Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: On Topic - Why are you doing speechlift from the can?
Transcript
- 0:00AV Superfriends on Topic is an independent production wholly owned and operated by AV Superfriends
- 0:04LLC.
- 0:05For the highest quality recording of all of our shows, visit AVSuperfriends.com.
- 0:10This is AV Superfriends on Topic, a 30-minute monthly roundtable focused on a single topic.
- 0:18This discussion will be opinionated to the point and saturated with our well-known blend
- 0:22of painfully-wond expertise and deeply-abrained imagery.
- 0:25For May, 2026, but we're recording in April, we know it's the best sounding and most
- 0:37audio-focused podcast in higher ed.
- 0:40This is the AV Superfriends on Topic episode number 70.
- 0:43We got it.
- 0:45Two good ones.
- 0:467D.
- 0:477D.
- 0:48Broadcasting live across the frequency spectrum from the low end rumble to the high end
- 0:52hiss.
- 0:53The cast that knows bad-gain structure can ruin a room faster than bad leadership
- 0:57ruins a department.
- 0:58So grab your headphones, check your mute status, and pray nobody routed the far end back
- 1:02into the program feed.
- 1:03I'm Chris Decker and I'm for another Friday afternoon podcast adventure, and let's say
- 1:06hello to our panel of August AV Superfriends.
- 1:10Our first panelist, oops sorry, miss fire.
- 1:14Our first panelist oversees institutional preparedness from the sacred moment for the sacred
- 1:19moment when someone says, "Can everybody hear me and nobody can?"
- 1:23He's an executive director of playback readiness and speaker confidence from Kansas City
- 1:27sailor Mr. Jamie Reinhardt.
- 1:29Whoa, sorry, miss fire, look at that.
- 1:32It's all, the magic is all in the feedback loop.
- 1:35It seems like you want to make sure you have that.
- 1:38Special feedback.
- 1:40Our next panelist specializes in making sure every guest speaker starts off their video
- 1:44with a laptop audio still selected instead of the room system.
- 1:47He's a senior audio experience curator from Corvallis Oregon, sailor Mr. Mark Kolozinski.
- 1:51I like to make sure everybody can experience just a little bit of sheer terror for a couple
- 1:57seconds just to start off every meeting because that's the best way to get everybody awake.
- 2:01Get your heart moving.
- 2:02Right, get your blood pumping.
- 2:04I just push wrong button.
- 2:07Our next panelist coordinates low frequency equity across campus so no building is left
- 2:11without at least one room that mysteriously rattles when the volume has turned up past
- 2:1580%.
- 2:16He's an associate dean for distributed woofer affairs from Greensboro North Carolina
- 2:19sailor Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:20Yep, I put woofers in every room but it's just for me to put a look so I don't actually
- 2:25alarm up.
- 2:26Woofer affairs.
- 2:27Woof woof.
- 2:28I'm interested.
- 2:29I'm not dogs Justin.
- 2:30Yeah, that's fantastic.
- 2:32Our next panelist ensures every campus event, classroom lecture and video conference
- 2:36has played at a volume that is somehow both too loud and yet not enough.
- 2:40He's a vice president for strategic loudness alignment from bowling green Kentucky sailor
- 2:44Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:45At least 99 dog biscuits in every classroom.
- 2:48Oh, your money bag has audio.
- 2:50If we need audio.
- 2:53If we actually need it, it's got to be 99 dog biscuits.
- 2:56I do like that people are using dog biscuits.
- 3:00So what's it is so we're going to discuss deploying audio in classrooms and why however we
- 3:04do it is wrong.
- 3:06But first a little bit of housekeeping.
- 3:07If you are listening to this as a recorded MP3 remember we do stream live on Friday.
- 3:10Is it about 315 Eastern to 1215 Pacific or whenever Mark finally finishes asking whether
- 3:14the room is getting enough coverage?
- 3:16You can join us live for that on Twitter linked in and you too.
- 3:18But if you can't join us live, we still want you to connect with us on the socials.
- 3:21Follow us on Twitter linked in and YouTube also blue sky for both of you over there.
- 3:25You can follow us there to keep up with the latest updates news, fresh opportunities to
- 3:28hear us complain about bad speaker placement, uneven coverage and the ongoing crime of relying
- 3:32on display audio and rooms built for actual humans.
- 3:35Finally, don't forget to spread the word share this podcast with your friends.
- 3:39Colleagues, enemies, perfect strangers and especially that one person on campus who
- 3:41still thinks a pair of mismatched computer speakers can adequately cover his lecture hall.
- 3:46If you could go tackle people in public and force them to listen to a few dozen episodes
- 3:50that would be great, consider a public service announcement for better audio playback.
- 3:53If you want to support the show please consider donating your contributions, help us to keep
- 3:56bringing you the honest content you love or love to hate with more clarity and less
- 4:00compression than the average classroom speech reinforcement system.
- 4:03You can find the donation link in the show notes or on the website.
- 4:06And we're always eager to hear from you.
- 4:07So if this topic you want us to cover, loudspeakers, DSP, speech intelligibility, conference
- 4:11room nonsense, event space disasters, why half the rooms out there sound like announcements
- 4:16being made from inside a trash can, all that stuff.
- 4:19Send us an email or comment on the social media.
- 4:20You can hit us up via email or mailbag@superfriends.com.
- 4:24I'm sorry, mailbag@avsuperfriends.com.
- 4:28I'm scrolling and trying to do two things at once here.
- 4:30Finally, while you're listening to us on YouTube Spotify, Apple Podcast, wherever you happen
- 4:34to find this, please leave a rating and review that forces more people to hear what we're
- 4:37talking about.
- 4:38And like a properly designed distributed speaker system, it'll reach more listeners.
- 4:45So we think we'll do a bit about a minute.
- 4:47And thank you for your support.
