Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Hard-To-Get Floorplans, Voice Control Over Physical Buttons, Online Choice Overload
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning, Monday morning. The first Monday in November. I've got Cirillo on that side.
- 0:09We're hanging out, talking about hard-to-get floor plans, voice control over physical buttons, and online choice overload. Here I go. The people really wanna know who I is and who I be. Without the fake with me.
- 0:18There's something sublime. I just need you to know, Cirillo, there's something sublime about nailing the drop on a Monday, right? Oh, dude. [laughs] It's all about the drop. I, I was like, "Here he goes."
- 0:30I could feel it. You were halfway through. I'm like, "He's gonna hit it." [laughs] You never know. Like, sometimes you get into it and you're like, "Whoa, where did my words go?"
- 0:38And sometimes you're like, "Okay, I need a few more words." And then sometimes you get a Monday morning and you just drop it right on the, right on- I love it... the button, right? 'Cause we don't script- I love it...
- 0:49these things. We're just, like, ad-libbing, you know? Ad-libbing. November already? Wait, November already? How did that happen? Dude, I don't know- [laughs]... about where you are.
- 0:57Well, you're in Texas, it's, like, always warm there. But it was like- Yeah... you know, I went out for a run, it was 62 degrees this morning. What is that? That's the best. It's amazing. That's the best- Oh...
- 1:07is what it is. Well, you know what it's the best for? It's great for car sales. Like, November, sometimes you get into this vibe and everybody's like, "Oh, buckling down for the winter.
- 1:18We'll wait for the Christmas sales." But, like, people are gonna be out and about on lots this, this fall. There's November. Oh, yeah. I'm ready for it. Yeah, it's gonna be amazing. Yep. It's amazing.
- 1:28I mean, and the test drives and the clean cars. That's what I always think about, because around this time of year in Canada- Oh, it got nasty... the lot crew is already like, "We're gonna have to- Oh...
- 1:38shovel off the cars every day." [laughs] Oh, I can't imagine. Oh, no, no, no. No, no, no. Yeah. Hey, we got a couple of things going on this week. We got an ASOTU Edge Quickshot webinar on Wednesday at 2:00 PM.
- 1:50Uh, we are chatting with our, uh, friends at Stream Companies about auditing your 2024 advertising performance. So a little look back for a look forward. It'll be a two-part series, so don't miss it.
- 2:01You can go to asotu.com, scroll down, and, uh, register for that guy. Uh, also, in a week and a half from today, we are releasing episode four of season one, finally, long-awaited, of More Than Cars.
- 2:16And we've got a few big, big announcements keyed up for that. You're not gonna wanna miss it. Go to our LinkedIn profile. You can, uh, find the event there. November 13th, 1:00 PM. Make sure you're there. Don't miss it.
- 2:29Be on the live stream. We'll be in the chat. It's just a ton of fun chatting with us, being in the vibe of the room, and, and, uh, jeering and jawing over, over the episode details. So there we go. That's all the stuff.
- 2:42We should get into it. Cirillo, what do you think? Let's go.
- 2:45Hey, new and smaller, smaller auto dealers are facing mounting difficulties, specifically this year, in securing essential floor plan loans, uh, a crucial step, obviously, in dealership ownership.
- 2:56Uh, rising interest rates, cautious lending practices, uh, and lenders who are re- increasingly reluctant to finance smaller deals, uh, are, are making it a little bit tougher on first-time auto dealers.
- 3:09Banks and lenders now often require floor plans to exceed $10 million. And many first-time buyers are confronted with last-minute cash demands.
- 3:18Um, sometimes they just need that extra 200,000 to a million dollars as collateral, um, and not that $10 million stake. Uh,
- 3:28f- friend of, friend of the family's, Josh Let- Lettis, uh, uh, who's, was aiming to buy a Chevy store earlier this year, was denied floor plans, um, because, uh, the deal, uh, was, it was just hard to get.
- 3:41And that collapse cost him about $60,000 just in fees from not being able to get the loans. Another dealer, Chad Chase, faced a similar setback when Stellantis unacceptably, unexpectedly pulled out of financing.
