Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto. We put a poll on Patreon asking people what the patrons wanted
- 0:07us to do our next big series on a public figure or something, and
- 0:13overwhelmingly the patrons voted for the Duggers. And people have been asking us to
- 0:21cover the Duggers for eight ten years plus, I can imagine, and whenever
- 0:28we would get emails or comments on YouTube, I would always think, I
- 0:32wonder who these people are. I mean, I just had no clue.
- 0:37And for the past month you and I have been doing a crash course on
- 0:43the Duggers, and I've just been completely obsessed with the States. Now there's
- 0:49so many details not only to the Dugger's case, but also to the religion
- 0:54that they were following, and just broader Evangelical Christians the United States, and
- 1:00the laws and the ethics and child abuse and you know, there's just so
- 1:04many things. Is it a cult anyway? Yeah? This is the Psychology
- 1:07and Shattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kurkanda. I'm a therapist and
- 1:11a professor. Who are you burto? My name is and I um braid
- 1:15nuts. So if you're listening to an audio version of this, there's a
- 1:19video version of just me and Burtos heads if you care to watch that on
- 1:23YouTube. Also, I'm getting over a cold, so you might hear me
- 1:29a little rascy. My doctor has reassured me I'm not contagious anymore. And
- 1:33I'm sick too. I can't hear this one. I'm wearing headphones. I
- 1:36had COVID and then a sinus infection. Then both ears are infected and I
- 1:40can't. Like, it's horrible. You had you had COVID like a couple
- 1:44of months ago, or yeah, yeah I was. I was on a
- 1:46trip on a vacation. Yeah, okay. So I want to read an
- 1:49email from an anonymous patron to humanize this a little bit. They say,
- 1:56Hi, I'd love for you to talk about the Dugger family. My family
- 2:00idolized the Duggers. I grew up in a quiverful, quiverful church. I
- 2:07was homeschooled my entire life in a very similar way to the Duggers. The
- 2:09trauma of being educated in this movement goes deep for me. Please please include
- 2:15an analysis of the book To Train Up a Child by Michael and Debbie Pearl.
- 2:21It is the book that all these families were obsessed with using, to
- 2:24quote unquote train their children. In the nineties and oughts, we were extremely
- 2:30well behaved kids due to these abusive tactics. People would comment on how good
- 2:36we were all the time to my mother, little did they know the vile
- 2:38things that were happening to us kids. We IBLP kids had to submit entirely.
- 2:46There was no such thing as consent. I'll be in therapy a long
- 2:50time recovering from the abuse. What do you think? That's horrible? Man,
- 2:54So sad to hear that, because honestly, you're right when you see
- 3:00the facade, Like again, I didn't know almost anything, but I didn't
- 3:02know that there was like this family with a lot of kids. The facade
- 3:06that they and the overall community percents looks happy and to some extent healthy or
- 3:10whatever. And but at the very least it doesn't seem like there's horrible abuse
- 3:15is happening or something that. And yes, and I've experienced that with other
- 3:19communities too, where where everyone's like very buttoned up and behaved, but sometimes
- 3:23that's not accomplished in a way that's healthy. And just to hear that you
- 3:27know and that this is not the first accounts sadly, because I've been like
- 3:30you watching a lot of content from people that were in it, and yeah,
- 3:35it's heartbreaking. Yeah, we all know that children are abused, which
- 3:39is a horrible, horrible thing in our society. It happens all that.
- 3:45The thing that I will often remind myself and tell people is that to really
- 3:50make it visceral, because you know, people intellectually get it. But there
- 3:53are children right now, at this very second being abused within a mile radius
- 3:59of your house. Depending on statistics and this sort of thing, and where
- 4:03you live and the density of the population, it's pretty much guaranteed that there
- 4:08are several children at this very second being abused to some extent. And that
- 4:15to me, when I remind myself about that, it just drives home that
- 4:18this isn't some distant thing. It's not something we've fixed, it's not something
- 4:23in the past. It's something happening at this very second. And when we
- 4:28understand that, we understand that there's a lot of causes to that. But
- 4:31what this series I think will demonstrate, and what the deep dive going into
- 4:36all the data has demonstrated for me, is that there's a pretty good possibility
- 4:41that a lot of parents would not have abused their children if they were left
- 4:45to their own devices. But because of the religious cult that they these people
- 4:49were in. We'll get into whether or not it's a cult later on.
- 4:54But because of the influence of this particular sect of Christianity, then the these
- 5:00parents became abusive, or abusive, parents became more abusive, or parents that
- 5:05maybe weren't themselves abusive allowed their children to be abused because of the hierarchy that
- 5:11was established. Right, So it's not just like, oh, it's a
- 5:15story about children being abused. It's a story about an institution that involved millions
- 5:20of people over decades in which many, many children have been abused and many
- 5:27many adults are hopefully in recovery from that. Many not obviously, because they're
- 5:32probably still in the cult, or they don't know to recover, or they
- 5:36don't have access to that, or they think they were to blame or something,
- 5:40or they literally died, which we'll get into you later as well.
- 5:43So, Yeah, it's just it's rough, and it's across the world.
- 5:46It wasn't even just the US, which is another mind blowing thing for me.
