Latest / Politics with Paul / Is a Party-less Future Possible in American Politics? w/ Metin Pekin | Politics with Paul #88
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09We have another great guest today and for such episodes, I always add a disclaimer that I do
- 0:13not take a stance for or against any guests' political views.
- 0:17Episodes are for anybody of any political persuasion.
- 0:20So political parties have been a staple of the American political system only a handful of
- 0:26years after the ratification of the US constitution.
- 0:30They came around at about the third or fourth congress.
- 0:33Yet they have also been a source of consternation for many voters and a big reason
- 0:38why many choose to identify as independents.
- 0:42Even so, a lot of people still identify as Democrats or Republicans or at least lean
- 0:46towards them, and the two parties make up the vast majority of elected seats that have
- 0:51partisan elections.
- 0:54But could issues with the two party system and frustrations bubble up to the point that the
- 1:00future of American politics sees the dissolution of parties?
- 1:04Well, that's what today's guest, Metzen Pecken, is here to discuss.
- 1:08Metzen is the author of the book, Breaking Democracy's Chains, Freeing and Fortifying
- 1:12Democracy Against Hidden Capture, which argues that parties are a bottleneck and calls for,
- 1:17quote, a no party democracy rooted in direct accountability, genuine representation, and the
- 1:23complete removal of party machinery from government.
- 1:25He's also an entrepreneur who founded and grew several companies and has a BA in political
- 1:30economy from the University of Greenwich.
- 1:33So let's talk to Metzen and get more insight into his thinking and discuss whether a party
- 1:38less future in American politics is possible.
- 1:41So please welcome Metzen to the show.
- 1:43Thanks for coming on Metzen.
- 1:44How are you?
- 1:45Thank you.
- 1:46Thank you for the invite and thank you for having me.
- 1:49I'm very well, thank you.
- 1:50Yes, looking forward to this.
- 1:51Fantastic, awesome.
- 1:53Mettin's actually over in The UK, so I believe he is my first international guest I've had on
- 1:59here, so it'll be an interesting perspective.
- 2:01So first up, Mettin, I like to get to the genesis of why my guests are involved in what
- 2:08they do.
- 2:08And before we get to the book, why did you get involved in general in this research and
- 2:13discussion about political parties and whether democracies can function without them?
- 2:17And what makes you so invested in this topic?
- 2:20Okay.
- 2:21So
- 2:23I suppose my interest in this subject began at university where I studied political economy.
- 2:29The course has exposed me to different forms of governance and ideas such as Marxism,
- 2:35exploitation, surplus value, class struggle.
- 2:41So after uni, I've kind of parked that up a bit after you now went into business and I was
- 2:48fortunate enough to grow a successful business and number of businesses.
- 2:53So that combination of education and the business experience kind of allowed me to see
- 3:00issues in real life, not just in theory.
- 3:03So you observe these things and you see these things at work as well.
- 3:08And over time, I suppose I've begun noticing something striking in politics, even though two
- 3:14main parties kind of present themselves as complete opposites.
- 3:19On many key issues, I've I've noticed there were very little difference between them.
- 3:24So that was kind of a saying, hang on a minute.
- 3:27What there's there's something right here.
- 3:29And in recent years, wanting to kind of dig a bit deeper into this problem, the problems with
- 3:35democratic problems, representation problems that we have, I came across the federalist
- 3:40papers written by written by founding fathers.
- 3:44And what struck me was the fact that how strongly the American founding fathers warned
- 3:51against factions and the party politics.
- 3:55And I suppose that was the eureka moment.
- 3:58Right.
- 3:59Okay.
- 4:00So what I'd come to see as being the problem in modern democracies was still a problem two
- 4:06hundred and fifty years ago at birth of American democracy.
- 4:10So that kind of reassured me to say your diagnosis is right here.
- 4:16Political parties are the problem here.
- 4:18And then the real challenge became, I suppose, a practical one.
- 4:22What could replace political parties?
- 4:25And that's what's ultimately led me to write Breaking Democracy's Chains.
- 4:30Interesting.
- 4:30You know, is The Federalist Papers are just such a fascinating set of documents to read,
- 4:36and I think a lot of people could do well with reading them again, maybe perhaps modernizing
- 4:42the language a little bit, because sometimes it could be a little harder to parse through
- 4:45because you're talking about how they use language two fifty years ago, but at the same
- 4:49time, just the amount of prescience, and of course, they were human beings too, they're not
- 4:55infallible, but the amount of prescience that they had about the future and problems of that
- 5:02day that were gonna continue to be problems of our day is just such a fascinating aspect to a
- 5:07lot of these founding fathers.
- 5:09Prophecy.
- 5:10Yeah.
- 5:10Absolutely.
- 5:11In a sense, they are prophecies.
- 5:13Yeah, exactly.
- 5:14Yeah.
- 5:16Now leading into your book, I mentioned a little bit of what it's about in the intro, but
- 5:22let's hear it in your own words.
- 5:24Obviously, don't want you to give it all away.
- 5:26You want people to see the book, but why write this book and what is it ultimately about?
- 5:31Okay, so why I wrote the book.
- 5:33I suppose I've wrote the book because I believe in democracy, and I believe it's a precious and
- 5:38a noble idea.
- 5:40Because without true democracy, society drifts towards dictatorship of one form or another.
- 5:47So I wanted to give something back to the wider community by contributing to this debate
- 5:53because the community has given me so much.
- 5:56You know, what I want to say is I certainly did not write it for financial rewards or I have an
- 6:02ambition of becoming commentator or a serial author or a writer and what have you.
- 6:10So it was just done as my way of saying thank you to the society and making a contribution to
- 6:16this debate because I see democracy being such a precious and noble idea.
- 6:22Now, in terms of what is it about, you know, in brief terms, I suppose what I could say the
- 6:29central argument of the book is that the party system is the reason democracy is no longer
- 6:35delivering genuine representation.
- 6:38So I believe I believe they're the core reason.
- 6:40And like we've said earlier, two hundred and fifty years ago, there was prophecies that they
- 6:45will subvert the will of the people.
- 6:47Broadly speaking, the book argues that democracy has been gradually captured by
- 6:53wealthy and, I suppose, organized elites via the political parties, through political
- 7:00parties.
- 7:01I suppose two fifty years ago, during the founding fathers era, parties would have been a
- 7:09practical necessity because it was a low information era.
