Latest / Consumerpedia / 95 - Cryptocurrency: Coins, Cons, & Chaos
Transcript
- 0:01Cryptocurrency is no longer a digital curiosity.
- 0:05It's moved into the financial mainstream.
- 0:07About 28% of US adults now hold some form of digital assets.
- 0:11Major financial firms and banks are increasingly offering crypto
- 0:15to their clients, and a growing number of merchants and
- 0:17businesses except crypto payments.
- 0:20Despite lingering concerns about volatility, scams and LAX
- 0:23regulatory oversight, digital currencies have evolved from a
- 0:27speculative niche into an increasingly accepted form of
- 0:30currency. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:32Man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:35Welcome to consumerpedia@checkbook.org.
- 0:38We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:42trouble and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:45advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:48can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:52objective. Now here's the host of Consumer
- 0:54Pedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man, Herb Weisbaum.
- 1:00In this episode, what is crypto, how does it work, and why are
- 1:03people buying a currency that's virtually unregulated?
- 1:06We'll also explain meme coins and stable coins.
- 1:09Plus, is crypto really as secure as we're led to believe?
- 1:13Spoiler alert, it's not. We have two experts to discuss
- 1:16all this, Amanda Fisher, policy director and COO of Better
- 1:20Markets, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that
- 1:23promotes the public interest in the financial markets and tries
- 1:26to make our financial system work for all Americans again.
- 1:29Before that, she served as chief of staff at the Securities and
- 1:32Exchange Commission, so she has an extensive knowledge about
- 1:35investments. Hi.
- 1:36Thank you so much for having me and Corey.
- 1:38Frayer, Director of Investor Protection at the Consumer
- 1:41Federation of America. Corey also worked at the SEC as
- 1:44a senior advisor. His focus was on financial
- 1:46stability and crypto asset markets.
- 1:49Prior to that, he held key positions on the Senate Banking
- 1:52Committee. Hello, Corey.
- 1:53Hi, thanks for having me on we all.
- 1:55Talk about crypto currencies, if we understand what it is and how
- 1:58it works, but let's be honest, we really don't.
- 2:00Most have heard about Bitcoin, the most popular form of digital
- 2:03currency, and that's about it. So in late terms, Corey, what is
- 2:07cryptocurrency and why was it created?
- 2:09Cryptocurrency started out as sort of a response to the 2008
- 2:13financial crisis, as this idea that people needed to take power
- 2:17of the financial system away from the regulators, the Wall
- 2:20Street banks and others that had failed them when we bailed out
- 2:23the folks that calls the financial crisis and really
- 2:25didn't do anything to help the regular people affected by it.
- 2:28Now, what crypto has become is essentially a machine where
- 2:32money goes in one side and political bribery and money
- 2:36laundering comes out the other. It is essentially a digital
- 2:40currency that's created out of thin air.
- 2:42It is hard to trace. The people who trade it are
- 2:45basically anonymous, and its value is based on sort of this
- 2:49public fervor about the technology itself.
- 2:52And Amanda, it's not regulated like banks and credit card
- 2:55companies and really has nothing backing it up, right?
- 2:57There is no underlying asset behind a cryptocurrency, unlike
- 3:02say stock where you are getting a claim to the future profits of
- 3:07a company. With a crypto asset you're
- 3:10really just buying into an idea, a meme, an image.
- 3:15But I will say that while crypto is not currently complying with
- 3:21regulations, there are long standing laws dating back to the
- 3:25Great Depression for which crypto should be complying.
- 3:28And the Biden administration did try to bring crypto firms into
- 3:32compliance. They strongly resisted those
- 3:35efforts, and now they are before Congress trying to retroactively
- 3:40amend laws to fit their business models such that they don't have
- 3:45to comply with regulations. I always hear people say digital
- 3:49currency is safe and secure because of the blockchain,
- 3:52whatever that is. The encrypted technology that
- 3:54makes all this possible. It's difficult to alter or hack.
- 3:57All the transactions are public so anyone can verify them.
- 4:00Is that? Right.
