Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / How Avoidantly Attached People Experience Intimacy
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:22love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It is Thursday, August 14th, 2025, 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:29Time, and tonight I thought we would talk about how avoidantly
- 0:33attached people experience intimacy.
- 0:37One of the things that come up quite, quite a bit, mostly from
- 0:42preoccupied people wondering how they're dismissing partners are
- 0:46working and what they can do to affect it.
- 0:50So we could talk about it from that point of view, but it might
- 0:53also be of interest to people that are dismissing in
- 0:58understanding the, the, the dynamics of that avoided
- 1:05attachment comes from profound neglect in childhood.
- 1:10And so secure attachment comes from good enough parenting.
- 1:18And when we describe good enough parenting, what we really mean
- 1:21is that 30% of the time or better your needs were met.
- 1:27And so when we talk about dismissing attachment or any
- 1:32insecure disorganized attachment, what we're really
- 1:35talking about is fairly adverse environment for the child to
- 1:39grow up in. The thing about profound neglect
- 1:45is that it means that your caregivers are present, but
- 1:48they're not available to you and they're, it's reliable, right?
- 1:53You don't worry about it too much.
- 1:55You just know that they're not really present and able to meet
- 2:00your needs. And that sense of consistency,
- 2:05it's what really allows you to give up on them in a way that
- 2:09preoccupied people don't. The dynamic for a preoccupied
- 2:14person is every now and then they get the care that they
- 2:17need. They just can't figure out what
- 2:19they did that got them the care at that time.
- 2:23So they become enmeshed in them, the mind state of the caregiver
- 2:28in an attempt to figure out what to do so that they can elicit
- 2:32the care that they want. Where the person who experiences
- 2:41profound neglect never has that consistency of their needs being
- 2:45met. They're always in a position of
- 2:47having to respond in the way that the caregiver wants.
- 2:51And what's what's important, what matters to them is not of
- 2:55particular consequence. Dismissing people also were
- 3:03avoidant people. There's a thing about talking
- 3:07about attachment, which is the sets of labels that we we have
- 3:11around them. We have the the original child
- 3:16set. We have then the the set that
- 3:20came later describes adult attachment and then we have the
- 3:24division between the purely research oriented side and then
- 3:29the sociology side, which is more colloquial in the way that
- 3:35it's discussed. So avoidant, anxious avoidant is
- 3:41the child state and dismissing is the adult state.
- 3:49One of the things that you learn as a child if you have neglect
- 3:55is to frame the world in, in the way that the caregivers that you
- 4:02have respond. And so really what you're
- 4:06centered on is how they like the world described.
- 4:11And so you learn how to do that. You learn it in a transactional
- 4:18framework, you make the presentation and they give you
- 4:22the care that you want and and because it's the the neglect
- 4:33happens before other developments might happen.
- 4:38There isn't the perspective that there's different ways to
- 4:42operate in the world. One of the the characteristics
- 4:46about dismissing people is that they understand that the way
- 4:50that they are operating in the world is a great way to operate
- 4:56and they like to get good at operating in that way.
- 5:01What happens to people who move beyond that early stage of auto
- 5:06regulation, which is what dismissing people do mainly
- 5:11regulate themselves independent of others, is create this
- 5:17perspective that there is that, but there's something else.
- 5:20But dismissing people typically don't have that perspective.
- 5:25So those of us who do move on beyond that early stage and have
- 5:30that perspective often can personalize the behavior of a
- 5:34dismissing person and think that they are doing it intentionally,
- 5:38that they have insight and options to do it in a different
- 5:41way. And they choose in this terrible
- 5:45manner to use the the more truncated and limited approach.
- 5:52Not only do they choose in a terrible manner to do that, they
- 5:56do it to us personally. But actually what they're
- 6:04thinking is this is a great way to do it.
- 6:07And I'm really good at it 'cause I always get what I want out of
- 6:11the situation. That you don't is because you're
- 6:15not as good at it, not because I have any obligation to to meet
- 6:20your needs really beyond the transaction that we're currently
- 6:24in. Is that making sense?
