Latest / Optometry Scale Up / Rename It or Keep It? How to Brand an Acquired Practice
Transcript
- Thanh Mai: you're gonna go in there and rename it. and destroy the brand equity that you had. they're gonna be like, this place sold out. Tyler: they walk in there and they don't know what to think of you, so it's almost like they walk in like you're the bad guy. Thanh Mai: Tyler, you have multiple locations. And I've got multiple locations. you've acquired other ones. They had like let's just call it like New Jersey Optical. You renamed it Premier Eye Doctors, right? Is it Premier Eye Doctors? Pr sorry, Premier Eye Associates. Tyler: Premier Eye Associates. Yep. Our w our our email's Premier Eye Doctors. Our website's Premier Eye Doctors. So yeah. Yeah, yeah. Thanh Mai: That's where I got that from. Okay. So Premier Eye associates. first of all, I love it. it's it's you're you're branding it. But the the the flip side, of course, the devil's advocate is the doctor's been there for 30 years. It was called New Jersey Family Optometry Forever by Doctor. It was called actually not even that. It was let's say it was called John Smith Optometry. And all the patients know as John Smith optometry for the last 30 years, you're gonna go in there and rename it. Premier Eye Associates and destroy the brand equity that you had. I'm j I'm devil's advocate, you know, I'm just joking. Tyler: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thanh Mai: Because then they're gonna be like, this this place sold out. Like I why would you do that? what are the pros and cons in your opinion? Tyler: Yeah. So the w I was I until about the last couple months, I was really, really set and had my feet in the sand on rebranding and having everything under the Premier Eye umbrella. I think the reason there's a lot of real good synergies for it, right? You have one, if you're in if you're in that geographic area, you should hopefully if you're running a practice the right way, have a good brand equity yourself, good name. You also then only need to operate one website and you only need one set of brochures that are going out. And you know, all the documents are the same and and everyone knows Premier Eye and and they see you have a location over here that has all these good reviews, and now there's one over here. I think there's a lot of simplicity in it all being under the same umbrella. I think now it's more of a case-by-case situation though. Like if you have a practice that is has really good brand equity. Right? if you're looking at one and you're like, wow, that practice is a really high end optical. They're they're really well known. Everyone loves them. And then you're gonna go in and change it to yours, I think it probably creates more complexity than than is necessary because pr patients will for that first year after you take over, they walk in there and they don't know what to think of you, right? Like you came in, you changed the sign, you made the office look different, you you know, and a lot of times you're charging more because the the previous owner didn't raise their prices in 20 years, right? so it's almost like they walk in like you're the bad guy. And you know, there is something to like this practice called Doctor's Eye Care is now still Doctor's Eye Care, but it looks nicer and maybe it's under a new owner, but I don't really know. And my doctor's still there and nothing really changes on the patient end. So if it's a good practice, I'm totally on board now with like having that be a different a different brand under the umbrella of Premier Eye. but I think that's a a good like pros and cons list. And I I think you were so let's get your take on this, because you were different brands and you rebranded all under Insight, correct? So tell me about that. Thanh Mai: Yeah, exactly. So let me let me tell you my journey. So I think I've I've learned a lot and this is where we're learning a lot together, honestly, through this journey. So if you're opening so if you're like well first of all, what's a brand? A brand is like you hear it, you're like Disney. You're like, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I know what that is. You know, Starbucks, okay, yeah. You just know what it is because they've got a brand, right? That's what a brand is. It's it is probably the most viable asset we can own. is a brand. For you and I it's our personal brand. And then for a company it's the company brand. So I think there's really two ways to go. I I see it kind of like two ways right now. So it depends on your strategy. If you were lens crafters, you'd be opening every location cold because lens crafters, I think, I don't think they were buying practices and rename them lens crafters. I I don't think so. I think they were Tyler: I don't think so, but yeah. Thanh Mai: just I think they're just opening brand new And then call them lens crafters every single time because their brand was so strong that they knew that they could open here. Glasses are done in an hour. And someone from a cold start would be like, a cold start practice would grow quickly enough where they're like, okay, well, the brand is so powerful, it's gonna help us, right? Or so if you are Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: lens crafters or Warby Parker, you would definitely call it lens crafters and Warby Parker. Now, let me tell you what Warby Parker is not doing. Warby Parker's not doing what we're doing, which is what a lot of private equity firms are doing and what you and I are doing, which is we're buying existing practices. And so Warby Parker wouldn't buy an optometry office from John Smith optometry and rename it Warby Parker. Tyler: Right. Thanh Mai: Because that'd just be weird. Right? Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: Because if because it's like what it's like not even the same brand. It's like it's not the same ethos. Like it was it was a family optometry office, you know, beforehand. Whereas you and I are buying practices And so for if you're a private equity firm and you're buying practices, let's say I'll give an example. there's one in California called Total Vision that bought 60 practices and then then they got bought by VSP. Or even I think AEG, for instance, Vision, they've got 300 locations. I think all the original names are still there. they'll have Tyler: AEG does keep them intact, yep. Thanh Mai: Exactly. So AEG is like, hey, you know what? We actually like the fact that it was The owner was there and the patients loved it. We don't necessarily say need to blow it up. We're we're willing to kinda leave it be a little bit because they're not opening cold and branding it their thing. They are actually gonna leverage the brand equity that they purchased. Cause that's the goodwill of what they bought, And so Exactly, exactly. It's bad you gotta rename fast. But like but Tyler: If you're buying a good practice, yes. Yeah. Right, right. Thanh Mai: like but stuff because you and I are not opening brand new offices, because we're buying existing offices. This has been my approach. My approach is that I want to have my cake and eat it too though. Because I don't want to have I don't want to reprint twenty I don't want have 50 different brochures that my marketing team has to print off. And so what we what we do right now is we co brand for a little while. So we'll say Tyler: Interesting. Thanh Mai: so we'll say, let's say you and I were the same business. Let's say I just bought you. It would be premier i associates premier i associates powered by insight vision. Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: And we we would run that for a year, maybe two years, depending on how strong your brand is great. We'll run it for two years, And because at the end of the day, once the patient comes in, they see Dr. Tyler Mills, they don't really care after a while, anyways. But at the same time, I want that insight vision to be there. I don't want to necessarily be there from day one and destroy the brand equity from day one if you've got a strong brand. And so, same thing with AG, or I think even my eye doctor, I think they call they're all called my eye doctor, but I'm not sure they read. Tyler: My Eye Doctor comes in, I believe they always rebrand and AEG does not. So they have they have Thanh Mai: so my Tyler: different yeah, it's interesting 'cause they're they're doing similar things but they have a a completely different strategy on it. Thanh Mai: Actually, no, you're right. One of my coworkers worked for my eye doctor. and then he they they would rip off the band-aid. So they Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: would actually go in there, they switch the EMR like right away, and then Tyler: Which has been my model. Thanh Mai: Yeah, I I agree with that by the way. Like don't Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: run like don't run with their don't run revolution there and crystal here for like a year. That's just weird. but Tyler: It's gonna hurt at some point, right? So might as well just get it done. Yeah, yeah. Thanh Mai: Exactly. you have to do it. It's like you have to do it eventually anyways, you might as well do it right away. And Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: so anyways, yeah, so I agree with that. But yeah, they just rip yeah, I think yeah, you're right. My I Doctor rips it off, renames it my doctor, whereas AEG leaves it alone. And so basically my approach is kinda like the the halves of co branding. And then and then and then make and then eventually the the parent brand takes over eventually after the patients have seen insight vision for a while. That's been our approach. Tyler: And what is the w why take a why change it two years down the road? Like what's the just because you wanna be able to have the economies of scale of like all the marketing? Okay. Yeah. Thanh Mai: Yeah, exactly. It's kinda it c it kinda helps to have a centralized marketing team be able to make collateral content for all locations. Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: So let's say ex for example, I think user generated content is a secret sauce now for us for marketing. So like social media. No one Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: in optometry does any social media. Like we get like three hundred thousand hits on our YouTube page a a month and we get patients. Every month. by the way, we don't even need 300,000 views. If I got 30,000 views, that'd be plenty. Guess what? Who's watching a video about keratoconus? Someone with keratoconus. I Tyler: Yeah, that's it's so true. Yeah. Thanh Mai: I don't need to make the tick like the the Instagram and TikTok video that has three million views, like of me dancing. I don't need that actually. I'd rather have three hundred thousand committed views Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: of patients with real problems. And they are flying in to see me, driving in to see me. And basically, but to create that content and have users generate content, it'd be nice if I had like, you know, ten locations, they're all shooting content for me to post. And we'd be posting like, you know, 20 times a day. Because I've got like all