Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Jon Meacham - Past as Prologue
Transcript
- 0:00A big thank you to Autodesk, the sponsor of Engineering Influence at this year's convention.
- 0:05Autodesk partners with the AEC industry and its leaders to shape a more connected,
- 0:11data-driven future, empowering engineers to work more intelligently and to make
- 0:16confident decisions to drive meaningful impact.
- 0:19This enables firms to evolve, stay competitive, and deliver stronger business
- 0:23outcomes, all while designing a better world.
- 0:27So thank you again to Autodesk.
- 0:33Welcome to Engineering Influence, a podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:37Companies coming to you from our 2026 convention and legislative summit in Washington, D.C.
- 0:42I am joined on the program today by our keynote speaker for today's session,
- 0:48noted historian, Pulitzer Prize-winning writer, historian, John Meacham.
- 0:52Thank you so much for joining us. Thank you. I really appreciate you taking
- 0:56the time to join us again at our convention, talk to the group.
- 1:00It's an interesting time in Washington. It's always an interesting time. I've heard that. Yes.
- 1:06It's always volatile. Right. And, of course, our members will be going up to
- 1:10the Hill to talk about infrastructure.
- 1:12But I think it was important this morning that you put a historical lens on
- 1:15really what we're living through right now.
- 1:18And I think to kind of kick things off, you made a really good comment about
- 1:23Reagan's, quote, shining city on Hill.
- 1:26Right. Which has actually become now scripture.
- 1:29Right. Right. And you extended that to say that America is a country that is
- 1:35best when it shines to illuminate instead of scorch. Right.
- 1:40And a lot of people out there right now would say that we're scorching.
- 1:43What's your perspective?
- 1:44I think we are. I think that our politics is more about total war than it is
- 1:50about arguing about differences. Yeah.
- 1:53I think it's about accentuating differences. It's about perpetuating conflict
- 1:58for the sake of conflict. And...
- 2:02What history tells us, I'm not being naive about this, what history tells us
- 2:06is that when we can break that pattern,
- 2:09when we can negotiate as opposed to battle, then better things happen.
- 2:19And you kind of extended to say that the difference is when you are in a democratic
- 2:27debate, you are trying to defeat the other opponent or at least defeat their ideas in total war.
- 2:33You want to completely defeat them. It's a different mindset.
- 2:37It's defeat versus kill. Yeah, exactly. Right.
- 2:41And we can get lost in these metaphors. But I think it's right.
- 2:45I mean, Thomas Hobbes said, you know, the state of nature is the war of all against all.
- 2:50And that doesn't work with the constitutional government. Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:56It's history, you know, they say the history doesn't repeat, but it rhymes.
- 3:00Looking at where we are today with, I guess it really comes down to a questions of institutions.
- 3:07I'm a big institutionalist. I believe that the core institutions are really
- 3:12what maintain us, right?
- 3:13That the founders were smart enough to look forward to say, we're going to put
- 3:18in the checks and balances necessary so that when situations of discord or concentrations
- 3:24of power arise, there will be a check against that.
- 3:27And I think one of the biggest concerns right now is the erosion of those institutions.
- 3:31You mentioned looking back to 1926 and putting that into perspective,
- 3:37coming out of a pandemic, coming out of World War I, you had the invitation,
- 3:42the invention of the first revolution in communications of radio.
- 3:47How is that analogous to what we're going through today? Well,
- 3:51so in the 20s, we had demographic change.
- 3:54So this is, they were moving from agrarian to industrial.
- 3:59Today, we're moving from manufacturing industrial to an information economy.
- 4:06And even that is now being disrupted, of course, by artificial intelligence,
- 4:10which is a whole tsunami that we haven't even dealt with yet.
- 4:14But so you have a difference in demography, how people live.
- 4:18You have a difference in communication.
- 4:21Radio actually, speed is relative.
- 4:24So if you didn't have any electronic means of communication and suddenly you
- 4:28have that, that's a big deal.
- 4:30And so there was a reaction. And
- 4:32the reaction was, we don't want too many foreign things, people, ideas.