- 6:32One of the characteristics of dismissing attachment is the
- 6:35suppression of emotion. So they're not particularly
- 6:38feeling Empathy and compassion, of course, are emotional
- 6:44experiences. And if you suppress awareness of
- 6:48of emotion, you're not particularly empathetic because
- 6:50you don't allow the experience of that.
- 6:58It's hard to be intimate in in the way that a secure person
- 7:02might consider intimacy if you can't feel anything, and it
- 7:07depends on how deep the the suppression is.
- 7:09Some avoidance, some dismissing. People are able to recognize
- 7:14facial expressions in body language and some are not, and
- 7:18so it's purely cognitive without any emotion.
- 7:25How do you have an intimate understanding of someone else if
- 7:27you're blind to the experience of their emotional states?
- 7:34If you're cognitive, of course, what that means is that you have
- 7:37to elicit from them in language of some kind, what their
- 7:42experience is. And so you have a limited
- 7:45perspective of what their experience is, which is
- 7:47dependent on what they tell you. And so you get good at eliciting
- 7:52from people what it is that you want to know about them, but you
- 7:55don't have any direct way of feeling it, any direct way of
- 7:59validating it in the same way that you would if you were
- 8:04empathetic. In empathy, of course, what we
- 8:07do is we use it to understand whether we think somebody's
- 8:11telling us the truth or not. 4 levels of empathy I'd like to
- 8:17talk about. The first one is the the
- 8:19whinginess that happens in witnessing somebody else's
- 8:23physical or emotional pain. You actually have a body
- 8:26response to that. You're in the kitchen, you're
- 8:28making dinner, you're talking to somebody.
- 8:31They're they chop, they're chopping the vegetables, they
- 8:33cut their finger. They have that immediate
- 8:36response and then you have a response right after that is the
- 8:41witness of that. You hear sliding tires in the
- 8:45banging of metal and you have a response, sort of a visceral
- 8:49response to it. If you have the first level of
- 8:52empathy. If you don't have the first
- 8:54level of empathy, then you don't feel anything in response to it.
- 9:00Hopefully you do because we think if you don't, we are a
- 9:03sociopath. You probably are, but what is
- 9:08that one or two out of 100? The second level of empathy is
- 9:14you can look at somebody and read their facial expression and
- 9:17body language and understand that that represents their
- 9:21internal emotional state. How would you learn to read
- 9:28somebody's facial expression in body language?
- 9:31Because somebody taught you. We don't come into the world
- 9:36with that capacity. And then it would depend on how
- 9:40good your teacher is, how skillful you are at being able
- 9:44to do that. In the English language, I'm
- 9:47fond of saying there are 220 words that represent discrete
- 9:52emotional states. Thinking back on your childhood
- 9:57experience of being instructed on what emotions are, of the 220
- 10:03possibilities, what'd you get? I'm going to guess most people
- 10:11it's around 15. If it's a, if it's a really rich
- 10:15environment, but if it's not, it's four or five.
- 10:29The Atlas of Emotion, which is a website not an app, has a pretty
- 10:34good display of all of those emotions if you want to look at
- 10:39it. They're centered on the the
- 10:40basic 7 Anger, fear, sadness, Discuss, contempt, surprise,
- 10:48happiness is the Ekman Group. It's like an inkjet printer.
- 10:55You have seven colors and all those colors mixed together to
- 10:58form that full, that full range of emotions.
- 11:05The third level of empathy we call compassionate empathy in
- 11:09Buddhism, where you actually feel in your body a facsimile of
- 11:13what somebody else is feeling and it's a sensation that
- 11:15appears in the body. And we tend to use the second,
- 11:19the external presentation and the third, the way it feels.
- 11:24And if they match, we have, we believe that the person is in an
- 11:29authentic expression. And if they don't match, we
- 11:32think that they're in an inauthentic expression.
- 11:35That's how we tell secure people, of course, have a
- 11:39fourth, which is they compare what people say they're going to
- 11:42do with what they do, which is an interesting dilemma for
- 11:50people who are not secure because early on in childhood,
- 11:54we learned to split off that part because we can't match what
- 11:58our caregivers are saying to us and what they do.