- 7:13So they were needed to help organize political competition.
- 7:16But in this day and age, a more responsive and more accountable form of democracy is possible
- 7:23without them.
- 7:24That's what the book argues and kind of it shows.
- 7:27That's an interesting take.
- 7:29I don't know if I've necessarily heard somebody say that political parties were necessary then,
- 7:34but now we need to get rid of them.
- 7:35Usually, I just hear it as a, well, political party, you need political parties, and it
- 7:40doesn't really make a difference what era it is, or people say that we just never should
- 7:44have parties, period.
- 7:46So I think that's a an interesting way to look at it.
- 7:49And there there are a lot of incentives for party formation, and we'll talk a little bit
- 7:53more about those coming up in a in a in a few questions.
- 7:56But there's definitely a lot of people go ahead.
- 8:00So I just want to kind of say something about this so that it's abundantly clear.
- 8:07We need to try to imagine what the world was like two fifty years ago.
- 8:13There was no internet, certainly no mobile phones, there was no television.
- 8:18I don't know if there was radio.
- 8:20There may have even not been radio at that time because these are recent technologies.
- 8:25So you needed an institution to give the cues to people as to what, they stand for and
- 8:31organize people and motivate people.
- 8:34But the era that we live in now, information is abundantly available.
- 8:40The communication is instant as we are doing across the ocean from UK to United States.
- 8:46So those kind of requirements are no longer here.
- 8:50So it's about time we at least debate it and say, well, do we need political parties?
- 8:56Yeah.
- 8:56It's there's definitely a lot of people that share your opinion.
- 9:02I've I've of course, for me, I I don't necessarily get into that, or at least not
- 9:06publicly.
- 9:06I have obviously, I have my own ideas about that, but there's certainly a lot of people
- 9:12that that feel the same way that you do.
- 9:15But deeping diving deeper, excuse me, into your book in the I was looking at the Amazon
- 9:22description for it, and it's you basically say that cosmetic reforms can't fix this problem.
- 9:30So I want to get a little bit more of your take on Mavik.
- 9:32What are some examples of these cosmetic reforms and why do you believe they are
- 9:37ineffective?
- 9:37By cosmetic, I mean kinds of reforms that try to improve the existing system, existing party
- 9:44system.
- 9:45I suppose we're all familiar with those.
- 9:47Some people suggest reforms such as open primaries, ranked choice voting, and so on and
- 9:54so forth.
- 9:54So the list goes on.
- 9:56I suppose others, some advocate even more parties to come into the equation.
- 10:01So two parties are not enough.
- 10:03So maybe we'll improve the system with three parties or four parties.
- 10:07Some very clever folks suggest technology, AI, to to get people more involved and understand
- 10:15the legislation, what's being debated, and kind of give feedback to the representatives as to
- 10:22what their constituents think and what have you.
- 10:25I believe these reforms will improve certain aspects of the system, but they don't deal with
- 10:32the root cause of the problem.
- 10:34These current problems that we see in democracies, reforms do not deal with that root
- 10:39cause.
- 10:40And my view is if diagnosis is wrong, then the treatment couldn't possibly work.
- 10:49The treatment cannot work because you've diagnosed it wrong.
- 10:52So I suppose we could say this is why democratic or democracy failures have persisted
- 11:00for all these decades because it's not it's not just a current problem that's just occurred.
- 11:05We've had these problem years ago.
- 11:07That's why these reforms had come about, but unfortunately, it did not fix the problems.
- 11:13Take, for example, the money in politics.
- 11:16There have been repeated attempts to curb the influence of money in politics, and you and I
- 11:20both know and most of your listeners would know.
- 11:23But the entrenched elite that I refer to have consistently found these loopholes and new ways
- 11:29to preserve their influence on politics, on these parties.
- 11:33So, in my view, only a structural reform has a chance to fix this problem from the root cause.
- 11:42Because if we identify the root cause right, then we can remedy it correctly.
- 11:46And I believe root cause is the political parties.
- 11:48What I want to kind of maybe add to this, you you use a bit of an analogy here for your
- 11:55audiences, money will always find or money will always seek to influence politics and
- 12:07politicians because it's their in in their interest.
- 12:09So that's human nature.
- 12:11The system the problem is how resistant is the system to that money.
- 12:19Now political parties are a perfect host, if you like, for the for the money.
- 12:26And once money and political parties kind of fuse together, you you've got a tumor.
- 12:32You've got a tumor.
- 12:33It doesn't just stay with within the government.
- 12:37It has spread.
- 12:39Unfortunately, it has spread into the media because what do we see in the media these days?
- 12:45It's consolidated.
- 12:4670% of it is owned by few corporations.
- 12:50And they as the name escapes me, Noam Chomsky, as he as he writes in manufacturing consent.
- 13:00So the the government has enabled the media landscape that we are in today, and therefore,
- 13:07the disease hasn't been contained within the heart of the government.
- 13:10It's spread to the media.
- 13:11It's spread into the schools through these donations and so on and so forth.
- 13:18It's even spread into the judiciary because we have been polarized and everything is based on
- 13:25that polarization.
- 13:26Each group sees the other as an existential threat.
- 13:30So that's my problem, and that's the root cause.
- 13:33The political parties are the root cause here.
- 13:35So if you want the tumor, you know, if you want the patient to get better, you really need to
- 13:41take the tumor out in my view, and then start undoing the damage that is done to the whole
- 13:47body of the system.
- 13:48So for you, it's not even just two party system, a lot of people would agree with that.
- 13:54But you would also say that even in some of these countries that have three or more
- 13:58competitive parties, I think Germany would be considered one of those.
- 14:03So even those you would say are not much better, they're basically still dealing with
- 14:07the same issues then?
- 14:08100%.
- 14:09And let me give you a couple of examples.
- 14:12In Europe, if you look at Netherlands, they have so many weak governments.
- 14:17France have had so many prime ministers in this last year or so.
- 14:20If you look at Israel, you know, coalitions, disproportionately influenced by the minority
- 14:26partner.
- 14:27So yes, my view is more parties, more problems.
- 14:32Interesting.
- 14:33I know some people would argue that, well, we we need to just have a third party to contend
- 14:38with Democrats or Republicans over here.
- 14:40For you, it's actually really just basically the same issue.
- 14:45Gotcha.
