Latest / The Showing with Katherine and Darin Persinger / Why Homes Aren’t Selling (Even After Big Price Cuts)
Transcript
- 0:00We sold a townhome in December of 2021, so it was almost five years ago.
- 0:08It was in Bothell, and that was when the market was really hot.
- 0:13Interest rates were, like, 3% or 3 point something.
- 0:17We listed it at, I think, 700, and then we got, of course, a few offers, and it sold for 735.
- 0:26Listed at seven.
- 0:27Seven.
- 0:28Yep.
- 0:28Multiple offers.
- 0:30Accepted offer at 735.
- 0:31Yes.
- 0:32Closing costs, uh, b- before buyer agent commissions.
- 0:38Yeah, seller didn't contribute- Yeah.
- 0:41Okay towards closing costs.
- 0:42Um, I think the inspection was just waived.
- 0:45Mm-hmm.
- 0:46Um, anyway.
- 0:47Okay, five years ago.
- 0:47Do you remember that? Yeah, I'm...
- 0:50We...
- 0:51Was that the only one we sold in there? No.
- 0:54Okay.
- 0:55Um, so we- So I say we, we helped a lot of people buy and sell in that community.
- 1:00We've helped three buyers in there, and then we've sold all three of them- Mm since then.
- 1:05This was, like, in, over the last 15 years.
- 1:07Okay.
- 1:08So they've been kind of spread out.
- 1:09Okay, so there was that sale December of 2021.
- 1:12Yes.
- 1:13Now, today, it is October 2026, so it's almost five years later.
- 1:18All right, so 735.
- 1:20Okay.
- 1:21So about, um, two weeks ago- Mm-hmm a listing in there, same exact floor plan, not the same exact unit, but same floor plan, was listed for 600.
- 1:35Okay.
- 1:36And that made me do a double-take.
- 1:38Yeah.
- 1:39Cause I was like, I knew the market's not as hot, obviously- Right but I wasn't thinking that prices had come down that much.
- 1:46Mm-hmm.
- 1:47'Cause if you do some quick math, that is, um, close to 20% lower than what our sale was.
- 1:55Mm-hmm.
- 1:55735 to 600.
- 1:57Um, so I was like, "Wow, that's crazy."
- 2:00And then couple weeks go by.
- 2:03That's just the list price.
- 2:05Yep.
- 2:05So I was thinking, "Okay, it will sell right away.
- 2:07That one's priced to sell."
- 2:09Who knows, maybe even multiple offers.
- 2:11But instead, what happened is a couple weeks went by, and so this was about two days ago, I saw that that townhome is still for sale.
- 2:21Not only is it still for sale, they've dropped the price, and it's now 550.
- 2:28A 50K price drop, but you, did you say two, only two weeks it was on the market? Um, probably about a month now.
- 2:35Okay.
- 2:35But closer to a month, but they started at 600, dropped to 575, and now they're at 550.
- 2:41All right.
- 2:41So not saying that this agent necessarily did this, but this is kind of our thought process when we have listings that maybe we got the price wrong.
- 2:55The market tells us about the price, and usually we don't do anything in the first month if there are showings If there's showings but no offers after a month, then we go, "We might need to look at the price."
- 3:11Well, and it depends on the market.
- 3:12It depends on what the average days on market is.
- 3:16'Cause five years ago, if this would've happened- If it's- average days on market- Five was, like, 10.
- 3:20Yeah.
- 3:21Not even 10.
- 3:21It was probably five or six, and that was only 'cause we had review dates.
- 3:24Right.
- 3:25Otherwise, it would've been one to two or maybe three average days on market.
- 3:29So if we kind of miss the mark on the price, but we're getting showings but no offers, we know, like, okay, we might need to look at our price a little bit.
- 3:38Normally, we, we wouldn't look at a price change in the first 30 days unless there's, like, no activity, no showings.
- 3:51That tells us that the market's completely rejecting the property.
- 3:55Yeah, so they must have not had many showings.
- 3:57Yes.
- 3:58'Cause they felt like they needed to drop it, um, after about two, I think it was about two weeks, they dropped to 575, and then they dropped it again maybe a week later, which is, like, right now, couple days ago, to 550.