these practices shooting content, right? For so so basically, and so I'd have one brand, one set of brochures, you know, contracts all the same way, printed the same way. It scales faster and easier than having my marketing team make like fifty pieces of content for fifty practices. Tyler: Yeah, I I I see that's the whole concept behind pulling the band aid off right up right up the bat. so I I think that's a cool hybrid. I never thought about that, like doing a one or two year powered by. We did think about doing that with our most recent acquisition, keeping the name and just putting powered by. and ultimately we decided to just keep the model going how we did, but that's something to consider. I like it. Thanh Mai: Yeah, and by by the just to be a nuance, we didn't say powered by, we said in partnership with Insight Vision. Tyler: Okay. I like that. Thanh Mai: So we're like partners. Tyler: Yeah, I like that. That's good. Thanh Mai: Yeah. And so, I think the origin owner likes it too, 'cause they feel like they still have some say for a little while. like it's still their brand, you know. And then we transit the goodwill better. So we're kinda like I think what what I think what AEG does though, for instance, or Total Vision even, they would still say Total Vision. But they'd also keep the original website up too, I think. So they have two up. They'd have Total Vision that has got their sixty locations. And Tyler: really? Thanh Mai: and then they'd have the original website s if you click there, it still goes the original doctor's website. Tyler: Interesting. Thanh Mai: So they'd they'd have both. So right now that's what we did too. we partnered with a with the owner in Las Vegas and she has a strong brand, amazing person, Stephanie Woo And so she has such a strong brand. We're like, why would we why do we undo that at all? She's an amazing partner. Tyler: Yeah, definitely. Thanh Mai: She's an amazing partner. And so for that, we just kind of like kept it was called Contact Lens Institute of Nevada. And then with Stephanie Woo and it was all about her. but of course we had to make sure it wasn't all about her. We had to wanna Tyler: Sure. Thanh Mai: make sure it's all about us together. And so we co-branded that happily because we're like, well, why why why destroy her brand? 'Cause she actually had she had a few thousand people following her Instagram page and she had a good Facebook page and a website. So we we we decided to co brand for that reason too. So I think to your point, it's not all or none. At the end of the day, you do want, in my opinion, you do want one strong overarching brand no matter what. So even in even in Las Vegas with Stephanie Woo, it's still Insight Vision Las Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: Vegas. But we still are co branding a bit. So yes. Tyler: I think there's probably room in the middle too where you have even if you had say two brands, right? You have Insight Vision and then you ended up acquiring say you say you acquire a a new hub, so multi-location group in I don't know. Northern California that's has brand equity. They have combined over a thousand Google reviews. Like it's a strong brand. I can also see a world where you have two brands under the same umbrella. So you still have like they have all of the same marketing and branding and you're just changing the logo on stuff. Like that that makes sense to me. I think that's doable, but like I I it I agree, like it's hard to have like it'd be hard to have like five different names of practices and make it all work without it being a a pain. Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: That's right. So let's say let's say it's let's say you've got John Smith optometry, par in partnership with Insight Vision. You can still at least qu add them to the website, one one co seed website. And then maybe you keep the original one on for a little while before you kill it off, Because most practices that I I've seen at least, they get no traction on their website. They get like two hundred visits a month. Like they get it's like nothing. You can find that out by a website called spyfu dot com. Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: That's spy spy f u dot com. And like I l I use it all the time. I'd be like, how many and then it'll be like, okay, there's a hundred people who visit this website. Like no one visits it. So if no one visits it, I just kill the website and just have it funneled to mine, you know, my main one. Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: And so it kinda builds that kinda helps on the website part of it. But but yeah, to c to your point, it kinda depends on the brand equity that's there. Tyler: Yeah, for sure. That's good. Thanh Mai: So going forward, so if you bought a practice that was four hours away from your current practice, say, or three hours away, your next one are you gonna co brand? Are you gonna let's say it's a big practice doing well not big practice let's say it's doing one million a year. What what what's your next move, Tyler, you think you're gonna you're going to do? Tyler: So I I think I'm probably, and this is something we can get into later on, but I I think I'm probably out on the one million sized location four hours away. I think in in unless it's a bolt on to a larger acquisition four hours away. So I'm open to that size practice locally that can fit our existing hub and spoke model. but I think if I'm going out of state, which we're actually considering at the moment, or farther away, like we're we're gonna look for one that's maybe two point five, three