Latest / The Morning Rundown / Press Bans, a Cultural Icon Goes Dark, and ICE's Day in Court
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, David, tell me you saw the White House thing this morning.
- 0:16[David] Saw it?
- 0:17[David] Still processing it.
- 0:19[Maya] Same.
- 0:19[Maya] All right.
- 0:20[Maya] All right, before we spiral, morning, everybody.
- 0:22[Maya] This is the Morning Rundown.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 0:25[David] And I'm David.
- 0:25[Maya] We've got three stories today, and honestly, all three are kind of
- 0:29[Maya] wild.
- 0:30[David] One press fight, one building going dark, one court case that might
- 0:33[David] end up with the Supreme Court.
- 0:35[Maya] The Kennedy Center thing still doesn't feel real to me.
- 0:38[David] Wait till you hear the ICE ruling.
- 0:40[Maya] Oh, I've heard.
- 0:41[Maya] We are getting into that.
- 0:42[David] Not yet, though.
- 0:43[Maya] Not yet, but it's coming.
- 0:45[Maya] Promise.
- 0:46[David] So where do we start?
- 0:47[Maya] Media story's freshest.
- 0:48[Maya] It just broke, so let's start there.
- 0:50[David] Fine by me.
- 0:51[Maya] Also, real quick, Happy Friday, everybody.
- 0:53[Maya] Hope your coffee's strong today.
- 0:55[David] Mine's basically espresso at this point.
- 0:57[Maya] All right.
- 0:58[Maya] CNN, MSNBC, and Politico, all locked out.
- 1:02[Maya] Okay, so the post itself, Trump literally just typed out that CNN,
- 1:06[Maya] MSNBC, and Politico are banned from the White House.
- 1:09[David] Wait, banned how?
- 1:11[David] Like off the grounds entirely?
- 1:13[Maya] That's the thing.
- 1:14[Maya] The post doesn't say.
- 1:15[Maya] Nobody's totally sure what the actual scope is.
- 1:18[David] No briefing room, no press pool, no building at all?
- 1:20[David] Could be any of those.
- 1:21[Maya] Right, and normally you'd wait and see if it's just talk.
- 1:25[David] But it wasn't just talk.
- 1:26[Maya] Nope.
- 1:27[Maya] CNN's follow-up reporting says a Politico reporter actually got turned away at
- 1:31[Maya] the door that Saturday.
- 1:32[David] So somebody in the Secret Service line said, "Sorry, you're on the
- 1:35[David] list."
- 1:36[Maya] Basically, yeah.
- 1:37[Maya] And Politico's editor came out swinging, said they're gonna defend their First
- 1:40[Maya] Amendment rights, full stop.
- 1:42[David] I mean, of course they did.
- 1:43[David] That's the only move available to them.
- 1:45[Maya] True.
- 1:46[Maya] What else are you gonna say?
- 1:47[Maya] Okay, fair enough.
- 1:48[David] Right.
- 1:48[David] Right.
- 1:49[David] So this isn't hypothetical anymore.
- 1:50[David] Somebody's badge actually got rejected.
- 1:52[Maya] And it's not the first time either.
- 1:54[Maya] An ACLU lawyer flagged that Trump tried this exact thing with the
- 1:57[Maya] AP before.
- 1:58[David] Yeah, the AP fight was over the Gulf of America naming thing,
- 2:01[David] wasn't it?
- 2:02[Maya] Something like that.
- 2:03[Maya] And ACLU's argument is basically that you can't pick which outlets get
- 2:07[Maya] in based on how they cover you.
- 2:09[David] Which legally is actually a real question.
- 2:11[David] The White House isn't just anybody's living room.
- 2:13[Maya] No, it's not.
- 2:15[Maya] And here's where I'll say something that might sound a little contrarian.
- 2:18[David] Go for it.
- 2:18[Maya] The West Wing has a lot of discretion over who gets a
- 2:21[Maya] badge.
- 2:22[Maya] It's not a public sidewalk.
- 2:23[Maya] Presidents have always managed access.
- 2:25[David] Sure.
- 2:25[David] Every White House plays favorites with who gets called on.
- 2:27[Maya] Exactly.
- 2:28[Maya] So I don't love the framing where every outlet acts like this
- 2:31[Maya] is some five alarm death of democracy moment.
- 2:34[David] But, and I think this is the actual distinction, managing who gets
- 2:38[David] called on in a briefing is different from physically blocking a credentialed
- 2:41[David] reporter at the gate.
- 2:42[Maya] That's fair.
- 2:43[Maya] That's the part that jumped it from a spat to an actual
- 2:46[Maya] enforcement action.
- 2:47[David] Because you can spin a tweet, but you can't spin a guy
- 2:49[David] standing at the door with a clipboard.