- 4:13Um, I will also say this unit is vacant, so I think the seller is just like- Motivated I am ready.
- 4:19Let's just do what we have to do to sell it.
- 4:21Um, fun fact about this one, this is a listing that we sold, this exact same unit, we actually did sell it about closer to a decade ago.
- 4:31Okay.
- 4:32And we sold it for, um, so we represented the seller, and we sold it for I think 420.
- 4:38Mm-hmm.
- 4:39Which we thought was a huge success back then, and so now I think about nine, eight or nine years later, that seller is asking 550.
- 4:48So that seller didn't do bad.
- 4:49Bad, and it's not, they have room.
- 4:52Yeah.
- 4:53Yeah.
- 4:53And so that, that also, uh, might be, we can assume it's making it easier for that seller to just go, "Let's just do what we have to do.
- 5:01Drop the price.
- 5:02What's it gonna take for me to sell it?" By the way, it looks great.
- 5:05It's vacant.
- 5:06It's staged.
- 5:07It looks clean.
- 5:08I haven't been in it, but I did get nosy yesterday and I called the agent because- He's the agent.
- 5:15He was the buyer's agent, um, eight, nine years ago- Mm-hmm who sold our listing, and now he is representing his client with the sale of that unit.
- 5:28So I called him just to say, "What am I missing? I, I'm just...
- 5:32The, the price caught my eye.
- 5:34Is it...
- 5:35I mean, I wish you the best of luck.
- 5:36I hope it sells, but, like, how's it, how's it going? What's your experience been like?" And, um, he said, "Yeah, I just think, um, you know, I've sold a few in the area recently," and he said, "I think you just have to be priced aggressively right now."
- 5:51He said, "We've got kind of a bad combination of factors.
- 5:54Obviously, interest rates, everyone knows that.
- 5:56They're not helping.
- 5:59Uh, they're not doing sellers any favors right now."
- 6:02And he said, "There's not a ton of hiring going on.
- 6:05There's not a lot of overseas buyers, um, buying our listings right now in, in that Seattle area."
- 6:13So, um, he's like, "We're just...
- 6:15The seller's just like- Let's just, let's just get rid of it.
- Let's just...
- Tell me what do we have to do in order to sell it.'"
- So that sounds like a realistic seller and a listing agent who's, um, giving good advice.
- Yeah, you wanna be, if you're a seller, you wanna be Realistic.
- You have to be realistic.
- There's two markets going on.
- I see a lot of these charts on Facebook of, like, this is the best buyer's market ever in the last 40 years because of the number of sellers versus the number of buyers, which by the way is...
- I feel like when the stats don't say what you want them to say, you make up a new stat.
- So, like, that more sellers versus more buyers, I'm not sure how they come up with that.
- I guess the number of listings on the market, but I don't know how you come up with- I guess just how many buyers are pre-approved.
- I mean, those stats are somewhat available, like pr- um, mortgage applications.
- Right.
- But I would, living in the real world, there's a lot of buyers who are looking.
- Like, is it pre-approved or pre-qualified or shopping? Because I s- there's a lot of buyers that we work with that are mo- like, they're motivated, they wanna do something, but that mean, that doesn't mean they've sat down with a lender yet, so we go, "You have to go sit down with a lender."
- But I think if you asked them, "Are you shopping? Are you a buyer?" They would go, "Yeah."
- So that stat doesn't make any sense to me.
- The stats are, they used to be months of inventory and absorption rate.
- You know? So, like, I think there's just, how do we make the market look worse than what it really is? We'll say there's more sellers than there are buyers.
- I don't know how you track that.
- Back to the sellers, I don't know how you actually identify who is a real seller.
- So you're talking about realistic sellers.
- Just 'cause someone puts their home on the market does not mean that they're a realistic, motivated seller.
- They're like, "Yeah, if I can get this price, if I can get the price that was, that my neighbor got or Zillow had it five years ago, then I'll sell it."
- Yeah, and it's kinda wild to think and to hear, like, a statement like that, that I guess where you're, um, what you're saying is home values were higher five years ago And I guess that's what I'm saying too, at least in this Bothell town home market.