- 12:00And so it's better not to check. And so we we lose the habit of
- 12:05checking or we lose the skill or we never developed the skill of
- 12:09checking what what is an authentic expression, what
- 12:18isn't, what is an intention, an expression that's kept in what
- 12:23isn't. It's less painful for childhood
- 12:28in childhood and less anxiety produced in childhood for that
- 12:34that all making sense. One of the things that happens
- 12:40to people who grow up to be dismissing is that the the
- 12:46primary exploration, the things that really matter to them
- 12:49because they aren't valued, tend to be held in complete secrecy
- 12:54so that they can be preserved. We're talking about how does an
- 12:58avoidant person express intimacy?
- 13:01And really, the answer is in the stuff that really matters.
- 13:05It's for the most part kept entirely secret from everyone.
- 13:11And so the process of a dismissing person opening up is
- 13:16being willing to express that stuff that's been hidden the
- 13:21whole time. You can't show the things that
- 13:27really matter to you because if they don't line up exactly with
- 13:31what the caregivers want from you, it's devalued in childhood
- 13:39and that is too painful. And so it it becomes this secret
- 13:44inner world that's protected from really from the expression
- 13:50of it to other people doesn't mean it isn't motivating.
- 13:54It doesn't mean it doesn't drive decision making even
- 13:57consciously. But what it isn't done is
- 14:00expressed openly to other people because the the painfulness of
- 14:06it being devalued in the family system over and over.
- 14:13I was going to say how you learn emotions.
- 14:19The you're an infant. The caregiver sensitively
- 14:24attunes you. They empathetically connect to
- 14:26you. They understand what emotional
- 14:31state you're in. They mirror that back to you so
- 14:34that you see reflected in the face of the caregiver, their
- 14:39interpretation of what you are experiencing.
- 14:43You begin to associate the physical sensation in the body
- 14:47with the facial expression. And then in language, the the
- 14:52caregiver expresses to you what they call that particular state
- 14:56of being. And then they teach you how to
- 15:00manage or regulate that that emotional state.
- 15:07If you have somebody who comes and is attentive and pays
- 15:11attention to you and has the capacity for empathy and is able
- 15:16to transmit all of that information to you, we have an
- 15:2385% chance of having the same attachment strategy as our
- 15:27primary caregiver. If you come out of early
- 15:30childhood without the skill to discern emotional states because
- 15:35you learn to suppress them, it's likely that your caregiver was
- 15:39using the same skill set and the suppression of emotion was what
- 15:43you learned rather than which emotion you're feeling right and
- 15:47how to manage it except through suppression.
- 15:52So you didn't have the mirroring, in fact.
- 15:55So it's it may be hard to understand what that is.
- 16:02That's for that that heart or shut down cognitive only person.
- 16:11Maybe they did give you enough of an instruction that you can
- 16:16read facial expressions and body language.
- 16:20Some distressing people are really quite adept at reading
- 16:25facial expressions in body language, but they don't feel
- 16:27it. It's a cognitive exercise, not a
- 16:31an emotional exercise. They use it as a way of
- 16:35understanding how to present themselves, and then they
- 16:39present a facsimile of that rather than an authentic
- 16:44expression of it. In transactional relationships,
- 16:52which is the currency of avoidantly attached people, on
- 16:59the organized side, there's agreements about the trades of
- 17:11care. So you do this for me and I do
- 17:13that for you. And it's transactional and each
- 17:17transaction is basically set up individually.
- 17:24The main difference between transactional care and
- 17:27collaborative care is that in collaborative care, you
- 17:30undertake the care of the whole person and they undertake the,
- 17:36the whole care of you. And in a transactional
- 17:40relationship, it's really almost one at a time that the the the
- 17:47deals are made. We should also talk about
- 17:55disorganized people who are avoidant, fearfully avoiding
- 18:00people. There's quite a bit of
- 18:03difference in the way that organized assisting people and
- 18:08fearful avoidant people operate. There isn't the suppression of
- 18:13emotion in fearfully avoiding people.