- 5:49Right at the Yeah, and at the center of all this is a
- 5:55reality TV show that everyone was watching. Yeah, well, because I've also
- 6:00come to find that there were actual exposs and documentaries before about IBLP, but
- 6:04they just never got attention really, and I think for better or for worse,
- 6:10the popularity of the show The Duggers was or nineteen account whatever you know,
- 6:15that actually finally was able to give it enough prominence to highlight, you
- 6:19know, shine a spotlight on this thing. But yeah, yeah, it's
- 6:24interesting. I want to touch on something related to that that when I was
- 6:29going into this world with the documentary and all the other documentaries and the articles
- 6:32and everything, I knew that these people are out there right right, you
- 6:38hear about them, But it's a whole subculture, a large subculture. Yeah,
- 6:44right in my country, maybe in my neighborhood. I don't know that.
- 6:48I was just completely I mean again, I'm aware of it, but
- 6:53not really aware of it. Just goope. I was, that's the thing.
- 6:58And I guess because I had friends in not this specific although actually I
- 7:02don't know, probably some affiliation some of them might have been, but in
- 7:06general where we would go to these mega church events at stadiums, so some
- 7:12of the things that were described, I was there. I was at some
- 7:14of these things, and I guess yeah, when I think of that,
- 7:16that is massive, right, tens of thousands of people. Right, it's
- 7:20not just IBLP as one particular institution within Christianity in the United States, but
- 7:28it's emblematic of a huge movement that has been happening, which will also get
- 7:32into again another tangent, right, that will go down. So yeah,
- 7:36so this topic branches off into a lot of topics, and I wrote down
- 7:42just sampling. So obviously the Duggers, which is a huge news story,
- 7:46and a lot of people are interested in us talking about the details of that,
- 7:48of which I have been just the documentary didn't really describe it well even
- 7:55though it was long, right, Yeah, there's a lot of stuff they
- 7:58left out. I feel like they were trying to split the difference, like
- 8:01they were trying to cover the Dugger story but also try to give like an
- 8:05account about the background of IBLP and everything, but as a result, they
- 8:09sort of like short changed both sides. Well. And also, so the
- 8:13documentary is on Amazon Prime called Shining Happy People, which I'm not in love
- 8:18with that name. I guess I understand why they named it that. The
- 8:22rim song right, well, yeah, and then they're supposed to that was
- 8:24they were always supposed to appear that way, right, But it just doesn't
- 8:28evoke the meaning of the documentary. You know. I feel like there's a
- 8:33trend around that, like Wild Wild Wild Country was about the cult in Oregon,
- 8:39and it's like that's not they need a catchy name. Yeah, like
- 8:43the staircase. That documentary you know, at least evokes the main topic.
- 8:48But anyway, so yeah, I felt like the documentary did a great job
- 8:54of innerweavy IBLP and everything you know, was it it was, you know,
- 8:58about the Duggers, but it really branched off into the areas that really
- 9:03needed to be branched off into. But what it didn't do, in my
- 9:05opinion, is it didn't really drive home the abuses that were happening, which
- 9:11we'll get into. But anyway, so the Duggers, they have a twenty
- 9:18year story, So we're gonna go through that whole thing year by years.
- 9:22A lot of details in there, and I think it's important to go year
- 9:26by years so that you understand the time spans involved and also the era in
- 9:31American history, which you know, twenty years ago things were different in our
- 9:35culture. We're going to talk about Josh Dugger, of course, who is
- 9:39a central figure in the controversy and criminal activity and the recent results of that.
- 9:48Also, we're going to talk a lot about the nature of sexual abuse
- 9:52and sexual abuse between siblings, which often isn't talked about very much, but
- 9:56it is a common enough occurrence. Of course, victim blaming and actual gaslighting,
- 10:01not gaslighting like the Internet refers to it, but the actual gas lighting
- 10:07effect of victim blaming, and also of what you could argue to be a
- 10:11cult messaging system. Then, so that's kind of just a jumping off point,
- 10:16and then we're going to talk about the religion that they were in and
- 10:20maybe evangelicals kind of in general. Have you heard of the term fundies?
- 10:24Yeah, well no, I hadn't. Sorry, I hadn't heard fundies,
- 10:28but I had. I have met people that are recovering fundies, So when
- 10:31that person mentioned that term, I thought, oh, that's interesting. Yeah,
- 10:35i'd never heard it though, and yeah, when I was younger,
- 10:39and I guess to this day, the only reference to fundies I've ever heard.
- 10:43Do you know what it is? Under us? Like, no,
- 10:48no, it was I don't even know if this is real, but it's
- 10:50underwear that you buy it a sex shop that is edible. Oh, I
- 10:54mean, at least I think that's what it was. I know there's edible
- 10:58underwear, but fundies. Yeah, and you know, I remember I was
- 11:01in an adult shop once and I found them. Do you know what they
- 11:05make it out of? Because they have to make something that you can wear,
- 11:09that you can eat. Well, can you wear an eat like?
- 11:13Once I say it, it'll make all the sense in the world. I
- 11:16don't know. Fruit leather. You can wear fruit leather. I mean it's
- 11:22especially if it's if it's a little thicker. I mean the summer. We'll
- 11:26remember fruit leather in those eighties. I feel like it was a lot more
- 11:28leather. I mean it's literally called leather. They would never call it that
- 11:33today, fruit leather. Yeah. In fact, as I say it,
- 11:37I'm like, is that the term that the stuff you buy today is barely
- 11:39like paper? Fruit paper? Right? It's like those Listerine strips that I
- 11:43use for breath. Have you ever had those before? Yeah? Oh my
- 11:46god, especially when they like dry onto your tongue and they like sting.
