel to the evidentiary hearing
- 47:01location, testify in person, et cetera, et cetera.
- 47:05With expert witnesses, you should consider hot
- 47:07-tubbing. A lot of people say, what does hot
- 47:09-tubbing mean with witnesses? In the old days,
- 47:12the witnesses would just kind of come individually
- 47:15one by one and offer their testimony and be cross
- 47:17-examined and whatnot. Now we're seeing a lot
- 47:20of witnesses kind of just together, sitting at
- 47:23the table, being examined together and their
- 47:26points kind of. live right there. It can actually
- 47:30shave a couple of days off of an evidentiary
- 47:33hearing if everybody's kind of together. Using
- 47:37a witness's depo for submitting depo experts
- 47:40for impeachment. This is a great way to get your
- 47:45certain people impeached based on just what they've
- 47:49already written. And again, you're going to want
- 47:50to have those depo experts, depo excerpts as
- 47:57exhibits and ready to go either in a trial binder
- 48:00or some other form. Sometimes if a hearing is
- 48:04going to be held virtually, there are some of
- 48:06these Depot companies that also host virtual
- 48:09hearings for arbitrations where they can automate
- 48:12exhibits and all that kind of stuff and have
- 48:13it very easy to find and present. And then the
- 48:16issue of arbitrator questioning of witnesses.
- 48:19And I'll ask David in just a second what his
- 48:21preference is. There are some arbitrators that
- 48:24will never directly question a witness. They
- 48:27will ask their questions to counsel. And if counsel
- 48:30wants to relay that question to the witness,
- 48:32they'll listen to the witness's statement after
- 48:35counsel's question to them. It is usually faster
- 48:39and more efficient. to allow the arbitrator to
- 48:42question the witness directly. I don't see an
- 48:45issue with that. David, do you have anything
- 48:46you want to add to this or a preference? Yeah,
- 48:48I do think that's right. Although I'll say my
- 48:51practice generally is to allow for the party
- 48:54putting on the witness to question. that initial
- 48:57cross examination and then for me to bring up
- 49:01any questions because that way both sides have
- 49:04had a chance to ask it in their own way and then
- 49:07I'm not stepping into the process too much. But
- 49:10at that point, if I still have a question, quite
- 49:13frankly, it's going to be faster and easier for
- 49:16me to ask those questions, get to that point,
- 49:19and then provide a follow -up opportunity for
- 49:22redirect and further cross -examination to clean
- 49:27up anything that I may have raised during my
- 49:30questioning. But I don't want to take the initial
- 49:33step. So your preference is after cross and before
- 49:38redirect. That's when you correct. That's that's
- 49:40the sweet spot for when I do have questions I'll
- 49:44find that during direct I will be taking notes
- 49:48and I'll have kind of a list of running list
- 49:51of questions and I'm You know very grateful when
- 49:55that list of questions gets crossed off throughout
- 49:58the cross -examination process because it means
- 50:01Council's already done the job there. If there's
- 50:05something that needs to be addressed, I will,
- 50:08sometimes it'll be about jurisdictional questions,
- 50:11for example, things of that nature, that are
- 50:14more procedural in nature than about the facts
- 50:16of the substantive case, but to the extent we
- 50:19need to, we will visit those issues, but I like
- 50:22to be in that middle part so that everybody has
- 50:25an opportunity before and after. Managing exhibits,
- 50:30so we always say whether the hearing is remote
- 50:32or live, be sure all exhibits are legible and
- 50:34manageable for the arbitrary both during and
- 50:35after the hearing. There's nothing more frustrating
- 50:37than fumbling around for exhibits so you can't
- 50:39find where something is in a trial binder or
- 50:42something was put out of place if the exhibits
- 50:44are going to somehow be automated electronically.