- 3:53Um, potential owners are shifting focus to used or independent dealerships as opposed to new car dealerships, where floor plan financing is often more accessible.
- 4:02Um, here's a, uh, Connor Duncan of Live Oak Bank reports that while they've successfully financed new dealers in the past, 2024's environment has led to stalled deals. So it's not just, uh, s- buying and selling cars.
- 4:15Buying and selling dealerships and getting in on the early ground level is getting a little bit tougher out there. You know, th- this kind of goes back to a thought I had, you know, mid-2020, '21, which was,
- 4:28you know, single points are gonna try and pick up a, a second point.
- 4:32Uh, mid-tier, like two, three, four rooftop groups are gonna try and get a few more of those one to two rooftop groups, and then the big dogs are just gonna come in and sweep everybody else. And this is...
- 4:43I, I, I don't know, maybe I'm off base here. I'd love to hear in the comments, but this is, I'm kind of seeing this.
- 4:48The banks are like, "Why would I try and help the more difficult deal when, say, an AutoNation or a- Yep...
- 4:54Penske or whatever who's self-fi- financed and has more than enough leverage can just come in and scoop up these, these deals without, you know, high risk?" Yeah. I don't know.
- 5:04I, I mean, it's similar to the car buying market where there's a little bit of a bifurcated market where you've got, you know, pretty wide open lending probably in what we would consider as, like, the prime credit or the prime lending, uh, scenario in auto.
- 5:17Yep. Um, and, and then you've got, like, net new lending, lower, uh, lower access to cash or funds, getting a little bit tight.
- 5:25Um, you know, for me, it's like, ah, man, you know, we've got so many great operators out there that are just looking for that first step.
- 5:34You know, we go to the NAMAD conference, and you just see all of these OEMs really leaning into, and, and banks like Chase and, and other banks leaning into how do we fund these early stage, you know, entrepreneurial dealers that are trying to get in.
- 5:49Um, but when you've got such high interest rates and, you know, loan, l- lending's getting a little bit more chippy out there, it starts to be tougher.
- 5:58And look, you got 20 rooftops and some cash flow, that looks real nice for a bank. So we'll see. And, and, and I mean, honestly, my, my-Other thought on this is fantastic.
- 6:09You know, every generation has had its, um, constriction of, you know, ability, and what that does is it actually weeds out all of the, the people that don't know how committed they are yet. Right.
- 6:22And so, you know, when we look at our society and our, you know, capitalist culture and the way that we're set up, I mean, this is how this happens.
- 6:30There will be fewer, more committed people who are willing to do whatever it takes to push a deal forward. Yep. Uh, and that just kinda- Knock down walls... separates it up. So- Yep... hopefully you're one of those. Yep.
- 6:42Speaking of being only one of those. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] It's slimming out there when it comes to the great button versus touchscreen debate.
- 6:53Rivian's chief software officer, Wassym Bensaid, doubled down on voice controls as the future, saying in-car buttons will be, quote, "An anomaly."
- 7:03Uh, at TechCrunch Disrupt 2024, he noted that physical controls are a bug, not a feature. Very interesting. Advocating that voice interaction should replace touch and physical controls.
- 7:14Uh, Rivian is aiming to make every vehicle function accessible by voice with AI advancements potentially solving current issues in voice assistance technology.
- 7:23Uh, on top of this, uh, Bensaid called Apple CarPlay, which isn't available in Rivian's, a lazy option that oversimplifies the UI, which Rivian plans to build out with proprietary integrated software features.
- 7:36They're getting rid of buttons, Apple CarPlay, and they're bringing their own software to the game. Cirillo? And you know what I did while you were reading this, Drew? [laughs] I went and muted my Alexa.
- 7:47[laughs] Because that stupid thing doesn't know when to shut up. Right. Yeah. And half the time I don't even know the right thing to say to it- That's-... so it will understand me... okay.