- 18:17It's more of a push, pull cycle of fearfulness overtakes.
- 18:21They they want and desire closeness and they'll come
- 18:26toward it, but when it gets too close, they become frightened by
- 18:32it and withdraw. So it's this, this swinging back
- 18:35and forth. And actually, I'll talk more
- 18:39about that next week. Because the dynamics are so
- 18:49different, the main thing is in both of them, the avoidance of
- 18:55intimacy, but they it just manifests quite differently.
- 19:04Secure people go with secure people.
- 19:06That's the most common. And the second most common is
- 19:11preoccupied people going with dismissing people.
- 19:16It's a good match the the capacities of the dismissing
- 19:20person and the capacities of the preoccupied person.
- 19:24I like to call it 1 + 1 = 1 in terms of mentalizing and
- 19:31emotional regulation. The dismissing person, because
- 19:40they use transactional relationships, are very focused
- 19:44on secondary exploration, the gathering of time, energy and
- 19:47resources in order to trade for the care that they need.
- 19:58The primary exploration is completely hidden and held
- 20:01privately because that was the way to preserve it in childhood.
- 20:06There was they it wasn't safe to express it.
- 20:13Preoccupied people are willing to trade proximity for care, and
- 20:17so that works well for the dismissing person.
- 20:20The dismissing person allows the preoccupied person proximity to
- 20:25them and in exchange for the care that they receive, the
- 20:32preoccupied person doesn't explore.
- 20:34And so they live vicariously through the secondary
- 20:38exploration of the dismissing person.
- 20:41But it doesn't satisfy in a deep way their their need for primary
- 20:45exploration because they're not usually Privy to the primary
- 20:50exploration of the dismissing person.
- 20:53So what that means is that you maintain a pretty steady
- 20:58distance between each other in the transactional roles that you
- 21:02undertake. But what we're really talking
- 21:05about is how do you bridge that and so that you become intimate.
- 21:13The dynamic of a non intimate relationship is that the
- 21:17distance between is maintained by both people.
- 21:22So if one person is approaching, the other person is withdrawing,
- 21:28and if the person who's consistently approaching gets
- 21:31fed up with never being able to reach their partner and they
- 21:35stop and turn in the other direction, then the partner
- 21:39reverses and becomes pursuing. So it's a back and forth.
- 21:44Usually in the beginning, the dismissing person, love bombs is
- 21:49the colloquial term, seduces the preoccupied person until the
- 21:54preoccupied person engages in pursuit of the dismissing person
- 21:58and then the dismissing person begins to withdraw.
- 22:02So the dynamic is always 1 of maintaining the distance in a
- 22:09secure functioning relationship. One person moves closer and the
- 22:13other person moves closer. One person withdraws, the other
- 22:16person stays the same or withdraws.
- 22:19So you have this dynamic of closeness and withdrawal,
- 22:23closeness of withdrawal, which is where intimacy can happen.
- 22:30So that if you were a dismissing person and you wanted to change
- 22:35the dynamic of closeness of intimacy, you might think that
- 22:42all you had to do was reveal yourself.
- 22:45All you had to do was seek closeness.
- 22:47But most of the time you're in a relationship with somebody who's
- 22:50keeping the equilimity, keeping the distance the same.
- 23:00And so as you pull closer to them in this attempt to seek
- 23:08intimacy, they're going to withdraw.
- 23:16And if you put them in a corner in a position where they have a
- 23:20hard time being able to easily withdraw, they're going to
- 23:22reject in order to maintain the distance.
- 23:27So that it isn't a unilateral decision that you can make in
- 23:31terms of relationships to to seek intimacy.
- 23:36Suddenly you have to engage the relationship and change the
- 23:42dynamics of it so that there's an agreement between you to to
- 23:47abandon the the non intimate approach and allow this dynamic
- 23:55of closeness and withdrawal. Closeness and withdrawal.
- 23:59The reason it can be tricky for a preoccupied person is that
- 24:03proximity is the goal mostly for them.