- 2:51[Maya] Right.
- 2:51[Maya] Right.
- 2:52[Maya] So both things are true.
- 2:53[Maya] The White House has real leeway here, and also this specific move
- 2:57[Maya] got acted on, not just posted.
- 3:00[David] And that's the piece that's going to end up in front of
- 3:01[David] a judge eventually, I'd bet.
- 3:03[Maya] And think about what this actually means day to day for the
- 3:06[Maya] reporters affected.
- 3:07[Maya] You plan around being able to walk into that briefing and suddenly
- 3:11[Maya] you can't.
- 3:12[David] Right.
- 3:12[David] It's not abstract for the people involved.
- 3:14[David] It's their access, their sourcing, their whole workflow disrupted overnight.
- 3:19[Maya] Which is probably why Politico's editor didn't hedge at all.
- 3:23[Maya] When your own reporter gets turned away, a mild statement isn't really
- 3:26[Maya] an option.
- 3:27[David] True.
- 3:28[David] And it leaves CNN and MSNBC in a strange spot too.
- 3:31[David] They were named in the same post, but we haven't heard reports
- 3:34[David] of their people actually being stopped yet.
- 3:37[Maya] Not that's been reported, no.
- 3:39[Maya] Maybe enforcement's been selective so far, or maybe it just hasn't made
- 3:43[Maya] news yet.
- 3:43[David] Which loops right back to the ACLU's point.
- 3:46[David] If outlets get treated differently based on their coverage, that unevenness becomes
- 3:50[David] part of the legal argument itself.
- 3:52[Maya] Probably.
- 3:53[Maya] We'll see if it actually gets that far or if it just
- 3:55[Maya] quietly gets walked back.
- 3:57[David] Speaking of institutions suddenly finding out how much the executive branch actually
- 4:01[David] has over them.
- 4:03[Maya] Oh, smooth.
- 4:04[David] There's a much bigger fight happening over at the Kennedy Center.
- 4:08[Maya] Oh, don't even get me started on this one.
- 4:11[David] This one's dressed up like a budget story, but it is not
- 4:13[David] a budget story.
- 4:14[Maya] Nope.
- 4:15[Maya] Hold that thought because we've got to actually get into what's going
- 4:18[Maya] on there.
- 4:19[Maya] Okay, so bigger fight.
- 4:20[Maya] The Kennedy Center just went dark.
- 4:23[David] Wait, like the actual building?
- 4:24[Maya] The actual building.
- 4:26[Maya] NPR reported the board voted to close the main building, and they're
- 4:29[Maya] warning it's within weeks of bankruptcy.
- 4:32[David] Weeks?
- 4:33[David] That's-- Okay, that's a fast collapse for a place that's been standing
- 4:36[David] since the '60s.
- 4:38[Maya] Right?
- 4:38[Maya] And NPR also tied it to plummeting ticket sales and artists straight
- 4:43[Maya] up canceling shows because of how political the place has gotten.
- 4:46[David] So it's not just a money problem, it's a reputation problem too.
- 4:50[Maya] Kind of both, yeah.
- 4:51[David] Okay, but here's what's bugging me.
- 4:53[David] Time reported this bankruptcy warning is happening at the same time there's
- 4:57[David] a push to get Trump's name literally put on the facade.
- 5:00[Maya] Oh, I saw that.
- 5:02[David] And Time quoted a law professor who basically said the bankruptcy claim
- 5:05[David] doesn't add up because the center is still planning to run some
- 5:08[David] programming anyway.
- 5:09[Maya] Wait, so they're closing the building but still doing shows?
- 5:13[David] Some activities, yeah, which is the part that made the professor go,
- 5:16[David] "Hold on.
- 5:16[David] That's not how bankruptcy works."
- 5:18[Maya] That's...
- 5:19[Maya] Huh.
- 5:20[Maya] That does sound less like a financial collapse and more like a
- 5:23[Maya] bargaining chip.
- 5:24[David] A bargaining chip for what, though?
- 5:26[Maya] For the naming fight.
- 5:27[Maya] Like, you want your name on the building, you've got leverage if
- 5:30[Maya] the building's supposedly about to go under.
- 5:32[David] Okay, when you put it that way, it does sound like a
- 5:35[David] negotiating tactic wearing a financial crisis costume.
- 5:38[Maya] Right?
- 5:39[Maya] And it's not just outside commentary.
- 5:41[Maya] Al Jazeera had Senator Mark Warner and Congresswoman Joyce Beatty actually going
- 5:46[Maya] after the board over this.
- 5:47[David] What'd they say?
- 5:48[Maya] Beatty called the whole naming push unlawful.