- 11:52Yeah. Yeah, I mean it is an effervescent experience. Anyway, So
- 11:56fundies, we're going to talk about them and also there their victimization. Also,
- 12:03homeschooling is a huge topic. IBLP, which is the Christian organization.
- 12:09Is it a cult? We're going to really go into their teachings. I
- 12:13did a whole deep dive wormhole, rabbit hole, wormhole, I wormholed.
- 12:20I read their books. I actually read their wisdom books that they used to
- 12:26teach the kids. I went through many of the stuff you sent me.
- 12:30But first, Bruto, let's actually take a pause right here and take a
- 12:33break. What do you say, Let's do it. Okay, we're back
- 12:39from the break. Let me get back to my notes here. So we're
- 12:41also going to get into Bill Gothard, who is the chrismatic leader of IBLP,
- 12:48and we'll get into his teachings and his crimes as well. We're going
- 12:52to get into a TI, which is the homeschooling organization. We're going to
- 12:56get into that book that the anonymous Patron talked about to Train up a Child.
- 12:58I had never heard of it before, but when I looked into it,
- 13:03there's a huge amount of information there to go over, and it's very
- 13:07influential. Millions of people I've been following this book. The author was in
- 13:13the documentary, which we'll get into. We're going to talk about gender politics,
- 13:16sexism, misogyny, the patriarchy because IBLP and it's sexist notions didn't just
- 13:22emerge out of nowhere now of course, so it's a rich, old old
- 13:28Yeah, we're going to get into actual politics because there's a lot of politicians
- 13:33and a lot of politics within this story to get into. We'll talk about
- 13:37gay panic and we'll eventually get to QAnon because I think it's kind of related
- 13:43in a way. Reality TV a whole other topic. We're gonna talk about
- 13:46reality TV and it's emergence and the ethics of it, and also the ethics
- 13:52of using children. I have always been for a while now, I've been
- 13:56talked since you know, I've been watching reality TV on YouTube. It is
- 14:00a topic that sometimes I think about and I look into while I use this
- 14:03deep dive as an excuse to really look into the laws and the history of
- 14:07the laws not only on child labor, but specifically in entertainment and how everything
- 14:13is right now, and we'll get into that. We'll talk about the rise
- 14:16of a reality TV and talk about maybe why, and I'm sure many many
- 14:22tangents such as fruit leather underwear. So I want to tell everyone where I
- 14:28did my research. By the way, I watched the documentary first Shiny Happy
- 14:33People, and like I said, it's I think it's about four hours,
- 14:37but it just scratches the surface. It gets into a lot of things,
- 14:39and it's good. I think it's good that it centers. Yeah. Yeah,
- 14:43I think it's good because it centers the victims and interviews them a lot.
- 14:48But like I said, it just wasn't as convincing as the data that
- 14:54I found later. In fact, while I was watching the documentary, I
- 15:00my wife can attest to this. When they were going into the specifics of
- 15:03what Bill Gothard had done criminally sexually harassment wise, I was really scrutinizing what
- 15:09the victims were claiming, and there were a couple of things in there obviously
- 15:13that were alarming and criminal, but it was kind of milk toast. It
- 15:18was kind of lackluster, and I remember thinking, well, either they're trumping
- 15:22it up to make it seem worse than it was, or they just kind
- 15:28of skimmed over that. When I looked into it, it's it's a hundred
- 15:31times worse than to document. You don't get kicked out of your own organization
- 15:37over a milk toast thing, right, right, you don't kick your chrismatically
- 15:41the whole reason why your organism, you know. Yeah, anyway, so
- 15:46we'll get into the document So so anyway, So I watched a documentary,
- 15:50then I listened to a lot of podcasts. So I searched on my podcast
- 15:56app for the Duggers and everything, and there's a lot of podcasts not only
- 16:02by people who are survivors or other kinds of podcasts that are focused on cult
- 16:07survivors, or podcasts that are focused on Christianity, more mainstream Christianity in the
- 16:11United States, and they actually want to criticize IBLP. But also that Duggers
- 16:17have podcasts of their own that I have listened to in which they've talked about
- 16:22the documentary. Are there nineteen podcasts eventually, I'm sure. And I will
- 16:29say that most, if not all, of the commentators on the podcasts were
- 16:34Christians themselves. So this is an inside critique of it. It's not like
- 16:41you and I criticizing from the outside. It's people from the inside. So
- 16:44it's kind of interesting gutears coming from inside the house. It's interesting to hear
- 16:48the way they talk about it too, because it's not the way you and
- 16:51I would talk about it. Right. Well, Like one of my favorite
- 16:53YouTubers, you might have seen him. He was Jehovah, Jehovah's Witness and
- 17:00he's no longer and he criticizes that community and posts a lot of videos.