- 4:01Well, it's complicated. First of all, most crypto users
- 4:05that are transacting in cryptocurrencies are not doing
- 4:09so on a blockchain. They're accessing these products
- 4:12through big intermediaries that call themselves exchanges like
- 4:16Coinbase or Binance. And when you interact with an
- 4:20intermediary like that, they are just changing entries in their
- 4:25internal databases. Saying that Amanda sold 10
- 4:29Bitcoin and Corey bought 10 Bitcoin.
- 4:31There's no blockchain involved. So much of the original promise
- 4:35of cryptocurrency was the blockchain.
- 4:38It was being able to transact without a centralized
- 4:41intermediary in the middle that could censor or surveil your
- 4:45activity. But today, most of the activity
- 4:49does not occur on a blockchain. And all of these firms have
- 4:52sprouted up to basically reinvent the wheel of exchanges,
- 4:57broker dealers, banks, and all the sort of trusted
- 5:00intermediaries that we come to rely on when engaging with the
- 5:03financial system. Corey, I would assume that
- 5:06thousands of people control the blockchain, right?
- 5:07Well, that's what the industry says and that's what they want
- 5:10you to believe. But the fact of the matter is
- 5:12sort of even what you might consider the most quote UN quote
- 5:16decentralized blockchains in fact have huge centralization
- 5:21and are typically controlled by a very small number of people.
- 5:24I think even the industry would agree that Bitcoin is sort of
- 5:27the prime example of a decentralized community run
- 5:31blockchain that requires many, many people on the network in
- 5:35order to keep it operating and therefore has very little
- 5:39control by small groups. Now the fact of the matter is
- 5:42there are 4 developers, the only four people in the world that
- 5:47have the ability to send updates to the blockchain software to
- 5:51propose changes. So that is an enormous amount of
- 5:55power over that network in the hands of just these four people.
- 5:59You look at the other large crypto assets, Ethereum being
- 6:02the next largest, and the Ethereum Foundation and Vitalik
- 6:06Buterin have enormous control over the development and changes
- 6:10of that blockchain. And even further, when they
- 6:13shifted to this what's called a proof of stake mechanism, which
- 6:17essentially means that the folks who have lots of Ethereum are in
- 6:22control of which Eerium transactions take place, you
- 6:27have seen again this centralization of the power in
- 6:30the blockchain into a small number of very, very wealthy
- 6:33people. People who could be blackmailed
- 6:36or bribed, or who could just decide on their own to do
- 6:38something nefarious. These people exercise enormous
- 6:42control over these networks. Some of them may be state actors
- 6:46working against the interests of the United States, facilitating
- 6:49money laundering, facilitating political bribery.
- 6:52Some of them may just be a attempting to manipulate
- 6:55transactions for their own gains.
- 6:58A number of the validators are able to profit off of charging
- 7:02fees for their transactions. And so they have many
- 7:06opportunities through their power to benefit more than the
- 7:10regular users. And then, you know, as Amanda
- 7:12mentioned, you have these large companies that have sprung up.
- 7:15The largest platforms are very centralized and often exercise a
- 7:20lot of power over the operation of the blockchain.
- 7:24They do a lot of Bitcoin mining, which is how they validate those
- 7:27transactions. And so there's enormous
- 7:29concentrations of power. Even the Trump family owns a
- 7:32very large and powerful Bitcoin mining network.
- 7:36So the fact of the matter is, regardless of the promise and
- 7:39the marketing of these blockchains as decentralized,
- 7:43the fact is they're very centralized, in most cases far
- 7:46more centralized than even our current financial system.
- 7:49And of course, then there's the issue of hack attacks.
- 7:51No matter how secure the blockchain may or may not be, it
- 7:54doesn't mean that criminals can't steal crypto that's stored
- 7:56on your digital wallet or with one of these third party
- 7:59companies that you guys have been talking about.
- 8:01I I looked it up. There have been at least 10
- 8:03crypto exchange hack of more than $100 million according to
- 8:07Crystal Intelligence. And earlier this year, criminals
- 8:10siphoned off $1.4 billion in a digital currency called Ethereum
- 8:15from a Dubai based crypto exchange called by BIT.
- 8:17It was the largest single theft of crypto in the industry's
- 8:21history. I think that's something people
- 8:22have to realize. It's digital.