- 14:45Yeah.
- 14:47So to dig a little bit deeper into this this vision of yours for having a party less future,
- 14:53if we were to get rid of parties in America, what what is your vision of what that would
- 14:58look like?
- 14:58So would they work like well, we have like a lot of local places have nonpartisan elections.
- 15:04So would it look something like that?
- 15:06Would it be ranked choice, proportional representation, or something else, a
- 15:09combination of the above?
- 15:11What exactly would these elections look like?
- 15:13Okay.
- 15:14So the democracies are not uniform.
- 15:19What we have in UK is parliamentary democracy.
- 15:21What you have over there is presidential democracy.
- 15:24Your presidential democracy is different to the presidential democracy in France.
- 15:28So, there's no one uniform kind of democracy across the globe, across the Western world,
- 15:36especially.
- 15:37So, the no party system that is proposed in breaking democracy's change.
- 15:47It's it's a very simple concept, and it basically replaces the structure provided by
- 15:55the political parties on the current system.
- 15:58So let's start with elections as you've said.
- 16:01What would it look like for your audiences, for your listeners?
- 16:04So I suppose at the constituency level, we probably have got to start at the constituency
- 16:10level.
- 16:11So candidates would stand as individuals without the party label.
- 16:15And you have that in, I believe, in Los Angeles.
- 16:17Mayor will mayor kind of stands without the party labels, and you probably get the is it
- 16:23about the 3,000,000 population in Los Angeles?
- 16:26And you've got about a million or so voters in there, if I'm not mistaken.
- 16:30Last time I've come to check.
- 16:32Something like that.
- 16:33Yeah.
- 16:33So roughly speaking.
- 16:34So what we know is that in your system, still have a nonpartisan without party labels
- 16:42elections where voters vote for the individual, not the party brands.
- 16:48So we know it's possible and practical.
- 16:52It it it it is currently being done in big cities in The US.
- 16:58So, if look at it at a constituency level, candidates would stand as individuals like the
- 17:03mayors in Los Angeles without a party label.
- 17:06So, you might say, but there's gonna be loads of candidates.
- 17:09How do you kind of filter those things and get it to a manageable number?
- 17:12They will qualify through, I suppose, demonstrated public spot.
- 17:16For example, you could each candidate, if they're serious, then can collect half a
- 17:21percent of voters' signatures in that constituency to become a serious contender.
- 17:27So when public goes to vote for their representative, you've only got the serious
- 17:31contenders with some serious sport from the electorate, from voters.
- 17:38So, once you have all the representatives in the Congress, I believe is it you have less
- 17:43than us, is it four thirty or so?
- 17:47435, yeah.
- 17:48435, you know.
- 17:50Well, in the US House there's 435, and then there's a 100 US senators.
- 17:54Yeah, so the four and thirty five.
- 17:57So once these representatives are in the House of Representatives, then the presidential
- 18:06process selecting a presidential process can begin.
- 18:10And presidential candidates will need first demonstrate some sort of a meaningful sport
- 18:16among the elected representatives, because ultimately we've voted for those
- 18:21representatives.
- 18:22We've sent them there to represent us, and on our behalf they can narrow the list down.
- 18:27So House of Representatives would of throw rounds of debate and voting.
- 18:32They will narrow the list down to two finalists.
- 18:35So those two finalists then would go to a general election with their chosen running
- 18:40mates as you have it in your constitution.
- 18:42The winning ticket, I suppose, would become the executive, whereas the runner-up can become
- 18:50whatever you wanna call it, minority leader.
- 18:53In UK, we call it opposition leader.
- 18:55You could call it shadow president.
- 18:56The labels are unimportant.
- 18:59The importance is the role with carrier public mandate to scrutinize the executive.
- 19:05So that office will also appoint a shadow cabinet to present alternatives and help
- 19:11representatives because don't forget, representatives are now independent, not being
- 19:17whipped to toe the party line.
- 19:19They make their own decisions with their conscience and in the best interest of their
- 19:26constituents.
- 19:27So the opposition can dissect the legislation, can put alternative proposals on the table, and
- 19:35then the corporation will naturally emerge around issues and the merit of the proposed
- 19:42legislation.
- 19:44So, you know, if if if you and I were representatives, we might agree and vote yes
- 19:50for one issue, but on the next issue, you might vote yes, and I might vote no.
- 19:55And if the the legislation kind of a commands broad sport from the house of representatives
- 20:02representing the wider public, then it goes through.
- 20:06If it doesn't, then it needs to be amended and and negotiated so that it does get the enough
- 20:12support from the representatives for it to go through.
- 20:16So you would have the competition.
- 20:19You would have the opposition, but not partisan opposition, genuine opposition looking after
- 20:26the best interest of the country.
- 20:28You'll have scrutiny, and you've got stability.
- 20:33So that's my kind of a take on this one.
- 20:36You you can't provide all these things without the parties.
- 20:40Well, that's a lot to dissect there.
- 20:42I do wanna go back to something you said at the towards the beginning.
- 20:45So just to make sure I understand where you're coming from, the idea is that how the elections
- 20:51happen is not quite as much your concern.
- 20:54It's just as long as it's something that doesn't have parties.
- 20:58It could look like a lot of local elections where it's, you know, works similarly to a
- 21:02partisan election except it's just nonpartisan or it could be proportional representation or
- 21:06whatever.
- 21:07It's really just more about just getting the party impact out of that.
- 21:11Correct?
- 21:11Yeah.
- 21:12Correct.
- 21:13Okay.
- 21:14Gotcha.
- 21:15I don't know as well how much it works in other countries.
- 21:18I know they're tend to be much more centralized, but, you know, in in America,
- 21:24there's a lot of our election system is very decentralized.
- 21:27There's a lot of the states and localities have a lot more leeway to decide how their elections
- 21:33work.
- 21:33You do, depending on which state you go to.
- 21:35They sometimes give local places a little bit more leeway in that regard.
- 21:39So that's that's an interesting point there.
- 21:42And now I wanna go a little bit more into the the
- 21:48can I can I can I just kind of come in on on something Sure?
- 21:53Look, I mean, I suppose what needs to be kind of elaborated on or or clarified for your
- 22:03audience is this point.
- 22:05We no doubt you'll kind of put questions to me on various aspects, we'll deal with those.
- 22:10But it's important that I get this message across.