- 4:48We could not do this without you.
- 4:49And unlike some campus sound systems, at least we know where the audio is supposed to go.
- 4:53Alrighty.
- 4:54Well, let's see.
- 4:56Why are we here?
- 4:57We've got a topic this month.
- 4:58This is on the topic.
- 4:59The topic of the month, Jamie.
- 5:00There's a jingle which came from you, Jamie.
- 5:04And this one's topic.
- 5:14This is Mark's fault.
- 5:15This started a debate about, I don't know, about three weeks ago.
- 5:18Just out of nowhere, it became a very passionate, like shouting match to each other as to how we
- 5:23do audio in our speech.
- 5:25That's not where it started.
- 5:26That's not where it started.
- 5:27I don't think that's like the correct exactly.
- 5:30See, this is how it always sideways.
- 5:32Just to do.
- 5:33You asked a dumb question.
- 5:34This is a double people.
- 5:35Yeah, what was a dumb question?
- 5:36I didn't ask a dumb question.
- 5:37You asked a dumb question.
- 5:38Mark asked a dumb question, Jamie.
- 5:39Remind me, because I asked a lot of dumb questions.
- 5:42You said, what are you all doing for sound?
- 5:44I think it was, was it speaker specifically though?
- 5:46Yes, it was speakers.
- 5:47How do you feel about JBL speakers or something dumb like that?
- 5:51It was something like, it was around cans versus point source.
- 5:56It just erupted into a whole back channel of nonsense.
- 5:59He did.
- 6:00We answered it and then Justin went off on us.
- 6:01Oh yeah, we were all clearly wrong based on uniform coverage, standard, blah, blah,
- 6:07whatever that may be.
- 6:08But yeah, I was curious around sealing cans or not or just having some speakers at the
- 6:19front of the room and then we got into the diapers market depends.
- 6:22I know, I know.
- 6:23And then, oh, are we doing speech lift?
- 6:25Are we not doing speech lift?
- 6:26Or do we still do speech just from the cans?
- 6:30Or are you doing it from the front as well?
- 6:32And then it was fully in my stomachs.
- 6:35Why are you doing speech from the can?
- 6:37Right, some lazy.
- 6:40What can the I like to sit on the can and just pontificate verbally.
- 6:47So I think there's several different things going on here.
- 6:50So let's start with the sealing cans versus speakers on the head wall where we add on
- 6:56this.
- 6:57Let's pick this simple solution.
- 6:59I don't want to not depends by location.
- 7:02That's not a viable answer here.
- 7:04Let's take a small classroom.
- 7:05And whatever you're conjuring in your mind every time, define that small classroom.
- 7:10The same that Jesus had a drop sealing in everywhere else in a little tiny 25 by 25 room.
- 7:19Yeah.
- 7:20Sailing speakers.
- 7:24That's my standard.
- 7:25That's what we go with.
- 7:26Okay.
- 7:27Jamie, play your cards.
- 7:30Let's see him.
- 7:32Both.
- 7:33Both all the time.
- 7:34Every room has both.
- 7:35Why?
- 7:36Therefore while I did.
- 7:37I don't do that much.
- 7:38But only one prognosis speaker.
- 7:40Or were you smoking while you were doing that?
- 7:42So probably 60% of all rooms, all rooms have sealing cans, voice lift of some sort, 70
- 7:51voice lift.
- 7:52And it's voice lift.
- 7:53I'm going to say that again.
- 7:55Voice lift.
- 7:56Voice lift.
- 7:57Period.
- 7:58Voice lift.
- 7:59And then I did have a point source at the front.
- 8:02And then I did, I was one of those fools who ran left and right.
- 8:05And that was back when we had blue ray discs and analog outs from computers.
- 8:11I needed for movie mode.
- 8:13Yes.
- 8:14I needed for movies.
- 8:15Okay.
- 8:16So everyone in that room has the same experience no matter where they sit.
- 8:20I want to come back to that moment.
- 8:22Absolutely not.
- 8:23Just like the movie theater.
- 8:24You want to come back.
- 8:25You spend $40 a ticket to go into the movie theater and sit in shitty spots.
- 8:27So why not in the classroom?
- 8:28You stand in line or get your reserve seats.
- 8:31Oh my God.
- 8:32I like the good old days.
- 8:34Right near a surround speaker.
- 8:35I want to hear what's going on.
- 8:36I like to find the sub and just cozy up next to that.
- 8:38That's the premium.
- 8:39I only want to hear the helicopter out of the left channel.
- 8:42I don't like it out of the right channel.
- 8:43It makes me feel we so easy.
- 8:45It's in cheapest is not always right either.
- 8:47I have tinnitus.
- 8:48No.
- 8:49I hear recently here recently.
- 8:52It's on criteria.
- 8:53I'm sure what the answer is.
- 8:54It's mostly ceiling voice lift speakers.
- 8:57And we don't do the front cans in small rooms.
- 9:00In big rooms I do have a proper set of program speakers.
- 9:05And I'll still use ceiling cans for voice lift to get it all the way back.
- 9:09Exactly.
- 9:10I might even delay said cans and have extra program audio come through.
- 9:16But okay.
- 9:17That's just.
- 9:18But I'm not really.
- 9:19I've always lived.
- 9:20I'm taking the other side of the spectrum where it's a lot of our rooms.
- 9:24I don't have the exact number in front of me.
- 9:28Those small rooms, some workhorse JBL's bolted on the front wall.
- 9:34Blowing across the room.
- 9:35Oh no.
- 9:36The smallest jibbles you can get.
- 9:3823s.
- 9:39Put it out in the corner.
- 9:40Yep.
- 9:41Those damn 23s.
- 9:42No.
- 9:43Price per because they're all sociopaths.
- 9:44And it actually works.
- 9:45I've not even gotten to my stuff yet.