- 8:24Anything digital can be hacked, right Amanda?
- 8:26Absolutely. Part of what makes
- 8:28cryptocurrency such an attractive honeypot for hackers
- 8:32is not only the ease with which can be stolen, but the ease with
- 8:37which it can be laundered once it is stolen.
- 8:40So there exists services online called mixers or tumblers that
- 8:45allows users to plug their cryptocurrency into this
- 8:48Internet application, essentially clean the Internet
- 8:53history of where that money came from and obfuscate movements of
- 8:59the funds. So, you know, if you think about
- 9:02traditional money laundering, if you've seen Ozark, the guy opens
- 9:06up a resort in order to hide the proceeds of a criminal
- 9:10enterprise. There's now just software that
- 9:12can do this. And the cryptocurrency industry
- 9:15has been very successful at rebuffing U.S. law enforcement
- 9:19attempts to shut that software down.
- 9:21So again, with the buy bit hack that you mentioned, $1.5 billion
- 9:26was stolen. But not only was it stolen to
- 9:29fund the North Korean nuclear missile program, but it was able
- 9:34to be laundered very quickly using these mixer Tumblr
- 9:39services so that the hackers could abscond with the funds and
- 9:44it would be outside the reach of law enforcement.
- 9:47And this can happen within minutes.
- 9:49So by the time that the crypto exchange or law enforcement
- 9:52realizes that it's gone, the proceeds are already taken
- 9:56offshore and you're retrievable. So just to recap, crypto is
- 9:59basically popular with criminals who are using it to move money
- 10:03around, people who want to avoid government regulation or avoid
- 10:06tax consequences. And then the rest of it, little
- 10:10percentage is used by people who think it's really cool to invest
- 10:12and make it rich and may lose a fortune.
- 10:14That pretty good summer, you guys.
- 10:15I think so. I'll just add, if you're
- 10:17familiar with ransomware attacks, which are attacks on
- 10:20companies, hospitals, Public Utilities, schools, you name it,
- 10:24where the hackers hold a software system or power system
- 10:29or an electrical grid hostage and demand a bribe to let the
- 10:33hostage go. 98% of those attacks are funded using cryptocurrency,
- 10:39meaning the hacker demands the bribe in the form of
- 10:42cryptocurrency. And the crypto industry will
- 10:44like to say, well, people launder money with cash, they
- 10:47launder money with artwork, Rolex watches, cases of wine.
- 10:51But I think it's important to note that all those items are
- 10:53physically bulky and hard to carry around, and it requires a
- 10:57large network of people to do the money laundering.
- 11:00So there's a reason that ransomware attackers demand
- 11:03payment in crypto and not watches or artwork.
- 11:07Good point. You know, when it comes to
- 11:09crypto, we're in what feels like a modern day gold rush where
- 11:12some people will get rich and some will lose everything.
- 11:14And we're going to talk about that next.
- 11:16I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 11:19powered by checkbook.org. At checkbook.org, we have the
- 11:24answers to your consumer questions 24/7.
- 11:27That's checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 11:30can help you with select local service providers, avoid
- 11:33trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 11:36advertising or take money from any business, we recommend, you
- 11:39can rely on Checkbook to be completely independent and
- 11:42objective. Our advice is always free.
- 11:45Ratings of local services are available with a subscription.
- 11:48If you live in one of these seven metro areas and haven't
- 11:51joined Checkbook yet, check us out.
- 11:53Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 11:57Minneapolis, Saint Paul and Washington DC Get your free 30
- 12:01day subscription by going to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 12:06In just a few years, crypto has gone from a fringe Internet
- 12:09experiment to something you hear about on the Evening News and
- 12:12see in your banking app. Big investment firms and banks
- 12:15now offer Bitcoin funds. Payment giants like PayPal and
- 12:18Visa make it easy to spend or store it, and apps like Venmo
- 12:21let you buy a few dollars worth with the same tap you'd use to
- 12:24split a lunch bill. Whether it's your cousin
- 12:26bragging about a new token, a Super Bowl ad for an exchange,
- 12:29or Bitcoin prices scrolling along with the Dow on CNBC,
- 12:33crypto has worked its way into everyday life, even if plenty of
- 12:37people still aren't sure exactly what it is or how it works.