- Um, so I don't think it's completely across the board.
- But yeah, I think there's, there's always unrealistic sellers.
- I think there's It feels like there's even more now 'cause inventory is so high and sellers need to get top dollar.
- That's how they feel anyway, because if they're gonna enter the market as a buyer, they have to be armed with, um, as much as possible from their home sale.
- So they can't-- They feel, and they, I don't think they're wrong, but they, they, um, they can't afford to leave money on the table with their home sale.
- Yeah.
- And, um...
- Or maybe if they can find a seller on the next one that's also motivated.
- Mm-hmm.
- I think I, I just wonder how many sellers are basing their price upon actives versus solds So what, what does the market look like versus what it's doing? So like this is a little inside baseball, um, about the industry, and maybe you have even forgotten about this on how bad-- when the market gets bad, what agents are like When agents aren't busy, when real estate agents are not busy, they want to feel busy, so they will take over priced listings.
- They don't wanna, they don't wanna have the tough conversation with the seller right now of like, "Well, I know you want 700,000.
- Um, you want it and you think you need it."
- Because the homes that are currently listed are all 700,000.
- But the home are-- that we have to look at is the one that sold last month for 600.
- That's the actual market.
- Not many agents when they are Not selling a lot of homes are willing to have that difficult conversation 'cause they're afraid they're gonna lose the listing, and they would rather have an overpriced listing that's not selling than nothing at all.
- Or even deeper inside baseball, some agents will just be like, "Yeah, I'll take the overpriced listing because then I can market that against other listings that are easier to sell.
- Oh, you think this home is a good deal, this four-bedroom home for 700,000? Come take a look at this five-bedroom home for 650."
- And it just becomes easier to sell the homes that are priced in the market.
- So there's homes that are on the market, and then there's homes that are in the market.
- Yeah.
- Well, and we've all heard, not in every market, but definitely in the Seattle area, inventory is way up.
- Way up.
- I think it's actually down in the North Idaho area.
- The market's still not easy, but I'd have to, I'd have to, um, look at my stats again.
- But back to the Seattle, Snohomish County area, Seattle, uh, King and Snohomish County, inventory is way up.
- Mm-hmm.
- But I think you, um, you have to kind of sift through that inventory to find the serious, like actual listings, because I think a lot of them, maybe half, maybe 20%, somewhere in there, maybe a third of them, are just overpriced and they're just unrealistic because they think or they know, they're not even wrong in some cases, they need more than what's realistic in order to pull off what they're trying to do.
- Well, there, there's a portion of the market, right, that does need it, that may be bought in the last four or five years when prices were at their peak and at an interest rate that was not below 4%, let's say even So if they're looking to do a turnaround quickly, they, they do kind of need it.
- If they're gonna do what they're trying to do.
- Or if they just wanna get out from under it.
- Mm-hmm.
- If something's changed.
- If, if they have some reason that- Yeah life has changed, they need to sell, then that is a tough spot, and it's a spot we haven't seen a lot of sellers in over the past- Yeah um, 12 years.
- How many, how many times did we see people buy, like, new construction and sell within even less than two years? 'Cause you and I, you and I would have these conversations about, like, they're gonna have cap gains issues.
- Yeah.
- They're selling with under a two-year window, but they're like- Mm-hmm "Well, we saw the appreciation, the last one.
- Uh, af- as they finished the, the community, we saw it, that floor plan sold for, so we're gonna pay off our student loan debt and just go rent for a while."
- Okay, hey, great.
- But did anyone talk to you about cap gains? Like, your agent should've tal- talked to you about that.
- So, like, people were moving two, three, four years, cashing out.
- Mm-hmm.
- It was just fun, and it was easy, and if you wanna change, you can make a change.
- Ba- back in the day- Yeah when interest rates were so low, values were increasing.
- So fast.
- Yeah.
- So it's a, it's a different vibe now that prices have been, we'll say, flat over the past- Mm-hmm four years in some cases.
- And I think that example that, that I described a minute ago, that's extremely current.
- Last I checked was, I think, this morning, and that listing is still active.