- 4:39The world got very close. The world got very, very, yes.
- 4:42It got very close very quickly. And so we isolationism, protectionism,
- 4:47and we know how the decade ended. It ended poorly.
- 4:51So I think that there's a lot of, there are analogous elements there.
- 4:56And that a vital thing for us to do is to try to remember what is it that makes the country work?
- 5:06What makes it appealing? And what makes it appealing is not total victory.
- 5:12And this is not a great rally crime, right? Moderation, you know, that doesn't work.
- 5:19But that's what the framers wanted.
- 5:23And that I think we get caught up in the moment.
- 5:27We have the little machines in our pockets, as you mentioned,
- 5:29really close, right next to
- 5:30our heart that kind of update us and tell us what to think all the time.
- 5:33And in 26, you had, you made a good point of saying that you had Los Angeles,
- 5:37you had Hollywood, and you had New York for the first time reaching into middle America, right?
- 5:42And to an extent, no time prior had the coasts shaped the thought patterns of
- 5:50middle America. Absolutely.
- 5:51You know, the, you know, the people knew about the financial sector and,
- 5:55you know, they worried about that.
- 5:56But in terms of your daily life, it was, the country became much more nationalized. Yeah.
- 6:05Than it had been. And that's part of what we're dealing with now is the nationalization of politics.
- 6:11When I was growing up in the seventies and eighties, I mean,
- 6:15there was this tendency, you, you didn't like Congress, but you liked your Congress.
- 6:19Exactly. Remember that?
- 6:20Oh yeah. And you know, you'd be a Republican, but you'd vote for the Democrat
- 6:23cause you knew the person or whatever.
- 6:26Gone, gone, gone, gone. And so it's become, and this is sort of a post 1996,
- 6:3297 thing. Al Gore paid a price for it in Tennessee, for instance, in 2000.
- 6:39So the nationalization of everything means that it makes things simpler.
- 6:46And there's something appealing about a simple narrative. Yeah, it's as easy.
- 6:51I mean, historically, you can say that, you know, the people who are the greatest
- 6:57aggregating power are the ones who are able to take complex issues and just
- 7:01boil them down to a simple route. Which isn't a terrible thing.
- 7:04It's not terrible. It's effective. It's human nature. It's psychology.
- 7:07You know, the Beatitudes were soundbites. Yeah. You know, it's okay,
- 7:10but it's not the simplification is the problem.
- 7:14It's the content once it's simplified. Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:18And you're right. I mean, as a long-suffering House staffer,
- 7:21the joke used to be that, you know, the Democrats are the enemy.
- 7:26No, Democrats are our opposition, but the enemy is the Senate. You know?
- 7:29And that was the joke, right? It's like everybody kind of got along,
- 7:32but we kind of institutionally knew where the problem was.
- 7:36Now it's become atomized where it's my enemy could be actually my colleague within the same party.
- 7:43The algorithm is driving me that way.
- 7:46And it just seems like we're in a situation which is a little bit unique in how.
- 7:54It's been nationalized, but it's also been atomized to the point where now it
- 8:01focuses on a specific individual and their own personality.
- 8:05And I think you made the point during your remarks about it's not so much the
- 8:11question of the era of Trump or Trumpism.
- 8:14And what is that Trumpism?
- 8:18Is that going to define us moving forward? And what is that thing?
- 8:22Because, okay, you can look at the nationalism of the 20s.
- 8:25You can look at nativism movements throughout history.
- 8:29Is this different, or is this just a repeat with a better brand?
- 8:34And that's the question we're living. You framed it exactly right.
- 8:40Unquestionably, this is the age of Trump. Yeah. Question is in 2028,
- 8:4529, does it become the age of Trumpism?
- 8:48And we don't know yet. Yeah. And what is Trumpism?
- 8:51Trumpism is a kind of weaponized nativism, a a bullying public culture. Yeah.
- 8:59A a resistance to compromise a view that.
- 9:05Dealing with the other side is weakness, not good governance. Yeah.