- 9:46It works.
- 9:47No.
- 9:48It does.
- 9:49Why?
- 9:50You can put two ceilings and cover everybody's thing.
- 9:52And that may be the case.
- 9:55However.
- 9:56You even know why you're bitching.
- 9:57You don't even use speakers.
- 9:58Yeah.
- 9:59What's your ceiling height?
- 10:0035 feet?
- 10:01The extra sound feels flat-build.
- 10:04They cover.
- 10:05This is why this is the topic happened.
- 10:07Everybody.
- 10:08Now you see.
- 10:09They're the standard 9.5 to 10 feet.
- 10:11And then you get the coverage cones.
- 10:13It's a 30-seat room.
- 10:15Let's go.
- 10:16Sometimes you can get to 4, but you don't need it.
- 10:18Like Larry said, those four inch rooms.
- 10:20And the extra one's case.
- 10:21The crappy 3-inch cans.
- 10:23We'll get 180 degrees.
- 10:24Don't you know?
- 10:25Do you have any degrees for two frequencies?
- 10:283,000 and 2,000 K.
- 10:29But that's all right.
- 10:30That's fine.
- 10:31No, measures test.
- 10:33So why would you do that?
- 10:35You don't test every standard classroom.
- 10:36I do my calculus later.
- 10:37Not every one's good.
- 10:38If you're going to do some weird shit that Jamie just talked about, what's fun?
- 10:43Not too much.
- 10:44What's effective this?
- 10:45It's fine.
- 10:46I test every single one of them.
- 10:47I go.
- 10:48Yep.
- 10:49Good.
- 10:50You're happy.
- 10:51That's the official designated S.A.R. method.
- 10:54Yep.
- 10:55It's about right.
- 10:56And if it's three quarters up on the volume control and it's too loud, we're perfect.
- 11:01It's slightly painful.
- 11:02In what seat?
- 11:05Well, I covered everything.
- 11:07I have a big, it's just covered with as much as you can.
- 11:14Intelligibility.
- 11:15It's a 30-seat room that's made out of concrete blocks and linoleum floor.
- 11:20That's why you should pay attention to it.
- 11:22All right, smart guy.
- 11:23What do you got?
- 11:24Like I said, it depends for a 30-minute.
- 11:27No, no, no.
- 11:28It doesn't depend.
- 11:29It's a 30 by 30 room.
- 11:31Small class room.
- 11:32With ACT.
- 11:33Yep.
- 11:34That's what we got.
- 11:35With a drop ceiling, we are either in the four to six speaker range, four and a half
- 11:39inch cans.
- 11:40There is no front.
- 11:41I understand what the calculator tells me to do, Justin.
- 11:44That's not what I'm asking you.
- 11:46What do you actually have?
- 11:47And everything is plus to minus 3DB and everybody hears at the same level.
- 11:52How many rooms do you have that are this exact way?
- 11:56One.
- 11:57And a half.
- 11:59My rooms?
- 12:00Yeah.
- 12:01I'm not sure how to answer this question.
- 12:05Where you work most often for your week.
- 12:09The rooms in which you think.
- 12:10I know you're talking to me or Larry.
- 12:12You.
- 12:13How, what's the percentage of rooms you would have that you think meet this criteria?
- 12:17That are class rooms that meet the 30 by 30 criteria that are drop ceiling.
- 12:21Have these, this supposed depends on four to six ceiling cans, equal to zero to eight.
- 12:25I would say probably 80%.
- 12:26Okay.
- 12:2790%.
- 12:28The other fuck, the other 10 to 20% is don't have speakers because they can't afford it.
- 12:35All right.
- 12:36I do do some math and try to figure it out.
- 12:38Yeah.
- 12:39The correct coverage area, but it keeps it away from the walls as much as possible.
- 12:44So now it's, we have, I have modeling.
- 12:46If you put it close to the wall, you get a better reflection.
- 12:49Mm-hmm.
- 12:50I get a little bit of the wall.
- 12:51I try to get a little bit off of that.
- 12:52Yeah.
- 12:53Any time that I do down for a new shaped room, I drop it in ease.
- 12:57And I save that as a template.
- 12:58And then when it comes up again, yeah.
- 13:00When it comes up again, I've got it.
- 13:02And it's already done.
- 13:03Now, one of the things your model is changing.
- 13:05It's a little bit.
- 13:06Maybe.
- 13:07But the general guide of how I do an auditorium, how I do a generic classroom, how I do a larger
- 13:14classroom with really low ceilings, we have, I have one that's a, I'm not sure, I'm
- 13:2050 by 40 classroom with eight foot ceilings.
- 13:22I probably have 25 speakers in that bitch.
- 13:28Is that, is that in a basement?
- 13:30It's on the top floor of a, you know, you can build up, right?
- 13:34Yeah.
- 13:35Yeah.
- 13:36I'm not a money.
- 13:37You're, you're not on the architect of this thing.
- 13:39Sightlines in that room must like, who cares about what you can do.
- 13:43Oh, we're just going to be a little bit bad.
- 13:44It's, we struggle providing designs for that for years.
- 13:47Is there any way they could add a column like in the middle?
- 13:50They could do.
- 13:51It's a ramp.
- 13:52Can you just sit around that?
- 13:56Can you just sit around that?
- 13:57You, you, I've got long arms and I can't touch my fingers when I hug it because I was trying
- 14:02to measure it.
- 14:04I remember that.
- 14:05It was right in the middle.
- 14:06It's not exactly in the middle.
- 14:07It's like a halfway back, but on the one third side of the room.
- 14:12So if you sit in the back, left quad, you're in here.
- 14:16Like not learning accounting back there because they're writing on the whiteboards.
- 14:21This is the whiteboard room that I talked about with the, oh, yeah, come up and read that
- 14:25and sit in the back and read that it's that same room.