- 5:51[Maya] Straight up.
- 5:52[David] Strong word.
- 5:53[Maya] And Warner's angle was more about the institution itself.
- 5:56[Maya] He warned they're at risk of losing a premier cultural institution over
- 6:00[Maya] this fight.
- 6:01[David] See, that's the piece I keep going back and forth on.
- 6:03[David] Is the concern really the building or is it who gets credit
- 6:06[David] on it?
- 6:07[Maya] I think for the politicians, it's genuinely both, honestly.
- 6:10[Maya] But I'll say this, if my read is right and it's leverage
- 6:13[Maya] dressed up as a crisis, that's a pretty aggressive move for a
- 6:16[Maya] board that's supposed to be running a museum, not a campaign.
- 6:20[David] Sure, but the board is Trump-appointed.
- 6:22[David] This was always going to lean political the second that happened.
- 6:25[Maya] Fair.
- 6:26[Maya] Fair.
- 6:27[David] So what happened after the vote?
- 6:29[Maya] People showed up.
- 6:30[Maya] The Washington Post covered a rally outside the shuttered building.
- 6:33[Maya] Thousands of people out there chanting, "Hands off."
- 6:37[David] Thousands?
- 6:38[David] Over a building closing.
- 6:40[Maya] Well, over what the building represents, I think, for a lot of
- 6:43[Maya] them.
- 6:44[David] That's a lot of people showing up for a marble building with
- 6:47[David] locked doors.
- 6:48[Maya] The Post literally described it that way.
- 6:51[Maya] Doors locked shut at the end of the week, and then this
- 6:54[Maya] vigil right outside.
- 6:56[David] That image really sticks.
- 6:58[David] Marble columns, locked doors, and a crowd outside anyway.
- 7:03[Maya] Says something about how much people care, even if the money story
- 7:06[Maya] doesn't quite add up.
- 7:07[David] Man.
- 7:08[David] Okay, so between the press ban and now this, it's been a
- 7:11[David] rough week for anybody who runs an institution the administration has opinions
- 7:15[David] about.
- 7:16[Maya] That is one way to put it.
- 7:18[David] Speaking of institutions running into trouble with the federal government, there's a
- 7:22[David] legal fight brewing that's actually going to go in front of judges,
- 7:25[David] maybe the Supreme Court, over how ICE detains people.
- 7:28[Maya] Oh, this is the one you were texting me about last night.
- 7:31[David] Yeah, and unlike the Kennedy camp thing, this one isn't about optics.
- 7:35[David] This is a court deciding whether the government is actually breaking the
- 7:38[David] law.
- 7:40[Maya] So here's where the story actually lands.
- 7:42[Maya] Mass detention under ICE has been getting blocked over and over in
- 7:47[Maya] the appeals courts.
- 7:48[David] Wait, like actually blocked, not just delayed?
- 7:51[Maya] Politico laid this out on September nineteenth.
- 7:53[Maya] Court after court has been ruling against how ICE is holding people
- 7:57[Maya] without bond hearings.
- 7:59[David] Huh.
- 7:59[David] It's not one ruling, it's a pattern.
- 8:02[David] Judges keep saying the government's detention authority has limits, and ICE keeps
- 8:06[David] running into that wall.
- 8:07[Maya] Okay, but ICE doesn't just shrug and stop, right?
- 8:10[Maya] There's gotta be a next move.
- 8:11[David] There is, and it's a big one.
- 8:13[David] The Supreme Court could take this up.
- 8:15[Maya] Wait, seriously?
- 8:17[Maya] The actual Supreme Court?
- 8:18[David] Yeah, and Politico's framing on this is pretty blunt.
- 8:21[David] The appeals courts have routed the administration so far, but the high
- 8:24[David] court could reverse that whole tide.
- 8:26[Maya] So everything these lower courts have been doing could just be wiped
- 8:30[Maya] out?
- 8:30[David] Could.
- 8:31[David] Doesn't mean it will, but that's the risk sitting on the table.
- 8:33[Maya] That's a lot riding on one bench.
- 8:36[David] It always is with immigration cases.
- 8:38[David] The lower courts are the speed bump.
- 8:39[David] The Supreme Court is the one that decides if the road's actually
- 8:42[David] closed.
- 8:43[Maya] I mean, from where I sit, ICE has a mandate to enforce
- 8:46[Maya] the law.
- 8:46[Maya] If judges are blocking detention wholesale, at some point that's Congress's job
- 8:50[Maya] to fix, not nine people in robes.
- 8:53[David] Sure, but the courts aren't inventing this out of nowhere.
- 8:56[David] They're saying due process rules still apply even to people ICE wants
- 9:00[David] to hold.
- 9:00[Maya] Right.