- 17:07It's not the only thing he does. He specializes actually in cults and things
- 17:08like that. But you know, it's who's that YouTuber? The name is
- 17:14escaping me. I'll have to so I just a side note one of our
- 17:18tangents, the YouTubers who have terrible names to their YouTube channel. Yeah,
- 17:22I know there. I would say a lot of my favorite YouTube channels if
- 17:29you just asked, even though I've watched thousands of hours and I maybe watch
- 17:33him every day, I'm like, wait, what's their name and what's the
- 17:37name of the channel, Like, uh yeah, because some of them are
- 17:41like okay, the skeptical atheist or something, you know, right, But
- 17:44but often they're like a string of letters and you could tell that they made
- 17:48the account in nights or in two thousand and eight, because that was how
- 17:52you did things back then, and they gained notoriety and they just kept at
- 17:57the same it's like that guy Enguin's Penguin zero, Penguin Z whatever. Yeah,
- 18:03and he's one of the biggest, biggest things. Yeah, so I've
- 18:04been referring to him as Penguin zero or something, and then people are like
- 18:08in the comment section, like, isn't that quaint that doctor Kirk refers to
- 18:12him as Penguin guy when it's his name is Charlie something. But then his
- 18:17whole brand is called something else. Well, it's like, so my favorite
- 18:22Diablo two YouTuber is mister Lama. Do you know mister Lama. I don't
- 18:26know, but that's his name, mister Lamma. But at least that's you,
- 18:30I mean, Penguin zero, but it has nothing to do with Diablo
- 18:33or anything anyway. Yeah, So this podcast series also dips into could be
- 18:41applied to a lot of different cults around the world, right or destructive groups,
- 18:47high control groups. Also, I watched a lot of YouTube documentaries which
- 18:52were not Christians talking about it. A lot of really great documentaries. Again,
- 18:56I wish I had them in front of me, but you can just
- 19:00search from I read a lot of articles, I researched a lot of laws
- 19:03in entertainment, and reality TV. I also, as I said earlier,
- 19:07skimmed and read large sections of the Wisdom books themselves, the Home School of
- 19:14Instruments and a lot of things. Again, I pulled a lot of quotes.
- 19:18It's it's interesting again in the documentary they get into it kind of,
- 19:25but not as anyway, we just had more time. Well before you told
- 19:29me about this topic that we were going to do it, I had randomly
- 19:32seen a whole thing on one of those crime channels about Josh Dugger and it
- 19:37was all about that. So you had, but I hadn't connected the dots.
- 19:41Actually, even though the name is I don't know any other Duggers or
- 19:45something. I just had like, yeah, there's this Josh dude that I
- 19:48saw this thing. And so when I when you're like, hey, we
- 19:49need to we want to do this. But it probably wasn't a really lengthy
- 19:52documentary, right, Well it was, but it was like an hour and
- 19:55a half with police interviews and all that, you know, all this stuff
- 19:57because it was about and it was about his recent stuff, so I didn't
- 20:02talk about the old allegations. It was all about the child pornography. So
- 20:06I just knew that. And then when I started looking into the duggers,
- 20:07I'm like, wait a minute, that's that thing. Yeah, the dude
- 20:14has a real generic face, you know what I mean. So I could
- 20:17imagine it not being registered for you. Okay, So some caveats that I
- 20:22want to get up front and berto, you don't have to agree with this,
- 20:26but I'm not going to ridicule Christians in this series. If that's the
- 20:32sort of thing you're looking for, then this might not be for you.
- 20:37Among the two point three billion estimated people who identify as Christian, there are
- 20:44highly problematic Christians, and highly problematic Christian groups, and also really ethical and
- 20:51wonderful Christian groups. There are Christian churches in Seattle that have queer pastors,
- 20:56for example, and have the gay Pride flag as the only flag that's waving
- 21:03in front of their church. Not that that's an indication that there aren't any
- 21:08problems happening, but you know what I'm saying. So if it's a broad
- 21:12range, yeah, there's a broad range. I'm a recovering religious person and
- 21:18I wouldn't have appreciated being made fun of. There was a little period of
- 21:22time in the two thousand and eight time frame where I was listening to a
- 21:27lot of debates and things with but I don't know, it's just I agree.
- 21:33I don't think it's conducive or fair to anyone to make fun of their
- 21:37of them or their beliefs and things. In that sense. What I do
- 21:40think is it's fair to criticize when institutions and people in power in those institutions
- 21:45cause harm. Yeah, and Christianity is not a monolith. I've talked about
- 21:52the Christian Church that I grew up in in the seventies, and I describe
- 21:56it as like hippie Christian And I've actually asked my parents a lot about if
- 22:02my memories were accurate. There was no talk about anti gay people. There
- 22:07was no talk about the sort of things you hear from contemporary evangelical churches.
- 22:14Right, There's no talk about about politics. I don't remember that ever being
- 22:18a topic. In fact, when I was growing up, I was explicitly
- 22:22told by adults that it was impolite actually to talk about politics at all.
- 22:30You couldn't it was impolite to talk about money and politics. Now you could
- 22:33maybe say that privileged individuals can do that and it doesn't affect them. But
- 22:38anyway, so I actually full disclosure. Have a lot of positive memories,
- 22:45maybe exclusively positive memories. In fact, one of the only negative memories I
- 22:51have from church is I was with my friend and she was playing Imagine by
- 22:56John Lennon on the piano. And we were sixteen seventeen and we're in the
- 23:00main I don't know what you call it, Yeah, were the main what
- 23:04do you call it the worship room or whatever? The church? Yeah,
- 23:07and the church. Yeah, so it's the main piano that's you know,
- 23:11by the pulpit and everything. And she's playing a match on the piano by
- 23:15memory, and we're both singing it and you know, just kind of casually,
- 23:19and it's pretty empty, and this new congregant walked in, probably from
- 23:26one of the maybe even an IBLP member for all I freaking know. And
- 23:30she was and I was in the church since we were in a trailer by
- 23:36the fish hatchery and its aquad you know, there was this little field that
- 23:41I think it was maybe abandoned or something, this tiny little thing, and
- 23:47by this point we actually got a history. Yeah, it's like, uh,
- 23:51yeah, I've been there a long time. This this newcomer walks in
- 23:55and hears us playing Imagine, by John Lennon, and she says she who
- 24:00whoa you can't play that song? And we're like, one, who are
- 24:03you two what? And she's like, well, it's like I can't religion.