- 14:27I can hear everything.
- 14:29You default to in most rooms.
- 14:31You default.
- 14:32Yeah, they can hear all the accounting numbers.
- 14:33They just can't see them.
- 14:34That makes no sense.
- 14:36You default to ceiling speakers.
- 14:39Well, in most rooms, in most rooms, auditoriums.
- 14:44I always try not to do fills, but sometimes I have to to get the plus minus 3 DB, but
- 14:49I try to get everything from the front.
- 14:52And it's sometimes, it sometimes just doesn't work out.
- 14:56I just think large spaces are, it's a little more customized.
- 15:00I just didn't warn them.
- 15:01Tracker jack box things.
- 15:03It's pretty basic.
- 15:04We had an integrator come in, I don't know, 15, 10 years ago, throw up some rink of
- 15:09signs on the front wall in the sawdatory and then they were the ones.
- 15:13When it's on rink of signs as bad, it's just not the right speaker for the space.
- 15:18It just wasn't getting to the back.
- 15:20They kept complaining, complaining.
- 15:21I was like, look, if you want it done right, we got to just redo the audio system and
- 15:25I'll drop it in ease.
- 15:27And I'll make sure the numbers match.
- 15:29And if the numbers match, you should be happy.
- 15:30So I've dropped everything in, gave them the option.
- 15:34They gripped and complained about the price.
- 15:37We had to put like eight to 10 foot column arrays on each side wall, which is stage level.
- 15:44And they had to be four foot off the ground, which is terrible.
- 15:48I know.
- 15:49But it sounds, but you got it.
- 15:52It's got it.
- 15:53And everybody's like loving it and they can have more events in there and not complain.
- 15:58That's the goal is just making sure you get it right.
- 16:00I feel like that's underpowered for their.
- 16:02They always go away.
- 16:03We're talking like they want the full thing.
- 16:05We want trusting Mark.
- 16:07Why do you go with two points, always in the front instead of speaking instead of ceilings?
- 16:12This is baffling me because why do you see my ceiling is 30 foot in the air?
- 16:17Not in his space.
- 16:18Not there.
- 16:19We're going back to the original question.
- 16:21Mark what mine.
- 16:22No, no, Mark.
- 16:23Mark.
- 16:24Yeah.
- 16:25Because it's probably the S.A.R. method to be on a person honest.
- 16:29And I think there's diminishing returns at a certain point.
- 16:32Now is it technically right versus right enough to actually be adequate?
- 16:36We can go in there.
- 16:37And a lot of this came out of ease, not the ease software, but deployment.
- 16:41The ease of ease of the install.
- 16:42The ease of ease of the install, right?
- 16:43And it's not the wrong, like we're obviously doing this at a mouse, but the smaller spaces,
- 16:48traditionally they didn't have speech.
- 16:50They didn't have all that.
- 16:51It was literally deployed as content playback.
- 16:54What do we need as content playback in a space like that?
- 16:58Minimum.
- 16:59It's what it kind of defaulted at.
- 17:00That's where it came from.
- 17:01Did any easier to put them on the front wall and to drop it.
- 17:05Now that said, I've been defaulting to the drop in tiles.
- 17:09Right.
- 17:10I think this is kind of where that conversation picked up.
- 17:12And we talked about that price for deployment.
- 17:14We have to play two lay in speakers on the front wall.
- 17:16There you go.
- 17:17You know, I'll be honest.
- 17:18I don't really give a shit about how easy something is.
- 17:21Clearly.
- 17:22What?
- 17:23What?
- 17:24Yeah.
- 17:25So you don't get complaints or like, oh yeah, I get complaints, but you don't care.
- 17:29Yeah.
- 17:30Okay.
- 17:31I'm not sure.
- 17:32Yeah.
- 17:33Now, do I listen and take in those complaints?
- 17:37Yeah.
- 17:38And would I change my method potentially?
- 17:42Now would I sacrifice the students experience or the audience experience for it being easy?
- 17:48Sure.
- 17:49Nope.
- 17:50Nope.
- 17:51Not.
- 17:52It's not happening.
- 17:53And every time that I do a system now and I apply physics to it, I don't have to worry.
- 18:00I sleep at night and I always get, you know, good feedback.
- 18:04It's never no complaints since I've been doing physics.
- 18:07So feedback is actually at a better frequency than my future pitch.
- 18:12Yeah.
- 18:13Yeah.
- 18:14I think it's, as you started off, Justin, it depends.
- 18:17Like what are, and we didn't even kind of get into criteria to have like voice lift or
- 18:21not voice lift and all these things.
- 18:22And I think that drives a lot of what's going on here is that, you know, the smaller classrooms
- 18:28historically did not have voice lift.
- 18:30They did have microphones and such and for ADA capacity, but it was not there for a speech
- 18:34lift in the actual class itself.
- 18:36Do you want to let your house cut off for voice lift?
- 18:39Because mine keeps dropping.
- 18:41Anything with 40 are actually now it's 30 or more.
- 18:45We just automatically had it.
- 18:46Larry, when you say voice lift, do you mean capability or actively deployed?
- 18:51Actively deployed.
- 18:52If it's not a sound bar in my space, if it's not a sound bar, it's got voice.
- 18:55If it's not a conference room, then it has it.
- 18:58So that was not the case here.
- 19:01That wasn't the case here either.
- 19:02I'm like, yeah.
- 19:03I don't think why, which is why I've been, I mean, look, we've talked about, I've been over
- 19:08building for years, but it's covered my rear in most cases.
- 19:12And, you know, I'm okay with it.
- 19:18Do you all have like a ton of dead battery microphone tickets?
- 19:25Do you have to contend with regularly?
- 19:27No, those don't get tickets.
- 19:29We delete them.
- 19:31Since we have part-timers that go around most days, the batteries are refreshed or charged
- 19:38when they do the system checks.