- 12:40The crypto craze is also powered by the potential for enormous
- 12:43riches. In 2010, when the first exchange
- 12:46opened, a Bitcoin was valued at about $0.03.
- 12:49Today, a single Bitcoin is worth $122,000.
- 12:53So, Corey, why wouldn't I want to get on on this action?
- 12:56It's important to remember that crypto isn't really an
- 12:59investment. Crypto is as much an investment
- 13:02as betting on next week's Indianapolis Colts game.
- 13:06So it's important to realize sort of the distinction between
- 13:10growing your money based on companies that contribute to the
- 13:14overall growth of the economy and sell real goods and
- 13:17services, and this digital technology that's kind of made
- 13:21out of thin air and where you have to trust whatever the
- 13:26creator says rather than having verifiable information about
- 13:30your supposed investment. Now there are these traditional
- 13:35vehicles that we've seen crypto sort of creep into like exchange
- 13:40traded funds. And that makes it seem as though
- 13:44these could be safe investments because they come with this
- 13:47small number of regulations. But the fact is those funds have
- 13:51the same vulnerabilities to hacking.
- 13:54They're subject to the same concentration of the crypto
- 13:56markets. They have all of the volatile
- 14:00qualities of that broader non compliant ecosystem with the
- 14:05veil of safety. There's really not a Safeway to
- 14:10quote UN quote invest in crypto now.
- 14:14When you talk about seeing other people get rich, that's just the
- 14:18law of big numbers. There are always going to be
- 14:21winners. There are always going to be
- 14:22losers. But if you take a look at who's
- 14:25winning in this space, take for example the Trump meme coin.
- 14:29About 50 people who invested in that meme coin made money, and
- 14:33they made millions of dollars. About 750,000 people who
- 14:39invested in that meme coin lost money.
- 14:41And so you really have to think about, do you really have a
- 14:45chance in this marketplace that doesn't have the same
- 14:48protections, doesn't have the same rules of fairness, doesn't
- 14:53have the same oversight as the kind of investments that track
- 14:57the broader economy, the kinds of investments that are subject
- 15:00to those protections that we established after the 29 crisis
- 15:05and the Great Depression that we established after the 2008
- 15:09crisis? Amanda, he used the word
- 15:11volatility a couple of times. People need to realize that it
- 15:14doesn't always go up. It can drop precipitously.
- 15:17And if you need that money for some reason, you could lose a
- 15:19fortune. It is not uncommon to see 203040
- 15:24even 50% price swings in the price of Bitcoin over the course
- 15:28of a day, and I would say that Bitcoin tends to be one of the
- 15:31less volatile crypto currencies out there.
- 15:34Another thing that I think is really important to keep in mind
- 15:37is that there is also not the market surveillance in law
- 15:41enforcement that exists in other markets.
- 15:45Certain individuals could have huge positions in cryptocurrency
- 15:49and then who knows, maybe they use subterfuge techniques to
- 15:55spread Internet rumors to change the price of Bitcoin.
- 15:59Or they fake press announcements from major retailers saying that
- 16:03we're going to accept Bitcoin now as payment.
- 16:06Or they hack the SEC's Twitter account and say that certain new
- 16:10Bitcoin based products were approved.
- 16:12These are all things that happened, which means that
- 16:15outside actors can influence the market to change the price of
- 16:19Bitcoin. And it is very, very difficult,
- 16:22if not impossible, to find the culprits behind that behavior,
- 16:26as the SEC could in, say, insider trading cases in the
- 16:30stock market. Not only is there volatility,
- 16:33but there's also really not a lot of reliability that the
- 16:38market reflects the innate behavior of buyers and sellers.
- 16:42So for someone who just wants to play with some funny money they
- 16:45may have that they'd go to Vegas with or something and get into
- 16:48crypto and realizing all the things we just said about all
- 16:51the inherent dangers, is there a safer way to do that?
- 16:54Would it be the exchange traded fund through some big brokerage
- 16:56house or something? Is there a better way to do it
- 16:58if you're going to do it knowing you could lose all that money?