- 22:13What do parties do really for the electorate, for the public?
- 22:18So I would like your audiences to kind of think for a moment.
- 22:23We have filtered choice.
- 22:26So before before you and I get to the ballot box, the choices have been filtered because to
- 22:36to to have a party label to become a party candidate, you need the party approval in a
- 22:42roundabout way.
- 22:43Every kind of a system differs, but you don't tell the public party line you're not you're
- 22:48not on that list.
- 22:49So you will not have the and this is why you have problems with existing or sitting
- 22:55representatives, reelection rates of 90% plus.
- 23:00You know, you you basically get them out of the job when they die, more or less.
- 23:05So, very few or or they kind of go against the party they represent.
- 23:10So, the parties have there's this kind of three points that I wanna make on the parties.
- 23:17One, they filter the choice.
- 23:20So, you you haven't got a a full menu to choose from.
- 23:23You've got filtered menu.
- 23:25They say you can vote two candidates here for conservatives or as Republicans or Democrats.
- 23:32Then the story doesn't end there.
- 23:35Once these representatives in the house, they're told which way to vote.
- 23:41So that's a problem.
- 23:42Now in in UK, we had some veteran MPs, members of parliament, your representatives equivalent.
- 23:5021 of those was sat and withdrawn and basically their careers ended by Boris Johnson because
- 23:56they decided to not vote along the party lines for Brexit.
- 24:01So not only that the choices are filtered, but parties also what they call discipline.
- 24:08They basically tell your representatives which way to vote.
- 24:12So this is why if we kind of tie it back to this citizens involvement through AI and and
- 24:18digital platforms and what have you, it becomes meaningless when the representatives haven't
- 24:23got a freedom or free will to vote for legislation in line with their conscience or in
- 24:29line with their constituents.
- 24:31And then finally, the third point is the money doesn't just the wealthy entrenched behind the
- 24:40parties don't just limit their influence through selecting candidates that's loyal to
- 24:46them or align with their thinking.
- 24:50They also fund think tanks who draw up legislations and so on and so forth.
- 24:56And that's kind of a cent to the government and they put in the the whatever you wanna call it,
- 25:02that, you know, their advantages, what what works in their benefit rather than what what
- 25:06works on the interest of the wider public.
- 25:09And this is why you'll see massive corporations, billionaires pay very little tax.
- 25:14You and I will pay 40%, and they will be paying something like a six or 8%.
- 25:20So there's all these loopholes that's been drawn up.
- 25:22So parties are not really serving the voters or the public.
- 25:26They're really serving their masters who finance them.
- 25:29Sorry.
- 25:30I've butted in there, but carry on.
- 25:32Over to you.
- 25:32No.
- 25:33No.
- 25:33It's okay.
- 25:34But I get what you're saying.
- 25:36It is it is true.
- 25:37There is it's undeniable to some extent that there is filtering going on before we even get
- 25:43to election time, and that's not even talking about districts that are so heavily Democratic
- 25:48or so heavily Republican that the minority party can't possibly challenge the majority
- 25:54party in the election in a lot of districts.
- 25:56And, unfortunately, you are seeing more of those uncompetitive districts.
- 26:01But now as for the ultimate vision that you have, not just, you know, talking about the
- 26:07symptoms of the current system, but looking towards the future.
- 26:11As I said up top, this is not I don't argue for or against, I guess, political views.
- 26:17But I will admit though that I have a little skepticism as to whether a part of this future
- 26:23can happen.
- 26:23Not not it's not really about whether I think it should or shouldn't.
- 26:26It's just I I do find it hard to believe it can have it.
- 26:29But I do wanna get your take on some of the arguments that some people will make against
- 26:35your ideas
- 26:36Yeah.
- 26:37And give you give you a chance to rebut them and and and give your take on all of them.
- 26:41So Yeah.
- 26:42I think first of all, it makes this makes sense because these are the people that are gonna be
- 26:48the most adamantly against your proposal.
- 26:50What would you say to Democrats or Republicans who would argue that if you got rid of parties
- 26:55that their representation would be diminished if they can't have candidates running as
- 27:00Democrats or Republicans, and a lot of them will use the First Amendment right to freedom
- 27:05of association as one of those arguments.
- 27:08What would you say to those people?
- 27:10Okay.
- 27:10Yeah.
- 27:11So, under no party system that's being proposed in breaking democracy chains, the freedom of
- 27:16association remains exactly the same.
- 27:19So there's no restrictions or whatsoever.
- 27:22We want a more democratic system, not a more oppressive system.
- 27:27Democrats or Republicans do not need to give up their values.
- 27:32Their values are their values, their culture, you know, they believe in that deeply, and we
- 27:37haven't got a problem with that.
- 27:39And on some cultural issues, I would put my hand up and and admit there are cultural
- 27:45differences or real differences between the two parties.
- 27:49I suppose broadly speaking, one tends to be more liberal and other tend to be more
- 27:54conservative.
- 27:55So, that's where the divide line is.
- 27:57We have a similar sort of a system here in The UK.
- 28:00Although previously it was more of a working class and the business class kind of a thing or
- 28:05upper class in UK, but that's more kind of a move towards American system.
- 28:11So, yeah, conservative and liberals.
- 28:14But on, you know, what's important, I I suppose, it's it's kind of a to highlight that
- 28:19when it comes to major issues, there's hardly any daylight between those two parties on
- 28:25issues like a foreign wars.
- 28:27They continued under Obama, Biden, Trump, Bush.
- 28:31So whether you have Democrats or Republican, that continues because of the pressure from
- 28:35military industrial complex.
- 28:37Surveillance, that has gone worse over the years, just got tighter and tighter, and both
- 28:44parties are equally responsible for that.
- 28:47So it's not that there's any difference between them.
- 28:51Austerity, you would expect democrats to be better, but no.
- 28:55Far from it.
- 28:56When in the February, banks were rescued, billions, if not nearly trillion, was spent on
- 29:03those things.
- 29:03You and I and ordinary people were asked to tighten our belts and and go for the austerity.
- 29:09So they're broadly aligned when it comes to the key issues.
- 29:13But that's another matter because as I've said earlier, like Tuma, once the government is in
- 29:19hands of the parties, they've kind of passed laws to create the media landscape we have now
- 29:25and that parties in media now pits us against one another basically.
- 29:32And hence, we kind of are in this situation.