- 50:47Joint or separate exhibits? Obviously joint exhibits
- 50:51are going to be a lot more efficient. I know
- 50:54sometimes parties really can't agree to how they
- 50:57want to put their exhibits together so it's kind
- 50:59of hard to get them to agree to this but you
- 51:01should always shoot for joint. And then obviously
- 51:03considering the wholesale admission of exhibits
- 51:05as opposed to trying to introduce each exhibit
- 51:10individually and setting the foundation for it
- 51:12and whatnot and all the normal trial practice
- 51:15stuff you have to go through. I mean, if you've
- 51:16ever been to an actual hearing in court or trial
- 51:22in court and seen how long this process takes,
- 51:24it can take just as long in arbitration and you
- 51:26want to avoid that. David, do you have anything
- 51:27to add to that? No, I think, I mean, same points
- 51:32I've been hammering on. To the extent you can
- 51:34agree to the extent that you can't, that's fine.
- 51:37But as long as it's in an organized fashion,
- 51:40we can move quickly through the matters. If there's
- 51:43questions about the exhibits, we can move to
- 51:45those quickly before or at the beginning of the
- 51:48evidentiary hearing. But it just has to be sorted
- 51:51out. All right, we're in our last 10 minutes
- 51:54here. So closing arguments and issues of interest
- 51:57costs and attorney's fees. So obviously, your
- 51:59closing argument is an opportunity for a summary,
- 52:01not a restatement. So we're not re -arguing everything
- 52:04you should have argued actually during the evidentiary
- 52:06hearing. You're kind of summarizing the strong
- 52:08points of your case. Focus on the elements and
- 52:10the evidence towards those elements, common sense.
- 52:14Post -evidence, you're hearing briefing. You're
- 52:15going to want to focus on helping the arbitrator
- 52:17think about and then draft the final ward. And
- 52:20David was helping me draft this slide. you can
- 52:24get the arbitrator into that mindset of kind
- 52:26of what the final award would look like drafted
- 52:29in their head. The faster the process is going
- 52:31to be for David to draft the award and make your
- 52:34arbitrator arbitrator's life easy by being clear
- 52:36into the point. Right. David's going to set page
- 52:39limits on posteering briefing and kind of tell
- 52:41you what he wants to see in the briefs. But really
- 52:45Pay attention to that when he's giving a post
- 52:48-hearing briefing instructions, whether he's
- 52:49giving it live during the final day of the evidentiary
- 52:54hearing or he's issuing an actual statement,
- 52:57a written statement explaining what he's looking
- 52:59for after. Attorney fee applications, all right.
- 53:02If the arbitration agreement is not explicit,
- 53:05then you'll need to one, both brief the right
- 53:08to attorney's fees and costs into the actual
- 53:11attorney's fees and costs. A lot of people, some
- 53:15states don't actually have statutes that surround
- 53:17the right to recoup attorney's fees and costs
- 53:21in arbitration. A lot of states, it's just case
- 53:23law that's kind of floating around out there.
- 53:25Again, if this was explained in the arbitration
- 53:28provision, in a well -drafted arbitration provision,
- 53:29you wouldn't have to do all this extra briefing
- 53:32on whether or not you have the right to attorney's
- 53:34fees or costs. But you want to make it as clear
- 53:36for the arbitrator as possible. And then when
- 53:39briefing the attorney's fees and costs, you want
- 53:41to itemize as much as possible. A lack of itemization
- 53:44may result in not being aware of your full fees
- 53:48and costs. I've seen block billing when attorneys
- 53:54are issuing like their hours and things like
- 53:56that, or they'll just say kind of like a rough
- 53:58estimate of how many hours they spend on part
- 54:00of process. You know you're not giving that kind
- 54:03of estimate back to your clients. You're actually
- 54:06sending your clients invoices with the exact
- 54:09number of hours you spend on certain tasks, right?
- 54:12So you want to be as detailed with that with
- 54:14your attorney fee application. David, do you
- 54:16have anything to add to that? Yeah, I'll just
- 54:18say, I mean, I've had that situation, unfortunately,
- 54:20where There was insufficient detail and so I
- 54:25suspect lesser awards were provided than would
- 54:28have been provided had further detail been provided.
- 54:31You obviously ask for follow up and ask for that
- 54:34further detail. Sometimes it's forthcoming and
- 54:36that's great. Sometimes it's not and that's unfortunate.