- 24:07So the dynamic of closeness and withdrawal, closeness and
- 24:12withdrawal is not something that works that well for them.
- 24:16They're also in pretend mode a lot of the time, pretending to
- 24:19be who it is that you want them to be.
- 24:23And if you move into a dynamic of intimacy, you're also moving
- 24:29into a a dynamic of authentic expression.
- 24:34And if you're in a relationship with somebody who's in pretend
- 24:38mode most of the time, but you're also asking of them is
- 24:42that they stop pretending and become authentic.
- 24:49And so that that for most preoccupied people is a
- 24:53Herculean ask, right? How difficult that is for them,
- 24:59if they even know anymore what it is to be authentic.
- 25:04On the dismissing side, what you would have to do is be willing
- 25:07to share your authentic exploration, which is tied up
- 25:15with a terrible sadness of a childhood of neglect and
- 25:21rejection. And this is also very
- 25:25challenging. So it it isn't a simple decision
- 25:29to just become intimate. There's a lifetime of
- 25:36conditioning set up against that happening.
- 25:40If you, for instance, were dismissing person and you
- 25:42suddenly decided that you were going to be intimate and you
- 25:45would just share about your primary exploration.
- 25:50This thing that you've been keeping secret your entire life
- 25:54and the and you were in relationship to a preoccupied
- 25:57person who suddenly felt trapped.
- 26:00They would be rejecting, which would be a repetition of the
- 26:04early childhood experience, which would just in most cases,
- 26:08what it does is shut down the the attempt at intimacy that
- 26:15that are all making sense. And so we have to to begin to do
- 26:21this in order for a, a preoccupied person to tolerate
- 26:26the closeness and withdrawal that that separation is about
- 26:32exploring, right? They would have to begin to
- 26:34learn to explore something that had real meaning to them that
- 26:38would be more important than the emotional regulation that comes
- 26:43from proximity. The dismissing person starts out
- 26:48as an auto regulator, and So what they would have to begin to
- 26:53allow is somebody else to help emotionally regulate them in a
- 26:57conscious way. But the preoccupied person who
- 27:02is used to seeking proximity and emotionally regulating the
- 27:07dismissing person would have to turn the attention to themselves
- 27:12and learn to emotionally regulate themselves so that they
- 27:15had the capacity to separate and begin primary exploration.
- 27:24Preoccupied persons tend to be able to support the exploration
- 27:30of someone else pretty well, but they're not so good at
- 27:35determining what they might want to explore and then supporting
- 27:39themselves emotionally while they go do it.
- 27:44And so there's a lot, a lot to do in that way.
- 27:49But maybe you're a dismissing person who prefers the power
- 27:54coupling dynamic. Where both of you are dismissing
- 27:58in the relationship. Now that's a little bit easier
- 28:02to to manage Christian. George, do you find that I, I, I
- 28:12wonder if such a dynamic is a thing where the avoidant person
- 28:17is trying to do kind of a primary exploration and you
- 28:20know, maybe they're like little baby gazelle and it's not, it's
- 28:24not, it's like new to them and they're asking their partner
- 28:27who's more preoccupied for that support.
- 28:32Does it ever happen that the preoccupied partner is kind of
- 28:36good at supporting the the kind of secondary exploration of the
- 28:40avoidant partner, but not so much this kind of new unsure
- 28:46primary exploration? I don't think that it's
- 28:50necessarily true that the specific person can't do their
- 28:54primary exploration. I think they can do it.
- 28:57What they don't do is ever share it with anyone.
- 29:01So what's vulnerable for them and the support they need is not
- 29:06in doing the exploration, but in the preoccupied person receiving
- 29:13it and in supporting and encouraging it.
- 29:19I think that the because the preoccupied person vicariously
- 29:28enjoys the exploration that they are allowed in on, which is the
- 29:35secondary exploration. And they do support it and
- 29:39encourage it in a way that is to to say they demand more of their
- 29:45partner. And actually dismissing people
- 29:48can use that demand for greater social position, more money,
- 29:53more stuff that comes from the preoccupied person because it
- 29:58encourages them to compete more and get more stuff, which means
- 30:02they can transact for, for better care that's useful to
- 30:08them. That sounds.