- 24:07Yeah, not only anti religion, but it was it was evils.
- 24:11It was it wasn't just anti religion. It was like it'll infect you.
- 24:17Yeah, it'll it'll it'll it's spreading evil or something, you know. And
- 24:22I remember the two of us immediately just I don't know if we verbally told
- 24:27her, but in our heads were just like, you're an idiot. Like
- 24:32listen to the lyrics of the song. Yeah, it says, you know,
- 24:36be religious if you want to, but let's focus on being good to
- 24:40people. So we should actually try to help people, not be hungry.
- 24:45We should end war. Like, so you're you think this song is evil
- 24:48just because there's this one line where he says, no heaven above us,
- 24:52no hell below no no, I mean imagine no religion. Listen. I
- 24:56remember those sentiments. So a lot a lot of my friends, I wouldn't
- 25:00say my main friends, but like I had this second set of friends that
- 25:03were in uh, fundamentalists Christian churches in Tacoma or in Tacoma. Okay,
- 25:11were these your non Asian friends? Yeah? Uh yeah, I don't think
- 25:15yes, correct, because famously when Burto came from to the United States,
- 25:22he somehow So my best friends rash you you sat down at the Asian guy
- 25:30table, and they invited me, Like I was at the nerd table,
- 25:33me and these two dudes that aka the Asian table, No, the hufflepuff
- 25:38table. No, no, but I was. So I was with these
- 25:41two other dudes, these two white dudes that I had befriended, and I
- 25:44was bored out of my mind because you know, like I'm nerdy, but
- 25:47these guys had social problems. I don't have that. So wait, I've
- 25:52never heard the story, tangent. So how did were they assigned to you?
- 25:57No? No, it's just I'm brand new school. You know,
- 26:00I started in tenth grade. I'm in Tacoma and at this Lakes High School.
- 26:04And you're English? Is I speak as I speak? Now? Right,
- 26:07you're fluent. But I don't know anyone. So you know, it's
- 26:10lunch time and so I don't know. And I think I met one of
- 26:12them in a class. So I think I had a class with one of
- 26:15them. And I'm like oh, hey, so I just sit down and
- 26:18we had we did that for a few days. I think you were real
- 26:19extroverted. Yeah yeah, so I think we did that for like a week.
- 26:22Maybe I was sitting with them for a week. So it's it's a
- 26:25pattern that's now a step. Like We've gone several days sitting at lunch.
- 26:29But I'm bored out of my mind because they don't have anything to talk about.
- 26:33I've seen this movie. It's called Can't Buy Me Love. Oh,
- 26:37and he's and then he graduates to the cool kids. But this is basically
- 26:41what happened to me. I'm sitting there and they Can't Buy Me Love table,
- 26:44by the way, a movie I watched like twenty five times when I
- 26:48was a teenager, all right, And so I'm sitting there. Anyways,
- 26:52I had met this other guy at my youth group. So speaking of youth
- 26:56groups, this guy tyver Zoni, super cool, Vietnam, half half Asian,
- 27:02and he tells me one day, hey, you should sit with us.
- 27:06And with us was him a Korean, a Japanese, another half Korean,
- 27:11and then a white dude, and then an exchange student from Germany also
- 27:15went. But you know, lots of Asians in there, and plus their
- 27:18extended group included three or four other Asians up. So I thought, Okay,
- 27:22that sounds cool, but I didn't know what to do because I'm like,
- 27:26so, did you know, like this is a better Oh yeah,
- 27:30it was an upgrade for sure. And I don't want not to mention they
- 27:33had a band. I was kind of interested in that. I don't wanted
- 27:37to talk more about that. So I'm like, how am I gonna tell
- 27:40him? And so I sit down. It's still sad. I sit down.
- 27:41I'm like, hey, I'm gonna go sit over there, and they
- 27:45look at me like but like puppy coog eyes, like why, oh,
- 27:48it's just I don't remember, but it probably said I'm like, oh,
- 27:52it's because like he goes to my youth group and I picked up my little
- 27:55lunch and I walked away and that was the end of that short lived yeah,
- 28:00And they probably turned to each other and was just like, good fucking
- 28:04They're just like, man, we almost had it all. We could have
- 28:08had it all. He was our ticket. They might have said that,
- 28:12or they might have said, like, god, that guy talks a lot.
- 28:17Anyways, So that was my entry into the Asian world. But what
- 28:22I was saying about the other and then the Japanese guy sitting at the table
- 28:27through a friend of mine, I met you, That's how we met.