- 54:42All right, once the arbitrator has closed the
- 54:46hearings, the rules at least at AAA is the arbitrator
- 54:49has 30 days to issue the final award. And essentially,
- 54:55what does the closing of hearings mean? It means
- 54:58that any direct exchange with the arbitrator
- 55:01is essentially ended. Most arbitrations at AAA
- 55:04are what we call direct exchange arbitrations,
- 55:06where the parties have permission from the arbitrator
- 55:10to communicate directly with the arbitrator throughout
- 55:14the process. So whether it's, I need permission
- 55:17to file leave, to file a motion of some sort,
- 55:21or I have a question, or we're planning on filing
- 55:26an MSJ, I need some guidelines from you on the
- 55:28process. Essentially, one party can... Email
- 55:32the arbitrator their communication, and as long
- 55:36as they're CCing all of the other parties in
- 55:38that communication, as well as the AAA staff,
- 55:42that's not considered ex parte communication.
- 55:44A small percentage of cases do not use direct
- 55:47exchange. These tend to be cases where, in a
- 55:51large complex case, the parties have basically
- 55:55demonstrated to the arbitrator that they lack
- 55:58the civility. to use direct exchange to communicate
- 56:01with the arbitrator. They're usually very much
- 56:03at each other's throats. They are just firing
- 56:06off emails at the arbitrator off the cuff at
- 56:09one o 'clock in the morning on a Saturday for
- 56:12no reason, just to get the other side angry.
- 56:15And the other side is going to respond an hour
- 56:17later at two o 'clock in the morning on a Saturday
- 56:19night because apparently people don't sleep.
- 56:22You know, those are the limited situations where
- 56:25direct exchange is not used. In that situation,
- 56:28all communication from the parties has to go
- 56:30through the case manager and the case manager
- 56:33will relay communications to the arbitrator.
- 56:38So once the hearings have been closed, then essentially
- 56:41everything, all the communications have to go
- 56:43through the case manager. Now something to remember
- 56:45is sometimes the arbitrator may choose to issue
- 56:49an interim award and not a final award. And just
- 56:52because an interim award has been issued, that
- 56:54doesn't mean the hearings have been closed. So
- 56:56what is an interim award? Well, an interim award
- 56:58is typically the arbitrator has made a determination
- 57:01who has won the arbitration, who has lost, and
- 57:04just what the winning side is entitled to. But
- 57:08the arbitrator would like further briefing from
- 57:11the prevailing party on attorney's fees and costs
- 57:14if they believe that they're entitled to those.
- 57:17And then they have to give the respondent the
- 57:19opportunity to challenge whether the arbitrator
- 57:22has the authority to award any attorney's fees
- 57:24and costs, and if the arbitrator does have that
- 57:27authority to question what's been submitted as
- 57:30far as the legitimacy of those charges. And so
- 57:34just because an interim award has been issued
- 57:37doesn't mean necessarily the hearings have been
- 57:39closed, because oftentimes the parties are still
- 57:42communicating directly with the arbitrator between
- 57:44the interim award and the final award. Occasionally,
- 57:50once an arbitration award is issued A mistake
- 57:54has been issued in the final award. Now, once
- 57:57the final award is sent, the arbitration is essentially
- 58:00over. The parties can no longer communicate with
- 58:02the arbitrator about the award. If they had any
- 58:05questions, they would have to go through the
- 58:07case manager. Now, we have a commercial rule,
- 58:10R -52, that basically says within 20 days of
- 58:13a final word being issued, any party upon notice
- 58:15to the other parties can request through the
- 58:18AAA that the arbitrator correct any clerical,
- 58:21typographical, or computational errors in the
- 58:23award. Now, notice I didn't say, re -argue the
- 58:28merits of the case or point out to the arbitrator
- 58:31that they might have failed to rule on one of
- 58:34the 27 different causes of action or something
- 58:36that you're trying to go after damages on. This
- 58:39is very, go ahead. Let me say this, if there's
- 58:42something where there's a failure to rule on
- 58:44a cause of action, that is something that I think
- 58:47is legitimate. But to your point, it's not about
- 58:50re -arguing No, you got it wrong, Arbitrator,
- 58:53and here's why. This is really about the technical
- 58:58error, not about the stuff in there. You put
- 59:02a decimal in the wrong place. Right. Right. Or
- 59:06you agreed with the parties that the interest
- 59:09rate that would apply to claimants award was
- 59:135 % per nuem. And instead of 5%, you accidentally,
- 59:18when you were drafting the award, typed in 6%.