- I think it's a great deal if anyone is looking for a Bothell townhome.
- But, um, I think that's an extreme example.
- I think that's an example of our sellers sold at a specific time.
- Of course, they had really great marketing, too, great exposure.
- But, um, they had kind of the ideal situation for their sale, and it's been five years, and these sellers are kind of-- they n- they have almost a opposite situation.
- They have less than ideal, uh, circumstances and a lot more competition.
- So, um, I don't think prices are down 20 to 25%- 20 to 25% everywhere.
- But, um, like we talk about a lot, there are markets inside of markets, and real estate is local.
- Like, we could probably find other examples of listings that sold that exact same month that are worth the same.
- Maybe they've, it's held its value since then, or maybe it's down 5%.
- Yeah.
- Touch on that as we're wrapping up, just really quickly, the market inside of markets, because we're, we're talking about King and Snohomish County.
- And Bothell, but what, what do you mean by markets inside of markets? Sometimes just for whatever reason, there will be a neighborhood or a price range or a city that has, or just like any kind of somewhat specific criteria that has more inventory than usual, and it's just, a lot of times it's just pure coincidence that, um, usually there's like three or four listings in a certain, um, part of town in a certain price range, s- certain number of bedrooms.
- Maybe there's like three or four usually at a time.
- But for whatever reason, one week, seven sellers that have a house exactly like that in that criteria all list at the same time, and all of a sudden the buyers who are looking in that price range have a lot more options.
- And you can feel it.
- I think, I think, um- But th- this neighborhood doesn't have multiple listings in it, does it? It- This community? It does.
- It does.
- I didn't say that, yeah.
- But that's- Okay.
- So that- that's part of their problem.
- Okay.
- So this one is trying to beat out the others.
- Yes.
- They're trying to say, "Hey, pick us next."
- Pick us first.
- We wanna be the next to go.
- Right.
- Which- We realize there's four others on the market, but we're the best price which is what you have to do as a seller in this market, is you can't necessarily wait to be the one after th- or the one after and expect, like, there might only be one buyer for that community over the next three months Right? A- and, and that means only one of those five units that for s- that's for sale right now will sell.
- Right.
- But if you want to force your unit, you wanna force a sale, you have to be priced even more aggressively.
- Mm-hmm.
- Like, as a seller, you have to be thinking about, "Okay, who's in the market? Who could potentially buy my unit right now?" And sometimes there's just no one out there.
- But to get that either investment, like investor-minded buyer, or a buyer who's maybe more like nine to 12 months out from buying, you can more or less force them to become a motivated buyer- Yeah by dropping your price that much more.
- I, I think that's a great point of, like, the person who's like, "We're gonna wait till spring.
- We're gonna do-- we're gonna wait for this and get our ducks in a row and do this."
- But if you price at a certain point and make it an obvious choice, then you can speed up their process.
- Or you can pull someone from another market.
- So even though you're a market inside of a market, maybe someone's looking at single-family homes in the area, and townhomes do not register for them.
- But all of a sudden, you become a price that is so ridiculous for them, they would be silly to not consider it, and then they're gonna wanna come take a look at it, and you pulled them out of another market.
- So you can either pull them from a timeline or from another market into your market.
- And the- these are the things you're gonna have to look at in this market right now, where it's a bit more challenging than just putting up a sign and then waiting for the offers to come in.
- You just have to do something as a seller to get on your buyer or your, um, eventual buyer's radar, and price is probably the easiest way to do it.
- I-- you know, the Brewers are heading to the World Series.
- The Brewers play a certain type of baseball where they manufacture runs.
- They're stealing bases.
- They're bunting.
- They're making sacrifice flies.
- They're moving people around to manufacture runs.
- Our style of real estate is we play Brewer ball.
- We manufacture interest for our seller clients.
- If you wanna be on the market, we can't just put it up there with a nice twilight photo and call it a day.
- We have to do things that manufacture interest, pull from those other markets, pull from future, pull from different timelines, uh, so that people will be interested in your property.
- Well, I think the, what one thing that feels a little bit different about the market right now as opposed to back when it was really hot and there were, um, you know, buyers outnumbered sellers, inventory was low.