- 28:30But what I was saying about like the other the other groups of friends that
- 28:33I had that were in the fundamentalist churches. In fact, one of them
- 28:37was kind of like my second best friend in high school, second or third
- 28:41best friend in high school. But I had a lot of these acquaintances and
- 28:45stuff, and there was a lot of this of what you're describing where they
- 28:51would talk about the negative influences of media, like songs and bands and like
- 28:56what almost anything that wasn't a Christian band was a bad influence. Like Madonna,
- 29:03Yeah, that's already, you've already like you are in hell already,
- 29:07we're talking about even like like pop music that was not I know, there
- 29:12was a controversy with Amy Grant, Yeah, exactly because she got a divorce
- 29:18or something. Well maybe, but the big thing was that she transitioned from
- 29:22purely overtly Christian music to pop music. Right, so then that was not
- 29:26okay and stuff, and it wasn't just music. There were certain movies that
- 29:30you shouldn't watch and stuff. And their conversations often were about demon and angel
- 29:34warfare, so like a lot of this what sex they'd be talking about,
- 29:40like they would you know, they'd be like, well, I see I
- 29:42saw yesterday, I saw this person was being mean. I saw the demon
- 29:47rise up. And they were always engaging in these actual in their heads battles
- 29:51for their souls and the souls of everyone around them between angels and demons.
- 29:53So to them it was this real thing. Yeah, you know, there's
- 29:56a lot of beliefs in the world, but when you have a system that
- 30:02systematizes cult harm of people and society, then that's a whole other thing,
- 30:07right right. And by the way, if you were a Catholic, which
- 30:08at the time I was, you're kind of as good as an atheist or
- 30:14worse, you know, or maybe not worse, but like to them,
- 30:17to them, yeah, because like that wasn't real Christians. Yeah, it's
- 30:19like so they're also very slight, like you had to be a reborn Christian
- 30:23in these specific churches, right, I think it was, I wonder anyway,
- 30:27So we'll get into that sort of thing. Also, trigger alert because
- 30:33we'll be getting into discussions of child abuse and physical abuse of children and some
- 30:38of the descriptions and the details can't be avoided and really should be discussed,
- 30:44so trigger alert. Maybe for the whole thing, I'm going to try to
- 30:47sprinkle them in as it's more important to point out. And another thing is
- 30:52that each chapter of this series will have a free portion and a patron only
- 30:57portion, because when I spend a lot of time away from other kinds of
- 31:04work, like at my university or in my private practice, I want to
- 31:08reward the patrons because they're literally giving me the money so that I can spend
- 31:14that time. But first, Bruto, it's actually take a break. What
- 31:15do you say? Let's do it all right, we're back from the break.
- 31:22So I'm going to quickly summarize the entire story, basically leaving out obviously
- 31:27a lot of details of the Duggers, because that's the jumping off point here.
- 31:33I'm guessing some of you know it in full detail. Some of you
- 31:37maybe you've never heard of the Duggers, like I had never heard of them.
- 31:41So in a nutshell, the Duggers were a family on reality TV based
- 31:45on the fact that they had so many children. They had nineteen children.
- 31:48Well, we'll get into specifics on that later they had nineteen children, and
- 31:52the show was focused on the parents and the children and maybe other family members
- 31:57and how they managed to make things work on with so many children. You
- 32:04know which, by the way, at the time, I remember hearing that
- 32:07there was a show about a family with so many children, and yeah,
- 32:10I literally thought that was all of it. And I guess that was their
- 32:14angle, was like, wow, yeah, how do you have that many
- 32:15children? That's crazy? How could you even manage? Right? I think
- 32:20that was the spectacle, the circus spectacle of it, right exactly. They
- 32:23were hugely popular. They were on television for seventeen years. Berto wait wait,
- 32:30yeah, because they had specials before they had their TV show, So
- 32:36if you include their yeah, and then they had their spinoff show. But
- 32:39yeah, but it's just the timeline because they started. Wasn't the first special
- 32:45fourteen or something in County. I mean, they already had I have it
- 32:49all written down somewhere. It's it's all in my notes. I have it
- 32:52pretty micro. But yeah, seventeen years and they'd still be on today if
- 32:57it weren't for what we'll get into. They were even after they had spinoffs
- 33:01of some of the kids and stuff, right, I mean, arguably they're
- 33:05still making money from their fame, you know what I mean. One,
- 33:09this show was one of the early reality TV juggernauts that we have all come
- 33:15to know and love in today's world, you know, because in the nineties,
- 33:20of course, and you could argue that reality TV goes back before that,
- 33:22but it started in earnest with the Real World. Yeah, so let's
- 33:28talk about that for a second. Because so, first of all, when
- 33:30this whole Dugger Dugger family thing, in my mind, reality TV was so
- 33:35over because I was an early adopter of reality TV, which also to your
- 33:39point, it's not exactly right, because yeah, there've been reality type shows
- 33:44forever, really, but the Real World was such a phenomena. And I
- 33:47think it was because at the time, most of the content we consumed that
- 33:52wasn't like the news, was like these produced kind of like fake stories and
- 33:57stuff, and then outcome these people that supposedly are just living their lives without
- 34:01any script well, and also it was on MTV, right, so at
- 34:07the time, I'm sure maybe younger people might not be able to relate to
- 34:13this, but MTV in the eighties was essentially our entire lives, our entire
- 34:19lives revolved around MTV and we watched everything. We watched all the interviews and
- 34:25all the videos and the countdowns and when you had there was an alternative there's
- 34:30a two hour span of time from ten to midnight on Sundays, which isn't
- 34:36a good time slot, but I lived for those two hours because they had
- 34:39alternative bands that, like alternative rock wasn't a term yet, and they had
- 34:46bands like the Posies and other kinds of bands that I Hoosker do ri em
- 34:52like before they were famous and yeah, so when so when they came,
- 34:57when they came out with anything, we would have watched it. But they
- 35:00had this reality TV show. And another aspect was that these kids were cool.