- 59:21into the calculator and one side's like, you
- 59:23gave them too much interest, things like that.
- 59:27And to David's point about missing a cause of
- 59:29action or something like that, all of our awards
- 59:33have a closing statement that basically addresses
- 59:36this. It says, this shows how to satisfy all
- 59:39causes of action basically brought before the
- 59:41arbitrator. And in the event the arbitrator actually
- 59:44missed one of those causes of action, well, that's
- 59:46covered in that catch all sentence there at the
- 59:49end where Maybe the arbitrator made a mistake,
- 59:53maybe they should have addressed that, but that
- 59:55sentence prevents them from reopening their causes
- 59:58of action and having to reopen the case. The
- 1:00:01majority of parties do comply with the parameters
- 1:00:05of Rule 52 and submit things that can be reviewed,
- 1:00:08but sometimes they don't. And the other side
- 1:00:11has the ability to issue a response to any R52
- 1:00:16request. So if the claimant is claiming that
- 1:00:19David applied the wrong interest rate and they
- 1:00:21do a little bit more interest, the respondent
- 1:00:23gets a certain amount of time to argue that David
- 1:00:27applied the right amount of interest and the
- 1:00:28claimants don't get that amount before he makes
- 1:00:30a decision. And lastly, I'd like to point out
- 1:00:34that the joint drafting of a model final award
- 1:00:37after interim award is issued is one of the best
- 1:00:39ways to avoid an R52 motion. If both parties
- 1:00:43have, after the interim award is issued, work
- 1:00:46on drafting a final award themselves and simply
- 1:00:48ask for the arbitrator's signature, then if there's
- 1:00:51some mistake in the final award, it's on the
- 1:00:54parties, right? It's not on the arbitrator because
- 1:00:56they're the ones that essentially submitted this
- 1:00:58product for the arbitrator's signature. All right
- 1:01:01I know we're a little bit over and I'll just
- 1:01:02spend another minute or two. I'm not going to
- 1:01:04read through this entire slide here but this
- 1:01:07is video hearings in the time of COVID and beyond
- 1:01:09and these are just basically best practices for
- 1:01:11video hearings and in -person hearings and also
- 1:01:14kind of a checklist of whether it makes sense
- 1:01:17to proceed with something in -person via or proceed
- 1:01:19with something via video hearing. I hope we never
- 1:01:22have another situation with COVID where we can't
- 1:01:25do in -person evidentiary hearings because of
- 1:01:28some disease or condition floating around that
- 1:01:33one might catch. But if some other disease other
- 1:01:37than COVID comes or somehow mutates and we all
- 1:01:40get shut down again, these are good rules to
- 1:01:43kind of follow as far as proceeding. All right,
- 1:01:47I've included our email addresses here. If you
- 1:01:50want to reach out to either one of us, we love
- 1:01:52answering questions. I am going to... I guess
- 1:01:57stop sharing and then see if we have any questions
- 1:02:00in the box. I'll give folks a minute or two if
- 1:02:04they want to take a picture with their cell phone
- 1:02:05or email addresses or anything like that to get
- 1:02:08them down. But I will now stop sharing. And let's
- 1:02:14see. OK, Q &A. Okay, what are AAA statistics
- 1:02:24on MSJs, less than 1 in 10 commercial arbitration
- 1:02:30cases? So I guess Jack is asking how many MSJs
- 1:02:36are granted. Off the top of my head, I don't
- 1:02:39have those statistics, Jack, but David, in your
- 1:02:43experience, how many times, what percentage of
- 1:02:45your cases would you say an MSJ has even filed?