- 29:35But another, I suppose, important point to make here is that parties restrict choice.
- 29:41By nature, the parties want to get into the government and they kind of aggregate or vote
- 29:46aggregators.
- 29:47They they kind of aggregate votes, if you like, bundling many different issues into a single
- 29:52package.
- 29:53Donald Trump, when he was campaigning, he was asking for the Muslim votes in in US, and he's
- 30:04probably got them.
- 30:05And then that's what may have tilted the balance for him to to win the presidency.
- 30:10So you can see conservatism and the Muslim votes don't necessarily go together.
- 30:15They were traditionally with the Democrats.
- 30:18And when Biden didn't do the job that wider Muslim population expected off of him in Gaza,
- 30:25they've kind of drifted to go along with Donald Trump.
- 30:28And like yourself, I try to stay out of politics.
- 30:32My job is better democracy.
- 30:34I respect each side equally because they have genuine concerns.
- 30:39They have they're genuinely liberal.
- 30:41They're genuinely conservative, and I fully respect each side as long as it doesn't kind of
- 30:46lead to any form of violence kind of a thing, whether it's on the right or whether it's on
- 30:52the left.
- 30:52And I think we could make the point that very few voters truly agree with everything a party
- 31:00stands for.
- 31:01You know, I might like some of the policies that are in conservative manifesto and some of
- 31:08the policies that are in republican manifesto.
- 31:11But because of this identity, we kind of associate with one camp or the other and and
- 31:18kind of a vote in that manner.
- 31:20So the voting then becomes about choosing not really choosing what you want.
- 31:28It's about strategically voting to keep other side out, and that's not democracy.
- 31:34You you want to be able to vote some something that you truly believe in, not just
- 31:39strategically.
- 31:39So I'm gonna vote on this election because I just don't want other guys to come in.
- 31:44I know my set are bad, but I just really do not want to see these other guys come in.
- 31:51And that's what kind of keeps the the the society divided.
- 31:55I think there's a good book by Liliana Mason, Unsimple Agreement.
- 31:59I don't know if you've come across that one.
- 32:01But as she kind of lays bare, parties have managed to fuse this cultural identity with the
- 32:11political identity basically and created what she calls this mega identity.
- 32:18So people are now seeing other side as existential threat and that's not a that's not
- 32:26a healthy situation to be to be in.
- 32:29But removing party labels, to come back to your original question, does not mean voters abandon
- 32:35their beliefs.
- 32:35The candidate or the candidates in your constituency, they will still campaign openly
- 32:42on their values.
- 32:43And in the book, I say pledges, their policy pledges, what they're promising the electorate.
- 32:50So, if voters want somebody with somebody conservative values, they can vote for that
- 32:55candidate.
- 32:56If they want somebody with democratic values or liberal values, they can vote for that
- 33:01candidate.
- 33:01That's not a problem.
- 33:02So, that choice is not taken away from them.
- 33:05The difference, I suppose, is that you're choosing a person and their program directly
- 33:12rather than choosing a party label.
- 33:14So you've still got these republican or democratic values.
- 33:18The representation, in other words, is not diminishing.
- 33:22I would agree is strengthened because you're not strategically voting.
- 33:26You're voting for something that you believe in, and you have a full control over it as a
- 33:30voter.
- 33:31Because if this representative consistently betrays his or her pledges to the constituents,
- 33:40to the voters, you can punish that person.
- 33:45You can punish that person at the next general election without worrying about letting other
- 33:51side in because there is no other side anymore.
- 33:53I think a lot of people can agree with the idea of they want something to vote for, not
- 33:59something against.
- 33:59And that is you hear that lament all the time as people think they're voting for the lesser
- 34:04of two evils, which may be a little bit harsh because even if, you know, some candidates are
- 34:10not even if they're not fit for office, evils might be a little bit harsh.
- 34:16Obviously, it's just the phrase.
- 34:17But
- 34:18Yeah.
- 34:18Sometimes people really do people really do feel that way that it is just evil people when
- 34:24they don't agree.
- 34:25And that's, yet, like you said, it's not healthy for democracy.
- 34:28But let's go more into the practical side of the debate.
- 34:32Obviously the theoretical, the philosophical is important, but ultimately you do have to make
- 34:38this vision happen.
- 34:41So there are we talked about this a little bit towards the beginning.
- 34:45There are a lot of incentives for political parties to perform.
- 34:48There's a book I've I've shown a couple times on here on this podcast called, why parties?
- 34:53The second look by John Aldrich.
- 34:54That's a really great analysis of these incentives and a lot more, such as being able
- 34:59to more effectively advocate for their interests or more effectively mobilize voters.
- 35:03You talked about how that was very helpful in the early days of The United States.
- 35:09But so bringing that into the present day, how would you incentivize people, particularly
- 35:15elected officials, to get behind this idea of party less politics?
- 35:20Yeah.
- 35:21Look.
- 35:21I mean, I've not put my hand up.
- 35:23I've not read the book by Aldrich, but I think from what I've kind of gathered from similar
- 35:29authors is that they kind of acclaim that parties organize candidates, mobilize voters,
- 35:35provide structure.
- 35:36We've talked about some of those points earlier and make governing more manageable, I suppose,
- 35:41in large representative systems because after all, we don't live in Athenian democracy where
- 35:47mass participation is possible.
- 35:49We know that's not possible.
- 35:52Representation in modern days can be much more responsive and can be much more accountable to
- 36:01the voters.
- 36:02So, I think, first and foremost, we need to deal with the coordination.
- 36:08Democracies do need some sort of coordination.
- 36:12We've kind of answered that question earlier in the sense that we have a structure put in place
- 36:18of the parties where we have independent candidates, representatives in the House of
- 36:24Representatives, then the presidential candidates emerge and they're voted on and they
- 36:30form the executive and then the opposition, legal, know, constitutional and mandated by the
- 36:37public.
- 36:37I think the key point to discuss here probably is how would the cooperation work and how would
- 36:46the alliances work and how would the structure would work?
- 36:50Well, it's quite simple.
- 36:52It's quite simple in the sense that, well, you have these representatives that's not being
- 36:58whipped by the party bosses to behave in a certain way, vote in a certain way.
- 37:04They can have a look at each legislation or proposal that comes in front of them.