- 19:39How about broken mics?
- 19:40They go in early like at five in the morning and check out a little bit.
- 19:46They don't have, actually, they don't have to, Aaron.
- 19:49They don't have to have voice lift and assisted listening system.
- 19:52It's best to have a voice lift.
- 19:53We have a whole department of students.
- 19:55This is no joke.
- 19:57We don't have a lot of hearing assistants ifs and then our classrooms because our best
- 20:00effort is our ADA office has student workers and whenever we get a request, the student
- 20:06worker goes out and write down all the notes and, you know, and all that stuff.
- 20:10Now, is they what?
- 20:11Yeah.
- 20:12Are they due interpretations?
- 20:13Yeah, we have Diaz office who goes out and checks for us accessibility and features
- 20:18and make sure that they're given that.
- 20:20And they'll sit there with the student and transcribe notes that the teacher is talking
- 20:23if they can't hear correctly, if they get a complaint, there's no hearing assistants
- 20:26in a room.
- 20:27So, we just don't, we don't have to have hearing assistants in every classroom.
- 20:32We don't have to get the capability.
- 20:35I just don't know when needed.
- 20:36Yeah, I just don't know when needed.
- 20:38It was part of my standard.
- 20:40Not this part of it.
- 20:41We can't.
- 20:42They send people there to circumvent that.
- 20:44Well, it was part of my standard for years and years and years and years.
- 20:48I have hundreds of these things out there.
- 20:50And about two years ago, I just stopped because they don't get used.
- 20:53And B, several of the students I talked to you about as well as our Diaz office, the students
- 20:58themselves hate those systems.
- 21:01Because they, now they have to self-identify.
- 21:04Now they have to make them, you know, they have to wear the goofball headsets or something.
- 21:07And yes, there's ways to plug it in or get it to your phone.
- 21:09I get it.
- 21:10Oh, put in the hearing loop and it talks, yeah, I get it.
- 21:12Sometimes, you guys have to underground concrete loops in all your classrooms.
- 21:15Yeah, I'm putting loops in every freaking room.
- 21:16Yeah, that's not happening ever.
- 21:18I don't want to.
- 21:19I'm not concrete.
- 21:20No, no, I'm just going to say, but we do provide the capability.
- 21:23So when that request comes in, just like you said, Justin, when the request comes in, we
- 21:27can go install one in the rooms that need it.
- 21:28We bought a bunch of the Bluetooth ones to get Bluetooth in the room because those are
- 21:32already compatible with their hearing agent they can use it and they don't have to self-identify
- 21:36in all that.
- 21:37For the most part, yes.
- 21:38So we make, it's that best effort.
- 21:40We make the effort.
- 21:41I'm not going to light up every space to have that stuff permanently installed.
- 21:44Yeah.
- 21:45And there we will get it installed very shortly within a day or two at most.
- 21:50So what are you doing?
- 21:51You're the only one that we really didn't do.
- 21:54Do you know my answer to this?
- 21:56It's a two-barter.
- 21:57720p.
- 21:58Mono.
- 21:59Everyone can.
- 22:00Mono can mean Mono.
- 22:01I bet.
- 22:02That can mean Mono can be a lot to places.
- 22:06Okay.
- 22:07I have 72 channels of Mono.
- 22:08That's right.
- 22:09Yes.
- 22:10No, I actually go around and affect on, I did a site walk this morning with some integrators
- 22:14who are bidding on some projects.
- 22:16And as part of the scope, they are removing program speakers because I am removing program
- 22:20speakers from those point-source speakers at the front of the room that were never tuned
- 22:23properly and don't do anything.
- 22:25It's all coming out.
- 22:27You get an even sound field from the ceiling all the way down on all your content.
- 22:31Voice lift, program audio.
- 22:32I don't care what it is.
- 22:33Now, large auditoriums, that's different, but in most rooms, even up to 75 seats or whatever,
- 22:37even sound field of the ceiling down to the, to the speech to the seating level, no point-source
- 22:42speakers in the front.
- 22:43So, I got a number of point-source speakers I have installed in the last two or three years.
- 22:47I'd say probably 20 maybe.
- 22:49So.
- 22:50Okay.
- 22:51So, Larry brought up and this was what I remember from our last argument is, you know,
- 22:56if you were really starting to get down and do some crunchy math here, you got a presenter
- 23:00in the front of the room with the students in the front and the presenter talks and the
- 23:04student hears them directly before the mic and all that stuff and loudness and all that.
- 23:08So, question is, do you all zone your speakers?
- 23:13Or how you want to duck the front row and then do it.
- 23:17You don't zone your own.
- 23:18If you can back, you go left to right, follows the rows, right?
- 23:23So that I can bring this down a little bit versus the back and still have plus minus 3 dB.
- 23:30And that's what I mean about balancing everything out.
- 23:33And Justin, again, like I think me and Jamie are really leaning into the voice lift and
- 23:38you're going sound reinforcement.
- 23:41I'm doing voice lift plus program.
- 23:43Yeah, I don't want to.
- 23:44Is that different?
- 23:46It is.
- 23:47Is it according to Jamie or Larry and Jamie?
- 23:49It is on the like the definition of them.
- 23:52No, no, I know the sources are different, but at the end of the day, I'm making.
- 23:57We're moving air.
- 23:58Everybody's moving air.
- 24:00But hand in the equally.
- 24:01Everybody here is equally, but that doesn't mean that everybody gets exactly the same thing.
- 24:07It just doesn't.
- 24:08I want to play devil advocate here.
- 24:10I don't need to hear this instructor coming above me.
- 24:14That's distracting.
- 24:16That adds cognitive.
- 24:17But I'm interested in a myersound constellation.
- 24:19I'll help you this one soon.
- 24:21So I can wrap you like a warm hug.