- Um, back then our thing was like, Hey, we're going to help make sure that your house looks its absolute best.
- We're going to stage it for you.
- We're gonna pay for that for you.
- We're going to get the best photos available, the best video available.
- You're gonna get the most exposure online.
- You're gonna get 10,000 plus views."
- And we did that, um, so that we could get as m- as much as possible, which that hasn't changed.
- But it was, it was like, okay, one offer, like, "Hey, seller, one offer isn't good enough.
- Two offers isn't good enough.
- You are gonna get top dollar."
- Mm-hmm.
- And that was fun and it was exciting.
- Now it's like, "Hey, we're gonna do all that stuff because we have to."
- Mm-hmm.
- "Because we have to, and then if all that stuff doesn't work as well as it still isn't working, we really have to talk about price."
- Well, I, I guess I still think about it as manufacturing the most amount of interest, 'cause one offer isn't enough.
- We want three, four, five, six offers.
- Right now, you s- you need, you only need one offer though.
- Yeah.
- Three, four, five, six probably isn't realistic.
- Yeah.
- You only need one in order to sell.
- You can't sell it to three, four, five, six people.
- So now we're trying to manufacture still the most amount of interest, and sometimes that means just one.
- So if the market doesn't exist, then we have to pull from the future.
- We have to pull from a different market.
- We have to start pulling investors in of like, "Hey, I know you're sitting on the sidelines right now, investor.
- This one shouldn't be the one that you're letting go, though.
- Time to get back into the game for this one specific property."
- Yeah.
- Don't, don't snooze on this one.
- Yeah.
- So it's still about how much interest can we manufa- manufacture.
- We might not get as many offers as we once did, but you only need one.
- That's right.
- closing notes.
- Um, I guess I would just like to say that I'm always watching not just Snohomish County, but Kootenai County and a little bit of King County as well, and I'm-- I, uh, I always notice the deals like this.
- I, um, I've sold enough condos and townhomes specifically and worked with enough buyers who are looking for something specific that I know how different it feels when there's three, four options available all the time that would match their criteria compared to when there's one and sometimes zero.
- Mm-hmm.
- And so anytime I see a unit like this one that we've been talking about that's one of five in there, and this is the only one we're talking about because, well, one, we've been in it.
- We've sold it twice to the buyer and then eventually sold it, so we're familiar with it.
- Um, but it's the best deal in there.
- Um, that's why we're talking about it.
- But I guess I would just, I would just say, um, you know, reach out to us if you are looking for something like this, if you're looking for kind of a unique opportunity.
- I'm always aware of the motivated- Mm-hmm sellers that are out there.
- And then also if you're a seller or going to be a seller, let's talk about ways we can, um, help your home stand out against the competition.
- Yeah.
- So my closing thought is on the sellers.
- Maybe a little bit, let me touch on buyers a little bit.
- I think we hear a lot about sellers right now, like, "Well, they're not motivated.
- That's why they're not bringing their price down."
- And granted, I know that affordability is a reality, but I wonder about the motivation of buyers of not changing criteria, of, "I only want the single-family home."
- Well, here's a great deal on a townhome to get you into a home that's yours to get you started.
- And at least there's no one above you, no one below you.
- Yeah.
- So are you going to reject that? Then are you motivated? So like I think that's what's going on with the market of why we have such a stalemate, is we hear the sellers aren't that motivated.
- I, I think there's a lot of buyers that aren't that motivated, 'cause there are a lot of homes still selling, and I think those are motivated buyers that are like, "Well, I'll, I'll sacrifice this and I'll give up on this, and I'm focused on these big things."
- So there's still, there are motivated buyers out there.
- I think if you're looking to buy, you have to really consider, are you motivated or are you holding out? 'Cause bec- I, I get it, that affordab- it's, it's such a huge payment.
- You wanna check all the boxes.
- So I totally get that.
- I just don't know.
- If you can do it, great.
- I just don't know if you can.
- We've never been able to do that.
- No.
- We've, we've always had to be realistic.