- 37:09Look at this proposal, listen to the opposition to see if there's alternatives, to see what it
- 37:16means, because even the representatives will need to digest this legislation and understand
- 37:22it.
- 37:23So what I'm basically say is saying legislators can still cooperate, mobilize, sport, and
- 37:29organize governor, but that doesn't mean permanent politicals are the only way to
- 37:34achieve that to that mobilization.
- 37:37The difference is the alliances would form issue by issue, and they will be fluid.
- 37:43So you're not restricting the freedom of association or or or voting in one one way or
- 37:49another, but that will reflect the true will of this society as a whole.
- 37:55So I really don't see at all, and please do push me back on this one, push back on this one
- 38:02as to what if we have alternative structure to political parties, what purpose would they
- 38:08serve apart from that we've been used to them for nearly two and a half centuries?
- 38:15And, you know, I would draw your listeners to another point, and that's female suffrage, the
- 38:24women's suffrage.
- 38:25Do you know it was hundred and nearly a hundred and fifty years.
- 38:29It was only in 1920 that women had the right to vote.
- 38:35Now, for those hundred and fifty years, that looked unrealistic.
- 38:40That did not come through.
- 38:42Now, if you look at it from today's perspective, today's lenses, you will say well
- 38:48that's rather stupid isn't it?
- 38:50Know why it's quite realistic it's happened so we call things unrealistic until we kind of see
- 38:57these things happen And that's because I wanna kind of go back and tie it all together.
- 39:04That's because through the party system, the entrenched elite had captured the government,
- 39:12passed legislation through think tanks.
- 39:15And because once you capture the party bosses, important people in the party, then you've
- 39:21captured a whole block of representatives.
- 39:24You basically get them to vote in the in the way you want.
- 39:27And through that, they've kind of changed the curriculum because we've not got critically
- 39:32thinking public students.
- 39:35You know, from day one, parties have been part of our everyday life in elections, in schools,
- 39:40in education.
- 39:41And so when you say to people a democracy is possible without political parties, they say,
- 39:47well, yes.
- 39:48I can understand that.
- 39:49It's been two hundred and fifty years.
- 39:50It's not easy.
- 39:51It's just like it.
- 39:52I suppose it it it says it sounds as radical as going to somewhere like Iran or Saudi Arabia
- 39:58and say you should have a democracy.
- 39:59People will say, no.
- 40:00No.
- 40:00No.
- 40:00We don't want that.
- 40:01That's not practical.
- 40:02That's not gonna work here.
- 40:03So, yes, I can understand the the reason why people will see it that way, but I could never
- 40:10understand why in a civilized Western society, we don't debate it and see if there's a better
- 40:19form of democracy that improves everybody's lives and really restores the power where it
- 40:25belongs with the people.
- 40:27Well, maybe that debate will be coming sooner rather than later.
- 40:30We'll we'll see.
- 40:31But it it is a good point.
- 40:32I mean, a lot of things have been realistic in the past, and then eventually they did become
- 40:35realistic.
- 40:35Fun fact about women's suffrage though is there actually were a few states before the
- 40:41nineteenth amendment was ratified in 1920.
- 40:43There were actually a few states that did let women vote in elections.
- 40:47Now sometimes they weren't able to vote in every election, but Wyoming calls it is
- 40:53nicknamed the the equality state because they were actually the first state to allow for
- 40:58women's suffrage.
- 40:59And I was gonna say it's something eighteen eighty something, eighteen ninety something.
- 41:03So fun little fact there that I just thought about because of what you brought up.
- 41:07But it it is true.
- 41:08So hey.
- 41:09Maybe one day this will happen.
- 41:11Like I said, I am a little skeptical of whether it will happen, but it is a good point.
- 41:15Sometimes there's a lot of things that are realistic today that weren't once weren't
- 41:20realistic.
- 41:20And we're human beings.
- 41:22We like to push the boundaries of what's possible.
- 41:24Absolutely.
- 41:25Absolutely.
- 41:25So we'll see.
- 41:28We are coming a little close to time, so I do want to get a couple more questions in real
- 41:32quick before I end with the random question of the day that I like to do.
- 41:37But Yeah.
- 41:38Another practical argument somebody might pose is how we might see lower voter turnout because
- 41:43voters won't be able to rely on that heuristic of the party where they see a Democrat or
- 41:48Republican, and then they vote in there.
- 41:49And low voter turnout can be its own issue for democracy.
- 41:54Actually, the episode I just put out today, which
- 41:57by the
- 41:57time this episode comes out, it'll be next week Yeah.
- 41:59Did talk about low voter turnout being a problem for representative ness in government.
- 42:05But in any case, what would you say to people who say that, well, if you get rid of the
- 42:11Democratic and Republican and all party labels that it's gonna lead to lower voter turnout?
- 42:17Okay.
- 42:17Now fair point.
- 42:18Fair point.
- 42:19It is true that many voters do rely on shortcuts, and party labels are one of those
- 42:25shortcuts for sure.
- 42:27Yeah.
- 42:29But this is not a good reason to preserve that party machines because those same labels often
- 42:35encourage passive tribal voting rather than meaningful choice as we've explained earlier in
- 42:42detail without going back over the same point.
- 42:45Under the party system, there are so many voters that feel frustrated and disconnected on
- 42:51the current system.
- 42:52They often say, well, my vote does not really change anything, and I'm one of those voters.
- 42:59So parties tend to kind of rely heavily on fear, identity politics, cultural divisions to
- 43:10mobilize their base rather than really inspiring the voters.
- 43:14And that that is a there's a problem.
- 43:15And besides, voters would still have clear cues because not everybody is a political
- 43:23philosopher kind of a thing, so they need cues.
- 43:25But those cues would come from the candidates.
- 43:28The voters can see the top pledges they make to the constituents, for instance, whether they're
- 43:34Republican aligned or Liberal aligned and what have you.
- 43:38And in practical terms, I suppose this could be made very straightforward.
- 43:42A public government website could, you know, could list every candidate alongside with their
- 43:48top 10 pledges so the voters can compare them easily.
- 43:51And this could be what is their position on abortion, on guns, on immigration, and so on
- 43:56and so forth.
- 43:57So the list goes on kind of a thing.
- 43:59So the top 10 pledges, you will know immediately whether that person is like a
- 44:04republican values or the liberal values.
- 44:08So you'll immediately have that.