- 24:23I want to go back to like that small space.
- 24:25So I think we're teetering into these larger spaces.
- 24:28Yeah, the larger spaces I'll become.
- 24:29I don't want to have that in the small, seemingly most affordable cookie cutter style system
- 24:35you're doing a lot of.
- 24:37I'm sensing a diminishing return of all this excessive wigitry in here.
- 24:43Moving air, which arguably is competing with just my mouth in the room.
- 24:47Like what?
- 24:48How much more do I need to carry my voice 30 feet?
- 24:51Like I just I don't I get it.
- 24:53There's there's soft spoken people and then I understand all that.
- 24:57But at a certain point, are we are we doing a sanity check?
- 25:01Or are we really needing that much and I don't care what the computer says.
- 25:08Do you need it in that space to actually have a functioning learning space?
- 25:13That's what physics tells me.
- 25:16Physics told you that or did your computer tell you that?
- 25:19Physics.
- 25:20I can get the same answer with my hand and a pencil that I came with a computer.
- 25:24So I think it's a bell that has the instructor's voice can be heard at X decibel with the last
- 25:30row and the first row, whether it's coming from the speakers or directly from that instructor's
- 25:35mouth, that's the goal.
- 25:36Have you stood at this concrete room with a tile floor or whatever and just whispered
- 25:43and see how it just reverberates across that room.
- 25:45I feel like usually it's not about more audio.
- 25:49It's probably less audio in these spaces.
- 25:52Again, physics.
- 25:56But I think you're making choices that are employing additional stack technology in spaces.
- 26:04I have a hard time believing you absolutely need to have these things widespread across
- 26:09campus.
- 26:10I also have a hard time believing you measure the noise floor in every room you're going
- 26:14to do that summer.
- 26:16When it's a loud room, I do.
- 26:18Because we walk in and a lot of our rooms have self-contained air conditioner units.
- 26:22That sound like a semi-truck driving by.
- 26:25People say I want to turn this into a zoom room.
- 26:27I know at that point.
- 26:30I can't say no.
- 26:32I'm not allowed to say no with how we're funded here because they have money and they want
- 26:36to do something by God.
- 26:37We got to do it.
- 26:39I'm like, "Okay, if you do this, this thing is at 87 decibels right now.
- 26:44That means I have to pump in 96 decibels for you to hear it, which means we have to cut
- 26:48off the fire alarm.
- 26:49You want to spend 50 grand on this sound system?"
- 26:52No.
- 26:53Okay.
- 26:54And that's how we say no.
- 26:58Now I will say, "Well, I walk into a room and I hear thank you good night from the performance
- 27:02that was going on last night because it's still reverberating around in there."
- 27:05Yes.
- 27:06We're going to take a different tack in here.
- 27:08Yes.
- 27:09No, I don't measure every room.
- 27:11I measure outliers and weird things that I come up with or come across that I haven't
- 27:18done before.
- 27:19Now, everything that I come across has been measured once.
- 27:24And then I can see that I'm in time.
- 27:25At least once.
- 27:26Okay.
- 27:27And an empty space without any...
- 27:29So let's go back and read the whole space for a little bit of what we got here to say.
- 27:33I don't understand what the mileage may vary.
- 27:37Sounds like there's a mix.
- 27:40But I'm sensing ceiling cans are kind of back and vogue again.
- 27:46I can't.
- 27:48Sailing speeders are not in.
- 27:51Not cans.
- 27:52I've completely...
- 27:53If I have to cut a round circle, I'm out.
- 27:57Yeah, exactly.
- 27:58My team hates cans.
- 27:59Okay.
- 28:00So lay in...
- 28:01Lay in speakers that fit cleanly within the two slash four or whatever grid.
- 28:06Are you putting the trim piece in them?
- 28:09They look clean or you just drop in a minute with the ragged edge.
- 28:11Depending on the model, they don't have two pieces.
- 28:12The thing is, is they're good enough.
- 28:14They're good enough.
- 28:15See?
- 28:16They're not high-called...
- 28:17I mean, these are contractor-grade.
- 28:18They're good enough.
- 28:19They're easy to install.
- 28:21They usually do enough that I need them to do within the frequencies I need to do them
- 28:25in.
- 28:26And...
- 28:27What are we willing to spend for good enough?
- 28:30I think that's...
- 28:31100 bucks.
- 28:32That is where it all comes down to is how we got into this mess.
- 28:35100 bucks per speaker for the whole audio.
- 28:37Per speaker.
- 28:38Per speaker.
- 28:39100 bucks.
- 28:40That's a press.
- 28:41There you go.
- 28:42Like a pair for 180.
- 28:43Miner like 150 depending on whatever.
- 28:46Up to 199 is 100 bucks.
- 28:49That's be real.
- 28:50I need 150.
- 28:51I'm like...
- 28:52I'm saying it's easy math to do.
- 28:53I need 8 speakers in this room.
- 28:548 in her bucks.
- 28:55I had a manufacturer asked me not too long ago.
- 28:58So, would you guys be interested in 2x2s?
- 29:01Yeah.
- 29:02As long as you're not trying to make it concert grade, make it good enough and I'll buy a crap
- 29:06load of them.
- 29:07If you try to make it concert grade and charge me $500 a pop, you can keep them put them
- 29:11in the house.
- 29:12You got to be real careful because those 2x2s, they can get really shitty.
- 29:17I bought some.
- 29:18I mentioned the manufacturer.
- 29:19I found some.
- 29:20I had to throw them away from a new job and just find them.
- 29:24There are different levels but if you buy from manufacturers that we're pretty comfortable
- 29:31with and they're at the right, they're fine.
- 29:33They're fine.
- 29:34They're good enough.
- 29:35I have a stack setting in a warehouse that after the one room we did, I was like, "No,
- 29:39he's just going to sit here and do."