- 30:12Like a kind of like the preoccupied person's like
- 30:15dismissive by proxy. Right, Well, what you're the the
- 30:22but also under said the preoccupied person is not really
- 30:26supporting the dismissing person.
- 30:29They're getting their stuff right.
- 30:31It's a transaction. So they support the the they
- 30:35appear to be altruistically taking care of the dismissing
- 30:40person, but actually they're taking care of themselves
- 30:42because they're in a transactional exchange.
- 30:45I do this for you. And then I get the thing that I
- 30:47want is that making sense? So it's always I'm taking care
- 30:53of you so that you'll take care of me.
- 30:55It's never I'm taking care of you so that you'll be taken care
- 30:59of. Which is the secure dynamic,
- 31:03right? Makes sense.
- 31:05I'm doing this for you, and I'm telling you that I'm doing this
- 31:07for you because I'm an altruistic, beautiful person and
- 31:10it's free. But actually you're paying me
- 31:13for this. I'm getting what I want from
- 31:17this. So it's always I do this so that
- 31:19you'll do that. It's never I'm taking care of
- 31:22you because you need the care. Well, that that would make it
- 31:27seem like the preoccupied person probably wouldn't be very
- 31:30interested in supporting the primary exploration.
- 31:33If the primary exploration is a very kind of personal thing to
- 31:36each person, then. What was that?
- 31:38And that it takes them away from the secondary exploration,
- 31:42right? Yes, exactly right.
- 31:44OK. Interesting.
- 31:52Yeah, you want to do what? It's very funny, you know, one,
- 32:10one question that always comes into my mind is what is the
- 32:13purpose of this life that we have, this one wild and precious
- 32:18life that we have. And you know, we get trapped in
- 32:22this culture. I liked Chomsky's description of
- 32:30it, which is we're allowed a vibrant discourse in a very
- 32:34narrow band of ideas. And anything that doesn't
- 32:39doesn't land within that very narrow sliver of of discourse
- 32:46disappears. And if you think it was bad
- 32:49before AI came along, it is going to be a vacuum.
- 32:55Everything except what's allowed in this very narrow band of
- 33:02discourse. What's acceptable?
- 33:06What should you spend your life pursuing?
- 33:15And at the end of all of it, will you be happy that you did,
- 33:21Paul? George, I probably have a couple
- 33:25of questions because I I just want to a very short 1.
- 33:29The implication from the Chomsky quote was that to say that the
- 33:32very narrow band is what's socially acceptable, where you
- 33:35won't be marginalized because you're exploring something
- 33:37outside that band as opposed to the human brain can only get so
- 33:42interested in so many things. So there will be a narrow band
- 33:44of things that you're interested in, regardless of what society
- 33:46thinks. I don't know.
- 34:02Fair enough. Worthy of exploration, perhaps
- 34:12that was sort of the material because maybe to get to the it's
- 34:17probably a 2 fold question about one just to confirm the, the way
- 34:23I'm thinking of intimacy is the way that you're thinking of it
- 34:25when you describe it. So I'm taking it to mean both
- 34:30the in the moment, what is really true, so that the
- 34:34authentic expression in the moment of what's happening
- 34:36that's important to convey and then the linkage to the primary
- 34:41exploration of like what is most enlivening to you that you want
- 34:44to share with others? Right.
- 34:46And both of those. Anything else that you're
- 34:51thinking of that I haven't mentioned?
- 34:57I mainly think of it as your, your ability to express what
- 35:02your experience is. And if we were to just expand
- 35:08that a little, that the fear of abandonment does not get to the
- 35:13point where it's so frightening that if you expressed something
- 35:18to somebody that is to say you, you become so afraid that if you
- 35:22expressed what was actually what you were actually thinking and
- 35:25feeling to somebody that they would abandoned you, that you
- 35:28don't express it as a result. So the capacity to be intimate
- 35:34with somebody else would mean that you're able to freely
- 35:37express your authentic experience to them without being
- 35:40frightened that in doing so they would abandon you.