- 7:59See, now you're getting to the heart of it. Yep. Yes. Like, have you ever... I don't know about you, and, and guys, chime in on the comments.
- 8:08Have you ever been in a group of people who are experiencing the slightest amount of pressure? And by slightest amount of pressure, I mean trying to decide where everyone wants to go for dinner that night.
- 8:19[laughs] The stuttering. It's un- The una- inability to form a sentence, and now all of a sudden you want me to concentrate on driving a car- Right... in traffic and know precisely what command to say to this deal?
- 8:35I don't know. Yeah, recalling all of the unique commands. Like, I've, I've... There are entire YouTube toy- tutorials on just how to use Siri, right?
- 8:45Because if you ask Siri something one way, it will respond with action, and then the other way it'll be like, "I can't even do that." But it, you wanted the same outcome, right?
- 8:54And this is where in a car, I'm telling you what, I, uh, I go back to Mazda a lot, but they've done something that I think and, and I think Mercedes tried this back in the day, but Mazda has this whole, like, what they call command center, right?
- 9:08Yeah. And it's this l- little tactile thing that's right on your hand. It's, you don't have to reach up high. But it's four buttons and a knob.
- 9:16And there's something going back to, like, you remember when, um, you know, when, when T9 texting and, and someone could, like, text, you know, th- behind their back basically with, with a nine key, right? Yeah.
- 9:29There's something to kind of like the tactile memory and our brain, right? Yeah.
- 9:35That, that allows you to more quickly do tasks that don't have to just recall by memory, but, like, connect memory function to tactile function.
- 9:45Um, and I, I, I just can't get over the fact that that linkage, especially when driving, is already active and I just, man- Yeah... I'm concerned about this move, you know? Yeah.
- 9:59You- some, some poor individual out there who will have had to steer aggressively to not get, you know, rear-end somebody 'cause somebody slammed on their brakes, gonna jump the curb,
- 10:10heaven forbid, hit, hit a, a stop sign or a pole or something, and they're gonna go, "Rivian, call 911." And Rivian's gonna go, "Are you asking about the time?" Right. And you're like... [laughs] You know, I just see,
- 10:25I just see it's, it's gonna be a powerful ride. My problem is gonna be it's gonna, like, recognize my kid's voice and they're gonna be like, "Rivian, play Bluey-" Yeah... "soundtrack." And I'm gonna be like, "No!"
- 10:37[laughs] No. And then the airbag, you'll program it so the airbags deploy 'cause you'll do anything to get out of hearing that sound. [laughs] Oh, speaking of doing anything to get out of it. Stop. Segway. Time.
- 10:53[upbeat music] Oh, man. You want me to read this one? Do it. Do it. I feel you, I feel like- Well-... you got opinions on this one. [laughs] Okay.
- 11:00So with endless options and extensive product information, today's online shopping experience can feel less like convenience and more like an exhausting chore. Oof.
- 11:10Research suggests that too much choice is paralyzing, creating a phenomenon some call choice overload. Oh, you're, you're right. I already...
- 11:19So a recent Accenture survey revealed 74% of customers abandoned online shopping carts due to feeling overwhelmed by choices and content.
- 11:28And top abandoned online shopping carts included clothing, 79%, flights at 72%, snacks at 70%. [laughs] People abandoning snacks. They're just out. Can you believe that? Home goods and electronics.
- 11:41Uh, Barry Schwartz, who's a psychologist, uh, of the paradox of choice, explains that while variety can make us happier initially, too many options complicate decision-making. Ooh, come on now. And now this one, right?
- 11:54'Cause we all know this one. We all need to have the filters.
- 11:57Tools like filters and recommendations often backfire by introducing more factors to consider, which can make shopping fatigue worse according to NYU's Raluca Ursa. Look, here's- Uh- L- let me say this. Yeah, please.
- 12:11The whole, like, recommend-After you've already said, "Let's check out" thing- Yeah... bugs the heck out of me.
- 12:19And I know that there's so many studies on, like, increased, you know, revenue and all that type of stuff, but I gotta believe that a large swath of the 70 to 80% that are bouncing from these carts are going, "Give it up already.