- 17:01I mean Corey spoke to the exchange traded fund point
- 17:04earlier. I would say with regard to those
- 17:05products, there is still no regulation of the underlying
- 17:09asset that undergirds the exchange traded product.
- 17:13So the wrapper of the product is regulated on say the New York
- 17:18Stock Exchange or NASDAQ or other exchanges.
- 17:21So there might be a slight enhancement for the regulation,
- 17:25but really when the underlying collateral of Bitcoin is not
- 17:28regulated, it's not going to buy you much in terms of getting the
- 17:32product inside of an exchange traded wrapper.
- 17:35Individual investors, I would say, treat any cryptocurrency
- 17:38investment like you would any sort of budget for sports
- 17:42betting or gambling. It's only put up what you can
- 17:48afford to lose. This should not be the basis of
- 17:51your nest egg. You should not rely on it for
- 17:53retirement, but if you have disposable income that you can
- 17:57essentially play and speculate with, sure.
- 18:00I fear that the cryptocurrency industry is painting the asset
- 18:05class much more like stocks or bonds than they are sports
- 18:11betting. Good point.
- 18:12Which brings us to President Trump, who in 2021 told Fox News
- 18:16that Bitcoin quote seems like a scam.
- 18:18Now he says he wants to make the US the crypto capital of the
- 18:20world. This summary signs an executive
- 18:22order that could make it possible for Americans to have
- 18:24their retirement savings invested in cryptocurrency.
- 18:27Corey, is that to concern you? It's really concerning.
- 18:30I think we've covered why these kinds of investments even for,
- 18:34you know, your typical investor that has a brokerage account and
- 18:37isn't relying on this for their retirement are risky, are
- 18:41generally just gambling. And so to say that these highly
- 18:45protected employee sponsored plans, the plans that have a
- 18:49fiduciary duty attached to them should be made subject to a
- 18:54quote, UN quote investment that has incredibly high fees, non
- 18:59transparent fees, that has enormous volatility that doesn't
- 19:03have any real basis for growth in the real economy.
- 19:08It's incredibly dangerous. And it is hard to imagine how a
- 19:11plan manager would ever justify putting this kind of product in
- 19:16retirement savings accounts. And I really fear the
- 19:19consequences of what happens when people are exposed to these
- 19:25volatile assets in an account they rely on to feed and house
- 19:30themselves through their retirement.
- 19:32It's important to remember that these employer sponsored plans
- 19:37like 401K's are also tax advantage.
- 19:40So what the president is really doing is trying to put his thumb
- 19:43on the scale and saying, hey, not only can you buy crypto, but
- 19:46you can buy crypto pre tax. And the only thing I would say
- 19:50about that is the Trump administration and the
- 19:52Department of Labor can put out this guidance saying employers
- 19:56are free to put crypto into 401K options for your employees.
- 20:02But as Corey said, employers are still fiduciaries to their
- 20:06employees for the purposes of selecting these 401K plans.
- 20:09So it remains to be seen if employers actually think that
- 20:13they can offer these options to their employees and still comply
- 20:18with the law and their responsibility to act in the
- 20:20best interest of their employees.
- 20:22You know, 2 terms we hear a lot these days are stable coins and
- 20:25meme coins. We're going to discuss exactly
- 20:27what they are next. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 20:30man. You're listening to consumer
- 20:31pedia poweredbycheckbook.org. Consumer PDF Fast Facts Bitcoin
- 20:38was created in 2009 and is the largest and oldest
- 20:42cryptocurrency. Bitcoins are continually created
- 20:45through a process called mining. The maximum number of bitcoins
- 20:48that can be mined is 21 million. Currently, there are
- 20:51approximately 1.3 million left to mine.
- 20:54It's estimated that a significant share of mined
- 20:56bitcoins, about 15 to 20%, is permanently lost due to
- 21:01forgotten passwords, discarded hard drives, or lost private
- 21:04keys. The IRS treats Bitcoin and other
- 21:07cryptocurrencies as property, not currency.
- 21:09That means transactions involving Bitcoin are subject to
- 21:12capital gains tax, just like transactions involving stocks or
- 21:16real estate. Crypto holdings and transactions
- 21:19must be reported on your income tax form each year.