- 44:10And then I suppose the same information on that website or shorter version of it could also
- 44:17kind of appear on the ballot paper itself.
- 44:20So that would give the voters something far more meaningful than just their party label.
- 44:25So for you, it's more that even though it's one, albeit very common heuristic that people
- 44:33use, maybe arguably the most powerful one, which party they are, It's, they're just really
- 44:38just gonna be more relying on other mental cues instead.
- 44:44Maybe voter turnout will pick back up after a while then.
- 44:47What I was gonna say is that I think this is, know, over time, the voter turnout will improve
- 44:55because people will feel their vote matters
- 44:58because Gotcha.
- 44:59Yeah.
- 45:00That's the whole point.
- 45:01Because, yes, you have cues.
- 45:03You wanna kind of vote tactically to keep somebody out.
- 45:06Whereas under the no party system, if I'm voting for Paul and I want to see if he's kind
- 45:13of stayed loyal to his pledges, stay true to his pledges, and then if you have, I'll say,
- 45:20well, I need to support this guy because he's 10 out of 10.
- 45:24Or if you haven't, then I say, well, look.
- 45:26I need to get somebody else in because this guy had betrayed us as voters.
- 45:30So I know my vote makes a difference.
- 45:33Whereas on a party party whole party machine, nationally, it's it doesn't make any difference
- 45:40kind of a thing apart from, well, I don't I'm not gonna waste my waste my vote because I
- 45:45don't wanna let her decide on.
- 45:47You know, independence in US, 45% of the people in US identify as independents.
- 45:54Only you know, that's more than both parties put together.
- 45:57They're only under 20% each that people identify as republican and democrats according
- 46:04to the 2025 survey.
- 46:07So, yes, the queues will be there and and more more openly because, you know, if I if I have a
- 46:14piece of paper that I can see Paul's picture on it and his pledges on it and regarding money, I
- 46:20can see your top donors as well.
- 46:22So I know whether you're gonna serve my interests as a voter or whether you're gonna
- 46:27serve interest of the I don't know.
- 46:29Some sort of a special interest group.
- 46:31Voters will be more engaged and the turnout will increase.
- 46:34But there's another point that needs to be made here, Paul, and that is we assume the voter
- 46:39turnout is good.
- 46:41Well, hang on a minute.
- 46:42It's it's on the floor.
- 46:44It's, you know, your primaries attract something like a 20% of the voters.
- 46:49Your your, you know, your main general election where there's more enthusiasm is 60% or or or
- 46:54so.
- 46:55And if you if you if you say you get, you know, part because the the the the margin is very
- 47:02small between the conservatives and and democrats, they only win by a couple of
- 47:08percentage points.
- 47:09So if you said 50% of 60% turnout, that's only 30% of the voters that gives them the Monday.
- 47:15Now look further afield.
- 47:19In Australia, the voter turnout was diagnosed diving under these systems, and they brought in
- 47:25compulsory mandatory voting system.
- 47:31So if if if you don't go and vote, they they pushed it up to 90.
- 47:34But, you know, if you don't go and vote, they fine you unless you have a valid reason.
- 47:39So the voter turnout is as it is on the current party system is what I'm trying to get across.
- 47:46Sure.
- 47:46And you do bring up a a good point.
- 47:48The US is one of the something else I brought up in my last episode is that US voter turnout
- 47:54is one of the lowest amongst democracies in the world.
- 47:59And like you said, part of it is, you know, some countries use compulsory voting, but even
- 48:04so, like, if you look at you talked about primaries.
- 48:07If you even look at local general elections, sometimes they could be something like 15% of
- 48:14eligible voters that turn out to vote.
- 48:16It it can be very it's used to be back in, I wanna say, right around the turn to the
- 48:23twentieth century was some of our highest points of voter turnout.
- 48:26And since then, it's been it's been a lot lower.
- 48:29But but that that that is another point to make too is even if there is lower voter turnout
- 48:34with no parties, you already see very low turnout in the first place.
- 48:39Well, I think we need to call a spade a spade.
- 48:42The voter turnout has gone down because people have lost faith in the system.
- 48:48That's the only explanation.
- 48:50They've lost faith in the system.
- 48:52They don't trust the system delivers for them.
- 48:54It doesn't matter whether it's the reds or blues, you know, no matter who wins, we lose.
- 48:59That's my conclusion.
- 49:01That is true to some extent.
- 49:02Some people do just not vote just because of what you said there.
- 49:06Just one more question before we get to the closing part here, but I did wanna get to this
- 49:11one because I like to have towards the end of my episodes, I want to have at least one set
- 49:17question dedicated to practical takeaways for listeners.
- 49:20Now this might be something that's a little bit harder to make practical because it's a very
- 49:25broad forward vision, but what are two to three actionable tips you'd like to give to people
- 49:30when it comes to pushing it back against a two party system and possibly ushering in a party
- 49:36list system?
- 49:38Okay.
- 49:38I think my number one would be to to kind of recognize what is being proposed here is not a
- 49:46utopian fantasy.
- 49:49In The United States, as I said earlier, 45% of the adult voters do not belong to either major
- 49:57party.
- 49:58So, there is already dissatisfaction.
- 50:01So, this is not a utopian fantasy.
- 50:04That's the first message I want to kind of get across to people.
- 50:07It needs a serious look at to discuss it because we deserve a better system, a more
- 50:15democratic system.
- 50:17Second, and probably even more importantly, realize power of your vote as citizens please
- 50:26please please I know I'm not a good example I said out of frustration I did not vote realize
- 50:34power of your vote It is the most powerful tool in the world.
- 50:39Why is that?
- 50:40Because you can use it either to choose genuine representatives free from the party filter or
- 50:49keep performing the ritual that legitimizes this broken system.
- 50:53So that is my second but probably more important point is to realize the power of your
- 51:01vote is the most powerful thing in the world.
- 51:04Finally, on on on third point, I I I would advocate a citizen's super PAC for independent
- 51:14democracy because, you know, money is flooding these political parties.
- 51:19So what we need is a super PAC for independent democracy, independent candidates, and we need
- 51:26to build that sport.
- 51:27Sorry.
- 51:28The the sport from the whole nation maybe, you know, like minded people, that 45% that don't
- 51:33associate with these parties in order for the independence to effectively compete with the
- 51:39party candidates.