- 29:41Does the manufacturer begin with a queue by chance?
- 29:44No.
- 29:45I don't think so.
- 29:46I'll talk to you later.
- 29:47I'll talk to you later.
- 29:48You know what I'm talking about?
- 29:50Is it four letters out of Chicago?
- 29:52I don't know where they're from.
- 29:54So you're telling me?
- 29:55I have a handful of those.
- 29:56They are okay.
- 29:57Is it the quam one?
- 29:58So you can.
- 29:59There you go.
- 30:00You're telling me.
- 30:01We're trying to walk around it but thanks Jamie because that's awesome.
- 30:03I can't even believe you guys bought them.
- 30:06Manufacturers make different types of 2x2 so I might have just bought the worst possible
- 30:12grade and that's just what they sell and they're probably like, "Yeah, you shouldn't
- 30:16never bought those for a classroom."
- 30:18Even they're like, "Dude, what a lot of them."
- 30:21The mouth is on the front wall.
- 30:23They're fine.
- 30:24So enough good enough will get you ready.
- 30:25It's got an ancient and baffled.
- 30:26That's what I'm hearing.
- 30:27Enough good enough gets to great as long as you put enough.
- 30:28Good enough gets you there.
- 30:30I mean I'm not arguing that good enough is wrong.
- 30:33It's definitely right.
- 30:34It's just make sure you know what you're doing with some numbers and you'll get your
- 30:37heart.
- 30:38You're saying stack a bunch of good enough stuff up there.
- 30:40Below the thing else, a register is in green on my screen and we're good to go.
- 30:44Yep.
- 30:45We're good one DB in every classroom at every seat, dollar everything back.
- 30:50We're good.
- 30:51You're doing 1001 decibels per seat.
- 30:53What the f-
- 30:54Why is one on the ever do that?
- 30:56I'm just going to get a reaction first of all.
- 30:59So your goal is to have everybody who's wearing an Apple watch or a Google smartwatch
- 31:04whatever to get that little commercial where that guy's in that chair and he's looking
- 31:09at that TV and it's growing.
- 31:11It's here back.
- 31:12I'm doing it and it's blowing everybody's hair down.
- 31:16I do not think that's the way to approach it.
- 31:19No.
- 31:20But I mean that's you will get measurements.
- 31:22Yeah.
- 31:23I do look for.
- 31:24Yeah, but he runs all the feed.
- 31:25He runs down to like 25% he's fine.
- 31:27And then next year he just takes all the speakers out and puts in ASLs because they all have hearing
- 31:31aids.
- 31:32Now some of the classrooms can get to 100 DB but we dial those back and it's just because
- 31:37the equipment that's in there.
- 31:39You can hear the transformer melting.
- 31:41Yeah.
- 31:42That's not allowed.
- 31:43They're not allowed bouncing up and down on the chalkboard.
- 31:46We don't allow them to burn it up that loud.
- 31:49Wow.
- 31:50Okay.
- 31:51Well, next you're going to tell me you guys are doing this all with low impedance.
- 31:55Yeah.
- 31:56Home runs.
- 31:57I'm every one of them.
- 31:59Series, series parallel.
- 32:00It's much much easier there every time.
- 32:02You're a block.
- 32:03Just the biggest thing going to the lecture never.
- 32:06I mean, I just buy car amps because they're stable down to quarter home.
- 32:09We're good.
- 32:10Oh, I got a question.
- 32:12How many times have you all had to wire in a bunch of speakers in a series parallel configuration
- 32:19because the integrated to put in for them, eight home speakers and there was 50 of them
- 32:23in a ceiling.
- 32:24No, why?
- 32:25I'm doing it.
- 32:26They were all home run.
- 32:27And all home run or all in parallel.
- 32:29And you're like, you know what?
- 32:31I'm just going to do a little bit of math and we're going to rewire this.
- 32:35You know, parallel, series parallel.
- 32:37And I ran into that scenario two years ago in a space.
- 32:42And of course, I saw ceiling speakers throughout the space and I'm assuming it's a channel.
- 32:47They were wired wired in series 70 volt.
- 32:50You know, everything was fine.
- 32:51No, they were all low impedance.
- 32:52They were all wired and they were mixed too.
- 32:55And they're like, would you do wired home runs back to these giant blocks?
- 32:58I'm like, what is happening?
- 32:59What did you do?
- 33:00I replaced every speaker.
- 33:02All I did.
- 33:03And then we wired them because I didn't like to replace them.
- 33:06And the kind that didn't have the money to replace them.
- 33:09We were college business.
- 33:11They had the money.
- 33:12Yeah.
- 33:13So, I don't know what to do.
- 33:15And we've already established my budget for ceiling speakers.
- 33:17So that was a good learning opportunity for some installers on how to do.
- 33:22So I had a brand new technician and a couple of the student, the lead student and a couple
- 33:27of other students, like, hey guys, this is what you get to do for the next few days.
- 33:29And they now know ceiling speakers left, you know, inside out, left and right.
- 33:33And they can do them.
- 33:34I just, and I haven't done 50, but when I was doing installs at an integrator, I was
- 33:40sent off to program a system that was done.
- 33:43And I was the only one there at that job site.
- 33:46And it was like three hours away from our office.
- 33:50And there were 12 speakers and they were like that.
- 33:54And so I did the math and I read.
- 33:56Did you do a series parallel?
- 33:58I did.
- 33:59Yeah.
- 34:00I'm not coming.
- 34:01I'm not driving back here.
- 34:02I'm going to fix this right now.
- 34:03How long did that take you to?
- 34:05Did you?
- 34:06I didn't know how to figure out what was happening.
- 34:08The math sounds weird.
- 34:10Yeah.
- 34:11Why are you sounding weird?
- 34:12I started getting weird things like what the hell is happening right now?