- 35:44Yeah, helpful. And it brings me to the next
- 35:50question. When you.
- 35:52When do you speak of abandonment?
- 35:56Are we talking about the full spectrum of the anticipation
- 36:00that it might lead to the loss of the Bishop in total or
- 36:04starting maybe from? Or is it just as simple as they
- 36:08might be so disinterested in what you're sharing as to
- 36:11abandon you in the moment of something that's emotionally
- 36:13important to you and that that's painful to not be have the
- 36:17attuned accompaniment? Right.
- 36:19Well, I think both of those are true, but the, the, the from the
- 36:26child's perspective, it's you don't survive right from that
- 36:30very permitted flow because you're abandoned, you don't
- 36:33survive. That's what that's so
- 36:36compelling. Maybe a different way when I
- 36:40think of this question, I was thinking the other day and
- 36:42wanted to ask, it actually did come back to that, which is it's
- 36:45the adult expression. Maybe sometimes, maybe often the
- 36:49reliving of that the, you know, having caregivers and childhood
- 36:54who weren't able to meet the needs enough.
- 36:56So you're, you are actually afraid of abandonment, even if
- 36:58it logically wouldn't make sense that you're going to be
- 37:01abandoned, but that that is still kind of dominating the
- 37:04experience because it would be, you know, lethal or almost
- 37:09certainly lethal to a child. And that that hasn't been
- 37:12resolved. So it's still living there where
- 37:13you're worried they might not be attuned in the moment, but
- 37:16that's still scary because it's like this childhood version of
- 37:19abandonment, still alive. Well the the loss of mentalizing
- 37:25that can happen in stress states can lead to very primitive
- 37:31formulations, right? Right.
- 37:34But also it isn't true just of childhood.
- 37:38It really depends where you fall on the socio economic ladder
- 37:43whether or not what the ultimate risk to survival might be.
- 37:49In that, sure. Very familiar with.
- 37:54That so also the conditioning, the conditioned experience of
- 38:08its secure people would probably react quite differently than a
- 38:13dismissing person who anticipates rejection and has,
- 38:19you know, an elaborate defense system to hide out from other
- 38:25people because that was a requirement of preserving
- 38:29anything that had real meaning to them in childhood.
- 38:32So that the the the consequence of of plunging into the terrible
- 38:37sadness of, of that abandonment, that isolation, that rejection
- 38:45of of anything central to them is quite a different experience
- 38:50than the the preoccupied person who who gets or doesn't get what
- 38:57they need based on their the haphazard experience of the
- 39:03caregiver. If the, and these are feelings,
- 39:07right and, and the momentary creation of reality, which does
- 39:14not necessarily represent what's actually happening.
- 39:20You know, the child perspective of the preoccupied person is if
- 39:24I do the right thing, they'll give me the, the care.
- 39:29And that's a complete distortion of reality.
- 39:31The the the adult doesn't have the experience.
- 39:34Oh, they finally did it right. So I'm giving them the care that
- 39:38they want. They're not paying attention to
- 39:40what what the child is doing. And so sometimes they respond
- 39:44and sometimes they don't. It's haphazard.
- 39:49It's not as a result of what the child is doing, but the child is
- 39:53believing that they have some agency in it, which is which is
- 39:57easier for them to manage then that.
- 39:59It's just completely the arbitrariness of the caregiver
- 40:05and then disorganized kids, you know, grow up in danger and so.
- 40:09For that man, it's a lot. It's it just zips to life and
- 40:13death. Right.
- 40:18So maybe the that's a great segue if you have time for one
- 40:22more facet of this question, which it's actually played an
- 40:24independent question some like, you know, real lived experience
- 40:29of different kinds of relational or sorry attachment strategies
- 40:33going on. So the anecdote of my life is
- 40:38wasn't particularly endangered as a child from my parents, but
- 40:41they were largely not physically not present in my life.
- 40:45What I've noticed as an adult is that I'm really good at
- 40:48enmeshing, which looks a bit like preoccupied.