- 9:01[Maya] No, I get that.
- 9:01[Maya] I'm just saying a win in the Ninth Circuit today doesn't mean
- 9:04[Maya] much if the Supreme Court flips it in six months.
- 9:07[David] Exactly.
- 9:08[David] So if you're a detainee who just won your case or you're
- 9:11[David] ICE and you just lost one, neither side should be celebrating too
- 9:14[David] hard yet.
- 9:15[Maya] It's genuinely just paused, not settled.
- 9:18[David] Paused, yeah.
- 9:19[David] And depending on your politics, that pause is either relief or a
- 9:22[David] countdown clock.
- 9:24[Maya] That's one way to put it.
- 9:26[David] The other thing worth noting, this isn't a fringe legal theory anymore.
- 9:29[David] It's stacked up enough losses for the administration that it's basically forcing
- 9:33[David] the issue upward.
- 9:34[Maya] So the Supreme Court might not even have a choice about picking
- 9:37[Maya] it up.
- 9:37[David] Might not.
- 9:38[David] When enough circuits disagree with each other or enough of them line
- 9:41[David] up against the government, that's the kind of split that gets a
- 9:44[David] case scheduled.
- 9:45[Maya] So walk me through it in plain terms.
- 9:47[Maya] If the Supreme Court actually takes this up and sides with the
- 9:51[Maya] administration, what changes for someone sitting in detention right now?
- 9:56[David] Practically, it means the bond hearings these appeals courts have been requiring
- 9:59[David] could go away.
- 10:00[David] The legal floor under detainees right now is really just whatever the
- 10:04[David] circuit they're in is ruled.
- 10:06[Maya] And that floor could just vanish if the high court reverses it.
- 10:09[David] Right, and that cuts both ways.
- 10:11[David] It's also the floor ICE is operating under when it decides how
- 10:14[David] it can hold people.
- 10:15[David] Right now, ICE has to work around these rulings.
- 10:18[David] A reversal removes that constraint.
- 10:20[Maya] So for ICE, a reversal is basically getting the green light to
- 10:24[Maya] go back to doing what it was doing before all these court
- 10:27[Maya] losses piled up.
- 10:28[David] That's the shape of it, yeah.
- 10:29[David] And that's exactly why nobody on either side should treat where things
- 10:33[David] stand today as final.
- 10:34[Maya] It really is just a snapshot, not the ending.
- 10:38[David] Exactly.
- 10:38[David] The story right now is courts pushing back, but the next chapter
- 10:42[David] could easily read Supreme Court pushes back on the pushback.
- 10:46[Maya] Man.
- 10:47[Maya] Okay, so we've got a press fight, a closed building, and now
- 10:51[Maya] a detention fight that might land at the Supreme Court.
- 10:55[David] Busy week.
- 10:56[Maya] Busy week is an understatement.
- 10:59[Maya] Okay, David, I think that's plenty to chew on for one morning.
- 11:02[David] Yeah, let's wrap it up before Maya's coffee gets cold.
- 11:05[Maya] Too late.
- 11:05[Maya] Already cold.
- 11:06[Maya] Let's do a quick recap and get out of here.
- 11:08[David] Sounds good.
- 11:10[Maya] Okay, so three things today.
- 11:11[Maya] A reporter gets physically stopped at the door.
- 11:14[David] A concert hall goes dark over a naming fight dressed up as
- 11:17[David] money trouble.
- 11:18[Maya] And judges are the only thing standing between ICE and a much
- 11:22[Maya] bigger detention push.
- 11:24[David] Three totally different stories, same underlying question.
- 11:27[David] Who actually gets to say no to power right now?
- 11:30[Maya] Reporters, board members, judges.
- 11:34[David] Honestly, not a bad job posting.
- 11:36[David] Must enjoy saying no to the White House.
- 11:38[Maya] Apply within.
- 11:40[Maya] Low pay, high stress.
- 11:41[David] Great benefits, though.
- 11:42[David] You get to be right eventually.
- 11:44[Maya] Maybe.
- 11:45[Maya] We'll see how the Supreme Court feels about that.
- 11:47[David] Anyway, keep an eye on all three of these.
- 11:49[David] They're not done.
- 11:50[Maya] Not even close.
- 11:52[David] That's it for us today.
- 11:53[Maya] Thanks for hanging out with us.
- 11:54[Maya] We know your morning's busy.
- 11:56[David] We'll be back tomorrow with whatever chaos shows up next.
- 11:59[Maya] Which, given the week we've had, could be anything.
- 12:02[David] Take care of yourselves out there.
- 12:04[Maya] See you tomorrow.
- 12:05[David] Bye, everybody.
- 12:06[David] Go finish that coffee before it gets any colder.