- 1:02:51I mean, there's definitely a fair number of motions
- 1:02:54to dismiss. That's usually the nature that these
- 1:02:57positive motions take. I would say MSJs are probably
- 1:03:01in about 10 % of the cases. That being said,
- 1:03:08they are, in my experience, I'd say more successful
- 1:03:12than not, maybe about two to one. But again,
- 1:03:18in that smaller number of cases, and I think
- 1:03:20that's because I'm going to try to discourage
- 1:03:24the extra time and effort of an MSJ if there's
- 1:03:29not a pathway. Sometimes people will feel obligated
- 1:03:31to file an MSJ. It's an opportunity to present
- 1:03:34your case in briefing to the judge or arbitrator.
- 1:03:40I don't take that view, but yeah, that would
- 1:03:43be what I've seen. And that may just be the types
- 1:03:46of cases that come before me, but it's not incredibly
- 1:03:49common in arbitration. Another good question
- 1:03:53from Jack, is low -cost desk arbitration ever
- 1:03:56allowed in small disputes under $100 ,000 in
- 1:03:58commercial arbitration cases? So the parties
- 1:04:02can certainly agree to using desk arbitration.
- 1:04:05Basically, where an arbitration is just heard
- 1:04:07on the papers without actually any live testimony.
- 1:04:11desk arbitration written into a couple of our
- 1:04:13rule sets for smaller consumer disputes, as well
- 1:04:15as our construction fast track cases, which are
- 1:04:18construction defect cases, usually residential
- 1:04:20construction claims under $100 ,000. So if the
- 1:04:26parties would like to do desk arbitration for
- 1:04:29smaller disputes, and it's outside one of our
- 1:04:31rule sets that actually calls for desk arbitration
- 1:04:33to resolve the dispute, the parties can always
- 1:04:36agree to that. Does AAA ever allow smartphone
- 1:04:40recording and no -cost automation of transcript
- 1:04:46generation via AI technology? David, do you allow
- 1:04:52the parties on their own to record any of your
- 1:04:56hearing or your process? I don't believe I've
- 1:05:00encountered a cell phone recording. I have had
- 1:05:05parties want to use the transcription features
- 1:05:08of video conferencing software. I do think that's
- 1:05:12something that has to be addressed is something
- 1:05:14that I will talk about either in that preliminary
- 1:05:17management hearing or in the pre -evidentiary
- 1:05:20hearing status conference just because it is
- 1:05:25making a recording. of what's going on. But I
- 1:05:30have allowed it. Generally, I'm open to it. I'm
- 1:05:35open to the use of the technology. I haven't
- 1:05:38had a request to use a cell phone or a smartphone
- 1:05:41or something like that to set it up on the side
- 1:05:44and record the screen, something like that. I'll
- 1:05:48just add to that, especially the transcript generation
- 1:05:51via AI technology. I think what the question
- 1:05:54is, is pointing out, there's all these different
- 1:05:57transcription tools. You can basically have almost
- 1:06:01like an AI bot on your Zoom transcribing what's
- 1:06:04being said and all that kind of stuff. And within
- 1:06:06Zoom itself, I believe. But we do partner with
- 1:06:09an organization, a depot company called Optima
- 1:06:12Juris, that has a virtual court reporter, which
- 1:06:14is a tiny fraction of the cost of an in -person
- 1:06:17live court reporter that some parties use to
- 1:06:20transcribe the evidentiary hearing and sometimes
- 1:06:22even motion hearings that basically listens to
- 1:06:25the party's voices, comes up with a rough transcript,
- 1:06:28and then a human being on the back end kind of
- 1:06:31cleans the transcript up. But again, it uses
- 1:06:34AI technology and it's a lot less expensive than
- 1:06:38a traditional in -person court reporter. So let
- 1:06:41me just say this that what I do point out when
- 1:06:42when I allow for those kinds of things is I also
- 1:06:45point out depending on what you're using if you're
- 1:06:47using the transcription using some kind of bot
- 1:06:49that joins the meeting type thing or you're using
- 1:06:52a middle range product where it's there's AI
- 1:06:56and then human going through doing some editing
- 1:06:58versus a full -blown court reporter in a traditional
- 1:07:01sense. Those various levels are going to have
- 1:07:04various levels of reliability. And if there's
- 1:07:07a distinction or an issue that comes up, that's
- 1:07:09going to be taken into account later on, if we
- 1:07:13have to go back and try and rely upon the auto
- 1:07:16generated transcript. And there's a word that's
- 1:07:20going to make a difference to an element of the
- 1:07:23case. But, you know, the parties, as long as
- 1:07:27they're aware of that and understand that they
- 1:07:30I feel like that's their choice to make. I just
- 1:07:33want to get to these last two questions quickly
- 1:07:34because I know we've run over here. How common
- 1:07:36is the grant of attorney's fees and costs and
- 1:07:38what is the most important consideration in awarding?