- 35:05They were cool, they were young, they were and their music was
- 35:07related to it because you know, yeah, and every one of them was
- 35:10kind of an interesting personality and they all It was also sort of progressive because
- 35:15they started having gay gay folks as well, and there were conflicts and they
- 35:22didn't sugarcoat the conflict. Yeah as far as we knew, right, like
- 35:24it was like they're really having an argument, yeah on TV. Yeah,
- 35:30yeah, And it was relatable to me because literally at the time when that
- 35:34show was coming out. I was living with several roommates because I couldn't afford
- 35:37to live on my own, and yeah, we fought. Yeah, and
- 35:44these were friends of mine that some of them I was friends with since preschool.
- 35:47So you know, we knew each other really well, more than maybe
- 35:52I knew my siblings, and we could really get under each other's skin.
- 35:58Yeah. Another aspect I think of its success was that it introduced, or
- 36:04at least it was it gave younger people an excuse to watch basically a soap
- 36:08opera. A soap opera, good point. We're marketed towards a different demographic,
- 36:15and for our generation, we didn't have any mainstream soap opera material that
- 36:21was really marketed to us in this country. In Colombia, I grew up
- 36:24like everyone around me watched soap opera, so I couldn't. I mean I
- 36:29even was watching some of them because like I couldn't get away from it,
- 36:31Like my grandma was watching. It's like it was all over the place,
- 36:35but up here absolutely, yeah, kids, they were watching other stuff.
- 36:38Yeah, and yet you're right, that's a good observation. This is a
- 36:40soap opera. Yeah, And it was a part of the cultural talk.
- 36:45You know, everyone was talking about it. They were in different cities.
- 36:49It was in New York, right, first time. Eventually it's in Seattle
- 36:51because Seattle was all the rage. People were telling me that I should audition
- 36:55for the show. But did San Francisco? Yeah, Puck, Puck was
- 37:00the maybe maybe it was was it? It was I think it was New
- 37:02York, San Francisco, then Seattle or something. Yeah, anyway, yeah,
- 37:07Puck, he's still famous. So yeah, so you were saying that
- 37:13when where were you saying? Well, I was saying so, like,
- 37:15yeah, that was a big phenomena, and that kind of kick started for
- 37:17a lot of us, officially the beginning of reality TV, right, And
- 37:22then MTV obviously saw that, and then they started doing a whole bunch of
- 37:25reality ish type stuff, and then other channels caught on, and then all
- 37:29of a sudden, you start seeing Survivor, and you start seeing the dating
- 37:32shows. Who wants to date a millionaire? Who wants all these kinds of
- 37:36things. And so I was a big consumer of reality TV through the nineties
- 37:39and into the two thousands, early two thousands, Like, I watched so
- 37:45much of that stuff. Really, what'd you watch all of it, like
- 37:47I didn't watch a Survivor, like I was very much into Survivor. Well,
- 37:52one of the reasons what just side note that I didn't watch any of
- 37:54these shows is I didn't have I couldn't afford cable, right, Yeah,
- 37:58I had Bunny ears that didn't work that well, and then antenna. So
- 38:02I just watched VHS tapes. I watched, I watched a lot of movies,
- 38:07you know, and so I couldn't watch it, but I remember the
- 38:10whole phenomenon around Survivor and stuff. Yeah, and so I watched that and
- 38:14then we watched I did get into all the dating things at first. So
- 38:16there was I don't remember the first one, but it's like maybe who wants
- 38:20to marry a millionaire? But then there was Joe the Millionaire. But then
- 38:24there was like Joe the No. One or something like there's all these variants
- 38:28in the Bachelor and all those that's all these variants. Then there was the
- 38:31Flavor of but there was one thing. There was Rock of Love, and
- 38:35then there was Flavor of Love. Yeah. By that point, that's when
- 38:37I started sort of like dropping off. But I spent the good I don't
- 38:43know, eight maybe even a decade of reality TV. I didn't know that.
- 38:49Yeah, I completely missed it. Another reason why I didn't watch any
- 38:52of these shows was because I was starting to get into my career and didn't
- 38:58have a lot of didn't have a lot of time for TV. I had
- 39:02a hard time even watching sports. I was an avid Sonics and Seahawks fan
- 39:07throughout the nineties, and I remember I just had to make this choice.
- 39:10I'm just like, I have to stop because I will not be able to
- 39:15succeed in this career. You know, as as a student, as a
- 39:17professor, you know, I was working all the time anyway. So yeah,
- 39:21the Duggers, the various different reality TV shows became one of the early
- 39:25reality TV juggernauts and kick started the TLC phenomenon. As a I didn't know
- 39:31that at all, Like I didn't raise That's the thing that I didn't either.
- 39:36So so so, as many of you know, I've been watching ninety
- 39:39Day fiance On on YouTube reacting to it. It's on TLC. But even
- 39:46a couple of months ago, if you had asked me what channel is ninety
- 39:50Day fiance On? I would have been like, uh, I don't know.