million top line above or multi-location. So I can speak. I have there's there's a practice loc relatively locally two hours away in New Jersey, three locations. I don't know any details yet, but it's a bigger practice. Really good Google reviews, like really good reputation. I think that one, I'm if it were to come to fruition, I would probably keep it the way that it is now because it's such a large footprint and in that area, it's almost like We created in South Jersey in our in our area, we are the largest group, we have the geography locked down here from a a name standpoint. There they already have it. So I think from that standpoint, I would probably keep it. I think if I were gonna buy a practice four hours away that you know was doing a million. That one I would maybe consider rebranding because it's just or rebranding to to Premier Eye because it's a it's a standalone, you know, smaller location. But I don't know. It would depend on the on the brand equity of that practice. Like I I think Google Reviews is an easy way to to look at it. it's kind of hard to like figure that out otherwise, but just like the the reputation of the practice online would would matter a lot. Thanh Mai: Mm. So I love that. So the let's say the group practice over there, let's say they're doing two point five, three million, that they've got a reputation, a thousand five star reviews. Would you co brand or just leave it completely? Like no one would even know Premier I Associates is involved. Tyler: I think my answer right now is keep it. Not co brand. Yeah. Thanh Mai: I see. Yeah. Tyler: I may I may co brand that one that one million dollar practice four hours away and then ultimately rebrand it. Like I l I like that standpoint, but I think the the three location, say five million dollar practice, I would probably leave. Yeah. Thanh Mai: Got it. So then your marketing team would just create content and collateral separately for that. And then Tyler: Yeah, I think I would just say, hey, here's all of our all of our marketing materials. We need it now branded for this brand with this logo. and like have all the content exact, but have it be a different practice name. Thanh Mai: Ooh, okay. So you have a different scaling law than I do then. So my scaling law Yeah Tyler: This is fluid. This is new. Thanh Mai: yeah. Yeah yeah. That's okay. By the way, it's all good. Let's say I've got a back office answering the phones for that, you know, four million dollar group over there. And I've got the same people answering the phones for my offices here, right? And so I I want them to be like I won't I wouldn't want them to be like, Hi, Premier I Associates and this number. Hi, John Smith of Thomas Tree. And it'd be it'd Tyler: Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's fair. That's a good point. Thanh Mai: be the same person context switching, like like every other phone call, potentially, let's say. Tyler: Yep. Thanh Mai: now of course you can you can have hey, you U three answer for these three locations, U3 answer for these three locations. You could segment like that. But if you want, and you probably should do that at a certain point, of course. But let's say you're not big enough yet to do that, you want everyone to answer the phone calls for every location. Because some have more call volume than others. Then to me my scaling law would be like, well, I want the back of a scale marketing team to have like, you know, the same. And then I want like the tax IDs to all look the same for billing and things like that. And I'd so the marketing side, the billing side, the call center side, and and Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: and even building this the the the brand. So my goal is to build brand. So my goal would be that everyone knows Premier I Associates in the whole world eventually. Tyler: Sure, sure. Thanh Mai: And so so so we've got and they're more likely to know it if I've got twenty locations all named the same. But if they if they're not named the same, people would have to somehow find out that we're together. And then Tyler: That's fair. Thanh Mai: that that would be not a b as good a way to build a brand in my opinion. So I gave you free consulting, hopefully. I don't know. Tyler: Yeah, yeah. Well, it's funny. I it I we go back I feel like you and I changed our course a lot on different things, right? we I was all about that and then you got on board with that and now I'm like I don't really know if I'm fully on board with that. it's a I think it's all fluid and that's that's important to not have hard rules on everything, right? Because I think everything comes with nuance, and if you are trying to always fit into the same box, it might not it might not work. So yeah, it's a good conversation. And I there's there's obviously no perfect answer because my doctor does it one way, A G does it another way. I think it's yeah, I don't I don't really know. And we're gonna have to have a conversation on the fifth my fifth acquisition so we can decide what what we're gonna do. Cause I'm still not sure. Thanh Mai: That's we' we're we're talking about that's right, who knows? Yeah, there's no right answer. But I just remember this. I went to a dental conference called the Dental Entrepreneurial Organization or something like that. It's called D E L. And I actually like learn a lot from them. Basically there this this group of dentists that they all they talk about is scaling and growing multi-location Tyler: Cool. Thanh Mai: dental offices. And they dentistry is like if you look at what they do, just like They're always ahead, I