- 21:24Two other things I want to touch on before we go stable coins and
- 21:27meme coins. A stable coin, as the name
- 21:29implies, is any digital currency designed to have a relatively
- 21:33stable price. How does that work?
- 21:35A stable coin is a crypto dollar that claims that it can be
- 21:40exchanged for AUS dollar at any point in time on demand.
- 21:45Like you would go to a bank and demand to get your money out.
- 21:50What you do when you purchase a stable coin is you give your
- 21:53U.S. dollar to a company, they take that U.S. dollar, give you
- 21:56a crypto dollar in exchange, and then invest the money that you
- 22:00provided them in a basket of assets.
- 22:03And that basket of assets can include treasury bonds, stocks,
- 22:07other types of bonds. They could put the money in a
- 22:10money market fund or in a bank account, including uninsured
- 22:15bank accounts. And the Stable Coin Company
- 22:19earns and keeps all of the returns on those investments,
- 22:24but promises you that you can get your dollar back at any
- 22:28time. So what's in it for the Stable
- 22:31Coin Company is obvious. They get to take people's money
- 22:33and make a return on it, and they don't have to give any of
- 22:36that return to the customers. But what's in it for the stable
- 22:39coin customer is that they get this crypto dollar to play with
- 22:44in the markets. And people are supposed to use
- 22:47stable coins for everyday transactions like movie tickets,
- 22:50concessions at AMC theatres and Regal Cinemas.
- 22:52They'll take them to buy computer products at Newegg or
- 22:55make payments through Shopify. I don't know why anyone would do
- 22:59that. Corey, do you see any reason why
- 23:00I have to change my dollars, The stable coins that go back and
- 23:03buy something, I could give them my dollars?
- 23:05It really is a nonsensical notion.
- 23:07Again, it is one of those promises from crypto that does
- 23:10not hold up to reality. The claim of stablecoins is that
- 23:14they create this new high technology infrastructure for
- 23:19payments. And the fact of the matter is,
- 23:21we saw with the legislation passed in Congress that because
- 23:26stablecoins couldn't compete on their merits, because they
- 23:29weren't getting adoption, this legislation was passed that will
- 23:33end up giving them access to what are called Fed master
- 23:36accounts. And essentially what that is, is
- 23:39access to the payment system, the public payment system that
- 23:43we already pay for, that we created decades ago in order to
- 23:48get their crypto tokens into the real economy.
- 23:51So what they're really doing is sort of vampiring onto
- 23:56infrastructure that we've already created and we've
- 23:59already paid for with this false promise of updated, more
- 24:04efficient technology. Is this the genius act that
- 24:07President Trump signed a law in July?
- 24:08Yes. So that now basically
- 24:10legitimizes stable coins for use in commerce.
- 24:13It is essentially an endorsement of stable coins and it is a
- 24:17deregulation of all of the laws, the consumer laws, the financial
- 24:22stability laws that apply to every other type of payment.
- 24:27In fact, one of the reasons you're seeing PayPal, Venmo,
- 24:32MasterCard, Visa all start to move into stable going products
- 24:37is because they are currently subject to all of those
- 24:41regulations. But now if they move into stable
- 24:43coins, they don't have to offer those protections.
- 24:46They don't have to do the same kind of compliance.
- 24:49And then there are meme coins. They're basically a novelty, but
- 24:52they can increase in value. Dogecoin is the original meme
- 24:55coin. It was launched back in 2013 as
- 24:57a joke. And now President Trump and
- 24:59Melania have meme coins. So do Caitlyn Jenner and Iggy
- 25:02Azalea. Amanda, how do you feel about
- 25:04meme coins? Look, to a certain extent, all
- 25:06cryptocurrency is meme coins because they're all backed by
- 25:09sentiment, avatars, stories that people tell, and not future
- 25:16profits or an enterprise with a real business model that may or
- 25:20may not grow. But this recent advent of meme
- 25:24coins is really something in that the purveyors of the meme
- 25:27coins don't even purport that maybe one day the underlying
- 25:32token will have value in some sort of blockchain system.