- 39:54But but a lot of people refer to the tal see umbrella. You
- 40:00know, there's a whole culture around that because it's it's been basically just so
- 40:07it was the learning Channel, right, So you and I remember when it
- 40:12was programming like educational for kids. Assessed my memory anyway, Like they had
- 40:19all sorts of medical things and they had right, there was a lot of
- 40:22actual learning ish material. Yeah, and I think it was sort of like
- 40:27PBS. Yeah, and and the way they described it as at first they
- 40:31I do think they saw this in the vein of like because in the documentary
- 40:36they were talking about how a lot of their things were about odd medical situations,
- 40:40like oh, this person has a conjoined twins, and I think they
- 40:44saw it as like, wow, how do you give birth to so many
- 40:45people and keep them alive? So it's sort of like a medical oddity almost
- 40:50interesting. I didn't catch that, but they didn't probably realize what it was
- 40:52going to do. Yeah, that's right. Another factor is there was a
- 40:58writer strike in Hollywood, which the first one well I don't know, I
- 41:01don't know, but the one that we remember, yeah, right, the
- 41:04big one we remember. And so what happened was the production companies for TV
- 41:10shows suddenly couldn't make any of their television. So they had already known about
- 41:16reality TV and they're like, well, we don't need quote unquote writers for
- 41:22reality TV, and so anyway, you just need a smart producer to chop
- 41:27things right, right, I mean you could argue there's writing, yes,
- 41:30there they you know, scripted ish anyway, So TLC became this reality TV
- 41:36powerhouse because of the Duggers. You know, starting with the other shows would
- 41:39follow the Duggers, John and Kate plus eight, which maybe we'll deal a
- 41:44deep dive on them at some point. Very highly controversial family as well,
- 41:50but I have no knowledge of what those controversies are from. I think what
- 41:55the show is based on is similar to the Duggers. They probably said,
- 41:59oh, the Duggers are doing well, Well, what's She's not the one
- 42:01that had eight eight tuplets? Right, Octomom? That was octimm Right did
- 42:08Octimom have a TV? I just I just remember she was on tabloids.
- 42:12No, John and Kate had they just had eight kids. Date well,
- 42:15but they had I think a set of twins and then a set of sex
- 42:21tuplets. Oh so they really okay, so they did have a big yeah
- 42:25output here six kids at once, so at least five or six anyway,
- 42:32Sister Wives, which is about a polygamous family. I think LDS. I'm
- 42:37not sure. Hoarding TV show two thousands, and I got into that quite
- 42:40a bit, the hoarding series he did for a while. I don't still
- 42:45but I did watch a lot of those episodes, so tangent on that we
- 42:50should have maybe a little sign tangent alert. So according to experts, including
- 42:54my colleague at Antioch University, Jennifer Sampson McNamara, the show is a horrible
- 43:01thing for people with hoarding and also for but I don't know this specifics,
- 43:07and also for the culture. I mean, it's good that it raises awareness
- 43:12of the problem, but yeah, it because correct me if I'm wrong.
- 43:15The show's premise is they confront these individuals and then they clear everything out,
- 43:21sometimes very aggressively. Yeah, I guess I have thought while I was watching
- 43:23some of them, I'm like, I don't see, is this healthy for
- 43:27them? Like yeah, I mean it certainly satisfies an itch for the viewers
- 43:31because including myself, like not, I don't think this about hoarders and people
- 43:37with actual mental illnesses and disorders that have reasons as to why they exist,
- 43:40not just that they haven't had time to clean, you know, but I
- 43:45when I see clutter, like at my parents' house or something, I'm always
- 43:51like, especially to that extreme. But there's also the aspect that most often
- 43:54the episodes involved their relatives or close loved ones who are offering as a result.
- 44:00And so there's part of it we're like, well, enough is enough
- 44:02and stuff, But I could totally see the other side, which is,
- 44:06hey, when you do actually have this trauma, this approach might not be
- 44:09or whatever. You know. Yeah, research even shows that not only does
- 44:14the hoarding renew itself after the film crew leaves, but within a short amount
- 44:21of time, like an alarmingly short amount of time, maybe just a few
- 44:24months, the hoarding will be worse than it was before because they have an
- 44:29additional trauma of having been forced to face something way too fast and they were
- 44:36ready. Well, I have only ten gents. I have a friend who's
- 44:39got a relative who has had hoarding disorder for as long as I can remember,
- 44:45and they've gone through several rounds of tablasa where they cleaned out and everything,
- 44:50and then it just comes back, and it's so disheartening. Yeah,
- 44:52I mean without treatment for the disorder and specialized treatment because it's really a special
- 45:00and Jennifer Sampson McNamara in Tacoma has the Hoarding Project founded the Hoarding Project that
- 45:07pulls together a team of professionals and experts to help families, and they go
- 45:13slow, They talk with the family and the individual. They involve police department
- 45:20because sometimes you have to or not police, but the fire department. You
- 45:22have to involve people who understand structural problems of a home or fire hazards because
- 45:30as a clinician, you don't want to enter a home because that's often to
- 45:32where it has to happen the treatment. You don't want to enter a place
- 45:36that you're going to die in which you know can happen anyway. So Hoarding
- 45:38another show which raises the topic of the unethical harm that happens because of some
- 45:46reality TV shows, including the Duggers shows. So Berto, I have to
- 45:52just, you know, abruptly pause here and say that due to our ramblings,
- 45:59we need to end the free portion here and the rest of this will
- 46:02just be for patrons of the podcast. So if you want to hear the
- 46:05rest of this chapter, become a patron on Patreon and you'll get access to
- 46:09this episode and hundreds of other episodes that arguably are our best episodes. You
- 46:15know, deep dives on personality disorders, other kinds of thing are full.
- 46:17Jodiarius series in full, and everyone out there please take care of yourself if
- 46:24you're not going to be a patron, because you deserve it,