I feel like they're ahead of optometry. So what they're doing is like a peek at what we should be doing. And so I go I go to their conferences to learn practice management now. And so I just remember this distinctly from one of the lecturers. He's like, okay, the difference between scaling and just adding locations is this. Is you can duplicate the the difference in duplication and scaling is this. Duplication is I get this practice here and it's running well and it's awesome. And then I'm gonna duplicate it and have it over here, they're gonna do the same thing. And then I'm gonna duplicate it and do it here and have it do the same thing. Then I'm gonna duplicate it and have it and have a fifth location. They're all gonna be the exact same thing, duplicate it again. And that's okay, but it's eventually it's it's very inefficient. It's not a scaled approach. The scaled approach is eventually you got these five locations, but they actually are not duplicates of each other because you don't need to have like, you know. A receptionist here, a receptionist here, you don't need to have recep you don't need to have five receptionists for five locations. You need to have just three point five. And so you need to have three point five be, shared amongst all five. And Tyler: Mm-hmm. Thanh Mai: you don't need to have one billing person for every location. You need to have three point five of them. And then same thing with marketing. You don't need to have a social media team for all of them or creating content for all of them. You need just one, you know. And so that that was that was what they got that guy said at the podium and he had five hundred locations. And so yeah, yeah. Tyler: Which is why we're gonna get into this later on in a in an episode, but we're gonna talk about and I think we should coin this term because no one actually says it. The optometry services organization, right? Like we're everyone we're Thanh Mai: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Tyler: just taking the MSO and that and we're putting that for optometry, but there's DSOs, they have their own one. Why don't we? You know? Thanh Mai: Yes. Tyler: so well let's let's let's cue that up for a future episode. Thanh Mai: Let's let's coin that term and then just own it. Tyler: I love it. I love it. Optometry services organization, you heard it here first. I think. so. Thanh Mai: OSO I guess OSO sounds better than MSO, I think. Tyler: I think so too. I think so too. But in that in that scenario Thanh Mai: Yeah, we may maybe good. Yeah. Tyler: what you just talked about, you have you have O OSO level positions, right, that that are gonna oversee or do things for all the locations under the OSO. And then so you don't that's where your economies of scale come in. You don't have five of each one or or four of each one. You have one that oversees it. and you might need more than one, right? But it's all located at that at that services organization level. and that's where you get your economies to scale and and you drive profit. Thanh Mai: Exactly. You need economy of scale. Because I know we're we're totally off the topic of branding now, but but but that's Tyler: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thanh Mai: okay. That's okay. Hopefully people still listening to this. But basically, Tyler: Yeah. Thanh Mai: one practice, I if if I had to pick between five locations doing ten, let's say two men each, five locations doing ten man, or one off one location doing ten. I'm always gonna pick one office doing ten. Tyler: Always. Thanh Mai: It's so much easier to run. It's more profitable because it has economy of scale. And so I learned this from someone else. The the fastest the the quicker the fastest way you can make it, so it's just five locations, but they act as if they're just one location. Which is like, you know, the the same call center, the same billing team, ideally maybe the same Tyler: Mm-hmm. Yep. Yeah. Thanh Mai: brand brand. Who knows? That's debatable. But like then then then the then you've you're closer to that single location, basically. Yeah. Tyler: Yeah. Yeah. And th that's a good that's such a good point. I've there's been a few like million dollar practices that we've looked at that are two locations. And like that's not that doesn't that's not the Thanh Mai: Yeah. Tyler: same thing. You can't expect the same valuation. You can't like it's it's just it's two of everything, right? Versus having it all under one roof. so it's yeah. Thanh Mai: Yeah, exactly. it two practices doing five hundred K. So if they're trying to sell you the million dollar practice for the two locations, I'm like, Ugh. maybe I'll write you a check four hundred grand. Whatever, But if you're one Tyler: Right. Thanh Mai: location doing a million, I might write write your check for seven hundred. So yeah, it's I agree. Tyler: Right. Yeah. Yeah. So on a on a future episode we're gonna dive deep in the optometry services organization, the OSO or whatever we're calling it. And then we're gonna talk more about I think revenue per location when you start to get multi-location is a really good metric. Cause if that's driving down like we you'd you never wanna buy a bunch of small practices. The integration risk and cost of that is just too much. so I think that's there's different metrics that come in when you have multi location that you should track that you shouldn't track when you have one. necessarily. So that that's another good topic to to dive into. Future episodes. Thanh Mai: Future episodes. Alright. All right. Great talking to you, Tyler. Tyler: You too, Thanh