- 40:52I'm also really good at hiding what's important to me, which
- 40:56looks like highly dismissive. And those two tend to have been
- 41:00fairly strong and fairly obvious to me even before I learned
- 41:03attachment work. And, and maybe I'll leave it at
- 41:09that. Let's say that, you know, I
- 41:13realize most researchers who are active in the field of
- 41:15attachment do talk about, you know, everything is no one's
- 41:20perfectly wonder one thing or another.
- 41:24But then there's, I think the question.
- 41:25But the practical question for me is working in the attachment
- 41:29repair of kind of making sense of this on the one hand to make
- 41:33to make the the the repair activity valuable.
- 41:41The complexity disorganized is one thing that happens, but also
- 41:48if you are preoccupied and you have to hide, then it it looks
- 41:51more like passive preoccupation. It's hard to tell the difference
- 41:55between passive preoccupation and the passivity is often
- 42:00judged as being an avoidance strategy, but it's actually not
- 42:03an avoidance strategy strategy. So that's where I would look.
- 42:09It's it's phenomenally popular in the tech world, which I find
- 42:14hilarious. It's supposed to be really rare,
- 42:18but it's ordinary in in the tech world, which I think is.
- 42:23So interesting. OK.
- 42:26Thank you, George. So why don't we leave it there?
- 42:30We can continue next week with the focus on disorganized
- 42:35attachment, but why don't we do some meditation practice?
- 42:39Would you like to one, do insight and concentration
- 42:45practice, 2A heart practice, loving kindness, or three ideal
- 42:51parent figure protocol? You have 1/2, so 2 to 1 so far.
- 43:04Oops. Do we have one more vote?
- 43:11What was three? I didn't understand. 3 is to do
- 43:17some guided ideal parent figure protocol.
- 43:21Still don't understand SO. Yeah, you totally got that.
- 43:26I was like. I don't know what that is.
- 43:29Well then, hard practice or insight?
- 43:34Choose for me. They both sound awesome.
- 43:36I never can take over somebody else's exploration.
- 43:40It's always your obligation. OK, number one then.
- 43:45I'm a weirdo. I'm a weirdo.
- 43:46It's all well, you know, with my birth stuff, you know what we're
- 43:50talking about. I I didn't have needs.
- 43:54That's my perinatal therapist a couple years ago.
- 43:56Helped me to understand that. I mean, I did, but I went
- 44:00through life as though I didn't. I pushed it through everything
- 44:03and everything worked out. But multiple sclerosis wasn't
- 44:07something I could do that with and I didn't know that's what
- 44:09was going on. So it's just one there's
- 44:14concentration and insight which carries the day.
- 44:19So go ahead and settle in. OK, Let go of the meditation
- 44:27comments, questions, Christian. I was having some hearing that
- 44:35Lady Macbeth must have been the preoccupied 1 and Macbeth, but
- 44:42now that I think about it, they're probably just both
- 44:43avoidant. I might go with the first
- 44:49constellation, all right. This weekend on Saturday from
- 45:009:00 to 1:00, we have the second Saturday of the meditation and
- 45:04Addiction series. It finishes the following week.
- 45:08And then what else are we going to do?
- 45:14Starting on September 13th? We're going to do a meditation
- 45:17and attachment level 1 and then that'll run for three weeks.
- 45:29We're going to start a meditation and addiction level 2
- 45:33on September 15th. That runs Monday, Wednesday and
- 45:37Friday from six to seven. We're going to do a How to date
- 45:46like a secure person Even if you're not workshop on the 19th
- 45:51of September. It's Friday evening.
- 45:59It's an interesting thing. Let's see what else we got.
- 46:12We're going to start a meditation and attachment level
- 46:152 soon on October 21st. That's what's coming up.
- 46:25You're interested in any of that.
- 46:26It's on the website. Take a look.
- 46:28Really appreciate your practice. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 46:33if you are resourced and can make a donation, that's also
- 46:36appreciated. Any amount is helpful.
- 46:39It helps support me and also the work we're doing.
- 46:41I look forward to seeing you soon somewhere along the path.
- 46:45Bye.