- 34:14I'm up there.
- 34:15You immediately get the overprotection.
- 34:16It's like I'm not even turning it.
- 34:17Yeah.
- 34:18What is happening?
- 34:19Yeah.
- 34:20By the way, the number of times I've gone into a room and found like, hey, there's a 70
- 34:23volt or a four home A-dome amp, whatever.
- 34:26And the opposite type of speed.
- 34:28Look.
- 34:29And these have been in here for you.
- 34:30Like no wonder it sounds.
- 34:31What has happening here?
- 34:33So it's not difficult people.
- 34:35We've replaced this amp four times.
- 34:37I wonder if there's something to do with it.
- 34:39Sometimes we just keep blowing through amps.
- 34:41Well, I've told you guys a number of times I go into a room and there's like an old crown
- 34:44or AKG or whatever, but there's like a 600 watt amplifier and there's more ceiling
- 34:48speakers.
- 34:49And I think it's because that's my 100 dB room.
- 34:53No.
- 34:54That's I think it's a 70.
- 34:56You don't have a more grade rack of crown macro tech amps and everyone in your classrooms
- 35:02burn on the way.
- 35:03Those things were bullet proof.
- 35:04You're doing it right.
- 35:05Well, and I think it's because this company kept blowing speakers and amps and they were
- 35:08just like, well, just buy a bigger one so it doesn't do that anymore.
- 35:11I'm just like, you're eventually going to try that one too.
- 35:13It doesn't have that works.
- 35:14No, those macro techs.
- 35:15What I show my team are putting in this time.
- 35:18Anything that they're looking at.
- 35:19So, yeah.
- 35:20Those macro techs were amazing.
- 35:21Yeah.
- 35:22I may have wired one of those things up completely backwards like phasing one time and
- 35:26watched it.
- 35:27We're going to run this at 100.
- 35:28No, I'm a hero style.
- 35:29I hate how it works.
- 35:30Did these plus minuses matter?
- 35:32You're doing live rock and roll tying into like a demo.
- 35:35It's going to be doing all the same.
- 35:37It'd be fine.
- 35:38A panel and you just have like completely abused one of the just learning stuff like, I wonder
- 35:42what this will do.
- 35:43Oh, man, I am just amazed with what those macro techs used to do.
- 35:47Buy them by the pound.
- 35:48Imagine the amount of stories we have just on speakers.
- 35:52Yes.
- 35:53Oh, man.
- 35:54Well, Mark, did we answer any questions for you?
- 35:55No.
- 35:56No.
- 35:57Mark's not changing his stance.
- 35:58He believes in a new school.
- 35:59You have not proved it.
- 36:01Now, what is there to prove?
- 36:04You don't prove it.
- 36:05I think we've proved the fact that good enough.
- 36:07We'll take us to the future.
- 36:08There we go.
- 36:09Mark hands voice lift.
- 36:10Mark hates even coverage.
- 36:11Mark doesn't care if you can't hear the instructor.
- 36:14Nord is the instructor.
- 36:15So let's start there.
- 36:17If Mark can't hear it, nobody should be able to hear it.
- 36:20Well, Mark can't actually hear any hearing.
- 36:22I know.
- 36:23I've found for way too many years.
- 36:24Yeah.
- 36:25It's like Mark and I go to these shows and our headphones.
- 36:28Like, oh, my God.
- 36:29Whenever we're here, Chris, like, turn your fucking headphones down.
- 36:32Jesus.
- 36:33Oh, yeah.
- 36:34But I'm Mark.
- 36:35You're close.
- 36:36You're somehow your closed can headphones that come back through your damn microphone.
- 36:38Yeah.
- 36:39I get feedback in my office just because my cans are too loud.
- 36:41How do you and your wife talk at night?
- 36:44What?
- 36:45They just text.
- 36:46They just text.
- 36:47They have individual little megabytes.
- 36:48No, we have kids.
- 36:49We don't have kids.
- 36:50They don't talk.
- 36:51They don't talk.
- 36:52Crazy.
- 36:53Yeah.
- 36:54Usually it's a good night and it's an head nod.
- 36:56Yeah.
- 36:57So anyway, yeah.
- 36:58I know.
- 36:59I think they got their megafallion.
- 37:00They got their ass off.
- 37:01Isn't that how all your classrooms are?
- 37:02That's how Jamie's room sound.
- 37:04Bad.
- 37:05Hey, the ease says it's fine because it's green.
- 37:09The back of the room.
- 37:10I ran the ease calculations on it.
- 37:12The green bleeding into blue.
- 37:13That's not how that works.
- 37:16How it looks.
- 37:17Green means, like, the light is green.
- 37:21The trap is clean.
- 37:22Green just means that you have one constant.
- 37:25It's green, Justin.
- 37:28It's fine.
- 37:29It's plus or minus three.
- 37:31All right.
- 37:32Well, we're way over on our topic here.
- 37:34Any last thoughts?
- 37:35I'm just going to hit this button.
- 37:36We're going to roll out.
- 37:37Hit the button.
- 37:38Cover the space.
- 37:39Power accordingly.
- 37:40Do something fun.
- 37:41Or does healing two by two.
- 37:42We're done.
- 37:43Get it good enough.
- 37:44Thanks for putting up with yet another episode of A.V.
- 37:51Super Friends on topic.
- 37:53You can contact us with questions, topic ideas, or general complaints at A.V. SuperFriends.com.
- 37:57Nice work, everyone.
- 38:04Short broadcast.
- 38:05Really good.
- 38:06Everyone on the floor as well.
- 38:07Really a lot of hustle I liked it.
- 38:10The opinions expressed by the A.V. SuperFriends are solely those of the individuals and do not represent
- 38:17their respective institutions, organizations, companies, or clients.
- 38:20[BLANK_AUDIO]