- 9:12And it's going to be fascinating to see whether, also if the Democrats were to win,
- 9:17to what extent of these, you know, these executive tools that President Trump
- 9:23has hewn and sharpened, to what extent might they use some of them?
- 9:27Yeah, I'm a, you know, cards on the table. I'm a small limited government guy.
- 9:32I like classical. you know i'm a reagan person
- 9:35yeah but at the same time i have
- 9:38to admit that that reagan was also the the he
- 9:41started the enlargement of the
- 9:44executive branch right and he expanded the the
- 9:47the breaths and the power of the executive that has
- 9:50only grown over time you know the power just consolidates and
- 9:54it's going to be interesting to see what happens after even if even if it
- 9:57does switch over and let's say a gavin newsom wins
- 10:00is there is there a chance that it's just going to be a continuation of
- 10:03that or are we going to see it it's going to be interesting to see just what
- 10:06what we choose as as an electorate yep yeah
- 10:09and yeah that's of course the big question but of
- 10:13course you know as a part and parcel with your
- 10:15remarks i mean we could go in all day about this and i mean have a conversation
- 10:19i could talk to you for hours about this you know you have a new book yep american
- 10:26struggle democracy dissent and the pursuit of a more perfect union which is
- 10:31out now and tell us a little bit about the book where it came,
- 10:34where, where, where the idea came from and, and, and how it fits the mind.
- 10:38So it's sort of a sequential volume to a book I did, uh, eight,
- 10:42nine years ago called the soul of America. Yeah.
- 10:44Which was an argument about that. We are in.
- 10:49Our politics is this arena of contention.
- 10:54The soul of a person, I think, and the soul of a country is a battle between
- 10:57our worst instincts and our better angels.
- 11:00And most of the time, the worst instincts win, but sometimes the other side
- 11:03wins. And what I wanted to do to some extent was get out of the way.
- 11:08This is a book of first-person accounts, arguments from 1619 through Vice President
- 11:17Vance's acceptance speech in 2024 of voices in the arena arguing about who we are. Yeah.
- 11:27And there's something reassuring about knowing that these arguments have gone on forever.
- 11:33But I don't want it to be this. I don't want to be a narcotic.
- 11:37Yeah. Right. It's not that, oh, therefore, it's all going to be fine because
- 11:41it damn near wasn't fine then. And it may not be fine now. Yeah.
- 11:45But the only way to understand it is to reengage with these moments. Yeah.
- 11:51I agree with you 100 percent. I think that the one thing that kind of anchors
- 11:54me throughout the contention is the fact that, you know, now I was talking to
- 11:58my wife about this, that, you know, the idea of the American experiment isn't just a throwaway line.
- 12:04We are an experiment. The experiment is not over.
- 12:07Right. And I think people look and say, oh, you know what? This is the end.
- 12:10This is, you know, no, the experiment continues and you have the opportunity to alter its direction.
- 12:17Right. But we can't lose fact to the sight of the fact that we are a country
- 12:22continually writing its own history and its own direction.
- 12:24And as long as we take the the sovereignty of our own decisions to push it in that direction.
- 12:31We have the future. Exactly. So, John, one final question, something you brought
- 12:36up that whenever you go up to meet a politician, one of the best questions is
- 12:41what would you want to see in your portrait and see what their reaction would be?
- 12:45So what would you like to see in your portrait?
- 12:49Oh, that's a great question. First of all, I don't think anyone's going to be looking at my portrait.
- 12:53You know, look, I'm incredibly fortunate.
- 12:57You've been very, very lucky. I hope people would see a guy who tried to articulate
- 13:04fairly and judiciously both the possibilities and the pitfalls of human beings
- 13:15in the mails from a history. Yeah.
- 13:17And if any time we needed some history to look back on, now is it.
- 13:21Exactly. John, thank you for joining us on the program. Great.
- 13:23I really appreciate it. And again, this has been Engineering Influence Podcast
- 13:27from the American Council of Engineering Companies. We'll see you next time.