- But, um, yeah, o- on that note, I would say that buyers tend to get tunnel vision.
- "I'm looking for a single-family home in a certain neighborhood, in a certain price range.
- It has to have a yard that's a certain size, has to be fenced."
- But I think that listings like this one, this one that we're talking about- Mm-hmm which is probably the same or similar square footage to a lot of single-family homes, just, yeah, it doesn't have a fenced yard, and yes, it's attached to its neighbors.
- It is a town home.
- But I think what sometimes changes a buyer's mind is if they have a good agent who's bringing them options, who's- Mm-hmm aware of deals like this, opportunities- Yeah I'll call it.
- Um, 'cause I've, I've presented what I like to call them wacky ideas to my buyers- Mm-hmm dozens of times over the years, and sometimes they hate them and they say, "Absolutely not.
- Don't, don't ever bring that up to me again."
- Mm-hmm.
- And sometimes they'll say, "You know what? I'm gonna think about that."
- Yeah.
- And then, like continuing with this example, sometimes it's, okay, in order to be in Bothell, in Northshore Schools- Right this square footage, a place that's this new, in this kind of condition, um, I'm either gonna pay, um, 1.1
- million- 1.1
- for a house with a yard like- Mm-hmm I am imagining, or I'm gonna pay 550 for a- Yeah town home, so.
- Trade-offs.
- So yeah, trade-offs, and, and I, I think, I guess the moral of that story is just have a really good conversation with your, or work with an agent that you trust.
- DM me.
- All right, and now for the sellers, my closing thoughts for sellers.
- There's two markets going on.
- There's the in-market or the on-market, like you put your home on the market.
- Great.
- That means nothing.
- Technically, every home is for sale if you go and knock on a door and make a good enough offer.
- Every home is on the market.
- Ours is.
- If, if you give us a great offer, you can have this home.
- If, if you really wanna sell though, you have to be in the market, and that is knowing what is selling, what are the terms that are, that are making it sell.
- So you have to ask yourself, and you have to be having that conversation with your agent, "Am I actually in the market or I'm only on the market?" The tale of two markets.
- The other thing that I look at on motivation of being able to sell is if you're looking to get on or in the market or maybe you're already on it, uh, we talked about this this morning, it's like a, you're chasing a ball down the hill, and if, if you keep running after it trying to bend over to grab it, you're always gonna q- just slightly miss it.
- Like, I don't know if you remember this saying, uh, "You don't do the dog any favors by cutting its tail off an inch at a time."
- We would talk about that with price reductions like 15 years ago.
- You, you have to do a big enough price reduction where it gets it back into the market.
- You can't chase the market if it's going down, if prices are going down, which they're not in all markets.
- You have to know your market.
- But if it is, you can't chase that ball down the hill expecting to get it.
- You have to sprint past it and get in front of it and let it meet you.
- So are you trying to chase that market down or are you willing to get out in front of it? Right.
- And you can't do the thing where you, uh, cut the dog's tail off a little bit at a time by, like, dropping your price.
- Like, let's say you're $50,000 overpriced, and you drop it by 5,000 every week just to manipulate the, um, websites and show up as price reduced.
- Certainly, that helps you get a little extra exposure, but I, uh, I don't think you should be insulting the buyer's intelligence like that because buyers know.
- They're searching.
- They know if there's a- Doesn't register on, on them, they'll know.
- If it's not significant, they notice.
- I think buyers are-- I think we gotta give buyers a lot of credit because they're looking, um, and most are o- obsessively looking.
- They know the inventory.
- They know, they know your house, you know, if it could potentially sorta kinda work for them.
- Um, they know it.
- They've seen the pictures, and they know a few others as well.
- And so, if you just drop the price a little bit and you're still 10% overpriced, they're not impressed.
- Yeah.
- So, uh, DM Kat for that property in Bothell if you are looking for a Bothell townhome, and if it's still available by the time this show airs, then...
- It's not our listing, but, um, it's a deal.
- I put it out on my stuff this week as a deal alert because I think it is.
- And so, yeah, try to catch me while it's still for sale.
- And if not...
- We'll find another one eventually for you.
- There are others just not priced as well in that community.