- 1:07:45The most important consideration in awarding
- 1:07:47is if it properly explains what David's authority
- 1:07:50is in the arbitration provision. But David, whether
- 1:07:53you've seen your authority granted in the arbitration
- 1:07:55provision or it's silent, how common is the awarding
- 1:07:58of attorney's fees and costs? And what are your
- 1:07:59most important determinations? You know, that's
- 1:08:03a good question. I don't even necessarily know
- 1:08:05offhand. I would say it's less than, maybe, I'd
- 1:08:12say probably under 20%. of arbitrations where
- 1:08:17it's been awarded. But that also, the problem
- 1:08:21is it's not always something that is granted.
- 1:08:25I don't have the authority oftentimes. And if
- 1:08:28I don't have the authority, well then obviously
- 1:08:30it's out. So I can't give you a good... a good
- 1:08:33estimate. Out of those cases where I have the
- 1:08:35authority and it's granted, I can't give you
- 1:08:37a good number on that. And it's important to
- 1:08:39mention that David handles cases here at AAA
- 1:08:41all the way from some of the smallest consumer
- 1:08:44disputes all the way up to large complex cases.
- 1:08:47under our LCC rule set. So it's more common,
- 1:08:51I would say, the awarding of attorney's fees
- 1:08:52and costs in the large complex case tracks at
- 1:08:58that level, especially where the parties might
- 1:09:00be spending hundreds of thousands of dollars
- 1:09:02or millions of dollars on attorney's fees and
- 1:09:04arbitration costs in a really big case. And I
- 1:09:06think that's a function of those larger cases
- 1:09:08are going to have more complex contracts involved
- 1:09:10where it's an issue that is addressed. All right,
- 1:09:14David, last question here. How are CCP 998 offers
- 1:09:18and compromise handled? Is there a AAA rule of
- 1:09:21practice in California, and how is this handled?
- 1:09:25Yeah, so 998 offers do not automatically translate
- 1:09:30over to AAA. It's a civil procedure unless there's
- 1:09:34a provision in the arbitration clause. that specifically
- 1:09:38is going to be applying California procedural
- 1:09:40law. I haven't encountered that situation myself,
- 1:09:44but I do think the principles behind it stand
- 1:09:49in that it really, at its core, what 99A is encouraging
- 1:09:52is settlement discussions and mediation. And
- 1:09:55as Aaron went over, AAA does that through a number
- 1:09:58of other vehicles. And just to really summarize
- 1:10:01that, the reason AAA doesn't have a California
- 1:10:04-specific rule to address that is our rules are
- 1:10:07drafted for a national audience. Many states
- 1:10:10do not have the equivalent of a California 998
- 1:10:13offer rule. So it wouldn't make any sense for
- 1:10:15us to add something like that into our rule books,
- 1:10:18especially when they're being used for all 50
- 1:10:20states and territories. OK, without further ado,
- 1:10:23that's the final question. Thank you all for
- 1:10:25joining our presentation today. And we'll see
- 1:10:29you next time. Thanks, everyone, for your time.
- 1:10:31Thanks, Aaron.