- 12:32Like, you already got me with the Instagram ad. I fought through the mobile app experience, and now I'm finally ready to pay you, and you're just begging for more." Like, it, it is. Yeah.
- 12:44It's, it's, it's exhausting out there, I think, in the e-com world because everybody's fighting for this, for this dollar.
- 12:50It's the-- I, I love how you said fight through the mobile experience, 'cause even if you look in terms of a car dealer's website, how the customer- Yeah... has to fight.
- 12:57Like, you land on the site, next thing you get a pop-up. [coughs] Yep. It's like the wind that nobody... I, I mean, just, I know the web company that develops these things says it works.
- 13:06But right immediately upon closing that, you get the chat pop-up, and immediately upon closing that, you get some other thing asking for your location from the top left.
- 13:15And we're not considering, you know, for, for an industry, here's my salty bit.
- 13:19For an industry that talks so much about improving the customer experience, look at how many stop signs you put in the way, uh, to just get to something as simple as shopping activity. And my other thought is this.
- 13:31I mean, years ago, I interviewed a guy named Rico Olinger, um, and he, he and I were talking about, um, you know, conversion rate optimization.
- 13:41And one of the things he brought up is that when you introduce more options into the mix, the less likely people are to feel confident in any one of those decisions. It, it increases abandonment. Yep.
- 13:53And more than one CTA on a page actually will decrease, uh, will decrease conversion rate by, like, 30%- Yep... just in that one thing.
- 14:03So then you go to a s- a vehicle detail page on a car dealer website, and there's 170,000- [laughs] Yep... CTAs still, and we're still debating this in 2024.
- 14:14I just feel like here's the real world example that I think everyone can get behind to demonstrate what we're talking about here. You're driving down the freeway.
- 14:22You see the billboard that says 180 flavors of soft serve, and you're like, "That sounds great." Then you're standing in front of 180 flavors of soft serve, and you're like, um- The panic, the heart.
- 14:35Yeah, actually, I point to this a lot. There's a, there's an old Brain Games. I don't know if you ever watched that, um, uh, show series.
- 14:42But there's an old Brain Games where they, they basically put, like, heart monitors and eye monitors on people, and they gave them the choice of do you wanna go to the ice cream shop with the bunch of flavors or the ice cream shop with the, the, the three flavors?
- 14:59And, like, the people that ended up picking the three flavors had a much more clean and easy experience. Um- Yeah... it is, it's wild. Like, the, the overwhelming option of choice in anything.
- 15:13I mean, you go back, actually, like, think about the old BDC scripts and how you would get someone to move into an appointment. It's all about only giving ever two choices, right? Yeah.
- 15:25Would you like morning or afternoon? 1:00 or 3:00? And that still works today because limiting choices actually provides greater clarity for the user.
- 15:33And so when you think about the number of clicks it takes to get to a VDP, right, limit the, limit the number of nos that you can potentially put in, in front of someone's, uh, face.
- 15:44When it takes-- When it comes to, like, what, what to do next, limit the number of options, right? And, and think about this.
- 15:50When you say CTAs, a lot of people think about, like, the number of buttons that are on the VDP- Right, yep... in the CTA "stack," but, like- Yep...
- 15:59the window sticker button, the share button, the like button, the phone call button, those are all CTAs too. So now you go from, let's just say you have four or five.
- 16:08Now you've added seven, eight, nine, 10, and all of a sudden people are just crowded with decision fatigue, and they're gone.
- 16:15So our abandoned carts are a lot, a little bit different than e-com, but not also d- all too different. You got us on a- I mean, we- We got ourselves on a little bit of a train this morning, Cyrill [laughs]. Yeah.
- 16:27We can go forever on this one. We- We need follow-ups on this one. We could go with follow-ups on this one.
- 16:32But hey, today's a Monday, and you gotta get to it 'cause there's people to love, customers to serve, employees to train and, and exert. Let's get after it. Sell some cars, service some cars, do good.
- 16:46[upbeat music]