- 25:36They freely admit that it should be treated like a digital
- 25:39trading card. Except at least with trading
- 25:42cards, people get true collectible joy from them.
- 25:47They can display them. Whereas with these meme coins,
- 25:51it's really just a way for the promoter to make a ton of money,
- 25:56banking on their likeness, their image, their popularity, their
- 26:00fan base or political power, and get users to give them money for
- 26:05something that has no real value except the slight promise that
- 26:11the tokens might appreciate one day.
- 26:14Final point, and it's a really important one, crypto is
- 26:16becoming a favorite way con artists convince you, the
- 26:19listener, to send them money for all sorts of bogus reasons.
- 26:22It sounds scary in the moment. According to the Federal Trade
- 26:25Commission, scams involve Bitcoin ATMs quote have surged
- 26:29dramatically in recent years. 10s of millions of U.S. dollars
- 26:33are now being converted to digital currency and sent to the
- 26:35fraudsters. And the widespread access to
- 26:38Bitcoin ATM machines across the country has been a godsend to
- 26:41these bad guys. The FTC calls them quote payment
- 26:44portals for scammers, a really serious problem.
- 26:47We need to tell people, if someone is telling you to go to
- 26:49an ATM machine, put money in and send that money to me in the
- 26:53form of bitcoins, I think you need to run as fast as possible,
- 26:55right? Absolutely.
- 26:57And fraud involving Bitcoin ATMs is some of the fastest growing
- 27:01cryptocurrency fraud. It is affecting older Americans
- 27:05disproportionately. And look, a lot of people have
- 27:08heard about past scams where scam artists would call folks
- 27:12and demand iTunes gift cards or Visa gift cards.
- 27:16This is just the updated version of that scam.
- 27:19But instead of sending somebody to Walgreens to buy $500 worth
- 27:23of iTunes gift cards, they're directing someone to the nearest
- 27:26Bitcoin ATM to funnel money to them.
- 27:29This is not hypothetical. Local law enforcement agencies
- 27:33are really struggling with this. Illinois just passed the law
- 27:36related to Bitcoin ATMs and a lot of state legislatures are
- 27:39looking at this. So folks should really be aware
- 27:42that if anyone is making a time rushed plea for them to go to a
- 27:47Bitcoin ATM, to really steer clear and frankly, to steer
- 27:50clear of Bitcoin ATMs generally because they can charge up to
- 27:5322% fees. It's just a very troubling
- 27:57trend. And by the way, if you think
- 27:59you've fallen for a crypto scam, contact the FBI's Internet Crime
- 28:02Complaint Center at ic3.gov. That's ic3.gov.
- 28:08This has been so enlightening. I want to thank our wonderful
- 28:11guests, Amanda Fisher, Policy director and COO of Better
- 28:15Markets. You'll find them on the web at
- 28:17bettermarkets.org. Thank you, Amanda.
- 28:19Thank you so much. And Corey Frayer, director of
- 28:22investor protection at the Consumer Federation of America.
- 28:24You'll find them on the web at Consumer fed.org.
- 28:28Thank you, Corey. Thanks for having me on.
- 28:30Before we go a couple of other consumer pedia podcasts, you
- 28:32might want to check out number 88, Cyber thieves Weaponize AI
- 28:36to Perfect Online Scams, 81 Algorithms secretly Control Your
- 28:41Financial fate, and #11 How to protect yourself from identity
- 28:45theft. And with that, we're out of
- 28:46time. We hope you'll rate this
- 28:48episode. It's really helpful.
- 28:49And follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 28:53to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 28:56episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 28:59show is to follow us at Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 29:02Instagram, at consumerpedia.org on Blue Sky, and at my
- 29:06Consumerpedia on X. You'll find me at
- 29:09consumerman.com. I'm Herb Weisbaum, always
- 29:12looking out for you. Until next time, be smart and
- 29:16shop wisely. Consumerpedia is a public
- 29:19service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 29:22helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 29:25You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 29:27and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 29:31unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 29:33seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 29:37Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 29:40Seattle, San Francisco, and Washington DC.
- 29:43To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 29:46checkbook.org slash Consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 29:50Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.