- 51:40So this national no party movement that pulls small donations from across the nation, builds
- 51:47network, identifies target seats, and strategically kind of begs candidates in one or
- 51:54two constituencies at a time so that they become viable.
- 51:58A similar sort of a kind of setup exists in Australia.
- 52:02I think they call it climate two hundred, which is a similar kind of a sport.
- 52:07They get pull the money, they get all the small donations from the public, and they counter
- 52:11these big monies behind big parties, and they support independent candidates.
- 52:17They've got about 10 independent candidates, if not more, in Australia.
- 52:21So it's possible.
- 52:22So I think we need this super PAC to to get behind the independence because nobody in power
- 52:27in history has ever let go of that power voluntarily or or out of decency.
- 52:33They will hold on to that power.
- 52:35So it's gotta come from the grassroots.
- 52:37It's gotta come from the people that demand better, and that's how we will get to this
- 52:41system.
- 52:42So to recap, know the power of your vote, have an open mind that better system is possible,
- 52:49and these disenfranchised voters get behind independence and create a super PAC for
- 52:55independent democracy is my practical tips.
- 52:58Okay.
- 52:59Well, for those of you at home, like to hear your takes on all that.
- 53:02Well, of course, the whole episode, but also hear about what had to say, what Mitton had to
- 53:08say there for the practical takeaways.
- 53:10But since we're pushing up on time, I'm gonna go ahead and get to the final part of this
- 53:15interview.
- 53:16So for my interviews, for anybody for for obviously, you, Mettin, and for anybody here
- 53:21who listening to this episode who hasn't listened to this podcast before, I like to end
- 53:25things with a random nonpolitical fun question just to round things out and just to add a
- 53:30little levity to things.
- 53:32So Yeah.
- 53:32Matin, today's random question of the day for you is, what is one of your unpopular food
- 53:39opinions?
- 53:40Unpopular?
- 53:42Yes.
- 53:42Sorry.
- 53:43Say that again.
- 53:43I I didn't I missed it.
- 53:46What what is one of your unpopular food opinions?
- 53:50Food opinion.
- 53:51Unpopular food opinion.
- 53:54Now then.
- 53:56It's alright.
- 53:56Let it out.
- 53:57Let it out.
- 53:59Well, I mean, in which way?
- 54:01I'm trying to kind of work out.
- 54:03My opinion Here, on it's a broad Is
- 54:07there a food that a whole lot of people like and you're like, I'm not about that.
- 54:11Like, I'll tell you, pickles suck.
- 54:12I hate pickles.
- 54:13I don't get why anybody likes pickles.
- 54:15Yes.
- 54:16Yeah.
- 54:16I would say sushi.
- 54:19Japanese food.
- 54:20Sushi?
- 54:20Yeah.
- 54:21Sushi.
- 54:21Yeah.
- 54:21I Okay.
- 54:22I could not touch raw fish.
- 54:24No.
- 54:25I'm not a sushi guy either.
- 54:27Yeah.
- 54:27I will say one of my I I I think it's unpopular because it seems to be happening more and more
- 54:34often here.
- 54:35So you're in UK.
- 54:36I don't know if the English Premier League teams do this in their arenas, but there's a
- 54:41thing in American professional sports places that for some reason, they really feel the need
- 54:46to mix foods together that absolutely do not need to be, like putting, like, hot dogs and
- 54:52ice cream and stuff like that.
- 54:54I I what are we doing?
- 54:56This is so dumb and you're just adding to this this stereotype of Americans being food slobs.
- 55:03It's it's I I just just because you can do it, it's it's like that.
- 55:07I don't know if you've ever seen the movie Jurassic Park, but Yeah.
- 55:10Jeff Goldblum's character.
- 55:12You're so preoccupied with whether you could, you never stop to think about whether you
- 55:15should.
- 55:16We don't need to be mixing all these disparate foods together.
- 55:20I've never understood.
- 55:21They're perfectly fine by themselves.
- 55:23Just stop
- 55:23the I agree.
- 55:24I agree.
- 55:25You'd be pleased to know that whatever happens in America, few years later is in UK.
- 55:30So we're not far behind you.
- 55:32Okay.
- 55:33Yeah.
- 55:33Well, that's well, in in this case, that's a shame.
- 55:36But yeah.
- 55:37No.
- 55:37That that that's that's that's one of the things that just drives me crazy.
- 55:42And I like to try to focus on some of those things that don't matter and get mad about
- 55:46those so I don't
- 55:48It's it's good
- 55:48to up at things that do matter.
- 55:50Yeah.
- 55:51It's good to let steam out.
- 55:52We're human beings.
- 55:53Yeah.
- 55:54Absolutely.
- 55:55Indeed.
- 55:55But, yeah, no.
- 55:56Pickle pickles also do suck.
- 55:57I hate pickles.
- 55:58I I don't I don't get why why they're put
- 56:00on I'm I'm good with my burgers and pickles, definitely.
- 56:04Okay, well, hey, you can go ahead and have all the pickles that would be on my burger.
- 56:07Yeah, perfect combination.
- 56:09There you go.
- 56:10But anyways, we are gonna have to wrap things up here.
- 56:13So Matin, thank you so much for being on here.
- 56:15Obviously, I'll share a link to your book.
- 56:17Is there any other link that you wanna share?
- 56:19No, it's available on Amazon, Barnes and Noble.
- 56:22Thank you.
- 56:22So yes, that's perfect.
- 56:24Okay.
- 56:25I will put that link in the show notes.
- 56:27And then of course my links, my Facebook, LinkedIn, medium.com profile, email, my website
- 56:35and the Paul Raider dot org and PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 56:38And my five day educational email course about how we can more effectively depolarize politics
- 56:44in America because a lot of the ways that we try to depolarize politics is actually
- 56:48ineffective and sometimes has the opposite effect.
- 56:50And that's EEC, educational email course, talks about ways to counteract that.
- 56:56So that's going to end things here.
- 56:59So thank you so much, Benton, and thank you so much for all of you listening.
- 57:02Please like, comment, share, subscribe, and share the podcast on YouTube, Spotify, Apple
- 57:08Podcasts, and wherever else this eventually pops up in the future.
- 57:12So we're gonna end it off here.
- 57:15So thank you so much again, and we'll Much see appreciated.
- 57:19Thank you.
- 57:20Absolutely.
- 57:20And we'll see you next time.